Moondancer's Madness

by PegPony

Rating: mature
Tags: Alternate Universe, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Fetish, Rarity, Porn, Moondancer, Sex, Profanity, Non-consensual
Length: 5136

Futa Moondancer kidnaps and rapes Rarity

Rarity is a beautiful, successful, smart and confident business woman who owns three boutiques and is now working as a part-time lingerie model, a very popular lingerie model as well! However, with so many fans there is bound to be at least one person who takes their adoration and admiration a little too far, something Rarity finds out the hard way when Moondancer kidnaps her and attempts to force a romance and a relationship that simply doesn't exist until she can claim that Rarity is truly her mare.

This story was written for: Tailsic

Warning, this story contains: Futa, kidnapping, rape, light bondage, voyeurism, general not-nice-ness

Published 2023-01-18 14:50:00 UTC
Last updated 2023-01-18 14:50:00 UTC

Restraining Rarity

Rarity had been a lingerie model for quite a while now and after Moondancer had seen her on the front cover of a magazine at the local store... she had become obsessed with her. Every magazine that featured Rarity she bought, every costume that Rarity wore she bought, she visited her boutiques regularly just to see if she happened to be there that day, it had gotten so out of hand that Moondancer was spending more money than she was earning, had began to lose focus on her career and was becoming more and more disconnected from her friends and family. The new sexy version of Rarity had completely consumed Moondancer's life and she was back to the old version of herself that she used to be, staying at home and only going out if she absolutely needed to. To say that she was a number one fan would have been a gross understatement, Moondancer had never been more attracted to anyone in her entire life and most of her days were spent at home, looking at pictures of Rarity, fantasizing about her and furiously jacking off her huge throbbing cock.

Part of Moondancer's reluctance to go out was the fear that people would tease her for having male genitalia despite being female, the need for a job, food and a social life had gotten her to leave the house for the sake of necessity but ever since Rarity... she only left the house for three reasons. One was her job and though she had gotten a little sloppy with it and was taking more breaks so that she could think about Rarity and jack off in the staff toilets, she was still doing well enough and was too valuable an employee to be fired, she was one of the lucky few that were irreplaceable. Two was shopping, shopping for food and anything even remotely related to Rarity and outdoor activity number three...... stalking Rarity.

That was how she had managed to sneak into the studio of Rarity's latest photo shoot and perv on her from the shadows, quietly masturbating all the while, she'd already emptied her nuts into two of the three condoms she bought for the sake of containing and disposing of her load and she had just finished filling the third and final one when the photo shoot ended. Moondancer was panting and sweaty from all the constant fapping but she'd never been more happy or more aroused than at that moment, she had gotten to witness the photo shoot from start to finish and considered it lucky there were other fanatics out there on the internet who could give the inside scoop on Rarity's whereabouts.

Despite all of the merchandise she had bought, all the recorded interviews, all the poor imitations in porn, despite having access to everything a Rarity fan could ever want... it wasn't enough. Moondancer was in the studio where Rarity was doing one of her famous photo shoots and despite ejaculating three times in quick succession... she needed more. After tucking her cock back into her jeans and throwing the filled condoms into a nearby bin, she had managed to follow Rarity back to her dressing room unnoticed and peeked through the door, salivating as she saw Rarity undressing to get back into her regular clothes. Moondancer couldn't help herself, freeing her hard-on once more and rapidly pumping her member as she watched, she could just blow her load on the door, who'd notice?

The unfortunate thing was that during the photo shoot, Moondancer wasn't under a time limit to cum but Rarity wasn't going to stay in the studio forever and more importantly, it didn't take her more than three minutes to get changed. Moondancer had the good sense to wrestle with her erection and, with a struggle, stuff it back into her jeans so she could hide around the corner as Rarity exited the room. Moondancer looked longingly at Rarity as she strutted away down the corridor, once she disappeared from sight, Moondancer was about to go and find a toilet to finish herself off when she had an epiphany... Rarity's dressing room was right there... what was to stop her just going in to explore? Moondancer bit the bullet and went to the door which, luckily, wasn't a door that locked automatically, granting her access to Rarity's dressing room.

