Nightmare Night Accident

by Nightskies

Rating: mature
Tags: Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Fluttershy, Porn, Sex, Fetish, Profanity, Anthro
Length: 7977

Nightmare Night is a time for costumes and fun, a time to adopt a new temporary identity for a single night. And sometimes, that can lead to some accidents.

The time of Nightmare Night is always a fun time for many. And tonight is was going to be fun for two, Fluttershy and a stallion she meets at a party. However, this bout of fun may be more than either bargained for.

Kinks: Costumes, some roleplay, teasing, huge breasts, huge cock, huge ass, accidental incest, mother and son, and a very horny Fluttershy.

Written for: Spooky, Cloppy Contest returns

Published 2022-10-31 23:50:00 UTC
Last updated 2022-10-31 23:50:00 UTC

Party Night

19 years ago, Fluttershy gave birth to her son. No one knew who the father was, but some had theories. All that was known was that she was a mother. She would give her son the name Butterscotch and, for the next 19 years, she would raise him.

It was a cool autumn night, perfect weather for Nightmare Night, and even more perfect for a party! Fluttershy, dressed in a full body suit, skin tight and oddly comfortable, was excited to attend. She walked along the sidewalk with a soft smile and unassuming gaze, humming a happy tune. Kids who were walking past stared at her large, curvaceous figure, some parents having to shield their eyes, but Fluttershy didn’t seem to notice, blissfully unaware. As she arrived at the venue, she knocked on the door. The party was bustling with music and countless ponies, more than could probably fit in the house. Nevertheless, she squeezed past the crowd and made it to the snack table, serving herself a glass full of punch. She didn’t recognize anyone in the room, as not only were there just that many other people, but it was slightly dim as well. She scanned the room until her eyes fell on a much smaller stallion in the crowd, and her eyes widened with curiosity

Butterscotch had spent the day hyping himself up to go to the party. He was a rather nervous stallion who tried his best to help his equally nervous mom. This party would be different. He would finally come out of his shell and help him meet a mare. He arrived at the party nearly an hour before Fluttershy would and would spend his time dancing, though he would do so alone. He wore a similar skin tight bodysuit that accentuated certain parts of him. Notably, his very small and narrow chest and waist, along with a rather long stallionhood that was pressed against one of his thighs. He was far shorter than any mare at the part and had his face hidden by a black bunny mask that covered his eyes. He failed to notice the mare look over at him with curiosity as he continued to dance a bit awkwardly.

Unknown to the large mare, she was subconsciously watching her own son with a cheeky gaze, taking a sip of her drink as she observed him through the crowd. He looked very cute, with a lithe frame and the bulge of an enormous package underneath his skin tight suit. She couldn’t help staring down at it with a nervous hunger. Putting her drink down, she decided to approach him, squeezing through the crowd while her eyes remained focused on him “H-Hi there, cutie~” she spoke with a soft tone, crossing both hands over each other, which only caused her large bust to pop out further. She was lucky the suit was fairly stretchy, because if it weren’t, her body would be bursting through the seams. As she gazed down at the stallion with sheepish excitement, she couldn’t help reaching down, taking his hands in hers, still not knowing who the masked stallion was “Dance with me~”

The stallion continued dancing until he saw her. She was far larger than him but he did not care. She was gorgeous, her body like any stallion's greatest fantasy and here she was, coming towards the small him. He couldn't stop his bulge from growing a bit hard as he looked over her very curvy figure. When she spoke, his heart melted a bit with how adorable it was from such a large and sensual looking mare. "H-hi." He replied to her as his blue eyes couldn't help but stare towards her massive bust in that tight outfit. Seeing a bit more of her coat appeared made him harden a bit more as he was just glad his own suit was stretchy, so that it could accommodate his growing erection. As she took his hand in hers, he looked back up to her. "O-okay." was all he could muster as he danced with the large mare.

Their size difference was alluring to Fluttershy, being attracted to those much smaller than herself, especially this well endowed stallion. She swayed her body to the music, giving him a sensual wink as she gave a cute spin, showing off all her curves and gorgeous features. Teasing him was going to be so much fun, so as the crowd bustled, pushing their bodies together, Fluttershy gave a soft yelp as she felt herself press against his growing member, blushing in arousal. Feeling her own body grow hot, especially between her thighs, she bend down and cupped them side of the mysterious stallions cheek “You’re a p-pretty good dancer, cutie” she hummed, leaning in a fraction closer so her bust pushed up against him “I hope you don’t mind me getting a bit closer~”

