Accidental Love

by CrimsonEquine

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Twilight Sparkle, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Other, Romance
Length: 1882

Twilight Sparkle meets the love of her life who was somepony she did not expect.

Twilight Sparkle is lonely, no pony around her is up to the challenge of dating her.
So she does what anypony would do and joins a dating program.
The rest is not what she expects.

Published 2023-05-22 13:00:02 UTC
Last updated 2023-05-22 13:00:02 UTC

Accidents happen

Twilight Sparkle stared at the large building. It had a huge purple sign on it. The sign read the words, “Dating Pones” on its front. She knew that this was a bad idea. Something Spike had told her to do. Yet, she wanted to go through with it. Even though meeting a pony like that was weird to her. She just couldn’t find anypony to get along with. Twilight didn’t know why no pony wanted her. She had a few ideas as to what caused this. They were too scared to court a purple pony princess maybe. Or the fact that she was the apprentice of Princess Celestia herself. Well, all this lollygagging in the past didn’t help her get with somepony. She needed to take a leap of faith and try something different. This would probably be her second chance after all. There was no pony who knew who she was here. That was made sure of with this slight magical disguise. No pony would notice her wings behind this well made long skirt. It had ribbons and covered her entire waist.

Twilight walked down the concrete floor and pressed her hoof on the long red double doors with a circular window on the top. Inside, a green merengue mare sat at the guest allocator. The mare didn’t look at Twilight until she hoofed her a card.

“Go to the door on your left Mrs. Sparkle and your date will be waiting for you” she said with a low but quick tone. “Make sure to put on a smile while you're at it, it helps stallions be intrigued with you”.

Twilight Sparkle gave a quick smirk and then went her way to the room on the left. There, she sat on one of the two single chairs and placed her tired hooves on the purple round table. It had two glasses of water on each opposite end, the said stallion nowhere to be seen.

The microphone that had glue below its metal body had a square shaped frame. The speaker began to crack with noise before a mare’s voice spoke through.

“This stallion was chosen by your qualifications and likability, by the questions you answered online, please welcome the best love you’ll find” it said with a static before it quieted after a loud screech.

Twilight shook the chair a bit as she sat. This stallion had to be the perfect candidate, since Dating Pones uses a state of the art A.I. to calibrate the best qualities for matches. There was no way that this date would turn into a dud. And from the looks of things, the stallion she met sounded strong from the heavy hoofsteps he emitted. She could hear him get closer and the excitement shocked her core. Even if this whole situation was nerve racking and something desperate ponies with no love life would do. There was a allure to the fact that their qualities would be brought together by science. A fact that she couldn’t stop shaking her body over.

A white stallion walked into the booth. He smiled and shook his mane as he sat on the seat. To his horror, he noticed that her face turned from an excited smile filled with glee to a nightmarish frown that spread across her face. Her eyebrows heightened to the top of her head. Her skin wrinkled from the realization at who the stallion was.

“Did I do something wrong?” he said as he sat down on his chair. “My name is Shining Armor, its nice to meet you”.

Twilight watched in despair as the pony she was paired with was her own brother, who was married as well. She froze and gasped; this had to be a mistake. The results matched her with somepony who was related to her and was to be the perfect match. There was no way that this was a mistake unless this A.I. was somehow wrong. All of this couldn’t be real, maybe it could be all faulty.

“Eeeep” said Twilight Sparkle. A shock to her head made her notice that Shining Armor didn’t see her as his sister. Whether the disguise was working or this whole situation was wilder than she had thought.

“I’m sorry, did I scare you?” said Shining Armor as he lifted his hoof up towards his face and showed his pearly whites. “Was it my devilish good looks, or the fact that I’m such a attractive specimen?”

“Aren’t you married to a Princess of Love?” said Twilight. “Don’t you have a daughter with her too?”

Shining Armor looked down on the table and gave out a deep breath of carbon dioxide. He was caught so he shook his head while his body slouched. There was an expectation that there was a secretive aspect to all this. He questioned how she knew him, but guessed it was his status as the leader of the royal guard. There was no turning back at this point. All he wanted was to avoid more damage from this crazy adventure. Maybe it was best this never happened.

“I’m sorry but, this was a bad idea, maybe I should just leave” he said with a low tone. “Sorry for wasting your night, I need to get back soon anyways”.

A loud smash hit the table. As Shining lifted his legs up, he paused and turned back to notice the mare with a wide grin.

