Wish the Day Went Without a Hitch

by lego3

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Anthro, Sparky Sparkeroni, Sunny Starscout, Porn, Fetish, My Little Pony: A New Generation, Sex, Hitch Trailblazer
Length: 2955

Work schedules don't cooperate for Sunny and Hitch's plans, but can Sunny convince her friend to soldier on through the night?

Contains interrogation, Sparky, messy foot love, a bit of sweat from a professional roller-skater, and nachos. Neither Sunny or Hitch realized how late their rather busy schedules have kept them from one another. They had been planning a game of O&O for a while. Hitch may be too tired to go through with it, but perhaps what's in Sunny's trademark skates could give him a bit of energy?

Published 2024-02-25 22:50:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-02-25 22:50:00 UTC

Intoerrogation

It was proving rather difficult to keep the entire station from going up in flames, or worse yet, being transformed into a massive cake or something by his magical flame.

“Urgh, Sparkyyyyy!! I’ll even let you have a little nibble if you come and lay down in the locker! You just…need….your na-“ The stallion was cut off by running straight into his colthood friend, Sunny Starscout, who fell right onto her behind because she was panting hard, and also had her trademark roller skates on her feet.

“Owwwww….hey there Hitch, sorry I’m la-whoa!” she giggled, the tiny green dragon taking quite a liking to her lap all of a sudden. He sat down and made himself more comfortable than he had been all day around his adoptive father.

“Sunny! Sunny! I’m so sorry, Sparky is being too much today! You’re early, I haven’t made the nachos yet!” he panicked, seizing the opportunity to grab ahold of the diminutive lizard.

The roller skating mare managed to push herself back up, smiling softly as she continued to gasp for breath. “Oh it’s ok Hitch, it was an accident…wait, I’m early? Are you sure? I thought we were supposed to meet here at 5, and not 5:23?”

Hitch tilted his head. “Wait, it’s been that long…? Oh…uh, better late than never I guess?”

“Yeahhh, I’m sorry, I just had a LOT of customers today at the stand, I’ve been running around like crazy, and I even had to skate over here as quick as I could!” she explained.

Sparky, having calmed down for the most part, was wrapped in his security blanket by his adoptive father, and gently placed into his favorite locker to rest.

“Phew…well, at any rate, I’m glad you’re here, at this rate I’ll be surprised if we even make it to O&O! I’m beat!” the normally-energetic officer sighed, wiping sweat off his forehead.

Sunny frowned. “Awww, c’mon Hitch, we’ve been looking forward to meeting up for days! You can’t just poop out on me like that! I mean, I’m tired too, and a little messy, but hey…I’m ready for adventure!”

Suddenly, an idea popped into the orange mare’s head. Something evil. Something diabolical. Something lemon-scented.

A perfect little pick-me-up for her best friend.

“Hey…what if I were to…sweeten the deal a little bit?” she murmured, making sure the door to the station was locked. The last thing she needed, and probably Hitch too, was Sprout busting in in a panic.

Hitch suddenly gulped, shifting around in his chair. He knew what that tone of voice meant.

“Would you feel a little more energetic if…we did a little of that stuff you like? You know…a little roleplay?” she said, smirking. She hadn’t encountered a single situation where THAT didn’t work on him. How do you think she got him swept up in half of her unity-schemes before magic returned?

“Roleplay…you mean, I get to…”

“In the cell. Me. Captured. You do weird stuff to me. Interrogate me. Use your…methods of torture, on the evil magic-user,” she explained, pointing to a nearby hairbrush used for Sparky.

“Be a sheriff. Whaddya say? For me?” Sunny giggled as she finished filling her friend’s head with naughty images, grabbing the keys to the one cell and jingling them.

Hitch gave a great big sigh. He knew he couldn’t turn down such an opportunity, to relieve the stresses of the day, with his beautiful best friend. “Oooooh alright, alright, Sunny, just a little bit.”

‘Just a little bit.’ Sunny knew that to be a lie. Hitch put on an air of maturity and tried his hardest to set an example, to maintain an image of self control.

