A Perfect Hearth's Warming Eve

by StormLuna

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fluttershy, Porn, Sex, Fetish, Self Insert, Human, Anthro
Length: 4093

Hearth's Warming had arrived again and despite having lived in Ponyville for three years now, I still felt kind out of place when the holiday came along. That would all change though when my best friend came to visit me.

Hearth's Warming had arrived again and despite having lived in Ponyville for three years now, I still felt kind out of place when the holiday came along. That would all change though when my best friend came to visit me. I had something for her but what she had for me was unexpected but it would make my Hearth's Warming perfect.

https://www.deviantart.com/penzyy/art/Fluttershy-942564473

Published 2023-12-23 23:30:00 UTC
Last updated 2023-12-23 23:30:00 UTC

A Hearth's Warming Eve to Remember

It was over one year ago that I took part in a program that allowed ten humans to move to Equestria and ten ponies to move to my world all while maintaining our natural forms. I remember when I was one of the lucky ten who were selected. One major reason I chose to do this was because rather than being the Equestria I was familiar with, it was an anthro version. The main reasons were because I felt like I would fit in better and also, I thought maybe that I could find love in a mare who wouldn't mind me being human.

Once I arrived and met Princess Celestia, she decided that Ponyville would be the best place for me. I was kind of hoping that I wouldn't be the only human to get sent there but I was. I just hoped that the ponies there wouldn't see me as an alien creature that may be a threat and not want anything to do with me. When I first arrived most ponies seemed indifferent of me although I did catch a few odd glances. I figured that was the case because none of them had seen a human before.

Ultimately I did make some friends. It didn't take too long for me to befriend the ponies at the bowling alley because not only did I enjoy bowling but I was pretty good at it. I did get to know other ponies, including Filthy Rich who gave me a job. First he had me working in the back but once I had been around long enough and he knew that ponies didn't have any negative opinions of me, he had me working as a cashier. That is when I began to get to know more ponies, including Twilight Sparkle and her friends. I did get along with them fairly well but there was one who really wanted to get to know me.

The first one that wanted to get to know me was surprisingly Fluttershy. I thought it would be Twilight so that she could get to know about my culture but instead, if was Fluttershy. I was happy about that because while I would never admit it to anypony, I had developed a crush on her. I still remember that day when she asked me if I would want to go out to supper. I was naturally surprised but I did go out with her to the cafe and I think she was surprised when I offered to pay despite her being the one who asked me. I still remember that smile of hers. It was accompanied with a blush and it was at that moment that I fell for her. I wasn't sure if she could tell how I felt but she did want us to spend more time together after that.

At first it was just us going out to the cafe but soon she started wanting me to go to her cottage to help her with her animals and ultimately she started coming to my place because she did like the hayburgers I would fix. I wasn't sure if anything would ever develop between us but it did seem like we were growing closer. I will admit, I was really hoping that something would happen before Hearth's Warming Eve but I wasn't going to be upset or disappointed if it didn't. It was just back in June when we first went out to supper and knowing Fluttershy, she would likely be the last pony in Equestria to rush anything involving a relationship.

Hearth's Warming Eve had arrived and all of Ponyville was in a very festive mood. At work it was incredibly busy as many ponies had come to Barnyard Bargains to buy last minute gifts for their friends and family. In the afternoon Fluttershy came in with a smile on her face but what surprised me was that she came to the check-out counter but did not have anything. I asked her, "Fluttershy, is everything ok? Do you need help finding something?"

She gave me the smile and blush that found so attractive and replied, "No but I do need you to come to my cottage this evening because I have something really special for you!"

I was in a state of shock that she would have something for me, especially something that she would put so much emphasis on being really special. I asked, "What time do you want me to be there?"

She gave me a smile as she replied, "I know today is busy for you so how does seven sound?"

I got off that day at five and that would give me time to hopefully be able to get her something as well. I replied, "Seven sounds good."

She gave me a smile before heading out. The rest of that day seemed to drag by as all I could think about was Fluttershy and what it was that she had for me. I also wondered what in Equestria I could get for her. I never had been good at knowing what to get others for either their birthday or for holidays but I knew of one pony who would know what she would like, Rarity. There was one problem though, by the time I would get off work her boutique would likely be closed. I figured that I could try and pay her a visit and hope that she would be at home.

