Taming the Batterscotch... Together

by Lighttone GryphonStar

Rating: mature
Tags: Comedy, Big Macintosh, Sex, Thunderlane, Anthro, Applejack, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Fluttershy, Porn, Coloratura
Length: 4118

Batterscotch, the genderswap version of Flutterbat, keeps breaking into Apple Farm, and Applejack has been forced to take on the tasks of taming him every full moon and keeping the secret from her beloved marefriend, Coloratura.

NOT A SEQUEL. Rather an alternate take with Applejack and a genderswap Flutterbat. In his transformed state, he keeps breaking into the farm and feasting on some blood. But this time, Applejack has to keep the secret and tame him behind the back of her beloved marefriend, Coloratura. Being the element of honest, this hurts her far more than just simply killing in the previous version. Thus when things get more complicated with the prime witness in this version, the ending changes dramatically.

Warning: Dubious consent,, slight voyuerism, blowjob, chest fucking, guilt ridden sex, Shocking compromise, Double Boobjob, Hardcore blowjob, Cum swapping, Pussy swapping, Happy Ending/Threesome Climax

Published 2024-03-04 22:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-03-04 22:00:00 UTC

Sometimes, you can't face it alone.

The full moon hung high in the sky, and the night was lovely. Applejack had plenty of light as she walked home after the concert. She just got back from an amazing date with Coloratura, her marefriend. But before it got too late, she had to return home, and check the trees before going to bed.

When she arrived at the front gate, she saw a strange yet familiar scene. There was a trail of blood leading to the barn. This was a troubling sign, for sure. She could hear the screams of panic and agony coming from inside as she drew closer. Her hands tensed and teeth gritted as she thought of all the horrible possibilities. Was it somepony she knew this time? One of her siblings? Big Mac? Apple Bloom? Those were her most dreaded assumptions.

Applejack burst into the barn and was immediately greeted with a sight she had grown way too accustomed to seeing. The blood trail led directly to the scene of the crime. The barely clad standing over a fresh victim was the barely clothed Butterscotch, fully transformed into Batterscotch.

Thunderlane, one of the best wonderbolts in the country, was his target. Rumble's older brother and best man of Applejack's wedding to his sister Coloratura. The stallion was a well-known and beloved friend of the family. But when he reached out to Applejack for assistance, all he saw was the blank face staring back at him.

Applejack moved to a pitchfork nearby. The creature seemed to notice the sound of the metal on the ground, as he lifted his head and glanced up at the mare. Batterscotch hissed and growled at her. Applejack lifted the pitchfork and aimed it at the vampire. When she saw that he would not give, she hurled it.

Yet, much to the shock of Thunderlane, it didn't go through his attacker Applejack had pierced it through the poor stallion's chest instead, pinning him into the wall far from him. This killed him instantly. When Applejack sighed and narrowed her eyes on Batterscotch crouching beneath Thunderlane's lifeless body, almost as though he was trying to hide from her

Batterscotch's ears were drooped, letting out a small whimper. His food was stolen from him so easily. And he knew that the only way he could get it back would be to steal it from another. Turning his attention towards Applejack he licked his lips and charged right at her.

Applejack was able to move away just in time to dodge Batterscotch's bite. Grabbing him by the sides, she flipped him over and pinned him to the ground. As they struggled, his fangs snapped at the air near her. He was still very hungry and had no intention of letting Applejack stop him from satisfying his hunger.

"Stop this Butterscotch!" Applejack said. "Yer not like this!"

Batterscotch was having none of it. He kept fighting with everything he had, but his strength was no match for Applejack's. Eventually, Applejack managed to roll him onto his back and grabbed him by the throat. He continued to growl but was no longer able to make any words.

"Listen," Applejack looked right into Batterscotch's glowing red eyes. "I can help ya. Just calm down--" She was stopped upon feeling something long pulse along her backside. Her face scrunched up as her eyes widened. She glanced down, and noticed a familiar bulge ripping out from the vampires shredded pants

Batterscotch wasn't just hungry for blood. He was horny too. Applejack groaned, knowing the best way to calm him down, and prevent him from attacking anyone else, would be to satiate his appetites. Gulping hard, she flexed her legs muscles and prepared to flip around.

"Okay... I know how ta deal with this." She released her hold on his throat, and quickly rolled around. Pinning his head in the vicegrip of her legs and landing her face and large chest right in front of it. Her face was burning with embarrassment, but she tried to stay focused on the task. "Now, to phase two..."

