The Disappearance of Sacred Records

by Lillup

Rating: teen
Tags: Princess Celestia, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Rarity, Thriller, Original Character, Mystery, Spike, Adventure
Length: 14799

Canterlot library's restricted section gets raided of several books by an unknown perpetrator. The motives are unknown, is there something more scary to the thefts than initially thought? Where is the perpetrator now?

At the Summer Sun festival, sacred or important books were stolen from Canterlot Library's restricted section. When leads start to go cold, Twilight, Rarity and friends search for clues to the missing texts before they become forgotten history.

Recommended reading in order. New chapters steadily released.

This is my first non-trollfic, so that's something I guess. Feedback and criticism appreaciated.

Published 2022-09-27 21:20:00 UTC
Last updated 2022-11-02 23:58:09 UTC

1: The Inciting Incident

The scenery of ponies celebrating and fireworks lighting up the sky was picturesque like a well-crafted painting. This showcase was for the Summer Sun festival, a celebration dedicated to the ruler of Equestria, Princess Celestia, who watched them from a balcony alongside her sister Luna.

"Have you spotted Twilight in the crowd, dear sister?“ Celestia asked.

"Indeed I have, though she has been busy with her friends and catching up with acquaintances,“

"I see, she has truly come a long way from when I first met her, hasn't she? She used to not let friendship in her heart, but now everyone seems to know and adore her. Maybe she could take over for us in the future?“

"If I may sister, I believe she is still too immature.“

"Oh come now Luna, we've both seen each other's immature side, immaturity is not something that disappears with age. A little is okay.“

"Ha, quite true I suppose. Though I feel she needs more time and experience.“

"Yes of course, we can ease her in, but I feel confident she is on the path to being one of us. I mean, she just reformed Starlight Glimmer the other day, so she must have something truly special about her.“

Their conversation was cut short by the door flung open by a E.U.P royal guard.

"I'm sorry to disturb you, Your Highnesses.“

"It must be rather serious,“ Luna commented. "Are we under attack?“

"It's not as urgent as that, but there has been theft in the Canterlot library restricted records.“

"What?!" Celestia exclaimed with raised eyebrows.

"Somepony managed to take som-“

Princess Celestia galloped forward through the open doors giving little notice to her surroundings. She eventually made it to the library, which the other guards were looking around.

"Did you see anyone come near here? Anyone from the hall?“

"Oh Princess Celestia; I'm afraid not.“

Celestia began frantically checking the bookshelves for empty spaces and her agitation did not dissuade.

"Sister,“ Luna panted, short of breath from trying to keep her Sister's pace "What ails you this much? I have never seen you so uncomposed. They are important records, but we can find them.“

"This is very serious Luna and I truly wish you understood how serious this is; do not act as if I am over-reacting.“

Her coldness took Luna aback, but she decided to back off for now; she could see how this could stress her out. Feeling disassociated from the situation, she walked back towards her quarters. Celestia stopped her part-way.

"Well there is one important task I ask of you, Luna. Please observe the crowds attending the Summer Sun festival and make a note of any abnormalities within the crowd, even if it is someone you know and trust. Take names and notes of anything odd about their appearance, if you don't know them well or any suspicious behaviour. Report to me later.“

"Yes, Sister.“

With that, she went outside, trying not to get noticed from a distant to get involved in conversations. She noticed Twilight and her friends drinking punch and making conversation. She knew Twilight could be trusted, right? There was no need, but no, she had to be critical, no matter who it is. Twilight looked fine, but she noticed something odd about Rainbow Dash's tail; it was missing a few of her rainbow hairs, looking messy. She proceeded with these judgemental observations until Celestia herself appeared on the balcony.

"Everypony, thank you very much for attending the Summer Sun festival. I hope to see you all next year.“

The crowd started mumbling to each other.

"That's strange, isn't it?“

"Shouldn't this be going for another hour or so?“

"Well, no helping it I suppose.“

Noticing the crowd's behaviour, Celestia elaborated.

"I apologise it may be earlier than expected, but we have important business tomorrow and need to end a little earlier, but I wish everyone a good night and farewell.“

This brought up the mood a little more and everyone began to slowly leave. Luna flew up to meet Celestia.

"Sister, how has the investigation inside gone?“

"We have found some pieces of evidence, but we will have our resident detective come tomorrow to give their opinion; I also wish for Twilight Sparkle to take a look, her critical eye may be of great aid. How was your search?“

"I did as you asked and have a good few names, but none seemed outwardly suspicious.“

"That is plenty, I will call them all in tomorrow for questioning.“

"Sister, is there a theme with the books that were stolen?“

"No, it was a strange collection of books, but they must be for a particular purpose; no-one would risk getting caught with theft here for meaningless reasons.“

Celestia paced round the room.

"Please share your lists of names with me, Luna.“

Luna silently passed her the list.

Rainbow Dash
Gray Tank
Amethyst Maresbury (Crystal Pony librarian)
Love Joyful
Discord

"Okay, it is not a bad start, but I have some names that definitely need adding, even if they didn't attend.“

Starlight Glimmer
Twilight Sparkle
Library staff

"Twilight? Are you sure?“

"Well, why did you ask Amethyst?“

"Well, she's a librarian, she would have a motive for wanting to steal books.“

"Is Twilight not the same though?“

"I suppose you're right, so that's why you want to watch over those who investigate, including Twilight, correct?“

"That's correct, I will not turn a blind eye to anyone. Now, we'll have a lot to do tomorrow, so feel to get some rest. The guards will take turns searching this place from top to bottom. I want to check a few places myself, they could still be hiding in the castle out of sight after all, but I have somewhere out of the castle to check too.“

"Okay Sister, please make sure you get some rest though; do not wring yourself dry.“

"We will see.“

With that, she flew straight back to the library and began checking the staff room cupboards.

"Well, what do we have here?“

She found rainbow hairs in the cupboard. Not drawing immediate conclusions, she carried on checking places the pony could still be hiding, but it did not turn up anything.

"One more place I wish to check tonight.“

Author's Note

Here's my first story that is not a trollfic, so it's been a fun experience creating this story. All but two chapters are fully written and I hope people enjoy what I have in mind for this mystery. Feedback and criticism are welcome.

2: Trust in Twilight

Twilight, after a great day celebrating the Summer Sun festival, was ready to hit the hay and get some rest.

"Hey Spike."

"Twilight, how was the Summer Sun?"

"Yeah, great thank you. Sadly didn't really see Celestia, but I think she was quite busy."

"Makes sense, it's not all fun and games ruling all of Equestria. I bet you're partied out, right?"

"Ah yeah, you could say that. I think I'm gonna need some good rest."

Twilight peered over at the Cutie Map.

"Anything from the map Spike?"

"Nope, it's been totally quiet for the past three weeks, is it broken or is there really nothing exciting on around here?"

"I wouldn't mind a bit of peace for a while Spike."

”I don't know, seems a bit boring to me. Oh, I have something I need talk about you with you sometime soon Twilight.

"Sorry Spike, but could we leave it for another time please? I really need some sleep right now, I can barely stay awake."

There was a short, breathless pause but Spike responded with a low tone, "Alright Twilight, good night."

Twilight's eyelids drooped effortlessly, she had never found an easier night of sleep.

For all of an hour.

"Twilight."

"Princess Celestia?" she murmured with creased eyelines. It took a moment to distinguish reality. "Princess Celestia! Oh I'm so sorry for any mess, would you like any tea? Is there anything you need?" She dashed around the room in a panic.

"I'm afraid it is not a simple visit Twilight, I have serious matters to attend to, and most importantly, I wish for your assistance."

"Me? Is Equestria under attack?"

"I'm afraid the Royal Library has been robbed, in paritcular the restricted section."

"What?! What pony would do such a thing?"

"I have been looking into it, but we have only just begun. What I request if you could assist us in giving your critical insights into what we find starting tomorrow's morning."

"Of course, I'll do what I can."

"And one more crucial thing please, I want to do an extensive search of the castle please. May you and Spike remain in this room, please?"

"Er, of course! Whatever you need."

"Thank you, I will try to disturb as little as possible."

Spike, woken by Twilight, was brought into her room as Celestia rummaged through practically all of her belongings, the bookshelf was under particular scrutiny. Twilight wanted to ask more questions, but Celestia seemed pretty focused.

"Thank you, I now wish to inspect the other rooms, could you please accompany me?"

With Twilight and Spike close behind, Celestia's extensive search was paired with equally critical questions.

"Where were you during the Summer Sun, Spike?"

"I'm sorry I didn't attend Celestia, please don't be offended, but I've... uh OH I really hurt my back yesterday and I just don't feel great, no sirree. I only come with you out of your request, Princess."

"Hm I see, and how exactly did you hurt your back may I ask?"

"Oh," Twilight interjected. "You told me your back started to hurt before we left I remember. I don't know what I gave you though that was so heavy."

"Those books you had me lift, it must've been the straw to break the Griffin's back I guess, I just couldn't seem to handle it."

"Wow, I thought it was only a few, but maybe I've been too harsh on you Spike, I'm sorry."

"It's okay Twilight, I feel I just need some rest."

"Maybe indeed," Celestia commented "Well I can get you the very best medical service and we can take a look at that back of yours."

"Oh no no no," Spike shook his head. "I'm sure I just need some good rest and I'll be right as rain in no time. I wouldn't want to waste the efforts of your medical staff, Princess."