Despite it being rather busy, Filthy Rich allowed me to get going at five when my shift ended. The very first place I headed was to Rarity's to see if she was still there. I noticed that she still had an open sign in her window despite it being so late on Hearth's Warming Eve. When I headed in I heard her normal greeting, "Welcome to the Carousel Boutique where everything is chic, unique and magnifique." She then noticed I was the one who came in and continued, "Oh hi Luke." She gave me a smile and asked, "I take it you're here to get something for Fluttershy?"

I was surprised that she would know about me needing to get something for Fluttershy. Perhaps Fluttershy had told her about her plans to invite me over and figured I would need some advice on what to get for her. I replied, "Yeah, she invited me over and I'm horrible when it comes to getting others gifts. What sort of things does she like?"

Rarity had a smile on her face as she headed into the back. I wasn't sure why she did that at first but then I figured that she was likely going to show me something she knew that her friend would like. Once she got back out she showed me a rather revealing nightgown that was green in color. That was something that I really couldn't see Fluttershy liking but Rarity was probably her closest friend so that is what I decided to get her. After paying Rarity for it, she put it in a bag and handed it to me. She gave me a smile and said, "Now don't have too much fun with Fluttershy darling!"

I nervously replied, "Alright."

As I left her boutique, I couldn't help but wonder what she meant by "don't have too much fun." Did she know something that I didn't? Did she know about what it was that Fluttershy had plans for? While I was headed to her cottage, I kept on wondering why Rarity said what she did. I wondered what Fluttershy may have told her.

I was so focused on this that I had completely lost track of time and was there before I knew it. Once I arrived, I noticed something strange. I noticed that there were more animals than normal outside. This shocked me because it was chilly and she normally had more of them inside with her this time of year. Even Angel was outside and I thought that she would never have him outside, regardless of the weather conditions.

After noticing all her animals were outside, I knocked on the door immediately and heard a loud voice, "Come on in Luke and lock the door behind you!"

I headed in but I did not see a trace of Fluttershy which was not normal. Normally she would answer the door and give me a warm welcome. I knew she had to be somewhere in there so I called out, "Fluttershy, where are you?"

Fluttershy replied, "Come upstairs Luke, I'm in my bedroom."

I have never been in her upstairs before but the couple times I had looked up, it looked like there was only one room up there so I headed up and once I got close to her door she yelled, "Close your eyes and come on in."

I headed in and then I could tell that she had approached me and was very close. She then suggested, "Alright, how about you open your eyes." I opened my eyes and then she exclaimed, "Surprise!"

When I opened my eyes I was in a state of shock. Standing right before me was Fluttershy in a blue bra that was barely holding in her enormous breasts and a black leather thong. I was in such a state of shock that I didn't even know what to say until I focused more on the seductive look in her eyes. She asked, "So Luke, do you know what your Hearth's Warming Eve present is?"

I nervously replied, "You?"

She giggled, "Mhmm!" She then grabbed the bag I was carrying and continued, "Hmmm....what did you get for me?" She pulled out the nightgown and exclaimed, "This is perfect! I love it!" Before I could even respond she grabbed my hand and ordered, "Now Luke, I can tell you like your Hearth's Warming Eve present but to get her, you must undress!"

I replied, "Alright." I then began to undress and she looked at me with a look of hunger, a look of lust as I was undressing. Once I was fully undressed she stroked my fully erect member and asked, "Is this for me?"

I was blushing as I replied, "Mhmm!"

She then began to remove her garments, revealing her oh so sexy breasts and her marehood, her obviously needy marehood. She pulled us together and suggested, "How about we warm up a bit before getting to what I truly want to give you!"

We pulled one another close and began to kiss passionately. It was a sloppy opened mouth kiss, a kiss that I absolutely loved. I could feel her saliva flowing into my mouth, saliva that I was greedily swallowing and she could tell it. She broke the kiss briefly and asked, "Do you like it, do you like my spit?"

I blushed deeply and replied, "Mhmm!"

She then pulled us back into the kiss and continued to flood my mouth full of her saliva. I was in heaven as we were kissing and then I decided to do something, something that I had always wondered about mares, well her specifically. I moved my hands from her back down to her flanks and began to massage her, right where her cutie marks were. She quickly broke the kiss and moaned, "Not yet Luke, not yet! Please don't massage me there!"

I knew it! I had often thought about how massaging her cutie marks would likely make her desire sex and judging by her reaction, I was right. I replied, "Alright Fluttershy, we can wait."

We then resumed our kissing, our wet kissing. I wasn't sure how long it was until she broke the kiss and plopped down on her bed. She gave me a sultry smile and ordered, "Luke, take me! Now you show me all your fetishes, all of them!"

I gave her a smile and replied, "Don't worry Fluttershy, I will!"

