Andy was incredibly nervous right now. Never before in his life had he met someone so interesting as Sunny Starscout before. Before meeting her, he always thought that his sisters and his mother were the most gorgeous mares he had met in his entire life... And then, Sunny arrived. And things completely changed on a dime.

Since the very first moment he laid eyes on her, he was entirely into her. It wasn't just that she was pretty, of course. In fact, after meeting her better, her beauty was just a big plus. Andy loved Sunny's energy, optimism, smile, and giggles... Gosh, how much he adored her giggles.

Her curiosity was also another quality he adored from her. It simply was never enough for her, and whenever she had a question related to the Pegasi culture, Andy joyfully answered it.

The fact that she's pretty much the reason why everypony came together and why magic returned to Equestria only made his love for her grow. Yup, he was definitely in love with her, even though that kind of messed up his relationship with his sisters and mother because it's been six months since magic returned... and he pretty much stopped having sex with them ever since. Crazy to think.

Either out of fear for Sunny (or his new friends in general) finding out or simply because his love for her told him that he had to stop doing such a wrong thing.

It was hard to believe that it could be that last thing because he never cared for morals or if it was right, so... what changed? He couldn't tell at all, but he was sure that he was so in love with Sunny that he actually chose to stop having sex with his family.

He knew pretty well that he was a hypocrite right now because a year ago or so, Andy promised his mother that he would never put her nor his sisters aside if he ever got married... And now? He was in love and didn't want to pound his own family anymore because of her.

"... Why does it have to be so frustrating?" Andy muttered to himself with a frown.

He was lying on a wall of a random shop, watching Sunny from the distance as she peacefully worked on her Smoothie Stand in Maritime Bay.

Andy came over to watch his sisters, even though Pipp streams almost everything she does in Maritime Bay. Still, he decided to come over because of Sunny. He wanted to ask her out, but he was incredibly nervous and didn't know where to start.

He had never been in a relationship before, and I don't think I even have to explain why, but still: Andy always thought that his sisters and his mother would be enough to satisfy him... And here he was, struggling to ask out a girl he liked. Ironic, in a way.

Of course, it wasn't a big deal, but he didn't want to screw things up. He wanted to ask Sunny out and, hopefully, bond more with her. He had no sexual intentions; he wanted to know more about Sunny. Heck, he could be happy with answering more questions to feed her curiosity if she wanted. As long as he could be with her, he didn't care.

Still, he wanted to find the right words to say so he wouldn't look like an idiot or like a blushing mess since Andy tended to do that a lot around Sunny because he really liked her. He was surprised that neither of his sisters teased him about his silly little crush on their new friend, probably for the better.

So, with a deep breath, Andy nodded to himself, and he started walking slowly towards Sunny's stand as she waved her hand with a smile at a customer. That last gesture made Andy's heart melt, and his face was already red, but he shook it quickly and managed to keep his cool as he resumed his walk toward her.

"Hey there, Sunny!" He greeted her with a smile.

Sunny noticed him, and her smile grew, making Andy's heart melt again. "Hi, Andy!" She greeted as well. "What brings you here to Maritime Bay?" She asked with a smile.

"Oh, you know. Mom's sending me as my sisters' bodyguard." Andy replied with a little smirk as he leaned over the stand's counter. "Although, with Pipp streaming daily what she does around here, she doesn't really need me around..." He pointed out.

"Fair enough!" Sunny giggled, and Andy smiled unconsciously at the sound he adored. "So, can I serve you something? Or are you here just for a talk?"

"Actually, I came here because... W-Well..." He started to sweat nervously, blushing embarrassed and scratching his right cheek as he looked away from her. "A-Actually... I was looking at you..."

Sunny felt her heart skipping a beat and her face blushing slightly after he said that. "M-Me?" She asked, pointing at herself with a finger.

"Y-Yeah..." He replied, now looking at her as his blush increased, which also increased hers. "Look, I was thinking that, in order to know each other better, maybe we could... y-you know, hang out?"

Sunny felt her heart rising wildly at the idea, and she immediately zoomed from her smoothie stand to stand right beside him. "Y-You mean, l-like a date?!" She asked with sparkling eyes as she also excitedly grabbed his arm.

