Wereapple Failing

by Lighttone GryphonStar

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Porn, Tragedy, Non-consensual, Fluttershy, Violence, Anthro, Applejack, Gore
Length: 4603

In another alternate take, Applejack's family has been hiding a very dangerous secret that happens only during the full moon. Male Applejack refrain from following in love with anypony, less there be consequences. However, Fluttershy is too tempting.

Genderswap Applejack has been hiding a dark secret in his family tree. Every second child has suffered this horrible curse. As such, he has reframed from falling in love with anypony. However, he can't deny his heart's ravenous desire any longer. Fluttershy leaves her door unlocked on the cold winter night, knowing he's coming for her. The sight of a full moon confirming this night might end in tragedy!

Not a sequel to the previous story, but rather another alternate take on the story.

Warning: Dubious Consent, NOT RAPE, I'm not going there so get over it, Pussy sex, Anal sex, Conflicted emotions during sex, Uncontrollable Urges, Multiple ending, one good, and bad.

Published 2024-04-06 17:20:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-04-11 19:21:48 UTC

Howling Moon

The full moon hung high in the sky, and the night was icy cold. Winter was fast approaching Ponyville. It was a night that the Apple family had long feared. For tonight, Applejack's pungent horny stallion musk had already filled the crisp autumn air. He had spent the whole day working in the orchards to prepare for the winter when suddenly a craving came over him. His stomach growled. No, not a hunger, but a thirst. Not for water, but a drink. But not a drink of cider. No, a different kind of taste.

At the far end of the farm, under a lone tree, Thunderlane screamed out in agony. A former apple farmer slowly transformed into a monster right above him. The pegasus' fighting was pointless as the teeth dug into him. "Applejack! No! Please!" He begged as the apple stallion ripped out chunks. The taste of his blood was so delicious. Thunderlane's blood was like a sweet apple pie. Applejack's teeth and his face grew sharp and jagged. He was already starting to look like a beast. Thunderlane's screams only excited the former apple farmer.

He felt his teeth grow sharp, claws growing from his fingers. The fur around his body was thick and brown. His coat turned a deep crimson. And his eyes glowed neon green. Applejack cried out in rebellion, but the effort was pointless. No matter how hard he had tried to resist, his lust would always win. This was the curse that his family had carried. Only two things could slate this.

He tore off Thunderlane's arm next, squeezing its contents like a tube into his mouth. The taste was divine, every single time. So many nutrients and vitamins were inside the muscle fibers. He felt his strength increasing by the minute. "I'm sorry!" Applejack growled out as his urge to fight faded completely. "I can't stop."

He pulled one of Thunderlane's wings off next, then a leg, and finally pressed his claws into the collarbone. The ribcage broke apart with just the grip alone. The pegasus' heart flopped out, still pumping. Applejack's monstrous eyes widened at the organ. He cupped it carefully in his claws, his salvia dripping all over. Thunderlane watched in shock and horror as his own heart was lifted to the wereapple's jaws. With his last breath, he let out a final scream before his heart was gobbled up.

Afterward, he was silenced the beast went about eating everything else. His body grew in size and strength, his mind slowly turning feral. All that was left after the feast was a puddle of blood. In the morning, the Apple family would bury the remains of the body alongside the rest.

The final full moon of the month rose up. In Applejack's farmhouse, the rest Apple family locked their doors and covered their eyes. All knew Applejack's hunt was about to reach its peak. The night was long and cold. The wind was bitterly howling as the snow fell. Applejack stood outside Fluutershy's cottage, covered in white flakes.

The front door was slightly cracked open, and Fluttershy leered her head out slowly. Her eyes widened at the towering wereapple standing out in the blizzard. The sight was enough to make her heart skip a beat. It took her a minute to compose herself before she spoke.

