Jack of All Trades

by Omegathyst

Rating: mature
Tags: Applejack, Porn, Fetish, Rarity, Sex, Profanity, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Zecora, Alternate Universe, Romance
Length: 30271

Applejack’s once purely friendly feelings on Zecora begin to shift as he sees the zebra take the unicorn that the farmpony had wanted for years for himself. Even if it means becoming a zebra's sub [RULE 63]

RULE 63

Applejack found himself content with his life, especially as his good buddy Zecora kept helping him bring lots of bits to better benefit Sweet Apple Acres and his family. But when Zecora took Elusive as the newest member of the Herd, somepony that Applejack had wanted for years, the farmpony's desires began to shift. There is a saying: if you can't beat 'em...

...join them~

Cover art done by Snow Quill
Commission for Magician-Horse 😄
Contains Gay Zebradom + sex scenes between femcolts, Rarijack, Zebrican rhymes, lots of self-discovery, friends to lovers, various romantic herd dynamics, femboys, a deep-voiced dominant zebra stud, three subs and a switch, and more tags at the beginning of each chapter!

Published 2024-07-01 03:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-07-30 01:58:48 UTC

Horny Honesty

Author's Note

Contains secret meeting between non-poly Elements of Harmony, hiding zebra fantasies very poorly, erections, staring at graphic exhibitionistic zebra on pony sex, brief anxiety attack, getting caught, suppressed feelings of love and lust, and discussions about sexuality and herds. No sex scenes.

Horny Honesty

Applejack, the big and powerful earth pony stallion that Ponyville knew as the hard worker of his family, felt like more of that of a mouse as he walked down the School of Friendship hallway after the students had been dismissed. He knew that the Head-Stallion that was one of his dearest friends, Dusk Shine, had called this meeting about something urgent. About rumors that were spreading about Zecora and his sexual patterns. If it had been several months ago back when the orange stallion was still getting to know Zecora as a platonic buddy, Applejack would’ve outright refused getting into his newest friend’s business. But since then, Zecora had fucked one of his own femcolts in front of Applejack and others, and most surprising of all, decided he wasn’t completely satisfied with just the pegasi lovers. He took the beautiful, svelte, silky Elusive as his newest mate.

Applejack felt his cheeks grow red and flushed with the realization that the unicorn that seemed untouchable and too busy with his work was open enough to date Zecora and his femcolts, becoming one himself. The orange stallion couldn’t be farther from a femcolt, having worked up a considerably masculine body and dominating his fair share of stallions. It was why he figured he got along with Zecora so well, though while his body remained as sturdy as ever, his fortress of a mind was compromised and a lot of his core values had begun to shift. Most of the stallions he was attracted to were no longer available whether due to work or being taken, leaving the closest stallion in his life being Zecora by default. The striped adonis remained true to constantly visiting Applejack, at least once a week, to help the farmpony with growing those trees with his potions and creating new kinds of apple. The money kept rolling in for even more renovations to the barn as well as Big Mae saving up money to support any foals she ended up having in the near future. And yet, with Applejack almost immediately catching on to Elusive’s involvement in the herd, their hangouts grew tense and awkward. Not that they didn’t have plenty of conversation still, but Applejack found himself having to bat away the thoughts of Zecora and Elusive getting it on. Of half his best friends being the subs of a zebra stud and not knowing if Zecora would want to hit on any of the others.

Applejack bit his lip, finding that he liked the idea of Zecora hitting on him a bit too much for his liking. He’d wish his feelings for Zecora would’ve remained friendly, as he didn’t have too many actual friends beyond the Mane 6. But it was incredibly persuasive to see half of them underneath Zecora willingly and happily, and Applejack wondered constantly what it was about the stoic zebra stallion that had them falling one by one. Perhaps it would be better if he held back as much as possible, finding a nice stallion to settle down with and staying in Sweet Apple Acres as much as possible to focus on his family. Maybe one that had silky fur and a gentlecolt personality…

Applejack shook his head, holding back on the familiar image that was trying to take a hold of his mind. He was already at the door that led to the teacher’s lounge, and he pushed the door open and trotted in to see only Dusk Shine and Bubble Berry at the spacious table inside. Pushing the door behind him in hopes that he closed it, Applejack frowned as he approached the wide-eyed alicorn and pink stallion.

“Ah guess ah could’ve assumed that Zecora’s femcolts weren’t part of this meeting, but wouldn’t have it been a good idea to have them so we could ask them directly?” Applejack groaned, knowing that he had plans to hang out with Elusive as soon as the meeting was over. Which would’ve made it a lot harder to hide the contents of the meeting since he’d have much less time to process it. Dusk Shine’s ears flattened against his floppy dark mane, something that Applejack found to be kind of cute even if he’d never say it, as he narrowed his eyes down at the farmpony.

“This is about Zecora potentially conquering the rest of us as some glorified harem,” Dusk Shine shook his head. “Something I didn’t even consider a possibility until I started reading these!”

With a large flash of light from his long alicorn horn, Dusk Shine dumped a comically large amount of newspaper clipping and photos onto the big table. Several of them even fell off the table from the force they landed, which Bubble Berry moved in a pink blur to pick all of the pieces and place them back on the table. Even though the chubby pink stallion remained appearing tense, his mane was still poofy, which Applejack knew was only possible if he was excited. What was he excited about? Surely Zecora going after all of them was bad, right?

Wait, why exactly is it bad again?

Applejack pulled several of the clippings and photos at random towards him and looked at them. The photos were incredibly graphic in nature, showing Zecora fucking all three of his subs including Elusive on a model runway in Canterlot. There was even a picture of all three of them side by side facing away from the camera, their ponuts in the focus as they were dripping with zebra seed. And Elusive was striped, something that gave away his new relationship to Dusk Shine and Bubble Berry before the newspapers made their way to Ponyville. The headlines included sentences such as “Ponyville zebra takes half of the Elements, will he complete the set?” or something more egregious such as “Three Elements of Harmony fallen to exotic depravity, is Equestria going down a dark path?”

Applejack was utterly torn on being disgusted with the public for their aghast treatment of Zecora, and partially agreeing that it seemed more than odd that he had only brought Elements of Harmony into his herd. Even though the orange stallion could vividly remember when all six of them had harshly judged Zecora just for being a zebra years ago, Applejack knew that his specific suspicion had nothing to do with the species of his friends’ Master. He was more concerned with the fact that he was taking up not only members of the Elements, but that he had taken Elusive up as a partner. As Applejack kept fixating on Elusive’s unorthodox decision, his eyes subconsciously were pulled to a picture of Zecora and the unicorn femcolt. The much lighter stallion was being held by Zecora in a full nelson, the zebra’s fat bitchbreaker fully plunged into Elusive’s ponut to where his fat balls were right nestled near the Element’s diamond cutie marks. Applejack should’ve felt furious, that Elusive of all ponies was being completely dominated by somepony other than…well, that didn’t matter. All that mattered was that Applejack was seething.

“Well, isn’t it just because Elusive enjoyed watching them fuck at their own party?” Bubble Berry questioned. “I don’t think Zecora would go out of his way to hit on any of us if we didn’t express interest-”

“Are you sure?” Dusk Shine scowled. “Why hasn’t Zecora brought any of the other Ponyville citizens into his special herd? Why has it been Elements so far? He fucked a bunch of the adults here and even impregnated some of them, probably, so why aren’t they part of his circle?”

“Maybe because they only saw Zecora as a hookup?” Applejack tried to defend his buddy, ignoring the surge of desire that rushed from his mind down to his dark orange loins as he stared at Elusive being taken in the photo. He wished he could tear it up and focus on pursuing somepony else, letting go of Elusive’s lack of interest. But seeing his zebra buddy and his…unicorn friend, having sex with each other was bringing up a lot more dizzying excitement than he would’ve liked. The feeling went dangerously beyond simply being happy for them, and Applejack observed with shock that Dusk Shine and Bubble Berry were also blushing as the conversation went on. As they stared at more of the clippings and pictures.

“I don’t know why Zecora would be arrogant enough to think I have time for sex,” Dusk scoffed, the sharp exhale blowing his dark blue and pink mane a little as he rolled his eyes. “I’m a Prince of Equestria for crying out loud! I barely have time to read a good book anymore, let alone go out on a blind date or try out a relationship.”

“Have you gone on blind dates?” Bubble Berry asked.

