Circumstances Permitting

by SigmasonicX

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Fluttershy, Slice of Life, Sex, Twilight Sparkle
Length: 7847

Fluttershy is asexual, but decides it's worth exploring with Twilight what sex means to her

Fluttershy is asexual with two allosexual marefriends, but any issues the pegasus had about that have long been resolved. One day when she's spending time with Twilight, she decides these are the right circumstances to explore what sex means to her.

Note that Fluttershy is asexual for the full duration of the story. Being asexual does not necessarily mean you can't have sex, and this depicts one way that can work out. I myself am asexual and based this story on what made sense to me.

This story started out at T and I intended to cut away before anything happened, but as I figured out the concept more, I realized most of the interesting stuff happened while they had sex. Thus, I ended up writing porn.

Content warnings: honestly it's pretty vanilla other than Twilight magicking up a penis.

Cover art by mellodillo

Published 2022-07-14 19:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2022-07-14 19:00:00 UTC

Like Now

Fluttershy felt the breeze through her mane as she sat in the grass with her wing over Twilight Sparkle’s back.

The itinerary for Twilight’s day in Ponyville was simple: stay at Fluttershy’s cottage for a while, go see the animals at her sanctuary, and then head into town to do whatever they wanted. As hectic as Twilight’s schedule always was, Fluttershy found that sitting around doing nothing was the best present she could give the princess. Especially if it involved cuddling, which it had for the past half hour or so.

It would have been even better with the third part of their throuple, Rarity, but her fashion work was keeping her in Manehattan. In any case, being alone with Twilight carried a quiet tenderness that Fluttershy appreciated.

Twilight pressed against her side and nuzzled against her neck. Fluttershy stifled a giggle as Twilight’s mane tickled her. Twilight moved further up and Fluttershy planted a kiss on her cheek.

Twilight blushed, prompting a smile and a wink from Fluttershy. Then, the pegasus closed her eyes and leaned forward. Twilight’s soft lips met her own, sending a thrill up her spine. The kiss was light and, as an asexual mare, Fluttershy didn’t particularly get physical excitement from it, but it was just nice to be kissed like this and know her partner enjoyed it too.

As Fluttershy pulled back, she felt the alicorn follow her as though she were the only source of warmth in a blizzard. However, her pleading lips quickly relented. When Fluttershy opened her eyes and gazed into Twilight’s, she briefly saw the embers of desire before they faded away.

“That was nice,” the princess said with an easy smile. After a moment, she added, “So, did you want to head over to the animal sanctuary? You mentioned there was a new otter there.” Before Fluttershy could respond, Twilight slid away and got up. She splayed out her wings and stretched her legs. “We’ve been sitting for a while, huh?”

Fluttershy smiled gently as she stood. “Twilight, there’s no need to hurry, we can just sit some more if you’d like.”

She shook her head. “Oh no, I’m fine. I just want to make sure there’s enough time to see everything.”

Fluttershy hummed. Whenever they kissed, Twilight would always suggest they do something else before they got too into it. Her eyes widened. Actually, now that she actually thought about it, it was obvious what was going on. Twilight didn’t want their kissing to go too far!

On one hoof, this was a compassionate move. Fluttershy was just dabbling in physical intimacy, so she truly appreciated the care that Twilight took in making sure she never got uncomfortable. On the other hoof…

Why was she only dabbling?

She started slowly because she feared she’d be uncomfortable, but she wasn’t. She kept to mild kisses out of habit and because neither Rarity nor Twilight asked for more, but she was sure that wasn’t all she could do. She was comfortable enough remaining where they were, but she didn’t like the idea that Twilight would have to restrain herself like this. Plus, Fluttershy couldn’t help but wonder…

“What’s on your mind?” Twilight asked.

Fluttershy smiled and rubbed one front leg with the other. “I was thinking, we still have plenty of time left to see the animals, so I’d like to try something first. An experiment, if you will.”

Twilight nodded. “Oh sure, you know I love experiments. Is it like an animal compatibility test? To see if I’d get along with the otter?”

Fluttershy blinked. “Uh, no, this has nothing to do with the otter. It’s more along the lines of…” She adjusted herself and smiled. “Twilight, if you don’t mind, could we kiss again? But a bit more intensely this time?”

Twilight’s eyes widened and Fluttershy could hear her feathers just slightly shifting. “Oh! I mean, I suppose it has been a while since we’ve gone further with our kissing.” She blushed momentarily then shifted to an analytical expression. “Last time, we went from kissing on the cheek to kissing on the lips. I imagine you want to go just a step past that, and what comes to mind is tongue kissing, but that can’t be what you mean. So perhaps we could kiss while hugging. Does that sound right?”

Fluttershy giggled lightly. “I think I phrased that wrong. I should have said ‘more intensely, to an unknown but possibly large extent.’”

Her mouth opened ever so slightly and red crept up her cheeks as she shifted her gaze away then back. “So you really do mean tongue kissing?”

Fluttershy tilted her head. “I think I should just show you.”

Twilight just barely nodded. “O-OK.”

