We're Done

by TheKing2001

Rating: teen
Tags: Trixie, Spike, Starlight Glimmer, Profanity, Discord, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Sad, Main 6, Romance
Length: 2261

Spike decides to leave Ponyville and his marefriend after they made him do something he didn't feel comfortable

After being forced to do stand up because none of his friends and marefriend wanted to, they forced Spike on the stage. Spike has a huge stage fright phobia. Sure, he did the Hearths Warming Eve play script but that was easier because it was planned. And he wasn't being made fun of by the town for it. He decides to leave the town and make new friends, leaving Starlight in the process.

(I'm not a huge shipper of Spike and Starlight, I ship Trixie and Starlight. I just want this story to be as sad as possible and what better way to make it sad than your partner leaving you? Comments are shut off because of rude and negative comments to each other. I don't tolerate that behavior nor do I tolerate negative likes because of that drama going on the the comments. Hopefully you all understand. I don't tolerate any form of disrespect to anyone, even if I don't agree with them.)

Published 2023-06-09 03:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2023-11-04 06:07:35 UTC

Chapter I

I gulped as we looked out at the massive crowd. We were supposed to be doing a comedy act tonight to help Pinkie win some prize or something. I never did well with massive crowds like this. Sure, I helped Trixie and all but this was different than that. Trixie only got about fifty or so ponies. There was easily more than a thousand out there.

“Wow that’s busier than I expected,” Rainbow admitted as she peered above my head. “How about you go first Starlight?” I let out a nervous laugh at that.

“You’re funny,” I leveled a flat stare at her. “You’re always so confident. Why don’t you go first?” Now it was Rainbows turn to laugh.

“I would but I’m uh sick. Sick of standing here,” Rainbow chuckled. “Rarity. You go! You like all the attention of ponies anyway.” Rarity gave her a glare.

“What does that mean darling?” Rarity asked indignantly. Rainbow scoffed and rolled her eyes.

“It means you’re a drama queen and an attention seeker.”

“And ya ain’t one?” Applejack asked in her normal drawl with a smirk. “Yur the biggest attention seeker I know.”

“Fine. I would suggest Fluttershy go but we all know she is too scared,” Dash sighed. She turned around and Fluttershy was clinging onto her mane, shaking in fear. She always scared of everything except animals. She understood them more than ponies. Must be nice to be able to talk to animals. I would be able to easily tell the spider in my room to leave and never come back. I hated spiders with a burning passion.

“It would take some pony a lot of guts to take them on,” my coltfriend Spike peeked under me out into the crowd. We had been dating for some time and it was probably the happiest I’ve ever been. A lot of ponies at first thought it was weird we were dating and I thought it was kinda weird when he admitted he liked me at first mainly due to my age. Then I founs out he was my age because of how fast dragons aged. I’m only twenty six and i feel old. Ponies in town don’t even cast a glance at us now thankfully. Rarity and Rainbow Dash made eye contact and nodded.

“Not some pony. Some creature,” Rarity grinned along with Rainbow. I instantly caught on and we all walked to him. He can go and win Pinkie whatever it was she wanted. He gulped and I levitated him up with my magic and placed him on the stage.

“Quick! Get him something to entertain them with!” Rainbow said. I quickly levitated some bowling pins into his claws.

“So uhm how do you all feel about juggling?” Spike asked with a shaky voice as his entire frame was shaking. I tilted my head to the side in slight concern. I’ve never seen him act this way before.

“You guys think we might have made a mistake?” I hesitantly asked. “He doesn’t look okay.” Rainbow was rolling around laughing on the floor.

“He’s fine! He does public speaking all the time. Doesn’t he look funny!” Rainbow burst out laughing again. Applejack, Rarity and Pinkie joined in laughing and I just watched as he dropped a pin and everypony in the audience laughed. I had a weird feeling something bad would happen tonight.