“That’s irrelevant,” Dusk Shine spat the two words quicker than Bubble Berry could finish his sentence, and Applejack could see tension in the powerful purple alicorn’s shoulders with a sense of empathy in his heart. The orange stallion felt a lot of stress keeping his family afloat before Zecora helped him out, he could only imagine how difficult it was to be one of four Princes running an entire nation. Before he could offer his sympathy, Dusk Shine continued. “If Rainbow, Butters, and Elusive want to waste time fucking, than that’s their problem to have when we inevitably deal with another threat to Equestria. I’ll actually make sure that we are safe and at peace from another evil hurting our land of Harmony.”

Dusk Shine was no longer looking at Applejack or Bubble Berry, blushing heavily as he stared intently at the window behind him. Applejack then turned to the chubby pink stallion that was blushing just as much, staring at a picture of Zecora putting Rainbow Blitz in a mating press before his head flicked up to look at Applejack.

“I mean, I’ve uh…got a bunch of parties to organize all the time, helping the Cakes with catering orders, and taking care of their twins,” Bubble Berry shrugged despite his twitching poofy tail as he slowly looked away. “Plus uh, herds aren’t really my kind of activity. Kind of takes me away from the adult parties that I hold at different houses.”

“The what parties?”

“Nothing!” Bubble Berry blushed profusely when Dusk Shine resumed paying attention to the chubby pink stallion, and as the two were staring intently at one another, Applejack moved his forehoof from underneath the table as he moved it slowly towards the picture. With sharp timing, Dusk and Bubble stared at Applejack right in the eyes without noticing that his forehoof had started moving.

“What do you think of all this?” Dusk Shine asked the muscular farmpony, tilting his head at him. “Out of all three of us, you’ve easily spent the most time with him.”

“Ah mean,” Applejack stopped, deeply hating even the slightest hint of lying to the two of them. He couldn’t bring himself to do that, so he settled for telling the truth on what he was comfortable with sharing with them. “Ah didn’t even really care about what Zecora was doing until he got Elusive involved in all of this.”

Dusk Shine stopped, his eyes turning from their sharp gaze to something more heartfelt and more pitying. Applejack didn’t like the look, but it was better than lying and still having that on his chest.

“Yeah, I brought you two closer at that sleepover and remember how much that changed you,” Dusk sighed, his blush slowly fading as his frown deepened. “That’s such a shame, I really thought something would’ve happened between you-”

“Yeah, uh, let’s not talk about that anymore,” Applejack blurted out before Dusk could finish his sentence, though he knew that Bubble Berry would’ve already known due to his Berry Sense. Even in his hot arousal staring at the picture, that pang of sadness came back hitting him in the heart. Even if they all knew the truth, Applejack felt it too much to fully face it when there was nothing that could be done. If Elusive had interest in any stallion besides Zecora, he would have acted on that instead. There was no point in dwelling on what ifs that didn’t exist. Though, Applejack thought, the picture could be at least something to look at when he was bored. He slowly pulled it towards the end of the table as Dusk was satisfied enough with Applejack’s answer as he opened his long alicorn wingspans and huffed as he circled around the room.

“What kind of power trip does Zecora even think he’s on? Does he really think he’s the best stud that Ponyville has to offer? Or even Equestria? Especially when Solaris and Artemis exist?! Or the griffons and dragons that have integrated into Ponyville? They’ve scooped up a lot of the ponies here for themselves, and you don’t see them bragging about what big dicks they have-”

With Dusk Shine moving away from the table and back to it, Applejack inevitably saw a long and dark purple appendage swinging about in its half-hard state, something that was clear as day to the orange farmpony and even the pink party pony, though neither would admit such. Especially when Applejack was on his own mild mission of trying to pull the photo to himself for further looking. He had gotten it off the table, with Bubble Berry too busy intently looking down Dusk Shine’s body to have noticed, before the tall purple stallion turned to look at the chubby pink stallion.

“I’m right though aren’t I?” Dusk insisted. “We should make a pact right now, that none of us three would submit into this carnal foolishness. The Elements of Harmony are completely dependent on us not just becoming…becoming…”

Dusk Shine stopped at the center of the table, his long alicorn wings launching out from his sides nearly like an attack as one of them nearly hit Bubble Berry in the face.

“Like sluts!” Dusk snapped.

“Hey, that’s a bit too far,” Bubble pouted. “There’s nothing wrong with embracing your sexuality and having a good time.”

“As long as you can maintain some sense of reality,” Dusk grumbled. “Do you think Ponyville will be chill with any one of us taking dick or plapping cheeks while a villain appears out of nowhere and destroys our homes? Conquers and ruins all of Equestria? It’s happened more than once! I’m just trying to not lose my head and think with my dick at the cost of Equestria!”

Applejack saw that a lot of the arousal was gone from Dusk Shine that was there before, the anxiety episode causing the orange stallion to reluctantly place the photo back on the table as he rushed over to his dear friend and placed his forehoof on the Prince’s shoulder.

“Breathe, Dusk,” Applejack insisted. “Ah know that they’ve all been experimenting and going through a lot exploring their herd, especially Butterscotch. But ah do believe they’d pause their antics in a heartbeat to protect Equestria if need be. Their stripes don’t make their dedication any less real. But do you really want them to act like a monster is going to ruin Equestria at any moment? Is that how ya want us to live?”

“No, but I need to live that way,” Dusk insisted, looking down at the floor and shaking his head. “If I don’t focus on every possibility in the future, I leave Equestria vulnerable and lacking any defense. Ever since Solaris gifted me with my alicornhood…this is my burden to bear.”

Applejack clamped up, backing away and looking at Bubble Berry’s pitying look directly at their leader and best friend. When Dusk was a unicorn, it was easy to emphasize and relate even despite their differences. Now, Dusk Shine’s status as an alicorn and a Prince made him become a stallion that was worlds apart from the rest of them. Zecora or not, it would be nothing short of a miracle for somepony out there to not only bring Dusk back to Equestria mentally, but to convince him that he had time for love.

“Urgh, whatever,” Dusk groaned, pressing a forehoof against his head as Bubble Berry stepped forward and leaned against the sleek and well-built purple alicorn with his chubby pink body, staring up with big blue eyes.

“Are you going to be okay?” Bubble asked. “I don’t want you to think that any of us having sex lives is going to destroy Equestria. I lo…really loathe the idea that you’re forcing yourself to suffer because you’re holding the stress of an entire nation on your back. You’re not alone in your responsibilities, you have us beyond having Solaris and Artemis ruling Equestria. Now, why exactly did you bring the pictures? Don't the clippings sell your point enough?”

“I, um-” Dusk blushed profusely, both at becoming suddenly and vividly aware of Bubble’s tooth-rotting sweet smell, touch, and words as he then pulled his eyes off the chubby stallion and looked at said pictures before continuing. “Well, obviously it would’ve been outlandish to claim that they were all fucked on stage with no visual proof. Pics or it didn’t happen?”

“Oh yeah,” Bubble blanked out of his suspicion as he pulled a clipping with his eyes flashing wide and his tail bouncing side to side. “Great Solaris’ sun cheeks, I can’t believe Rainbow Blitz quit the Wonderbolts only hours before their show. That’s crazy…”

Applejack winced, worried that Dusk would go back into his episode due to being reminded of one of the Elements giving up a crucial part of their life, instead he seemed enamored with the pictures that Bubble had brought his attention to. It was the perfect timing, Applejack rushed over to his picture and slowly pulled it off the table as they conversed about the various positions in the pictures and scoffed in disbelief. Well, Dusk scoffed while Bubble only stared in quiet awe. Opening his hat with his other forehoof, ready to hide the photo in there to take back to the barn while the others were getting flustered over the rest of the pictures, Applejack watched in a blink of an eye as a sparkly purple magic took hold of the photo and ripped it out of his hoof. Though, with a cold jolt of shock and horror at being caught, Applejack turned around and realized it was not Dusk Shine who had caught him. Somepony far worse.

Elusive.

“Ah…uh…” Applejack nearly dropped his hat on the floor as he damn near pissed himself, backing away from the unicorn femcolt as he glanced at the door that the farmpony never ended up closing after all. Dusk’s pupils shrunk to pinpricks as he used a spontaneously powerful magic spell to teleport all the clippings and photos out of sight besides the one Elusive already took.

“Elusive!” Dusk stammered, growing bright red even as Bubble Berry stepped away from pressing against the alicorn. “Oh dear Solaris, um, you didn’t walk in on anything! You just spooked me is all, is there anything I can help you with?”

“Yeah! If this was an actual meeting, we would’ve invited the rest of you!” Bubble laughed, blushing just as much as he refused to look at any of his friends in the eye. “Luckily, it was just a normal hangout with Applejack till you came over. Which you did, we totally planned that!”

“You two are just adorable,” Elusive giggled, his only acknowledgement of Dusk Shine and Bubble Berry before he looked at the muscular orange farmpony with an expectant nod, even though Applejack was blushing just as hard as the others. “Are you ready to catch up at the boutique, darling?”