I then headed to the foot of her bed and took to one of her big toes. She immediately began to giggle and kick her foot. She giggled, "Luke, stop it! I'm ticklish there!"

I replied, "Well you said for me to show you all my fetishes and a foot fetish is one of them!"

She pouted, "Not fair! I know I said all of them but ticklish ones should be out!"

I replied, "Alright Fluttershy, but next time I'm not just going to move on!"

I then began to move my sucking up and she did not react much of any until I got to her inner thighs and began to suck. She began to giggle and once the side of my face was rubbing up against her wet marehood she giggled, "You want to be marked as mine, don't you?"

I stopped sucking, looked up and blushed, "Maybe!"

She gave me a sultry smile and firmly stated, "Well, after you give me what you want to, I will mark you as mine, all of you!"

I returned the smile, "Well I really look forward to it."

She gave me another smile before ordering, "Now get back to work and eat my butterfly, you know you want to!"

I gave her a smile before taking to her marehood. The moment I began to suck on it she began to moan loudly, "Oh Luke baby, yes baby yes!" I then shoved my tongue up inside of her and proceeded to eat her out. As I was doing this, her moaning was getting louder and her breathing was becoming harder. I then decided to move my hands to her cutie marks and began to massage them again. Her breathing continued to get harder and her moans got louder, "Oh yes Luke yes! Oh buck yes!" I continued to massage them and it wasn't long until she screamed, "Oh Luke baby, I gotta cum, I gotta cum, I gotta cuuuuuum!"

She then unleashed a torrent of marecum into my mouth, cum that I greedily swallowed. I continued to suck on her until I had consumed every last drop. I then got up and exclaimed, "Oh my stars Fluttershy! There are no words for how tasty you are!"

She gave me a huge smile, "Hopefully things will get to where you can eat it everyday." Her smile then became full of lust as she added, "You know, I could talk to Twilight about using her magic to make it even better, to truly make you mine!"

I wasn't exactly sure how Twilight would do that but the idea of truly becoming Fluttershy's sounded very appealing to me. After all, out of all the mares in Ponyville, she was the one that I had developed a close friendship with. She was the one who wanted to get to know me first so naturally I was very fond of her. I then decided to continued move up to one area that I was unsure that she would like, but an area that I looked very forward to doing with her.

I moved up to her belly and began to suck, causing her to squirm and begin to giggle loudly. She pouted, "Luke, not there! Please not there, I'm so ticklish there!"

I pouted in return, "But seeing you squirm and giggle like this makes me so hot! Seeing you like this is so sexy!"

She became a bit more firm and said, "Well maybe next time but move on up to another thing I know you truly want! My girls want to feel your sucking, come and have my needy girls!"

I gave her a smile and then took to her tits. The moment I began to suck on them she started to moan loudly. Her moaning continued to get louder and her breathing got faster and I had a very strong feeling that she may be getting ready to cum again. I bent my knee up and began to massage her marehood causing her to yell, "Oh yes Luke! I know you want to be covered in my cum, yes baby yes!"

She then moaned loudly as she soaked my knee with cum before pulling me up and ordering, "Alright Luke, the time has come. The time has come for you to give me what I want, the time to give me what you want!"

I knew exactly what she meant and I will admit, I found her more assertive personality incredibly attractive. Yes it is her shy and introverted nature that caused me to grow so fond of her but in this situation, her more assertive behavior was so sexy. I gave her a smile and replied, "Alright Fluttershy, are you ready?"

As I lined my member up with her marehood she got a nervous look on her face and requested, "Luke, could you please be gentle? This is going to be my first time."

I gave her a smile, "Don't worry Fluttershy, if it starts to hurt I will stop." I paused before leaning down and whispering in her ear, "Don't worry, this is my first time too."

Fluttershy immediately gave me a huge smile, "Oh my, I get your virginity too? This will truly make you mine!" She then gave me a more stern look and ordered, "Now give it to me, I am your Hearth's Warming Eve gift after all!"

I again lined my member up with her marehood and once I entered her, she let out a moan of delight. The look in her eyes was full of lust yet it was so lovely at the same time. As I continued to go into her that look became more lustful until I felt myself hit a barrier, a barrier that quickly gave way. The moment I penetrated her she wrapped her arms around me, sank her fingernails into my back and let out a scream of pain. This truly concerned me and I asked, "Fluttershy, are you ok? Do you want me to stop?"

She yelled, "No, just lay still for a minute and then get back to work! We both want this, we both need this!"