"Applejack? I've been waiting for you." Her voice trembled as he inched closer. Never said a word at all, but she already knew why he was there. It was the curse that had plagued his family since the creation of the Apple clan. They had always suffered under the moon, turning into hideous creatures that craved blood, flesh, and...

She could see the pain in his eyes and gestured him inside. "Don't freeze out there, Applejack. I-It's warm inside..." She gulped hard and draped open the door completely. This revealed her very thin attire. Her entire cleavage on display, and the nightgown barely covered her hips and thighs. No bra, or panties, very ready for the night that awaited her.

His nostrils flared up at the sight, the smell of her pheromones was like a sweet perfume. His cock peeking out of his sleeve urging to run inside and just take her. Yet despite the complete transformation, his movements were so timid. That is until he crossed the door's threshold. Bracing Fluttershy against the wall, his nose buried deep in her hair, licking and kissing her neck. His cock rubbed against her legs in full stride without any help.

"Applejack... oh dear!" Fluttershy shivered with panic but cooed softly. She ran her hands along his back, feeling his muscles bulge up. His teeth scraped against her skin. She bit her lip, letting his tongue taste her neck and shoulders. His tail kicked the door closed, as his teeth reached her large divine breasts. Her nipples were fully erect. The wereapple bit down and Fluttershy let out a squeak.

She held onto his ears tightly, her teeth gritting between pain and pleasure. Her cheeks were flushed red, unsure if she was still panicking or loving it. "Easy boy..." Her voice was silent as he ripped open the nightgown and tossed it aside. Her heart was racing a mile a minute as his claws traveled over her naked form.

His tongue licked the nipples and pressed hard enough. Within seconds, Fluttershy threw her head back. Her screams echoed through the cottage as her animals hid away. A drop of milk seeped out and he lapped it up. It tasted so good, his cock was throbbing, and his tail was wagging. It was such a relief that the night was over.

Fluttershy felt him shift around and soon his cock was poking against her. It was trying to find any hole to squeeze into. She gulped hard and lifted her right leg. It found the entrance quickly, the head pushing the folds open. "Applejack, are you ready?" Her voice was a whimper as his hands gripped her hips.

Her heart racing even fast, the penetration was always so violent. She knew the next few minutes would be painful, but it was worth it. Applejack pushed forward, his cock sliding deep inside her. It was so hot and hard, pulsating rapidly. "Applejack!" She cried out, and her body quivered. He didn't even need to thrust yet, his monstrous dick was stretching her pussy wide.

"Fluttershy!" Applejack howled in his deep voice, as he slammed his pelvis into her. The walls tightened up around his cock, but it kept going deeper and deeper. The pain was excruciating, her eyes started to tear up. Yet the shy mare never pushed him back. From the first time this happened over a year ago, she knew he had no control.

He kept his head buried into her breasts. The taste of the milk was intoxicating. Every few minutes, his cock would push further and further. The walls would tighten up from her horror. The kind mare had to remove all her fears and let the lust take over them both. Fluttershy wrapped her legs around his waist, the heels dug into his thighs.

"Oh, Applejack. Oh, please!" She begged softly. Her hands reached around his back and pulled him close. His mouth was still biting her nipples, switching between each orb the moment the previous one sagged. Milk spilled out onto his lips and onto the floor. Her cries of agony mixed with moans of pleasure. The pain of his monstrous cock was unbearable, but the pleasure was too great.

His pelvis slapped against her against the wall, their hips connecting with every thrust. It was like they were in heat, a mating frenzy more ferocious than anything a regular pony could ever contain. He was the animal, but she was the one who needed to be tamed. She held onto his face and kissed his forehead.

"My body for you, Applejack." Her voice was shaky and weak, but her body was burning with passion. "Please, give it to me! Oh, fuck me! Fuck me harder! Oh, please!" She begged and whined into his eyes. His claws dug into her hips, breaking her skin and drawing blood. She cried out as the pain shot up her spine, but she still didn't let go.

