The Mane Six Scat Orgy

Chapters

Chapter 1 - Twilight's Turn
Chapter 2 - Applejack's Turn
Chapter 3 - Rainbow Dash's Turn
Chapter 4 - Rarity's Turn
Chapter 5 - Fluttershy's Turn
Chapter 6 - Pinkie Pie's Turn

Chapter 1 - Twilight's Turn

Author's Note

Hi hi! Hope you all enjoy the beginning to this very fun commission~ If you want to see more, consider subscribing to my Patreon! The whole story is already uploaded there, all six chapters:

https://www.patreon.com/kitokito1?fan_landing=true&view_as=public

Or commission me! Just send me a message and we'll discuss the details!!

If you want to see more of my work, check me out on Furaffinity: https://www.furaffinity.net/user/toiletlover55

Chapter 1 - Twilight's Turn

It was a late night in Ponyville, the moon hanging high overhead, every light in every house dark, the streets empty and silent. Every pony had likely gone to sleep hours ago - only a select few would be active at this hour…

…and it just so happened that six of those very ponies were inside Twilight’s castle.

Twilight and her friends all sat in her bedroom, chatting away by lamplight, only a soft glow coming from the single source of light to chase off the shadows of the night. Twilight, Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, and Pinkie Pie all sat around that very lamp, sharing stories and anecdotes, all giggling with nervous excitement over the topic of that day’s meeting. They just needed Rarity, and they would all be ready to begin. Already, they could hear stomachs gurgling and growling, ponies fidgeting in place, holding back their loads of waste.

“Twilight, are you really sure you wanna do this in your bedroom?” Applejack posed, tilting her hat up a tad. A few scuff and dirt marks from today’s work on the farm marked her hooves - she hadn’t concerned herself much with cleaning up before this, considering she was about to get quite a bit messier than any amount of work could make her.

“It’s fine - I don’t mind the smell, really.” She floated a teapot to her cup, filling it with hot black tea, adding a cube of sugar before downing it all. It was less that she didn’t mind the smell, and more that she actually quite liked it - her fantasies would be much more vivid if she could smell that wonderful, disgusting scent. “Has anyone heard from Rarity? She’s usually one of the first ones to arrive at these things.”

As if on cue, the bedroom door gently creaked open, a magical shine surrounding the knob. Following it was Rarity, her head low to the ground, a slight blush on her cheeks. “Sorry I’m late, every pony - I’ve just been a bit… hesitant about tonight’s plans.” She wore a purple hat with a wide brim, a white feather tucked inside.

“It’s okay, Rarity,” Fluttershy spoke, her voice soft and sweet. “You don’t have to participate if you don’t want to - you shouldn’t force yourself to do something that makes you uncomfortable.” Her blush was even worse than Rarity’s - she was surprisingly on-board with today’s actions, though still considerably nervous.

“No, no, I do really want to try it, even if I am a tad trepidatious.” Her hat floated up and landed on a corner of the bed frame, her horn glowing as it did so. Her beautiful hair now flowed freely, brushed to perfection. “The thought… well, it does get me quite excited.” She bashfully turned her head away, a small smile appearing on her lips.

“That’s more like it!” Rainbow Dash piped up, laying on her back, an adventurous grin on her face. “Now, come on and give us the details, Twilight - I’m dying to get started! I stuffed my face with as much junk food today as I could fit just for this moment!”

Pinkie Pie giggled. “Me too! I ate so many sweets we had to close Sugar Cube Corner early!!” She bounced up and down, somehow just as active at night as she was in the middle of the day. Probably from all the sugar. “And my stomach feels all gurgly and rumbly!”

“Seems like everyone is ready to go~” Twilight stood, grabbing a piece of paper from off her desk - one of the many scattered throughout the castle, filled with papers neatly arranged into stacks. “So, we’ve all been gathering to try some new stuff with our bodies a few times a week for a while now, and today, we’re going to do something much… dirtier than usual, at Fluttershy’s suggestion~”

Flutter blushed much harder, covering her face with her hooves. “Oh, I didn’t think you would tell them it was my idea!” She giggled, biting her lip.

“Well, well~ Not who I would’ve expected, but that just makes me even more excited~” Rainbow Dash flapped her wings, flying to her feet.

“Here’s the details. Today, we’re doing a scat orgy - all of you have held in your shit the whole day, just for this moment, and things are going to get very messy. Just to make sure everybody gets a turn to be the one being shit on and the one doing the shitting, we’re going to take turns, round-robin style. We’ll roll this die to decide who goes first~” She grabbed a cube off the desk, balancing it on her hoof. She assigned numbers one through six to each pony. “Whoever wins gets to be the first user, and they get to choose their toilet. After they finish, the current toilet becomes the user, and chooses the next in line. Any objections~?”

Assenting chatter waved through the room; each pony stared with excitement at the die, waiting with bated breath for it to finally be cast.

“Alright, here we go~” She tossed the die to the ground, watching as it tumbled across the carpet, each pony’s eyes glued to it fervently… and it landed… on number six. “Ah, it’s me!!” Twilight tapped her hooves against the floor in excitement, knocking the die to the side, magically floating the lamp off the ground and hanging it on the ceiling to make space. “Thank goodness - I’ve been holding this in for days! Celestia’s been making me practice holding my bladder and my gut back, since you have to do it a lot as a princess, though I’m starting to think she might just like to see me desperate. Either way, I’ve gotten pretty good at it, and my load today is going to be monstrous~”

“And for my toilet, I’ll start with… Applejack~” She pointed a hoof at the orange pony, who tensed up in surprise, eyebrows rising. Twilight beckoned her to come closer. “I want someone who already knows how to get dirty~ I’m gonna smear your mane until I’ve stained it a whole new color~” The unicorn’s heart thumped out of her chest, her outward confidence only slightly concealing her extreme horniness. Her back legs shook as she walked to the middle of the circle, her tail wagging, face beat red. “Come on, don’t make me wait - you have no idea how hard it is to hold all this back!” Her exasperation leaked through her tone.

“Hehe~ Alright, sugar~” Applejack walked with a certain swagger, her dominant aura and self-confidence palpable to every pony in the room. She was the clear dom of the group, right above Rarity when she was more in her element. “It’s far from my first time playing in the ‘mud,’ if you know what I mean~”

Twilight’s horn glowed; the earth pony’s eyebrows rose as she found her hooves being swept out from under her by a magical wind, quickly falling to her side on the floor. Thankfully, the hard floor had recently been covered by a fluffy carpet… a white carpet. “Darlin’, are you sure this rug was a good choice for this occasion?”

“More sure than I’ve ever been~” Twilight walked to the center, turning around and holding her ass above Applejack’s face. “Our little bit of fun today will just make it that much more special~”

“If you say so~” She tried to move, but found that her limbs and neck were restricted, as though she’d been chained to the ground. Just as she noticed these, light appeared around her hooves, purple light, the same type that currently surrounded Twilight’s horn.

“No moving - I want you to stay right where you are~” She chuckled, tilting her ass down, getting nice and close, inches away from directly sitting on Applejack’s head. “I’ve been calculating the perfect angle for this all night~ I’m going to make sure you’re smelling my waste for days~”

Applejack chuckled, with both excitement and nervousness; her slit leaked with femcum. “Y-you aren’t even going to let me jill off, T-twilight?” The bondage made her feel significantly less in-control… and she liked it.

“Some pony else can take care of that~ Right, Fluttershy~?”

Every pony’s heads turned to the usually calm and reserved pony, who was currently gently vibrating with overflowing horniness. “Oh, I thought you’d never ask! Hee hee!” She trotted to the middle of the circle and rubbed a hoof against Applejack’s back, petting her like a dog. “I figured I’d get a little revenge for the time you lassoed me at the farm and used me like a urinal pony~ Not that I minded, though I did ask Twilight to do all of this~ A little taste of your own medicine, right, ‘sugar~’?” She giggled, leaning down and giving Applejack a cute kiss on the cheek.

“D’awh~ Well, now that I know what you’re into, don’t expect to leave the bedroom with just piss on your fur next time I get my rope around your hooves - I take after my farm animals with my fecal matters~”

“I look forward to seeing it~” They shared yet another kiss, getting lost in each other’s eyes for a moment…

“Alright, alright, you two are an adorable, disgusting little pair, get on with it!! I wanna see some action!” Rainbow Dash’s wings were fully erect, one hoof already inside her slit, ready to get busy.

“Alright, no more delay~” Twilight sat down on Applejack’s head. “I hope you don’t mind if I start with a bit of gas, toilet pony~ When I was a foal, shining Armor used to leave the room every time I let one out cause they were so bad, and they’ve only gotten worse~ Since you work on the farm all day, I bet you’re the only one who could handle them without passing out~”

“I live with Big Mac, Twilight - just try me~”

“Here it comes then~ Remember everyone, safe word is ‘alarm’ - don’t be afraid to use it, we’re all friends here. You might need it in a moment, Applejack~” She relaxed her lower body, finally letting go days of horrible tension. “Here it comes~”

Immediately, a monstrous, repugnant fart rung out, the sound of an out-of-tune tuba emerging from Twilight’s ass as her cheeks vibrated. She looked back at Applejack’s face below her, wearing a mischievous grin. Immediately, the earth pony gagged - it was horrible. It smelled like spoiled cheese and milk, like a barrel of fertilizer made from cow dung, like the latrine on Sweet Apple Achres after a big harvest. Her nose shriveled, her head spinning for a moment, the smell practically toxic. And it was hot, too, humid, almost wet, rushing past her with surprising, tormenting speed.

“Dear Celestia, that smell is a-abhorrent!” Rarity spoke, but her words and actions didn’t align - the dress maker sat on her behind, legs spread, drool dripping from her mouth, hearts practically beating through her eyelids as she rubbed her clit.

“Never thought you’d be the type to enjoy something so rude~” Rainbow Dash sprinted over to Rarity, getting behind her, putting her arms underneath the unicorn’s armpits and pushing her own hoof out of the way so the pegasus could rub her off instead. Simultaneously, she hugged her close from behind, their warm, fuzzy coats of fur mixing, body heat trading.

“Oh, my, Dashie~ I didn’t expect you’d be so good with your hooves~” She chuckled, her legs shaking in pleasure. “But slow down a little - I just have to see this next bit~”

“Ah, that felt so good~ It didn’t take becoming a princess to learn to hold back my gas, but still, it just gets so much more hot and disgusting the longer I hold it in~” She raised her ass to get a look at Applejack; her mouth hung open, eyes hazy. “Doing alright, Apples? I’d hate to stop before we even get to my actual load~”

The earth pony shook her head, forcing the horny, toxic fog from her brain. “I’m just perfect, Twilight~ But you sure do have a mean bit of wind in those thighs~”

“It’s more than just wind, Applejack - you’re gonna find out exactly how bad it can really be. You might wanna hold your breath for this next one~” Her legs loosened; Applejack listened close, freezing in both fear and desire as she heard the very wet sound of shit sloshing through Twilight’s asshole. She stood up on all hooves once again, raising her tail up into the air. “Here it comes~”

The lips of her tail hole stretched open, wet sounds of greasy shit sliding against her fleshy hole echoing into the room. Everyone fell silent, listening as closely as they could, watching with baited breath, as her cheeks parted. Her hole stretched like it was made of rubber, Twilight groaning in slight pain from the feeling, as a nasty brown log peeked through. “Sweet Celestia…” Applejack stared up at it, close as could be, smelling the horrid scent of shit from her position already. She gulped, closing her mouth and bracing herself; her pussy felt more slick and needy then it had that whole night so far.

