Puzzling Insanity's Interesting Hearts and Hooves Day

by PuzzlingInsanity

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Zebra, Anthro, Original Character, Porn, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish, Romance, Sex
Length: 2215

Puzzling Insanity has an interesting proposition for Hearts and Hooves Day.

Puzzling Insanity and her partner, Xander, have been together for three years. She has a proposition for a Hearts and Hooves Day activity that neither of them will forget.

Contains: Consensual sadomasochism, light raceplay and zebradom, bondage and aftercare.

Published 2024-02-07 23:20:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-02-07 23:20:00 UTC

Black, Blue and Red All Over

“I’m sorry, can you please repeat what you just said?” Xander said, staring at the earth pony mare sitting across the kitchen table from them.

A smile formed on Puzzling Insanity’s face as she said, “I asked you if you wanted to do that thing we talked about tonight.” She sipped from her water bottle and gave them time to process her words properly.

Xander could feel their heartbeat in their ears as they realized what their marefriend was talking about. “You’re serious?”

“Yeah,” Puzzling said, her smile growing. “I want you to tie me up and absolutely ruin me.”

Xander’s nostrils flared and they looked down at her with a smirk. “Someone’s excited,” they said, receiving a nod in response. “You do understand that I’m going to make you wait, right?”

The fanged mare pouted, but nodded. Her pale face reddened as the zebra reached across the table and playfully booped her muzzle with a finger.

“Use your words,” Xander said.

Puzzling took a shuddering breath and squeezed her tree trunk thighs together. “Y-yes, Ser, I understand.”

The zebra grinned. “Good girl. We can talk about it a little more after you finish eating.”

The earth pony nodded and returned to her dinner, trying to think of literally anything other than what they were going to do that night.

Xander took a sip of their protein drink, a sadistic gleam in their eyes.

Puzzling finished her salad and put her bowl in the sink before sitting back down at the table. Her blush grew and she felt her core throb when she saw the look in her partner’s eyes. “You’re enjoying this,” she whined playfully.

“You bet your sweet ass I am,” Xander said, inhaling deeply through flared nostrils. “You can’t tell me you aren’t, baby girl; I can smell you from across the table.”

The earth pony’s face burned as hot as her nethers as she desperately tried to cross her legs, squirming in her seat. “S-so…”

“Yes?”

Puzzling Insanity cleared her throat and said, “I figured we could talk beforehand. Communication is a cornerstone of BDSM.”

Xander nodded. “You’re absolutely right,” they said. “First things first, how do you want me to tie you up?”

“With rope, of course,” Puzzling said, “but in all seriousness, do you remember that one bondage video I did all those years ago?”

“Yes?”

“I want to be tied up like that, please.”

“Noted,” the zebra said. “Now, what else would you like me to do to you?”

The fanged mare took a deep breath, shuddering as she smelled her own essence. “I want you to fuck me hard,” she said, “and use some impact toys on me.”

Xander smiled. “Which toys do you want me to use?”

“If you’re comfortable with using a crop and a cane, I’d really appreciate it.”

“And what else do you want tonight?”

Puzzling bit her lip and looked at her hooves under the table. “I, um…”

The zebra leaned in and took their marefriend’s hand, squeezing it gently. “I promise you that nothing you want me to do to you will be too extreme,” they said.

Looking up at her partner, she said, “I’m not worried about it being too extreme. I’m worried that it might be, uh, offensive.”

“Offensive?”

“Are you comfortable with raceplay?”

Xander took a deep breath. “When you say raceplay, what exactly do you mean?”

“Do you remember that one server we met in?”

“Yes?” the zebra said, cocking an eyebrow.

Puzzling Insanity said, “I mean like calling me a pony slut and telling me to take your big zebra cock and all that. No slurs.”

Xander gave it some thought, then said, “Just this once.”

Puzzling nodded in understanding.

“And now, for the most important detail for tonight: what would you like the safe word to be?”

The earth pony looked up in thought before it came to her. “Pomegranate,” she said, smiling.

