They Kind of Look Alike

by SmutAltYAY

Rating: mature
Tags: Human, Mrs. Cake, Porn, Equestria Girls, Sex, Sunset Shimmer
Length: 4183

Sunset sees Pinkie holding Cup Cake's new daughter in a picture. She remembers her conception.

Cup Cake and Carrot Cake have had a new daughter! Everyone is happy for them. Though someone has pointed out something.

"You know. She kind of reminds me of Sunset."

"Huh. Yeah. They do kind of look alike. It's just the colors though."

They're more right than they know.

Can I just ask Y'all how this got featured?

Good to know y'all were just as horny for the only Sunset x Mrs. Cake smut on this site as I was.

Published 2022-06-10 04:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2022-06-10 04:00:01 UTC

It's just the skin color... and the hair looks like Sunset's colors mixed... and her eyes look like Sunset's shape... and-

Sunset smirked as she scrolled down Pinkie's social feed. She was visiting the Cakes again. Cup Cake had just given birth to a cute little girl. Yellow skin and dark orange, almost red hair. At a glance, one might say she was the spitting image of her dad.

But Sunset and the girl's mother knew better. She licked her lips as she remembered that night. She'd shown up late just wanting something small to eat. It was a few months after she'd turned over a new leaf and she ended up letting herself basically bare her soul to the bakery owner.

Cup Cake frowned at the mess of a girl on her counter. She'd heard tales about Sunset Shimmer. How horrible she was. How conniving and sneaky. But she'd also heard more than a little about how hard she was trying to turn over a new leaf and how hard she was having it. Most of the school still hated her. Many for good reason. But they were all teenagers -though apparently there was still confusion about if Sunset herself still fit into that age range for some reason? Pinkie mentioned something along those lines in one of her hyper speed tangents- and teenagers were cruel.

That tangent of Pinkie's did give her an idea though. It wasn't a good idea, but she felt like this girl could use it. So, she'd pretend to believe she wasn't a teenager (granted eighteen was on the tail end). For tonight.

So, while Sunset still had her head cradled on her arms, Cup Cake slipped out from behind the counter and locked up the place. Pulling down the blinds, turning the sign to closed and double checking the lock.

She went up to Sunset and gently pressed against her shoulder "Hey. Come with me to the kitchen, hm?"

Sunset sniffled a little and shrugged. "Mkay." She muttered before following a little listlessly.

Once in the kitchen, Cup Cake grabbed a bottle, one that confused Sunset but only for a moment. Cup Cake spoke up before she could say anything "It's not expensive. It's not strong. I just... I just think you could use a girls night to just relax with someone you don't really have history with. Someone you can do what you did earlier with." She offered before lifting the bottle. "And... something to help loosen the nerves to help you do exactly that."

Cup Cakes blush was adorable. She was clearly nervous about offering the idea but the offer itself was made from an innocent place. One of wanting to help, of wanting to be kind and to be there for someone. Sunset really appreciated that.

Sunset smiled softly and took a breath before sitting down. "I think I'd like that. It's been a while since I've drank with such a nice woman so I'm not sure if I want to ruin it by complaining but we'll see what happens."

Cup Cake blushed more and it was then that Sunset realized that Cup Cake blushed kind of easily which flipped a switch in her. Making the pudgy woman blush was adorable and she wanted to do it more. As the wine glasses were set down and filled her goal was decided.

Even if the wine was weak, after a bottle it didn't really matter much. Once they started to break into the second bottle, it really didn't matter.

They had touched on Sunset's issues with others and especially herself much more than she expected while she did her best to get Cup Cake to blush while trying not to be too forward. She didn't want to end the night early or get kicked out. By now though, both of their minds were buzzing a little.

Sunset reached over and grabbed Cup Cake's plump thigh. "I wish I had a girlfriend like you." She admitted with a sigh before leaning over and laying her head onto the counter. For a couple seconds longer than she intended she stared at Cup Cake's large chest before her eyes lazily made their way back up to her face. All the while her hand stayed gripping and squeezing her thigh.