Seeing Twilight so taken aback felt electrifying. Looking into Twilight’s eyes, she placed a hoof on her shoulder then slipped it down her upper back. The tense princess relaxed under her touch and Fluttershy used this opportunity to draw herself in, closing her eyes and letting their lips meet. This first kiss was close to chaste, resulting in Twilight’s breathing calming further, but for the next one, Fluttershy pulled Twilight in close and pressed hard.

They certainly never shied away from tight hugs, but kissing while doing so was a new experience for Fluttershy. She could feel Twilight’s warm chest beating hard against her own as they tried to bring as much of themselves into contact as possible. The pegasus stroked the princess’s soft coat under her wings. Soon she could feel Twilight’s tongue timidly entering her mouth, desiring but unsure where to draw the line. Fluttershy showed her where the line was by forcing her own tongue against Twilight’s. It was an odd feeling, to be sure, and Fluttershy wasn’t quite sure if it was pleasant, but it also wasn’t unpleasant. Twilight, on the other hand, clearly enjoyed it and vigorously returned the favor.

Wishing to keep her advantage, Fluttershy pushed further and they both fell over onto the grass. Their lips separated and Fluttershy opened her eyes to see Twilight on her back pinned between her legs. She always found Twilight pretty, but the princess’s beauty in this moment surprised her, looking up at her with half-lidded eyes and a red tint to her cheeks, breathing heavily. This was a side of Twilight that Fluttershy never would have seen if she hadn’t tried this, and she was thankful she took the chance.

After catching her own breath, Fluttershy knelt down to kiss Twilight again, letting gravity do the work of bringing them together. Twilight’s tongue acted without hesitation this time and the pegasus tried her best to match her energy. They separated again, but rather than giving Twilight the opportunity to recover, Fluttershy peppered kisses on her cheek and then down to her neck. Twilight’s breath hitched once Fluttershy reached a particular point, which made her realize this was the same place she’d seen Rarity kiss from time to time. So it was a sensitive spot for her, then. Fluttershy chose to linger there, sucking on it with her lips, and to her surprise, Twilight let out a short soft noise.

Fluttershy pulled back and her mind raced. Did she just make Twilight moan? Was that seriously something she just did? Was it even proper of her to do that? She smiled timidly, still unsure what to make of this. “It sounds like you really liked that.”

Twilight looked at her playfully and said in an unexpectedly husky voice, “I didn’t expect you to be so aggressive. It’s really doing it for me.” However, upon saying that, her expression shifted immediately to wide-eyed horror. “Sorry, sorry! I went too far there, didn’t I? We can stop and I won’t mind.”

Fluttershy’s eyebrows scrunched for a second. Was she uncomfortable? Surprised, yes, but was any of this bad? Usually when a social situation was bad, it was really bad for her, with her stomach twisting tight. That wasn’t happening here.

But even knowing that, did she want to continue down this path, wherever it was taking them?

It didn’t take her long to conclude that yes, she did. Twilight was enjoying this, she was enjoying this, and Twilight was only uncomfortable out of concern. However, unless she was the one to push things, Fluttershy just knew the princess would keep doubting herself every step of the way. She needed to show Twilight how little she needed to worry.

What came next would have been an absurd thought to Fluttershy just ten minutes ago, but it came to her naturally and without any sick feelings. Well, if it was with Twilight…

Fluttershy hummed then smiled serenely. “No, let’s keep going. And if you’re really that turned on by me being assertive, I think I’d like to try having sex with you.”

Twilight blinked up at the mare pinning her down. Then she blinked again. “What.”

Rarity always told Fluttershy that it was precisely when you were not confident about an idea that you should act your most confident. She put that lesson to use here, but found that confidence oozed out without any effort after the initial push. Somehow the idea of her sleeping with Twilight was the most natural thing in the world to her now.

In a swift motion, Fluttershy stepped to the side and circled around. As Twilight hesitantly got up, the pegasus said, “We should go to my bedroom.” Fluttershy tilted her head as she noticed Twilight having an unusual amount of trouble standing without shaking, her eyes a million miles away. She added cheekily, “You could also teleport us there if that’s simpler.”

Broken out of her trance, Twilight shot a glance to Fluttershy then down to her unstable legs then back again. “Uh sure, let’s teleport.”

As Twilight gathered magic into her horn, Fluttershy felt an impulse come over here, intoxicated by the flustered princess. She sneakily walked alongside her marefrield and oh so softly stroked her tail against her thigh. She heard Twilight softly gasp and the alicorn looked at her with a blush. This wasn’t enough for Fluttershy, so she leaned in to kiss her on the lips.

If Fluttershy had taken a moment to think about this, she might have been concerned about Twilight messing up her spell—the mare certainly lectured her on teleportation malfunctions only to then insisted they had a very low probability of occurring enough times—but ultimately, she had faith in her magic skills and the princess brought them to their destination. With a flash of purple light, they appeared to the side of Fluttershy’s bed, their lips connected.

Twilight pulled away, breathing heavily. Fluttershy giggled. “I’m surprised I have that much of an effect on you.”

Twilight, though her face was still red, had a much less amused expression. “Fluttershy, are you sure about this? I thought you didn’t want to have sex.” She moved her front legs as though putting something on a table. “I have this mental model of you, and it has ‘no sex’ written in red and all caps. No one pressured you into this or anything, right?”