“Y-Yeah, ah’m ready,” Applejack agreed, despite his brain still being in shock over Elusive agreeing to hang out despite the farmpony trying to steal a pic of him being fucked by his stud. Then again, if they did it on stage for everypony to see, why would Elusive be upset about it?

Applejack followed Elusive out of the room and then the hallways as they left the School of Friendship, the tall orange stallion looking down with a swarm of thoughts storming his mind while Elusive turned to look at him.

“You alright, darling?” Elusive asked. “I can assure you, I still want to hang out. Especially since how far apart we’ve become over the years, despite being Elements of Harmony. It’s a travesty really, and we should continue to make it right.”

“Yuh-huh, yer absolutely right about that,” Applejack admitted, looking into Elusive's deep blue eyes and unable to hide his thoughts about the unicorn anymore. Ever since he was roped into a sleepover with the stallion he found arrogant and spoiled via Dusk Shine and bad weather, Applejack had found himself falling head over hooves for the beautiful unicorn and didn’t know how to address it and be successful since they were worlds apart in terms of upbringing and personality despite knowing and being friends since they were both very young colts raised in the same small town. They shared that in common, what with Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch coming from Cloudsdale, Bubble Berry coming from a rock farm, and Dusk showing up to Ponyville very late as a young adult. And now Zecora had won him over, somehow, despite the shopkeeper seeming absurdly unavailable to anypony else. And on top of that, Elusive had even cut his working hours significantly in order to make time for his new Herd. With Zecora also helping Applejack have more time on his hooves with the help around Sweet Apple Acres, both events lead to the stallions being able to hang out more often as of very recent. The events made them realize how little they saw each other anymore.

Despite Elusive’s reassurance, the two of them walked the rest of the walk in silence to the boutique as they both processed what had happened. Applejack’s bitterness about having his long-time crush “stolen” was overshadowed by the fact that they had time to hang out at all, something that left him feeling less broken about his feelings and more fulfilled in the mere company of his past attraction…

Elusive caught Applejack blushing and giving him wide-eyed glances with those captivating green eyes of his as he quietly alongside the dainty femcolt. The unicorn may not have been as intelligent as Dusk, or as perceptive as Bubble, but the femcolt certainly gets the hint from how often their conversations would steer in a certain direction. How their conversations from the farm or the boutique would shift into how Elusive was getting on with three more partners than he had before, how Zecora was treating him, and what seemed to be harmless questions about what they all were into. Elusive initially thought it was mere curiosity about how such an unconventional relationship would even work half-decently, perhaps that it would make no sense to Applejack and he needed to have it explained to him. But instead, with how often Applejack sought after hanging out with him specifically out of the Mane 6 since he made the time, Elusive had started to wonder if the orange stallion had a crush on him as well as possibly Zecora.

Catching all three of them, especially Applejack, pining for Zecora and the graphic sex he was having in his herd, seemed to easily put those suspicions to rest.

Though, Elusive knew that Applejack would never truly get mad over the unicorn deciding to directly ask for the truth from his mouth. Even if Applejack got flustered or defensive, Elusive knew that Applejack would respect his approach if nothing else. Taking a deep breath and readying himself to clear the air and potentially change Applejack’s life forever, Elusive smiled softly as he looked back to his dear friend.

“Darling, do you have feelings for me or Zecora? Perhaps both?” Elusive asked. “I truly have no judgment, I just want to understand what just happened earlier.”

“Ah saw a picture of y’all fucking,” Applejack shrugged. “That’s what happened.”

Elusive scowled, of course Applejack wouldn’t lie but wouldn’t exactly answer the question either.

“And what were you doing with it?” Elusive pointed out, magically floating the picture in front of Applejack’s eyes to remind him that he had tried to take said picture. Applejack stopped walking altogether, frozen to the spot as he was torn between fight or flight. If Elusive had wanted him, they would’ve been together. He had chosen to be with Zecora, and that was that.

“Ah tried to take it for mahself,” Applejack grumbled. “What exactly is the point of this conversation for you? Zecora did something great for both of us, giving us time off working so hard. But that didn’t keep ya from dating him, now did it? You became his newest sub even before you took off a huge workload, and ya didn’t do that for me. So that is that and-”

“You’re upset that I chose Zecora and not you.”

“Honestly?” Applejack stopped, waiting for Elusive’s eager nod of approval for him to continue. “Yah, ah definitely am. And at the same time, curiosity has been eating away at me. He’s been my best friend for a while and he’s gotten all three of you under a spell. Ah want to know what’s so special about being with him, beyond his company which ah’ve already had regularly. He’s a cool stallion, but…”

“You want to know if he’s good in bed, even though he took me and that’s got you in a tizzy?”

“Yeah!” Applejack shouted a little louder than he had intended, though he spoke the truth as he always did. “It’s embarrassing to get turned on by the stallion that took the one you’ve wanted for such a long time. You know how to work hard like ah do, you keep up a lovely appearance, and you are the most generous pony ah’ve ever met. Ah feel like a fool for letting that go, even though…ah guess ah never had it. Zecora’s help has given me time to actually sit around for a change every so often, and it’s given me pause to actually think about what ah want. Though choosing to go after any one of you seriously puts so many friendships on the line, especially after ah finally got to spend so much time with you again and ah don’t want to lose what ah got. And ah don’t want to leave Dusk and Bubble alone to spend more time in a herd, they need me. Especially Dusk, he feels so alone without you guys.”

“Oh,” Elusive deflated a little at that news, not too happy that Dusk Shine was hurting from their time spent primarily in a herd. Shaking his head, Elusive continued. “I can’t exactly solve all your problems, Applejack, but I know where my commitment is and I know where your heart and loins are. This all seems like something to be discussed with the polycule in the Everfree Forest, though Zecora would probably want to get a bigger hut at this rate…”

“What’s that?”

“Nevermind that, darling!” Elusive laughed, waving his forehoof back and forth before bringing it back to his side. “But you should be very sure that you want to be a sub, yes a sub, to Zecora and the sexual whims of the rest of the herd. That’s no easy commitment, even if you have the option to consent to anything obviously, because making such a bigger relationship a priority and doing right by everypony takes a lot of effort. Especially since doing such leaves me walking funny for days at a time…”

“Ah’ve…” Applejack blushed as he looked at Elusive’s legs before looking up at the femcolt. “Uh, noticed.”

“Would you want to walk with me now, darling?” Elusive asked. “Zecora will be comforted by how honest you are and how strong of a bond you two already have. I’m sure he’ll be happy to keep as much of an open mind as possible.”

“Yeah, yer right, he would be nice no matter what,” Applejack nodded, feeling some relief taking the weight off his shoulders as the two steered away from the boutique, walking again only this time they made their way to the Everfree Forest. With the farmpony’s muscular strength, and Elusive’s decent skill at magic, they were certainly fine off trotting throughout the tall trees that used to scare them terribly. Though with the latter’s frequent trips back and forth from Ponyville to the hut, the idea of Zecora fucking Elusive’s brains out usually eclipsed any fear the unicorn might’ve had of the wild creatures within the weird forest.

Applejack saw the sight of the hut and maintained the same pace he had before, even though he wanted to slow down and think over everything more. Though truly, Applejack knew in his heart what he wanted deep down, he was just bringing himself to prepare for any fallback or rejection that might sting him down the line. And Elusive didn’t exactly tell him if he returned Applejack’s feelings, though the farmpony highly doubted that the femcolt would dupe him into a herd only to rub it in his face that he didn’t feel the same. That seemed incredibly cruel, nothing like Elusive.

Taking a chance, Applejack took a deep breath and knocked on the door. Waiting several moments for the scuffling on the other side to stop, Applejack’s heart nearly jumped out of his chest as Zecora was naturally the one to open the door. The tall bulking zebra stud, a paragon of masculinity and sex appeal, normally was just seen as a buddy to Applejack in the context of their typical hangouts. Though this time, Applejack felt his length starting to harden even though he knew that it wouldn’t end in an orgy like his mind had tried to convince him many times it would. Despite being hornier than a mare about to get gangbanged, Applejack knew he still had a lot of feelings to sort out and even recognized that Zecora being into another masculine stallion was a longshot in itself.

“Hello Applejack, what seems to bring you to my shack?” Zecora asked, gently tilting his head at the orange farmpony. Applejack felt time stop, even feeling Elusive fading away in the background as it was one-on-one with telling the powerful zebra stallion of absurd capability how exactly he felt.

“Ah, uh, would like to become a sub in yer herd, Zecora.”

