Who Hitch loves

by Timothy1509

Rating: teen
Tags: Romance, Sunny Starscout, Comedy, Hitch Trailblazer, My Little Pony: A New Generation, Zipp Storm, Slice of Life, Izzy Moonbow, Pipp Petals
Length: 2592

Hitch decides on which mare he loves the most.

Hitch Trailblazer was doing his casual patrol and stroll through Maretime Bay like he always does everyday as the sheriff. However, this day is when events get more intriguing when the sheriff receives many gifts and assistance from the four mares who are trying to win his love. Will this be a pleasant day?

New story! I hope you all will enjoy this one! Also, I do not own My Little Pony, it belongs to Hasbro.

Published 2022-07-08 13:40:00 UTC
Last updated 2022-07-08 13:40:00 UTC

Which mare will it be?

Maretime Bay 10:00am

It was a bright and sunny day in Maretime Bay, home to the earth ponies. The earth ponies, unicorns and pegasus were all seen having a chat with one another, doing work, having a stroll and many more like usual in this peaceful world of their ever since the reunification. Life was perfect for these ponies after they also found peace with one another after Maretime Bay day and apologized to one another for their bitterness against one another and commencing a controversy between each species.

On a street of Maretime Bay, sheriff Hitch Trailblazer was seen doing his causal patrol shift as usual as the sheriff of Maretime Bay, he must enforce the law and corroborate the safety of his pony citizens from certain hazards that may arise in an unpredictable manner.

"Wow, what a lovely day it is." Hitch said breathing I the fresh air, exhailing in the process. "I wonder what this day might bring today?" He asked himself.

Suddenly, the sheriff felt a sudden tingling sensation in his throat doe to the sore dryness that is slowly beginning to take over, as well as some sweat forming on his forehead.

"Wow, it sure is hot today." Hitch said wiping the sweat off of his forehead. "I just need something good to drink in order to soothe my throat and rehydrate myself." He told himself.

"Hello Hitch!"

When Hitch heard the familiar voice, he looked to his left to see his friend Sunny Starscout walking up to him with a bottle of smoothie in her hooves, she was also giving him a smile.

"Oh, hello Sunny, what brings you here?"

"Hello Hitch." Sunny greeted back with a blush due to how handsome he looked. "I just saw you here seeming very thirsty so therefore, I decided to drop by and give you this smoothie that I made specially for you." She told him.

"Wow, thank you so much Sunny." Hitch said as he grabbed the cup of smoothie. After that, he bit onto the straw area and began to sip the entire smoothie in order to rehydrate himself.

During the process, Sunny was seen blushing at the sight of how handsome Hitch looked even when drinking that cup of smoothie. She will surely win his heart and become his wife, having a strong, smart and kind colt in the process which she always wanted. Ten seconds later, Hitch has finished drinking all of the smoothies and exhaled a pleasant breath. After that, he looked at Sunny with a pleasant and grateful smile.

"Thank you so much Sunny, your smoothies are amazing. You even did a good deed today." Hitch said as he petted Sunny's head gently with his right hoof as well as rubbing her right cheek.

"You're welcome Hitch." Sunny cooed as she began to feel warm due to Hitch's gentle rub on her right cheek.

However, not far from where the two were, there were three mares known as Izzy, Pipp and Zipp peeking out at the two behind a house with angry expressions.

"Grr, how dare she?" Zipp asked while gritting her teeth.

"She just got lucky." Izzy said.

"She won't win." Pipp said.

In an electronics shop located in Maretime Bay, there was a crowd of ponies seen lining up to buy the newly released wireless earbuds that is currently trending in Maretime Bay, Bridlewood and Zephyr Heights. At the back of the line was Hitch Trailblazer who was seen waiting as patiently as he could so that he could buy the earbuds.

"Aww, what a line. There is no way that I'm going to make it and buy the newly released earbuds."

"Hey Hitch, you don't have to wait in that silly line."

Hitch looked to his left to see Pipp standing there in front of him with a smile on her muzzle, she was also seen holding a bag I'm front of him.

"Oh, hello Pipp, what do you have here?"

"It's a present for you so that you don't have to line up in that stupid line." Pipp told him.

Hitch then looked at the bag with a perplexed expression before shrugging and grabbing itm after that, he looked inside to see what is inside it. When he did, his eyes widened when he saw what it was, inside was the newest released earbuds that he wanted.

"Whoa! Thanks a lot Pipp, but, how did you get this so quick?"