Fluttershy was similarly entranced, though she was sure not to let it distract her too much. “Rarity, could you use your magic to lift Applejack’s bottom left hoof?”

“Ohhhh…” The dress maker was speechless at the beautiful sight ahead of her; only a quick hoof tap on the snout got her to pay attention to the yellow pegasus. “Oh, yes, of course, dear!” Her horn glowed and the hoof lifted, making it so Applejack’s legs were spreading apart, giving Fluttershy easy access to her slit.

“Thank you, Rarity~” She gave the dressmaker a quick peck on the lips - a kiss from Fluttershy was always a treat, for any of the mane six - and she layed on the ground, putting her head between the earth pony’s toned, muscular thighs, closing her eyes and gently beginning to lick her flesh, starting shallow. Her eyes still stayed focused on Twilight’s ass, though she did take note of how Applejack’s tale flittered and wagged in response, her legs following a similar movement.

Although, she was a bit too focused on the imminent threat of the boulder about to land on her face to take a look at whoever was pleasuring her at the moment. She began to feel small and helpless, imagining this was really what it was like to be a toilet for a princess - her mind only briefly wondered to what Celestia’s shits must be like if this was one of Twilight’s. Though, she didn’t have much time for errant trains of thought.

Twilight moaned and groaned, pushing as hard as she could, until finally, she felt it began to slide. The unicorn let out a sigh of relief as her shit began to really pour. Applejack quickly closed her eyes as it rushed closer, shivering in lust and disgust as it finally fell across her snout, and continued to pour out.

Twilight felt like a weight was being lifted off her shoulders, panting like a happy dog as she shit out her massive load, legs shivering with delight. It was a large but incredibly slimy log, splatting down, perpendicular to Applejack’s snout. It felt so greasy, so wet - it was the kind of shit that was absolutely going to leave a stain, that would take hours to wash from her fur… and she was going to have a lot to wash off. The first log was a good ten inches, drooping down on both sides, almost falling apart, only a bit of texture visible over the grease. And with that, the damn had broken. Log after log quickly poured from her ass, each one landing right on her face, little drops of brown splattering all over with every impact, Twilight even lifting her ass a bit to make them fall even further. Each one was big, suited for royalty, at least an inch and a half; they began to pile up in moments, a mountain of shit burying the poor toilet pony’s face. Her nose inhaled nothing but that shitty scent and gas-filled air, her lips coated with brown like it was lipstick.

“Ah, that feels so good!!” Twilight said, rubbing her clit as she shit, biting her lip and watching the whole thing through her legs. She moved a bit further back, making sure to let some logs stream down her mane, hitting her hair and sliding off of it, greasy shit sticking to it like glue. “That’s gonna be a nightmare to clean~ Maybe I should make it a little easier on you~” She stepped further back, pointing her pussy at Applejack’s head, then letting out a trickle of urine, golden, befitting of a royal pony, hitting the shit-pile and streaming down. Some logs slid off from the force of the current; she made sure to soak every bit of Applejack’s face that she could actually see, anything not already covered in slimy brown. She made sure to give particular attention to the lips, giggling to herself as Apples silently stuck her tongue out for a light taste of that strong, bitter liquid. And of course, she made sure to drench her mane, her golden shower streaming down every thread on her head, matching the color perfectly.

It was amazing.

Applejack couldn’t form a coherent thought; her head just swirled in a mire of horniness, the disgusting scents blending together to make her feel woozy, like she’d been put under a spell. She felt so full of pleasure and lust, her whole body shivering - she felt like she was already on the verge of an orgasm without even needing to touch herself, like an angel was eating her out. Once it seemed that Twilight had finally stopped, she gently opened her eyes, only to realize that Fluttershy was currently hard at work doing exactly what she’d been imagining - the shy mare was snout-deep inside her pussy, licking her clit down with all her might. Twilight laughed, turning around, pointing her slit, and pissing right on Fluttershy’s head - it was too cute of a scene to leave completely clean. It didn’t stop the pegasus for even a moment; she just blushed harder as the warmth soaked into her fur, wrapping her hooves around Applejack’s ass and holding her tight.

“M-mmph, m-my, T-twilight,” Applejack’s voice stuttered rapidly, her pupils spinning, looking to Fluttershy eating her out, to Twilight pissing on Flutter, to all the shit piled on her snout and on the ground before her, knowing there was so much more she couldn’t even see. “Y-y-you- AH!” She moaned, a violent shake running from her head to her tail as she orgasmed, squirting what might as well have been a liter of sticky, translucent, milky femcum all over Fluttershy’s head, accenting the already-present piss in her fur. The pegasus held her head there until it had all come out, happily being covered in every bit as her tail fluttered behind her, eventually pulling back and squealing in glee.

Applejack huffed and panted, trying to regain her breath to speak, absolutely exhausted; she soon felt the weight of the magic binding her hooves to the ground lifting off her. Slowly, she began to move again, pulling herself back up onto all fours, letting the logs of shit naturally fall off her head as she went upright. They slid down her fur and hair, leaving streaks of hazelnut in their absence, spilling to the ground, a few losing their form and devolving into a pile of soft manure. She shook her head a bit, causing a few other pieces to fly over the room, Pinkie Pie catching one on her lips - she licked it up and swallowed before anyone noticed, the bitter taste making her want to throw up immediately, somehow exciting her despite the painful gulp.

“Feeling alright, Applejack?” Twilight asked, still smiling, though showing genuine concern for her friend. “If you need to take a second before you take your turn being the user, we can always wait a little bit - that was a pretty intense load, after all~” Her words curled smugly into the air, her pride at the massive shit clear.

“Oh, don’t worry about that~” Applejack spoke, grinning, lust on her cheeks. “I will admit, that load could probably rival some of the livestock at Sweet Apple Acres, but I’m not one to go down so easily~” She rubbed a bit of shit from her brow, flinging it to the ground with a decisive flick of her hoof. “Though, you’re payin’ my water bill for the amount of time I’m gonna be spending in the shower after that one~”

Twilight chuckled, floating her tea cup back over to her mouth and taking a sip - cold, but caffeine was her lifeline. That shit had taken a bit out of her, more than she wanted to say. “Whatever you say, Applejack, though I wonder how I’ll explain using that money from the royal coffers to Celestia. I can’t even imagine how she’d react to learning that one of the elements of harmony spent all that money on water to get shit out of her mane~”

“Hehe! I think it would be a hell of a lot more interestin’ to see how she looks when she finds out it was her star pupil that put it all there~”

“She might not be as surprised as you may think~” She gave a cheeky wink before taking a look around the room - her ass was covered in slimy residue, and she didn’t want to let it get itchy. Her eyes soon settled on Applejack’s hat; her magic floated it into the air. “You have more of these, don’t you~? Mind if I use it to clean up~?”

Applejack bit her lip. “Go right ahead~” She had more, of course, but if Twilight meant what Applejack thought she meant, this one would be going in a special place.

“Great~” She leaned forward, sticking her ass in the air towards the group so they could all watch as she magically wiped the hat through her ass, leaving brown skidmarks over every bit - the rim, the top, the sides, she wiped and wiped and wiped, even turning it inside out to get as much use from it as possible. By the time her ass was even slightly clean, the hat was ruined, covered in shit, a much darker brown than it had previously been. “Eh, good enough.” She hovered it over to Applejack and let it fall on top of her head; the earth pony looked up at it lustfully, pulling the rim down a tad to get a better smell.

“Mmm~ Not what I was expectin’ to go home with today - I’m gonna have a rough time hidin’ this from the other apples. But, more importantly, I think it’s my turn to let out what I’ve been keepin’ in for so long~” She turned to the other ponies. “Now, who’s ready for a little taste of what I have cookin’ back there~?” Her eyes scanned the participants, each one seemingly eager as all the others to get a taste. “Hm, hm, hm~ Maybe Fluttershy would look a bit better with a brown blush instead of a pink one~”

Fluttershy giggled, hiding her face behind her hooves, tail thumping against the ground.

“Well, I think I’ll be able to do that to you easily enough just by catchin’ you peekin’ at me at the farm again - better be a little more stealthy next time, unless you wanna leave with a way bigger mess~” She winked to the pegasus, making her swoon, falling back; Pinkie Pie quickly caught her, using the opportunity to hug her close, wrapping her front hooves around her yellow fur and holding her head against her pink chest. She didn’t resist, enjoying the warm cuddle.

“Oh, oh!!” Rainbow Dash hadn’t moved her hoof a bit since Twilight had really started shitting, only pleasuring Rarity the smallest amount before sprinting out from behind her, tapping her hooves excitedly. “Pick me, pick me!!” She smiled wide, showing her teeth, her excitement clear.

“Rainbow Dash, huh~? Lookin’ to add a new color to your rainbow, I see~” She chuckled, stepping back, motioning to the formerly white, now yellow and brown, carpet. “Step right up, sugar, and try to contain your excitement - you’re about to get fertilized like one of my crops~”

In a flash of multi-color light, she was there, laying on her stomach like a cat, tail waving in a similar way, eyes glistening with bright, excited energy. Rarity quietly pouted to herself - she’d never been touched by a pony quite as well as Dashie had rubbed her in that moment.

Applejack turned around, her tail lifting, spreading her legs out, one hoof on each side of Dash’s head. “Ready, sugar~? I’m not holdin’ back a bit~”

“Yes, yes!! Come on!!!”

And so, the fun continued; the night’s affairs were far from done. Still many mares to use and be used - Twilight might be enjoying the lingering smell until she finally moved to Canterlot.

Chapter 2 - Applejack's Turn

Applejack stood with her hooves to either side, shit still stuck to her fur and tangled in her mane, even a few logs sitting on top of her head. The whole room smelled of urine, farts and pony logs, an overwhelmingly gross scent, mostly coming from Twilight’s rear so far, though now, it was time for Applejack to throw some into the mix.

“Ready, sugar~? Hrngh…” Applejack groaned; she could feel her body getting desperate to release her stored tank of waste. She’d been holding it for almost three days, which was a lot for her, considering how much she had to eat to work on the farm. She stuffed her stomach at every meal, keeping her strong physique through hard labor every day, but now, her belly looked slightly bloated - she clearly needed to empty her system, and it seemed Rainbow Dash would be the toilet she’d empty it onto… or into. “I can’t hold this much longer~”

“R-ready!!” Dashie stared hungrily into the puckered orange asshole, watching as it pulsed and twitched, preparing to release what would certainly be a monstrous load of pure waste. She barely resisted the urge to lift her head and dig her snout in for a little preview, a light sniff of the contents that were soon to burst forth. It seemed like she wasn’t going to have to move to get that preview, though, as Applejack spread her legs a bit farther apart.

