I love you Too! Mate Me!

by underrated Drake

Rating: mature
Tags: Alternate Universe, Sad, Anthro, Porn, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Spike, Romance, Fluttershy, Sex, Profanity
Length: 4779

Now or Never too!... But with a plan.

It's been years since they met, years since they became friends, years since she discovered her feelings for him, but she was never brave enough to confess, even more, when she found realized her feelings were not reciprocated, hoping to better support his love for someone else, And then, that dreadful day came, the day he said he was leaving for good... and then mating with Rarity, love story completed... but what about her? is she actually happy for them? will she find love again?... well, life has a way of rewarding those with kind hearts, and the person that came up with the idea, is even more surprising.

Thank you to Anxiety-Chan for the cover art

FEATURED JANUARY 8, 2023 THANKS FOR THE SUPPORT!!!!

Published 2023-01-08 03:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2023-01-08 03:40:01 UTC

I love you Too! Mate Me!

ONE WEEK LATER

“NEGATIVE AGAIN!!!” Rarity said in anger as she threw the pregnancy test against the wall shattering it.

“Uhm… Darling, are you sure you’re not going overboard?” asked Spike as he went over and picked up the pieces of the broken pregnancy test and placed them in the trash with the other bunch of them.

“OF COURSE NOT! THIS IS PERFECTLY NORMAL!!” Rarity said as she headed over to the cupboard and grabbed another test.

“Rares, I don’t think using another test will change the result,” said Spike as he held her hand lovingly.

“It might, maybe the other 25 tests were broken or…” Rarity began

“... Or you’re really not pregnant,” said Spike

“I must be, we had sex a total of 46 times this past week with you cumming inside of me a total of 40 times, you creampied me so much I MUST be pregnant,” said Rarity trying to break free from Spike to go have another test.

“Rares, I might not be an expert in biology, I mean, I passed the class in high school, but, I don’t think you can get pregnant without being on your period,” said Spike as he held her close

“Oh, darling, a woman can get pregnant even if she's not on her period, it's a matter of ovulation, not stupid cramps and bleeding,” said Rarity

“Then… what if…” Spike tried to say making Rarity nervous

“What?” asked Rarity

“What if our sperm is not compatible because we are of different races… or, one of us is infertile,” Spike said

As soon as he finished that sentence, he felt a jolt of pain in his right cheek

“I FORBID YOU FROM EVER THINKING THAT AGAIN!!!” Rarity said as she slapped Spike.

Spike looked at her surprised, tears were even forming in her eyes

“We have done all the tests, we’re both able to have children… and Twilight and Autumn Blaze confirmed it, Dragons and Earthlings can bare each other's children… there is nothing wrong with us,” said Rarity as she hugged Spike close

“... We will have a child, I know of it, we must,” said Rarity

“Rarity, does this franticness for pregnancy has something to do with what Ember said?” asked Spike

“NO~yes, a little bit…” said Rarity

“Rares, sometimes, Dragonesses don’t get pregnant on the first go, they have to have sex various times, it’s normal, plus, I told you already, you are my mate, I ain’t going anywhere, anytime soon, our lives are forever connected,” said Spike as he kissed her

“I know, but… I at least wanted to be pregnant before heading out to Canterlot for the weekend… sigh, no matter, that just means when I come back, I’ll have you fuck me so hard I won’t be able to walk straight, and definitely get pregnant,” said Rarity as she kissed Spike again.

“Whatever you say… my dear wifey,” Spike said as he booped her and parted ways.

“Oh, Spikey… you’re such a flirt,” Rarity said as she saw him leave for the day and head to the School of Friendship.

Rarity looked at him flying away from behind a window lovingly, but then, Spike’s words came back to her head.

“I don’t want to admit it, but, I’m also concerned… what is wrong with us? We took the tests, his sperm count is high, and I’m ovulating normally… then why can’t I get pregnant?” Rarity thought as she walked towards their room with all of her suitcases ready for her weekend at Canterlot helping Sassy and Coco with the boutique’s increasing orders; just then she remembered a conversation she had with Fluttershy

“Dragons have more than one wife, it's normal, and, according to an anatomy book on dragons, that increases their sperm, making it faster to impregnate the females, since, his body realizes he has more mates,” said Fluttershy

“So, having more than one wife is going to send his balls into overdrive?” asked Rarity

“Wife, girlfriend, mistress, whore… doesn’t matter, the more wives, the faster he impregnates, something about “Mate to procreate” mentality, they called it,” said Fluttershy

“THAT’S IT! I need to get Spike… and me, a third party… and I think I know just who to ask for this massive favor,” Rarity said as she grabbed her coat and rushed out of the door.

