This Isn't Reality

by Fuzzee

Rating: teen
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Sad, Comedy, Violence, Death, Main 6
Length: 1132

Pinkie is scared of one thing becoming a reality.

Pinkie Pie and the rest of the Mane 6 head out to the apple family maze on Nightmare night, as they do every year, Rainbow Dash has a sneaking suspicion that something's off.

Based off of gridmark stories like Cupcakes And Smile HD

Hints of Twipie near the end.

Published 2023-12-28 17:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2023-12-28 17:50:01 UTC

Nightmares

As Rainbow Dash, Applejack, Twilight, Pinkie Pie, And Rarity made their way to the Apple family maze for Nightmare Night, everypony was oblivious to the fact that majority of them wouldn't come out. Not alive anyway. Nopony knew this but Pinkie Pie.

"Applejack, are you sure you know what's in the maze this year?" Rainbow Dash asked, with caution in her voice. After last year, when Fluttershy scared them all, Rainbow always made sure to ask AJ if she knew what she was doing.

"Now of course i do Rainbow, what kind of a question is that?" Applejack said with offense in her voice. Twilight sighed and Rarity rolled her eyes.

"Look everypony, we're here, we're here!" Pinkie shouted with glee. Pinkie Pie knew that something, even the tiniest thing could trigger it, and yet, she came anyway. This Nightmare Night, she was super focused on not letting it out.

"Rainbow, darling, i'm sure Applejack knows what's in the maze this year." Rarity assured Rainbow Dash as they walked into the maze.

snap.

Rainbow Dash heard something that nopony else heard, as she twirled around, lightning bolt striked , and Dash saw an image of a psychotic looking Pinkie Pie flash, it scared her to the point in which she might just scream.

"Oops, sorry Rainbow!" Pinkie said sheepishly.

"What's wrong Dash? Chicken? AJ said, with a smug smile plastered on her face.

"No, i-i just heard Pinkie step on a twig, and was just a little startled."

Dash lied through her teeth. Applejack just rolled her eyes. Just as they were about to turn a corner, they all fell through a trapdoor. Twilight looked back to her friends to make sure they were alright.

"Pinkie Pie? Are.. You okay?" Twilight asked with concern in her voice.

"Just p-peachy Twi!"

Pinkie was sure if she could hold it much longer. Twilight just raised an eyebrow, and kept moving once everypony was back on their hooves. They trotted their way through the cave, trying to find an exit, and Pinkie, she lost it. Pinkie felt her hair deflate, that's when she knew it was too late.

"Hey, who wants to play a game?" Pinkie eerily asked.

This wasn't the Pinkie we knew and loved. Everypony agreed, they thought Pinkie was just being Pinkie and had no thoughts about it.

"Everypony, run. As fast. As you. Can." Everypony pony agreed and ran away, still paying no mind to Pinkie's antics.

It was just Pinkie Pie. Right?

They ran in different directions, which was to Pinkamena's liking. She laughed, as if she was insane. Which she was.

"Ready or not, Rainbow Dash." Pinkamena said, she growled when she said Dash's name.

She galloped in Dash's direction. She had her mind set on getting her revenge on Dash. Rainbow doesn't like pie and didn't tell her, she constantly tries to ditch her, and finds her annoying.

Rainbow Dash was nervous, and she should be. Very nervous.

why would Pinkie tell us to run? It makes no sense. But that's Pinkie for ya.

Rainbow Dash thought to herself. She then heard galloping hooves, but they weren't from her, and right after came a sinister laugh. Now she was really scared. Rainbow Dash turned around to see that same psychotic Pinkie image galloping towards her. Dash flew as fast as she could, fast enough to do another Sonic Rainboom.

She unfortunately, couldn't escape Pinkie's breaking the laws of motion and gravity. Pinkie stopped Rainbow dead in her tracks, appearing in front of Rainbow, but Rainbow couldn't fly away in time.

As soon as Rainbow fell on the cold, hard cave floor, Pinkamena stomped as hard as she could on Rainbow Dash's face. Dash quickly fell unconscious, and was bleeding from her ears, her nose, her mouth and her forehead. At this rate, Dash was long gone from the physical realm. But for good measure, Pinkamena pulled her trusty knife out of her hair, and cut off both of Rainbow's wings. The result of this, Rainbow's face went pale, and her sides were rapidly bleeding.

"Loser."

Pinkamena started galloping towards Rarity's direction, she had no reason to go after Rarity, this was for fun. Rarity moved at a slow trotting pace, as she didn't fancy running.

"Easy target, you inconsiderate pony, makes the game less fun." Pinkie said in her normal cheery voice, but still the same sinister Pinkamena.

She galloped fast, and attacked Rarity once she caught up. Pinkamena Jumped on Rarity's back and cut off her horn, while giggling a creepy giggle. Rarity screamed at the top of her lungs, and Pinkie covered Rarity's muzzle so nopony would hear that oh, so shrill scream of hers.

Her Next victim was just a few meters away, and was trotting at the same pace Rarity was.

As Pinkie galloped towards AJ she realized, that she had just gotten rid of-

Crap, she's coming back, better make this quick then.

Pinkamena thought to herself. Pinkamena continued galloping toward's AJ's direction, when she finally reached AJ, Pinkamena jumped her and in the process, broke AJ's back, and broke both of Applejack's hind legs.

"Pinkie Pie!! What in all of Equestria are you-" AJ was cut off by a baby pink earth pony.

"Oh, shut it you work horse. Now, what should i do with you?" Pinkamena thought for a second.

"Nah, i'll just leave you here to die, rot, and finally decompose into the worthless life form you are." Pinkamena said, and followed it up with a chaotic giggle.

"So long, friend." Pinkamena said, and simply walked away.

Before Pinkamena even got a chance to say Twilight's name, or even think it, Pinkie woke up. She gasped for breath, sweating, looking like she was about to have a mental breakdown.

Pinkie almost Immediately started weeping, scared if this would become a reality. It was around 10:00 AM when she finally woke up. She heard a vague knock, and got from under her blanket, to head downstairs. Pinkie opened the door, to reveal Twilight standing there.

"Hey Pinkie, are you ready to bake? I remembered looking on my schedule and seeing that i was making cupcakes with you! Or was that tomorrow, or was it next Thursday?" Twilight asked.

She looked up to see Pinkie Pie, who looked like she'd been crying. Which she was.

"Is it a bad time? I'm sorry i'll go-" Twilight was cut off.

"No, stay, please." Pinkie put her hoof over Twilight's and Twilight returned this gesture with a small smile. Pinkie wrapped her in a hug.

"It felt so realistic. Gone. All of you." Pinkie said.

"Thank you."

" Of course."

Author's Note

Had this in my head for weeks, tried to get it out, and here ya go! Luv ya'll :heart: