A Sweet and Salty Treat

by Applefai

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Nightmare Moon, Romance, Sunny Starscout, Porn, Hitch Trailblazer, My Little Pony: A New Generation, Non-consensual
Length: 3031

An ancient evil is awakened

A holiday is in the midst of a revival, Sunny gets possessed by a long forgotten an ancient......and horny evil

Written for: Brony's spooky, cloppy contest returns

Published 2022-10-05 15:50:00 UTC
Last updated 2022-10-05 15:50:00 UTC

A witch rides her stick

Sunny happily hums to herself as she carves pumpkins into jack o'lanterns with her friends, steadily using her hooves to carve eyes into her gourd.

Izzy, mumbly sings as she carves hers using her magic. "This is so fun!" She exclaims with a snorting laugh as she sets down the carved fruit. "But, what are we doing again?" She asked, confused as to why it was fun.

"We're celebrating Nightmare Night, Izzy, it's a holiday lost to time." Sunny replied as she put down her knife, admiring the work she had done.

"I've heard about that, in school we learned about a ritual where young ponies would offer up candy to an entity known as Nightmare Moon." Hitch interjected as he finished carving his pumpkin.

"Nightmare Moon? Who's that?" Izzy asked, tilting her head in confusion.

"Oh, I've read about her," Sunny said as she took out her book. "She is the evil side of Princess Luna, who used to rule Equestria alongside her sister Celestia, while Celestia guarded the day, Luna would guard the night and protect ponies from her nightmares."

Sunny said as she read from her father's book

"You said something about a ritual, there, sheriff; why would they do that?" Zipp asked, puzzled.

"According to legend, it was to keep Nightmare Moon at bay, so she wouldn't eat the young ponies." Hitch continued as Zipp belted out laughing.

"That's the funniest story I ever heard, who is Equestria came up with that?" Zipp asked as she placed her jack o'lantern down.

"Come on, Zipp, it's all in good fun, besides I want to bring this holiday back, even if we're the only ones celebrating it." Sunny chimed in as she pulled out candles for their lanterns.

Zipp sighed and took a candle. "I know, Sunny. It does sound like fun, but are there any other customs to this holiday?" The pegasus asked as she lit her lantern.

"According to this book, young ponies would go door to door and say Nightmare Night, what a fright, give us something sweet to bite," Sunny said as she read from the book she carries with her.

"Then what would happen?" Izzy asked excitedly as she lit her lantern.

"Then they would get handed candy," Sunny said as Izzy's face lit up.

"You mean…..for free?" Izzy asked excitedly as she smiled from ear to ear.

"Yes, and according to this book there were also parties and other activities for the older ponies." Sunny continued as she read through her book.

As Sunny read through her book, a knock came at the door. Shutting the book to answer it, Sunny was greeted by Phyllis Cloverleaf.

"Oh, good evening Miss Cloverleaf, please come in, may I get you any cider or maybe some tea?" Sunny asked as Phyllis walked in.

"No, that's alright, but thank you. I'm here to tell you that your request to use Canterlogic to hold a Nightmare Night festival has been approved."

Sunny smiled as she hugged Phyllis. "Oh, thank you, thank you, thank you, Miss Cloverleaf, I promise this will help more of a community thrive.

"You're quite welcome, Sunny, and please, call me Phyllis." The business pony said as she embraced the hug.

After a few parting words, Phyllis left and left the friends to plan. Sunny waved her off as she poured herself and her friends some cider and sat down on the couch with them.

Taking a sip of cider, Hitch smiled as his eyes grew wide. "Hmm, this is great, Sunny. Where did you find the recipe?" Hitch asked as he set his cup down on a coaster.

"Oh, just from a recipe book my dad had, I think it's called 'Blooming Home Cooking' '' Sunny said as she drank her cider.

"Changing the subject, when is this Nightmare Night?" Pipp asked as she sat there, watching Zipp chug the cider.

"Oh, it's at the end of this month," Sunny said as she smiled, taking out a personal notebook of ideas.

"So we have a month to plan?" Hitch asked as Sunny nodded.

