An Alternative Ending

by ultrapoknee

Rating: teen
Tags: Tragedy, Main 6, Profanity, Discord, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Human, Other, Princess Luna, Drama, Suicide / Self Harm, Violence, Princess Celestia
Length: 98197

When you discard something, it's easy to forget the wrongs you committed. But, more times than not, the past always comes back to remind you of your fallibility.

Jason Wright returns at a pivotal moment in Equestria's history. He bares his vengeance, not with the hand of a conqueror or an invading force. But with the greatest weapon of all; the truth. And the truth is seldom pretty when it reveals the lies we tell ourselves.

This story is inspired by the Ending-verse.

Published 2023-01-06 14:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2023-05-21 16:28:14 UTC

The Gjallarhorn

Author's Note

Chapter two in under a week? I think I found my muse again. But, yeah, this is turning out to be more fun than I thought. The ideas are just flowing, and I got to jump on them. I hope I have captured what the Gjallarhorn is in this chapter. Now, I realize the pillars planted the elements. But it would lean too much toward the ponies being op if they made the Gjallarhorn too. There's still more to reveal about this mac Guffin, so stay tuned and enjoy.

The Gjallarhorn

[Canterlot Castle - Royal Library.]

"Hmm, no. That's not it," Twilight said, moving one book to the side and onto the next. "No, nothing here either," Twilight leaves another book in front of her. "No, nothing. Urgh! Did you girls find anything?"

"Nope," Applejack said from her pile of books.

"There's a passage on how to play the trombone. A description of how to make a blowhorn. Nothing in these books about this Gjallarhorn," Starlight stated.

"Nothing here either, darling," Rarity hummed as Rainbow looked over her shoulder.

"Rarity, that's a magazine about fashion trends!" Rainbow exposed.

Rarity's features develop a tinge of pink. "W-well, we've been at this all evening and haven't made any progress!"

"Maybe, we're looking in the wrong place," Spike grunted, setting down a tower of books.

"We've taken every book on every type of horn we could think of, and still nothing on what Chrysalis used," Twilight groaned.

"We ought to be kicking her ugly butt out of Equestria like last time!" Rainbow said.

"I know I'll feel safer knowing I'm not sleeping next to one of Equestria's biggest threats," Applejack added.

"Yeah, it doesn't look like we can do anything about it. Chrysalis has diplomatic immunity. Attacking her would be the same as starting an international incident," Starlight explained.

"But it shouldn't be the case!" Twilight exclaimed. "Queen Chrysalis violated international peace accords the moment she invaded Canterlot the first time! Any immunity she would have should be null and void. Urgh!" Twilight turns to Fluttershy. "Any luck on the strange creature?"

"Oh, um, I've been over every primate species, from chimpanzees and gorillas, but nothing fits," Fluttershy said. "Maybe, it's not a primate,"

"It could be a Diamond Dog or even a Minotaur?" Starlight offers.

"A Diamond dog and minotaur that's been shaved bald and doesn't have horns or a tail?" Spike said incredulously.

"No, it wouldn't work. The face, hands, and skeletal structure don't match the two species. The only similarities would be opposable thumbs and bipedal," Twilight explained.

"Then, what the hay is that thing?!" Rainbow throws her hoof up in exasperation.

"Jason Wright…" Pinkie mutters.

The group turned to Pinkie, who had been uncharacteristically quiet the entire time. "Who?" Spike asked.

"That's his name, Jason Wright,"

"Wait, you know Chrysalis' new monster!?" Rainbow demanded.

Pinkie shook her head. "I don't know him. But, he's not a monster,"

"I wouldn't be so sure about that with the company he keeps," Starlight said.

Pinkie shook her head harder this time, her usual bouncy mane straight as her coat was slightly dull. "My pinkie sense has been going off like crazy since the two of them showed up! It feels like we all should know him, but I can't remember from where,"

"Hold on a minute! Didn't Discord say its name? It sounds like he knows who this varmint is. Where did he scurry off to now?" Applejack said.

"Discord left as soon as Chrysalis and Jason did," Fluttershy said with a frown. "I think, with everything that is happening, he felt upset,"

"Darling, this is Discord we are talking about; he never cares enough to be upset," Rarity said.

"That's not true, Rarity. You should've seen him back at my cottage. He was so worried about the mistakes he's made toward the rulers that he almost didn't want to go,"

"So, there was an issue with him. I knew there was something wrong. What if this Jason Wright is part of a scheme he cooked up a millennium ago, and it's coming back to haunt every pony like the plunder vines!" Twilight theorized.

"He wanted to make amends, Twilight,"

"We'll, he not here to do that or explain himself. His absence all but confirms Twilight's theory," Starlight said.

"I don't think he's just mad at Discord…." Spike said. "He didn't seem to like ponies too much. Especially you, girls,"

"Like we did anything to it! I bet Chrysalis might have that thing under her spell! After all, Twilight was the one that ruined her wedding crashing," Rainbow reminded.

"It might be more than that, Dashie. Didn't you hear what he said? Didn't you see his face or look into his eyes? He's been hurt!" Pinkie stated.

"And it might've been either Chrysalis or Discord that did it! You know both of them can mess with ponies' heads!"

"I wouldn't put it past either of them to put some devious lie into somepony's head," Applejack snorts in disgust.

"Rainbow! Applejack! It's not fair to blame Discord. You know he's changed. And he's never worked with Chrysalis!" Fluttershy defended.

"Whatever the case, we can stop for the night and wait for the press statement tomorrow," Twilight said, sensing an argument growing.

"So, there's nothing we can do?" Applejack asks.

"The Princess gave explicit orders that no harm would come to Chrysalis and Jason. Our hooves are tied,"

"I don't like this…." Starlight said.

"Me neither…" Twilight's horn glowed as her magic encompassed everyone in the room. "There. A little spell that will react to us when we're together. This way, we'll know if some pony's a changeling in disguise. Whatever her plans, as long as we're together, nothing can hurt us,"

[The Next Day - Canterlot Square.]

The grounds of Canterlot were a buzz with activity. As promised by Princess Luna, an emergency meeting to address the state of affairs is underway. Reporters from various outlets lined up in front of the empty podium where the other rulers waited. Ember stood with her arms crossed while tapping her claw against her arm. Standing on stage before a crowd of gawkers made her feel like a sideshow attraction. She would've already left if it wasn't for this odd compulsion to stay. 'Whatever issue the changeling and that bald minotaur has with the ponies is their business. But that horn reminds me a lot of my bloodstone specter. I'm sure dad might know what it is, but I'm already here, so I might as well find out now,' The dragonlord thought to herself. She found herself thinking back to that creature known as Jason Wright and those horrible scars.

"Something on your mind, dragonlord?" Ember turns to her right to see the Saddle Abarian rulers. "Shifting Sands, and this is my wife, Amira," The stallion and mare bowed.

Ember gave a curt nod. "I'm mostly wondering when we're going to get started,"

"Nothing about the strange creature or his accusations?" Shifting said.

The Dragonlord shrugs her shoulders. "Who knows? It could be true. It could be a lie that bug came up with, but the pony sisters seem to be siding with them,"

"We've known Princess Celestia for the majority of our rule. Her trade agreements are fair, and she is a pleasant company," Amira said.

"Aw, but we have known her for all of our lives. We do not know the Princess for all of her life," Ember noted with a bit of surprise at the other ruler. She appeared to be a pony, yet she was as tall as Princess Celestia. Her fur was a light brownish-gray. But, the shock came from the white scales running along her back and face down to her muzzle. Her green mane and tail complement her red eyes and long red horn. The newcomer noticed the stares and introduced herself. "Queen Rain Shine,"

"You're a kirin?" Ember asks. "

"That I am,"

"Huh, so father's drunk rabblings weren't complete nonsense. Scabbard did mate with a pony,"

"You're presence has set our minds adrift. I thought your kind was but a myth," A zebra stallion stated. "Oh, pardon me. I am Chieftain Zullki,"

"Charmed," Shifting and Amira stated.

"Yes, it is a pleasure to see the outside of the sea. Queen Novo of the Hippogriffs," The sea pony turned Hippogriff bowed.

"Yak is Prince Rutherford. What does dragon pony mean about what she said about Princess?"

"Merely that an oak can hide its rotting bark under its luscious leaves," Rain Shine says.

"So, the Princess has secrets or an unsavory past. Should that matter to any of us?" Ember asks.

"For a pony like the princess Celestia - who is the head of a powerful and prosperous country - to be this shaken by a horn speaks volumes for all our state of affairs," Amira said.

"Well, the least she could do is get on with this sideshow so I can get to Griffinstone. And none of them bothered to say hello to me? Grandpa Gruff," Grandpa Gruff hacked.

Just as Ember was going to respond, a bright flash went off. Princess Celestia appears at the podium with her sister on the left with Cadence, the elements Spike and Starlight. However, on the right were Chrysalis and Jason Wright. At first, the crowd of ponies before was silent as they beheld Jason's appearance. The silence didn't last as screams of panic went off before morphing into jeers and boos. The royal guard acted immediately and became a barrier from anypony looking to rush the stage and prevent a riot. Chrysalis took the reaction in stride and even had the gull bow in reference. Jason, however, was a statue of stoicism. The shouting, the angry faces, and the hurtful words. He'd seen and heard it all and became numb to it. All he could now was shake his head in pity and disappointment, except when a rock struck his person. Jason stumbled and clutched his head as blood dripped onto the floor. The princesses looked horrified as the stone left a gash above Jason's right eye. However, instead of screaming or cursing out in pain, Jason laughed. He looks back at the stunned crowd with a manic grin, made even more terrifying by the blood leaking out over his eye and down his cheek.

"Oh, boy. That didn't take long. But thank you all the same. I could always count on you, bigots..." Just then, the Gjallarhorn reappears.

"Wait, stop!" Celestia called out in futility. The Gjallarhorn pulsed a wave over the crowd. Moments later, a pony appeared before Jason via teleportation. Celestia recognized the stallion as Jetset. "Jetset, you fool...!"

"W-what is going on? Why am I here? Princess?" The stallion looks around in a panic.

"Hey there, Jetset, did you throw this?" Jason asks as he kneels to the stallion with the rock in hand.

Jetset shrinks back before scampering to his hooves. "Of course I did, you hideous ape! Canterlot does not barter with monsters-- Wait, how do you--"

"--Know your name?" Jason's wicked smile made whatever brave the unicorn had faded away. "That part comes later. I don't want to distract you from this next part~,"

"What are you talking about?"

Jetset began to feel woozy as his legs wobbled. He felt a sharp pain in his head. Bringing his hoof up, Jetset moves it back to see blood streaming down a gash above his right eye. The same wound he'd inflicted upon Jason was now reflected upon himself. But that was not all. With a steady glow surrounding the Gjallarhorn, a white aura surrounds Jetset. The horn sounds out again as Jetset struggles. The struggle did not last, as the unicorn's grey magical aura began to seep out of his body and into the Gjallarhorn. The process lasted a moment before the force holding the unicorn cut out, allowing Jetset to crumble onto the ground. The onlookers shriek back in terror as they beheld Jetset features. His eyes lost their vibrant color, and his cutie mark was gone. Twilight noted that the effect of the horn was similar to Tirek's abilities. 'I-Is Tirek in league with them?!'

"JETSET!!!" A mare's voice called out, rushing to the stage. She holds the unresponsive stallion in her arms as tears stream down her visage. "WHAT DID YOU DO TO HIM?!?!"

Jason's smile only widens as the baneful glare from the noble pony falls into confusion as he speaks again. "Hello, Uppercrust. Yeah, I know you too. And I didn't do a thing. It's simple, and it reminds me of a phrase my kind says; do unto others as you would do unto yourself," Jason broke out into another fit of laughter before continuing. "It seems your husband looks a bit winded. Cuts like these tend to make everything woozy. You should make sure he's not concussed,"

"Somepony, get him to the hospital, for pony's sake!" Cadence commanded as guards escorted the unconscious stallion and weeping mare off the stage.

"Interesting choice of words, Princess,"

"Was that necessary?" Celestia asks.

"Was this?" Jason countered, pointing to his wound. "Is it my fault you dragging your hooves about keeping your lemmings in line?"

"Enough! Now I know what's going on! You're both in league with Tirek! That horn stole his magic away just like he did!" Twilight accused.

The crowd gasped at the accusation, only to be shut out by Chrysalis' laughter this time. "Oh, poor naive Twilight. We can always count on you to solve the solution with only half pieces of the puzzle. Had that pony merely waited for Celestia to explain, he'd still be fine. The Gjallarhorn is not a creation of Tirek's. It is a tool much like your elements of Harmony,"

"Do you think we're stupid or something--"

Rainbow started, but Chrysalis interrupted. "Yes,"

"Why you!!!"

Rainbow went to charge again, only for Luna's magic to catch her in the air. "I am beginning to question your intelligence, young Rainbow,"

"Princess! We all saw him use that horn to hurt and steal Jetset's magic!" Rarity reminded.

"And what did you see before that, hmm?" Chrysalis asks. "Did you not see that pony hurl this rock?" Chrysalis leaves said stone before Rarity with Jason's blood on it. "Did you not see this rock strike his face and draw blood? What kind of mental gymnastics does one have to do to feign innocence so they can remain morally superior?"

Chrysalis's words hit home as the fashionista shied away from the changeling monarch, as the rest of the elements fell silent. Finally, Celestia stamped her hoof on the ground and flared out her wings. She stares into Chrysalis's smug expression before turning to the crowd with a deep frown. "There'll be no more outbursts such as the actions Jetset displayed. My sister has already stated that we will explain what is happening. However, any further acts of violence against the pair on my right will face dire consequences. Treason is not barred from consideration. Is that understood?" No one dared to challenge the statement as they knew the Princess of the sun was severe. Inwardly, Celestia hated going to such lengths. But it was the only protective measure she could offer her subjects. The irony was not lost on the Princess.

Once she was sure the message was clear, Celestia sighed. "Long ago, when we were fillies during the pre-unification era, war plagued the lands. Diamond dogs raided the southern plains. Dragons launched raids in Fillydelphia. And the three pony tribes were constantly at odds. One such conflict was the founding of Manehattan. It was once a farmland called Trotsberg. A unicorn stallion noble name Snively happened upon the lands hoping to start an outpost. Once he saw that the farming community barely had any defensive options, he strolled into the small town and offered the inhabitants an ultimatum. The village lacked the means of transporting their wares, and they desperately needed blankets for the harsh chilling nights. So the unicorn offered to transport their product and provide a fair share of the wages.

The leader at the time - a mare named Merry Gold - felt the deal was too good to be accurate, but the farmers were out of options. The leader told the noble that she would give their answer by week's end. The unicorn agreed and waited the week. The villagers struggle against the cold night for the entire week, with some even perishing. The villagers begged Merry Gold to accept the deal, but she knew Snively was dishonest. At her wit's end, Merry Gold prayed to Faust. The goddess and author of all life. Her prayers were answered in the form of the Gjallarhorn,"

"So, this horn is a divine artifact?" Ember suddenly asks.

Celestia nods, excepting a question to arise. "Yes, they say our creator became saddened by the constant death and destruction and devised a way to quell urges of war. If the elements are to promote Harmony, the Gjallarhorn encourages peace talks and negotiation," She cast a glance toward Chrysalis, who smirks. "Merry did not know the significance of the Gjallarhorn, but she took the horn to the meeting. It was a good choice as Snively came to the meeting with a small contingent of personnel guards. His intentions were clear; force the community to fuel his outpost while he reaped the benefits of the food and profit. Resistance would meet the end of his guards' spears. At this betrayal, Merry Gold produced the Gjallarhorn and blew upon it. The same effect we all felt happened there. For you see, the Gjallarhorn is tied to the magic that resides within us all. Snively took the call of the horn as a declaration of defiance and commanded one of the guards to strike Merry Gold down,"

"You mean after all that, Merry Gold was slain by that ruffian?" Rarity asks.

"Nay, Generosity. The wound the guard inflicted upon Merry had reflected onto himself. That means that any acts of violence against the wielder of the horn will fail and cost the attacker. That is what happens to the guard. That is what occurred to Jetset just now," Luna explained.

Everyone was now wearier of this divine item in Jason's possession. "That explains the wound, not the horn stealing the magic," Shifting Sands reminded.

"If your enemy insists on war, you take away their ability to wage it. Snively did not know this aspect and lost all his guard. Yet, he stubbornly tried to use his magic to attack Merry Gold and lost that along with them. That is the protection the Gjallarhorn grants,"

"So, you mean to say that Queen Chrysalis is now invulnerable to any threat, physical or magical?" Queen Novo asks. "What's to stop her from conquering our lands?"

"That would go against the Gjallarhorn's nature. No harm can indeed come to the wielder, but they must set their terms with no ill intentions against the opposite party. The Gjallarhorn reads the purposes of everything around it. Merry Gold wanted warmth and prosperity for her community and gave Snively his magic once he agreed to uphold his end of the deal," Celestia finished.

"But, Princess, Chrysalis invaded Canterlot intending to harvest our love. Shouldn't the horn steal her magic for that?" Cadence brought back up.

"If the Gjallarhorn had deemed that action unjust, then she would've lost her magic. No lies or deception can fool it. As it stands, Chrysalis does have a legitimate grievance against us,"

The elements and the crowd went into an uproar at that. All the while, Queen Chrysalis smiles at the display. "Oh, yes, woe is me. I merely wanted love, but I was denied such a request,"

"One must ask why you chose such a brazen method if love was all you sought!" Luna seethed.

"Ah, ah, ah. That part comes later~," Jason smirks again at Chrysalis, parroting him.

"You still haven't explained why we haven't heard of this Gjallarhorn until it was right at our doorstep!?" Chancellor Neighsay suddenly spoke up. Princess Celestia turns sharply to him as he clears his throat. "My princess..."

"The Gjallarhorn does not belong to any nation, country, or species. Once its task is done, it returns to the ether. Only those who desire true peace and truly believe in the creator can access it. There is also no means of tracking it otherwise. My sister and I never used it because we'd learned how to engage in peace talks and negotiations. That is the lesson the Gjallarhorn teaches us all," Celestia said.

"Hmph, I hear that horn allows others to bully them into submission!" Many murmurs of agreement went off behind the Chancellor.

"Still slow on the upkeep and trying to play victim, huh? Let's say we didn't use the horn and went to Princess's little throne room with our grievance. Would you listen? Would you hear us out? Or would you raise the alarm, break out the spears and hurl the rocks at us while chasing us out?" Jason asked. The silence was all the answer he'd need. "I thought so,"

"You don't know that!" Twilight cried out.

In response, Jason tilts his head to her and runs a finger across his gash, showing her the blood. "This happened with me just standing here. Are you sure about your stance?"

"I..."

"So, what are we supposed to do now? Smile and wave while you bring all your changelings here!?" Rainbow angrily asks.

"Oh, fret not, my little Dashie. I know how nervous you ponies get around predators, so I made the preemptive move of integrating my subjects into your society already," The ponies all balked at that. "They've been living with you for some time now,"

"But, the horn--"

Twilight started before Chrysalis continued. "--Would only react negatively IF any of my subjects cause undo harm to your subjects. No one had been replaced or harvested. We do not need such methods anymore. We only wanted peace and love after all," Chrysalis couldn't help but giggle the more frustrated the royal Princess got from her every word. "They are even productive members of society with jobs and citizenship. All of it through perfectly legal means. Any changeling in disguise right now is unique - a new identity, if you will - so there's no need to claim fraud. And my request for using the Gjallarhorn will give me the means to ensure they have a future without fear of persecution. I know you understand the slight subterfuge,"

Princess Luna had a vein over her forehead, while Princess Celestia could only sigh in resignation. There was some degree of which did they understand. But, the fact remains that Chrysalis had thoroughly embarrassed the Equestrian government. "I see some reforms in border security and intelligence department shall be our next topic of discussion!" Luna said through gritted teeth.

"Indeed," Celestia stated. "Regardless, that is all the information on the Gjallarhorn and its function. I realize that today has revealed a lot, but I urge you all to return to your lives as before, with no more outlandish outbursts. Thank you,"

Celestia's words did not have the effect she hoped for. None of her subjects panic at the news of Changelings in their ranks. But she could see the seeds of suspicion cultivating. There were many shifting eyes and nervous twitching. She would have to talk to Luna about easing tension and doubling guard patrols. However, who knows how many guards are trustworthy now? Before she, too, could feel the effects of paranoia, Twilight confronted Chrysalis and Jason. "Wait! I still have questions! With all that's been said, how do we know you haven't found a loophole with the Gjallarhorn? How can anypony trust the pony next to them when they could be a changeling? You have to tell us who they are! What if you planted them to spread fear and confusion!? And how are we free from the Gjallarhorn effects? You can't expect us to accept things as they are.!"

The changeling queen regarded Twilight's words with an exasperated sigh of aggravation. "Do you want to take this, or shall I?" Chrysalis asks Jason.

"Go on, ahead. You've been killing it so far,"

"Thank you. Now, Twilight, can the elements be corrupted in any way, shape, or form?"

"Discord was able to corrupt us briefly before we reminded ourselves of how strong our friendship is--"

"Yes, yes. We get it. Friendship, huzzah. I don't mean the wielders of the elements. I mean the elements themselves,"

Twilight looked confused for meaning before shaking her head. "No, not that I know of exactly.

"They can't. I tried, and it failed miserably..."

"What?!" The elements exclaimed. "When did you do that?"

"Around the time you lot was in Canterlot, and I disguised myself as that photographer to get a strain of your manes and tails to clone you. I figured stealing your greatest weapon and turning it on you would be the best revenge. It turns out the elements know real from fake,"

Twilight and the others made their best impression of goldfish before Cadence spoke for them. "How can you freely admit to a revenge plot and still have your magic?"

"Because that plot failed before it started, and I did not have the horn, Caddie. A lot of time passed for me to get over my revenge schemes," Cadence huffs as she stamps her hoof. "Anyway, the Gjallarhorn works the same. No tricks. You are putting your very being under scrutiny so that two parties can meet on equal ground. Suppose trust is a concern; that falls on you ponies to have it. As I said, my subjects lived peacefully among yours with no issues. If that changes, it will be because of your intolerance. I will not compromise them until you have accepted my terms and stuck to your word that no harm will come to them! It should be easy for the Princess of friendship,"

"You still stuck them in without any of us knowing!"

To that, Chrysalis shrugs. "Better to ask for forgiveness than permission,"

Twilight gritted her teeth but stayed silent after a while before a gaze landed on Jason. "If those are your terms, what was his? You mentioned something about a tribunal. That means a trial and something about our sins. Surely, you can't mean that you are putting us on trial?" Twilight waved a hoof gesturing to her and her friends.

"My terms come after the tribunal. After I tear away the mask of hypocrisy and reveal the truth. So, I suggest having a chat with your good buddy Discord. It might clear your perspective," Jason looks to Chrysalis and gestures his head to leave. The queen gives a mocking bow as she struts over to him, and the two teleport away from Canterlot Square.

The Tribunal

Author's Note

Okay, I tried not to speak in the past tense so much here. But let me know if I missed something.

The Tribunal

[Canterlot - The Next Day.]

A turquoise and gold-maned earth pony trotted down the street of Canterlot. The pony spots his favorite shop and enters the establishment. Taking a seat at the counter, the pony rang the bell. "Hey, Joe. Are you there?"

"One sec," Pony Joe said, stepping out of the kitchen. In his mouth was a brew of coffee. "How you are doing, Hefty Tips,"

"Hiya, Joe..." Hefty Tips pauses while taking in Pony Joe's features. "Jeez, Joe. You look like you slept in an Ursa cave,"

"Yeah, well, I haven't gotten much sleep at all. Did you hear that Queen Chrysalis is back? I still have nightmares from the last time those changelings busted through the roof. Now, they could be walking around in this shop right now! Anyway, you want the usual?"

"Yes, please," Pony Joe goes into the kitchen before coming back with a small cappuccino. He set it in front of Hefty as the two ponies looked around the store to see various ponies. However, they were spread out to put as much distance between each other as the store would allow. The conversations were kept to a bare minimum as everyone eyed each other. Hefty couldn't help but share his head. "I can't understand why ponies are freaking out like this,"

Pony Joe tilts his head in confusion. "What do you mean, Hefty?"

"Well, we didn't know there were changelings in the city until yesterday, and everything was fine,"

"Yeah, we did not know there was love stealing parasites walking among us,"

"But, if they've been here so long and haven't caused any trouble, should we start making it ourselves?"

One of the ponies overheard the conversation and approached the counter. "Of course, we should do something. Did you forget the wedding invasion? They don't get a pass from that!"

"I'm just saying we shouldn't lose our heads over this if nopony is causing problems..."

"How can you say that? What if somepony got replaced, and we don't even know it!" Another pony said.

"Come on, nopony is that good at impersonating others. Even Princess Twilight discovered Princess Cadence was a fake,"

The ponies around the counter regarded the earth pony for a moment before another spoke. "Why are you so calm about this?"

"Huh, what do you mean?"

"It's just that you're arguing that we should accept a bunch of parasites in our mist. That we should forgive them for attacking us and harvest our love!"

"What, no! I am saying that if the changeling has been with us all this time and didn't cause any trouble, why should we? Maybe they want to live in peace or even make friends. Isn't that what Princess Twilight wants?"

"What kind of creatures sneak in and disguise themselves if they want friendship? Why hide away? For all we know, they could be brainwashing ponies to like them!"

Hefty suddenly felt the atmosphere in the store change. The customers were looking at him more intently now."C-Come on, that's ridiculous,"

"You know, I've noticed something about you, Hefty. You moved in Canterlot a while ago, and you were quick to make friends with me," Pony Joe said.

"W-well, yeah. Shouldn't I?"

"You always come in and order drinks, but never any food,"

"I don't like sweet food. Joe, what are you getting at?" Hefty backs away from the counter as Pony Joe get in his face.

"It's just that you could be a changeling yourself! Why else does it seem like you are on their side?" The ponies in the store share the same sentiments, forming a line by Joe.

"What? Joe, listen to yourself. That's crazy! I've been a loyal customer and friend since I moved here!"

"Yeah, you could suck out my love or replace me when nopony was looking!" Pony Joe took the glass he had prepared and hurled it at Hefty. The cup missed him but broke against the floor, the shards of glass cutting the lower part of his forearm.

"Ah! Wait, wait, see? If I were a changeling, then you would've lost your magic. You're all just being paranoid. I'm sure the princesses handling the situation--"

"--If the princesses could handle things, then why haven't they?" One pony in the crowd said. "How do we know they haven't been replaced or mind-controlled? It happened before!"

"But, it's the princesses we're talking about right now. Surely, you are not saying they would fail or betray us!" Another pony said.

"Hey, let's not forget whose the changeling puppet here!" Pony Joe reminded.

"Hey, what if we break the spell?"

"How do we do that?"

"A friend of mine goes to Celestia's School for gifted unicorns. She said we can usually break by disrupting the spell or by knocking the pony out,"

"What, no! Even if I was under mind control, shouldn't you at least get professionals?" Hefty suggests.

Soon, the shop broke out into arguments with yelling and accusations. Before everything could spiral out of control, a pair of royal guards burst through the shop. "What's going on in here?"

Every hoof pointed at Hefty Tips as Pony Joe spoke. "He's been brainwashed by changelings! he was saying how ponies shouldn't worry about changelings hiding near our homes! He probably snuck some of his buddies to feed off of us!"

"Yeah!"

"He's a traitor!"

"Take him away!"

"No, no, no! Please! It's all a misunderstanding!" Hefty pleaded.

"Save it! You're coming with us to the station for questioning. All of you are to vacate the shop immediately and go with us. We're closing this establishment down for possible changeling activity!"

"Whoa. Hold on a second. I can't close down my shop!" Pony Joe argued as more royal guards poured into the store.

"Take it up in day court!" All the ponies were carted out of the donut shop as the royal guard locked the shop down. On the way to the station, Hefty noticed many more shops getting the same treatment. "What a morning,"

[Guard Station.]

A guard shuts the cell to the latest batch of ponies into a cell. All the ponies inside are screaming about wrongful imprisonment and blatant injustice. "That's the third batch of ponies we put in there. And it's not even noon,"

"Well, when you have shapeshifters running around, ponies tend to get jumpy,"

"Too jumpy. Have you read the case of some of them? Stalking. Disorderly conduct. Vandalism. Flash mobs. It's like Canterlot is going mad. Some of us are still on duty from a double. I saw Swift Sweeper asleep in one of the bathroom stalls!"

"Unfortunately, until this mess gets sorted out, we all stand between complete anarchy. Come on; the captain had an announcement in the conference room,"

The two guards began walking as one of them continued. "If you think it's bad here, you should've read the reports from Manehattan. I heard all the sky scrappers were on fire,"

"Yeah? Well, Detrot always has something burning. That's nothing new,"

The two ponies enter the conference room with other guards of both divisions. The night guards were busy trying to stay awake, while the day guards appeared to be overcharged from caffeine. A gruff-looking pony stood in the front of the room with a grim expression. "Hmm? Good, you're both here. You better have a seat and brace yourselves. I just got news from up top," The two ponies exchanged a look before sitting down. "Now, since the revelation of changelings living in our fair capital, the Princess has ordered extra patrols. That means we have to make some cuts of responsibilities. Anypony that's been stationed to guard any nobles are to cease and work the beat on the streets," That change garnered several groans from the guards. Guarding VIPs in Canterlot was easy because it is the capital where crime is low, and you can stand inside a fancy mansion. "Next, we are getting some CSGU graduates to help sort out the prison population to see whose a ling from a pony. However, the apprehension process must require as little force as possible. We don't want to get sued because a prep turned out to be a pony and didn't like the horn handling. Or, get our magic sucked out,"

Another set of groans went off as many of the preps were entitled know-it-alls that needed a good hazing. "Finally, all staff - senior and junior - shall serve to undergo reevaluation. We will be looking at the time of enlistment and thorough background checks to see if any pony is who they say they are. Any resistance will result in immediate disbarment,"

The groans cascaded in rightful belligerence. "Captain, that's not fair! Are you saying I might get kicked because I'm a recruit?"

"I agree. It should just be the recruits under evaluation. I don't want my twenty years of service thrown out because of some upstart,"

"More like you don't want the brass to see your report records before you have time to alter them again,"

The two ponies glared at each other as the other guards voiced their concerns. "Bat ponies should get more breaks during the day. We nocturnal after all,"

"More breaks? I haven't been able to sleep for the past two days!"

"Alright, alright! Enough! Like it or not, this is how things will be for a while, with no exceptions. If you have any more issues, quit or take it up with the royals. Dismissed!" As the ponies filed out of the room, the captain wondered how many would return later in the day.

[Canterlot - Jason's room]

Chrysalis sat in the middle of the room. To the onlooker, she appeared to be sleeping. To those that knew the subtle twitch of her wings and the shimmers of magical aura around her horn, Chrysalis is currently communing with her progeny within the hivemind. It is a place of darkness where the only light comes from the Changeling queen's aura surrounding her body. Soon, multiple auras appeared around her as Chrysalis smiled. "Hello, my little brood. How goes your affairs since my announcement?"

"The ponies are reacting exactly as you thought they would, my queen,"

"They scramble and panic but fall just short of a full-blown riot,"

"They are attempting to locate us through many measures. Some by dragging random ponies to the stations. Others by accusing new ponies that moved to Canterlot,"

"And have they been able to find any of you?"

"No, my queen. The ponies do not have an effective means of tracking us while in disguise. The best they can do is put a spell on themselves to prevent replacement,"

"Hmm, do not free any spells the ponies may use. The Gjallarhorn is proving to be an excellent deterrent against brazen actions. However, make sure you rotate if somepony gets wise. Remember, if this is to work, we cannot be the aggressors,"

"Yes, my queen," The drones said as the connection faded.

Chrysalis blinks away the spell as she smiles. She turns to find Jason sitting on the bed while reviewing several documents. "Our changelings are doing well," Jason grunted in acknowledgment. "The ponies are practically tripping over their hooves with panic and paranoia. You were right to suggest complete integration in this regard. I haven't had this much fun in ages. Who justice could so much more gratifying,"

"..."

Chrysalis scoffed at Jason's silence and flew over to him while encasing the forms in her magic to neatly pack away the papers. Jason glares at her while Chrysalis smiles. Jason tried to reach for the documents again, but Chrysalis pulled his hands to her hooves with her magic. "You know, it's no fun gloating all by myself,"

"...There's nothing to gloat about until after the trial,"

"Jason, at least try and humor me. Do you know how long I've wanted an advantage like this?"

"Chrysalis, I need to go over our evidence!"

"You need to relax. I can feel your hands shaking and your anxiety building. Between your memories and these papers, the trial - as you would say - is a lock,"

"Chrysalis. This trial needs to go well. It's the only way I can--"

"--I know. Jason. I promise you that everything will go well. They can scream and shout today, but tomorrow? They'll beg for your forgiveness,"

"...And I'll whisper no..."

[Canterlot Judicial Hall - First day of the trial.]

It's a rare sight when the courtroom is filled with this much activity. Ponies scampered about trying to get the best seats. The reporter ponies line the outer walls with the royal guards. The resident nobles of Canterlot made up the rows of spectators. Starlight and Spike sat closest to where the elements were on the defense side while the plaintiffs had yet to arrive. Princess Celestia is currently sitting in the middle of the judge's bench. Next to her on either side were Cadence and Luna, along with the other world leaders. With a burst of green light, Chrysalis and Jason appear in front of the door. Once again, the boos and jeers filled the room. Chrysalis puffs out her chest in mockery of the poor reception, while Jason is as stone-faced as ever. Unlike last time, the ponies knew better than to express their distaste for the pair through physicality. Jason and Chrysalis calmly walked to the plaintiff's stand as Jason set his papers down. The Gjallarhorn materializes next to him, and all the jeering and boos cease. Celestia sighs in disappointment at her ponies. It takes a magical artifact to bring order. Regardless, she steels herself and meets Jason's glare with an impassive one. She clears her throat as she speaks.

"I thank you all for attending this tribunal. As the offended party called this court session in Equestria, I will preside as the leading judge. Any questions?"

Twilight instantly raised her hoof. "Princess, in the interest of fairness, why are you presiding? Wouldn't that spark a potential conflict of interests?"

Celestia nods in understanding. "If this was a standard trial, then yes, but that is not the case for a tribunal. It is a meeting of the world leaders, who will also act as judges, to hear a grievance that could potentially affect their kingdoms. As such, these proceedings will be transmitted live to the other domains so that there is no fallacy or undermining of the ruling. Now, will the plaintiffs please announce their names, species and aim for calling this tribunal,"

"Queen Chrysalis of the Changeling. I've already stated my terms. This trial is all at the behest of my benefactor,"

All eyes fall on Jason Wright. "My name is Jason Wright of the human race. What I want is for those that wronged me to face the punishment of my choice regardless of their status!"

Many murmurs went off at the terms laid out. Some talked about what a human is, while others sneered at the ridiculousness and audacity of the strange new creature. "And you believe that the elements of Harmony have harmed a creature we've never seen or heard of before?" Celestia asks.

"Ah, there's that arrogance again. The elements can do no wrong. The elements are paragons of good. And everyone loves them!" Jason lets out a bitter chuckle. "You know what I discovered about those little trinkets? They spread falsehoods,"

"What do you mean?" Queen Novo asks.

"You might've been led to believe the elements of Harmony are forces of good. But that's not true. They are forces of balance. When one side tips too far in one direction, Harmony balances it out. Harmony mirrors chaos because it doesn't sway between good and evil."

"You seem to know a lot of artifacts that you couldn't possibly know without wielding them yourself. As a former bearer, I can tell you that your assessment is wrong," Celestia stamps her hoof down to emphasize her point. The gallery gave her applause while her entourage said some supporting words. However, Celestia felt a sliver of doubt at Jason's passionless look.

"My, my, Princess. I never know you to be so foolish and haughty. You are making this event all the more sweetie for me," Chrysalis taunted, earning her a round of boos.

"And you speak for all the past and present elements?" Jason asks. Celestia gave a curt nod. "Good. It's not just them. I wouldn't get too comfortable up there, your highness. You're not innocent either!"

"And what crimes have I committed against you?" The indignant tone was palpable within the solar Princess.

"Criminal negligence. A crime you have repeated multiple times during your rule and even more so recently. I know you doubt me when I say this, so let's start with the big one. A thousand years ago, when ponies embraced open tribalism and slavery, two alicorn sisters united the three tribes for the birth of Equestria. However, one sister was more cherished than the other. So great was her reign, so brilliant her glory that long was the shadow she cast," Jason smiled as every word made the normally unflinching Celestia's eyes go wide in shock. "But that shadow fell on the one you loved most. How long did it take you to notice your sister wasn't getting her due? A week? A month? A decade?"

"I-I-- No! How could--" Celestia stammers. Lullaby for a princess was insanely popular after its release. It was also widely considered how many relate Celestia's viewpoint about the birth of Nightmare and a favorite theory for how Celestia's mane became rainbow-colored. Judging by the reaction, the video was spot on with events of this world. "This is pure speculation! You were not there! You couldn't possibly know the events leading to--"

"--Nightmare Moon's birth? Everyone should know that by now. As for speculation? That's not possible with this thing!" Jason points to the Gjallarhorn. Although, the truth is more abstract to a degree. What Jason know is the truth of his world. It's only a happy coincidence that it lines up with this world's history. "If you want to dispute this, you can touch the horn and display what happened through your memories. Or, you can opt out and accept what's been said,"

"There is no need to accept anything! Becoming the Nightmare was my sin due to my jealousy!" Luna stated., coming to Celestia's defense.

"But, is that all, Princess? Did you honestly play no part in your sister's descent into madness?"

Celestia grimaced as she eyed the horn, which turned to face her. It was as if it was daring her to say anything but the truth. "I was self-absorbed back then. I was but a young, foolish little mare, barely into her adult years but responsible for the most prosperous up-and-coming kingdom. My subjects adored me, and I reveled in that adoration. But such is the way of the limelight. It sweetly takes hold of its host. I..." Celestia pauses as she gathers her thoughts. "I did not notice Princess Luna's alignments until a year after she petitioned to have the nights last longer," Celestia openly glares at Jason for reopening this wound. "The rest is ancient history now. Princess Luna returned as the elements cleansed her of Nightmare Moon, allowing us to make amends,"

Princess Celestia got up from the bench and walked to the Gjallarhorn. She places her hoof on it as it glows and projects the image of Luna cleansed of the Nightmare. "It has been a thousand years since I've seen you like this. Time to put our differences behind us. We were meant to rule together, little sister. Will you accept my friendship?"

The memory displays Princess Luna embracing Celestia in a hug. "I am so sorry!" Luna apologized. "I missed you so much, big sister,"

"I did as well," The memory ends with a tearful hug from the two sisters. The gallery erupts in sympathetic cries while the Judges nod in approval. "As you can see, now can we get to the real issue of your grievances? Are we going to continue to waste time?"

"Oh, we're just getting started," Jason said, prompting Celestia to arch a brow. "Since you brought this up, why didn't you apologize?"

"What?"

"You did not apologize after your big reunion. Princess Luna did. But, your words at that moment were hardly an admission of guilt. You came from a position of moral superiority like you were owed an apology when both parties are at fault,"

Celestia steps back as she realizes how the memory looks. Her words did seem to come from the moral high ground rather than repentance. Sensing the mood shifting in the human's favor, Luna teleports to Celestia's side. "Enough. Anypony can see that the apology was implied. And princess Celestia has more than once asked forgiveness after my banishment. Such matters are private between siblings,"

"Except it wasn't private. Your sisterly quarrel had deadly implications for the world at large. But let's talk about your banishment. Another point to Celestia's negligence. Why did you banish your sister?" Jason asks.

"What kind of question is that?!" Luna stated, growing irritated now. "She did so to stop the Nightmare from plunging the world into eternal darkness!"

"I'm not asking about the motivation. I am asking why she chose to banish you to the moon," Luna's irritation vanished after that as she looked at her sister. "When you returned from your glorified time session, Twilight and her friends used the elements again to cleanse you. Why didn't Celestia free you herself?"

Celestia back peddles at Luna's questioning gaze. "W-We were in the middle of a battle. Nightmare Moon was relentless in her assault. There wasn't time to think properly!" Celestia argued.

"Yet, Twilight, a unicorn at the time - along with mere citizens - faced off against an alicorn! They were in significantly more danger than you were!"

"I had the help of my friends to see me through that! Princess Celestia was all alone!" Twilight defended.

"If an army of Breezies and a pony get into a fight, who would win?" Twilight recoils at that. "My question still stands. Or, maybe you wanted the throne to yourself?"

"No!" Celestia denies the claim vehemently. "I wanted the creature trying to kill me to disappear!"

"Tia..." Luna said in a small voice.

Celestia grimaces again at her choice of words. "I was scared, Luna. Everything was happening too fast!"

"You can't fault the Princess for something done in the spur of the moment!" Twilight counters. "A fight like that could go either way. I know that when we faced Nightmare Moon, she shattered the elements. If it weren't for the spark of friendship I got, then we would've lost!"

"And that brings me to my next point of the Princess's crime; why did the wise and brilliant Princess of the sun send you, her student, to deal with Nightmare Moon? Wouldn't it have been easier to properly prepare for Nightmare's return with an army of guards? You can't tell me she did not know Nightmare Moon was coming back!"

"Well..." Twilight pauses while looking at the horn. She didn't dare risk lying now. "I did notice the signs myself. And Princess Celestia said she knew Nightmare Moon was returning. But, the elements could only work with the spark of friendship that my friends and I possessed!"

"Yeah!!!" Rainbow stated.

"You tell him, Twilight!" Applejack supported.

"Indoably!" Rarity added.

"That's right!" Fluttershy said in a surprisingly firm tone.

"..." Pinkie remained quiet.

Jason crosses his arms at the empty platitudes. "So, the entirety of your success was nothing but a gamble on you making friends? Princess Celestia risked the entire world - millions of lives - on a pony who didn't have friends until that moment?"

"I-I had friends before then!"

"But, did you consider them friends? Did you hang out when they asked you? Did you go to their birthday parties or get together?" Jason could see it clearly in his head. The episode where Twilight ran away from Minuette and Lemon hearts to pursue her Nightmare Moon's second coming. How Twilight brushed off Moondancer's invitation for her studies. And judging from Twilight's shifting eyes and splayed ears, she thinks the same.

"...N-no..."

Jason smiled at the admittance as murmurs went off around him. This time, they were leaning toward his view. Some even began to look at Celestia a bit differently. "Let's say it had to be you and your friends. Let's say she did put the world's safety on faith in your ability to overcome being antisocial. Why wasn't she there with you to help tip the scales? If Nightmare Moon was trying to kill her, why wouldn't she try and kill you six? That's a sizable risk when her being with you would've given her backup she did not have before. Or, again, having an army to aid her while you six activate the elements,"

"I would like to hear this as well, Princess," Queen Novo suddenly spoke. "We feared the storm king because of his brutal tactics and unrelenting army. It took a large junk of our military force to retreat into the shores of Eris Peak. And Nightmare Moon was a far more significant threat! Where were you? Surely, Nightmare Moon appeared before you again to settle the score,"

That was going to be Jason's next question. But this was a good result. Now, others were beginning to cast doubt on Celestia's decision-making. Celestia looked like a deer in headlights before looking down in shame. "She did appear before me again. But I could not bring myself to fight with my sister. Not again. So, I allowed myself to be sealed on the moon by her. I did so so on the belief that my faithful student would succeed. And, to experience the fate, I subject my sister too as penance..."

Silence reigned over the court as no one knew how to process this information. Chrysalis was smiling ear to ear. She witnessed the pony's faith in their beloved leader crumble right before her eyes. Jason, however, scoffs; it isn't hard to see Celestia's flaws if you point them out. Regardless, it was time to close this line of questioning. "You know why the eternal night was so dangerous?

"Why?" Luna asks carefully. There was no longer any rightful anger in her tone.

"Because it would've killed the whole planet. The below-zero temperature wouldn't allow for any crops to grow. That's Bye-bye for all food sources for the ponies. All plant and animal life would've died out. So, the predators had no chance. And that is just the side of the planet with the moon. The other would've been burnt to a crisp from the sun's heat—a barren world of blistering heat and frigid cold. All those lives lost because of someone's else neglect,'

"No! It would not have been like that. Surely, with magic, a solution would've been found!" Luna tried to argue.

"And how long would that have taken before an untold amount of deaths? And that's considering your would-be subjects accept Nightmare Moon's usurpation of the crown?" Chrysalis chimed in; this line of questioning is too good to sit out on.

"ENOUGH!!!" Celestia bellows while flaring her wings. "Yes, I have made mistakes. Yes, I have taken things on faith when I could've been more prepared. But I am not a god. I never claimed to be one. Perhaps I am guilty of negligence. But I will not sit here and have you villainize my sister!!!"

"But, you did that! You villainized her when you created Nightmare night. How did that song go again, Chrysalis?"

"Something like this," Chrysalis horns projects an image at a Nightmare Night festival.

Every word of the projection made Celestia shrink away. "One has to wonder why you would do this to your sister, knowing how she would feel. Why, I didn't even know of Princess Luna since you so thoroughly removed her from history,"

Jason levels a glare at the solar Princess as she can provide no answer. "I wasn't trying to demonize your sister. I was pointing out your flaws. Your sins. And there's still a long list. If anything? Princess Luna is just as much of a victim as I am!" Jason looked directly at the Princess of the night as he said his following statement. "Although, I doubt I can call this mare Princess Luna,"

The courtroom did a double-take at that phrasing. "What kind of hooey are you spouting now?" Applejack said.

"Yes, of course, she's Princess Luna!" Twilight firmly said.

"Is she, though? Let's not forget that your little rainbow lasers hit her as Nightmare Moon. Then, she became small before regaining whatever magic to gain her current state. But, Princess Luna - regardless of her motivations - chose to become Nightmare Moon. She didn't get redeemed or convinced she was wrong. The elements saw Nightmare Moon as an imbalance. She tipped the scales of Harmony. So, they took whatever choice Nightmare Moon would've made away from her. And, this mare is the result,"

Princess was now as place as a ghost as she moved away from her sister and the elements, standing in the middle of the courtroom. "...No, I am me. I am!"

"Are you?" Jason pushed. "Don't you find it strange that you are thousands of years old yet barely taller than Princess Cadance? Nightmare Moon was at least at eye level with Princess Celestia. What if that was your mature state? But because her ideals were so radical, the element deemed a full blanking and personality shift was necessary. Do any of you understand how those trinkets work?"

"..." The silence was deafening despite no word uttering.

Jason shakes his head. "It must've been horrible up there on the moon, trapped for days without any means of contact. You probably had to use all your anger and hatred to stay sane. Then, you come back seeking your misguided justice, only to essentially die in all but your name,"

Princess Luna fell to her knees with her wings, and her ear splayed out in submission. Tears threatened to spill as Celestia held out a branch of comfort, but Luna shied away from it. "...I, as a result of this news, recluse myself as an acting judge. I must reflect on some things,"

"Lulu, wait--" Celestia's cries fell on deaf ears as Luna teleported away. Everyone stares at Luna's former position for some time before Celestia, with her mane covering her eyes, turns back to Jason. "What did my ponies or I ever do you to warrant this hatred?"

Jason stared into Celestia's magenta, sorrowful eyes as they held an undercurrent of hate. Without taking his eyes off hers, Jason touches the Gjallarhorn, and a new memory plays out. The courtroom gasps out as the image displays Celestia standing with Jason Wright at the train station. He was slightly younger and dressed in a black jacket, red undershirt, and blue jeans. His appearance was much cleaner than the current dark robe he is wearing now. His hair was combed over neatly, and there was no scarring or blind eye. He looked happy, a far cry from his current stoic demeanor. The two in the memory were conversing, leaving the courtroom speechless.

"You know, I'm nervous. My hands won't stop shaking,"

"Oh? Well, if your hands need something to occupy themselves, my ears are more than up to the task," Jason, in the memory, leans in and scratches behind Celestia's ears as she sighs contently. "If you lead with this, I am sure no mare would resist you,"

"Haha, a bit early for that. But, still, I'm about to meet my heroes. I don't know what to say. It feels like I got butterflies doing gymnastics in my stomach,"

"I am sure a particular mare might help with your shyness. Don't fret, Jason Wright. Ponyville is the friendship capital of Equestria; after all,"

"Did you make that official, or is that just a saying?"

Celestia tilts her head up playfully in thought. "I can't say. I'm not the Princess of Friendship. But, all the same, Twilight and her friends will welcome you just as I have. Don't forget to Wright," Celestia winks at her little pun.

"Later, Princess Sunbutt," Jason waves as the two share another laugh while Jason broads the train.

The memory fades as Celestia struggles to find words. "W-What was that!?"

"That was when you saw me off to Ponyville three years ago..."

"Wait! You met this human before?" Ember asks.

"I-Impossible! We met two days ago. I-I don't remember..." Suddenly, Celestia went weak in her knees. The Gjallarhorn glows briefly as an aura of magic burst from Celestia. The ponies all shrieked in alarm, but the magic dispersed as quickly as it came, with Celestia's eyes still clear and cutie marks still present. The Princess of the sun shook off the cobwebs and looked at Jason in a new and familiar light. Whatever was clouding her mind was now gone as she whispered his name. "...Jason Wright? I remember now! W-what happened to you?"

"Hey, Princess Sunbutt," Celestia remembered that little observation. But, there was no joy or upbeat tone in the delivery. "You asked why I am doing this. Why am I so different? Why do I hate you and your ponies?" Jason walks to the center of the room, still keeping his eyes on Celestia as he pulls down his robe. Several things happened once the robes hit the ground. Most of the gallery screamed in horror. Others fainted on the spot. Jason heard the gasp of the leaders behind him as he did complete three sixty turns. Jason's body was a road map of pain. The scarring over his left eye traveled down the left side of his torso, left arm, and lower back. A purple and black discoloration of skin stared angrily over his right abdomen. And several more minor welts and bruises decorated his upper right pectoral and right arm. Each injury had its tale as Celestia traces Jason's frame. Her hoof flew to her muzzle in horror as Jason spoke in a bitter and broken tone. "The answer to your question is straightforward, Princess. You left me alone with them!"

The Princess of Friendship

Author's Note

Memory dialogue will be in Italics and bold. Zebra rhyming is a hassle. I had to rewatch a lot of episodes for this one. :derpyderp1::derpyderp2:

The Princess of Friendship

[Canterlot - Luna's quarters.]

Several hoofs trotted down the halls of Canterlot palace. Cadance called for adjourning after Jason revealed his scarring. No one objected, and everyone left to digest today's proceedings. Everyone was deep in thought and greatly disturbed. Starlight looks between all her friends and the two princesses. The walk was silent from the courtroom, and Starlight couldn't stand it any longer. "Um, everypony. We need to talk about what happened back there..."

"Where should we start? The stuff about the scars or Princess Luna or..." Spike inquires, pausing as he looks at Princess Celestia.

"I don't believe it. The elements wouldn't change somepony like that!" Rainbow denied.

"I agree, darling. We would certainly know how such a spell is done," Rarity said.

"Do we? Do we know anything about the elements besides them looking like our cutie marks and some silly virtues?" Pinkie asks.

Rarity gasps at Pinkie's words. "Pinkie Pie! Don't tell me you agree with Chrysalis and that thing. Next, you're going to tell me you believe that slander he said about Princess Celestia,"

"Much of what Jason said shouldn't be taken at face value. Anypony can twist events with enough information. The real question is how much does this Jason Wright know," Twilight said. "In all honesty, he shouldn't have known half the things he said unless he was personally there,"

"That thing got to be lying somehow!" Rainbow asserted.

"He isn't a thing, Rainbow! He's a human!" Pinkie reminded vehemently.

"And what is that exactly?" Rainbow asks.

"I wish I knew. But he was so hurt. None of those wounds were fake. I think somepony's abused him," Fluttershy said.

"Like, who? Come on, girls. Think about it. That Jason thing--" Rainbow stops at Pinkie's glare. "That Jason Wright showed us a memory of him coming to Ponyvile. Who's to say he didn't go further than that and ran into some bandits?"

"That could be possible if the train between Canterlot and Ponyville is practically bandit-proof. No criminal would dream of robbing something close to the country's capital," Starlight shot down.

"Then, it must've happened later on. Or, you know, Chrysalis is messing with its head. I, Pinkie, promise that absolutely nopony from Ponyville did those things to him. Cross my heart--"

Pinkie's hoof shot out to grab Rainbow's before she could start the promise. "STOP!!!" Everyone stared at Pinkie's serious face in astonishment as Pinkie lets go. "Please, no promises this time,"

"Pinkie, what's wrong? It's just a standard Pinkie promise. This one doesn't even have cause to break. Ponyville is the friendliest place in Equestria," Rarity stated. "This Jason Wright is misinformed,"

"There can be no falsehoods when one wields the Gjallarhorn. It reveals the truth of everything. Even the lies we tell ourselves or the ones we don't realize," Celestia finally spoke.

"Are you talking about you suddenly remembering Jason at the end?" Cadance asks as Celestia nods. "What was that anyway? The spell was so weak that I couldn't detect any identifying markers,"

"I do not know what that was or where that magic originated. All I know is that what Jason has displayed is real. I did see him off to Ponyville three years ago. And for those three years, I'd completely forgotten he existed. His words were not slander because, under a critical lens, my decisions regarding the elements were flimsy and incompetent. My actions were neglectful..."

"I still say that's a bunch of pony feathers. Why is it an issue when everything turned out fine?" Applejack asks. "And why does this Jason fella seem so bent against us if you were friends?"

"It is the fact that my choices had a margin for error, Applejack. Yes, things turned out for the best, but there was a chance for things to fall apart. There should've been more careful consideration rather than blind faith," Celestia sighed. "As for our Friendship, I doubt we can use that term anymore. Jason's wounds tell all but the hooves that dealt them. The scar over his eye trailing down his body? A strike from a lightning bolt. The bruising over the abdomen? A shift kick to the ribcage caused that. And the welts came from rocks cruelly thrown at him. I do not know if the resident of Ponyville is responsible, nor would I believe it..." Celestia paused as she looked down in contemplation. "...At first,"

"At first? Excuse me, Princess, but even considering the possibility of anypony doing those things to Jason is wrong!" Twilight stated firmly.

Celestia turns to the group with an unreadable expression. "Then, I suggest you look into whatever magic left me and ensure it's not within yourselves. I fear a foul hand is at play. One that seeks to discredit us. In the meantime, prepare for the next day as best as possible. Jason's argument is compelling because he wields the truth. So, only the truth can prevail. Now, if you all will excuse me, I wish to speak with my sister alone,"

The group shares a look but honors the request as Celestia enters Luna's room. What awaited her was a sorry sight. Luna was not there, but evidence of her anger and frustration was. Several articles of clothing lay on the floor and were ripped apart. The vanity mirror was broken into pieces and shattered across the floor. Scanning the room for more clues, Celestia's eyes fall upon the empty case on the north wall. It was Luna's prized possession, gifted to her by one pony. Without a moment's delay, Celestia's horn glows as she vanishes from her sister's room. And reappear in the gardens. She walks a short distance past some shrubbery to find Luna sitting beside a cherry willow tree. At its base was a small tombstone. Celestia calmly walks up to her sister, noticing an obsidian blade in a sheath next to her hip. The two sisters exchange a brief second of eye contact. Celestia feels a new wave of sadness from the red, puffy, and tear-soaked look of her sister's features before they both glaze upon the grave. After several seconds of silence, Celestia spoke softly.

"He always loved this tree. I remember he took us here after our studies to meditate. He felt the calm rustling of the cheery leaves was good for focus,"

"...Indeed..." Luna's horse voice replied.

"That's the blade he gifted you after our graduation, correct?" Luna gives her a shallow nod. "He gave me a spot of ink and a feather. It was another lesson that you figured out before me. What was that proverb he said when he gifted it?"

"A blade is but an instrument to defend our ideals, yet a parchment is real power. A lesson in the ruling. To remind us to be prepared to fight for our homes and be mindful of the laws we govern. I remember it well. But, are these memories mine?"

"Of course they are--"

Luna's magic shoots outward as she flares her wings. Her eyes fade into a bright white as a whirlwind surrounds the two sisters. "DO NOT LIE TO ME! THOU USED THE ELEMENTS TO BANISH THINE MONSTER! THOU SENT A FOAL! BARELY OUT OF DIAPERS! TO DOETH WHAT THOU WAS TOO COWARDLY TO DO THINESELF! HOW LONG DID THOU PLOT WITH THINE LACKEY UPON MINE RETURN? AM I THE SISTER THOU WANTED? ARE MY THOUGHTS MINE ALONE OR WHAT YOU DEEM SATISFACTORY? WELL? HAVE YOU NOTHING TO SAY!?!"

"..." When Celestia remained silent, Luna unsheathed Starswirl's blade and pointed it at Celesta. Celestia's eyes shift from Luna's angry face to the edge. "...Why did you take this with you?"

"If I am a walking fallacy - a puppet by your design - I chose to make the only actual choice I have!"

"No, I do not believe that. If you genuinely desired an end such as that, you wouldn't have waited for me,"

"Perhaps another command set in place for your golem to make yourself look better. All hail Princess Celestia, the kind and sympathetic ruler of Equestria!"

Luna saw the hurt flash in Celestia's eyes before she grew more determined. "I will not deny you the choice between life and death. Just know I do not intend to let you go alone. I will shred myself from this mortal coil!"

"Why would you do such a thing?"

Celestia takes the sword in her magical grasp and sets it to the side before pulling Luna into a hug. "Because a thousand years without you was torturous with the slim hope for your return. I could not do so again if it were permanent! You are no puppet. You are my sister!"

Luna returned the hug as the two sisters cried into their embrace. "Perhaps this was the humans' plan all along. Divide us with a careful narrative and cherry-picked events,"

"You know such a thing is not feasible with that artifact. But, even more important is that I know Jason Wright,"

"How?" Celestia's horn glows as she shares what happened after Luna's departure. The memory of Celestia and Jason. The magic that dispelled from Celestia. And the reveal of his horrific scarring. "No, that cannot be. Ponies of this day and age would never be this cruel. And what of that magic that left you? What is its origin?"

"I wish I could tell you. All I can say is that some creature out there may be manipulating Jason's pain and our perceptions,"

"If nopony comes to mind, what shall we do?"

Celestia turns her gaze back to Starswirl's graze as she responds. "I don't know..."

[Canterlot Judicial Hall - Second Day of The Trial.]

The courtroom was a lot more subdued as everyone filed inside. No one made a sound as Jason and Chrysalis took their spot. However, the whispers and murmurs fell upon the returning Princesses. The two made their way to the bench. Luna stood in front of the Gjallarhorn as she touched it. There was a brief glow as Luna made a silent request. When the light ended, the Princess of the night looked a little more relieved. However, the real shock came as Celestia joined the elements on the defense's bench. Celestia ignores the whispering and glances over to Jason. Chrysalis smiled, whereas Jason didn't even look in her direction. Noticing the awkwardness of the room, Queen Novo spoke.

"Court has reconviened. Princess Luna. I take it you wish to rejoin as an acting Judge? Equestria still needs a representative,"

"Yes, I have gotten my personal affairs in order—no need to regale the previous proceedings. I have been informed already," Luna replies, taking back her seat. "Now, as I've come to understand, you claim that you received those grievous wounds. Can you explain how this occurred?"

Jason closes his eyes before casting a sideway glance at the elements. "My people have a saying: Never meet your heroes. We get so caught up in their ideals, platitudes, and moral grandstanding that we forget a crucial fact,"

"Which is what exactly?"