FLUTTERSHY’S COTTAGE

Fluttershy didn't think her day would be any different from the others. It was quiet and relaxed, a dark comparison to her own thoughts as she cleaned her house, now that most of her animal friends were out hunting or mating.

She was too into her cleaning, doing her best to keep her mind blank, doing her best not to think about the events that happened a few days ago, and how broken her heart was.

She remembered the get-together, seeing Spike again after almost a month of not seeing him, then the news of him leaving, and then how he and Rarity had mated.

She hated that last part of her memory, seeing Rarity walk funny up to them as they got together 2 days later to talk again, and she told everyone what had happened, she didn’t skip any details, from how she found out she loved Spike, to how he made her his bitch and fucked her so hard she literally couldn’t walk straight.

And to make it worse, the question, the question she hated and hated Rainbow Dash for daring to ask it

“Are you pregnant now?”

“What was Dash thinking when she asked that?! Even if she were pregnant, which I hope she is…and at the same time I don’t… ARGH! WHY IS LOVE SO COMPLICATED!” Fluttershy thought getting angry and breaking her broom

“Oh dear,” she said as she brought another one to clean the mess again.

The Pegasus cleaned up the mess and started sipping from a chilled bottle of Gatorade when she heard a knock at the door.

This surprised her, she wasn’t expecting anyone to come to see her any time soon.

Her first thought went back to her house, was it clean enough, was it nice enough, was it presentable? She asked this over and over as she warily opened the door, but she saw Rarity standing before her, all of those thoughts and even her smile disappeared.

"Hey, girl," Rarity smiled. "May I come in?” she asked

“Rarity… what can I help you with?” asked Fluttershy, doing her best to hide her jealousy as she welcomed the “Homewreacking-bitch-of-a-unicorn” into her house
“I came to talk to you about important business,” said Rarity as she walked into the living room

“Important business?” asked Fluttershy raising an eyebrow

“Yes… dear, please keep an open mind when I say this and, most importantly, don’t judge me for this… but…” Rarity began turning red

Fluttershy looked at Rarity with concern “Oh no, did something happen between her and Spike?... I hope not… but I wish it did,” she thought

“... Would you… be interested… in… joining Spike and me and becoming a big happy family?” Rarity finished

Fluttershy looked at Rarity in surprise as her request repeated itself inside her head over and over again

“You want me to do what?” asked Fluttershy turning red

“What I said dear, join Spike and me in marriage and become a happy family”.

“Why?” asked Fluttershy

“W-well… I had another negative pregnancy test result and it stressed me out… then I remembered what you said about dragons, and then I called Ember and she told me the same thing, so… I thought, if we add 1 or 2 other heads in our marriage we can have an even bigger happy family,” said Rarity with a wide smile.

Lots of images started to flood Fluttershy’s head as she started to remember her wet dreams and fantasies of her and Spike together.

“Wh-why me?” asked Fluttershy redder than ever as a smile appeared on her face

“Well, simple really… I know of your crush on Spike… albeit I found out about it thanks to Rainbow Dash a few days ago… your reaction gave it away rather easily…” said Rarity as she remembered Fluttershy crushing her smoothy glass when RD asked about their sex life.

“... and, if I were, to be honest, I can see myself having sex with you and you having your way with me and we would both enjoy it… so, what do you say?” asked Rarity

“Guilty… In reality, I’ve been in love with him since the first time I met him…” Fluttershy said

“Excellent, that makes matters less complicated,” said Rarity with a big grin

“B-but, is Spike gonna be ok with this?” asked Fluttershy

“Sure he will, listen, I’m leaving for the weekend, so, why don’t you call him over and have some nice time,” Rarity said with a wink

“A-are you sure?” asked Fluttershy

“Wouldn’t be here if I wasn’t… plus, if it means that I can bare Spike's child sooner, the more the merrier I say,” Rarity said with happiness

“B-but… under what pretext would Spike even come here?” asked Fluttershy

“Oh darling, you are just so adorable, ok, let me give you some ideas to get his attention and improve your A-game…” Rarity said as she started to give Fluttershy some ideas.