“No wait, I haven’t come all this way just for you to leave” she said. “Why don’t we give this a try and you can give me an answer to this over a hayburger or something?”

He paused and felt a shot of energy flow though his chest. There was a unique opportunity heading his way. All he knew that whatever happens, he might get what he wants. It didn’t pan out in a entire way, but at least this would go better than what was thought.

“Really, you would go out with a married stallion?” he said.

Twilight raised herself and walked down the pathway towards the double doors that lead outside. Shining Armor walked behind her with a fluttered heart and shaky hooves. There was a magical allure that this mare gave out. Even if they just met, he eyed her and felt a rush of power he hadn’t gained in a while. This would be what he needed to forget things.

They went to the nearest hayburger place down the street. Inside was the incredible scent of hay being seared in a high heat. It caressed the senses as the hot steam carried itself through the air. There was no pony to be found cept the waitress and the cooks behind the stall. It must've been a slow night for them. A typical diner spot with rounded tables and chairs with pictures of old Equestrian celebrities on the wall.

“So why cheat on your wife for?” said Twilight while she scratched her chin. “It seems weird to break off with a bombshell like her with a filly born too”.

Shining Armor looked down with a gaze that would split atoms.

“Its because she has become enthralled In her work at The Crystal Empire and we have barely any time to get together, and she refuses to accept anything less, and I believe she might be cheating on me”.

Twilight Sparkle sighed, “why would she want to cheat on you for?”

“I didn’t believe it at first, but it is apparent now that she was just using me to get more power and be closer to Celestia too”. He lowered his head and rested it on his hoof. “She was actually a agent of Sombra the whole time, but I haven’t the proof to show for it except for what I saw her speaking to one night behind a magic mirror”.

Twilight opened her mouth and let out a big grunt at the ramifications of these claims.

“No way, I don’t believe you, this can’t be”.

Shining Armor contained his mane with a pass of his hoof through its strands. To tell this to a random stranger whom he went out with made things even more awkward.

“I know this was sudden, but I feel so betrayed that I went ahead and wet my mojo again to see if I can find somepony who wasn’t going after me for power or status, but it seems that my reputation precedes me ”.

Twilight grasped his hoof and clenched it tight.

“I understand completely, no pony else except you could understand, let me show you why I’m here in the first place”.

From her horn, a red aura circled around her before the entire body was its usual purple self. It vaporized the deceitful colored mane and ribbons on her body to show her large wings, and everything else.

“Twilight!?” yelled Shining Armor. “But how is this possible!?”

She giggled and then pressed her lips deep into Shining’s own.

“I’m as surprised as you are Shiny, it must be fate or a match made to perfection”.

“But, Twilight, we may be perfect for each other, but you are my sister, oh screw it”.

They kissed and exited the diner, ready to express their love through any means. A unhinged need to breed, the final testament to their willpower of decency. They strode into the nearest motel and began their passion without a second left.

Shining Armor pressed his teeth on to her ear. Twilight screamed a high-pitched squeel as Shining’s cock peeled away her marehood’s flower. It penetrated deep and a warm pressure squeezed him hard. The flesh walls pulsated and squeezed with all their strength.

“Oh Shiny, your cock belongs to this mare now, this little naughty mare”

She pressed her lips on to his as she made a loud moan. The fat thickness smacked her womb.

“Why did you ever choose that mare over me, I don’t care if I’m your sister, rut ME!”

Shining Armor felt his member being squeezed, it was impossible to not enjoy his sister. Like a wild animal, she rode him with fast pumps on his cock, each hump was met with a fat squish that motivated her to ride even harder than before.

Shining smacked Twilight’s fat plot which caused her to yell. Her buttcheeks shook in erratic ways from the force.

“Shiny, your cock is so big, I’ve had enough with rules and regulations, give me foals now!” she screamed. “If you can give that whore Flurry Heart, you can give thrice as many to me, aww yea”.

Shining Armor stuck out his tongue to which Twilight shared with her own. A tongued kiss filled with saliva and heat.

“Oh man, Twily, your riding me so hard, I’m gonna-aah!”

He shot a loud, thick gurthy blast of seed that made Twilight scream at the force to her loins. His eyeballs went out of control as the warm pleasure branded his brain with love. The semen came out of her and drenched her hind legs, the bed they were on, the television, and the closet stained with unholy essence. It overfilled her that her grin felt strained across the ends of her mouth. They both slept covered in semen, with wacked out facial expression on their faces.