"That the person behind the heroes is not who you imagine. If there is one crime I am guilty of, it's forcing my expectation on others, thinking it to be reality. I brought it into their hype. I believed their lies!" Jason lets out another bitter chuckle. "Looking back, I can't believe how naive I was..."

"I don't think ponies that acted differently from your impression warrant hatred of all of them. Neither does the actions of a few individuals," Twilight said.

"Haha, the-the actions of a few? Spare me. Xenophobia thrives in your culture,"

"I can confidently speak for anypony here--"

"There. You just said it. Anypony. Nopony. Everypony. How can you claim different when even your speech patterns are exclusive? Are any of the judge's ponies? What about the two dragons here right now?"

"Humans have a point. But, Yaks say every yak when we around other yaks," Prince Rutherford said.

"The same goes for Griffin and hippogriffs," Grandpa Gruff said.

"And Dragons," Ember added. "Don't humans do the same?"

"Everyone. Everybody. Nobody. Anybody. No one. Anyone. People. I guess humans prefer more inclusivity in our speech," Jason said, earning a frown from the judges.

"Even so, as you just heard from several different creatures, admit to similar speech patterns. But it all stems from varying cultural differences, not xenophobia!" Twilight stated smugly.

"Can you say the same for Zecora?"

All the smugness turned to confusion as she responded. "Zecora?"

Jason pulls up one of the papers. "Isn't it true that a zebra named Zecora is a resident of Ponyville?"

"Yes, what does she have to do with anything?"

"She's here today as a witness," Jason smiles. As if on cue, the doors open as Zecora walks down the aisle. At first, the elements were glad to see their long-time friend before said friend shot a glare. Zecora stood in the middle of the room as Jason approached with the Gjallarhorn. "Can you please state your name and profession for the court?"

"My name is Zecora. This is true; I pour and mix potions for you," Zecora responds.

"When did you move to Equestria?"

"It was many moons ago—a great distance to travel for those in the know. A new beginning I seek, to carve my path, but I discovered most citizens to be rather daft," Zecora touches the horn, and memory is displayed. It showed her leaving the lands of Zebrica and entering Equestria. She passed by many villages, but the reception was the same. The ponies cast wary glances at Zecora's cloaked figure. Even in cases where she reveals her face, she is regarded with suspicion and unease. It continued until she entered Ponyville. "Ponyville is where I finally settled. But, I discovered the ponies there were easily nettled. Screams and despair followed me like a ghost. Ponyville was not a gracious host. Every time I sought supplies, the shops were closed off from my curious eyes,"

The memory continued to show the resident of Ponyville locking their doors and shunning Zecora, who did nothing except paw at the ground. Jason couldn't resist shaking his head at the reaction. Especially at Pinkie Pie, as the memory showed her screaming evil enchantress before running off. "Look at the reaction of the so-called friendship capital of Equestria. Even from one of its national heroes. Zecora, when did you meet Twilight and her friends?"

"The day was the tenth of December. It's hard not to remember. These pony folk came to the forest with paranoia and fear, as if I would strike at one they hold dear," Another memory played with the elements confronting Zecora in the Everfree forest with Applebloom.

"Applebloom! You get back here right now!" Appleack said in the memory.

"Beware. Beware, you pony folk, Those leaves of blue are not a joke!" Zecora warned.

Everyone saw Applejack scoop up her sister while disregarding Zecoras' warning about the poison joke. "You-You keep your creepy mumbo jumbo to yourself, Ya hear!"

The rest of the elements said words supporting Applejack as Zecora warns them again as the memory concludes. "Beware, beware!"

"You know, when someone tries to warn others, they do it for your benefit. Instead, we see Zecora receive scorn and disparagement," Jason said.

More murmurs erupt at what Zecora showed, causing Applejack to shield herself with her hat as she was the antagonist. The elements received a harsh glare from Judge Zekia. Twilight quickly got up and moved to Zecora. "Hold on. That's only when we first met. I will admit that the first impression went poorly, but things got better. Watch!"

The horn glows again as Twilight and Spike walk into Ponyville. The two notice something amiss with the empty streets until Pinkie calls them over to Sugarcube corner. From there, Twilight's memory played out as Jason remembers the episode, with Twilight being skeptical of her friend's overreaction to Zecora. Jason smiles inwardly as he knows Twilight would go for full context to support her cast, not that she could lie. It worked out as he hoped it would, as the judges frowned at the words of each element. Looking over to the defendants made Jason smile wider. Rarity bit her lip nervously at her part in insulting Zecoras' stripes and her overly dramatic fainting from the cultural differences. Applejack buries her face deeper into her hat. Her words made her appear ignorant and insensitive. Fluttershy shies away during her portions of the memory as she is less intuitive than Applejack. Rainbow groans as she drags a hoof down her face at the unflattering display of herself. And Pinkie closed her eyes and covered her ears when her song played.

"And that wicked enchantress Zecora lives there doing her evil stuff! She's so evil I wrote a song about it!"

"Here we go!" Rainbow said with a roll of her eyes.

"She's an evil enchantress. She does evil dances. When you look into her eyes, she puts you in trances. Then what would she do? She mixes up an evil brew. Then she'll gobble you up in a big tasty stew. So, watch out!"

"That is quite enough! Your memories display nothing but your friends messing up!" Zekia scorns. "And you!" The zebra judge points at Rarity. "The stripe on our hide is a mark of pride! How can one so fair speak ill and foul air?"

"I-I, well-- It was a mistake! I didn't--"

"And you!" Zekia thrusts his hoof at Pinkie pie, who winces as if she was hit. "Your song spreads lies and distrust. An apology is an absolute must!"

Pinkie gave another shudder, prompting Rainbow Dash to speak up. "Hey! Back off. Pinkie was being herself. We made up with Zecora afterward," The chromatic soon regrets this as the zebra judge continues to glare at her.

"It is plain to see that you three disgust me!" Zekia said, pointing at Rainbow, Applejack, and Fluttershy.

Twilight winces as she looks to the courtroom. Everyone shot her friends disapproving looks. It was true. Her memories of those events did nothing but cast doubt on her friends. Sensing this, Chrysalis decides to sit the pot. "Good job, Princess. So far, you've managed to prove your friends are everything we said, being that they are ignorant specist. Quick to judge and insensitive. All the while casting yourself in a favorable light. Are you looking to cast them aside for a lighter sentence?"

"N-No! The court must understand everything that led to one of the most important lessons I learned. The lesson I planned to teach at my school and share with every creature!" Twilight said.

Twilight touches the horn again and displays the effect of the poison joke, as Zecora warned. The memory continues as the afflicted ponies traverse the Everfree and burst into Zecora's home while breaking items from her homeland. It was only when Applebloom returned with the ingredient for a cure that everything settled down. After Zecora explains the misunderstanding, Twilight and the others return to Ponyville to clear the air about her. The memory ends with everyone sharing a laugh in the spa. Twilight then produces a paper and reads it aloud.

"After that day, I wrote this to Princess Celestia. Dear Princess Celestia, my friends and I learned a vital lesson this week. Never judge a book by its cover. Someone may look unusual, funny, or scary. But you have to look past that to learn who they are inside. Real friends don't care about covers. It's the contents of a pony that count. And a good friend - like a good book - will last forever. Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle,"

There was a round of applause as Celestia, Luna, and Cadance smiled at the lesson. Zekia's scowl softens somewhat as the judges all nod in approval. That is until Chrysalis begins coughing and hacking up a lung. "Oh, I am sorry. I was choking on all the dribble you were spouting. How can you make a creature that feeds on love itself sick to its stomach at the display?"

"Maybe because you don't truly understand love despite needing it!" Cadance spat.

"Ignore her, Cadance. She's probably upset that her latest scheme to hurt us is failing," Twilight said, turning to Zecora. "It's alright, Zecora. I know these two brought you into this as a pawn in their game, but it doesn't hurt our Friendship,"

Twilight places a hoof on the zebra's shoulder. But, to the young alicorn's shock, Zecora bats it away. "As always, Twilight, the obvious answer escapes your sight. The lesson you learned that day is a good one indeed. Unfortunately, it was one you did not heed,"

"What are you talking about?"

Zecora narrows her eyes as she touches the Gjallarhorn again. The memory was one of her entering Ponyville for one of her visits. As she walked the road, she heard a commotion. Moving to investigate, she gasps at the sight of Jason Wright running through the market. His appearance was far more worn than he is in the present. She could see a mob of ponies chasing him down while throwing various items at him. The zebra gasps again as one of the ponies scores a hit with a rock, causing Jason to trip and tumble. Horror itched itself on Zecora's features as she got closer and listened to what the mob was saying.

"You bucking freak!"

"We told you we don't want a monster like you here!"

"Crawl back to the Everfree!"

"What were you doing behind my store!?"

Every cruel word had a rock accompanying it as the mob peppered Jason with them. The human tried to shield himself as best as he could. "Please, s-stop. I was just hungry! That's why I was going into the trash! I didn't mean--"

"Oh? Were you hungry? More like you were stealing from me. Or maybe looking to hurt my foals!" Twilight and the others gasp at the sight of Mr. Cake leading the mob. "But don't worry. We've got something for you to eat..." The mob of ponies gathered several trashcans and emptied their contents. Mr. Cake grabbed a hooful of trash, as did the others. "Here! It's on the house!" The pelting resumed as Jason entered the fetal position. Several bits of old and spoiled food stained his clothes, while more rocks were thrown. It lasted several seconds before Jason managed to scramble to his feet and run off into the forest. The ponies even cheered at their accomplishment as the mob dispersed.

Zecora's eyes widen further as she sees Twilight, Rarity, Applejack, and Fluttershy walk right by the event as if nothing happened. Zecora quickly rushes to them and speaks in a panic. "Twilight! Has your sight gone bad? The citizens of Ponyvile have gone mad!"

"Hmm? What do you mean?" Twilight asks.

"A creature I have never seen just suffered something most obscene. Rocks and perishables were thrown freely. The creature ran in terror. You must believe me!"

"Oh, don't worry yourself about it, Zecora. There's been an infestation as of late," Twilight said.

"Thanks for the info, Z. I'll be sure to have Wynona on guard duty in case the varmint comes around the farm," Applejack said.

"We should have the guard stationed around town—anything to spare us from its unsightly presence," Rarity stated while throwing her nose in the air.

"I'd wish it would just go away," Fluttershy said with a shudder.

Zecora could only mimic a goldfish at the acidic words of her long-time companions. "Are you alright, Zecora? The girls and I were heading to the spa. Do you want to join us?"

"No, no! I must go!"

The memory ends with Zecora fleeing from the elements and Ponyville. Once again, the courtroom fell silent. The three princesses' mouth's nearly hit the floor. The remaining defendants were rendered speechless. Meanwhile, Twilight took things the worse. She backed away while her pupils shrank. Her gaze shifted from the stone face of Jason Wright to the scowling visage of Zecora. She tried to speak, but her voice failed her. It was as if the memory version of herself stole her voice away.

"..No! That was-- I don't. Zecora, you believe that I would never..." Twilight squeak. Any explanation for what they saw eluded her.

Zecora merely shakes her head as she turns away from Twilight and faces Jaason. "If that is all you will have me say, I wish you a good day..."

Jason nods as Zecora leaves the courtroom. Jason looked down at the stunned Twilight as he spoke. "That happened a week after our first meeting. The garage and rocks were the tamest part of my Ponyville experience. It gets so much better later on,"

"Y-You must've done something. Ponies wouldn't just do those things,"

"Oh, yeah, I did something. I knocked on your castle doors,"

"What? That can't be all!"

"But that is all," Jason touches the Gjallarhorn again. "You weren't the worst, Twilight. But you were the first. Everyone else followed your lead. Your crimes would be reckless endangerment. The counts are Ponyville's population,"

Another memory displays Jason arriving in Ponyville. Stepping off the train, Jason shields his eyes from the sun before taking Ponyville and all its splendor. His smile was wide and broad as he watched the ponies go about their daily routines. Jason spotted the castle of Friendship in the distance. He walked at a brisk pace, not noticing ponies starting to take notice of him. The resident sat back and watched as Jason made it to the castle doors and knocked. Moments later, Twilight Sparkle answers the door. Twilight's eyes widen as she looks Jason over before she frowns. Jason, on the hand, was starstruck at meeting the Princess of Friendship in the flesh.

"Wow. It's you. Um, hello, I'm Jason Wright. And--"

Twilight's hoof shoots up sharply, prompting Jason to look down in confusion. "Sorry, I am not in the mood to deal with any more humans. Goodbye!"

The castle doors slam in Jason's face as he flinches away. Turning around, Jason sits on the steps, scratching his head in confusion. "I guess she's busy right now..." At this time, Jason notices all of Ponyville staring at him. For a second, he could see all the colorful rainbows shift into an ominous shadow. Ignoring this, Jason gets back up and tries to approach the citizens instead. "Excuse me, do you know where I can find a motel?" His question went ignored. Jason tries again with another group. "Do you know where I can stay for the night?" Ponies started giving Jason a wide birth. He saw mothers usher their foals away. There was even a nasty look shot at him. Soon, Jason was the only one standing in front of the castle with a perplexed look. "Huh?" The memory soon fades with Jason walking away from the castle.

"And that's on my wonderful journey started,"

"Twilight...?" Spike squeaked out, unable to process what he's seen and heard. Twilight looks at Spike with shock and a little fear.

"S-Spike. T-That wasn't me! I would never--" The Gjallarhorn glows briefly as Twilight stumbles. And, much like with Celestia, a burst of magic leaves Twilight's body. The young alicorn looks at Jason with new clarity before the shock sets, and she back peddles. The action does not go unnoticed by the court. "I-Its you...!"

Jason smiles at Twilight as he spokes. "So, are you ready to deal with me now?"

"H-Hold on a second. I understand that was bad and flat-out rude. But those ponies wouldn't resort to what Zecora showed us just because Twilight wasn't feeling friendly," Starlight said cautiously.

Jason looks her way with a slight scowl. "If the Princess of Friendship doesn't want to be friends with you, why should anyone else? I bet you are so proud of your little minions. They probably couldn't shit without your say-so!" Jason spat, his anger slipping out. All the ponies recoiled at the foul language.

"Jason, why didn't you try and contact me?" Celestia asks pitifully.

"Why didn't you ever come to visit?" Jason counters, causing Celestia to flinch as the attention is back on her. "To answer your question, though, I didn't have access to any quills, parchment, or even the dragon voicemail over there," Jason points to Spike, earning an arch brow from Ember. "I slept on a bench on my first night there. No one would hire me while they were too busy running away and shunning me. So, that meant no bits to travel. I was pretty much a bum by the end of that first week,"

"What did you mean by dragon voice mail?" Ember asks. "What's voice mail? What does it have to do with the hatchling?"

"Ah. Voice mail is a device in my homeland. It saves messages from other people that you can return at your convenience. You see, I wasn't the only one Twilight brushed off. Her so-called number assistant suffers from it too,"

"No way!" Spike said, placing himself between Twilight and Jason. "Twilight's never done anything wrong to me!"

"Is that right? Funny, I was going to call you as another witness. Well, let's go back to Zecora for a second. We saw that Twilight had the same book for the cure in her library. We saw Twilight admit that she did not look into the book because it was too weird. Now, as her assistant, did you find that book?"

"Y-Yes,"

"And what did she do?" Jason subtly points to the Gjallarorn to make sure Spike understands his position.

"She said that the book was a bunch of hooey..."

"Completely dismissing your input,"

"That doesn't make Twilight bad. Everypony can be thoughtless sometimes!"

"Sometimes? What about using you as her message and voicemail? Isn't it true that you send letters between Princess Celestia and Twilight through dragon fire?"

"Yes, so what?"

"Wait! What? How is that accomplished? Show me!" Ember said, landing in front of Spike. Spike nervously nods as he touches the horn next. Here, many memories of him sending letters through dragon fire. "Enchanted flames. It's real?"

"Um, what?" Spike asks in confusion.

"Spike. Enchanted flames are the rarest skill a dragon can have. It's a bloodline trait to the arcane dragons. They were the only dragons able to use magic as the ponies did. Father said the last of the dragons died out. Why haven't you told me?"

"Isn't that obvious? It's a security risk. Spike has a direct line to Equestrian royalty. Who wouldn't want such a valuable asset? That's another hallmark of Celestia's negligence and Twilight's recklessness. Using and endangering a child's life to political rivals," Jason said.

"You're twisting things!" Spike called out. "I never told her because it feels like bragging. It was never a big secret anyway. I did it all the time in front of ponies. It's never put me in any danger!"

"So, you can confidently say there have never been any drawbacks to writing and receiving a message?"

"W-Well, there was this one time when Discord escaped, and Celestia kept sending all Twilight's lessons to help her..."

"And how did that feel? Since it's coming out of your stomach, wouldn't that be a choking hazard?"

Spike was looking more and more nervous. "I couldn't move or keep food in my stomach for a few days," Spike shakes his head as he glares at Jason. "No, it was the only way to help after Twilight got corrupted by Discord!"

"The hero of the nation got corrupted? If that can happen, how can anypony entrust their safety to her?" Chrysalis stated.

"Urgh! No, watch!" Spike touches the horn, and the events of return to harmony play out. From Spike's perspective, all the element bearers with their colors faded act as the opposite of themselves. Ember let out a snort of disapproval as a sleeping Spike had water dumped on him. The fight over the elements guidebook. How Spike was trampled over as the group left the library, and how the elements of harmony failed to work because the girls were too corrupted and Spike wasn't Rainbow Dash. Spike saw that the judges were unmoved, but the scene quickly shifted as the letters Spike heaved inspired Twilight to try and save her friendships. Thus, one by one, Twilight uncorrupt her friends and confront Discord, and they defeat him and save Equestria. The memory moves to a ceremony in the throne room with Celestia presiding.

"We are gathered here today to honor once again the heroism of these six friends who stood up to the villain Discord. And saved Equestria from eternal chaos!" The memory ends with Celestia immortalizing the element bearer's accomplishment on a stained glass window.

"See? If it weren't for those letters, Discord would've won!"

"But, what did you prove? Do the ends justify the means? All I saw in that memory was that Twilight forgot her important lessons again!" Jason said.

"Ah, no! She--"

"--She was quick to give up on her precious friendships, which caused her corruption in the first place. Discord didn't graft a new personality on any of the defendants. These were aspects of their character that were already inside each of them. He just brought it to the forefront. Twilight looked at her friends at their worst and decided to give up and leave Ponyville. What kind of leader is that?! One that forgets the lessons she preaches and goes back to being apathetic towards others!?"

Spikes starts to back away as Jason steps forward. "No! It isn't like that!"

"Except Twilight doesn't need the spirit of disharmony to make her indifferent, does she? Wasn't there a time when she mistreated you?"

Spike almost said no until a memory flashed, and he winced. "Please, don't make me say it. They didn't mean it,"

"They didn't mean what, Spike?" Ember asks.

Spike looks between Jason and Ember with tears threatening to spill. "I-It was during winter wrap-up when I fell asleep on a patch of ice. Twilight told me after it melted, I fell into the freezing water. The girls were laughing when I caught a cold..."

Spike looks down in shame as Celestia and Luna gasp. Ember's features morph into a full scowl as she faces the defendants. "You all laughed at him?! Don't you know we dragons a cold-blooded?! He could've frozen to death!" None of the elements could offer any rebuttal, as even Celestia gazes at them in disbelief.

"I find it funny that the supposed studious mare missed the most basic facts about dragons, like how cold weather makes them sleepy. Yet, she still took you outside, didn't she?" Spike could only whimper at Jason's questioning. "Are you even getting a proper diet? You're a dragon. That makes you a carnivore. It must be hard getting any protein without any meat from herbivores,'

"I-I eat plenty of gems,"

"A gem-based diet isn't good enough, Spike. It's like candy to dragons, but it helps sharpen our fangs. Their reflective surfaces prevent lava and fire from damaging our stomach lining. We need protein from the meat we get from hunting game in the Everfree or fish," Ember informs.

"So, who's to blame for this error in judgment? The mentor or the student and caretaker?" Jason gestures to Celestia and Twilight.

"Alright, that's it!" Twilight suddenly shouted. She trots up and pulls Spike behind her. "You can say all you want and twist facts to make me look irresponsible, but I won't allow you to bully Spike!"

"Tsk. You've been doing that his whole life,"

"And what about you, human? You're trying to make yourself out as the victim here. But I remember precisely what spawned my reaction towards you that day—members of this courtroom. Don't let what you've seen so far fool you. This creature is not a wounded animal but a far worse predator than any of the ones gathered here. Look at this!"

Twilight touches the Gjallarhorn again, and another memory plays. This time, it showed Twilight stumbling out of a statue in front of a school building. Jason instantly knew what he was seeing. It was the Equestria girls' universe. The gallery and judge were put off by the uncanny resemblance to Jason's species. "What you see is a mirror world where I suspect you came from, Jason. This place is a high school for teenage humans. I say mirror world because, in this realm, they are Equestrian counterparts here," Twilight noticed the confused expressions of everyone in the court. "Doppelgangers?" Still, everyone was confused. "Um, twins? This world had twin look-a-likes of us," Finally understanding, everyone nods. "Now, I entered this world to regain the lost element of magic from a thief. I blended in with the teens, and I even met the human version of my Equestrian friends,"

The memory confirms this as Twilight meets up with the human element bearers in a launch room. "But, this is where the real horror started!" Jason had to admit that he didn't know what Twilight was trying to show. All the memory was showing was a typical lunch day. "See? Look at the food they are eating! Bacon! Pork chops. Ham sandwiches. Steaks! These human versions of us were butchering sapient creatures! They're cannibals!!!" The courtroom occupants let out several gasps of horror. Jason covered his face with his hands while Chrysalis looked worried for the first time. Twilight smiles triumphantly as she continues. "After I discovered this, I quickly left the room before I could eat anything. From there, I took back the Element of Magic and went through the portal. Is it any wonder why you got such a reception? When you're kind butchers innocents so freely? Why else is there a portal between our worlds that opens every few moon cycles? Ponies and humans are not meant to coexist!"

"That is a rather severe revelation!" Queen Novo said.

"A scary one at that," King Shifting Sands said.

"Even our griffins don't eat anything that can talk back," Grandpa Gruff said.

"Nor dragons," Ebmer said, eyeing Jason warily.

The judge agreed as Twilight smiled at the other defendants. "Ha! What do you get to say to that?" However, Twilight's smile faded when Jason began laughing. A deep belly laugh left him doubled over as he wides away tears. "What's wrong? Do you realize your plot failed and lost composture?"

"Oh, wow. I needed that. I can't believe that's what you thought this whole time. Whoo!"

"Stop with the bravado. It's over! every creature here knows you are a monster now!" Rainbow said.

"Then humor the big bad monster for a little bit. What's the acceptable meat of non-sapient creatures the predators of this world can eat?"

"That would be fish. While most animals retain a level of sentience and intelligence - to the point where they can process and express pain - fish do not," Luna educates.

"Okay, that's how it is for all animals in my world," Jason said.

All the wind from Twilight's sails left her. "That's impossible! You came from that mirror world. That's the only realm with humans in it!"

Jason rolled his eyes and touched the Gjallarhorn as he spoke. "I did not come from the world that you visited, Twilight. The humans of my world are not counterparts or twins to your world. I came from a different Earth entirely. There, we are the only creatures capable of expressing intelligence and wisdom,"

Another round of gasps went off as the Gjallarhorn did not react. Therefore, Jason was not lying, causing Twilight to stammer. "But, but, but--"

"I bet you thought you had something there, didn't you? It's a shame you didn't stick around in that mirror world. You might've learned that humans are omnivores. That means we can eat meat and plants, as long as it's not hay. See?" Jason opens his mouth, allowing Ember to look at his teeth.

"He has fangs and molars in the mouth," Ember said with an undercurrent of relief.

"There was something else that you said too. That humans and ponies cannot coexist?"

"..." Twilight was less sure of her position now and stayed quiet.

"Well, luckily, I have another witness to disprove that statement..." Jason gestures to the double doors again as they open. Another pony came walking, though. She was a mare with bright amber fur and a two-toned mane of red and yellow. Celestia's eyes shot wide as she stared at the estranged mare's stern features. "Witness, please state your name and occupation for the court,"

"My name is Sunset Shimmer. I was formerly Princess Celestia's first protege,"

The Shimmer in the Sunset

Author's Note

Sorry, this is late. I had a rough week. The next chapter should finish Twilight's part.

The Shimmer in the Sunset

[Canterlot Judicial Hall.]

More surprised whispers of the new witness's identity went off. Candance stares at Sunset with wide eyes. She remembers the unicorn as Celestia's newly adopted niece when she moved into the castle. Besides being older, Sunset remains the same as when they were fillies. However, Cadance can see that an entitled, self-absorbed filly was not present in the mare. Celestia could see this as well. Sunset stood tall and resolute in her position to Jason's cause. The Sunset of old wouldn't have associated with a creature such as Jason Wright if he couldn't help her toward her destiny.

'Was that it?' Celestia thought. 'Could Sunset still have those same ambitions and find a way to utilize Jason? No. The Gjallarhorn would not allow such manipulation. So, then why? Has she changed?'

The youngest alicorn could not help but openly scowl at the unicorn. This was the mare that stole the element of magic. The mare that forced her to experience the traumatic horrors of the mirror human realm. The mare that's here to prove her wrong and discredit her further. "Sunset Shimmer!"

"Princess," Sunset said in the same tone as when they first met.

"I should have known you'd be in on this scheme. How dare you come back here after what you did!"

"What scheme? I came here to see that justice is done. What's the matter, Princess? Is your little bubble of reality finally bursting?" Sunset smirks as Twilight grows more irritated.

Twilight gritted her teeth before she smirked. "You're the one in for a rude awakening. Guards! Arrest this mare! She is wanted for the grand theft of a national artifact!"

The guards moved to Sunset, who remained smiling until Princess Luna raised her hoof. "Belay that order. Young Twilight. While this tribunal is in session and you are one of the defendants, your royal status and authority are suspended. You cannot issue any arrest, especially if they are a part of the trial,"

Twilight gawks at Princess Luna as Sunset giggles. "Ah, was that your latest plan to have me removed as a witness? Are you afraid of what I might say?'

"How can we trust your credibility when you abandoned your position as Princess Celestia's protege and stole the Element of Magic?"

Sunset merely scoffs at this. "I left my position as Celestia's student for a personal reason. I do admit to stealing the crown. However, only Celestia can prosecute me for that crime, as she is the only Princess with senior authority. And I will gladly surrender myself for her judgment afterward,"

Princess Celestia arches a brow at this. "Why would you do this if you know the potential consequences?"

"Because I've come to regret my stealing the element and how I acted as your student. But I don't regret leaving because I've had some amazing people during my time in the mirror world. People that I am proud to call my friends," Sunset shot a slight glare at Twilight and the rest of the element bearers. "People that would be disgusted and disturbed by the action of their counterparts!"

"So, what made your time in the human world different from the Princess's?" Queen Novo asks.

Sunset takes a deep breath and sighs. "Before I get to that, let me start at the beginning. When I was Celestia's student, she told me of my potential to become an alicorn. I was going to be her successor when she finally retired. Because of this destiny, I became so full of myself. I lorded my status over all my peers. It did not help that I was top of my class the same way I bet you were, Twilight," Twilight was genuinely surprised by this information. "And, for anyone that threatened my future, I made sure to bully them into submission," Sunset cast an apologetic glance toward Cadance. "I was exceedingly awful towards Princess Cadance. She became an alicorn before me. And I was not too fond of that. That sparked the falling out I had with Celestia. She came to my room about my attitude and how it was unbecoming of a future Princess. She urged me to try and make friends. I scolded her about her decision to make a former pegasus an alicorn when I was more magically gifted. I called her a hypocrite for forcing me to make friends while she didn't have any.

I rushed off to my room, angry at the Princess's betrayal. I thought that if I proved myself, she would see I was the only one worthy of being by her side. I snuck into the forbidden wing of the castle and to the mirror. Celestia told me that only high-level unicorns could interact with it, but none could define the mirror's purpose. But I did as I discovered it was a portal to another world. You can call it hubris on my part, but I knew my destiny lay beyond that mirror. I knew it was the key to becoming an alicorn. And I was able to activate it just in time for the Princess to come in and see my work. Only, it didn't happen how I wanted. Instead of praise, I was scolded for disobeying her. I got mad and demanded she makes me an alicorn. But, when the Princess refused, I knew my destiny lay elsewhere. So, I went through the portal,"

"Hmph! How can you try and besmirch Princess Celestia when you didn't try and follow her teachings? You gave up!" Twilight said. "Then, you came back and put all of Equestria in jeopardy by stealing the element of Magic!"

"Right back at you, Twilight. You didn't try and understand the humans. You saw one thing you assumed was bad and ran away with your tail between your legs," Sunset flips her mane. "I can admit my flaws now because of those same humans you dismissed. It wasn't always like that because I wanted to utilize the crown's magic to give me an advantage. The mirror world had no magic until Equestrian magic crossed over,"

"My crown was never meant to even be in that world!"

"So, it's fine when you steal something, but not the other way around?"

"You do seem to have a nasty habit of justifying theft," Queen Novo said with a slight glare, causing Twilight to flinch.

"If somepony steals something from you, and you get it back, are you guilty of theft of your property?!" Twilight shot back.

"Possession is nine-tenths of the law~," Chrysalis teased, earning a scowl from Twilight.

"I will give you this point, Princess Twilight. But I was referring to the theft you committed against me and my kingdom!" Queen Novo said, causing Twilight to gulp.

"E-even still, you've forgiven me for that. You can't drop charges and then reopen them just because you changed your mind!" Queen Novo nods at this, but Twilight could tell the issue isn't concluded yet. "And while we're on the topic of theft, if you had not stolen the crown, I would've never gained such a negative view of humans in the first place!"

"Are you seriously telling me that you would not have eventually found that mirror yourself and gone exploring? I may have stolen the crown, but you still freaked out on the other side,"

"Don't pretend you were not shocked at what you saw too!"

"Hmph, maybe I am made of sterner stuff than you. I guess that's the problem when you go with second best,"

Jason made a note to revisit the hippogriffs point. But he smiles at how red in the face Twilight is at Sunset's comment. "I think we're getting a little off-topic. Sunset, how did things go after the crown was back in Equestria? What changed for you? And how did you learn Princess Celestia's lessons without her influence?"

"Well, I won by default after the school faculty discovered the crown was stolen. But, It wasn't the crown I needed to further my plans. And, I let them know..." Subset lets out another sigh as she touches the Gjallarhorn.

The memory showed Sunset on the stage of the auditorium. Principal Celestia was presenting the new crown for the fall formal. However, Sunset knocks it away. "Get that cheap imitation away from me! Do you think this stupid knockoff will satisfy me? Do you know how long I was planning this? My crowning achievement is ruined. My destiny is denied because you had lousy security. You're fakes! All of you fakes!!!" The memory ends with Sunset breaking a replica of Twilight's crown with a stomp.

"And that's how I won the fall formal. It is precisely how it looks and sounds; me throwing a tantrum. And, as it turns out, humans don't like some brat insulting them any more than we do. No one would talk to me after that. Sure, the teachers did. But that was their job. The students, not so much. They came up with a name for me; Fallen Diva. And from there, no one wanted anything to do with me. I tried to convince myself that I didn't need any of them. But, after a few months of being a pariah in the school, it wears you down. Before I knew it, I was trying to reach out and talk to people. But no one would give someone that treats others like an afterthought a chance. That is until we got some new transfers from Crystal Prep,"

A new memory starts with Sunset sitting alone in front of the statue with a sullen expression. She stares intently at the journal in her hand. A bark caught her attention, and she looked down to see a purple and green familiar puppy looking back at her. The next thing she knew, the dog grabbed the book and ran off. Sunset gives chase all around the front yard until she bumps into someone. Sunset hears a groan and looks up. The girl in front of her was vaguely familiar. But she did not know from where. She had a maroon school vest and a dark purple skirt. She adjusted her glasses as the dog danced happily around her. Twilight instantly recognizes the new arrival, but she is stunned, much like the other court members.

"Ow,"

"Yeah, ow,"

The girl looks up and sees Sunset on the ground with her. She sees her dog run around the two of them with the book still in his maw. "Spike? Where did you get that book? Oh, I'm sorry. Did he bother you? Please don't report him. I know pets are not allowed on school grounds, but I'm not comfortable leaving him alone at him,"

"You're new here?"

"Yeah, I just transferred from Crystal Prep. I was going over all my supplies in order when Spike leaped out. He's a good dog. He normally doesn't take things..."

Twilight hands Sunset back her book. "It's okay. I wasn't doing anything with it, and it's not that important. What's your name?"

"I'm Twilight Sparkle, and this is Spike,"

"I'm Sunset Shimmer...?" Sunset paused, waiting for Twilight to lash out at her, but it never came.

"Could you show me the way to the student directory? I'm a little lost,"

Sunset appeared conflicted, but she eventually agreed and escorted her new classmate. The two started talking and discovered they had a lot in common: they both excelled academically. And both of them were not the best social butterflies. Although, Sunset could tell her status was vastly different from hers. Sunset felt the tension ebb away the more she spoke with Twilight. It was nice being able to talk to someone. Twilight told her about her family. The day she adopted Spike. And that she transferred for a new start. Sunset could relate. As the two walked the hallway, Sunset felt the glares of the other students. Sunset grew more concerned with each step as some nasty stares fell on Twilight by proxy. Twilight began to notice as well. The closer the two got to their destination, the louder the whisper got. The moment they reached the directory, Sunset saw a group of students approaching them. All of them were wearing frowns directed at the pony-turned-human. Sunset knew what was coming. Those students were about to reveal her sins to Twilight. She would be denied her first friend before she even got the chance. Rather than face that humiliation, Sunset ran in the other direction.

"If you're trying to prove that humans are every bit as mean and spiteful as I believed, you're succeeding," Twilight said. There were a few ponies that shared those sentiments. Sunset, however, scoffs at the remark.

"I'm not showing you this to enforce your lopsided beliefs on humans. The worst thing any of them did was ignore me. I was anonymous to the students and faculty because of my actions. The point is to showcase treating others how you want to be treated. That little voice in your head that tells you at least ponies can do no wrong is nothing but misplaced pride. Every species have that duality of good and evil. Just look at how your counterpart reacted when she learned about my past," Sunset said as another memory played.

Sunset was back at the statue with her head buried in her knees. She is crying now. However, as before, a bark catches her attention. Sunset's tear-stained face glances at Spike, who looks back at her with concern. She gazes at Twilight, who gives her a sheepish wave. "Come to tell me off? Call me a terrible person and say you'll never see me again?"

"Why would I do that?"

"I'm sure they told me all about my past. I'm the big nasty Fallen Diva of Canterlot High, cursed never to have friends..."

"Well, the things the other students said didn't line up when we first met. You didn't seem mean to me. Besides, Spike seems to like you, and he's an excellent judge of character," In response, Spike jumps onto Sunset's lap and starts licking her face.

The two girls giggle as Sunset replies. "So, you'd be willing to be friends?"

"I don't see why not,"

"But everyone else probably won't like you as much..."

"No one in Crystal Prep liked me that much either. Besides that, I can tell you want to change. We can show them together," Twilight holds her hand with a big smile. "Friends?"

Sunset returns the smile and firmly shakes Twilight's hand. "The best!"

The memory ends with the two girls laughing as Spike happily runs around them. "Things began to change after that. My Friendship with that Twilight leads me to gain more. Even with the people I wronged, I started winning them over. I became friends with Fluttershy after Spike got sick during my free period, and Twilight wasn't available to take him. We hit it off when she learned I was keeping him a secret for Twilight and cared enough for Spike. She went told the rest of her friends about me. That leads to Applejack asking for help around her farm. Rarity is inviting us to donate clothes to the salvation army. And Rainbow asked for help with her sports team. By the end of that year, and through word of mouth, I made amends with everyone at the school,"

Twilight was less sure of herself now than when she was yesterday. The parallels and differences between her and her counterpart were clear. Where she would've been wary of Sunset's past, her double embraced her. Where she dismissed humans capable of holding Harmony's virtues, Sunset displayed to everyone in the human version of her friends. 'Did I make a mistake? Surely, I can turn this around,' Twilight thought. "Even so, our worlds were meant to be separated. There's no magic there, and bringing a new element could prove harmful to that environment!"

"Oh, now you care about humans? Where was this concern when the siren was banished to that world?"

"The sirens?" Celestia spoke up. "How can that be? Starswirl dealt with them himself,"

"Yes, he did. By sending a trio of magically enchanting dragon subspecies to a nonmagical plane of existence!"

"It begs the question of how often Equestria throw away their problem for someone else to deal with, doesn't Princess?" Jason asks Celestia. The Princess of the Sun looks down in shame.

"These Sirens? What were their names?" Ember asks with suspicion.

"Sonata Dusk, Aria Blaze, and Adagio Dazzle," Sunset answers.

Ember's eyes grew wide before a deep scowl formed. "Those were the names of the three missing Siren princesses. Queen Event Tide blamed my father for their disappearance. It sparked the Siren Wars!"

"I was not informed of this! Those three were terrorizing small villages along the mountain range. Ponies were left in a state of misery and psychotic behavior because of the influx of negative emotions. We did not know those three were of royalty," Celestia stated.

"I talked with them about why they were banished. Adagio had a nasty spat with her mother and took her friends to blow off some steam. She said they got hungry and happened upon that village. Adagio regrets going there because of what happened. I am not saying what they did was right, but throwing them into a different dimension entirely? Taking them away from their family? That was far from being any better," Sunset could only shake her head at this. "You always told me never to make excuses when you make a mistake. Yet, that's all I hear now. I wonder how many threats or problems could've been avoided if Equestrian Royalty had handled them better. Would Nightmare Moon have been a big issue? What about Discord's return? Why wouldn't you tell anyone about him until after he was freed? What about Chrysalis? Would she have nearly taken over Equestria if you had heeded Twilight's concerns about Cadance acting unusual? Shouldn't you have seen through her disguise?"

"I am right here, you know. Give me a lot more credit than that!" Chrysalis whined.

Sunset ignores the changeling queen and stares directly at Celestia. "Why did you wait to tell anyone about me until I stole the crown? Was it really out of sight, out of mind for you? Is everything an afterthought that you leave issues for others?"

Every word was like a stab at Celestia's heart. "I don't know what I can say without it sounding like an excuse..."

"You don't have to listen to this, Princess. You've done the best you can!" Twilight said.

"Tsk! You're still defending these poor choices. Well, of course, you would. You mirror them as much as you can!" Sunset scolded.

"You don't know me!"

"I know that for all your talk about the human world being a threat, you did not bother to decommission the mirror world, did you?" Twilight flinches at the truth of that statement. "You left it alone and exposed for anyone unfortunate enough to stumble upon. Unlike my Twilight, who was able to study the magic around the portal and create a barrier to stop anyone from falling inside,"

"How can the human Twilight put up a barrier?"

"When the Sirens showed up with their magic, their presence fundamentally changed that world. The magic started to build and spread. But, they were the catalyst. We discovered that the portal releases the magic of this world to that one in a more passive role. Thus, the nonmagical world was steadily becoming a true mirror of this one. The Sirens, however, accelerated the process with their magic. My friend's and mine magic results from that world seeking to balance out the negative imbalance. Haven't you wondered why you turn human when you go through the mirror? Humans are the mirror version of us, not some cosmic byproduct of another pony's meddling. If Jason were to pass through, he'd be a pony. My Twilight was the one to figure this all out. I couldn't keep her away from the statue for more than a few minutes that first month of research. It makes me wonder why you didn't do the same?"

"...You already know I left the same day I arrived!" Twilight said through gritted teeth.

"Right. The ever-curious, studious, and gung-ho Princess Twilight Sparkle followed her knee-jerk reaction instead of her intuitive nature. It's incredible how much the differences between you and my Twilight exist. She's compassionate. She values her friends and others. And she treats Spike as more than a pet!"

"I love Spike. He's my number one assistant. My brother! That is never in question!"

Twilight's horn gave off threatening glows as she lowered her head. Sunset remained unflinching as she moved closer. "He's your assistant before he's your brother? Does he cook and clean the entire castle?"

"No, he's both. Being my assistant doesn't mean I devalue him as a family! And Spike doesn't mind those chores!"

"Are you telling me that Spike, whose a baby dragon, organizes your extensive book collection, handles political documents, and clean that massive eyesore of a castle by himself? Where's your staff or chefs or guards to ease the burden?!"

Many of the courtroom members shook their heads in disapproval. Cadence's face is in a constant state of shock while Celestia and Luna frown deeply. "I-I don't mind if it's to help..." Spike offers weakly.

Sunset shakes her head at the drake. "She called you her brother, but have Twilight's parents even said they love you? Are you a member of the family or just another project Celestia placed on her?"

There was a long silence as Spike spoke in a soft tone. "...No. When we were little, Shining and Twilight competed over everything. Our parents would make a chart with gold stars for everything they did to keep things friendly. When the week is out, the sibling with the most gold stars will get the crown of the sibling supreme. I was too young for the first couple of years. But when I was old enough, I tried to do things too, like breathing fire or doing stuff with my claws and tail. It never got me a star, and I did burn something every time, so I just gave up on it. B-But, I was always with Twilight when she won!"

Spike looks around frantically, only for many of the court members to send him sympathetic looks. Twilight, however, stares blankly in morbid realization. "Spike, why didn't you ever--"

Twilight starts to ask, but Sunset would not let her. "Stop! Don't you dare try and frame your neglect as his fault! As his friend, you should have noticed. Twilight Velvet and Night Light should be actual parents. It would be best if you treated him less like an underpaid employee and more like a friend and family member. Hay, I can't even call what you are doing to Spike neglectful. It borders on slavery and outright child abuse! I'm just glad my friends are not here to see this. Because the only dark mirror is the mare in front of me!" Sunset Shimmer moves past Twilight and kneels to Spike. "You deserve better,"

Spike fidgets in while tears swell in his tears. He could not deny that he always feels left out when their parents don't acknowledge him, or the girls go on fun adventures without him. At the same time, it felt as though he was betraying his friends the more he voiced those same feelings. The walls started to close in on the little drake. The gallery members no longer looked like ponies but shadowy figures that criticized him and called him a traitor. Spike felt a hoof on his shoulder when it was becoming too overwhelming. The shadows started to recede as Sunset came into view with a gentle smile.

"Hey, if this is too much, you can take a break,"

"Yeah," Starlight walks up to the distraught baby dragon. "I think they reopened donut Joe's. And he has a new item on the menu!"

"...Yeah, I'd like that..." Spike said in a low voice. He cast one last glance at Twilight and the girls before hanging his head down and walking out with Starlight.

Twilight tried reaching out to him, but a glare from Sunset made her think twice. Satisfied with the turnout, Jason clears his throat as Sunset moves to the plaintiff's stands. "I think a recess is appropriate now if the judges allow it?"

"Granted!" Ember suddenly said before marching out of the courtroom.

"Yes, we should all take some time to process everything. The court will reconvene in an hour," Princess Luna said. Many in the gallery left the courtroom in a hurry. Luna could not help but notice various news ponies practically tramble each other racing out of the courthouse. She sighs deeply at the development. The press was going to have a field day with this trial. Watching the defendant bench, Luna felt a frown start to form. Luna waited until they were the last in the courtroom to approach Cadance. "It would seem that ill tiding are upon us,"

"Always so grim, sister. Are you sure you should be speaking with us? Your position as a judge might be questioned," Celestia said, but her tone was far more subdued.

"I doubt that is a concern we should discuss. But, I do believe that I will not be the target of scorn,"

"I agree!" Cadance said, glaring at the elements with utter contempt. "What in the hay is wrong with you girls?! Slamming the door in Jason's face and then walking by as an angry mob chased him out?! It's like I was looking at strangers!"

"I-It wasn't us, Princess. Or, at least, it is whatever this spell was infecting us! I know I can be critical in my opinions about fashion, but that was too cruel," Rarity comments.

"Then, why is it when the spell is canceled out, you remember Jason like he was your worse enemy?"

"Well, maybe he was. He did something so terrible that the Princess had to wipe our minds to forget or something!" Rainbow offers.

"That would be the case if our magic was present. Sadly, it is not," Luna said. "I am afraid the truth of Jason and his time in Ponyville will come out at his ledger,"

"Let's forget about Jason for a minute focus on Spike!" Now, all the elements shied from Cadance's glare. "Did everything he said conveniently slip your mind as well? Is there a spell blocking your basic common sense to treat him with decency?"

"..."

"Oh, Spike. I-I have to see him!" Twilight did not make it two feet before a golden aura caught her. Celestia guides Twilight back to her position as she tries to plead her case. "But Princess! You saw him! I need to--"

"To what, Twilight? Explain away your mistreatment, as Sunset stated. No, you have done quite enough. Besides, going out now will only make you appear worse,"

Cadance grew more irritated from the elements' lack of response. "Maybe Jason is onto something with his accusations. Although they are looking less and less like indictments with each passing second!"

"But, the magic? We can't deny it's there and messing with our perceptions!"

"I find it strange that only the elements and my sister are the targets of this spellcraft. Perhaps four alicorn mages can break through it," Luna suggests. The four princesses nodded as their horns lit with magic. However, a white aura appears on the defendants after several seconds of waiting. The spell did not break as it did for Celestia and Twilight. "...Nothing..."

"No. No! There has to be something! How can we know something is there but can't get rid of it? It makes no sense!!!" Twilight exclaimed.

"What do we do?" Fluttershy asks.

"Nothing. We sit here and do nothing but accept that we did something horrible," Pinkie said, her voice far removed from its usual cheerful tone.

"Darling, you don't mean that!" Rarity stated.

"Yeah, it's looking rough right now, but we'll pull through," Applejack stated.

"Yeah, we'll win like we always do, and whoever is behind this is in for a severe flank kicking," Rainbow shadow boxed.

Pinkie remains still. She doesn't show any signs of acknowledgment. Instead, she calmly walks back to the defense bench and sits down. "I hope you girls can keep that thinking that way when it's finally our turn," Once again, the courtroom went silent.

[One Hour Later.]

"Big court is back again. Pick up where we left off," Prince Rutherford said.

"We're in the middle of questioning the Princess of Friendship. A title that should promote unity-- given to a mare that is its antithesis," Jason stated.

"..." Twilight frowns but says nothing. Everyone retook their position in the courtroom. However, Twilight did not see Spike or Starlight return. She took some small comfort in that. It meant that Spike could not be used anymore. 'But, is that better? Doesn't it confirm my guilt in everything said about our relationship?' She shook her head and frowned deeply. If there was an issue in Spike's dynamic with our friends and family, that was for us to settle, not for Jason to manipulate!' She looks back to Jason to see him still waiting for her answer. 'But Jason might be a pawn as well. I need to appeal to his better nature,' Twilight sighs as she speaks. "Jason. I realize that our first meeting went poorly, and some ponies took that the wrong way. But, even you can see that some foul hoof is at play here. Every creature here saw the magic leave mine and Princess Celestia's bodies. There might even be magically manipulating you as well,"

"Is this a bid to throw the trial out? Let's join our forces and hunt down the big lousy villain of the week hiding in the shadows,"

"Yes,"

"We'll scour the world, leaving no stone unturned while learning valuable lessons on friendship and acceptance,"

"Yeah!" Twilight said, along with her friends, save for Pinkie. Celestia, however, looked at her former pupil and friends as if they'd gone mad.

"Except, there's one little problem..." Jason puts his hand on the Gjallarhorn. "I'm not under a spell. What happened to me wasn't done by anybody else but you, your friends, and that hate-filled nest you call home,"

"Huh?" Twilight asked in shock as the horn did not react.

Finally, having enough, Rainbow Dash hovers in front of Jason. "Where do you get off messing with us?! Making Spike all those things about his family - trying to make us look bad! Twilight is a good Princess. You're just a lost cause!"

Several gasps went off while Jason and Rainbow had a staring contest. Slowly but surely, Jason begins to smile. Rainbow lost a little of her nerve as Jason spoke. "You know, you were one of my favorite ponies. Then, you became one of my favorite tormentors. But we're going to get to you later. Right now, you need to relax. Yeah, I am unraveling your world piece by piece. But that's the law of equivalent exchange. You took from me; now I am taking from you. However, I will share a little secret with you in just a bit. But, first...."

Jason turns to address the court. "Members of the court. I have said many things regarding the defendants. Things that cast doubt on their very characters, abilities, and very soul. I do this not out of malice but out of concern. Concern for their future victims. You all claim that Princess Twilight Sparkle is a virtuous mare and worthy bearer of Harmony's tenants. But, I pose those questions to you in the form of another witness that has had multiple dealings with the avatar of Friendship. Please welcome--"

The courtroom doors burst open as smoke pours inside. A blue and white-maned mare with a purple wizard hat and cape stood on her hind legs. In a loud and boisterous voice, she speaks. "The Great and Powerful TRRRIIIXIIIE!!!"

The Great and Powerful Showmare

[Canterlot Judicial Hall.]

The courtroom fell into silence once again. Trixie continues to hold her pose while the occupants react differently to her presence. Jason has his hand toward her as if to introduce her on stage. Chrysalis groans while slamming her head on the podium. The gallery and judges look on with confusion. Whereas the elements had varying degrees of shock.

"Her?! You have her as a witness!" Rainbow said, pointing at Trixie.

"Yes, I feel Trixie has good insight to share with the rest of the world," Jason said.

Rainbow falls over, laughing as Trixie approaches the center. "Wow. You must be scrapping the bottom of the barrel. What she's going to say? How to be a blowhard?"

"Hmph, this attitude is precisely why the Great and Powerful Trixie is here today. I can't wait to wipe that smug grin off your faces!"

"I thought we were past this, Trixie!" Twilight said.

"Did you forget already, Twilight? Ponyville doesn't give second chances. Now that Trixie knows what kind of monster you and that hick village are, Trixie will not allow you to poison my new best friend! Stand aside, Rainbow Dolt. Your day of reckoning is at hand!"

Rainbow wipes the tears from her before moving back with her friends. "It's right shameful, Trixie,"

"And ungrateful," Rarity added.

"We thought you had changed," Fluttershy said softly.

"We get it. You're hurt. I want to hear what she has to say!" Ember said sharply.

"Witness. Name and occupation, please," Jason said,

Trixie clears her throat. "Look upon me, members of the court, for I am Trixie Lulumoon. The most excellent and most astonishing show mare in Equestria!"

"We heard you the first, girly. Get on with your testimony without all this bloody posturing!" Grandpa Gruff angrily said.

"Sheesh, tough crowd. Anyway, I was but a simple traveling stage magician before I came to the town of Ponyville. I believed I could entertain the simple-minded ponies with my bedazzling tales and performances. However, as I set my stage to begin my act, a few neigh sayers disturbed my show!"

"Believe me; it wasn't much of a show," Rainbow stated.

"Ya'll wasn't doing anything but blowing hot air," Applejack said.

"And humiliating everypony in the town hall!" Rarity added.

"It was you who humiliated the Great and Powerful Trixie!"

"Enough! Miss Trixie. Defendants! We are not here to have a back-and-forth with conjecture. Please use the Gjallarhorn so that we can have a clear picture of the events in question!" Luna stated.

"Gladly," Rainbow said while flying up to the horn. The memory plays out with a group of ponies standing before a stage. Trixie came out with her pitch. She was telling the audience of her feats in defeating an Ursa Major. The elements voiced their opinions on Trixie being a braggart, prompting Trixie to challenge her hecklers. Applejack went first, showing off her skill with her lasso. Trixie enchants the rope to wrap around Applejack's legs and shoves an apple in her muzzle. Rainbow went next by bursting through clouds, making the water splash on her for a miniature rainbow to appear above her head. Trixie used her magic to make the rainbow swirl around Rainbow Dash, leaving her dizzy. Finally, Rarity goes up and uses magic to fashion a beautiful dress. Trixie uses magic to turn Rarity's mane green with twigs. The memory ends with Trixie professing her greatness. "See that? Your star witness is nothing but a big jerk!"

Rarity, Twilight, and Applejack supported Rainbow as the gallery and judge appeared to agree. Fluttershy looks especially appalled as she was visiting her parents at the time. "Hey! You said I was not going to get into trouble...!" Trixie whispers harshly at Jason.

Jason, in response, calmly brings out one of his papers. "Do you see this, Miss Dash?"

"It's a piece of paper. So what?"

"This paper contract permits Trixie to set and perform on her stage in Townhall. You can see the signature of Mayor Mare right here, so it's official. As Trixie stated, she is a traveling stage magician whose job is to entertain an audience to make ends meet. The Great and Powerful Trixie is her stage persona. Are you following me so far?"

"Where are you going with this?" Twilight asked.

"It's simple. Everything Trixie does on stage is a part of her act. What is not a part of her act was pony's disrupting her show with baseless comments, as you and your friends did," The elements all share nervous glances. "Therefore, you four committed disorderly conduct by badgering Trixie Lulumoon,"

"Now see here, if you are going to accuse us of such a crime, what of Trixie's actions against us?" Rarity said indignantly.

"Her actions? You mean when she offered an open challenge for audience participation, and you three willingly accepted? You could've ignored her or even left Townhall, yet you all actively joined in her act. Thus, you became a part of a government-sanctioned performance,"

"That is true, defendants," Luna said with a frown. "Miss Lulumoon was well within her right as a performer to act as she did,"

"B-But she humiliated us!" Rarity exclaimed.

"After you attempted to humiliate and provoke her yourselves? Let's not forget that you all acted brash and self-entitled. The same thing you accused her of doing. Rainbow Dash flat-out admitted it herself in the memory. Trixie did not insult, badger, or discredit anyone in her audience until you three directly confronted her. She did nothing wrong,"

"Trixie did plenty wrong!" Twilight said as she approached the horn. A new memory plays with Twilight reading in her home until Spike rushes inside in a panic.

"Twilight. Come quick!"

"Spike! I told you I am not going to show up, Trixie!"

"No, it's--"

A roar cuts Spike off. "Was that what I think it was?"

"Majorly!"

The memory continues with Twilight and Spike running past a crowd of citizens and bumping into Snips and Snails. "What's going on?!"

"We brought an Ursa Major to town," Snips said nonchalantly.

"You did what?!"

"Don't worry. The Great and Powerful Trixie will defeat it," Snails said.

Trixie hangs her down in shame as she confesses. "...I can't. I never have! No one can defeat an Ursa Major! I made that up to make myself look better!"

Spike once again urges Twilight to act, causing the unicorn at the time to gulp. Twilight's horn starts to glow as a soothing melody plays in the wind and lulls the star bear into a calm state. Next, her aura envelopes a nearby water tower and passes through a barn full of cows. Now filled with milk, Twilight strains her magic, lifting the bear and feeding it milk. Finally, she hovers the Ursa back into the Everfree forest. The ponies all cheer while Twilight looks remorseful about her magical display. Applejack, Rarity, and Rainbow Dash all assure Twilight that magic was never the issue, but Trixie's attitude. Twilight later explains that the bear was only a cranky baby due to Snips and Snails waking it up.

"Ha! You may have defeated the Ursa Minor, but you never have the unique, show-stopping ability of the great and powerful Trixie!" Trixie stamps down, producing a smokescreen, before running out of town.

"Why that little!" Rainbow Dash said before taking off after her.

"Let her go, Rainbow. Hopefully, one day, she'll learn her lesson,"

Twilight's horn glows as she produces another letter. "Here's the lesson for that fiasco. Dear Princess Celestia, I have learned a precious lesson about friendship. I was so afraid of being thought of as a show-off that I was hiding a part of who I am. My friends showed me it's okay to be proud of your talents. And there are times when it is appropriate to show them off. Especially when you're standing up for your friends," Twilight said before frowning at Trixie. "Unfortunately, it seems like you did not learn anything,"

Trixie grumbles indignantly before Chrysalis starts chuckling. "O-Oh, this is too rich!"

"What are you laughing at!?" Rainbow hollers.

"You. I am laughing at you. Never in my wildest dreams have I seen such ingrained stupidity in one species before. Urgh! It makes me feel even worse for losing you so many times,"

"Keep your insult to yourself and explain your point!" Cadance said sternly.

"Very well. I am assuming the day's lesson is humility-- A virtue none of you showed during that whole affair, which is evident that you continue to point out Trixie's supposed terrible qualities. A quick reminder that her attitude was a part of her stage prop, so that lesson does not make sense. Or at least, it does not come without conditions. It would be best if you liked the pony before accepting its flaws. Of course, I also have to point out the apparent flip-flopping. You berate Trixie about showing off her magic. Yet, you call for a unicorn-to-unicorn tussle," Chrysalis that part in a perfect copy of Applejack's voice. "You urge Twilight to take Trixie down a peg, and when she does, you flip the script and say it's not about magic. Trixie's just a loudmouth," Chrysalis finished with Rainbow's voice. "Even that pathetic lesson spews falsehoods. It's ideal for you to be proud of yourself and your ability. Yet, when a pony has legal means to do the same, she runs out of town. Just look at the pot calling the kettle black,"

"I think we're going to need to find alternative words for hypocrisy," Jason comments.

Sensing the shift, Trixie added her two cents. "Y-Yes. Trixie was dealt a bad hoof. Everything was against her when I was only doing my job!"

"I wasn't aware of all these circumstances behind this lesson Twilight," Celestia said sternly, causing Twilight to shy away.

"I will say that both parties could've benefitted from humility. But Trixie's lie about defeating an Ursa Major put all of Ponyville in danger!" Twilight counters. "Don't forget that two impressionable colts believed every word and sought to prove her claims true,"

"So, Trixie is at fault for - once again - seeking to entertain ponies with a story about herself as her job entails? If we follow that logic, we should burn every book that's ever told a story to keep impressionable foals out of danger," Jason said. "Trixie, did you knowingly and willingly ask Snips and Snails to bring the Ursa to Ponyville?"

"Of course not. I even told those two colts they were out of their minds!" Trixie stated.

Turning to Twilight, Jason continues. "And those two colts understood the danger an Ursa presents and still brought it to town. I fail to see how any of that falls to Trixie's accountability,"

"No, but--"

"What I want to know," Luna said, cutting Twilight off. "How can a pair of the foals go unsupervised into the most dangerous forest and bring such a beast to Ponyville? Where were their parents? What was their punishment?"

"W-We sufficiently punished Snips and Snails by cleaning up the mess the Ursa made and placing spell number twenty-five on them. Also, the colt's parents grounded them for three months,"

"Spell number twenty-five?" Ember asks.

"It gives the wearer a long mustache. Spike loves it..."

"Show us!" Twilight did as Ember asked. The memory showed Twilight looking down at Snips and Snails. Spike makes the suggestion, and Twilight agrees. A flash of magic later, and all three had mustaches, expressing their joy over their facial hair. The memory ends with a loud groan from the judges.

"That's it!? That's all the retribution those two idiots get? They're enjoying it!!! Trixie lost everything that day! My home, my job, my reputation! Everything!!!" Trixie shriek.

"Big whoop! It's what you get after you come back with the alicorn amulet!" Rainbow calls out.

"The alicorn amulet?" Queen Novo asks.

"It's an artifact of dark magic that can give regular unicorns the powers of alicorn but at a dreadful cost. The amulet slowly corrupts you until everything you were is gone. It was crafted by a fanatic cult of ponies a millennia ago that wanted the powers of an alicorn. We caught wind of this and shut down the cult. I secured the amulet in the vault. But, we did not account for a surviving cult member infiltrating our ranks. Thankfully, we caught the pony over by the waterfall. Unfortunately, the pony put the amulet on and utilized an unstable beam spell. The explosion destroyed the pony and presumedly the amulet as well," Celestia explained. "It was not until Twilight sent a letter that I discovered the amulet survived. How did you come across it?"

