The Other Choice

by ThomasZoey3000

Rating: mature
Tags: Twilight Sparkle (EqG), Alternate Universe, Human, Original Character, Romance, Equestria Girls, Porn, Sex
Length: 4991

Inspired by the Story by AliceLiz, we see what happens if Twilight did go with the girl she met in chapter 5.

Twilight goes to the party, she meets the pizza delivery girl from earlier. Said girl asks if she would like to spend the night with her, but she says n...
Wait a second, that doesn't happen here. Instead, we see what happens when Twilight goes with 'The Other Choice'.

This story was inspired by the story 'The Unexpected Adventures of Sparky Selene, Professional Pornstar' by AliceLiz.

Published 2023-07-02 01:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2023-09-26 01:15:10 UTC

First Time with a Girl

The Other Choice

Inspired by: The Unexpected Adventures of Sparky Selene, Professional Pornstar by AliceLiz

Written by: ThomasZoey3000

Chapter 1: First Time with a Girl

The last couple of weeks had been interesting for Twilight Sparkle. She had wanted to get into modelling to be just like Sunset Shimmer. Yet, she found out upon her arrival that the job was actually one for a porn actor. Still, she stayed at it and did at least three shoots, two with men and one by herself.

Tonight however, she wasn't thinking about that. She went to a party with one of her house-mates, and at the moment, she was on the couch, kissing the pizza delivery girl who invited her. The kiss felt like fireworks going off in her mouth, it was that good.

"I could taste the alcohol there," she grimaced after the second kiss.

"Sorry about that," Cheery apologized.

"Don't worry about that," smiled Twilight.

Cherry's hands were feeling around on her exposed midsection, it really felt good to Twilight.

"So how far do you want to take this?"

"I-I don't really know, but I don't want it to stop."

Cherry smirked and made the daring suggestion, "oh yeah? Well, how about you come back to my place?"

Twilight's eyes opened wide in surprise. Going back to a place with a girl she only met hours ago? It sounded crazy to her. On the other hand, not many girls would offer such a wonderful deal. Not to mention, she did find girls more attractive than men.

So with a smile, she answered with; "sure, why not."

Cherry's smile only seemed to grow hearing Twilight say that.

"Well then, let's go have some sexy fun."

Before leaving, Twilight texted the other girls to inform them of where she was going. They all responded with, "that's how you do it! Have fun girl!"

Cherry and Twilight walked a short distance from the house and soon arrived at what looked like an old hotel. A few years back, it had been remodeled into apartments. It looked very clean and quite peaceful, which was different from what Twilight thought of when it came to places like this.

"First off, I just want you to know, I may have had a few drinks, but I am aware of what I am doing," Cherry said as she unlocked her door, "so believe me, the loving feelings I'm showing are real from me, not the booze."

"I never doubted you for a second," smiled Twilight. "I can tell if a person is drunk, and you don't seem like one."

The door was opened, and Cherry walked in first. Twilight followed and was surprised to see the inside. It was beautifully decorated with a big TV, decent sized love seat couch, vintage coffee table, silk curtains, a decent sized kitchen and a queen sized bed. Also present was a box of dildos.

"Sorry, I was using one before going to the party," Cherry apologized.

"Don't apologize. It's actually good you have these out, maybe we can use them."

"I like the way you think. Before we do though, I need to tingle, but don't take off your clothes yet. I want to watch you do that."

Cherry walked into the bathroom, but didn't close the door. Twilight sat down on the bed, leaving her with her thoughts. She began thinking about what Adagio had said about keeping this a secret from those she cared about. She could only imagine how mad they'd be if they found out, and she never told them.

So while she waited, she decided to call Sunset. But it seemed Sunset was either asleep or busy, so she only got the answering machine.

"Hey Sunset, it's Twilight calling. I know it's late, but I just wanted to tell you about my job a bit more. You're my friend after all, and I've felt guilty about hiding these things from you. I'll be turning my phone off for the night, so you can call me tomorrow at around noon, and I'll tell you everything. Bye."

She ended the call and turned off her phone.

"Everything okay?" Cherry asked.

"Yeah, just had to call an old friend," Twilight answered. "So, you ready to continue?"