Andy ignored how the heck she got out of her smoothie to stand so fast and, instead, simply smiled at her as he nodded his head. "Y-Yeah! I mean, if you want it to be a date, I-I don't see why––"

However, he was abruptly interrupted when Sunny pulled him over and kissed his cheek, which made his blush increase in levels it never did before, to the point his skin stopped looking blue, which caused Sunny to giggle again since she noticed his reaction. Her giggling made Andy realize how much he was blushing and smiling.

"I-I'll love that, Andy..." She said with a warm smile that melted his heart again. "How about you come back when I finish my job?"

Andy felt his blush decreasing, although it didn't leave, and he smiled at her warmly. "It's a date, then."

"R-Right... a date," responded Sunny with red on her face. Andy also laughed nervously as red formed on his face before zipping away.

Today, Andy discovered he has so much more in common with Sunny than he ever thought. He could barely believe she loved escape rooms as much as he did. Like, he knew she was a curious girl, but he never expected that her first pick for their date would be an escape room instead of a fancy restaurant or something like that.

Maybe he hangs out too much with Haven and Pipp to believe every girl wants that, but no... Sunny was actually a really simple girl. And you know what? He really liked simple better than something fancy.

They both had a blast in their escape room and whenever they deciphered a clue together, they felt so incredibly happy and like little colts jumping over a candy.

He also discovered how much Sunny likes those carrots that pretended to be hot gods. He never learned their name, but he could perfectly understand why she was obsessed over them: the texture, the flavor, the feeling on the mouth... It was like a little pet to his soul, and he really loved it.

Besides the escape room? He also discovered that she loved karaoke. It wasn't an activity he liked to do every single time, but he did like it too, so he accepted Sunny's invitation to sing along with her, and he could tell that she sang pretty well in general. Now, he would probably cross a line here, but he could swear that she sings better than his sister. Don't tell Pipp that, though. She's going to be really jealous.

After that, they only walked around Maritime Bay for about two or three hours, talking about random stuff. Of course, Sunny did ask a few more questions about pegasi culture, and Andy replied gladly. However, he also decided to ask some questions to Sunny about earth ponies' culture in Maritime Bay, and she replied with a smile.

It was a great date because they had fun and got to know each other better. Yet, Andy made a last risky move, so he asked her if she wanted to watch a movie in his apartment that he kept hidden so nobody could bother him. Sunny immediately accepted, although she did leave a message to Izzy about staying over with Andy in case her staying with him got longer than she could expect.

Andy's apartment was pretty simple, to Sunny's surprise. It wasn't a bad thing, of course, but... she expected him to live in a place that looked like a literal copy of a suite in a castle since he was literally a royal prince.
Instead? His apartment was very simple and small, with a large brown couch, a TV, a small kitchen, a bathroom, a bed, and a closet.

Thankfully, it had a lot of space so she could move around freely, and the fact that he was very organized with his stuff also helped a lot. Haven clearly taught him well because he was also a gentleman since he offered her to hang her red hoodie once they entered to place. However, she was still surprised that he grew up in a very fancy place, yet he chose to live in such a simple apartment. It probably made her very happy because Sunny couldn't help but smile and blush at the idea of someone so rich and spoiled being such a gentle and sweet person. Her feelings from earlier and while solving the escape room returned to the Earth pony as she tried to hide them from the royal prince.

After a while, they decided to watch a comedy movie to finish their date, but they could barely pay attention to it because they just kept looking at each other repeatedly. They immediately looked away, though, but still... they were so happy and comfortable with each other that, at one point, they locked eyes and couldn't look away.

"... You know, Sunny?" Andy called out suddenly. "I'm sorry to say this all of a sudden, but... You are beautiful..."

Sunny felt her heart skipping a beat for the millionth time today, and her face blushed entirely. "A-Andy?!" She said nervously and embarrassed. "W-Why do you say that so suddenly?!"

"W-Well... Y-You are beautiful, Sunny..." He replied nervously, looking at her again. "I... I actually have been thinking that ever since I met you..."

"... Ever since... Ever since Izzy and I were dragged to the castle?" She asked with sparkling eyes, although her blush only increased as well.

Andy gulped and simply nodded at her. "I... I really... Sunny, I––"

However, he couldn't speak because Sunny grabbed him from his scarf and pulled him closer, locking her lips with his, which startled him entirely. However, he didn't try to pull away since he really liked the sweet taste of Sunny's lips, so he kissed her back.