There were interesting things in the dressing room for sure but Moondancer only cared about one thing, the lingerie that Rarity had laid out on a nearby table when getting changed but more specifically, the lacy black panties of the garment. Moondancer's lip trembled as her shaky hands reached out to pick up the silky underwear, the very underwear that Rarity had been wearing not even five minutes ago... this was a rare opportunity to "borrow" something that had actually clung to Rarity's body and practically hugged her... naughty bits. Moondancer worked on autopilot, pulling her erect cock out of her jeans once more and building up a steady rhythm as she stroked her aching fuck stick while she unashamedly picked up the panties, pressed them to her face and inhaled deeply, shuddering in arousal as she reveled in the residual scent of Rarity's skin and what surely must have been an absolutely exquisite pussy.

Moondancer quickly ducked into the private bathroom of the dressing room and continued to press the fabric to her nostrils, breathing in the most minuscule semblance of Rarity's essence as she could, her hand a blur as she jacked off with wild abandon, pushing herself to yet another orgasm, panting, sweaty and desperate to cum while she rubbed Rarity's panties all over her face. Seconds later, Moondancer held back a groan as her churning fuck sacks tightened while she fired several ropes of jizz into the watery abyss of the toilet bowl, cleaning herself with some tissue and flushing as her over-worked and soft penis was put away. Moondancer figured she'd pocket the panties, it would be her most treasured possession and go-to masturbation glove.

Then again... when would she get the chance to be in the same building as Rarity again where the only other person there was Photo Finish, who would surely assume that Rarity had left for the day... what was to stop her from finding Rarity and then "persuading" her to put aside some time to engage in a little sexy fun with her biggest fan? Moondancer couldn't imagine Rarity got much action and a little break to show some gratitude to a fan with her body surely wasn't out of the question, Moondancer would only keep her for a couple of hours! Or days... weeks maybe at a push... months... years... lifetimes...

Moondancer stopped lying to herself, she was going to make Rarity hers, hers and hers alone and all she needed was the opportunity... which is exactly what she got when opportunity walked through the door while Moondancer was still hidden from sight in the toilet. Rarity had returned, somehow forgetting that the lingerie she was modelling had actually been given as a gift by the company and so it was technically hers, Moondancer watched through a crack in the door as she watched Rarity, less than a meter away from her go "Huh... odd, where are the panties to this outfit? I'm sure they were right here..."

Moondancer waited patiently to choose her moment, Rarity began looking around and when her back was turned, Moondancer pounced, wrapping an arm around her torso whilst pressing the palm of her other hand to Rarity's face, blocking her airways. Rarity's eyes went wide as an unknown assailant attacked her from behind, she attempted to thrash wildly to free herself but her attacker stood firm, Rarity tried to scream but was muffled by the hand pressing against her face and her effort to scream only wasted what little air she had left in her lungs to remain conscious. Slowly her eyes began to droop and her limbs went slack as her mind slipped away until she was fully passed out. Moondancer's boner was pressed up against the ass of a sleeping Rarity and while she would have liked nothing better than to hump her idols rump and splatter seed all over her back, she could do all that and more if she took Rarity home with her.

Moondancer dragged Rarity's limp and lifeless body through the back exit and quickly stashed her in the trunk of her car before zooming off towards home, trying to seem casual despite the adrenaline coursing through her veins. She couldn't believe what she had just done, she had kidnapped Rarity so that she could hold her hostage in her home and force her into agreeing to be in a relationship with her... so exciting! It was the best day ever!

Hours later, Rarity woke with her vision still blurry and not remembering anything after being jumped by someone in her own dressing room back at the studio. As things came into focus, she found herself staring at a ceiling she didn't recognize and upon trying to get up, found that her arms and legs had been tied to the corners of a bed that definitely wasn't her own and no matter how hard she tried, she couldn't pull herself free of the restraints. Lifting her head up, she also saw that, save for her panties, she had been completely stripped of her clothes. Then Rarity had an idea, she was a unicorn! She'd simply use magic to escape whatever rape dungeon she was trapped in, only to find that she couldn't, Rarity panicked as time and time again she attempted to light up her horn and ended up with the same result as before, the result being that nothing happened. Suddenly to Rarity's left, there was a giggle as a feminine voice said "Struggling to use your magic?"