His dance with the mare only served to do two things for him. One, make it obvious to the stallion that he knew nothing of dancing, his attempts being quite pitiful in the presence of the mare before him. And second, was making him harder than he had ever been. The sensual wink she gave him made him freeze for a few seconds as his member twitched against his thigh and the tight material, making it almost break out. Her spin and her showing off of her amazing body only served to tease him further as she danced in ways that he had only ever dreamed a mare would dance with him. When she pressed against his member, he gave a soft moan as she felt soft to the touch. When she cupped his cheeks, he looked up toward her. Her words made him blush. "T-thank you, m-miss." he managed to get out before her bust pushed against him and he was nearly face first into them. He tried to tell her it was fine that she would be getting closer, but her only response would be throbs and twitches from his erection.

“O-oh my~ someone is getting excited~” hummed Fluttershy as she felt his bulge throbbing against her body, causing her to sigh longingly, pushing her bust against her face. After a few moments, she pulled away, but kept her closeness as she continued to dance to him, guiding his hands around her waist, which thanks to their height difference, only caused the stallion to be hidden amongst her plush bust and body. She was growing more and more restless as the minutes passed, her marehood now soaked in excitement, even staining her suit with its juices, All the while she continued to tease and provoke the young stallion with her soft, whispery voice and large, beautiful body “I want you~” she whispered down at him at one point as the music got louder, and just as she did, she heard the sound of threads being popped. Looking down, she realized her chest had ripped open the seemingly stretchy material, and now her cleavage was bare and pressed against the stallion. Despite this, she only seemed a little embarrassed, shyly looking down at her son with a wantful gaze

He would continue to try and reply to her but was however blocked from doing so due to her large bust making it so his face was constantly in between her massive breasts. When she would push against his face, he felt a nice sense of slight pleasure and a strange sense of familiarity. As she guided his hands to her waist, he was once more put between her breasts, but his hands were not idle. On some occasions, they would reach out and grab her massive thighs or her large booty out of a need to feel something. He was once more amazed by how soft and jiggly it felt in his hands. Her teasing was reaching many points of high intensity as her voice only made it hotter for him. He blushed hard at her comment before he threads popped and her breasts had ripped open her suit and were bare against him. They felt so soft and warm as he inhaled her scent. He would look up at the mare and smile a bit, lustfully. "I want you too, miss~"

His hands on her body, feeling her incredibly plush hips, butt and thighs, Fluttershy couldn’t help let out a soft sigh of pleasure, adoring the feeling of his touch. Running a hand over his head, she flushed at his positive reply, leaning down a fraction more so her lips would brush against his mask “It’s crowded here, let’s go somewhere else~” she hummed, nervously looking around while covering her split bust. Standing up, she took his hand and led him away from the plethora of people. She nervously looked for a room, trying not to bump into anyone, before finally spotting an empty room “Let’s go here~”

He was insanely hard at the moment as his hands grabbed around her body. Had his hands and member been replaced, he would have cum from how stimulated he was. He needed to be with this mare as she brought her face down to his. as she pulled him away from the crowded dance floor, he walked with her leading as his eyes were glued to her massive butt, watching it jiggle as they walked through the party before she found the empty room. He went into it after her and his member was now plainly obvious from under his suit, making an obvious tent there.

Shutting the door behind her, she dimmed the lights a little and looked down at the stallion, a cheeky, yet harmless smile on her face. Her tongue passed over her lips as she noted his hardened stallionhood, wanting nothing more than to rip it out and shove it in between her plush breasts. Noticing the room was likely the owners spare room, she pulled the boy to the bed and sat him down “You’ve been such a good boy, I think you deserve to see more~” she teased softly, fondling her jiggly bust, before pulling the rest of the material concealing her nipples away. Out on display for Butterscotch to see, his unbeknownst mothers massive, gorgeous pair of breasts. She fondled them a bit more, before leaning close to the stallion “Now let me see what’s down here~” she whispered, letting him play with her body as she ran a finger over his painful erection, begging to be released

When she closed the door behind them, he knew he had been pulled into the lair of a very hungry beast. His stallionhood would continue to twitch against his costume and his thigh as he watched her lick her lips in anticipation. As she put him on the bed, he couldn't help but stare over her amazing body. His eyes glazed over her massive breasts and her butt as he sat there. his face grew red as he blushed madly at her comment. He watched her play with her massive bust before she would unveil them to her unknown lover. He was in shock at just how amazing they looked and how beautiful her nipples were, topped on the amazing soft breasts. As she leaned down, he wanted to press his face against her bust. He would do just that as she let him enjoy her body some more while she ran her delicate finger over his erection. She would unknowingly cut a bit of the strained material, causing his member to break free and fall out for her.