Cup Cake continued to blush and chuckled a little. "Pinkie had said once she thought you were checking her out. I suppose that proves you like girls." Cup Cake said with a chuckle. She wasn't drunk. But her filter had clearly gone home for the night.

Sunset chuckled "Ha. Yeah. I'm bi as fuuuuuck. Though right now I'm leaning towards girls. Last guy I went out with was kind of a let down. He wouldn't even suck my dick!" She exclaimed, earning a loud laugh from the woman next to her, who probably thought she was kidding. That was fine.

Cup Cake giggled again "Yes. I suppose there's a number of men who might be averse to that."

Sunset rolled her eyes "Wimps. If they want tits, that's fine. Tits are great. Look at yours! I bet they feel amazing! I totally understand! But if they want tits then they gotta suck some dick too! It's only fair." She said with a sagely nod before grinning at Cup Cakes flustered expression.

Cup Cake shook her head "N-no. These are just bags of fat. Nothing to write home about. They just hurt my back."

Sunset nodded softly "I get it. It's a double edged sword. Your chest looks amazing and probably feels amazing but hurts your back and probably makes it near impossible to run. I can relate. My big dick makes any cute pants impossible to wear and bikini's? Forget about it. That's not even getting started with how big of a target it is for getting hit." She groaned.

Cup Cake, still blushing, decided to finally approach the topic she thought was a joke. "Uhm. Sunset. You keep mentioning... Your... dick. Are you saying, you have-"

"A dick?" Sunset perked up and turned her body to face to mother of two before pulling her skirt up a little. There, bundled in her teal tights was an undeniable bulge of cock and balls. "Yup. Full package. Pussy hides behind it. Annoyingly big. Seriously. Like, I dunno. Nine inches? Maybe? Dunno. Never got around to measuring really."

Cup Cake's blush had taken over her face now and spread to her collarbone. She couldn't help but stare to boot. This young girl had... quite the package hiding down there. Well hiding might be the wrong word, since, like Sunset said, it seemed hard to hide that thing anywhere.

"...p Cake? Hello? Are you okay?" Sunset's voice faded into reality "Are you done staring at my dick? If not, I can take it out." Without waiting for a reply, Sunset did exactly that and quickly fished out the massive thing.

It was a darker tone of yellow from her skin. Heavy, heaving balls bouncing as they seemed to celebrate freedom, quickly followed by the heavy slap of flesh against flesh as her shaft flopped down. Cup Cake's mind probably exaggerated a lot of it but... it'd been a long time since they'd been in the mood and Sunset was so, SO much bigger.

Sunset reveled in the attention she was getting. "You like it?" An unconscious nod confirmed that Cup Cake had very much gone into autopilot to an extent. That was nice and all but she wanted Cup Cake. Not a robot. She reached over and grabbed Cup Cake's hand, pulling it to her warm package before speaking up. "You have to use your words Cup Cake or I'm just going to assume you want all of this."

Cup Cake flinched for a moment. Almost pulling away. Carrot Cake flashed into her mind before turning into a haze that eventually reformed into Sunset. She bit her lip. "I... Just... We won't speak to anyone about this, okay?" She asked with a gulp, inwardly ashamed at how easily Sunset won over her husband. At how easily lust beat loyalty. She'd heard how many things Sunset had done to people at the school and knew she could very well become another victim of blackmail but... well, most girls with both were infertile right and... Cup Cake was weak. Despite what some people might think. She'd never cheated on her husband... before this. At least she wouldn't have to worry about pregnancy this way.

Sunset nodded softly and gently ran a hand across Cup Cake's cheek "Of course not. You've been nothing but kind to me. Besides. I'm sure Pinkie's told you how I'm trying to turn over a new leaf. Blackmail and all that kind of stuff is behind me."

Cup Cake took a breath and nodded before getting off her stood and kneeling in front of the girl. A part of her expected the typical masculine smell to be strong and there was some, but it wasn't overwhelming. But strangely it affected it just as badly.

She rolled Sunset's balls between her fingers as she kissed along them before beginning to kiss and lick along the shaft. She could feel it starting to harden on her lips and tongue. She could see it getting longer and bigger. She could feel her body getting warmer and her thighs getting damp as the scent and the sight started to affect her more.