Rarity looked towards where the voice was coming from and saw a completely naked mare... or at least most of her looked like a mare but the last time Rarity checked, most mares didn't have what this mare had between her legs. Moondancer continued by saying "Don't worry, the potion I drugged you with to cancel out your magic isn't permanent, it should wear off in about twenty-four hours... though depending on how this goes, I may have to use it on you a few more times before I achieve my goal"

Rarity, confused, just went "What do you mean? Who are you and what do you want?! Let me go!"

Moondancer looked at Rarity with a loving smile and said "Oh Rarity.... you are so beautiful and are more successful than most but with that little bit of defiance you just showed me there.... fuck, you've also proved just how confident you are, which makes sense considering you're a business woman with her own label and yet you can model lingerie without it ruining your image... that's part of what I love about you Rarity, you're so perfect! That's why I have to make you mine! I want you to be my mare forever and ever! I love you so much!"

Rarity was flabbergasted at this delusional woman, she furrowed her brow and said "You kidnapped me, drugged me and tied me up because you're in love with me?! That isn't love, that's sickness! That's obsession! You clearly need mental help and if I pull a few strings I can get you the medical attention and therapy you need! Just let me go!"

Moondancer went "No Rarity, I don't need help, I need you... you must belong to me..."

Rarity gritted her teeth in anger and said "Well I won't be! Not now, not ever! I don't want to be yours and I never will want to be yours, so please release me! If you want money I can give you money!"

Moondancer climbed onto the bed with her legs either side of her idol's body and stared at Rarity in the face with a death glare as she said "No, I don't want your fucking money... I want you to be with me for the rest of our lives, we belong together... you say that you don't want that for us... but you will......"

Moondancer started crawling towards Rarity's torso, Rarity looked down at this predatory woman and confirmed that she wasn't wearing a strap-on, she did indeed have a fat and stiff cock attached to her body, as real and natural as her own pussy. Moondancer continued to speak "Oh Rarity... I'm such a big fan... I've bought every magazine you've ever been in, I've taped all of your TV appearances, I've even made a little shrine in my living room! Not to mention that I've bought every single bit of lingerie you've ever modeled, you should start wearing some of them once we're having regular sex with each other..."

Rarity was sweating in fear as she floundered for reasons why she should be set free and said "People will realize I'm missing! They'll come looking for me and arrest you! If you let me go right now though, I won't tell a soul and I won't press charges! I swear! I won't even demand a restraining order! I'll grant you a VIP pass to see all of my photo shoots!"

Moondancer chuckled and said "It's tempting Rarity but why would I want that when I can have you all to myself right here for more than just some teasing photography sessions? By the time people figure out you've disappeared you'll already be mine, so even if they found you, you wouldn't have me arrested anyway because I'd be your lover..."

Rarity couldn't think of anything else she could possibly use to barter with her captor, especially when said captor sat down on her chest. Moondancer waved her cock back and forth in front of Rarity's face and said "You see my genitals? They're the real thing you know, it's not a magical addition, I was born with them. This is how I came into this world, it's my own flesh and blood... my balls are swollen and filled with cum, my dick is so hard, pulsing and erect... and it's all for you Rarity. I'm so turned on right now and my body is preparing itself for you... you're my everything Rarity, aren't you happy that I want you so badly?"

Rarity stared at the tip of Moondancer's cock as a bead of pre-cum bubbled to the surface, a good minute passed before Rarity stared up at Moondancer and angrily growled at her "If you bring that thing any closer to my face I'll fucking bite it! Don't test me bitch! I'll do it! I swear!" Moondancer was getting tired of Rarity's continued attempts to escape their destiny together, all Rarity had to do was realize that being forced to love Moondancer, or at least develop Stockholm Syndrome, was what was best for both of them. Moondancer got it, why was it that Rarity didn't understand yet? Moondancer embraced the challenge of course, it was always more fun and rewarding to work hard for what you wanted and the only thing she wanted was Rarity.