She gave a soft moan as his face pressed against her warm, sweet smelling cleavage, pushing it closer to his face. As soon as she felt his package break free from her playful teasing, she took his length in her hand, massaging up and down slowly “Your stallionhood is so cute, and it’s all mine~“ she cooed, her other hand petting the back of his head. She kept indulging in his touch, and mouth if he were to decide to use it on her breasts, giving soft groans of delight here and there. Her fingers continued to edge and tease his poor throbbing cock, a smile on her face as she did so “Would you like me to put your cock here~? I think it would fit nice and snug~” she sighed, motioning to her gorgeous, soft beasts

He would continue to enjoy the soft and warm embrace of her breasts as his large member was now exposed to the open air. Her massaging made him moan as it sent shivers of pleasure down his spine. her coo made him smile a bit as she petted his head a bit while he would latch his lips around one of her nipples and suck for a bit. He would grab her other breast with his hand as he tried to grab all of it but it was too big for his hand. she would remove his face from her cleavage and asked him about where he would like his stallionhood located, he nodded with his cock throbbing a bit. "Yes, m-miss. I would l-love it there."

With his words of confirmation, Fluttershy would kneel down so that her breasts would rest against his knees, taking his stallionhood in hand. Using her spit, she daintily dribbled some in between her cleavage, before slipping his cock in between. She gazed up at his expression, before fondling her bust in a circular motion, teasing his throbbing tip “Tell me how good you feel right now, baby boy~” she spoke in her gentle tone, pushing her tits down so that his cute stallionhood would be entirely engulfed in her soft, warm bust, the tip erupting out from the top of her cleavage. From there, she dipped her head and took his tip in between plump lips, sucking it and licking eagerly and lustfully, clearly incredibly aroused for his member.

He sat there patiently as she kneeled in front of him and placed her breasts against his knees. He moaned and shivered at her handling of his cock in her hands. His eyes would widen as she would slip his cock between her soft breasts. They felt so good, he felt he could've died happy feeling them. Their soft embrace made him moan out as he leaned his head back before he looked down at her. She looked briefly familiar, but brushed it off as her gorgeous blue eyes made him blush. "I-it feels so good, miss. Better than anything. So s-soft." her gentle tone was doing so much for him, and his cock would throb every time she spoke. As she massaged his cock with her bust, he would moan as his eyes would flutter from pleasure. When she took his tip in her soft, plump lips, he let out huffs and pants from how much pleasure he was receiving. It felt amazing. "W-wow."

Fondling her breasts up and down, she maintained eye contact with the sweet, mysterious stallion, her mouth catching and suckling on his tip every time his member broke through the top of her cleavage. Her saliva dribbled down, creating a sloppier, hotter experience for Butterscotch’s delicious cock “G-goodness, your expressions are so cute, keep moaning for me, okay~ I want to hear your cute voice moan for my body~” she kept speaking lewdly at him, increasing the speed of her titjob, the warm, squelchy abyss between her breasts only doubling in pleasure. She continued to suck and lick the stallions tip, coaxing him for that salty, sweet release that she wanted so badly

His legs were shaking from the pleasure of her soft breasts wrapped around his cock and her soft and hot mouth taking his tip and sucking like there was no tomorrow. The feeling of her saliva running down his cock made his eyes glaze for a moment as the pleasure was reaching an apex. her words were met with only a blushing nod and a throb from his member. Her boobjob was coaxing him better than anything he had ever used to get off with. Her speed was causing his legs to unintentionally buckle a bit and lean inward as he was feeling incredibly close to his approaching orgasm. He was panting from pleasure as his eyes would stare at her amazing work. "M-miss~"

Extremely aroused from his noises and their sensual act, Fluttershy watched his face keenly as she felt his explosive orgasm edging closer and closer. But instead of giving him the satisfaction, she lifted her breast up, forcing the stallions member to slide out “Nuh uh~ i'm not done with you yet, cutie~ you can’t come so soon” she hummed sweetly in his ear as she continued to fondle her own tits, almost taunting him with her body that he was pulled away from “Tell me how much you want me, and I’ll consider putting that amazing stallion hood back in between my boobs~” the mare whispered in a motherly voice, staring down at the boy with a tender, yet incredibly lustful gaze

All his ears could hear were the sounds of the actions and the slight noise of the party outside. He was so close to release, so much that even one more stroke would send him over the edge. Which is why her moving made it so much worse for him. He was teetering on the edge of orgasm and she was in total control. her soft voice made him only want her more and her taunting fondle was just there for his eyes to have some candy for his eyes. He was throbbing and could feel his orgasm dropping fast. her whispered request of him made him harder than ever, the soft maternal voice sounded vaguely familiar but right now, he just wanted to cum. I want you so badly! I would give a limb just for the chance to cum with you! Please give me release, miss!" he was a shivering, pleasure addicted mess under her, with his eyes looking into her soft eyes.