Fluttershy shook her head. “No, no one pressured me. I didn’t even think of it until a moment ago, but when it came, I realized I actually did want to do it.“

Twilight raised her eyebrow. “You’re not ace, then?”

“It’s kind of hard to explain. I don’t think I want to have sex with you the same way Rarity would want to have sex with you, or you with Rarity, but asexuality is a wide spectrum. I think within certain parameters, I wouldn’t dislike sex. If that’s the case, then you’re definitely someone I’d like to try it with.” Fluttershy smiled. “I know you’ll keep it safe.”

Twilight rubbed her cheek. “So that would make you a gray ace?”

“If classifying it helps you understand, then sure.” She stepped closer to Twilight. “But Twilight, I want to make it clear. I’m interested in having sex with you right now, so do you want to have sex with me?”

Twilight blinked then tilted her head from left to right. “Uh, well, you see, this is a pretty big step for us, and I’m concerned that this might end up straining our relationship, and I’m worried about the otter—”

Fluttershy put her hoof up to Twilight’s lips and the alicorn froze. “Twilight, we’ve been dating for a while. You don’t have to worry about my feelings so much. If I end up not liking this, that won’t change anything. Now, can you please answer my question?”

Fluttershy pulled her hoof away and Twilight stood there, contemplating. Finally, she said, “OK, if you’re really up for this, then yes, I would like to have sex with you.”

Fluttershy smiled. “Wonderful!”

“Though, uh, full disclosure. Just because I’d feel bad hiding this, I will mention that I have thought about this whole scenario before. Or fantasized about it, rather. But—”

Fluttershy interrupted, “And you’ve done a fantastic job not making me feel uncomfortable despite that.” She grinned sneakily. “And now you get to live out your fantasy. Lucky you.”

Twilight blushed at this, but her warm smile showed that she finally seemed to be loosening up. She got onto the bed and sat up. “We could start slow, with me kissing you all over until I figure out what works. Then I’d be able to narrow down where we go from there. Does that sound good?”

Fluttershy hummed. “Actually, until you mentioned it, it didn’t even occur to me that you’d want to pleasure me. Sorry, I don’t think I’m interested in that."

Twilight’s eyebrows scrunched. “Wait, then what do you want to do?”

The princess let out a gasp as Fluttershy pounced on her, knocking her onto her back and pinning her onto the bed. Fluttershy flipped her hair and looked at her marefriend with narrow eyes and a sly grin. “Let’s start where we left off.”

With wide eyes, Twilight nodded and squeaked, “OK.”

Their lips met and they quickly reached their previous intensity. After some time, Fluttershy pulled away and her kisses traveled down to the princess’s neck. She lingered there for some time, but Twilight’s reactions weren’t quite as intense as before, so she chose to go further. Stepping backwards, she kissed Twilight’s collarbone, then down to her chest, then down to her belly. She couldn’t see Twilight’s face, but she could hear her breathing become hungrier as she got lower and lower.

Finally, she was in front of Twilight’s sex and she felt her confidence waning. Here it was: the big moment that would define this as a bonafide sexual act.

She noticed the way her fur glistened there—had she really already gotten her wet? With every sign of Twilight’s attraction to her, she felt a mix of confusion and honor. Twilight was a beautiful mare that already had an equally amazing partner, and it made her feel light inside that she could make her feel like this. It was time to share this feeling with Twilight. She swallowed and went for it.

Except as she leaned in, she hesitated. Deep in her stomach, she felt disgust at the fact that her mouth would be going there of all places. She looked up at Twilight, who looked back at her expectantly. She lingered just a moment too long and Twilight’s expression shifted to concern. “Is something wrong?”

Fluttershy sat up and looked back at her sex. “Uh, sorry, do you mind if I use my hoof for this instead?”

Twilight smiled. “Oh, sure, no problem.”

“This will be just like, um, masturbating, but doing it to another mare, right?” Fluttershy couldn’t help but feel a bit ashamed to use that word in front of another pony, as silly as it was in this context.

Twilight nodded. “Correct. I’ll tell you how to move your hoof.”

Fluttershy hesitantly placed her hoof onto Twilight’s crotch and the alicorn smiled.

“OK, good start. Now move it up a bit and forward.”

Fluttershy moved carefully, shifting her skin and, from Twilight’s sharp gasp, making contact with her clit.

“Now let’s try going in small circles until I figure out what feels best. OK, that direction is good, and—uh, Fluttershy, sorry to tell you, but you aren’t touching my clit anymore.”

Fluttershy blushed in embarrassment. “Oh, sorry. Let me try again.”

Fluttershy placed her hoof under Twilight’s hood again, but barely made contact before her hoof slipped off again.

The pegasus sighed as she pulled away and sat up. “I’m really sorry, Twilight. Hooves aren’t really good for this, I guess.”

Twilight nodded as she got up. “It’s fine. Rarity and I generally use our magic or our tongues for this.”

Fluttershy eyes darted away. “I’m not really comfortable using my tongue.”

“That’s OK. Do you have any sex toys or anything like that here? We could use those.”

Fluttershy looked at her with wide eyes and exclaimed, “What? No!” Seeing Twilight’s startled expression, she quickly added, “I mean, I do have some, but using them on you feels really uncomfortable and I’d rather not. Something about that feels too private. I’m sorry if that doesn’t make any sense.”