“Hnnrgh~” She grunted; her body gurgled, shit sloshing in her belly. “G-goodness, I think I’m gonna need to let out a little… g-gas first.” She smirked. “Guess I better make sure you can enjoy every bit of that~”

Rainbow Dash tilted her head, not quite understanding what she meant, until she suddenly folded her back legs in and sat her behind right down on top of Dash’s snout. Her nose burrowed right inside the crack of her fluffy, squishy ass cheeks without the pegasus moving an inch; she could already smell something terrible brewing inside from just that first bit of contact. Applejack was heavy - she could feel not just the pounds and pounds of muscle on every limb of her body, ass included, but also the weight of everything she’d been holding inside. “Ready sugar~?” Applejack spoke. “My gas doesn’t exactly smell like apple pie~”

“Y-yes, let it all out!!” Rainbow Dash spoke. She was really most excited about the shit, but the farting would certainly be an amazing precursor, and something about Apple’s profession as a farmer made Dashie think she was certainly in for something terrible in all the right ways. “I can handle it!”

“Alright, here it comes~” The earth pony closed her eyes, gritted her teeth, and pushed, releasing a fart like a flamethrower directly onto Rainbow Dash’s face. She felt that blast of hot, steamy gas douse her every feature, tickling her lips, rubbing her fur, even stinging her eyes. It smelled like manure, like fertilizer made from horse and cow shit, gross but weirdly natural. It was surprisingly dry, but somehow, that just made the scent worse. The pegasus wrapped her front hooves around Applejack’s waste and pulled her closer in as she sniffed up the gas and inhaled it through her mouth; she felt it fill her lungs, drying her throat, making it feel scratchy and gross; she couldn’t help but cough some back out. The scent was certainly bad, reeking of the most disgusting smells of any farm, but it was bearable, blunt in a way that she could appreciate.

She could not say the same for the next one.

Applejack’s cheeks shook like she was in an earthquake as a bomb seemed to go off in her asshole, an explosion of sound and air like a flash bomb to Rainbow’s senses. Her ears rang, her nostrils burned like she’d stuck grenades up her sinuses, she tasted actual shit on her tongue and felt her lungs shrivel inside her body. None of the other ponies seemed to get it quite as bad - Dashie had managed to inhale the brunt of it, and she regretted it immediately. The smell was horrid. Unimaginably bad. It was like Applejack had spent 10 days without showering, then rolled around in mud and fresh feces for several hours, then condensed that all down into a single cloud of gas… plus some hints of apples, which only made it more overwhelming. It was way wetter, in the most uncomfortable, visceral way, like a thick fog wetting her fur.

The farm pony stood as Applejack began coughing like she was having an asthma attack; she beat her wings in an instinctual need to escape, sending her flying straight into the air, knocking her head against the ceiling before falling right back to where she’d started. She saw stars in her eyes, the world spinning slowly around her, everything a blur as she tried to take it all in, and that wasn’t from hitting her head - that fart was like a toxin. She felt as though she’d just drunk ten bottles of hard liquor. She wanted to vomit.

“Hehe, wow, was it really that bad~?” Applejack looked down on Rainbow Dash, chuckling to herself. She was concerned for her friend, sure, but she knew a simple fart wasn’t really going to hurt anyone. More than anything, she felt triumphant and dominant - causing such a terrible reaction with a single fart felt wonderful. The many looks of awe and even envy from the other four filled her with pride. “Well, seems like you’ll need a bit of time to recover, but my gas tank isn’t empty yet~ Anypony else want to take it for a spin~?” She leaned down and stuck her ass in the air, gently waving it back and forth, her tail sticking straight up.

“Ooo! Me me me!!” Pinkie Pie’s tail thumped against the ground; she was still holding Fluttershy close in her arms. At this point, the yellow pegasus had cuddled up to the pink party pony, resting her head right underneath Pinkie’s, the earth pony holding her tight in her embrace. They both felt so warm against each other’s fur; it was wonderful. Though now, Fluttershy was starting to wish Pinkie’s grip wasn’t quite so strong.

“U-um, y-you should probably l-let go of me f-first,” she spoke, laughing nervously, a light cold sweat above her brow. Seeing that first fart had filled her with fear for Applejack’s gas. At the same time, though… she was very curious, and that fear was making her kind of excited. Well, very excited, honestly, as her tail’s wagging made very clear to everybody else, Pinkie Pie and Applejack included.

“Why do that? It looks to me like you two are set up for a two-in-one deal~” She pivoted on her back hooves and quickly aimed her asshole at the two of them like a rifle preparing to fire; she backed up, closer and closer, until the barrel was right in front of the both of them. Fluttershy squirmed, trying to escape, but Pinkie held very tight.

“Come on, Fluttershy, you know you want it~ Do it, Applejack!!” The pink pony closed her eyes and leaned forward, preparing to sniff it up, as Fluttershy stared at the ass in terror.

“Here it comes~” Like a blast from Pinkie’s party cannon, a loud, low-pitched fart rang out. The sound was like an armchair being pushed across a wooden floor but so much louder, deafeningly so, her ass cheeks flapping as the blast of warm hair hit the two of them, making their hair wave in the wind. Pinkie Pie smiled bright through the whole thing, while Fluttershy squinted her stinging eyes.

The party pony was happy to snort the gas in as it was released, and immediately, she could see why Rainbow had reacted how she did. She started coughing wildly, releasing Fluttershy and turning to the side. Her hooves shook in disgust, her nose scrunching, her lips curling; she felt like her insides had been lit ablaze. She shook her head to try and free up her foggy brain, but all she got was a spinning room. She fell to the ground like a drunkard, stars spinning around her head.

Meanwhile, Fluttershy had been smart enough to give it only the slightest smell, and then dash out of there when she was let go. Just the tiny whiff she took was absolutely rancid; her eyes watered. She scraped her tongue off with her hooves, gagging in disgust. Though, still, Applejack couldn’t help but notice the pegasus’ pussy throbbing, pulsing, getting wetter and lustier; Fluttershy herself was even surprised to find her hot pounding so heavily, her pants being of the much more horny variety, rather than a desperate grasp for air.

“Well, well~ Seems like someone enjoyed that~” Applejack paced towards Fluttershy; the pegasus began to back up instinctually, until her rear end hit a wall, only a few steps needed. She suddenly felt very cornered, only making the marecum dribbling from her pussy come out faster. “Let me make sure you get a proper appreciation for it~” With another quick pivot, Applejack turned her ass towards Fluttershy and shoved it against her head, pinning her to the wall with the soft, squishy cheeks, and she farted, letting out a nasty sound like a stack of papers being torn apart, with a fart to match it. The pegasus felt her vision go black for just a moment as the poison entered her nostrils and invaded her skull, throwing her brain into a miasma of gas; the moment Applejack stepped away, she fell to the ground, eyes wide open, limbs twitching, frozen in place as her body attempted to recover.

“Well, I won’t be too cruel~” Applejack rubbed the pegasus’ clit nice and hard; in seconds, her body was shaking like a rattlesnake’s tail, and she let out a soft moan, squirting against the wall, an amazing orgasm slithering through her veins while the horrible smell of gas infected her brain. “Hehe~ Anyways…” She looked back to the middle; Rainbow Dash had finally seemed to recover. “I think I oughta get back to business, don’t you, Dashie~?”

“Yeah, f-for sure!” She responded, a tad more nervous now. If her farts had been that bad, surely her logs were going to be something terrible. And she was correct, though not quite in the way she suspected.

“Hmm… feelin’ hungry, Rainbow~?” She pulled off her hat, still stained with Twilight’s shit - it was a bit dry now, but the smell certainly remained. She put it in front of Rainbow Dash like a bowl or a plate. “I’m feelin’ in a bit of a cookin’ mood right now~”

“...you want me to eat your hat?”

“No. How did you even come to that conclusion?” She shook her head and squatted over the hat. “I said I wanted to cook somethin’, didn’t I~? Let’s just say your dinner has been broiling in my crockpot for the past three days, and I think it’s finally ready to be served, fresh and hot~”

Dashie’s eyes widened as she looked up form the shit-stained hat and into Applejack’s asshole as she slowly squatted over it. Her form was like a dog stopping to take a shit during a walk, her four hooves all on the ground up against each other, her ass hovering above the hat, lightly shaking as the cheeks spread themselves apart. Her tail hole twitched and pulsed; she caught a whiff of the horrible scent of shit lying beyond it.

“Hold the hat up underneath my ass, would you, darlin’~? I want you to c-catch it all~” She stuttered a tad bit; this position in particular was making it very difficult to hold in.

“O-ok!” Quickly, the pegasus grabbed the hat and held it up, right underneath that plump orange ass.

“Good girl~” Dashie blushed at the degrading compliment and focused her eyes the orange, puckered hole in front of her. It gently opened and closed, each opening getting a bit larger; she could see the waste beyond it, the dark-brown shit that’d been waiting for so long to make its way out. Her eyes sparkled in anticipation, waiting for it to finally make its way down, Apple’s legs shaking and shivering as she pushed and pushed… and eventually, it was stretched apart by a torrent of shit.

Rainbow’s mouth opened in awe as she watched Applejack lay her logs. The farm pony sighed in relief as she emptied her gut. Each one was impressive - wide, long, all having the same dark color to them, the texture smooth and hard, much less slimy than Twilight’s. The first one to drop out was a foot long, landing inside the hat and curving around it. The second was similarly large, and the third was even longer - her hole seemed to be being pushed apart just to accommodate them. They were almost as thick as the mare’s legs, far bigger than any log Dashie had ever laid eyes upon before. She bit her lip, watching the hat slowly fill up, the shit piling into a mound inside.

“My, that sure did feel nice.” She lifted her ass back into the air. It wasn’t quite as dirty as the princess’, but it was definitely deeply in need of a cleaning - despite that, she seemed uninterested in giving it one. She turned to face the pegasus, who was now holding the hat in below her face, sitting on her behind, drool dripping onto the edges of the accessory. “Well~? Aren’t you going to give it a little taste~?”

To most, the already shit-covered hat full of thick, compressed, hard logs would’ve been a very unappetizing, disgusting sight… but right then, Rainbow Dash felt like she was looking at pure ambrosia, a meal given by the gods themselves. She didn’t care about the taste at all - it was the sheer size of the monstrous logs that made her want to swallow them so much. Such an amazing load shouldn’t simply be flushed or disposed of - it deserved to be eaten. She leaned forward and gave it a little sniff - it smelled horrible, just like manure, similar to Apple’s farts, but not quite as paralyzingly bad. She gulped, picking up a log between two hooves - even though she’d fantasized about this and she was exceptionally excited, it was her first time actually eating a log of waste, and it was a tad intimidating.

“Come on, sugar, give it a little bite~ It’s just full of love~” Applejack chuckled; watching another mare eat her shit was an incredible feeling.