But Sunny knew he was just a big, soft pushover.

As she had done plenty of times before, she rolled her way into the single cell of the station, giggling and handing Hitch the keys. Soon, she was locked in, as Hitch’s little prisoner.

The sheriff had Sunny sit herself down on the floor, gently bringing her ankles and wrists through the bars, using a pair of handcuffs for each set. The cuffs left both her hands and feet outside the cell, compromised, while she was able to to very little about it.

And Hitch could never deny his love for the position.

Thanks to their constant imaginary adventures with figures of six Equestrian legends, the two of them grew up to be able to thrust themselves into the roleplaying mindset without a hitch (hahaha funny pun) and that was just what the sheriff did.

"Now what were you doing on the night of January 12, 1214 ANM (After Nightmare Moon)?" Hitch growled, slamming his hoof on the nearby desk.

Despite her compromising position, hands and roller-skates feet handcuffed outside the bars of the cell, Sunny had to giggle. She was quite impressed at Hitch's remembrance of the Old Calendar. Maybe she rubbed off on him more than he would have liked?

"Did I hear a laugh, Sunny Starscout? What right do you have to be chuckling at this time? You are under investigation for conspiring to make use of alicorn magic to stir up trouble!" Hitch said, a slight grin on his face as well.

"As if I'd tell you that the Canterlogic building would be a perfect palace for me to bring about the return of alicorn rule again, a-..." Hitch's ears perked up considerably at Sunny's little villain-tirade. She quickly buried her mouth in one of her arms, wide eyed at what she'd just told the sheriff.

Hitch flashed his trademark movie-star grin, something starting to stir between his legs. Images flowed through his head. Naughty images. Of his best friend.

He could never get enough of such images, nor the actions that followed.

"So that's where the trouble's brewing...I see, Miss Starscout, and how about you inform me exactly what the SOURCE of this evil magic of yours was?"

She clenched her fists and glared at her captor behind the bars. "You're not getting a THING more out of me, you...you...MUCKER!"

The sheriff snorted and coughed, trying to keep a straight face. "Mucker?"

"ONE. WHO MUCKS," Sunny shouted.

Regardless of how terrible Sunny was at calling ponies mean names, the handsome officer was expecting resistance from her. That was exactly what he was hoping for, in fact.

So he flashed her a grin and took a seat on the floor, right next to Sunny's cuffed legs, and began to remove her roller skates.

"H-hey, Sheriff! What do you think you're doing? Let go of me or I'm gonna-"

"Easy there, Starscout. It's only gonna make things worse!" he said. It was a little harder than usual to get Sunny's feet uncovered, as he would usually be removing her sneakers. This time, he was dealing with her favorite roller skates instead. But with some extra effort, he was able to remove them and toss them aside.

Sunny's toes curled in her socks rather enticingly as they were freed from their roller-prisons. "Y-you don't know what you're dealing with! Knock it off!"

"Sure thing, alicorn. You tell me what your nasty little plot was, and today could be easier on BOTH of us," Hitch replied. His fingers pinched her big toes, peeling off her socks at the same time to reveal the prizes inside.

Upon the last inches of the socks being removed, the cuffed earth pony's feet crossed over one another. Hitch noticed that things were...a little bit different. He noticed a sheen of sweat on his friend's soles, which made them shine when they caught the sunlight streaming in. They felt extra warm that day, as if Sunny had just been let off work and was trying to cool down.

Something in that moment awakened in the proud sheriff. It was getting harder to stay in character.

Regardless of the appealing sight in front of him, Hitch pressed on with this ‘interrogation techniques’.

“N-no! Whatever you plan on doi-EEP!” Sunny squeaked. Hitch’s strong hand held one of her soft, sweaty feet in place, and started to explore the sole with the nails. It was a torturous touch that Sunny could never quite get used to, but one she found genuinely fun to feel.

“If you won’t tell me what I wanna know, I’ll just have to make you SQUEAL it!” Hitch said, deepening the scritches his fingers were making. He pulled back Sunny’s slightly moist toes to keep her foot taut and vulnerable, granting him free and full access to the rest of her tired foot.