"Oh its nothing Hitch. It's all thanks to me having the access to everything first due to me being a royal." Pipp replied with a giggle.

"Wow, either than that, thanks a bunch." Hitch said petting her head with his left hoof.

"You're welcome Hitch." Pipp said with a warm smile due to how lovely her crush Hitch is petting her on the head. She is just eager for him to become her prince.

However, unknown to the two, three mares known as Sunny, Izzy, and Zipp were seen peeking at them behind a building shooting Pipp an angry glare.

"Grr, how could she buy that for him so quick?!" Sunny asked in an angry tone.

"I was going to give that to him!" Zipp said.

"She is just lucky because, she is a royal." Izzy said with a pout.

On a street in Maretime Bay, Hitch Trailblazer was seen making his way to the donut shop for some replenishment due to how hungry he currently is after patrolling the streets for at least three hours. Now, he deserves a well earned break.

"I wonder what flavour of donut I'm gonna go for today?" Hitch asked himself.

But, just as he made it to the donut shop, he noticed that it is now unfortunately closed due to the owner of the shop going to have lunch for himself. The sight made Hitch frown in disappointment.

"Oh come on." Hitch said with an aggravated expression. "Where am I supposed to eat now?" He asked himself again. Luckily, help was on the way.

"Hey Hitch!"

Hitch looked to his right to the source of the familiar voice to see Izzy walking up to him with a purple box in her hooves.

"Oh hi Izzy, what do you have here?"

Izzy replied by standing in front of him with a smile before flipping open the box, revealing six donuts inside of it, three chocolate flavours on left, and three strawberry flavours on the right. The sight made Hitch's eyes widen.

"These are for you Hitch. I figured that you might be hungry during your shift." Izzy said in a sweet tone.

"Wow, thanks a lot Izzy." Hitch said with a smile as she petted Izzy's head, making her giggle in the process. She just can't wait to marry him and have a daughter or a son!

However, just behind a building were Sunny, Pipp and Zipp who were seen shooting Izzy a glare.

"Grr, I was going to give him food after forcing that employer out of his shop temporarily by coming up with an excuse!" Pipp said in anger.

"I was going to do the same!" Sunny said with an angry expression.

"She just got to him before us, that's all." Zipp said while gritting her teeth.

In the sheriff's station in Maretime Bay, Hitch Trailblazer was seen mopping and cleaning up his entire station before concluding his shift for the day so that he could rest for the day after a ton of hard work.

"Geez, this is gonna take a while to clean up." Hitch said.

Them, the doors of the station were pushed opened by somepony. Hitch looked to the doors to see his friend Zipp standing there with a smile.

"Hello Hitch, I see that you're having a troubled time with cleaning up the sheriff station."

"Hello Zipp, and yeah, it is quite a mess right now, it might take me a while." Hitch told her.

"You know what Hitch? Allow me to assist you with this job." Zipp offered.

"Oh no no no, it's okay Zipp I can handle-"

Hitch wasn't able to finish his sentence when Zipp zoomed towards him rapidly and snatched the broom out of his right hoof. After that, she began to clean the entire station rapidly as quickly as she could which made Hitch impressed at how fast she could fly.

Ten seconds later, Zipp has finished cleaning the entire station, leaving no dusts in the area too.

Hitch looked around the station to see that it was sparkling clean with the files stacked up nicely on his desk, the couch was placed perfectly and many more.

"Wow, thanks a lot Zipp." Hitch said in a grateful tone as he walked to her. "You sure did made me appreciative today." He told her as he gently began to pet her on her head.

"Thank you Hitch." Zipp cooed.

However, just outside of the office were Sunny, Pipp and Izzy who were seen looking through the window frame area of the sheriff station, glaring at Zipp.

"How could she beat me to here?" Sunny asked.

"She is cheating." Izzy said.

"She finished it all due to her being so hasty." Pipp said.

Maretime Bay 9:00pm

It is now late at night in Maretime Bay, the ponies were all seen returning home to call it a night as well as have some dinner with their families.

On a dirt track that leads to the Crystal Brighthouse, aka the home of Sunny, Hitch, Izzy, Pipp and Zipp. Hitch Trailblazer was seen making his way back home while carrying shopping bags with him to pay the mares back for helping him for today when he needs them.

"I hope the girls will all love these." Hitch said.