"Oh, Trixie found it in an old pawnshop," Celestia stares at the show mare with a flat expression.

"Don't matter where she got it. The point is that she had it. Trixie here could not leave well enough alone and challenged Twilight to a magic duel. She was all decked out with that amulet and forced Twilight to duel her. When she won, Trixie banished Twilight from Ponyville and cut the rest of us off, where she made us her servants!" Applejack said, touching the Gjallarhorn. It showed Trixie causing havoc in Ponyville until Twilight arrived. She used the citizens and Twilight's friends to goad her into a magic duel. Despite Twilight's best efforts, Trixie displayed advanced unicorn magic that she could not contend with, and thus, Twilight was banished from Ponyville.

"Oh, it was dreadful! Trixie had us slaving away at her every whim. Some of the things she wanted hardly made sense. She forced me to make crude banners. I can't tell you how often I picked myself trying to keep up with her demands!" Rarity said as the memory displayed what she was saying.

"Yeah, and we had to carry those banners all day. She made the Cakes build a cookie throne. She said it was when she got hungry and wanted food available pronto," Rainbow said.

"She had me mash up my apples for some applesauce face cream. You can't use applesauce for that, and she tickled me something fierce if I don't comply," Applejack said. "Thank goodness Twilight thought of a plan to get that amulet off of her,"

The memory ends with Twilight utilizing her friends to trick Trixie into taking her fake amulet while Rainbow snags the alicorn amulet. Twilight performs her show for the Saddle Arabian delegates and Princess Celestia. Jason tried to remain stoic as each scene of Trixie's occupation played. But Jason could feel one of his start to tremble as a scowl slowly formed.

"This is oppression to you? This is the pain you suffered under the horrific and unjust Trixie? Hooves prickled from needles, holding banners and mashing apples into applesauce. If that's the worst you've ever experienced, I got three years of stories that will make you wish Trixie with the amulet became your Princess! Try living in a cave. Try surviving the bitter cold at night. Try crying yourself to sleep. I wish I bumped into a corrupted Trixie instead of meeting you. She, at least, would've given me a roof over my damn head!" Jason saw the ponies flinch over his bite. He calms down and focuses on his witness. "More on that later. But, it would interest the court to know why Trixie returned,"

"You mentioned that your life became sour. What events lead to this dark hour?" Zekia asks.

Trixie eyed Jason for a time after his short speech and moved to the horn. "When I said I lost everything, I meant it. Thanks to the Ursa, the wagon that held most of my possessions was gone. I snuck back into Ponyville to try and salvage my earring for my show. Instead, the mayor refused to pay me and handed me a bill for the damages the Ursa caused. Trixie had to pay for those outlandish damage costs and use her savings to get to her other venues. But everywhere I went, ponies would ostracize and boo me off the stage. They would constantly bring up my first defeat of Twilight Sparkle and throw it in my face. I was a laughing stock..." The memory played out various scenes of Trixie receiving more hecklers than before, as some would throw rotten food at her, forcing her to run out of each town she visited. "It got so bad that I could no longer support me through my dream profession. I had to seek work at a rock farm to make ends meet. I got a letter one day. A small venue owner had enlisted my talents. I thought it was going to be my big break. It turns out it was anything but that..."

Another memory plays with Trixie entering an average-looking building. Inside, she saw several mares and stallions with various outfits going about their day. A portly brown-furred, golden-maned stallion approached her. "Ah, Trixie. Thank you for coming. Did you find the place, okay?"

"Trixie had no trouble. You have a lot of other talents with you, Mister Poon Sleazy,"

"Oh, them? Believe it or not, this is a slow day. Now come into my office so we can talk business~," Trixie shudders as she sees how close he got to her and the awful cologne he was wearing. They entered a room where two ponies - a mare and a stallion stood by the door. Poon Sleazy sat at his desk, taking out a large sack of bits. Trixie's eyes sparkled at the money as Pon spoke again. "We are always in the habit of finding mares like you. You have the right kind of attitude that our audience loves. Here's the script,"

Trixie shakes her head and takes the paper. "Oh, I appreciate your input, Mister Sleazy, but-- AH!? What is this?"

"It's your new script for the film you'll be starring in,"

"B-b-but, this isn't a stage show! It's-it's an adult film!!!"

"Well, yeah, this office works in the adult film industry. Did you not see the business card I sent with the letter?"

"Yes. But I thought that was a joke! The Great and Powerful Trixie cannot be seen peddling smut! I'll never recover!!!"

"Oh, I get it. This is a big change from what you are used to. Don't worry. You're still in the show biz, just in a different field,"

"And this-this script!? Why should I perform in something like this? I thought you said ponies like my attitude,"

"You like it? We want to keep that arrogant show mare persona-- have your scene where she is getting her comeuppance with her assistants. Ponies have a lot of switches geared to the rough treatment. Besides, if you were any good at your previous gig, you would've taken off by now. Then again, tangling with a mare that defeated an Ursa might not have been a good advertisement. Anyway, let's get started on your initiation," The stallion suddenly exposed himself while the two ponies behind her took out lewd objects. "Now, you want to pace yourself. Believe it or not, the actors need a lot of stamina for this kind of thing,"

The memory ends with Trixie shouting out in a panic before using her firework spell to blind the ponies in Sleezy's office. She took the bag of bits and ran out of the building. "After that horrible experience, Trixie had to lay low. Trixie knew that my life would never return to the way it was because of you, Twilight! Trixie needed to beat you to get her life back! Eventually, Trixie caught wind of an old shopkeeper selling magical charms and artifacts. Trixie needed that edge to face you down. But Trixie did not know of the corrupting effects of the alicorn amulet. So, after my second defeat, Trixie was back to square one. My apology tour had minimal success because I had to pay back Sleazy for the bits!"

"That's a harrowing experience, Miss Lulumoon. And all of it traces back to Twilight and her friends' callousness. Well, do you still find Trixie's suffering funny?" Jason asks. None of the defendants could muster a response. Rainbow didn't look as smug anymore. Fluttershy and Rarity had massive blushes on their face. At the same time, Twilight made her best impression of a goldfish. Celestia visibly shifts slightly away from the elements as she hangs her head. Pinkie was a different case. She wasn't expressive like her friends. She merely stares at her bench while sending the occasional glance toward Jason. Jason dismisses it. "You know, Miss Lulumoon. I would say you have cause to sue Ponyville for your treatment,"

"I do?" Trixie asks in confusion.

"Yes, you do," A new voice stated. Everyone turned to see Starlight and Spike returning. However, the two did not go back to the defense side. "Per Ponyville law articles and subsidiary contracts. Once a venue has been rented, the presiding officer must pay the amount owed by audience attendance, with the official host receiving a 25 percent cut upon completion. Trixie, how long were you going to do your show?"

"Three days total. But, I fled after one," Trixie said.

"That means you weren't fully paid for that show and were unjustly charged. I think mayor Mare does have a lot of explaining to do. Or, will the crown fit the bill?"

"Spike!" Twilight exclaimed. It was unclear if she blocked out or did not hear Starlight as she rushed over to him. However, Starlight's aura surrounds her, and they teleport back to the center. "Starlight! What are you doing?"

"Weren't you the one who told me to respect decorum? Besides, another witness has come forward; me!" Starlight said with a frown.

"What!?" The elements save for Pinkie exclaimed.

"You're turning your back on us!?" Rainbow shouted.

"Why, darling?" Rarity wails.

"Starlight...?" Twilight asks in a hurt tone.

"When I asked what Trixie did for everypony in Ponyville to put her at hoofs length, you would tell me to ask Trixie. But Trixie would never say anything beyond ponies there don't give second chances that she did not want to talk about it. I figured it was like my situation. But that wasn't bad. Trixie got ripped out of her career and mistreated for it. All those lessons, all those lectures, I thought I was becoming a better pony with you girls. I should've realized this when you tried to convince me not to be friends with Trixie!"

Starlight moves to the Gjallarhorn as Twilight raises her hoof. "Starlight, please!"

Starlight shakes her head. She touches the horn, playing a new memory. It was one of Twilight and Starlight setting the table. Twilight tried to work a friendship lesson that was poorly received and thought out as Starlight used her magic. But the real purpose was to set up a meeting with Princess Celestia about Starlight's friendship studies. Starlight was shown trying various methods of befriending the citizen of Ponyville with no luck. It wasn't until she met Trixie in the spa that she made progress. The two mares shared common ground, having formerly been antagonists to Twilight and her friends.

"Trixie was the only pony with whom I felt any real connection because she had a troubled past. But what did you do? You tried to convince otherwise!"

Twilight recoils in shock at the reappearance of Trixie. After a brief exchange, Twilight pulls Starlight to the side. I know I said to make friends with anypony. But, with your past and Trixie's past, I'm not sure she'll make the best first friend,"

"But you did forgive her for whatever she did, right?"

"Of course, it's just she wasn't a very friendly pony,"

"Well, you did say anypony. And I just assumed that you trusted me to make friends on my own. The same way Princess Celestia trusted you!"

Twilight sighs before smiling. "You're right. I trust you. Just be back before the dinner,"

"But you did not trust me! Or forgiven Trixie. You stalked us that whole time while we were out!" Starlight said as the memory shifted to Twilight talking to Starlight in a bush.

"Hey, how is it going with your new friend? Because if it isn't working out for any reason, I can introduce you to my friend here. You can come out now," A white-furred two-toned blue unicorn pops out of the bushes next to Twilight. "You like music. DJ PON3 would make for the perfect last-minute change for the dinner with Princess Celestia,"

"You kept switching from ponies. I've never even spoken to impress the Princess. It bothers me that you didn't give Trixie a second chance. You even took the ponies you picked to dinner. But you still tried to break us up!"

"Hold on, Starlight. Don't forget that Trixie was using you to get to me!" Twilight said, showing the memory. "Ahem, you just decided to skip our dinner without telling me! Are you aware at this very moment, Princess Celestia is waiting for you at a table with exquisite silverware placement!"

"Y-Yes, but--"

"This is precisely why I didn't want you to make friends with Trixie!"

"Aha! You still don't trust me. But guess what, Princess? It doesn't matter if you want to give me a second chance. Starlight had to choose between you and me. And she chose me! Your pupil chose me! So, ha! I win!!!" Trixie gloated.

"See? It was all about winning for you, Trixie!" Twilight stated as the memory ended.

"Yeah, it was about winning at that moment. But I genuinely wanted Starlight as a friend. She was the only good thing I had going for me. It broke my heart at the thought of losing her. So much so that I went to do the moonshot manticore mouth dive, hoping my friend would save me. But, if she didn't, then that would've been fine too,"

Starlight gasps at that revelation. "Trixie. Tell me you didn't intend to do that!"

"I am sorry, but what are you talking about? What is this trick you performed?" Chrysalis asks. Trixie touches the horn again as the memory shows her getting inside a cannon, lighting it, and launching herself straight into a manticore's maw. She only survived due to Starlight returning to teleport her. "So, you mean to tell us that you were going to commit suicide because you lost your only friend?"

"How quaint," Jason spat.

"Starlight returned after I admitted I was wrong and encouraged her friendship!" Twilight stated.

"So? Do you want a medal for fixing a problem you actively caused? One that could've been avoided if you weren't a control freak! You don't get to pat your back on this. Not this time. Not after everything we've learned. What's the point of learning lessons if you still make the same mistake? Do you remember the lesson for convenience's sake at that moment, then go and abuse some other poor sap as part of your friendship quota? 'Oh, I need to write a friendship letter, but nothing is happening. I know; I'll hypnotize an entire town to create one,''

Twilight's eyes widen at Jason's words. "W-What? What did you say?" At Twilight's question, Jason merely smiles.

Before Twilight could inquire further, Luna spoke up. "I believe that is quite enough for today. Much has been revealed, and I cannot help to express my disappointment. Trixie Lulumoon. You have suffered extensively with little compensation. My disappointment only grows concerning your time in Ponyville and the behavior of its citizens. Especially those two colts. Such an action of bringing this beast would be cause for banishment. At a minimum, Snips and Snails would've been taken away from their parents by foal protective services!" Luna said. "The Equestrian crown will personally see that you get your due, Miss Lulumoon,"

Trixie bows her head deeply. "Oh, thank Princess Luna,"

"Court is now adjourned,"

The Changeling Queen

Author's Note

Alright, we are back to our regular schedule writing. Enjoy.

The Changeling Queen

[Canterlot Judicial Hall.]

The ponies in the gallery were scrambling within the courtroom. The judges were screaming for order. However, most of the attention was now on Rainbow Dash. Her body was comically flat against the opposing wall of the courtroom. With her speed, no one can react in time to stop her. Rainbow is just that fast. Everyone expected to see Jason flatten against the wall. However, no one expected Pinkie Pie to push Jason out of the way. Jason and Pinkie sat on the floor with the party mare lying across his stomach. Pinkie winces as Rainbow peels off the wall and hits the ground. Looking back at Jason, Pinkie wonders why he stares intently at the ceiling.

"Are you okay?" Pinkie asks tentatively. Jason remains silent. "I better get up now, huh?"

"..."

"...Right..."

Pinkie Pie removes herself from Jason as Chrysalis approaches him. The changeling queen offers a hoof as he takes it and sits up. "Thanks. I slipped and couldn't get up for some reason,"

Chrysalis arches a brow at this before turning to Pinkie's hurt expression. "Yes, you should be more careful around marble floors. I don't know why you insist on balancing on two limbs when you have four,"

"What do I look like, a baby?"

"Speaking of foals, the Rainbow one and Cream one are stirring,"

Rainbow Dash was indeed shaking off the cobwebs. Her eyes refocus on Jason as she snorts angrily. Instantly, she was in the air again. Only this time, Chrysalis catches her in her aura. "Ah! Let. GO!!!"

"Dashie, please stop. You're making things worse!" Pinkie pleaded.

"I'm making things worse?! Are you bucking kidding me!? Look at what he did to Fluttershy! Trying to make us the bad guys. Spying on us! Everything was fine until he showed his ugly mug. Now Fluttershy's cutie maker is gone!!!"

Rarity was right beside Fluttershy as the shy mare had a vacant hollow expression with fresh tears staining her cheeks. A hateful scowl lands on Jason as Rarity goes on a tirade. "Are you proud of yourself? Does it feel good to harm an innocent mare? Fluttershy is a fragile pony. She abhors violence. It's only natural she'd run away from it. She doesn't deserve to lose her cutie mark for the actions of others or be criticized for her timid nature!"

"A timid mare? Is it true that Fluttershy? - as an element of harmony - faced the likes of Nightmare Moon, Discord, and yours truly?" Chrysalis asks. Jason emphasizes her point with memories from the Gjallarhorn of Fluttershy performing said acts.

"Yes, but she didn't do it alone,"

"Did she not face down a dragon that thousand times her size? A timid mare convinced a dragon to leave its den,"

The image changes to the elements going up to the cave where the dragon is sleeping. The court saw the various attempts of the bearers to wake the dragon failing. At first, Rarity smiles at the memory as it shows Fluttershy being her timid self and hiding away. But then, her smile leaves, leading her to get the dragon to go so she can claim his hoard of treasure. She cringes when Rainbow Dash bucks the dragon's snout, waking him in a rage. And she becomes nervous when Fluttershy activates her stare and dresses him down.

"How dare you. How dare you! Listen here, mister! Just because your big doesn't mean you get to b a bully! You have huge teeth, snore smoke, and breathe fire, but you do not - I repeat - do not hurt my friends! You got that!"

"Y-Yes, she did do that," Rarity said reluctantly.

A groan sounds from the judges as Ember covers her face. "Wonderful. Now I have to talk with Crimson about his dwelling relocation. No dragon believed it when he returned to the Dragonlands because of a pony,"

"I must ask why a group of civilians went to convince a fully grown dragon to leave its cave instead of you or your guard, Celestia?" Queen Novo said.

Celestia sighs as another of her decisions comes into question. "I believed that the presence of the royal guard might have led to a gross misunderstanding between the two parties. It was a chance to test Twilight and her friend's diplomacy skill,"

"A test that they very nearly failed due to the actions of that one!" Queen Novo points to Rainbow Dash, who stops struggling with Chrysalis's' hold as Luna's and Cadance's aura overrides Chrysalis as they sit Rainbow back at the defendant's bench."

"The disappointment is mounting, Miss Dash. This is the second time you are acting both carelessly and recklessly. There shall not be a third!" Luna stated. "The court will add attempted assault charges after your little display,"

"What!? But he--" Rainbow exclaimed.

"Jason conducted himself as a plaintiff should. You, as a defendant, only hurt Fluttershy and those beside you more," Cadance said with a shake of her head.

"Why did you not report the issue to Celestia instead of resorting to violence? Why were you also without the elements of harmony"?" Queen Novo continues."

"W-Well, the dragon wasn't bad, just a little thoughtless in his sleeping pattern. And Princess Celestia trusted us. I believed we could handle it, and we did!" Twilight said.

"Was it misplaced trust or incompetence all around, I wonder?"

"A little from column A and a lot from column B. But we also forget when sweet, timid Fluttershy stood up to a minotaur seeking his proper monetary compensation," Chrysalis said.

Playing the memory shows Rarity and Pinkie trying to dissuade a minotaur from seeing the shy mare. The judges all frown when Rarity and Pinkie refer to Iron Wall as a monster. Finally, after Fluttershy opens the door, Iron request what he is owed.

"You were a doormat, andIronn Will turned you into a lean, mean, assertive machine! Pay Iron Will what you owe Iron Wil!"

"No," Fluttershy said to the shock of everyone. "As I recall, during your workshop, you promised one hundred percent satisfaction from your customers, or we don't pay. Well, I am not satisfied,"

"Not only do we see FLutterhsy stand up to several creatures larger than her, but we also see the supposed good pony scamming a hardworking creature," Chrysalis said.

"Now, hold on! That Mon-"Rarity quickly catches herself. "That Minotaur's seminar turned Fluttershy into an awful and horrid pony," Rarity said.

Another memory plays of Fluttershy interacting with ponies after IronWill'ss seminar. However, while some cases show ponies being rude to Fluttershy and the shy pegasus responds accordingly, other issues show Fluttershy being the aggressor. "Now, can you tell the court where in Iron Will's seminar he says throw ponies into haystacks, beat ponies out of a taxi, and mail post ponies in a display of irony? Fluttershy clearly states she is proud of her new attitude. And you two supported it. Fluttershy, in the end, even openly admits that she took the assertiveness lesson too far. So, Iron Will has grounds to sue all three of you for his compensation. Especially considering it was you two that convinced Fluttershy to do so,"

"But, his so-called lesson was far too general. Any pony could've done the same things Fluttershy did!"

"Then, where are the cases of other ponies who attended that seminar going over the top with their assertiveness?" Rarity could not answer. "It is only common sense to know when and where to be assertive. Although being assertive is not grounds for assaulting ponies."

"The court is inclined to agree, Miss Belle," Luna said. "The crown will hear his case about producing Iron Will with his full and proper payment for his seminar,"

"And, now the question becomes this; Is Fluttershy going to avoid accountability for her actions again? We saw it in the memories of Iron Will. We saw it with Jason. Hay, we even saw in this court when she used an ability known as the stare to attack Jason,"

The murmurs were starting to grate at Rarity's nerves. "Enough. You stand there so smug while talking about accountability? What about yours? You evaded punishment for crashing the wedding! You impersonated and foalnapped a princess! You committed espionage and brainwashing against Shinning Armor! You attempted an invasion! Yet, here you are now, trying to champion a creature that happens to have a grudge to make yourself seem virtuous! This whole charade is nothing more than your latest revenge plot. If I am guilty of hypocrisy, what about you, little pot?"

Chrysalis loses her smile and glares at the prissy unicorn. "You think it is so simple, don't you? I am a big evil villain who comes to ruin your lives. You believe me to be one-dimensional, only desiring revenge. Well, I'd be lying if I said otherwise. But, like I told Shinning Armor, we are effective because it is not just revenge. It is justice that drives us. You see, my dear element bearer, the one thing a villain affords you is that you can spot those of the same cloth. I've been around plenty of despicable creatures. Some are overt, like Sombra and Discord. Others are subtle and covert, like me. But, you and the Princess? Yours is a villainy that makes me sick to my stomach. The kind that hides behind their sanctimonious platitudes while being either willfully ignorant or blindly dismissive to the harm they cause!"

"And what harm has any of us brought unto you!" Cadance asks.

Chrysalis scoffs as she approaches the Gjallarhorn for the first time. The memory took place in an unknown castle and throne room. A different yet similar changeling to Chrysalis was waiting inside an empty throne save for a few guards. A small nymph beside her huddles closer as she can see and feel the baneful glares of the assembled ponies.

"Mother. Why are they staring at us like that? I feel something making me ill,"

"Tis alright, little Chrysalis. Keep close to me, always. We'll see the king and Queen of the pony land for aid,"

A moment later, a large teleportation dome appears. Two alicorns were flanked by two unicorns, a commander pegasi and a grinning Earth pony. The female alicorn arches a brow as she speaks while holding her foals. "Husband? What manner o creatures are these?"

"Egads!" The Earth pony said. "They remind me of the ants during the summertime harvest,"

"They do appear insect-like at first glance," The breaded wizard unicorn said.

"Urgh! And they are as vile!"[/] The unicorn mare said.

"State your business. Why have you come here?" The king spoke in a commanding tone.

My name is Metamorpha. With me is my daughter, Princess Chrysalis. We have to your bedding kingdom to ally ourselves with you," "/b]

The alicorns looked skeptical, while the unicorn mare was unimpressed. "You come to us, asking to participate in our kingdom and reap our spoils, with nothing to prove your worth? Such impertinence!"

"We are waring with the minotaurs of the east. What might you bring against them? Mayhaps you will use your visage to terrify them," The pegasus said.

Metaphorma smiles at her before green flames shroud her. A moment later and a minotaur was standing before the ponies. "We are changeling. We assume the form of any we desire. With our skill, we can--"

"ABOMINATION!!!" The king roars as the guards aim their spears. "You steal the form of your slain? Might you do the same to us if left unchecked,"

Chrysalis flew up to eye level with them. "No, sir. You don't die change. We can do so on our own," Chrysalis morphs into one of the foals in the Queen's hooves. "See?"

However, this did not get the reaction she hoped for, as the Queen sent out a burst of magic at her. Metamopha had little choice but to take the blast herself. "MOTHER!!!" Chrysalis shrieks as his mother collapses.

"Seize them!" The king ordered.

"Stay. S-strong little June bug...!" With the last of her magic, Metamorpha's magic surrounds Chrysalis, and she finds herself back in the hive. The memory ends with the little nymph releasing a wail of sadness.

"That's how I met your mother and father. King Solaris and Queen Selina. Starswirl, Princess Plantium. Commander Hurricane. Chancellor Pudding Head. You met with all of them while we were foals?" Celestia said in a hollow voice.

"Yes, that's how I met that's founders of Equestria. A political meeting of rulers ending in bloodshed!" Chrysalis sp" t as she glares at Celestia and then at Luna. "That is the true virtue you ponies hold. Fear. Hatred. Distrust. We came to offer our services. We came to see if we could join you, and what did that get us?"

"No. I-It was a time of war. It hardens us all. And harmony was yet to be found between the tribes. Surely, with your ability to change the form, that such a reaction---"

Chrysalis cut Luna off before she could finish. "So, because of who we are, my mother deserved to be tortured?! Yes! Tortured! After she got me to safety, your famed wizard Starswirl experimented on her for days!" Chrysalis took an aggressive step to the defendant's bench. "Go ahead! Doubt my claims! I'd love to shatter that image of the great Starswirl the Breaded! Do you want to see what it's like to hit your skin peeled away? Well, any takers?"

No one breathes a word in objection. "We shall accept your word on this. Such imagery may prove traumatic to witness. As I am sure you already know...." Luna said softly.

"When you share a connection to the hive mind, your thoughts are not just yours. Your feeling is not just yours. My mother was strong enough to hide what she was experiencing, but her memories came to me when she died. I saw everything he did! My only saving grace was that some of our elite drones recovered my mother before that bastard could gleam anything of our species!"

"B-But he's Starswirl the Breaded. He wouldn't..." Twould pauses as Chrysalis stares into her soul. She would not dare finish lest she sees her all-time hero's name forever tarnished.

"Then, that's where your animosity towards ponies comes from? Because of how you were treated as a foal?" Cadance asks "more softly this time.

"That's where it started. I suffered two more slights against me years later. One was from you, Princess Celestia. And you, Mi Amore Cadenza!"

"How can you count that as an offense when I was but a foal? Or perhaps, you are referring to the wedding day? It is my shame to admit that you bested me that day. Or are you counting me along with Cadance?" Celestia asks.

"Big surprise! You got mad because Cadance and Shining Armor sent you packing for crashing their wedding!" Rainbow said. Most of the gallery shares her sentiments.

"No, Celestia, I am not counting you with your niece. The wedding day shall forever be her sin against me and my race. No, the slight you dealt me came from this," Chrysalis brings two documents up to project the words for the court.

"Dear Princess Celestia. My name is June Bug. I am the Princess of the changelings. I am writing this letter to you because I heard you were a kind pony, unlike the others. My mommy doesn't like ponies very much. But I know you are good and that there are good ponies. I look forward to meeting you,"

"Who letter is that from? June Bug?" Cadance asks"

Chrysalis shivers before she responds. "...She was my daughter. There must always be a queen to the hive. The most potent queens are born from the love of a mate. However, as a survival trait, a queen can asexually reproduce should no mate be present. This method runs a high risk of the Queen becoming infertile to the prior process of conceiving progeny. And, unfortunately, I am picky when choosing mates," Chrysalis said as a soft smile formed.

"You seemed fond of my Shining Armor!" Cadance said, her tone laced with venom.

Chrysalis rolls her eyes. "Please, do you know how much love a bride and groom produce on their wedding day? Weddings are a full buffet to a changeling. Shinings a decent colt toy. But I never dip into someone else's sloppy seconds,"

"Hey!" Shining calls out, only for Cadance to silence him with a glare.

"I see. But I've never gotI'vethat letter in my docket," Celestia informs.

"Then, what do you call this?!" Chrysalis summons a second paper to read aloud. "To whom it may concern, it is within the interest of preserving Equestia's gloEquestia'se by not associating with the inferior likes of literal bugs. Your presence would be a plague to our way of life. Therefore, an audience with you and your ilk is denied. Further attempts at interactions will resort to ill tidings. Don't write again, signed Princess Celestia. This is your royal seal!"

Inspecting the letter, Celestia frowns as she replies. "I know who wrote this letter. It was a unicorn by the name of Flippant Desire of house Avarice. They were a noble clan that I disbarred for stealing from the royal treasury and selling equestrian secrets to the enemy. One of his duties was handling royal documents while I was busy with other affairs,"

"I suppose it did not matter if it was you or that stallion. The result would've been would've. Ponies skittish nature rejecting non-ponies,"

"Now you speak in conjecture! Had I known of this letter, I would have offered you an ear and worked out some negotiation. I have made great strides to turn Equestria away from those savage beginnings. If you had come, you would've been--"

"--Don't give me that!" Chrysalis cuts the Princess off. "Even if you are different from your wretched parents, can you say the same for your subjects? Would they hold your views when you are not huddling over their shoulder? How many of my changelings would've stuffed before they are treated with basic decency?"

"No, I can not force ponies to confirm my views. Doing so would take away free will - make me a tyrant - I can only stand as an example for all ponies to carry themselves,"

Chrysalis smirks as she gestures to Jason. The human glared at a hole through the Solar Princess as she did not meet his gaze. "I am sure Jason has some critiques of how wonderful an example you set, Princess. He still has so much to show,"

"You said it was your daughter. What has happened?" Queen Novo asks.

Chrysalis lets out a bitter chuckle. "The royal wedding of Princess Carance and Shining Armor happened. June Bug was a healthy nymph despite her birthing method. But she was stubborn. She argued with me constantly about trying the pony method, believing that true friendship you tote so much. Naturally, because of my experience, I forbade it. But, she would go with my plan if I did not follow some of her requests,"

"Which were?" Luna asks.

"No one comes under harm. Everyone has their memories erased after sufficient love harvesting. And, sending a note to announce our arrival,"

"Why would you knowingly declare your attack? Is that not arrogant?" Ember asks.

"Yes, but then, June Bug had a stroke of genius to the idea. Ponies generate more emotion during a stressful situations. So, with the threat against the capital made and my agents soothing the masses, the emotional harvest would've kept my changeling fed for decades. But everything fell apart when you got wise to my plan, Twilight,"

"The fault all your own. You treated every pony like dirt. Then, you sent me to the cravens with Cadance. If you had been nicer or left me alone, I would not have freed Cadance!" Twilight said.

Chrysalis sucks her teeth. "You try being around the creatures that killed your mother and stay civil. I had to remove you since you proved troublesome. Just be glad I loved my daughter more than I hated you, ponies. My original plans were far messier. Especially for you, Cadenza. But my daughter was so insistent on her plan. Right up to the moment, you blasted us from Canterlot," Another bitter chuckle leaves Chrysalis as creatures display sadness. "You know, you would think that your barrier of love would strengthen us instead of blowing us away. The funny thing is that it did,"

"It did?" Shining Armor asks nervously.

"Yes, you dullard! While the kinetic force of the spell pushed us away, it was still love-infused magic. But that did not matter in the end. That much love all at once without proper increments is like feeding a starving, malnourished creature a fast food buffet. Most of my drones died of sensory overload before they hit the ground…."

A sudden and horrible realization hits Cadance like a freight train. "You mean the other drones—"

"…" The changeling queen remains silent as Chrysalis shows the memory to everyone. She was the first to hit the ground. Her limbs broke apart upon impact, and the chitin around her torso cracked. Despite these injuries, Chrysalis slowly heals. Her features are one of pain and anger.

"Gah! Insolent prey. I will - Ah - I will be back!" A shadow looms over the downed Queen as she looks back up. There was a heavy thud and sickening splat as Chrysalis saw several of her drones crash against the ground Blood and viscera shot out in every direction as she watched her hive die. "N-No. No!!!" Chrysalis could only watch as my body fell. A particularly harsh impact lands right next to Chrysalis. The dust settles as Chrysalis feels all the color drain from her being. There, her daughter June Bug lay with a jagged, sharp stone piercing from her bin through her left eye socket. The vision was lost while blood oozed from the wound. Her right gaze was unfocused, with tears streaming down her cheek. Chrysalis hobbled to her daughter as best as she could. She stumbles and falls next to her daughter's face as she gently caresses it.

*Gurgle*

Chrysalis choked back a sob at the pitiful sound her daughter was making. There was no saving her. With tears streaming from her eyes, Chrysalis taps her horn against June Bug and the noises she is making. The memory ends with Chrysalis softly crying while holding her deceased daughter, glaring into the space toward Canterlot. "...I'm sorry..." Cadance said after a moment of silence. "I didn't mean to - I wanted you gone for ruining my wedding and attempting to steal Shining. But, I'd never wished that on a mother..."

"Don't be too quick to lay your sympathies, dear. What happened was a tragedy, yes. But you still attacked another nation's capital with an army. Casualties in any conflict of that scale are bound to happen," Shining Armor said.

"Well, what was the alternative when someone is desperate?" Jason suddenly said. "Can anyone here - who saw what happened to Chrysalis's mother - feel safe enough to open negotiations?"

No one had a rebutal. "You ponies and your skittish nature and tribalist tendencies leave no room for negotiation. I suppose I should've tried peace again, but at what risk? Are you and your kind any different from a thousand years ago? How can you ask me to let go of my hatred when you all cling to your fear and distrust?" Chrysalis said before gesturing to Jason. "Meeting Jason has only reinforced my opinion that you are as villainous as I could ever be!"

"Since the beginning of this trial, you two have come up in many conversations and speculation about your relationship. Cadance posed the question earlier. Now, it is time you expand upon that; how did you and Jason meet?"

Chrysalis walks back to the Gjallarhorn. A new memory plays out with Jason running through the Everfree Forest. From his panicked expression, everyone assumed that one of the creatures native to the forest was chasing him. However, as Jason stopped to catch his breath, nothing was behind him. Collapsing on his knees, Jason stares intently at the ground. The court saw Jason looking the worst he's ever been so far. A tattered and ripped-up cloak covered his malnourished-looking frame. The same scarring over his blind eye looked more recent. However, a new addition the court participants missed gave everyone pause. An angry red indention formed a perfect circle around Jason's neck. The human in the memory was not bothered by this newest scar. He idly traced it with his fingertips before rustling in the bush caught his attention. Spotting the scrub, several more rustles went off. However, Jason made no move to hide. Instead, he sighed and waited.

"Not my first choice, but I won't complain..."

The rustling continued until several changelings emerged from the bushes, with Chrysalis closely following them. "The emotional spike is here, my queen," A drone said.

"There's nothing here," Chrysalis said. Chrysalis notices Jason kneeling in front of her as she recoils. "Expect the unusual wildlife,"

"My queen!" The drone alerted with his horn glowing. "The emotions are coming from this creature!"

Chrysalis arches a brow and approaches with her magic active. Taken aback, Chrysalis began to stalk around Jason's form. "Interesting. These emotions you exhibit. They are far too complex to be from the average wild beast. Despair. Depression. Anguish. And little sprinkles of rage. Well, more than a little sprinkle. The emotion was enough to alert nearly all my sentries around Equestria from potency alone. But, I've never seen a creature such as yourself. What are you?"

"...Does it matter?" Jason asked.

Confusion forms on the gather changelings group. "The queen has given you an order, creature!" One of the drones hissed.

"Well, you didn't call me a freak. You are already better than them. And, Chrysalis asked a question, not gave me an order,"

"You know me? And who are they? I imagine from your sorry state that you escaped from somewhere unsavory. Are you an exotic pet? A new zoo exhibit, perhaps?" Chrysalis asks.

"As I said, it doesn't matter. I might as well be an ant the world likes to step on. What's one more hoof to the list? Who am I before the great Queen of the changelings? Just do what you're going to do..."

Chrysalis arches another brow as her magic surrounds Jason. The human did not resist as she brought him closer. "Do as I wish, hmm? Since you are familiar with me and my kind. You realize that forcefully draining your emotions will render you a withered husk. There isn't a single creature alive that would want such a fate. So, is this act a strange sense of bravado for your kind?"

"Do you usually play with your food? Is that why the ponies beat you so easily? Whose the one with false bravado here?"

Chrysalis gritted her. She's gotten tired of this strange insolence. Her magical hold grew tighter as she sneered at him. "Curb your tongue! Do not think a lowly creature like you can talk down to me. I will--"

"What?! What are you going to do!?" The sudden shout made Chrysalis lose her hold. Jason fell to the floor. He got up with a glare as Chrysalis felt a sudden surge of rage flowing off of him. "Talk. Talk. Talk! That's all you fucking are! You had everything! You beat Celestia! You captured the elements! And you still fucked it up! Now, you're here in this godforsaken forest trying to scare someone who's done with everything!" Jason tore off his cloak and revealed the rest of his battered body. All the changelings recoiled in shock and disgust while Chrysalis was gawking. "Do you think you can do better than this? Huh? Do you think you're a monster? That you're evil? Let me tell you, you got nothing on the ponies! So go ahead! Find a clean spot and leave your mark. Then, for once in your life, finish the job!!!"

Chrysalis was at a loss for words. No one had spoken to her like that. No one has said anything in a tone that sounds so angry and defeated. The raw emotion from every word of the creature sent her reeling. "Ponies? Did you say ponies did this...?"

"..." Jason merely slump back to his knees, his outburst draining him of his remaining energy.

Chrysalis sucks her teeth and moves closer. She taps her horn to his head as her magic glows. There was a green flash as Jason collapsed, and Chrysalis recoiled while doing the same. The drone was by her side immediately. "My queen?"

Chrysalis immediately did not acknowledge her drone as she got on shaky hooves. ...I am fine,

"What of the creature? Should we end its suffering?"

Chrysalis at Jason's prone for a time before getting up. "No, we're taking Jason back to the hive,"

The drones exchanged a look but complied. "Yes, my queen,"

Chrysalis snapped at them when one of the drones began to drag Jason. "Stop it, you idiots! Must I do everything?" She surrounds Jason in her magic, far more gently than earlier, as she drapes him across her back. We are returning to the hive now. I want a room thoroughly clean. And prepare some suitable food for our guest here. I expect you to treat him like he was another ling amongst the hive. There will be no mention of his scars. And, you will be as cordial as possible. Understand?

"Y-yes, my queen,"

The memory ends as the changelings and the human teleported away. "As far as first impressions go, I'd say we hit it off rather well," Chrysalis said cheekily.

"I fail to see how your meeting with Chrysalis is any better than meeting Twilight. The worse you can say was she was rude. But, Chrysalis abducted you!" Rarity stated.

"Yet, she was far more courteous, kind, and generous than the elements you represent. That says a lot about you heroes when your enemies uphold your virtues. But, since you are so opinionated and sure of yourself, let's talk about you now, Rarity," Jason said as Rarity felt a foreboding chill down her spine.

The Element of Generosity

[Canterlot Judicial hall.]

Rarity trots to the center of the courtroom with determination in her eyes. She glares at Jason and Chrysalis as she speaks. "I believe I am wise to your methods. You point out our worst moments to smear us. But I am well aware of my faults. And I have no shame in revealing them if it means beating all this slander!"

Rarity places a hoof on the Gjallarhorn as several memories play for the court. "Listen, spooky eyes! Why don't you take a picture? It will last longer! On second thought, don't! I can't stand to have my picture taken in this state!"

"Oh! I left my scarf for the wedding at the boutique. Of all the things that could happen, this is the Worst. Possible. Thing!"

"Oh, this is horrible. Look at those drapes! I can't tell if they are tacky or not!"

The memories end as Rarity speaks again. "So, yes, I will freely admit that I play up the dramatics. But, I ask this court, do we all not have our little quirks? Can we not improve ourselves and strive to be better? I, for one, do not let my negative tendencies stop me from being a good pony," More memories started playing, depicting Rarity performing acts of generosity.

More acts play out, such as cutting off her tail to give to Steven Magnet. Another was when she offered to make costumes for a designer for their show. And she makes clothes for needy foals in various orphanages between Ponyville and Canterlot. And all the times she and her friends dealt with threats to Equestria. "Of course, there are the more personal challenges my friends and I face," It was confirmed as Rarity dons a detective outfit to expose a ploy to get Rainbow Dash kicked out of the Wonderbolts by Wind Rider. A different scene with Rarity applauding Fluttershy during her stint as a model where no one else would. And, the time at the Canterlo garden party where Rarity chose her Ponyville friends over Canterlot's elite.

"As you all can see. Yes, I am flawed, but that is not all I am. I believe my better qualities far outshine my worst ones,"

The gallery applauded, but it wasn't as loud as before. The gallery members were cautious about giving their full support as Jason has a counter for all of the defendant's rebuttals. The fact that Jason is applauding them supports the thought. "Very nice show. But I believe you left out some aspect of that generous personality, Miss Belle,"

Rarity narrows her eyes at Jason. "And you presume to know me better? Does that little show about our lives grant you that knowledge!?"

Jason shakes his head. "Only important key events, not every single aspect. But, from my experience, some of your negative tendencies take priority over your generosity. What I mean is that you are vain, manipulative, and greedy,"

"I beg your pardon!" Rarity shrieks in denial and outrage.

"My people have another saying; we all wear masks. The one that hides your face and the one that is your face. For the mask that hides your face. It can be a literal mask. For the latter, it can be a smile from a fair maiden. Or a reassurance that everything is fine when it's not. Princess Celestia has had thousand years to craft her mask," Celestia shifts in irritation. "You hide your true face behind your looks and charms. Just look at how you take advantage of Spike's crush on you,"

Several gasps go out as Rarity's jaw falls open. However, more gasps erupt as Spike runs to the center and shields Rarity. "D-don't listen to him, Rarity. I like you as a good friend. And I won't let you use me anymore!" Spike said with a sharp glare.

"I'm not using you, kid. I'm waking you up. Girls like her only know her to use her looks to get what she wants. Rarity has no problem stringing along others if she can benefit from it,"

"That is not true!"

"Alright, let's ask then. Rarity, are you aware of Spike's feelings for you?"

"It's as Spike said earlier. I love him as a dear and irreplaceable friend!" Rarity said.

Jason stares flatly at her. "Alright, I'll be more specific. What I mean when I say that is, are you aware that Spike loves you as more than a simple friend?"

"That is not relevant at all to the matter at hand!" Rarity stated.

"I'd say that it is!" Ember said with a low growl. "Answer the question!"

"I intend to prove all three claims I levied at you. You know about Spike's feelings - as do the other defendants - and use that to your advantage. Do you deny it?" Jason made a gesture to the Gjallarhorn. The mystical artifact gave off a low hum as if daring the unicorn to say otherwise.

Rarity bites her lip before she sighs. "...Yes, I am aware of Spike's feelings..."

The baby dragon adopts a look of surprise until a smile forms. "R-Really? Then, does that mean you..."

"I care deeply for you, Spike. But only as one would care for their little brother," Rarity turns away as Spike's smile falls off his face. "The age gap between us is simply too big,"

"In dragon years. B-But, by pony standards, I have five years until I'm of legal age!"

"Spike, I never had the heart to tell you because I didn't want to break yours,"

"So, leading him on, making him believe there was a chance was the better option?" Jason cuts in, earning a glare from Rarity. "Oh, I get it. It's easy to order someone around when they adore you. How many times did you throw flirtatious signs at Spike just so he could perform a task for you,"

"That has never been true!" Rarity denies.

"I present to the court exhibit A, Vanity," The episode of the Sonic Rain-boom plays. At first, everyone was surprised to see it was mainly about Rainbow Dash. However, Rarity's moment came when Twilight cast a spell that allowed the unicorn to fly. From there, Rarity became self-absorbed by all the praise Rarity's new wings gave her. So much so that Rarity completely disregards Rainbow Dash and the bullying she suffered. The fashionista showed Rainbow Dash up every time turn until it was the two of them left in the Young Flyers' competition.

"Look upon me, Equestria! For I am Rarity!" The memory ends with Rainbow Dash saving Rarity and the Wonderbolts after Rarity's wings burnt away in the sun.

"Is this not vanity in its purest form? You were the one to propose you support Rainbow Dash for her competition. Yet, the moment you got praise for your false wings, Rainbow became an afterthought,"

"I already apologize to Rainbow for losing myself with my wings. Everything resolved itself in the end," Rarity stated.

"Oh, so we should just gloss over the fact that three Wonderbolts nearly lost their lives trying to save a unicorn that never should have been in danger in the first place? How appalling. But, it does not stop there members of the court,"

The Gjallarhorn glows as an image of Rarity and Spike in her shop plays out. Rarity is currently working on a dress Fluttershy is modeling. "More sequence!" Spike comes skipping along with a bowl of glitter and a lovestruck face as Rarity sprinkles it on Fluttershy. "Ah! It needs more ribbon!" Spike appears behind Fluttershy while adding two ribbons. "No, less ribbon," Spike removes them. "No, wait, more ribbon!" Spike returns it as Rarity inspects the dress's helm. "Urgh! The helm is completely off. Pincushion!" Spike returns with several needles sticking out of his back a moment later.

Twilight and Pinkie walk into the frame with a look of concern for Spike. "Doesn't that hurt you?" Twilight asks.

"Thick scales. I can't feel a thing. Besides, anything is worth it to help the most beautiful pony in the world~." The memory ends with Rarity getting ecstatic to the point where she repeatedly jumps up and down in joy onto Spike's tail. The baby dragon winces at every stomp with the same lovestruck face until Twilight moves him away.

"Miss Belle, do you deny the events we just saw?" Jason asks as murmurs from the crowd go off, and a growl escapes Ember's maw.

"No, those events did happen. I recruited Fluttershy's and Spike's aid for that dress. I asked them both, and they wholeheartedly agreed," Rarity said.

"Yeah! There's nothing wrong with friends helping each other!" Spike stated.

"So, Rarity, ordering you around like a servant is fine? Rarity using you as a pincushion is fine?"

"You heard what I said. Thick scales! It did not hurt. I was the one that put them there, not her,"

"But, did Rarity show an ounce of concern? Twilight at least did that. And what about when she was jumping on your tail? You were clearly in pain there,"

"..." Spike could not find a proper retort and seethed silently.

"I tend to get swept up at the moment whenever inspiration hits. I would never intentionally harm my little Spiky-Wicky," Rarity said.

"And that's an excuse for hurting your friend? It's fine if it's not intentional. No wonder I didn't stand a chance if that's how you absentmindedly treat those you call friends. Throughout that whole memory, you paid Spike no heed. You even waved him off in a dismissive manner. Was Spike even paid for helping you with your profession? Doesn't Equestria have strict rules against foal labor?"

"Equestrian law dictates that foals under the age of fifteen are not permitted to work in any capacity," Luna recites.

"I am already past that age limit!" Spike reminded.

"In pony years, not in dragon years!" Ember stated. "Ponies may have raised you, but you are not one. So, that one had no right to use you!"

"Excellent point, Judge Ember. What's the law about other creatures/non-ponies regarding work labor?" Jason asks.

Luna did not answer right away. "Any non-pony is not eligible to apply for work themselves. They must have a third party of a pony living in equestrian. The employer must take the non-pony to an official establishment for processing. After that, the third party can determine the payout for any labor assigned,"

All the judges narrow their eyes at that law. "So, you must be an enslaved person with less pay than a pony citizen. I have other documents of incidents where non-ponies suffer unjust treatment. But I will get into that later. By Equestrian law, Miss Belle, you did not register Spike as under your employ. Hell, you had no grounds even to do so since Spike is the house of Sparkle pet,"

"Spiky-Wicky is not a pet!" Rarity shrieks.

Jason pulls out another document. "I have here a letter of adoption signed by Princess Celestia and Twilight's parents for Spike the Dragon," Luna levitates the letter and displays it for the court. "As the court can see from the writing, Princess Celestia signed over ownership of Spike the Dragon to the house of Sparkle under Canterlot Pet Emporium!" Several gasps went off as Jason continued. "I also have the documents of Spike's registration into the emporium as a stray. Now, I ask the court where Spike's birth certificate is. Where is his citizenship? Why did he have to be admitted in the system as a stray - an animal no different from a dog or a cat - in the eyes of Equestria?"

"T-That's not-- Twilight? Princess?" Spike asks.

"Spike. I didn't know," Twilight said before turning to Celestia. The Princess of the sun turns away. "Princess?"

"As a creature like a dragon, citizenship was never possible given their nomadic nature and various issues of raids in the past. Using the adoption agency was the only way to keep Spike in Equestria..." Princess Celestia stated.

"It should go without saying that Spiky-Wiky is not a pet in our eyes!" Rarity staunchly defends.

"That's funny that you keep calling him by that pet name," Jason said, earning a sneer from the unicorn. "It's just another means of you manipulating a creature that's keen on you. That brings me to Exhibit B: Manipulation." The memory of Fluttershy facing the dragon returns. "I want to bring back the time the elements went to remove the sleeping dragon. As we can see here, Miss Belle enters the cave after Twilight's failed attempt. She begins talking to Crimson by laying on the 'pony charm,' as she calls it. At the same time, we see Rarity taking pieces of Crimson's hoard on her person. I do not doubt that if she convinced the dragon to leave, the treasure hoard would've vanished without a trace!"

"Ah, haha..." Rarity laughs nervously, unable to deny what was evident.

"Crimson isn't the only dragon Rarity lays on the pony charm,"

Another memory plays from the Gjallarhorn. "Spike! You got to stall Twilight! Whatever you do, don't let her come home!" Rarity asks.

"Like forever? But she lives here," Spike says.

"Oh, well, maybe you can manage until sunset-sh," She ends her sentence while fluttering her eyelash in a flirting manner.

"Anything for you, Rarity~,"

"Ah, yes, the fluttering eyelashes. Always a favorite for the prissy types," Chrysalis said, imitating Rarity's blinking. "Who knew the element of generosity was such a seductress,"

"That isn't true!" Rarity denies.

"Then, what do you call this?" Jason said as another memory played.

Spike is coming down the stairs of the Library with a gem. It was no ordinary jewel as it was bright red and shaped like a heart. When Twilight inquires, Spike explains that it was a fire ruby he had been cultivating for months. It was a birthday present to himself as a snack until Rarity entered the Library.

"Hellooo. Twilight? Is anypony home?" Rarity gasps as she spies Spike with his gem. "Is that a fire ruby?! That must be twenty carrots! No inclusions. New facets!"

"And, totally delicious!" Spike said.

"Uh, you guys don't mind?" Twilight asks in irritation.

"Oh, sorry, dear. I came by to see if you have any books on historical fashion," Rarity begins to walk away before questioning Spike. "Did you say delicious?"

"Sure did. Next week is my birthday. And this is my birthday dinner," Spike said.

The memory shows Rarity reading her book, but her attention keeps returning to Spike and his Ruby. "I hope it is as tasty as it is beautiful, Spike. I've never seen anything quite so stunning before,"

Spike looks at his Ruby as Rarity paws at the ground. "Gosh, you like it, huh?"

"Like it? It's magnificent~," Rarity, in the memory, made another show of flicking her mane and fluttering her eyelashes.

The effect causes Spike to sigh as he hands Rarity his Ruby. "Then, you should have it. This beautiful gem should be with you, Rarity,"

Rarity takes the jewel in her magic while prancing around happily. "I don't know what to say. What a thoughtful gesture. Thank you, Spike. Mmwuh~," The memory ends with Rarity kissing Spike on the cheek as the dragon goes stiff and faints.

"It looks like we also have an early example of your greed. Don't you feel any shame using your charms to con Spike out of his Ruby that he spent time nursing? And all he gets is a kiss on the cheek?" Jason said in an accusatory tone.

"N-No. It wasn't like--"

Rarity started, but Jason cut her off. "Then, what was it like!? You heard Spike say he was saving that Ruby for his birthday! He found and was entitled to it, but your greed prevented him from having it. You can find gems on your own; why take Spike's? Because you knew if you laid on the charms knowing Spike wouldn't refuse you,"

"I-I still could've said no. It's not Rarity's fault for liking the same gems I do!" Spike defends.

A sudden slam got everyone's attention as Ember stood up, flaring her wings. "It's more than that, Spike. Don't you realize what you did?" She moves to the center of the room while glaring a hole through Rarity. "Fire Ruby is a special jewel because of their rare and elusiveness nature. Do you know why?"

"Um, why?" Rarity asks cautiously.

"Because a dragon's essence cultivates it. Our ambient magic allows it to grow anywhere near the dragon's location. That makes it easy for the dragon to find. In the dragon's possession, it gains more of our essence the longer we keep it. Yes, it makes for a tasty snack. But, more importantly, dragons use it as a sign of love! We present it to a mate we find desirable. What Spike did was basically like giving you his heart. Hence the shape of it! But it's also dangerous because rejecting a fire ruby can cause the dragon to go into a deep depression. Or, taking it and not giving your love back makes the dragon subservient to you!"

Now, it was the defendant's turn to gasp. "Subservient?"

Anger and contempt began forming on the Dragonlord's features. "It means he can't say no to you. He'll always yearn for you and no one else! Where is it? The only way to break the effects is to give it back!"

"Oh, well, I - um - sold it..." Rarity taps her hoof together nervously.

"You got rid of it?" Spike asks in a heartbroken tone.

"It was a slow season when I did it. I needed the extra bits to support my boutiques. Surely, the effects of the gem are exaggerated?"

"It could take years to get over the feelings he gave to you!" Ember shouts.

"So, you took Spike's heart, his kindness, generosity, and love for yourself just to throw it away at a moment of convenience," Jason summarizes.

"No, none of us knew that was the case. Dragon culture is still a mystery to us," Twilight spoke up.

"I find it shocking that a studious mare like yourself would leave such a glaring gap in knowledge. Especially for one so close as their supposed brother," Chrysalis taunts.

"That was one of the purposes of my new school. To learn about a friend's culture and how to respect it!"

"Spike's been with your family since you hatched him. And you are telling us that you are only now seeking knowledge about his kind?" Jason counters. Twilight shrinks away from the judgemental stares of the judges. "I guess it's better late than never. But it doesn't stop there, does it, Miss Belle? I call the court's attention to Exhibit C: Greed. For this, I have two more witnesses..."

The doors open, and two creatures walk inside. One was a diamond dog the same height as Celestia. He had black and brown fur with a maroon vest. Jason noted that he reminds him of a Doberman dog in appearance. The other was a pony that sparked several whispers going off. He was as tall as Big Macintosh except with all-white fur. There were black cufflinks and a red rose to rest on his chest. And his voluminous blonde mane bounces regally with his every step. Princess Celestia's eyes widened at his appearance as she spoke his name.

"Prince Blueblood?!"

"What!?" Rarity shrieks.

"Hello, aunty. And, good day, assorted members of Canterlot,"

"Bluey?! You are speaking as a witness for the plaintiffs?" Cadance asks in shock.

"Yes, dear cousin, and you are acting as a judge. Must we state such apparent positions?"

"You-You can not be serious! Why is he here? What possible thing could the worst Royal pony in Canterlot can say against my character!?" Rarity said with a stamp of her hoof.

"We can say plenty," The Diamond dog said gruffly.

"Who are you?"

"Yes, please state your name and occupation for the court," Jasons asks.

"I am Bark Hide. I am the alpha of the Diamond dog pack off the edge of Ponyville,"

"And I am Prince Blueblood. Fifteenth heir to clan Blueblood. Nephew to Princess Celestia herself. And, sixth in line to the throne," Blueblood said with a bow.

"It is surprising to see you are speaking against the defendant, nephew," Luna's tone was icy as her threat.

"But, of course, aunty Luna. Sorry, Judge Luna. When I heard this creature's story of abuse and suffering at the hands of our very defenders, I had to act to improve Equestria's good image!"

"And, this stance you are taking now is in no way fueled by your grievances against Twilight and her friends?" Celestia asks in an accusatory tone.

"Aunty. Your opinion means the world to many. But, even you can see that elevating a lowborn noble clan to your heir was a lapse in judgment. I am sure Mister Jason has regaled his treatment at the hands of Miss Sparkle and her compatriots. As a prince, I cannot let such cruelty go unpunished. We--"

"Can we get on with this?" Bark said impatiently.

"Well, I never. Very well. My meeting with Miss Belle at the Grand Galloping Gala shall be a cautionary tale for all eligible bachelors. Behind those admittedly dashing looks," Rarity cuffs her mane at the praise before cringing at the rest of Blueblood's sentence. "Is a pony the young foals would call a coquette,"

"WHAT!?"Rarity shrieks. The courtroom erupts into gasps and conversations.

"Order! Order, I say! That is no small claim to label, nephew," Luna warns.

"I am aware of the implication, Judge Luna. And I give them for a good reason. Rarity is the same as many other unsavory mares in my life. The ones that look at me and see a crown, a title, and prestige. A means to elevate themselves to royal status. She approached me like a timberwolf in luxurious garments. She blinks at me with her mesmerizing eyes while whispering honeyed words. But it is not the stallion she wanted, but his expansive wealth,"

Blueblood turned out to be just as dramatic as Rarity in his recounting. Soon, the fashionista had enough. "That's it. I won't stand for this! You dare accuse me of such lies. Well, I see right through you!" Rarity marches to the Gjallarhorn show on the night of the Grand Galloping Gala. The memory plays out with Rarity meeting the Prince in the garden. Rarity gestures to the rose, expecting the Prince to adorn it to her person. Instead, he fixes it to his clothing. The night continued with the Prince shattering every expectation Rarity envisioned. Moments like the Prince hogging the pillow for himself, urging Rarity to use her cloak to walk over a puddle, having Rarity pay for the food he instantly found disgusting, and making her open doors for him. Finally, everything fell apart when a flying cake hit Rarity's body after the Prince used her for a shield.

"Urgh! You, sir, are the most uncharming Prince I've ever met! The only thing royal about you is that you are a royal pain!!!" Rarity shrieks.

"Ew! Get Away! I just had myself groomed!!!"

"Afraid to get yourself dirty?!" Rarity shakes herself violently, launching the remaining cake all over the Prince, who topples over and ends the memory.

"Do you all see? This stallion is the furthest thing from a Prince you could get! He is uncouth! Selfish. And a worse diva than I could hope to be. And you call me a fence squatter!"

"And since when am I under any obligation to cater to the whims of a mare after my status? All you have seen was a creative act and the perfect method for dealing with coquettes. Did you honestly believe you were the only pony approaching me that night? I've had many letters leading up to the Gala from mares with the same desire as yours," Blueblood's horn glows as he produces said letters for the judges.

Cadance sighs as she reads a few. "You might be right about these letters, Bluey. But your method was not becoming, and it was downright humiliating for everypony involved,"

Prince Blueblood, however, adjusts his mane as he turns to Jason. "Mister Wright. Would you kindly show the court what else happened that night,"

"I'll do you one better and show why your claim and mine are true. This next episode is called ticket master," Jason said, touching the horn.

A new memory plays with Twilight receiving tickets to the Gala. All elements state their reason for the Gala and why they should go. Then, it came up to Rarity. "I have designed dresses for the Gala for years. But I never had the opportunity to go there. Oh, the society, the culture, the glamor. It's where I truly belong. And it's where I will meet him,"

"Him?" Pinkie and Twilight ask.

"Yes, him, my Prince charming. I would stroll through the Gala, and everyone would wonder, who is that mysterious mare? They would never guess I was a simple pony from little old Ponyville. The sensation I would cause would allow me to be invited to an audience with Princess Celestia herself. My style and elegance would so take her that she would introduce me to her nephew, Prince Blueblood—the most handsome eligible unicorn stallion in Canterlot. Our eyes would meet, our hearts would melt, and our courtship would be magnificent. He would ask for my hoof in marriage, and I would say yes. Then, we would have a royal wedding befitting a Princess, which is what I will become upon marrying him. The stallion of my dreams~,"

Rarity loses vigor as she backs away from the Prince, "Hmm, I believe that proves merit to my claim and yours, Mister Wright," Blueblood stated.

Now, the whispers were thoroughly against Rarity. "W-Wait. That was just a filly hood crush! At some point in their lives, every mare would have the same aspirations," Rarity stated.

"Honestly, Miss Belle, accept your defeat gracefully. It is most unbecoming. No, that is what I expect from your ramble. Mister Wright, please show the court the rest of that evening," Jason obliges and shows the events of the season one finale, where the elements' actions led to the destruction of the Gala ballroom. "As you can see, members of the court, the Princess of friendships little group, are far from the heroes they pretend to be. Just look at the destruction of the ballroom and the Gala. Who do you think had to pay for such a travesty?" Many galleries were now throwing questionable gazes and narrowed eyes at the elements. "I love you, Aunty Celestia. But putting your stock in these six was simply a mistake. One I hope this court will rectify. Ah, it feels good to perform my civic duty. I bid you all goodbye,"

Blueblood proceeds to exit while Rarity slumps on her haunches. She turned to the last witness, who was openly glaring at her. "Mister Bark Hide. You seem to have some grievances to share. What has the defendant done to earn your ire?" Luna asks.

"They stole from the pack!"

"Stole? What did they steal from you?" Cadance asks.

"Our gems! You ponies invaded our territory. Took our precious gems!"

"Wait, you mean you are the leader of those diamond dogs that foalnapped me!" Rarity stated.

"They didn't foalnapped you. You were in our land. You trespassed!"

"I was looking for gems. That is not a crime! I've always gone east of Ponyville to farm for gems!"

"I believe we are getting ahead of ourselves," Jason said. "For clarification, Bark Hide leads the Diamond dog pack that resides in the rocky fields where the defendant said,"

"And you foalnapped Miss Rarity - an element bearer - because she was trespassing?" Luna asks.