Cherry didn't answer, at least not with words. She walked up to Twilight and kissed her again. Twilight kissed her back, enjoying the feel of female lips on her own. So soft, so sweet and so...minty? Clearly Cherry had used mouth wash.

When the kiss ended, Cherry reached down and pulled her top over her head, revealing a bright pink bra. Next, she removed her shorts, followed by her shoes and socks. She stood there in her underwear, looking quite pleased with her own body, and so she should Twilight thought to herself.

With her new friend and partner for the night in her underwear, Twilight began to undress. She had to admit, doing it in front of a girl was less scary than doing it in front of men.

Before long, she was in her plain white bra and panties, but Cherry still seemed to like what she was seeing. She walked up to Twilight and kissed her again. As they kissed, she pushed Twilight towards the bed until the nerdy girl was laying on the bed.

They stopped kissing and Cherry lifted her right hand towards Twilight's bra. Twilight nodded. Cherry smiled, and using her left hand, she went behind the girl, undid the bra and removed it, showing Twilight's beautiful nipples. Without asking, Cherry placed her mouth around the nipple, licking it over and over again, making Twilight moan. Her back arched, her legs thrashed about and she wrapped her arms around Cherry, keeping her where she was, almost holding her down. Despite that, she was able to switch to the other nipple and using her left hand, she rubbed the right breast.

"Oh Cherry!" Twilight cried.

Cherry only smiled as she continued for another minute before finally getting up. She watched as Twilight took deep breaths, making her breasts go up and back down as she did. She also looked down to Twilight's panties, seeing a wet spot on them.

"Did I do good for you Twilight?"

"Yes, yes you did," she panted.

"Good to know. Now hold still, and I'll get you comfortable."

Moving down, Cherry began to remove Twilight's panties, revealing her soaking wet pussy. The panties landed on the floor, leaving Twilight completely nude before her new lover.

Without another word, Cherry removed her bra and panties, leaving herself in the nude like Twilight.

"Like what you see?" she asked.

Twilight nodded and reached out for Cherry. She didn't need to say a word as Cherry crawled over to Twilight and lowering herself down, she planted her lips on Twilight's once more. Twilight wrapped her arms around Cherry, deepening the kiss between them.

"Oh god, I'm glad I went to the party!" Twilight cried happily.

"So am I," Cherry smiled. "Now hold still, and I'll make sure you won't regret your choice to come here tonight."

Twilight looked down to her pussy, and it was a good thing she did as Cherry started lapping up at it. Twilight nearly screamed at the top of her lungs, but soon the screams turned into moans of pleasure, and she moved her hips in time with Cherry's tongue movements.

"More! More! Go Inside!" Twilight cried.

Cherry wouldn't deny her request, and so thus stuck her tongue inside her pussy.

"Delicious," she mumbled.

Twilight's breathing got heavier and heavier as her chest rose up and down. She wrapped her legs around the other girl, placed both her hands on her breasts and rubbed as hard as she could.

This was even better than any night of masturbathing. Instead of just her panting, there was the slurping from Cherry's tongue, and instead of her fingers in the pussy, Twilight felt the wet tongue all around her walls.

"So...so...so good!" Twilight cheered happily.

This went on a bit more, but soon Twilight could feel she was reaching her limits. The amazing feeling grew and grew until, "I'M CUMMMMMIIIIINNNNNNGGGGGG!" And she did, right into Cherry's mouth, making the other girl swallow the cum until Twilight had calmed from her orgasm.

"So delicious," said Cherry as she licked her lips.

She crawled up to Twilight again and kissed her, giving her a chance to taste herself for the first time. She had to admit, the taste wasn't that bad, but of course, it was even better with Cherry's lips on her's.

"You were really good with your tongue there," Twilight panted.

"Thanks, I tried my best."

Twilight, with renewed energy, shot up and kissed Cherry again. The other girl happily accepted the kiss, and even cheered with joy as Twilight flipped her over making the nerdy girl be the top one.

"You gave me an amazing orgasm, now I'll give you one."

Cherry spread her legs open, and winked, "go on, have your taste."

