Star swirl dark secret

by Ulcktktxyo

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Spike, Starswirl the Bearded, Starlight Glimmer, Non-consensual, Stygian, Sex
Length: 3688

Starlight and Spike find a diary of Starswirl's dark secret.

Starlight ends up finding in her purse,with Spike,A diary of an unknown person, After opening it she discovers that it belongs to Stygian.

However, After the two friends started reading the diary, They discovered a dark secret in Starswirl.

Published 2022-12-31 00:30:00 UTC
Last updated 2023-01-02 23:55:43 UTC

Secret diary

Starlight glimmer was in the twillight castle library next to spike, they were arranging some books by category and letters,And spike was putting old books in a pile on top of the table in the center of the library, While starlight put the new ones in place of the old ones with her telekinesis.

"I can't believe there are so many old books," Spike says

"Twilight must have bought an entire library to replenish all of this," starlight said

"That must have been it,"—spike climbs onto the table and climbs one of the book stacks to place the last book on top of it"ok, I think they're all here,"

"Ok spike, i'm about to finish here so call twilight," starlight spoke aloud.

Spike started to get down from the pile of books looking down, but suddenly Spike sits up something falls on his head something hard and flat, making Spike startled and screams.

"Haa!!,"spike yells "Oooo OO!,"—spike releases his claws from the pile of books, staggering and falling to the ground on the shore, thus making a loud POW noise.

Starlight takes a big scare and turns towards Spike letting the books she was levitating fall to the ground, She sees Spike lying on the ground next to a strange old book with a white label with something written in black on it.

"Spike are you okay!?," Starlight yells

Spike starts to stand up using his hands for the "Yes yes I think, but what was that?" Spike turns to starlight with his hand behind his back.

"I don't know I think it was this book"—starlight approaches the book which flies at her with the flick of her horn "Weird I've never seen this book before"

"It must be some book Twilight must not have seen."

"Knowing Twilight she must have already read this."

"Strange he falls out of nowhere on me."

Starlight looks at the stick that is in the book and it says "PLEASE READ ME".

"I don't think this is a normal book"

"Why?" Spike asked.

"It has this weird tag"—starlight turns the book over to show the tag to spike"I don't think this book is by twilight,"

"Hmm...very strange,The tag is new and the book is incredibly old" Spike said.

"I think we should look into it"—Starlight sits on the floor and opens up as she moves to the floor.

"Let me see it too"—Spike sits on the starlight side to read the book.

———————————————————

STYGIA DIARY

———————————————————

Starlight is surprised that it is Stygia's diary and she wonders what is he doing here?, until she notices a resentful smudge under the title.

"Stygia's diary?, but what else is he doing here" Spike said.

"I don't know Spike, but let's investigate further"—Starlight turns the page and she is surprised to see that many pages have been ripped from the book, Leaving another page in sight "Weird looks like someone tore all of this to hide something,"

"There should be more information on the next few pages," Spike argued.

———————————————————

Dear diary, today was the best day of my life, Starswirl proposed me to study with him and the 6 pillars, And today I'm already packing my bags to go there tomorrow. I'm very excited and happy.

———————————————————

"So,everything looks normal," Spike says.

"But it doesn't make sense this sudden warning and the pages cut, Let's read on," starlight says.

"Okay"—Spike puts his hand on the book and turns the page and the two begin to read.

———————————————————

Dear diary, today I moved to the castle of the 6 pillars, Starswirl showed me all the places in the castle and even the library, Tomorrow I will start my studies of magic and sorcery.

———————————————————

"Still normal" Spike says.

"Always the rule of thumb, Everything seems normal at first spike," Starlight murmured.

"If you say"

Starlight and spike start reading the other page.

———————————————————

Dear diary today i went to the library with star swirl to learn new spells, i learned how to teleport a book to other corners and even myself, And starswirl said i was off to a good start.

———————————————————

"See, I told you, it's nothing to worry about" - Spike gets up and walks towards the door "Probably someone trying to pull a prank"

Starlight doesn't think the same as Spike, and her curiosity grows in her head, So starlight starts flipping through the pages and reading them quickly, There's nothing strange so far but she looks at a page with something written in the top corner "HERE !".

"SPIKE!" Starlight yells.

Spike after hearing the scream he goes back close to starlight "What do you hear?" Spike asked.

"I found something here that says "here"...That means what?," starlight says in a rather arrogant tone.

"That there must be something there..."—Spike rolls his eyes and gets a little mad that this is wrong, And then sits down next to starlight again and the two begin to read.

———————————————————

Dear... diary today was a normal day I learned potions with mage, I had a test of strength with Rockhoof, And I also learned botany with Mistmane but in starswirl classes it was kind of strange, At the beginning it was ok I was sitting down in the chair with my book on the table, Until he sat next to me and started explaining to me how a microscope worked, But at the end of the explanation he rubbed his hoof on my leg, I didn't feel comfortable with that but maybe it was just an accident right...?.