“M-mmmm…” Rainbow responded, gulping one more time, before finally closing her eyes and sticking the foot-long log inside. She bit down on it, pulling off a large chunk and chewing it up inside her mouth, feeling the hard log turn into mush in moments as her teeth tore through it. It was insanely bitter, reminding her of the taste of extremely strong alcohol, like vodka, and it was hot, too, but in a more warm-food kind of way rather than a painful one. As she went to swallow, she felt her body physically resisting the act, as though it was pleading with her not to do it, not to let this literal pony waste sink down into her stomach. Still, she managed to gulp, shivers running down her spine as the remnants of the log fell to her belly. It left a prickling, burning sensation in her throat; she could almost feel the slimy residue it left behind as it slid down.

And it was amazing.

Her tail thumped against the floor as she opened for another bite. Everything about it was objectively horrible, flavor, texture, aftertaste, all of it was bad. But her lust made it feel as though she was eating a perfectly cooked steak. She wanted, needed more of that amazing flavor in her mouth - it really was so full of love, just as Applejack had promised, but not in the way she’d expected.

“Oh, come on, no need to take it so slow~” The pegasus felt the pressure of an orange hoof against the back of her head; she looked up into Applejack’s smitten eyes, into her dominant smirk. “Let’s speed things up a tad~” Dash looked down to the shit for a moment, before suddenly finding her head being forced down into it.

Apple shoved Rainbow into her shit with as much force as she could, her snout mashing a hole through the middle of the pile of hard logs, leaving her face buried deep inside of it. She held her hoof down, forcing her to stay right in place, using her other hoof to gently rub herself, biting her lip. “Come on, eat it up, little puppy~ No hooves allowed, just use your head~”

“MMPH!” Rainbow Dash responded; her heart pumped out of her chest as she began slurping it up, just like Applejack commanded, happily using her tongue to pull mouthful after mouthful into her maw, chew them up, and swallow them down. She wrapped her arms around the hat and held it tight, enjoying herself immensely, soon sticking her ass up into the air and spreading her shaking legs, revealing a drip of femcum from her slit. Every log tasted so much better than the last as it slid down her throat - she soon found herself forgoing the process of chewing entirely just to swallow them, faster and faster.

“Mmm~” Applejack shivered in pleasure as she carefully slid her hoof tip against her clit. She could feel some more shit pushing in her gut, but she didn’t want to let go of the pegasus - someone needed to hold her. “Would anyone here mind holding this little pony down into the shit pile? I got a bit more I need to release, if you know what I mean~”

“Oh, allow me!” Rarity perked up; she’d had relatively little involvement so far, but she wanted to get in on the action. She held her head up, and her horn glowed with translucent blue light, the same light soon surrounding Rainbow’s hair. She used her magic to hold the pegasus in even further; to the shit eater, it felt like a huge hoof was pushing her in and refusing to let her up, like she was being stomped on by a giant, and she didn’t mind even one bit - she felt like she was a victim to the whims of her friends when it came to all this shit, and she wouldn’t want it any other way.

“Thank you, Rarity~ Maybe I’ll save a log for you after I finish up with Rainbow~”

The fashionista blushed; she found the prospect just as exciting as she might’ve normally found a kiss or something more similarly romantic. “T-that m-might be nice,” she murmured, still not quite sure how she felt about letting her fur and mane get ruined with all this dirty stuff, but still, when she imagined the streaks of brown all over her… well, the resulting pulsing of her pussy was a clear enough indication of what she truly desired deep down.

Applejack didn’t seem to hear her quite remark, though, as her attention was shifted right back to her current victim. She turned around and held her ass over Rainbow Dash, this time with her legs spread on either side of her head, much like what Twilight had done. Her tail hole began to quiver, pulsing just like last time. The pegasus had no idea what was coming, buried far too deep into her meal, though she was about to learn.

The farm pony grunted as she forced out another juicy, thick log, slowly sliding from her hole, creeping out, rubbing against her flesh with a wet, squishy sound. Eventually, it sped up, coming out faster, and faster, another foot-longer, and it fell right down on Rainbow’s head, thumping onto her rainbow hair. It was followed by more and more, raining down like a hail storm, coming out hot and steamy. It piled up between her ears, and soon, logs began to roll down the hill, onto her neck, her back, sliding off her cheeks and leaving marks, some hitting the carpet and adding to the filthy mess that was the poor piece of furniture. She released at least a dozen more logs, leaving most ponies watching stunned in disbelief. Dash felt the pressure, the slime, the dirtiness and the warmth; it just led her to eat even faster. She felt like she was being buried alive, and she loved it - she couldn’t imagine anything better than having her whole body covered in these incredible logs, put in a hole filled with them. She soon felt the trickle of warm urine adding onto it all, clearly coming from Applejack to accompany all the solid waste.

The only pony there whose focus wasn’t on the incredible earth pony’s shitting - which still continued, even after the dozen - was Twilight, who’s horn was glowing, a large, purple dildo floating in front of her face. She licked her lips, grinning mischievously, and stood up. She first fucked herself with it, fast and hard - she was already so horny; it took only seconds for her to orgasm and cover the whole thing in her juices. She didn’t let her lust fade, though; she held the slimy dildo up to her ass and made it way grosser, pushing out a small spritz of what shit still remained to cover it in a thin layer of brown slime on top of her marecum. She then floated it over to Rainbow Dash’s raised cock, pulled her tail up with magic, and with no warning, shoved the cock inside the pegasus’ pussy. She immediately began fucking her as hard as she could using the hot, slimy, shitty dildo, her fluids acting as the perfect lubricant.

Dashie’s legs began to shake far harder than they already had been, her knees buckling in moments, her whole body caught in an intense shake of passion and pleasure. It was so unexpected to be entered, but it felt so incredibly good~! And it was going deep, super deep - that dildo was at least a foot and a half long, and Twilight was making sure to get her full use out of it. Rainbow couldn’t tell what the slimy sensation came from, but she had a guess - a guess that she’d later find out was completely correct.

As the last of Applejack’s logs fell, the pegasus orgasmed, moaning out into what little was left of her dinner, covering the dildo in a new rush of milky-white femcum before her whole body went flat, laying on the ground, the toy stuck deep into her belly. The purple pony teleported it away, putting it beside her with a happy smirk. Twilight, Rarity, and Applejack had all made an impeccable team for reducing Rainbow Dash into a shivering, lustful mess of a pony, covered and filled with shit, her mind reduced to nothing but a horny mush.

“Well, well~ Seems like somepony else played a little part in getting our cute little Dashie all worn out~” She smiled at Twilight. “I might have to have you try that on me sometime~”

“Anytime you’d like~” The magic pony winked, floating the dildo into the air for a moment for emphasis. She waited for Applejack’s attention to turn back to Rainbow Dash before the magic pony started fucking her own pussy with the dildo, trying to be discreet with her own self-pleasuring.

“Let’s see… last thing to do is just to clean up in the back~” Applejack held up Rainbow Dash’s tail, a beautiful thing made with every color in the rainbow, all in bright, beautiful, vibrant colors. “This’ll do quite nicely~” She rubbed it through her ass, using it to thoroughly clean herself off, leaving the gorgeous rainbow streaked with dark-brown, knotted with chunks of hard shit. She felt quite proud to leave such a masterpiece behind.

It took Rainbow Dash a minute or two to recover enough to stick her head up, causing a few logs to fall to her back in the process. “W-wow…” was all she could muster, her head still spinning with lust and horniness.

“Had a good time, sugar?” Applejack smiled down at her.

The look in Dash’s eyes said it all. “Y-yeah,” she muttered; “I-it was a-amazing~”

“Hehe, I’m happy to hear it~ Though, it seems to me like you’re going to need a minute before we get on with it. Just take a little break, alright, darlin’~?”

“Y-yeah, I-I will.” She closed her eyes and relaxed, still just enjoying the remaining feeling of the shit on her head, letting her energy build back up a tad.

After a few more minutes, though, she was ready to go. She slowly stood, tipping her head forward and letting the whole pile of logs fall to the ground, except for a particularly big one that stuck to her hair like a new accessory. She didn’t seem to notice, but everyone could see it - nobody was going to tell her, though. Her face was completely smeared with shit all over, mashed into her fur, like she was doing makeup on her whole face; she wiped it off with both hooves, though it didn’t help that much. “I love shit and all, but this is kind of uncomfortable. Could one of you unicorns poof it away or something??”

Twilight snickered. “Sure, Rainbow Dash~ Allow me~” Her horn shimmered, and the pegasus disappeared.

She found herself teleported into a stainless private bathroom, right near the bedroom, standing right in front of a toilet. She burrowed her brow in confusion, only to find her face being magically shoved into the bowl, another spot of magic flushing it. She struggled helplessly as she was forced in, the cold water rushing around her face and pulling her snout down, the flush completing before she was teleported back, her face wet and dripping, though significantly less covered in shit. Twilight laughed. “Nothing like a good swirly to help clean off, isn’t that right, Rainbow Dash~?”

The pegasus blushed in humiliation as the others laughed, making a wavy smile; something about the way Twilight degraded and bullied her made her pussy throb just like it had last time. That unicorn was playing with her like a toy. “You’re lucky you’ve already taken your turn with the shitting, Twilight - otherwise, I’d be making sure you need way more than just one flush to clean off your mane~” Her eyes gazed around the room, trying to decide who would make for the most fun victim; it didn’t take long to settle on Rarity, Dashie’s eyes narrowing in a sinister look. “For my turn… how about you, Rarity~? I’d love to what your fur looks like with some new brown accents~”

The fashionista’s eyes widened; her face flushed with nervous lust. She stepped forward, her hooves shaking. “I-I’m still not so sure about this… w-will you go easy on me?”

“Don’t worry, I’ll start slow, at least~” Her tail waved lightly. “If you get cold feet and you need to stop, just use the safe word - you don’t need to force yourself. I’m sure Twilight would make for a fine substitute, anyways~ I’ve got some payback to give her for that little swirlie~”

Rarity shook her head, brushing off her reservations - she wanted to try this. She felt the excitement within her for this experience, for this filth, and she wasn’t going to let her fear stop her. “No, no - I want this, Rainbow Dash. Forget what I said - don’t hold back a single log! I want it all~!”

“That’s more like it~”

Everybody watched in excited anticipation. This was definitely going to be an interesting round.

Chapter 3 - Rainbow Dash's Turn

Rarity gulped nervously as she stepped onto the rug, listening to the wet squish left over from spots of piss and shit stains. Such a disgusting, gross sight; her love for fashion and the cleanliness that accompanied her focus on her own appearance clashed heavily with what she was about to subject herself to. She was somewhat of a germaphobe, honestly; it was not a great trait to accompany an interest in toilet play.

But something about that made it so much more exciting. It made it feel more taboo, more wrong… and something about that wrongness, that disgust, made her so much more lustful for it.