Moondancer deadpanned and said "Rarity... you've always been a smart woman so please don't disappoint me now"

Rarity, quick as a flash, just went "Ah! You see! I'm not the one for you! I've disappointed you as a sex slave already! Imagine how much more disappointed you'll be the longer this continues! May as well spare yourself the heartache, cut your losses and let me go!"

Moondancer gently grasped Rarity's neck, not enough to choke her but enough to be threatening, shortly before whispering "I'm not fucking stupid Rarity, stop resisting this and it will all go much smoother for you. Now, you're a smart woman so think about this for a second... I'm a woman who has knocked you out and taken you prisoner because of how much I love you... if you decide to hurt me, anger me or make me fall out of love with you... do you think that will end well?"

Rarity thought for a moment, if Moondancer was crazy enough to get violent in the name of love, there's no telling what she might do in the name of vengeance. Rarity shook her head and replied "No... I don't think that would end well... I'm gonna have to at least slightly accept this to some degree if I want to remain safe, right?"

Moondancer smiled, her love for Rarity rekindled as she said "Yes Rarity, correct as always, just let this happen and I promise we'll soon be in each others arms, willingly and forever..."

Rarity swallowed her pride and, for the time-being, just let Moondancer do whatever it is she wanted to do. Moondancer shuffled forward and started rubbing her warm and heavy nuts on Rarity's face, using her to cock to pat her cheeks and forehead and smearing pre-cum on her soft and sensitive skin. Rarity groaned in mild discomfort, this kind of sexual practice wasn't uncommon, it was a man's way of asserting dominance over his mare and the mare's body would in turn equate the submission to sexual pleasure, thus preparing both of them for intercourse. As an independent woman, Rarity often had a spell that cancelled out the effects of such a thing and usually let her sexual partner do it just for the sake of being generous, though without her magic, her body was feeling the effects full force for the first time.

Moondancer continued to breath heavily as she grinded, swiveling her hips harder to get her balls to make as much contact with Rarity's face as possible, now actively slapping her with her cock and coating her features with her seemingly endless stream of pre. Rarity just took the demeaning and humiliating treatment as gracefully as she was able while the pleasurable sensations in her body sky-rocketed, at this rate she wasn't sure that she'd have the power to stop herself from having an orgasm, it was during this period of conflicting feelings that she wondered why she hadn't let any stallions do this before, this felt incredible! Moondancer gasped out "Oh Rarity... this is like a dream come true, you have no fucking idea... oohh we're gonna be so fucking happy together! Just me and you! Loving each other always! You and I can finally be together forevermore just like I've always wanted!"

Rarity was struggling to keep her composure, if she tried to close her eyes and not think about what was happening then her mind focused on her impending climax and if she opened her eyes so that she didn't think about it so much, then her vision was just impeded by the presence of a pair of sweaty nut sacks, a fat and veiny wang striking her across the face and leaving sticky pre marks everywhere and the strong, raw and pure masculine stench of musk. A musk that addled her brain, dulled her cognitive functions and made her hair stand on end from the absolute flood of dopamine and constant signals to every pleasure sensor in her body. Rarity was caught in between two sexual experiences she hadn't consented to and was constantly shifting back and forth between the two of them, unable to decide which was worse so that she could choose the lesser of two evils. Then suddenly... it hit her...

Rarity's orgasm hit her and hit her HARD. Out of nowhere, Rarity's cunt convulsed and started gushing her female fuck fluids, all but ruining her panties from such an unexpected and out-of-the-blue climax. Rarity moaned whorishly, inadvertently being treated to a taste of Moondancer's junk as it still stroked and smothered her face throughout. Moondancer pulled away and looked back to where Rarity's now transparent panties clearly showcased what could only be a twitching vagina at the tail end of the throes of ecstasy. Moondancer actually blushed as tears welled up in her eyes and said "Oh my goodness.... you came... because of me! I made my Rarity cum and she was cumming for me! I made her cum! She loves me! She really does love me so much that I'm the only person in the world who can make her feel good enough to cum! This is the best day of my life! I knew we were meant to be Rarity! See? I told you! There's no way I could make you cum unless it meant that you and I belong with each other! You get it now right? It's fate! We were always meant to be together just like I said!"