———————————————————

Starlight and Spike are shocked, Starlight looks on with anger and disapproval after reading about alleged harassment, And Spike is confused and repulsed upon reading such information as starswirl is a good guy right?.

"What the nightmare moon is that?," Starlight screams.

"B-but...why...no...t-that can't be possible," Spike stammered.

"This could be very real, But we can't trust it one hundred percent, Spike will call twilight I need to look into this better,"

"Ok I'm coming,"—Gets up and runs out of the library.

Starlight turns her attention back to the book "I hope I don't find anything too bad" Starlight complained.

sink in the pages

Spike was running all over Twilight's castle,Screaming her name to find her.

"TWILIGHT, TWILIGHT," Spike yells.

Until Spike arrives at the exit of the castle, And Spike will see a paper glued with something written on the door to the right of the exit.

"what?,"

Spike walks over to the paper and starts reading it.

———————————————————

Dear Spike and Starlight, Me and the other girls have to leave, Because the map called us to the middle of the desert because flim and flam are gone, We don't know when we'll be back so I want you to keep the new books and enjoy the day.

Signed: Twilight.

———————————————————

"Series?...o man...."Spike mutters in rage and despair.

Spike removes the paper from the door and puts it in his right hand, Then he starts desperately running back to the library.

Meanwhile starlight takes Stygia's diary with her telekinesis, And she looks at the books on the library table, And with a movement of her horn they levitate one by one to the floor leaving the table without any books.

"I wonder if spike found twilight already, He's taking too long,"

Starlight moves the old diary with telekinesis to the table and leaves it open on it, And Stalight walks to the table and sits on one of its benches to read the diary.

"Let's see what you hide starswirl"

Spike enters the library through the door,With the paper in hand and a little sadness and worry in his eyes.

"Errr...Starlight" Spike says rather low.

"Yes!...where is Twilight?," Starlight asked.

"They and the others left for the desert"—Spike shows the letter in his hand.

"WHAT!?"—Starlight takes the letter from Spike's hand using her telekinesis, And the reader places it in front of her thus reading it quickly "AAhhh.....great,"

"But....what should we do now?,"

"Let's read the diary more so we'll find out what starswirl did, And maybe find out that I sent the diary" - Starlight uses her magic to levitate spike until she leaves him sitting next to her.

Starlight uses her telekinesis to move the diary page, And she and Spike begin reading the page.

———————————————————

Dear diary, After what happened yesterday i was afraid to be near starswirl,But today was a normal day of studies,So maybe...just maybe it was an accident?.

———————————————————

"MaYBe iT WAS AN ACCidEnT" Starlight yells "IS THIS SERIOUS?"—Starlight stomps her hooves hard.

"Starlight calms down"—Spike places his right hand on starlight's shoulder.

"Ok...i'll give it a try"

Starlight takes her hooves off the table and she turns to the next page, And she and spike start reading it.

———————————————————

Dear diary, it happened again but it was different, I was in my room with a towel on me, Until I hear a knock on the door, I walk to it and open it and see starswirl on the other side, And this was the conversation:

" Mr Starswirl?, What are you doing here?"l said

"Well I came to ask, Are you going to take a shower?"

" As you can see I'm wearing a towel, So yes I'm going"

*So I wanted to ask if...."

Starswirl he approaches... his face close to mine.... very close... even too close, With a strange serious look,With a little smile and with... desire for something.

"If you want some help in the bath?"

I got uncomfortable, And moved my face away from his.

"err no, I don't need to"

"Are you... sure?"

Starswirl places its upper straight hull at half a chin.

"Ye-yes.....I have"

"hun....okay"

Starswirl takes his hand away from my chin, And then he turns and leaves as I close the door.

I felt horrible in that situation...I'll talk to him about it tomorrow.

———————————————————

Starlight and Spike feel like they've been punched in the stomach by a bull, Starlight is disgusted and so are you. Huge disdain mixed with anger, Making her snort, And Spike feels disgust and sadness inside of him,At the thought of what Stygian went through on starswirl's hooves.

"THAT SON OF A MARE!" Starlight screams

"This is getting worse and worse..."

"When we're done here, We're going to destroy starswirl"

Starlight and Spike start reading the next page.

———————————————————

Dear diary I think there is something wrong with me, I don't remember writing you that starswirl hoofed my leg, And "Seduced" me to go to the bath with him......, I must be losing memory because this is my handwriting, So I'm going to start writing down the situations in more detail so I don't forget, While I try to figure out what's going on.

Note for me: I'm going to talk to Starswirl about the harassment, But I'm afraid that this didn't happen, I'm going through a situation with a backlash.

