Fight or Flutter

by MaskedMare

Rating: mature
Tags: Pinkie Pie, Slice of Life, Sex, Applejack, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Rainbow Dash, Romance, Fluttershy, Porn, Rarity
Length: 1130

Fluttershy and Rarity celebrate Nightmare Night

Fluttershy and Rarity celebrate Nightmare Night together before meeting up with their friends. However this Nightmare Night is different and Fluttershy's life changes forever.

Published 2022-09-26 09:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2022-09-26 09:40:01 UTC

sticky treats

I was easy to please. Especially compared to the quality of customers Rarity was used to socializing with. Rarity burst into song while she worked. She had dreams of living amongst the rich and famous upper-class stallions and mares, but she also loved us; her friends.
I was dirty from my work with the animals, but my hoof falls were too gentle to trail the mud. Not like Applejack’s super strength and Rainbow Dash’s unrivalled aerial speed.
“Good evening, Flutters.” Rarity smiled with a mouth full of clothing pins. “I’ll be with you in a moment, darling~”
“Oh, okay. Um, I’ll wait.” I blushed with her soft, whispery voice. “D-don’t mind me.”
Rarity surface from behind the curtain with a neatly folded pile of what was going to be my costume for tonight.
“Climb up onto that uh…platform…” Rarity couldn’t use the word stage in front of me, just in case. “...over there and I’ll make sure everything fits you like a glove, darling.”
“L-l-like this?” I stumbled up while my girlfriend unfolded the costume, draping it in half over a pony-shaped mannequin nearby before picking up a tailor’s tape and a lacquered-timber box full of anything she could possibly need to tighten or loosen the costume for me. My head spun trying to identify the pins, threads and everything else.
“Perfect.” She replied curtly.

Rarity busied herself after casting the costume over my body. Carefully pulling my wings, hooves and my head through the proper holes in the fabric. Muttering as she did. She asked me if it was too tight or too loose at several points before she surfaced, winding up the tailor’s tape.
“And for the finishing touch.” She said proudly, pulling a bejewelled hair stick from her hair. Her ringlets cascaded down, bouncing to a stop over her shoulders and framing her face. She combed my long hair with her hoof, plucking out stray leaves and twigs before spinning my hair around the bejewelled hair stick. “This will keep your mane out of your face all night long. It’s one of my favourites.” It was a very Rarity accessory.
“What’s the matter, Flutters?” Rarity battered her long eyelashes at me as she slipped into her own costume. Even the ripples of fabric were seductive as if she was putting on a show for my eyes. Rarity strutted to the mirror to apply her autumnal eye eyeshadow.
“I almost forgot the most important part of your costume. Come here.” She smirked.

I walked towards her, padding lightly on the tips of my hooves. Trying not to trip over. Rarity wrapped her arm around me, raking me closer. Her other hoof pressed against my chest and trailed down all the way to my marehood. I gasped at the forwardness of her touch, but my gasp was lost as Rarity’s lips crashed against my own. I surrendered.
“Good girl. You need to be sopping wet.” She breathed in my ear, making my heart race.
Rarity pushed me down, knocking all of her valuable fabric rolls off the sketching desk.
“Spread your legs for me, darling.”
“L-l-like this?” I obeyed without thinking.
Rarity pushed my legs wider. Holding something behind her, obscured in a cloud of magic. “Close your eyes, Flutters. Lean back and trust me.”
I closed my eyes and leaned back in increments, not sure what to expect. My girlfriend wouldn’t perform cunnilingus after applying make up would she?
“I do.” I whispered breathlessly.

Rarity laughed. An oval lathered in lubricant pressed against the lips of my marehood.
“Breathe.” She commanded. “Don’t move yet. It isn’t going to hurt you. It’s an egg vibrator. I can control how much pleasure you will feel with the click of a single button that will be in my clutch this evening. It’ll help take your mind off all of the festivities. What’s this look for? Don’t you like it?”
“It’s…thank you. What will our friends think?”
“They don’t need to know. Should I show you how quiet it is?”
“What do you mean-”
I tried to push myself up, but the vibrations ripped my breath from my lungs. Rarity laughed behind her hoof.
“I told you to lay back and trust me. You’ve been naughty. I was only teasing you darling, but as punishment, you are going to wear it all night. I’ll push it in nice and deep so no pony knows except for the two of us.” Rarity lifted my leg and pushed it as deep as it could go. I composed myself and slid down off the desk, feeling embarrassed. She pulled down the pleats of my costume and wiped her hooves on a handkerchief.
“I’ll quickly fix your hair and my makeup and then we can depart.” My girlfriend smiled innocently over her shoulder at me. “What would you do without me, Flutters?”

I HATED Nightmare Night, but I appreciated my girlfriend sewing a costume for me. I did occasionally try the festivities with my friends. There were some seasonal traditions that I liked, like decorating my animal sanctuary for customers and raking the autumnal leaves. I did not want to be a soft spoken, scaredy pony for my entire life. It was on a night like every other that my life changed forever. Rarity gave me an ultimatum that buzzed in my pussy whenever Rarity pressed the button on the remote control. Satisfied by the blush covering my face and the way I bit my bottom lip; Rarity laughed and slipped the remote into her saddlebag. I swept my tail over my dripping pussy. My costume muffled the vibrations. I was already weak at the knees when I shuffled to the door to lock it behind us. How am I going to survive an entire night torn between paralyzing fear of Nightmare Night festivities AND feeling aroused in front of my friends?

Pinkiepie’s colourful clown costume ruffled and jangled with every bounce and giggle.
“Hey!” Pinkiepie exclaimed in her usual high pitch that made me jump and gasp. “Cool costume, Flutters. I didn’t think you’d come, with tonight being spooky and scary. Hehe!”
“Don’t scare her Pinkiepie.” Applejack roused. “You’ll be 100% safe with me, Fluttershy.”
“I know.” I glanced at Rarity and then back to Applejack. “Th-thank you.”
I’m lucky to have friends like-
My train of thought was cut off suddenly. While speaking to Rainbow Dash, Rarity’s hoof dipped into her clutch. The vibrator roared to life inside my marehood. I yelped and quickly slapped my hoof over my mouth.
“What’s the matter, Flutters?” Applejack asked with a look of concern.
“N-n-nothing.”
“Are ya sure?”
“Why were you two so late?” Rainbow Dash asked.
“I was making some CRITICAL adjustments to her costume.” Rarity winked at me.
I blushed. “Y-yeah. Sorry.”