Mare Do Well Vs. Pinkamena Diane Pie

by Serenity Darkmoon Raven

Rating: mature
Tags: Tragedy, Mare Do Well, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Death, Alternate Universe, Rainbow Dash, Horror, Violence, Pinkie Pie
Length: 3837

Mare Do Well fights Pinkamenia when she was torturing Rainbow Dash.

Pinkamena is at it again, she was torturing Rainbow Dash and use her remains or her blood for cupcakes.. But Rainbow Dash screamed for help, Mare Do Well heard it and jumped into the scene. Both ponies fight for a cause. Mare Do Well wants to defeat Pinkamena and rescue Rainbow Dash from her cruel fate. Pinkamena wants to fight Mare Do Well and prevent her from stopping her evil plan of torturing and killing Rainbow Dash then using whatever's left for cucpakes... and being thrown in prison.

Will Mare Do Well defeat Pinkamena? Will Pinkamena escape?

Who will win?

Published 2023-08-06 04:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2023-08-06 04:50:01 UTC

Chapter 1

It was a cloudy and dark Friday night, Rainbow Dash's eyes were closed, her hooves were being restrained against the wall by Iron straps. She's been out for a while. Then, after a few minutes, which felt like forever... she slowly opened her eyes. She doesn't remember what happend. She just walked into Pinkie's house and was getting one of the ingredients for cupcakes, milk. She then felt something hit her head. And she's been out

She saw the room she is trapped in, there was a splatter of blood on three of the steel walls, there was a puddle of blood under her. Under the brown table with scissors, knives, and sharp object there was a pink lock of hair, which Rainbow Dash thought belonged to Fluttershy. She saw a skull with a small hole in it on the ground ahead of her. Then, she heard giggles in the room, the room was dark, there was a flickering light, there was some blood on the lamp and lightbulb.

She was confused why she was there and why she all of a sudden heard giggling, the giggles got louder, and louder. She asked in a worried expression, "Wh- Who.. is there?" she looks around and sees nopony. But she saw something that shocked her to her core.

It was a head, not a regular head. The head was orange, there was some splatter of red, sticky blood on it's cheeks. The head still had a purple mane, the eyes were missing. Rainbow Dash then saw a smile, that was stitched. She asked, "Isn't.. isn't... that the... head of Scootaloo... and where are her eyes?" then she saw a small black spider walk out of the eye hole.

Then, hoofsteps were heard, it sounds like if a pony was walking the stairs downstairs. Then, her eyes blinked and fluttered when the lights turned on. She had a shocked look when she saw Pinkamena. Pinkamena was wearing a dress, that had yellow, blue, purple, green and many other colors.

The dress had icons on it like a red heart lock, an orange triangle carrot, a purple bunch of grapes, a tree with a long brown bark and bushy green leaves. It even had a picture of a small cupcake with cyan frosting. She had splattered of blood on her face, she was also wearing a black eyepatch on her right eye. The wall behind her had a message, it was written in dark red blood, "Got Cupcakes?" some blood drops from the letters written in the wall race down to the ground. she had an evil grin on her face.

Pinkamena then giggled and said with an evil look on her face, "Hey Dashie.."

Rainbow Dash struggled to get out, the straps restrict her movement. She had a worried and terrified look on her face, her eyes rapidly examined the room with blood, body parts that smelt like a dumpster, and blood everywhere. She felt like she was in a medieval torture room. She asked in a raspy voice, "Pinkie.. what is the meaning of this! Why am I stapped against the wall and why is there blood and dead bodies everywhere... there is.. even a head belonging to Scootaloo!"

Pinkamena chuckled and said, "Oh Dashie, I am going to kill you and torture you... then use whatever is left.. for cupcakes... what did you think I made cupcakes with, silly?"

Rainbow Dash's face was a racing ground for sweat, her grin was upside down, and she looked at Pinkie Pie, there was a moment of silence. After a minute she said, "I am not worried... I.. will escape!" When Pinkamena heard this, her grin was sharp like a knife. She then burst into laughter, the sounds of her giggling echoed in the room.