"Sorry Spike, but I must insist. I will book you in soon and we will have a close look at what happened. Twilight will not get in trouble, I just want a closer look."

"Okayy," Spike painfully grined. "Let me know and I'll make my way."

Princess Celestia stopped in the room Spike showed interest in earlier.

"Tell me Twilight, when was the Crystal Mirror last used?"

"Well Sunset hasn't visited in a good while, maybe a month or so? But I told her she may travel as she pleases."

"Hm, well what is this on the ground?"

She picked up a necklace with a magicless purple gem embedded in it. Spike suddenly spoke in a louder than intended voice.

"Oh I'm sorry, I need to confess something. Erm, Sunset Shimmer actually came by last night."

"What? Really? Why didn't you tell me last night?"

"Oh it's just because she came through, called to me, asked if you were here and then when I said you were busy, she smiled and said she'd come back later for you. That was it. It wasn't anything worth talking about."

"And this object?" Celestia added.

"Oh, that, she must've dropped it. I'd go and return it, but a dog carrying around a necklace might make me stand out too much."

"Hm, well I think I have seen every room now Twilight. I'm sorry to ask of this, but I humbly request that your house, in particular the mirror, is sealed off for a little while."

"Do you suspect something wrong, Celestia?" Twilight asked with worry she was being looked at unfondly.

"I do not wish to suspect anyone Twilight, I just wish to explore every opportunity. I trust you, you are my faithful student and pupil, I just wish for this panic to come to an end."

"What did they steal to have you so panicked, Celestia?"

Celestia did not respond, she just lowered her head.

"So we're gonna have this whole area sealed off, Celestia?" Spike asked. "Isn't that a little extreme?"

"I'll keep it as brief as I possibly can Spike; I'm sorry for all this. I will wait for some royal guards to protect this area and I will provide you all with good beds in Canterlot."

"Thank you for your generosity," Twilight said. "We hope we can help you solve this problem soon."

"And thank you for co-operation Twilight, we began early morning and I will call in the greatest detective of Ponyville."

Suspect list:
Rainbow Dash
Gray Tank
Amethyst Maresbury (Crystal Pony librarian)
Love Joyful
Discord
Starlight Glimmer
Twilight Sparkle
Library staff
Sunset Shimmer(?)
Spike

3: Detective Deployed

"Detective Rarity has arrived!“ Rarity declared triumphantly as she entered the Library of Canterlot, her suave hat catching the attention of the Royal Guards who were busy doing their own job. There was no civilians at the library due to the incident, only the staff were still present so they could be questioned.

"Thank you for agreeing to help, Rarity,“ Luna bowed to her. Celestia, Spike, Twilight, Royal Guards and witnesses were also in the room, on standby for whatever Detective Rarity needed.

"Yes, thank you for being here,“ Celestia echoed, her eyes scrunched and aching, drinking some royal coffee; in her misfortune, she was not made aware of the fact it was decaf.

"Anytime darling, I haven't had to outfit myself in these drapes for a good while, it's nice to land back into this role again.“

"Twilight, do I really need to be here?“ Spike asked. "My back is realllllly killing me right now, I don't think I should be out and about.“

"Come now Spike, we'll only be here for a couple of hours, then I'm sure you can go home.“

"Sorry Twilight,“ Celestia said. "but I want Spike to remain.“

Spike grumbled, but ultimately felt uncomfortable at disobeying the Princess.

Rarity went up to Luna with a comically serious tone on her face, more cartoonish than she perhaps meant. "So tell me the factoids you know so far.“ Luna walked forward and began to describe what they knew.

"According to the librarian, at abbout 17:00 during the Summer Sun festival, Princess Celestia herself came to the library.“

"What, that's perpostorous, Celestia was obviously here at the Summer Sun festival!“

"Yes, but the impersonator of Celestia told her she had to temporarily leave in order to acquire some important documents from the library's restricted section. Only my Sister, Cadence and I are allowed access to the restricted section, but this person impersonated, so there is only one conclusion I can come to.“

"A changeling?!“ Rarity exclaimed. "But we dealt with the Queen of the changelings a good while ago, how could this be?“

"I wonder myself, but it is far from impossible that they could re-appear and strike again.“

"But darling, that asks a very important question, something that is immediatedly fishy about this.“

"What do you mean, Rarity?“

"Why would the changelings requre books? What would be the purpose of us showing themselves just to steal documents they have little use for?“

"I agree,“ Celestia added, who was also having a quiet conversation with another pony at the same time. "The changelings may have a role, but they do not seem a likely culprit.“

"It does ask a lot more questions,“ Rarity murmured. "However, that means more work to do. Let's talk to this librarian. Excuse me, Amethyst Maresbury, is it?“

"Yes dearie, how may I help you?“

"So you claim you saw Princess Celestia at about 17:00 yesterday, is that correct?“

"Yes Ma'am, it was her spitting double, like a twin sister.“

"But one ist-“

"Not you, Luna.“

"Back on topic,“ Rarity cried. "So you let the Princess in without a single doubt in your mind? You knew she was at the Summer Sun festival, correct?“

"Of course man, everyone knows Summer Sun, but she is a fast flyer and I am always ready to help our wonderful princesses at any time.“

"Was there anything odd about this 'Celestia‘ at the time? Something just odd about her appearance, mannerisms, anything at all?“

"Well, there was something. The way she spoke was kind of strange. She mostly spoke royally, but it was overly so, like every word was made to be as posh as possible. The last thing was on her leaving, her royal speech as she was leaving sounded very, well, common!“. She began to tear up slightly as she continued "At the end, she spoke rather rough, to be honest, it surprised me, but I thought she may be mad at me, maybe I didn't a good job.“

By the end, she started to cry fully, Rarity supporting her with a front leg over her shoulder.

"Oh I'm sorry dear, this impostor, I have some real words for their behaviour. I'm sorry to hear about that. Please tell me the phrases she spoke as they were said please.“

"The imposter said 'Thanks a lot Library... person‘ like that, Celestia always calls me by name, as she does everypony. Princess Celestia!“

"Yes, dear Amethyst?“

"I'm sorry to have let you down by letting this impostor through.“

"It's okay Amethyst, I understand now you were manipulated carefully. I'm afraid there may be more than one perpetrator though.“

"Oh that is horrible. I have another person under suspicion I am waiting for, she should be arriving any mome-“

The door burst open with a rainbow gleam engulfing the room, the rainbow-maned mare flying proudly in-air.

"Rainbow Dash?“ Twilight shouted. "What are you doing here?“

"Oh I was called by Celestia, I must be hitting the big time. Are you gonna make me head of the Wonderbolts? Accepted.“

"I'm glad you have come, Rainbow, but I'm afraid it's more serious than that. Rarity and I will have some questions for you“ Celestia stated.

"We do? What do you mean, dear?“ Rarity quizzed.

"This hair,“ Celestia stated, showing a bag of Rainbow hair and a picture of them on the crime scene.

"What?! You suspect ME?“ Rainbow exclaimed. "Pff, as if. The only books I care about is Daring Do.“

"I need you to take this seriously Rainbow Dash,“ Celestia demanded. "I need an explanation for why your hair was found in the storage closet of the library.“

"Uh uh no way, it must've been someone else. I've not been in here, there's no way it could have been me.“

"That's right!" Twilight added. "I didn't realise you were bringing my friends here to point the hoof at them.“

"I concur!“ Rarity added.

"I need to explore every possiblility Twilight, it is not a personal matter, this is for the good of Equestria. No-one is beyond observing.“

"Even me?“

"That's not-“

Luna interrupted the heated conversation with a light hoof stamp.

"To be honest dear sister, I have my doubts about the hairs“ Luna said.

"Why would that be? You pointed out Rainbow's missing hairs in the first place, did you not?“ Celestia asked.

"That i did, but there was something strange about the missing hairs I didn't notice before; take a closer look, don't these seem a little clean cut to have fallen out naturally in there?“

"I see, you may be right,“ Rarity added, "these look cut with an implement of some sort, likely scissors or shears. Rainbow dear, did you notice anything strange to do with your hair?“

"No honestly, I don't; I can't lie, I don't even remember letting my guard down for a minute, other than...“

"Other then when, dear?“

"I suppose I may have took a bit of a snooze on Foal Mountain for a couple of hours, that's all I can think of really. But who would even bother visiting there? It's a no-pony's land.“

"Hm, we may need to visit Foal Mountain soon Luna.“ Celestia's looked stressed from the mystery expanding further, but she had to commit to this; she would do just about anything to find those files.

"Well I thank you for coming, Rainbow Dash, please do not take my words to heart.“

"It's no biggie, let me know if I can be of help.“

"I have one request for certain, I want you to try and find someone please.“

"Absolutely. Their name?“

With a name and a description, Rainbow went on a blind ponyhunt through the skies.

"Okay, who shall be Detective Rarity's next interogee?“ Rarity asked Celestia.

"Well, let's talk to the rest of the library staff, see if they know anything, by then Gray Tank should be here, unlike our other suspect who has yet to show up.“

They spent the next half an hour asking the staff who had very little of worth to offer, so they had to rely on Rarity and Twilight's observations. Finally, they went down to the Restricted section with the assistance of Celestia and Luna.

"I must say, this decor is quite old-fashioned, the drapes really need to go.“

"It's not a room to leisure in Rarity, ths is for storing the most valuable information in all of Equestria“ Twilight responded.