LATER THAT NIGHT

“... and here I thought I was going to have a relaxed night now that Rarity headed over to Canterlot for the weekend, but, once she comes back it's back to the same routine… not that I mind, I really want her to bare my… our children… anyway… what is surprising right now is the fact that Fluttershy called me out of the blue, and that it sounded urgent, I wonder what’s wrong,” thought Spike as Fluttershy’s cottage came into view.

Spike quickly went up the stairs into her porch and rang the doorbell.

Suddenly, Spike heard a loud thud inside the house that put him on edge, as he turned to look into the window which showed a dimly lit room.

“FLUTTERSHY?!! ARE YOU OK?!!!” Spike asked getting no response

Spike then turned towards the door and was about to kick it down when it opened revealing a sight Spike thought he was never going to see.

Fluttershy appeared in the doorway, her face a red, yet, shy expression fixed on it, but most surprising of all, her body was covered by one of the sexiest black laced lingeries he had ever seen, it left almost nothing to the imagination.

“H-hello Spike, g-glad you could make it,” Fluttershy said as she looked into the dragon’s eyes, doing her best to be confident and assertive, and not laugh at his nosebleed and surprised face.

“S-shy… I-I… am really confused,” said Spike

Fluttershy grinned wide and threw her arms around Spike. She peppered his face with kisses there on the threshold.

“Then let me help you,” Fluttershy said as she kissed him all over again, increasing the passion with every second.

Fluttershy pulled her drake in and shoved the door shut, and the squeezing and smooching shifted into something harder and more lurid as Fluttershy's tongue invaded Spike’s mouth.

"Did that help you understand?" Fluttershy laughed. "Or is the outfit too little?."

The Drake slowly placed his hands on Fluttershy’s hips as he pushed her away slowly.

“Shy, I… I don’t… I didn’t know…” Spike said

“That’s my fault Spikeybear,” said Fluttershy as she looked at him lovingly “But, Rarity came and made me realize, how dumb I was… and I promised that… from now on, I’ll be more assertive.”

Just like that, Spike and Fluttershy’s faces came closer as they kissed, Spike’s hands exploring Fluttershy’s coat as they kissed.

His wrists then landed against her thick breasts, the focal point of his brisk appraisal. "What are you talking about?" he said after a few seconds. "You’re perfect the way you are," he said as they continued kissing.

"God, Spike," Fluttershy moaned as she felt him touch her boobs “Wanna go somewhere more comfortable?” she said coyly

"Really?" Spike smiled in surprise.

And with one swift move, she grabbed him by the wrist and tugged him up the stairs, and up they went.

“Shall we,” Fluttershy said as she guided Spike into her room and sat on the bed

Spike could’ve passed out then and there, the sight of Fluttershy on her bed, the lingerie, and her shy, yet, sensual expression was enough to even make the gods jealous.

“I-is everything to your liking?” asked Fluttershy

A tentpole in his pants succinctly told Fluttershy what the answer to that question was and that the need was mutual.

"You don’t know, how much I wanted this," Fluttershy said with a sultry growl, closing her hands around the bulge in Spike's pants. The dragon ever so slightly growled at her grope and his teeth showed through in a grin.

"And here I thought Rarity was the only one with this desire," Spike said ruefully.

Fluttershy smiled up at Spike but her green eyes said so much more. "We'll get to that, Spikey," she said with a wink, imitating Rarity.

Being up on her all-fours over Spike's legs as she unbuttoned his fly gave him an easy look down into her bottomless cleavage which was shrouded only slightly by her hair. The view was unintentional on her part, a happy coincidence as she went for the dick.

Past the jeans and with the boxers pulled down, Fluttershy saw the penis she had heard of and she'd been craving.

Spike was her one and only sweetheart, and his cock was the only one she wanted in her life and inside of her hard body.