“Ready, Rarity~?” Rainbow Dash turned, bent over, and held her ass in the air, waving it and looking back with a smug smirk. She felt much more natural in the dominant position - she could feel confidence rushing through her. “I take the biggest shits in all the Wonderbolts, you know~ I’ve clogged the locker room toilets more times than I can count~”

“Mmm…” the white pony blushed hard as she looked at the pegasus’ ass, at the puckered tail hole, at her raised, shit-stained tail. She felt so repulsed she could vomit, and at the same time, so enticed… still, she found it was hard to move her body at all. Her legs shook; she felt frozen in place. “Oh my… I-I really do really want to d-do this, but I just feel so nervous, my body won’t even listen to me!”

“You’d better figure that out soon - my load isn’t going to wait forever~” Her stomach grumbled; there was a good amount stored in there. She hadn’t been holding it for weeks or anything, but she’d stuffed herself so much this whole day that she’d have plenty to release. “I’ll give you a little warm-up with a nice, hot fart~ Just rub your snout up against my hole and get ready to feel your nostrils burning~”

Rarity hugged; her pussy blinked thirstily, her eyes focused with intense lust. She tried to inch herself forward, but it was like she was being held in place. “Mmm… I-I-oh, why am I like this! I want it so bad~!” She groaned.

“Alright, sugar - clearly you’re going to need a little bit of help~” Applejack stepped up to the carpet, putting a hoof around Rarity’s back. “If you really, truly want to do this, but you’re too nervous to make it happen… then maybe you just need someone to give you a bit of a helpful hand~” She moved her hoof to the back of her head. “Or maybe more of a… forceful one~”

“Oh, Applejack~!” She felt herself on the verge of swooning in both gratitude and horniness. Her type was definitely more a high-class mare or stallion with a focus on etiquette and tenderness outside of bed… but in this state, she wanted to be manhandled, tossed around like a toy. “Force me to endure every single bit~! Handle me like one of your livestock~ Don’t let me escape no matter how much I struggle~!!” Her entire face went red, marecum dripping to the carpet.

Applejack chuckled. “I like this side of you quite a lot~” She wrapped a hoof around her hair, hard, getting a firm grip on the pony. “Rainbow Dash, get ready - I’m gonna shove her snout so deep that your gas is goin’ straight in her nose~”

“Hehe, come on, do it already~!” Dashie used her front hooves to spread her ass cheeks apart as much as she could, her puckered hole becoming a much bigger target.

“In you go~”

“W-well I don’t know about- OH~!” Without waiting for confirmation, Applejack shoved the pretty pony’s nose into Rainbow’s hole with surprising force. Her sensitive, well-groomed and brushed, smooth and silky snout stretched the pegasus’ arse to double its size. She felt the wet, velvety walls on her sensitive skin; she didn’t even need to sniff to get a nose-full of the horrid precursor to an incredible blast of shit. “Mmm~” She found herself already melting into it, becoming much more susceptible as it was forced on her. Still, Applejack held her inside, made sure she wasn’t escaping.

“Here it comes~” Rainbow closed her eyes and grinned wide as she released a hot cloud of pungent gas, and Rarity inhaled the brunt right up her nose, filling her head and lungs with a steamy haze of thick, disgusting shit-air. It was horrible - the smell was like burning rubber and charred meat, and the heat made Rarity feel like her snout would soon be similarly cooked. She bit her lip, shivers of disgust traveling through each part of her body, her entire face bright strawberry. Applejack didn’t move her hoof an inch; she just chuckled, happy that she was only getting trace amounts of the terrible burst of gas.

“That felt great~” Dashie moved her ass a bit, pushing it back against Rarity’s head, nuzzling her snout deep as she could get it. “How about just one more~?” Without waiting for a response, she began to push… but immediately, she could tell that what she was about to push out was much more solid than gassy. “Never mind - looks like my body doesn’t want to wait~ It’s time to bring out the main course~”

Applejack loosened her grip on the white pony, who quickly pulled her snout out. It was dappled with liquidy brown, nestled deep into her fur. “Eugh!” She groaned, shaking her head, feeling so horribly gross. “T-that was terrible!” She huffed, never having appreciated just how good it felt to breathe fresh air until now. However, her huffing was not simply from her desire to clear her synapses of the stink (which was not happening - it was sticking solidly to her nostrils). The wagging of her tail and her scarlet flush were clear signs that she was enjoying this.

“Well, well~” Rainbow Dash wiggled her ass in the air, looking at the fashion pony, sticking her tongue out, eyebrows raised. “Seems like someone’s gotten a taste for the Rainbow Dash style~ Why don’t you lay down and let me do your makeup for once~?”

“Oh my!” She backed up reflexively; her heart pounded so loud, she worried the others would hear it. Thoughts raced through her head of her beautiful purple mane and sleek white fur stained brown and yellow; they all brought with them equal amounts of primordial disgust and sensational pleasure. Her body resisted the cravings of her flesh… but Applejack wasn’t going to let her get far.

“Now, now, don’t make her wait~” Applejack grabbed Rarity’s hair once again, noting the smutty look in the white pony’s eyes whenever Apple held it so roughly. “If I have to, I’ll happily hold you down the whole time~” She quickly leaped to the mare’s side and tackled her, rolling her over onto the ground, making sure to be gentle as she did so - Twilight’s magic cushioned the fall. Applejack held her by her back as she laid on her side, wrapping her fore and back hooves around her whole body with a grip of steel. The unicorn’s legs failed rapidly in resistance, but the earth pony brushed them off like she was being attacked with feathers. “Come on, now, just calm down and let Rainbow Dash do her work~ You’re going to look as pretty as a pumpkin by the time she’s done with you~”

“P-pumpkins aren’t even pretty!!” Her flailing suddenly froze to a stop as she watched Rainbow Dash place her back hooves on either side of Rarity’s head, puckered blue asshole hovering over her face. “Oh boy…” Her eyes widened; it pulsed and twitched, something massive sitting behind it, waiting to release. Her eyes seemed to sparkle with wonder as she watched it. “B-but that might be…”

“I’m not holding back any longer~” Rainbow Dash held her tail high into the air, like a gate to a castle raising to release an army. “Hope you like the new look~”

Before she could get off another response, Dashie grunted, hole opening wide. Before the shit came rolling forth, a blast of a trumpet to announce its presence filled the whole room. The pegasus let out a startlingly loud fart, brassy, bold, and brash, everyone in the room hearing it loud and clear. It blew past Rarity’s features like a sudden gust of strong wind, her fur visibly waving in it; the smell was terrible, but it was way less condensed than the one from earlier. She was far more disgusted by the accompanying sprinkle of brown… although, she had little time to worry about that, as it looked like that sprinkle was becoming a downpour.

With a few more gassy warning shots, shit began to drip out. It was thin, the opposite of Applejack’s more compact logs, but it came fast, spooling out like rope with surprising force. Rarity squinted her eyes closed and grit her teeth as the first solid piece touched down on her cheek, followed by far more beginning to circle around her face. It was soft but definitely solid, slimy and wet, but also weirdly sticky, not sliding or moving even an inch from where it had come down; she just knew it was going to be a nightmare to remove from her fur.

“Ah, finally~!” Rainbow wiggled her ass around, moving her body, leaving her waste-rope spread all around Rarity’s face, back and forth, like she was decorating a cake with icing from a bottle. Every once in a while, she’d stop to push out something bigger, a clump of the nasty substance, splashing onto her fur, like a grenade in the midst of gunfire. Rainbow looked between her legs as she let it pile up on top of the unicorn. “See, isn’t that nice~? Think of it like a facemask at the spa~ I bet it’s great for your skin~”

Rarity would’ve loved to disagree, but there was waste sitting on her lips; the moment she opened her mouth to speak, she’d be getting a disgusting taste. Still, though, she did find it… oddly comfortable. It was hot and steamy; the dampness was gross, sure, but it was also weirdly nice. Perhaps the smell of it, now streaming right into her nostrils due to the fresh logs sitting right on her snout, was messing with her head, or maybe she was just going insane, but she didn’t want it to stop for a second - she wanted more; she was greedy for it. She loved that disgust that made her heart turn and her stomach churn; she loved the way her throat constricted in pure lustful revulsion.

Thankfully, Rainbow was happy to give her just as much as she could ever want; the pegasus pony’s stomach gurgled as she crept away from the mare’s face and began shitting down her body, slowly moving over, making sure she didn’t leave even a bit unstained. “Applejack, you’re going to get caught in the crossfire if you stay there~”

“I’m not complainin’~” She replied, smiling, holding Rarity tighter. Now that the fashionista had calmed down a little bit, she was beginning to appreciate the warmth of the orange pony’s fuzzy fur, so soft and comfortable, like being hugged by a big blanket… very tightly. Dashie’s rope-like slop trailed down Rarity’s neck, leaving a few bursts of bigger clumps before covering the rest of her body - every single day, she brushed it all to perfection, cleaned herself thoroughly, put in so many products to stay as healthy and beautiful as she could, and now, she was becoming the exact opposite, treated like a toilet pony, covered in muddy shit. She loved it so much.

“Urgh…” Rainbow held her stomach; she felt a bit achy. “Hmm… my body’s doing somethin’ weird. I think things are going to get a bit messier~” And indeed, she was correct - her shit began to lose its shape, becoming more soft and malleable, splashing into more of a puddle of soft, solid shit as it hit Rarity’s flank. She moved back up to the fashionista’s head, careful to make sure her ass stayed solidly pointed to her white fur, and eventually, she was bursting out shit like a cement truck laying cement. It slopped out of her, barely maintaining its form at all, her asshole bulging wider and narrower and wider again. “Hrgnh…” Dashie grunted, stomach grumbling louder than ever before, as a few spurts of gas exited her system. “I think my tank’s almost empty. Better make sure I get the best part~” She moved to Rarity’s mane - it had been splashed with shit already, of course, but it was nowhere near as covered and dirty as her face, or the rest of her body, really. “I always wondered how you would look if you dyed your hair~ How about we find out~?”

She leaned her butt down, getting into a position much like Applejack did when she shit in her hat, and Dashie grabbed the silky-smooth purple hair, so perfectly combed and cared for, just like her fur. She held it up to her blue ass and released a storm of sticky shit on top of it, watching as she drenched the hair in brown, quickly covering it and removing any hint of the previous purple color. She smirked as she did so, taking great satisfaction in covering every single inch, soon leaving a thick pile on top of it so that barely any strands of the mane could be seen except for ones that stuck out in random directions, all the work to make it look nice and style it being undone.

“That’s much better~” Dashie stepped back and admired her work, her asshole seemingly done with its release, but stained with very sticky clumps of brown. It would be easier said than done to get it all out. Still, she had left some toilet paper clean - she went to Rarity’s tail and grabbed it. “And now, just to wipe myself off~” She ran the lustrous tail through her cheeks, feeling soft and smooth as it glided through, catching a surprising amount of her dirtiness. She was as through as she could be, using clumps of hair to form a thick braid, soon leaving her tail almost as dirty as her mane. Her ass remained very dirty - her shit was no easy thing to clean off - but she seemed satisfied, not worried about leaving a bit of a mess and a lingering scent of shit for whoever happened to be sitting near her to enjoy.

