I didn't ask to be a mare!!!

by Pyro_Leo

Rating: teen
Tags: Princess Luna, Drama, Original Character, Princess Cadance, Fetish, Comedy, Violence, Princess Celestia, Sex, Main 6, Profanity, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Narcotics, Romance
Length: 2000

Twilight used her male human friend as a test subject and accidentally turned them into a female pony.

Twilight sparkle found a new spell and needed a friend to help her with it so she got her best friend anonymous who was also a human. She promised him that she would be careful but after a mistake she accidentally turned anon I to a pony and a mare leading to the creation of the pony Scarlett Ray.

Published 2023-12-31 21:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-01-21 03:48:07 UTC

Chp 1

EAnon looks at himself in the mirror, or now it's herself as she glares at Twilight. "Twilight what the hell did you do to me you fucking prick?!" Anon yells as their ancestral nationality kicks in they scream in an Irish accent they don't do unless very mad. Twilight stood shocked and confused. "A-Anon please I'm sorry I didn't expect this to happen, I must have made a slight mistake."

Anon stomps to her struggling to walk on hooves, especially four at once. "Change me back now!!!" Twilight was more nervous. "I might have accidentally destroyed the spell book during that magic explosion." Anon was horrified. "So now I'm stuck to forever look exactly like you?!" Twilight tries to calm her friend. "Anon please I promise I'll find a way, maybe there's a copy or maybe someone who knows about the spell that was used."

Anon shook their head as their mane got in their face. "MOTHER OF BUCK'S!!!" Suddenly the rest of their friends busted in. "Twilight is something wrong-!" They all fell silent seeing their friend with a random mare who was looking frustrated and angry. "Oh hey girls, also just to clarify it's me anon but Twilight made a simple mistake during a spell."

Suddenly the girls laugh as Anon gets angry. "It isn't funny how'd you like it if you were turned into another creature and turned into a different gender?!" This caught them on but Pinkie laughs. "OOOHHH a male human me?! That would be so amazing, could you do that to me twily?" Anon grumbled. "When she made a mistake in the spell the book was destroyed meaning I'm stuck this way!!!"

Later anon made Pinkie grab some things while they were poking their horn. "So I guess this means I'm a unicorn." Twilight then realized. "Oh, maybe I can teach you to use magic!" Anon shrugged. "I think watching everyone do it I can too." Anon looked at a simple book and concentrated when their horn glowed but it was Anon's favorite color as rarity was surprised. "Wow anonymous darling, you truly are doing so easy for your first time," Anon smirks as Rainbow says the joke. "That's what she said." Rarity was confused when she remembered when Anon explained it and blushed.

"Rainbow dash how dare you say such naughty things." Anon was laughing and it was weird how Anonymous was doing his normal things in a random Mare's body and voice when Pinkie brought the things Anon asked for. "If I'm gonna be a pony I'm gonna make myself look the way I'd like to." The girls and Spike waited when Anon came out with a new look, she cut her hair to match their original hair, the hair was dyed with the same hair color as Anon's normal hair color, and his favorite color was added in.

They also wore some clothing rarity made that looked like their normal clothes as she sighed. "Now I need an alibi." The girls were confused as Anon answered. "We can't have ponies know about me being turned into a pony so pinkie no party about this." Said Earth Pony drooped like a deflated balloon. "But maybe a party to make me seem like a new pony visiting Ponyville while Anon is out exploring the region of Exuestria while I care for his home until he returns." Pinki jumps back to life grinning widely.

Anon then looks to Applejack. "AJ I'll need you and Pinkie's help learning to walk like a pony, twilight and rarity will teach me magic, and Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash you can help me with other things I can't think of now." They all agreed as Anon sighed. "I'll also need a name." Pinkie jumps to Anon's face. "Oh! Oh! What about Scarlett Ray!!!" Everypony was confused as Pinkie explained. "Scarlett means red as in your red hot temper and your red hair and eyes, and ray means sun which you said in your world is your birth sign or something."

Anon/Scarlett sighs. "Ok well until I'm normal again I will be known as Scarlett... Now time to set up my alibi and start the undercover game... Pinkie go plan the party for my arrival and don't tell anyone who I am!" Pinkie was already gone as Twilight tried to speak to her friend. "Um, anon or Scarlett... You sure about this?" Scarlett sighs. "Don't worry twilight, think of this as research of a species entirely different from ponies living most of their life as a pony."

Scarlett then approached Sugercube Corner as she started to change her personality to another person hoping their acting was good as she opened the door. "SURPRISE!" Everypony shouts as Scarlett puts on a happy face. "Aw thanks everypony, also if you don't know me allow me to introduce myself... Names Scarlett Ray, a pleasure to meet you all."

Later Scarlett was the center of attention to everyone while the mane 6 were surprised by their friend's change of personality but maybe it was to hide the truth about them. Meanwhile, Scarlett was talking to Lyra and Bonbon. "You know I've noticed Anon hasn't been around for some time, do you think something happened to him?" Scarlett made a scoffing sound. "Oh yeah I know Anon, he and I are friends, we met outside of Ponyville and one day he said he wanted to explore the beautiful world he asked me to house it for him."