At first, it was a very shy kiss because it seemed to be Sunny's first one, but once Andy wrapped his hands around her hips, Sunny's confidence got a massive boost. Soon enough, she kissed him more healthily and caringly as she wrapped her arms around his neck while Andy lay on the couch and Sunny lay on top of him, with her breasts pressing against his chest. However, Andy didn't get any excited at that touch since he was too busy enjoying the sweet lips of his crush. To Andy, Sunny's lips were like heaven. He couldn't describe how they felt. It was like... biting into a peach: delicate and supply, juicy almost to the point where he thought juice would dribble down his cheek, and sweet, so very sweet.

Unfortunately, the lack of air finally separated them from their kiss, so they looked straight into their eyes. Sunny was... shocked, confused, and surprised by what she did, while Andy was beyond happy that she decided to do such a thing, and everything he did was calling her beautiful.

"... I-I'm so sorry––" Sunny tried to say, but Andy cut her off by locking his lips with hers again, and while it did startle Sunny at first, she smiled and decided to kiss him back.

Once they broke their kiss, Andy looked at her into her eyes. "... Sunny... I don't think there's going to be a better moment for me to say this, but––"

"I know." Sunny interrupted him with a shy smile. "And... I like you too, Andy... Ever since you decided to escape with us..."

Andy's heart was racing a marathon, and his cheeks burned like never before. He definitely blushed many times when he kissed his sisters or mother, whether it was a romantic or passionate kiss... but with Sunny, it simply felt different. It felt... so right... And he loved how she tasted.

Sunny? She was beyond haven right now. She dreamed a lot about this moment but never thought it could be so perfect.

And trust me, it was going to get better.

Sunny unconsciously moved one of her hands from his neck to his chest before slowly moving it downwards until she reached his crotch, as she started to rub it while Andy moaned in surprise, although he didn't try to stop her.

Sunny grinned once she felt a bulk growing over, so she quickly put over her knees and zipped his pants down, and then pulled them away before pulling down his boxer as well, and then felt his mouth watering as Sunny stared at his 15-inch member standing tall and proud, as she immediately grabbed it and started to move her hands up and down, fapping his cock while Andy started to moan, both startled and pleasured.

"O-Oh shit..." He said as he looked down at Sunny and smiled at her. "I-I didn't expect you to have such a dirty side, Sunny..."

"You shouldn't blame me..." Sunny said with a smirk. "Zipp and Pipp are always talking about how big and wonderful this thing of yours is... I really needed to try out myself."

However, those words startled Andy, who opened his eyes wide after Sunny mentioned Zipp and Pipp. "W-What?! You... Y-You know that we––"

"Yeah, Izzy and I know about your secret..." Sunny confessed, although she only started to fap him faster, which made him moan even more. "Don't worry, though. Even if I have liked you since we met, I don't think that's weird. In fact, now I don't understand why they always showed your member off... and honestly? I do not blame them!"

Andy felt relieved that Sunny was okay with him doing this kind of stuff with his own family... And yet, he was still a bit concerned, although he decided not to think too much about it since right now? All he wanted was to feel Sunny's insides, as he's been dreaming about it for the past six months. And it seemed Sunny was too.

"Hmm... I think you're ready..." Sunny said with a grin before standing up and removing all of her clothes, while Andy did the same thing with his scarf, shirt, and jacket.

With both of them entirely naked now, Andy opened his wings and carried Sunny in bridal style, as Sunny squealed a bit startled but still smiled as she held herself close to Andy's chest.

Then, the pegasus carefully placed Sunny over the bed, now staring at her marehood and touching it with his hand, making Sunny moan in pleasure. At the same time, she was also incredibly wet already.

"A-Andy..." Sunny called out with a shy voice. "C-Could you please go for it already?"

Andy felt a bit startled when she asked that. It wasn't that he didn't want to do it; of course, he wanted it! But... He also felt startled and worried when he saw that she was incredibly tense after he rubbed her pussy.

"... Sunny... T-This is your first time, isn't it?" He asked with concern.
Sunny looked away from him, but a nod was all he needed to feel even more worried now.

His erection was still growing, but... He was now conflicted about what to do: Take her virginity right now, even if she seemed to consent to do it, or stop before he did something he'll regret forever...

"Andy... J-Just goes on..." Sunny pled suddenly. "I-If you want... Go inside me slowly..."

Her beg startled him at first since he still didn't want to go in and hurt her, but after she suggested going slow... the heat returned, and he nodded in agreement.