Twilight shook her head. “It’s fine, you don’t have to justify being uncomfortable. If you don’t want to do it, we won’t.”

Fluttershy sighed. “I’m sorry. I was excited about doing this with you, but we hit a wall already.”

“Oh, don’t worry, there’s still plenty we could do. You were rushing through kissing me earlier and I didn’t really have a chance to point out my sensitive spots to you, so we could focus on that again. And I could just touch myself while we kiss.”

Fluttershy hummed in disinterest. “I don’t know, Twilight. I really wanted to do something for you, and I didn’t want you to do it all yourself like that.”

“I understand.” Twilight put her hoof on her cheek. “Rarity and I have been experimenting with magic for a while now, so there are a lot of options there. I feel like most of those would be too extreme for a first time, though.”

Fluttershy tilted her head curiously. “What’s one that comes to mind?”

“Well, one that we use a lot is a spell to give me a penis, but I’m not sure that it would address the core problem—”

Fluttershy leaned toward Twilight. “We should try that!”

Twilight blinked at the smiling pegasus’s face. “Really?”

“I had a hard time touching your clit before, but a penis shouldn’t be any trouble at all, right?”

“That… makes a lot of sense. So you aren’t scared—” Twilight shook her head to end that thought. “Well, if you’re sure, I’ll go ahead and cast it.”

Fluttershy nodded.

Twilight smiled somewhat nervously. “I really didn’t expect to whip this out on our first time, but here we go.” Her magic weaved around her horn in a practiced motion, then it traveled down her body to between her legs and formed a bright sphere of light. Before Fluttershy had time to fully process what the spell was doing, the light dissipated and Twilight had transformed.

Fluttershy moved in for a closer look, making Twilight lean away slightly. “Oh wow,” the pegasus said. “And this works just like a, well, non-magic one?”

Twilight nodded frantically. “Well, you see, with spells that modify the body, they work by following back the paths of possibilities and taking one untaken. Which is to say, they make the modification look as though the spell’s target always had that modification, which you may recall from when our transformations into breezies and seaponies resulted in forms that still looked like ourselves. In my case, essentially, this is what my penis would have looked like if I didn’t get therapy as early as I did and then magically transformed into a princess on top of that with a body that seems like it would have been AFAB—which incidentally seemed to have been confirmed by that one time I got sick and turned into a baby and… OK, I’m rambling.”

Fluttershy nodded with serene patience. “A bit, yes. Twilight, are you nervous?”

Twilight got quiet. “This is kind of a touchy area for me. I know Rarity still very much views me as a mare when I use this, and of course I know you will too, but it’s hard not to feel like this could change the way you view me.”

Fluttershy smiled then looked back between the princess’s legs. “It’s much prettier than I expected.”

Twilight smiled lightly. “Yeah, Rarity said that too. She calls it my little hen.”

Fluttershy gasped. “That’s adorable!” She smiled teasingly and added, “Though it isn’t exactly little.”

Twilight giggled. “I’m glad I figured myself out when I did. Getting rid of all this would have been a huge pain. Being able to summon and dispel it whenever I want, on the other hand, is pretty nice.”

“Is it OK if I touch it?”

Twilight’s face turned red again. “Well, I suppose that is the entire reason I brought it out.”

Fluttershy’s hoof hesitantly reached for Twilight’s hen, with the latter tensing herself up. As soon as they touched, Twilight softly gasped and her hen stiffened slightly. Fluttershy smirked. “Twilight, are you more sensitive like this? Is that another reason why you were worried?”

“A bit,” Twilight squeaked. She cleared her throat. “Or rather, it takes a lot more control and I’m still not one hundred percent used to that. And add onto that the fact that you’re an exceptionally pretty mare.”

“And would you like this exceptionally pretty mare to kiss you while stroking your hen?” Before Twilight could stammer her reply, Fluttershy’s face fell. “Was that too cheesy? I’m not quite sure what I should be saying.”

Twilight giggled, releasing some of her tension. “Don’t worry, this is the last place you should worry about being cheesy. Just say whatever comes to mind. And yes, I’d love it if you did that.”

The princess scooted back on the bed and propped her shoulders up on pillows. Smiling, Fluttershy followed after her and pinned her diagonally, with her right hoof available to do its work. With ease that surprised even her, Fluttershy kissed Twilight deeply on the lips and moved her hooves up and down her shaft, making it quickly grow erect.

When their lips separated, Fluttershy gave Twilight a teasing smirk. “How are you feeling? Are you going to burst already?”

Twilight smirked back. “Don’t worry, I can go for way longer.”

“Now, you were saying earlier I was rushing my kisses? I’ll take my time now.”

As Fluttershy softly stroked, she stretched for quick kisses on the neck then moved down to her chest, where she made sure to linger. Twilight’s breath hitched and she knew she hit the spot.

“OK,” Twilight said with an unusually airy voice, “can you try biting here—lightly?”

Fluttershy did so and got a soft gasp in response. She continued following Twilight’s instructions, getting the proper reaction each time. She could feel Twilight’s warmth and how her coat started shimmering with sweat.