His desperate words sent shivers down her spine, her own arousal barely containing the urge to touch herself, but she remained strong as she leaned down, running her tongue across the underside of his throbbing member. She wanted to tease him more, however, so instead of giving him what he wanted, she began to slowly kiss, lick and give the occasional suck on his cock, looking up at his expression once and a while “So cute~” she whispered against him, before pulling away just before his release. She waited a few more moments, before engulfing his rod back between her slippery, soft breasts, but instead of moving them herself, she leaned in close and pressed a kiss to the boys cheek “Go ahead~ use my body, thrust into me~ I want to see your cute little face as you cum all over my face and tits~”

His cock would throb from the lack of attention before she would begin to lovingly care for it with her kisses and licks. The occasional suck would make him peak a bit before she would let go. her words would make him nearly painfully erect as he would just stare over her body in lust. Her breasts were so beautiful and her lips were so plump and perfect for sucking on a stallion. His eyes would still often go to her still clothed ass and would watch it jiggle a bit. Then, when she brought her breasts back down to his cock, he shivered in pleasure and moaned, before blushing at her cheek kiss. As soon as she finished her words, he went to town. He thrusted hard and fast into her big, beautiful breasts with lust in his eyes under his mask. He would just thrust and thrust into them as all he could do was stare at her big bust and her beautiful, soft, motherly face. He knew in a few moments he would be cumming hard all over her..

Encouraging him but giving a few moans of delight, she held her breasts together and even jiggled them a little “Good boy, doesn’t it feel amazing~? Keep going, keep going~” she hummed, letting more saliva to drip in between her bust, extra hot, slippery lubricant for her tight, silky soft mounds. She wanted to edge him even more, so as she felt his orgasm peak once more, she pulled away, a twinkle of mischievousness in her round eyes “Now now, hold on~ You’ve been so good, but I think I want your cum somewhere else~” standing up, she turned around, her fat, beautiful ass bouncing up and down as she did so. Bending over, she heard the threads holding her ass popping as well, and like her bust, her soft, jiggly ass erupted from beneath the fabric. Pushing her booty closer, she wiggled it some more “D-Does my butt look cute~?” she asked the cute stallion, looking behind to see what his expression was, if she could even see it from behind her curvaceous body.

he was so close to Cumming as her voice would nearly push him over, along with the extra hot saliva on her breasts. He was getting close, and just as he was about to peek into orgasm, she stopped. He whined a bit as she left him be, and all he could do was pant and huff as his orgasm died down. her words would fuel him more as she stood up and his eyes became glued to her ass. It was so beautiful, even under her skin tight suit. When the suit broke and her ass began to spill out, his eyes widened from just how gorgeous and big it was. The more she wiggled it, the more he just wanted to bury his face into it. at her comment, he would nod as he grabbed the sides of her ass. "it's amazing, miss. Perfect, big, and so juicy." he would rip more of her outfit, exposing her ass until about the beginning of her cutie mark. He didn't care though as he pressed his face against one of her ass cheeks.

Satisfied by his whining and whimpering from lack of climax, she put a hand to her lips, stifling a cheeky giggle “Now I want your cum even more~” she confessed as she pushed her big, beautiful ass up to his face. Biting her bottom lip as he fondled and shoved his face into her plump, soft body, she reached behind her and separated her cheeks so Butterscotch would be able to see both her slick, warm marehood, and her tight butt “You can pick~” the seductive mare hummed, wiggling her backside even more to further entice the young stallion.

he continued to rub his face into her ass, smiling from how soft and jiggly it was as he then kissed it. He ripped more of her outfit off until it was only covering her thicc thighs and her back as he smiled with joy. as she spread her ass and saw both her hot pussy and her tight ass, he smiled as he licked his lips. He brought himself up and then slapped his cock between her ass cheeks and left it there for a while as he moaned at how soft and warm it was. "Why don't you shake this fat ass, m-milf?" he said with nervousness.