"Well it certainly wouldn't hurt to add a little more mystique with some new décor, would it not?“

"Decor...“

"Oh, do you have any ideas yourself, Darling?“

"Not that Rarity, that curtain on the floor.“

"Truly an eyesore, the place is falling to bits.“

"I noticed it had fallen," Celestia commented "but I could not see it relating to the books.“

"I just find it interesting some of the little metal rings attached to the top came out, it must have been pulled with some real weight. I feel it was either done intentionally or they fell over and they grabbed this curtain in desperation, trying to break the fall.“

"There's nothing to slip on in here though Twilight, there'd have to be pretty unlucky, we ponies tend to be pretty good on our hooves.“

"Sadly I can't tell anything else from the scene, which books were stolen, Princess Celestia?“

"It's a strange variety, but there were books on early pony history, outdated law books and... memoirs.“

"What would a thieve want with those? Books on forbidden magic and things of that nature are still here. Surely those would be more valuable?“

"The only things I can think of is it could be a pony of the distant past somehow back in our time, an overly eager historian, someone who had no idea what they were grabbing or someone wanting to stir trouble, I just don't know.“

Celestia seemed in reminiss about something, but Twilight thought it best not to pry.

"We'll get them back, Princess Celestia, I swear on it.“

"Thank you Twilight,“ she responded through held-back tears. "I put my trust in you. I think I need some rest, I have not slept in fourty winks or so.“

"Yeah, I'll help settle this, please get some rest.“

"Twilight, I ask of you kindly, please consult with Luna; Luna, please take this list of people and do your best. I will see you all in a couple of hours.“

Celestia slowly made her way out of the restricted section, Twilight looking to Spike. "Are you okay Spike? You've been quiet, are you feeling okay?“

"Sorry Twi, trying to not rest myself up a little where I can.“

"Look Spike, sorry, go back home to the castle for a little bit, get some rest. I'll let you know when I need you.“

Luna exhaled a sound with no particular words, she seemed hesitant about something.

"Is everything okay Luna?“ Twilight asked.

Luna was looking down at her list, before finally letting words out.

"It's nothing.“

Suspect list:
~~Rainbow Dash~~ (Her evidence was planted?)
Gray Tank
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
Love Joyful
Discord
Starlight Glimmer
Twilight Sparkle
Library staff
Sunset Shimmer(?)
Spike (Most suspicious)
Changeling (A changeling seems to be almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

4: Gray Generalisations

"So you're this Gray Tank everything's been talking about huh?“ Detective Rarity inquired.

"Yep.“

"And you're a deliveryman, isn't that right?“

"Uh huh.“

"A man of little words huh? Well I don't mind it myself, ya get me darling?“ Rarity spoke with a batting of eyelashes.

"Nope.“

Rarity frowned, charms weren't likely to go far with someone like this. The green stallion with the envelope cutie mark must have had the greatest poker face this side of Las Pegasus.

"Very well, let's get to brass tax if you insist. Yesterday, you were under orders to deliver some new books for the library, right?“

"Right.“

"Do you deliver books for Amethyst regularly?“

"Fortnight.“

"Every two weeks huh? So how far have you gone into the library?“

"I place some for her.“

"In the bookshelves? How about the... lower levels, say the restricted section for example.“

"Nope.“

"Certain?“

"Only the princesses are allowed in, to my knowledge.“

"Hm, so you know that much. So tell me, on the day in question, which parts of the libary did you explore?“

"Reception; Amethyst said to.“

"Okay, lastly, see any suspicious people?“

"Nope.“

After Gray was let go, Rarity stress sighed.

"When are we gonna find our first lead, Luna? This is not going how I expected.“

"This is indeed quite an issue. He had nothing of value to say.“

"Actually,“ Twilight said. "Toward the end, when he said he had nothing to add, something felt off. Spike, write me a reminder to look into-“

"You let him go Darling, to get some rest remember?“

"Oh yeah, I hope he's getting some good rest at the castle. Oh Luna, how long will my home be blocked off?“

"I'm sorry, I'm not certain on that, it would be a query for my Sister.“

"Speaking of Sister, wouldn't Cadence be able to help us?“

"She has important diplomatic duties in Griffonstone, I'm afraid she may yet be busy for a while; I will only call her back if this escalates.“

"Was there anyone else at the festival to talk to?“

"Love Joyful was reportedly there, but we are trying to locate her as we do not contain her residence in our records. We have ponies on duty for finding her; Twilight, would you kindly locate Starlight Glimmer please?“

"Of course, she should be staying at the Hoof Inn.“

"When is she set to move in with you Twilight?“

"In two days, but with this incident, it's hard to say for sure. Okay, I'll check on Glimmer, but I'm not gonna be too harsh, okay? She's only recently reformed and I don't want it to seem like we're straight back to judging her.“

"I suppose there is no helping it: very well.“

Twilight spread her wings and took to the sky. The Hoof Inn was in Canterlot and she knew it would be a short journey.

"Well, maybe I should check up on Spike after I see Glimmer, see how he's doing. I'll make my visit quick as can be.“

Having talked to the receptionist, Twilight knocked and then came in immediately.

Starlight was sat at a table with playing cards sprewed across it, the other seats hosting various objects such as a balloon, a rock and a golden cane with Twilight's face on it.

"No Mr Squiggles,“ Starlight said to the green balloon "You can't say ask for any 9's if you don't have a 9. that's not how Go Fish works.“ She was so engrossed with her mono-directional conversation she did not hear Twilight's arrival. "Oh Twilight, how are you? I'm just uh... cleaning up,“ she lied, shoving the other 'players' away. "How did all these get here? Haha, definitely wasn't practicing friendship or something like that heh.“

"WIth rocks?“

"Well, we have to start somewhere I guess. I haven't got to really learn how to talk to people without manipulating them into doing what you want after all. I've been reading a good book on it.“

"Well I'm glad to see you make an effort Starlight, but yeah you will definitely need some real friendship lessons too.“

"Why are you here anyway Twilight? Am I ready to move in?“

"Oh right, sorry sorry, yes I'm here on important business. I have some questions please Starlight, it's to help solve a strange case of theft at Canterlot.“

"Oh, you don't think it was me do you? I wouldn't do that... anymore.“

"No no, there's no way you're suspected, it's just asking around for information, but just to make sure, where were you yesterday at about 17:00?“

"i was teaching my uh... friendship partners about Go Fish, but I guess someone didn't get the message huh, Jerry?“ she pointed judgingly at the balloon.

"Sure. So er, you were here. Have you seen any suspicious ponies around lately?“

"Can't say I have, but remember until recently I've pretty ran a closed society for a long time, so there'd be loads of ponies I would not have met. I don't know how is and isn't typically up to no good.“

"Fair point. Just for confirmation, do you have an alibi for everything?“

"Well there's a record at the inn for when I have checked in and out, so that can be checked of course.“

"You do remember we can teleport, right?.“

"By that stretch, you can't have an alibi either Twilight, but doubt it could be you.“

"That's true, well I trust you Starlight. You've already shown so much improvement and it's clear you've been-"“Twilight looks around the room at Starlight's 'friends'. "you've been busy anyway.“ She smiled and left the inn.

"Well, that was another dud, I suppose I had better get back to Princess Luna and report.“

She made it over pretty quickly to Luna, who was finishing up questioning with Detective Rarity.

"So Rarity, how is the inve-“

"Oh Twilight dear, it's been a disZAAAster, we've not made any more progress.“

"Well we still have a few leads to chase Rarity, you never know-“

"Oh you're right, but who else were there?“

"Well I checked on Starlight and she seems to not be involved. She was *ahem* talking with friends when I got there.“

"Oh wow, she already made some new friends. I'm so happy for her!“

"Luna, who did we have yet to talk with?“

"Well if you must know... Love Joyful has not been found yet, Discord is on our list being an entity of chaos and easily capable, Sunset Shimmer is under heavy suspicion because Spike reported she came and left yesterday, and if I may be honest Twilight, please do not take this the wrong way.“

"I promise Luna.“

"You are under suspicion, but you are not our main suspect.“

"Oh well, I er- I understand, we have to be careful, right?“ Twilight smiled.

"But I'm afraid the more pressing matter is Spike; you see-“

"Spike? Oh dear, I forgot to visit him.“

Twilight flew out the door, shortly returning.

"Wait, Spike is being suspected too?“ she grimaced.

"I'm afraid so Twilight, please be a little wary. I don't know why, but Celestia seemed most suspicious by his actions.“

"Spikey wikey would never!“ Rarity interjected. "He's just a boy, why would he even do that?“

"I don't know, but please believe my sister.“

"But you won't believe in Spike?“ Twilight replied angrily, forgetting whom she was addressing. "I need to check on Spike.“

She instantly teleported to Spike's room.

"Spike I need to tal-“

The room was empty.

~~Rainbow Dash (Her evidence was planted?)~~
Gray Tank Little to offer, never made it past Reception, backed up by Amethyst
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
Love Joyful
Discord
~~Starlight Glimmer~~ Far from bulletproof, but seemed busy and had nothing to add.
Twilight Sparkle
~~Library staff~~ No suspicious or helpful people
Sunset Shimmer(?)
Spike (Most suspicious)
Changeling (A changeling seems to be almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

5: Surveyance for Spike

"Princess Luna, Spike has gone missing!“

"What?“

Twilight was in a panic, having returned straight from his room.