"It was not a foal napping, Judge," Jason corrects.

"Of course it was! They took me into their burrows and made me work in horrid conditions, farming their gems!" Rarity said a matter of factly. The fashionista returns to the Gjallarhorn and displays the moment the diamond dogs capture her. From there, everything played out as Jason had seen from the episode, with Rarity whining and complaining to get the dogs to release her and surrender a sizable portion of their gems. "See? Your pack accosted Spike and I while forcing me to mine their gems. And they called me a mule!"

"Yes, as it was their right to deal out a proper punishment for your crimes," Jason said.

"What possible crimes could I commit against Diamond Dogs? They have no standing kingdom! They are more nomadic than the dragons!"

"Actually. The diamond dogs did have a functioning kingdom several hundred years back. I can attest to this as much I believe our dear Princesses can," Chrysalis said. "No one knows why the kingdom fell. I have some speculate, but nothing concrete or noteworthy to the trial,"

"However, the diamond dogs do have stock on the land," Jason pulls out another paper. "This is a letter from Princess Celestia recognizing Bark Hide's pack's claim to the rocky fields at the edge of Ponyville. Bark Hide's great-ancestor petitioned a few years ago,"

"But diamond dogs are not smart enough to do something like that!" Rarity winces at her phrasing, sounding too insensitive.

"Not all dogs are dumb. My family wasn't. The burrow was good. And my ancestor wanted to keep it. Keep our pack from wandering into danger. So, he went to Princess pony to get the deed," Bark Hide said. "We set up rules and gave them to the neighboring ponies,"

"Each Mayor of each generation had these rules renewed. For some strange reason, when Bark went to complain about all the ponies invading and taking their gems to the current Mayor, he was chased out by the local guard," Jason said, picking two pieces of paper. "I have an invoice from Mayor Mares's office. What's on it is a list of damages. Ponyville is disaster-prone, after all. The second document is a letter Mayor sent to outside contractors to mine in diamond dog territory. Normally, if any ponies wanted to operate in Bark's territory, they would engage in some trade. But, with Bark effectively banned from Ponyville, the ponies can trespass with impunity. Thus, going against Princess Celestia's decree,"

"And you, whiney pony, constantly steal from us!" Bark snarls. "Our rules are simple if you trespass and take our gems. You work off a debt to the pack. Time spent working is measured by how many gems you took—one cart equals one week of work. You and your pony friends took six carts. That's six weeks of work. But you have been taking multiple carts for years!"

"But, what about those three that captured me? Those dogs said they would make me work for them forever!" Rarity said.

"I was away on a hunt. Those dogs I left in charge while I was gone. I told them the rules, but they were not smart. I would've fixed everything when I got back. But you were gone with all our gems!"

"And, if we tally up the crimes you continued to commit until now. It would be trespassing—multiple counts of grand theft. Evasion of punishment. And the invasion of foreign territory without cause. You and the other defendants practically caused an international incident," Jason finished.

"Diamond dogs demand all of our gems returned to us!" Bark Hide snarls.

Luna rubs the temples of her head, trying to dispel the growing headache, before responding. "...Very well. The crown will hear from Bark Hide's pack and discuss suitable compensation for their losses,"

Bark Hide nods and turns to leave. Jason surveys the courtroom. The gallery all whisper harsh criticism about Rarity and, by extension, the defendant bench. Most of the judges sent disapproving glares at the elements. However, Cadance shows a deep concern with how the trial is going. And Luna was a picture of irritation and fatigue. The defendants themselves were looking more run down with each testimony. Fluttershy was still catatonic from losing her cutie mark. Pinkie Pie was by her side. She would send some sad glances toward Jason, which he promptly turned away. Applejack was hard to read as her hat was covering her features. Rainbow Dash was looking angrier with each passing second. Twilight's mane began to gain split ends from all the stress. And Princess Celestia held a tight stoic expression. But the sharp flick of her tail told Jason she was also angry, but not at him. Finally, Rarity was looking lost. She looks around the courthouse for any sympathy but finds none. Now, it was time for the nail in the coffin.

"You know, Miss Belle, I have another claim against you. It stemmed from when I came to you one rainy night. Ugliness,"

The Gjallarhorn glows again as a rain image displays. Jason's ragged form treks, holding his shoulders and shivering from the cold. He looks up to see the carousel boutique and spots Rarity throwing out some trash before returning inside. Jason quickens his pace. He makes it to the door and knocks at it. However, Sweetie Belle is the one to answer.

"Um, who are you? We're closed right now. You'll have to come back in the morning,"

"I-I know," Jason shivers. "I just would like to speak to your sister, please,"

Sweetie stares at Jason in confusion, trying to see past the hood covering his face. "Okay, I'll get her. Do you want to come inside and warm up?"

"T-Thank you," Jason said sincerely.

Sweetie allows Jason inside. She guides him to one of the chairs and lets him sit. "I know just the thing to help me whenever I am cold—some good old hot chocolate. I'll make you some. Oh, yeah. Rarity, we have company. Somepony needs to talk to you,"

"I'm on my way, Sweetie. Just give me a few seconds," Raity calls out from upstairs.

Jason sits alone and smiles for the first time in weeks. "I knew I could count on your generosity. Finally, something is going right,"

Sweetie comes back with a cup of chocolate, just as promised. "Here you go. Don't worry. It's not burnt. I've been practicing,"

Jason lets out a weak chuckle while looking at the clear brown liquid. "Y-You did a good job,"

Just as Jason was about to take a slip, Rarity came downstairs. "Now, Sweetie, who is it you said was visiting-- WAAH!?! Sweetie! Get away from that thing!!!"

Rarity's magic flares out as she flips Jason's cup into his face. "AAAH!?" Jason screams from the sting of the hot choco. He falls to his knees and feels several items strike against his body.

"You brute. You horrid, disgusting, filthy monster! How dare you come into my home! You were trying to take my sister, weren't you?!"

"No, stop! Please!"

"Rarity!" Sweetie calls to her sister.

Rarity stops her assault long enough to check on her sister. "Oh, my poor Sweetie Belle. What has that thing done to you? It's okay. Your big sister will protect you,"

Sweetie looks back to Jason, who struggles to protect himself. "But, he--"

"It's okay. I won't let that brute harm a hair on your mane," Rarity turns back to Jason with the most hateful glare he'd ever thought a pony could make. "You vile contemptible fiend! Have you no shame? Traumatizing my sister with your wretchedness!"

"W-Wait. Please. I only came for some clothes. Please, it's freezing out," Jason begs, but his pleas fall on deaf ears.

"You'd honestly think I'd waste a single stitch of clothing on your putrid hide. I would sooner sully my brand-making clothes for a mule before entertaining such lunacy! Get out! Get out and don't come!!!"

Rarity throws more items with renewed vigor. This action prompted Jason to hurry out of Rarity's boutique. The memory ends with Jason stumbling out of sight, still reeling from the hot choco to the face. Once again, no one spoke in the courtroom. "Ah, what a beautiful face for one so fair as yourself," Jason said sarcastically. "You know, in an ironic twist, the hot choco to the face did warm me up,"

"N-no. That-- I wouldn't. That was not me!" Rarity cries.

"That is you. That was the mask coming off and your true face and nature coming to the surface," Jason chuckles as he shakes his head. "A filly. A tiny child showed me generosity with two mere acts than you ever did. It must be a cruel twist of fate that such a good pony is related to you. I thought you were generous. I thought you saw beauty in everything,"

"Rarity?" Spike calls out. Rarity looks at him with tears threatening to spill. "Tell me you didn't do that. Please!"

"No, Spiky. It wasn't me. You know me. You know I am generous..." The Gjallarhorn glows as magic from Rarity now. She strumbled much like the others did before her eyes went wide. "...I did. Sweet Celestia, I did do that!"

"Yes, it appears so!" Luna said with a deep frown.

"Princess. Please, I am--"

Luna cuts her off before Rarity can finish. "I believe we have heard enough for today. The court will reconvene tomorrow!" Luna bangs the gavel harder this time as she and the others leave.

Many of the court members also glared at the fashionista as they left. "Wait. Wait! I can explain! Please!" Rarity cried, but no one would heed her. Rarity and Spike share a glance as she smiles through her running mascara. "Spiky-Wiky. Y-You, believe me, right?"

"..." Spike could not find the words. Tears swell up in Spike's eyes before he bows his head and turns away from his crush.

The Unrest

[Ponyville - Sugarcube Corner.]

Mr. Cake sits at the counter, looking burnt out. Since Pinkie had been up in Canterlot for a few days, business duties were starting to overflow. While Pinkie may be overbearing at times, she has a good work ethic. She was getting a raise when she got back. However, Mr. Cake could hear the whisper in the town. Ponies were getting more and more anxious as this trial went onward. It did not help that some of those whispers were about him. Who would ever think one of the owners of the best pastry shop had such a nasty side to him? Mr. Cake shook his head and saw the garbage overflowing.

"Honeybunch, I'm taking out the trash,"

"Okay, please hurry. I need somepony at the register managing the customers," Mrs. Cake calls out.

"Sure thing," Mr. Cake takes the trash around the shop and into the dumpster. However, after turning back, a small pegasus filly with a curly light blue mane and pink fur. She smiles up adorable to Mr. Cake while waving. "Oh, hello, little one. Are you lost?"

"No, sir. I was wondering if you are the owner of this shop?" The filly asks.

"That I am, little miss. But, I am afraid that taking orders from the trash is a health violation. Why don't we go back inside and start there,"

"That's okay. I only wanted to ask a question,"

"Alright, go ahead,"

"Is trash valuable?"

"I beg your pardon?"

"Trash. Garbage. The things we throw away when we don't need them anymore or when it breaks. Is that valuable?"

Mr. Cake looks at the filly with confusion but answers anyway. "I suppose not. Otherwise, we would not throw out it anyway,"

"And, is trash still your property if you decide you don't want it and put it out for somepony else to collect?"

"No, once it's in the bin, the town or government sorts it out by recycling or proper disable. Unless some critter gets to it first,"

"What about food? If you eat something but don't finish and throw it out, can you claim it afterward? Even when weeks or months go by since you did it,"

"Well, I don't know anypony that would half eat something and want it after it's been in the trash,"

"What if that creature was desperate? What if they had no choice but to eat out of the trash? Is it right to get mad at them for their hunger?"

Mr. Cake was feeling a little nervous now. "Um, I can't say anything about that question. I've never known a pony in that situation,"

"But, you did say something on the matter, remember? When you lead that mob of ponies against that poor human. You decided that trash was valuable. You decided that something you no longer wanted wouldn't go to him. Then, you took that same trash you didn't like and used it to hurt him. That doesn't seem to make sense,"

"Now, little miss, I don't think you should be talking about this like this. It's for the big ponies to figure out,"

"But, big ponies always tell me to treat others nicely. To be good and kind to everypony. Are you saying that it only applies to ponies?"

Mr. Cake takes a step back. "No--"

"So, why did you do something you know was wrong?"

"I didn't--"

"Are you a good pony? Or do you not like non-ponies?"

"I am! I--" Mr. starts to sway back and forth as a burst of magic leaves his body. He stumbles to the ground, hitting the trash while some spills on top of him. Groaning, he stares back at the filly with wide and frightening eyes. "I-I—"

"I guess you know how he feels now. If only a little bit," Mr. Cake said nothing as he curled up and trembled in a fetal position.

"Honey? Are you okay?"

Taking that as her cue, she quickly leaves as Mrs. Cake enters the corner. "It was nice talking to you, mister,"

[Sometime later - Townhall - Mayor Mare's office.]

Mayor Mare was at her wit's end. She just got another letter from one of the store merchants refusing to sell products and rent out stalls in Ponyville anymore. Some were polite, telling her they wished to seek business elsewhere. Whereas others were blatant in their grievance, citing that they were, I'll no longer associate with xenophobic ponies. The town's revenue was starting to plummet. Mayor Mare throws the letters in a heap as she hits her head on the desk.

"Why is this happening? My perfect term is turning into shambles!"

"Mayor Mare. You have a visitor," The receptionist said.

Mayor Mare perks up this. Visitations have been steadily declining since the trial began. She straightens her tie and combs her mane. "I am ready. Send them in now,"

The doors open as a Pegasus flies into her office with saddle bags. Mayor notes her room cutie mark with curiosity as she puts on her best smile. "Hello, dear. What brings you to my office today? Are you here for permission to sell some filly scout cookies?"

"I would love to do that. But I can't. Everything seems so crazy right now. But I think you have a different problem,"

"How so?"

"Well, look at how this trial is going. Ponies are starting to leave town. It will start making it hard to do fundraisers like the filly scouts. Why do you think that is happening?"

Mayor Mare slumps on her chair and sighs. "It's all the fault of that creature. It's not just Princess Twilight and her friend's reputation, but ours by association. I've known those girls since filly hood. There's no way any of what we see is true!"

"I was wondering about that. It won't look good for anypony here when this trial is over. I mean, how did the human get so hurt and so destitute? He should've had a job even if he could not make friends. Did you give him one?"

"No, I've never seen it before,"

"But, all those places and ponies were from Ponyville. It's impossible to fake that. So, why did he look like he did not have a home? Are you sure he never came to you?"

Mayor Mare felt like she was standing at her podium facing reporters, looking for another the next scandal. "No, at least I am sure I never saw it. Something like that thing would never be in Ponyville,"

The filly frowns a little. "Why is that? Because he's different?" The filly reaches into her saddle bags and pulls out a book. She flips through the pages until she finds the section she wants. "See? It says here in the friendship memoirs - written personally by Princess Twilight and her friends - that you should never judge a book by its cover. I read this book all the time. Are you saying the Princess and her friends lied when they wrote this?"

"No! Of course not--"

"But, you said creatures like Jason shouldn't have any business in Ponyville. Is it because they are mistreated because they are different?"

"I-I didn't say those words exactly--"

"Now, I am confused. Which is it? Do you like or don't like non-ponies? Or did Jason hurt you so bad that you wouldn't give him a job?"

"No!" Mayor Mare suddenly stumbles as, much like before, magic leaves her body. Mayor Mare's eyes flutter before going wide in shock. She recalls the several times Jason walks into her office.

"Hello, I was wondering if I could apply for a job?" A healthy Jason said.

"Gah!" Mayor Mare cries out as she takes in Jason's alien form. "Sorry, I wasn't expecting any arrivals today. Um, Are you here for Princess Twilight? She's in the big castle. You can't miss it,"

"Yeah, I just came from there the other day. She was too busy, I guess. Anyway, I am in a bit of a bind with no bits. Can you help me out?"

"The Princess refused you? So, it's true..." Mayor Mare mutters softly before clearing her throat. "I am afraid I don't have any listing for you now. Please try again later,"

Jason returns a week later. His appearance was slightly worn from the last time. Seriously, there's still nothing?!

"As you can imagine, sir! The office is hectic, and we get applicants all the time. I am afraid that you are too late. You can try some other time again!" Mayor mare's attitude was far more stern than skittish this time.

A month later, a haggard and worn down Jason bowed his head at Mayor Mare's hooves. "Please. You have to have something! I'm barely getting by off scraps from the garbage. I'll work any shift you have!"

"For the last time, this is an official government building! We don't give handouts to those that cannot contribute. Leave this property immediately, or else I will summon the guards!!!"

The last word echoes continuously in Mayor Mare's head. "Oh, dear. Sweet Celestia. I sent away a creature in desperate need of help! What have I done? If he says anything about me, I'll be ruined!"

"Golly. That does sound bad. But I think I have an idea,"

Mayor Mare threw herself at the filly while pleading with her. "What?! What is it?! I'll do anything within reason!"

"It simple..." The filly reaches into her saddle again and pulls out a paper. "As it turns out, I need your permission to do this. After that, I will take care of the rest,"

Mayor Mare took the paper and quickly read through it. "You want to hold an assembly?"

"Yeah, since a lot is going on with this trial, you need to let ponies know where you stand,"

"Yes, yes! This idea could work! Thank you!"

The filly smiles as Mayor Mare signs the document. "I am just doing my part,"

[Ponyville - Cranky Doodle Residence.]

Cranky sat on his porch with a bitter grump expression. His home was just at the southwest edge of Ponyville, primarily out of everyone's sight. That suited the old donkey fine for a time. The ponies were a nuisance at best and unbearing at worst. But, the loneliness was everpresent. That is until he reconnected with Matilda. The loneliness was far away from the day he spent with her. He grabs a picture of him standing with Matilda on their wedding day.

"Oh, Mildy..."

"That's your wife?"

With the filly's sudden appearance, Cranky jumps back in fright, nearly breaking his wedding picture. "Gah!" Cranky catches his breath as he glares at the little pegasus. "Excuse me! Didn't your parents teach you any manners!"

"Oh, I am so sorry I scared you,"

"Whatever. Just get on out of here and leave me in peace!"

"Well, that's not very nice,"

"Yeah, tough. What do you ponies know about being nice? A bunch of liars - the lot of you - Liars!"

"Hmm, I can't speak about other ponies, but I know I am friendly. But you're all grumpy even though you have this beautiful home and wife. Where is she? Can I meet her?"

Cranky scowls at the filly, about to tell her off, when he stops. He looks at the photo again and sighs. "You can't. No one can see her anymore,"

"Oh..." The filly looks down before she hugs the old donkey. "I'm sorry. How did it happen?"

The scowl returns as Cranky speaks bitterly. "Ponies happened! Matilda was sick for a long time. It turns out she came looking for me to spend her last year. When she got worse, we went to the hospital only to find out that non-ponies are not eligible for treatment because we are not seen as Ponies! I couldn't get to the shaman because she lived in that dangerous forest, and Matilda could not move by then! The only reason I still have this house is that it is technically declared condemned by the Mayor's office!"

"Wow. I see why you don't like ponies very much," The two sat in silence for a time before the filly spoke again. "What if we change that? What if we make other ponies understand what they are doing is wrong!"

"Hmph! You can't change the rule if everyone likes it. And ponies do not like change!"

"Yeah, but I think a lot of things are changing regardless. Just look at the trial. That human is speaking up for creatures like him. You can do it too!"

"I'm a cantankerous old mule. I don't have any fight in me now..."

The filly flies up to Cranky's face with a look of determination. "You don't have to fight. All you have to do is stand up and speak. Just like Jason is now, speak from the heart. Speak the facts. Speak the truth! I can help you do that!"

Cranky looks between the filly and his wedding photo before gently setting it down. "Alright, what do you need me for?"

"Just follow me. We're going to Canterlot!"

[Canterlot - Sometime later - Clan of Sparkle Residence.]

Cadance was not happy. Marching the streets of Canterlot, many ponies gave her a wide berth. That is with her fine as she knew went kind of face she was making now, and she did not want to waste her anger on somepony undeserving. Shining Armor tries to keep up with her, but Cadance is walking purposefully.

"Honey, are you sure you can't take a moment to calm down?" Shining asks.

"No!" Cadance sharply said.

"But, you're freaking out the citizens,"

"I don't care. Talking to Velvet and Night Light is more important!" Cadance made it to the door of the Sparkle household. She went to knock, but Shining's aura got in the way. "Shiny!"

"Just think about what you're about to do. You want to go in there and question my parents!"

"Yes! Question them about Spike! I need to hear from them that it is false!"

"But, you saw the document. That was Celestia's seal. If you have doubts, why don't we go to her?"

"Because a lot of things said in that courtroom that only they can answer. Aunty Luna already went to speak with Aunty Celestia,"

"I just want to wake up from all this..."

Cadance puts a hoof on her husband's withers. "If there is one thing we can take from this trial, it is accepting accountability. That means no more running and making excuses!"

With that said, Shining steps aside as they both enter the home. The house was pristine as always while the two walked through. "Mom, Dad?"

"Shining? Is that you?" A voice calls out. Night Light and Twilight Velvet came from one another and smiled at their son and daughter-in-law. "How are you two? And how's my granddaughter? Let me get you some tea," The ponies move to the couch as Twilight Velvet returns to the kitchen and brings the drinks.

"She's back at the Crystal Empire," Cadance said in a no-nonsense tone. "I trust you both are aware of the trial,"

Shining's parents share a glance at the tone Cadance is using. "Yes, and it is awful what's happening," Velvet said.

"It's not right! I can't believe the Princesses let this go on for so long!" Night Light said with a snort.

"You mean about what Twilight, her friends, and all of Ponyvill did to Jason?" Cadance asks.

"What? We can't believe so many ponies are buying into these lies! Some strange creature comes from nowhere - with Chrysalis of all villains - and tries to slander the Elements. Our Twilight! It's like the whole of Equestria forgot what she did," Velvet ranted.

"Then, there is the fact that it knows all our lives. How can that not be considered espionage? What if it is watching us right now?" Night Light said.

"It is a bit creepy, Cady..." Shining Armor mutters.

Cadance spares him a glance as he chuckles nervously. "I don't fully understand how. But, I suppose it is like reading a book, only we are the main characters. There are ways to visit different worlds. Twilight tells me Discord brings mementos from different dimensions at the end of each month. However, while I was skeptical of Jason and Chrysali's partnership, some of the things we've seen are too real to be fake,"

"Because of that horn? If it's so dangerous, why does Chrysalis have it? Why not use the elements to destroy it?" Night Light asks.

"I've felt its power, and Celestia attests to it. The Gjallarhorn is real,"

"I don't care if it is real or not. I will not sway against our daughter!" Twilight Velvet stated. "We only see what that creature is showing us. We've hardly gotten Twilight's side of things. She could've been very stressed that day it came to the castle. We raised our foals right!"

Cadance's eyes narrow more at the fact Velvet and Night Light keep referring to Jason as a thing. "Did you raise Spike right?" That was the question that Cadance was building up. She was studying all of Shining's parent's reactions. So far, you can say it was except for parents to support their foals and dismiss their wrongdoings. But, at the mention of Spike, all that dogged persistence vanishes.

"Cadance," Shining said in an uncertain tone.

"What do you mean?" Night Light asks. "Of course we did!"

"Is it true that you adopted him through a pet agency? Is he even considered equal? And have you done anything to change that?"

"Cadance. I think being a judge is too stressful. Maybe--"

Velvet started, but Cadance cut her off. "What's stressful is finding out about Spike's mistreatment. He's been with Twilight every step of the way. And now, I find out that he could've sat in some cage for the rest of his life. Or that he could've been spayed or even put down! Please, I need to know that out of everything I saw in that courtroom. This one claim is wrong,"

Shining's parents share a glance before their faces become stoic. "Truth be told, I never wanted that dragon in my house," Night Light said.

"Dad?" Shining asks in surprise.

"Spike was a walking disaster waiting to happen. A fire-breathing carnivore sitting in the capital of Equestria? How could Princess Celestia want that?"

"We always read about the raids. The details of how villages and their citizens getting burned to a crisp or eaten alive were horrifying!" Velvet said with a shudder.

"But, why did you take Spike in with us?" Shining asks.

"You don't simply say no when the Princess herself gives you an opportunity. It was for both of your futures that we indulged in this project. We already knew that when Twilight passed the exam, Celestia chose her as her successor. So, maybe taming a dragon was a test. Albeit a dangerous one," Night Light said.

"You two have no idea what it was like knowing we could end up as lunch if we turned away from him. Sure, I tried to wean him away from any meat. But I often caught Spike chewing on birds or mice! He even maimed the neighbor's dog. That hush money came out of my book sale that year. The gems were a good alternative. But, even the cheapest gemstones were starting to cut into the budget. Then, the fire-breathing started. The Princess had to relocate us twice for fire damage!" Velvet said as she began to shudder. "Sometimes, he would sneak into our room and stare at us while we slept,"

Cadance slumps into her seat as her mouth hangs open. "Sweet maker above. It's true. You don't love Spike,"

"Honestly, love is a strong word. But, we are fond of him and how he turned out. Twilight's influence did wonders--"

Cadance shoots up from her seat as she glares at her inlaws. "HOW?! How did growing up loveless help Spike? Was it making him a doormat? Was it being a servant or a pet? No wonder Spike has confidence issues. He can't do anything beyond writing a letter, breathing fire, and eating gems! Who knows what depriving him of essential proteins did to his biological growth? Never mind his ability to interact with others. He's worse than Twilight in some aspects!"

"Cadance, try and calm down," Velvet asks.

"I have no intention of calming down! All the years, I foal-sat for Twilight and Spike. I thought there was love for every creature, not just the ponies!"

"I don't see the issue here. Spike got the best deal any of his kind could want. For a lot of good, it did. We got a letter from Twilight about Spike becoming a giant rampaging adult dragon that destroyed half of Ponyville. How can a baby grow like that from just having a few items? It's not natural. If that had happened here, then ponies would be hollering for him to be put down," Night Light stated.

"Spike's greed growth was due to the ignorance - from us - of his dragon nature, not Spike himself! Ponies are not the moral authority on how any creature should act. If anything, after what I saw, we are the ones that have a lot to learn!" Cadance stood up and walked away. Shining, looking downcast, quickly follows after his wife. "I am going to take Spike somewhere he can be free to be himself, not a water down parody of a dragon!"

"Doing that would effectively be stealing our property, Cadance!" Night Light said.

Shining looks at his father in shock as Cadance sends one last glare before leaving. "Then, I guess we'll see you in court," Shining said with a heavy heart, walking out while the door shut.

[Canterlot - Maretplace.]

Rarity was running through the streets of Canterlot while frantically looking and calling for her friend. "Spike! Spiky Wiky! Oh, where are you? Has anypony seen a purple and green baby dragon anywhere?"

"..." Rarity received nothing but judgemental gazes and harsh whispers.

"Oh, this is worst than I thought. No one seems very helpful today,"

"I can't imagine why, sugar cube," Applejack stated.

"This is hardly the time for snide undertones, Applejack!"

"If I were Spike, I would not want to see the mare who broke my heart!"

"I did nothing of the sort!"

"That is not what we saw!"

"Um, girls," Fluttershy spoke for the first time since her questioning.

"Don't sit here pretend you all did not see Spike fawn over me. You all could've put a stop to it at any time!" Rarity said.

"Yeah, we all saw it. But it wasn't our place to say a thing when you pulled Spike's strings!" Rainbow added.

"Girls, we're making a scene," Fluttershy mutters again.

"And what about the rest of you, hmm? What about all your pranks? Or, telling Spike, he's not a real dragon! What about all the favors on the farm did you ask him to perform? What about all those letters and book organizing you made Spike do?" Rarity said.

"Girls!" Fluttershy said a little louder this time.

"I never had Spike lug all my shopping bags like a pack mule!" Applejack shot back.

"And I only ever did some light prank and teasing. It was not that bad," Rainbow said.

"You once had Spike hiccuping for an entire day because of a prank!" Twilight stated.

"Better than going through five reshelving and list checks a week!"

" GIRLS!!!" Fluttershy shouts, gesturing to the crowd's attention on their group. "I think what's important right now is checking on Spike, not throwing blame around,"

"She right! Where would Spike go in Canterlot when he is feeling down?" Twilights ask.

"Donut joes!" Twilight's horn glowed, and the elements vanished from the market and reappeared before Donut Joe's shop. However, the girls saw that there were two guards outside. "Um, excuse me. Why are you two stationed here?"

"Security assurance, your highness. Nopony gets inside the establishment without a magical background check," The guard said.

"Well, this is an emergency! Our friend is troubled and needs our help," Rarity said. She starts to move past the guards. But, they bar her path with their spears. "What do you think you are doing?!"

"Nopony gets past without a background check. Failure to comply will result in confinement!"

"Right, the recent developments allow ponies to carry out these checks to see who is a changeling. There hasn't been much success, if at all," Twilight informs.

"Then what's the point?" Rainbow asks.

"Ponies are less incline to panic this way," The other guard said.

"It's better if we comply, girls. No sense in causing a bigger scene," Twilight said.

"B-But, we're the elements!" Rarity cried out.

"All the more reason to confirm you are who you say you are," The guard on the left said.

The elements perform the check and enter the shop. Rarity searches for Spike. However, he was nowhere inside. Seeing Donut Joe at the counter, She rushes to the stallion. "Joe! Please tell me you know where Spike is!"

Joe frowns as he addresses her. "I am sorry, Miss Rarity. But Spike is no longer able to visit the store,"

"What?!" The girls exclaimed.

"Why? Spike and I have always come around the shop all the time. We're your best customers," Twilight said.

"The rule is obvious. No pets. And, since the royal guard is cracking down heavily on the procedure. My hooves are tied on this," Joe said.

"But, Spike's has come here plenty of times alone!"

The other elements also voice their displeasure at the sudden betrayal while Joe's frown grows more profound. He suddenly slams the glass he was cleaning on the counter. "If you want somepony to blame for Spike's predicament, blame your parents for signing those papers. Blame Celestia for making that law and never bothering to change it. It's a shame that a good kid like Spike gets the raw end of the deal because of the ponies that should love him. You know what? The shop is closed for the rest of the day!"

Joe knew better than to kick out a Princess. Instead, he put a close sign on the counter and went in the back. The elements got the message and left. "Oh, now what? Where else could Spiky-Wiky be?"

Twilight sighs as she looks at Rarity. "The next place I could think of would be Canterlot Memorial Park. Our parents would take us there every other weekend to relax,"

"Then, let us hurry!" The elements began walking toward the park.

"I still don't think we should be bothering the little guy right now," Applejack said. "Sometimes when Big mac and I get into a spit, Granny boots us out the house and separates us until the heat dies down,"

"Applejack, you should know Spike is more fragile than that. He is a baby still,"

"Oh, so now he's a baby with sensitive feelings. That didn't stop you from using him before!" Pinkie said.

"Pinkie. I am merely saying that because of that look Spike gave us at the end of the trial!"

"What? The look of having you heartbroken or the fact that his great crush is a monster," Fluttershy said to the shock of everyone.

"F-Fluttershy?"

"No, Rarity. I can't keep defending and dismissing our actions anymore. Not after what I saw,"

"Are you talking about when you used your stare?" Twilight asks.

"I still owe that jerk a flank-kicking for that!" Rainbow growls.

"No! We are the ones that need a flank-kicking! All of us. We've done some horrible things. Things that other creatures would call us villains for, undoubtedly!"

"Fluttershy! You're not making sense!" Rarity said.

"No, I am seeing things clearly for the first time in a long time. Three years too late. We deserve everything that Jason is doing,"

The other elements were at a loss for words until Pinkie responded. "...You saw what we did, didn't you?"

Fluttershy closes her eyes with a shudder but nods. "It-it's so bad that I don't think I can repeat. All I know is that the worst is still to come. And, if being an element of harmony means anything to you girls, we should accept our punishment,"

"Are you crazy? Why are you giving up, Flutters? We always got through worse things before this!" Rainbow said.

Twilight moves to Fluttershy and rests a hoof on her shoulder. "She's right. We--"

Fluttershy, however, shrugs it off. "No. Please do not say things will be okay because it is not okay! We're guilty. All of us! We tricked ourselves with all the so-called good deeds and friendship lessons. But, we never truly grew as ponies!"

"But, the magic--"

"It could just be a memory spell you put on us to make us forget!"

Twilight gasps at the accusation. "Me? I would never do something of this caliber without a way to reverse it. Doubly so if it is as bad as you claim!"

"Why not? We are all learning who were truly are now,"

"Urgh! We don't have time for this! I am finding Spike! Can we sort this out after we make sure he's okay!" Fluttershy relents and follows along quietly. However, as the elements reach the park, they notice a large crowd. It was a crowd comprised of many creatures with no ponies in sight. "What's going on here?"

"Yeah, what's with this crowd? Are they doing a show in the park? Spitfire didn't tell me anything," Rainbow said.

"I think they are saying something," Applejack noted.

"Rights for him and Rights for us! Rights for him and Rights for us!" The crowd chanted.

"Rights for him and rights for us? Is this a protest?" Twilight wonders.

"Look!" Rarity points to the crowd. The group spies Spike standing next to a griffin while holding signs. "Spiky-Wiky!"

The elements quickly gallop to the wayward drake as the crowd stops. "Hey, there they are! There are the liars!" Cranky Doodle calls out.

The word stop the elements in their tracks. "Liars?" Twilight asks. Twilight could barely hear anything over the sea of jeers. "What's going on? Why are you all here?"

"We have every right to be here! Just like you!"

"Yeah, we won't let you ponies keep us down anymore!"

"Creatures of Equestria!!!"

"Now, now, everyone. I think the Princess wants to talk. It's only fair we listen. Otherwise, we won't be heard too," A filly Twilight never seen states as she flies in front of the protestors.

"What is this, and who are you?" Twilight asks.

"Golly, it's nice to meet you. I never thought I would see all the Elements of Harmony together. Now everything is perfect. My name is Cozy Glow. Welcome to the first-ever Creatures for Equestria protest!"

The Element of Laughter

Author's Note

Hey, if anyone knows any other things Pinkie did, let me know. It's hard shifting through all these episodes.:twilightblush: Enjoy.

The Element of Laughter

[Canterlot Memorial Park.]

"Creatures for Equestria?" Twilight asks.

"Yeah, it's a new movement to help the non-ponies in Equestria. Did you know that all these creatures behind me are not considered equal? Most, if not all, the creatures behind me are seen as pets, disposable workers, and downright enslaved beings in everything but name. You are a Princess. Did you not see the concern of your subjects?"

"O-Oh, I never-- I mean, the issue never came up..." Twilight said weakly. Even she could tell that was not a sufficient answer.

"But, you are The Princess of Friendship," Cozy reinforced. "That title should me you have everyone's best interests in mind,"

"Yeah!" The crowd said.

"I-I do. I did not know about the current state of affairs--"

"We don't want your excuses! You've been a Princess for four years before all this, and you haven't done a thing! A new Princess but the same status quo!" Cranky Doodle said.

Twilight recoils as she shrinks away. It was all true. As the newly christened Princess of Friendship, she never tackled issues such as equal rights. She always wanted more responsibility, yet she never thought to ask. 'Was I so content with the little bubble that I failed to see outside the fog?'

"Spike. Why are you here?" Rarity asks tentatively.

"What? It's not obvious?" Spike said in a bitter tone.

"W-Well, we were looking all over for you--"

"I'm fine!" Spike said sharply, cutting Rarity off.

"Yes, we can see that. Say, why don't we go somewhere to eat and talk about things?"

"Why? You miss your pet that bad?"

A flash of hurt hits all the element's faces. "Spike, you're not a pet!"

"The paper signed by Princess Celestia and your parents says differently. But you are right. I am not a pet. I am something lower than that. Ponies at least say I love you to their pets. I never heard it once from your parents!"

"Spike..." Twilight said in a hurt tone.

"See? Stuff-like creatures seen as pets need to stop. What's to stop somepony from spaying and neutering Spike? Or, worse, euthanizing him," Cozy said.

"That would never happen!" Twilight asserted.

"Are you sure it hasn't happened already?"

"...I don't know,"

"Spike, come on! You know that we care about you!" Rainbow said.

"That's right. Nothing said inside that courtroom can drive a wedge between us!" Rarity said.

"Says the mare that laughs at me for not being a real dragon and pranking me all the time!"

"Spike, please, we can work this out," Rarity said as she moved closer. However, a wing bars her path. "Excuse me! I am talking to my-- Gabby?"

Spike's pen pal and mail griffin brings the drake closer while glaring at the elements, but Rarity especially. "I think Spike has clarified where he wants to be right now!"

"Gabby, why are you here?"

"I am here supporting my friends' future. All of our futures here in Equestria. And I am making sure my friend isn't hurt by you anymore!"

"But, I never--"

"Yes, you did! You've been doing it since before we met and after. I thought you were sincere when you wanted to apologize to Spike. But, all you wanted was your favorite poster dragon back to order around. Spike is not even allowed to make friends of his own! He always told me in his letters that he was exhausted from cleaning that big castle alone. And how his back sometimes hurt from carrying all your bags. But he always thought it was helping his friends. So, he never said anything against it! Real friends don't do that. Real friends, don't wait until some other horrible abused creature comes along and stand up against all the unfairness!"

"Now, now. We can't be too hard on them. It's not like Princess Twilight was the one that made the laws. They are more like enablers, if nothing else. We need to go right to the source so that our voices are heard through Canterlot and beyond. Let's march to Judical Hall!"

"Yeah!" The crowd supports.

"W-Wait! You can't just march into court while a trial is in session. You can't even hold an unauthorized protest without a permit!" Twilight stated.

Cozy produces a piece of paper and hands it to Twilight. "Here you go. Signed. Dated. And, official,"

"Mayor Mare signed this?!"

"What?!" The elements exclaimed.

"Yes, she realized it's essential to have the right mindset and back the good creatures in these types of things,"

"It sure sounds like she is trying to save her hide," Applejack said sourly.

Twilight frowns as she looks back at Cozy. "Well, I am sorry to inform you all, but since I reside over Ponyville, my authority supersedes Mayor Mare regarding an assembly such as this,"

"Golly, I guess that does make sense, but I thought you didn't have any authority during the trial,"

"Court was adjourned today. My princess status is reinstated after the courtroom door closes,"

"You see? She is trying to silence us even now! Tyrants!" Cranky Doodle yells as the group voices their displeasure.

"What?! No! I was just--"

"What's going on here!?" A new voice cuts Twilight off. Twilight turns to see a gathering of royal guards. A guard steps forward with a stern look on his face. "We received several noise complaints coming from the park. It's making ponies restless,"

"Oh no. There's no noise here, Mister Guard. My friends and I were about to leave. We were only talking with the Princess here. So, we got a little delayed," Cozy Glow said sweetly.

The guard spies the group suspiciously. "What are you doing that requires such a large group of creatures, and where are you going?"

"We're holding an assembly for the Creatures of Equestria movement. We are showing our support of Jason Wright to bring equal rights to every creature in Equestria," Cozy Glow stated.

At the mention of the human, the guard narrows his eyes. "Litte miss, I will have you know that unlawful assembly is not tolerated, and it is punishable by confinement to the dungeon!"

"Golly, you would lock up innocent creatures for gathering and speaking peacefully? Would you even lock up a filly? That's not very nice. It's a good thing that Princess Twilight signed my permission slip,"

The attention was back on Twilight. The guards were looking at her for confirmation. Twilight looks between the two groups, looking at her sternly for different reasons before she sighs. "Spike, take a letter," Twilight winces again when she says that. It was done out of instinct but is highly inappropriate now. And the deep frown on her number one assistant made it worse. "...Right..." Twilight produces a feather and signs the paper. "Here you go. I now give full permission for the Creatures for the Equestria assembly. There is no issue here. This group was going to attend the court proceedings. Would you guards spreading the word, so there are no misunderstandings?"

"Yes, your highness. Disperse," The guard said.

Cozy Glow smiled broadly as she took the newly signed documents from Twilight. "Thank you so much, Princess Twilight. I knew you would be on our side," Cozy starts to fly ahead as the group follows her.

"Hmph, it's about time she did something right," Cranky said.

"Spike?" Pinkie asks softly. "Are you coming back with us?"

"No, probably not for a while either. It's time for creatures like me to have a voice and are no longer considered pets," Spike said with a frown as he looked toward Twilight. "Don't expect a thank you..."

"Come on, Spike. We don't want to lag," Gabby said, ushering Spike back with the group.

"How did things get like this?" Twilight asks.

"What the hay, Twilight? After all that time we spent finding him, you're just going to leave Spike with a bunch of strangers?" Rainbow asks. "And why didn't you get the guards to break that group up? There's no way Mayor Mare would sign up for this!"

"Because Spike would never come back to us if I didn't. Besides, he's with Gabby,"

"Gabby, who is not particularly fond of us at the moment," Rarity said.

"And letting him go off with this group will lead him back around to us?" Applejack said incredulously.

"Saying no would've driven the wedge further between Spike and us!"

"Yeah, but how do we know Jason didn't send out his goons? I mean, they show up right when this kangaroo trial starts?" Rainbow suggests.

"It's hardly anything suspicious. Other creatures are tired of the way things are for them. Jason is just the only one that's been brave enough to speak his mind," Fluttershy said.

"Not this again. Fluttershy! How can you defend somepony that stole your cutie mark?"

"It would not have happened if I didn't use the stare, Rainbow. No matter what my reasoning was, it wasn't the right thing to do,"

"Urgh! Whatever, I'm going back to my room," Rainbow said, zooming off into the distance.

"Yeah, turning would do us all some good," Applejack said.

"I don't know how we can get any sleep," Rarity mutters.

"Coming, Pinkie?" Twilight asks, receiving no answer. She looks around to see Pinkie Pie gone. "Pinkie?"

[Jason's room.]

Jason and Chrysalis were walking back to their room after today's trial. Chrysalis had a little more swagger as yet another element's credibility was shot down in flames. "Oh, this is the best week of my life. Did you see the look on that prissy unicorn's face when the dragon left? Haha. Her type could never handle rejection well,"

"I guess not. But Spike might be in the same camp,"

"You care for the dragon?"

"As I said, he's innocent in all this,"

"Hmm, do you feel the same about all the foals in Ponyville? I am sure their lives will change once we're done here,"

"If anything, they will be better than their parents,"

"Or, they could grow to resent you as the parents no doubt are now,"

Jason stops at the door and looks back at Chrysalis. "They brought this on themselves!"

"Oh, relax, it is just food for thought. Speaking of food, we should call for room service. You are looking a bit hungry," Chrysalis opens the door as the pair enter.

"As if I would eat anything made by ponies..."

Jason stops as a large present sits in the middle of the room. It was shaking and trembling before it burst open in an explosion of confetti. Pinkie launches out of the gift with several noise makers, a silly whistle, and a cake in her hooves. "Oh! Welcome, welcome, welcome. Welcome to your room. Welcome, welcome, welcome, I'm saving you from the gloom. The party's right here. There's no need to fear. Pinkie's going to spread some cheer!"

The party mare slides to the pair with her head back with a broad smile while presenting the cake. "What?" Chrysalis asks. Chrysalis looks to Jason to notice his attention is on the ceiling. A fact Pinkie missed.

"Hey, there, Chryssi and Jason. I'm glad you finally made it back. I was in that present for almost an hour. It gets cramped after a while. I wonder if they make present lining?"

"And you are here because?"

"For your party, of course. Did you miss the song? I can sing it again!"

Pinkie takes a massive intake of air before Chrysalis magic closes her mouth. "No more of that!"

Giggle, Pinkie looks to Jason, only to catch him entering the bathroom. "Chrysalis, tell the guards there's a noise outside,"

Pinkie's smile wavers a bit, but she approaches the door. "Oh, yeah. Good idea. You want to make some room for all this cake we got. I figured we could start with some cupcakes, move on to pound cakes, and finish with strawberry shortcake!"

"..."

"Oh, that's right. I don't know what kind of cake you like. Not to worry..." Pinkie pulls out another cake from her mane. "I have dozens of cakes ready to go in case of emergencies,"

"You pulled that cake from your mane," Chrysalis deadpans. She spies the pound cake and takes a bite. A look of surprise adorns her features as she eats it.

"W-well, the cake might not be your thing. Don't worry. I have pies. Rainbow doesn't care for them, but I bet you will!"

"..."

"A-and there's also candy and ice cream to consider. We could do the Pinkie bonanza sweetie treats festival! It's a working title, but basically, we eat all the sweet treats we can in one sitting,"

"That sound like a buffet of health issues," Chrysalis comments.

Pinkie ignores her as she moves closer. "We have all the time in the world to figure it out. We'll make up for those three years faster than you can blink. Please come out,"

"..." Jason, again, says nothing. He was so quiet that if Pinkie didn't see him go into the bathroom, her first thought would be that it was empty.

Getting desperate now, Pinkie knocks on the door. "Please! Can you at least say something to me? Please tell me what I can do to make it better. I'm sorry!"

"Alright, come here," Chrysalis said, pulling Pinkie away from the door using her aura. "As much as I like begging, this display is pathetic! What are you doing here? Really?"

"...I wanted to apologize..."

"Is this an attempt to throw out the trial through assaulting a witness? I can feel the anger he's admitting. It's particularly a sauna in there,"

"No! But, if it makes you feel better--"

Chrysalis's loud sigh cuts the party mare off. "You don't get it, do you? Nothing you say or do will stop this trial from happening. Shining Armor and his pet dragon have tried this already. You can ask them how that turned out,"

"No, this isn't about the trial. Since you two came here, my Pinkie sense has been acting all wonky. I feel like I did some stuff, but I can't remember!"

"Ah. Then, you are not sorry. Even if you can't remember your part in his suffering, you can hazard a good guess from all you've seen already. I know that you know that you and your friends are guilty. But does that changes anything? Does apologizing help him or bring you closure? Why should Jason give that satisfaction? You have no idea the kind of pain you have wrought. You don't deserve forgiveness. Now, you have to live with that knowledge. The idea that all your parties and smiles could not fix anything. Honestly, you should feel grateful you are not a target,"

Pinkie looks back at Chrysalis in shock. "W-What? But I am a defendant!"

"Yes. But, we are going from most minor offenders to worst. I would put you right after Twilight and before Fluttershy from your actions. But Jason is content with ignoring you, as you are experiencing now," Chrysalis finishes the cake and wipes her mouth. "I can't fathom Jason's mind on these things. Although I can't argue with the results," Pinkie's smile finally left as she started trembling. She looked back at the bathroom and thought of breaking through the door. However, her eyes fell on the Gjallarhorn as she took several steps to it. "Oh, the Gjallarhorn? Go ahead. You are free to use it. Answer all your burning questions. Fair warning, though; you might not like what you see. Can you confront your sins, Element of Laughter?"

"Chrysalis? Are you doing your monologues in the mirror again?" Jason asks, deliberately disregarding Pinkie's presence now.

That was it. Pinkie touches the Gjallarhorn and asks a question. "Show me what I did. Show me how I took his smile away," Pinkie's eyes went white from the Gjallarhorn's power. Magic bursts out of her as it did with her friends. Her mouth was open in a wordless scream before she stumbled back on her haunches. Her body shuddered as her mane and tail lost their usually poofy volume. Even her vibrant pink colors were not duller than when discord corrupted her. Tears formed around her eyes as they fell off her cheeks.

"So, now you know. Are you going to make excuses like your friends? Say things like 'that wasn't me' or 'I would never be that pony!' Which is it?"

Instead of answering, Pinkie slowly cleans up the confetti and throws away all the treats. Chrysalis arches a brow at the change before Pinkie speaks again. "...I'm sorry for disturbing you two..." Without another word, Pinkie leaves the room.

"Well, she is gone now with all the color drained. Out of all those ponies, I might feel a little bad for her," Chrysalis said as Jason said nothing. "But, as I said before, I like your methods better,"

[Canterlot Judicial Hall - Fourth Day of the Trial.]

The judges sat in awe of the courtroom. Where most of Canterlot's nobles were sitting, now were non-ponies. They were waiting by the entrance as everyone came inside. There was a standing ovation for Jason as he and Chrysalis. The changeling queen soaks up the praise while Jason remains somewhat indifferent. Nobles naturally were against allowing common folk in their fair city. Non-ponies are even more so until Cozy Glow explains the situation.

"Golly, I don't see why so many ponies are upset. Creatures for Equestria don't want much. We want to be treated the same as everypony. How can Equestria be a place of harmony if that harmony doesn't extend to everyone," Cozy moves to Spike next. "Why, Spike here is seen as a pet, despite having the same feelings as the rest of us. Do you know what that means? At any time, if somepony wanted to do anything to him, it would only be animal abuse. He could've even been put down at a vet! How is that okay? Then, there is Cranky Doodle's wife, Matilda. She could not get the treatment that would've saved her life because of her status. We're here because we believe in what Jason is doing. Rights for him. Rights for us!"

The defendants all gasp out in shock. "Matilda is gone? We never--"

But a noble speaks up before them. "But, you're a pony. What do you gain from helping non-ponies?" A noble said.

"All I get from this is what I always thought Equestria had. Friendship and harmony for all,"

"Great, this brat," Jason mutters. He had no idea what Cozy was planning. But he didn't like that she was associating his justice with her movement. He would have to tell Chrysalis about her soon. For now, their goals align. "The Plaintiff has no issue with the group and offers our sympathies. The existence of their movement is but further proof of the basis and institutionalized speciesism in this country,"

"The defense has no qualms about the group as well. We, too, offer our sympathies," Celestia stated. She glances over to the elements to ensure there are no objections. When none is given, Celestia nods to her sister.

"Very well. The fourth day of trial shall commence. The floor is yours, Mister Wright,"

Jason gets in position in front of the defendant's bench. Jason stares down each mare, starting from the left and moving to the right. Celestia tries to hold a stoic visage, but her mask now has more cracks. He can hints of weariness and shame. Twilight was more trepidation upon his appraisal of her. It was almost like she was afraid of what Jason had in store. Moving to the next mare, Fluttershy looks away from him. It was not out of fear but disgust with herself. Rarity was next, and she was more cautious with he gaze. Pinkie watched the whole thing and waited for her turn. She did not know how she could convey in words how sorry she was, but she would try when their eye met. However, that never happens as Jason skips her by without a sideways glance. He stops in front of Applejack as the cow pony tenses. Like Rainbow next to her, they were the only two still openly defiant against their just scrutiny. But, before Jason could start on Applejack, Pinkie raises her hoof.

"Yes, Miss Pie?" Judge Luna asks,

"...I would like to confess," Pinkie said solemnly. There was no joy or any of her usual vibrance in her tone. Now that Pinkie spoke up, everyone got a good look at her dull coat and straight mane. Her friends looked the most worried at this sudden change in demeanor.

"Confess to what?" Judge Novo asks.

"To my part in abusing Jason Wright. For the pain and anguish, I caused him by going against my element. When I stop and think about everything I did leading up to Jason, I can see that I never deserved to be the element of laughter..."

"Pinkie, what are you doing?" Rarity asks.

"Yeah, sugarcube. That's a bunch of nonsense," Applejack said.

"Yeah, you're just as awesome as the rest of us,"

Pinkie merely shakes her head. She gets up and walks over to the Gjallarhorn. "I'm not suited because I let silly things like my friends being busy lead to a nervous breakdown,"

The image displays Pinkie Pie hosting a party for her pet alligator. She sent invitations to all her friends, but none of them came. Pinkie was growing irritated as all her friends avoided her the whole day. She decides to disguise herself in a haystack. Rainbow Dash comes by, and a chase ensues. Pinkie is shown to be relentless in her pursuit, matching Rainbow's speed on her hooves before she flies into Applejack's barn. After Applejack rebukes Pinkie, Pinkie brings Spike in for integration. Another growl escapes Ember's maw as Pinkie clamps Spike's tail with Gummy's mouth. After Spike misses Pinkie Pie's intent on what she wants from him, Pinkie guides him to what she wants to hear from him, causing her to have a psychotic break. The memory shifts to Pinkie holding her party with many inanimate objects.

"Thank you all so much for coming. It means so much to Gummy," Pinkie said at the head of the table.

"Could I have some more punch?" Pinkie puppeted the pale of turnips.

"Of course, you can have more punch, Mister Turnips,"

Pinkie's eyes twitch as she moves to the pile of rocks. "This is a great party, Pinkie. You have outdone yourself,"

"Why thank you, rocky," Another twitch before Pinkie moves to the lint ball.

"I'm having a delightful time as well,"

"Why, thank you, Sire Lintcelot,"

"Might I trouble for another slice of cake?" Pinkie said with shaking the bag of flour.

"Anything for you, Madame Flour,"

"I'm just glad none of those ponies showed up," Pinkie said in a deep voice for the rocks. "Oh, they're not so bad," The memory ends with a crossed-eyed smile from Pinkie.

"Are you telling the court you have psychosis?" Judge Shifting Sands asks slowly.

"No, she doesn't. It's just that we were planning a surprise party for Pinkie and--"

Twilight went to defend her friend, but Pinkie cut her off. "And I took things the wrong way and had a breakdown instead of waiting as a normal pony would,"

"That's not even the first time I went assuming..." Pinkie looks at Cranky Doodle as he glares at her. "When Cranky came to town, he wasn't looking for a big welcome. He was trying to settle in, and I kept bugging him about being friends and getting him to smile. All I ended up doing was making him a laughingstock,"

Another memory shows Cranky pulling a cart. As many who live in Ponyville would expect, Pinkie greeted him with over-the-top hyperactive antics. However, Pinkie did not seem to have an understanding of boundaries. Her antics led to Cranky's toupee getting ruined by her. Then, Pinkie made the mistake of drawing the attention of the citizens to them.

"Hey! Does anypony know where we can find a wig? This donkey is super bald!" The ponies laughed as Crank went red with embarrassment. "Come on, ponies. This is no laughing matter. Cranky needs the wig to hide his glaringly bald head!"

Pinkie looks down from the memory as Cranky runs away. "I don't know why I thought that was a good idea. I sometimes found a group of ponies standing in front of Cranky's home wearing wigs. They laughed, and I would join in because I thought it was a fun wig party. Little did I know that they were making fun of him..."

"That's right! Your little stunt brought all those cruel ponies to my home! They would bother me every other week. And you made it worse by joining them!" Cranky hollers. "The only time there was peace was when those ponies had better things to do. But that only lasted a few days at most!"

"But Pinkie made up for it by finding Matilda. And Pinkie can't control how others act!" Twilight stated.

"We already covered this with you, Twilight," Chrysalis said, stepping up to the center. "Pinkie should've seen how her actions affect others. She is not a foal whose actions we can excuse; she is a grown mare and an element bearer,"

"Besides, the stress only added for matilda when she finally passed!" Cranky hollers. "I wanted a private funeral. After getting rejected aid from the hospital and paying off the bills for renting that building for the wedding - which our sponsor refused to help - I wanted nothing to do with any ponies,"

"There's more. When we went to Applelosoa, the buffalo tribe, and the Applelosians were feuding," Pinkie said, showing the memory of the stand-off between the town and the buffalo tribe. Chief Thunderhooves were standing on the cliff with his tribe flanking him. The Applelosians stood behind their defenses as the clock tower rang at noon. However, Little Strong Heart laid a hoof on the buffalo's head, and the chief relents. All the ponies sign in relief until Pinkie Pie begins singing her song about sharing and caring. The chief and sheriff already shared their displeasure toward the performance. Thus, Pinkie's actions spurred Chief Thunderhooves into going through with his plan to stampede through the town. "I started a big fight between the buffalos and the Appleolsians because I thought a silly song that no one liked would stop the fighting. It was by dumb luck that the war stopped because a pie flew into the chief's mouth, and he liked it. I didn't take any of it seriously..."

"I cannot lie and say singing was helpful. It escalated the situation for no apparent reason. Still, I have to ask why wasn't an official deal broker sent there to settle this dispute?" Cadance asks.

"The Appleosian is as prideful and stubborn as the buffalo. Neither side sent any correspondence to the crown," Celestia said. "I believe it is worth stating that Twilight and her friends' presence help deescalate the issue without serious harm,"

"It still doesn't change the fact that I made everything worse. Like the time you came to visit Ponyville during Nightmare Night..."

The scene changes to Ponyville as Luna descends from the sky with her bat pony guards pulling her chariot. Luna announces her arrival and intends to join in the festivities. However, Pinkie suddenly shouts and misinterprets her words. "Did you hear that everypony? Nightmare Moon said she's going to feast on us all!"

"Fluttershy, you got to hide us! Nightmare moon is here and is going to-- Aah! Nightmare stole Fluttershy's voice so she can't scream when she gobbles you up!!!"

"Hey, girls. have you seen Pipsqueak-- AH! Nightmare moon is gobbling Pipsqueak! Everypony Run!!!"

Each memory ends with the foals running away on Pinkie's fear-mongering as she sadly speaks. "I always said you make sure the pony your pranking is okay with it. But, I didn't bother to see that you were upset everypony kept running away from you, Princess Luna..."

"You speak too harshly n yourself. I was just off my recent isolation and misinterpreted the holiday's intent. I learned this thanks you and Twilight later," Luna said, but it did not take with Pinkie.

"I didn't consider anyone's feelings. Just like with Jason Wright," Pinkie said, showing what the Gjallarhorn showed her last night.

The memory starts with Pinkie busing the tables in Sugarcube Corner. Now and then, her body would twitch awkwardly. "Hmm, there it is again. I never had these combos before, but I can never find out what they mean. Oh, well, I guess even my Pinkie sense can have an off day,"

"Urgh, that freak was picking trash again!" Flitter said.

"Disgusting. Why does it do that?" Cloud Chaser adds.

The conservation of the two mares caught Pinkie's attention. Pinkie sees that it is the twin pegasi sisters, Flitter and Cloud Chaser. "Oh, there's a new pony in town? That's weird. I didn't feel that there was a new pony. Unless they are not a pony. We're still working on a combo for other creatures and non-ponies. Did you say something about trash?"

"Uh, this thing isn't a pony or any other creature out there. It's like something the Everfree forest spat out on us!" Flitter said.

"Yeah, it goes around picking at our trash and being a nuisance!" Cloud Chaser said.

Pinkie adopts a thoughtful expression. "It came from the Everfree, and it picks through the trash. Oh! It might be trying to find personal effects!"

The two mares looked deeply concerned now. "F-For what?"

"Well, it could be trying to get the scent of ponies to gobble them up later,". The mares shivered as Pinkie continued. "Or, maybe, it's probably to put some curse on us, like some voodoo witch doctor!"

"Y-You mean like the evil enchantress?" The mare said fearfully.

"No, silly. That was Zecora. She's a shaman, not a voodoo witch doctor, totally different. We won't want to make that mistake again. But, this time might be accurate because no pony or creature would be this thing. Wait, what does this thing look like?"

"It's as tall as Celestia!" Flittter said, standing on her hindlegs.

"It wears an ugly black cloak or robe and stinks to high heaven," Cloud Chaser said, using the tablecloth as a cloak.

"Yep. A voodoo witch doctor," Pinkie said as the memory shifted.

Pinkie was walking in front of the flower shop. "Hey, Roseluck, you there? I need some parsley for a recipe. Hello?"

"Shush! Pinkie. Come inside quick!" Lilly voice calls out.

Pinkie hurries behind the counter to see the flower girls huddle against the wall—a look of fear was present on each of their faces. "What are you doing? Are we playing hide and seek?" Pinkie whispers.

Roseluck points a shaky hoof to the backdoor screen. Pinkie looks in that direction and immediately huddles next to the flower sisters as a tall silhouette moves past the door. "I-It's the creature. The creature of the Everfree. It's here! It wants to harvest and eat us up!"

"I heard it looks for ponies to steal their coats, tricking everypony into that it is one of us!" Daisy said.

"I heard if you look at its face, it steals your soul," Lilly added.

"Oh. Those sound way scarier than my voodoo witch doctor theory. I bet it does all those things, but instead of wearing the coats, it uses them to build a pony mannequin," Pinkie whispers along with them. "Since it's incapable of making friends, it goes out to build a friend for itself!"

Pinkie's words only serve to heighten the flower girl's fears. On the outside, Jason manages to open the door. In a panic, Roseluck picks up one of the flower pots and hurls it at the doorway as Jason steps inside. "Hello-- Argh!!!" The pot hits Jason square in the head while knocking him down. He quickly scampers away as Pinkie goes out the back and sees him running toward the forest.

"And that's what I did. Even though I never got a good look or got to know him, I kept adding to the awful rumors and gossip about Jason. I helped feed the town's fear of him. The cramps and combos I had were all telling me that somepony - someone - was hurting. But I never tried to help. At the end of it all, I made the same mistake with Zecora, only a thousand times worse..." Pinkie said with tears in her eyes. She looks toward Jason to see his eyes glued on his papers as he sorts them out. He never once looks in her direction. "I deserve punishment,"

The judges were once again at a loss. No one said anything at Pinkie's tale until Chrysalis spoke up. "A very compelling and heartfelt confession. But, one that is ultimately unnecessary,"

"Why is that?" Judge Cadance asks.

