A Cheery Household Herd

See, I left as a classic fakeout tactic in order to give Diavolo a false sense of security. If she really was on the up and up, then I’d have to see for myself when she thinks she isn’t being watched.

And that’s why I was on the roof of the building, having climbed up here via a grappling hook…which was really just a bunch of rope tied to an old fishing pole, but still. I made my way downstairs through the door on the top floor, and snuck into the building…

As Pale made his way through, his ear flicked when he heard a conversation in the distance in on one of the lower floors. “...”

“...don’t-a get cushy with an officer,” a familiar voice boomed, “He’ll be the one to take you away from everything that you’ve ever wanted. That’s not-a what you want…is it, my dear?”

“...N-no…” he heard Suri reply.

“Good-a. Don’t you forget it. Around here, I give the orders. The girls and I are prepping to bring in some new stuff tonight, so you better keep-a quiet, understand? You know what’ll happen if you don’t…”

Suri spoke up in a panicked state. “Y-yes, ma’am. I got it, okay?”

“Hmph. You’re dismissed for the day.”

And with that, the conversation ended, and Suri began to walk downstairs towards the front lobby where she’d eventually leave the building.

Pale made a mental note to ask one of his crewmates to perform a sweep of this place, but wanted to check on Suri first.

“If there’s evidence to be found, I need to talk to her.”

Pale would tail Suri back to her apartment complex--the fifth floor and in the middle of a hallway of brown carpet and white walls. He knocked on the door he watched her enter, and she answered moments later.

“Uhh…Pale?” she asked as she stuck her head out of the door, “Is everything alright?”

“...Not really, no. I saw everything.”

Suri’s pupils shrank as she bit her lip, then she sighed and relented. “...dammit. I can’t hide anything from Equestria’s greatest detective, eh?”

“Is that what they’re calling me now?” Pale shook his head and got back on topic. “Look. If you tell me what’s going on, I can guarantee your safety. If not, then…”

Suri cut him off, “Okay okay! Look, just…come inside, ‘kay?”

Pale entered her studio apartment, to which Suri quickly shut the door behind him.

“...Alright, I’ll tell ya everything I know, ‘kay? Just so long as you do me a favor in return.”

“And that would be--hey?!”

Suddenly, Suri invaded his personal space by rushing up to him and pressing her snout against his. “Fuck me like a whorse! I can’t stand this life anymore, but I…kinda wanna know that it’s like’ta have sex with a stallion that won’t beat me.”

“Wait what?” Pale took a literal step back followed by a figurative one. “Hold the phone--could that be the reason why you were so rude to Coco Pommel in the past? You were accustomed to an abusive relationship and didn’t know how to express yourself otherwise--is that close?”

“...I guess?” Suri idly dragged one of her hooves on the floor, “The guy that hurt me is in jail now, so don’t worry. But I uh…” she tilted her head with a nervous, wide smile on her face and continued, “I may have heard about your little herd from a certain someone we both know.”

All Pale could do was roll his eyes and sigh, but then he gave it some more thought.

“...while she is desperate, it’s clear that her life has gone through a series of ups and downs that won’t be easily resolved anytime soon. That is of course, unless I offer to take her into my safety directly and watch over her as best I can.”

Suri spoke up, “...Ya don’t have to, ‘kay? I was just kinda messin’ around. I’m…kinda ugly anyway, so…”

“...Don’t sell yourself so short,” he replied, “You’re rather good-looking and I’ll be happy to help you. So long as we can crack this case open.”

Her face lit up with a hopeful smile. “So…you don’t mind bangin’ me?”

“...I suppose I can deal with it, yes,” he muttered through his teeth, though he was actually interested in giving her some much-needed comfort anyway. After all, Suri had never known true safety…until now that is.

“Great, cuz there’s this sick thing I’ve been itching to try out but could never find a guy willing to do it with me--” Suri rushed off to a nearby closet…

That’s when Pale reached into his coat and took out the device that Moondancer gave him. “Well…may as well see how it works in the field.”

With a quick activation of the Anthros Necklace…

Pale soon found himself in his anthro form once again, albeit this time with some clothes--specifically boxer briefs.