Feeling his big cock slid between her soft cheeks, she gave a cute giggle and smiled, reaching back to slap her ass gently “Anything for you, cutie~” she adored his newfound confidence, as so she thought it was best to give him exactly what he wanted. Shaking her hips, her juicy, giant ass bounced and jiggled over his lubricated member, sighing and whining in desperation as she felt his balls touch her marehood, his cock slipping over her puckered ass greedily. She wanted the stallion deep inside her, and now he was the one teasing her instead. But she’d hold off, despite dripping her excitement down her thighs, she kept rubbing her fat ass up and down his cock, letting him admire her body

He moaned at how soft her ass felt on his cock as it rippled from her slap and echoed across his cock. he huffed slightly at how she shook her hips and caused her ass to bounce around his cock, it still drenched in her saliva as he thrusted slightly against her gorgeous ass. He would also begin to run his fingers through her tail as he shivered in pleasure before pulling back from it and staring at her ass. He sat there for a minute before he decided. "I want your p-pussy, s-slut." he struggled to say with nervousness and his usually good nature tried to win out over his horniness towards this large, beautiful mare.

Biting her lip to suppress her excited groans and noises, she kept moving her hips around, stimulating and smothering her masked son's gorgeous cock. After a few more moments, she pulled away, giving her ass one last small slap, before turning to face him “G-goodness~ someone is getting excited. Shouldn’t you say ‘please’~?” she hummed, but despite her cute, gentle words, she pushed Butterscotch down onto the bed hungrily, straddling his lap with a lustful gasp. She towered him easily, her slippery, warm folds pressed eagerly against his throbbing member. She wanted all of him, and without a word, as soon as she’d hear him speak once more, she’d hastily align his cock to her tight pussy, and sink down onto it with a loud moan of delight

He moaned out at her continued movement as he sat there. When she faced him, he tried to look up to her but her was only focused on how hot her torn outfit made her, generously hugging her thighs and her arms as he sat with an extremely hard erection. he was excited by her words as she pushed him down onto the bed and it became clear to him that she was the one in charge of this session. As she straddled his hips and pressed her hot pussy against his cock, he spoke his words and awaited her response. As she pushed him all the way inside her, he moaned loudly before panting at how hot, tight, warm, and soft her pussy was. Better than anything he had ever used in his life. He placed his hands on her thighs as he awaited the ride.

“O-oh my~! You’re so big” she whimpered lovingly as she felt his huge stallionhood slip deeply into her tight cavern. Squeezing her thigh around his torso, the ripped fabric muffin topping her squishy legs, she began to slowly ride him with shaky hip roles and soft moans of pleasure. He fit so snuggly inside her pussy, slipping in and out with audible sloppy noises “Oohhh~! Celestia, yes!“ she whined as she picked up her speed a little, fondling her bouncing breasts and ass with both hands

His face glowed red at her comment as he watched her slowly ride his cock with her hip rolls and the moans of pleasure sounding pleasant to him due to her cute, soft voice. Her squeezing around his torso with her soft thighs felt both amazing and hurt a bit as he watched her breasts begin to bounce as she fondled them. He reached his hands over to grab her ass and squeeze it as she rode while her whines of pleasure made him twitch a bit inside her. All the while, his mask got a bit looser from their new activity.

She loved his touch and how much he adored grabbing her juicy ass, which gave her incentive to pick up her pace even more. She relaxed her thigh and leaned down, her soft tits pressed to his chest and face. He felt so damn amazing, she couldn’t even put it into words. He felt…right, as if his body was part of hers. Through her pleasure, half-lidded gaze, she dipped her head and moved the bottom part of his mask, pressing her lips to his. She was yet to notice who it was, especially in the heat of the moment, and so she eagerly and messily kissed the boy, swinging her hips up and down, and forward and back “S-so good~ n-nghh”

He moaned out at how she rode him with her, his hands grabbing her ass more and enjoying her softness while her pussy felt amazing around his cock. When she bent down, he smiled at how her breasts pressed against his chest and face. Before long, she then lifted a bit of his mask and then kissed him. He was shocked by her boldness, as he tried to look at her face. He could not see it as he kissed her back and held her ass as he moaned. "Y-you're so good. Fuck~"

“T-tell me when you’re close, baby boy~ I don’t want you to cum without me” she demanded with a breathless cry of desire, riding him a little slower, but a lot harder now. She was careful not to bounce down too hard so as not to hurt him, but the pleasure of his rock hard cock kissing her cervix and squeezing through her incredibly silky tight walls was so incredible she almost forgot to be gentle at times. Kissing back with undeniable passion and lust, she only pulled away after a few more moments, leaving a string of salvia between their lips. Even still, she wasn’t paying attention to his face, and so she continued “I want you so badly~” she mumbled, stifling her moans as she tried to fight back the pleasure “I want you to fill me up and make me your mare~”

Everything about this was incredible for him as his cock twitched inside her while his hands squeezed her ass and their kiss last. He could not see her face but her words caused him to nod while she rode him hard and slow, her walls milking his cock for all its worth. When she pulled away, he gasped as their saliva was all that connected them from their mouths. "I want you as my mare. I want you everyday." he said between pants as he laid there and just accepted her amazing pleasure.