“That was funny Spike!” Rainbow giggled as we started walking through town to the castle. Apparently the others wanted to hang out and such inside since Twilight was off on a quick three day trip to Canterlot. “You looked absolutely ridiculous!” The rainbow maned pegasus giggled to herself. Spike said nothing and just kept walking. That wasn’t like him either. He typically talked all the time. Plus, most of the time we went out places he opted to ride on my back but tonight he chose to walk. Once you’ve been with a pony or dragon in my case, you pick up on the little things.

“Spike?” I asked as I leaned in to nuzzle him. To my shock, he leaned away from it and kept walking forward. Now that was even weirder and just confirmed something actually was wrong. Spike never turned down affection from me, no matter the situation. Me and Applejack looked at each other, both of us wearing the same concerned and confused expression on our faces. Apparently she picked up on what I was feeling too. She was good like that. Scarily good in all honesty.

“Sugarcube?” Applejack touched him with a hoof and he slapped it away to all of our shock, especially Rarity.

“Whatever is the matter darling?” Rarity asked. Spike spun around and glared at us. I took a shocked hesitant step back at the angry and hurt expression on his face. He honestly looked like he was about to cry which made me even more concerned.

“You all should know!” Spike fumed. “I was humiliated out there for your entertainment! They were all laughing at me. Hell, you all were laughing at me. You guys did that intentionally for your amusement!” I stepped forward nervously.

“Spike we never meant to hurt you. We just weren’t thinking,” I tried to plead with him. Looks like my feelings of something bad going to happen and that he was acting off out there were right.

“Bullshit. You knew exactly what you were doing when you levitated me out there!” My Spike never swore, no matter how angry he was. I didn’t know how serious he was until he said that.

“We really didn’t sugarcube,” Applejack tried to convince him and he glared at her with such an intensity she faltered and stayed quiet, taking a step back and bumping into Dash who had been watching quietly with a confused look on her face.

“We’re not friends anymore,” Spike announced as he glared at them. They all let out a gasp and stared at him.

“B-but why?” Fluttershy whimpered as Applejack hugged her.

“You know why. I just told you. Don’t interact with me again,” Spike grumbled as he climbed the castle stairs and opened the door. “Oh and Starlight?”

“Yes love?” I asked nervously.

“We’re done.” He slammed the door shut and I heard it lock. I felt my ears flatten against my head as my heart broke into a million pieces. I could feel the tears threatening to escape as I played those words over in my head. I had never wanted to hear him say those words but here we are. I hurt him somehow way more than I realized.

“W-what just happened?” Pinkie asked as her mane flattened and she lost a bit of her bright pink color.

“Ah don’t know sugarcube. Ah don’t know.”

Author's Note

So this is based on that one episode where spike had stage fright after Starlight and everyone minus twilight forced him on the stage. I felt that was super fucked up, especially for Starlight to have agreed with it and taken part in it. I don't typically ship Spike and Starlight, but I wanted the story to be sad and what is more sad than a partner breaking up with you after a fight? This is my most controversial story yet so please no dislikes.

Chapter II

“I can’t believe he broke up with me,” I sighed as I slumped against the wall. Fluttershy gave me a sympathic look. We were sitting in Fluttershys house by the fire. I had a small cat on my lap that I idly petted. Thank God Angel wasn’t around. That monster was a criminal I bet you. Would start a war to end all of Equestria if he had the opportunity.

“You guys were all pretty awful and insensitive to him,” she agreed as I glared at her.

“Excuse me? YOU we on our side as well!” I snapped. “All of us shoved him out there without a fucking care in the world about how he felt. All we cared was about us. All I cared about was my own selfishness and not my partner.” I curled myself into a ball and felt Fluttershy wrap a wing around me. The cat jumped off my leg and went chasing after a toy or something.

“I’ve been spending too much time with my human version. She’s way more bold than me. I apologize for what I said. Spike just needs time. He will come around. You can stay with me,” she rested her head on mine. I nodded as I hugged her.

“I’m so disappointed in myself. I never should done this. I can’t stop resisting the urge to cry or cast a spell to go back in time to convince us to not to,” I admitted quietly.