———————————————————

Starlight and Spike are confused and curious, Making them forget about the other pages for a moment, And wondering what they hear.

"What's going on?" Spike asks.

"I don't know anymore this story is getting worse, Maybe some memory erase spell," Starlight says.

"I don't know, I don't understand spells"

"I'll find out while you're reading the diary" Starlight uses her telekinesis to place the diary in Spike's hands, And Starlight gets up from her chair and walks to the library's exit "If you find something, tell me Spike"

"Ok starlight"—Spike turns the page in the diary.

"Good"—Starlight opens the door and walks out,and then closes it.

Spike is looking worriedly looking at the diary with a sad face, Then Spike takes a deep breath and starts reading it.

———————————————————

......Dear diary, Today in starswirl's class I had a chat with him.

Starswirl was explaining to me how he thought pegasus fly, Because their wings are not propocinative to the body, And that was the conversation that took place.

Starswirl: So I think pegasus have some levitation magic in their wings, Any questions?.

"Starswirl"l say.

"Yes?"

StarSwirl moves in next to me.

"It's just that one day you rubbed your hoof on my leg, And on another you asked me if I wanted to take a shower with you.... I didn't feel comfortable, And I wanted to ask you to stop with that because I I don't want to end our friendship"

"....If...you felt that way, that's fine, I didn't want you to feel that way, But you know that you're only here because of me, Right?"

"Yes B-"

"So you don't want to get kicked out of here…do you?"

"n-no sir"

"Then I recommend that you don't bring it up any more....ok?" Starswirl brings her face closer to mine, With a serious and angry look.

"ok...but I-"

"Stygian.....you know I can finish you off in 3 seconds right?"

I swallow hard in fear, And I feel sweat trickling down my forehead.

".......Well....More because of your bad behavior, You received a punishment" Starswirl says.

"Punishment?, What punishment" I ask.

———————————————————

Spike is scared and disgusted by what might come on the next page, He even thinks about calling starlight but she must be busy, Because she still won't come back. Then spike turns the page and swallows hard and starts reading it.

"calm down spike"

———————————————————

Suddenly Starswirl uses her telekinesis to take off her cape and hat, And leaves them on the floor, While she walks to a chair and sits on it with her legs closed.

I have a good feeling of what is going to happen, So as if it were a flash of light I remember the exit, So without wasting time I gallop towards the exit.

"HEL-"

But Starswirl's telekinesis catches me locking my mouth, And I levitate from the ground and take me to the front of him.

"Don't resist Stygian...you are no match against me"

I try to struggle and scream through his telekinesis, But I couldn't move.

"You're so cute and young...it makes me horny.."

———————————————————

Spike feels queasy, As if he's been run over by a herd of ponies.

"Ok that's enough!" Spike yells

Spike takes the book in his claws, Then he gets out of his chair and runs to the library exit.

"Starlight!" Spike yells.

Problem beyond the diary

Spike was running with the diary in his clutches, He was looking for Starlight to read the rest of the pages with him.

"Starlight!" Spike yells "Where are you?"

Spike opens every door in the hallway to find her, Until he opens the door to the map room, And sees a pile of books piled up on Twilight's chair.

"Errr...Starlight?" Spike speaks loudly

Until the pile of books moves and from the middle of it comes starlight, With books floating around her by her telekinesis.

"Hey!, did you find something?"—Starlight starts reading one of the books that is wrapped around her.

"well......you won't like what's here"

"Why, I'm going to find what?" Starlight frowns, And looks at Spike doubtfully.

"I can't explain it in words"—Spike lifts the book toward Starlight.

Starlight stays still, And uses her telekinesis to levitate the diary to her, and opens it.

"page 10....."Spike growls in a sad way.

Starlight opens to page ten and starts to read it, As she reads her face changes from confused to angry, She frowns and her breathing gets louder.

"Starlight?" Spike asks.

Starlight closes the diary and throws it on the table, And it goes into the pile of books.

"Stralight...are you ok.....look I know this is serious, And to solve this we can tal-"

Suddenly a muffled scream from Starlight comes out of the pile of books, Then Starlight uses magic to grow a shield around herself, Pushing away all the books that are thrown across the room.

Spike uses his arm to cover his face from the rain of books, Luckily no books hit him.

"AAAAAAAHHH!" Starlight screams.

Spike is in shock with all that outbreak of anger, So Spike approaches Starlight to try and puts his hand on her shoulder.

"THAT OLD MAN WILL SEE, WHEN HE LAST EXPECTES IT I'M GOING TO PUT MY HORN IN HIS EYES." Starlight screams.

"St-"

"I'll get that beard of his and AAAA!"-Starlight starts galloping around the map table.

"Sta-"

"When the others get back, we're going to break him—" Starlight slams her hoof into the ground.