Suri was also in an anthro form. Her entire body was rather well-rounded with plump, perky breasts, thick, flabby thighs, and a decently sized butt that jiggled. The items she got from her closet conformed to her body and adjusted to being lingerie--specifically a black set of garter straps attached to stockings. Her thighs were so thick that they spilled out over her stockings and the garter straps were clinging tightly to her body and sinking into her skin a little.

And on her upper half, Suri wore a black corset that also clung to her body and was barely able to contain her breasts. “Mm…is this some kinda magic? I think I like it,” she said with her usual giggle. “‘Kay, now hold still with your eyes shut, ‘kay?”

Pale shut his eyes…and found himself tied to a chair via rope with his legs spread apart.

“Open ‘em.”

And when he opened his eyes, he watched as Suri drew her foot against his crotch--her heel pressed against the bottom of his shaft as her polished, freshly pedicured toes grinding against his tip.

“M…M-Ms Polomare…” he huffed, “Is this what you’ve been looking to do to me this whole time?”

“Well duh,” she added with a snarky grin as she continued to press her foot against his shaft that was slowly hardening, “Who wouldn’t wanna bag the world’s greatest detective? And now you’re all mine~” she said with a wink.

“Gahh…do what you please, heathen,” Pale replied with a huff as his member swelled within the boxers--pitching a tent in the process, “Ngh…I’m only doing this for the sake of helping you get to safety.”

“Mkaaaaay, but is that the real reason?” Suri teased him as she continued to grind her foot against his hard shaft--the added friction from his member being stroked off within the fabric of the underwear caused him to moan, much to Suri’s delight. “‘Cuz it sounds like you enjoy this whole ‘mustang’ lifestyle where you get to fuck multiple mares.” She then pushed his member down, placing her foot on top of it where she proceeded to grind his shaft into the seat. “Ain’t that right~?”

“Arrrgh…” Pale growled from the way her foot teased his shaft within the undies. His erection was still growing and slowly tearing the pair of blue briefs apart at the seams! “M-maybe…s-so what?”

“You don’t wanna admit that you love it,” Suri went on, and teased him further by leaning over and jiggling her pink, corset-clad cleavage in front of his face. “You wanna fuck ‘em all in a big orgy…all those mares praising as their harem master with your wife Cheerilee loving on you…”

Pale really didn’t want to admit to that as he adamantly shook his head. “N-no…I-I…aaaah~!”

But it was hard to resist when Suri used her toes to pull back the boxers and fully expose Pale’s large, girthy, pulsating shaft. “Well, looks like your other head is honest at least,” she said with her usual giggle as she squeezed the tip of his cock with her toes--expanding and contracting them to further stimulate him with her pristine, silky digits. “Just admit it, ‘kay?”

“F-fuck…that’s too good…” he gasped and started to pant as he watched her toes continuously grab at the tip of his member--as if she was trying to pull his orgasm up and out of his testes. Something that could likely be attributed to her skill with attention to detail with her earth pony magic.

“Well?” she asked as she sped up her actions, stimulating him with her toes even faster. “What’s it gonna be? You gonna be honest or what, Pale?”

“O-okay, yes!” he yelped, “I-I want it badly…just please let me cum on those feet of yours…”

“Good boy~!” Suri would oblige as she sat on the side of the bed and wrapped both of her feet around his shaft, now stroking him off with all ten of her silky toes at once. “Now give it to me, ‘kay?”

“Arrrrghhh~!”

With her toes gripping at his shaft tightly with every stroke, Pale couldn’t put up a fight any longer and spewed perfectly straight lines of semen onto her legs and feet as he moaned aloud. Suri kept ahold of him--squeezing his shaft with her toes to force his cum out as if she were violently choking a tube of toothpaste--forcing him to give up everything he had for the moment with thick globs of white landing on her legs.

“Damn…” Suri raised her feet and watched as his seed dripped off of her legs with an impressed, smug smile on her face with half-lidded eyes. “You’re a real bronco, huh Pale? I can see why so many mares want you~”

“Gaaagh…would you please just give me the information now?” he asked bashfully, trying his best to avoid looking at the rest of her body.

But Suri wouldn’t let him have it so easily. “Aw, c’mon, Pale. Didja really think I’d give in after one orgasm when I know you can do more than that?” she commented while gazing at him intently, licking her lips.

Pale puffed out his cheeks in response. He couldn’t deny that his member was still fully erect and demanding more of her attention. Something that Suri’s dripping pussy was all too eager to enjoy.