Twilight nodded and without warning, she launched her mouth onto Cherry's pussy. Right away, she had to admit that Cherry tasted way better than she did. She lapped up the pussy with such vigor she never knew she had. Cherry clearly was enjoying herself as she thrashed about, and like Twilight, moved her hips to match Twilight's movements.

"Oh god Twilight, I could get used to this every single night!" Cherry cried.

As she continued, Twilight thought on the words Cherry said. She was enjoying herself, and clearly, so was Cherry, but could she do this every night? She shook the thought out of her head for now and continued until Cherry cried out, and cum shot out of her pussy and into Twilight's mouth.

But Twilight wasn't satisfied with the amount of delicious taste in her mouth. So she lapped up the pussy again until Cherry gushed again. Twilight swallowed the cum happily and finally allowed the girl to calm down.

"Wow Twilight, you are amazing," panted Cherry. "I would like to do this with you more."

"I do too. I will admit, I was scared about doing this with someone I only met. However," she smiled and rubbed Cherry's belly like she would with a dog, "of all the people I met here, I feel safe around you. So, if I need your love, can I call on you?"

"Of course you can. Anytime you want. You got my number right?"

Twilight nodded.

"Good. However-" she paused, which caused Twilight to worry. Cherry smiled and said, "I would like to continue having sex with you tonight, if you want to."

"Do you even need to ask?"

Cherry beamed and leaping up, she wrapped her arms around Twilight before the two kissed once more.

After drinking some water and having a short break, the girls returned to the bed. Only this time, they were going to face each other while fucking dildos. After applying enough lube to the dildos, they were ready to began. To make it more sexy, Cherry slid her dildo into Twilight's pussy while Twilight slid her dildo into Cherry's pussy.

When they were ready, they started to ride their dildos. The hard rubber rubbed all sides of their pussies, making them moan out loud.

"Oh Cherry!" cried Twilight.

"Oh Twilight!" cried Cherry.

With her right hand, Twilight reached up and rubbed Cherry's right breast. Not wanting her partner to be left out, Cherry did the same thing to Twilight. It only increased the ecstasy they felt. At one point, Cherry reached down and rubbed at Twilight's clit, making her moan even louder and her breathing quickened.

"I'm getting close Cherry!"

"Rub me and I'll join you!"

Twilight did as she was asked, and with loud screams, the two girls squirted on their dildos and the bed below them. Twilight's dildo flew out of Cherry's pussy on it's own while Cherry pulled her's out of Twilight.

"Oh my gosh, this is better than my lonely nights," cheered Twilight.

"I know what you mean," panted Cherry. She looked to the nerdy girl, "I have enough for one more round if you're interested."

Twilight nodded. Truthfully, she could go on all night, but she could tell Cherry was getting tried.

"What do you have in mind?"

"Have you ever tried scissoring?"

Twilight shook her head and admitted she didn't know what that meant. Cherry beamed, "well, allow me to show you."

First, she asked Twilight to lay on her side and keep her legs spread open. Twilight did this and gasped as Cherry slid over her left leg and made her pussy rub up against Twilight's.

"Ready?"

Twilight nodded.

Cherry moved forward a bit, pulled back and slid across Twilight's sex once again.

"OH MY GOSH!" Twilight cried.

At first, Cherry did all the work, but after a dozen thrusts, Twilight joined in.

"That's it Twilight! That's it! Now you got it!"

"This is the best!" Twilight screamed. "You're amazing!"

"Not as much as you are!" Cherry cried back.

They grinded against each other over and over, moaning in ecstasy. Cherry even ran her tongue along Twilight's leg. All this made Twilight want to cum badly.

"I can't," she thought to herself, "not until she...she's ready."

Lifting her right hand, Twilight reached out and rubbed her thumb on Cherry's clit. It was a little difficult as Cherry moved back and forth alot, but Twilight soon found a way to continue and didn't stop, even when she heard;

"Twilight, I'm going to cum!"

"Let's do it together!"

Cherry reached down and rubbed Twilight's clit as they both felt the waves of orgasms. They gushed big time, leaving a big wet stain on the bed and leaving the cum all over their bodies.

Cherry panted as she sat down on the bed.

"Okay, that's it for me, I'm done."