"The prosecution has no plan to charge Miss Pie at the time. As we saw, Miss Pie never came face to face with Jason Wright, believing him to be a creature of the Everfree. Whereas all the other acts against Jason, ponies had a clear view of him and still chose to act abhorrently. Given Miss Pie's playful nature, it is possible that she was under the notion that the town was playing a prank. Tell us, Miss Pie, has the town engaged in a prank involving everyone?"

"Y-Yes. The time we pranked Rainbow Dash into thinking the ponies turned into cookie-craving zombies," Pinkie said.

"And, after hearing more outlandish rumors, did you believe another prank was going on?"

"W-Well, some of the things the ponies said were unbelievable. I thought it was like a competition to see who could create the craziest story," Pinkie shakes her head as she pleads with the judges. "But, it still hurt him in the end. I was still careless with my words and didn't spread laughter like I was supposed to!"

"There are charges to label against you, but I am afraid you do not fit the criteria of slander and deformation as you never said anything against Jason Wright as you did not know him. And, you never acted maliciously as others have. So, as I said, we don't seek to charge you with anything,"

"If the prosecution does not wish to file charges, then you may leave the defendant bench, Miss Pie," Judge Luna said.

"B-But, I am guilty!" Pinkie shrieks.

"I respect your loyalty to your friends, Miss Pie. But, if they were your true friends, none of them would expect you to go down for their behavior," Chrysalis said. Her smile was everpresent at Pinkie's increasingly spiraling mental state. Looking back to the Creatures for Equestria group, an idea forms. "Not that we could charge you under normal circumstances,"

"What do you mean?" Ember asks.

"All the charges we listed against the defendants are authentic. But Jason is not a citizen of Equestria. The law is applied to ponies and ponies only. If that were not the case, this group would not be here. We fully expect the Equestrian crown to gloss over the week's event once the tribunal has concluded,"

"That does seem like the case!" Ember said with a snarl.

"It is somewhat concerning the actual state of affairs in Equestria. At least for non-ponies," Queen Novo said with a sneer.

All the judges shared the same sentiments as Cadance felt small, and Luna grits her teeth at Chrysalis. "The Equestrian crown gives our word that there will be revisions to our standing laws so that these events are not repeated!" Luna said begrudgingly. She cast a harsh glare at Chrysalis for putting her character into question.

"Do you, Pinkie promise?" Pinkie mutters.

"I beg your pardon?"

"You have to Pinkie Promise! No breaks a Pinkie Promise. It's the only way to ensure we are serious about change!"

"I have already given my word, Miss Pie. This court isn't the place for foolish notions--"

"NO! You have to make the motions! Cross my heart and hope to fly. Stick a cupcake in my eye!" Pinkies go through an elaborate motion with her hooves.

"Miss Pie! Settle down! The court must continue--"

"Fine, I'll do it. And you better not break it!" Pinkie leaves a slackjawed Luna as she turns to Jason. However, a barrier appeared around Jason before she took a single step. Undeterred, Pinkie rests her hoof on it. "See? I Pinkie Promise things are going to be different. You know that no one breaks a Pinkie Promise, right? We can be friends when this is over, right?"

"..." Jason says nothing. His focus was squarely on his documents as he shifted through them.

Pinkie shudders and starts banging against the shield. "PLEASE SAY SOMETHING! PLEASE DON'T IGNORE ME!!!"

"Order! Order in the court! Miss Pie, you will cease these actions!" Luna commands.

"Pinkie! You have to calm down!" Cadance said.

Pinkie only redoubles her efforts as she starts bucking at the shield to get to Jason. "Guards! Escort Miss Pie out of the court and place her in confinement!" Lunad orders as she swings her gavel.

Several guard ponies came and pulled Pinkie from Chrysalis' barrier. However, she fought and struggled against their grip. Tears fell from her eyes as the guards moved the distraught mare to the courtroom doors. "NO! I CAN'T BREAK MY PROMISE! NOPONY BREAKS A PINKIE PROMISE!!!"

As the door slams shut, the barrier fades as Jason returns to his previous position. A hateful scowl from Applejack met Jason's indifferent eyes. "Yeah, I remember that glare. You wore it well when I came to visit your farm that day. Now that there are no more distractions, let's talk about you, Applejack,"

"Indeed we shall," A new pair of voices said. The doors open again as two cream-coated red-maned unicorn stallions walk to the center of the courtroom.

"Who are you two?" Cadanece asks.

"Why, we are witnesses," The stallion on the left said.

"And we're here to regale the court of our awful treatment at the hands of this rotten apple, Applejack," The other stallion said, curling his mustache.

"Flim and Flam?!?!" Applejack shrieks.

The Element of Honesty

Author's Note

We are back, baby.:yay: Enjoy

The Element of Honesty

[Ponyville - Train Station.]

"Come on! Why are there so many ponies here today?" Scootaloo cries out. Many ponies move back and forth on the platform as the line to the ticket booth spills into town.

"Yeah..." Applebloom says as many of the ponies came in with luggage. "It seems like a lot of ponies are in a hurry to leave,"

"Gee, I wonder why?" Sweetie Belle said sarcastically. "I think it's this trial that got everypony all worked up,"

"You youngins' stay close to Big Mac and me. We don't want you getting lost," Granny Smith said.

"Eeyup," Big Mac agrees.

"Do you think ponies are afraid?" Sweetie Belle asks.

"Afraid of what?" Applebloom asks.

"Of what Jason is going to say about them next. Do you think ponies are leaving so they won't get in trouble?" Sweetie asks.

"No way! If anything, I bet these ponies are going to Canterlot to support our sisters and the Princess. That thing's got to be making all this up somehow. Would Rarity be that mean and nasty to any creature?"

"I don't know. I saw that memory, and I can't remember when that happened. But..." Sweetie is hesitant as the line moves forward. "It feels real,"

"I think it's real baloney! It's got to be that weird horn doing all this!" Scootaloo said.

"You girls hush up now," Granny said, cutting the conversation. "I know a lot is going on that you may not understand, but I can tell that that horn ain't something to doubt. Why, our great ancestor Grand Apple once called upon it. He used it to get a better deal on some fertile lands before coming to Equestria. It's as real and powerful as the elements. Maybe even more than those trinkets,"

"Then, why does Chrysalis have it?" Scootaloo asks.

"Only true believers can use it. If she has it, then I think a lot of ponies have some explaining to do,"

"But wouldn't that mean Rarity, Rainbow Dash, and Applejack did all those bad things?" Applebloom asks.
Granny Smith and Big Mac share a glance before she speaks again. "Come on; it's time to board,"

The group finally gets their tickets and boards the train. Inside the car, they took their seats. As Applebloom looks around, she spies another family. "Hey, look. There's the Pies,"

Sure enough, Pinkie's entire family was on the same train heading to Canterlot. The Pies spots the Apple and goes to join them. "Good day to you, Apple matriarch," Cloudy Quartz said.

"Hmph," Igneous Rock grunts in acknowledgment.

"Howdy to all of you as well," Granny Smith said.

Eeyup," Big Mac smiles down at Marble Pie

"Hmm," Marble smiles up at Mig Mac.

"Hey there, cousins," Applebloom squeaks, hugging Maud and Limestone Pie.

"Hello, Applebloom. It's good to see you again," Maud Pie said.

"Hey, squirt," Limestone grumbles out.

"I guess Y'all heading to Canterlot too?" Applebloom asks.

"Yeah, Maud came down to the farm when this trial started. You should've seen how bad she was when she got home. She was practically screaming her head off,"

"I was very distraught at the thought of Pinkie Pie going through this ordeal," Maud Pie said in a monotone and deadpan expression.

"...Right. But, do you believe any of what's been said?" Applebloom asks.

Cloudy Quartz walks up to the filly and shows her a geode. "This rock broke off of Holder's Boulder. The discoloration spells for ill tidings to come. We know not of our daughter's relation to this human. But, we will help through this troubling time,"

"I suppose that's the best any of us can do for our kin," Granny Smith said as the train began moving toward the castle hanging off the cliffside.

"Right you are, Granny," A new voice said.

Everyone turns to see two cyan-furred pegasi come up to their little gathering. "Mrs. Windy Whistle and Mr. Bow Hothoof!" Scootaloo exclaims, hugging her surrogate family.

"Whoa, whoa. Easy, there, Scootaloo. You got to save some of those hugs for Rainbow Dash when she beat this thing!" Bow Hothoof said.

"That's right. I don't know what kind of creature thinks he can get one over on our daughter. She's never lost anything in her life!" Windy said proudly.

"Yeah, she's the best. That human thing picked the wrong pony," Scootaloo said. None of the celebrating ponies notice Cloudy's grim expression and Granny shares.

[Canterlot Judicial Hall.]

"Now I know you are spouting some horse manure if you think these two con-ponies can say anything against me!" Applejack says hotly.

"Ah, Such a dastardly claim," Flim said.

"Such foul language. We are only here performing our civic duty now that we have the opportunity and freedom from your influence," Flam said.

"You two are nothing but lying snakes!" Applejack hollers.

"The plaintiff does not associate these two as our witnesses," Jason said to the shock of everyone.

"Whoa. Now hold on there, good sir," Flim said.

"Yes, we have information that can propel your case to new heights," Flam said.

Jason merely gives the brothers a flat look. "I have no issue with you two airing your grievances against the defendant. However, due to your less than savory ethics, I have no good faith in your credibility,"

"If you wish, the court will add these two brothers' testimony as a third-party account. However, this means that you cannot call them as witnesses regardless if they have any validity to your claims against Miss Applejack. Is that understood?" Judge Luna asks.

"The prosecution has no qualms with this stipulation," Jason says as he moves back to the plaintiffs' bench.

"Well, it is his lost, brother," Flim states.

"Yes, and our gain to reap the glory!" Flam exclaims as he clears his throat. "Members of this illustrious court. My brother and I have been the unfortunate victims of one held in such high regard," Flam says.

"A national heroine. A role model to fillies and colt everywhere turned sour," Flim adds.

"A--"

Luna slams her gavel down before the brothers can continue. "I will advise the two of you to get to the point. This court is not one for pointless triviality such as theatrics!"

The two brothers gulp as they compose themselves. "Yes, we first met Miss Apple and her family during apple cider season. A popular event in Ponyville where all the ponies can partake in Sweet Apple Acree Cider consumption," Flim explains.

"However, there was much customer dissatisfaction as the Apple family could not meet the demand. That's when my brother and I offered them a solution," Flam adds.

"We came in to offer a solution. Our Super Squeezy Cider Machine 9000. It would boost cider productivity tenfold, ensuring that everypony would have some delicious cider. We only required a decent wage for our services and machine," Flim said.

"Decent?! The price for that contraption would've bankrupted the farm!" Applejack shrieks. "Nopony can grow anything in the winter months. The cider sales help us past them!"

"What was the price?" Luna asks.

"Why, it was a 70/40 split where we get the 70%. It's only fair since we supplied the machine and magic to utilize our tool," Flims says.

"That is hardly fair to the Apples, given how much time and dedication goes into growing their product. A better deal would've been a 60/40 split, with the Apple's getting a majority. If the partnership grew past that point and you required more maintenance for this machine, then you could've asked for a higher percentage," Cadance said as the brothers gaped at her.

"That's a good idea. We should've added maintenance cost to make the price gauge more authentic," Flim whispers.

"Well, live and learn, brother of mine. We'll bring it up in our next project," Flam responds.

"So, you two didn't see eye to eye on working together. How is this an issue against the Apples?" Grandpa Gruff asks.

"Well, the issue comes from the Apples agreeing to a friendly sport of competition between our machine and their traditional way of producing cider. It was clear that we were going to win. Thus, we would win rights to the farm in its entirety," Flim states.

"Why in Equestria would you bet the farm, Applejack?" Cadance asks.

"Well, It's no secret that Apples are proud of our product and work ethic. So, when these two swindlers started goading us, then, of course, we would not back down!" Applejack responds.

"Pride comes before the fall, Young Applejack. Is the problem stemming from you two being the rightful owners of Sweet Apple Acres?" Luna asks.

"Of course we are! We would've won easier if Miss Applejack's co-conspirators had not jumped in at the last second and cheated!" Flam accuses.

"What!? We did not cheat! If anything, you two bozo did after you started taking rotten apples into your cider!" Rainbow shot back.

"Not to mention, you two did not have any problem with honorary members of the Apple family participating!" Twilight said.

"Be silent!" Judge Luna said, slamming her gavel down. "We would like to see these events in question and determine for ourselves any foul play,"

"I'll be happy to oblige, Princess," Applejack says as the two brothers share nervous glances. The events of the Super Squeezy episode play out precisely as Jason remembers—everything from the Flim-Flam brothers showing up to the competition to decide farm ownership. The brothers bite their lips when Flim states their true intentions of running the Apples out of business. It ends with the Flim-Flam brothers making a hasty retreat out of town from their poor-quality cider. "Ya see that, Princess? These two tried to pull a fast one, only for them to produce a subpar cider that everypony hated!"

"Hmm, yes. I have seen enough. The Flim-Flam brothers would indeed be rightful owners of the Sweet Apple Acres,"

There was a momentary pause before the elements did a double take. "WHAT!?!?" Even the unicorn twins were not expecting that one.

"Princess, how can you say that?" Applejack said in disbelief.

"It is quite simple. The nature of your agreement was that whoever produces the most cider wins ownership of the farm. Even with your combined efforts, these two stallions produced more cider than you did. The rules specifically called for quantity, not quality,"

Applejack falls on her haunches in despair as Flim and Flam celebrate. "It seems that you and your family are the true swindlers. Right, brother?" Flim said.

"Indoably so, brother of mine. I can't wait to get started on the renovations!" Flam said, rubbing his hoof together in a devious fashion.

"You brothers presume too much," Judge Luna calls out, ending the brothers scheming. "If you recall my earlier words, I said you would be the rightful owners. The problem lies in the absence of a contract signing over the deed to the farm to you two,"

The brothers went slackjawed at this revelation. "But, we have witnesses. Everypony heard the Apples agree to our terms!" Flim states in a panic.

"That detail matters little. Anypony can say they heard anything, especially with the right incentive. That is the reason contracts exist in the first place to prevent confusion and misdeeds. This deal was unofficial. Therefore, despite your victory, you are not the legal owners in the eyes of the law,"

"Ha!" Applejack cries out in triumph. "That's what you two, sorry, no good silver-tongued cheaters get! All your devious rotten scheming could never beat out an honest apple!"

"Is that a fact?" Jason said, gaining the courts' attention again. He cracks his fingers as he moves back to the center of the room. "I find your choice of words very ironic, Miss Applejack. Just as ironic that the pony associated with the Element of Honesty is the biggest liar,"

"What'd you say? I ain't a liar!"

"Then, what of the time you lied to Pinkie on her birthday?"

"What? That was for her surprise party. We figured we would surprise her for once. But, Pinkie Pie being Pinkie Pie went off the handle and thought we were dumping her as a friend,"

"Is this how you deal with your friend with clear mental issues? You completely dismiss it and let it rot? One can say that Pinkie's breakdowns can be avoided if you sit her down and talk it out. Here's a simple example; Pinkie, we are sorry you feel left out, but we're planning something special. I can't tell you, or it will ruin the surprise. See? what was wrong with that?"

Applejack scowls at this. "I won't listen to the fellas that made Pinkie upset! She doesn't have issues! She gets stuck on an idea and takes it far left field!"

"More generalization. How healthy for Miss Pie. Did she not admit to the court that same issue? Did she not have a breakdown in this very court?"

"You're the one that--"

"I did nothing. I said nothing. Ignoring and negligence are two very different practices. And you cannot force someone to pay attention to you just because you can't take a hint. But, as usual, your bullheaded stubbornness rears its head even when you know you are in the wrong. That's what makes you a liar!"

"I ain't a liar!" Applejack growls.

"Yes, you are. You are because you worked with two well-known con ponies known as Flim and Flam,"

"Objection! Judge Luna made it clear that since the plaintiff doubted the credibility of Flim and Flam, you cannot use them as witnesses!" Twilight reminds.

Jason sends her a flat look. "I'm not using them as witnesses. There was never a need to do that. I am, however, using them as an example,"

"I would like to see this example," Queen Novo said.

"As would I," Shifting Sands agrees.

"Continue, Mister Wright," Luna said.

Jason nods as he goes to the Gjallarhorn. The memory shows Flim and Flam standing amid an assembled crowd. They were marketing their latest Miracle Curative Tonic for all the ailments the public had. The Apples were also there, naturally skeptical of the brother's product. However, when Granny Smith's interest was piqued when the brothers mentioned that tonic could make you younger, she jumped at the chance and bought it.

The next day, Granny Smith was swimming and dancing like a filly again. The sudden change did not sit well with Applejack as she and Applebloom went to confront the Flim-Flam brothers about their tonic. Upon reaching their tent, the Apple sister saw the pony Silver Shills exit the tent again despite drinking the mixture a day prior. After cornering him and discovering he was never sick and a part of the act of selling the tonic, Applejack confronts the brothers.

"Well, if it isn't our favorite Apple," Flim said.

"What brings you back to our humble abode?" Flam asks.

"You two con artists sold my Granny a bottle of tonic, and now she's off acting like a filly again!" Applejack stated.

"What's so wrong about that?" Flim asks.

"If she keeps gallivanting about like a yearling, she's bound to drop from exhaustion or worse. What's more, I know that your friend here is dressing up as a different pony every night so he can pretend to be cured!"

"Well, well, well, that's quite the accusations," Flam said.

"But, let's say that it's true," Flim said as the brothers went to their table.

"Hypothetically,"

"Therotheically,"

"As I understand, your granny was once a famous aqua pony,"

"The star of the show once upon a time,"

"But, as she sent so much as a hoof in the water ever since?"

"Not until today. That's right," Applejack said, uncertain of the brothers' point.

"Well then, even if our tonic were nothing more than apple juice and beat leaves," Flim continues.

"Hypothetically," Flam said while tossing the apple and beating leaves to his brother.

"Theoretically," Flim said while crushing the produce into an empty tonic bottle.

"The fact is that Granny is happier now than before she tried it," Flam concludes with a new bottle of miracle tonic.

"I guess..." Applejack slowly said.

"So, the question is..." Film starts.

"Do you honestly want to be the pony that takes that happiness away?" Flam finished while handing her the tonic.

"I..."

Applejack hesitates as Applebloom comes inside."There you are, Applekjack. Did you find out what's in that tonic?"

Applejack looks at the smiling face of the brothers before sighing. "Honestly, Applebloom, it doesn't matter what's in it as long as it works,"

"Well, if it doesn't matter to you, then it doesn't matter to me either, sis," Applebloom said with a smile.

"That's the spirit," Flim said while waving.

"Come back anytime," Flam said, also waving.

The memory concludes while the brothers look at the horn in awe while Applejack frowns. "Miss Applejack. Do you deny what we just saw?" Jason asks.

"...No. That happened alright..." Applejack begrudgingly admits.

"So, can you explain to the court why you- the self-proclaimed honest apple - were willing to lie about the truth of Flim and Flam Miracle Curative Tonic? You, who knew the brothers to be con-ponies. Liars. And cheats,"

"Hey!" Flim and Flam complained.

"Be silent!" Judge Luna states the brothers shied away.

"You, who constantly preaches honesty. Was it really because you found the truth too hard to swallow?" Jason continues as Applejack grits her teeth.

"No! I just-- Y'all saw how Granny was feeling down about herself. Then, she drank that tonic and felt more confident and more spray than she had in years. I-I didn't want to make her sad again,"

"No, you were fine with letting Granny Smith risk her health for false confidence. You even said that she could drop from exhaustion or potentially even die. Yet, you said nothing. I guess you don't love your Granny all that much,"

Jason was pacing around Applejack like a shark before she hollered. "You take that back! I love my Granny!"

"Then, why did you endorse a product you knew was a false advertisement!"

A new memory plays with the Apples returning to the tent. A long line of ponies was waiting to buy more Flim-flam tonic before Granny Smith dropped a massive bag of bits. "We'll take the whole case!" Granny Smith said.

"You mean this tonic works?" A pony in a wheelchair asks.

"It seems to work for Granny," Applejack said.

"You heard it here, folks!" Flim suddenly said.

"Our Miracle Curative Tonic is Granny Smith tested, and Applejack approved!" Flam said.

"If Applejack says it works, that's good enough for me!" The same pony said as the crowd broke out in a frenzy, buying the tonic.

"Do you see the damage your words were doing? All those ponies had serious injuries and ailments that they would do anything to get better. So, when the pinnacle of truth says it is okay, then who would doubt her? Another example of negligence and carelessness from a national hero!" Jason spat.

More murmurs went off as harsh glares fell upon Applejack. None of her friends knew what to do. In truth, most of them were just as shocked that Applejack would lie to such a degree. "How could you do that, Applejack?" Cadance said in a disappointed tone.

"Indeed. That was a most unwise act!" Luna said with more venom than she meant.

"I-I-I..." Applejack sighs forlornly as she dips her head in shame. "Y'all are right. I should not have lied about that tonic. I should not have given that endorsement. I'm not perfect. Why, I used to lie up a storm something fierce when I was a filly. But, I always made up for it in the end,"

Applejack approaches horn and shows the Leap of Faith episode again. While Applejack's had visible concern for Granny Smith, those concerns turned out to be as Granny and Applebloom won the competition. However, more and more ponies were buying the tonic as it kept coming up. The brother took every opportunity to flaunt Applejack's endorsement until it became too much for the farm mare to bear. Applejack starts to tell the truth about the tonic, but Silver Shills points at Granny Smith, attempting to break the high dive record. Applejack narrowly made it in time to catch her Granny mid-dive.

"I hate to disappoint every pony, but this tonic is a fake!" Applejack declared.

The ponies all gasp as the one in a wheelchair speaks up. "But, you gave it your stamp of approval,"

"Are you saying you lied?" Another pony said.

"I am. I didn't mean to, but everypony seemed so much happier. I couldn't bring myself to say anything. I hope that with time, I can earn back your trust. Believing in something can help a pony do amazing things. But if that belief is based on a lie, eventually, it is going to lead to trouble,"

"You see? It's okay to make a mistake now and then. As long as you own up to it," Applejack waits for applause, but she receives none. Instead, she looks around to see the gallery waiting for Jason's retort.

"Yes, a good lesson. That is one I can personally attest to as well. It's a shame its value is wasted on a pony who has repeatedly made the same mistake over and over again. What good is a lesson if you never learn?"

"Where's your proof, huh? I've learned plenty from my friends!"

"Did you learn anything when you poisoned half of Ponyville?"

"What? I have never done that!!!" Applejack shouts at the mere implication. She turns to her friends for support only to find Twilight looking nervous. "Twilight? What's wrong?"

"She never told you about this, has she?" Jason said while holding another piece of paper. "I have here for the court a medical report from Ponyville Hospital. It involves a large number of its citizens suffering from food poisoning after consuming the baked goods Pinkie Pie served,"

The courtroom gasps as the judges read the reports. "Are you saying Pinkie poisoned the town?" Cadance asks in shock.
"No. I am saying Applejack and her stubbornness did,"

Jason moves to the Gjallarhorn again. This time is showing the episode of Apple Bucking Season. It starts with Applejack declaring she can buck all the apples from the trees in the orchard to an injured Big Mac. At first, it seemed like she had everything under control - refusing aid from Twilight when the unicorn asked. However, she was running herself ragged. Many ponies saw how tired she looked when accepting an award. This prompted Twilight to ask again if she was alright, only for Applejack to rebuff her again. Then, while helping Rainbow Dash perform a trick, she nearly sent the prismatic mare into orbit.

Twilight came to revisit Applejack, only for Applejack to stubbornly refuse her. Finally, the scene of Jason's claim shows up with Applejack and Pinkie Pie baking goods in the kitchen. However, every ingredient Pinkie read out from the book, Applejack misheard due to her fatigue. The courtroom gagged in disgust at all the ingredients Applejack added. The result was Twilight standing in the hospital, complete from the influx of ponies green in their faces and sick to their stomach.

"No. Not bake goods. Bake Bads!" Pinkie gags as the memory ends.

"I didn't know that..." Applejack said in disbelief.

"I wonder why because not only was what you did a health violation, but many of those ponies were bedridden for weeks. You should've been fined heavily for that. Maybe, even prosecuted back then. But, the mayor swept it under the rug. It would've been bad form for an Element of Harmony involved in a potentially life-threatening scandal like food poisoning,"

As Applejack grew more uncertain, the doors opened again. Jason caught the apples and the pies coming inside. "Twilight? Why didn't you tell me?"

"I already used my stipend for that month to cover the medical bills for the sick ponies. So, I figured there was no reason to worry you," Twilight said meekly.

"What's the point of bringing up something already fixed? Twilight looked out for a friend. We helped her on the farm. And Applejack learned her lesson! it shouldn't matter!" Rainbow states firms.

"No, Rainbow. I messed up and got off easy. I can't in good conscience accept Twilight paying for my mess," Applejack said.

"Good conscience? There's nothing good about you!" The edge in Jason's tone made everyone stiffen up. "Throughout your testimony, you maintained your good character. Yet, you are the opposite of everything you said you were. Honest? Dependable? Good conscience? If any of that were true, what do you call my visit to your farm?"

Applejack gulped as her encounter with Jason was about to begin. The scene was like any other day for the apple farmer. She was there in the field bucking apples from here the trees. Wynonna was at her side, playfully barking as the apples fell into the bucket. Applejack was about to move to the next tree when Winonna started to whine and bark. Following her pet's direction, she sees a figure standing behind her fence. Applejack narrows her eyes as she moves up to her new guest.

"Can I help you?" Applejack asks. The farm mare had to cover her nose from the stretch. Jason's appearance took another dip from the last memory. Several dirty smudges and stains adorn his worn-down cloak. His clothes were showing signs of tears and holes.

"H-Hello, I'm sorry to bother you, but I have nowhere else to turn," Jason said in a soft and fragile voice.

"And what do you want?"

"If-If it is not too much trouble, would you let me work at your farm? I can work any hour and out of sight,"

"Hmm, you don't look like much of an apple bucker,"

Jason leans a little forward as he pleads his case. "That's not a problem. I-I can climb the trees if you want and carry the buckets. Whatever chores you have or don't like, I can do," Jason drops entirely on his hands and knees, bowing his head as he begs. "Please, don't send me out there again!"

Applejack arches a brow as she sighs. "Alright, let's see what you got. By the looks of you, I'd say you need more than a place to work. How's a nice shower, cot, and meal sound?" Applejack motions to follow her as she walks back to the trees.

"That's great," Jason said with joy. "So, what do you need me to do?"

Applejack positions herself right in front of Jason. "I thought I show you how to buck something up close properly. It goes like this!"

Before Jason could blink, Applejack twirls around and bucks her hindlegs into his torso. There was a sickening cracking sound as Jason flew halfway back to the fence before hitting the ground. Jason gasps, trying and failing to catch his breath. White noise dominated his ears while black spots danced in his vision. He tried to sit up, but the pain flooded his body as he coughed up blood. He barely had the strength to look up at Applejack, who wore a hateful glare.

"Ya think I was born yesterday? I know who you are. You're the varmint that broke into Rarity's place and had been stalking around town! I hoped you'd be smart enough to stay off my property, but all you monsters are the same. I'm just glad I was out here instead of Applebloom or Granny. Now go back to whatever mudhole that spat you out and leaves good honest pony folk alone!"

Jason still could not move. He could barely hear Applejack's words between the ringing in his ears and Winonna's barking. He could barely even breathe. "A-A-Ark!!"

"Alright, you want to play hardball?" Applejack spins on her heels and blows into her hooves. "Winonna, sick him, girl!"

The apple family dog was on Jason in seconds. He barely had time to put his left hand up as Winonna bites into it. The new surge of pain was enough to spike an adrenaline rush in Jason as he shook the vicious puppy off and ran off into the outskirts of the farm and the forest beyond. The memory ends with haggard breaths of Jason clutching his bleeding hand and side as he collapses on the ground unconscious. Once again, the voices of the courtroom are silent. All the members, even the Flim Flam brothers, wore looks of abject horror. For added effect, Jason shows the deep bite marks on his hand to the court as he goes over to the new arrivals. Smirking, he disrobes to show off his scarred body again.

"So, tell me something? Does my tattoo match any of the trees you saw your sister buck?" Jason asks Big Mac. He saw how stern their gazes were at him. Now, their expression was one of shock and disgust. Big Mac opens and closes his mouth before he looks away. Jason then shows his hand to Granny Smith. "How about it, Granny? Can you see Winonna's dental work? She has a strong jaw,"

"..." Granny said nothing. She hangs her head in shame.

Jason only spared the fillies a glance but saved his words. All of them looked horrified, so the point was well made there. He does the same for the Pie family, sparing them a glance but saying nothing. Igneous and Cloudy looked deeply disturbed. Maud Pie was the most expressive he's ever seen her. Her eyes were wide like an average pony while she covered her muzzle. Limestone's face was a mixture of anger and disgust. But it was directed at Applejack, not Jason. She covers her ears, no doubt an instinct to hide from the sound of bones breaking. Poor Marble Pie was the worst. She crouched against her father, covering her eyes and letting out soft whimpers. Jason didn't bother looking at Rainbow's parents. They would come last with their daughter.

Moving back to Applejack, Jason saw she was still frozen in shock. He brings his fingers to his lips and blows a whistle, much like Applejack did in the memory. The sudden sound works as the mare turns her gaze to him. "Have you finished processing yet? To save time, yes, that was you. No, that was not fake. Yes, you are a lying contemptible abuser like all the others. Do you need anything else? But, I got to give you credit. You lured me in, giving me hope, only to shatter it like my ribcage. Not even Chrysalis is capable of that level of deceit,"

"N-No, I--" The Gjallarhorn pulses at that moment, seemingly done with the excuses itself, as magic bursts from Applejack. A realization flashes over her before she slowly falls to her knees. "I did that. I honestly-- Urk!" Applejack covers her mouth as she swallows the bile in her mouth.

"Yeah, I'd be sick to my stomach too. I meant what I said earlier about agreeing with that little message of the day you showed us. It fits so well with what I said about meeting your heroes. It's funny. Out of all of you who betrayed their elements, the liar is the biggest hypocrite,"

"...Why...?" A small broken voice calls out. A voice Applejack knew exceptionally well. "Why did you do that, Applejack?"

Applejack looked into the teary-eyed face of her little sister and felt more bile beginning to rise. "Applebloom, I--"

"Why?! How could you be so mean? How could you be so cruel? You always told me to treat others kindly and be straight and honest with the truth. But, you hurt him. He was begging you for help, and you sicked Winonna on him! Is that why I found blood around her mouth that day? I thought she got hurt!"

Tears begin to form in Applejack's eyes as she reaches out to her sister. "Applebloom. I'm sorry. I--"

"Sorry doesn't fix this! You! You ain't my sister!" Applebloom cries out as she runs out of the courtroom.

Granny Smith sighs deeply as she turns to her eldest. "Big Mac, can you please go after her and take her back home?"

Big Mac looks between Applejack and Granny Smith before shaking his head. "...Eeyup..." He said in a soft tone.

"Big Mac?" Applejack calls out to her older brother. Big Mac stops momentarily before quickly leaving the courtroom without turning back. Granny Smith was now standing before Applejack with a hard, stern glare. Applejack suddenly felt like a filly again as she could not look her Granny in the eyes.

"Applejack. Look at me!" Granny's tone made Applejack wince, but she complies. She trembles under Granny's gaze before the apple matriarch holds out her hoof. "Give it here,"

Applejack's eyes went wide. "G-Granny, please. You know I--"

Granny raises her hoof to silence her. "Don't embarrass them and us further,"

Nothing could stop the tears from flowing now as she slowly took her stetson hat off and handed it to Granny Smith. "...I'm sorry..."

"I ain't the one owed an apology," Granny turns away from her granddaughter as she faces Jason. Everyone gasps again as Granny bows to Jason in reverence. "I don't suppose you'd be willing to do an old mare a favor?"

"..." Jason merely cocks his head to the side.

"I figured not..." Granny silently moves and sits at the defendant's side. Applejack does the same as she sits back down at the edge of the bench. Her blonde mane cast shadows over her eyes in place of her missing stetson hat.

"Pardon our intrusion of the court. But I am Cloudy Quartz, and he's my husband, Igneous Rock. We are looking for our daughter, Pinkie. We understand that she's been dismissed,"

"Yes, she is held in confinement at the moment. The guards will take you to her. If you choose to return, there shall be no more outbursts from Pinkie Pie. Understood?" Luna asks.

The pie family all bow their heads. "Thank you, your grace,"

As the Pie family leaves, Jason steps toward the defendant's bench. There was only one left now. One more hurdle until his justice is finalized. He glares into the soul of the last mare, cocks his head to the right so that his blind eye is more prominent, and grins down at his worst tormentor. "And we saved the best for last. Hello, my little Dashie,"

"NO!!!" A sudden scream draws everyone's attention as an orange blur tackles Jason to the ground.

Update

Hey, guys. I have some bad news. I got to take some time off here. Things are getting wild. I'll try and be back when I can. It was real foolish of me to think I could keep putting things off. The chapter should be out in half of Fortnite. :trollestia:

The Reject

Author's Note

I had to split this one. Enjoy.

The Reject

[Canterlot - Dungeons.]

All members of the Pie family are walking briskly through the dungeon. The guards were on either group, moving at the same pace. The jail itself had a slew of occupants. But, it was primarily vacant the closer they got to Pinkie's cell. There, the Pie family finds Pinkie. She is sitting with her back facing them. However, a white jacket covers her body. Pinkie's mane and tail were still flat and straight. She is rocking back and forth while Limestone looks at the scene with a scowl. She turns to one of their escorts and starts shouting.

"What the hay is this!? Why is she in one of those looney pony clothes?!"

"A precaution, ma'am. She would not stop struggling and bending the bars to escape," One guard said.

"Yeah, the only way to appease her was to give these rocks. Aside from the muttering and occasional twitch, she's been docile," The other guard said.

Limestone huffs and goes back to her sister. "Pinkie?"

"La-la la-Lala. Hmm-hmm hm hm hm-hm-hm," Pinkie mutters.

"Pinkie, it's us," Maud's tone was slightly higher due to her concern.

When Pinkie continued to hum that song, her mother spoke. "Pinkamena Diane Pie,"

Pinkie finally turns around as her family grimaces. Black tear stains left streaks on her cheeks. A manic smile unnerves her family. And her pupils darted in every direction. In front of her were miniature stone figurines of her and her friends with Jason. "Hey, Ma and Pa. Limey, Marbie, and Maudie. You're just in time for Jason's birthday bash,"

Seeing Pinkie throw her unrestrained hooves in the air made the guards move forward. "How did you get out of your restraints--"

Before the guards could finish, Maud was standing in their faces. "Leave!" There was no indication of two escorts save for an outline of pony-shaped smoke. "Pinkie? What's going on?"

"I'm making up for lost time with all my best friends. See, I did the math. Jason missed his welcome party. Then, three birthdays. And we can't forget the once-a-month get-togethers. So, that's like two thousand hours of partying. All my friends are having a blast. Come say hello, Marble,"

Marble Pie flinches back as Pinkie thrusts the figure of Jason to her face. "H-hello?"

"Hello, Marble. Your sister told me all about you. Let's have fun," Pinkie puppets.

"Pinkie," Limestone asks tentatively.

"You'll all love Jason. He has so many new and crazy stories from his world. Weirdly, no one else has come by yet. I could've sworn I sent invitations to everyone in town. Meeting an alien is something everyone should enjoy," Pinke said with a deranged chuckle.

"Maybe they don't want to come to see that thing! It's so uncouth!" Pinkie puppets the Rarity figure.

"It terrifies me more than any critter I've met," The Fluttershy figure said.

"Now, that's not very nice," Pinkie said.

"It's freaky and dishonest looking. I don't want it near my family!" The Applejack figure said.

"Pinkie!" Limestone calls her name.

"Come on, girls. If we like Spike, then Jason is no different. Did you hear all the funny jokes he told us?" Pinkie asks.

"What jokes? You don't know any because you never talked to him. You were fine spreading fake rumors. I bet you can't name any of his favorite foods," The Rainbow puppet said.

"Sure I can!"

"Pinkie Pie!" Maud said more forcefully than her sister.

"There's chocolate cake. Strawberry cinnamon rolls--"

"Those are all the things you like eating. You don't know anything about Jason, do you?" The Rarity puppet said.

"Well, that's what the party is for, silly. To get to know each other better,"

"Pinkie!!!" Marble mutters loudly.

"How can you do that if Jason ignores you? Face it. He wants nothing to do with you, and you have no one to blame but yourself!" The Twilight puppet stated.

"No, he's not ignoring. I, Pinkie, Promise everything is going to be better now! I Pinkie Promised! I Pinkie--"

*SMACK*

Pinkie's head jerks back from the sudden blow to her cheek. She looks at her father in shock as he hugs her. "No more, pumpkin. You hold no fault in this,"

Pinkie tears up again as she pulls away. "I can't, Pa. I Pinkie Promise. I have made things right!"

"Pinkie! Get this through your thick head! He wants nothing to do with you! It's time to stop all these silly promises. You can't fix things like that!" Limestone hollers.

Pinkie's lips tremble as she looks down. "It's the only way I know how to be serious--"

"No, it isn't! Do you know your problem? You never grew up! From the moment you first left the farm to now. You treat everything like it's sunshine and rainbows,"

"What was I going to do? Stay at the boring old rock farm and always be miserable?!"

"No. But farming those rocks build maturity. Something you never did! I always told you that the world isn't friendly. It can be mean and nasty!"

Maud places a hoof on Limestone's shoulder and moves past her. "I know you don't want to hear this, Pinkie. But she is right. Being a grown-up means accepting the mistakes we made. Only fillies and colts rush to fix things when they know it's bad,"

"B-But, adults do fix the problems. H-He won't let me do that. Even though I am guilty..." Pinkie said solemnly.

"And part of an adult is accepting things beyond our control. Pinkie. There is a strong chance that Jason will never forgive anypony for his suffering. You must understand that. Some scars never go away, and he wears them for the world to witness. What must happen now is you learn this. Give yourself room to grow, and never repeat your failings. Undersand?" Cloudy Quartz explains.

"So, he'll never forgive me?" Pinkie whines.

"That is his choice, Pinkie. You have to respect it," Marble said. Overcome with more emotion, Pinkie hugs her family and sobs intensely.

[Canterlot - Hall of Mural Windows.]

Big Mac trots up and down Canterlot to find his sister. It was amazing how much ground a distraught filly can cover. Eventually, with the aid of some guards, Big Mac finds his sister sitting in front of the stained glass window of the time their sister defeated Nightmare Moon. Big Mac sighs in relief before he gasps at what is in Applebloom's hoof—a big fat rock. Big Mac quickly gallops to his sister just as she goes to rear back a throw. Thankfully, Big Mac stops his litter sister before she can ruin it.

"What are you doing, Big Mac?" Applebloom said in a huff.

"Stopping you from defacing a royal mural and dropping a fine on us the size of the farm,"

Realizing her actions, Applebloom drops the rock before scowling at the window. "...She doesn't deserve ponies looking up to her! She isn't a hero! She belongs in Nightmare Moon's place! I hate her!"

Big Mac frowns as he tries to find the right words. "I suppose you're right. I can't rightly excuse what she did. It goes against our apple hospitality. I understand protecting your kin. But, the way she has gone about it wasn't right..." Big Mac looks down at his sister and sees her grumbling before looking out the window. "Do you think Princess Luna is evil?"

"What? Of course not. She's not Nightmare Moon,"

"So, you like her even though she did something bad, got banished, and returned to do it again?"

"Nightmare Moon took over Princess Luna. Nothing took over, Applejack!" Applebloom counters.

Big Mac nods at his sister. "But Luna is feeling responsible because she got all jealous. Since then, she's done an excellent job making up for it. You don't have to forgive Applejack right now. I know she's kicking herself down right now. But give her a chance to make up for this. Apples don't abandon their kin if they are sorry,"

"...I didn't hear her apologize to Jason..."

Another frown appears as Big Mac responds. "It will take time for Applejack's actions to hit her. You know how she is. And, I reckon that Jason fellow is not in the mood for any of her words. Things will get better with time. Granny asked me to take you home,"

"No, I want to see how this ends,"

"Eeyup," The two Apple siblings begin walking out of the castle and back to the courtroom.

[Canterlot Judicial hall.]

Jason groans in annoyance as, yet again; he stares up at the ceiling. He knew this was going to happen eventually with one of the crusaders. And it was the first one he thought would do something like this. However, the weight was off his chest almost as soon as he hit the ground. He sits up to see Scootaloo struggling in a green aura. The unamused face of Chrysalis came into view.

"Honestly, I am going to have to put foal locks around you. How many times today will I be scrapping you off the ground?' Chrysalis complains.

"Let her go!" Rainbow hollers as she gears up for a charge. However, Celestia's wing bars her path. "Princess, what gives?"

"If you move an inch into the air, I will pluck out each feather until you're as flightless as a chicken!" Celestia threatens. The look she was sending Rainbow made the prismatic mare shriek into her seat.

"Enough! It appears this court is far too lenient on all these outbursts. Guards! Take Scootaloo--"

"No, let her stay," Jason said, cutting Luna off. "Tempers are bound to flare up during this. And a filly like Scootaloo here lacks the self-control of any adult. Well, mature adults anyway," Rainbow scowls at the subtle jab at her and Pinkie Pie. Jason smiles at her before moving to Scootaloo. Chrysalis lets go of her hold while the filly glares up at Jason. Jason noticed she clutched her stomach in the same spot she hit him. "You should count yourself lucky that little tummy ache is all you are feeling right now,"

"Is that all you got?!" Scootaloo grunts out.

"Scootaloo, stop!" Sweetie Belle said.

"Well, that was all you had. Actually. Have you not been paying attention? Now, why did you feel the need to disrupt court proceedings?"

"I'm not going to let you bully my friends!"

Jason stares at the filly for a time before he bursts out laughing. "Bully, huh? That's a new one. Tell me do you know at all how courts work? Here's how adults do handles bullies. The defendants - your friends and sister - hurt me. They tease me. They pushed me. And many other things I haven't shown the court yet. Ponyville was the schoolyard, and I was the kid everyone pointed their hooves at and laughed. I mean, look at them and look at me. If I was the bully, where are their scars? You know exactly what's that like, don't you?"

Scootaloo was hesitant a moment before continuing. "W-Well. You didn't have to make Applebloom--"

"I didn't. She did," Jason points to Applejack. "Alright, let's get down to the real thing bothering you. You're an intelligent filly. You know right from wrong, which is more than I can say for Ponyville. But here's why you acted out. It's not because I am a bully. Or, I made your friend cry. It's because you are afraid. You're worried that your hero, Rainbow Dash, isn't who she said she was. You're so scared that I am right. Everything that you believe I am, Rainbow Dash is! You're afraid I'll ruin the image of your hero. And, you know what? You should be! The one thing the world loves more than a hero is to see a hero fail. Why do you think no one is defending her?"

"You're wrong!"

"Yeah, you don't know our daughter!" Windy said.

"We'll stand by her no matter what you try to say!" Bow said.

"By all means. Stand by the rotten mare you help create. I can see why she thinks she's god's greatest gift to the world. There's nothing I hate more than parents that excuse the fucked up behavior of their kids! But let's get started. We all know Rainbow Dash. Courageous. Heroic. Element of Loyalty. She's also reckless. Headstrong. Arrogant. Always the first pony to engage--"

"You forgot one hundred percent more awesome than you'll ever be!" Rainbow said proudly, but no one but her parents cheered for her

"--And make everything worse,"

"Indeed, this appears to be true. Your boastful pride will be the end of you!" Judge Zekia said.

"What? So, am I wrong for having confidence in myself? And tackling anything that would hurt my friends and Equestria?" Rainbow said.

"So, when you and your friends went to tackle Crimson, why did you think assaulting him and driving him into a rage was a good idea?"

"None of the other ideas was working. Get him out of the cave. Let Fluttershy work her magic,"

"Right, because Fluttershy only responded to the imminent threat to all your lives. We wouldn't have had this conversation if she had not stepped up. But that's what you believe is a job well done. Was this the same mindset you had at the Gala? Where you knocked a stallion in the air to impress the Wonderbolts. Not to mention the statue you so bravely stopped from breaking until it smashed into the pillar that destroyed the ballroom,"

"The thing was too heavy. Yeah, I was trying to impress the Wonderbolts. But, I wasn't out there looking to hurt anypony. I was good enough and fast enough to make sure things went smoothly. Princess Celestia even said it was the best triple G she's had. That's why we have invited us!"

More murmurs went off as Celestia hid her hoof with a groan. "Mother of me..." She said.

"So, all that damage was blown over because the Princess knew you and your friends' penchant for causing disaster was just the thing to liven the party up. It's incredible how many things involving you girls are overlooked. But, you contest that there is no fault on your part. Well, what about this?"

The Gjallarhorn glows from Jason's touch as the memory that Pinkie displayed shows again. "Why are we watching this again?" Rainbow asks.

"There's a segment I want to court to see. This entire conflict between the Appleloosians and Buffalo tribe did not escalate with Pinkie's Pie's silly dance. It happens much earlier with you and Applejack,"

"We promised to get the buffalo a chance to talk," Rainbow said while pushing Little Strongheart to Bareburn.

Applejack walks up with a frown on her face. "Yeah, about what?"

"We brought our pal Little Strong Heart here to explain to the Appleloosian why they should leave Buffalo lands,"

"Why, thank you. That sounds helpful--"

Braeburn tries to say, but Applejack pushes him. "That's funny because cousin was about the buffalo and why the apple trees need to stay,"

"That will be a useful thing to--"

This time, Rainbow Dash cuts Little Strong Heart off. "The land is theirs. You planted the trees without knowing. Honest mistake. Now, you just got to move them, that's all,"

"They busted their rumps here. And now they're supposed to bust their rumps again because some buffalo won't stampede somewhere else?"

"Plant the trees somewhere else!" Rainbow inisited.

"Where? It's the only flatlands around these parts!" Applejack refuted.

"The Buffalo had it first!"

"The settler ponies need it to live!!!"

The memory ends with Applejack and Rainbow arguing. "What does that prove? That Applejack and I can disagree on something?"

"No, it proves that you could not keep impartial on an important matter that honestly did not concern you. If you had let Braeburn and Little Strongheart talk things out instead of walking over them, the fight in Appleloosa never would've come about,"

"Or if the Appleloosians made sure there was nopony else on the land before planting trees, then none of that would've happened!"

"To settle on the land, the Appleloosian should've gone to the royal court for permission," Judge Luna said. Celestia nods in confirmation. "However, the responsibility over the land dispute lies with the settlers and buffalo tribe. What were the circumstances of the element's arrival?"

"We were delivering a tree from Applejack's to help out," Twilight informs. "We just stumble across this problem,"

"Then, I do not believe it is fair to place sole blame on this issue on any of the elements," Judge Luna said.

"If you merely stumble upon this incident, why did you not report to Celestia about the issue instead of injecting yourselves right in the middle? You had no diplomatic authority,"

"Well, if the elements attempted to use their status to promote themselves as diplomats, they would be guilty of any consequences for posing as them. They acted only as civilians helping their friends and relatives,"

"Hmm, I suppose I can concede this point to you," Rainbow smiles smugly at their first win. "However, I have to question why you switched loyalties and stood against your friends and the Appleloosians. This was not the first instance of this happening,"

"I've always been loyal to friends and Equestria. I never turned my back on them!!!"

"Well, I have two witnesses that say different,"

The door opens as several ponies and a griffin walk through them. Rainbow's eyes slam open at so many familiar faces. "Spitfire. Soarin. Fleetfoot? You're speaking against me?"

"We were invited here. I don't know what's going on, to be honest. We only just arrived from Cloudsdale," Spitfire explains.

"You should be worrying about us, Rainbow Crash!" A blond-maned and turquoise-furred pegasus said. She wore a black and green flight suit with a cocky grin.

"Huh? I used to call her Lame-bow Dash. Let's combine them. Lame-bow Crash. Ha, nice," The griffin laughed. She had white feathers with purple accents around her eyes with brown fur.

"Gilda? Lightning Dust?" Rainbow hollers.

"Hey, she remembers me," Lightning Dust snarks.

"How could you, Gilda? Lightning, I get it. But, you? I thought we made up!"

"We did until I got his story. And it fits so well with how you always treated me," Gilda said.

"Not to mention, you got me kicked out of the Wonderbolts!" Lightning added.

"You did that to yourself when you nearly got my friends killed. And you G were acting like a jerk at your welcome party!" Rainbow counters.

"Order! Order in the court! It seems you have a lot of disgruntled acquaintances, Miss Dash," Luna said.

"I can attest that Lightning Dust was kicked out of the Wonderbolts. Judge," Spitfire said.

"Then, I would say you tarnished the Wonderbolts' reputation," Jason calls out.

"Gah-- Oof!" Soarin nearly shouts out before Fleetfoot elbows him in the side.

"What makes you say that?" Spitfire asks.

"Before I answer that, could everyone here state their names and profession for the record?"

"Captain Spitfire of the Wonderbolts,"

"First Lieutenant Soarin of the Wonderbolts,"

"Second Lieutenant Fleetfoot of the Wonderbolts,"

"Lightning Dust. Ex Wonderbolt cadet,"

"Gilda Bronzetalons. Scones baker,"

"How would you describe Rainbow Dash and Lightning Dust during their time at the training academy?" Jason asks.

"Both mares are exceptional. However, Lightning pushed herself harder than Rainbow Dash. But, therein lies her flaws. She went too far, and her extreme stunts were a danger to herself, her teammates, and bystanders,"

"Tsk," Lightning sucks her teeth. Rainbow Dash shoots her a smug grin.

"But that isn't the full detail. As I understand, the training academy puts their cadets in pairs where one is the leader and the other is the second. You appointed Lightning Dust as the lead pony because she pushes herself harder than Rainbow Dash, correct?" Jason asks.

"Correct," Spitfire said. Lightning sends a grin right back at Rainbow.

"How would you describe Lightning and Rainbow as a duo team?"

"The two of them together were exemplary. They were breaking every academy record we had. Unfortunately, we had to scrub them when Lightning was expelled,"

"What?! You mean you didn't keep my records?" Lightning shrieks.

"Why should she? You didn't deserve recognition for ignoring safety rules and putting ponies in danger," Rainbow taunts.

"Just like she did not deserve getting kicked out in the first place," Jason said. "Lightning, can you show the court the events leading up to your expulsion?"

"Just touch this horn thing, right?" Lightning asks while Jason nods.

The memory plays out at the dizzy Tron. Rainbow had the fastest recovery time from a spin-out, while Lightning Dust requested to do her test with the maximum settings. While she did not recover the most immediately, Spitfire commended the mare for going the extra mile. Thus, Spitfire made her lead pony. The next scene shows the cadets running obstacle courses. Lightning tells Rainbow to follow her lead. While Lightning had no trouble moving at her pace, Rainbow was struggling. They broke the course record by the end, but Rainbow clips her wing. The final exercise was cloudbusting. Lightning suggests the two form a tornado to pass the course quickly. The tactic was working; however, no one accounted for the elements to arrive and get swept up in the tornado. After being saved, Lightning goes to hoof bump Rainbow Dash, but she refuses. Sometime later, Lightning Dust was flanking behind Spitfire and two stallions as the elements sat at the runway.

"Rainbow Dash. How dare you leave my office without me saying a word back! You were right. The Wonderbolts accept only the best. But being the best should never come at the expense of our fellow pony. We should strive to push ourselves in the right direction. You've shown that you can do that," Spitfire motions for Lightning to come forward before she rips the medal off her uniform and sends her away.

Lightning pulls her hoof away in a huff. "Ha. That's for the reminder. If you wanted to make me look bad, you're doing a sorry job," Rainbow taunts.

"Rainbow Dash, could you show the court when you told Spitfire you'd quit the Wonderbolts?" Jason asks, undeterred by the taunting.

"Pfft, fine, make me look better," Rainbow Dash said.

Touching the Gjallarhorn, Spitfire's office came into view. "This better be important. You're supposed to be out there busting clouds with your partner,"

"We're done with that, ma'am," Rainbow saluted.

"Already? That's an academy record. Explain your methods,"

"That's why I'm here, ma'am. Lightning Dust decided to use a tornado,"

"A bit excessive for cloudbusting. But, judging by your time, it was an effective tactic,"

"Yeah, well, that effective tactic nearly took out my friends! There's a big difference between pushing yourself as hard as possible and being reckless. And if being reckless is award around here, then I don't want any part of it!" The memory ends with Rainbow taking off her wing pony medal.

"Whoo, Way to go, Rainbow," Scootaloo cheers.

"That's my girl!" Bow said.

"You're an inspiration," Windy said.

Suddenly, the sound of uncontrollable laughter goes off. Gilda was on the ground, holding her belly as she wiped the tears from her eyes. "S-Seriously? Are you plucking kidding, Dashie? Are you trying to act like you are the humble, upstanding type? You're the most reckless pony I know. I got more than a few stories to prove it,"

"You don't know what you're talking about, Gilda!" Rainbow sneers.

"You will have your chance, Glida," Jason interrupts.

"So, what was the point of showing us this?" Cadance asks. "This only works in favor of Rainbow Dash,"

"The point is to highlight the rampant hypocrisy the elements bearer exude. Rainbow has the nerve to lecture Lightning Dust about recklessness when we have seen time and again her doing arguably worse with her recklessness. And, she, ironically, is rewarded for said behavior that she abolishes. Where was the integrity for all the other times? Now, I know what you're going to say. It was all in the past. Rainbow has changed. Yet, in this same court, in the present time, Rainbow Dash tried to attack me twice and received multiple warnings. Despite this fact, the Gjallarhorn would not allow such actions. Is that not reckless? In truth, I do not believe Lightning Dust should've been expelled from the Wonderbolts,"

"Are you saying that her behavior was acceptable?" Spitfire said, stunned.

"No, I am saying that Rainbow Dash and Lighting Dust should've been expelled!"

"What?!" Both Lightning and Rainbow exclaim.

"Both Rainbow and Lightning made that tornado together. Both Rainbow and Lightning made their classmates spin out on the course. A wing pony doesn't just follow their leader. They can tell their leader when they disagree with a course of action,"

"Are you kidding? Lightning wouldn't listen to anything I said. She's too full of herself!" Rainbow said.

"Hello, pot. Have you met my friend, kettle?" That simple phrase made Rainbow Dash lose steam. "Why else were you so quick to be her friend initially? Regardless, you could've informed Spitfire of Lightning Dust's actions earlier. But, you still aided her."

Spitfire signs as she speaks up. "Okay, I may have given the wrong impression of what the Wonderbolts wanted from our cadets. But I am a big enough mare to admit I am wrong. Rainbow showed me that. So, I let her stay,"

"But that is not the only reason. Let me ask you this; are civilians allowed on military grounds?"

"No, we have specially assigned dates where civilians come tour the grounds,"

"And why is that?"

"We run dangerous drills that can be detrimental to inexperience flyers and non-winged creatures," Fleetfoot said.

"Then, it is safe to assume that Rainbow's friends were punished accordingly for trespassing on military ground unannounced,"

Spitfire's eyes go wide at the question. "I am afraid I don't understand your meaning," She winces slightly and rubs her ear as the Gjallarhorn emits a low hum.

"It's a simple question. I am sure you have a procedure - Laws even - for illegally entering military buildings. What was the punishment for the elements interrupting a training drill?"

"W-Well, you see. It was an honest case of wrong place, wrong time. We can't punish everypony too harshly," The hum grew louder as Spitfire grunted in discomfort.

"Is it that everypony gets a pass for an honest mistake? Or is it to do with those ponies and their connections? I want to know why only Lightning Dust was punished when you praised her behavior multiple times. Why was she kicked out for nearly smashing Rainbow Dash's friends when none of them had the authority to be there? Lightning could not have known that would happen since cadets and experienced members were allowed there!"

The humming was loud enough for everyone to hear. Yet, strangely, only Spitfire was showing signs of visible discomfort. "Stop! Stop that humming!"

"You cannot lie in the presence of the Gjallarhorn. All you have to do is answer truthfully, and the humming stops,"

With sweat pouring down her brow, Spitfire screams out. "ALRIGHT! Alright. Here's the truth; I did not want to expel Rainbow because of her status as the Element of Loyalty..." Several gasps went out from this confession. "Neither did I want to punish her fellow elements. The news headlines would tear us apart if I punished Celestia's student and the mares that saved Equestria. The Wonderbolts would lose our credibility,"

"Ugh! I don't believe this!" Lightning screams as she gets in Spitfire's face. "Do you know what I faced getting kicked out of the bolts? I was a laughingstock in my hometown. A failure! Some losers could not bring their A-game to be a wonder bolt, but I am the one thrown away because I'm not buddy-buddy with the Princess. Well, forget that! I'm starting a group of my own. The Washouts! We'll be better than any show and member your cheap organization puts out!"

"For what it is worth, Lightning Dust, Rainbow Dash never wanted to play second to you," Jason touches the horn again to show Rainbow going into Spitfire's office again.

"Permission to enter, ma'am," Rainbow said.

"What is it, Rainbow Dash?" Spitfire asks.

"I had the best time on the Dizzy-Tron. Only six seconds!"

"And?"

"And you made me a wing pony!"

Spitfire slowly takes off her glasses. "Because I believe you and Lightning Dust will be an unstoppable time. Do you not think you will be an unstoppable team?"

"Yes, ma'am. I mean, no, ma'am. We'll be an unstoppable team, ma'am!"

"Then, what's the problem?"

Rainbow puffs out her chest as she speaks with conviction. "I think I should be lead pony, ma'am!"

"And I think Lightning Dust likes to push herself harder than you do. That's why I made her lead pony, got it?"

Rainbow's expression visibly deflates as she sulks out of Spitfire's office. "...Yes, Ma'am..."

As the memory ends, Lightning turns to Rainbow with a snarl. "Well, would you look at that? I always knew I was better than you. But, you could not stand it. How do we know you weren't trying to sabotage me?"

"Please! Even if I was a little bummed about being a wing pony, it doesn't change that you would've hurt somepony eventually," Rainbow said.

"But, I bet your ego could not stand that there was a pony better than, huh, Dashie?" Gilda taunts.

Rainbow grits her teeth in response. "Shut. Up!"

"You deserve everything this guy has in store for you. And can't wait for you to be the one that's rejected!" Lightning turns with a flock to her tail as she moves to the prosecution side.

"Miss Gilda. How long would you say you've to know Rainbow Dash?" Jason asks.

"We've known each other since we were fledglings. We both met at the Junior Speedster Flight Camp," Gilda explains.

"And how would you describe your friendship from then until now?"

"Looking back? We weren't friends,"

The Element of Loyalty

Author's Note

Added the "May the Best Pet Win" Episode to this.

The Element of Loyalty

[Cantelot - Judical hall.]

"We weren't friends?" Rainbow gasps. "How could you say that? I was the only one to talk to you!"

"Oh, you came by and said hello to me. We hung out. Everything was excellent for a while despite nopony else wanting everything to do with a griffin. For about a month. Then what happened after that? First, you ditched me for little Miss Wallflower over there. You stuck to her like glue. You kept the bullies off her back while leaving me to fiend for myself. Blowing me off for her. You never even bothered to introduce us!" Gilda points to Fluttershy, who squeaks. "Then, when you did your Sonic Rainbow, you were the talk of camp. Miss popular. Your fans always surrounded you, and you never seemed to notice me. The only time you ever bothered to help me was when I was fighting with three pegasi. And that was so that you could look good!"