"He was supposed to be resting, where could he have gone?“ Rarity queried.

"Or, who could have taken him“ Twilight uttered, panic overdriving rational thought.

"I'm gonna find him.“ She flew out, not waiting for a reply.

"They aren't any Royal Guards spare, but we cannot do nothing. Rarity, please assist me in rallying for a search party.“

"Certainly Luna.“

The two dispersed, in a desperate search for Spike, hoping for his safety.

Twilight realised she hadn't checked the whole castle yet, so she searched through quickly, but there was no sign of him. She knew the first place to check would be their house. When she arrived, the whole house was sealed off with tape and protected by Royal Guards. She knew Celestia ordered it, but seeing it herself didn't feel real. She saw a group of three guards carrying out the crystal mirror.

"Hey, erm, are you taking away everything from the house?“

"Oh, Twilight! No, just particular things.“

"Can I come in and se-“

"Oh no sorry, no one is allowed in, under orders of Princess Celestia, not you or even Luna has permission.“

"Right, but what I need to know is whether Spike was here or not.“

"Oh yeah it was weird, did you not bring Spike with you?“

"What? Of course he was, he was with me half an hour ago, but he's gone missing.“

"Well that's mighty perculiar, Spike came out of this house about five minutes ago.“

"Wait, really? Where did he go?“

"Well uh, he went round the corner down there, something about seeing a friend.“

"Great, thank you,“ Twilight shouted as she sped off quickly. The guard tried to shout to her as she left, fell on deaf ears.

"Can you ask him how he got in? He never en-, oh she's gone. Ah well.“

The guard watched the guards above heaving heavily with the heavy mirror, having to fly it in their hooves toward Canterlot Castle.

Twilight tried to generally overlook as many creatures as possible, but the chance of spotting Spike was so slim, but at least she had a general idea of where he went this time.

"Hm, he said something about a friend. What friend could Spike have gone to, especially in this direction? This is East back to Canterlot, but what friends in Canterlot could there be, unless he was coming back to find me? Unless it's somewhere further east, but Fillydelphia is the closest populated place and Spike has no-one to visit there. Could he have gone to Foal Mountain? There's nothing there. Come on think. I just really, really hope he's gonna be at the Castle and I can STOP panicking so much.“

"Hey Twilight,“ Spike exclaimed hurriedly, flying in the air in front of her. "How are you doing?“

"Spike!“ Twilight embraced him tightly. "Spike!"

Twilight begun to cry as she gripped Spike.

"Twi, nice to see you and all, but your grip is a little-“

Twilight let go of him.

"Tight, right. Sorry Spike. Honest though, where were you? I've been looking all over for you.“

"What? Me? I was resting at the castle.“

"But I went and you weren't there.“

"Oh, uh, I mean I went to get some air for a while. You know, some fresh air.“

"But you also went to the house, right?“

Spike's face grimaced for a moment, he had little to say.

"Um, who said-“

"I went to look for you and a guard told me you were there.“

"Oh, um, sorry Twilight. I may have told a little lie, I'm sorry. It's just I- I was feeling really homesick and hoped they were done, but I guess we're not gonna be able to go home anytime soon.“

"Oh Spike, I'm sorry, I should have known that would bother you. I'm sorry for paying more attention.“

"No no Twilight, don't beat yourself up. Let's just move on from this. I mean you found me, so we can just pretend this never happened and-“

"I'm sorry, but I needed to find you, so I told Luna and Rarity about you missing. I don't know for sure, but they might have-“

"We need to tell them you found me.“

"Right.“

They went back to the library and sure enough, Rarity and Luna were no longer in sight.

"Oh no this can't be happening,“ Spike flew around the room aimlessly "We need to get the word out the fastest way possible, how do we do that?“

"We must turn to Celestia, if she lowers the sun, perhaps Luna will realise something is wrong and fly back.“

"I hate to wake the Princess, but we have little choice.“

They both went up to the Princesses quarters, guarded by multiple guards.

"I'm sorry, but we request to speak with Celestia, we urgently need her help. Luna is putting out a missing creatures report and they've been found.“

"Sorry, but we are under strict orders-“

"Come in,“ a powerful but aching voice echoed from behind the door. The guards wasted no time in opening the quarters.

"So Spike went missing, did he? I will try to signal to my Sister, please wait a moment.“

The simmering sun in the sky swiftly descended down, only a small part of the sun remaining to provide some light. After a few seconds, the moon rose up for a moment before dipping again and Celestia returned the sun to its original position.

"Thank you so much.“

"I wish to know what happened to Spike. Were you whisked away by somepony?“

"No, I'm sorry it's my fault,“ Spike apologised. "I went to get some air, but I started to feel really homesick and briefly went to the house, but I came right back, I didn't think Twilight would come and check on me so soon, I feel stupid.“

"I see, you understand how greatly you worried Twilight, correct?“

Spike lowered his head.

"I just ask of you to please not do that again, I don't think Twilight could take it again and lest we need another search party for you. We all care about you, Spike.“

"Yeah, I'm really sorry, I don't plan to disappear again.“

"Glad to hear, you should be safe here, but if something happens, we swear to protect you.“

Twilight updated Celestia to the goings-on in the investigation, Celestia given no more hope than before.

"Celestia, may I ask why these books seem especially important to you?“

Celestia held her tongue at first, but she submitted.

"It's more so one book in the collection if I may be honest. Do you know of somepony named Opal Yodel?“

"I do not.“

Luna suddenly came into sight with another pony by her side, hurriedly flying over.

"Thank you for coming Luna, we have found Spike safe and sound and needed the search cancelled.“

"Oh thank goodness I started to worry you were in danger. Well, I will need to inform Rarity.“

"Who is this pony you have brought, Luna?“

"Ah nice ta meet ya, I'm Love Joyful.“

~~Rainbow Dash~~ (Her evidence was planted?)
~~Gray Tank~~ Little to offer, never made it past Reception, backed up by Amethyst
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
Love Joyful
Discord
Starlight Glimmer Far from bulletproof, but seemed busy and had nothing to add.
Twilight Sparkle
~~Library staff~~ No suspicious or helpful people
Sunset Shimmer(?)
Spike (Even more suspicious)
Changeling (A changeling seems to be almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

6: Love Located

"Do not fret, darlings! Detective Rarity has returned!“

"Sorry for you having to go looking for Spike, Rarity,“ Twilight apologised. "You're sorry, right Spike?“

"Really sorry.“

"Oh no, it's no worries, I understand your panic, if my dear Sweetie Belle went missing, I don't know what I would do.“

"Oh, are you the pony 'ere to interview me?“ Love Joyful smiled.

"it's called an *interrogation*, darling; don't get the two confused. I'm afraid this is a little more serious.“

"Oh well that's okay, if I tell ya what ya want, I'll get to go, I can't see it taking migh'y long.“

"If you're co-operative, then absolutely.“

Luna was also in the room to watch the interrogation unfold, Celestia was here but she went to leave the room.

"Where art thou going, dear Sister?“

"I have another suspect to attend to, but I am in need of the Crystal Mirror.“

"Ah, you mean Sunset Shimmer.“

"Wait," Spike said "but that's at our place.“

"No need to worry Spike, I've moved it back to the castle, just temporarily of course. Once it's all done, I'll return it.“

"Oh, but you're gonna see Sunset through there?“

"Yes, I will have her come straight here to be interrogated too.“

Detective Rarity sighed melodramatically.

"No rest for a good detective, I see. Well, let's get through this one before Celestia is done.“

Love Joyful sat with her legs crossed on the stool provided for her. Her smile was small but consistent. She was an earth pony with a brown mane and a cutie mark with indescript purple markings.

"So Love, or how may you be referred“

"Love or Miss Joyful be okay, miss...“

"Rarity, pleased to meet you. So I have a few questions to ask you Love. Firstly, where were you at the time of the incident?“

"Why, I was at the festival celebration, I must have been spotted, had I not?“

"Were you with anypony at the time?“

"Oh I was making my rounds through some of the pony folk, see how they're doing.“

"Okay, so no solid alibi, but I can confirm that Luna saw you after the books were stolen, so that's something I suppose.“

"Oh Rarity, I saw her there too“ Spike added.

"Oh really? Well I suppose that makes at least two. When did you see her?“

"Oh I saw her about halfway through the party.“

"Huh, that's roughly when the theft took place, so that's pretty solid. I must ask more questions to be sure though, Miss Joyful. Especially your address, there is no formal writing of your address. So where may that be?“

"Oh, that's an easy un, I'm a travelling pony miss, all of errrrquestria's ma home.“

"I see. You move in some locomotive?“

"Yeah, my wagon, I'll show ya sometime.“

"Now now, no flirting with a lady on the job.“

"Beg ya pardon?“

"Anywho, how do you explain your disappearances? You're rarely ever seen in Equestria, I only know of a few ponies who have even heard of you.“

"Tis' the life of a hermit. We don't associate too much with other... folk.“

"Huh, makes sense I suppose. Okay well, I don't believe I have any more questions for you.“

"Great, then I'll be-“

"Well I have one," Luna stated. "Why were you at the party?“

"Yer- Excuse me?“

"If you really do not speak to others, then why had thou attended the party?"“

"Well I-“

"Infact, did you not mention you were 'making rounds with the pony folk?'“

"Well, I just wanted to see everyb- everypony once in a while, I don't like talkin' ta folks regular, but a party's different you know?“

"Hm, okay. I have no more questions.“

Love Joyful aired a sigh of relief.