“Y-yay~” she whimpered softly as he returned the affection by confessing his own attraction. Just for that, she doubled the speed, jumping up and down hard and fast, her whole body jiggling and bouncing up and down. At this point, she didn’t care about being careful, she didn’t care about teasing him. She needed his hot seed planted inside her body, and her growing climax was fueling this urge. She leaned down again, kissing his lips over and over, pulling a bit more of his mask from his face as she did so “I’m so close~” she gasped and panted, her motherly voice shaking from the pleasure.

He moaned out as she sped up her riding, the bed and their bodies rocking with her intense bouncing while he huffed and panted. He stared over her jiggling breasts before she lifted up more of his mask and kissed him more. He kissed back, their tongue meeting for a bit as she rode him like there was no tomorrow. "F-fuck~ me t-too!" hid face was now fully exposed as their orgasms were approaching fast, both too caught up in pleasure to care who the pony they were fucking was.

She gave her final few bounces before pushing down hard and arching her back. As she orgasmed, her entire body trembled in ecstasy, while her silky slick walls contracted and became as tight as a vice grip, milking the stallion’s cock with every shudder. She let out a long, slutty moan as she did so, squeezing her own breasts with a lustful, satisfied smile on her face.

As she finished her final bounces and pushed down all the way onto his cock, he felt her orgasm and felt his mind burst in pleasure as he squeezed her ass hard before he came inside her womb. His tip was buried deep in her womb as he came hard inside her, all the teasing having built up a large orgasm for his mom as he moaned out in pleasure. His face was on full display and it was clear he was in pure pleasure.

Adoring the feeling of his hot cum filling her womb and painting her insides white with ribbons of love, she leaned back down, pressing their lips in a sloppy, breathy kiss. Her eyes were still shut, but as she pulled from the smooch, she fluttered them open. A look of recognition came over her otherwise lust ridden expression, and for a moment, she seemed confused, but then her cheeks burnt a bright red and she sat in with a gasp, still technically riding her son and leaking his milky cum from her slick pussy “B-Butterscotch?!”

He loved the feeling of her tight walls still milking his cock as she leaned down and kissed him. The feeling of her soft, plump lips against his was great as he soon opened his eyes and got a good look at the mare's face. His face glowed red as he realized that the hottest mare and the one who he had the best night of his life with was his own mom. The feeling of her pussy still around his cock as he felt the desperate need to pull out of her. "M-mom?!"

Author's Note

Hey. This is my first fic on the site. Just though I'd do something for the holiday and the contest.
It's been an idea of mine for a while now.

Hope you enjoyed it.

Nightmare Night Bonding

With confirmation that she had indeed just had sex with her own son, she quickly climbed off of him and covered her flushed, embarrassed face. She tried to muster a few words, anything, but she couldn’t seem to speak at all without stuttering “I-I…o-oh my..” she finally breathed out, unable to even meet her son's gaze. She couldn’t believe she’d just done that, but she also couldn’t deny just how amazing it all felt.

He was speechless at his own actions, his eyes trying to tear away his gaze from her body. But his eyes remained glued to her amazing body before he looked down to his own ruined costume and his member. "U-u- i." he tried to hide his cock as his eyes once more became glued to her large breast, her thighs contained in her tight outfit, and her massive ass.

“B-Butterscotch…” she finally was able to form a word without sheepishly stuttering or feeling absolutely mortified. Turning towards him, her entire body still on display, she caught him staring and quickly tried to sober her large breasts and butt, but to no avail “I-I’m so sorry! I didn’t k-know it was you…” she apologized, reaching down to take his hand in hers, giving it a soft squeeze

He was staring with wide eyes as he tried to process everything that had happened. He tried to hide his slowly erecting cock as his eyes would watch as she tried to cover herself. He soon covered his own face as he felt awful. Then she grabbed his hand and he looked up to her. His eyes stared into her deep blue eyes. "I-I didn't either." he squeezed her hand as he tried to remain looking at her face, but would often stare at her large breasts without thinking.