Applejack pulled his mouth away, her nipples dripping with milk and saliva. He leaned into her neck and gave it a lick. His lips moved upward to her mouth. She opened her jaws and let him in. The kiss was deep and ravenous. It was like when like the last pieces of meat were off the bone. Fluttershy tried every time to match it with passion, but it was too wild.

He slammed into her harder, faster, and deeper. Her moans and groans were muffled by the kiss, her cheeks stretching to the point of tearing. Applejack's cock was already beating into her womb, the tip slamming against the cervix. It was getting harder to move, her pussy was gripping him too tight. Her mind was melting into a pile of goo. She couldn't hold it back any longer.

She broke the kiss and threw her head back again. Screaming so loud that her animals covered their ears. Her body shuddered as her orgasm ripped through her. Her walls gripped him tighter, but his thrusting didn't stop. The wereapple didn't care that the mare came, the beast wanted the prize. He kept going, pounding her harder and harder. The cum was rising up, it was getting ready to burst. His cock was growing, the girth expanding. Her pussy stretched over the wide base, locking his cock in place. He couldn't hold back any longer, the seed was filling up her womb.

Tears flooded down her eyes as the warm seed made her fears vanish. "I love you, Applejack!" Fluttershy whimpered.

The wereapple roared and pulled her close, their bodies pressed together. The heat and lust were driving him mad. But his mind was clear for a few short seconds. It was just long enough for him to whisper into her ear. "I love you too, Fluttershy."

She slowly smiled at that before the beast threw her off and onto the couch. She didn't have time to recover, her pussy filled with his seed. As soon as her belly touched the cushions, his claws slashed her ass. She yelped and her body shivered. The wereapple pressed her hips down and spread her ass cheeks.

The little rabbit, Angel, had been forced to watch all of this. He gulped hard and glared at the monster as the cock reached full stride again. The rebellious white bunny rushed to his mommy's aid and kicked the beast in the foot. The wereapple stopped, turned back kicked the small thing into a wall on the far end of the cottage

"Angel Bunny!" Fluttershy cried out, but could not reach him as the wereapple pushed her back into the couch. "Please..." she begged the bunny to stop its defense. "Let mommy tend to daddy's needs." Angel bunny whimpered and lay there defeated. All it could do was watch in horror as the wereapple went back to the task.

The monster faced her and slammed his cock into her tightest hole. She screamed again as his claws gripped her sides. It was the same painful routine as previously. The monster's cock slid deeper and deeper, spreading her apart. Her panic now would only excite the monster more.

Her teeth grit, her jaw clenched, tears pouring out like waterfalls. Applejack's cock was so big, and so strong in this state. No other stallion could compare to it. Her body was being pushed to its limit every time. She could feel it growing inside her ass. The swelling of the tip pushed her anal walls open all the way.

Despite all of this horror, she could not deny her love for this beast. Never a whore for some random stallion like Thunderlane. But for Applejack, the craving was sometimes too much to resist. She was willing to give her all to him. Her body, her heart, and her soul. Her only regret was the pain and lack of control. Oh, how she would love it if this moment could enjoyed together, as one.

The wereapple's hips thrust into her ass. It felt so good to the monster. This hole always left him panting and drooling. Her ass was the tightest hole and it was making the wereapple's eyes roll. His cock was already at the base and the tip ripping into her stomach. Her moans and whimpers were music to the beast's ears.

Grabbing her by the mane, the beast forced her head up. The monster pulled her up and off the couch. With their bodies staying connected, as he juggled her arms over his shoulders. Her feet dangled and her head leaned back. His cock was now sliding in and out of her stomach. Fluttershy's eyes widened and her mouth dropped.

"Applejack, no!" Her eyes widened in horror as he displayed her body over the little animals. "Don't force them to watch me climax again!!" They stared up in shock and fear. Some hid their faces and others fled out the window, into the freezing cold. The ones who couldn't escape were left helpless. Angel Bunny could only watch as the monster violated his mommy. This happened every full moon, and each time her mind would break a little more.

