More Than Just Best Friends

by StormLuna

Rating: mature
Tags: Porn, Fetish, Starlight Glimmer, Self Insert, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Anthro, Romance
Length: 5269

It had been one year since I moved to Equestria and I befriended Starlight Glimmer. We began to grow closer and ultimately we thought of one another as best friends. I knew we had grown close but I never knew how close.

It had been one year since I moved to Equestria and I befriended Starlight Glimmer. We began to grow closer and ultimately we thought of one another as best friends. I knew we had grown close but I never knew how close until one evening Starlight paid me a visit.

Story contains: Oral, Vaginal, Anal, panty fetish and engagement.

Cover art source: https://derpibooru.org/images/2750189

Featured on 9/30/2023 & 10/1/2023

Published 2023-09-30 20:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2023-09-30 20:00:01 UTC

Fulfilling Our Fantasies

About Me

It had been one year since I took part in a program that allowed ten humans to move to Equestria while maintaining our natural forms. I remember when we first arrived, we were not given an option of which community we would get to live in. I remember hoping so badly that Princess Celestia would make Ponyville my residence and much to my delight, she did. The good thing about the program, Celestia provided the participants with housing. The bad thing though was that we had to find jobs on our own and given that we were all humans, that was not the easiest thing.

Luckily finding a job was rather easy for me. Given that I worked at the credit union where I lived in my world, getting a job at the credit union in Ponyville was rather easy and thus, money was not an issue. This also made getting to know ponies not so difficult. They would see how friendly I was on the job so that made getting to know them off the job easier, well once I came out of my shell and started attending community festivals.

I still remember that one day when I decided to attend the local Hearts and Hooves Day festival. Now I wasn't expecting anything special to go on for me, I simply went and hoped that I could make a few friends. Now befriending Pinkie Pie was easy since she wanted to be friends with everypony, well everyone in my case. Befriending Twilight Sparkle wasn't difficult either since she wanted to know more about my culture and write a paper about it. Befriending Fluttershy was a bit more difficult because of her introverted nature but hey, it happened.

Befriending Starlight Glimmer though took time. I don't know if she didn't know what to think about me being from a completely different world but after a couple of months, we became friends and that friendship wound up blossoming to the point where we thought of one another as besties. We would spend multiple evenings a week together and unless Twilight had her doing a friendship lesson or they had an out of town trip, Sundays wound up becoming a day that we spent together at my house. I think Twilight was a bit suspicious of that at first but after a couple months of us doing this and nothing out of the ordinary happening, she seemed to be perfectly fine with her friend doing this.

Starlight Comes Over

Fall had arrived and temperatures had begun to cool some along with the leaves changing colors. For me this was always something that I dreaded in my world because it was a signal that winter would ultimately arrive and well, I hated winter. It was cold, uncomfortable and the days were short and I figured it would be the exact same in Equestria. During the summer the sun would still be brightly shining when I got off work but by this time it would be setting and I'd walk home as darkness was setting in. It wasn't that I felt uncomfortable doing so, it was just a matter that I couldn't enjoy doing much of anything after getting off work.

I remember one evening temperatures were a bit cooler than normal for October when I headed home. It was a Friday evening so I figured that I'd treat myself to a larger than normal meal like I always did. One thing that I missed quite a bit from my world was meat and that was something that I learned that only griffons ate in Equestria and unfortunately, no griffons ever came to Ponyville to sell any food. Well it wasn't like any of them would given that I was the only one in the town that had a history of meat eating. I figured then that I'd just go to Griffonstone the following day and buy some, well that and some of the griffon scones I had heard so much about.

After eating supper it was probably around 7:30 so I decided to sit down and read one of the Daring Do books that Twilight had loaned me. Just as I got sat down I heard a knock on my door. That was really surprising given that I was not expecting any company that evening. Yes Starlight would come over to visit on some evenings but normally Friday nights were when she and her friends gathered for supper in Twilight's castle.

I got up and yelled, "Coming!"

I got up and answered the door. Standing there was Starlight with a smile on her face prompting me to continue, "Hi Starlight, I wasn't expecting you this evening."

She gave me a smile, "I know but Twilight and Rarity got called on a friendship mission so I figured I'd come and see my best friend!"

While she had referred to us as best friends before, she had never put that kind of emphasis on it before and this caused me to smile a bit more than normal. I pulled my door open further and said, "Come in, it is getting cold outside!"

She came in and headed straight towards my living room and like she had been doing for quite some time, she plopped down on my couch while I sat down in my recliner. Once I got sat down she gave me a smile and asked, "Luke, why do you always sit in that recliner when I come over? Why don't you come sit by me?" She then giggled a bit, "Don't worry, I don't bite!"