Into the Herd

Author's Note

Contains discussions about sexuality and herds, planned dates, and group hugs. How degenerate...

Rest of the chapters will be clop!

Into the Herd

Zecora stared at Applejack, the orange stallion that he was used to hanging out with as a buddy outside of his busy and erotic herd, asking to enter it and become one of them. The strong zebra stallion couldn’t pretend that the idea didn’t put him off at first, because Applejack represented time away from his subs even though he loved them very dearly. On top of that, Applejack was a far cry from the lithe and slim femcolt figures that Zecora had grown to have more of a preference for, being a masculine and muscular earth pony even though he wasn’t as tall or strong as the zebra stallion. But then he thought about how reliable and trustworthy Applejack was, and that he wouldn’t have asked such a bold question unless he really felt deep in his heart that he wanted Zecora and…the zebra stallion looked abruptly to his sub of choice that had brought the farmpony over. While Applejack was blushing, staring up at Zecora expectedly awaiting a proper answer, Elusive was making goo-goo eyes at the orange stallion. With sudden jarring realization, Zecora took a deep breath and collected his thoughts together.

“Well I won’t pretend that the suggestion didn’t give me shock,” Zecora admitted, Elusive snapping out of his staring to look at his Master with a big smile of his full and undivided attention. “That somepony that I thought only saw me as a friend would want to join my flock. Though you seem to have a preference for somepony in the herd that isn’t me, and everypony’s feelings should be free. I’m no stranger to my subs being fond of each other, though above all else it is my fat zebra balls you must smother.”

“Does that mean-”

“I am not done, for my attraction that I currently have for you is close to none,” Zecora spoke bluntly, half-expecting Applejack to cringe or walk away from the rejection. Though from Applejack’s mostly neutral expression, it seemed as though the earth pony understood. Perhaps while he had more feelings, they still weren’t half as big as his love for Elusive. Zecora thought about it, how happy Elusive seemed to be in Applejack’s presence and how deeply the orange pony cared for the unicorn femcolt. Elusive had only been a sub underneath Zecora for three months, an absurdly short amount of time in comparison to the subservience of Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch, but the zebra stud was exceptionally confident of Elusive’s devotion to him above all else. And that Applejack was too honest to genuinely try and pull a fast one, knowing he never would’ve made a proposition unless he had some kind of feelings developing for the zebra stallion.

With that, Zecora gave a small nod as he had made his decision.

“Very well, here is what I have to tell,” Zecora began, noticing a flicker in Applejack’s green eyes as he continued. “Let me bring Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch out of our shared room, and see if they too would like this idea of yours to bloom. If all four of us are on the same page, then I am willing to set the stage. Give dating a shot, and see if the herd benefits from what you got. If not for Elusive standing here, and for our friendship which is held dear, I don’t think I could’ve said yes. But your idea I wish to bless.”

Zecora beckoned his forehoof to have Applejack come inside the hut with his permission, Elusive trotting alongside him. There was a table near the cauldron where Applejack waited in a chair with Elusive sitting next to him while Zecora entered the main room of the herd. The orange farmpony, normally composed and level-headed, was overcome with a sense of shock as right in the moment he was going to get expectedly rejected, Zecora suddenly had a change of heart to the point where he was even asking the permission of his pegasi subs. There was muffled speaking, and Elusive’s half-lidded gaze of sapphires staring right at Applejack was too passionate to completely ignore. Applejack found himself torn away from trying to overhear what they were talking about when he turned to look at Elusive fully with a surge of arousal hitting his loins. Year after year of working relentlessly for his family, of providing exceptional quality to Ponyville with his food, Applejack hadn’t gotten to receive a fraction of the pleasure in both his mind and heart from the way Elusive looked at him. He couldn’t even care less that his longtime interest had the stripes of another that had claimed him, Applejack’s heart wasn’t to be deterred and he would follow the unicorn femcolt to the ends of Equestria if it meant giving his best shot at being with him.

If he had to fuck an entire herd at the end of this to be with Elusive, Applejack wouldn’t just do it, he would do it eagerly.

“Are you excited by his answer, darling?” Elusive giggled, staring at Applejack’s doey-eyed expression as if they were colts all over again. “I don’t think I’ve seen you this happy since we were young.”

“Yah, ah can’t believe…” Applejack gulped as he felt his heart flickering with renewed life and want, smiling gently as he was captivated by Elusive’s eyes. “Ah can’t believe my greatest dream would ever happen to me…well, second to my family getting a better life.”

“Well, I can take a guess as to what you’re referring to~” Elusive smirked and gestured his head in the direction of the bedroom door. “Though even if you have a favorite of us in mind, do remember the zebra stud that made both of your dreams come true. He didn’t have to help you after his subs left or even to indulge you being a part of the herd.”

“Yeah…” Applejack’s mind turned with the realizations that Elusive had brought to his attention, seeing the truth in them as while Elusive was the apple of his eye, Zecora had far more positive impact on the farmpony’s life. If the orange farmpony was to move forward with honest intentions, he knew he had to genuinely develop a mutual spark with Zecora in order for his place in the herd to work. Anything less and he would have to accept the loss with dignity. Humbling himself, taking a deep breath and thinking more with focus towards the zebra stallion that he had spent so much time with, Applejack felt a particular fondness blossoming about Zecora.

Then, he heard the loud and distinct voice of his former rival.

“No way!”

That was when Applejack winced, fearing that the blue pegasus would stomp around and refuse to share his zebra Master with the stallion that he used to despise. Before he could think twice about it, Rainbow Blitz had kicked the door open and flew towards Applejack in a blue-blurred frenzy. Applejack braced himself as Blitz knocked him out of his chair with the orange farmpony’s eyes as wide as saucers as he landed on the floor with the lithe blue pegasus pinning him. He briefly took in Blitz’ figure in the brief time since he had quit the Wonderbolts, drinking in how he still maintained a healthy level of exercise, but also let go enough to have a fat blue ass and a little more pudge. Then, his eyes moved to Blitz’ wide pink eyes as Applejack had realized that he was grinning down at the muscular stallion.

“I can’t believe you want to be Zecora’s sub!” Blitz giggled. “I knew I wasn’t the only one of us who couldn’t resist~!”

Applejack clammed up, not knowing what to say at the shocking response he got from the blue pegasus. He looked out of the corner of his eye, seeing Butterscotch slowly walking up to stare at the both of them with his eyes wide and a slight blush on his cheeks. Their interactions one-on-one ever since Applejack patched up the tension with Butterscotch was pretty rare, though the orange farmpony felt a pang in his heart at the fact. The yellow pegasus had a mental breakdown over something very understandable, and Applejack failed to be the friend he needed at the time. He promised himself that when he spent more time with Butterscotch, whether it was in the context of a herd or not, Applejack would make sure that he opened up properly to the pegasus. Though despite all there was to still say, Butterscotch still smirked as he eyed Applejack up and down…

“Let me make sure you are aware, so the surprise doesn’t give you a scare,” Zecora walked up beside Butterscotch, placing a foreleg over the pegasus’ shoulders and pulling him close. “One compromise I’ve made for the herd is that Butters is a switch, he has just as much right to the subs as I do if that makes your dick twitch…”

Applejack’s eyes widened as the discovery of the demure and fat-assed yellow pegasus sunk in, realizing that he would likely take Butterscotch’s dick as well as Zecora’s. Even though Applejack was turned on by any stallion that could get him closer to Elusive, the orange farmpony felt the pressure of the situation start to kick in. He wasn’t normally the kind of stallion to just sleep with multiple partners, though neither were any of Zecora’s subs before they fell in love with him. So Applejack took a deep breath as he spoke despite Rainbow Blitz still standing on top of him.

“Ah uh, think it's best to be honest and admit that mah heart is with Elusive in this,” Applejack gulped, watching Blitz’ smile morph into a look of unexpected shock while Butterscotch nodded with what seemed to be a lack of surprise on his end. Zecora nodded as well, and Elusive wasn’t in view for Applejack to analyze his reaction. “But ah won’t be a part of a herd that doesn’t feel like a natural fit for me, or vice versa. That wouldn’t be fair, so ah’d like to keep the dates one at a time and perhaps not get into…uh, orgy territory with y’all right away. Ah wasn’t exactly raised to be a herd-type a’ pony, mah parents raised us to settle down with one pony to bring as a member of the Apple family. And ah still don’t know how this will integrate with the rest of mah life, but ah won’t sacrifice taking care of mah family.”