The wereapple held her hips tightly, ramming harder and faster. The tip of his cock was stretching her stomach. He was pounding her so hard, so deep. It was a wonder she didn't pass out before he was finished. The beast howled and roared as his cock was throbbing again. Fluttershy's legs tightened and her toes curled. Her second orgasm was approaching quickly.

She tried to scream, but her lungs were empty. Her body convulsed and shook and her whimpers were just shredded whispers of his name over and over. Her eyes rolled into the back of her head. Her tongue hung out and her cheeks flushed. Applejack's cock burst the second time and flooded her insides.

The wereapple threw its head back and howled through his climax. His hot seed filled her stomach and overflowed and down his sack. Fluttershy's body shivered and her pussy leaked the white seed all over the couch. Her mind was completely blank. She hated the monster but loved the stallion trapped inside with all her heart.

Once finished, the head of the beast dropped down, and blood splattered over the walls and floor.

******

Author's Note

So what just happened?! Cliffhanger ending.

Just kidding. I've got two additional chapters planned. A good ending and a bad ending. That way, both of us can be happy. Posting them on Tuesday and Thursday respectively.

The Good Ending

Applejack blinked and grabbed his head. It's always throbbed the next morning. His body had completely returned to normal, but the after effects were always brutal. Sheering pain from head to toe, especially if he received any wound during the transformation. "Ah feel like ah drank ten bottles of cider..." He muttered as he rubbed his temples. The only part of him that wasn't hurting was his crotch. It was the only relief as his member pumping in joy at something beyond his sight.

His body jumped at the bloodstaining the ceiling of the cottage. "No, no, no!!" Applejack jerked up, only to be pushed back down. He winced hard as something bit down on him. Leering over, his eyes soften at Fluttershy working his morning wood. "Fluttershy.. I feared the worst."

"Oh, it's ok, Applejack." Fluttershy stopped sucking and winked at him. "Twilight's healing spell worked perfectly. Your cuts are all healed and there's no evidence that you were transformation or... assault on my body.." She blushed and giggled, going back to working his member. Her tongue swirling the head of his cock and sucking up the morning precum.

He blushed and pet her head. "You're the best, Fluttershy." He cooed and relaxed into the cushions, let her continue. His mind was racing over the previous night. It was a blurry, but he knew it had to have been bad. He could still taste Thunderlane flesh on his teeth, and the image of his blood dripping down his claws.

Fluttershy wouldn't let the images haunt him. This moment was meant for his joy, so she dropped her mouth down hard. Her throat took the length and Applejack's eyes bulged out. The shy mare's lips kissed his hilt, his head reaching the entrance of her stomach. Applejack's hands gripped her mane as she bobbed her head.

"Oh, Fluttershy! Yer my dream mare!" He thrusted into her face multiple times. "Yer the only thing that matters in my life! Ah couldn't live without you!" He kept pumping his hips, her cheeks were stretching around his sack. Her lips and tongue were massaging his shaft. It didn't take long before the tension was getting too great. "Ah'm gonna..."

His balls tightened and his cock erupted inside her stomach. Fluttershy closed her eyes and drank his sweeter, normal cum. Her throat swallowing the massive load and the rest pooling into her belly. Once the final drop was released, she pulled him out and smiled at him. Licking up the entire length, she giggled and gave the tip and quick kiss.

"Applejack, there's nothing we can't do together. We can make it through all." She snuggled up the couch. "Just hold me in your arms, and know that I love you."

"I love you too." He grinned bolder and pushed her back onto his lap. His cock was still standing at attention, and it was ready to go for a round two. Her eyes widen as he lined his member with her folds. "And ah'm gonna show ya right now!" With that he lifted his hips and penetrated her pussy. Fluttershy's back arched as his cock stretched her walls. Her arms and legs wrapped around his body. "Fluttershy, yer still so tight!"