“Argh…fine…but you better hold up your end of the deal,” he grumbled.

“I promise I will, mkay?” she undid the ropes that bound his body and gave him a simple command, “Now get on the bed.”

Meanwhile, just outside in the hallway…

“Now where in the hell is he?” Babs muttered to herself as she listened in closely to each apartment building’s door. “C’mon, Babs--if ya can’t keep a promise ya mad to his wife then what the hell are ya doin’...?”

Luckily, she wouldn’t have to worry for too much longer. Some familiar voices soon came into earshot as she rounded the corner to approach the next set of apartment doors.

“Wait a minute…what’s goin’ on ova here?”

She could hear faint gasps and moans coming from one of the doors, to which she approached. But as soon as Babs entered the radius of the spell…

Wooosh!

Her body changed to that of a typical ‘biker’ girl once she became anthropomorphic. Babs now wore a leather jacket on her upper half which was unzipped and exposed her muscular, chiseled abdomen which was rounded out by a sizable pair of breasts contained by a gray sports bra alongside gray shorts and purple sneakers.

“What in the mothasuckin’--is this some kinda weirdo freakazoid magic or sumthin’?” she commented as she looked over her body, but she knew she wouldn’t find an answer by simply standing around outside, so she took her newfound hand and twisted the knob to open the door…

Plap--plap--plap--!

“Augh! Yes…grab my milkers, and cum a lot, mkay~?”

Suri had been riding Pale’s stiff cock with reckless abandon, moaning to the heavens as she came down upon him each time. Her wet pussy left a shiny sheen along his cock that made it easy for her to bounce herself up and down upon him. As soon as she spoke, she pulled the corset down to expose her breasts and grabbed Pale’s hands and brought them up to her jiggling bosoms, encouraging him to grope and squeeze them as she rode him.

“Yeah, you like that, don’tcha~?!” Suri squealed as soon as his hands met her plump breasts. She then put her hands behind her head and struck a pose, winking at him while biting her lip as her hips continuously rose and fell upon his shaft.

“S-so damn hot…aughhh…" Pale moaned as he maintained his grip on Suri's breasts--holding her tits tightly--squeezing them and rolling his hands around the curvature of each one.

Suri would then up the ante by grabbing ahold of his wrists, forcing him to grope her further. “C’mon--treat me like your slut, ‘kay? Ahh…mmm…I’m yours, Mr. Detective~!”

Pale’s cock was throbbing and leaking precum as Suri pounded and impaled herself upon him. Her tight walls combined with her repeated speed made it difficult to hold back as his balls swelled from the way her ass slammed down upon them.

“F-fine…you’re miiiine~!!” he squealed as he neared his orgasm from the mare’s powerful slams.

Suri increased her speed further and leaned forward, placing her hands on Pale’s chest to reciprocate the act that she placed onto him--her nipples became erect and started leaking milk all over his face from the state of sheer arousal she was in. And finally… “Omigoooosh~!”

They both came together--Suri slowed to a stop as Pale filled her womb with his cum with her vaginal walls strangling everything out of him, making sure his cum was nearly completely extracted.

And to finish, she raised her hips up, and let the fluids run down Pale’s erect shaft. “...Fuuuck…you’re so damn, good~!” she squealed as she moved Pale’s arms out of the way and brought him into a hug, burying the stallion’s face in her cleavage.

“Mmmph!” Pale squealed in return from both the intense orgasm and the comforting hug, pursing his lips around one of her nipples out of instinct.

Meanwhile, in the corner of the room…

“Goddamn, yo…ya’ll fuckin’ hot…” Babs breathed warmly as she rubbed herself off with one hand in her shorts and her other hand groping herself under her sports bra which caught the attention of both anthro-ponies on the bed.

“...Babs? You’re under the spell too, huh? Shit, my bad…” Pale apologized with a soft shudder.

“Nah, don’t worry aboudid,” Babs replied with a chuckle, “I’m a bit jelly’ta be honest.”

Suri then made a proposal, “Wanna join in?”

Pale simply yelped, “Wait wait--?!”

Meanwhile, in Madison Mare Garden…

Cheerilee was relaxing herself at one of the spas and talking to another mare that was next to her in a hot tub.

“...and that’s basically how you get a room full of crazy foals to calm down,” she finished an explanation.