Twilight got up, pulled back the covers and climbed in. She patted the spot next to her. Cherry got the hint, and climbed in right next to Twilight. As soon as she did, Twilight reached out and pulled her close, have her face close to her breasts. Twilight rubbed Cherry's back and even kissed her forehead.

"See you in the morning love," Twilight whispered.

"See you...morning..." Cherry let out one last yawn before going to sleep. Twilight only smiled, and secretly hoped Cherry would remember this night. With that thought, she went to sleep as well.

When the morning came, Twilight awoke to a wonderful smell. She opened her eyes and looked to the nearby kitchen to see Cherry was up, and making breakfast. She was wearing an apron, but that was all she was wearing.

Cherry looked back and smiled, "good morning sexy girl. You ready for some breakfast?"

"Yes please," Twilight nodded.

She climbed out of the bed and walked up to Cherry and as if by instinct, she wrapped her arms around Cherry's waist.

"Last night was the best night I've ever had," Cherry admitted. "What about you?"

"I'm not going to lie, I've been feeling a little uncomfortable since I came to this city. But last night," she smiled as she kissed a well known sensitive spot on Cherry's neck, "was the best, most comfortable and sexiest night I've ever felt."

"Oh Twilight."

Cherry turned around and kissed her on the lips. Twilight happily kissed her back.

"I know I asked this last night, but are you going to be okay with me coming by every now and then if I want to feel comfortable?"

"The answer remains the same, yes you can."

Twilight beamed. She then leaned forward and whispered, "I'll come back, I promise."

As she started to help, Cherry whispered, "I know you will. You're a girl of your word."

And with one more quick kiss on the lips, the two girls went to work on the breakfast.

Author's Note

Special Thanks to AliceLiz, who without which, would never have given me the inspiration for this story. By the way, Cherry is an OC created by AliceLiz.

Twilight's New Bestie

Author's Note

To be honest, I was having alot of trouble thinking up other chapters for this story and I was about to cancel it, but then I thought, why not build on the characters in this story? Cherry being one of them as we don't know that much about her from AliceLiz's original story.

Hopefully chapter 3 won't take me too long to work on. Till then, have yourselves a new chapter of 'The Other Choice'. :twilightsmile:

Twilight's New Bestie

Chapter 2: Twilight's New Bestie

"Well here we are, you're little home sweet home," said Cherry.

Her car stopped right in front of the house Twilight was staying at. Deep down, a small part of her didn't want to leave Cherry, but at the same time too, she knew she'd have to return for her next shoot, whenever that was going to be.

"I have to say though, I really enjoyed what we did last night. Certainly beats all my other nights."

"What?" Twilight asked with a raised eyebrow.

"Oh, it's nothing, really." Cherry said with a fake laugh.

Though Twilight could tell she was lying, she didn't push the issue any further, and instead decided to compliment the girl.

"You were really good. Like really good. It makes all of my previous shoots seem like it was nothing."

Cherry's cheeks turned red, "do you really mean that?"

"Of course I do. Not to mention," she added with a little giggle, "you are the first girl I've ever done the deed with."

Now Cherry was really blushing and smiling, "well, I'm flattered really. Maybe we can do it again sometime?"

"Sure, and maybe we can also hang out." Twilight paused as she looked to the house, "the girls in there are nice and all, but we're more like work colleagues than friends."

"But you went to the party with one of them."

"Yeah well, I did that because I was nervous, and asked for her to tag along to be on the safe side. But I'm glad I went, cause I really could use a friend here."

Cherry reached out her hand and grabbed Twilight's hand gently, even going as far as rubbing the skin on top.

"Well then, let's try and hang out more. If you ever get the time, just call me and I'll try to be there."

Twilight nodded. She opened the door and was about to climb out, when she heard a click and looked back to see Cherry holding out her bra.

"I'd like you to have this, as a token of our new friendship."

Twilight smiled, then she decided to do something bold. She brought her legs back into the car and pulled down her panties until they were off. Then she passed them to Cherry, "and you can have this as a token from me."

Cherry accepted the panties and took a big sniff from them, "I'll treasure them, I promise."

With one final good-bye, Twilight climbed out and waved till Cherry was out of sight.