"Eeyup, I already produced flyers on the off chance I got approved, so I need help posting them around town and handing them out." Sunny replied as she got up and brought out a box of flyers.

The friends looked at the box and decided to help.

"I'll help you post them around here, Sunny," Hitch said as he took a hoof full.

"Pipp and I will hand some out at Zephyr Heights," Zipp said as Pipp squealed with excitement.

"I could totes live stream this event," the streamer uttered as she took a hoof full along with her sister.

"That leaves me, I'll take these to Bridlewood to see if any of the other unicorns will attend," Izzy says as she grabs a hoof full.

Sunny smiles as she and Hitch take their hoof fulls, "ok, let's bring back Nightmare Night," she says as they go their separate ways.

After they spread the word, the gang meets back up at the lighthouse and plans on what they can contribute to the endeavor.

"I already plan on performing with some music and a live stream," Pipp said as the rest of the friends pondered.

"Oh, I can run a crafts table," Izzy said as she shot up excitedly.

Sunny's eyes lit up as she got an idea of what to do. "I'll hold a presentation since this is the first Nightmare Night in many moons, I can explain the history along with the customs," Sunny said as she smiled.

"Would you like any help, Sunny?" Hitch asked as he sat up, since we were told about the holiday at school, with what we learned combined we can explain the whole history of it," Hitch said as Sunny nodded.

The days fly by as the friends get ready, and some of the ponies come to give them a sneak peek at the gimmicks they'll be doing.

Alphabittle comes to the lighthouse with a crystal he has kept in his collection. "Ah, there you all are, I figured, and show you lot first," the gray unicorn says as he comes in.

"I've been reading about Nightmare Night and how Nightmare Moon supposedly put a bit of her essence in a crystal, such as this one," Alphabittle brings out a dark blue crystal as he smiles, not realizing the legend is true.

"I figured I'd display this crystal, and tell the tale of Nightmare Moon and how once a year, her spirit comes out, possesses anypony it can, and goes on a spree looking for candy, but dire consequences happen if done is found," Alphabittle explains as Sunny takes note of it to put in the program.

"Alright you're all set Alphabittle, I can't wait to hear the whole…………story," Sunny replied as she trailed off, her eyes fixated on the crystal as Alphabittle smiled and laughed.

"Thank ya, Sunny. But save the act for the event, that'll help sell it." The gruff unicorn says as he takes the now spiritless crystal away.

"Sunny…….Sunny!" Izzy yells as she shakes her friend.

Snapping out of it, Sunny looks around until she sees Izzy. "Oh, what is it, Izzy?" Sunny asked as she gripped her head.

"I looked at the list and I think we got plenty of booths and activities," Izzy said as she handed Sunny the list.

Looking through the list, Sunny decides Izzy is right. "Yeah, this will do, this will be the best Nightmare Night ever," Sunny says as she hands Izzy the list back and heads to bed.

The night of the party arrives and the five friends dress up for the occasion. Sunny as a witch, Hitch as a knight, Zipp as a vampire, Izzy as a zombie, and Pipp as a mermaid.

"Alright, is everypony ready?" Sunny asked as her heart pounded in her chest at ninth miles per minute.

Getting a resounding yes from her friends, they all entered the establishment and saw it bustling with life, ponies playing games and bobbing for apples as storytellers spun yarns of evil spirits and how to ward them off.

Pipp made her way to the stage as she had Zipp hold the camera for the live stream. Izzy made her way to her crafting booth as Sunny and Hitch prepared for their presentation.

"You ready for this, Sunny?" Hitch asked as he hooked up the slide reel.

Sunny didn't answer right away, her senses flooded with the thought of candy and sweets. Coming out of the daze Sunny finally answered. "Oh, yes, I am Hitch, I hope we can bring back the holiday," Sunny said as she smiled.

As the night went on, Sunny grew more and more lightheaded, her eyes taking on a white glow as she got taken over by Nightmare Moon.