“Nor should you, I’ll always make sure that my current help towards them stays true,” Zecora smiled with a nod. “Given the lack of feelings between you and me, taking everything slower makes perfect sense to me and probably the other three. Best to let everything occur naturally with a plan, so let me tell you where I stand. Obviously you and I will go on a one-on-one date first, then it’ll be Blitz and Butters for the second date since those two are more of a package deal…”

“And of course,” Elusive interrupted, already getting what his Master was putting down with a surprising lack of rhyme. Rainbow Blitz moved off Applejack finally, allowing the orange-furred powerhouse to sit up and stare at Elusive’s captivating and demanding eyes as he placed his own forehoof against his silky white and black chest. “We shall save your favorite for last, darling. I’ll make sure our date is one you’ll never forget~”

Applejack’s jaw dropped, skyrocketing desires clashing with one another as he fought to contain himself from further reacting. Elusive’s words were more confirmation that he was more than on board, very likely feeling the same way as Applejack. Even though that still raised more questions for the farmpony, Applejack was more than satisfied with that plan as he felt butterflies in his stomach with a slow nod.

“Take it that works perfect for you?” Zecora asked, offering a forehoof to help Applejack stand back up on all four hooves.

“Yah, it does,” Applejack barely spoke above a whisper, feeling mystified as he felt like his hooves were dancing on very thin clouds. Staring into Zecora’s gentle gaze, Applejack saw a certainty in them.

Don’t worry, Applejack. You’ll find you love zebra dick more than anything else~

Applejack gasped, feeling a ripple of shock and arousal surging through his body as his legs wobbled a little before the powerful zebra stud as he frowned.

“Is…everything alright, Applejack?” Zecora asked.

“Yes, yes! Definitely!” Applejack nodded, finding himself still truthful despite the surprising thought that reared its head. “Though, do you think you could come over tomorrow while mah family is out for our one-on-one date? That feels fitting more than anything else, and ah feel like ah already have some ideas forming around that…”

“Yes, I love it already,” Zecora smiled brightly, even blushing a little at the orange farmpony’s enthusiasm to impress him regardless of how the date would go. “Dates with the herd that are slow and steady. Group hug?”

Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch rushed to each side of Applejack and opened their wings to rest on his broad shoulders, while Zecora walked up to him and wrapped a long and heavy foreleg around the orange farmpony’s neck. Elusive trotted up to Applejack’s butt and draped himself over the stallion’s cutie marks, hugging his back tight with his dainty forelegs as Blitz and Butterscotch also moved their wings against the unicorn’s silky shoulders and mane.

After the group hug, Applejack nodded and walked out the hut by himself this time as he trotted back to Sweet Apple Acres with his mind moving a mile a minute. Not something he intentionally hid, but while his family raised him to be a one-pony stallion, Applejack had only the occasional hookups to give some level of experience. Not only did Zecora not know that Applejack’s only experience was being a dom…

…but the bulking zebra stud didn’t know that Applejack’s series of dates were the first ones he’d ever have. That Applejack had never gone on an honest-to-goodness date before.

Oh Ma and Pa, what did ah get myself into?

Zecora the Honorary Apple

Author's Note

Sex Scene Participants: Zecora/Applejack
Contains: first date jitters, submission into zebra superiority, rimming, twerking, ball-sucking, blowjobs, consensual roughness, facefucking, little-contact orgasms, brief deepthroating, and a goodbye kiss~

Zecora the Honorary Apple

Applejack woke up in his bedroom, feeling his heart pounding in a frenzy as the thoughts he wondered on the way back to the barn showed up in full-swing. It should’ve been relaxing, knowing that it was the same place that Zecora had shown up week after week, especially since he had long since met the orange farmpony’s family already. It should’ve been relaxing, given that Applejack had already had a good and detailed plan of what to do for the date to keep Zecora entertained as well as thoroughly getting to know the farmpony even better than before. It was at least comforting to have made sure to have everypony that normally occupies the house to be out somewhere else, whether it was hanging out with the other elderly in Ponyville or having date night or hanging out with the Cutie Mark Crusaders. And yet, the irony of that was that he had none of his beloved family to comfort him. Especially as his mind was wrought with how they would feel about him dating a zebra. They’ve long since known him to be gay and had no issue with that so long as the stallion was a proper contributor to the Apple family. Zecora had easily proven that ten times over, but would they accept Applejack being part of a zebra’s herd despite that?

“Helloooooooooooo?”

Applejack’s heart stopped for the briefest of moments, before his heart thundered hard in his chest at the deep and eloquent voice that was unmistakable. Bolting out of his bed and forgetting about everything else, including brushing his teeth or hair, Applejack bolted to the front door of the barn and opened it wide to see Elusive in all his feminine unicorn glory. He stared at Applejack with a gentle half-lidded gaze, smirking wide as he looked Applejack up and down.

“See you got a headstart on the day?” Elusive giggled.

“What’re ya doin’ here, exactly?” Applejack looked over his shoulder before looking back to the smaller unicorn with wide eyes. “Oh great apple on a tree, please don’t tell me ah remembered the order of the dates wrong. Ah don’t think ah could recover from something that embarrassing…”

“No, definitely not. May I come in?” Elusive asked, getting a quick nod from the big orange stallion as the striped unicorn entered the barn and closed the door behind him with his magic. Making a beeline for the couch, almost as if it was his home, Elusive sat himself down and looked at Applejack with a gentle smile and a pat on the couch. Applejack felt some of his nerves fluttering away from Elusive’s sweet gesture, and trotted to sit on his own family’s couch as the unicorn looked at him.

“I’m sure you feel like a fish out of water, darling,” Elusive expressed, and clarified before Applejack could interrupt to ask. “You know, entering the herd so late as I have. And especially with your worries about your family and our other friends on top of that, it’s only natural that you’d have so much more stress than a normal date would offer. But because I know many of the main reasons behind what you’re doing, I thought it was important that I visited you and gave you a sense of relief…let me excuse myself for a moment, darling.”

Elusive gently moved off the couch without making a sound, Applejack’s eyes widened as he drank in the lithe unicorn’s light gray ponut and balls right below his backdoor. He wasn’t going to pretend that he didn’t glance at his best friend’s goods for a few moments longer than normal up until that very moment, but now that it was clear he was going on dates with all of them and being seriously considered as a new part of the herd, Applejack found himself far less guilty of getting a good look at what the beautiful unicorn’s body had to offer. For years, he saw himself as easily fucking Elusive into a moaning mess as the dominant stallion in the hypothetical relationship. Now, having declared himself as a future sub to Zecora and Butterscotch, Applejack had no clue where that left his potential romance with Elusive. Would they still fuck each other? Would their dating be while getting fucked by their doms? Either way, Applejack knew he would do anything for the diamond-flanked cutie that had been nothing but generous in the process so far.

Elusive skipped off with a light hum moving from his lips as he disappeared down the hallway, coming back several moments later with a clean brush that he had bought for Applejack a couple weeks ago, but the farmpony had never used it. The light bluish green brush was held in Elusive’s magic as he trotted behind the couch and used another magic spell to gently remove Applejack’s hat from his head and place it on the empty spot the unicorn once sat at.

“Oh Elusive, that’s uh, super sweet of you ah certainly promise,” Applejack laughed as his short blonde mane was exposed and at Elusive’s mercy. “But ah don’t know how effective mane-brushing is going to be at getting ready for a date. At least, for more than ten seconds.”

“Oh Zecora isn’t going to be here for at least half an hour,” Elusive laughed, placing his gentle forehooves on Applejack’s rugged shoulders and moving them back and forth as he inevitably heard the soft moan from the orange farmpony slowly caving to whatever Elusive wanted from him. With a giggle, Elusive brought the brush to Applejack’s mane and slowly worked it through the knots. Through the first few brushes, it certainly wasn’t moving flawlessly as Applejack’s mane was certainly tough. But Elusive worked through his mane patiently, even hearing Applejack hum along with the unicorn, as he gradually worked his forehooves down the big stallion’s back and worked through the knots there as well. Eventually, after Elusive’s forehooves tired a bit from the strenuous movement, the unicorn moved his forehooves and placed them on the couch as he replaced their touch with his own magic taking over. Two surges of magic began massaging Applejack’s body with quick pace, moving down towards his butt back up to his shoulders.

Applejack, though he knew it wouldn’t be the case due to the fact that Elusive wouldn’t disrespect Zecora, longed for the unicorn femcolt to take it a step further and to truly give the orange farmpony the most pleasure possible. Though Elusive remained true to getting all the knots out of his dear friend’s blonde mane, moving easily with little effort as Applejack’s mane became silky smooth from the brushing and the knots in both his mane and back were completely smoothed out.