Applejack removed her top, and pressed her bare chest around the think foot long meat. Batterscotch immediately responded by bucking his hips, causing his member to slide between the valley of her breasts and punch her chin. It pulsed and twitched in her softness, sending shivers of both disgust and arousal down her spine.

"It's alright sugarcube," Applejack whispered, stroking the throbbing appendage. "I'm here for ya." She leaned down and licked the tip. "Just relax."

Batterscotch moaned louder. His eyes rolling back and fangs retracting as the pleasure overcame him. He started thrusting his hips into Applejack's large bosom very slow. As his member slid, he began to pant heavily.

"That's right," Applejack cooed, rubbing her orbs along the cock. "Enjoy this, and don't fight it."

Batterscotch's growls softened into a purring sound. His member twitched more and more with each thrust, the tip poking out between her boobs. His tongue flapped out of his mouth and his eyes rolled back. With each passing minute, his speed increased.

Applejack did her best to keep up with him. She opened her mouth wide and took the tip inward. It wasn't long before Applejack found his cock pushing against the back of her throat. She gagged slightly, and felt her face burn hotter. Her nipples were growing hard, and the heat was rising in her core. She couldn't deny this, especailly after her date with Coloratura, this felt so wrong. But every second of this was turning her on.

The more Applejack bobbed her head and rubbed her tits along the shaft, the more it started to swell up. This was the point where Batterscotch was close to bursting. Wincing, Applejack knew what to do next to tip him over. Pushing her breasts aside, she shoved a good chunk of the meat into her mouth and down her throat and bit down hard.

Batterscotch screeched with delight as the pain mixed in with his pleasure. This was the tipping point as his seed flooded deep into Applejack's maw. The first shot came in fast, and caught Applejack by surprise as it sprayed her stomach with hot sticky white liquid. The next few were more controlled and allowed Applejack to drink up as much as she could.

After a couple seconds, Applejack pulled her head back. Taking a big breath, she looked down and saw his cock was still hard and throbbing. She knew it was going to take more than that to bring back the Butterscotch she cared so much for. Hiding his secret was always a tough task, but she had a duty to fulfill. Though, often it felt like she was doing this for more than friendship.

Applejack stood up, and began undoing the belt on her pants. Batterscotch lay there, watching her strip down. Once his eyes caught a view of her vagina, his mouth dropped open and his fangs grew back. His member started to twitch, and demanded attention. Quicker than Applejack could react, he tackled her under him.

"Not so fast--" Applejack protested but was quickly silenced as Batterscotch rammed himself into her walls. Her words were replaced by a long loud moan.

Batterscotch held her hips down, and began bucking into her. His tongue hung out and drool dribbled out of his mouth. The only thing that mattered to him was feeding his carnal desires. He was an animal now, and nothing could stop him from ravaging the mare beneath him.

Applejack tried to fight her own urges. She had a job to do, a mentality to maintain. But his power was always too much for even a strong mare like herself to handle. The more he rammed his rod into her, the more her mind clouded and the louder her moans grew.

"Oh, sugarcube," Applejack whined. "Oh yes..." Her pussy was tightening around his rod, and her clit was getting rubbed with every thrust. The heat was overwhelming, and the feeling of him deep within her was driving her wild. She bit her lip, and her mind started to melt. She wrapped her legs around him and started moving her hips along his thrusts. "Harder..."

Batterscotch snarled and obliged. His cock was reaching deeper and deeper into her, his tip was hitting her cervix. It was almost like he was trying to rip open her womb. She wasn't even thinking about taming him anymore. Thoughts of Butterscotch's true self and even Coloratura were fading away. All she could smile for was the dick slamming into her.

"Oh, yes!!" Applejack screamed. Her juices squirted and sprayed out around the cock and covered the hay. Her walls clamped around the dick. She dug her hands into his back. Her head was thrown back and her entire body was shaking with pleasure. Her orgasm was so quick and powerful that she could even hear the footsteps echoing toward the barn.

Her jaw dropped and drool seeped out of the side of her mouth. Her eyes went blank. Her ears were deafened to the world. She had gone limp, and had no control over anything. Her body was being moved by his dick alone. She was losing herself in this pure, animalistic lust.