"And you're still hard." She moaned and rested her chin on his shoulder. "Applejack, I'll never love another stallion like you. Please, give me everything. Every day, I want to be yours."

"Everyday..." He whispered into her ear.

"I'm ready!" Fluttershy squealed and dug her nails into his back. "Never hide that beast, for I will tame it every time!"

His eyes fell timid and pulled her into a passionate kiss. Their mouths wrestled and twisted as his cock pressed into her. Her walls gripping him tighter and tighter. He thrust deep inside her. Fluttershy's screams were muffled by the kiss. Her body shaking as her mind melted into his. The passion and love were driving them both so wild.

Breaking the kiss, he whispered into her ears, "Tame me, Fluttershy."

"Whenever you desire?!? For as long as you need me!!!" Fluttershy cried and her eyes rolled to the back of her head. "Breed me... Breed me until those horrible memories fade from your mind! Give me every single drop of seed you have!" She kissed his cheek.

Applejack couldn't believe this was happening. Fluttershy's voice, her body and her mind. He wanted to give her everything, and she was ready to take it. He grinned and held her hips tightly. Lifting her off the couch, he dropped her down his full length. Fluttershy threw her head back and howled into his ear like the wolf he was before. He slammed his hips up and her tits bouncing like crazy. He pounded her pussy was already raw from the night before. She didn't stop him though, wishing to enjoy the real him.

"Applejack!" Fluttershy howled like the wild beast. "It's so good, please don't stop!"

"Naw, Ah won't!" He kept pumping, slamming his pelvis into her hips. The sounds of their bodies connecting echoed through the room. His cock was stretching into her womb, her pussy walls trying to keep him inside. The friction was building up the pressure, they were both reaching the edge.

"Applejack!" Fluttershy screamed and dug her heels into his back.

"Fluttershy, I'm..." His words were cut short as her pussy locked his cock in. Hi eyes widened and their bodies fell back onto the couch. She came and the walls clamped down on him, making him erupt inside her womb. He groaned and held her tightly, the cum filling her to the brim. Fluttershy was shuddering and her toes curling. The climax was too much.

Slowly his cock softened, and Fluttershy's face collapsed onto his lips. "I love you." She purred through sweet kisses.

"Ah love you too." He responded in kind. They spent the rest of the morning making love. Their bodies pressing against each other, until the afternoon. It was a beautiful sight to behold, the two ponies so close and happy. The animals could see their true love from the windows and smiled. Even if Angel Bunny hated the way that monster treated his mommy.

Author's Note

Bad Ending coming Thursday

The Bad Ending

Applejack blinked and grabbed his head. It's always throbbed the next morning. His body had completely returned to normal, but the after effects were always brutal. Sheering pain from head to toe, especially if he received any wound during the transformation. "Ah feel like ah drank ten bottles of cider..." He muttered as he rubbed his temples. The only part of him that wasn't hurting was his crotch. It was the only relief as his member pumping in joy at something beyond his sight.

His body jumped at the blood staining the ceiling of the cottage. "No, no, no!!" His eyes raced over the scene. The whole room was torn apart. The animal pets were nothing more than shredded pieces of meat. The furniture was turned over and shattered into splinters. The walls and floor were drenched with, fur, bones and blood.

"Fluttershy?" He stopped at the final scene. She was lying over the floor, her arms and legs ripped off. The tattered remains of her wings clutched tightly in his hands. All of her remain organs were strung over him like a blanket. His cock still firmly inside what was left of her pussy. Applejack's jaw dropped as his hips moving up and down unconsciously like it was his personal fuck toy.