“You know, you would’ve hated hearing this a long time ago,” Elusive giggled, still working his literal magic to buy a little more time with Applejack. “But you and Blitz are a lot more alike than you give yourself credit for. He properly lets himself be dolled up now since he left the Wonderbolts, which is perfect given that beautiful rainbow mane of his. Maybe if everything goes really well, I’ll style up your blonde mane like I’ve done with him too~”

“Ah…” if it were any other stallion, Applejack knew he would’ve gotten in a tizzy over the pride that would’ve taken him over, not ready to admit how good it felt to lean into his feminine side a little. But since it was Elusive, a gentlecolt that proved that femininity was wildly attractive on stallions, Applejack surprised himself with a little giggle that he let out of his muzzle. “Ah think that anything with you sounds mighty wonderful~”

“As I figured you would say,” Elusive laughed, opening his mouth to continue as he considered giving Applejack a harmless kiss on the cheek. Though with perfect timing, the both of them heard a loud trio of knocks on the door that got both of their heads turning with their eyes wide and their ears alert. They didn’t have to think twice as to who it was, as Elusive magically teleported the brush back to its normal spot as he trotted towards the backdoor. “Don’t worry, I’m certainly not sneaking. But I’d rather let you two have a proper start to your one-on-one date without my presence interfering with it. Hug me and lock me out?”

Applejack jumped off the couch and made a beeline for the silky and svelte femcolt that batted his long eyelashes at him, stealing his heart with the subtle body language in of itself as he wrapped his burly forelegs around the unicorn’s tiny figure. Applejack let himself inhale the minty berry perfume that wafted his nostrils with a sense of delight, always enjoying whatever new perfume that Elusive put on his own body. Elusive let the hug linger as long as the big orange lug needed, before Applejack stepped back and let his dear friend walk out before locking the door. He returned to the couch, placing his signature hat back on his blonde mane, before trotting and stopping at the front door where he knew the significantly bigger zebra stallion would be waiting for him. Looking to the kitchen counter and seeing the recipe books and several of the cooking supplies and food laying perfectly where he had left it, Applejack took a deep breath before placing his forehoof on the door handle and pulling it open to see the tall zebra adonis and smell a different smell on him. It was far more earthy, a smell Applejack personally loved, with a hint of herbs from all the potion-making he did. His cool cyan eyes and small smile spoke of no lewd intentions, but a proper date of getting to know Applejack beyond their platonic friendship.

So why couldn’t Applejack get those lewd and craving thoughts out of his head? Vivid images of Zecora’s far bigger and fatter cock pistoning in and out of his dark orange ponut, of the zebra stallion marking him both mentally and physically…

“Hello Applejack, assuming we’re going to be helping ourselves to quite the snack?” Zecora asked, glancing over to the kitchen counter of stuff. Before Applejack could answer, Zecora trotted up to him and gave him a firm yet gentle hug around his strong earth pony shoulders. Even though Applejack was a paragon of earth pony strength, his figure still wasn’t as strong as Zecora’s and the orange farmpony didn’t even know how beyond either zebra genetics, powerful potions, or a mixture of both. All of such was admittedly, Applejack’s lewd fantasies coming to the forefront and causing his heart to thunder in his chest.

You’ll never have a figure like that, because Zecora is superior to all his pony subs~

Applejack gasped at that feisty intrusive voice coming back full-force with a hungry need behind it. He had no clue if the others had the same voices in their heads, or if his honesty was coming out as he spent more time with Zecora in a new light. The hug ended, and Applejack moved aside as he allowed Zecora to enter his family home that only contained the two of them now that Elusive had left.

“Ya, well, ah honestly feel bad with how little ah’ve integrated you into my family given how much you help around here,” Applejack sighed. “And if we’re gonna properly become an uh…item, ah feel like it's only fair to make you an Honorary Apple. And if the family approves, actually become an Apple by title. So ah’m going to be teaching you a few recipes kept in the family, and ah’ll tell them the truth if they ask. Though, ah won’t uh, offer that information voluntarily. Not sure how…uh…”

“How Grandpa Smith would take you giving family recipes to a zebra?” Zecora remarked, tilting his head as he closed the door behind him with a casual movement of his hindleg.

“Yah, that,” Applejack admitted with a slow nod of his head, trotting over to the kitchen counter as he showed the open cookbook. “Ah’ve got a few items in mind for us to work on, especially from all the recipes ah made from the first day you three were here. Perhaps we should try making apple cider donuts first?”

“I think that is a lovely choice, coming from an even more beautiful voice~” Zecora grinned wide, giving a determined nod before looking at the recipe book made by several generations of the Apple family with a sense of shock at being allowed such an honor. If that didn’t prove Applejack was truly committed to giving the herd dynamic a shot, Zecora didn’t know what was. They began with mixing everything, making sure the right portions were in bowls and getting the dough in the right shapes for the oven. Applejack worked like clockwork, making sure everything was done to a T. That wasn’t necessarily the weird part to Zecora. What was weird to him was the orange farmpony barely making conversation as he used Zecora for glorified help for the next half hour. With how prompt Applejack was on a daily basis, usually more talkative with his family around, Zecora didn’t necessarily see it as rude. Rather, he could recognize the growingly obvious fact that Applejack didn’t have a default to going on dates because he had never been on one before. But then, after Applejack finally put the apple cider donuts in the oven, the orange farmpony’s ears flattened against his blonde mane as he looked at Zecora earnestly.

“Ah’m so sorry,” Applejack deflated.

“Whatever for?” Zecora frowned.

“Cooking family recipes is something ah already do on a daily basis,” Applejack pouted. “That’s not really a special date idea is it? It’s pretty mundane now that ah think about it, but ah’ve never been on a date before, let alone planned one out. Ah know you said the donuts were a lovely option, but ah thought ya might have been flattering me…”

“I wouldn’t lie to you, especially since I know you deeply value what is most true,” Zecora explained. “I thought this date idea was very sweet, to make a very good treat. Despite what your grandpa might think of you giving out the book, I know it flatters me that you trust me with being a Honorary Apple cook~”

“You’re right, ya wouldn’t exaggerate and ah should know better,” Applejack spoke in a dry laugh.

“No putting yourself down though, I prefer to see that bright orange face of yours glow,” Zecora commanded Applejack’s own self-respect, even taking the extra measure of lifting the orange farmpony’s face with his forehoof to get the stallion to look right into his eyes. The simple gesture got Applejack blushing as his green eyes widened. Still, despite the enjoyment of feeling such a hot touch, Applejack remained without a word as Zecora continued. “You know what I would like to do?”

“What is that?”

“Begin working on a few more recipes with you~” Zecora leaned in, his half-lidded eyes and sweet smile looked smug and pulled Applejack in further with his eyes. Before that moment, Applejack was certain that Zecora had no interest and that he was merely chasing the big zebra stud. But looking at the zebra’s powerful allure, Applejack started to wonder if he and Dusk Shine were both wrong about their own respective flavors of paranoia. Zecora wasn’t going after all of them, he didn’t need to. Just the mere fact that half of the Elements were charmed by him simply meant that the rest of them were destined to fall into his Zebrican trap. Subs under his spell to be plowed and striped by him. All Zecora had to do was be himself and they would come to him.

So why did that make Applejack so…happy?

“Ya, of course ah’d love to keep doin’ that,” Applejack couldn’t help his facial muscles, the glowing smile that Zecora asked for lighting up the room as the orange farmpony willed himself to pull away from the zebra’s gentle forehoof embrace as he looked to his own Apple cookbook. The apple salad was a far simpler one that could be easily done before the donuts were even complete in the oven, so Applejack got the bowl of mixed greens going as he mixed them with the apple vinaigrette while Zecora was at the cutting board working on cutting the apples at the right perfect slices. Or at least trying to. Some of the slices came out a little too big, at least to the hyper-fixated eye of Applejack. So after he had finished mixing everything else in the salad bowl, the big orange farmpony trotted over behind Zecora to help. But right before Zecora could wonder what Applejack was doing behind him, the farmpony was brought to drinking in the zebra’s powerful figure and given another sharp reminder to what he could never be. What he never really wanted to be as long as he got to enjoy the splendors of looking at the superior zebra stud. His powerful rippling figure that was built like a God, a paragon of masculinity and exotic magnetism. He blamed all those mares and stallions that had fawned over him in Ponyville less and less with each moment he gave up his pretend interest in submissive stallions and began to savor the superior likes of fucking hot zebra stud-

“Are you going to do something over there, or are you simply choosing to enjoy and stare?” Zecora snickered without taking his eye off the cutting board, causing Applejack to light up like a Hearth’s Warming Tree as he blushed profusely. His stare was captivating, prolonging the orange stallion from talking for a few more moments before he realized that Zecora was talking to him.