"Sugarcube, yes!" Applejack yelled. "Give it to me!" She was starting to sound just like him. "Unleash all your vampiric desire upon me!!" His replies were nothing more than growls and grunts. She was getting close to an orgasm. "Yes! I'm a slut for the bloodsucking beast inside you! Yes!!"

"Applejack... what's going on here?!" A soft and sensual voice echoed at the doorway.

Applejack's blissful expression vanished in a flash. Her eyes shot open and her body went stiff. Her gaze shot towards the door. Coloratura, her marefriend, was standing there. She was unable to stop as Batterscotch roared at the same time, and filled her womb with thick seed. Her eyes winced closed and her face convulsed with her finishing climax.

Batterscotch retracted his penis as his vampiric features retreated. The feathers upon the wings grew back, iron muscular body refined into a smooth and budgie state, and his fangs shrank down. By the time he was done, he had reverted back into his normal self, collapsed to one side, and fell unconscious.

In the same moment, the first peaks of the sunlight shined behind Coloratura, adding the contrasting horror on her face upon seeing the last moment that transpired. Applejack was quick to rush over and cover her mouth. Pushing her against the wall to prevent a scream.

"Shhh," Applejack pleaded. "Please, don't tell anypony about this, please?!"

Coloratura pushed Applejack off of her and turned her head. She was silent, but Applejack could see her lip trembling. Her eyes were wide and glistening with tears. "No, I want answers, now!!"

Applejack winced back and forth between Butterscotch's naked body and Coloratura shaken state. Her stomach twisted and her heart pounded. This was her worst nightmare come true. And she had no idea how to fix this. She scooted back, until she was at least a full foot away from Coloratura. Both of them fell to the ground as the full weight of everything hit them.

"Rara..." Applejack tried to start, but her words were just a mess. "I can't... I can't tell you."

"Do you love him?" Coloratura stopped her own mouth. There was so much anger in those words that she didn't want out in the open. But at the same time, she was in so much pain.

"I..." Her eyes dropped and spoke softer. "I love you, Rara. That's the truth."

"Then why..." Coloratura choked back. "Why were you letting him..."

"I need to!!" Applejack snapped back. "If I don't contain him then the whole of Ponyville is at risk."

"So..." Coloratura was starting to shake. "Why can't you tell anypony?"

"The whole family swore to secrecy!" Applejack answered. "We... or rather I didn't want to ruin his already very fragile life. If he's caught, he will be hunted, and probably executed. Even if the law didn't do that, or if it was even possible for Twilight to just fix him, everypony will look at him differently. He would have a hard time finding peace in his actions."

"Is there really no other way?" Coloratura asked, tears beginning to trickle down her cheeks. "Can't another take this stand? Twilight? Rarity, Maybe Barb even--" She was stopped as Applejack flipped around and put her arms around her in a tight hug.

"You think this is any better?" Applejack sobbed. "Do you have any idea what this has done to me? I feel a mix of disgust and love with myself and him every second that I spend in the act. I never wanted to do this, but I have a responsibility to help him!"

Coloratura was so surprised by how much more hurt Applejack seemed. She always knew her marefriend to bottle up emotions, but never this strong. And now she could feel how much Applejack's body was shaking. Her hands stroked over Applejack's mane, and she pulled her into a tighter embrace. "So, do you... love him?"

"I..." Applejack pulled back and looked into her eyes. "I love you both." She placed her hand on Coloratura's cheek. "I don't know what else to say. I'm so sorry for keeping this from you."

"I... I understand." Coloratura's tears faded and replied, pulling her into a kiss. "But if you love me too, promise me, that you won't leave my side. That you won't push me away and hide your pain." She smiled. "Tell me everything that you can't say to him."

"Oh, Rara..." Applejack leaned her head onto her shoulder. "Thank you..."

"You're welcome." Coloratura kissed her forehead and pulled her into a tighter hug. Dropping her over her shoulders, her eyes caught sight of something rising upward. "Oh..." The songstress blushed intensely. "Wow..."

"What?" Applejack pulled back and raised an eyebrow in confusion to the powerful warmth burning off her marefriend's body. She turned to see the same and gasped with a bit of a smile. "Yeah... His morning wood is just as impressive as his vampiric side."

"I don't know," Coloratura blushed. "I've never been with..." She fell over into Applejack. The heat growing inside wasn't helped by her marefriend's fully naked body beside her. "Maybe we should let him rest."