Once the sheriff made it to the front doors of his and the mares house, he pulled the right one open with his right hoof and stepped in, closing the door behind him. He then looked in front of him to see that Sunny, Izzy, Pipp and Zipp were there in the living room or in the kitchen, the sight has made him perplexed.

"Huh? Where did they all go?"

Then, the sheriff got his answer when he heard the sounds of crashing and thumping coming straight from the mares bedrooms.

"Huh, what's going on up there?"

Then, Hitch slowly began to make his way to the mares bedrooms to see what was happening.

In the mares bedroom of the Crystal Brighthouse, the mares Sunny Starscout, Izzy Moonbow, Pipp Petals and Zipp Storm were all seen brawling each other out due to their own personal reasons as well as their envy and anger at one another for trying to win Hitch's heart in a very selfish way.

"Hitch loves me the most!" Pipp yelled as she punched Sunny in the face while on top of her.

"No he doesn't! We were friends ever since I was a filly and when he was a colt meaning that we're destined to marry one another!" Sunny yelled pushing Pipp's face with her right hoof.

"In your dreams Sunny! Hitch and I spent more time with each other helping each other with our needs while you just lazily sit on your stupid butt on the couch watching TV and eating pancakes and snacks!" Zipp insulted while underneath Sunny trying to punch her in the back of her head.

"You three are always envious and against one another as well as resorting in using violence as a solution! Hitch will never pick any of you three!" Izzy exclaimed hitting Zipp's left hoof while she was underneath the three mares in the stack. "While I'm the more gentle one, meaning that Hitch would choose me instead of violent brats like you three!" She finished.

"No he won't Izzy!" Sunny, Pipp and Zipp shouted in unison.

As the four mares continued to battle against each other for Hitch's love, they all heard the sounds of their bedroom doors being pulled opened.

"Whoa! What's happening here?"

The four mares looked to the doors of their bedroom to see the stallion of their dreams Hitch standing there right in front of them looking at them all with a shocked expression.

"Ah Hitch!" The mares exclaimed in unison as they all got off each other, standing next to each other in the process. "It's good to see you back!" They all finished with smiles.

"Are you four okay?" Hitch asked as he was scrutinising their wounds with a concerned expression. "Why were you four fighting like that?" He asked again.

"Grr, it's all because of Sunny here who selfishly gave you a smoothie drink to win your heart!" Zipp exclaimed pointing at Sunny.

"Me?! You selfishly assisted Hitch in cleaning the entire station just to win his love too!" Sunny accused back.

"Pipp here also bought the earbuds for you to win your heart as well Hitch because, she is very spoiled!" Izzy accused while pointing at Pipp.

"Excuse me Izzy Moonbow, you even gave Hitch those donuts when you also forced the donut store owner to make up an excuse and close his shop temporarily!" Pipp shouted.

"You did too!" Izzy shouted back.

Hitch was nonplussed to hear all of this. So that's what caused them all to generously help him out with his work as well as giving and buying him what he wants. They all fell in love with him just like how he fell in love with all of them, and are now fighting and competing against one another to win his love and become his wife. As the controversy rages on, Hitch decides to put a stop to it.

"Whoa Whoa Whoa okay, everypony let's break it up shall we?" Hitch told them in a polite tone, and the mares all stopped shouting and accusing one another. "Before we start to dig deeper into the argument, I want to give you all these gifts." He said with a smile.

The mares eyes all widened as they saw Hitch giving them flowers, teddy dolls for mares, heart shaped chocolates and new fashioning equipments that they've always wanted.

"Oh wow, thank you so much Hitch!" The mares said as they grabbed the gifts and set it aside on the floor behind them. "But, what made you buy all of this for us?" They asked.

"It's simple, all you mares have been helping me a lot today with my work and giving and buying me what I want for today so, I decided to return all of that by contributing the similar services back to you all." Hitch replied with a smile. "Besides, all of you are the most pulchritudinous, most kind, and the most cutest mares that I've ever met in my entire life. And if I were to say who I love, I would choose to love each and every single one of you. All of you are awesome." He complimented.

The mares all blushed and squealed in a merriment and gaiety way after hearing Hitch confess their feelings to them all. Then, without warning, the mares all jumped onto their stallion Hitch which caught him off guard as well as making him fall on his back.

"We all love you too Hitchy." The mares said in unison with a smile.

After that, the four mares kissed Hitch on both his cheeks, causing him to blush furiously.

Author's Note

My new story has been accomplished! I hope you all enjoyed it!