"Stop... Stop!!" He threw the piece of flesh away and covered his mouth. "Fluttershy!" Applejack gasped, his eyes filling up with tears. The realization hit him like a ton of bricks. His hand stopped jerking his cock, and he just stared at her corpse. His mind was trying to find some reason for this. "I'm sorry! Fluttershy, I didn't mean to!" He slowly crawled down to her side. He hugged her, not caring that his seed and her blood would stain the corpse thick. "Ah'm so sorry, Fluttershy!! This is all ma fault, if ah hadn't come here. if ah wasn't cursed?!"

"Please, no!!" He couldn't hold it back. Vomit spewed out of his mouth and spilled over his chest, crotch and the remains. Tears falling down his face, he couldn't stop vomiting and crying to the point his mouth went dry. When nothing more came out, he threw his head back and screamed over and over.

His tears fell on her face and her dead eyes. They were so lifeless, but still smiling for him. "Ah killed the mare ah loved..." Applejack was too ashamed and broken to even cry out loud. He buried his face in her neck, holding her cold body. He stayed like that for hours, unable to let her go.

"I'm sorry..." He begged forgiveness from her corpse. But there was nothing he could do. There was nothing that could bring her back or save him. No one would believe him. He'd be sent to prison or executed. His family would be forced to abandon him of all guidance and support. His sister and his brother would have to grow up without him or worst, suffer because of his shame. Slowly his voice growing hoarse, yet he didn't stop. His mind was slowly fading and his sanity crumbling. He didn't want to leave his family to fend for themselves. So, there was only one answer.

"Forgive me, Fluttershy." He picked up his lover's remains and placed her on the bed. Applejack pulled his hat over his eyes and took a deep breath. "I'll turn myself in. Tell everyone what ah did, alone, not with cause the curse. Ah can't let the truth come out... and hurt the family. They'll hate me, but at least they can keep the farm." He leaned in and kissed her cold, dead lips.

He took a deep breath and stood up, staining her blood over his hands to make the proof assured. Applejack looked down on her and gave a small smile. "Ah promise, if there is another life, Ah'll find you and spend eternity making up for what ah did. No matter what, Ah'll love you forever. "Ah love you, Flutter--"

He was stopped a giant spear rushed through the window. It was so fast and violent that he couldn't stop it from impaling through his chest. His body jerked up and the spear ripped him through the window and dragged him outside. He screamed and gagged at the pain, but reached out to Fluttershy all the same. The spear slammed him into the ground, and he was met with a group of armed ponies.

All of them screaming and kicking him while he was down. They showed no mercy at all, beating his blood everywhere. On eof them dropped down an iron mace, breaking his legs. He was unable to run or fight, or even defend himself. Applejack didn't understand what was happening, or why. , his ribs broken by the spear's removal. Applejack's arms were crushed under a warhammer. He didn't even have the strength to scream or cry, his eyes staring over at Fluttershy. That vision cut by Apple Bloom stepping between him.

The young mare pulled back the chains, ripping the spear out of her brother's chest. This revealed it was her that threw the spear. Her eyes were filled with hatred but also deep regret. She glared at him and her mouth opened, but not saying a word to him. However, it slowly became clear to him what was happening. Applejack slowly smiled at his sibling true feelings hidden under this guise.

Apple Bloom wasn't being cruel but merciful. She knew very well that this wouldn't end the family's curse at all. It would only hide the facts for another generation and that was okay. Applejack would be portrayed as a mad murderer. A symbol of pure evil for the family to stay far away from. And thus ensure the citizens of Ponyville were none the wiser to the dark truth of the Apple Family.

Applejack took these final thoughts with joy and smiled. He nodded her to finish it, spending his last moments of sight staring back at Fluttershy beyond her.

The young mare raised her spear and struck him through the brain. Death were instant, but Apple Bloom didn't stop until she was certain her brother's pain was over. Stabbing it down again and again, shaking and shivering each time. The whole time knowing that the same fate awaited either her children and Big Mac's children one day soon enough.

And so, the legend of the Apple Family's Curse, the Werewolf of Ponyville, would continue for all time.

******