I blushed a bit before getting up and sitting on the couch with her. I wound up sitting on the other end of the couch from her and she seemed to sigh in frustration before moving closer to me. She pressed herself up against me and suggested, "How about we sit closer together? I am cold and I was thinking that a nice warm body up next against mine would feel better."

Once she got up next to me she threw her arm around me and immediately I blushed, which she quickly noticed. "Luke, was that a blush?" I wasn't sure how to answer it with the exception of an even deeper blush causing her to add, "It is, isn't it?"

I replied, "Uh...." I then decided to take what I thought was a risk despite her putting her arm around me and put my arm around her too. I then continued, "Uh, maybe!"

She gave me a cute smile, "Oh I'm sure it is more than maybe!" She paused before giggling, "Do you have a crush on me?"

I am going to admit right now, I did have a crush on her, a huge crush. During any other visit there is no way I could have flat out admitted it to her but this time, I knew I could admit it because she had obviously figured it out. "I do Starlight, I have a crush on you." When I saw her smile grow bigger I added, "A huge crush!"

She then turned to where she was facing me and threw her other arm around me before exclaiming, "I knew it Luke, I knew you had a crush on me!" She then paused before kissing my ear and whispering, "I've had a crush on you too since the day that we met and I'm sure you've been crushing on me for just as long."

I gave a nervous smile, "Uh huh!"

Starlight then released her hold on me and asked, "Can I use your restroom?"

I replied, "Of course you can, you know where it is."

She got up and headed towards my bedroom which is where my bathroom was. It was kind of odd because she had only used it once before and never had been so quick to ask. I at first wondered why but then it hit me, given that we had revealed our crushes she likely felt more comfortable asking. One thing was for sure, I did look forward to her coming back out and hopefully us holding one another close and maybe, just maybe even us sharing a kiss.

My Fantasy Fulfilled

It had been roughly five minutes and she had yet to return. I was getting a bit concerned about her but then I heard her yell, "Luke, could you come back? I need help with something!"

I wasn't sure exactly what she would need help with but I headed back fully expecting my toilet to be overflowing or something else that would be less than pleasant. When I got back I discovered that Starlight was not in my bathroom but was standing there by my bed wearing nothing but a black bra that was barely holding her voluptuous breasts in along with a pair of matching black panties. As I took in what I was seeing I gasped, "Starlight, you're, you're, you're so......."

I was unable to finish my sentence before she finished it for me, "Sexy?" I nervously nodded and she must have noticed that I had got hard rather quickly as she approached me, groped me and asked, "Is that for me?"

I nervously replied, "Uh-huh!"

What I thought was just a friendly visit from her was becoming much more. I never once imagined that she would be thinking of such a thing. Everything I knew about her, including things Twilight had told me, caused me to think that something like this would never cross her mind, much less her asking about my member being for her!

She gave me a smile, "Well you know I can't have it with both of us still having clothes on!"

She then grabbed me and began to undress me. As she was undressing me, I felt like every single dream I had ever had since first meeting her was coming true. Here was who was obviously the sexiest mare in existence undressing me. Once she got me down to where I was only in my boxers she pointed to herself and suggested, "Luke, how about you get me undressed and then I'll finish with you!"

I gave her a smile and immediately began to undress her. The first thing I did was remove her bra, revealing her sexy tits in all their glory. It felt like they were staring straight into my soul, begging me to start sucking on them but I knew Starlight was wanting something else so I got on my hands and knees and readied myself to remove her panties. I wasn't going to do this the standard way though, I wanted to remove them with my teeth.

Once I bit down on them she giggled, "A panty fetish? That is so sexy!"

I gave her a brief smile before beginning to remove them from her. Once I got them low enough she raised her legs so that I could fully remove them. Rather than simply releasing them from my mouth though, I took the part that covered her pussy and began to suck on them and oh my goodness, they tasted so sweet! When I started doing this she giggled, "Is this your way of saying you want to clean my panties for me?"

I gave her a nervous smile, "Uh-huh!"

She then suggested, "If you like that, just wait until you taste my girl!"

After sucking for a few more seconds I spit them out and immediately took to her vagina. The moment I began to suck on her and run my tongue up in her she let out a moan, "Oh Luke baby, yes!"

The moment I started eating her, I felt a wave of ecstasy flowing through me. Here I was eating the tastiest thing ever from the sexiest mare in all of Equestria. The more I sucked on her and probed her, the more of it I wanted. As her moaning became louder and the more she called out my name, the more I anticipated the meal that I would soon receive. After a few minutes she let out a loud moan, "Oh Luke baby, yes baby yesssss!"