Sunny threw her head back with a scream, clenching her fists. Her friend had always been rough with her feet, but the extra slickness that day allowed for a new level of torment. Since her ankles were cuffed outside the cell bars, she was able to do little but wriggle her feet back and forth, rubbing the tired soles over one another to try and shield them from Hitch’s assault.

“Still refuse to talk, Starscout? Huh? Well, I got all day! My patience is infinite, and it’s only a matter of time before you go insane!” Hitch smugly said, wrapping his fingers around Sunny’s big toes. She gulped and looked away with her eyes closed, curling her remaining toes tightly in anticipation.

When no ticklish torture came after a few seconds, Sunny let out the breath she wasn’t aware she was holding. “H-hah, you earth ponies don’t have the guts for-EEEEEHEHEHEHEHE!!”

She didn’t see Hitch reaching up to his desk, nor did she predict that he would bring out Sparky’s rough scale-brush to use on her exposed, worked up feet.

Up and down, side to side, in circles the stiff bristles swept, easily able to glide across Sunny’s well trained feet. She wasn’t able to try and defend herself like before, Hitch’s grip on her big toes was too strong, and she was forced to thrash and laugh merrily at her torture.

“You coulda told me everything and this would be over by now, Starscout, you’re just digging a deeper hole at this point for yourself!”

“GYEAHAHAHA! D-DO WHAT YOU WAHAHANT, I’M G-GONNA GET OUT! ALSO EARTH PONIES SMEHEHEHELL!!” Sunny squealed. Terrible though her evil-talk was, she knew that was something that would get her into even more trouble with the sheriff. Backtalk. Insults. Threats.

She had given him all the reason to go further.

The tickling slowed down to a crawl, enough to keep Sunny on her toes, so to speak, but not enough to make her cry out for help. “Earth ponies smell? Let me guess, Starscout, you’re going to say alicorns are as fresh as Foal’s Breath flowers and consequently should keep us all serving at your feet?”

As soon as Sunny managed to catch her breath, she gave her friend a condescending look, slipping her sweating toes out of his grip at last. “Hah…haha…I’m not just gonna say that, I can PROVE it! You will have the honour of ‘sampling’ our superiority…and you will LOVE it…” she commanded, trying to keep up her air of authority, of arrogance. She knew that saying such things, along with gently rubbing her feet together, would push his buttons.

Hitch’s face began to turn red at the rather enticing show that Sunny’s beautiful orange feet were putting on, his nose just about picking up their scent. “Y-you monster…I’m adding attempted harrassment, BRIBERY I might say, to your charges, Starscout…”

Though something in his lower body was disagreeing with his strong, law-abiding mind.

“Come onnnnn….just a little nibble, sheriff? On my alicorn honor, I would NEVER tell your superiors…” Sunny teased, extending her legs a little further through the bars. Her big toe prodded the defiant officer’s cheek playfully.

Barely able to contain himself, Hitch gave his friend a scowl of contempt, and gently held both of her cuffed feet in his hands, gazing into the almost-reflective, sweaty, worked up soles like delicate works of art. His face slowly drew closer and closer, his breaths starting to become deeper. More…needy. More so than usual.

Sunny couldn't help but break character to inquire, "Hitch? Are you sure about this? It’s been a little bit busier for me today, and my feet might be-WHOA!” Sunny gasped. Clearly, whatever her roller skates or standing up in her smoothie trailer did to her soles was not bothering the town sheriff whatsoever.

It seemed to be encouraging him. More than usual.

Hitch held the heels of his friend’s trapped feet, placing his nose against the right sole. Taking a long, needy breath of the enthralling scent, his tongue made its way out of his mouth, continuing the work he started. Slurp after lustful slurp he took, his adventurous tongue collecting the taste of a good day’s activities.

Sunny put her hand over her mouth, her strong toes curling as she tried not to giggle. Out of genuine shock, she asked, “H-Hitch, you’re actually…liking this? Like, enjoying? That I didn’t even get, hehe, to wash up before I got hehehere?”