Sunset chuckled as she watched the older woman work on getting her hard. What a wonderful sight. Really. If flash had been willing to do half of this, maybe she might have considered asking him out again, he was an alright guy considering he put up with her bitchiness for all that time.

Too bad now she felt like she'd awakened to something completely new. Something she liked far more. All the boys and girls couldn't compare to a pair of mature, motherly lips wrapped around her dick. Which was exactly what Cup Cake was doing. Carefully licking the tip before wrapping around it and moving forward. Moaning slightly as cock disappeared into baker.

Sunset realized that while one hand was still fondling her balls, the other had started doing something else. She moved her head a little to get a better angle and smirked. Cup Cake was fingering herself down there.

Cup Cake continued to bob her head. Angling it slightly each time. Fuck. Yup. Mothers were the best. She was sure of it now. She hadn't thought of it before this but now she totally understood why "Mother I'd Like to Fuck" was too prevalent. Because MILF's were good at it.

She didn't want to waste the night on a blowjob though. She also didn't want to only receive. So, with a gentle hand she cupped under Cup Cakes chin and pulled her cock out of her mouth before guiding her up to stand. "Fuck you're so hot." She said in complete honesty before leaning in and kissing her.

Cup Cake, for her part hadn't felt so attractive in ages. As she felt Sunset's tongue dominate her mouth, her hands grope her chest and her cock grind between her legs. She felt like she was in her early twenties again. Before she met Carrot. Back in her dating days when she could have her pick of any stallion just with a wink. God, she'd yearned to feel like this again. Just for a night.

When the kiss finally broke Cup Cake was left panting "We... we should take this to the bedroom. Carrot brought the kids to their grandparents for the weekend."

Sunset grinned and kissed her again, hands still groping her chest. The girl hadn't lied about how much she liked Cup Cake's chest. "I'll accept that invitation. I'd have to be insane to turn down a weekend with such an attractive woman." She said before getting closer and finally stopping her groping, only to wrap her arms around and grope her as instead as she kissed her neck.

If Cup Cake wasn't already blushing as much as she could then that's exactly what she'd start doing. Sunset just assumed she invited her to a weekend of sex and ... Cup Cake couldn't find a reason to correct her.

"Lead the way, Cup Cake." Sunset whispered into her ear with a hard squeeze of her ass before stepping back with a smirk.

Cup Cake gave a quick nod before turning around and doing exactly that. Leading this girl to the bedroom she'd shared with her husband. The room where only they'd done anything in. Once she opened the door to it, doubts started to creep into her mind. She turned around, only to find Sunset completely nude, her clothes on her arm.

"I prefer being nude. I'm sure that's okay, right?" It was a question but it wasn't asked like one. "Honestly I hope you'd do the same. I'd love to see that body of yours." She cooed and those doubts got drowned out by appreciation.

She blushed "Are you sure? I'm not exactly in shape anymore. All these years of working in a bakery took it's toll on me."

Sunset rolled her eyes and reached down to her dick pulled it upwards and stroking it slowly. "This is what your body does to me with clothes ON." She said before walking behind her and gently slapping it against her ass a few times before reaching under her yellow dress and pulling up.

Cup Cake shivered as Sunset took the initiative. She reached behind and untied the apron she'd forgotten to take off earlier before lifting over her head. By the time she'd tossed it to the floor, Sunset had reached around and undone the buttons in the front of the dress and was kissing along her now slightly exposed light blue shoulders.

"You want me to take it off?" Cup Cake asked, already knowing the answer.

Sunset stepped back and once again made a show of stroking herself "I want to see all of you."

Cup Cake slipped out of dress and was left in simple plain undergarments. Certainly not ones meant to be shown off. Bland and her panties were stained with her arousal. But she wasn't able to worry about how boring they looked, or how her out of shape body looked since Sunset wasted no time in rushing over and groping any part she could get her hands on. The bra didn't stand a chance. No bra did when faced against a woman who proudly declared themselves "Bi as fuck".

