Beauty Like Yours Is A Rarity

by scrungusbungus

First published

[Cover by universe_deity on Instagram]
[Proof-Reading by Bad Touch]

An M / F Anon x Rarity HIE Story, involving normal Rarity, and horror-themed Nightmare Rarity.
Chapters with actual, written sex scenes (ew) will be titled very obviously. Mostly a writing challenge to see if I could.


Nightmare Rarity sits upon her throne, gazing out past the moonrock ruins of her lair, towards the Equestria below. The Mane 6 were captured, trapped in the shadowy dungeons, unable to escape as the Nightmares play with their Dreams. The Moon was closer to Equus than it had ever been; and the Nightmares that swirled around her whispered and promised her everything.

But the Nightmares were disgruntled. It turns out, the Nightmares didn't have full control of Rarity quite yet, despite their whispers, meddling and promises. For beside her throne, sat Sweetie Belle and Anon. Not caged, chained up, or captured; simply playing games on Anon's phone, much to the Nightmares repeatedly verbalized dissapointment. She had refuted such, despite their control and corruption over the Element of Generosity.

Why?

Well, Rarity and Anon have always had a bit of an odd relationship, ever since his arrival in Equestria a year and some ago.

They don't share many hobbies or interests. Or any, for that matter. They're almost complete opposites.

Anon's fashion sense for socks, sandals and khaki shorts for every situation is outlandish and garish to Rarity, as her desire to dress-up constantly in elaborate and varied dresses is as odd to him.

Rarity is a proud workaholic, more than eager to spend an entire week and it's weekend working away on her dresses; hardly allowing herself a chance to relax outside of times designated on her calendar. Anon, inversely, prefers to lounge and relax, sit and snooze, more than happy to watch the entire day slowly and lazily roll by, either at a grill, with a fishing pole in hand, or sprawled on a lawn chair.

Rarity, ever devout in ensuring she always looked her best, bought, made and used a wide variety of products to enhance her personal feelings of beauty; a strict routine every morning. Actually, Anon also had his own morning skincare routine. He just didn't talk about it. Mostly moisturizers.

If it wasn't for hanging out with the other girls and Ponyvilles disasters, they'd almost never interact on their own; well, if it wasn't for Sweetie Belle. The CmC's, particularly Sweetie, are quite fond of Anon and his willingness to either help, or cover for their shenanigans, which often inadvertently puts Anon and Rarity into each-others path again.

This was simply how things were, and it worked. They didn't dislike each-other, they were simply... different. Acquaintances. Friends of friends.

Anon might come by to ask for new clothes or a touch up, try to help with one of their near-weekly Ponyville disasters, or might simply swing by to drop off Sweetie Belle from the CmC's latest machination. They'd be cordial, chat, maybe even have some light banter, and be on their way.

Until Rarity struck the deal of a lifetime. Her big break to smash into Canterlot's upper-ranked graces. Following a chance to display her work at that years Gala, nevermind the interruptions, they'd still caught the eye of several of the local Nobles, who proved interested, including a most notable Fancy-Pants.

Rarity had been invited to show off her works at a formal Dinner Party, where numerous Nobles and their Partners would be dining. In a lapse of judgement born from nervousness, she promised to bring along her own partner for the event, for a high profile meet-and-greet, and to assist in showing off her latest outfits and accessories. But that was alright, she had Ponies she could rely on to help make this go smoothly.

One small problem. Everyone else was busy. She had nobody to ask. All of the girls were busy with their own business, or even outright out of town for days. There were hardly any Stallions she could ask without things getting messy, if they weren't already busy themselves; and as sweet as Spike was for offering, there was no way she could take him.

Which, at Sweetie Belle's dreadful idea, Rarity realized she had one person she could ask, unable to avoid it any longer. Someone who was up to absolutely nothing, guaranteed.

Anon. Socks, Sandals, Khaki Shorts and oversized Hawaiian shirt wearing, phone-in-hand Anon.

And he, of course, was up to absolutely nothing. While surprised she asked him of all people, or ponies, he accepted.

Neither had any idea how much their relationship would change because of it.