“Ah uh, wanted to help you with cutting ‘em properly if ah may,” Applejack stammered, starting to stand on his hindlegs as soon as Zecora gave his nod of approval. Draping his earth pony body over Zecora’s back, snaking his forelegs over the zebra stallion’s much thicker and muscular striped forelegs, Applejack felt his breath briefly stolen from the electric touch that flashed through his senses. Big, casually confident, and just all around superior in every way, Applejack almost felt unworthy to be touching him in such an intimate manner. Almost, because not only did they have a long friendship beforehoof unlike the others, but Zecora smirked deeply and gave a deep and comfortable sigh as he gave Applejack full control of his forelegs as he adjusted his movements.

“Ya just…” Applejack helped him, until Zecora was cutting the apple slices more neatly and with better consistency in their shape and size. With Zecora getting better technique, Applejack relaxed more with each moment and shivered in contentment at how much he was enjoying himself. He would’ve been astounded at how easily he was leaning into the idea of being one of Zecora’s herd members, had he not felt at peace for the first time in a very long time. Had Elusive not been extremely dedicated to Zecora, to the point of being striped and fucked on stage, Applejack would’ve felt guilty on his behalf for how much he was enjoying himself. Instead, the orange farmpony delighted in naturally having the same desires as his unicorn femcolt love and kept himself on Zecora until the apple was completely cut. Slowly moving off of him, feeling cheated out of being able to touch Zecora more, Applejack bit his lip and looked away as Zecora turned around and faced him.

“How smooth and clever you are,” Zecora snickered. “Though your friends-turned-slaves of mine told me how your past sexual preferences in comparison to some of theirs are off by far.”

“What is that supposed to mean?”

“It’s supposed to mean that I know you’re used to taking the lead with your past endeavors since you’ve told them,” Zecora pointed out, smiling wider as he booped Applejack gently on the muzzle. “I’m certainly not privy to all your history though I am not dumb. With Butterscotch I can tell he loves to switch, but I can clearly tell what makes your dick twitch. Let go, and I promise you I will give you a wonderful show~”

Applejack shuddered as Zecora’s forehoof smoothly moved from his orange muzzle to his chin, remembering that he had asked the zebra stallion specifically to be a sub in the herd. While he resigned to being the dominant stallion most saw him as due to his hardworking ethic and muscular physique, Applejack knew deep down it wasn’t his deepest desire. The orange stallion just wanted to be fucked, though it was hard to give up the image that he had presented so carefully without it being a blatant lie. He was being more honest with himself by the minute, and so with Applejack giving a gentle nod, Zecora grinned.

“Very good, my little pony,” Zecora giggled, the deep and sonorous sound ringing delightfully in Applejack’s ears as the striped adonis turned his tail to the farmpony after scooping up the sliced apples in his forehoof. “You can start on whatever dish you wanted to make next and leave the finishing touch of the salad up to me~”

Applejack’s jaw nearly dropped, though he willed himself to keep his muzzle closed as he simply blushed more instead. Zecora placed the slices in the salad, took a brief look at the recipe in the book, and just started mixing it with the utensils already in the bowl while Applejack stood still. How was it that a date in which Applejack was seemingly in charge was upended by Zecora’s magnetism, his confidence? Suppose if Applejack was as dominant as he acted in the past, he would’ve been offended at Zecora’s change in dynamic. Only instead, the orange farmpony felt himself getting hard as he trotted closer to Zecora and looked to his own cookbook to look through the recipes till he saw the classic apple pie that had spanned through generations. Zecora had it at least a dozen times, though Applejack didn’t see a better dish to create for the final course. As he read over the different supplies he would need to get out, Applejack’s green eyes shot wide as he felt a firm forehoof slipping up his figure.

“I hope you don’t mind me returning the favor, since staring at your apples certainly gives me something to savor~” Zecora swooned, still mixing the salad with one forehoof while his other forehoof was occupied. His eyes were staring down at Applejack’s cutie marks now, bright red and far more appealing to the zebra than the apples he was going to eat. His other forehoof was on the muscular earth pony firmness of Applejack’s orange ass cheek, close to his dark orange ponut and big balls, though they certainly weren’t as big as Zecora’s own zebra balls. “Why don’t you give me a show of your own if you’d feel delight. Perhaps as you make your pie you can shake those cheeks with all your earth pony might~”

Applejack felt his body on fire, like a young stallion on prom night feeling desire for the first time as he gulped and felt a mixture of bright orange and hot red at that point.

“Of course, Zecora,” Applejack nodded really fast, even taking the initiative to part his long blonde tail to the side to show how receptive he truly was to the zebra’s advances. Hunger started to wake in his loins as he turned away and trotted to the lower kitchen cupboard below the counter and pulled out various items such as a pie tin for the apple pie. As he had lowered his body to do so, he made sure Zecora was watching his toned and big earth pony ass while his head and forelegs were closer to the ground as he moved his lower body in action. Giving a decent clap, though not the loudest clap Zecora had heard from a pony, the magnetizing movement of Applejack’s apple cutie marks was something that sealed the deal for the zebra stallion. Progressively over the past ten minutes he had got hornier, and for the last stallion that he had expected. While Zecora was thinking to himself, Applejack gave a couple more shakes of his ass before resuming with making the apple pie as he had gotten a bowl out and started cutting his own slices.

Zecora finished mixing the salad together, turning around and getting two bowls out and splitting the whole salad between the two of them before placing the two bowls on the kitchen table. Just as Applejack was going to ask what Zecora wanted to do next, his eyes went wide and excitement began dancing both in his heart and loins as he felt both of Zecora’s forehooves on him this time. The farmpony, once proud of his determination to settle down with a stallion sub to please his traditional family as best he could despite being gay, felt himself becoming alive and almost begging for more as he felt Zecora’s forehooves parting his muscular ass cheeks apart and showing off his own apple donut.

“Mmm, you know, don’t tell the others this…” Zecora muttered, that deep voice and its teasing words catching Applejack’s perked up ears as he continued. “But you’ve got the sweetest smelling ponut that I could just kiss~”

“Oh stars!” Applejack gasped, realizing that Zecora’s lack of action was him asking for permission, flattering the orange farmpony as he managed to gain his bearings with a small smile as he looked at the zebra stallion over his shoulder. “Well, ah suppose one gentle kiss wouldn’t do any harm…”

Applejack slightly shook his rear, giving Zecora permission with his body on top of saying it outright, and the zebra stud moved slowly and placed his muzzle against the farmpony’s ponut softly as he had asked. Parting his muzzle from Applejack’s dark orange ponut just as quickly as he had placed it there, Zecora placed his forehooves on Applejack’s shoulders as their positions were reversed from earlier. This time, the much taller zebra stud was pressed up against Applejack from behind as he unapologetically had his erect pillar against the orange farmpony’s muscular buns. Applejack would’ve guffawed at the idea of a stallion trying to assert such dominance before today, but with Zecora against him as he sliced his own apples, the orange farmpony couldn’t hold back those all too real images of him being a proper housewife to his future zebra Master…

Everything was set on the table, from the apple cider donuts to pie to salad. And instead of eating on opposite sides of the table like Applejack was used to with Zecora, the tall and bigger zebra stud was sitting next to Applejack while the orange farmpony was leaning against him despite the two being in their own chairs. They were enjoying their own plates of food, Applejack feeling his heart fluttering at how seamless the two seemed to be getting along for their first date. He had a fear, something that he was sure was mutual, that Zecora wouldn’t have been his type like he was convinced of for a long time. But astonishingly, they enjoyed each other’s company way more than the friendship that they normally partook in. Applejack even felt natural eating against Zecora’s side, getting a good bite of apple pie in his mouth and chewing it before he saw Zecora’s fork full of apple cider donut move towards his lips.

“Are ya tryin’ t-”

Before Applejack could finish asking his question, Zecora hummed affirmatively as he kept moving his fork and had the orange farmpony eat the bite off of his utensil instinctively. Applejack enjoyed the flavor, but this time more than usual as he felt the affection behind it take hold in his heart and body. Deep delight raced through him, savoring the enjoyment that many mares in his family experienced before him: a strong stud that would take care of his needs.

Feeling his eyes begin to water, and his chest getting tight, Applejack saw Zecora place his fork on his plate as he pressed his forehoof against the rippling shoulders of the earth pony.

“Are you okay, are your thoughts astray?” Zecora questioned.

“No, it’s just…ah felt like ah needed to be the stallion mah family needed, and that meant choosing a marish stallion to give them the ‘wife’ they wanted in the family,” Applejack explained. “Even if ah’m gay.”