“W-well…uhm…I c-can’t say I didn’t…enjoy it” she confessed as she watched her son with a soft, shy gaze, her glassy teal blue eyes looking down at his still erect cock. Why did she still feel so hot and horny for him, even now that she knew his identity? Taking a deep breath, she shuffled a bit closer, her ass and breasts jiggling a little “S-sorry, but it’s okay, right? I-I mean, I love you so much, my dear. A-and no one needs to know”

He was shocked by what she had to say and he blushed hard as she looked over him, her soft eyes making him feel hypnotized as he looked over her again. He felt so horny for her, even though she was his mom. He was fully erect as she looked over him and he watched her body jiggle, her ass especially as she shuffled closer to him. "I-i guess you're right. I mean, this was the best night I have ever had." he blushed hard and hid his face a bit.

“R-really~?” she was surprised he’d enjoyed himself that much, a smile now on her once horrified expression. She felt much more relaxed beside her son in this situation than she’d ever felt before. Glancing between his huge member and his cute, flushed face, she took his hand and placed it on her hip, bringing them even closer “I’m surprised…y-you’re still so hard” she hummed gently, running her other hand over his cheek “Did you…did you like having sex with your mommy~?”

He blushed hard as she sat next to him before she smiled up at him. Her cute expression made him feel more relaxed as he sat there with his erection hard before her. As she looked between his stallionhood and his face, he felt nervous before she took his hand and put it on her hip. He was so tempted to squeeze it as he looked down at her ass. He blushed at her comment and her question as he sat there with his cock still covered in their love making. "Y-yes. I absolutely did love having sex with you."

She secretly wondered if maybe Butterscotch wanted to go again, even now knowing that it was his own mother he’d be making love to. Her cheeks flushed brightly at his words, covering her cheeks with one hand shyly “M-my~” humming, she shuffled on the spot a little “So did I~ y-you don’t think…and it’s okay if you say no, but maybe we could do this again~? I know I’m your mom, but I can’t help it…” she cooed softly, her hand reaching down to take his cock in her palm. She had grown tired of holding back, jerking him off a little with slippery fingers from their juices along his member “I just love you so much, a-and you’re so good at using this. And mommy gets so lonely sometimes~”

His blush grew as he realized what he was saying to his own mom and he just sat there, his own cock hard as can be with his mom almost fully naked next to him. As he sat there, he could only think about going again. at her response, he was once more shocked as she seemed perfectly okay with going for another round. His cock twitch a bit at the thought of going once more, just before she wrapped her hand around his cock. He moaned softly at the sensation, her using their own juices as a lube for his cock. "I-I know, mommy. I-I would l-love to go a-again. If that's okay with you."

Surprised yet again by his response, she took her hand from his cock and promptly lay down on the bed, doggy style, with her rump in the air and her chest pressed to the bedsheets “Then p-please…just a little more~” she moaned quietly, wiggling her butt to lure her son in. She wanted, no, she needed him.

He simply enjoyed her hand stroking him as he awaited her response. Before long the sensation was gone as he saw he get into position on the bed. The doggystyle was very enticing to him. The way her large ass looked bare for him. At her quiet moan and her wiggle of her butt, he approached her as he tore off the rest of his outfit before tearing the rest of hers off and laying his cock between her ass cheeks and stroking her tail lightly.

Feeling happy that her son had taken up her offer and was laying his cock between her curvaceous backside, he bounced and shook her butt even more so, silently pleading for more “P-please, could you fuck mommy some more~? I cant wait any longer”

He smiled some more as she shook her ass on his cock, moaning slightly as it felt soft against his hard cock. He bit his lip as she pleaded for him to thrust into her warm pussy once more. He lined himself up, his tip teasing her before he thrusted into her and he moaned out as she squeezed his cock with her inner walls.

“O-Ohh~! Y-yes baby~” she cried out in pleasure as she felt his member slip deep into her love tunnel. This is where his cock belonged, inside her. She lifted her head and looked behind at Butterscotch “M-Make love to me, don’t hold back~”

He moaned out as he panted a bit at how tight and warm she felt. He kept himself deep inside her as her walls milked his cock soothingly. At her demand, he began to thrust into her hard, holding onto her hips as he slammed himself into her, their hips meeting and him loving the soft feeling of her ass.

She stuck her tongue out in ecstasy as he began to plow into her marehood, her moans becoming sporadic and loud “A-ahh~! G-goodness you feel amazing~ y-yeah just like that, fuck your mommy~!” she cried out in delight.

The sound of their hips meeting echoed as he kept thrusting into her with force as his tip buried into her womb several times. His hands groped and squeezed her ass and even slapped her cutie mark as he kept going. He was in pure pleasure as he moaned out. "Y-you feel so good, mommy. You're the best mare ever."