Its dense purple flesh throbbed and pre-drooled from its tip on down the shaft to the bulbous knot, and it was that bottommost spot where Fluttershy grabbed it.

She knew the knot was the most tender spot of all and she made a point of massaging it while she smooched and suckled on the pointed tip. She did so with as much intent to savor his flavor as to pleasure him.

"Ooh, that's the stuff," Spike dumbly smiled, tail thumping the bed. His toes curled and his claws slid over Fluttershy's head. He managed to keep the touch from being a patronizing one as he stroked through her hair and dragged his blunt claws behind her ears.

The pegasi growled fondly at Spike's touch. She seemingly rewarded said touch when she pushed down further, engulfing most of Spike's cock down to the knot.

Spike wasn't small by any stretch and his cock was to proportion, but so was Fluttershy's skill, and her familiarity around that meat was second to none.

Every suck she gave it coaxed loose heavy squirts of pre to wet her palate and soil her tongue. His scent and flavor were perfectly arousing to her.

“D-damn Shy… H-how did you learn to do this?” asked Spike

“It’s a secret… Thank you Rarity,” Fluttershy said

Fluttershy could have gone on forever like that though Spike's endurance certainly wouldn't hold out.

As Rarity had told her in her earlier visit, he had amazing stamina, but, in all of their times in bed, Rarity had discovered all of Spike’s G-spots, to her, it was the best way to get pregnant as fast as possible, but at the same, she had discovered that Spike became a bit more forceful in his actions on the bed “A perfect combination” Fluttershy remembered Rarity said

It didn't seem like Spike minded as Fluttershy pulled back, but it put a lewd smile on his face to see a runner of her drool from her lips to his meat. "That's a nice look for you, Shy."

The pegasus peered down at Spike's swollen red shaft and laughed. "If it is for you, I can make it permanent. Now, let's see about giving you another warmup..."

Up on her knees, Fluttershy easily kept Spike's undivided attention when she removed the upper part of her lingerie, letting her boobs free and then cupping them, pressed them together, and drew her tongue across her lips. "Like these?"

"Fuck," Spike grinned, his dick getting harder

"That's the reaction I was counting on," Fluttershy cooed, "Because you're about to get real familiar with them again."

The dragon was about to say something playfully lewd when Fluttershy pushed her thick tits up into his groin.

Their soft curves pressed up into the husky's balls for a little pleasurable pressure, but it was the feeling and the sight of his cock disappearing between Fluttershy's thick tits that made Spike groan.

Fluttershy held Spike's knotted cock fast between her tits, pushing them together with her forearms and keeping the male flesh compressed but none too harshly.

From the top of her cleavage peeked Spike's pointed tip and Fluttershy pressed her lips against it for a sloppy kiss. "How's this doing for you, Spikey-bear?" she whispered.

Spike could have been dirty but he cooed, "A-amazing. Love you, babe..."

"Love you too," Fluttershy chuckled. The pegasus bucked her tits into Spike's groin, grinding them harshly against his loins and crooning at the feeling of his red meat grinding on her mounds.

The pre which Spike drooled into her cleavage came to be a staggering amount which soon left her fur matted and slicked.

Spike's output didn’t cease to please her, but it did amaze her. It was comforting in that it was exactly what she expected from him.

Over the wet suckle and squish of Fluttershy's damp cleavage being plundered by Spike's shaft, the dragon groaned. One stout arm was folded across his front but the other was on the bed with fingers digging into the sheets.

"You gonna pop for me, honey?" Fluttershy said, finding herself giggling at the thought. A sticky mess would be fun indeed.

Something changed in Spike.

He sat up with a little effort, suddenly realizing how tired he was from his past week managing Rarity and his work, yet he knew he had it in him for Fluttershy's sake and his own.

The pegasus kept her tits around Spike's meat but she peered up at him with sweet green eyes and a swish of her tail.

Spike grinned and brushed her hair aside in a soft pet. "Let's make this about us, baby, not just me," he cooed. "Let me do the things you’ve waited so long for."

Fluttershy didn't need to be told twice. She would've been a bad liar to say she wasn't as eager as Spike about getting her rocks off. She pulled back and came to rest on her knees. Implicit in her pose was the offer of her fine breasts but Spike gave them only a gentle rub as he kissed Fluttershy on the lips.