"Are you sure?" Applejack's turned sly. "Since you are here. You could help carry him back into the house. He is a heavy stud."

"I guess so," Coloratura giggled.

The two mares walked into the barn and picked him up. Applejack took his upper half, leaving his massive dick to bounce over Coloratura as they carried him out of the barn, and through the yard. The songstress's face was getting bright by the second as the member snuggled between her breasts.

"So," Applejack looked down. "How are you feeling now?"

"This is a lot of cock," Coloratura admitted, trying to keep his from hitting her mouth. "It's really thick."

"You ain't seen nothin' yet, darlin," Applejack giggled, closing the door behind them. "Prop him over here." Their voices echoed through the house soon followed by silence and soon enough a soft licking sound.

Outside, back by the barn, Big Mac came out of the shadows with a shotgun in hand. With regret deep in his eyes, he entered the barn. There he discovered Thunderlane off the wall, gradually changing. He tore out the pitchfork as he crawled to his knees. The morphing beasts squirmed in confusion realizing he had not lost any blood from the wound. Seconds later all that changed as his body twisted in agony. Muscles pulsed and bones snapped out loud. His fur was becoming paler and his feathers were dropping out.

"Shh," Big Mac pumped the shotgun. He shoved the barrel right into his mouth just as his fangs curved. There was a loud blast and light flashed into the barn. The contents of Thunderlane's brain flew all over the place. After observing the body tremble a few times, Big Mac fired additional rounds, tearing away the limbs. Ensuring that the undead beast would not rise again, he fired two more blasts into the heart. After a moment Big Mac's ears flickered at the sound of the two mares moaning together back at the house. "Have fun, Applejack, and Coloratura."

Back inside, Butterscotch awoke to the surprise of two pairs of bouncing breasts rimming along the length of his cock. He watched as his dick disappeared between them before popping out and rising to hit their lips. He had never seen anything like this before, but he couldn't deny the pleasure. His hands gripped the rim of the couch as his mouth gaped open and tongue lolled out. He could barely contain his excitement as his penis twitched.

"I think he's waking up," Coloratura pointed out. "What next--" She was silenced as Applejack shoved her mouth onto the tip.

"You can enjoy the taste, sugarcube." Applejack cooed. She licked her lips and smiled. "Take in all hi scent."

Coloratura giggled, and opened her mouth wide. Taking a deep breath, she pushed her head downward and took as much of the shaft in her mouth. It wasn't long before she felt the tip hit the back of her throat. She began to gag and pulled back, only to repeat the process. Luckily, her breasts collided with Applejack's along the parts she couldn't fit, keeping the stud entangled in pleasure.

Butterscotch was in such a blissful paradise that he couldn't even remember what happened last night. His eyes were glazing over as the heat started to rise inside him. No matter how strange this scene was for such a shy stallion like himself, He didn't want it to stop. All the pressure in his body was gathering around his hips. The more these two beautiful mares bounced on him, the stronger the need became.

"Applejack..." Butterscotch whined and grabbed Coloratura's head. "I can't... hold on!"

"Give it to her." Applejack demanded, crossing her fingers with his, pushing Coloratura further down his dick. "Fill her belly."

Hearing the songstress gag and choke on his base, Butterscotch winced. His cock exploded inside Coloratura's mouth. Seed splattered against the back of her throat, filling her mouth to the brim before sliding into her stomach. Butterscotch was so overwhelmed by the sudden burst, that his hips started thrusting on their own.

Coloratura was shocked by the unique taste and texture, but it didn't bother her. She wanted to gulp it all down, but there was just so much. She had to pull her head back and gasp. Just then, the rest of the white liquid splattered all over her chin and breasts. If anything, she was more surprised that Applejack was hiding this from her for so long. The mix of love and guilt must have been absolute torture for such an honest mare.

Coming out of the white daze of thought, Coloratura raced forward and tackled Applejack to the floor. Not giving time for words, or an attempt to clean of the mess over her, the songstress stole the apple mare's mouth into a strong and tender embrace. Their tongues intertwined and their mouths opened wide. They basked in the flavor of his jizz and each other's scents, and even took a swig of the white substance back and forth, before swallowing it all.