Applejack let go of her friend and stepped back, shaking off the errant strands of shit that had hit her legs. They left behind some lasting streaks, though Twilight had made a much worse stain anyways - she didn’t mind that much. Rarity, however, was significantly worse for wear.

She slowly stood to her feet, no longer restricted; clumps of shit fell to the floor, splattering on the carpet. She shook her mane, causing a bunch more to follow, but still, her face, her hair, her tail, all of it remained covered and streaked with shit, tons of tiny logs and solid pieces nestled in her hair like glue. She tried to rub it off with her hooves, but she only managed to squish them in, leaving way bigger streaks. “W-why is it so sticky!?” She tried much harder to wipe it off; Twilight smirked, horn glowing again, but Rainbow Dash stopped her with a hoof on the horn.

“Don’t give her any help - I want her to live with her new makeover for a while~” She turned back to Rarity. “You should take a look in the mirror~”

The fashionista gulped; she didn’t love the sound of that - she knew she’d be horrified at what she saw. Honestly, she even felt she’d be better off not looking at all, but still, her head turned towards a long-standing mirror next to Twilight’s bed, and she gasped in shock. She saw herself, just how absolutely disgusting and wretched she looked from head to hoof; it was abysmal, horrid, repulsive.

But instead of being angry, sad, or anything else… she just silently moved a hoof to her pussy and rubbed it against her clit, the waste only acting as lubricant, as she silently orgasmed all over the floor, her body shivering in delight, the tiniest moan escaping her polite maw.

“I knew you’d love it~” Rainbow Dash chuckled, sitting with her hooves behind her head.

Rarity cleared her throat; the burst of horny energy had managed to clear her mind a bit. She turned to the remaining ponies and stared them down with focused eyes. “Well, now that Rainbow Dash has made some… changes to my current appearance, I believe it’s about time I do the same~” She smiled. Her choices were few - just Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy, really. “And I can’t think of anyone better than one of my favorite models~” She pointed a huff at the yellow pegasus; Fluttershy’s eyes widened. “Come here, Fluttershy - I promise you, my load will be far more graceful and eloquent than those of the ruffians before me~”

The shy pony’s lips quivered; she blushed hard, mouth slowly turning into a lusty smile as she stepped forth. Finally, it was her turn! She was way more eager than most would’ve expected - she loved the thought of acting like a toilet pony, being covered in waste, used like a toy or an object, and for other purposes, too. This was going to be a lot of fun.

Chapter 4 - Rarity's Turn

Rarity’s normally pure-white coat was now stained and drenched with viscous, chunky brown, also sticking to her beautiful purple mane. Out of all the ponies so far, she’d certainly gotten the worst of it - she looked abysmal. It was a miracle of lust that she didn’t faint the moment she glanced at a mirror. Instead, she embraced it… and looked to make a mess of a similarly beautiful pony, though one with less royal grace and more adorable cuteness.

Fluttershy’s eyes sparkled in excitement, her smile stretching across her lips as she quickly trotted onto the carpet, now so dirty that nobody would ever think it used to be white. She’d been anticipating this day since the six of them had made the plans for it - few of them knew just how much she loved this sort of filthy, kinky activity. It was a well-kept secret, until now, at least, where the clear excitement on her brow made everyone blissfully aware of just how much she was about to enjoy herself.

“Luckily for you, Fluttershy, my loads tend to be a bit more… elegant than others. It’s not quite as sticky as Rainbow Dash’s, but I don’t plan to leave your body any less dirty than my own is~ And even if you can wash it off a bit easier… I don’t think you’ll want to~” She turned and hiked up her tail, revealing her fluffy, soft cheeks; each was perfectly squishy and rounded, just enough size to excite any who looked upon it without being too much. “Lay down, and don’t move a muscle - I’ll make sure to give you a makeover that’ll look finer than any dress I’ve ever sewn~”

The pegasus’ legs shivered; she let out a squeak of pure pleasure, quickly falling to her stomach, her wings as erect as her pussy was wet. “P-please, don’t hold back!!” She requested, tail flapping left and right.

“I won’t, darling, not one bit~” Rarity hadn’t exactly planned to make a particularly big mess with her rear today - she’d eaten just as much as she normally would. Her diet was healthy as could be… though, surprisingly, it always left her with a huge load of waste. She’d normally taken it as a curse, but today, it felt like much more of a blessing to be graced with naturally huge output. She listened as her stomach quietly rumbled, preparing to spill its contents - she was going to push until there wasn’t a bit of solid waste inside of her system.

The unicorn backed up until Fluttershy was directly below her ass, her head between her legs. Fluttershy couldn’t resist turning her eyes up to admire the delicate, tight asshole, as well as the wet, puffy pussy accompanying it. The white legs began to gently shake; the dressmaker’s normally composed and polite expression slowly turning to one of concentrated effort. She could barely hold back from releasing a few little grunts and groans as her cheeks spread, her hole pulsing and beating. Soon enough, it opened, and the rounded edge of a log began to slide from it.

Fluttershy’s blue eyes widened further, her mouth agape in excitement, as it slowly made its way out, listening intently to the quiet sounds of slimy shit pushing against flesh. It slowly peaked its way out, further and further. It was a large log, wide and powerful, and it certainly looked like just how Fluttershy had imagined Rarity’s loads would. It was creamy, only slightly textured underneath the slimy coat, as though it’d been dipped in light-brown liquid chocolate. It looked just as tasty, though the pegasus resisted the urge to open her mouth and swallow it down - Rarity wanted to make her fur messy; she wasn’t going to prevent that.

It took a surprisingly long time to come out, the dressmaker soon bending her knees, sweat dripping from her forehead, as she pushed and forced it. Her horn soon began to glow, a telekinetic sheath gripping her stomach and all its contents to help move it through her; she didn’t realize it, but the magical infusion ended up making her load practically double in size. She’d never been much of a magician like Twilight - she didn’t have quite the same control as the alicorn. It was no surprise that her horniness and her desire to produce as much waste as she could manage has led to more of it filling her insides.

Fluttershy had no idea what was coming.

“Ah~” Rarity sighed in relief, closing her eyes, the tension fading as her stream of shit flowed forth. The first log, a good footlong of soft, creamy shit, plopped down on Fluttershy’s snout at a diagonal angle, covering one of her eyes which she squinted shut. It was a gross, disgusting texture, smooth and wet, making her quiver in instinctual disgust. The smell was gentle but gross, the normal scent of shit, but far more fresh and oddly humid. The log itself was quite warm, almost steamy. She gave it a slight lick, enjoying the bitter, spiky flavor on her tongue.

Another log soon followed, the unicorn relaxing much more, bending forward as it all just came tumbling down with little to no input. Each log kept its consistency and shape, all looking as if they’d been hand-molded for this, with all the care and love Rarity put into her fabric. Fluttershy found her head soon covered in five large logs, spread all across her face, only one of her eyes and half of her lustful smile visible underneath them. Still, though, the white mare was far from done.

She admired her work with the same pride as she would a finished piece of clothing. “You look simply marvelous that way, darling~ Perhaps I should be offering this sort of dressing as a new product in my boutique~”

Fluttershy was far too lost in her dreamy horny haze, the fantasies of her head all coming to life before her eyes. Pinkie Pie responded for her. “You’d be getting a lot of new customers with that!” She cheerfully stated, watching with surprising calm and patience. “I bet you’d make double what you get from your dresses in no time!”

“Hmm… perhaps I’ll have to consider putting such plans into action~” She turned and leaned her head down to Fluttershy, a smutty smirk on her face. She gently pushed one log away from the pegasus’ covered eye. “And when I do… I’m sure you’ll make for the perfect model~ If only I had a camera, I’m sure I would have income rolling in just from pictures of your adorable form~”

Fluttershy blushed, biting her lip; she couldn’t help but find the idea surprisingly hot. She imagined appearing in magazines on two-page spreads showing her laying down, her five friends’ huge asses hovering over her and covering her in filth. So many people seeing it would be so embarrassing… but so exciting, too~

“Something to ponder another time. For now, I’ll finish off my current work~” Rarity walked to Fluttershy’s side and held her ass over the pegasus’ neck, then began to shit once again, having nowhere near as much difficulty as she had earlier. Her waste plopped down into Flutter’s gorgeous pink mane, a log sliding down it and streaking a bundle of strands brown; she gave it a few more logs to make sure it was perfectly beautified, then turned, pushing her hooves into each piece and rubbing the filth deep into the cotton candy mane. She licked her lips, smearing it nice and deep, as though she was washing the hair with shampoo or some other product.

After feeling like she’d successfully dug in her mess, she stood over Fluttershy, flank hovering above her neck, and began to shit once again, slowly moving forward, leaving a vertical line of creamy logs in her wake. Each one plopped down, some staying right in place, others turning or angling themselves, others hitting previous logs and piling up on top of each other, and some simply sliding to the floor, leaving a smeared stain of brown in its wake. She produced what must’ve been at least 15 more logs - she didn’t even realize how impressive such a number was, far too focused to care. She could still feel more inside herself; her horny mind was telling her nothing but that she needed to make sure every square inch of the yellow pony was properly covered.

She magically lifted Fluttershy’s tail and wiped herself with it, thoroughly covering the pink hair with her mess, before releasing a few more logs on top of it while still holding it up, unconcerned with the fact that she’d undone the wiping. “And now, for the finishing touch~” She walked to Flutter’s left wing and raised her bottom above it, pushing out one single log onto the feathers, which were splayed out and erect, laying on the ground. Following that log was a second, third, and fourth, large and heavy, making it so the pegasus found it slightly more difficult to lift the wing - not that she wanted to. The fashionista happily repeated the process for the remaining wing, breaking her symmetry by placing five logs in her excitement.

At the end, she backed up, admiring her work as a painter examines a painting after placing the finishing touches. “Hmm, just needs a few little adjustments~” Her horn glowed; multiple logs began to slowly move, ever so slightly shifting away from their current positions to achieve Rarity’s perfect picture, leaving slimy stains in their wake. Soon enough, the pegasus had officially topped every previous pony in terms of messiness, easily the most dirty of them all.

“H-how do I look?” She quietly asked, not daring to move an inch out of worry that she might mess up Rarity’s work. Her friends answered with positivity, each one watching intently the whole time, most of them doing so with their own hooves or each other’s hooves rubbing gently against tender flesh. However, Applejack spoke up, a lusty smirk on her brow.

“I think you might be forgettin’ a little somethin’, Rarity~” She spoke.

The unicorn tilted her head in confusion. “Forgetting what, Applejack?”

“This~” Applejack stood and trotted over to Rainbow Dash, whose eyes were on the orange pony, also a little confused; that confusion was soon replaced by surprise as the farmer lifted her back hoof and let out a trickle of urine directly onto the pegasus’ nose.

“Hey!!” She responded, blushing, feigning annoyance from the sudden pitter of piss on her face. The stream ended soon after it began. “What was that for?!”