“What would Twilight say if you did that?” Fluttershy pointed out. I paused and let out a sigh.

“You got me there. She would be disappointed in me,” I admitted. “I just don’t know how to fix this.”

“I don’t either. He’s been ignoring even Rarity and he used to like her. He kicked Rainbow out of the castle and yelled at Applejack. He’s only allowed the cmc, Lyra, Bon Bon and his friends from Canterlot in. If I remember correctly, he let the flower sisters and Blossomforth in.”

“I didn’t know he was close with any of those ponies,” I said. He never mentioned them to me ever. I never really saw him with them except Lyra and the cmc.

“He and Lyra go way back. She is Twilights original friend from Canterlot,” Fluttershy explained.” That made sense a bit now that I think about it. I think Twilight had mentioned something about it once during one of my lessons about friendship. I clearly didn’t learn much if I just got dumped.

“You know Spike was my first relationship?” I suddenly said. “I never had much time for dating back then. I always cared about getting more ponies in my village.”

“I haven’t dated either. Not because I don’t have time for it or anything but everytime I meet someone I like, I get too shy and nervous to do anything. Me and Rainbow Dash had a teeny thing back in flight school but that was years ago. We are just good friends now.”

“Wow she never told me that,” I mumbled. Fluttershy gave a little giggle and played with a bird, watching it do loops in the air. Rainbow and the others were trying to come up with ways to get Spike come out. Or at least let us inside to apologize. Knowing Dash she would give a super shitty apology. She sometimes gave a good one but meh it was kinda rare.

“We keep it a secret. Even if the public would support us, we like having a private life with us being national heroes we don’t have much of a private life anymore. Rarity and Rainbow like the spotlight but even Rainbow has her limits believe it or not,” the yellow pegasus explained.

“That does make a bit of sense,” I admitted. I never really thought about it but it does make sense that they would get a lot of attention in public. It was somewhat tame in Ponyville but it still happened here and again I bet. That would explain why Rainbow was hiding in the castle a few days ago.

“It’s okay I guess. I just stay indoors now.”

“Isn’t that what you always do?” I pointed out. Fluttershy gave a giggle and nodded.

“Indoors is my safe space. It’s nice and quiet in here,” she explained. I looked around with a raised eyebrow at the animals running around and making all sorts of noises.

“Uh Fluttershy have you looked around your house? It’s a zoo in here or at least it sounds like one.” Fluttershy gave a shrug as a fox rubbed against her cheek.

“I guess I got used to the noises. It’s comforting really,” she admitted. I guess that made some sense. I stared at a tiny white mouse staring at me and I jumped a little bit. Mice used to scare the hell out of me. Messy creatures too. They are nothing compared to rats though. Now those are some scary freaking things.

“Uh why is he staring at me?” I asked curiously as the mouse took a step to me. She made some squeaks and I stared in confusion. “Uh what did she say? I don’t speak mouse, Fluttershy.”

“She. Her name is Georgina. She’s saying she wants to introduce you to her children,” Fluttershy translated with a warm smile.

“Oh uh sure.” Fluttershy nodded and made some noises. I assume it was the sound mice make. Not entirely sure. The mouse made some squeaks back and five small mice came walking up. As much as they scared me, I couldn’t help but let out an aww. “They’re adorable!”

“That’s Teeny, Tiny, Nut, Will and Bob,” Fluttershy pointed a hoof to each one. “She’s a very proud mom.” I tentatively reached out a hoof and the one I think was Teeny touched my hoof with a paw.

“I like this one. The black spot is absolutely cute. I should get a pet. Spike wanted to get a dog,” I announced as my smile faded.

“Are you okay?” Fluttershy asked as the mouse crawled up my foreleg.

“I’m going to sleep. Can I take Teeny?” I asked hopefully. Fluttershy gave a smile and made some squeaks.

“Yeah the mom is coming too she said.”

Chapter III

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.