What if Spike Joined Nightmare Rarity?

by Big Imagination E

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Alternate Universe, Anthro, Porn, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish, Spike, Other, Romance, Nightmare Rarity
Length: 2060

This is what happens when Spike joins the nightmare version of Rarity.

You will see what happens when Nightmare Rarity returns and Spike made the ultimate choice.

Contains: Lovemaking, big breasts and butt, twerking, facesitting, tittyfucking and sucking and kissing.

This was requested by ChazMLPFIM.

Published 2024-01-07 20:40:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-01-07 20:40:00 UTC

The Ultimate Choice

It was a lovely day in Ponyville and everyone was loving the weather. Spike a 19 year old full grown dragon was spending his day with his friends and loved everything about it. But all that changed when the sky suddenly grew darker. And the storms were rising! Then suddenly a cloud started taking form of one pony Spike knew years ago. The Nightmare version of Rarity. She had G-cup breasts, a hourglass figure and a giant plump ass. She walked to Spike and his friends and glared at them. And beside her was the leader Shadowfright.

"Well Spike. Long time no see." Shadowfright said.

"Shadowfright. What are you doing here?" Spike asked.

"I'm glad you asked. As you can see my slave is in need of a husband and who will love her plot. But so far she was only interested in you." Shadowfright explained.

"He won't accept!! So beat it buster!!" Rainbow shouted.

"SILENCE!!" Shadowfright shouted.

They all went quiet after that.

"Thank you very much. Now Spike I will give you a choice. Either you become her king and accept the marriage or stay here and watch all your people die." Shadowfright said.

Spike was scared having to choose the ultimate decision. If he turned down the marriage then everyone will die. But if he didn't then everyone will be safe. Sighing in defeat he gave him the answer.

"Shadowfright. I will admit that I had dreams about your daughter and I be lying if I said I didn't have a thing for her big butt. So I accept. If I marry her you promise everyone won't be killed?" Spike asked.

The girls gasped hearing the decision.

"Why yes Spike. I'm really happy that you accepted this. You have my word. But first I think a few changes are in order. Dear if you please." Shadowfright said.

Nightmare Rarity did what he said and generated a wave of magic turning Spike into a nightmare dragon. He is a dark dragon with wings. The girls gasped seeing him like this. She also used her magic on Rainbow Dash and the wonderbolts now are the shadowbolts, along with Scootaloo and Rumble, and the other Crusaders. She also used it on her parents and Sweetie Belle into turning them into night alicorns.

"What did you do to Spike?! And my friends and family!?" Twilight shouted.

"Oh relax. He's okay. She just made him better. If he's gonna marry her then he needs to look the part." Shadowfright explained.

"Well then if your taking Spike then take me too." Twilight demanded.

"Sure. It makes no difference to me. Come everyone! It's time for a wedding!" Shadowfright shouted.

Soon all the nightmares obeyed and followed him to his Nightmare Tower. Once in they got the wedding all ready for them. Nightmare Rarity is wearing her new night wedding gown based on Princess Cadance's wedding gown, her sister Nightmare Sweetie Belle is the head flower girl. Spike is wearing his suit based on Shining Armor's, except that the color is dark blue with green sash. Lastly, the bridesmaids are the mane five, Apple Bloom and Scootaloo are the flower girls, and Rumble is the ring bearer. Nightmare Rarity's father is the father of the bride. Once everyone was in the throne room the Shadowbolt at the organ begin playing. The others got up and watched the two walked down the aisle all the way to the podium. When they got on the podium Spike removed the veil off of Nightmare Rarity's face and Shadowfright came to the stand. Everyone turned to face him and sat down.

"Dearly beloved. We are gathered here today to witness the wonderful marriage of King Spike and Queen Nightmare Rarity. to become the royal couple of our family. The couple will now say their vows before the rings are exchanged. Nightmare Rarity you may go first." Shadowfright said.

The couple looked into each other's eyes as Nightmare Rarity prepared to speak.

"Spikey. You were like the dragon of my dreams and now that we were here now and about to be married we will rule the night forever." Nightmare Rarity vowed.

The Nightmare crowd shedded some tears as they heard Rarity's words. Now it was Spike's turn.

"Nightmare Rarity. I admit that for the past few years I did dream about me and you together and since were about to be married I can say that you are the one for me." Spike vowed.

Everyone cried a little and then Rumble came with the ring which had a nightmare symbol on them and they each took one. Shadowfright then started to say the vows.

"Do you Spike take Nightmare Rarity to be your lawful wedded wife? To love her and cherish til death do you part?" Shadowfright asked.

He placed the ring on her finger. "I do." Spike said.

"And do you Nightmare Rarity take Spike to be your lawful wedded husband? To love him and cherish til death do you part?" Shadowfright asked.

She placed the ring on his finger. "I do." Nightmare Rarity said.

"Then by the power invested in me I now pronounce you husband and wife. Spike you may now kiss the bride." Shadowfright finished.

The two leaned in and sealed their love with a kiss. Then everyone cheered as they finally have a king and queen to take the throne. Wedding bells can be heard and the new couple went outside of the castle to celebrate their marriage. This is a new beginning for the nightmare forces.

After the wedding was over the new couple went to the bedroom as Nightmare Rarity took off her dress showing her body to Spike as he blushed really hard from that. She unhooked her bra and panties til she was nude.