She then looked at Rainbow Dash with a happy smile and said, "Oh Dashie, you are sooooooooooooooo funny... you will never escape... you must accept that this will be your fate.." she wiped a tear off from her right eye, she then grabbed a knife. Rainbow Dash had an un amused look on her face.

Rainbow Dash then yelled in an angry tone, "You are wr-" she couldn't finish her sentence because Pinkie Pie used her knife to remove a piece of cyan skin of Rainbow Dash, the skin that was cut off contained Rainbow Dash's cutiemark with the white cloud and lightbolt consisting of red, yellow and blue. Rainbow groaned in pain, she never been in so much pain before. Then Pinkie mercilessly stabbed her in her soft, cyan torso with the sharp, silver knife. Rainbow Dash groaned in pain, she closed her eyes and hissed. Small doses of blood leak from the stab wound. Rainbow Dash looked at Pinkie Pie, the stab was unbarable. She then said, "Pinkie... ow.. that hurts.."

Pinkie Pie slowly walked to the wooden table, there was blood on the brown, wooden table. She then looked through the table, she is looking for a good weapon to use to continuing torturing poor Rainbow Dash. She then grabbed a golden sickle and walked over to Rainbow Dash. She, all of a sudden lunged it at Rainbow Dash's face, she then pulled the sickle back, there was some blood that jumped out, some blood even got on Pinkamena's face, dress and even her deflated mane. Rainbow Dash yelled in pain, a few tear escaped her eye, her grin was crooked. After a few minutes of Rainbow Dash moaning in pain, she then looked at Pinkamena and asked, "Why... why? Why are you doing this? I been endlessly loyal to... you.... I always been a loyal friend and Pegasus to you!

Rainbow hung her head down low as she remembers the times she and Pinkamena have been best friends. She also remembers all the times that Rainbow Dash helped Pinkie and defended her against bullies in school, they bully her for some unknown reason. She even remembers that on Rainbow Dash's birthday, Rainbow Dash saw her best friend attacked by a mugger, the mugger hoped to rob Pinkamena from her money and valuables. she dashed into action and tackled the mugger. She took the Muggers gun and slapped him endlessly. She even remembers grabbing the mugger and throwing him into the flagpole, the cops came and the mugger was arrested. A tear of joy escaped her eye as she remembered those events. Her smile was slightly crooked.

Pinkamena didn't respond, her evil grin got wider and wider, she then swung her sickle at Rainbow Dash's face. She then yelled in pain, more blood leak from the eyehole. It was crimson red, and gooey blood that was leaked from the empty eyehole. Nothing could be seen in the eyehole. There was a huge stain of dark red blood on the golden sickle, Rainbow Dash then yelled, "OW!" There was a puddle of blood under her body. She then moaned in pain.

Pinkamena then walked over and put the sickle down, she then grabbed a baseball bat and walked over to where Rainbow Dash was restrained. She then swung the baseball bat, Rainbow Dash felt a massive pain in her stomach. She said, "Ow... what's that pain?" Rainbow Dash felt another pain in her stomach when Pinkamena swung a baseball bat at her stomach. She then put the baseball bat down.

She then looked at Rainbow Dash, who was in pain. Both her eyes were gone, there was blood leaking from the eyeholes. There was a small puddle of dark red below her. There was a huge stabwound in her chest. Rainbow Dash had a worried grin on her face. She worries that she could die, by being tortured and stabbed by the pony, she called, her best friend!

Rainbow Dash then asked, "Can you please... stop? I'm sorry for whatever I did to offend you... let me go and I won't tell anypony... nopony... not even the police not even Princess Celestia.. I'll lie."

Pinkamena then replied after a few seconds, "No." She then smiled, she then after a few seconds walked over to the table, she grabbed a butcher knife. She turned around and walked to Rainbow Dash. She had a crooked smile on her face.