“Oh wow,” a purple mare with a blonde mane and a pair of glasses on her face, “You’re a real trooper you know that? Now if only I could control a stallion for half as long,” she added with a half-hearted chuckle.

That’s when Cheerilee had an idea, “Well…there might be a solution for that.”

Back with Pale and the gals…

“Okay, Suri--tell us everything you know first,” Pale insisted as he sat up on the edge of the bed.

Suri sat beside him and started off, “Well, to make a long story short, I think I’m working for the mob but I’m not sure. Ms. Diavolo doesn’t seem like she’s a bad pony, but…” she looked away with a regretful expression on her face.

“But…?”

“I’m scared…she kinda talks down to me like I don’t matter to her. Every day and night it’s just--” Suri’s eyes went wide as she realized what she had put Coco through all those years ago. “...Oh shit.”

“It’s hit, hasn’t it?” Pale asked, pulling her in for a hug, “Listen, I’m primed to start investigating once nightfall hits, but we have to make sure you lay low until then. Understand?”

Suri nodded silently. “Got it. Thanks so much, ‘kay?”

“It’s my job--think nothing of it,” Pale replied, then looked at Babs. “Alright--what should we--”

Babs had removed her new leather jacket, leaving her in just her sports bra and shorts as she approached Pale. “Since we ain’t goin’ nowhere until lata--may as well have some fun, yeah? Ain’t fair that she got some’a ya without me.”

Suri giggled as she grabbed ahold of Pale’s shaft and started to stroke him up and down with her hand. “She’s right ya know~”

“Gghh…” Pale bit his lip and sighed, “If it means that you’re under my watch…then I suppose-”

Suddenly, Babs grabbed ahold of Pale and stuffed his head under her sports bra and in between her cleavage. “Brudda--you betta take responsibility. My tits are now up here and they sweatin’ like hell in these clothes!”

Babs’s breasts were much firmer and larger than Suri’s to the point where Pale found himself lost in a sea of darkness and cold sweat from the anthropomorphic earth pony mare’s body.

“Mmmghghg….” Pale sighed happily and drew his tongue across her chest, lapping up whatever sweat he could. The result was a firm erection that would harden in Suri’s hand as the latter continued to stroke him off.

“He can still keep going? Impressive as hell, Big P~”

Babs snickered at the nickname, “I like dat. ‘Big Daddy P’ eh?” she lifted her chest off of Pale’s face, leaving the anthro stallion covered in sweet apple sweat. “How about it?”

“Gghgh…please don’t embarrass me like that…” he humbly replied. “I-I don’t need a crazy title or anything like that. I’m kinda over it--gah!”

Babs had gotten down on her knees and, with her fingerless gloved-hand, grabbed ahold of his girthy shaft and started jerking him off--slowly pumping her hand up and down the length of his equine cock.

“Damn, bro,” Babs commented as she continued to idly stroke his cock with her right hand, “You ain’t eva told me you was this huge. Ya wife must be unable’ta walk straight when ya done.”

“W-well…sometimes--hrrk!” Pale squealed as Babs tightened the grip of her hand, using some of her athletic, mane-cutting earth pony strength to attack the nerves in his cock. “B-Babs!”

“Oh, ya like that, don’tcha? Knew ya would~” And without warning, she took his cock in her mouth, causing Pale to throw his head back and moan passionately as Babs forced her way down to the base of his shaft. “Mmm…gghkk!” she grunted through it and ultimately managed it, then pulled back halfway so that she could jerk him off from the lower halfway point of his cock down to the base with her mouth bobbing back and forth on the front half.

“Damn…dammit…too fuckin’...~! Mmph!”

Suri joined in, holding his face against her breasts but just barely so that he could still watch Babs please him. “I told ya you’d want this, ‘kay? Just let us treat you right~”

“Gahhhhgh…fuck you both…” Pale huffed defiantly as he forced his lips onto Suri’s, lovingly smooching her and moaning into her mouth from Babs’ treatment.

“Mmm..mmm…” Babs used her left hand to continuously rub herself off with her fingers as she jerked Pale off. When she felt his orgasm brewing, she pulled her sports bra down below her breasts, exposing them to him and further enhancing his arousal by teasing him with them. She then pulled his cock out of her mouth, and angled it straight at herself, pointing directly at her naked breasts. “Ya gonna be a fair playa and gimme some too, or do I hafta beat it outta ya?”