"What? You got that all wrong!" Rainbow counters. "Maybe, if you did not start pushing ponies away and acting like a jerk twenty-four-seven, then ponies would want to hang out with you. You had to know that ponies were sensitive about that stuff!"

"What a load of manure! I only did that so those bullies would back off! In Griffinstone, you're either in front of the flock or behind it!"

"Order! I will not have this court delve into petty arguments. Miss Bonzetalon. Show us these alleged events for the sake of clarity,"

"Sure," Glida goes up to the Gjallarhorn and shows the memory. It was the same as the flashback in the Griffin Bushoff episode. Little Gilda was looking around the room with a nervous expression. All the other foals were playing and taking amongst themselves as Gilda was the only griffin. Jason noted that Gilda was a lot like Fluttershy in that she was timid and painfully shy. Suddenly, a Rainbow blur lands before her, causing Gilda to shield herself with her wings and tail.

"Hey, you're different," Little Rainbow said bluntly. "What are you?"

"I-I'm a griffin. My name is G-Gilda...."

"Hey, Gilda. I'm Rainbow Dash—the fastest flyer in flight camp. Since I'm awesome and you're different, we should be best buds,"

Little Gilda seems to beam and smile as the two shooke hoofs and claw. "It was all fine at the beginning. We laughed and played together. But when the pranks started, you flanked me more than once. And it didn't help that the teachers all had out for me. I was blamed for tricks I didn't even do!"

Another memory played with Rainbow Dash putting tacks on the teacher's seat. When she came and sat down, she shot into the air with a loud yelp. The students all laughed, but the teacher's eyes fell on Gilda. "Miss Bronzestalon! I suppose you think disrupting the class with pranks is funny!"

"But I didn't do it!"

"Whom else is there? You are becoming quite a nuisance. A month of detention should straighten you out! You can start sitting in the corner with the dunce cap on for the rest of the day!"

Gilda looks to Rainbow, only to receive a pleading look from the filly. With a sigh, she gets up. "Yes, teacher..."

Another memory shows Gilda and Rainbow walking by the building. They came across some students with paintbrushes defacing the side of the building. When they saw the teacher coming, they tossed the paint can and brush to Gilda and Rainbow. Rainbow took offense and flew after them. Thus, leaving Gilda alone as the teacher catches her with the incriminating evidence. Gilda smiles sheepishly while the teacher glares down at her.

"So, up to your tricks again?"

"But-but-but--"

"Enough! Detention for two months. You'll be cleaning every wall three times a day, starting with this one!"

The next memory shows a crowd of foals around Rainbow and Fluttershy. Rainbow was drinking in their praise and cheers after performing Sonic Rainboom. However, as Gilda went to approach, three coats blocked her path. "And where do you think you're going, chicken head?"

"E-Excuse me. I'm trying to get by, please..." Gilda timidly said.

"What's that? I can't understand you with that stupid beak face,"

"I bet she does nothing but bird craws anyway. Nothing important from a dumb parakeet,"

"I don't craw. Rainbow..." Gilda peers past the three bullies circling her to see Rainbow still laughing with the crowd. Suddenly, one of the colts pushes her. "H-Hey!"

"It's funny you think Rainbow cares about you. She only hangs out with you because you're a freak!"

The colt pushes Gilda again as she stumbles before the pony behind her pushes her again. "...Stop it!"

"Oh, yeah? What are you going to do, Chickenhead?"

Another push. This time Gilda stops herself and lets out a low growl. "Stop. It!!"

"Aw, that catbird is purring. It's so cute--"

Gilda shoots up and pushes the colt to the ground. She quickly bucks the second colt with her hind legs before tackling the third. The two tumble for a bit before Gilda rolls onto the top of the colt. She glares down at him while the pony looks up in fear. "I. Said. STOP!!!!"

Gilda's roar got the other students' attention. Many of them were afraid of Gilda's vicious scowl. Unfortunately, Fluttershy curls up to Rainbow's side. All the foals start leaving as the bullies start crying and running for the teacher. Gilda's anger fades to one of worry as Rainbow glares at her. "Not cool, Gilda,"

"You can guess what happened after that. The teacher came, I got in trouble, and my supposed friend ditched!" Gilda said as the memory ended.

"How was any of that my fault? We were foals, G. Foals! I can't stop other ponies from being jerks!" Rainbow said.

"You did it for her!" Gilda points to Fluttershy. "You needed a crowbar to separate you two while I was fiending for myself. After that, I quickly stopped being a chicken and became an eagle!"

"Right, because becoming a bully helped you make so many friends," Rainbow said flippantly.

"Our Dashie is right. You all were foals. Should those foals have bullied you? No. But that's the parent's fault for raising them poorly," Windy said.

"Yeah, and becoming a delinquent was never a good idea," Bow added.

"I can blame her for ditching me. I can blame her for not standing by me the same as she would for her pony friends!" Gilda counters.

"It was never like I didn't like you. But after you started acting like a bully, nopony wanted nothing to do with you anymore," Rainbow said.

"I did that because I had no choice! I wouldn't be a doormat for the entire flight camp!"

"...I'm sorry..." Fluttershy said.

"Fluttershy, what are you apologizing for?"

"Because I noticed Gilda would try and talk with us back when we were foals. But, I always felt uncomfortable around anypony new. And I was scared of you back then. I took Dashie's attention because I was too afraid. Even when we saw each other again at Ponyville, I haven't changed..."

"That's horse feathers. We were kids. We didn't even know we were going to be the element bearers. Even Applejack said she used to lie. Now, you're trying to blame us for things that happened years ago? What about you, G? You're not innocent in anything. Or did you forget you stole an apple, nearly gave Granny Smith a heart attack, and flipped out on all of us at your welcome party!"

"Order!" Luna bangs her gavel. "Unless we have misheard, you stole produce and assaulted the elderly?"

"Tsk," Gilda sucks her teeth before going to the horn.

The episode of the Griffin brush-off plays off from Gilda's perspective. The court saw how Pinkie kept trying to interject herself with Gilda and Rainbow Dash. However, Gilda started making excuses to leave her behind, such as races and flying higher. But Pinkie was persistent. Finally, Gilda resorted to physical means by popping her balloons and breaking her helicopter. Rainbow frowns at the words Gilda says about her friends. Then, the scene from the market plays. Gilda used her tail to scare Granny Smith away from the stand so she could swipe an apple. Afterward, Fluttershy bumps into Gilda, causing the griffin to unload and roar at her. Finally, at the party, Gilda loses her cool again after setting off all of Pinkie's pranks. Rainbow scolds her and effectively ends their friendship. Gilda storms off in a huff. However, the memory ends with Gilda wiping away her tears.

"It would seem that loyalty may have a point in her claims about you, Gilda. Your actions that day were far from acceptable," Luna said with a frown.

"While Gilda's actions were not ideal, much of it came to be attributed to how ponies have treated her. During her days at flight camp, she received bias and bigoted scrutiny. Exposure to that kind of treatment at a young age will harden anyone. It's why she became the bully, so she would not become a target of continued abuse. But, as for the party and the aftermath, a lot of it could've been avoided if Rainbow Dash was not so quick to abandon Gilda again," Jason said.

"Abandon her again? Gilda lied about treating my friends like dirt and losing her cool when she set off all my pranks! She could've stayed and apologized. But she chose to leave!" Rainbow said.

"And knowing Gilda for as long as you did, you should've seen her getting more irritable from those pranks. No one likes being humiliated like that. And you were quick to throw your friendship out the window,"

"Even so, I cannot condone all of Gilda's actions leading up to her outburst. There are better ways to conduct oneself. Gilda failed to do so," Luna said.

"Now, you want a minute, missy. I will let you know if there's more to what happened that day. I was the one that gave Gilda the bits to go to Equestria in the first place. Life isn't easy and fun-filled in Griffinstone. We griffins have to scratch and claw over scraps. We can't be soft and talk our problems away with friendship and harmony. And trust doesn't come without a price. Gilda went to Ponyvile so some loan shark wouldn't come clipping her wings. But she only had enough to get to Ponyville. What's one little apple compared to going weeks without food? You lot don't know how good you got it!" Grandpa Gruff said as he sighed. "It wasn't always like this. Our kingdom was bright and vibrant back when we had the idle of Boreas,"

Many members of the gallery had mixed reactions to Grandpa's Gruff explanation. "There's something that I believe is relevant to this case and the current state of affairs at Griffinstone. That attack from the Arimaspi wasn't an isolated incident," Jason said.

"Why do you say that?"

Jason hands another paper to Grandpa Gruff as he continues. "Arimaspi was paid off by a pony noble to steal the idol of Boreas. That letter would promise a hefty sum if Arimaspi were successful. He did not like King Guco, apparently,"

Grandpa Gruff bristled and shook with anger as he read aloud. "I, Shady Trot, promise the sum of one hundred thousand in the treasury to you, Arimaspi, to bring me the Idol of Boreas. Such a treasure does not deserve to be sullied by griffin claws!" Grandpa Gruff turns to Luna in anger. "What is the meaning of this?! I know this pony is talking about the royal treasury! Where else would he get that kind of bit?!"

"We know of the noble clan that Shady hails. Rest assured that the Equestrian crown has nothing to do with this plot. I swear on my word as a princess and the Gjallarhorn before us. We will be correcting this offense!" Luna said. Since the Gjallarhorn did not react, Grandpa Gruff sat back down.

"But, is this not par for the course for Equestrians by now? Who knows how many more dealings like this have gone on? How many other kingdoms have been undermined? I assure the court members that it does not stop there," More murmurs of agreement went off from the CFE side of the room. Jason pulls out another set of documents. "Now, back to you, Rainbow Dash. Isn't it true that you are a weather pony manager?"

"Yeah, what of it?"

"Yes, our Dashie is the best weather pony manager this side of Equestria," Windy said.

Jason nods. "That means you have the most knowledge in weather control. Enough to say operate the factory in Cloudsdale?"

"Yeah, it's not a problem for pros like me," Rainbow said.

"Nopony does a better job than her!" Bow said.

"Interesting statement. Especially considering she was responsible for Cloudsdale malfunctioning, leading to several thousand bits in equipment replacement and several ponies injured when the giant snowball hit Ponyville," Jason concludes, leaving Rainbow Dash to stiffen up.

"Wait, what do you mean?" Princess Celestia asks.

"I have here the hospital reports and the letter of request to you, Princess, for a stipend to replace the damaged machinery. However, it was not a freak accident or corroded appliances that led to the weather factories shut down for three additional months. It was sabotage from Rainbow Dash,"

"That's a lie!!!" Windy, Bow, and Scootloo said. None of them notice Rainbow Dash suddenly looking nervous.

Jason merely smirks as he touches the Gjallarhorn. Season 5, episode 5 of My Little Pony, plays for the court. It features Rainbow lamenting that Tank is going to hibernate for the winter. Rainbow does every conceivable method to prevent this. Her actions involved sabotaging her fellow weather ponies by redirecting snowfall back to the clouds, steering a flock of geese North instead of South, and busting clouds to reveal the sun. But, her most grievous offense was her going to Cloudsdale and sabotaging the equipment, resulting in the giant snowball crashing into Ponyville.

"As we can see from this memory. In supreme recklessness and selfish motives, Rainbow Dash set Clouddale back several months and brought harm to her fellow ponies," Jason said.

"B-But, I--"

"All to keep her pet tortoise awake from performing his natural biological functions. The element of loyalty chose to go against her fellow ponies' safety - To go against the natural order of the seasons - for a pet. I am sure the more knowledgeable ponies here know what happens if the seasons are not properly aligned," Now, there were many openly glaring at Rainbow Dash. "You endangered not just yourself but everyone in this very courtroom. All because you didn't want to be without a pet for a few months. A pet she, ironically, almost killed not once, not twice, but three times!"

"What? I would never hurt Tank!" Rainbow vehemently denies it.

"But you could've, Rainbow," Fluttershy said with venom. "Not just Tank, but every animal that hibernates. Sleeping during winter is essential to their lives because food is so scarce! Others need to sleep, or their bodies will shut down! Please tell me that was not the reason for all that craziness that winter,"

"Where was this energy when Rainbow Dash hosted a pet tetrathlon to see which pet was remarkable enough to be her pet? You even actively encouraged and handpicked animals to 'compete.'" Jason asks.

Jason touches the Gjallarhorn again to show Rainbow Dash standing before a group of avians. She had a coach cap and whistled as she gave the various flying creatures the rundown of what's expected for them to be a pet of Rainbow Dash. Applejack and Twilight question Rainbow's methods and if she knows that pets require care and affection. At the same time, Fluttershy moves Tank to the lineup. Fluttershy was adamant about letting Tank participate, while Rainbow was highly dismissive—the challenges initially seemed tame. However, many of the gallery members were off-put regarding the guts challenge. As Opal was highly aggressive would've no doubt injured any of the animals without a protective shell like Tanks'. The worse offense came when Rainbow held a race through the ghastly gorge. While Rainbow initially had no difficulty navigating the course, the animals were scratched, tangled, and almost eaten by the eels. Rainbow's hubris nearly results in her downfall as she crashes against the wall while praising herself and causes an avalanche. Thus, resulting in her wing getting trapped.

"No, wait, don't leave me! I'm supposed to win! I don't want to be stuck here forever! Somepony! Anypony! HELP ME!!!!!"

The memory ends with Tank and Rainbow leaving the gorge and Tank becoming Rainbow's new pet. "As you can see, not only did Rainbow Dash endanger the animals. She risked herself by making such an insane course. It's even worse when you consider that not one of the elements told her idea was ashine. Hell, you cheered and enabled her! I know your current laws practically degrade non-ponies to nearly the same status as animals, but how is this not a clear-cut animal abuse case?"

All the elements visibly wince at the memory and the truth of Jason's words. "I am inclined to agree," Cadance said with a deep frown. "What were you thinking, Rainbow Dash? Pets are not athletes. They are not meant to go through a path as deadly as the ghastly gorge! And why didn't you girls stop her? Especially you, Fluttershy!"

"...We had no idea it was that bad. If I had known beforehand--"

Fluttershy tries to explain, but Judge Novo cuts her off. "With a name like Ghastly Gorge, how can you think differently about the risk?"

"It seems even household animals are not safe around you, mares," Judge Squak said.

"But, everything worked out--"

"That is no excuse!" Celestia cuts in, glaring down at the pegasus. "As egregious as this new development is - and I am not underselling my vast disappointment in you girls - three extra months of winter delayed the crops of several farmlands. That put undue strain on their finances and food supply. Ponies would've starved if not for the bailout the crown provided, But that resulted in higher taxes for that year!" Nobles in the room were in an uproar as they had to pay some of those taxes.

"Order. Order in the court!" Luna said.

"I, well--" Rainbow stutters, unable to find the right words.

"What was the second time?" Fluttershy asks.

"T-There wasn't! Fluttershy, you know I wouldn't--"

This time, Jason interrupts. "It was when you avoided telling Pinkie Pie you did not like pie. So, you threw away every pie she made. One disposal method was feeding Tank a pie," Jason pulls out a medical file with Tank's picture and displays it for the court. "I am sure what several weeks of sugar overlord can do to animals,"

Fluttershy reads the reports with a look of horror. "...Rainbow. Animals are not like us! They can't eat large quantities of sugar! Especially tortoises. Their organs are too thin. Tanks' digestive tract can't handle something that complex! Why would you do that? To avoid telling Pinkie you don't like something!?"

"You know how Pinkie gets! She would never stop whining about it. Besides, I told Pinkie I did not like pies, and Tank is fine now--"

Fluttershy slams her hoof on the defense bench. "It's not okay! You can't keep messing up this bad and expecting things to be okay!"

"Fluttershy," Scootaloo said. She's been unsure of what to say as some of her friends from school were hurt by that giant snowball hitting Ponyville.

"I can't believe you're buying into this, Fluttershy," Windy said in a firm tone. "After all the times Rainbow stuck up for you!" Fluttershy flinches at this a little but remains strong.

"I can believe it. It's exactly how Dash rolls," Gilda said.

"And we should listen to you? Somepony quick to turn into a thug and try to besmirch our Dashie because you were too proud to say I'm sorry," Bow said, earning a snarl from Gilda.

"..." Scootaloo bows her head, choosing to stay silent.

Jason, at the words of Rainbow's parents, throws his head back and starts laughing. "What's so funny?" Rainbow asks.

"Oh, everything you said. Everything your parents said. I knew out of all your friends that you would be the most stubborn and delusional. You would deny every accusation - Every fact - to protect that ego and reputation. But, in a way, you should thank me for this,"

"I should thank you for trying to ruin our lives? You're crazy!"

Jason shrugs. "Maybe. I came close to it halfway through year two at Ponyville. But, no, I am afraid I am entirely sane. I would've loved to drift off. Go somewhere else. Wake up from the living nightmare. But, I was denied that release in more ways than one," Jason sends a pointed glare at Applejack as he says this. "But, I couldn't. You made sure of that, Dashie. But, as I said, you should thank me for all this. After all, all the attention is on you now,"

Jason puts his hand on the Gjallarhorn, and everyone tenses up. Rainbow put on a brave face. However, she feels a growing put of nervousness in her stomach. Jaason saved her last for a reason. The memory plays out like any other day in Ponyville. And again, Jason was sitting in an alley behind, sleeping against the wall. There was a calmness to the scene for a moment until a looming shadow appeared above Jason. Jason looks up to see a storm cloud and sees Rainbow Dash grinning down at him. Jason looked confused until a lightning bolt struck the space between his legs. Jason immediately scrambles to his feet in fright. The bright flash was disorientating. But he shakes it off and looks back up at Rainbow Dash.

"What are you doing?!"

"Dealing with a pest problem!"

Rainbow jumps on the cloud again to send another bolt of lightning. Jason barely managed to run out of the alley to avoid the strike. However, Rainbow Dash chased after him while continuously sending strikes at his feet. As Jason ran, ponies began blocking his path. Soon, several inhabitants of Ponyville were surrounding him in a circle. Jason frantically tried to look for a way out. Before he could speak, another clap of thunder rang out. White hot pain and a burning sensation spread throughout his entire body. The strike was only a few seconds, but it felt like an entity before Jason collapsed on the ground. The memory became fuzzy as Jason's vision was half black and uneven. The only sound the court members could hear was ringing and cheering.

"Good work, Rainbow!"

"You got that monster good!"

"You're a hero!"

"I know. I know. I told you my plan would be awesome. You should've seen how he danced when the lightning hit his hooves. Haha, priceless!" The ponies shared in Rainbow's laughter before the prismatic mare said sound something truly disgusting. "Alright, let's dump this thing in the Everfree where it belongs,"

"I don't want to touch it,"

"Yeah, it stinks!"

"What if poison my magic?"

"Fine, I'll do it," Rainbow said with a roll of her eyes. The memory ends with Rain carrying a barely conscious Jason by his leg in the air and unceremoniously dumping him slightly above the treeline.

The silence in the court was far more palpable than in any other instance since the trial began. Nearly everyone had their mouths gaping from the imagery. Rainbow's parents looked ready to faint; their seemingly unlimited support of Rainbow was momentarily gone. Applejack manages to wake up from whatever trance she is in to gasp at the sight. Jason also notices that the Pie family returned with the Apple siblings. Pinkie Pie broke down in silent sobs at the scene. Even Cozy Glow could not hide her shock. Jason's eyes never left Rainbow Dash. He scans Rainbow's surprise. The way her ears pinned themselves against her skull was terrific. She was looking even more diminutive than Scootaloo right now. Her number one fan was in a daze, unable to deal with the actions of her idol. It was time to twist the knife further.

"I woke to find that the vision in my eye was gone. Have any of you ever been electrocuted before?"

"..." No one responded.

"I thought not. It's like every cell in your body is on fire. It scrambles the nerve impulses the brain sends out to move your body. Oh, here's a fun fact. The survival rate is only ten percent for humans when struck by lightning. Let that sink in for a bit. An element of harmony - the hero of Equestria - made several lethal attempts at my life,"

"...I-I," Rainbow squeaks out.

"Oh, and that was just the first time. You shot lightning at me at least half a dozen times. That's multiple counts of attempted murder number one, complete with motive, opportunity, and premeditation. You can also add the citizens as accomplices as well. You even went the extra mile to toss my body in the Everfree for any creature looking for a quick meal," Jason said as another memory began to play.

This time, Jason was by a creek. His blind eye scanned the fish flowing into his crudely made fishing net. A small smile adorns his face as he pulls the net out of the water. That's when another crack of thunder and lightning strikes him. Jason lets out a wordless scream before he collapses on the ground again. Rainbow lands beside him, laughing as Jason wheezes.

"Ah haha. You thought you could pull a fast one on me? Nothing gets past Rainbow Dash, Wonderbolt extraordinaire!" All the Wonderbolts winced at the association. Rainbow then proceeds to empty the net of Jason's catch. "There you go, little fishy—safe and sound from the big bad monster. When you return to doing whatever it is fish do, tell the story of Rainbow Dash. The most awesome, loyal hero around,"

Rainbow Dash flies away as Jason slowly gets to his feet. He stumbles forward, trying to catch his breath, only to stop when a low growl goes off behind him. Jason hobbles to the water simultaneously as a manticore bursts from the bushes. The stream carries Jason into a muddy patch before he spots a cave. The sound of wings flapping gave him enough motivation to quicken his pace. Jason enters the cave and dives behind a stalagmite. The manticore following him was only a scout. Three of them entered the cave and started sniffing the area. There were numerous times when the beasts came close to finding Jason. It was only by the grace of Faust that they finally gave up and left the cave. The memory ends with Jason quickly sobbing after his brush with death.

"And, you claim me to be evil..." Chrysalis said with a shudder.

"It's funny how that works. I was under the impression that fish was acceptable for carnivores to eat. But, no, nothing was redeemable in Rainbow's eyes. There was no such thing as a compromise with you! You self-serving cunt! I was out of the way. I was already driven to live in that damn cave you saw. And that wasn't the only time my Everfree neighbors came for a bite to eat! But, anytime I came close to the village, Rainbow Dash was there with a trusty fucking torture device. Let's all wave and cheer how she bravely zaps a person that can't even fly!"

"Wait!" Rainbow said. "I-It's a lie. I never would do--" The Gjallarhorn glows brightly at Rainbow's words. It was brighter than any of the times it broke magic off the defenses. Rainbow even clutches her ears as Spitfire did from the loud hum. Rainbow jumps back from the stand when the magic bursts from her and crawls away from Jason as her parents comfort her. With a shaking hoof, Rainbow points to Jason in horror. "It's you! The monster!"

"Monster? No, no, no, Dashie. The only monster here is you! A more enormous monster than Nightmare Moon. That's you. A bigger villain than Chrysalis, that's what you are! Please don't run from it. Embrace it! It's not like you will be punished for your sadism. That's because you're in good company. I tell you what, I'd take Gilda and Lightning as friends instead of breathing the same air as you! Take a good look, Scootaloo. There is your bully! There is your monster! There is your hero!"

Scootaloo looks down with tears streaming down her face as Rainbow responds. "But, those clouds weren't big enough to k-kill any creature. They-they were like hoof buzzer,"

"Our Dashie isn't a killer!" Windy said.

"You have to be exaggerating those scars. I know I can take a few bolts now and again," Bow said.

"...I can't believe how dumb you are, dweebs," Gilda said in a low tone. "Non-ponies like us don't have the magic to soften the blow of electricity as ponies do. That was something they did teach in flight camp. Oh, right, I forgot. You flunked out of flight camp!"

"Gilda...." Rainbow cries weakly.

"NO! You don't get to justify anything! This is sick! Losing you as a friend was probably the best decision I ever made! I hope all your new friends were worth it!" Gilda walks past her and joins Lightning Dust.

"Rainbow Dash!" Spitfire calls out as she approaches her with venom in her eyes. "In all my years as a Wonderbolt, I never saw anything so heinous. Your actions spit in the face of everything we stand for and more. So, effective immediately, you are disbarred in disgrace from the Wonderbolts. All your accomplishments are null and void. And I suspect Cloudsdale will have some words with you. I wish you luck, but I won't waste my breath!" Spitfire turns away from the stunned mare. Walking out, Spitfire faces Lightning Dust. "If you still want another chance, my doors are open,"

Lightning scoffs at the offer, however, while pointing to Rainbow Dash. "If that's what passes for a Wonderbolt, I'll wear my Washout uniform with pride,"

"W-Wait...!" Rainbow says pitifully. Spitfire only glares at her and leaves without another word as Soarin and Fleetfoot follow behind. Meanwhile, Rainbow Dash starts to hyperventilate. Everything she has ever wanted since foal hood is now gone. Looking around the room, everyone was now glaring at her. All except Scootaloo, who turns away in shame of her. Her dream. Her reputation. Her achievements. Her sister. Her friends. She is losing every aspect of her life. And, in her eyes, there was one creature to blame. "...It's all your fault...!" Before anyone could react, Rainbow shoots up into the sky and bucks a nearby cloud. There was a thunderclap as lightning left the clouds and down at Jason. Jason had enough time to spread his arms as the bolt hit its target. Once again, Rainbow was too fast for anyone ready to stop her. However, her anger blinded her to a crucial detail as her body started to convulse in pain and agony. The same bolt that hit Jaosn envelops her. It was a pain Rainbow was unfamiliar with and wanted nothing more than never to feel again. She returns to the courtroom and lands in a broken heap before Jason.

"RAINBOW!!!" Her parents call out, rushing to her side. However, they both gasp as they examine Rainbow's form. Fractal scarring adorns her body in the same pattern as Jason's. But, the scarred tissue went to the base of her wings, resulting in them hanging limply to her sides. Her left magenta eye was now dull and blind, matching Jason's. Finally, like Fluttershy and Jetset before her, Rainbow's cutie mark is gone.

Jason's experience was much different. He shakes off the slight tingling sensation. The lightning strike did as little as a joy buzzer this time. He moves slightly closer. Seeing the scarring on Rainbow's body brought a certain level of satisfaction. Although, he also sucks his teeth when Rainbow Dash starts to stir and get up. At least now, he could look down at her as she did him. "It doesn't feel too good, does it?" The only answer Rainbow gives is harsh wheezing.

"What have you done to our baby?!!" Bow Hothoof paws at the ground.

"Guards! Restrain him now!" Luna orders as the guards swarm Rainbow's father.

"H-Hey! Get off of me!"

"No, why are you doing this? He's the one that hurt our foal!" Windy shrieks.

"Restrain her as well. I said there shall be no more outbursts!" Luna said as the guards converged. "And her, as well!" Rainbow cringes in pain as the guard pulls her aside with her parents. With one good eye, she looks at Scootaloo again, who is getting a hug from Sweetie Belle before Big Mac and Applebloom guide her away from the scene.

"No! Stop this! Give Rainbow her cutie mark! You are a bucking monster!!!" Windy wails.

"For what!? This is the result of your piss poor parenting. I don't remember you setting boundaries. It bothers me that you didn't tell her no. You gave her the impression that Rainbow was above reproach. So, when faced with her actions, she responds with the same reckless abandon she always does. Take a good look because this is the mare you raised,"

Jason shakes his head in disgust. "Throughout this whole trial, my reasons were questioned. Constant jeering and attempts were made to get me to throw my grievances out. Why? Because your lives are ruined? Because the elements are fucking saints? No! Because I deserve justice! No, I demand it! Just like any other living being! But look at what I had to do to get this far! I aligned myself with one of the biggest villains Equestria has ever known! I had to pray to the gods to have my voice heard because no other avenue was available. But you continue to call me a monster for wanting to go through proper channels. Believe me when I tell you it would've been easy to be the villain you tried to make me! In another place and time, I would've been out for blood! Well, too fucking bad because I wasn't going to give you that satisfaction because that is not who I am! But now we all know who your so-called heroes are!"

Jason points to Rainbow Dash. "Sadist!" He points to Applejack next. "Abuser!" Then, to Fluttershy. "Coward!" Rarity is next. "Selfish!" Then, he points to Celestia, "Neglectful!" And finally, at Twilight. Pinkie choked back another sob at Jason, who ignored her again. "Betrayer! All of you perfectly encapsulate the opposite of what you constantly try and preach. And, you dare say you want to open a school for other creatures? Why? So can they be abused? So that they can be your next target? It would've been a glorified veterinarian building anyway with your laws!"

Jason's face is contemptuous while glaring at the defendants and everypony present. "An now, here we are at the end. I said I would expose all of you. Now comes your punishment. But I only have one question left. Why me?"

"...W-What?" Twilight asks.

"Why me! I didn't come seeking to disrupt your lives. I didn't threaten to bring eternal night. I didn't invade you or replace you," Jason's voice starts to crack. "I didn't come to enslave you. I didn't come to steal your magic away. I didn't steal your crown. I didn't create alternate timelines to ruin your friendships," Tears start swelling in his eyes as he trembles. "I just wanted to know you. I just wanted to be friends. You gave all your villains a chance at redemption. Some of them are in this courtroom as better ponies!" He gestures to Luna and Starlight, who shy away from him. "Why was I denied that courtesy? What was wrong with me that I was beaten down? That I was hurt so bad when others have done so much worse! Was it honestly because I was different? Do you truly hate something distinct from yourself? What did I do that was so vile to deserve all that? Why me? Why did you do this to me...?"

In the face of Jason's tears, Twilight did not have an answer. None of her friends, Celestia, the judges, or the gallery members could respond. The only sound now was Jason's cries as Chrysalis comforted him. Twilight felt tears leave her eyes as the total weight of her actions now hit her. She also looks at her friends to see the tears in their eyes. "...I don't know..." She said in a small and pitiful voice. "Everything you showed us. All our actions against you. It all seems surreal, but it's not. I keep denying it even though I remember it all so clearly. I-I wish I had an answer for you. But none of it makes sense. I'm the Princess of friendship, and I failed you..." Twilight shudders at the mere thought of her being synonymous with failure. However, her ego had no place for her now. "I know this doesn't fix anything, but I am sorry for everything,"

Jason wipes his face as he composes himself. His expression goes from sorrowful to bitter resentment. "You're right. It doesn't! The prosecution rests,"

"Hey, don't you think a recess would be appropriate?" Chrysalis asks.

"Yes, we shall reconvene tomorrow," Luna orders with a swing of her gavel.

The Spirit of Chaos

Author's Note

Warning: This chapter showcase material readers may find discomforting.

The Spirit of Chaos

[Canterlot - Later that evening - Celestia's chambers.]

Celestia sits down by her fireplace as she levitates a bottle of wine. Normally, she would never drink on a work day, but the stress of today's event demands it. She pours her glass and goes for a drink before a knock. "Princess, your guests are here," A guard said.

"Let them inside, please," Celestia sighs. Moments later, her sister, the elements Shining Armor, Cadance, and Sunset, came inside. "Spike?"

"He's helping Cozy Glow," Shining asks.

"I suspect the Equestrian crown should expect more from Cozy's group," Cadance said with a frown.

Celestia arches a brow at Cadance's phrasing. "I see you have been treated. How are you, Rainbow Dash?"

Rainbow's form had numerous bandages around her barrel, wings, and half of her face. "Everything. Hurts!" Rainbow wheezes.

"I imagine it would. It certainly looked painful from my position. Perhaps now, you understand the suffering you inflicted upon Jason! Only five hundred years ago, I saw such sadism from the vilest of the vile. For it to come from one of the elements? I have gravely misjudged you! I have warned you of the horn effects. Yet, you did not listen. Instead, you attacked some creature acting as a court official. During the highest court - involving all our allies - while a worldwide broadcast is happening!" Rainbow did her best to look up at the princess but looked down. "Is it any wonder that your parents are currently detained?"

Celestia took a sip of her wine while moving in front of Fluttershy. "I never thought I would look upon you in disappointment, Fluttershy. I can understand Rainbow's bullheadedness to act rashly, but I never thought you would use your stare on someone merely asking questions. Are you that fragile? What was it that Jason did? I must've missed something. Your actions in that court and the clearing were truly one of cowardice!"

Fluttershy clothes her eyes and whimpers as Celestia faces Applejack. "I must admit that you surprised me as well, Applejack. I can forgive the small personal acts of lying. Nopony is free of such a thing. But, you might just be better at deception than even Chrysalis herself. Seeing you lure Jason closer so that he would receive the full brunt of your buck was masterful. Oh, did you train Wynonna to be an attack?"

"..." Applejack keeps looking down until her Celestia magic pulls her up. "...No..."

"I see. It was a spur-of-a-moment action. Commendable. Of course, she will have to be put down now,"

"No! Please, it was all me! Wynonna would never hurt anypony---"

"So, non ponies are fair game?" Applejack was on the verge of tears, causing Celestia to scoff. "Let's not leave the lovely noble mare wanting, right Lady Rarity?"

"I appreciate the complete, but I am no noble, Princess," Rarity said nervously.

"Don't be modest, Lady Rarity. It ruins the image of the same sycophant flank kissers I deal with day in and day out. You already have the attitude of one. Tell me, what disgusted you more? Was it his smell from being forced into poverty? Was his beaten appearance from his abuse too much to bear? Since you aspire to be an aristocrat, I would love to hear your opinion on how you are superior to everything else!?"

Celestia takes another drink as she stands in front of Twilight. "I can at least say that you, Pinkie, were not malicious in your part in this tragedy, and you confessed when you realized what was wrong. But Twilight Sparkle. My faithful student and future successor. None has failed me more than you have. What would it have taken for you to treat Jason amicably? A letter from me? A reference from all of your teachers? A vote of confidence from Luna, Cadance, and your entire family line? Which is it, Twilight?"

"..." Twilight does nothing but silently cries.

"I suppose the fault is mine. After all, the failings of the student reflect upon the teacher. In truth, I should've had you come back after you hypnotize all of Ponyville. I have made many mistakes. One of them was assuming any of you were ready to represent our values. A harsh lesson has been learned indeed. You can wield an element of harmony, but you cannot embody them,"

As Twilight said nothing, Cadance spoke up. "Since we are venting our grievances, Princess Celestia. How are the laws in the state they are in now? After a millennium-long rule, how do you now see the glaring and horrific issue plaguing Equestria? Nonponies are nothing more than indentured servants that can be used and discarded. Laws that allow for abuse at the level of King Sombra. Spike is nothing more than a pet you allow for walking among when you had twenty years to correct it!"

Celestia takes another drink as she looks at her niece with defeat. "I believe most of today's laws stem from the noble houses of old. After Luna's banishment and my bout of depression, they saw an opportunity. A thousand years of ruling does not come without comprise,"

"So, what are you going to do about it?!" Sunset asks. "It's easy to see that your problem is that you cuddled ponies too much. A country built upon harmony and friendship is also the most isolated and ignorant of the world around it. Equestria needs to grow, not in economics and culture, but in maturity and morals!"

"I used to believe that you were one of my most significant failures as a teacher. Yet, you were able to grow away from my guidance. So, that is what Equestria needs now. A changing of the old guard,"

"...You mean, you are stepping down?" Twilight asks in a small voice.

"I will have no choice regardless. Jason's punishments are to come, and I suspect that the fate for me," Celestia finishes her glass and looks to Luna. "What can you glean from the other judges, sister?"

"Nothing good. I suspect they have decided during Spike's mistreatment. The severity of Jason's abuse only solidified their decision. Our alliances may crumble after tomorrow if nothing is done," Luna could not help but glare at the element bearers.

"Then, this makes my announcement easier. Effective immediately, the Crystal Empire is severing all communication, trade, and ties with Equestria until a real change has occurred," Cadance said.

The elements and Sunset gasped at this. "You're breaking ties with us?" Twilight asks.

"Sunburst contacted me after the trial concluded today. None of the crystal ponies are happy with how things are in Equestria. They believe I am nothing more than you're puppet that will carry on your viewpoints. Some are even calling you the modern-day Sunny Sombra. And That's only the concerns focusing on nepotism. Spike's mistreatment has ponies rioting in the streets! Anything Equestrian related is being taken out on a bonfire. If I don't want to be forced to allocate the throne as well, this is the necessary course of action,"

"...You never said how you feel about--"

"Make no mistake, Princess Twilight. I am finding it hard to stay in your presence any longer. And I am only polite right now to maintain some semblance of stability. Do not seek to contact more for the foreseeable future,"

Twilight drips her head at her sister-in-law's words. "There's something else you should know," Shining sighs. "We'll take Mom and Dad to court for Spike's custody. We believe a change of scenery and ponies that will treat Spike well will do him some good,"

"Right, because I doubt Spike would want anything do us right now..."

"Surely, you can talk with Spiky Wiky on our behalf," Rarity said.

"You don't have to keep up the act anymore, Rarity. Spike knows you'll never love him," Applejack said bitterly.

"Oh, the lying abuser is trying to lecture me. It must be the end times,"

"Last I check, you are on trial for being a fraud and abuser too!"

"Well, some of us are more guilty than others,"

"Buck. You!" Rainbow wheezes.

"Girls, stop this!" Pinkie said.

"I don't see why you care. You got off scot-free. An easy life awaits the carefree Pinkie Pie!" Rarity said.

"You want to do this now? Does blaming us make you feel better about your contribution?" Fluttershy said with a frown.

"I'm surprised you're not curled up in a ball right now," Applejack grumbles.

"I would not be surprised if Wynnona is at the pound by now!" Fluttershy growls. "How dare you use Wynnonna like that? Animals are our friends, not weapons!"

"And do you think your helpful advice to Flithy was doing? Training the orthos for pet pageant?" Fluttershy flinches but presses her head against Applejack.

"ENOUGH!!!" Sunset calls out, stopping the arguing. "Let me restate the obvious here so that you understand. All of you are to blame! The severity does not matter when the sheer amount perpetrators are staggering! If none of you can accept accountability for this, not only do you not deserve to be an element, but you don't deserve to be friends! It takes more than just holding some virtue of harmony. It's having the empathy to guide others to harmony," With left to say, Sunset leaves.

"Tell Night Light and Velvet Sparkle that we sincerely hope they do the right thing by Spike and leave him with us," Cadance said as she took her to leave.

"I have much to deliberate with my fellow Judges and prepare prospects for the future. Stay strong, sister," Luna teleports out of the room without a word to Twilight and her friends.

"Princess--"

"No! We are done here for today. Leave my presence and be there for the sentencing tomorrow. Please do not make me come looking for you. Dismissed!" Celestia said, cutting Twilight off. Twilight and the others are left with sad expressions as Celestia is alone. She takes the wine bottle in her magic and looks it over before she hurls it into the wall.

[Jason's Room.]

Jason sits on the chair with his fist resting on his hand while he looks out the window. Chrysalis and Zecorasits across from him while staring at him. "So, is it everything you dreamt about?" Jason grunts. "Am I to decypher your grunting?"

"What do you want me to say?"

"How about how satisfying it is to get your justice? After checking with the hive, ponies are no longer talking about changelings. It's all about how horrible the elements are, how everything they know about their princesses is a lie. You've brought down Equestria's faith in its leaders and protectors. And made ponies question their morality, all with the truth. Yet here you are, pouting. Why?"

"You mustn't be so daft. He just gave the ponies the shaft. A time for punishment is neigh, and he knows many will cry," Zecora said.

"Urgh, you and your rhyming. But I am curious as to how much worse you can do now,"

Before Jason could speak, a knock came at the door. "Oh, I wonder if that's Twilight coming to gravel. Enter," Chrysalis said.

The open as Jason's blank expression becomes a frown at his new guest. Cozy Glow, Spike, and Cranky Doodle all were standing in his room. All had bright smiles, although Spike was more reserved. "Hey, Mister Jason Wright. I'm glad we can finally meet face to face,"

"Hmm," Jason grunts.

"Hey, Zecora," Spike says.

"Oh, Spike. I am glad to see that you are alright," Zecora said as the two hugged.

"No, I am not alright, not after what's happened this past week and what's still happening now,"

"That's right, Spike. This trial is only the beginning of the Creatures of Equestria movement," Cozy said proudly.

"Is that right?" Jason asks.

"That's right, sir. I have to say that you are an inspiration. You open doors for us that I thought would never budge. You've shown me that we can get a better life. My only wish is that Mildy was here to see this. Can I shake your claw?" Cranky asks.

"Hand. Humans call it shaking hands," Jason saw no harm in humoring Cranky, so he shook his hoof.

"Huh, hands. They're a lot softer than I thought,"

"Hey, I wanted to say sorry," Spike said to Jason. "I didn't think the girls could ever be evil like that. I didn't consider that you were telling the truth when you tried to warn me. I guess I know now. But don't worry. I'll work extra hard with Cozy to get the change that non-ponies deserve,"

"We should come up with a better term than non-ponies. It makes other creatures sound inferior," Cozy said.

"Why not people? It's what humans use," Chrysalis offers as Cozy beams. Jason shoots her a sideways glare.

"So, is that all you wanted? To give thanks?" Jason asks, trying to hide his annoyance.

"Well, I have two questions I want to ask you. The first is asking you to join us as the spokescreature for the CFE. Our movement needs some creature like you brave enough to stand up against those who claim to have our best interest but only want to keep us down further. You'll help our group so much more. What do you say, Mister Jason,"

"I'm not much of an activist. I was only doing this for justice. I was thinking of resting after this,"

"I understand. I know this wasn't easy. But we'll gladly pick up the slack. My second question what will their punishment be for tomorrow?"

"I haven't decided on what yet. You'll have to wait until tomorrow,"

"Aw, oh well. I am sure you'll come up with something great. We should get going anyway," Cozy stops as Spike and Cranky leave. "Oh, I almost forgot. That tv show that shows our lives am I in it?"

"Yes, you're very famous. You and your penpal,"

Cozy's smile wanes ever so slightly before she replies. "Golly, that's amazing. Well, we don't want to hold you up anymore, Goodbye Jason Wright,"

The trio left the room while the other three occupants said nothing. "So, anyone else notices how she dropped the mister? You must've got under her skin," Chrysalis states.

"A child that is most rotten indeed. It seems she does not want you to impede," Zecora said.

"Have you done what I asked about her?" Jason says to Chrysalis.

"Tch. Yes, I have some of my drones in her little group. I hardly believe she can be any problem," Chrysalis says.

"She's the leader of many creatures looking to change the status quo. That's nothing to take lightly,"

"But, what would you gain for playing neighborhood watch? I thought you hated the ponies. Why do something that would help them?"

"It's for the changeling's benefit,"

"The road to recovery will be pretty long. But you cannot keep playing the same song. There's no reason to debate. To cleanse your soul, you must relinquish your hate," Zecora said. Jason merely deadpans at her. "You may think I possess a lot of sass. But, doing so with friends will help you get past,"

"Tsk. We'll see whose in a charitable mood after tomorrow,"

[Canterlot Judicial Hall - Fifth Day of the Trial.]

The tone of the courtroom is very different from the beginning of the trial. The ponies are less expressive and mute with their voices. In contrast, the CFE side is full of speculation on Jason's punishment. The judges had grim expressions. Save for Luna, who was stoic and anxious. The defendants were slow to enter the court. When the doors open, the jeering begins. The non-ponies were very vocal and loud. At the same time, the ponies themselves sent disdainful glares at them. Celestia was the only one to keep her head up during this. She would not falter in receiving her punishment. Twilight tries to emulate her mentor, but her splayed ears betray her stoic demeanor. Rarity was a mess in every sense of the word. Her mane was unkempt, and her coat was less pristine. Fluttershy was constantly shielding herself with her wings to hide from the angry voices. Applejack is numb to it all and wants the whole ordeal over now. Rainbow was the only one to look the most physically drained of the group. She is never looked more defeated than she does right now. Pinkie was with her family, visibly stressed from everything happening.

Jason awaits them patiently; his features are again indifferent to their position. Queen Novo speaks up as they did, gaining the court's attention. "Before the punishment is cast out, my fellow leaders and I have reached a consensus regarding the current state of affairs. I, Queen Novo, effectively immediately pronounce the elegance between Equestria and Eris Peak to be null and void," Several gasps went out as Celestia did her best to surpass her dismay. "I do not make such a decision lightly. But the events of the tribunal have only reinforced my prior opinion of doubt about Equestrian leadership. I am, of course, referring to how Princess Twilight Sparkle attempted to steal our scared orb for the benefit of Equestria while dooming Sequestria,"

Celestia's head snaps to her student as she glares. "...You did what?"

"I-I was desperate. Queen Novo wasn't willing--"

"Stop! We will be discussing this later!"

"Hmm, it seems Equestria has fed all of us lies at various points. As king of Saddle Arabia, I now sever all ties with Equestria. Any saddle Arabian is strongly urged to renounce their citizenship in these lands. We want to interview you for any injustice you faced while here," Shifting Sands said.

"It is a sad day indeed. Equestria is full of misdeeds. The country of Zebrica shall not abide. In Equestria, we will no longer confide," Chef Zekia rhymed.

"I met many creatures in my life. You could always tell who was trying to con you. But, you ponies? Who knew hooves could have hidden claws? Griffinstone wants nothing to do with you, con artists! And tell that Sady Trots to keep his eyes on the skies!" Grandpa Gruff threatens.

"Yaks is sad. Yak likes ponies. But, It seems ponies don't like yaks. Yaks will stay with Yaks in Yakistan until ponies act more like Yaks," Prince Rutherford said.

Ember snorts as she takes her turn. "If Equestria has the gall to lecture us about our way of life, they need to take a good look in the mirror! A lot of our issues were due to your meddling. Never mind the fact that you are keeping dragons as pets! The Draglonlands will not tolerate any pony presence in our territory!"

"The Crystal Empire expresses sadness for our decision, but we boneless agree with our fellow leaders. And we will no longer commence in this alliance. Equestria needs to change. It must uphold its morals and values instead of loading them over others. The mindset of rules for me and not for thee will no longer be acceptable!" Cadance stated.

The announcement hurt the ponies—none more than Cadance as Equestria since equestrian intervention that prevented Sombra's take over. And the nobles were keen to remind her of this fact.

"Traitor!"

"Ungrateful welp!"

"Princess of frauds!"

"We don't need any of you!"

"Equestria survived for a thousand years! We will survive without you!"

The noble's outburst swiftly came under fire by the CFE side of the room. "What a surprise. The ponies are bigots!"

"What's the matter? Sad that the world knows you're all specist!"

"It serves you, pretenders, right!"

"We won't be silent anymore!!!"

Luna's face slowly morphs into a scowl. "BE SILENT!!!" The chatter instantly stops at Luna's royal Canterlot voice. "Foals. That is what you have shown the world here today. You are nothing but spoiled foals! Are we, not adults? Are you not the representative of Canterlot? Never in all my years that I've seen such disgrace. The tribunal is about to conclude. If you have any respect for yourselves and your station, you will keep your comments to yourselves! It is time for the madness to cease!"

"But, the madness is where all the fun resides," A new voice said.

"By Gover's plumage! Who said that?!" Grandpa Gruff.

"Discord?" Fluttershy asks while looking around.

In the center next to Jason, a zipper appears before a paw comes from behind it and opens it. Discord comes stepping out of space. More murmurs went off at the sudden appearance while Fluttershy could only stare in disbelief. "Discord? What are you doing here? Where have you been?"

"Oh, I was tidying up here and there in my home. Time flows sporadically there. How are things for you," Discord said.

"Discord! We are in the middle of a tribunal! It is not a place for your antics!" Celestia firmly said.

"Oh, I love courtroom dramas. Here, let me get the proper attire," Discord snaps his talon and dresses in a blue suit and a spiked wig. Many occupants didn't know why the word objection popped out whenever Disord pointed.

"Discord!" Twilight shouts. "We are not in the mood for any games! For once in your life, be serious.

"Oh, come now, Twilight. I know that spell I put on you has made everything fuzzy, but you do remember how to have fun,"

"Discord, you--" Twilight stops at his words. "W-what did you just say?"

"Hmm, are you still feeling the after-effects? It's always like this with perception spells,"

Slowly, realization dawns on Twilight as she recalls the past few days dealing with the spell.

"But, the magic? We can't deny it's there and messing with our perceptions!"

"I find it strange that only the elements and my sister are the targets of this spellcraft. Perhaps four alicorn mages can break through it," Luna suggests.

The four princesses nodded as their horns lit with magic. However, a white aura appears on the defendants after waiting several seconds. The spell did not break as it did for Celestia and Twilight. "...Nothing..."

"No. No! There has to be something! How can we know something is there but can't eliminate it? It makes no sense!!!" Twilight exclaimed.

"No!"

"Perhaps the elements of harmony? If foul magic infects us, they may clear it," Rarity suggests.

"It's worth a shot," Twilight said as her horn made the elements appear around their necks. "I always wanted to try that spell. Alright, girls. We have to focus on any corruptive or invasive magic within ourselves," The elements began their sequence of powering up. Each Pony hovers in the air as a rainbow aura surrounds them. Eventually, the magic of the elements dies down, and everyone returns to the ground. Twilight opens her eyes and frowns. "Nothing. There's still nothing!"

"You didn't...!"

Celestia turns to the group with an unreadable expression. "Then, I suggest you look into whatever magic left me and ensure it's not within yourselves. I fear a foul hand is at play. One that seeks to discredit us. In the meantime, prepare for the next day as best as possible. Jason's argument is compelling because he wields the truth. So, only the truth can prevail. Now, if you all will excuse me, I wish to speak with my sister alone,"

"I-It's been you this whole time!"

"Hold on a minute! Didn't Discord say its name? It sounds like he knows who this varmint is. Where did he scurry off to now?" Applejack said.

"Discord left as soon as Chrysalis and Jason did," Fluttershy said with a frown. "I think, with everything that is happening, he felt upset,"

"Darling, this is Discord we are talking about; he never cares enough to be upset," Rarity said.

"How come I didn't see it?"

"So, there was an issue with him. I knew there was something wrong. What if this Jason Wright is part of a scheme he cooked up a millennium ago, and it's coming back to haunt everypony like the plunder vines!"

Twilight theorized.

The last words echo in Twilight's mind as she shouts. "Discord! What did you do!?"

"What's wrong, Twilight?" Fluttershy asks.

"I believe she is referring to the spell I put on all of you regarding our resident human. I am the reason he's here," Discord said.

There was a moment of silence before everyone, save for Jason and Chrysalis, said anything. "WHAT!?!?"

"Explain yourself!" Celestia said. The pupils in her eyes shift into a bright white color while her mane is now bright orange.

Discord snaps his finger again as he adopts a severe expression. "Well, to understand that, you need to understand chaos's role in the world. While reformation is excellent and all, don't get me wrong. It's harmful to the balance of the world. Chaos must thrive as much as order does to achieve perfect harmony. You know this, Fluttershy. If I don't enact some clutter, I fade away, leaving the world in peril. But I quickly faced a new dilemma; how do I cause my brand of mischief without upsetting my friends? Then, I got it! I get someone else to do some chaos for me. And a human, no less. A tough as nails, thick skin human that can handle anything,"

Discord gestures to Jason, who is still wearing a deep frown. "So, you admit to being the cause of the memory manipulation the Princess and elements fell under?" Queen Novo asks.

"That's correct. But it's a little more than that. See, I heard about Twilight's escape from the human realm. And, from how she came back so distant, cold, and melancholy. I knew it was the perfect means to spice things up. So I sent out my magic to the human world and plucked out the nearest human I could find,"

"Against their will, no doubt!" Rarity spat.

"Oh, pshaw, you know the old saying, better to ask for forgiveness than permission. Besides, I know human lives a dreadfully mundane, so I bet coming here was the adventure of a lifetime," Jason didn't say a word. "Anyway, I wanted to get the most genuine response from you, so I added a tiny spell to bring out your innermost feelings,"

The elements stare at Discord aghast. "You messed with our heads again?" Pinkie asks in a hurt tone.

"Like the good old days from when we all first met. Although, I had to tweak it a little. I didn't want anypony noticing anything out of the ordinary. The kind of result one can get from so little effort is incredible. Of course, that also meant I had to put a spell on Celestia. We can't have her coming to Ponyville and ruining the fun. Put a barrier around the town to make ponies forget about our dear human friend, and viola. I had a chaotic live-action play for my viewing pleasure. And what a performance! The flash mobs are throwing garbage. The name-calling. The lightning strikes. But the best part was the elements of harmony turning Jason away at every turn! It was the most enjoyment I ever had since reforming!"

"But, you didn't reform! Look at this madness we're in because of you! I honestly believed I said those vile things!" Rarity shrieks.

"Y'all made me shatter his ribs!" Applejack hollers.

"You're. A. Jerk!!!" Rainbow wheezes.

"Nothing about what happened to Jason was funny, Discord!" Pinkie shouts.

"I can't believe I ever considered you a friend!" Twilight said with venom in her tone.

The gallery is once again split on opinions. The CFE was mostly watching on in confusion. This revelation of Discord's involvement made them unsure of their movement. The nobles were all in an uproar. For all intents, Discord betrayed Equestria again. All the judges were also skeptical, but their shock morphed into disgust at the confusion. Cozy was the only one beside herself. Her movement was dying out right before it even began. She wants nothing more than to beat that draconequus senseless. However, looking at Jason, she noticed he wasn't doing anything. There were no yells of outrage or apologies to the defendants. He was waiting for Discord and everyone to finish.

"Did he expect this?" Cozy asks.

"Why, Discord. Why would you break our trust again? You could've found another way to enact chaos without hurting any creature!" Fluttershy said in a hurt tone.

"More importantly, why reveal yourself?" Luna asks with venom in her tone. "The trial would've ended with all of us none the wiser of your scheme,"

"Because once I saw Jason return with the Gjallarhorn, I knew things went too far. I can't let you hurt them for something I did. If you want to punish anyone, Jason, punish me,"

"Interesting. But I have a question; how do we know you are not merely trying to cover for the defendants?" Chrysalis asks.

Discord takes a deep breath while preparing his answer. "Why didn't you leave? After your treatment got worse and worse, why would you stay? If you were afraid you would get more of the same somewhere else, that wasn't the case. I put a spell on you to keep you from leaving,"

There were many gasps at Discord's words as all eyes were all on Jason now. Everyone expected to see the same magic burst from so many times before. But nothing is happening to the disgruntled human. "Hmm, you look confused about something, Discord," Jason said.

Discord looks between Jason and the Gjallarhorn while his confusion grows. "B-But, where is the magic within you?"

"I got to say I was expecting to rear your ugly face when I got to Fluttershy's testimony. I wasn't expecting you to take the fall for their mistake. That's amazing. Truly noble. But I've learned the hard way never to take things at face value when it comes to ponies. So, you want to confess again while touching the Gjallarhorn?"

"There's no need for that. I am telling the truth, and it's not reacting with that annoying hum," Discord said.

"Then, there should be no issue. Go on, touch it, prove to me that you are genuine because your being here doesn't quite add up. You could've come clean the moment you saw me. But, no, you didn't. You let this drag on for five days. What, were you worried about what people would think of you? They already hate you, Discord. Look at how quickly they turn on you. Look at how fast they are willing to shift the blame. Nothing would've changed if you had confessed earlier. No, you ran away to cover your ass. See, I knew you were involved because the magic in me dispelled when I was in Chrysalis hive,"

"Yes, it was quite particular," Chrysalis said. "Jason would wander the hive while trying to return to the ponies. At first, I assumed he was a spy trying to give away our location. But I saw that his action was guided. There was a daze in his eyes like he was under mind control and not my branch of it. Naturally, I subdued him and tried to peer into his mind to trace the spell's origin. Imagine my surprise when I found small traces of chaos magic. It latches on to the subconscious mind. No pony magic could discover it or define its purpose. Since changeling mental magic is more precise, I was able to remove it. But, the spell itself had no discernible direction or purpose for it. Almost as if you put it there by accident,"

"W-Well, chaos operates without rhyme or reason," Discord said nervously.

"Yet, this plan you cooked up has multiple steps and well-thought-out applications of what you wanted—bending the elements to your will, stopping the ruler from visiting. Erecting a barrier. These are not actions of the unpredictable,"

"So, which is it, Discord? How can we trust what you say as fact when you already have contradictions in your story?" Jasons said.

"It doesn't matter! The horn did nothing. Therefore, I am not lying. You're lucky I'm even doing this right now. If you tried before I was reformed, you would've been stuck as my court jester,"

"Is that right?" Jason smirks. "Well, then, It's time I get the punishments out of the way,"

Discords' eyes widen at that. "Punishments? No, wait. I already confessed! Leave them be!"

"If we take your confession at face value - which I don't - then it changes absolutely nothing. The spell you put on everyone can be comparable to a nudge-- a tiny little push. If you put more power into it, your little game would've ended because everyone would see something was wrong. For example..." Jason touches the Gjallarhorn again. The episode of Return to Harmony plays out. Everyone saw how Discord corrupted the elements through trickery and deceit. Fluttershy flinches when Discord forcefully changes her. "As we saw here, when Discord corrupts someone, their colors gray out, and they act the opposite of their usual personality. However..."

Jason shows the memory of all his encounters with the elements again. "From my interaction, we see none of Discord's influence. So, what does that tell you, members of the court? Discord wanted genuine reactions. He did not twist their minds to be the reverse of themselves. He removed the filter between pleasantries and nastiness. The elements still had a choice! And they chose rudeness. They chose cowardice, neglect, deceit, and, more importantly, violence! So, what did you honestly accomplish here, Discord? I don't know how you're fooling the Gjallarhorn with these lies, but it doesn't matter,"

Discord was becoming more desperate as the crowd from the CFE agreed with Jason. "Wait, please reconsider this. Nopony else needs to suffer--"

At these words, Jason's glare burns into Discord's soul. "Suffer? Suffer!? Could you show me a pony that's suffered like me? Could you show me a pony that's been discriminated against like them!? You don't know shit about suffering! Look at this!" Jason removes his robe again and shows off his scars to the spirit of chaos. Discord immediately adopts a look of horror upon seeing them. "This is suffering done by your precious friends you're trying to protect!"

"B-But, your magic should've--"

"What magic? I thought you knew about humans. We don't have magic! We can't shrug off beatings and lightning strikes. We feel everything! Everything. Damn! Thing!!! Do you think I am faking this somehow? Here, feel for yourself!" Discord wasn't expecting Jason ever to try and touch. At least not in a non-threatening manner. The Gjallarhorn would've ensured he was all but safe from the human's wrath. But, he had no idea of the scope of Jason's pain. So, Jason's hand already passes through his paw, shocking everyone in the court.

"Discord? Your presence is merely an illusion?" Celestia asks.

"Surprise...?" Discord said meekly.

"Where are you?" Cadance asks.

"I am still in my realm. The magic there throws everything for a loop," Discord sighs. "The horn did not react because I am not in Equestria,"

"So, even now, you are still hiding away and trying to play both sides of the fence, huh? You're just like them in that you refuse to take accountability. I guess you don't care. But that's fine with me. If you don't come willingly, I'll make you!" In response to Jason, the Gjallarhorn glows brightly. The fake image of Discord breaks apart as the real draconequus replaces it.

"W-What? How?!"

"Come on, Discord. Did you forget the stipulation for this entire trial? I said I would get to punish everyone that's wronged me. That includes you!"

"Jason, please, I am begging you; find it in your heart to forgive them,"

Jason's stare becomes hard as stone. "There can be no forgiveness. Not for what they did and not for what they denied me!"

The Gjallarhorn glows again as Applejack's farm comes into view again. Jason's limping form was entering the tool shed of Apples. There was a dead and near-lifeless look in his eyes as he looked around the shack and found Applejack's rope. Unfortunately, Wynnoa's barking alerted him, and several voices in the distance. Grabbing the rope quickly, Jason humbles his way deep into the orchard. The thick trees provided enough cover, and Jason could no longer hear the voices and bark. He sighs, but not in relief, in resolution for his next decision. He gingerly fashions a noose out of the rope and ties it to the thickest, highest branch of the tree. He sits on the tree branch with the loop tied securely around his neck while taking in the scenery. The same wondrous feeling of being in Equestria washed over Jason for the briefest moments. It was there to greet him. And, now, it is here for his departure.