“Pomegranate it is,” Xander said. “Now, let’s go get you ready.”

Puzzling shuddered in anticipation as Xander set everything out where they could get to it as needed. The zebra then removed their clothes with a breath of relief.

The fanged mare knelt on the floor and looked down, watching Xander’s hooves approach her. When they stopped, Puzzling felt her chin being lifted until she was looking her partner in the eyes.

They were holding an emerald green and black leather collar with black lambskin lining. It bore a golden tag, which was engraved with a single letter: X.

“Who do you belong to?” Xander asked.

“You, Ser.”

“Very good,” the zebra said. “You are mine. Now, hold still for me.”

Puzzling held as still as she could while Xander secured the collar in place, making sure it wasn’t too tight or too loose before clasping the buckle in the back. Her heart pounded in her chest as the zebra kissed her deeply, time seeming to stop in that moment. She moaned into their mouth as her pussy clenched violently until the moment was eventually broken, and she snapped back to reality.

“Let’s get you tied up,” Xander said. “On the bed for me, on your back.”

Puzzling Insanity was blushing profusely at that point. “Yes, Ser,” she said, crawling over to the bed and hoisting herself up onto it with a small grunt. She bit her lip as Xander used her favorite black rope to tie her left arm to her left leg, her hand resting on her shin.

As they did the same to her right arm and leg, they asked, “Are you comfortable?”

“Yes, Ser, thank you,” the fanged mare said.

“Good,” Xander said before smacking Puzzling’s mountainous rear as hard as they could, relishing the way her flesh rippled as a loud gasping moan escaped her lips. They shushed her and placed a hand over her muzzle. “Don’t want any noise complaints, do we?”

Puzzling shook her head and looked pleadingly up at the zebra. Her cunt was on fire, begging for stimulation of any kind.

“You poor thing,” Xander teased, getting up close and personal with the submissive mare’s most sacred place. “Such a filthy little slut. You’re fucking soaked.”

Their hot breath on her sopping wet pussy made the mare shiver in her bondage. She was trying desperately to hold back her moans and screams as they smacked her cunt, a series of wet thwacks filling the room until she was a whimpering, quivering mess.

The zebra spat on her pussy and got up, looking over the selection of impact toys before choosing the crop. Dragging it over her sensitive flesh, they asked, “Are you ready, whore?”

“Y-yes, Ser,” Puzzling said, her voice trembling almost as much as she was. She needed this. Stars entered her vision as Xander swung the crop as hard as they could, the leather biting into the flesh of her ass and leaving marks. A whimper bubbled forth from her throat as the heat and pressure deep in her core became unbearable.

Xander could tell by the sounds she made that she was close, and they stopped with a cruel smirk. “Not yet,” they said, receiving another whimper in response. “Don’t you want to cum while being stretched out by my big zebra cock, my little pony slut?”

“Yes, Ser, I want it so bad!” Puzzling Insanity whined, making her best puppy-eyed expression. Soon her vision was dominated by the dark pillar of flesh that was Xander’s cock.

“First you gotta show me how bad you want it,” they purred, grinning as Puzzling opened her mouth as wide as possible. With a low growl, the zebra slid into the earth pony’s gaping maw. “Ffffffuuuuuuck, you really know how to suck cock!”

The fanged mare gurgled and moaned in response, her face quickly becoming a mess of drool, tears and makeup. She felt their balls hit her muzzle, the musk overpowering her senses as they groped and slapped her breasts.

Xander watched Puzzling take as much of their cock as possible, reveling in the noises she made. Not wanting to cum yet, the zebra pulled out of her throat, leaving her a gasping mess as they moved to position themself between her legs.

As Puzzling’s eyes fluttered open, she whined.

“Use your words, slut,” Xander said, giving her ass a hard smack.

“P-please,” she begged, “give it to me!”

“Give what to you?” the zebra asked as they teasingly rubbed her cunt with their cock.