“Now, there’s another spot a bit to your right, and—GAH!”

Fluttershy shot up and gasped, lifting her front hooves. “Oh my gosh, I’m so sorry! I bit too hard!”

Twilight winced. “It’s OK. The spots that feel good and the spots that really hurt can be pretty close together. That’s why you bite lightly and—mmf.” She got interrupted by Fluttershy kissing her on the lips and any sign of pain disappeared instantly.

Fluttershy pulled away just barely, looking into Twilight’s eyes. “Kiss to make up?”

She smiled back. “There’s nothing to make up, but I definitely won’t complain if you want to kiss for a bit.”

Fluttershy pressed her body against Twilight’s chest as they kissed, and soon she heard the alicorn’s large wings unfurl. One reached up for an embrace, while the other couldn’t fully open due to Fluttershy’s body being in the way. Twilight wanted to wrap her wings around her, which the pegasus would absolutely love, but she realized that wouldn’t work from this position.

Fluttershy placed her right hoof on the bed, swung her rear right leg over, and moved directly on top of Twilight, resuming her kiss. She could feel the warmth and softness of Twilight’s wings on her back, and it was fantastic. She had scrunched up her back a bit to get in this position, so she relaxed it and moved her hips back.

Fluttershy felt Twilight’s hen against her inner thigh. Somehow it left her mind that she should have expected it there. More startling than its presence, however, was the fact that she didn’t particularly mind having it there. That was strange, wasn’t it? She couldn’t lick her marefriend’s pussy, but an erect penis between her legs got no reaction.

Well, if that’s how it was, then she might as well lean into it.

Fluttershy pressed against Twilight’s hen, arousing a gasp from the princess.

“Fuck, that feels amazing. How are you doing that with your hoof?”

Fluttershy looked at her innocently. Twilight blinked and then looked at how they were positioned and her wings splayed out wildly.

“Ah! Fluttershy! Crotches touching! Are you OK?!”

Fluttershy playfully rolled her eyes. She loved Twilight, she really did, but she hoped this was the end of her freak outs today. “Twilight, how do you think I ended up here?”

Twilight blushed. “Well, I mean, it’s not impossible that I unknowingly used magic to put you there.”

“You should be happy to know that that didn’t happen, then. I’m perfectly comfortable here.” Her smile turned impish. “In fact…”

Fluttershy gently shifted her hips back and forth, eliciting another gasp. Fluttershy pressed her lips against the princess’s before she had a chance to complain and soon enough, her wings wrapped around her again.

Fluttershy’s moment of tranquility was broken when she felt herself getting wet. This in itself wasn’t unexpected. After all, given what she was rubbing against, it made perfect mechanical sense. However, she thought back to how Twilight got wet earlier. If she was allosexual, would this have happened much sooner for her?

Best not to think about that in the middle of making out.

Then another wild thought crossed Fluttershy’s mind. If she was fine with this, then…

Fluttershy lifted herself up. “Question, Twilight. Exactly how, uh, viable are you like this?”

Twilight lit up. “Oh, like for viable sperms? Those need to be generated by magic, so that’s an extra part of the spell I need to cast. Which is to say that right now, I’m not viable at all.” Upon seeing Fluttershy’s smile, Twilight’s eyes widened. “Wait, do you really want to…?”

Fluttershy nodded. “Would you like us to?” Before Twilight could respond, Fluttershy added, “And no being wishy-washy, please.”

Eyes still wide, Twilight nodded. “Yes. I would like us to have vaginal intercourse.”

Fluttershy giggled. “Is that what you call it with Rarity?”

Twilight laughed. “No, but I’d feel weird telling you I’d like to fuck you hard with my hammer hen,” she said, mumbling the last words.

“I’d like to be fucked by your hammer hen,” Fluttershy said with a smile. When Twilight blanched, Fluttershy added teasingly, “Like you said, don’t worry about being cheesy.”

Fluttershy got up on all fours and looked back. “Hmm, it might be awkward getting on it from this position.”

Twilight started getting up. “It’ll be easier if I do it from behind.”

Fluttershy slammed her hoof next to Twilight’s head, making her fall flat onto the bed. With a serious expression, she said, “I’d much prefer it if you stayed down.”

Twilight squeezed her mouth shut and nodded.

Fluttershy looked back again and adjusted her hips. She got on top of Twilight’s hen but getting it inside proved tricky. Thankfully, Twilight adjusted it with her magic and then their mutual arousal allowed it to enter easily.

The pegasus smiled. Still no adverse reaction on her end. She wasn’t entirely confident before, but it seemed like she really would pull this off.

She slowly lowered, but then Twilight gasped. “Wait!”

Startled, Fluttershy froze in place as Twilight breathed heavily then bit her lip. Finally, she sighed.

“Sorry. I kind of forgot to stay in control and I was about to cum right then and there. I usually last way longer.”

Fluttershy smiled. It remained exhilarating just how much of an effect she had on the princess. “Are you fine now?”

Twilight nodded and Fluttershy continued to slowly lower. In many ways, this wasn’t too different from the ways she used her sex toys, but it was still quite remarkable. The warmth, the way Twilight’s hen slightly moved, and most especially the fact that it was part of a really cute mare she loved made for a unique experience.