"So Spikey? You like what you see?" Nightmare Rarity asked.

"Oh I sure do. In fact..." Spike said as he ripped off his clothes leaving him bare naked.

"Ooh. Mama likes. Come here and kiss me you fool." Nightmare Rarity said.

Spike blushed really hard from that but needed no more encouragement as he grabbed her and engaged in a passionate makeout session. Next he then decided to grope her breasts and began playing with them. First thing he did was suck on her tits as she moaned loud. Then he groped them and gave each of them a big squeeze. After 20 minutes he looked at her in the face and started making out with her in a French kiss. Their tougues battled in that French kiss. And Spike couldn't help but place a hand on her butt and squeezed it making her moan. The kiss lasted for 15 minutes til they separated.

“Wow Spikey. That was divine. And is your hand on my butt?” Nightmare Rarity asked.

“Guilty. Your ass is so plump and soft that I has a weakness for it. And I want to bury my face in it.” Spike spoke dirty.

“Oh you naughty boy. Before I bury your face in my juicy cheeks why don’t you rub it first?” Rarity teased.

“Okay. Whatever gets me closer to your butt.” Spike agreed.

He then placed both hands on her cheeks and started rubbing them making her moan. He even decided to squeeze them real good as she squealed a little. After a few minutes she smirked at him.

"Oh you beastly beast. You really do love them." Nightmare Rarity said.

"I sure do. But I think your girls need some love." Spike replied.

"Go ahead. Give them all the love you got." Nightmare Rarity begged.

His inner perv awakens now as he grab her tits and squeeze them together, pressing his face in between them as he enjoys the softness and the warmth. Pulling away, he let go of the right tit and grab the left with both hands. Bringing the nipple to his mouth, he wrap his lips around it and gave a suckle on it.

Hearing his wife moan cutely above him, he squeeze the mound and knead it with both hands. Gently biting the nipple, pull back to let it snap back, making the breast ripple slightly. Using his left hand, he pull the right breast closer to his face as he begin to suckle on the right nipple.

"Oh, you really love those, don't you..." Nightmare Rarity coos as she closes her eyes and sighs happily.

Nodding, Spike pull away and grip both breasts as best you can, squeezing them. "They're amazing..."

Then after all that he got out of her chest and Nightmare Rarity held him closer to her bosom again.

"Oh Spikey that felt so good. Lemme do the same." Nightmare Rarity replied.

She got down, saw Spike's enormous cock and placed it in between her boobs and started titfucking him. He loved how his cock is between two of the softest pillows ever imagined. Then after 10 minutes he blew his load into her mouth and licked up the juices. Then she began bobbing her head up and down sucking his cock more faster than ever. Spike moaned louder from that and after 15 minutes he blew another load into her mouth. Spike was sweating and panting.

"Ok. That felt really good. Now can I see your plump ass now?" Spike asked.

"Sure you can. Who am I to deny my husband's wish?" Nightmare Rarity agreed.

He laid down and suddenly he felt her butt on his face so soft and squishy. He placed his hands on her butt and got ready to massage them.

"Okay sweetie. Go ahead and make my butt feel good." Nightmare Rarity purred.

Spike got started right away. He squeezed her cheeks like balls of dough and licked between the crack. She giggled and moaned from that meaning she's loving it. He even slapped her butt a few times making her moan a little louder. The treatment lasted for 2 hours til she blew her load into his mouth and he licked up the juices. Spike laid down next to her and they cuddled. He still couldn't resist her butt as he placed a hand on it.

“Oh Spikey you really are a beast at this.” Nightmare Rarity replied.

“Thanks my lovely nightmare. But whoo!! I feel so tired now.” Spike said.

“Spikey? I’m not done yet. How’s bout I put on a little show for you?” Nightmare Rarity offered.

“What did you have in mind babe?” Spike asked.

“You’ll see. Prepare to witness of your angel.” Nightmar Rarity smirked.

The first thing she did was twirl around and showed her rump in Spike’s face. And once she did she began twerking her tight ass. Spike’s hormones were going crazy seeing those juicy cheeks jiggle with every move. She even started shaking her butt begging Spike to squeeze her. After 15 minutes she stopped and Spike was sweating like a pig. Then he laid down and saw her butt covering his face once more.

“So Spikey? Did you enjoy the show?” Nightmare Rarity asked.

He could only give her a thumbs up for an answer and started squeezing her cheeks again.

"Mmm. That always feels so good." Nightmare Rarity said.

She got off of him and cuddled him and engaged in another makeout session. While they did that Spike took the time to squeeze her tits and butt at the same thing as she moaned from the treatment. After an hour of kissing they separated and cuddled while laying down.

"Oh honey. That was the best fun ever." Nightmare Rarity said.

"Agreed. And im sure that one day we will have some little ones we to have a mother who will care for them. Along with their father." Spike replied.

"Yes they will be. One day but not today. For now let's get some sleep my king." Nightmare Rarity said pulling Spike into her cozy bosom.

"Good night sweetie." Nightmare Rarity said turning off the light.

"Good night honey." Spike said muffled.

The two fell fast asleep dreaming of what the future may hold in store. But one way or another the nightmare forces were happy that a king and new queen has taken the throne. And that's what happened when Spike joined Nightmare Rarity.

Author's Note

Man that was something when he joined the Nightmare Rarity. Guess it worked well.