I laid there on top of her for a couple minutes before she gave me the go ahead. I was not sure if she would want it rough or if she would want me to be gentle with her. I truly wanted to be gentle with her and make this intimate moment last for as long as possible so I started thrusting her gently. She immediately moaned in delight, "Oh yes Luke, yes baby yes! This is perfect!"

I continued to thrust her gently as she pulled me down into another open mouthed kiss. She then wrapped her legs around me, tightening her vaginal muscles and it felt like I was imprisoned in a hot, wet, tight slice of heaven. We continued to moan loudly into one another's mouths and before I knew it, she began to grind her body up against mine and I quickly started to do the same. It was not long until we had began to work up a nice heavy sweat and that had always been a fantasy of mine, especially since I had got to know Fluttershy.

She soon broke the kiss and demanded, "Alright Luke, enough of being gentle. Give it to me hard, be rough with me, own me!"

I was surprised because she had suddenly went from wanting to make me hers to wanting to belong to me but that was something that I certainly wasn't going to object to. I then began to pound her and her breathing became heavier as she moaned, "Oh yes Luke yes! Own me, dominate me, make me yours!"

I then began to pound her harder and we continued to grind our bodies together harder and harder. Very quickly I was giving it to her so rough that her bed was squeaking and I could tell that she absolutely loved it. She then wrapped her hands around my head and forced me into a very rough kiss and forced her tongue into my mouth. Very quickly our tongues were wrestling one another for dominance but hers was easily winning. I truly felt like I was in heaven at this point, here I was dominating the mare that I was crushing on so badly. I loved her wanting to own me but a part of me woke up that was wanting her to be submissive to me.

I continued to pound her and then she started screaming, "Pound me Luke, own me, dominate me, fill me up!"

I continued to get rougher with her before she finally started screaming, "Oh Luke baby, I gotta, I gotta, I gotta cuuuuum!"

She then unleashed a torrent of cum right as I began to unload into her. As I was unleashing rope after rope of semen into her, I truly felt like I did own her, I felt like we had bonded together as one. Once the two of us finally exhausted our supplies, we got on our sides and pulled one another close and looked lustfully into one another's eyes. She was the first to say anything, "Oh my goodness Luke, I never knew such pleasure existed!"

I replied, "I know Fluttershy, I never felt like this before!"

As we laid there basking in our afterglow, we didn't say much but I could feel the lust coming from her. I could feel her desire for me radiating from her. She eventually asked, "Uhm Luke, I know we've been friends for a while but what would you think of adding benefits to our friendship?"

I will admit that I was a bit disappointed that she didn't want more but that was something that I was very open to. I gave her a smile, "I would love that Fluttershy, I would absolutely love that!"

She gave me a smile before ordering, "Now lay on your back. The time has come for me to mark my new friend with benefits as mine!"

I was very excited over this. Once I got on my back she lowered her marehood over my face and began to rub it against me and it felt so good. I was in a state of bliss as she began to cover me with her cum. After finishing with my face she began to move down on me, covering me with her warm marecum. When she got down further she noticed that I was once again erect and she suggested, "Luke, how about once I fully mark you I ride you for a while?"

I gave her a smile, "I would love that Fluttershy, I would absolutely love that!

She then continued to mark me and once she had got the whole front of me covered in a very firm voice she ordered, "Turn over Luke, I'm marking all of you!"

I complied and she continued to mark me with her warm marecum. Once she had finished marking me she again ordered, "Now turn back over." She then laid back beside me and continued, "I've changed my mind Luke. I want you to pound me again! I have decided I want to be the sub in this friendship, always the sub!"

I gave her a smile as I mounted her and began to give it to her again. I truly felt happy that it sounded like my hot friend with benefits wanted me to be the dominant one. Once I had filled her up again she gave me a sexy smile, "Luke, I've always heard about this 69 thing. What would you think about us doing that tomorrow?"

I knew what she was talking about and loved the idea of us doing that. I replied, "I'd love that Fluttershy." We both yawned and I suggested, "For now though, how about we get some sleep?"

Fluttershy replied, "Alright but you're spending not just the night with me but all day tomorrow too!"

I nodded and gave her a smile before we embraced tightly and readied ourselves to go to sleep. She was rather quick to fall asleep. As I laid there, holding her tight and listening to her rhythmic breathing, I felt a sense of true happiness. Finally here I was laying close with the mare I had developed a crush on and it was obvious that our friendship was going to be extremely sexual. While I would never let her know this, I hoped that someday I would get her pregnant and we'd become a lot more.