Butterscotch stared down at the two, and his dick was starting to harden again for one final round. Standing up, he took a deep breath and faded away all shyness entirely. Rolling the two mares around until he found a pussy to stab into. Coloratura winced and yelped as his cock penetrated her. His massive dick ripped apart her virgin pussy with ease. Her mind blank in and out and her whole body began to twitch. She wasn't sure how she should feel, but it wasn't exactly bad.

Applejack wasn't going to be ignored either. She spread her legs and grabbed his hips, pulling him in towards her. Feeling the attention, Butterscotch quickly pulled out of Coloratura and stabbed into Applejack, staining her marefriend's fresh juice into her. Applejack's mouth gaped as his cock slammed deep inside her. Her eyes rolled back and her legs kicked around his sides.

Feeling the emptiness bring her back to reality, Coloratura spanked her ass at him. He listened and switched back to her once more. The songstress cried out. She wasn't as ready as Applejack for the sheer size of his cock, but the pleasure was overwhelming. Her juices were already leaking out, and the heat was burning her. It was unlike any other heat she ever had with a mare, and the desire for his dick was so strong.

Not wanting to deprave both mares for too long, Butterscotch switched back and forth at random moments. Maybe giving Coloratura a few thrusts before slamming into Applejack and giving her plenty of attention. It was a strange rhythm, but it worked out for the three lovers.

"Oh, wow!" Coloratura gasped and moaned. Her body was shaking, but becoming more accustomed to the impalement. "This is... amazing!"

"I told you he was special," Applejack giggled and gasped, "And his stamina is incredible, especially after a vampiric transformation."

"Yes," Coloratura smiled brighter, cried and moaned. "Fuck me more! Please, fuck us both!"

"You heard her, Butterscotch!" Applejack teased. She was so happy to finally enjoy this moment with the mare she loved the most.

Butterscotch moved even faster and harder, and the two mares became a mess. They were gasping, moaning and crying. The more their bodies shook, the wetter the sounds became. Their juices were flowing out with each thrust and their orgasms were close. He had to fight hard to make sure he wouldn't finish until they did.

Applejack pressed Coloratura's body downward, pushing their pussies together as he continued his relentless switching. Their clits rubbed against each other and their juices were mixing. They held hands tight and pulled each other into a deep kiss. Both of them were so happy that they were finally sharing this together. There would be no more secrets at all between the two.

"Rara!" Applejack moaned and gasped, "I'm almost... I'm cumming!!"

"Me too!" Coloratura's whole body began to spasm.

With their pussies clamping down on his cock with each pass made it hard for him to control which one to end it on. Butterscotch had no choice but to give in and slam deepest into Coloratura. Leaning over he groaned hard.

"Rara," Applejack whispered, "I love you!"

"I love you, too, Apple!" Coloratura whispered back, and both of them hit their climax.

Coloratura and Applejack cried out loud and squirted together. At the same time, Butterscotch filled Coloratura's virgin womb with a river of hot and sticky seed. Both mares were lost in their own world as their pussies sucked the life from him. Neither cared that both might be carrying his seed deep inside them now.

So much white fired in the last few seconds that plenty of it leaked out over the other mare, and dripped to the floor. When he pulled out, a pool of their combined fluids spilled out. Butterscotch had done a number on them and was exhausted himself beyond his limit. He fell over and lay on the couch, breathing heavily.

"That was amazing," Applejack cooed into her marefriend on the floor. "Did you enjoy it, Rara?"

"Yes," Coloratura giggled. She could barely move her legs. "He is the best... I'll gladly help you every night that we need to tame him."

"Yeah, every bit and more" Applejack leaned in and kissed her. "I love you so much."

"I love you, too, Applejack." Coloratura leaned up and gave her a loving embrace.

"Does that mean we don't have to destroy so many corpses!!" Apple Bloom jumped out from behind the couch.

"What?!" Applejack and Coloratura's jaw dropped.

"Apple Bloom," Scootaloo was right out behind her, blushing with her hands covering her eyes. "You are so loud."

"Yeah, how are we supposed to blackmail them if you don't shut up!!" Sweetie Belle followed.

"Well..." Applejack turned her head at her marefriend and chuckled. "Looks like we're going to have to make a family secret out of this, too."

"Unless you don't think five mares can handle him" Coloratura giggled and winked.

Applejack looked back at Butterscotch's shrinking dick and then to her sister and her friends before bluntly saying. "As Pinkie Pie would say, this ship is weird and kinky enough, let's not throw incest into this."

******