In her excitement, Moondancer jumped off of the bed and practically ripped the soiled panties from Rarity's body so the she didn't have to untie her legs just yet. Then Rarity witnessed what was surely the most depraved and repulsive thing she had ever seen as Moondancer brought the panties to her own face and breathed in deeply as she rubbed the wet cloth all over her face, Rarity almost gagged as this radical fanatic breathed in her scent and even moistened her own face with her orgasmic juices. Moondancer shuddered, this pair of panties she was smelling and rubbing on her face was even better than the last pair because it was actually drenched in Rarity's love liquid, not to mention that she was the one who made it happen!

Moondancer tossed the panties away and went "OK Rarity! This proves it! We're meant to be lovers! I always knew it and now you know it too! Now I can finally do what I've always wanted to do! Rarity... I'm going to make love to you..."

Moondancer got back on the bed in between Rarity's legs and pressed the tip of her dick to Rarity's quivering folds, as Moondancer tried to ease herself inside Rarity, she heard Rarity sobbing as she whimpered "This isn't love-making... this is... this is rape..."

Moondancer leaned down, pressing her breasts up against Rarity's as she brought a hand to Rarity's cheek for comfort then whispered "Not for long..." before engaging in a passionate kiss with her, a kiss which Rarity reciprocated if only for the sake of comfort. Moondancer heaved her hips forward and penetrated Rarity's yielding cunt, the walls stretching to accommodate Moondancer's impressive girth, the tip of her member kissed Rarity's cervix as she bottomed out with her nuts resting comfortably on the fashionista's smooth buttocks. Then Moondancer started fucking.

Moondancer wasn't a stranger to sex, before her infatuation with Rarity she had enjoyed the occasional fling with a couple of girls at her college who were sluts that didn't mind taking dick from another woman, there were even one or two guys who were still into her after learning about her unique condition and weren't hesitant about paying a little attention to her rod, beating her off, blowing her and even taking it up the ass on the odd occasion. Similarly, this was not Rarity's first rodeo either, she'd bedded a few guys in her day and had dipped her toe into the waters of the girl-on-girl world during the experimental years of her life, though this was different.

It was different for Rarity because she hadn't volunteered for this sex, so despite enjoying all the familiar things like kissing, the filling sensation of a raging erection and the clapping of balls on her ass... it was somewhat tainted by the fact that her innocence was being taken rather than her giving it up willingly to a partner. It was different for Moondancer because she was fucking Rarity... the only novelty of this union was the identity of the person, the owner of the hole she was currently defiling, the sex with Rarity could have been the worst sex in the world and she still would have loved it because she was claiming Rarity as hers. This woman who she had obsessed over and masturbated to more times than she could count was finally hers, was the sex terrible? No, it was fantastic but that was just a bonus, the cherry on top of the cake, the cake of kidnapping Rarity and forcing her into a relationship that she didn't want and had been against from the start. It seemed romance was still alive in Equestria.

The squeaking of rusty bed springs and the clapping of flesh carried on for several minutes, Moondancer kept up a consistent thrust pattern as Rarity's love tunnel squeezed the phallic intruder, her muscles clamping and clenching in an effort to tightly grip the cock that was being pounded inside and effectively milk it for its seed. Moondancer got goose bumps as she felt the walls of Rarity's cunt rippling across her length as if begging to be filled, the sensation of their breasts rubbing together and the vibrations she felt whenever Rarity involuntarily moaned, unable to truly deny that despite not wanting the sex initially, it was still a sexually pleasurable experience no matter how excruciating and traumatizing the circumstances were.

Rarity was approaching yet another climax and was secretly hoping for her peak to arrive quickly, if she was trapped here then she might as well at least try to make it more enjoyable and there wasn't something more intense and powerfully wonderful she could think of than an orgasm, other than for her suffering to end of course. Unfortunately Rarity never got her wish, when Moondancer felt that familiar feeling in her own groin that signaled that she'd soon be blowing her load, she immediately pulled out of Rarity and broke the kiss, denying both of them their finish. Rarity, looking somewhat heartbroken, looked at Moondancer with mascara stained tears rolling down her cheeks and said "Wha... why'd you stop?"