“Just provin’ my point~” Applejack sat down next to the pegasus, pulling her into a hug, which soon melded into a cuddle. “Can’t help but notice you didn’t move an inch as I let it out, sugar~ I’ll have to make sure I stay nice and hydrated so I can give you a bigger stream next time~”

Rainbow Dash mumbled something under her breath, hiding her flustered blush under her hooves, even as she wrapped a wing around the earth pony, holding her close. Applejack chuckled. “See what I mean now, Rarity?” Applejack said.

The dress maker and Fluttershy had both been giggling themselves as they watched the scene. “I know exactly what you mean, darling~” She turned her attention back to the subject, then, like a dog, lifted her left hind leg, pointing her pussy at the yellow pegasus’ face. “Hope you don’t mind a little shower, darling~”

“Not at all~” Fluttershy responded, prepping herself for the incoming golden stream. She’d begun her dirty obsession with the more liquid stuff - she still loved it just as much as the more solid variety of waste.

“Good~'' It took a moment for Rarity to work up to it - she hadn’t expected to find such difficulty with peeing on a pony - but soon enough, her stream burst forth. It was a rush of steaming piss, trickling and pattering right onto the pegasus’ head, streaming all over. It bounced off of logs and made some almost melt, sticking deeper into the fur it rested upon as her coat became damp. The temperature was wonderful, as was the view - something about the position Rarity held as she did her business was especially appealing to the pegasus. She felt like it was a stance the dressmaker could easily take whenever she needed to release her bladder no matter where she was. “Ah, that feels nice~” The stream soon dried up; not quite as impressive as her shit, but it was a wonderful accent to her work of art. The canvas licked her piss-soaked lips, enjoying the warmth rushing down her throat.

Rarity lowered her hind hoof; she still had a few logs left, though she wasn’t sure how to use them. A quick look around the room for inspiration soon left her with a realization - one of the six was missing. “Wait, where did Twilight go? I never noticed her leaving.”

As if on cue, the alicorn appeared in a flash of magic, teleporting back into the room, a camera floating before her. “Didn’t you say you wished you had a camera on you~?” She hovered it over to Rarity; the fashionista smiled happily as her own magic overtook Twilight’s hold on the technology. “As long as Fluttershy is ok with it, you can take as many pictures as you want~”

“Oh, how perfect!” Rarity had been planning to simply memorize the look of the pegasus, creating a perfect picture in her mind that she could use for her own… private purposes when she felt the need hit her late at night. A physical picture would be so much better - she’d just have to be careful not to stain it with any… fluids. “Is that alright with you, Fluttershy? I promise, nobody outside of this room will see it!”

“Of course!” She responded, her tail wagging in happiness. She smiled, a cute, shy smile, for the camera, her cotton candy blush intensifying greatly. She was absolutely adorable under there; Rarity was sure to get a good few pictures of her. She’d definitely be getting quite a lot of use out of them.

“Thank you, darling~” Rarity petted Fluttershy’s head, pushing shit aside with her hoof to make space for the gentle, warm rub. A hug may be what she’d normally go for as a show of appreciation, but… well, it wasn’t the best course of action right then. “I’ll certainly be enjoying these quite a lot the next few nights~”

Fluttershy giggled - she imagined Rarity touching herself while admiring the photographs of her. It made her very excited.

“How about one last little gift to show my gratitude~? Are you feeling hungry, dear~?” She squatted over the pony’s snout. “I’ve got a log of two left, and I’m sure they’d be quite filling~”

Immediately, Flutter’s eyes opened wide. “Oh, yes!!” She quickly opened her mouth, rolling her tongue out like a red carpet, eager to accept the delicious gift.

“Then enjoy~” Rarity’s horn glowed, lifting the pegasus’ chin up. She held her asshole barely an inch from the open maw and began to shit, letting the log slide out, going straight into her mouth, sliding off the tongue gently and smoothly. Two large, fat logs slid out, both barely fitting inside the pegasus’ jaw. “Mmm~” Rarity moaned, quivering in a sudden burst of lust. She looked at the little chocolate stains on Flutter’s lips, her messy tongue, her cute eyes full of horny pleasure gripping her heart. She suddenly felt her ability to control herself flying out the nearest covered window as she turned, dropping her head to the ground. She nuzzled her snout up to Fluttershy’s nose, booping them together; the smell was gross, but so, so good~ She wrapped her hooves around the pegasus’ head, her magic dissipating as she now used her own limbs to hold her head up, and, closing her eyes, she went in for a passionate kiss.

Fluttershy’s eyes showed her surprise, but she didn’t resist; rather, she wrapped her own hooves around Rarity’s head and quickly engaged in the makeout just as much, both of them shutting their eyes as their lips slid against each other. It was only moments before the two of them were invading each other’s maws with their small, wet tongues, Fluttershy’s own bringing with it a big helping of Rarity’s own creamy waste, coating her flesh in it and forcing her to taste the bitterness. She didn’t mind at all - if anything, she wanted more, and she soon got it. The pegasus hadn’t swallowed a molecule of the waste the unicorn had just dumped inside her - instead, it now traded between their lips, grinding into a soft paste against the force of their passionate love. It dripped to the floor, coated their teeth and maws.

Neither of them even noticed as their bodies began to move with no logical input, the animal lover rolling onto her back and the dressmaker quickly leaping over top of her. They held each other even closer, deep moaning escaping from the wet sounds of their intermingling; Rarity spread her hind legs and found herself releasing yet another log of shit, this one falling right down on top of Fluttershy’s wet, needy pussy, slimy and warm, the pegasus squirming in delight from the feeling of it. Though it was immediately beaten out by the amazing sensation of Rarity pushing her own slit onto Flutter’s, pushing their flesh together, the dressmaker humping faster and faster, mashing the log between them, not caring even a moment as it coated their privates and even slipped its way inside. Barely a minute passed before the two found their grips as tight as steel, their bodies both letting out vicious shakes as their bodies erupted in pleasure, squirts of marecum exchanging between them.

The two huffed and panted, pulling their faces apart, looking at each other with weary expressions, cuddling in their disgusting mess. The two soon felt their eyes closing, sleep overtaking them as they cradled each other, far too tired to continue being awake for a moment longer.

Twilight took one last picture. A stack of square photos sat at her side. She was quite sure neither of them would mind having a few of these… and they also probably wouldn’t mind if she were to keep a few for herself. Everybody else had been watching, enraptured by the sight, multiple orgasms spread between them aside from Rarity and Fluttershy’s own. Nothing hotter than passionate, lustful, loving horniness taking over its host and forcing them to action.

Rainbow Dash didn’t bother cleaning up her marecum-covered pussy before standing to take a look at the two of them. “I think they fell asleep,” she said, matter of fact.

“Let them rest for a little while.” Twilight magically pulled a fuzzy blanket over top of them - a white one, too. It was a good excuse to get another memento of this occasion. “We’ll wake them up in a little bit. Rarity can go back to sleep if she wants, but Fluttershy still needs to take her turn~” The unicorn turned to Pinkie. “And there’s only one mare left to be the toilet~”

“Oh, who’s that?” Pinkie said, oblivious; the stares of the other three soon clued her in. “Oh, it’s me!!” She giggled, jumping up, bouncing on all four hooves. She was practically bursting with excitement. “I can’t wait!!”

“Looks like you won’t have to for long,” Applejack said, pointing to Fluttershy, whose eyes were slowly flittering open. “Need some more time, sugar?”

“Mmm…” She rubbed her eyes, only managing to smear them with more brown. “I’m ok. It’s my turn now, right?”

“Correct~” Twilight’s horn glowed; Rarity was teleported onto Twilight’s bed, taking the blanket (and quite a lot of shit) with her. The princess was going to be avoiding washing her sheets as long as she could. “Pinkie Pie seems pretty excited about it, too~” The pink earth pony nodded rapidly; no words were needed to express her clear excitement.

“Oh, perfect!” Fluttershy rolled to her feet, tail wagging. “Well then, I’ll do my best to make it worth the wait~” A few quiet gurgles sounded from the pegasus; she blushed in embarrassment. “Um, I-I guess my belly is excited, too.”

Everyone chuckled; a cute sight, of course. Pinkie Pie soon bounced to the middle, prepared to finally be dirtied just like her friends. Fluttershy would certainly have an amazing load to dump onto her.

Chapter 5 - Fluttershy's Turn

Fluttershy smiled timidly as Pinkie Pie bounced over to the carpet. Many of Rarity’s logs had slid right off the yellow pegasus as she stood, her wings curling inward and dropping the piles on top of each subsequently, however, it was clear that she’d been the subject of quite a heavy load - her fur was smeared with so much brown that she looked like she’d spent the better half of a day in the latrine at Apple Orchards (and she would know, but that’s a story for another time). Her smell gave a similar impression.

Her blush hardly showed threw the streaks on her cheeks, but Pinkie Pie could see it as she got closer. “Your blush looks just like me!!” She said, her voice cheery and excited as usual; her next bounce ended in all four legs suddenly being splayed out, landing on her stomach, squishing multiple logs underneath of her from past users. The carpet didn’t look like it had spent any time in a latrine - it looked like it was the latrine. Considering the night’s events, that wasn’t far from the truth.

“U-um,” the shy pony nervously murmured, turning around, aiming her ass at the pink pony, whose tail was wagging so fast it was a blur to all those who watched, her eyes open wide as she could get them. “I-I guess I’ll just s-start like this?” The pegasus generally preferred to be in a more submissive position; she’d been pushing it down the whole time, but honestly, she was pretty nervous when it came to performing any particularly dominant acts. She gulped, raising her tail, her legs quivering from a combination of lust and shyness. “I-I hope my load is big enough…”

“Come on, Fluttershy, no need to be so worried!” Pinkie Pie stated, always ready to support her friend. “I’m gonna love it no matter the size~!” She licked her lips, raising her own ass a tad so she could rub her clit. She gazed at the pegasus’ hole, small and cute, her pussy puffy and wet.

The pegasus gulped once again; wordlessly, she backed up, her ass over top of Pinkie Pie’s face, her hooves spread, smile fading. Her toilet-paper tail lifted above, revealing the full majesty of her soft rear. She definitely needed to go - just like everyone else, she’d been holding this in as long as she could - but for some reason, even as she pushed and tried to release it, nothing was coming out. She felt the eyes of her friends all staring in anticipation, all expecting so much of her, Pinkie Pie most of all. She felt her social anxiety welling up inside her; she was moments from breaking into tears. Her shit just wouldn’t come out, no matter how hard she tried.

“Hey, Fluttershy.” The lemon pegasus opened her eyes, not having realized that she closed them in the first place. Standing right in front of her was the other pegasus in the room, Rainbow Dash, her smile soft and caring. “There’s no need to be so nervous - you can take as much time as you need to get it out. None of us are going to be disappointed in you if it doesn’t work out, or if you don’t feel comfortable doing this. You already put on a great show earlier, anyways!” Flutter’s mouth was agape as she acknowledged the blue pegasus, her eyes much more tender and caring than usual. It was rare for Dashie to act in such a calm and caring fashion - usually, she was far more bold and brash, no matter the situation. “Just do whatever makes you feel the best, ok?”