The sound of his appraisal sent shivers down her spine. She loved being wanted like this, and the feelings he gave her were absolutely incredible. His cock melted in her warm pussy with each deep thrust, kissing her already cum lubricated cervix “A-and you’re the best boy ever, my cute son~ keep going-nghh~!” she encouraged, pushing back on his cock while also rolling her hips a little. As they moved together, her gorgeous, soft body bounced and jiggled

Her encouragement egged him on as he kept thrusting into her tight, silky walls with all the force he could muster. He kept thrusting into her like mad, his cock twitch and always throbbing inside her as he fucked her roughly. "F-fuck, mommy. You're so good. You're so tight, and your body is a stallion's wet dream come to life." he smacks her cutie mark before grabbing her flanks and her curvy ass again.

It had only been a couple of minutes, but she could already feel herself getting close to her second climax. He was stimulating her so well, with each thrust sending shivers down her body. She felt hot with pleasure, her marehood squeezing his cock desperately “R-really~? M-mommy is so happy to hear that, baby~!” she cried out as she rolled her hips some more “Harder~! Keep going, keep going!”

He felt close to his next climax as he thrusted into her rolling hips. The way she rolled her hips, that caused his cock to be massaged in her tight marehood more tightly. Its warmth and softness continued to spur him on as he kept thrusting, his hands still on her butt as he started to thrust faster into her. "T-thank you, M-mommy. You're so good. So tight. S-so warm. So s-soft. You're just the best m-mare ever!" he said between grunts and moans as he kept going as his orgasm was fast approaching.

“A-and you’re the best son ever~ your cock is so big and perfect for me~!” Fluttershy whimpered in delight as his thrusts caused her to see stars from the pleasure. She was so close, just a few more thrusts “I’m gonna cum baby~! Please fill your mommy with your hot cum~!”

his thrusts became much harder and faster as he kept going, his hips slapping against her rolling hips with great force. Each time their hips met, it caused her ass to ripple under him. "I'm s-so close too, mommy! I'm gonna fill you up to the absolute brim! Y-you're my mare!"

A few more thrusts later, and Fluttershy reached her most explosive orgasm she’d had in a long time. Her back arched and she cried out loudly, her tongue lolling from her mouth and her eyes rolled to the back of her head. Her tight walls clenched around him like a vice grip, flooding his cock and her marehood in her love juices “I-I’m all yours, my body is all yours~! I love you!!”

As she came hard, he tried to hold his back for as long as he could. But her tight walls constricting around him like a vice and the friction of thrusting into being right was too much for him as he soon pushed himself as far as he could inside her and came, filling his mom full with his seed once more. "F-fuck~ I'm yours too! I love you so much, mommy!~"

Loving the feeling of her son's milky cum filling her body, she gasped and panted, catching her breath after a few minutes. Leaning forward, she reached back and pulled her ass cheek, letting Butterscotch’s seed leak out past her marehood “S-such a good boy~“

He panted and huffed as he tried to catch his breath. He breathed normally now as he saw her leaning forward and felt her spread her ass cheeks, and felt his seed leak out of her pussy. He smiled a bit. "Thank you, mommy.~"
“N-now~ we should probably get ourselves cleaned up…and find something else to wear~” she chuckled as she sat up, turning to Butterscotch and pressing a small kiss to his lips “And then we can head back, and if you’re a good boy, we can have some more fun back home~”

"Alright, mommy." he smiled at her as she sat up on him. He pressed a kiss on her lips when she kissed him. He was happy as they embraced. And as he heard her words, he blushed. "O-okay, m-mommy." he was blushing hard as he looked for some clothing for them to wear to leave. He just found some very tight pants for him.

Fluttershy found a tight dress to wear in the nearest closet, pulling it on and gasping slightly from just how tight it fitted around her bust and ass. She took her sons hand soon after and left the room, dodging the crowd as best they could. Butterscotch stared at how tightly the dress she found hugged all her beautiful curves. He followed her out of the party until they were past the front doors. He sighed a bit as they reached outside. "So, I take it we're going home?"

“Yes~ I hope you had a good time, even though we didn’t spend much time in the actual party” Fluttershy giggled as she shut the front door behind them, breathing in the cool night air, before leading her son back to their house

"Yeah. So did I, mommy." he smiles at her as he walks home with her, the cool air hitting them both as they walk the path home. They probably won't speak of this again, but he didn't mind. It was only for tonight that they were strangers.

Author's Note

Again, first fic on the site. This was supposed to be out sooner, but life happened and that could not happen just yet.

Probably not good, but ehh. Hope you enjoy.