She then flooded my mouth with cum and oh my goodness, it was so tasty. As I began to drink it, I felt a shock wave flowing through my body. It was unlike anything else I had ever experienced and I did know one thing, I was hoping that I could have more of it, lots more of it.

Once I got done drinking every last drop of her cum she pulled me up by the hair and suggested, "Luke, you've eaten me and now it is my turn to eat you!"

I gave her a huge smile as she got down on her hands and knees and removed my boxers. She looked up and gave me a smile, "Oh my, this looks so so tasty!"

She then took straight to my member and began to suck hard. I moaned, "Oh Starlie baby, yes baby yes!"

She briefly stocked and giggled, "Starlie? I like that, I really like that!"

She then took to me again and I continued to moan out the pet name I had given her as she was giving out muffled moans. As she was doing this I began to moan louder and breathe heavier as my heart began to race faster and faster. Never before in my life had I felt anything so good but unfortunately I would climax all too quickly as I moaned out, "Oh Starlie baby, oh Starlieeeee!"

I then flooded her mouth with my cum and I could tell she liked it as she was moaning gently while she was swallowing it. Once she had milked me entirely she stood up, plopped down on my bed and suggested, "Luke baby, come fulfill our fantasies, come take me, show me your kinks!"

I gave her a smile and replied, "Oh I will hot stuff! Get ready for me to rock your world!"

I had multiple fetishes and I decided I was going to start with the part that was closest to me, her feet. I quickly leaned down and started sucking on her big toe but quickly she kicked and giggled, "Luke, stop! My feet are ticklish!"

I gave her a smile, "But Starlie, you said for me to show you my kinks!"

She then resigned herself to this, "Oh alright, I did tell you that!"

I then resumed sucking on her toes as she continued to giggle and gently kick. Once I had sucked on each toe and ran my tongue between them, I began to move my sucking up on to her legs. Very quickly I noticed that she wasn't like other ponies, even other mares. I had noticed that every other pony in Equestria had a rather coarse coat but Starlight's coat was much more silk like, it felt like a woman's skin back in my world and this made me very happy.

Soon I got up to her inner thighs and I could smell something, something just like what I had tasted earlier. I stopped sucking for a moment and asked, "Somepony's really turned on, isn't she?"

Starlight gave me the cutest response ever, "Mhmm!"

Oh my goodness that turned me on so much. I had never been in a situation like this before but I knew it was a sign that she was truly enjoying this so I moved on to something I had before, her love canal. The moment I began to suck she began to moan, "Oh Luke baby, yes baby yes!"

I intensified my sucking and started probing my tongue as deep inside of her as I could. I could feel her heart beating faster and hear her breathing becoming heavier as she continued to moan out my name. This time she took a bit longer to climax but when she did, she seemed to taste even sweeter than before. Once I finished I gave her a smile, "You're even sweeter than before!"

She gave me a mischievous smile, "Oh just wait Luke, I have something even better waiting for you!"

I wasn't sure exactly what she was talking about but then I continued to move up right to her belly. The moment I started to suck on it she began to squirm and pouted, "Not fair Luke, not fair! Sucking on my belly is not nice!"

I giggled, "But seeing you squirm is so sexy and so adorable!"

She then giggled, "Oh alright but you better let me make you squirm too!" She then raised her voice and giggled louder, "I'll let you make me squirm as long as you'll submit to me whenever I want you to!"

The very idea of submitting to Starlight made me hot, very hot! I had developed such a connection with her that I would be willing to let her do pretty much anything she wanted to me. I replied, "Oh alright Starlie, it is whatever you want!"

She gave me a smile before pointing to her breasts and ordering, "Now come and suck on my girls! You know you want to!"

I did want to, very badly. Before that day, I always wondered why she dressed so modestly but then I knew why. Now here she was wanting me to suck on the tits she hid from everypony else and I wasn't about to pass up this opportunity. I immediately took to one of them the way a newborn would and it felt so wonderful. As I was sucking on her, I saw her light up her horn and cast a spell. I had a feeling as to what kind of spell it was and readied myself for another tasty meal.

Very quickly I began to feel milk flowing into my mouth and sweet Celestia, her milk was by far the tastiest thing I had ever consumed and it seemed like the more I drank, the more of it I wanted. It was as though it was addictive and soon I began to feel something strange, I began to feel my member grow in length and in circumference. It wasn't just that, I began to feel my testicles grow in size too and at that moment I knew, I knew she was doing what it took so I could give her the maximum amount of pleasure.