"I'll see you soon, Susie,"

Jason leans forward and lets gravity do the rest. Unfortunately, the fall did not snap his neck instantly. The noose went taunt around his neck and cut off his airway. Jason's hand instinctively went to the rope to alleviate the pressure. It took considerable effort to ignore the survival impulses and the panic in his being. His vision had stars, and it was getting harder to breathe. Slowly, Jason puts his hands down. In a few seconds, all the pain would stop. The vision in his eyes fades into darkness as he lets out one last sigh. The world finally went silent. Finally, there was peace. That was until Jason fell hard on his back. He heard the telltale sound of levitation magic and the rope loosening around his neck. Opening his eyes, Jason breaks out in a coughing fit as all the elements look down at him. All of them had looks of apprehension as Applejack spoke.

"Why?"

"..." Jason did not respond. Instead, rage takes over, and Jason grabs the nearest object and wings it wild. The elements back off and allow Jason to run away.

Jason removes his hand from the Gjallarhorn. His face is still glaring at Discord, who is currently mimicking goldfish. "Why? That's what I was asked when I went to hang myself. Why,"

"You attempted to slay yourself?" Luna said.

"Why would you do this...?" Celestia said in shock.

"Because I saw no way out. Because friendship and harmony rejected me. Yet, even the most personal choice anyone can make was taken from me," Jason said softly.

"B-But, they saved--"

"Shut the fuck up!" Jason shouts before Discord can finish. "I wasn't saved! I was denied my death! And, then you ask me why - like the last three years of torture didn't happen - and you're showing genuine concern! None of you are innocent. So, before I cast my judgment, Discord, how are you involved in this?"

Discord looks at Fluttershy with a sad expression. "...Alright..."

The Crime and Punishment

Author's Note

Edit. So, after reading some comments and rereading the chapter, I decided to take off the three-year punishment for Celestia. Celestia is like Pinkie because she does very little to hurt Jason. She was the first to accept Jason and is the only one manipulated directly by Discord.

The Crime and Punishment

[Canterlot Judicial Hall.]

Discord can honestly say that it is the first time he wishes he was not the center of attention. Many reproachful eyes are watching, waiting for the truth of his involvement. He was counting on his little ruse to work, that he would take the fall and his friends could be free. But, he did not account for the Gjallarhorn or Jason's resolve for justice. It's why hiding away in his realm was a good idea at the time. With another sigh, Discord begins to speak.

"I wasn't lying when I said I bring you here was relating to Twilight's experience with humans. But, it wasn't to pick at the scab. It was to help her deal with that issue by showing her that not all humans are imperfect. I believed that if she was going to be a princess - one that could fulfill the needs of everypony - then she couldn't have any resentment that could impair her judgment. So, I reached beyond the veil to find a human and bring them to Equestria. That human was you, Jason,"

"You made the website that brought me here to help Twilight be a better princess?" Jason said with an undercurrent of rage.

"Well, I didn't know exactly how my spell was going to manifest on your side, but it worked regardless,"

Jason was seething now. He knew precisely how this correlated directly. It was the same as when Discord united Equestria's villains to help Twilight with her doubts about Equestria's sole ruler. "Of course. It makes so much sense now. You fucked me over to help that one be a better ruler for Equestria. But, you did it in the ashine way possible, just like in the show,"

"W-What do you mean?"

Discord flinches when Jason touches the horn again. This time, the elements were in Canterlot. Unlike the previous memories, no one was familiar with these current events. The mention of a coronation threw everyone present for a loop. Discord eventually came onto the scene. He gripped his reptilian leg as his body was covered in dirt and debris. "Oh! My aching metatarsals! You know you forget how convenient snap travel is,"

"Wait, did you just say you walked here? On foot?" Spike asks.

"Yes. Actually. And I have a confession to make. You see, I might have made the tiniest boo-boo. All very well-intentioned and noble on my part but--"

"Get to the point, Discord," Applejack said.

"You remember that whole thing with King Sombra? That was slightly my fault, and by slightly, I mean that I brought him back..."

"You did!? But why?!?!" Rarity exclaims.

"Well, it seemed like a good idea then, so I brought back three other villains, who are now on the loose and not big fans of yours. So, uh, my bad,"

"Wait, I never did that!" Discord hollers as the memory ends. "You can't seriously try and pin events on me that I haven't even considered! That's like arresting me for a crime I was only thinking about doing!"

"It's not to show your guilt!" Jason snarls. "It's to compare what you have done to me! It's precisely the same concept. You are going off behind everyone's backs with a solution you think is best for the situation when, in reality, it is beyond fubar. No one fucking asked you to rip me from my home to help Twilight get over being a bigot. A trial she failed spectacularly!"

"I only had the best intention like in the memory. I-I never knew things would go so wrong!"

"Good intentions are the surest path to hell!!! What were you expecting to happen, huh? That Twilight would see me, and we would be instant friends? Or that Pinkie would have one of her famous welcome parties? All I got from that visiting Ponyville was pain and misery. So, at what point did you notice things were going wrong? Was it when I was sleeping homeless on the streets? What bout the lightning strikes that left me half blind or the buck that shattered my ribcage?! The flash mobs were always a fun time too! Maybe, you missed my new place of residence in the fucking cave with manticores! Tell me something; in what part of your social experiment would you intervene? When shit hit the fan, why did you not get me out of there? Why was there magic on me preventing me from leaving? Why erase everyone's memories?"

Discord looks down in shame at Jason's inquires. "I wasn't keeping an eye on the things. There was no reason to believe that the capital of friendship would treat you so poorly. If they can accept somepony like me, then I doubt any creature couldn't make friends with them," The element all seem to deflate at how badly they proved Discord wrong. "Never in my wildest dreams would I believe any of what happened to you was done by the ponies in Ponyville, let alone the elements. But here we are. I did check up on your progress near the end. But I never found it in Ponyville that day. I saw you thanks to the residual chaos magic inside of you. I believe some chaos magic got stuck in you when you crossed over to our dimension. I never gave it a direction or purpose. My only guess is that since I frequent Ponyville quite often, the magic inside was drawn to the other signatures around town. Thus, you were drawn to it as well. Back in my realm, I tried sending you back home. But I realized I don't know where your home is. It's like finding a needle in a haystack,"

"And what about their memories?" Cadance asks.

Discord could not face anyone at that question. "After I returned to Ponyville, I noticed Jason was on Applejack's farm in the middle of the night. At first, I thought that perhaps it was a sleepover while all of you got to know each other. Fluttershy would be gushing over the fact of an exotic creature. Pinkie would try to mack friends. Rarity would do her fashion thing, and so on and so on. Instead, when I followed my residual magic to him, Jason was hanging by his neck from a tree with the girls just standing before him. I couldn't believe it. What led you to go to such extremes? I did not know, but I knew that whatever happened must've damaged Ponyville by a large margin. Suicide was not a concept ponies could handle. So, I took away everyone's memories of you,"

"How very convenient for them. Let's spare the ponies the mental anguish of knowing they drove someone to end their lives. Their weak constitution can't handle their guilt!"

"I am sorry for--"

"You're not sorry because you made a mistake. If that were true, you wouldn't have erased their memories. You wouldn't have run away when I came back. No, you are sorry because this is it. You and they got caught with your hands in the cookie jar. Now, Daddy is here with his belt. I overheard what you and Fluttershy discussed at the Gala, how you wanted to make amends with the other rulers. That tells me you did something unsavory to them as well. So, why don't you share with the rest of the class?"

"I don't see how that is relevant," Discord says.

"I believe it is very relevant. It does concern us, after all. And your guilt is clear for all the see. There shall be no more hiding it!" Queen Novo said harshly.

"W-Well, initially, I wanted to mend some bridges that I broke with each of respective kingdoms after some introspective thinking of my actions when I was a young Draconeuus. You see--"

"How about you start with what you did and cut out all fluffy squeaking!" Grandpa Gruff said.

Discord sighs as he pulls out a list. "Okay, for the griffins, I put all their positive moral aspects into that precious Idol of Boreas. I thought it would be funny to know that all your decency would disappear as soon as somepony stole it. I significantly decreased their intelligence for the diamond dogs because of this one diamond dog know-it-all. I made the desert surrounding Saddle Arabia-- a prank on the ruler of that period. I made the staff the storm king wielded that lets him control Alicorn's magic. I was drunk on poison joke juice at the time. That's also why I was absent during his invasion. I cursed the zebra's to only speak in rhymes. And, the dragons' I messed with their internal emotional spectrum so their bodies would respond to their emotional state. I was bored that day and decided to wing it,"

Many of the creatures from the kingdoms Discord brought up were in an uproar. The judges all are wearing a look of disgust and rage. "You scum!" Ember snarls, with flames licking her lips as she says this.

"T-That cannot be! Rhyming is considered sacred and free!" King Zekia said.

"I had always been told stories about how Saddle Arabia was once a giant oasis. It was more fertile than even Equestria. And you robbed us of that as a prank!?" Shifting sands said in outrage.

"You took my nation's decency and threw it into our idol. No wonder my griffin folk acts greedy and indifferent! Whatever happens to you, I wholeheartedly agree with it!" Grandpa Gruff squawks as all the Judges agree.

"So, in the end, you still prove yourself to be a plague," Luna said with a shake of her head.

"It is regrettable, Discord. Sadly, we are at this point now. Mister Wirght, I believe you can carry out your sentence now," Cadance said in disappointment.

"I got the answer I wanted from you. You're all guilty of many crimes that would be grounds for execution!" Discord and the defendants went pale at Jason's words. "But don't worry. Unlike your sorry excuse of a legal system, I'll ensure my punishments fit the crime. Let's start with the big mastermind of this shit show. Discord!"

Discord feels all the saliva dry in his mouth. "Yes...?"

"For a creature that revels in chaos, you have given your allegiance to Equestria. In my world, the disorder is natural. It is tied to no loyalty, but its own. I mean, there is no guiding force like you to give chaos direction. It flows freely, and the rest of us must adapt to how it goes. You, on the other hand, give all your powers to Equestria. You did so at the behest of Celestia's absurd plan to reform you using Fluttershy as a means to an end. But that reformation was never genuine. If that were the case, you would've told the Princesses about the plunder vines or removed them yourself. You would've never sided with Tirek and betrayed everyone. You also had plenty of time to fix all those horrible misdeeds you did to the other nations and their people. But, no, you were fine with what you did. You were fine with letting everyone wallow in ignorance,"

"I was going to try and make amends..."

"And, it would've been either meaningless or conditions along with it. The fact of the matter is, Discord, you are nothing but an immature brat that constantly plays with fire. How can the world be safe and free of the fate I suffered when you can wield godlike power with the whim of a foal? No more. Your punishment will be as follows; you shall forever be stripped of your chaotic magic. You will know what it feels like to be like the rest of us; powerless, average, normal!" Discord's eyes widen with horror at every word. "Ha, you could say you would be just like any other human. But I won't insult my species by actually turning you into one. You will also feel the same pain I felt for the past three years in that same amount of time. You will feel a dull ache from dusk to sunset that mirrors all my wounds. However, at 9 am, 12 pm, 3 pm, 6 pm, 9 pm, and finally midnight, the pain will spike as if it had just been dealt to you. After three years, the pain will stop, but the dull ache will remain for the rest of my natural life. A permanent reminder of your actions against me,"

The Gjallarhorn begins to glow as Discord hunches over in pain. "W-Wait! Where is my magic going?! You can't remove it from this dimension! Chaos needs to exist here!"

"It's going someplace where you will never have access to it again. But it will still be present in this world," Jason puts his hand to his back and turns away from Discord as he suffers. That was one down and seven more to go. Standing before Celestia, the princess of the sun, felt a nervousness she had not felt in some time. "Princess Celestia. One can say that you are perhaps the most decorated ruler in the world. You kept Equestria going for over a millennium. But your peace comes with a hefty price that other creatures besides ponies must pay. Non-ponies are just one step above being slaves, thanks to your laws. Spike the dragon is nothing more than a pet in the eyes of Equestrian rules. At the same time, you maintained peace, you could've changed all that, but you did not!"

"I did the best--"

"Your best was faulty and insufficient. It was manipulation at the best of times, especially when it came to these six to your right," Jason said more forcefully as he cut Celestia off. "The elements list of crimes goes further than merely what they did to me. Yet, you always gave them a pass. You always bailed them out, made excuses, or outright ignored the glaring laws they broke. But, you always had the nerve to charge anyone else that was not the bearer of harmony—no more. Your punishment is as follows. You will no longer be acting senior princess of Equestria!" There were several gasps from both sides of the courtroom at that proclamation. "I will give you one week to get your affairs in order. After that, you no longer be a ruler of Equestria!"

Celestia hangs her head down in shame as a lone tear drops down her cheek. It was a small comfort that her mane was blocking it. Initially, Celestia chose Twilight as her future successor so that she could retire gracefully. A thousand years of rule has finally run its course. It was time that she rested and started living as a mare instead of a princess. But, now that choice is gone. Now, she will forever live in disgrace. The soon-to-be former princess begins to feel the Gjallarhorn's magic enforcing Jason's punishment. "If I am to be deposed, who will rule in my stead?"

"Don't be so self-centered. Your sister is right there. She's due for the millennium of ruler she missed out on because of you! Cadance could always come to the capital. Hell, even Blueblood can rule. It can be anyone as long as it is no longer you!"

Celestia nods and goes back to sulking as Jason stands before Applejack. The farm pony allows a large gulp while Jason glares at her. "You know, I had thought about putting Wynnona down for the attack command you gave her,"

"Please! Please don't do that! As you said, I made her do it! Please! She has been a part of the family since I was a filly. We need her on the farm to warn us against the Everfree critters! Please, don't hurt her. I'm sorry!" Applejack begs.

"Spare me. But I am not heartless. I'll leave her be so long as the apples promise to give her proper obedience training," Applejack looks to Granny Smith, who nods vigorously at the terms. "Good. Now that leaves you, Applejack. Honestly, I can have you rotting in the dungeon for the rest of your life for the pain you caused. Instead, just like Discord, you will feel the same pain you inflicted upon me. You will feel your hooves shattering your ribcage at the same time I specified earlier. This will continue for three years, and there will be a dull throb as a reminder for the rest of your life. A visible mark of your hoofprint will sit over your coat in the same spot you hit me for all the world to see!"

Applejack immediately clutches her barrel as she groans in pain. The magic from the horn left an exact imprint of her hoof over her ribcage. The pain was dull since it was not noon, but Applejack still had tears in hers. "H-How - Urk - will I get any w-work done on the f-farm?"

"I miss the part where that's my problem," Jason moves to Rainbow next. He can still see the defiance in her eyes while he holds contempt for her. "Rainbow Dash. Most of what I had in mind for you is already done and by your doing. But, to make sure it sticks. You will never terrorize those on the ground again. Your wings shall be worthless until you genuinely apologize for your actions. For the next three of yours, you will experience that same lightning strike again at the same time I said for Applejack and Discord. You will feel every awkward twitch and every involuntary muscle spasm in between as I do. And the dull ache shall remain for the rest of your life. You shall be like the character of Icracus. He was cocky and arrogant to think he could fly close to the sun. His wings burned off as a result,"

Rainbow attempts to make a retort, but the Gjallarhorn's magic begins its effect. She only grunts a painful wheeze after that. "...Urgh!!!"

Moving to Fluttershy, the timid pegasus wilts slightly under Jason's gaze, but she maintains eye contact. "W-Wait, not her, please!"

Jason lazily looks at Discord blankly before turning back to Fluttershy. "Fluttershy. I am deciding to give you back your cutie mark,"

"You are?" Fluttershy said in confusion. The magic takes hold of her as her cutie mark returns. No one knew what to make of this change of heart.

"Yes, it is essential for your punishment. For you, your punishment will be as follows; you shall never come into contact with any animal again. Any critter near you will become scared and run away from you. For the next three years, you will no longer be able to understand any animal at all. And ponies will hold a distrust to your opinions save for your friends and family,"

Fluttershy breaks down in tears as the magic takes hold of her again. Jason's punishment was harsh in that he gave her cutie mark back but muted her voice to her critters. Despite being a herbivore, they will treat her like a plague and dangerous predator. It was the same way she treated Jason. Seeing Fluttershy cry, Rarity snarls at Jason. "So, it's my turn now. Go on, then. Get your revenge. You can't do any worse than I haven't done to myself. Apparently. Even though there are those far more deserving and guilty!" Rarity glares at Discord.

"Are you done?" Jason asks, uncaring of Rarity's words. "And, I believe I can do worse. Rarity, for your punishment, you shall only be allowed to sell your product outside Equestria's borders! There shall be nowhere within Equestria where you are allowed to sell clothing! Any business you have now is to be shut down!"

"No, you can't do that! I'll lose too much just selling out of the border. I haven't established myself yet!" Rarity wails.

Uncaring to her plight, Jason goes on. "Furthermore, for the next three years, you shall always speak your intentions to anyone you meet. This way, we'll curb your manipulative nature so that your rose thorns will not any victims of your charms like Spike,"

Rarity joins Fluttershy in crying, albeit with more dramatics, as Jason stands before Twilight. Twilight is currently feeling smaller than she ever did before. She could not hide her trembling. "Jason--"

"Twilight Sparkle! As for your punishment, you are to be stripped of your title as a princess. You will not have a say in any political matters. You will not engage in any diplomatic sessions. You will be like an ordinary citizen with no aid or stipend from the crown or any other royalty! Your Alicorn magical reserve shall be dampened to match that of an average unicorn again for the rest of your life. For the next three years, however, you shall not have access to your magic. You will know what it is like to do things as an Earth pony. Finally, you will also announce all your faults to any new creature you meet. It will be up to them if they want anything to do with you after that!"

Twilight hangs her head low as the Gjallarhorn takes effect. She suddenly felt frail. She could feel her magical reserve but only access a fraction of it. She begins to weep, just like her friends. All of her accomplishments are now undone. All because she went in the opposite direction of her title. All because she let one terrible experience poison her viewpoints. Jason leaves the defendant's bench and faces the courtroom again.

"Now, for the last guilty party,"

"There's more? Who else did you have in mind?" Luna said. Her voice had some apprehension as she thought she was a target now.

"Yes, the citizens of Ponyville. Discord's admission reveals that none of them were affected beyond having their memories erased. They all had a choice to be better than the example Twilight showed. But instead, they went above and beyond to outdo her. The punishment for them is as follows; fifty percent of Ponyville's earrings shall go to me for the next three years as compensation for my pain and suffering. I want all the installments in bits. If there is any refusal to my terms, those same businesses shall fall under misfortune until they inevitably shut down! And, every time someone enters Ponyville, they will gain the knowledge of all their xenophobic tendencies to spare them from it. Everything they have ever done to any non-pony shall be forever known to the public,"

The Gjallarhorn sent out one last magical pulse beyond Canterlot and struck Ponyville. Luna feels the pulse die down. She looks to Jason and sees the Gjallarhorn slowly fade away while Chrysalis joins his side. She seems to the defendants with varying degrees of sadness in their hearts. With a sigh, Luna bangs her gavel. "The condition of the Gjallarhorn are met. The Tribunal has not concluded. FI there any closing statements either party wishes to share, please speak now,"

"..." None of the defendants went to speak. They were either too preoccupied with their sorrow or dealing with the pain.

"...and the prosecution?"

"...You were all once my heroes. My idols. My hope was when Susie died. But xenophobia and specism tainted you! It corrupted you at your core without you ever realizing it. Maybe, if you're mature enough, you can learn from this. Or, maybe you won't. Regardless, I want nothing more to do with any of you. Justice is served. I'm done!"

Jason turns to the door and begins to walk away. "Thank you so much for being such gracious hosts. This has been fun. Ta-ta," Chrysalis said with a coy smile. No one did or said anything in response as the pair left the courtroom.

The Aftermath

Author's Note

Welp, this is it. Today's my birthday, and here is my gift to all of you. Thanks again for all the support, likes, and criticism. I am going to miss writing this story. But it's time to move onwards. Enjoy.

The Aftermath

[Crystal Empire - One Week Later.]

"Now arriving at Crystal Empire station!" The conductor said.

"Behold, Crystal Empire, marvel at the spectacular debut of the Great and Powerful Trixie!" The show mare said with an array of fireworks sparkling behind her. The ponies at the station gave her applause, albeit one of confusion.

"Um, does she normally do this?" Sunburst asks Starlight who was pushing their luggage.

"Every new place she visits. She calls it sampling her potential audience," Starlight says. "Thanks for putting us up on such short notice,"

"Of course, I didn't want to waste a second after your part in the trial," Sunburst says as he frowns. "Did you have any trouble getting here, okay?"

"No. Trixie and I took the morning express. However, some ponies did feel the need to lob trash through my window in the castle when I returned that day. So, I figured it was a mess Twilight could clean up for once,"

"I can hardly believe Princess Twilight and her friends could do such horrible things. They helped save the empire, for crying out loud!"

"Yeah, you think you know some mares,"

"I say good riddance!" Trixie says, coming next to her friends. "Ponyville was never worthy of our presence from the start. Now, the whole world knows what kind of ponies they are. But, um, there are no Equestrians here, right?"

"No anymore. Once the crystal ponies heard how Spike, the brave and glorious, all the ponies from Equestria got deported, Cadance had to act fast to prevent total anarchy," Sunburst says.

"Then, it looks like it's a fresh start for all of us. Anyway, why don't you show us to the palace? There are some ideas I want to share when the Princess returns," Starlight says.

[Ponyville - Town Hall - One Week Later.]

"So, you are honestly doing this?" Chrysalis asks Jason.

"Yes," Jason said with his hands behind his back.

"We changelings may not use bits, but we understand their value. What you're about to do is wasteful,"

The two of them were standing in front of a large crowd. All of them were carrying various sums of bits and placing them in a large container per Jason's instructions. It was time to collect his first annual compensation for his pain and suffering. Many ponies gave Jason the harshest stink eye they could muster but not much else. Jason met their glares with cold indifference. However, he could not help but notice that all elements were missing from the gathering. Jason chalks that up to the shame and injuries. When the last bits fell into the cart, Mayor Mare spoke with utter contempt.

"There. All of Ponyville's businesses and half of their overall profits. Is this to your liking?"

"This is an absolute travesty!" A pony from the crowd yells out. Jason sees Filthy Rich struggling against the royal guards, taking his earnings. "All of us ponies work hard for our money. And you're just giving it away to some freak of nature?!"

"He's practically a millionaire now. All those bits should be going to support us, not in a free handout!" Mr. Cake stated.

Other ponies begin voicing their displeasure as well before stopping while Jason laughs. "I-I guess the old saying is true; a nod is as good as a wink to a blind horse. You're still missing the point of all this. You're still clinging to the same bigot mindset that's led to your generous donation. It's alright. I have nothing more to gain from interacting with you anymore. But I don't think you're right about one thing. I don't want your money. It was never about that. It's about the message, and that message is..."

Jason snaps his finger as Chrysalis rolls her eyes. "You owe a lot of love for this," Chrysalis then charges a powerful spell and shoots it into the pile of bits. A moment later, the gold and jewelry dissolve in rust and slag. The ponies all gasp in horror as an unfamiliar smell fills the air. Filthy Rich crumbles under his wobbly legs as his hard-earned bits are reduced to nothing. "That was taxing,"

Chrysalis chuckles at her little pun as Jason addresses the crowd again. "Everything rots!" Jason tips over the cart of former bits with one final exclamation as a brown slug spills over the floor. "See you all next year,"

[Canterlot - One Week Later.]

The light echoes of hooves throughout the halls of Canterlot. Celestia looks to either side of her to side a line of royal guards - both day and night - giving her the best salute they can muster. Her sister is by her side, as always. However, Blueblood is currently flanking her right. He is sporting a sizeable self-satisfied grin. The group made their way into Celestia's throne room. Many pony nobles were attending, along with several ponies from news outlets. There were many cameras flashes as Celestia went to speak.

"Hello, my subjects. Today marks a day of new beginnings. I have sat upon this throne for a thousand years to govern you all. But now, my time has come to vacate the throne and rulership of this great nation. It has been and will be my greatest honor to serve you all as your Princess. However, the time has come for a change. This day is different from how I visioned it. But it is no less significant. I ask that you give these two ponies the same kindness, understanding, and admiration you've shown me. Now, would you two please face me?"

Princess Luna and Prince Blueblood do as instructed while Celestia's horn glows. Luna's regalia became a mixture of onyx with gold highlights, while her tiara was now the same size as Celestia's. Blueblood himself receives silver regalia and a crown similar to Twilights'. Luna offers her sister a soft, sad smile. In contrast, Blueblood could not stop grinning like a mad pony. "Thank you so much for placing your faith in me, Auntie. I promise to uphold Canterlot's values as you did. I am glad you finally came to your sense regarding your successor. Having that low-born pretender tarnish and sully the crown and your good name is almost too much to bear,"

At the mention of Twilight, the news ponies went into a frenzy. "Princess, Princess! What's to come of the former Princess of Friendship?"

"Have you also added a punishment for her and the elements?"

"Will new elements be selected?"

"Have you disowned them?"

"Are you ashamed that the mare you picked was a failure?"

"Silence!" Celestia said with the royal Canterlot voice. "The matter concerning Twilight and her friends was already resolved. I see no reason to add to their punishment, which would be unjust and cruel. However, this day is not about looking into the past but stepping in the right direction toward the future. Now, I step down as a high-acting princess and welcome my two successors. Princess Luna and Prince Blueblood,"

There was a brief pause before the ponies began applauding. "We thank you for your acceptance. Just as it was upon my return from my banishment, I shall serve Equestria and renew our values so that all of our subjects can enjoy the friendship and harmony I know Equestria possesses!" Princess Luna said.

"How can we trust the word of another princess that fell to darkness?"

Luna nearly winces at the question as she responds. "My sister has faith in me. You trust her judgment, do you not?"

"Yes, but she was wrong about Princess Twilight,"

"Princess Twilight made her bed. My sister is not responsible for every choice she makes. To do so would be nothing short of being a tyrant,"

"But Nightmare Moon was a tyrant. Is this a dream come true for you?"

"The nightmare is no more! As the elements have cleansed me of that curse. And, the Gjallarhorn absolved me of any lingering doubts,"

"But, if you intend to renew Equestria values, why did you want until now? You came back from your banishment six years ago. How did you not notice some of the appalling laws at that time? And what of the Tantabus incident? That was a recent event isolated from your time as Nightmare Moon. How can the citizens of Equestria be safe from your self-flagellation?"

Luna's growing frustration caused concern for Celestia and Cadance, who exchanged worried glances. However, Celestia saw the soft smile n Blueblood and knew these questions were by his design. But, before either of them could move, Prince Blueblood began to speak again. "How dare you! Princess Luna is a mare of a begotten time! Do you honestly think a few short years in the modern world is enough to know everything about it? And, that incident - while bizarre - yield no harm to anypony. We all have things we punish ourselves for; there's no shame in that. That is why I was chosen as well. To help. Now, this line of questioning has outlived its welcome. It is time for the celebration!"

As Blueblood went to mingle, Cadence, Luna, and Celestia all stood dumbfounded by the sudden event. "That miserable little lout!" Cadance hissed.

"My, my, who knew Blueblood was so brazen?" A familiar voice said.

The three alicorns turn around to a well-dressed ebony mare with a green mane. From the voice, Cadance instantly knew who they were talking to. "Chrysalis?"

"Good guess, and here I thought I would have to lend you some hints,"

"Why are you here? I thought you returned to the badlands?" Luna asks.

"I did. But then I heard that you idiots were having a coronation of the biggest idiot this side of Equestria. In the interest of my brood that is still among you, I have come to offer my services,"

"And why would we seek aid from you?" Luna asks with a sneer.

"Really? Are you still harboring ill feelings? Tell me, were any of you expecting Blueblood to try and discredit you today?"

"We knew our nephew had some scheme in place. But, nothing this nefarious," Celestia said.

"Then, you're already at a disadvantage for not expecting Blueblood to pull a stunt like this. Please don't fret. We can recover from this. But, let's talk in private,"

"Jason, is he alright?" Celestia asks.

Chrysalis sends Celestia a look. "He is fine. He got his justice. Now, he wants his peace,"

The alicorns nod in understanding at the clear message. "Then, this is where I must part ways. I cannot be involved with your planning, which goes against my punishment. However, I still have several ways to aid you, and there is no stipulation preventing me from offering any advice,"

"I am not one of your students, Tia. But I welcome your console. What will you be doing in the meantime?" Luna asks.

"I believe it is time to start my journey away from Canterlot, like my students. Many of the issues I leave you with come from my compliancy and stagnation. I intend to see the entirety of Equestria and the rest of the world,"

"A little soul searching and broadening one's horizon is always a good start. Do you have any place in particular?' Cadance asks.

A soft smile graces the former Princess's face. "Sunset gave me some suggestions,"

"Speaking of your wayward students, I noticed Twilight was absent. I am quite surprised none of you rushed to her defense," Chrysalis said.

All the alicorns wore frowns. "Young Twilight is a disappointment. There's nothing to discuss!" Luna spat.

"While her actions against Jason are regrettable, I don't think it is fair to cut her off completely. After all, whatever failings she's had can be directed back to me. There are no innocent parties," Celestia said.

"So, does that mean you talked with her at all this past week?" Cadance asks as Celestia stays quiet. "I thought so. I haven't, either. I believe it is best to keep to our own devices for now. The aftermath of the trial is still a fresh wound,"

"Especially since all the other nations made good on their threat to cut ties. What are the projected damages for that?" Chrysalis asks.

"We won't see any decline in our overall economy for a while. But I estimate two years at most before we enter a recession," Celestia said while shaking her head. "Some of the more 'traditional' ponies seem to be in good spirits from the decision..."

"You mean the hateful specist that thinks themselves above even your standards," Chrysalis said. All the alicorns frown at her words while she smiles. "All the more reason for you to enlist my help," The walk to the Princess's study was swift as Chrysalis dropped her disguise. "Now, let's talk strategy,"

[Two Weeks Later - Day Court.]

"So, what is the issue here again?" Blueblood asks.

"The issue is the custody of one Spike the Dragon. You must focus on issues such as these, nephew," Luna abolishes.

Before, the two were Spike, Twilight Velvet, Night Light, Cadance, and Shining Armor. Surprisingly, Ember was sitting behind Cadance, Shining Armor, and Cozy Glow. Over on the Sparkle parent's side was a well-dress stallion with bifocal glasses. "We thank Your Highnesses for giving us their precious time. I am Clear Spectacles. And I am representing the Sparkles in this case. Simply put, the documentation for the adoption of Spike the Dragon is authenticated and signed by Princess Celestia herself. By law, he is the legal pet of the house of Sparkle."

"It is a law that goes against everything any society stands for! We cannot be a nation that promotes harmony and friendship if sentient creatures can be reduced to companion animals. It's borderline slavery!" Cadance argues.

"Forgive me if I am wrong, your highnesses, but since when does slavery involve living under a comfortable roof in the nation's capital? Has Spike ever been beaten or whipped for speaking out of turn or showing defiance? Was he starved or forced to sleep outside? Did he not handle personal official documentation? So, we know he has a substantial education. Shining Armor and Twilight Sparkle both refer to Spike as a brother. Is that not right, Shining Armor?"

"That's correct," Shining said.

"A gilded cage is still a cage! And while there was no physical abuse, there was substantial emotional abuse and neglect. Both of the purviews are under abuse! But I believe I can settle this. What would you describe to be a pet?" Cadance asks.

"What an absurd question. Pets can range from a variety of animals and serve a variety of purposes. The most common is companionship for ourselves and foals," Clear Spectacles said.

"Yes, but can they talk to you? I know some animals lack this ability of cognitive thought. So, what is a pet in the eyes of Equestria?"

"Urgh! I'm not too fond of pets. Sadly, all the animals I dealt with were not up to my standards. And the maintenance and upkeep they demand from me are utterly despicable. Any pet to grace my home should count their lucky stars. I paid a fraction of attention to them," Blueblood said.

"But you can agree that none of your pets can converse intelligently with you, correct?" Shining asks.

"Of course not. That would be lunacy to talk to animals,"

"Then, by that standard, Spike's classification as a pet is null and void since he is capable of sapience the same as the rest of us," Cadance said.

"Spike's classification is the only thing allowing him to stay in Equestria!"

"I'd rather be exiled than be seen as less of a living being!" Spike spoke up.

"And I will gladly welcome Spike with open arms in the Dragonlands!"

"Enough! This issue has been prevalent for far too long!"Luna said while pulling out a document. "I have been in constant converse with the legislate, and while some laws will take more time to revise, we have made a new law. Creatures displaying a certain level of intelligence are not to be considered pets. A test will be administered to test the level of intelligence. Since Spike is self-aware and clearly understands us, he is no longer considered a pet! I trust that both parties have no objections?"

"It's a start," Cadance reminded.

Clear Spectacles sucks her teeth while the Sparkle parent looks on with impassiveness. "If this gets the walking disaster out of our home, it is all the better. I think it is time to take our leave," Twilight Velvet said.

"Agreed," Night Light said.

Without another word or even a glance at their opposition, Shining's parents remove themselves from day court. "Well, another productive day in day court. If you all will excuse me, I am late for a spa appointment," Blueblood said as he took his leave.

Cadance shakes her head as she approaches Spike. "At least we're finally moving in the right direction. So, Spike, do you-- Oh..." Cadance stops as she notices the tears streaming down Spike's eyes. Regardless of his treatment, Spike saw Velvet and Nightlight as family. And, the two ponies he's known all of his life effectively disowned him for being different.

Shining was the first to embrace in a hug. "Come here, little buddy. Let it out. I'm right here," Spike sobs loudly in his brother's chest before joining the hug. Ember comes up and places a hand on Spike's back. Luna cancels the rest of the day's activities to comfort the baby dragon.

[Manehattan.]

Cozy stood tall in front of a podium as a large assortment of other creatures. Spike was moving in between the crowd, passing out pamphlets. There were some ponies in the mixture, but all were wearing looks of confusion. "Hello, Manehattan! I want to thank you all for coming to our audit. The Creatures for Equestria happily welcomes anyone that wants to spread our message for equality for all creatures. Now, you may have heard me say anyone instead of anypony. Well, that's because anypony just doesn't fit with our cause. It singles all the non-ponies out. And that's not fair or fun. Since the trial, our numbers have gone up a lot. Today, we're here to open a chapter in this great city,"

"How can we ponies help? I don't want to be intolerant,"

"You can help by standing with us. Show the world that you are not the same as the ponies that think they are superior to everyone else. We all saw the trial. I know it's tough knowing that the ponies we looked up to let all of us down. But all that means is we should not trust the words of those in power over our judgment. We can be better! We can represent harmony and friendship! But something like this is big and expensive. So, anyone joining the Manhattan chapter, I would like it very much if you donate one bit to continue our efforts," The crowd all let out cheers as many jumped at the chance to join, donating more than just one bit.

Spike and Cozy walked off the podium. "Wow. Everyone seems on board," Spike says.

"I know. We'll have enough members to start our chapter here and beyond. Say, could you hold down the fort? I have to mail out a letter," Cozy says.

"Oh, I can do that for you,"

"Don't worry. I got it. You're not my mailbox. You're my friend, Spike the Dragon,"

"Alright, as long as you're sure,"

Cozy waves him off as she flies down the street and quickly into an alley once the coast is clear. She takes out her letter and reads it over. "Dear Tirek. Everything is going better than I would've hoped. Nopony believes in the princesses and the elements anymore. With a little more pushing, I think I can get you out. It'll be great! Your pen pal, Cozy Glow,' Perfect," Cozy takes out another vial and tilts it so that single drip land on the letter and watches as it ignites. The flames worked as Spike's mystical flame and flew off to its recipient.

[Two Months Later - Fluttershy's cottage.]

The silence was never something Fluttshy would come to hate about her cottage. The empty cages and feeding pans were even worse. The first day of the trial was a nightmare scenario for the shy pegasus. All her critters, even Angel Bunny, shrank back free of her and ran away. No matter how far she chased after them or how much she pleaded, none of her long-time animal friends would stop. However, when Fluttershy continued to pursue her pets, a raccoon ventured too far into a swamp. Fluttershy stops when a cragadile pops from the murky water to swallow her woodland friend whole. Broken, Fluttershy collapses in sadness, which strengthens as the monster runs away from the timid pegasus.

"Fluttershy?" Discord asks.

"Oh, yes, Discord?" She asks, snapping out of her thoughts. The draconequus is lying on the couch with a blanket and rag river his head.

"If it's not too much trouble, I would like more of that soup?"

"Sure, let me get that for you." Fluttershy goes into the kitchen while humming a song. Discord knew this song, and he could not help the ache he felt in his heart for his friend. Fluttershy always sang this song when tending to her critters. Now that it was only him, the song was hollow. "Here you go, Discord. Try not to drink it too fast,"

Discord was about to take a sip when he looked at the bowl. "Um, Fluttershy?"

Fluttershy notices the name Angel on the bowl, causing her to flinch. "Oh, I-I'm sorry. I'll get your bowl,"

"Fluttershy, it's alright. I can--"

Fluttershy cuts him off as she flies into the kitchen and back with Discord's name on a bowl. She puts an ice bag on his head and shoves the soup in his mouth. "Don't worry, Discord. I am still adjusting to the changes. But I'll get the hang of it. Momma will take care of everything,"

"Fluttershy," Discord said with worry while looking into his friends' needy, desperate eyes before resigning to her care. "Alright. Thank you..."

[Sweet Apple Acres.]

Applejack pants with exertion while carrying a bucket of apples. With a grunt, she put the apples in the cart. Applejack hobbles over to the next tree. Her face was covered in sweat. She gingerly moves to a bucking position. However, pain shoots through her barrel the moment she lifts both hooves. She clutches her side as she falls onto her belly. Applejack's mouth opens and closes from the pain, making breathing hard. She could finally send out a sharp whistle after what felt like hours. A few moments later, Wynnoa and Applebloom came down the field. However, Applejack notices Applebloom is taking her time in her approach while Wynnoa reaches her in seconds.

"Again?" Applebloom sighs. "Why do you keep trying to buck these trees with that condition of yours?"

"Big Mac is struggling with the workload. Granny is talking about hiring farmhands. I-I got to do my share," Applejack groans.

"You don't get to do nothing but sit in the house. Big Mac and I eye got things covered. All you're doing is being a nuisance,"

"Don't sass your big sister!"

"Whoose sassing? I think it's silly that we must keep dragging you back to the house when you know you can't work the orchard. Look, you barely even have one bucket full. And now, we must stop everything because you're too stubborn!"

Applejack glares at her little sister or at least tries to look stern. She was unsure what kind of face she was making under all the pain. "Just get Big Mac!" Applejack spots her sister's indignant look, which hurts worse than the pain. "...Please..."

Applebloom sighs as she runs back to the farm. Wynnona stays with her master while she looks past the fence. Images of that day she met Jason and the trial resurface as she hugs Wynnona tightly. She would've lost a lot more than her ability to buck trees had things gone another way not long before the apple farmer's brother arrived and hoisted her onto his back. Big Mac gingerly makes his way back to the house.

"Y'all okay?" Big Mac asks.

"...She hates me..." Applejack replies softly. "Everypony does now,"

"She hates what Ya did,"

"I deserve it,"

"Maybe right now, but not forever,"

"I've become a burden to the farm and a shame to the family. You hate me too, don't you?"

Big Mac can feel the tears stains on his coat as he sighs. "I am disappointed, but I can never hate Ya. You can make things right. For now, you got to take your licks. Granny has some to make the pain easier," The two enter the farmhouse without another word.

[Carousel Boutique - Two months later.]

"No. No. No!" Rarity frets as she dashes through her store. Her clothes were in zipper bags, currently resting in a large pile. Rarity was sitting at her desk with several letters. Her mane and tail were unkempt, with a multitude of split ends. Her eyes sported deep bags and black lines, indicating a lack of sleep. In between her fretting, Sweetie Belle slowly comes up to her sister.

"Rarity? Is everything alright?"

"No, it's not alright!" Rarity snaps. "Do you see these letters? Do you know what they are?"

"Um, no!"

"They are orders. Specifically rejection orders. I had this year completely booked for revenue and clients. They all cancel their orders and demand refunds. Sapphire Shores. Hoitey Toitey. Fancypants! None of them want to be my patrons anymore!"

"W-Well, what about the stores on the border? I know you had to close up the boutique in Equestria. But, I bet those are doing well,"

Rarity slams her head against the table. "It's no use! I don't have the funds to build a store on the borders. There's also the fact that anypony available for hire either has no eye for fashion or wants nothing to do with me! What clients would like to associate with my brand after that trial? The only thing keeping this store afloat is my savings. But it's dwindling by the day! How could this happen?"

Sweetie rubs her hoof on her shoulder as she looks at her sister with trepidation. "Rarity, I have something to tell you..."

"Please, Sweetie. Just go with your friends. I want to be alone. I need concentration if I want to salvage this debacle,"

"It's crucial you hear this, dear," A new voice said.

Rarity lifts her head to see her parents behind Sweetie Belle. Hondo Flanks and Cookie Crumble stare at their eldest daughter with a look of worry and something else Rarity does not like. "Mother? Father? When did you two get here?"

"Little earlier in the day. We came by, but you were busy, so we wanted to give you space," Cookie explains.

"But, while we respect you and your business so much, we've made a difficult decision," Hondo says.

"W-What's that?" Rarity asks.

"We're taking Sweetie Belle back with us. With everything happening, we don't want your sister caught in unnecessary conflict,"

"We feel that Ponyville is not the best environment to raise her. We want her around positive influences," Cookie finishes.

Rarity dips her head down so that her mane covers her eyes. "It's about the trial. I'm the bad influence..." Rarity says.

"No, dear, no. It's this place and the ponies here. It has nothing to do with what some mistreated human had to say. No matter how compelling," Cookie Crumbles says in a wavering tone.

"I see..." Rarity says. "So, I suppose you are also cutting ties with me?"

"Rarity, that's not it at all. You can come along with us. A change of scenery will do wonders, pumpkin," Hondo tries to comfort, but Rarity pulls away.

"Right; meanwhile, I sit in the background watching my dream that I worked toward since filly hood crumbles and wither away. Then, there's the face of me abandoning my..." Rarity stops herself from saying the word friends. In truth, she had not spoken a word to anyone in town, much less her closest friends. The facts and reveals of the trial left a sour taste in her mouth. Although, she did not know what disgusted her more. The actions of the town, her friends, or her own. 'But, this punishment goes too far! I am losing everything, from my sister to my parents' faith in me. It's not fair!'

"Mom, Dad. I don't want to leave Ponyville forever. What about my friends, the Crusaders?" Sweetie asks.

"Well, we can do nothing for other foals, Sweetie. We have to look after our own," Cookie Crumbles says.

Sweetie's eyes swell up with tears. "Can I at least say goodbye?"

"That's fine, dear," Hondo said as Sweetie bolted out of the shop.

Rarity flinches at those words as she speaks up harshly. "I am not abandoning my shop or my home! I've had rough spells like this before. I got through those, and I shall get through this!"

Rarity's parents share a look before responding. "We're here if you need us, pumpkin,"

Her parents quickly left the shop while Rarity took the letters she was reading and ignited them. Going to her workbench, Rarity summons a vintage bottle of wine, takes a big gulp, and starts to work on some unfinished dresses. "I will not let this beat me!"

[Rock Farm - Pie Residence.]

A pinkie hoof slams down on a stone, revealing several geodes. "Alright, that's good, Pinkie. Bring those with the rest so we can take them to Mom and Dad to sell them at the market," Limestone says.

"Hmm-hmm," Pinkie says, gathering up the gems.

The two sisters begin their trek to the marketplace. "This haul is excellent. Having you back has doubled our productivity. Now, I don't have to drag marble out here anymore,"

"You shouldn't force her too much. But, I didn't know it was a struggle to harvest these gems,"

"Since you and Maud left, I had to compile my resources. Besides, she can't keep whimpering at everything. Marble's got to get out more,"

The two pie sisters got to their parents with their cart full of geodes. Igneous picks one up and gives it the once over before handing it to Cloudy. The matriarch of the pie family taps it three times before turning to her husband. Both of them nod to each other and face their daughters.

"Good quality. Pristine and unmolested. This haul is adequate. Come, it is time for dinner," Cloudy says. The family enters the dining room with a full spread.

Pinkie found the food selection shocking as it was her favorite meal from Ponyville. "...You didn't have to make my favorite meal,"

"We wanted you to feel more comfortable staying here," Marble mumbles.

"Yeah, besides, some of these snacks are not half bad," Limestone says, biting into a cupcake.

Pinkie looks at her father as he nods at her. She gives him an appreciative smile before eating. Dinner was quiet and wholesome. It was the same as Pinkie's filly years. She remembers leaving when things felt too stale and blinking. But she must admit that she missed her old farm and her family. At first, she thought coming back was like running away. But taking some time to herself is helping somewhat. "Ma. Pa, could I have some rock soup?"

Everyone arches a brow at this. "Sure, Pinkie," Maud says with a barely visible smile.

[Ponyville General Hospital.]

Scootaloo is currently sitting in the waiting room of the hospital. She was not staring at anything in particular but was growing increasingly anxious. She is here now because she is absent-mindedly trotting to Rainbow Dash's home. Ever since the trial, the filly did not know what to do. Her hero, idol, and adoptive sister is nothing more than a cruel bully. Even worse than the sugar lumps. No matter how hard she denies it, that is now the truth. Rainbow hasn't left her home since, and whether out of reflex or genuine concern, Scootaloo tried visiting her home. But that was when she saw her hero. Rainbow jumped from the safety of her cloud home and soared through the air. At first, Scootaloo did not believe it. Rainbow was flying and defying that order the human placed on her. However, Scootaloo has seen Rainbow fly enough times that she knew something was amiss. There was no flare, gymnastics, or any of Rainbow's brand of fantastic flying.

It was like she was crawling on her belly in the air. Her wings were not even moving. That is when Scootaloo gasps out in shock. Rainbow wasn't flapping her wings. Her death-defying leap was little more than a lazy guide that soon became a nosedive and a freefall. Rainbow crashes hard into the ground in a few seconds with a sickening thud. Panicking, Scootaloo went to get help and is now sitting and waiting. The wait did not last long as the doors burst open to reveal Rainbow's parents. They quickly went to the doctor as they came out of Rainbow's room.

"Doctor! Doctor Horse!!! Where's my baby? How is my little filly?!" Windy hollers.

"Rainbow dash is thankfully alright. This isn't the first she has come here for crash injuries. She does have a broken muzzle and a mild concussion. So, we'll be keeping her for observation,"

"Did-did Rainbow say anything? Why would she jump from her home? You don't think..." Bow stops his thought, but the doctor reads the implications.

"No, nothing of that magnitude. She tried to fly. Although, I cannot imagine what passed her to do so, given her punishment--"

"Enough! We won't hear a word of that kangaroo trial and this unjust punishment! It's no wonder our little filly did this. She is frustrated! Can an earth Pony like you know what happens to a pegasus that's been grounded for this long? She is going stir-crazy!" Windy states, cutting the doctor off.

"Well, like it or not, she is grounded. And if Rainbow pulls another stunt like this again, I severely recommend putting her on a watch list! Now, there is the matter of her bill!"

"Bill?! I thought national heroes weren't charged!" Bow growls.

"That was before our income got cut in half. We cannot offer courtesies like that anymore!" Doctor Horse says firmly.

"And, what makes you think we have any bits left? We're still paying off that massive fine the Cloudsdale sent Rainbow!" Windy says.

"I'm sorry, but that is just how things are now. The receptionist will send you the invoice.

Scootaloo could not help but wince as she did hear that the weather factory sent Rainbow a hefty fine. Rainbow had to sell most of her Wonderbolt memorable to pay the interest fees. However, while Scootaloo ponders this, Rainbow's parents speak to her. "Say, little orange? Since we are bound with all these expenses, could you help your sister?" Bow asks.

Scootaloo looks at the two pegasi in confusion. "You want me to pay? With the bits, I get from my aunts? But, they told me only use it for the house and my food,"

"Oh, we would not ask if we did not need if Rainbow didn't need it. You know what's happening. It's far too much stress for our little foal. And, as her family, we need to do our part for the family, dear,"

"Well..." Scootaloo becomes more hesitant. Rainbow was like a sister to her. But, with everything she did, it was like she was a stranger now.

Thankfully, the decision was not hers to make. "That is quite enough!"

Everyone turns to the source of the voice to find four ponies entering the waiting area. "Mom, Dad, Aunty Lofty, and Aunt Holiday. What are you doing here?" Scootaloo asks, running to her family.

"We would've come much earlier, honey. But, our latest expedition was longer than we thought," Snap Shutter says.

"But, once we heard the news from your aunts, we came down to Ponyville as fast as we could," Mane Allgood says.

Seeing nothing wrong, Bow Hothoof extends his hoof to Mane Allgood. "Well, it's good to see you all made okay,"

"I am afraid we are not here for pleasantries. We're here for our daughter to take her away from this town!" Snap says.

"What?" Scootaloo exclaims.

"This place is no good for you, Scootie. The ponies especially are not what I'd call friendly," Aunt Lofty glares.

"And, what is that supposed to mean?" Windy sneers.

"You know exactly what she means! How dare you force our Scootaloo to pay for your filly's crime!" Aunt Holiday says.

"Crime?! Our Dashies is an expert flyer. It's that stupid human's fault she's like this!" Windy shouts.

"And, it was Rainbow that brought all that upon herself. Parents like you are exactly why Scootaloo is leaving with us!" Snap counters.

"Ha, as if you have the nerve to talk! You left a filly alone to pursue your precious job. We never put work over our daughter!"

"That's right! We supported Dashie in everything!" Bot Hothoof said.

"Does that include being a bully, a sadist, and a potential murderer?" Mane Allgood states.

The two stallions butt heads and punish one another before another set of hoof steps clop against the ground. Everyone turns to see Rainbow Dash hobbling out of her room. She walks past her parents and faces Scootaloo. The filly flinches while Rainbow pats her head. "Thank. You..." Rainbow then turns back and goes into her room. However, Rainbow collapses and spasms as her parents rush to find the doctor.

Scootaloo felt a rush of pain and guilt for Rainbow Dash before a pair of hooves rested on her shoulders. "Come on, honey. You'll enjoy all our adventures," Snap Shutter says, guiding her daughter outside. Scootaloo looks back one last time at Rainbow before looking ahead.

[The badlands - Changeling castle.]

"Big adventure. Faithful and strong. Sharing kindness is an easy feat. And magic makes it all complete. My Little Pony. Did you know you're all my very best friends!"

"Again," Jason calls out to the man 6.

"Are you sure, Jason? If we keep singing the same song, it will lose its luster," Pinkie says.

"Yeah, you don't want to ruin the awesomeness of my part in the song by having me sing it repeatedly," Rainbow says.

"And, it's getting a might tiring," Applejack says.

"One mustn't abuse a hot commodity after all," Rarity says. "my voice is getting parched,"

"But we don't mind going again if that's alright with you," Fluttershy says meekly.

"Regardless, you should get some rest yourself. You are looking tired," Twilight says.

Jason stares at all of them with a blank expression. "...Just sing it again,"

Just as The Mane 6 goes to comply, Chrysalis walks inside the room. "Urgh! What have I told you about torturing my subjects?"

"Since when is sing torture?"

"Since you started making my drones turn themselves into the elements to enact some bizarre fantasy," Chrysalis waves a hoof and dismisses the drones. "Jason. What are you doing?"

"..."

Chrysalis puts her hooves on Jason's face and makes him look at her. "Was your justice not enough?"

"...No, it was. I'm just..." Jason pauses as he collects himself. "I can't stop thinking about how things could've been different. Even after everything that's happened, I still love that damn show and its characters,"

"You can try to dream with your eyes open all you wish, but the real world will still be there for a wake-up call. Now, will I be the one to wake you up so that you can eat? Or do you want my drones to do it in disguise?"

Jason sighs and gets up from his chair. "...Fine, what are we having?"

"Grub worms! They are high in protein," Chrysalis says with a cheeky smile. Jason fails to suppress a shudder.

[One Year later - Ponyville - Twilight's POV.]

This town used to be vibrant and colorful—a place of wholesomeness. A Place of joy and peace. A place of harmony and friendship. Now, all that is gone. Walking through Ponyville was almost like walking into a ghost town. I always liked when Mayor Mare would greet me outside her office. She's no longer in office. The scandal with the diamond dog and her unauthorized mining of their gems was grounds for impeachment. The sight was not pretty. Mayor Mare did not go peacefully from her position. Instead, she went on a big rant on she kept the barren hick town together. Those are her words exactly. There were some words directed at me as well. I was a naive little know who didn't know how to operate without a list. Those words hurt because I thought we were friends. Ha, you think you do some ponies, right? Now, the town hall has banners of our newest Mayor, Pen Sharpie. He has a purple coat and a pink and wink mane and tail. He's promised to bring legitimately back to Ponyville. But, the truth is no one wants the position of governing this town.

The effects of the Gjallarhorn are powerful magic indeed. Any new visitors we get instantly turn away as memories of our sins flood into them. It would often lead to flash mobs of Pony protesting the residents of Ponyville. The act prompted the new Mayor to petition for extra guards to patrol the entrance and screen them for harmful objects. Of course, soliciting for more guards fell through. I still don't know whether Princess Luna or Prince Blueblood denied the request. That led to the Mayor getting creative with security and outsourcing help from a local mercenary guild. At least, I think they are. I have no idea. I can't talk to the Mayor about it as my punishment prevents me from speaking on anything in a government capacity, regardless of the level. It was on Filthy Riches' suggestion. He is paying a large part in the finances as of late. The guards he had hurt Jason were now under his exclusive employ since they were let go from the royal guard. While the crime they committed remained unpunished, Princess Luna was able to find multiple infractions on their record.

The guard's bitterness shows as they are stern and cruel in their duties. However, one of them paid a hefty price when a changeling was found walking out of disguise. Even after a year of no trouble from our new incognito neighbors, ponies here still harbor resentment toward them for disrupting their way of life. Too bad the effects of the Gjallarhorn were still in play. The example the guards wanted to set was not the one that happened, evident by the fact that Flithy used three guards to assault Jason, and now there are only two. It made them hesitant to keep up their method of conducting their duties. Between the hired help and most of the businesses giving half their sums to Jason, the town is struggling in the likes I have never seen before. Many shops are closed now—the flower sisters, Aloe, and Lotus Spa. Pinkie would be heartbroken to know that the cake family had to close up shop. Then, there is the rash of homeless ponies roaming around.

At least I finally found some use for all the extra rooms in the castle. Thus, turning it into a homeless shelter. And the crown does send stipends for their upkeep. I don't know why Princess Luna never seized it. But Prince Blueblood allowed me to keep it. It was out of kindness but as an insult—the fallen Princess presiding in a castle of no authority and nameless vagabonds for subjects. Again, these are his words, not mine. I never realized this castle's size until I started tending to it myself. I know precisely how Spike felt every time I asked him to clean. It wasn't a task a single creature could do without magic. No wonder Spike spent most of his time sleeping. I worked him too hard and then scolded him for seemingly slacking off. I tried contacting him a couple of times through his magical fire. I know it was wrong. But I miss having him as that constant in my life. When I awake, he was always right there with breakfast. Yet, I took him for granted. He ignored my letters until his new friend Cozy sent me one by standard mail. I can still remember the words clearly.

"Hi there, Princess Twilight. Oh, sorry. I didn't mean to bring up any bad feelings. But Spike and I are very busy with the CFE operations. And I am afraid all the letters you keep sending him are starting to cause some issues. Could you send your notes through the mail system instead of enchanted fire? It's very distracting, and Spike is, well, he is busy. A true trooper, I can tell you that. Well, you already knew that, didn't you? No wonder you were so good at everything. We hope to hear from you again—signed Cozy Glow,"

I got the message, and I haven't sent another letter since. I shook my head and continued my walk. None of the ponies that were outside greeted me. It was the identical harsh glares and crude whispers. It hurt, but none more than the state of my friends. We've drifted apart this past year. Any meetings we did have were always short. And, there was an air of resentment the longer we stayed in each other's company. I try to visit as much as possible to mend our friendship. Fluttershy is often too apprehensive about leaving Discord's side, so we have tea in her cottage. But, she usually spends the majority of the time tending to Discord. The apples are doing well enough.

I typically see Big Mac and Applebloom at the castle delivering food to the shelter. However, I'd only ever talk to Big Mac. Applebloom's glare puts all the other ones I receive to shame. The Cutie Mark Crusaders breaking up has been hard on her. But, Applejack rarely leaves the farm, and Granny Smith's barred me from setting hoof on her property. Rarity is by far the worse case. Since Sweetie is now gone and her businesses across Equestria closed down, she's been drinking a lot more lately. When Rarity is sober enough to converse, she makes blankets for the ponies without homes. But she's also distant and cold toward me and our friends. It's almost like she blames everyone for her current affairs.

Finally, there's Rainbow Dash. She's been going through a bad depression for months now. The only good thing about seeing her is that she can talk now without wheezing. But that's the only good thing. Her parents moved in to help support her, and they are every bit as overbearing as Rainbow describes. The only time I don't see them with Rainbow is when she sneaks off to have a drinking session with Rarity. At least those two are closer now, but I have to watch them. The castle itself constantly reminds me how badly I messed everything up. The once shining hue it used to give has dulled and faded away. I always cleaned off some fresh graffiti on the sides in the mornings. And, my occupants hardly say a word to me unless it is for food and clothes. With a sigh, I enter my castle to retire. But before I do, there's a knock at the door.

"I've told you, Snip and Snails, that you can't keep cutting it so close to lock-up time. These doors will be magically locked for the whole night--"

I opened the door to the biggest shock I'd ever seen—a human. There was a human standing in front of me. He was carrying a lot of luggage and bags like he was moving inside. There was a bright smile on his face as he looked at me. It wasn't like Jason-- who looked at me with barely visible rage and contempt. No, this one was happy. Happy to see me of all ponies. Did he come from Jason's world? Does that mean he's seen that show of us and is a fan? I heard several gasps come from behind me. I knew it was the attendants. They must have the same expression as me right now. I can feel the saliva in my mouth drying up and my heart racing.

"Wow. It's you. You're Twilight Sparkle. I mean, I know you know who you are. I'm kinda a fan," The human chuckles in embarrassment as he scratches the back of his head. He holds out his hand for a hoof shake. "My name is Gregory Graystone,"

I look back and forth between his hand and his face before I feel lightheaded. "...Oh..." The last I saw was a flash of panic on Gregory's face as darkness consumed my vision.

[??????]

A harsh, unrelenting wind bellows in the background of a tundra. A field of went snow stretches as far as the eyes can see. That is if the icy wind gales allow you to see. The snowfall never ceases, even for a moment. It was a land untouched by modern society with no inhabitants daring enough to tame the lands. Then, in the eye of the storm, a figure emerges. Two others soon accompanied it. Their bodies were transparent. But, their eyes were like beacons, piercing through the storm as if it was not there. Their appearance was equine in nature, but it was unlike the ponies of Equestria and Saddle Abria. For in their eyes lies a bitter hatred and ravenous hunger. The ghostly steeds look past the veil of their machinations and find something interesting. They flew off in the skies above while the storm grew in intensity. Even though the beings were alone, the sharp otherworld wail seemed to carry on for miles as they made their move.

"WOOOOOOOOUUUUGH!!!!"