"Starli-"

"Who knows!, We'll-"

"Control yourself girl!" Spike yells.

Starlight is in shock as she didn't expect Spike's explosive reaction, So she stops walking across the table and takes a deep breath.

"Apologies, Sp-"

"I'm sorry, I'm sorry??"—Spike spreads his arms with furrowed brows "We're here reading about these horrible acts, And freaking out doesn't help us at all!"

Starlight looks at Spike and her gaze turns sad, As she looks at the ground she walks to the diary, And levitates it with her telekinesis to her.

"You're right Spike"

Spike is sorry he yelled, So he lowers his arms and his eyes become worried and sad.

"Hey, I'm sorry—"Spike walks up to starlight"I'm sorry, I didn't mean to say that but-"

"No, it's not okay"—Starlight sits down at the applejack table, And opens the journal.

Spike stays beside her "it's not that I, I always got mad when they didn't hear me and I exploded, A thousand more excuses I didn't want to scream"

"I understand that after hearing everything in this diary... I"

"It's okay... if you don't want to talk, I'll understand"

Starlight takes a deep breath and sadly looks up.

"One thing I never told anyone is that when I was a teenager, I was studying restriction magic at the library"

"And ?" Spike asked.

“One day when the library was about to close, I was studying away from everyone, and the librarian came up to me asking about the book I was reading and...”

"and...?"

"He sat next to me, then he started to put his hand on me, I was scared and I was paralyzed, Until he reached my vagina and started sticking his hoof inside it"

Spike is shocked and breaks down with this story.

"Bu-but you didn't do n-nothing?"

"Yes I did, When he got up I exploded with fear creating a huge shield that destroyed the library"

".....er....I"

"I understand that you don't understand these things well, but after that he was arrested, But my hatred of that situation made me feel hatred for this type of pony"

Then Spike descends as a consolation and gives Starlight a hug, which is surprised by such an action, So she hugs him back for a few seconds.

"I'm sad this happened to you, but I know you'll get over it," Spike says.

Starlight is moved by such speech and a tear starts to flow from one of her eyes, And with a small smile "thanks spike...."

Starlight looks at the diary and looks at the books thrown around the room.

"I'll fix them for you, and I'll also look into Stygian's memory loss"

"Ok spike"

Spike starts picking up each of the books around the room.

Starlight looks at the diary and opens it with her telekinesis.

"Ok...let's find out more"—Starlight starts reading the diary.

———————————————————

After hearing such words from starswirl I get scared of what he can do, So I try to use my teleportation to teleport to the door, After teleporting I try to run away and scream, But his magic involves me in a bubble that blocked my screams.

"Such a fool, it seems that I must give a stronger punishment" Starswirl says.

Starswirl uses his magic to bring the bubble to him, And I squirm along with him.

"So let's get started"

Starswirl uses her magic to do something, So I turn to the door and see that there is a magic lock on it, Then the bubble expands and covers Starswirl making a large, 30 foot by 30 foot space.

"Help help, help"—I hit the bubble with my hooves but the bubble doesn't break.

Starswirl uses her telekinesis to lead me to him, Then I realize he's spread legged with his dick slightly erect.

"Don't worry you won't choke"—Starswirl uses her magic to bring my mouth close to his cock, His cock smelled like dry old papers...., Then with his telekinesis he opens my mouth and he puts his cock slowly in her.

"Oooo...what a warm mouth" Starswirl groaned.

After having... the cock inserted inside the mouth I break down and try to let go of the telekinesis, But Starswirl takes my head and starts and raises and lowers it on his cock.

"Wow even in a forced way you are good at this"Starswirl says.

———————————————————

Starlight is disgusted and repulsed, as the memories of her abuse come flooding back, Starlight takes a deep breath and looks at Spike reading one of the books, And using her telekinesis she turns the page of the diary and starts to read it.

———————————————————

I was choking on Starswirl's cock, Tears welling up in my eyes from desperation and fear.

"Don't worry your mouth will be free later—Starswirl smile.

I was scared of what he could do, I try to let go of telekinesis again trying to debate myself.

"Don't resist... I'm almost there"

Starswirl lowers and lifts my head quickly, Making me gasp even more.

"Oooo I'm close"

Star Swirl use telekinesis to levitate me, Thus taking my mouth off his dick, So I can breathe normally.

With his telekinesis he lowers me to the ground, Making and lying on my stomach and on my ass, And with my tail he lifts me up by his telekinesis.

"ok get ready"

I can't hear Starswirl, but I hear him get up and walk behind me, Then I feel the head of his cock slowly being pushed into my ass.

———————————————————

Starlight is disgusted and she feels her lunch back up her throat, But she notices that in the bottom corner of the page, There is a hard, Dark stain as if something slimy has dried, and she wonders what it could be.

"Oh!...Starlight I think I found!" Spike yells.