Looking at Hitch, Sunny licked her lips as she came closer, her voice more elegant now, as she started talking. "Hitch, might we take a break and goeth somewhere more private?" She asked as Hitch nodded and allowed her to take him to a family restroom where she locks the door.

"So what's going on, Sunny?" Hitch asked as Sunny pinned him to the wall.

Sunny's eyes glowed white as she spoke, her voice sounding like two. "WE ARE NOT THE ONE YOU CALL SUNNY STARSCOUT, WE ARE NIGHTMARE MOON." The earth pony said as Hitch struggled in her grasp.

"Sunny, please stop this charade." Hitch pleaded only to me pushed down to the floor.

"SILENCE, SINCE WE HAVE NOT RECEIVED ANY CANDY, WE WILL TAKE YOU." The pony said as they pin Hitch to the floor and straddle him, positioning their pussy over his erect cock and forcing it inside them.

Hitch moans in pleasure as Sunny starts riding him, unaware that she's possessed.

Nightmare bounces up and down as Hitch moans, feeling his cock deep inside her filled her with so much pleasure that she forgot all about the candy.

Nightmare looks at Hitch and leans down and licks his cheek. "Hmmm, you taste as sweet as candy, maybe even sweeter." She says as she rides on Hitch's cock.

Hitch blushes bright red as he is powerless to fight her off. "T-thank you, miss Nightmare, but when are you gonna release Sunny?" Hitch asked, concerned for his friend.

Nightmare looked at him and laughed. "As soon as I have my fun." She replied as she continued to ride on his cock.

Hitch looked down, concerned for how long it might take for his friend to come back.

Nightmare looked down and grabbed his cheeks. "Don't worry, your friend is fine…..she can also feel it, here see for yourself." Nightmare said as she closed her eyes, giving Sunny temporary control.

"Hitch! Help, I've been possessed by Nightmare Moon, my dad's journal should say how to de-...." Sunny cries out as she gets cut off.

"That's enough out of you, now let's take this somewhere else." Nightmare says as she activates Sunny's alicorn form and teleports them to the lighthouse, atop Sunny's bed.

"Now that we're completely alone, we can enjoy our time more." Nightmare uttered as she gave one more bounce, sending Hitch over the edge, causing him to cum in Sunny's tight and moist pussy.

Nightmare moaned in pleasure as Hitch orgasmed, making her feel alive for the first time in ages since being trapped in that gem.

"Hmmm, that's a good pony." The possessed Sunny said as she stroked Hitch's cheek. "You made me feel alive again, oh how I wish I could permanently reside in this vessel, but alas, 'tis not meant to be." Nightmare remarked as she pulled herself off Hitch's nightstick, cum dripping from her satisfied marehood as she walked casually to Hitch's side.

"Stay put, I'll be right back, but to make sure you're not tempted." Nightmare uses Sunny's alicorn form to restrain Hitch to the bed, before going to the bathroom.

"While in the bathroom, Nightmare wipes her dripping slit with a towel before magically cleaning it, catching a glimpse of Sunny in the mirror.

"Nightmare!" Sunny called out, hoping to talk.

"Save thy breath, you'll get control back, once Nightmare Night is over I'll forcibly be pulled back into the wretched gem that imprisons me; that is unless I find a host." Nightmare Moon replied as she looked in the mirror.

"Actually, I've always wanted to buck Hitch, but never had the courage to do so, so I must thank you, the feeling is amazing. So I have a deal for you, if you promise not to bring eternal night; I'll share my body with you, you can come out whenever you want, but you must consult with me first." Sunny said as Nightmare scoffed.

"And why in Equestria would I do that, do you know who you are talking to?" I am Nightmare Moon, ruler of the night, I outrank you in both age and rank to be subservient to you." Nightmare barked as she glared in the mirror.

"I know who you are, I also know you must be lonely in that gem, so I am offering you an out, and I won't consider you subservient, I just ask you not to make night eternal because it's impractical for agriculture. And at most it'll be a symbiotic relationship, like a clown fish and a sea anemone." Sunny replied as Nightmare smirked.

