The detective stopped one of the guards and started whispering to his unaware that a particular hot-headed sister was making her way down the street within earshot.

"Have you heard anything yet?" The detective asked coldly.

"No sir." The guard replied as he watched the mare stop and examine a shop selling rocks. "The only clue we have is there's a connection between it and the girls."

The detective huffed in annoyance. "Damm. That doesn't leave many options. With the girls disappearing left and right. It's going to be impossible to get one to lure it here."

The guard thought for a moment. "Word in the guard is that it has Rainbow Dash. Perhaps if you had something she wanted."

"Like what? Her pet?" The detective laughed. "Or are you suggesting I find her coltfriend."

"Pet sir." The guard replied. "No pony really thinks she likes stallions."

The detective shrugged. "Fine. I think one of her friends mentioned it was brought to the castle. Get it and have the boys set up the trap." With that he started to leave. "Soon that brat will be mine."

The mare grit her teeth at the news and nearly missed a voice from the other side of the counter. "You know. I find jade to be rather relaxing. Simply looking at it, the feel. And surprisingly sucking on them works wonders."

"Whatever." She groaned as she looked back to see where the two stallions went. "I don't have any bits. So-"

"I didn't ask for any." He countered.

Blinking in shock she turned to see a white stallion smiling at her. "It's on the house. But you should probably hurry if you plan on saving the pet of your sister's friend."

"How did you know?"

He shrugged. "You're not that hard to read when it comes to these things." He replied, sliding the stone over to her. "And before you ask. Let's just say… I'm covering my bases." Winking, he got up and tossed a tophat onto his head. "I should get going. Three have vanished from sight and one is in danger."

"What?" She asked. After a moment of looking at the rock she turned to face the guy and huffed at seeing nothing. "Great. Another one." Groaning, she took the stone and made her way to the castle. "First Pinkie now… whoever that was."

Rarity groaned as she slowly got up after a much needed nap. The first thing she noticed was that she was in a cage. Second was the inhibitor on her horn. And finally was a soft and sadly familiar whimpering sound coming from outside her cage. "Please tell me it's not who I think it is." She thought as she slowly approached the bars of her cell.

Looking around, she saw another cell nearby with Applejack looking at her with the same tired and fearful expression she had. It wasn't long before the voice of the stranger came from the shadows.

"Looks like our friends are awake dear." He laughed. "Don't worry. You might not be able to hear them. But they can hear you very clearly." The whimpering voice said something too low for either Rarity or Applejack to hear, which caused the voice to laugh surprisingly softly. "Don't worry sweetheart. You may not have a choice in where you are. But I will give you a choice on what you'll do during your stay."

It wasn't heard for either friend to guess who it was when there was a moment of silence before he spoke again. "It's simple. You can either be my little fuck toy. Or you take the dick of every animal that wants a turn and be a good mother." He paused for a moment before adding. "Oh. And if you pick one. Then one of your other three friends will take your place as the other."

Rarity and Applejack hung their heads knowing what she'd pick. After all, she was amazing with animals. If anything, this may end up becoming a dream come true. And within moments their fear was proven true. As soon as they looked up, they saw a large dog-like shadow mounting her and within seconds she let out a scream of pain that was near instantly muzzled by something mounting her from the front.

Both friends could do nothing but cry as they were forced to watch what was probably the nicest pony either of them ever knew being used as nothing more than a breeding mule.

The figure's voice came from near the cage. "What do you girls think? Should the pink one take Honesty's place? Or maybe should the purple one take Generosity's place?" It laughed as it faded away leaving only the muffled cries of their friend as she was taken over and over by the unknown creatures as they took turns with her holes.

Author's Note

The title may have spoiled who the mare is. But what is happening in the secret location seems to be getting intense. I wonder what would happen when the guard arrives or do you think there's still a deeper secret laying in wait for our little ponies?