Sunset got around to the front and her lips latched onto Cup Cakes nipple a moment later and a moan quickly followed as warm liquid flowed in. That reminded Sunset that Cup Cake was still breastfeeding her kids. They would probably have been weaned off that soon, so Sunset felt a little lucky to have gotten to try this at least once.

Sunset gently kissed along Cup Cakes body as she went lower and lower until she got to the bland panties. They were next to go. But before that she stood back up and gently pushed the woman back onto the bed.

Sunset looked down at the older woman spread across the bed, face red, hair a mess, one nipple still slightly leaking and panties drenched. "You're so hot. So fucking hot." She said with a smile. "I'm so lucky." She said before pulling the panties down and off, tossing them... somewhere. It didn't matter as she got to her knees and finally returned the favor that Cup Cake had given her earlier.

"W-wai-Ngh~! Mmmm~"

"Hm?" Sunset looked up from between Cup Cakes legs with a raised brow. She wasn't sure if Cup Cake didn't like being ate out. If she didn't, she was more than willing to stop. Her throbbing cock would be happy to get to the main show, after all.

Cup Cake shook her head "N-never mind. Go ahead." She mumbled, putting a knuckle to her mouth and gently biting. How long had it been since she'd been ate out? It wasn't that Carrot was unwilling to do it. He was just... really bad at it. His tongue was short and his skill was lacking. On the other hand, Sunset knew exactly what she was doing and it was as if her tongue was as long as a certain lead singer and bassist's. It was hitting every good spot inside her.

Cup Cake squirmed on the bed, grabbing at the sheets as her toes curled. She could feel her orgasm building up inside of her. How long had it been? Not just for an orgasm that didn't have to do with a toy or her own fingers? But for this good of one? It'd been way too long.

She moaned and squirmed.

Sunset pulled back for a moment, causing Cup Cake's head to shoot up, eyes wide "Wh- why'd you stop?" She asked desperately.

"Two reasons." Sunset began, licking arousal from her lips "One. You're holding back. You're staying quiet but you don't have to. I want to hear the amazing noises you make. Two. I want you to ask for it."

Cup Cake stared at her for a moment. Sunset was right about the first one. She was holding back. She'd gotten so used to staying quiet so she didn't wake her husband while masturbating, then so that she didn't wake their children. The second part was just Sunset being selfish. But Cup Cake wanted to cum. "Please Sunset. I want to cum. Please, please, please."

Sunset smiled and dug right back in. No hesitation, no smug reply. She simply ensured that she'd give Cup Cake exactly what she begged for.

"SunSEEEEEEET!" Cup Cake screamed as she wrapped her legs around Sunset's head as she came.

Sunset lapped up the arousal as it came while relishing the sound of her name being screamed by such a hot woman. Who would have thought that breaking down and crying late at night in an empty bakery would result in this?

Once she was released from the weak vice of Cup Cake's legs, Sunset stood up and gently slapped her throbbing cock against her mound. "That was exactly what I wanted to hear Cup Cake." Sunset said with a grin. "I love hearing you shout my name. I love hearing your moans. It's so hot. I know I keep saying it but it's true. You're hot as hell." She said, laying on the compliments thick. But she meant every one of them.

Cup Cake looked down at the large shaft sitting comfortably on top of her mound. She hated to admit how little Carrot could compare. How badly she wanted it. She didn't even want to wait for her body to relax a little. She gulped and shyly looked up at Sunset "I want it."

Sunset grinned and ground her tip against Cup Cake's-soaked lips. "Cum again?" She asked with a chuckle.

"Ngh~ F- fuck~ I want you inside me Sunset. Please. I don't want to beg. Please." Cup Cake pleaded.

Sunset chuckled and slapped her cock down a couple more times, but this time against her lips themselves, relishing the gasp and moan she got in return. She pushed herself inside without waiting for another request and was happy to find it welcoming. It was still loose, thanks to her recent pregnancy. But likely due to their lack of intimacy, it had tightened up enough to be just tight enough to be perfect around her.

"Mmm~ you feel amazing~" Sunset moaned out.