Once inside, Twilight found herself being surrounded by the other girls, "so? What was it like? Did you two use sex toys? Did she eat you out? Did you rub pussies together? Man I wish I could've seen it."

"She's lucky to have found you," said a voice. Everyone looked to see Scarlet sitting at the nearby table, "I've known Cherry for some time, and she's not really a social butterfly. She's had it rough, so having you in her life is something special to her."

"What do you mean by she's had it rough?" Twilight asked.

But Scarlet didn't answer. Twilight shrugged, she was sure she was going to find out later on. For now though, she had to get into some new clothes, and of course, get herself ready for her talk with Sunset.

When Sunset finally came on on private call, Twilight didn't waste time and told her everything. From her discovery of the job, to the people she's met, including Cherry, and the shoots she had been in. When she had finished, Sunset was quite speechless.

"Well? What do you think Sunset?"

"I...I honestly don't know what to say. Except maybe, why did you lie?"

"I don't know. I guess I was worried of what you would say if you found out, but last night, I started to realize that hiding the truth from you would only lead me into trouble. And I certainly don't want to lose my bestest friend."

"Well, I can respect your decision there."

"So, you're not mad at me."

"Oh no, I'm mad that you lied." Twilight looked down to her lap sadly, that was until she heard, "but I'll get over the lies and forgive you."

"I hope so."

"So, you're into that kind of stuff huh? Is it any fun?"

"Well so far, the scenes I've done are with men and while they are nice to me, and no they don't finish in me, it's just not really my thing. My one solo shoot was nice, but it was just me."

"So what you're saying is, you'd like to do it with girls?"

Twilight nodded, "yes, and I've been practicing with one. She's showing me how to do that stuff since I don't know what I'm doing."

It was true that their session last night taught Twilight alot, she didn't mention that it was more of a passionate night rather than just practice.

"And I have to wait for my agent to get me into a role with a girl, so until then, no money and no job."

"Yikes, that's bound to drive you crazy."

"Oh you have no idea."

She then decided to ask Sunset something important, "since I'm going to be here for a while, I am trying to become friends with this one person I met. But I heard she's not really a social person, so I like to know, what should I do?"

Sunset looked at her screen as though she had seen something confusing.

"Twilight, you already have the answer."

"I do?"

"Yes, just be you. It's always better to be honest and truthful with someone, and being yourself is the best thing you can do. After all, you don't want to be something you're not, and end up hurting someone."

"Or lying to them," groaned Twilight.

"Yeah, that too. Also, sometimes it doesn't go well."

"What do you mean?"

"Well, I won't get into details, but I can only say, it'll hurt more than that one person."

Twilight suddenly understood perfectly.

Sunset spoke in a calm manner, "just be you Twilight. That's why I and everyone else loves you. Remember that."

"I'll remember, thanks Sunset."

"Anytime bestie. Anyways, I got to get going. It may be my day off, but there's a new video game coming out and I've been itching to play it. By the way, what's your name?"

Twilight smirked, "why? You need something to look at before going to bed?"

"Maybe," Sunset said meekly.

"It's Sparky Selene."

"Right, got it. Thanks Twi, and call me if you need any help."

"I will, and please don't tell anyone about my job. I rather tell them myself."

Sunset nodded, "you have my word. Well, see you later Twi."

"See you Sunset." And with one final wave, the video call ended. Twilight put her phone down and leaned back onto her bed. Since she had some time on her hands, she had to figure out what to do.

"Maybe I'll go out for a bit. Until Broad tells me some good news."

With that thought on her mind, Twilight, carrying her phone and purse, left the room and went out to explore.

Using the GPS on her smartphone, Twilight started looking around, all the while, making sure she didn't get lost, or worse, end up in a part of the city she shouldn't. It was indeed quite a sight for the small town girl as she hadn't been to many big cities in the past, except on family road trips. But those places couldn't compare to the likes of Miami.

As she took more pictures, her phone rang. She looked and saw it was a number she didn't know, which meant it was another job for her.

"Hello," she answered.

"Hello, is this Sparky Selene I'm talking with?" asked a female voice on the other end.

By now, Twilight had walked up to a bench, and was now reaching into her purse for a piece of paper and a pen.

"Yes, you are talking to her. Who might I be talking to?"