The two easily believe her and Scarlett mingled with the ponies acting like a new pony as she then heads to the house that was supposed to be for them before the transformation. She then sat in the chair feeling uncomfortable with how it was meant for another species she just stared into her mirror studying her new appearance as she remembered what was planned for tomorrow. "Welp, let's see how I can handle this until I'm back to normal." Scarlett then laid down hoping tomorrow would be ok.

Day 1: a spy

After a few months, Twilight and the girls noticed Scarlett seemed to be getting used to her new life and form even ignoring their get-together to learn as a pony.

When they went to get on to her she made excuses that weren't wrong.

Twilight was speaking with Scarlett as she explained. "But two what would happen if Celestia found out that you accidentally turned your friend and destroyed the book that could change them back also think of how exciting it is to learn about me as a pony but also how fun it be to hang with a famous pony."

As an explanation during the months, Scarlett soon became famous and was called the sexiest pony in Equestria magazines.

When Rainbow Dash spoke to Scarlett she explained to her the great things to happen. "how about when the Wonder bolts would love to hang with you dash so they can also get to know me and technically you aren't being disloyal by hanging with a friend you are just having me help you get to know the wonderbolts to meet me."

With rarity, Scarlett was wearing dresses. "Darling I don't get it, usually you don't wish to wear dresses but now you seem ok with it." Scarlett giggled. "Rarity please, do you know how many ponies would beg me to wear their clothing just to make their business booming, but I only choose your clothes cause you are the greatest clothing artist I have ever known.

Fluttershy didn't have anything different Scarlett was being kind to the animals and helped her and when Fluttershy asked Scarlett she simply changed the attention by asking to work with the animals.

For Applejack Scarlett speaks of her farm. "In my world, we used famous people to speak of the products and make more people want them, with my new fame I can make everyone want your apples and soon the apple family will be getting richer than you ever had, I'm just trying to help you Aj."

Pinkie was the one who asked the biggest question. "Are you sure you're my bestie Nonny?!" Scarlett sighed as anon rolled their eyes. "Pinkie it's fine I'm still me it's just I'm getting used to this new me I don't mind if I stay this way for a long time but I hope Twilight can find a way to change me back, I miss my old life though maybe this won't be too bad cause the least I'd like is to be a male at least."

After dealing with Pinkie Scarlett was hanging with ponies when she bumped into some pony. "Owie, that felt like I got a wall." Suddenly Scarlett looked up to see a stallion running away saying something about being late for something Scarlett rolled her eyes and went home.

At home, Scarlett was looking around making sure no living thing was following her as she entered her home went to a wall, and opened a secret passage.

Scarlett goes down the hidden stairway until she finds herself standing in front of a mirror covered by a sheet while she approaches it speaking out loud. "I must say that I don't mind my new life out there, it's just disappointing that soon it will all come to an end... Is that right, Anon?"

She pulled off the sheet revealing her reflection but it was not copying her it was doing its actions. "You bitch when I get free I'll-" Scarlett interrupted him. "which by then will be too late, and during the day twilight should have looked around for this." She lifted a book revealing the spell book that Twilight believed she 'destroyed' by accident as Scarlett got close to the mirror.

"With you trapped in the mirror and I free, I'll help my master to distract your friends until my master is prepared to take over all of Equestria and soon Equestria will have its new ruler, and the main 6 will fall, and without you to get in the way Equestria is confirmed to be doomed!!!"

Anon growls. "What if they look into this mirror?" Scarlett laughs. "Unless I'm in front of the mirror giving you the ability to exist in the mirror they'll never know." Anon was shocked at this as Scarlett nodded in confirmation. "That's right when I am not in front of the mirror not only will you be unable to speak or move but it will be as if you became invisible and powerless to do anything!!!"

Anon could only stare as Scarlett laughed. "Without the spell book to change your body back and without her knowing the so-called 'magic explosion accident' was her cursing you to create me, that's right your friend cursed you with an alternate personality that will take over your mind and body and curse you into a mirror and steal the spell book to prevent twilight from turning you back and casting me out of your body!"

Anon gets angry as Scarlett turns to leave. "Oh don't worry Anon I'll let you go... After I find a way to frame you as the evil clone and I the defenseless and harmed friend while the evil clone will be locked away and forgotten then soon I'll make everyone believe that Twilight is evil for creating the evil clone then soon her friends will be framed and soon as their defense is disposed of my master will capture the princesses and soon they will rule."

Anon screams and yells but Scarlett covers the mirror silencing Anon and goes up the stairs as she smiles. "Soon Equestria will fall, my master will rule over the pathetic ponies and once I get rid of the Elements of Harmony allow my master to rise above to capture the princesses and will bow to my master, my king..."

"Watch yourself Equestria, cause soon all will bow before The King of all of Equestria the dark king Sombra!!!"