“Mmmmhh…S-sunny…mmh…f-for the crimes of resisting arrest, nyuh, backtalking during interrogation, attempted b-bribery, a-and teasing…I’m…sentencing, nngh, you to a night of...service..." the dragon-daddy moaned, between each movement of his tongue.

Sunny Starscout was stunned. Her pretty orange soles being messily made love to was fairly normal for Hitch, but she had never guessed that the sweat, the heat of being on her feet all day, would drive him this crazy. She could have sworn that would put him off…but after the things her soles had already endured…

Her toes scrunched as the officer opened up his mouth. One toe in, then two, until all five were firmly entrapped in his mouth. His tongue had moved on from Sunny's soft, warm soles, to exploring the spaces between her toes. The curling of her toes to catch Hitch's tongue seemed to egg him on even further, and he was barely even stopping for breath.

The tightness in his pants, of course, did not go unnoticed by the roller-skating professional, and she very gently weighed her slick free sole against the twitching bulge. Despite his shredded abs, perfect mane, and paid-off mortgage, none of the mares in Maretime Bay knew quite how to get him going like his best friend did. "Whoa there, H-Hihihitch, d-don't let go TOO early now…”

“Nyuhhh….th-that’s SHERIFF to y-you, Starscout…” the stallion replied, the front of his uniform starting to get a bit stained from the warmth and weight of his friend’s sole. Despite the restrictions of the cuffs, Sunny knew how to get her friend going. She made extensive use of her strong, toned-up toes, grasping the zipper of his pants and brought it down smoothly. Furthermore, she dug her foot into his pants and fished out his rather sizable length, holding it between her big and second toes.

“S-Sunny, aahhh…” Hitch groaned out, hardly able to hold character through the cloud of intense pleasure. His friend giggled playfully, the excessive amount of precum making it easy for her toe space to glide up and down his cock, until she was able to adjust her angle so the entire sole was pushing it into his belly.

Her toes curled onto the tip of his twitching member, her sole pulling up and down with such smoothness. The sheriff wouldn’t be able to hold on much longer, more and more of his pre leaking down over top of her orange foot.

Sunny was not going to let the restrictions of the cuffs stop her from giving her best friend the pleasure he needed. Her flexibility in her lower body served her quite well in situations like so, and she was able to turn both of her perfectly shaped feet inwards. The curved arches hugged around the sides of Hitch’s cock, gliding up and down in opposing strokes. The movements were shallow, but they were quick, confident, purposeful.

With one last tightening of the grip of her soles, Hitch could no longer hold on. His best friend’s footjob was too much for him to stop himself from unleashing what seemed like weeks worth of pent up, thick seed, spurt after spurt landing on each of Sunny’s toes. She ensured to cover his tip with her warm, slick soles to let him make a mess of her arches, and of her heels.

When Hitch was finally finished with his release, his friend turned her soles upwards once again to show off his…handiwork. Streaks of white were slowly, lewdly running down between her toes, and down over the curved soles. Sunny looked rather pleased with herself, an expression she knew Hitch loved, while the mess on her bare feet was slowly dripping down onto the floor.

“I TOLD you you would accept your new magical overlord, that you would see it my way…my new sheriff…” Sunny laughed, carefully rubbing her feet together to spread his cum further.

The honorable sheriff of Maretime Bay shook his head at the awfully lewd sight, but he couldn’t hide his satisfaction at the events. He unlocked Sunny’s arms and legs from their bindings, as well as the door to her cell.

“No…I…I’ve been corrupted…turned against my own people…I now…protect and serve…you, Starscout…”

Sunny laughed and patted him on the back. “That’s my sheriff. Now, I think you promised me some nachos, and a game of Ogres and Oubliettes: Ancient Equestria Edition after this?”

“But Sunny, I still have the rest of the day on the clock! I have to look out for the town!”

“Oh now you care about work-time, Hitchy-poo? Weren’t you just on the clock a few minutes ago? Roleplaying? Hello?”

“…Dibs on Fluttershy!”

-End

Author's Note

Yup. I just felt the need to write again. Hopefully I won't die again!