"This interview has migh'y tired me out, so Im'ma hit the hay, is that a thing?“ she asked. "Anyways, I'll be off, uh travelling.“

"Where may we find you darling?“

"Er... I just go where the road takes me. Maybe south or something.“

"Stay in touch.“

Love left out the door, trotting carefree out.

"Well she seemed pleasant enough,“ Rarity commented. "She even has a bit of an alibi, that feels unique here“

"Hey wait. I have an alibi too,“ Twilight pointed out. "I was with you guys the whole time.“

"Not quite,“ Luna commented. "I know you had excused yourself for about twenty minutes or so, did you not?“

"I was not feeling too well Luna, but yes I did do that I suppose. But Spike was there.“

"That's true, but he is suspicious for other reasons. Remember, we have strong reason to suspect a Changeling was involved in all of this, disguising themselves as Celestia. It's likely two, maybe even more, may be at fault here. For the same reason, I do not completely rule her out, but I agree she does not strike me as high on the list. Now we just wait for Celestia to return to continue the investigation. After that, I suppose Discord would be contacted next. After, I dread to consider.“

While waiting for their return, Rarity had a couple of Royal Guards grab up a sofa for her to collapse on, Twilight and Spike were pacing a little, both visibly stressed and Luna spoke to the guards.

"Twilight, can I go out for a bit please?“

"No, Spike.“

"But I'm not really needed her right now, I'm just a notetaker.“

"I apologise Spike“ Luna chimed in "but I concur. I wish for everypony to remain present here.“

"Right. Guess Spike the Notetaker has a long day ahead of him“

"Come now Spike, this is serious, but it won't be too long I'm sure.“

"Only if Sunset did it.“

"Don't joke about that Spike; Sunset would never do that.“

"I know, that's why I'm saying it's not gonna be over.“

"Speaking of, she's still not here. How long has it been now? An hour?“

"I am starting to worry,“ Luna admitted. "It has been a while, I must know what is occuring. She's in the other world, we need to find her, but I don't know that other world.“

"But I do,“ Twilight smiled. "I can go there and find them both“

"Excellent, I shall accompany you“ Luna smiled.

"I mean you can, butttt it's school time for them and you and Celestia's other half are the principals of the school, so it might be too risky. But if Celestia is there, maybe it won't hurt.“

"No no, I trust you, just please bring my Sister back safe.“

"I'll make sure. Take us to the portal.“

"Well, guess I'm gonna have to be a dog again.“

"Hey, at least you don't have to remind yourself how to walk on two legs.“

"Ahem, I'm on four, remember?“

"Oh, yeah. Well, we shouldn't be there long. We'll be in pretty quick and out the same.“

Luna guided them up to the portal room.

"I wish you luck Twilight,“ Rarity shouted. "If you could snap a piture of what I look like, I'd love to know, unless it's unfabulous, in which case, just enjoy yourself.“

"Just come through with us and hop back through.“

"Twilight, this is not a plaything,“ Luna scolded. "If there is another Rarity near the portal, let's not take unneeded risk, correct?“

"I suppose you're right. Come on Spike, let's get this done with.“

"Twilight, two minutes, I need to use the lavatory urgently.“

"Ah, alright, hurry up.“

After ten minutes of waiting, Twilight was ready to head in alone but Spike came rushing back.

"You were a long time Spike, there's no time to waste.“

"What? Right, Twilight let's get this done with. Let's do this, Operation: Princess.“

"Come now, be serious“ Luna moaned as the crystal mirror flashed before her.

~~Rainbow Dash~~ (Her evidence was planted?)
~~Gray Tank~~ Little to offer, never made it past Reception, backed up by Amethyst
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
~~Love Joyful~~ Has a reasonable alibi, but she's kind of an oddball.
Discord
Starlight Glimmer Far from bulletproof, but seemed busy and had nothing to add.
Twilight Sparkle
~~Library staff~~ No suspicious or helpful people
Sunset Shimmer(?)
Spike (Even more suspicious)
Changeling (A changeling seems to be almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

7: Seeking Sunset

Twilight legs collapsed pretty soon after making it through the portal. As expected, the sudden change of limbs after so long made her lose control.

"Twilight, you good?“

"Yes Spike, just grazed my hind legs a little, I'm okay.“

"Thankfully four legs are easier than two, which ain't too bad. Being a dog feels weird though, pretty demeaning.“

"We have no time Spike, we need to figure out how we're gonna do this. According to that clock, it's 14:00, so Sunset should be in class, right?“

"I guess. Twilight, don't you have a 'you' in this reality too?“

"Sunset told me she went to a different school, so it shouldn't be a problem. As for you... It's kind of strange we've never seen another you. I'm not complaining, less stress to deal with.“

"What's *that* supposed to mean?“

"It means we don't have to worry about bumping into another you, Spike.“

"Well sometimes I don't feel you appreciate me enough Twilight.“

"Can we talk about this another time, Spike? We're kinda busy right now.“

"If you say so.“

"Now, I don't think there's a back entrance and we're not likely to find an open window, so I guess we'll have no choice but to go through the front.“

"What'll we do if we get caught?“

"I don't know, we used to be a student here so we could say we moved back into town.“

"That's as good as cover as we can manage. Let's go for it.“

The two entered the oddly empty corridors of the school.

"Where is everyone, Twilight?“

"It's strange, I don't even see any faces in the classrooms.“

They wandered through, trying to be careful, but they managed to avoid any encounters, until finally after entering the second floor, they see two faces standing in the hallway. There was a janitor and Princess Celestia, but it was hard to tell from look alone which Celestia it was.

"Ah, Principal. I hope you're having a wonderful day today.“

"Oh er quite, young human.“

"Excuse me, but aren't you supposed to be at the Gymnasium with the other students?“

"Oh er yes, of course! I er... My dear sister Luna was watching over for them while I nipped out quickly, I'll be heading there.“

"You two are sisters? Wow, I never even thought to ask to be honest. If you'll excuse me...“

The man carried on toward Twilight and Spike, who hid quickly in a classroom nearby, keeping the door slightly ajar to not attract noise. They heard the man's foosteps go past, before he grunts and the footsteps get closer again. Twilight tries to hold her breath before the door gets shoved shut.

"Those darn kids again.“

The sound of footsteps went quiet again.

"Whew, that was close Spike. Let's not cut it that close again.“

"Yeah let's get outta here.“

"Wait Spike, what in Equestria is that?“

Spike let out a good gasp.

Twilight was shook by what she saw. The wooden desk had a small symbol carved into it with a sharp object and it resembled the Equestrian Flag, quite finely detailed.

"Who would do this? The only one who's been to Equestria is us or-“

"Sunset Shimmer.“

"But she wouldn't do that, surely?“

"It literally is not important Twilight, get your head in gear.“

"Spike, where is all this coming from?“

"Forget it. Let's get this done.“

Twilight's lengthy lexicon felt like a garble of sounds, she could not speak so she tried to calm down, to make sure Celestia did not get too ahead of them.

"Hello Tw- I mean, hello student. How may I help you?“

"Does 'Winter Wrap Up' mean anything to you?“

"Oh wonderful, It is you Twilight.“

"Yeah it's me, are you doing okay Celestia? Your legs are quaking.“

"Ah yes, it's these legs, still not used to them. Just standing is quite exhausting.“

"It took me time too. Has anyone else spotted you?“

"Other than that pony, err...“

"Person.“

"Yes, that par son, nopony else.“

"Nobody else.“

"Ah, blast this strange language.“

"You get used to it. Saying words like anybody and somebod- wait, didn't I hear-“

"Twilight, perhaps we should hasten. How long until the end of school?“

"About... fifteen minutes?! Yeah, let's get to this gymnasium.“

"Do you know its location?“

"Absolutely, some things you just don't forget.“

Still airing some caution, they found their way outside the gymnasium where Celestia and Luna are speaking through a microphone. There was a pair of windows in the door so they could look through carefully, trying not to draw attention.

"So that is Luna as a human, hm?“ Celestia noted. "It's a cute look for her, I will have to seek out an artist to recreate it.“

"I see Sunset.“

She was sat on the top row, they tried to watch for her eyes straying while trying to make sure the other kids were not looking. Their lucky break soon came. Her eyes glanced over towards the door and she recognised Twilight's hand and soon got a shot of her face. Once Twilight knew, she hid her face and used her hand, pointing down repeatedly, trying to indicate for her to stay there after it finishes.

"Do you think it worked?“ Spike asked.

"I don't know, but there's no more we can do. Let's hide in one of these rooms. But where could we go“

"Hm, they might go to their classrooms to pick up their bags, so...“

"I've got it, the storage closet.“

Twilight and Celestia took to Spike's idea, cramping themselves into the enclosed space.

"Hey Twilight, I have an idea.“ Spike said. "I could sneak my way in since I'm small and all, then I can tell her where we are.“

"Let's stick to the plan Spike.“

The door swung open, the brooms around them falling out. Fearing they had been spotted by the students or worse, Twilight cowered down. The caretaker from earlier stood outside the door, a bewildered look on their face.

"Erm principal, I thought you were going to the gynasium. What are you doing in there with a stu-“

The indoor lighting felt particularly loud.