Giving out a sigh and a chuckle, Nightmare looked at Sunny's reflection, "Thou are as nerdy as the one who defeated us long ago, fine, no eternal night, I'll even throw in only bucking Hitch unless thou saith otherwise."

A glow of white light envelops Sunny as Nightmare gets permanently sealed inside her, smiling that she can have her pussy ravaged again bringing a devilish grin to the possessed Sunny's face.

Sunny walked out of the bathroom, the white light being seen by Hitch, causing him to think Nightmare is gone.

"Sunny, is that you?" Hitch asked, trying to move. "Please help, Nightmare possessed you and tied me up."

Letting out a giggle Sunny came up to Hitch's face and kissed him. "We know, and now you have two marefriends in one, thou should feel lucky." Nightmare said as Hitch's eyes grew wide.

"W-what!" Hitch yelled out, causing delight to swell in Nightmare's chest.

"You see, my little pony; the one you call Sunny and I made a deal, she could sense how lonely I felt and so offered to share her body with me, now I am free, to walk the streets again, well only when I am in control. But I will always be with her now, and by extension, you." Nightmare said as she booped Hitch's nose and hopped up in the bed as positioned her ass over Hitch's face giving him a view of her puffy pussy and pucked ponut.

Hitch blushed bright red as he looked up, never before did he get hard seeing Sunny's backside, but being underneath her, getting a toilet's point of view made his rod stiffen like hard candy.

"Hmmm, like what you see, Mr. Sheriff, perhaps you'd like a closer look?" Nightmare said as she sat down, placing her new pussy and ass on the tied-down stallion as she asked at his erect cock.

Hitch moaned in pleasure as he stiffed Sunny's ass, her musk turning him on more as the sweet scent of her pussy coaxed out some precum to squirt out of his second head.

"Hmmm, excited aren't we? I can see your long cock throbbing, it urns to spew, maybe I can help." Nightmare cooed before she started licking his cock, her warm breath making him harder as she licks up from his balls and up the shaft, she stops at the head before opening her mouth and engulfing his stallionhood, deepthroating it as Hitch gasped before returning to lick the mare's pussy that was in front of him.

Now entwined in the sixty-nine position, Nightmare Moon maneuvered Sunny's tail to where it caresses Hitch's head as he eats her out. Nightmare starts bobbing her head as she tries to coax him to cum again.

Hitch moaned in pleasure as his possessed friend had him pinned in the sixty-nine position. Helpless to fight back, Hitch continues to eat Sunny out as Nightmare releases his front legs so he could place his hooves on her flanks, doing so Hitch does, diving his tongue deep in the pink as his nose dives in the stink.

As Nightmare bobbed Sunny's head, she along with Hitch was nearing climax, after a few more bobs from Sunny, Hitch climaxed, shooting a load of hot cum into Sunny's maw.

Nightmare, not able to catch it all took the rest of his load to her face and let it coat his pelvis as she orgasmed on Hitch's face, covering it in love juice.

Nightmare then turned around with a mouth full of stallion jizz, she looked Hitch dead in the eye as she swallowed his seed, tracing the bulge down her throat as Hitch blushed.

"Hmmm, delicious. Perhaps I did gobble up some ponies this night after all." Nightmare said as she laughed.

Nightmare Moon released Hitch from the rest of his magical bondage and laid down with him. "This has been a most fortunateness night, I got a new body, a wonderful new lover, and my belly is full of thousands of young ponies." Nightmare coos as she lays her head on Hitch's head.

Hitch smiled as she laid her head down, gingerly stroking her mane. "So, Miss Nightmare?" Hitch began to say before being interrupted.

"Oh, please. Call me Nightmare, or if you prefer you can call me mommy." Nightmare said with a sultry wink, causing Hitch to blush.

"O-ok, Nightmare, are you gonna give control back to Sunny?" Hitch asked as he looked at the now satisfied mare.

Putting a hoof to her chin, Nightmare thought for a minute, before smiling. "Not yet, Mommy's not done with you yet," Nightmare said as she turned off the light as she pushed her lips onto Hitch's and pulled the covers over them.