It was a short kiss which begged for so much more time than they had to give it. Fluttershy pulled away from it with an especially hot blush on her face.

The pegasus felt like she was giving into instinct when she dropped to her hands and knees.

Above her flawless ass, her tail flagged high.

Spike salivated and grinned at the sight of her behind. His hands took hold of the cheeks and fondled and parted them, briskly exposing the pucker between but that wasn't his goal. Below was her cunt which he knew she wanted so badly.

Two of his fingers eased their way down exploring her, perusing slippery pink flesh and wrenching groans from Fluttershy's lips.

"Hot as a fucking oven," Spike grunted. "And wet, too... You’re such a perv,”

"I've been waiting for you," Fluttershy said with a quiver. "I haven't done a thing - not even one finger. Give it to me, I-I… I want you to mate me… and bare your children,"

The sincerity and shyness in Fluttershy's voice made Spike smile and blush. He was inclined to do as his new woman asked and he gripped his swollen red flesh in the same hand he had just fingered her with. Pre leaked copiously from his tip even as his cock hung idly in the air.

When he pressed into Fluttershy, the pegasus shuddered and pushed back. Spike pushed forward to meet her.

His cock sank into her tight snatch and spread her as it went along, opening her up. It left her groaning and curling her toes as his dick took her virginity from her, making her his for the rest of her life.

Spike's paws came to rest on the curve of Fluttershy's hips. Even with all her lean build and strength, Fluttershy was thick where a woman should be, and he loved it.

Spike had a hard time keeping his hands and thoughts off of the pegasu's before, but now he could let it all go. Just as his balls pressed against her pussylips, Spike growled, "This was worth the wait..."

Though Spike's grip often returned to Fluttershy's hips for control as he bucked, he did stroke down her back for her pleasure and his own. It pleased him greatly to watch her spine arch and her tail wag, and as he caressed her, she clenched down harder for him. Sliding his hands back home to her hips and pressing his knot especially firmly against her folds, Spike said with a chuckle, "It seems someone is really eager,"

Fluttershy giggled sweetly but she pushed her ass back harshly for Spike. Her dragon gasped and so did she. "Spikey-bear, Rarity isn’t the only one who wants to be fucked by you… she just was the first to do it, I’ve wanted you to fuck me since we were 16," she grinned.

“Sorry it took me so long to realize,” Spike said

“Worth the wait,” said Fluttershy as she felt Spike pick up the speed

A good, happy laugh came out of Spike. He dropped down to his all fours much like Fluttershy had done herself, but when he was braced with an arm he reached up and fondled her breasts in a gentle touch. In particular, he stroked her nipples with his thumb.

"Then let me make sure you never forget it," he teased.

"Whenever, wherever, I am your woman now, as well," Fluttershy snickered. Not a beat had gone by when she hooked an arm back and pulled Spike in for a kiss on the lips. "Love you," she growled, still nose to nose with him.

"Love you too," Spike huffed. "More than you'd ever believe." Long, slow humps gradually became quicker and faster bucks.

Spike was bearing down on Fluttershy, pounding his knot against her tender pussylips. His balls swung up between her thighs harmlessly, for Fluttershy offered herself with a wide-kneed stance.

Getting fatigued in one arm, Spike put his weight on both and huffed sweet nothings into Fluttershy's perked ears.

She in turn wore a big, blissful grin with a blush on her cheeks and a burn in her loins.

Spike's knot pounded her, promising an amazing stretch when he finally got around to working it in. That was fine for Fluttershy “sex was best enjoyed carefully, even if bluntly slamming down on one was pretty fun sometimes… although, roughness can be delicious too” she remembered Rarity saying to her while she trained for Spike

"Damn, I'm getting close," Fluttershy shuddered to Spike, feeling very chuffed.

“Allow me,” Spike whispered into her ear as he nibbled playfully at it

Fluttershy was blushing and grinning not unlike Spike, and in her exertion she began panting.

Her tongue hung out in a typically doggish way but she slopped it back in to say, "I want it all inside me… every last drop,”

"As you wish…" Spike huffed. "Wifey," he chuckled.