"Oh uh you see I was just asking my student Twilight for help getting some brooms.“

"Uhhh huh.“

"And well, we struggled to find what we were looking for.“

"A broom?“

"Yes.“

"In a *broom closet*?“

"Yep.“

"Yeah, we'll see what the school board has to say about this when I take this pic- Ah the battery's dead, I knew I shouldn't have been browsing Insta so much, just wait there, I need a picture of you all.“

He took off jogging down the corridor. Soon after, the bell for the end of school rung and students were about to burst out the door, so Twilight hurriedly closed the door again, hoping they all left before they came back.

"I think we need a new hiding place huh Spike? Spike?! Uh, I told him not to sneak off.“

Celestia and Twilight waited for the noise to die down when the door swung open once more.

"I'm not photogenic, let's not,“ Twilight yelled, expecting the janitor again, but instead Sunset's beaming smile was on the other side with Spike in hand.

"Long time no see, Twi.“

"Sunset!“ Twilight gleamed. "So good to see you.“

"Yeah, a journal's nice and all, but face-to-face is the best. Hey, is that Celestia?“

"Long time no see my student. I'm sorry, but can we get out of this par-son box post-haste?“

"We've uh... been misunderstood by the school janitor.“

"Which way did we go?“

"He said something about a dead battery and Insta, whatever those may be.“

"He must've gone to the office to charge his phone. Let's go the long way out, we should be able to totally avoid him that way.“

The three scampered off to the exit, trying to not cause too much attention, though Celestia walking with the students seemed odd since Principal Celestia looked to be staying behind.

Sometime later, the Principal made his way back to the broom closet.

"Alright Celestia, say hello to 39 followers.“

Alas, Principal and the student had fled already. He ran into the gymnasium, where Celestia and Luna were packing away the supplies being used for the school presentation.

"Principal, I must know what you were doing with your student in the broom closet ten minutes ago.“

"Excuse me?“ Luna answered for her sister. "What exactly do you mean by that?“

"I saw her and Twilight in the broom closet just a few minutes ago. You can't deny it, I saw you.“

"That's clearly impossible, Celestia and I have been in this gymnasium for the hour; we hadn't even stepped out for a break.“

"But that can't be right, I saw you clear as day.“

"Well I was witness to Princess Celestia as well as every single student who was here today.“

"Do you have a twin Celestia? She looked exactly like you, plus that girl Twilight-“

"Was here, front row.“

"Well I suppose her hair was very different, she didn't tie it up like she normally does.“

"Hm, well I don't know what you think you saw Principal, but I imagine you have something to prove this, right? Perhaps a photo or something?“

"About that... Uh, my phone may have ran out of battery.“

"I think we're done here.“

"So Twilight, what did you come all this way out for?“

Sunset sat opposite to Twilight in a diner they liked to frequent on the infrequent visits. Spike was sat beside Twilight; Spike was light drooling and shaking, but Twilight was too pre-occupied to notice. Rarity sat on Twilight's side at the edge of the seats.

Sunset continued. "I can't imagine it's just a casual visit if you have to risk bringing Celestia of all ponies here at school time.“

"Unfortunately, it's true. I have questions I need to ask. Obviously Celestia wanted to stay here, but I think she underestimated how much attention being a principal brings to you.“

"Yeah, you didn't cause any trouble for the Principal, did you?“

"I didn't stay to find out, butttttt we may have caused some confusion for the poor janitor.“

"Well I'm sorry for intruding upon this,“ Rarity sighed "but Celestia stuck out too much, but I found out we're all friends in this world so I would blend in fabulously. And may I say, this form is so cute! What kind of fashion is in this world? Am I a designer here too?! Ooh, it all excites me, I look great in this world too!“

"Rarity, I know the feeling, but we need focus right now.“

"Yes yes very good, let's begin with questions. I'll have my partner, Junior Investigator Twilight Sparkle begin.“

"Right, so I have some questions about an incident in Equestria.“

"Oh that's right,“ Sunset said, lowering her head.

"'Oh that's right?‘“

"Oh uh I mean, obviously it had to do with Equestria right? Haha.“

BARK

Spike suddenly barked loudly, drawing the attention of everyone, causing Sunset to hide him quickly in her bag. Rarity stood up and made a scene.

"Oh, that dog is *so* noisy outside! Hm!“

Rarity's louder exclamation to deflect eventually worked, everyone returning to their conversations or work.

"That was close Spike,“ Twilight muttered in an annoyed tone. "Please be careful.“

"Hm.“

"Oh right. Sunset, we just need to clear some things okay?“ Rarity said. "I don't believe it is you, but we need information.“

"Sure, let's... er do this.“

"First, where were you at about 5PM yesterday?“

"Oh well school was over so I went home to relax a bit. Ow.“

"Are you okay Sunset?“

"Yeah sorry, just felt a pain in my leg. It's nothing.“

"Okay, continue when able.“

"Oh sorry, I forgot to mention, I didn't go home at first, not right away. I went to the portal in the statue.“

"Yes, Spike told me you tried to visit“, Twilight added. "Tell me more please.“

"Well, not much to tell to be honest. I went through, Spike was there and told me you were celebrating the Summer Sun festival, so I said I'd come back another time.“

"That matches what Spike said, but please tell me, why were you coming here in the first place?“

"Oh that, well you know I wanted to see my favourite pony.“

"I mean I understand that, but it's just odd, you normally write to me in the journal before we meet up.“

"I suppose, I was just lonely you know?“

Rarity, watching over Sunset's expressions carefully, took over as Detective again.

"Well, I suppose you don't fit as someone who would want to steal forbidden books from Canterlot's collection.“

"What? From the restricted section? Wow that's really serious.“

"I would agree Darling, but if I may say, you suddenly look like you have something to say.“

"What, me?“ Sunset spoke through grated teeth, sweat dripping down her face. "No no, I wouldn't. As you said, I weren't even there or had any reason to want to take any books.“

"But if you have any info, no matter how small, you can talk to us. You won't be in trouble you know. We honestly just want the books back and anything that brings us to that conclusion.“

"Well if that's the case, I wish you luck. I'm sure you'll find them soon. Say, I need to head home soon. We've been warned to be careful.“

"What do you mean darling?“

"A student has been missing from Canterlot High, so they brought us to the Gymnasium to warn us to take care on our way home.“

"That's horrible, I hope they find them soon Sunset.“

"Me too, well I need to go along, best of luck Twilight and nice to meet you other Rarity.“

"It's a pleasure, take care!“

Sunset soon left the cafe, leaving the others. The waitress came round to their table.

"Here's your bill!“

Rarity and Twilight suddenly panicked.

"I'll go fetch Sunset real quick.“

"Be a dear.“

~~Rainbow Dash~~ (Her evidence was planted?)
~~Gray Tank~~ Little to offer, never made it past Reception, backed up by Amethyst
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
~~Love Joyful~~ Has a reasonable alibi, but she's kind of an oddball.
Discord
Starlight Glimmer Far from bulletproof, but seemed busy and had nothing to add.
Twilight Sparkle
~~Library staff~~ No suspicious or helpful people
Sunset Shimmer, seems to be hiding something, but according to Spike, she went back home.
Spike (Even more suspicious)
Changeling (A changeling seems to be almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

Author's Note

Sorry for a week with no update; real life stuff.

8: Damming Discovery

Twilight and Rarity went through the statue, finally returning to Equestria. When they got through, they heard loud mutterings down the hallway.

"What in Equestria is going on in there?“ Rarity said.

They ran into Celestia's room, where Luna, Celestia, Fluttershy and the Royal Guards were stood around. Celestia was raising her voice at one of the guards. Spike ran off down the hall.

"Spike, where are you going?“

"Oh, I'm rushing to the little dragon's room, I'll be quick.“

"Spike, you went before you left! Uh.“

After a couple of minutes, Spike was back just as a Royal Guard was getting berated by Celestia.

"Have you truly not found any leads? Any at all?“

"I'm sorry Princess Celestia, we have done all I could.“

"I suppose that is true, sorry, please tell me everything, even if there is little of nothing to report.“

"Y-yes your highness. So for the Changeling situation, we did as you asked and questioned ponies if they had experienced anything recently that could be the doing of a Changeling. We had one elderly pony say that some stranger pony suddenly morphed into their wife, but it turns out they weren't wearing their glasses, so their sight was all blurry.“

"Okay, next manner of business. Finding Discord. All you could find was Fluttershy, but we've just asked and she hasn't seen Discord in a few days.“

"I'm sorry I can't be of more help Celestia“ Fluttershy apologised.

"It's okay Fluttershy.“

"Okay, lastly, how did the guarding of Twilight and Spike's home go?“

"Dear Sister, I actually got an update on that. Please tell them, Royal Guard.“

"Yes well, Spike exited the building earlier today while we were guarding.“

"Well, Spike did go missing for a while, but how in Equestria did you not stop him entering?“

"Well we never saw him enter. I swear we were guarding diligently, Your Highnesses, but somehow Spike made it in.“

Everyone turned straight to Spike, he started to back towards a wall.

"Anything to share Spike?“

"Uh, um, well the reason why is that I felt really homesick and I wanted to go quickly and take a moment inside. How, well, I admit I had to distract your guards guarding the entrances at the top. I'm really sorry, it wasn't right of me.“

"If I may be frank Spike, I've been suspicious of you from the start; your behaviour has been strange to say the least. Even if you did not steal the books yourself, I cannot shake the feeling you are involved. I swear this to you, if you tell us everything you know, you will not be held accountable. I just want the books returned, nothing more.“

"I'm sorry, I really don't know anything.“

"Can you tell me Spike“ Twilight asked. "After all this, I know Celestia keeps her word.“

"She does, but I have nothing to say“ Spike replied.