Once I finished sucking on her breast she pointed to her other one and suggested, "How about you drink this one dry too. After all, it wouldn't be very nice to leave one full." She paused before whispering, "After you drink it dry, then we can take one another!"

I gave her a smile and took to her other tit. As I was drinking her milk, I began to feel something so much more than just a major league crush for her. I had already developed love for her but this milk, it was making me want to be hers forever, it was making me want to submit to her but most of all, it was causing my love for her to increase exponentially. Once I had drank both of her tits dry I crawled up to where we were looking one another in the eyes and I could feel the love coming from her.

She gave me a smile and began, "Luke baby, tonight you have made almost all of my dreams come true and I know I have done the same for you." She pulled me into a deep kiss before adding, "Now how about we consummate the love we have for one another. How about we become each other's first, each other's last, each other's only!"

As she said this, I felt a surge of warmth flow through me that I never imagined possible. I had been a loner for most of my life but here I was about to consummate a loving relationship with the sexiest and sweetest mare in Equestria. It was everything I had ever wanted and then some. I gave her a kiss and replied, "I'm ready Starlie, I'm ready to be yours forever!"

She returned the kiss and said, "And I'm ready to bed yours forever too Luke, yours forever." She paused before adding, "Just be careful, as you know this is my first time."

I again kissed her and replied, "I know sweetie, I know."

I then lined my member up with her love canal and began to insert it. Both of us gave gentle moans of delight as I started to glide it in. Soon though I felt a barrier that quickly gave way and she screamed loudly and sank her fingernails into my back. I quit pushing into her and asked, "Starlight sweetie, do you want me to stop?"

Starlight yelled, "No, just lay still for a minute and I'll let you know when we can truly consummate our love!" I stopped for a minute before she ordered, "Now take me Luke, take me baby! Fill me up, make me yours!"

I then began to thrust her with more force and our moans became louder and louder. We quickly pulled one another into a deep kiss and moaned loudly into one another's mouths. As I was giving it to her hard, she wrapped her legs around me, tightening her vaginal muscles around me harder and the feeling was so wonderful. It was something that I truly had never imagined before but all too soon, I could feel it coming. I began to breathe heavier and moan louder but then I saw her flare up her horn and suddenly I didn't feel my climax coming.

Starlight quickly climaxed and moaned loudly, "Oh Luke baby yes, yes baby yes! Harder, faster, deeper!"

I continued to pound her harder and harder to the point where the mattress was squeaking and she continued to have climax and climax, releasing hot and wet cum all over me. I am not sure how long it was before I saw her flare up her horn again and almost immediately I felt it coming. I was slamming up against her cervix as I let forth a flood of cum into her. I moaned "Oh Starlie baby, yes baby yes!" as I began to release my seed into her.

It felt strange though as I was cumming in her. It felt like I continued to flood more and more of my seed into her, sending it straight into her needy uterus. I was unsure as to whether I would get her pregnant or not but deep down I wished that I could do that someday, someday if we was to ever get married. When my supply was finally exhausted, I collapsed on top of her and sighed loudly, Oh Starlie baby, I never knew such pleasure existed!"

She pulled me to her, kissed me and replied, "Oh Luke, you made me feel like a queen tonight! I could do this forever, I could have you pound me forever!"

I returned the kiss and whispered into her ear, "I could do this with you forever too Starlie." I paused before adding, "I love you so much Starlight Glimmer, I love you more than anything, ever!"

Her eyes lit up as she asked, "Really? You love me more than anything?"

I gave her another kiss and replied, "I do Starlie, I do!"

She then gave me a smile and suggested, "How about we get under the covers and get some sleep? I think we should get some rest before we express our love more tomorrow!"

I agreed and we crawled under the covers before wrapping our hot sweaty bodies together tightly. She was rather quick to fall asleep while I had so many things running through my mind. As I laid there and listened to her rhythmic breathing, I began to think about things much longer term. I knew that we had just consummated our love for one another but a big part of me was wanting to ask her the "big question." Yes it would be quick and it would be very risky but just from the way she was asking and some of the things she had said, I had a strong feeling that she might actually want marriage.

Yes, a Billion Times Yes and More!

Morning had arrived and the sun woke the two of us up. Despite me being the last one to fall asleep, I was the first to rise. Starlight was still breathing gently as I was holding her close. I couldn't help but smile as I took in her beauty, just imagining what I hoped would be a wonderful future with her. Soon she opened her eyes and gave me a smile, "Good morning sweetie!"

I gave a kiss and replied, "Good morning Starlie!"