Fluttershy finished lowering and sighed contentedly. Twilight’s hen really was quite big and she was impressed by how full she felt inside. She looked down at the mare in question and smiled. “Are you ready?”

Twilight’s face was flush. “Actually, there’s something I do with Rarity that I’d like you to do. Could you maybe tell me not to cum until you say so? Like you’re giving me a command?”

Fluttershy paused as she considered this. “You mean like a domme?”

Twilight nodded, seemingly a bit taken aback that she knew that word. “Yeah. You’ve actually been part of the way there already, with you being assertive and being the top. I’m usually the top with Rarity, and I never imagined until now how hot it would be for you to be one.”

Fluttershy hadn’t thought about it, but that was what was going on, wasn’t it? She was the top. Shy asexual virgin Fluttershy was topping a princess of Equestria. She couldn’t help but giggle. “Alright.” She leaned in close to Twilight’s ear. “Don’t cum until your mistress commands you.”

The alicorn’s eyes widened. “Mistress?”

Fluttershy pulled back and smiled with half-lidded eyes. “And one more thing, I’m not nice enough to just give you permission.” She stroked Twilight’s chest. “You’ll have to beg. Say ‘please mistress, let me cum’ and I’ll perhaps consider it. But make no mistake, I alone command your body.” Her hoof moved up to Twilight’s neck. “If you do anything without my direct permission, you’ll be severely punished.”

Fluttershy felt Twilight’s hen throb inside her as she gulped. “Holy fuck.”

Fluttershy considered breaking character to add she didn’t actually know how to punish her, but decided it was best left unsaid. Without further word, she moved her hips up. Once again caught off guard, Twilight sucked in a quick breath and bit her lip, but Fluttershy decided not to give her time to recover and thrust herself down.

To the princess’s credit, she recovered quickly and merely grunted with pleasure. At this, Fluttershy continued her motions, speeding up until she got into a comfortable rhythm.

Fluttershy gauged how she was feeling about this. By this point, it felt very different from her own experiences with sex toys, both physically and emotionally, but she couldn’t exactly say it was better. When using a toy, she could in a way force herself to get aroused and orgasm, but even with the electrifying emotions from seeing Twilight in such pleasure, she just wasn’t getting there. Having a real pony before her made it so it wasn’t a fantasy and it just wasn’t what her body was looking for.

However, this was what Twilight was looking for, judging from the way her lips parted and drool started forming in the corner of her mouth.

The princess seemed like she had gotten used to Fluttershy’s rhythm and she hadn’t begged to cum yet, so it was time to force the issue. She ran her hooves up and down Twilight’s body, remembering the sensitive spots from before and getting the occasional hitch in her breath. Carefully, she lowered herself down while trying not to interrupt her movements and, with some awkward bending, softly bit the alicorn’s chest. She didn’t think she could stay like this for long, but she got what she wanted.

“P-please mistress, let me cum,” Twilight breathed out.

Fluttershy straightened up and thrust herself down hard. “How pathetic,” she said in her best attempt at an evil voice, though she couldn’t help but let a smile break through. “Is this all a princess of Equestria has to offer?” Her hips moved faster than before. “I’ll wring every bit I can from you before I let you finish.”

That said, Fluttershy wasn’t quite sure how much she herself had left. This motion wasn’t exactly something she was used to. The last thing she wanted was to leave Twilight unsatisfied.

She leaned forward again, though she found that she had to slow down her movements a bit like this. While biting Twilight’s chest, she saw out of the corner of her eyes the princess’s wings move. She likely wanted to draw her in for another embrace, but Fluttershy doubted she could move her hips well like that.

She spread her front legs and planted them on Twilight’s wings. “Oh no you don’t,” Fluttershy said. “There’s no way to escape.”

“Please mistress, let me cum!” Twilight cried out, her face twisting as her wings struggled against the weight.

“I refuse,” Fluttershy replied curtly. She sped up her movements, hoping Twilight would run out of energy before she did.

“P-please mistress,” Twilight said.

Fluttershy hummed, then planted herself fully onto Twilight’s hen. “Alright.”

Twilight exhaled and Fluttershy felt her hen shake and then erupt. The pegasus’s eyes widened. Somehow she had forgotten that this was part of it. It was an unusual feeling, having the warm thick liquid pulse into her.

Her next thought was that this would leave a mess on the sheets, though she immediately realized it was a bit late to worry about that. However, that did give her an idea. Quickly, she pushed on the bed to turn Twilight and herself to their sides. Then, to the princess’s absolute amazement, she grabbed her with her front legs, rolled onto her back, and easily lifted Twilight above her, bringing her into a tight embrace of both hooves and wings.

“Every single drop belongs to your mistress,” Fluttershy softly said into Twilight’s ear, making it twitch. “You’re in big trouble if any spills out.”

Twilight panted as she filled up Fluttershy. “Y-yes, mistress.”

Fluttershy merely giggled in reply.

Once she felt nothing more come out of Twilight’s hen, Fluttershy released her and they rolled away. The pegasus thought she hadn’t been exerting herself too much, but once they separated, she found herself breathing heavily and that unfamiliar muscles were aching.