"Spike, this investigation is going nowhere! I want to believe in you, but your behaviour at times has been odd, but you won't explain.“

"You're on the list of suspects too Twilight.“

"That's not the point Spike, I've helped all I can.“

"Sister, may we adjourn for a moment? I believe the stress is causing everypony agitation“ Luna suggested.

"You may be right. Very well. We will take a couple of hours, but at 18:00, we all return to this spot.“

"Sounds grand,“ Rarity sighed. "This detective business is hard work, I need some me ice cream time.“

The group dispersed with heavy eyes; Twilight and Spike head toward their temporary living spaces.

"Spike, how would you like to stay in my room tonight? I can go on the ground if you'd like.“

"I knew it, you don't trust me Twilight.“

"Spike, I want to trust you, truly I do. If you can do this for me, I'll have no more doubt.“

"Twilight.“

"I really do believe in you, but I get upset at seeing everypony point the hoof at you. We don't want to do this, but if you stay with me and anything happens, you have an alibi; they suspect me a little, but they know I'm a poor liar.“

"Twilight, I... I want you to hear me out please, but you have to promise me you won't tell anypony else.“

"Cross my heart and hope to die, stick a cupcake in my eye.“

"Okay. So, I may or may not know who has been doing this, but I want to turn them in, but just telling you who it is won't do anything. If I can get out of here alone right now, I can trap them and get them to confess or at least get them all panicked. If it doesn't work, I'll tell everypony.“

"Will you tell me who it is?“

"Not yet, but very very soon you'll know. Twi, I really really need you to promise you you'll keep this quiet.“

Twilight felt there was still more to it, but if Spike was going to trust her with this much, she felt obliged to give some trust back.

"Thank you Spike, I promise. But you need to go alone, right? Are you sure I can't help?“

"They'd be suspicious of you Twilight.“

"Well in that case, I leave it to you Spike. Please come back safe.“

"I'm sorry I've been annoying lately Twilight, but I'm sure this will all end soon. I'll see you soon.“

With that, he flew out, trying to be careful not to be caught by a guard. Twilight waited without real rest for twenty minutes, then fourty more, when the two hours had nearly expired, Spike had finally returned.

"Spike, I was worried sick. Is everything okay?“

"I'm sorry Twilight, I tried to find them but they must have been hiding.“

"Well it's okay, there was no guarantee.“

"I think they might give up though. They're the type who knows everything going on, so they might know I'm going to tell Celestia; they might surrender themselves.“

"I'll give it a couple of days Spike, but after that please tell them what you've told me, every detail you can.“

"Of course Twilight. When are we meeting again?“

"Oh, we have about fifteen min-“

"Sweet Celestia!“

A young mare they knew screamed from downstairs.

"Rarity!“

They both rushed down alongside the elite guards, Celestia and Luna.

"Are you okay Rarity?“

"Oh, Twilight, I just found this uncouth note stuck onto the main gates.“

"How did the guards not see?“

"We haven't left, they must have snuck behind us.“

"Shall I read the note, Princess Celestia?“ Rarity asked.

"Proceed.“

"Yes, it was I who committed a crime at the library yesterday, tomorrow will be more of the same until you catch me. My clue I generously give unto you: My old prison is my new resting place. You have two hours.“

"Who would dare make a mockery of this?“ Celestia demanded. "We need to determine who this is. There are many foes who we have had to imprison in the past.“

"Could it be Lord Tirek again,“ Rarity pondered. "He was imprisoned in Tartarus before and he was sent back there by us.“

"It's not impossible,“ Celestia concured "That's one possibility. Perhaps the Pony of Shadow? No, the pillars would have returned if that was the case.“

"Wait, what about Discord?“ Spike chimed in.

"Discord's been reformed, Spikey,“ Rarity pointed out. "Surely we wouldn't cause this much trouble just for a gag unless he really did turn to evil again, but why?“

"I don't know why he would want the books, but we'll have to find out,“ Celestia frowned. "I think we have two likely leads. Luna, take half the Royal Guards to Tartarus and I will take the other half to the place he was turned to stone.“

"What should we have, Princesses?“ Twilight asked.

"You may come with me Twilight; everypony else should stay back for now. Wait for further word.“

Twilight joined her mentor in flying back to that stone statue. It didn't make sense to Twilight for Discord betraying them pver a few books when he doesn't even seem to read a whole lot. If it was a prank, it was a little too long for the punchline. Either way, nothing added up, but Spike swore to her he knew the perpetrator and he even named Discord, so this had to be right.

"I promised to believe in Spike, I can't take it back now.“

They soon made it to the statue podium, Discord mimicking the pose he made on that faithful day against the Mane six.

"Does he see this as some kind of joke?“ Celestia grimaced. They all landed down near Discord, his body breaking its still position.

"Whew, finally I can stop holding that, do you even appreciate how hard that was? I've been here for 20 minutes, it's not easy I tell you.“

"Discord, you are being detained under suspicion of commiting theft at the Canterlot Library. Do you have anything to say for yourself?“

"No I did it, kind of, basically, in a manner of speaking,“ he spoke casually as he placed his mis-matched hands into the hoofcuffs. "Oh come on, is this the best you have on you right now? You know I could break out of these with a single thought, you know? Come on be more creative, a suit that shocks me whenever I think of escape, a giant vat of jelly that gets me stuck there, something.“

A mere fifteen minutes later, they arrived back at Canterlot Castle.

"How did it go, Princess Celestia?“ Rarity asked.

"I believe this case is drawing to a close at last“ Celestia smiled.

~~Rainbow Dash~~ (Her evidence was planted?)
~~Gray Tank~~ Little to offer, never made it past Reception, backed up by Amethyst
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
~~Love Joyful~~ Has a reasonable alibi, but she's kind of an oddball.
Discord (Apprehended, the true criminal, any additional ponies involved unidentified
~~Starlight Glimmer Far from bulletproof, but seemed busy and had nothing to add.~~
Twilight Sparkle
~~Library staff~~ No suspicious or helpful people
Sunset Shimmer, seems to be hiding something, but according to Spike, she went back home.
Spike (Even more suspicious)
Changeling (A changeling seems to be almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

Author's Note

A long time once again, been busy unfortunately. This was intended to take a week or two to finish, but hasn't turned out that way.

9: Nagging Notion

It had been five days since Discord's arrest and much of Canterlot and its neighbouring borders had finally felt at ease. In the Canterlot Castle accommodation, Spike and Twilight had woken rather late.

"Whew, finally just one more day then we can move back in,“ Spike smiled. "All's well that's ends well I guess.“

"I don't know Spike, I just have this nagging feeling.“

"Come on Twilight, you've had that 'nagging feeling‘ more than I've ate these past few days. Don't worry, Discord confessed and all is well.“

"Did Discord even admit what he did?“

"He wrote the note, remember? It doesn't matter what he's said since, everything is fine.“

"Well, I suppose I should put this to bed. Anyway, for now, I've got something to do soon. Sunset Shimmer has requested to meet with me back at that Cafe.“

"But Celestia has the Crystal Mirror.“

"Relax, I asked for permission yesterday and had it granted.“

"I'll come with you Twilight, it might be dangerous.“

"I'll be fine, Spike.“

"Well I have a nagging feeling as well Twilight, about you going in there without me.“

"I don't know why you're so insistent Spike, please just be a good dragon and wait here, or go out for a trip, we're pretty much free now. Tomorrow we'll have our home back and then you can do whatever you want.“

"Twilight, if you could wait until tomorrow, you could go in and out of the Crystal Mirror at any point, I could come with you as a bonus then.“

"Sunset insisted it be today if possible Spike. I'll see you soon, Celestia's expecting me!“

Before Spike could continue, Twilight had left. He wondered what he should do now.

"Thanks for coming on such short notice, Twilight.“

"Oh of course Sunset, thank you for inviting me. I assumed from your letter the world was in peril, but things must not be so bad.“

"This isn't world-ending Twilight, but I need to talk to you personally; something's been nagging me Twilight, and I need to get something off my chest.“

"Of course Sunset, you know you can tell me anything.“

"I know, but this is about Spike.“

"Oh no, what's wrong? Was it the barking?“

"Twilight, please hear me out. I- I think Spike's been lying to you.“

"What? Spike? He wouldn't do that, yet he has been acting... odd lately.“

"Twilight, please forgive me, but Spike begged me to lie to you.“

"What?! How did that-“

"At the gymnasium, Spike snuck in.. He said in a hurry before I saw you 'Sunset I'm so sorry to ask anything of you, but I really need you to tell Twilight you came to visit me yesterday, it's super important.‘“

"Spike said that?“ Twilight spoke flustered. "Why would he say that?“

"He told me how to respond to your questions, that I was there but left home immediately. He told me to mention I went to Equestria to visit if you asked, even stuffing him into my bag on his bark was scripted by him.“

"Spike, what did you do?“

"I at first intended to keep my promise to Spike, I didn't think he'd ask me to fib to you without a big reason, but then you told me about the books being stolen from the library and I knew this was way too serious to hide. I debated with myself, but I knew I had to tell you.“

"I can't believe this, that nagging feeling all week-“

"Twilight, last thing, when I got leg pain when I said where I was at 5PM, Spike kicked me through the bag, trying to get me to change my story to what he wanted. What has.., what's gotten into him?“

Sunset began to cry, she didn't feel like she knew Spike anymore. Twilight embraced her with the onlookers trying not to be nosy for too long and make it more awkward.