We continued to smile for a moment before pulling one another into a passionate kiss. We began to rub our bodies together passionately, working up a heavy sweat. The feeling of her hot sweaty body wrapped around mine felt so wonderful, it was another thing that I had always fantasized about. I wasn't sure how long it was that we kept it up but we ultimately broke the kiss. At that moment I decided that I just had to tell her about my feelings before I would chicken out.

I gave her a loving look and began, "Starlie, I am going to admit that I have had a crush on you from the moment I first laid eyes on you. Your eyes are so beautiful, your smile is so appealing, your mane and tail amplifies your beauty further but most of all, the energy I feel radiating for you makes you so wonderful to me. You are everything I have ever dreamed of and last night was something I truly believed I would never have, Starlie, you are my everything!"

She gave me a kiss and replied, "Luke baby, before last night I never imagined I would find love. I have had friends in the past but never had I developed feelings for anypony, or anyone in your case, until I laid eyes on you. I remember when I first saw you, I began to fantasize about you and have the types of thoughts that I had to hide from everypony." She kissed me before continuing, "When I would finger myself at night, pretending it was you inside of me, I always had to be so quiet so Twilight wouldn't hear me but last night, my dreams came true. It was you inside of me, everything I have always wanted." She then paused before nervously asking, "Luke, I am so nervous right now but I want to know something, would you be my boyfriend?"

My heart exploded when she asked me this but I then decided to ask her something more, "I would love to Starlie but I have a much bigger question to ask you." I saw her eyes light up when I said this before I nervously asked, "Starlie, would, would you marry me?"

Starlight pulled herself on top of me and began to kiss me passionately. After her passionate kiss she exclaimed, "Yes Luke yes! Yes, a billion times yes! Of course I'll marry you!"

The two of us kissed again before crying tears of joy. Never before did I imagine that I would become engaged, much less to the mare I fell for the moment I saw her. Our cries became louder as we began to kiss passionately again. We wrapped ourselves tighter and tighter together as we cried harder and harder. Once we broke our kiss and our tears subsided I gave her a loving smile, "Oh Starlie, I never imagined this would ever happen! I never imagined I would be marrying you!"

She gave me a smile, "Well now you will be and we can make each other happy all the time!" She got up on her hands and knees, raised her tail and giggled, "Would you give me one more thing?" She then began to whine, "I want it so bad, I need it so bad and I know you want to give it to me!"

Her whine was so cute and I will admit, giving her anal was another fantasy of mine and I was not about to let her down so I mounted her and lined my member up with her hole. When she felt my member hit her buns she added, "Now get to it Luke and be rough!"

I leaned over and kissed her neck before shoving my member between her buns right into her hole and oh my goodness, her hole was so hot, wet and tight. We both let out a moan of pleasure the moment I was inside her and we both began to moan loudly as I drilled her harder and harder.

Our breathing became heavier as she began to moan, "Oh yes Luke yes! Yes baby yes! Pound me as hard as you can, buck me hard." I wrapped myself around her, groping her tits and pounding her harder. Her moans became louder and louder, "Oh yes Luke, yes! Pound your sexy fiance hard! Yes baby yes!"

"Oh Starlie baby, you feel so good! Yes baby yes!"

Soon my breathing became heavier and my moans became louder and I knew my climax was coming. She then flared her horn up again and cast another spell to delay my climax. I continued to pound her for what had to be hours before she flared up her horn again and finally I climaxed and flooded her behind with my cum. Once I had exhausted my supply I fell onto my back and she crawled on top of me. She exclaimed, "Oh Luke baby that felt so good! I could let you pound me like that for hours and hours on end!"

I gave her a quick kiss before replying, "And Starlight, I could give it to you for hours on end, in both holes!"

Starlight giggled, "And I wouldn't have it any other way!" She paused before adding, "And once we're married, I hope you'll get me pregnant, multiple times! I want us to have many, many foals!"

That was something I certainly never expected but it did sound very appealing. I gave her a kiss before replying, "If you want a lot of foals, we can have them but for the first few years of our marriage, I'd love it if it could just be us, making love every single day!"

Starlight giggled, "And I wouldn't have it any other way!" She paused before adding, "For now though, how about we shower, you fix us some breakfast and then we can do another wonderful thing." She paused before adding, "How about we 69 the rest of the day away, my spells can delay your orgasm for hours and hours!"

I gave her a smile, "I would love that Starlie, I want to do that so badly!"

When Starlight first came to visit me that evening, I never once imagined that we would do everything we did. I never once imagined that we would share our bodies the way we did but the most wonderful thing for me though was us becoming engaged to be married. I wasn't sure how Twilight was going to react to Starlight and I becoming engaged and hopefully married sooner rather than later but I did know one thing, our future was going to be bright....and filled with lots of love and naturally, tons and tons of sex.