Then, she swung her Butcher knife, Rainbow Dash's front hooves were cut off, a splatter of blood jumped and stained the steel walls. Rainbow Dash yelled in pain. She then asked herself, "Why did I come here..?" her heart is full of regret she thinks that if she never helped Pinkie she wouldn't be in this horrible situation. She hopes this is just a nightmare

Pinkie then stabbed Rainbow Dash's torso again, then, she created a huge hole in Rainbow Dash's torso, she then pulled a huge purple blob looking thing. It felt smiley and wet. Pinkie looked at the purple blob and back at Rainbow Dash. There was a ton of red, gooey blood splats on Pinkamena's face. There was even red, dried blood on her deflated, dark pink mane. There was even some red, and dried blood on her black eye-patch and dress. Some Pinkamena then said in a cheerful tone, "Nice Liver, Dashie!"

Rainbow Dash then groaned, "I need help... HEEEEEEEEEELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP, ANYPONY, please..." she hopes her cry for help can be heard by somepony, then somepony can come and rescue her from this nightmare.

Pinkamena then smiled and said in a happy tone, "Nopony will save you... Dashie.." Dash saw the creepy and wide smile on Pinkamena's face. Then, all of a sudden she saw Pinkie

Meanwhile, Mare Do Well was walking through the streets of Ponyville, tonight, unlike other nights, Tonight, Ponyville was peaceful. Most crimes Mare Do Well deals with are Muggers, drug dealers, or Foalnappers. Last night she dealt with some bruts who were trying to break into a house She sighed as she walked through the streets of Ponyville, the streetlights shine along with the moon and the stars. The purple and black hue of the night shines on the streets of Ponyville. She then heard something, she heard a mare screaming for help. She followed the continuation cries for help. She successfully traced the screams from the back of Sugarcube Corner after a long time. However, she had a shocked look when she saw Pinkie Pie lunging at Rainbow Dash with sharp objects though a small window that shows the basement of Sugar Cube Corner. She even sees a table with a sharp object, ranging from a butterknife, a butcher knife to even a chainsaw. There was even a pistol even though Mare Do Well knew that it is not a sharp object and it is really hard to get a gun in Equestria, Ponyville is the strictest when it comes to gun laws. Mare Do Well felt shivers down her spine, she never dealt with something serious like this before, usually she deals with brutes who are doing dumb things or selling illegal drugs..

Author's Note

How is it so far? Also, this story wasn't meant to attack or hurt anyone. I am not making fun of cupcakes, My intention was to make a parody of the ending in the Cupcake Creepypasta.

Chapter 2

She looked around the room and sees dark red, and dried blood on the walls, floor and even on Pinkamena herself. She then saw Pinkie cut a line on Rainbow Dash's neck. Blood leaked from the wound, Rainbow Dash then slowly closed her eyes. she tries to stop her eyes from closing. Mare Do Well then punched the window and jumped through the windows, a bunch of window shards fall on the basement. Pinkamena had a confused look on her face. She said, "What the?"

Mare Do Well stood there, she yelled in a confident tone, "Enough, you will back away from the mare and stop torturing and stabbing her!"

Pinkamena laughed when she heard this and asked, "Who are you, Nightmare Night isn't till six weeks from now!" She had an evil smile on her face.

Then, Mare Do Well then yelled, "I am Mare Do Well.." She stood confidently. She had a determined look on her face and plans how she will defeat the maniac.

Rainbow Dash then yelled, "Finally a hero who can help... me.." More dark red and slime like blood leak from the cuts Pinkie made, she struggled to stay alive. She had a sad look on her face, some tears race down her face. Pinkamena then jumped at Mare Do Well, a dagger was in her hooves, there was some blood on the silver blade. Mare Do Well punched Pinkamena and grabbed her. She then slammed Pinkie into the ground. She then elbow dropped on Pinkamena. Pinkamena moans in pain. She then tried to punch Mare Do Well but Pinkie blocked and punch Mare Do Well straight in the face.

