The Supreme Judge

by Mylittleponyfan21

Rating: teen
Tags: Discord, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Death, Comedy, Starlight Glimmer, Crossover, Twilight Sparkle
Length: 1043

What if most powerful Creppypasta also takes the souls of Twilight and Starlight for what they did wrong?

What if the The Supreme Judge, the most powerful Creppypasta of all Creppypastas also decides the final destination of ponies' souls? That's what Twilight and Starlight to find out.

This is a sequel to Twilight and Starlight Go to Hell, by ThePinkiedWonder, credit to him/her.

Published 2023-04-30 18:20:00 UTC
Last updated 2023-04-30 18:20:00 UTC

Here we go again.

Right after Twilight and Starlight revived by Princess Celestia, they thought of much processes that they thought from the beginning, Twilight was just as glad as she can still hold a book again, although she was kind of angry with Starlight for that accident that kill them.

"Twilight, no matter what happen, I'm sorry for what I did that cost our life's, I didn't knew that it would happen." Apologized Starlight.

"Nah, don't worry Starlight," said Twilight as she smiled. "I know you didn't do it on purpose, it's just that, I was quite egoed that I didn't knew that books are not that important for me."

"Don't worry Twilight." said Starlight. "What matters is that we are now here, alive on Equestria. Because if it wasn't of Princess Celestia, we wouldn't be back to life and still be in, you know the rest."

"Yeah." said Twilight. "And I'm also sorry that I got egoed about books, it's just that without them, I wouldn't be the egghead that I am now, I hope you understand."

"I know what you mean." said Starlight, "They also made me be powerful in Equestria, of course, way before you redeemed me and me be socialist before that you did to me."

"Yeah, I said the Friendship is the most important thing in Equestria, and look how ironic I am, caring over about books instead of our friends." said Twilight.

"Let's forget about what happened and relax that we're now back at the castle. hehe." chuckled Starlight.

They went to the library where the incident happen, the later spotted a bottle from the failed experiment, Starlight throws it away far so the incident won't happen again.

Twilight on the other hand, picks some books and hugs them, knowing that she can now touch them physically. "So obsessed with your books?" asked Starlight.

"Well, it was just that I miss them reading them, of course, before I knew that they don't mean more important of something material." said Twilight. "I just wanna read them."

"Go ahead," said Starlight. "I also read some with you and clear my head about the situation."

Twilight and Starlight were reading some books that they got, at least they found something to clear they're head from the situation they went thought.

But then, Twilight grabbed one book fro the shelf and spotted a bottle of a weird liquid inside of it, Twilight with her magic grab it carefully. "what it this? she asked.

"I don't know, and how did it get here?" said and asked Starlight.

"I don't know, I hope that Spike didn't put this, and whatever it is, we can't let the same happened again." said Twilight.

When Twilight started to walk with the bottle, the tripped to a book, causing her to fall down and let go of the bottle, when the bottle slammed to the floor, the glass broke and it caused an explosion all over the castle.

It passed like 5 minutes, and Twilight and Starlight woke up, and got shocked after seeing that they were spirits again. Starlight was the one who got angry this time. "Twilight, remember when you said about 'small mistake'?"

"Uh yeah?" answered Twilight confused.

"Well, your 'small mistake' killed us both this time!" yelled Starlight angrilly. "Now we're spirits again, and you can't not hold a book again!"

Twilight realized that she was now the pony who goofed up this time. "Oopsy, hehe."

"Oopsy? You even got deliciated and angry at me when I made that mistake, and look how ironic you are. What the actual hay is wrong with you?" said Starlight.

"Well, at least I didn't do it on purpose, I tripped over a book and this happened." cried Twilight angrily

"Mine it was also an accident too, I just let it go the bottle and made an explosion too, so don't be to innocent about it." defended Starlight angrilly.

"Alright fine, I got your point Starlight!" cried Twilight. "I can't not deny it, you made the mistake first, and now I made it now, are you happy."

"Totally." said Starlight, causing the groan of Twilight. "by the way, where are we?"

Later they realized that they weren't in the castle floating over their dead bodies anymore with everything messy all over the castle by the explosion, but in some kind of black limbo floating, where aside of it, was various multiverses creating and destroying by itselves, or at least that's what Twilight and Starlight think.

"Uh, Twilight, what is this place?" asked Starlight nervously.

"I don't know." said Twilight. "I think we're in some kind of black void or something."

Suddenly, they realized that they weren't the only ones, they soon saw a line of other ponies souls and spirits going to a red and blue shawning light, causing the confusion of Twilight and Starlight.

"Twilight? where are those ponies going to?" asked Starlight.

"I don't know, and why are they're heading towards that light?" said and asked Twilight.

"Should we put ourselves in the ponies souls and spirits' line?" asked Starlight.

"I guess, we should, just in case everything goes wrong." said Twilight.

They put themselves in the line behind, where our ponies' spirits and souls appear out of nowhere behind them, they saw some particular and knowed ponies in there too.

"Hey," said a random pony. "whatever you do, don't do anything that makes him mad."

"Who do you mean?" asked Twilight "you mean the de-"

"Don't mention his name here!" interrupt the pony.

"Why not" asked Starlight confused

"I can't explain now, we have to stay still in the line and bow to him, otherwise will suffer the consequences,"

Twilight and Starlight were confused about it, but at the same time worried for what will happen, they know that it won't be like the last time, but as soon as the light has shawn and reveal itself as, that's where Twilight and Starlight got nervous and saw that...

The trial has just be begone.

Author's Note

I know it isn't much that I've put, but I decided put here because I felt that it was appropriate to make the story more interesting and leave you guys more intrested for more.