"Make me a mommy too," Fluttershy whispered back at him

“Really?” Spike said faking surprise

Fluttershy reached up again and stroked the side of Spike's head before pulling him cheek to cheek with a tug on his ear. "I… want… to… bare, your children," the Fluttershy huffed. "God, I want that cum..."

The dragon could feel his balls throbbing and aching for release. Waiting such a long time was hell on a normal person, but for an especially virile stud like Spike, it was a herculean effort.

That he hadn't popped his load already was a miracle and one that was coming to a close, because he couldn't hold off anymore.

None of Spike's sudden efforts to wedge his knot into Fluttershy's pussy were selfless. That she wanted the knot as badly as he wanted to give it to her just so happened to coincide, but the pegasus didn't know and she wouldn't have cared. She groaned and neighed, shoving her ass back against Spike with every intent to get her cunt to swallow his knot right up.

"Ah, goddamn," Spike hissed. "I'm right there, I'm so frickin' close," he rambled on through clenched teeth.

"Me too," Fluttershy gasped in a little sing-song. "Ooh my Gawd, I can't hold it off..."

That was it for Spike. Now or never, do or die. He pushed himself up to his knees alone and he held fast to Fluttershy's hips.

With every buck in, he grunted at the shivers crawling up his spine. Fluttershy was perfect, she was all his, and she was dying for his knot - how could he deny his new girl that?

Despite her needs, Fluttershy wasn't as passive. She shoved back into Spike's hips and she gripped the sheets in her paws. Her teeth were clenched and so were her eyes. Words were lost on her, but hot grunting and groaning were not.

"Fuck, Shy!" Spike gasped as his balls grew so very taut. He bit his lip to stifle a grunt and he finally tied the knot.

It popped past Fluttershy's pussylips with a wet suckle and it spread her so wide and so quickly that she screamed and tossed her head back, flopping her hair into a wild mane. It was painful but in a way Fluttershy just loved it, and that pleasurable pain was what made the pegasus drop to the bed, face down and ass up, body quivering and mouth whimpering. She came hard around Spike's knot and that slippery clenching set the dragon off.

Fluttershy's oh-face was intense but she had nothing on Spike. Clenched teeth gleamed with spittle, eyes rolled back and clenched tightly, ears splayed down into his hair, the look said everything.

His cum blasted into Fluttershy and redefined excess. The ropes were thick and sloppy, clinging to her writhing cunt, filling her womb and leaving her hot as hell.

Right up until the afterglow washed over him, Spike continued to dump everything he had in his balls.

The sheer amount of cum he had to offer was stunning - but Fluttershy knew well of his virility. It was one more reason she loved her drake.

Against the plug of Spike's knot, the incredible load struggled to escape but couldn't. Spike settled on top of his new girl to pant and groan as he came down.

Soon Spike rolled onto his side along with Fluttershy. She cuddled against his back and closed her eyes against the dim light of the lamp. "That felt wonderful, Spikey-bear..."

Spike's arms were already around Fluttershy, but he squeezed her tighter still and kissed her behind the ear. "For me too... God, what a night."

"Hah, yeah," Fluttershy chuckled. "But… I’ve heard from Rarity that you can go ALL night… so,”

“Y-you really..” Spike panted

“You’re inside me already, I say we can still keep going,” Fluttershy said as she kissed Spike

“I mean sure if you want to,” said Spike

“Glad to hear…” Fluttershy said as she felt Spike’s knot pop out of her pussy followed by a cascade of cum.

“Let me do the moving now,” she said as she got on top of Spike and put his shaft back inside her.

“You really love my dick, don’t you?” said Spike

“I love you, your wonderful dick is an added bonus, plus, it’s just like Rarity said, you are wonderful in bed,” said Fluttershy as she began to ride Spike’s dick again

“Thanks for the compliment,” said Spike

“Plus, if I get pregnant before the others, it’ll mean I am more important to him than the others,” Fluttershy mumbled,

“What… others?... who?” asked Spike

“None important, just concentrate on me tonight… and tomorrow… we have some babies to make,” Fluttershy said as she laid down on his chest, pressing her massive tits on him and kissing him passionately as she began to go faster feeling Spike’s dick getting harder inside her.