Mare Do Well went flying, she landed on her hooves, she then saw as Pinkamena got up, pretty quickly. She then said, "I am not barely trying and I am defeating you!" She then threw a hoard of cupcakes at Mare Do Well, it had green, yellow and pink frosting. She threw this in a fast pace and plans to jump and punch Mare Do Well, hoping she won't see her coming with cupcakes in her face. But Pinkamena didn't expect Mare Do Well to jump as the hoard of cupcakes was being tossed at her in a quick pace. She jumped and swiped away the cupcakes that Pinkamena was throwing at her. She then groaned in anger, "How is this happening?" She then grabbed a knife and threw it at Mare Do Well it didn't hit Mare Do Well's body but it hit her big, purple fedora. Her fedora went flying and the knife hung the big, and purple fedora on the walls. Mare Do Well then dodged Pinkamena's surprise punch.

Mare Do Well then dodge punches, kicks. Pinkie ran at the table with the sharp, pointy, and lethal weapons and then jumped at Mare Do Well with the butcher Knife. When Pinkie was about to stab Mare Do Well grabbed Pinkamena's hoof that was holding the knife, she then punch Pinkamena in the throat. Pinkamena went flying and knocked over the table of lethal and deadly objects. Pinkamena can be heard moaning in pain. Pinkamena then slowly got up and when Mare Do Well was running at Rainbow Dash who was restrained against the walls. Pinkamena then tackled Mare Do Well. Mare Do Well and Pinkamena's hooves were pressed against the other, Pinkamena withdrew one of her hooves and pulled out a knife, and tried to stab Mare Do Well on her exposed belly.

But, Mare Do Well had no time to react, the blade was being pushed under Mare Do Well's belly. Mare Do Well then quickly lifted up one hindhoof and kicked Pinkamena, she this time knocked down three crates holding skulls of dead ponies that fell into this trap before. Mare Do Well tried to get up. Mare Do Well was slowly getting up she threw the knife and threw it at Pinkamena, she wants to defeat this maniac before it kills any more innocent ponies. The knife missed and made a hole in the wall.

Pinkamena got up and asked in a rude tone, "Done clowning around?" She had a tired but determined look on her face, she felt massive pain against her neck. She hopes she can end this fight sooner and defeat the hero preventing her from her evil plan. She then grabbed a gernade and threw it at Mare Do Well, Mare Do Well jumped towards the left side of the room and avoid facing damages. Pinkamena jumped and punched and even tried to kick Mare Do Well, but her attacks would fail as Mare Do Well will always block the attacks. Mare Do Well's luck expired when Pinkamena jumped and drop kicked Mare Do Well. Mare Do Well felt a massive pain in her leg, she walked backwards.

She saw Pinkie jumping at her, she sloppily pound her right hoof on Pinkamena's head causing her to be slammed into the ground. She felt tired and realized that maybe Mare Do Well might be too strong. Mare Do Well kicked Pinkamena in the head. Pinkamena suddenly punched Mare Do in the stomach. She then got up, Mare Do well jumped back. Pinkamena saw her chainsaw which was laying on the ground, she pulled the strong that turns on the Chainsaw and threw it at Mare Do Well. Mare Do Well dodges and it hits the stack of large, wooden crates behind her. Mare Do Well jumped to the left and behind a row of crates. She felt dizzy, massive pain in her head. She realizes this won't be easy and that Pinkamena could win if she doesn't try to end the fight now by throwing something lethal or something that will injure her badly and cause her to surrender.

She looked at the three items that were next other, as she was trying to select an item to use to end this fight, she heard Pinkie asked in a foal like and creepy tone, "Where are you, Mare Do Well.. I got a surprise for you..." She saw her looking around the room, blood was on her chest, and she had a tired look on her face, she was also carrying a dagger knife. Mare Do Well's options were a bottle with some flammable stuff inside, a match, and scissors, all three were sitting in the ground.

Chapter 3

Mare Do Well was shocked when she heard giggling from her left. She then slowly turned to where the giggling was. Pinkamena was holding a large, blue party cannon, with pink wheels. She then yelled, "Got you!" Mare Do Well waste no time and grabbed the red scissors and stabbed Pinkamena. She then picked Pinkamena up and threw her mercilessly against the wall. Pinkamena groaned and struggled to get back on her hooves. Mare Do Well then lit the match by swiping the match against the matchbox. She then lit the bottle.