So, unwilling to make her wait anymore, he introduced his tip slowly, as Sunny moaned in pain while slowly introducing his member inside of her.

Of course, a trial of blood soon came out of her pussy, and even if Andy already knew that it was a normal thing, just seeing Sunny covering her mouth as some tears fell from her eyes crushed his heart.

Still, he decided that the best way to ease her pain was to keep moving, so he slowly started to move his hips back and forth while half of his cock penetrated her pussy, as Sunny occasionally moaned in pain.

However, after a while, her moans switched from pain into pleasure as she finally started to like the feeling of Andy's cock going deep inside her walls. Andy, now feeling more excited and relieved since Sunny was enjoying this, decided to grab her before he lay over the bed, with Sunny now on top of him.

But that movement made his entire cock go inside of her pussy, although Sunny didn't seem to mind because her moans became louder and happier as she moved her hips on her own. Now Andy was occasionally moaning at the feeling of Sunny's walls. She was even tighter than his sisters, which wasn't a surprise since she was still a virgin just a few minutes ago... but honestly? He could tell he already had a new favorite.

As Sunny kept moving her hips, Andy sat down and grabbed one of her breasts, as he started to suck it and lick her pink nipple while Sunny's moans just became louder and happier. He also used his other hand to play with her free breast and nipple, which only made Sunny moan in more pleasure and bliss, pulling out her tongue, also burring her fingers in Andy's hair.

Andy started to suck over her breasts even harder and desperate, also moving his hips even faster and harder as well, with his cock now reaching her womb and entering entirely on her pussy, which only made Sunny moan louder and louder. At the same time, she could also tell she was reaching her climax, and judging by Andy's grunts; he was also close.

He pulled away from her breasts and locked lips with her again, desperately licking her tongue. At the same time, Sunny passed her hand over his hair and chest as she kissed him and licked his tongue back, also desperate and still moaning in bliss and pleasure as she felt Andy's 15 inches penetrating her.

They finally broke their kiss and moaned together. "S-Sunny... I-I'm going to––"

"D-Do it inside!" Sunny immediately shouted after Andy said this, not daring to pull her sight away from him. "Fill me up, Andrew! M-Make me yours!"

That was all that Andy needed to lock lips with her a last time, trusting his cock deep inside of her a last time, as they both reached their climax and moaned together in between their kiss.

Sunny felt in haven as Andy's cum filled her womb, and she was blushing more than she had ever blushed before in her life. Andy also felt incredibly happy since he managed to connect with the mare he was in love with, and he enjoyed every second of it, even if it didn't last as long as he wanted.

Perhaps he was losing his touch, or perhaps the fact that he didn't have sex in the last six months made him lose part of his experience. Either way, he didn't care because he was so happy that the first time in such a long time was with Sunny.

She slowly pulled away from Andy's cock, and it came out of her pussy with a 'plop' sound, and Sunny lay right beside him as his cum came out of her pussy because of his huge load.

"... T-Thanks for that, Andy..." She said with a smile, locking eyes with the pegasus prince.

"Anything for you, Sunny-bunny..." Andy replied with a smile as they locked lips again for a second. "So... I know this is going to be a stupid question after what we did, but––"

However, Sunny covered his mouth with a finger and smiled. "Andy, I would love to be your girlfriend... But only if it's more than just having fun in bed..."

Andy felt his heart skipping a beat and his face blushing again, which made Sunny blush as well. Still, he allowed himself to smile, so he leaned to kiss her lips again with pure love and care. "I wasn't planning on doing this with you yet, Sunny... But you seemed excited so that I couldn't say no. Still, I want to be with you because of who you are... I want to be with you because I love you, Sunny..."

Sunny felt her heart skipping a beat, and she kissed him again on his lips too. "I'm in love with you too, Andy Speed... I love you... More than you could ever imagine..."

Andy smiled at her after that. "And I love you too, Sunny Starscout."

And that's how their night ended, with the two lovebirds cuddling together and kissing. Of course, they did go for another round of passionate and romantic sex before finally falling asleep, hugging each other with smiles. It seemed this was the start of a loving relationship between them.

Author's Note

I apologize if you feel these chapters more rushed and less detailed or intense than the ones on the previous story, but I didn't wanted to repeat the exact same things, so that's why they are a lot shorter now.

Also, thanks to Sora21 for editing this chapter's mistakes.