"I had bad feelings since we caught the culprit five days ago, Sunset. Spike is hiding too much to ignore, I need to get the truth out of him. He's really chang-“

Twilight froze for a moment.

"That's it, that nagging notion, Changeling.“

"Changeling? Those shape-shifting creatures from long ago?“

"Yeah, they returned with Queen Chrysalis and we thought they were gone for good, but Celestia and Luna were sure that a Changeling was involved, because someone impersonating Princess Celestia went into the restricted section at the time. We felt sure there was one involved, but we never caught them.“

"So that changeling is still out there, they could even still be in disguise right now.“

"I need to get back Sunset, thank you so much, you're a great friend and thank you for telling me this.“

"Let me know if you find anything more.“

"Spike! Spike, are you still here?“ she called out in the empty Canterlot hallway. Sure enough, Spike had headed out once again. "I need to break my promise to Spike, Celestia has to know.“

Twilight went around the castle searching for Celestia. She was not in her quarters and the guards she spoke to did not know of her location, until finally a guard blocking the dungeons admitted to her.

"Her Highnesses are speaking with Discord at the moment, I must ask you to return later.“

Twilight seemed intent to wait at first, but that nagging transmorphed slowly into shaking anxiety. She imagined the dungeon in her mind and when out of the guard's eyesight, teleported herself next to the cells, frightening everyone inside. Discord with their handcuffs undone, Fluttershy, Celestia, Luna and a number of Royal Guards were there.

"Whew it's just you Twilight, but you shouldn't be here right now“ Celestia scolded.

"I know, but hear me out, I have info about the book stealing incidence. I don't believe it is Discord, at least not alone.“

"I'm afraid we know that“ Luna commented with a worried expression.

"What do you mean?“

"He just confessed himself. After days of not saying anything, we allowed him to have a visitor, Fluttershy. After 20 minutes of their scheduled half an hour chat, Discord said he would admit everything. He said-“

"No no, allow me,“ Discord interrupted. "I said oh I'm so sorry, I really was the one to commit a crime on that fateful day and I need to repent. I told her it was I, almighty Discord, who had my library book overdue. The looks on their face was priceless, guess Celestia wanted that missing Animal Welfare book too.“

"Discord, Fluttershy said "Please, no jokes. Tell them the truth.“

"Well though the library book thing is true, which by the way is now at least six days overdue, it isn't why I left an ominous note here. I was asked to do so, practically begged.“

"Who?“ Luna asked. "please give details.“

"You wouldn't believe me.“

"It's Spike, isn't it?“ Twilight chimed in.

"Spike!“ Luna exclaimed with surprise. "I thought you was so sure Spike couldn't have done it.“

"I was wrong, Spike is definitely involved. I don't know how he's involved or why, but this has to stop. I came here to give info on Spike.“

"Well, this is quite a pickle,“ Discord sighed. "Never thought I'd see the day dear Twilight turn on her friends.“

"Tell us what you know Discord.“

"Not a lot unfortunately. Spike came to me last night and told me he desperately needed a favour from me and swore he would pay me back in return. I told them there was nothing I could ever want, but he said 'what if you could get an audience to tease Celestia‘ and I admit the prospect sounded amusing for a little bit. I had the punchline planned and he told me the real culprit would get found out, then I could leave. I didn't realise how out-of-hand this would get.“

"Well the cuplrit hasn't found still.“

"They said the person they were protecting were a good person and couldn't get back.“

"Back? Back where?“

"They told me they're not of Equestria and they would never be seen again, just wanted to go home.“

"Not of Equestria? But the only place not of Equestria is through the-“

It finally clicked and that made Twilight even more concerned.

"They're from the human world.“

"That can't be,“ retorted Luna. "The mirror was under your protection and no-one saw them appear.“

"I didn't but maybe Spike did; Spike's protecting them.“

Twilight did not want to believe, but the whispers of doubt grew to screams. It seemed likely from what they found that there was, at the very least, a human, a changeling and Spike directly involved.

"At first,“ Discord added "I was going to stick with the plan as Spike said and wait to be set free, finally admitting it wasn't me and I didn't know where the books were, but Fluttershy came to visit and I realised I had let her down. I didn't consider her feelings and if there was one pony I refused to hide anything from, it was Fluttershy.“

"Thank you so much Discord and Fluttershy, tomorrow was supposed to be the day the Crystal Mirror would be returned home. If that had happened, they may have gotten away and the books could have been lost forever.“

"Discord,“ Celestia said. "I am disappointed you would go this far; I don't think you understood how serious this is to me.“

"I heard the books weren't valuable, so I figured it couldn't be so bad.“

"They are *very* valuable to me. One book in particular, of a very old friend no longer with us. She was a great friend to me and records of those times were taken alongside the books. I could not bare to lose those as I wanted those memories forever in print, I miss her often,“ Celestia said through held-back tears. "I understand you couldn't have known that Discord, but please consider how things small to you may affect others far more than you could know.“

"You're right, I'm so sorry everypony. If you choose to keep me here for a while, I would understand.“

"I will not Discord, I forgive, but I truly hope you learn an important lesson from this.“

"I will. Before I go, any leads to go on and can I help?“

"None. We are going to have to search blindly for two individuals, I fear this will run on much longer now.“

"Now, I have been truthful with everything I just said, but the next is a theory because something was bothering me about Spike. Have you heard anything about a pony called Love Joyful?“

"Yes, we had her talk to us before.“

"There's something odd about that pony, I was at the Summer Sun as Luna well knows, but later in the party I saw Spike lurking and I must admit, I was pretty curious.“

"Spike said he wasn't able to go because of his back,“ Twilight commented, "so that was-“

"Another lie, yes. Well, he didn't attend per se, but he was waiting nearby for her.“

Twilight felt further frustration at what Spike hid from her, but she had to try and remain calm for now and listen.

"Feeling curious what those two were up to, I hid myself as various objects, being the God of Chaos has its benefits and all. Then I saw him talking to somepony I didn't know very well, I had very rarely seen her ever, in all of known Equestria. This Love Joyful and Spike were on very good terms though, they spoke like they had known each other forever. Spike whispered to her towards the end and I couldn't quite hear properly, but soon Spike walked to the party and she went the other way. I wanted to follow but Spike spotted me soon, hiding in a balloon. He asked what I was doing and I pretended I was spying on Celestia. I know she returned to the party about twenty minutes later.“

"And why didn't you tell us any of this back then exactly?“ Celestia asked with a raised eyebrow.

"No solid proof honestly, I thought they were a secret crush or something. How was I to know that it was related?“

Celestia frowned, but let it go.

"You may leave Discord. I think we have something to go on now.“

"Care for some tea at my place?“ Fluttershy asked Discord.

"Yes please, I could do with a friend right now.“

After the two left, Luna turned to Twilight.

"So what did you have to tell us about Spike?“

"Sunset admitted to me that she was begged by Spike to lie. She never visited me that night and he pressured her into lying, even kic- I'm sorry, he's not been like himself, especially when we went there to the other world. He was so aggressive and rude.“

"So he's been selling some kind of elaborate cover-up?“

"I'm afraid so. I don't know if he's covering for Love Joyful or somepony else, but they aren't good news. I will never forgive them for manipulating Spike like this, we would never do this.“

"Twilight,“ Celestia spoke. "I understand you are reasonably upset, but please do not say such harsh words. We can forgive as there is nopony beyond forgiveness, I don't want you to say such things with finality as never.“

"I know that Celestia; I'm really sorry, I'm just... really upset and confused right now. You're right, I need to calm down, we need to hear out what's going on.“

"Is there anything else you know about what Spike is doing?“

"One thing, he begged me too, yesterday. He said he would tell me what he knew, but under the promise I would not tell you. I kept to that, hoping to show him I trusted him and receive that trust back, but I now know he barely told me anything. He told me he knew the true culprit and asked for him to let him sneak out to find them and make them confess or he would tell Celestia who it is himself.“

"So he snuck out to find them, but likely he went to Discord instead, to make that deal.“

"Yeah. The only way forward now is to find Spike, he may be with the ponies responsible or on his own. If we get everypony involved, we can find them, before they get away. I will tell him the Crystal Mirror will stay sealed until he confesses; if this bookthief really is from the other world, they'll have nowhere to run.“

"I agree Twilight, please help us find Spike and save him from this mess he's found himself in.“

~~Rainbow Dash~~ (Her evidence was planted?)
~~Gray Tank~~ Little to offer, never made it past Reception, backed up by Amethyst
~~Amethyst Maresbury~~ Seems emotionally incapable and tricked herself
Love Joyful alibi no longer holds up and is pointed as likely being either the human or changeling.
~~Discord~~ Confessed to not being involved and gave important information
Starlight Glimmer Far from bulletproof, but seemed busy and had nothing to add.
Twilight Sparkle
~~Library staff~~ No suspicious or helpful people
~~Sunset Shimmer,~~ Unlikely, has not been relevant to the search since and is neither a pony nor changeling.
Spike certainly involved, the evidence has been overwhelming
Changeling (A changeling almost certainly involved) What is the motive?

Author's Note

Bottom text