Cup Cake gasped and moaned as she groped herself "S-shush. I'm probably so loose. I had twins recently."

Sunset chuckled as she started moving her hips "It's been, what? Almost a year? I bet you two haven't been doing it much since then either." Cup Cake's silence (outside of moans and grunts) told her all she needed to know) "So, honestly? Right now, you're perfect for me. Actually perfect. Not too loose but not too tight." She moaned loudly again, not even giving a single thought to holding her voice back "It's like it was made for me~"

Cup Cake could feel as Sunset started to speed up and her own voice started to leak out more and more.

That was exactly what Sunset wanted though. She leaned forward, groping the mother and kissing her as she quickly moved with shallow thrusts. "I told you Cup Cake. Let it out. I want to hear you moan like you did earlier. No one's here but us." She said before kissing her again and backing away. Her thrusts slowed down again but went back to their former long, hard movements. She could hear as her balls slapped against Cup Cakes generous ass with each thrust.

"Ngh, ahh~." Cup Cake moaned out, her volume increasing as Sunset's words finally started to really make their way into her mind. She was the one who told Sunset that the building was empty. It was just habit that caused her to keep to quiet. "Sunset~"

Sunset shivered and groped Cup Cakes sides as she thrust harder still. "Fuck I'm so glad I came here today. I want you more and more every moment." Sunset panted. She could feel herself start to tense up. But she wasn't going to give up that easy. She wasn't going to cum on her own.

She tensed her body and moved her hips faster and harder. Doing her very best to try to push the still sensitive Cup Cake over the edge again. She wanted to ensure that this was as good as possible for both of them.

So, she held on. Somehow, her willpower and biting the inside of her cheek was able to push her far enough. The tell-tale sound of Cup Cake once again screaming her name at the top of her lungs was all the tell Sunset needed to finally let herself go.

Cup Cake could feel it. If she were to compare, Carrot Cake was a sink faucet, while Sunset was a firehose. She could feel her deepest places fill instantly. She could feel it backflow out onto her thighs. That would be a little bit of a mess, but that was apparently part of the plan as Sunset pulled herself out and took aim. Luckily, she avoided the eyes, but Cup Cake quickly felt glazed.

By the time she opened her eyes, Sunset was already there, kissing her deeply. There was another taste there and it only took a moment to realize that she'd scooped out a mouthful of her own seed to share.

That was only the first time. They'd gone again before passing out. Apparently, Cup Cake was more pent up than she'd realized since Sunset was woken up by a morning blowjob. Of course, she returned the favor right away. She lost count of how many times they did it from then on. She was sure they fucked in the shower once. Fucked in the kitchen once. Cup Cake's curiosity won out and Sunset (with the help of very generous magic to ease the process) fucked her ass... somewhere. There was more oral. Well, overall, it was safe to say she had fucked Cup Cake in that building far more than her husband had. There was something kind of hot about all that. She'd even managed to swap contact info at some point between all of it.

As hot as it all was and as turned on as she was just looking at that mare again in pictures, Sunset wasn't an idiot. She knew the mare might have considered it a mistake. They hadn't had any contact past customer service in the last nine months. She wouldn't be surprised if she didn't want anything to do with her.

She sighed and looked at the contact once again and sighed. There was no reason not to ask. As horrible as a person as she was inside for her thoughts on Carrot Cake caring for her child unknowingly, she didn't want to ruin the family they had built up. She was just... selfish. She didn't want to lose the connection she'd felt she'd made with Cup Cake.

So, she sent the message:

"This is Sunset. I was just wondering if I could meet your daughter. She looks pretty adorable from all that Pinkie has been posting. I completely understand if you want to keep it to a minimum though."

There. It was simple, it sounded normal, and no one would think it odd at all.

But then she got a reply.

She hated getting nervous. The feeling sucked and she knew it was all mental but couldn't help it.

She took a breath and unlocked her phone.

"She is. Come see her."

Author's Note

Eh. I dunno. I kinda lost steam for it like 3/4ths of the way through but I REALLY liked the idea for this. Cause when I thought about it, it made total sense or something. I dunno.

whatevs. Sorry for the mess.