Twilight sat up. “Fluttershy, that was amazing!” She playfully raised an eyebrow at her partner, who laid on the bed without showing much reaction. “Should I assume you’re done for today?”

She nodded. “Yeah, that’s it for me.” Judging from Twilight’s energy, she clearly tended to do much more with Rarity, but this was Fluttershy’s first time, after all, and there was no shame in stopping now.

Twilight nodded and, with a flash of her horn, her hen was gone and she returned to her normal body. “So how was it for you?”

Fluttershy rolled onto her side and hummed. “It was interesting. No, I should say it was pretty good. I enjoyed it! But, how should I put it? I kind of feel the same way about it as I would spending time at the spa with you. It isn’t exactly something I’d go out of my way to do, but I liked it as we were doing it.” She moved her head closer to Twilight. “Oh, but I loved seeing how much you enjoyed it! That was the best part for me.”

Twilight laid down on her side too, looking into Fluttershy’s eyes. “I’m glad you enjoyed it. It’s interesting hearing your impressions when you don’t have the same, well, sex drive that Rarity or any of my previous partners have. It’s actually kind of heartening knowing you still liked having sex with me despite that.”

Fluttershy nodded. “Because I enjoyed it out of love.”

Twilight blushed. “I love you, Fluttershy.”

Despite everything they had done, this made Fluttershy flush more than anything else. “T-thank you. I love you too.”

They leaned in for a light kiss, nowhere near as intense as the ones before, but it sent chills through Fluttershy regardless.

“Still,” Twilight said, “I do feel kind of bad that I didn’t really do anything for you. Aside from, well, fucking you, but I do much more to pleasure Rarity and it felt kind of weird to just sit back and take it. But since you didn’t ask for it, should I assume that’s just how you like it?”

Fluttershy nodded. “Yeah, I’d really rather you didn’t pleasure me like that. Aside from not wanting it, it feels like I’d be losing control over what we’re doing.”

Twilight had an analytical look in her eyes. “Control definitely seems to be the key here. You guided everything we did and even stopped me from getting up before. And really, I’m perfectly fine with you doing that. So, should we keep the arrangement like that?”

Fluttershy smiled. “I think so. I did enjoy being your mistress, so I’ll lean into that more next time.”

Twilight couldn’t help but blush. “That sounds good.” She tilted her lips. “So, I kind of play that role with Rarity, so I can help you figure out what you want to do.”

Fluttershy hummed. “Actually, I think I’ll ask Rarity, precisely because she’s usually on the receiving end and then I can surprise you next time. I should probably get some appropriate outfits from her too.”

Twilight’s rear legs shifted as she flushed. “Oh! Yes, that makes sense.”

Fluttershy suddenly frowned. “Although, I can really get into my roles with the right outfit, so that could be dangerous. Even when playing domme, I wouldn’t want to whip you or spank you or anything like that. Unless you want that, I mean.”

Twilight thought about this for a moment. “Actually, visualizing you doing that feels more weird than anything.”

“Would I be a bad domme if I didn’t do that?”

Twilight shook her head. “No, you don’t have to actually hit me. Just what you did now is already fine, and you could also have me restrain myself with binding magic or even ropes. I could look up more if you’d like.”

Fluttershy giggled. “I already said I was going to ask Rarity, but if you insist on looking it up, I am here to fulfill your fantasies.”

“Well, my fantasies are going to be completely different now.” Twilight propped herself up. “Actually, I’m curious. How often do you want to do this?”

Fluttershy hummed. Her instinct was to tell Twilight they could have sex whenever she wanted, but she knew that the princess would overly consider her feelings and end up rarely if ever asking. And on the off chance Twilight really did decide to frequently have sex with her, that wasn’t what she wanted. So it was up to her to consider what Twilight would want that would be fine for her. Well, it was already the case that they only met up a couple times a month, so…

Fluttershy smiled. “How about once every time we meet up?”

Twilight’s eyes widened. “Oh! OK, sure.” She rubbed the back of her neck. “And one more thing, should I always bring out my penis when we have sex?”

Fluttershy grinned. “You mean your hammer hen?”

Twilight blushed and scrunched her eyebrows. “Yes, that.”

“Well, what led us to that was that I didn’t want to use my sex toys. If you bring your own, then I’d be willing to try using them on you.”

Twilight rolled onto her front and sat up. “Oh! Actually, I have them set to instantly summon with my magic, so we could have brought one out from the start.”

Fluttershy giggled. “Oh, well now I feel silly that neither of us thought of that. We probably wouldn’t have tried your spell, though. Now we have more options for next time.”

Twilight fidgeted. “Are you sure you want to wait until next time for that? I can still go another round.”

“I’d like to wait, yes. This is still all new to me and I’d rather not push it too much.” She winked. “Plus, that gives you more to look forward to.”

Twilight, thankfully, didn’t seem too disappointed. “Well then, could we cuddle?”

Fluttershy nodded. “I’d love that.” She looked down at the sheets. “Though, we should probably clean up before we do that.”

Twilight smiled. “Oh, that’s no problem.” With a flash of her horn, the entire mess on the bed disappeared. Even Fluttershy herself felt cleaner. The alicorn had a smug expression. “Easy cleanup is just one reason why Rarity loves me. You still should shower after this, though.”