The Gala

Author's Note

Hey, guys. Here's a new story for you all. After reading it several times, I want to try my hand at the ending universe. This story is mainly inspired by kildeez https://www.fimfiction.net/story/239827/a-new-ending, but there will only be one aspect of that story that I liked that I wanted to explore. The timeline is a little murky. It has elements from every season, and the MLP movie. but, I hope you enjoy it.

The Gala

[Carousel Boutique.]

"What do you think, Sweetie? Too loud, or is it too subtle?" Rarity pondered as she stood on her stage modeling her dress. She was levitating a red scarf and white rose.

"Rarity! For the hundredth time, they both look fine! Can we please get ready before we're late?" Sweetie complained.

"Now, now, Sweetie Belle. To complete this particular ensemble, I need something to go with the intricate flow of the white trimming. Something to complement the curvature of the gold silk and offset the red highlight near my tail. Please, Sweetie! You know I value your input,"

"Urgh! The rose..." Rarity beams as she looks at the mirror and applies the rose to her mane. "Rarity. What makes this Gala so special anyway?"

"Oh, that's simple, Sweetie. All the rulers of the other countries will be here for Twilight's big announcement,"

"Wow, why would any of them come for an announcement?"

"Well, all our work with the cutie map has garnered us some favors. Why are even the brutish dragons attending? This gives me the perfect opportunity to gain some new and exotic clientele. As well as possibly expanding the boutique. Oh, imagine it, Sweetie. Carousel Arabia. Carousell Prance. carousel Dragonlands..." Rarity paused in thought as the name made her muzzle scrunch. "Hmm, we'll have to work on that one. And the location would scare off any managers. Perhaps I could outsource from the locals? No, dragons don't do clothing..."

"Why not ask Spike if--"

"Yes, of course, Spiky-Wiky. I could ask him to run the shop there!"

Sweetie gave her older sister a nonplussed look for cutting her off. "I doubt Spike would up and leave Twilight. I meant you could see if he knows any dragon,"

Rarity, however, gave a dismissive wave. "I hardly believe Spike would be able to find any of those dragons that would have a sophisticated interest like fashion. But he does know the Dragonlord. And she does owe Spiky - not to mention Twilight and me - for gaining her position as Dragonlord. She could wave her little specter and have her subjects pay in gems.

Sweetie waved a hoof over Rarity's sparkling eyes. "Rarity, that plan seems unethical,"

Rarity shook the stars off as she gave pause. "Hmm, I suppose. But, semantics, darling. I am sure we'll figure it out later. Do you have everything for your sleepover at Sweet Apple Acres?"

"Yep. I got the extra blankets. Scootaloo got the scary stories, and Applebloom got the food and drinks. We're going camping out in the clubhouse,"

"Oh, um, are you sure that is safe?"

"Don't worry; Big Mac will be working the field to pick up for Applejack's absence after the Gala. We'll be fine,"

"Aw, now there's a dependable stallion—a shame he isn't attending. I'm sure I could make him a proper member of the nobility. It would be a fun project getting him to look presentable. Although, Applejack would never let her brother anywhere near nobles,"

"Eeyup," The two sisters shared a laugh.

"Yes, this will be the best night ever," Rarity walked out of her home with Sweetie Belle as the two made their way to Twilight's castle.

[Sugarcube corner.]

"Pinkie, dear, are you sure you need that much frosting?" Mrs. Cake asks.

"Of course, Mrs. Cake. With our new cinnamon honey cookies, you need this much frosting for dipping. I know not many ponies in Canterlot like our brand of treats, so I had to dress them up," She had a tray of frosting balanced on her head while the cookies were in front. She took the dispenser and rapidly frosted the treats in a blink of an eye. Despite the speed and frosting flying everywhere, the cookies were perfectly frosted. Amazingly, her dress remains pristine—a puffy yellow dress with glitter lining and white swirls designed on her hips.

"Remember not to be too forceful in the pitch, Pinkie. If you push too hard, you push customers away," Mr. Cake said.

"Can do, Mr. Cake. I, Pinkie, promise that we'll have new Canterlot buyers before the week is out-- Huh?" Before Pinkie could start her motions, her right hoof began to tremble. It was subtle, tiny shakes that felt no bigger than an itch. Then, she felt a slight tinge in her stomach as if Gummy was doing gymnastics with her intestines. Finally, there was a dull ache in her heart. After a moment, everything went back to normal. "...Huh..."

"Pinkie, dear? Are you alright?" Mrs. Cake asks in concern.

"Yeah, I'm fine. Anywho, I better get going. Twilight said she had a big surprise at the Gala this year. I can't wait to see it!" As Pinkie smiles and walks out of the store, her hoof tingles again briefly. "Hmm, this combo feels familiar. Well, it must be something that future Pinkie has to tackle. Until then, I should focus on the best night ever!" With that, Pinkie skipped merrily down to Twilight's castle.

[Ponyvile.]

"And you're sure you wanna take the load all by your lonesome? Ya, remember what happened the last time an apple tried to take on the orchard on its own?" Applejack asks, her studs clicking across the ground. Her dress was simple yet elegant—a brown top with a yellow gown with the apple family brand on the sides. She was walking down to Twilight's castle with her brother and little sister, following closely.

Big Macintosh gave a sideways glance to his sister as he spoke. "I remember you were trying to pick all the apples 'till Twilight had to come, and you beg her to help,"

"Applejack? I was in the schoolhouse during that. you tried to clear the whole orchard and begged Twilight for help?" Applebloom asks.

"I ain't did no begging!" Applejack's nose scrunched as her sibling gave her a flat look. "Okay. I did ask for some help toward the end. The point is I don't want you working yourself to the bone as I did,"

"Nope," Big mac said.

"Don't you worry none, sis? The girls and I will be happy to help my big brother," Appleblooms said.

"Aw, thanks there, Sugarcubes. That makes me feel better about heading off to another headache from Gala shindigs," Applejack stated.

"I wouldn't say that, AJ. After all..." Rainbow Dash came flying down with Scootaloo in tow. She spotted her Wonderbolt uniform with a black jacket and the Wonderbolt emblem on the back. "The only heads that will spin is everypony that sees me,"

"Yeah!" Scootaloo cheered as her little wings buzzed. "Rainbow Dash is going to dazzle everypony at the Gala!"

"What are you talking about, Sugarcube?" Applejack asks.

"Twilight's got this big announcement in the works, and she asked the Wonderbolts to perform after it," Rainbow said.

'Do you know what this big announcement is, Applejack?" Applebloom asks.

"'Fraid not, Applebloom. Twilight has been muzzled about it," Applejack said.

"Whatever our favorite egghead is cooking up, if it involves me, it will be awesome!" Rainbow said.

"And 20% cooler!" Scootaloo added.

"That's right, squirt,"

Rainbow ruffles Scootaloo's mane as Applebloom speaks again. "Hey, there's Rarity, Pinkie, and Sweetie Belle,"

[Fluttershy's Cottage]

Discord stood in front of a mirror with a forlorn expression. He snaps his paw, and a black suit appears on his body. His frown deepens as he snaps his finger again. This time, a blue suit appears. Another snap, and Discord proceeds to go through the entire color spectrum before he stands before the mirror with nothing again. "Oh, for chao's sake!"

"Discord? Are you alright?" Fluttershy calls out. The timid mare came out the back wearing a beautiful evergreen dress with a transparent gown over the hindlegs.

"Everything is fine, Fluttershy. I only can't find anything to wear," Discord snaps his finger to summon a beanbag chair that was a literal bean as he slumps down on it. "Why are social gathers always so orderly? Urgh!"

"Oh, I know; I still get nervous around events like these. But you never like to attend these events or care about what others think of you beside me. Why does this Gala have you all out of sorts?"

"Well, normally, I wouldn't. I only care for the opinion of my best friend and greatest mare on the planet," Fluttershy pat the spirit of chaos on the leg. "Lately, I've been thinking of all the wrongs I committed to others, not just ponies..."

"Oh, well, I think this is a good chance to apologize for whatever it is you did,"

Discord rubs the back of his head nervously. "Yes, it is, but some of those I wrong is not here. And the effects of my wrongdoings span from a long time ago. It's like another plunder vine situation,"

"All that means is you should try and make amends before a problem of the past becomes the present. You have to show them you genuinely changed from the creature that pulled those cruel pranks,"

Discord folds his arms in a huff. "I don't see why not. I've forgotten about some of those pranks. And, if I forgot, so have the other creatures. It's like a clean slate,"

Now it was Fluttershy's turn to frown. "Discord, look at me. I know facing anypony is hard, especially when they are mad at you, but you owe yourself to become a better draconequus than you were before. Whatever you did is only bothering you now because of how much you changed. You got nothing to worry about because I'll be with you every step of the way."

Discord looks deeply into Fluttershy's blue smiles and smiles appreciatively. He coils around the timid mare and hugs her tightly as Fluttershy giggles. "What did I do to have a friend as wise and kind as you?"

"That's easy; you accepted my friendship,"

"Then, perhaps my friend could give some advice on what to wear,"

"Just wear what you are most comfortable with, and the other creatures will like you for it,"

Discord nods and walks back to the mirror. He snaps his paw once again to produce a mismatched suit. The jacket was split between maroon and pink. The left sleeve was lime green, while the right had zebra stripes. A polka-dotted yellow and pink sat upon his head with Fluttershy's cutie mark at the center. Discord smiles at his reflection as he turns to the gentle visage of Fluttershy. "So, how do I look?"

"Like a million bits, as long as we don't talk to Rarity..." Fluttershy mutters the last part quietly.

"What was that?"

"Nothing! We should head out now,"

"Of course, madam," Discord kneels and offers his left paw to Fluttershy, who graciously accepts, while Discord snaps his finger again, and the two vanish.

[Twilight's Castle.]

"Well? What do you two think of the design?" Twilight asks her number-one assistant and protege.

"I like it. It's extensive, cozy-looking, easily accessible, and in a good location," Spike said.

"I don't know about the nonstop waterfalls running through the structure," Starlight said.

"Oh, that's for the sea ponies. I figured it would be a nice little reminder of their home and maybe a fun waterslide?" Twilight offers.

Spike and Starlight both share a look before shrugging. "So, when do we begin construction?" Starlight asks.

"First, I have to talk with EEA to approve it. No sense in building an unofficial establishment and wasting precious bits," Twilight informs. "Once that is done--'

*KNOCK-KNOCK*

"Oh, that must be the girls. I guess it's time," Twilight's horn glowed as her magic enveloped the three. Spike now had a purple suit jacket with a black collar and green shirt. Starlight had a dark purple suit with a white shirt. Twilight was in a full purple dress with gold accents over the white gown. Twilight sighs in contentment as the spell finishes.

"You've been waiting to use that one, huh?" Starlight asks with a smirk.

"It's not often that I get reasons to use the dress-me spell, but it is convenient,"

"And fashion forward," Spike added.

"Rarity taught you that phrase, huh?" Twilight asks as she moves to the door. She turns away with a smile to greet her friends, only for it to turn into a frown when Discord comes into view.

"Why, hello, dear Princess. Aren't you going to welcome two of your best friends this side of Equestria?"

"Hello, Twilight; you look lovely this evening," Fluttershy said.

"Hello, Fluttershy and Discord. You both look..." Twilight paused as she tried to find the right words for Discord attire. "Good?"

"Yes, I am sure to be the center of intrigue," Discord said with a smile.

"In more ways than one," Starlight whispers to Spike, who chuckles.

"So, where are the others?" Spike asks.

"Oh, I didn't see anypony when we teleported inside. We might've beaten everypony here," Fluttershy said.

"Rainbow is not going to like that," Spike said.

*KNOCK-KNOCK*

"That's the front door this time," Starlight pointed out.

The group made their way to the main hall before reaching the front door. Twilight's magic develops the door, and she smiles at the sight of her other friends waiting outside. "hey, everypony-- Oof!?"

Pinkie brought Twilight into a bone-crushing hug. "hiya, Twilight!"

"Hey, Pinkie...!" Twilight strained.

"Oh, Pinkie! Get off of her. You'll wrinkle her wardrobe!" After feeling the abolishing stares of her friends, Rarity clears her throat. "And she can't breathe,"

"Whoopsie," Pinkie said, releasing her death grip.

Rarity tends to the dress while Twilight catches her breath. "Howdy there, Twilight," Applejack greeted.

"Hey, girls. You all look amazing," Twilight complements.

"Especially you, Rarty~," Spike swooned.

Rarity bounces her mane. "But, of course, darling,"

"So, Twilight, what's this big announcement you got cooking up?" Rainbow asks.

"Sorry, girls. I want everypony to hear this at the Gala," Twilight said.

"Oh, sounds ground-breaking. Then, by all means, build up that suspense. I can't wait to see what you have planned," Rarity supported.

"Yeah, a big awesome surprise for all the world to see," Pinkie cheered.

"Well, what are we waiting for? Let's head to Canterlot already," Rainbow said.

"One moment, darling," Rarity said, turning to her sister and her friends. "now, you three be careful with camping,"

"Yes, Rarity," Sweetie Belle said, hugging her sister. "Try and have fun at the Gala. Maybe this time, you'll meet your charming prince~,"

Rainbow and the others laugh as the prismatic mare moves to her surrogate sister. "Make sure you keep your friends out of trouble, squirt,"

Scootaloo looks at her friends, who look back with innocent smiles before facing Rainbow again. "No promises,"

Rainbow ruffles her mane again. "That's the spirit,"

Applejack rolls her eyes while walking up to Applebloom. "You know the rules?"

"Yup," Applebloom responded.

"You got your snacks?"

"Yup,"

"You'll call Big Mac if there's a whiff of trouble?"

"Eeyup,"

"Good, have fun, sugarcube," Applejack nods to her big brother as he nods back while he guides the fillies to the farm.

"Discord, if you would please?" Starlight asks.

"My pleasure. Remember to keep all hooves, claws, and feet in at all times, or you will be lost in the ether of chaos space," Discord said to his disturbed audience as the ones and dragon huddled closely together,"

As the group vanished from a snap, they overlooked a pegasus hovering outside one of the castle windows. It was a mare with a light blue and green mane carefully watching the Princess's entourage with a blank expression. "The guests are arriving..." The mare said seemingly to no one before flying off into the distance.

[Canterlot.]

The group appears before Canterlot castle, startling several ponies and making their way inside. Twilight waves meekly at the curious eyes of the residents of Canterlot. Many approach the national heroes with greetings and honey praises. However, most nobility spied on Discord and Spike and turned away disdainfully. Spike didn't catch it, as he was right next to Twilight. So, the crowd gave him a few passing greetings to not slight the Princess, but Discord certainly did. A frown started to form on the draconequus features as he was thoroughly ignored. Discord had only two regrets in his life. One was disappointing Fluttershy. The other was making Ponyvile the chaotic capital of the world and not Canterlot. Not only would planting his throne on top of Celestia be fitting, but it would also give him a chance to remind the nobility of the actual pecking order.

"Perhaps a little reminder is in order..." Discord mutters softly before preparing to snap. He almost did before Fluttershy called out to him.

"Discord? We're moving inside now,"

"Oh, sorry, I got lost inside my head again..."

The group went inside the ballroom to find a buzz with activity. Several Canterlot nobles were present. As well as representatives from different nations. "Oh, there's Fancy Pants and Fleur de Wis. They're conversing with Saddle Arabians. This is my chance, girls. Ta-ta. Oh, and Spike?"

Yes, Rarity?" Spike asks.

"I see that the dragonlord is here. Could you be a dear and pass along my idea of opening a shop in the Dragonlands? I would appreciate it immensely," Rarity said as she trotted over to Fancy and his wife.

"I'm on it, Rarity," Spike said, rushing to Ember.

"Hey, look, there's Prince Rutherford. Excuse me, girls. Hey, Prince Rutherford! Remember me?"

The yak in question smiles broadly. "Hello, pink pony!"

The rest of the elements shook their heads as Rainbow broke off. "See you, girls. I got to prep for the airshow with the rest of the team," Rainbow said as she joined the Wonderbolts.

"Howdy, their cousin," A male southern drawl spoke out.

"Well, I'll be a parasite at the end of blowhorn. Braeburn, you're here!" Applejack then notices a face she hasn't seen in a while. "With Little Strongheart?"

"Hello, Miss Applejack," The buffalo greeted.

"Wow, you two are the last folks I expect to come to these types of get-togethers," Applejack said as she hugged the two.

"Well, you can't expect me to let the fire misses wife prance about these snotty types all by her lonesome, do you?" Braeburn said with a cheeky wink.

Applejack's eyes widen at the pair. "No fooling? That's amazing. Why didn't you tell me sooner?"

"We knew you'd be busy with your affairs, and we wanted to spread the news of our union in pony," Little Strongheart said.

"Well, shucks, thank you kindly,"

"Oh, congratulations," Fluttershy said.

"Yes, I hope you allow me to officiate," Twilight asks.

"Sorry, there, Princess. But, we have a tradition of letting the eldest member do the officiating," Braeburn stated.

"Oh, it's no trouble. How about invitations?"

"Of course, that goes without saying. Any friend of Applejack is a member of the family,"

"Come on; Y'all got to tell me all about who did the asking!" Applejack said, moving away with the newlyweds.

"So much for comradery," Discard pouted.

"This was bound to happen since we've met a lot of creatures during our friendship problems. Do you want to try the thing we discussed?" Fluttershy asks.

"What did you discuss? Should I be concerned?" Twilight asks as she eyes Discord with suspicion.

"It's okay, Twilight. It's a minor issue that can be easily fixed. We can wait until after your big announcement,"

"Yes, it can wait. There's no need to steal the spotlight away from you," Discord nervously said.

"Are you sure this issue of yours isn't a big deal?" Starlight asks.

"We're optimistic. Come on, we can see the animals while we wait," Fluttershy stated.

"Yes, at least the critters are a better company that won't abandon you," Discord stated as the two went to the garden.

"Hey, Twilight. There's Chancellor Neighsay. If we want to get a good start on this project of yours, he's the pony we need on our side," Starlight said.

"Good eye, Starlight. Let's go," Twilight said. However, as the two began their trek through the crowd, the ponies started to shift around. Starlight and Twilight got separated. Twilight briefly looks around for a protege until she bumps into another. "Oh, I'm sorry," She looks at a unicorn mare with light blue fur and an orange mane with a black silk dress. Behind her was presumably a large stallion with a white mask and stylish cloak. The disguise caught the young Princess's attention more than anything else. Its shape was that of a pony. However, it had cracks along the muzzle and nostrils and a large over the left eye. She could tell the damages were there by design, but it was a little unnerving. 'Why would anypony wear something like this?'

"Oh no, the fault is mine. I was helping my friend here out of the crowd,"

"Is something wrong?"

"He's a bit shy around big crowds. He almost didn't have come at all if it wasn't for some business with some old acquaintances,"

"Oh! This seems like a friendship problem if I ever heard one. Would you like some help?"

The stallion stares at the Princess for a while before whispering to the mare. "Not to worry, Princess. It's nothing that garners your immediate attention. Besides, I heard from the rumor mill that you have something big planned. We would not want to keep you all night,'

Twilight appeared slightly disappointed at the rejection but understood. "Well, you're not wrong," She scans the crowd to see that Starlight made contact with the chancellor. "I got to go now, but if you still need help with your friends, come find me. It's my job as Princess of friendship to help any companionship thrive,"

Twilight trotted off as the pair watched her go. "Tsk!" The stallion scoffs.

"I know. She is arrogant, annoying, and massively hypocritical. Shall we make our move now?"

"...Do you know what your problem is?"

"I have a problem?"

"You have no sense of timing. We move after the announcement,"

Meanwhile, Twilight rejoins Starlight as the two make their way to the throne where the Princesses of the sun and moon reside. "So the chancellor agreed to give us an audience with the members of the EEA,"

"That's perfect. Now, I can announce the plan without any worry. But, first..." Twilight reached the throne and smiled at her friends and mentors. Princess Celestia stood as regally as she always does while donning an elegant sun dress with her cutie mark pendant on the gown. Her warm motherly smile shined as the sun. To her left was the lunar Princess. She kept a watchful eye on the proceedings but was no less extravagant with her sparkling silver dress and moon pendant around her neck. Next to them was Cadence, ruler of the Crystal Empire and sister-in-law. "Greetings, my fellow princesses. Thank you for having me at the Gala,"

"The honor was all ours, princess," Celestia smiled warmly.

"Indubitably. A mare who has done such great service for Equestria shall always have reserved seating at this event," Luna stated.

"Of course, being related doesn't hurt either. Although, we should forego our usual greeting just this once. You had all of Canterlot in an uproar from whatever you are planning," Cadence said.

"I didn't think it would be that big of a deal, but I guess I should've expected this with so many political leaders and rulers in on the spot," Twilight sheepishly said.

"Indeed, a gathering such as this is very rare. But I feel you held everypony in suspense long enough," Celestia said, gesturing to the crowd. All the participants had their attention centered on the princesses, specifically Twilight, prompting the young Princess to laugh sheepishly.

"Right, here we go..." Twilight stood straight in front of the crowd as her horn glowed. "Hello, honored guests. I want to thank you all for your attendance. As you know, I have recently been on many quests with my friends, the elements of harmony, repairing, strengthening, and building friendships across Equestria. It occurred to me that so many places and creatures seem to struggle or have no concept of true friendship," Twilight notices the pair she bumped into at the front of the crowd. The mare had her on the masked stallion as he seemed trembling. 'I didn't think I illicit that kind of response,' Twilight smiled at them as she continued. "So, to remedy this issue - to ensure that future generations know the same joy I feel of having wonderful friends - I, Twilight Sparkle, princess of friendship, do herby decree the opening of the School of Friendship!"

A banner fell with the school building design right behind the Castle of Friendship. Everyone attending saves for the couple cheered. Twilight's friends joined her upstage as they expressed their enthusiasm. "This school will have all the accommodations, room, and boarding for our students. Students that won't just be from Equestria but from the neighboring countries as well, being the first multicultural school for every creature!"

Once again, the cheering started again; however, the sound of laughter became more evident as the applause died down. Everyone turned to the couple to see the masked stallion deep in laughter. Twilight and the others were growing concerned as the stallion's laughter sounded jerky and manic. After a few minutes, he finally calmed down and moved closer to the throne. "That's it? That's the big announcement?! A school-based around friendship with students other than ponies. I never knew anyone could be so pretentious!"

Twilight looked confused at the stallion's sudden change in demeanor. However, before she could respond, Chancellor Neighsay spoke up. "I am inclined to agree. When your protege prosed this school, I assumed it would be for the benefit of ponies. Having other creatures that prey on us is a recipe for disaster!"

"What'd you say!"

"How dare you!"

"Yak will show puny pony disaster!"

As many of the non-ponies voiced their disapproval, the stallion spoke again. "See? This multicultural school is pointless. You ponies would never get over your xenophobia. Chancellor Neighsay is a prime example of how all the ponies in Canterlot view others!"

Now the chancellor was confused along with everyone else. "I-I beg you pardon?"

Instead of answering, the stallion moved closer, as did the mare. "But, I can at least give the Chancellor credit for being open about his hatred. But you and your so-called friends are the worst offenders. You hide your specism under the guise of friendship and harmony,"

"I don't know what you are talking about, nor will I put up this slander against my character. I've always treated every creature with respect!" Twilight said, stomping her hoof.

"Are you sure about that, Princess? Can you say the same about me?" Suddenly, the stallion rose higher from his position as if he was merely standing on his hind legs. But it was more than that as the stallion's body morphed into something distinctly not a pony. His full height was on par with the Princess of the sun herself. The elements could feel the icy stare of this mysterious creature despite the mask still covering his face.

The mare beside him steps up next as her eyes flash green. "You see, princess, we've seen your little facade, and we decided to unmask the truth," The mare was then engulfed in green flames. Her entire body changed from soft fur to sleck black chitin. A mossy swamp-green mane and tail flow outward before a pair of slitted green eyes glares back at the bearers and princesses. "Good even, members of royalty. The one true queen has returned,"

"Queen Chrysalis!" The elements exclaimed.

"You dare show yourself here!" Luna snarls.

"But, of course, did you not send an invitation to all the royals of this Earth? It would be bad form to refuse," Chrysalis chuckled.

"Whatever you are planning won't work! Your previous invasion failed, and now you'll have to contend with more than one alicorn this time!" Cadence said, flaring her wings.

"It is a shame that your only aspiration in life is revenge," Celestia said in disappointment. She flared her wings in preparation.

"Revenge? Oh, no, no, no. We're here for justice!" Chrysalis magic glows as a horn appears in front of her. It was white with an oval mouth. The length formed an S shape from the blow piece. However, there were symbols from various nations near the mouth that Discord, Celestia, and Luna instantly recognized.

"No...!" The draconequus called out with the sisters.

All three of them sent a blast of magic out. However, Chrysalis erected a shield that, surprisingly, deflected all their attacks. Chrysalis took a breath and blew into the horn. A single blare echoed throughout all of Canterlot and beyond. Many of the occupants recoiled from the sound but regained composure moments later. The horn hovered briefly in the air before it vanished as Chrysalis lowered her shield with a self-satisfied look on her features. The elements stood ready for anything, but after a few tense moments, nothing happened.

"Ha! Your stupid horn didn't work!" Rainbow Dash proclaimed.

"Oh, it did. Just not in the way you are most likely assuming," Chrysalis tittered.

"That's all ponies ever seem to do; assume the worst," The masked creature said.

"Now I had just about enough of you!" Applejack said, pawing at the ground as she was going to charge.

"Indeed. If your big plan was to put on airs and deafen us, you failed!" Rarity stated.

"Yeah, you big..." Pinkie was about to join her friends in their verbal tirade when her Pinkie sense flared. The same combo she felt at Sugarcube Corner returned. It was much stronger now as Pinkie's breathing picked up. She looked at the masked figure again, only to find him staring into her soul. Pinkie's eyes widened as she looked, really looked, at the creatures' form. She began to tremble and hyperventilate as she backed behind her friends and cowered under her hooves. "No, no, no, no!"

This action did not go unnoticed. "Pinkie, what's wrong?" Fluttershy said.

"No, no, no!" Pinkie muttered over and over.

"Pinkie, what's gotten into you, darling?" Rarity asks, kneeling to her friend.

"The horn!" Twilight realized. "It must be having some kind of delayed effect!"

"That's it!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she charged forward, only for a blue aura to catch her in the air. "What the hay?"

"You will be still!" Luna stated in a seething tone.

"Princess Luna? What are you doing? Did that horn affect you too? Don't worry, we'll--"

"You and the elements will do nothing!" Celestia spoke with authority.

Before Twilight could respond, Cadence's horn emitted a bright light. When it faded, the crystal princess looked confused. "That's not right..."

"What's not right, Cadence?" Twilight asks.

"I just cast a spell that disrupts mind-altering spell craft. But nothing is affecting my aunts or even Pinkie Pie!"

"That because there is no mind control, perception-alternating, or hypnotism at foot here, Cadence. Honestly, Celestia, this kind of insubordination would not stand with my subjects. Do none of them know of the call of Gjallarhorn? Have you kept such a pivotal artifact a secret, and will you not heed its call?" Chrysalis in a snide tone.

Every word made Celestia ground her teeth as she walked before queen Chrysalis and shocked all the occupants at the Gala. Princess Celestia, Princess of the sun and co-ruler of Equestria, had prostrated herself and bowed in submission at the changeling queen. Everyone gasped at the sight, but Celestia ignored this and spoke in a strained voice. "...Forgive the offense. What are your terms!?"

Chrysalis smiles at the humbled alicorn as she gently places a hoof under her chin and raises Celestia's head. "Much better. A princess should always bow to their queen,"

"Your terms, Chrysalis!" Luna spat out.

The changeling queen rolled her eyes at this. "Fine, ruin my fun. I, at this moment, request room and board for my subjects, benefactor, and myself for the week as you prepare for the tribunal. I was thinking of a luxury room at the castle,"

With a resigned sigh, Celestia spoke. "...It shall be done..."

"Excellent, now where are the escorts? We wish to retire for the evening,"

Celestia signaled to the guards at the door, who begrudgingly obeyed her command. "See to it that our guests are placed in the best accommodating room we have to offer,"

The two guards eyed each other before nodding and turning to the pair. "Follow us,"

"Now, can you speak to your honored guess more respectfully?" Chrysalis ask.

"Listen, bug--"

*CRACK*

A loud thud and crack echoed from Celestia as the guards turned to her. Her right hoof left a small indention on the marble floor as spiderweb cracks spread. "I would hope that my solar guards do not seek to embarrass me through lack of decorum,"

Gulping, the guards turned back to Chrysalis. "I-it would be our pleasure to escort you to our luxurious housing. Honored guests..."

Chrysalis gives them a cheeky smile as she flicks her mane. The masked creature remained silent as they began to follow the guards. However, before they could leave, Chancellor Neighsay spoke up again. "Princess, what is the meaning of this? Why do you submit yourself to one of our sworn enemies? I demand an answer!" Many of the other ponies agreed with the chancellor's assessment.

Celestia turned a sharp glare at the brazen pony, who recoiled. "I'd remember my tone when addressing the princess, Chancellor," Fancy Pants suddenly said.

"H-how can you be complacent after what we witnessed?"

"Simple, judging by the Princess's reaction to that Gjallarhorn, it must be an item of great significance. One that grants its wielder liberties that must not be violated,"

"Then, why are we finding out about this all-powerful horn now?"

"I haven't the foggiest idea. Who knows how many mystical items that have been lost through the ages? All I know is that we should trust the only two ponies with any idea about what is happening," Fancy pants gestures to Celestia and Luna.

"Thank you, Lord Fancy Pants. Rest assured. We shall release a statement on the matter tomorrow. Perhaps it best for everypony here to retire for the evening," Princess Luna said.

"Excuse me, princess, but you can not expect us to ignore the fact that Chrysalis has returned!" Starlight said.

"It ain't right!" Applejack added.

"Yeah, why is Chrysalis suddenly getting the royal treatment after everything she's done? And what's with that monster of hers anyway?"

"It might be some new minion Chrysalis managed to dredge up from somewhere," Twilight said.

"It must be a horrid creature from the Everfree forest. I've never seen anything like it," Rarity exclaimed.

"It is freaky looking, especially that mask," Spike said.

These words prompted the masked individual to stop and turn back. His pace was slow so as not to give away the boiling anger fueling his being. He stopped right in front of the elements, who remained guard; Celesta and Luna looked ready to intervene. However, the creature merely reached for its mask as he spoke. "Freak? Abomination? Monster? You ponies love your labels as if you can pass judgment on anything. But tell me, who's more of a monster? Me...?"

The creature removed his masked as many guests gasped for the time tonight. Some even began screaming in terror and running out of the room. The elements stood stock still while a pale skin creature stared into each of their souls. He had messy brown hair. At least to the ponies, a stern look in his emerald eye carried hatred, distrust, and disharmony. But the scariest feature of this being in front of them was the jagged scar tracing over the left side of his face over a milky white eye. "Or the monsters that did this!"

"I-I Wha-- Huh?" Twilight sputtered. She and her friends were left speechless at the sight of him.

"You don't remember me, do you? That's fine; some time has gone by since we last met,"

"What are you?" Twilight asks in a small voice.

"I'm something that friendship ignored, abused, and discarded into the darkness. But here's the thing; you can't escape our sins. And this upcoming week, everyone everywhere will know yours!"

"Jason Wright?" Discord whispered, his face as pale as a ghost.

"..." The creature, now known as Jason Wight, spares the draconequus a sharp, harsh glare but says nothing while turning back to Chrysalis. Cadence couldn't help but notice how the changeling queen walked closer to him as they exited the room.

The Element of Kindness

Author's Note

Hey, everyone. Fair warning. The next chapter will be late as I leave home for a week. Expect it in March.

The Element of Kindness

[Canterlot - Twilight's room.]

"I cannot believe this!!!" Rainbow said, bursting through the doors. "How could Starlight side with them!? We're supposed to be her friends! We're the ones who forgave her for making that weird cult and stealing cutie marks!"

"I guess a snake can shed its skin but still look the same," Applejack stated.

"Um, I guess it makes sense," Fluttershy said.

"Whatever do you mean, darling? How does betrayal make sense?" Rarity asked.

"She was only sticking up for her friend. I wasn't there, but I don't think she was treated fairly," Fluttershy said.

"She wasn't treated fairly? She made up lies about how great she is and defeating the Ursa major!"

"But, Rainbow, you can't accuse someone of bragging when you do all the time,"

"Yeah, but guess what? It's not bragging when you can back it up. When Trixie couldn't do it, Twilight did!"

"Trixie wasn't the one to bring the Ursa to town. Snips and Snails did," Pinkie reminded.

"Well, perhaps she should've put a disclaimer to ward foals like Snips and Snails from acting on impulse!' Rarity stated.

"Is Trixie responsible for Snips and Snails? Or are their parent getting a pass now? Would you let Sweetie Belle do what they did?"

"Of course not; Sweetie knows better. It's just that some foals have little sense of danger at that age. They find everything wonderous,"

"So, Trixie should've screened her audience for slow foals?"

"Pinkie Pie!"

"Alright, alright. Let's drop it," Applejack said. "Where's Twilight?"

On cue, Twilight was the last to walk inside. She carried a newspaper in her aura. However, her expression was still one of shock. "...Take a look at this, girls..."

"Newspapers and magazines? Please don't tell you to indulge in Canterlot Prime. Their integrity has been in the gutter for decades," Rarity said, looking down at the others. "W-What!?"

"What the hay?!" Rainbow exclaimed.

"Oh my!" Fluttershy said in shock.

"These are the new prototype headlines the publishers plan to print," Twilight said.

"The Setting Sun: Princess Celestia's age begins to show after millennia-long rule. Princess of Abuse: Twilight Sparkle's long history of child labor. Ponyville: Capital of horrors. Human details traumatic experiences on page eight?! What is this trash?" Rainbow exclaimed.

"That's not all. Look at the magazines. The love bug bit me. The new royal couple. A damaged soul and beautiful Chrysalis. Triumph in love: two creatures topple an empire. Urgh! Do you see why I don't subscribe to tabloids!" Rarity said in disgust.

"They do seem rather close," Fluttershy said.

"Now that ain't right—these news ponies are making stuff sound worse than gabby gums. Can they do this?" Applejack asks.

"Yeah! This is like slander or treason! Twilight, can't you do something?" Rainbow asks.

"Like, what exactly? If I shut down the papers, it will only make me look guilty. Besides, it is free speech," Twilight said.

"Not if it's harmful to our image and reputation! This could be grounds for deformation!" Rarity said.

"Only if they were making this up. All their information is coming from the trial," Twilight said.

"Why are ponies so quick to believe this nonsense? Did they forget everything we did to save their sorry flanks?" Rainbow shouted.

"Or maybe, everyone is getting a better look at what we did," Pinkie said.

"It's easy to twist things when nopony was there for themselves. And, why are you using its words?"

"I want to do better..."

"Pinkie, dear, you didn't--"

Pinkie cuts Rarity off before she can finish. "NO! Don't tell me I didn't do anything wrong. I did. We did,"

"How can you say that, knowing about this weird spell on us!" Rainbow stated.

"Well, are we any closer to breaking it?"

"No. Suppose all four alicorn magic couldn't. I am not sure what can..." Twilight said.

"Discord?" Applejack asks.

Fluttershy shakes her head. "He's still not answering any of my letters,"

"Figures,"

"Perhaps the elements of harmony? If foul magic infects us, then maybe they can clear it," Rarity suggests.

"It's worth a shot," Twilight said as her horn made the elements appear around their necks. "I always wanted to try that spell. Alright, girls. We have to focus on any corruptive or invasive magic within ourselves," The elements began their sequence of powering up. Each Pony hovers in the air for a time as a rainbow aura surrounds each of them. Eventually, the magic of the elements dies down, and everyone returns to the ground. Twilight opens her eyes and frowns. "Nothing. There's still nothing!"

"Could the elements have been tampered with before hoof?" Rarity asks.

"No. The Princess made sure that not even Discord could get through the wards again,"

"Well, since we got them, I say we take the elements to Chrysalis! Stop her plans once and for all!" Rainbow said.

Pinkie stares at her friends before taking her element off and handing it back to Twilight. "Pinkie?? What gives?"

"If that's what you want to use the elements for, count me out," Pinkie said.

"Why not, sugarcube? We're talking about Chrysalis here," Applejack said.

"We can't talk about Chrysalis without talking about Jason! Are we going to use the elements on him too? What about that horn? Do you want to risk losing our magic on the slim chance that they are doing something evil?"

"Come on, Pinkie. Nothing can beat the elements!" Rainbow reassures.

"Oh, I don't think we should do that either. How will we explain this to the judges? It will only look like we are afraid of what they might say," Fluttershy said.

"Oh, come on! When the elements work, it will be clear that those two are guilty!" Rainbow said.

"Well, clearly, you haven't been paying attention!" A new voice called out. The girls turned to the door to see Starlight standing there with a disapproving look.

"What are you doing here!?"

"I came to get my things. Don't mind me. I'll be out of your way in a few seconds," Starlight's horn flares as her luggage appears at her side.

"Is that all you have to say? Are you not even going to explain yourself? How you betrayed us, especially Twilight, for Trixie of all ponies?!" Rarity spat.

"The fact that you still see Trixie in that light enforces my choice. I did not betray any of you. I stuck up for my one true friend!"

"So, that's it? You're not friends with us anymore. I know I handled the Trixie situation poorly. But are you okay with leaving us after everything we've been through? Did everything we did mean nothing? Was it all a lie?" Twilight asks.

Starlight pauses as she stares at Twilight. "Based on what I've seen at the trial and what was said, how do I know you are not lying about everything?"

"...Where's Spike?"

"With your brother. Why? Do you want your servant back?"

"I want to make sure my brother is fine!"

"Well, he's not, thanks to any of you. I don't know what terrible things happened to that Jason character, but even I've noticed Spike getting a raw deal around all of you,"

"...You didn't answer my question,"

"I think the elements answered all our questions about this mysterious spell since it did not break. It's just like the time I tried bottling up my emotions. Eventually, those emotions are set free and infect everything,"

"But, what if you're wrong about us!" Fluttershy stated.

"I want to be wrong, but you're all scared Jason might be right. Either way, I got burned once by a friend. I won't go through that again. Later, girls..."

With that said, Starlight left the room. "Yeah? Well, good riddance!" Rainbow spat.

"The nerve of her judging us like that. Especially after all the things she'd done!" Applejack said.

Rarity places a hoof on Twilight's shoulder. "Don't worry, Twilight. Once we get this awful magic out of us, she'll realize her mistake,"

"Yes, Try your best and not worry," Fluttershy said.

"I can't help but worry. I feel like a failure, with all my deeds coming under scrutiny. Then, there is meeting Jason. I can remember that day so clearly now. I remember the excitement in his tone. I remember the joy in his eyes. I remember the sound of the door slamming in his face. But that's not all. Jason eluded to something at the end of the trial today. Something that I know he couldn't possibly know unless he was there,"

"What does that mean, darling?" Rarity said.

"it means that Jason may know a lot more than he is letting on,"

"Well, if it is more dirty laundry, then perhaps we can use it to our advantage. Are you sure that whatever he knows, it would be impossible to gleam without his presence?" Twilight nods. "And what of Chrysalis? What sparked their unique partnership? If that Gjallarhorn prevents lying on both sides, then I believe it's time for us to utilize it!"

"Yes, you're right, Rarity. If Jason wants this settled in court, we'll settle it there!"

"Finally, time for some payback!" Rainbow said, holding out her hoof.

"Darn tooting!" Applejack said, adding her hoof with Twilight, Fluttershy, and Rarity. Pinkie was the only one who had not joined. "let's complete the set, Pinkie,"

Pinkie stares at the huddle for a time before walking to the door. "Excuse me, girls. I'm going to get something to eat. See you later," Pinkie left the room, leaving an air of confusion and concern.

[Jason's room.]

"Are you sure you want to go in there, Spike?"

"I think it will be okay. I want answers, Shinning,"

"Well, I got your back, little bro," The two were walking down Canterlot hall to the plaintiffs.

Shining Armor saluted the guards as he and Spike walked inside. Scanning the room, Shining and Spike saw that it was currently empty. Unbeknownst to the two, something was slowly descending from the ceiling. The figure touches the ground as a pink hoof emerges from a green flame. Shining Armor felt movement from behind and quickly spun around. Spike became alert before falling into confusion at the familiar Pony in front of them.

"Princess Cadance?"

"Shiny! Spiky. I'm glad I caught you both. Have you two come to see Chrysalis as well? I have some choice words for her!"

"Yeah, and you can drop the act. I just spoke to my wife, and she wouldn't want to see you!" Shining viciously spat.

Cadance smirks as she moves closer, prompting Shining's horn to glow brighter. "Oh, careful dear. The Gjallarhorn effect is still present. I would hate for you to lose your magic. Although, you can use magic against me in another way~,"

"Change back now!"

"Ah, I get it," Green flames surround Cadance as she morphs back to her original form. "You prefer a vintage mature mare. But, think of the scandal. Prince consort has an affair with the plaintiff while his wife presides as judge. Oh, it's delicious,"

"We want to speak to Jason Wright!" Spike said.

"Hmm? And why is that? Are you looking to steal some information? Help the elements with their case? A word of advice: you should leave that sinking ship. No need to let them drag you down further,"

"We're not abandoning my sister!" Shining spat.

"Your sister? Not our? I see mistreatment runs from all branches of the Sparkle household!"

"My family doesn't abuse me!!!" Spike hollers.

"Still in denial, huh?" A voice calls out as Jason comes out of the bathroom in a towel. His scarred body is on full display.

Shining remains on guard as Jason walks to the chair and sits down. "Do you mind getting dressed? It's very uncomfortable,"

"Why? Can't stand the sight of your sister and her friends' handy work? I'm reminded of it every time I take my shirt. Every time I go to shower. Every time I look in the mirror. Every time I close my eyes. These scars will never go away. Telling me to get dressed is telling me to feel shame. And I refuse to do that anymore. Besides, you're naked right now. So's Spike. Why is it an issue when I do it? I'll stay like this because I am comfortable. If you're not, then the doors right there,"

"You're doing it again. You twist things to make everypony look bad," Spike said.

"I don't have to make them look bad. Their actions make them look bad. The thoughtlessness makes them look bad. Now, you're a kid. I never saw you when I was in Ponyville, probably because you were busy doing Twilight's chores. But that's fine. I don't blame you for anything that happened,"

"You can't expect us to believe that Twilight, her friends, and all of Ponyville did this to you," Shining gestures to all of Jason. "If there is a way we can resolve this, just name it,"

Chrysalis holds up her hoof in mock surprise. "Goodness! Are you attempting to bribe us? Ha! So much for the royal guard honor,"

"My honor and duty as a guard have always been for my family and country. Your little revenge scheme is destroying both. Now, what can I do to make you drop this case?"

"But, that's the beauty of all this, Shiny. It's not revenge. It's justice. That's why it's so effective. Your sister and her gaggle of friendship-spewing mouthpieces are the villains here. Besides, I thought you ruled the Crystal Empire. Nepotism at its finest,"

Jason leans in and looks Shining dead in his eyes. The Unicorn stiffens at Jason's blank stare. "What can you do, huh? What can you give me so I'll back off from exposing your sister and her cronies for the monsters that they are? Money? No, that's too common. When you have been around the block like I have, money loses its appeal. Love? I doubt you can pay a mare to be with me, not that I date a pony. Respect? Well, asking for consideration would mean your opinion matters to me somehow. News flash, it doesn't. We're running out of options here,"

"Please. I love Twilight and the girls. Whatever they did, they didn't mean it. I'm sorry that you got hurt, but please stop this!" Spike pleaded.

"You're sorry? I've suffered, but you're sad. I'm hurt, but you ask me to stop. I bled, but you don't want your friends to face accountability. You're selfish, just like them. There comes the point where sorry isn't good enough-- until it's just another excuse. But, you know what; I know what I want from you two,"

"What?" Shining asks.

"I want to sleep without screaming at the top of my lungs. I like the nightmares to stop. Take away every blow dealt to me. Bring me back my happiness. Could you give me back my faith in friendship? Or help me trust ponies again? Can you take away the three years of mental and physical abuse? How about these scars? Will you erase them and allow me to see from my eye again? Do I get justice for those that wrong me? I want the peace stolen from me from ponies I thought were heroes. Can you do that?"

"..." Shining and Spike said nothing.

"Then fuck off,"

Dejected, Spike and Shining Armor leave without a word. But not before Chrysalis could rub more salt on their wounds. "Come back anytime, Shiny. I enjoy our little sessions," Chrysalis made sure to speak as loud as possible into the halls before shutting the door.

[Canterlot Judicial Hall - Third Day of the Trial.]

"Court is now back in session," Luna said.

"Members of the court. It has come to our attention that the plaintiff has not been entirely honest with us!" Rarity proclaims.

"How so?" Queen Novo asks. "So far, the plaintiff's claims are proving compelling,"

"If the plaintiff claims originated from credible characters, then yes. However, little is known of Jason Wright's time in Ponyville. We cannot forget that Chrysalis staged an invasion against Equestria. She is a changeling—a creature whose very nature is deception," Twilight explained.

"Do I honestly have to explain the horns' effects to you again?" Chrysalis asks.

"There's no need. I am suggesting that it's possible to condition a creature to think and commit to a mindset. You said you planted changeling in our society in the beginning. And, throughout this trial, you've access to information that you shouldn't. Where is it coming from? Where did you and Jason meet if he isn't your creation?"

"Ah, so you're arguing that I am not real. And that, since Chrysalis has her hive hidden away, we got our documents illegally. Sorry to burst your bubble, but that's not what happened. The papers I have is freely accessible to the public upon request. There's just never been a need to put your and your friend's actions under a microscope—another poor example of negligence. Or, maybe that is intentional?" Celestia waves her tail angrily at the suggestion. "As for meeting Chrysalis. I wasn't a test tube baby spawned from her cacoons. We met in the Everfree after I got away from her,"

Jason points to Applejack while Twilight continues. "No doubt another carefully crafted tale so the horn doesn't react. What proof can you give us that you are not a golem of Chrysalis design?"

"Hmm, that is a good question. I could call up Celestia's knowledge of the horn. But I have something that I've been saving. The best way to prove that I am honest is to show you something far too intricate for Chrysalis or anyone in this world can come up with at all. So, member of the court, I would like to present to you; My Little Pony Friendship is Magic,"

Jason touches the horn again. This time, an image of a living room displays a little girl pulling him onto the couch. "Come on! It's starting! It's starting!!!"

"I told you I don't want to watch some pony show,"

The little girl pulls Jason onto the sofa as she picks up a remote and points it a the tv. Members of the court were confused as to what they were seeing. "What the matter? Afraid you might like it?"

"Sure, cuz. I'll like a children's cartoon for your age group,"

"Shush. Here it is!"

To say the courtroom was left speechless was a severe understatement. There, right before them and more or less the entire world, the defendants in a singalong at various locations in Ponyville and Canterlot. The locale themselves was accurate to a disturbing degree. The defendants were the most shocked towards the end of the intro as a picture showed everyone they knew in Ponyville. But the real shock came from the episode itself. It showed Twilight Sparkle obsessing over the fact that she had not sent Princess Celestia a letter in a week about friendship. So, she went out to find one. But, Twilight learned that none of her friends had an issue to report. Each failure caused Twilight to become more manic in her efforts until she stood before three familiar fillies. The episode continued with Twilight hypnotizing the town into fighting over her smarty pants doll. It got so bad that Princess Celestia had to intervene. Twilight's friends came to her aid, and the Princess dismissed Twilight's action by requesting a letter from each of the girls on friendship.

"Wow. That was great!"

"So, wait, Twilight doesn't get in trouble for hypnotizing a town?"

"No, that wasn't the point. It's about respecting friends when they are freaking out. Anyway, I told you you would like it. Want to watch another?"

"Alright, Susie,"

"So, was that enough for you?" Jason asks the defendants. "You all just saw an episode of a television program called Lesson Zero. Judging by your reaction, I'd say that memory is spot on. It also raises another question. Princess Celestia? Why is it you allowed Twilight to get off scot-free after messing with the minds of Ponyville? Mind-altering spells are illegal here, and I know I would not be safe with a pony that becomes manic from a messed deadline. That same neurotic mare is now a princess!"

Celestia, however, stammers a response. The reveal of the show threw her completely off balance. "I-I, you--"

"Hold on! Do-Don't try and change the subject! T-That was-- No, it's impossible! That memory. That was exactly how everything went that day to a T!" Twilight exclaimed.

"Which means it could not be fabricated because Chrysalis was not there to see it,"

It took another moment before Rainbow Dash. "Aha! That means you are a spy! How long you've been watching us?"

"Well, the show went on for about nine seasons. So, that's nine years. Susie loved it,"

Several murmurs erupted as Luna called for order. "This is startling news indeed. But, there are some inconsistencies I would like to address. The first is at the beginning. I know Ponyville enjoys a song. But I was not with Celestia when Spike sent that letter, nor did we hear voices,"

"What you saw was the introduction of the show. Back in my world, we have stories like MLP brought to life with moving pictures,"

"Are you trying to say that you kind created our world?!" Rarity exclaimed.

Jason rolled his eyes as he saw the ponies in the gallery begin to panic. "No. To make it easier to understand, Sunset came from the mirror world. We can classify that mirror world as an alternate reality. A world similar to this one, with some differences here and there. Do you know about the multiverse theory?"

"Upon discovering the mirror world, scholars have theorized the existence of multiple dimensions beyond our plane," Celestia stated.

"What does that have to do with humans watching our every move?!" Rarity said.

"What it means, Rarity, is that a pony can exist across infinite universes and timelines. For example, the mirror world has a human version of us. Each world has a set of rules. In Jason's world, it looks like they can view our world," Twilight said.

"I don't get it," Fluttershy said.

"Think of it like when you are reading a book. You are reading and watching another world,"

"So, what? we're just a bunch of made-up characters?" Rainbow said with an air of indignation.

"To a superficial extent, yes. It's a matter of perception. In my world, we can only see specific critical points of this. I don't know Chrysalis's story beyond her invading Equestria multiple times. Until I crossed a portal, I thought you were all fictional characters. Just like I am sure you thought humans were a myth," Jason explains.

"This would also explain how you knew who Jetset and Uppercrust were," Luna summarised.

"That still doesn't change the fact that you were watching us!" Applejack said.

"Yes, I watch the television program with my little cousin as a fan of the show. Honestly, you - the Mane 6 - the elements of harmony are all famous. My Little Pony is a rich and diverse fandom. Everyone, from adults and children, or foals if you prefer, loves you girls and all your adventures. Your lessons about friendship helped real people in need. People love this world so much that they make their own stories and factions about you. People like Rated Ponystar, kildeez, morbiugreen just to name a few. There are millions of stories dedicated to your honor. Some polls vote on who is the best Princess. Princess Luna won that one by a landslide," Despite herself, Luna could not help but smile at that. "If any of you came to my world, you would instantly become a celebrity. You'd be worshiped as gods. Humans love you. I loved you!"

The murmurs all stop as Jason's voice cracks. Rainbow Dash slowly floated back to her seat. "Is that why you came to Equestria? You wanted to meet your idols?" Cadance said.

Jason gives a shallow nod in response. "My cousin, the little girl you saw with me, got me hooked on the show. It was our favorite activity to watch whenever her parents dropped her off at my place. We'd watch the seasons over and over. Then, she got diagnosed with cancer after generation five was announced. She still managed to get excited over your world, even when she was getting weaker. The show helped her past the worse of her disease. She died, but I vowed to stay a fan for our sake. But I got depressed. Watching the episodes was harder without Susie there. Then, I found a sketchy website advertising a way to visit this world. I thought it was for a new theme park. So, I went to the location, found a portal, and went through. Poof, I'm here in the magical land of Equestria..." Jason looks down as he walks to the center. He turns to the defendants with the same blank stare. But, it was more hollow and empty now. "Did you know that Susie believed you were the best pony, Fluttershy?"

"M-Me?" The shy mare said.

"I would always say it was Rainbow Dash or Pinkie Pie. But she always loved how you were so kind. The way you treat animals. How soft-spoken you are. One of her favorite episodes was when you took Iron Hoof's seminar. It shows that you can get tough when you need to, even if you took it a little too far,"

"Oh, my. I-I hope that she did not learn the wrong thing from that," Fluttershy was feeling strangely calm. Jason's features were slowly morphing into a soft smile that felt comforting.

"No, she didn't. She took every lesson you learned to heart. She would always have a doll of you with that same soft smile,"

"Oh, that sounds nice," Fluttershy looks down in thought before speaking again. "I'm sorry for your loss,"

Jason nods again before he sighs and moves to the Gjallaarhorn. "You know, in a way, I am glad she is dead," There were several gasps of shock at the one-eighty turn in Jason's demeanor. "Don't misunderstand. I miss her. I'm just glad she didn't find that same website I did. Because meeting you, Fluttershy would've broken her heart!"

Jason spat as Fluttershy flinched. "W-What?"

Jason places his hand back on the Gjallarhorn. The image displays Fluttershy walking back to her cottage. It was midday, and several woodland critters hovered and scampered around her while humming happily. However, she stops when something calls out. "HELP ME!!!"

"Shut up, freak!"

*WHACK*

"AAAH!!!"

Fluttershy felt compelled to investigate. But, when she bursts into an open clearing, she stops. Jason was in a fetal position, trying to shield himself as three royal guard unicorn stallions wielded batons and beat him down. A brown well, dressed Earth pony stallion swirls his smoking pipe as he watches. Jason's face had welts and bruises. Blood trickled down his nose and the side of his head. Fluttershy saw a black eye and missing teeth. "Mr. Rich doesn't want some ugly monster prowling around his property!" The stallion ended his sentence with another swing against Jason's arm.

"I-I was in the shed. It's the only place I could be warm. Please. I'll work there for free if you--"

"Hit it again! Preferably on those tiny claws. I assume that's how it climbed over my fence. I can't have it trying to sneak into Diamond Tiara's rooms next. Who knows what could happen if it got inside the manor," Filthy Rich said. However, before the order is carried out, Filthy spots Fluttershy frozen in shock. "Oh, stay back, Miss Fluttershy. My butler found this dangerous creature prowling the property. I notified the guards here, and now, I'm making sure it doesn't get that idea again. You're an animal expert. Do you know how to keep pests like these out of our homes properly? I was thinking of getting some Orthros,"

Fluttershy heard the question, but she kept her eyes on Jason's face. Jason finally spots her and reaches out. "Fluttershy, help me, please!"

"Aah!" Fluttershy jumps back despite being the furthest away. "Yes, that will work. See you later, bye!!!"

Filthy watches as Fluttershy runs away. "Thank you, Miss Fluttershy. It's hard to see a sweet mare like her so terrified. Well? Smash those claws and break its hooves. I shudder to leave this thing capable of hurting an element of harmony,"

*CRACK*

"AAAH!!!"

The memory ends with the stallions following through with Mr. Rich's order. Once again, the courtroom fell silent. Some ponies left the room, while others found a nearby trash can to vomit. All eyes were on Fluttershy as the mare could not udder a word except an expression of horror. "Zecora was the one who found me in that clearing with my fingers and legs broken. She was able to nurse me back to health. But, I get these aches and pains in my knees, and it's hard to open and close my hand sometimes," Jason said. "I thank god Susie isn't here to see this. It could've easily been her at the receiving end of your cruelty. It's one of the few solaces I have had since coming here,"

"B-But-but, that was Mr. Rich and his goons. Fluttershy didn't touch you," Rainbow said, still in shock.

"A-And from the sound of it. You were trespassing," Rarity said, only to immediately regret it as Princess Celestia glared down at her and the rest of the courtroom.

"I was trespassing in a shed far away from the riches home. It was beaten and worn down. It looked like no one had used it for days. Remember that no hotel would take me even if I had the bits. The cold nights of Ponyville were unforgiving. I had no choice. But I guess beating someone and breaking bones is standard procedure for the royal guard,"

"N-no. That is not proper conduct!" Celestia denied it, as it was her day guards in the memory acting like hired thugs.

Jason ignores the solar Princess and questions the shy pegasus. "Why? Why did you run away, Fluttershy?"

"N-no, I didn't--" Fluttershy stammers, unable to form a sentence. Jason moves closer to her, his expression turning more aggressive.

"You saw me. You looked me dead in my eyes and ran! You even gave Filthy Rich advice to abuse me further!!!"

"I-I didn't mean to--"

"You could've told them to stop. They would've listened. You're a national hero! I thought you were supposed to be kind!"

Fluttershy trembles as she shoots up with tears in her eyes. "I am! I am kind!" Just then, the Gjallarhorn sends out another pulse. A burst of magic leaves Fluttershy as it did for Celestia and Twilight. She stumbles briefly before she looks at Jason in recognition and horror. "I remember. I-I did see you. I've seen you so many times in Ponyville. I saw you hurt, beaten, and bloody, but I never helped you..." Fluttershy shrank at her admittance. She curls into a ball, similar to Jason's, and openly cries. "I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry!!!"

"Where have I heard that before?" Jason asks, looking at Spike and Shining Armor. Both of them could not meet his gaze.

"P-Please. I am kind. I am a good pony!"

"Do you know my people have a saying that fits all the times you left me to suffer ideally? It goes like this: evil wins when good people - good ponies - do nothing. It bothers me that you didn't offer me any of that kindness you are known for all over Equestria. You did for a pony-eating manticore,"

"I'm sorry," FLuttershy's voice started to crack.

"You do it for all the dangerous animals in your cottage!"

"Please!"

"You did for the parasites that nearly devoured all of Ponyville!"

"S-Stop!"

"You give it to Discord! The same guy that ruled over Equestria in pure chaos while making ponies' life miserable. The same guy that corrupted you and your friends. Hell, he forcefully changed you personally. What else? Oh, yeah. He betrayed everyone, teamed up with Tirek, and helped him steal all the magic in Equestria. But, some fucking how, I was not worth the effort? Tell me something; if I came to your cottage on all fours while barking at a lost puppy, would you have shown me kindness then?"

"STOP!!!"

Fluttershy hollers while her eyes go wide. Jason knew what was happening instantly. It was the stare in full effect. Backing Fluttershy in a corner made her use it subconsciously. However, as Fluttershy glares intently into Jason's eyes, she sees everything. Jason's time o Earth. The times when he and Susie watch MLP. The moment he came to Equestria and the last time he ever smiled. Then, she saw Jason's time in Ponyville. She saw everything the citizens did to him. She saw everything her friends did to him. She saw every time she cowed in fear of him. She saw Jason standing in a tree with a noose around his neck before he jumped. It was too much. Fluttershy's eyes went blank white, her pupils fading out to show unconsciousness. Her body would give subtle little twitches before she began to wobble. Finally, with a soft thud, Fluttershy passes out on the defense bench.

"Fluttershy!!!" The elements, and Celestia exclaims.

"Medical! Get the medical ponies in here right now!!!" Luna commands.

Meanwhile, as a commotion begins to erupt, Jason rubs his eyes. There was a slight stinging sensation in them. He blinks away the tears in time to see the medical ponies looking over Fluttershy. He turns to the Gjallarhorn, noticing a soft glow before it fades. He looks at the scene again. Fluttershy's cutie marks were gone. He turns to the judges and speaks in the dead uncaring tone he can muster. "Hmm, no further questions,"

A tone that Rainbow Dash catches instantly. "That's it!!!" She zips into the air and charges toward Jason.

"Dashie, no!!!"

*SMACK*

Update

Good news everyone. The chapter is complete. Bad news everyone. My internet is out. I am writing this on my phone. It should be out this weekend at the latest. More good news. I have a lot of free time to start on the next chapter.