Moondancer smiled, Rarity had clearly said that because she didn't want Moondancer to stop, Rarity wanted her! Moondancer said "Don't worry, I just want to change position, that's all!" Moondancer felt confident that Rarity was accepting the undeniable and inescapable fact that they were made for each other and untied her legs from the bed and was glad to see that Rarity had the good sense not to try and thrash around in an effort to kick her. Rarity yelped as she was suddenly flipped over, her face pressed against the mattress and her butt stuck out as Moondancer roughly coerced her to kneel instead of lying flat. Moondancer got into position and slammed her cock all the way back into Rarity's nethers with one hand on her hip and the other holding onto Rarity's head, after they had both gotten used to the feeling of being connected again, Moondancer leaned down to Rarity's ear and whispered "Remember Rarity... I'm doing this because I love you, OK? I know that you'll love me the same way if you just accept it, I want that so much for you... for us. So I'm going to keep doing this until you're mine, you need to be my mare, it's the only way we'll ever be happy..."

Moondancer finished her final speech and began thrusting again, getting back into her natural fuck flow with Rarity beneath her who, whether she liked it or not, was along for the ride. Moondancer fucked Rarity for hours on end, day after day, never being truly sated. The breaks from the fuck sessions were very few and lasted fifteen minutes at best, they mostly consisted of food, drink and the special magic-dulling mixture that Moondancer had concocted and yet, to Rarity's knowledge, nobody had noticed her absence yet.

Prologue

"OK Rarity, just drei more pictures und zat vill be it for today!"

Rarity smiled and said "Of course darling, how do you want me?" It had taken a while for Rarity to adjust to her new part-time career, it wasn't often that she dabbled in the more sensual side of the fashion world but modelling lingerie for her long-time friend Photo Finish had turned out to be more thrilling than she had expected! She certainly hadn't expected to be quite so popular either.

Photo Finish went "Hmm, I zink you should be facing avay from ze camera zis time, ve haven't done many shots zat show off your supple buttocks und zis particular outfit draws plenty of attention to zem!" Rarity giggled and turned away from the camera with her juicy rear on display, for one pose she simply stood there with a smirk on her face whilst looking back at the camera, the second had her bending over whilst she looked back at the camera with her tongue out and the final one had her sticking out her rump on all fours while she looked back the camera biting her bottom lip.

Photo Finish beamed and said "Vunderbar! You make lingerie look so super zat I'm surprised i haven't bought any of my own! Zough if I were homosexuell I'd certainly have you out of zem as soon as possible!"

Moondancer couldn't agree more.

Epilogue

This cycle had continued for about a week and a half by the time Rarity was mentally broken, her perception of the situation became warped in her mind to a point where she had begun actively asking Moondancer to have sex with her. By the end of the second week, Moondancer was sat on the edge of her bed groaning, with Rarity on her knees in between her legs, sucking diligently on her cock and forcing herself down until her nose was pressed into Moondancer's crotch despite the fact that choking herself on every inch of the turgid fuck pole made her gag.

Moondancer grunted and said "Shit babe, I'm about to cum... get ready for your photo shoot!" Rarity wrenched Moondancer's cock from her throat and expelled it from her mouth in a hurried manner as she used both hands to pump Moondancer's member. Seconds later, Rarity was treated to a thick and heavy facial, at least half a pint of spunk had been fired out of Moondancer's cum cannon and every last squirt had landed on Rarity's face. Moondancer panted as she picked up her phone and took Rarity's picture, a cock in her hands and a face covered in jizz, Moondancer let out a breath and went "Phew... I'm the happiest and luckiest girl in the world..."

There was a pause before Rarity went "No... you're wrong..." which was a worrying statement, had she reverted somehow? That worry was put to rest when Rarity smiled and said "I'm the happiest and luckiest girl in the world"

The End

Author's Note

Thank You Tailsic for this story idea! I hope you enjoyed it :)