She then yelled, "Eat this!" she then threw this when Pinkamena was on the floor, all four of her hooves were on the ground, she had a tired and weak expression on her face. She and unintentionally Rainbow Dash felt their body heating up. After a long thirty seconds of yelling in pain and seeing Pinkamena being consumed by the flames. She had a worried and sad expression when she also saw Rainbow Dash being consumed by fire. She didn't mean to hurt her and was aiming at Pinkie, she forgot the damages that weapon caused. She only used that weapon once when a hoard of 12 brute ponies were robbing a bank, one Monday morning. The bank was robbed so they can have a lot of money, be rich and buy drugs, illegally. Mare Do Well saw their bodies are covered in orange and yellow flames. Meanwhile, Mare Do Well also failed to notice that fire can spread quickly. She felt something burning, and when she looked down the orange and yellow flames were on her hind hooves. She then quickly felt her front hooves, her face, and even her neck be consumed by fire. She, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkamena was yelling in pain. They can be heard yelling for help. There is no water down there and the front door is locked, the key location is unknown.

Meanwhile, Sugarcube Corner then slowly but pretty quickly got set on fire, the sign of the building was unrecognizable, the building is covered in orange and yellow flames. Mare Do Well then yelled, "Why did I do this?"

Rainbow Dash yelled, "Somepony help!" Her scream was not heard.

Pinkamena then had a sad look on her face, she then said, "This... is... not over.... this fight.. never ended," she then turned to Mare Do Well and yelled, "Mare Do Well.. I hate you.."

The flames consumed the three ponies and most of the building, the sound of sirens can be heard. Fire ponies arrived. The chief firepony opened the door of the firetruck and jumped out and closed the firetruck door. He had gray mane, gray beard, white coat and green eyes. He walked to where the fire was happening. Then he turned around and then.. the chief yelled in a commanding tone, "Ponies, you know what to do, get the hose, go inside to save the ponies inside, and make sure that fire is gone, completely.. I had a streak of stopping fires for 25 years now and I am not letting it be dissolved." The fireponies rushed and got the hoses, and splash water into the house being eaten by orange and yellow flames. One Firepony with an Orange coat, blue eyes and red mane and dressed in his firepony attire, ran with an axe and swung at the door, the door yelled, "CRACK, CRACK, CRACK" when the firepony swung his axe against the old wooden door. Before he can completely make a hole big enough for him and his team to come in.. fire got into his clothes and he ran around the scene while screaming in pain, a firepony tried to help but he ran fast and the hose keep missing, Finally after a long time, the pony fell on the floor, his eyes were closed, his breathing and heart beat stop, his scared look dissolved and was replaced with a upside down grin. He was removed and buried, he was not forgotten among his team members.

After what seemed like an hour, the fire stopped, the building was not the same, The building was rusty, had brown spots round the restaurant, a window had a huge crack in it. Not to mention, many treats and goodies were destroyed by the fire also the tables had dark spots and wasn't stable like they used to be.

Then, as the firepony did their duties and clean up, the chief said, "I can't believe the ponies in the building didn't make it... my streak and reputation is destroyed. But I know... they lived a good life..." He had a joyful look on his face.

Mare Do Well, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkamena's ashes were in the building. They were put in a burial. Mare Do Well was honored for her service and ensuring safety in Equestria, Rainbow Dash was also respected, they felt bad that she didn't get to join the Wonderbolts which was her dream job. They were happy Pinkamena was gone, she killed several ponies, even Scootaloo. She tortured and killed many innocent ponies. She wasn't caught since there wasn't a lot of evidence and the police ponies were corrupt. But now everypony in Equestria can rest easily knowing, Pinkamena bite the dust and won't be harming.. any ponies.

Author's Note

Thanks for reading. I also like to thank God for helping me make this.