“It really is convenient.”

She scooted closer to Twilight. Without another word, the princess closed the distance and they wrapped their legs around each other. She drifted down Fluttershy’s body until she settled on pressing her face into her chest, and she pressed hard, much more so than the previous times they cuddled. Fluttershy was a bit surprised, but she figured that they pretty thoroughly broke down the walls inhibiting them before. She squeezed with her legs and wanted to wrap her wings around her, but her marefriend beat her to the punch. Her great purple wings slid between her and the bed, and the princess sighed as she settled in.

Fluttershy watched her peacefully for a moment and then stroked her mane. The princess rubbed her face further into Fluttershy’s chest fur.

“I know I said this already, but I love you,” Twilight said.

Fluttershy couldn’t help but blush and fidget at this.

Twilight giggled. “And I love that saying that makes you act like this.”

The pegasus sighed. “Twilight, I love you so much.”

Enough to try things she never would have thought possible for her. Fluttershy was still asexual, if it was to show her marefriend how much she loved her, then she could enjoy sex.

Days later in Canterlot, Rarity and Twilight sat in a private balcony, waiting for a packed showing of a play to start. As busy as both their schedules were, they had to meet here, and with the course their conversation took, the princess was glad it was as private as it was.

“I’m surprised Flutter-dear had it in her,” Rarity said. She then nudged her marefriend. “Especially that she had it in her.”

Twilight giggled. “Rarity!”

The unicorn simply winked in reply.

“Yeah, it was a big surprise for me too.”

Rarity smiled teasingly. “I can imagine! Fluttershy told me you kept trying to change the subject to one of her otter friends.”

Twilight blushed and scrunched her brows. “I did not! Maybe just once.”

“And in the end, how was the otter?”

Twilight hummed. “Honestly, as far as otters go, he was average.”

Rarity laughed. “Imagine if you really did go see him instead of doing what Fluttershy wanted. Just sitting there watching an average otter, trying not to think about her proposal. Maybe if he was an exceptional otter or even a terrible otter it would have worked, but no, he’s average and you have nothing to distract you from your thoughts as they eat away at you.”

Before she could continue her sprawling hypothetical, Twilight giggled and said, “Rarity! I think we’re being too mean to the otter now, he didn’t do anything wrong. Anyway, Fluttershy said she was going to talk to you about what to do in the future. Did she end up doing that?”

Rarity’s eyes widened. “Oh, we did more than talk! We tried having sex too!”

This perked Twilight’s ears. “Really? How did it go?” Her mind catching up to the wording, she raised an eyebrow. “Wait, tried?”

Rarity sighed. “Alas, it wasn’t meant to be. I thought it’d be exciting, but when Fluttershy pinned me down and started kissing me, it just felt kind of bleh to me.”

“That’s a surprise. Her as a top really did it for me, and I figured that since you’re a bottom…”

“About that, what I realized is that I didn’t want to be Fluttershy’s bottom. No, I wanted to top her! But then you know what happened when we switched positions? Fluttershy started pouting!”

Twilight blinked. “Fluttershy pouted? Because she wanted to be the top?”

“I think it’s more that she didn’t want to be the bottom. But yes, there we were, two tops who didn’t want to give up our position. We were at a complete impasse!” She rotated her hoof. “We just kept flipping over and over and over again, from one end of the bed to the other, but there was zero sexual chemistry! Eventually we just gave up and snuggled for a while.”

Twilight giggled at the image. “Well, at least Fluttershy is a good snuggler.”

Rarity smiled. “She is, yes.”

Twilight put a hoof to her chin. “Interesting, so in our throuple, you and I are both switches, but Fluttershy is always a top. I really wouldn’t have expected that a week ago.”

“I know! Quite a fascinating development.”

“Though it is a shame,” Twilight said, tilting her head. “It means we have an uneven relationship with her now, don’t we?”

“Fluttershy mentioned something like that, actually. But remember Twilight, Fluttershy didn’t have an uneven relationship with us when neither of us were having sex with her. The same applies now.” She nudged closer to Twilight. “Besides, I’m the last pony who’d be upset about you having more sex. Like with that Raven girl, for instance.”

Twilight playfully rolled her eyes. “I keep telling you, she has a crush on you, not me. You winking at her again isn’t exactly helping.”

Rarity fluttered her lips. “I can’t exactly keep a record of who does and doesn’t get flustered by my winks.” Before Twilight could respond, Rarity continued, “Alright, yes, I do actually do that now thanks to you. I just didn’t think to include Raven.” She put her hoof on Twilight’s shoulder. “That point is, our relationships are evolving and that deserves to be celebrated. Rather than worrying, you should look forward to the outfits Fluttershy will be wearing when she visits.”

Twilight blushed. “Oh?”

Rarity nodded. “They’re here already, as a matter of fact. I had Raven stash them away before I came here.” She frowned. “And I just realized I winked at her yet again when I did, so I may have given her the wrong impression.”

Twilight shook her head. “Oh Rarity.”

Still, Twilight thought, Rarity was right. Their relationships evolving was a good thing. Whatever path they took, as long as they were all together, there’s no way things could ever go wrong.