“N-no! Agh!” the threat was admittedly arousing for Pale--evidenced by his heavy gasps. He watched as Babs furiously and speedily stroked his cock back and forth towards her tanned breasts which the mare was now teasing him with by pushing them closer and closer to his cock. “Yes…yes…I’m…cumming Baaabs~!!”

And he did--spraying a thick, hot load of white all over Babs’ tits--rope after rope of see coated both of her tan bosoms as Pale moaned to the ceiling. Suri would add to this by kissing along his neck and rubbing one of her hands in circles along his pectoral muscles.

“Hell yeah, brotha!” Babs cheered and quickly followed up by putting her sports bra back on to conceal and encase her breasts which made her cleavage that much tighter. She then brought his cock beneath them and pushed it through her tight, sweaty cleavage and started mashing each of her breasts together with her hands, forcing extra pressure onto his cock as she took them up and down his shaft. “Gimme it all~!”

“S-shit--I can’t…gaaaagh~!”

Yet again, he’d continue cumming, spurting hard and getting more of his hot seed all over her tits as Babs used the power of her cleavage to wring him dry as she put her mouth over his tip to drink up the rest. Lastly, she’d pull her bra down once more to show off how much of his seed had coated her tits and dripped down her cleavage along his shaft…

“...Ghhhfhfh…” Pale huffed and panted with drool leaking from his lips and his hands clutching onto the bedsheets. “...Alright…y-you win…” Pale deactivated the amulet used for the spell, reverting them all back to normal ponies…

Which he quickly took advantage of.

Before the mares could blink, Pale had flung Suri on her back, and Babs on top of her, placing both mares together with their pussies and clits rubbing against each other.

“Agh! What’s the deal?!” Suri yelped.

“H-hey, brudda I was just--eek!” Babs squealed as Pale slapped her flank with his hoof.

“Enough of this,” he huffed as he shoved his cock between both of their pussies--effectively sandwiching himself between them, “You’re my assistants on this case and you’ll do what I say, understand?”

Both mares gasped as Pale ravaged their clits--he fucked them both with all that he had, causing the bed to shake underneath them.

“Augh!” Babs shut one of her eyes and turned her head to look at Pale over her shoulder as her body rippled from the force of his cock. “Agh…mmm…t-that all ya got--yowza!”

Suddenly, he focused solely upon her, and started fucking her sweet apple pussy. It was a tight fit due to how well-built Babs was, but Pale took it as a challenge. Her walls refused to let him go and were clamping down upon him so tightly that it was a battle just to get to her womb.

“S-shit…” Pale moaned as he found himself in a loop of shifting his hips back and forth with his hooves on Babs’ ass--gripping her scissors’ cutie marks. “So…c-close….”

Suri was feeling the pressure from Pale striking Bab’s innards--as their clits were still rubbing against each other and driving her close to another orgasm. “Damn, he’s good~! We need’ta keep him around, ‘kay?”

But Babs was unable to reply as she had fully given in to Pale’s cock. As she lied upon Suri’s body, she started actively thrusting and shaking her hips left and right, bouncing her massive, firm pony ass against his pelvis. Her eyes started rolling back as she moaned aloud with her tongue hanging from her mouth.

“Yeahyeahyeahyeah! Wreck mah fuckin’ pusssyyyyy~!!”

“Grrrrgh~!” Pale had finally managed to pierce to Babs’ womb and immediately felt an entire thick, pastey load of his seed leave his body. Babs’ pussy walls were so strong that she took all of his seed in an instant, and left his balls dry!

“AUGH~!” Suri had also squirted underneath Babs from the pressure of Pale’s thrusts combined with their clits rubbing each other off. The end result was a mixture of fluids from all three ponies dripping down their asses and onto the floor as Babs lied atop Suri and started to smooch her on the lips.

“Damn…” Pale pulled out and finally felt satisfied with the result. Especially now that he had all the evidence he needed. “...I’ll let you two rest. I need to get ready to raid this place tonight.”

As soon as he finished speaking, he saw that both mares were fast asleep and finally tired from all they had been through from Pale and his cock.

Pale took out a candy cigarette from his coat, and bit into it as he left the room. “...Good. Stay safe you two.”