Fluttershy nodded. Her smile returned, her eyes shining with new found confidence. “I think I can do this. Thank you, Rainbow.” She nuzzled the fellow pegasus with her snout. “Though, um… could you stay nearby while I do it?”

“I can do something even better~” RD zipped over to Flutter’s side, rubbing her body against her friends, their asses side by side. “You’ve waited long enough, Pinkie Pie - wanna double dip~?”

“Ooo, yes yes yes!!” She rolled over to a horizontal position, moving so that her head was still near Fluttershy’s ass and her back was under Rainbow’s. “Why would I not want two of my friends to use me at the same time? It’s double the fun!!”

“That alright with you, Fluttershy?” Rainbow asked, her tail hovering up, brushing against Fluttershy’s.

“It’s perfect~” She gave the blue pegasus a light kiss on the cheek with dirty lips, wrapping her tail around the other, adding another new color to the rainbow. Her stomach suddenly grumbled; she blushed in embarrassment. “I think I can feel it coming~”

“Hehe, so can I~” It seemed Dashie’s body had taken some more time to process all of the shit she ate earlier - now, it was time to let it back out. It wouldn’t be as big as what she did to Rarity, but she didn’t want to steal the show from Fluttershy anyways. “Look out, Pinkie Pie~”

The earth pony gasped in delight as the yellow cheeks parted. Fluttershy pushed, biting her lower lip, her mouth still twisted into a smile as she groaned. A log poked from her tail hole, hovering in the air as it slowly made its way out, wet sounds of waste grinding against flesh filling the air, along with the smell of her load. Like Rarity’s, it wasn’t quite as bad as normal shit - it had a much more sweet aroma to it then one would expect, but it was still definitely shit. Pinkie Pie lifted her nose and nudged the log as it slowly crept out, sticking out her tongue and gently giving Fluttershy’s clit an unexpected lick. The pegasus quivered in horny surprise, her legs bending, her shit suddenly coming out much faster as she gave a surprised squeal. The smooth log shot out of her ass, a good ten inches of soft shit with a slimy texture. It went from Pinkie’s forehead to her snout, right between her eyes, and it was quickly followed by an uncontrollable barrage.

The pink pony immediately laid back down and held her head in place for the onslaught. Log after log fell with surprising force, Fluttershy’s legs shaking, her smile only growing as she pushed them out, groaning and moaning with each one. Surprising bursts of gas sounded from between them, a putrid stink filling the air, not quite as bad as RD or Applejack, but still noticeable enough to make a few ponies in the crowd either hold their nose or inhale as much as they could. Pinkie’s body seemed to vibrate as her head was covered, blanketed in shit like snow falling from the clouds. Rainbow Dash was stunned by the sight, so stunned that she forgot she was supposed to be shitting, too, though eventually, she remembered. Quickly, she turned her concentration to her own ass, pushing out a stream of sticky, ropy shit, bursting over Pinkie Pie like party streamers. It was nowhere near as big of a load as Fluttershy’s, though - it was all the blue pegasus could do to stop herself from making it a competition. It did make her want to try something like that sometime, though. “Wow…” she murmured, mouth agape. She was a bit envious of the party pony.

“Heeheehee!!” Pinkie Pie giggled happily, quickly rubbing a hoof against her slit. Every log was nice, warm, and so smooth. They were the picturesque example of what a good load should look like, nice and wide, too. Each one slopped onto her head, covering her snout, hiding her eyes, and soon enough, getting in her curly mane. She never styled her hair - she just wore it the same way every time she woke up, messy and bundled in curls and swirls. She had no issue getting Fluttershy’s logs as deep inside of the mess of pink as she could, even reaching her hooves up to rub it in like shampoo, just as Rarity had done with the current user.

“Mmmngh~!” Flutter’s grunts and moans merged into each other, her ass cheeks shivering with each new log she dropped. She couldn’t believe how amazing it felt - she’d never imagined she could enjoy the dominant position so much, but she was having so much fun! Hearing Pinkie Pie’s giggles and moans just filled her with even greater confidence; she soon moved away from Rainbow Dash and got in front of Pinkie Pie, then moved to stand over her, soon sitting down on her face like a dog. She put her front hooves on the party pony’s back as she used her like a chair, her ass hovering just above her fur as she continued to shit out more logs, up close and personal. Her pussy burst with a stream of fast, intense piss, moving in a straight line and splashing all over her toilet pony, drenching the hair with the golden yellow. She began to move in a humping motion on reflex, pushing her pussy into the dirty, curly mane, so soft and fuzzy against her sensitive slit. She’d lost track of logical thought - she was acting on pure impulse now.

Pinkie Pie soon found herself acting just as impulsively, though that was hardly anything new for her. She reached her hooves up, wrapping them around Fluttershy’s cheeks, and she stuck her snout to to the pegasus’ slit, nuzzling it inside and licking like she was digging the ice cream out of a waffle cone. The pegasus stood just a little to give her full access, shaking almost as much as the party pony was, her eyes practically rolling into the back of her head as she was overcome with in intense pleasure. She squirted onto her face, gracing her with the third of her body’s fluids, accompanied by sprays of yellow like a broken sprinkler. She quickly wiggled from her grasp and began the shitting once again, not nearly done, now working her way down Pinkie’s body. The blue pegasus quickly moved out of the way as Fluttershy walked over the party pony, her hooves on either side, trailing shit along the way as she went, each log shot out like she was using Pinkie’s party cannon for it.

She’d soon left a good trail of smooth logs along the way, each one slimy and soft as could be, maintaining their consistency. They plopped down onto the comparatively meager pile that Rainbow Dash had contributed, splattering the load all over, leaving it to drip down Pinkie’s sides and leave some nice, sticky trails in their wake. She soon added a few logs onto her tail for good measure, and then, without warning, flew over to Pinkie’s side and pushed the party pony onto her back.

The sounds of logs squishing was loud, accompanied by the surprised and delighted “Oooo!” from the earth pony, followed by giggling. Her hooves hung in the air, her stomach up, so many logs having flattened all over her, making her look like she’d been rolling in a mud pit. Fluttershy stood over top of her, her ass once again above the pink pony’s face, tail still hiked high, her ass looking absolutely disgusting. It was slimy and gross, covered in brown, many sticky chunks attached to her cheeks. “Clean it~” She quietly commanded, her voice still light and airy; it was her attempt at a dominant act, and although it was fairly weak, it was part of her charm. A charm that won Pinkie Pie over with no effort at all.

Quickly, the earth pony went to work, leaning her head up and licking ferociously. Her wet, slobbery tongue lathered the pegasus’ rear, going first to her cheeks. She lapped up the residual shit from Rarity, enjoying the bitterness filling her mouth as it was coated in brown, then got deeper, first scratching the surface, tracing the crack lightly, then slowly digging deeper, and deeper. She nudged her snout inbetween the pillowy, fluffy balls, feeling shit rubbing against her nose, and without stopping to make sure she was doing a thorough job cleaning the outside, she shoved her snout into the tail hole. Fluttershy yipped in surprise and pleasure as Pinkie Pie snout-fucked the pony as hard as she could, wrapping her hooves around her legs and pulling her down to sit on her face so she could get even deeper. Her grip was as tight as steel; Fluttershy wasn’t escaping until the earth pony was done with her. She quickly dropped to her knees and returned the favor with her tongue going to the partier’s pussy, the licks carefree, fast, like Rainbow Dash would’ve done it. She dug her nose deep and nuzzled the clit, rubbing and licking it with force and love, until both of them were on the edge of orgasm.

Quickly, however, right before either of them finished, Fluttershy stood up and 180ed, looking Pinkie Pie right in the face with a soft, warm smile, as her ass hovered over the party pony’s clit. “I think you could be just a little more wet for me~” She giggled, leaning forward and making out with Pinkie Pie’s shit-smeared lips as she shoved out a nice, smooth log, falling right onto the earth pony’s throbbing pussy. “Mmm~” She moaned, both in horny pleasure and satisfaction from shoving out another log; quickly, she pulled back, turned around once again, and resumed her prior position, her ass in Pinkie’s face, her head to Pinkie’s slit. Fluttershy wasted no time, plunging her snout down onto the log and smushing it into the exposed flesh, so wet and slimy. She licked and ate, swallowing pieces of her own waste as she pleasured her friend, making deep sounds of pleasure like a purring cat. Pinkie’s body shook with orgasmic pleasure as she went back to cleaning up Fluttershy, now with a whole new host of filth to lick up, and within moments, shivers ran through the party pony. She thrust her waist upwards and let out a thick moan into Flutter’s tail hole, spraying the pegasus with her clear marecum, covering her face in it.

Fluttershy chuckled, licking her lips clean of the mess, shit and cum both going down her throat, as Pinkie Pie quickly grabbed her by the hips and stuck her snout inside the animal lover’s pussy. Her sudden eating out instantly brought Fluttershy to her knees, the pegasus huffing in pleasure, taking mere seconds to let out a bone-shaking orgasm all over Pinkie, mixed with her own urine bursting out on accident.

By the end, the two ponies were huffing and panting, exhausted from their outpourings of pleasure. They felt amazing. They were both as dirty and filthy as could be, covered in cum, urine, and feces all over. Barely keeping herself from falling right back to sleep, Fluttershy floated herself off of Pinkie and a bit away from the carpet, collapsing on her stomach and letting out a tired yawn. She opened her mouth to say something, but Twilight was quick to throw a blanket over her tuckered-out body.

“You can rest for a while, Fluttershy. You put on a great show~” She said, encouragingly, giving Flutters a quick kiss on the forehead for emphasis. The pegasus blushed in response, a little smile on her lips, and she nodded, closing her eyes and dozing off.

Pinkie Pie was huffing and panting too, but she didn’t seem half as exhausted as the pegasus. Rather, she was hungry and raring to go, as could be seen by her rolling over and springing up to her hooves in one fluid motion. “Ooo, my turn my turn my turn!!” She bounced up and down, smiling gleefully, each of her (slightly browned) teeth visible to all surrounding her. “I gotta go so bad!! Who else is left!?”

The ponies - or, at least, those who were still awake - looked around at each other, unsure of what was coming next. Everybody had already gone, everyone was already filthy and covered. Everybody, except for Twilight, who’d started the whole thing. The lavender unicorn gulped as all eyes turned to her. She found herself being a little nervous about what Pinkie Pie could possibly produce; it certainly wouldn’t be anything like a normal pony’s load.

“Come on, Twilight~!” Pinkie’s saccharine voice beckoned, bouncing over to the unicorn and pulling her onto the carpet. “My load isn’t going to hold itself forever~! Hehe! I know it isn’t a competition…” She stuck her tongue out, eyes narrowing mischievously. “But I’m going to make sure you’re the messiest pony here~”

Twilight gulped; butterflies buzzed in her stomach. She was excited, but still a tad fearful. Certainly, whatever was in store for her, the last pony to finish this saga off, was going to be… well, interesting, at least.

Chapter 6 - Pinkie Pie's Turn

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.