"I'm Ruby Saddle," came the answer. "I was contacted by your agent that you wanted to get involved in some girl on girl scenes."

"That is correct."

"Well Miss Selene, I am happy to tell you that I have a shoot with your name on it." And she began listing some of the details of it, the location and who Twilight's co-star was going to be. Twilight wrote everything down without missing anything.

"Sounds great, so when does this take place?"

"Two days from now. Take an Uber or Cab to our location, and I'll give you and Shining Style all the details you'll need to know."

Twilight shuddered hearing the name 'Shining' as it reminded her of her brother, but quickly it off.

"Sounds good, I'll see you in two days."

"See you then Sparky, and if all goes well, maybe we'll work together more."

"I hope so."

The phone call ended and Twilight, with the information on the piece of paper, got up from the bench and continued with her walk.

She didn't go far though before she saw a familiar car. It was Cherry's car. Sure enough, coming from a nearby building was Cherry herself in her pizza delivery uniform, and looking rather miserable.

"Wonder what's upsetting her," Twilight thought to herself.

She decided to go over and greet her, "hey Cherry! It's me! Twilight!"

At first, Cherry didn't hear her, but after the third shout-out, she turned to the source of the voice. Her depressed look changed to a happy smile.

"Oh hey Twilight! Boy am I ever glad to see you."

"Yeah I saw you were upset, is everything okay?"

Cherry sighed and tried to hide a tear, but Twilight saw it. On instinct, she walked up to Cherry and wiped the tear away. This surprised Cherry a bit, but she didn't yell at Twilight, she just allowed her to continue. She took in a deep breath and finally answered.

"After dropping you off, my boss came to me and said that, if we don't get more money than what we have now, he may have to fire some people, me included. As if that's not enough, I had a costumer who argued over the price of the pizzas they ordered. And as you can see," she turned and showed the ruined back end of her shirt, "a young man dumped a ton of garbage all over me."

"Oh dear, I'm so sorry to hear that."

"It's just three more shitty moments ruining my life, I can't...bare..." but she didn't finish as she felt someone wrap their arms around her. That someone was Twilight, embracing her in a hug. The move may have shocked her at first, but Cherry soon accepted it and burst into tears right then and there.

Now Twilight was beginning to understand a bit on what Scarlet said before.

After a while, the two climbed back into Cherry's car where she finished crying.

"Thanks Twilight, I really needed that hug," she sobbed.

"Well I'm always happy to help a friend, especially a beautiful one like you."

Cherry started blushing again.

"You always know the right times to say these things don't you?"

Twilight nodded, "it's something all my friends and family back home know about, and they love me for it."

"I can see why."

The two sat in silence for another minute before Twilight asked, "would you like me to join you for the rest of your deliveries?"

Cherry didn't answer. It was as if she was thinking, "normally, the answer is no. But heck, if they're going to fire me, then I rather it be with my bestie beside me."

"Hey, I won't let them fire you."

"And how are you going to do that?"

"I don't know, but I'll think of something."

Cherry just smiled and as the car started up, she reached out for Twilight's hand. Twilight accepted it and joined Cherry for the rest of her deliveries.

When the deliveries were done, Twilight went back with Cherry to her workplace. She spoke with the manager, and even looked over all the paperwork, after asking permission, and discovered the reason for lack of money wasn't from lack of sales, but from three drivers taking the money for themselves.

The manager apologized to Cherry and fired the three drivers right away.

"My job is safe!" Cherry cheered, "and it's all thanks to you Twilight. Is there anything I can do to repay you?"

Twilight was about to say that their love making session was enough, but then thought, "well, I do have a free day tomorrow before I go for my next shoot. Maybe we can hang out for the day."

"Yeah, sounds good. Any ideas?"

Twilight shook her head, "I'm not too familiar with Miami, so I don't have a clue."

"Well, I can come up with something. What time do you want me to pick you up tomorrow?"

"Maybe around nine in the morning?"

Cherry nodded, "sounds good to me. Now come on Bestie, let's go make another delivery."

Twilight happily nodded to that, and given how happy Cherry was, the manager allowed Twilight to join her.

Though deep down, Twilight was still wondering what Scarlet knew about Cherry.