Puzzling Insanity cried out, “Please put your big zebra cock in my tight pony cunt!”

Xander was taken aback for a moment at her desperate outburst. Shaking it off, they slowly began to push into her depths. They let out a groan as her walls slowly accepted their cock. “Holy shit, you’re so fucking tight,” they said through gritted teeth.

Puzzling whimpered as inch after inch filled her up and stretched her out, tears of pleasure pricking at her yellow eyes as she felt the tip of the zebra’s cock finally kiss her cervix. “D-did I take it all?” she asked, her voice shaky.

Xander looked down and saw that their cock was buried to the hilt. They chuckled, “Well, I’ll be damned, you actually did!”

The fanged mare suddenly let out a loud gasp. Her ears began to ring and her vision went white as the heat and pressure inside of her exploded. She gritted her teeth, desperately trying not to scream out her orgasm as her stretched and filled cunt released a trickle of hot juices.

“Already?” the zebra asked, smirking. “You ponies always cum so quickly on a zebra cock.” As they felt her relax, they began to pound into her.

Puzzling Insanity continued to whimper as her pussy squelched around the thick shaft inside of it. She whined as an empty feeling made itself known.

Xander picked up the cane and brought it down on her ass again and again until she felt her pussy clench around nothing, her fingers digging into her shins as she tried not to cry out.

“My dirty little painslut,” the zebra purred, setting the cane down and admiring their handiwork before plunging back into the earth pony’s sodden cunt.

Puzzling could feel their cock throb deep inside her and bore down as hard as she could with what was left of her muscle control.

Xander gritted their teeth and held onto the bound mare for dear life, fucking her as hard and deep as they could. They let out a low growl as they leaned in and shoved their tongue down Puzzling’s throat, the tip of their cock pressed firmly against her cervix as they tensed up and came.

The fanged mare shuddered in her bondage as she felt every throb and the warmth flooding her insides. Her eyes fluttered closed as she moaned into the zebra’s mouth.

Xander rode out their orgasm, eventually coming down from the high and breaking the kiss. They withdrew their softening cock and said, “I can’t believe you let me do that.” A grin stretched across their muzzle.

Puzzling smiled and said, “Happy Hearts and Hooves Day.”

“Happy Hearts and Hooves Day, baby girl,” Xander said, nuzzling the bound mare affectionately.

“C-can you please take a picture of me real quick?”

The zebra chuckled and grabbed their phone, taking a few photos of their marefriend before untying her. “I’m going to go grab the aftercare kit,” they said, removing her collar and carefully setting it on the nightstand.

Puzzling nodded as the shivers began. Xander quickly wrapped a blanket around her and left to grab said aftercare kit. She sat on the bed in her blanket cocoon and waited for her partner to come back.

When Xander came back with the aftercare kit, they handed Puzzling a pink bottle filled with water, which she accepted and drank. The zebra sat next to her on the bed and opened the first aid kit. “Alright, sweetie,” they said, “I need to take a look at you for a minute.”

The earth pony obeyed and let her partner remove the blanket. Xander whistled as they looked her over.

Puzzling’s body was a mosaic of bruises and other products of their session.

“Get on your belly for me.”

She did so and gave the zebra a shaky smile as she felt the welcome chill of aloe vera being rubbed into the many welts and cane marks decorating her ass.

“You did such a good job, Puzzling,” Xander said, being sure to apply plenty of the cold substance to the bigger marks. “You took it so well.”

The earth pony cooed happily as she took in the zebra’s words. She looked back at them and asked, “Can you please get me something to eat?”

“Do you want chocolate or crackers?” Xander asked, fishing through the aftercare kit for a snack.

“Crackers, please,” Puzzling said, smiling as the zebra handed her an opened pack of peanut butter crackers. “I love you.”

Xander blushed and said, “I love you too. Let’s see what’s on TV, okay?”

The zebra found the remote and turned on the TV, cuddling up to their marefriend. The two of them spent the rest of the night like that, watching movies and enjoying each other’s company.