“Ah,” Zecora winced, moving his strong zebra forehoof in circles as Applejack took a deep breath to bring relief back to his chest. The zebra stallion understood instantly that feeling, especially when he thought of his beloved Butterscotch and how the yellow pegasus pressured himself to be completely submissive until it blew up in his face. Now it was Applejack, who didn’t even want to be switch let alone a dom, and the fact was clear in his glistening green eyes. Smiling wide, feeling a risky jumble of thoughts forming in his brain, Zecora spoke them aloud. “Now that you are being more yourself than before, don’t you notice you and Elusive getting together without me would’ve caused problems some more?”

“What do ya mean?”

“Well,” Zecora chuckled, gently and stopping himself before Applejack could take it the wrong way. “You both are subs?”

Applejack’s eyes widened with the sudden obvious realization, another damning reason why Zecora’s presence in his life and Elusive’s life was critical to their relationship. Feeling relief, validation for holding off on his confession, Applejack smiled and laughed a long laugh as Zecora snickered along with him. The orange farmpony couldn’t give a rat’s ass if Zecora was genuinely helping him with his advice or if the zebra adonis was being subtly manipulative in getting between his hindlegs. Applejack felt like his epiphany was his own no matter whose influence might’ve touched it, feeling free in his heart for the first time since his parents died as his tears falling down his face quickly took on new meaning. He wrapped his foreleg around Zecora’s shoulders as he nuzzled the zebra stallion’s sweet musky neck.

They had finished the food, the two cuddling on the couch this time as Applejack felt leagues better than when he had poured out his vulnerability at the table. His hat rested off to the side on the couch cushion. The sexual teasing from both of them while they were cooking, paired with the emotional progression that followed, left the both of them hornier than a pair of mares in heat. Zecora moved his forehoof close to Applejack’s butt, stopping, and then moving it up his back again before repeating the same motion. All the while as Applejack embraced the hot and delicious touch, he looked at Zecora’s massive zebra pillar. Black, thick, almost a foot long with balls below that were bigger than oranges, the Zebrican length was a legendary sight to behold. Even with all his love towards Elusive, Applejack knew now that the unicorn’s average gray length wouldn’t have brought even a quarter of the taboo excitement and thrill that came with being so sexually close to an adonis that had half of Ponyville wet or hard for him. And Zecora having deep emotional intelligence and a way with words only sealed the deal even harder.

The only problem? Applejack hadn’t had his ponut cherry popped, having never bottomed before. He wasn’t entirely ready to do that, strongly preferring to see how well the following dates go before taking that next step, but he certainly wasn’t about to let those superior zebra balls go without them being unloaded. Feeling several years younger, a pang of excited nervousness starting from his mind to his heart, Applejack gulped as he looked at Zecora’s length openly. Even gesturing his muzzle towards it and looking right into Zecora’s cool eyes and mild blush.

“May I?” Applejack asked.

“There’s a lot of acts I would happily permit you to do, though the words need to come from you~” Zecora nodded towards his own cock on full display, waiting for Applejack to continue, which he without a doubt figured that the honest pony could bring himself to do.

“Ah want to touch your cock, not just with my hooves but with my mouth,” Applejack almost pleaded, feeling much less like a stallion like a change and more like a young mare out on the town, sneaking off with some stallion her family didn’t approve of. That certainly didn’t help, causing the orange farmpony’s length to become hard and getting Zecora’s attention to Applejack’s length. Out of all the stallions that Zecora had genuinely considered to be part of a more long-term herd, the muscular farmpony had the longest length. Slightly thicker than all of his femcolts’ “clits,” Applejack’s length was seven inches and still decently dwarfed by Zecora’s massive bitchbreaker. That didn’t even need to be pointed out by the striped adonis, who pointed at his own dick with one forehoof.

“By all means do not let me stop you,” Zecora snickered as Applejack wasted no time getting up close and personal. The orange farmpony smelled the musk, the powerful salty scent invading his nostrils and continuing the undoing that had started with his thoughts the day before. He restrained himself from letting his eyes roll to the back of his head like he would’ve wanted to do, not wanting to entirely hide his enjoyment, but worried of how slutty he might’ve been coming off to Zecora for what was their first date.

Feeling Zecora’s forehoof pressed firmly against his blonde mane, Applejack’s dick twitched as he gasped and shuddered.

“Suppose you need a little help being more honest with yourself here?” Zecora asked gently, keeping his forehoof in place as Applejack’s green eyes looked towards him. He looked at Zecora’s cool eyes, normally relaxing, took on new meaning as he looked hungry for Applejack in a way the farmpony had never seen before. The zebra adonis stared at him intently, narrowing his eyes as he became more clear. “Would you perhaps like to be treated more like a naughty little queer?”

“Yes, please,” Applejack bucked his hips against the air, knowing that Zecora wouldn’t do anything too harsh. Though the idea of being “used” sent Applejack through the motions of hot and deliciously shameful desires as in the barn that raised him very differently, the orange farmpony was becoming a more honest version of himself. Zecora’s eyes lit up with a glint of excitement from approval as he moved his forehoof forward, nearly smashing Applejack’s blushing face against his fat zebra balls. The farmpony didn’t hold back, moaning against the stud that was merely considered a buddy not too long ago. Seeing that behavior looking back on it was laughable, knowing more fully that it was a mere defense for submitting into exotic euphoria. Feeling how much Zecora was pushing him towards his Element of Honesty, Applejack’s eyes rolled to the back of his head this time as he stuck his fat pony tongue against the zebra stud’s balls and began lapping at them. Tasting that masculine and salty taste brought excitement that pulsed into his own length all the more, hearing Zecora’s gentle hum as Applejack eagerly began sucking on the stud’s balls.

As Applejack moaned against them for a while before starting to kiss up Zecora’s length, the orange farmpony thought to how it was so much more than just relieving the zebra stud that was soon to be his Master. He was quickly shedding more and more of his guilty self, a stallion that felt wronged by how much he was pushing down his true self for a pony that was supposed to live in divine truth, and felt renewed in his element as he savored exactly the pony he wanted to be. Sexually open and not threatened by his own desires, submissive for such a gentle yet powerful stud, and still the beautiful caretaker of his family like he had always been. He had both embraced parts of himself that had been around the entire time, and remained true to what he loved to be. Reaching the tip of Zecora’s fat bitchbreaker, astounded at how he was eventually supposed to get that beastly appendage inside his backdoor. But he wasn’t to be deterred, and he steeled his resolve as he peppered the tip with a few kisses before taking the plunge. Opening his mouth, ensuring that his teeth didn’t accidentally graze such a beautiful body part, Applejack swiftly moved down on the first few inches till the tip of Zecora’s length bumped against the entrance to his throat. Such a simple and mildly pressuring physical sensation brought Applejack’s heart fluttering along with his eyelashes as the pleasure was deeply maddening as much as it was liberating. Zecora thankfully didn’t pull the aggressive pushing on Applejack yet, even if he wanted to be “mistreated” a little, allowing the farmpony to enjoy the very first time of touching not just zebra cock, but Zecora’s cock.

“Mmmph, hnng, nnph!” Applejack moaned against Zecora’s length hard, bucking his hips faster into the air back and forth as he felt his painfully hard dark orange length spilling pre-cum while he pushed his mouth further down with slow and careful precision. His lewd inner voice persuading him didn’t even need to be present anymore, just the pure physical magnitude of being so clearly dominated by a zebra stud barely doing anything on the couch bringing the once proud masculine stallion to new heights of submissive pleasure. He didn’t think he could get all of Zecora’s length deepthroated, not for his first time anyways, and so Applejack slowly moved his mouth back up till just the tip was in his mouth. He looked into Zecora’s eyes, so cool and carrying such authority as he stared right into the farmpony’s soul. Even if Applejack did choose to lie, there was no way Zecora couldn’t look past the words and into the very truth of his soul. Applejack closed his eyes, stirring alive with the deep and unapologetic desire that came alive in his movements, before pushing back down and then back up again. The sensation repeated, with his erection painfully needing release, and his own hardness spurring him on to keep bouncing his muzzle up and down Zecora’s length for several minutes.

Zecora’s hums turned into affirmative grunts as he lightly bucked his hips against Applejack, and decided that it was time to give the needy farmpony more of what he wanted. Pushing his forehoof against the back of the orange farmpony’s head and speeding his thrusts, Zecora essentially plowed Applejack’s face with half his length while the stallion was moaning like a filly on prom night. Drool spilled out relentlessly from Applejack’s mouth, his gag reflex was occasionally tested as his eyes watered, and the orange farmpony felt horny enough to twerk his ass unprompted like a stripper. He just wanted to be as needy for Zecora as possible, his eyes rolling to the back of his head as he felt just the slightest touch to his poor length would cause a cataclysmically pleasurable explosion of release. He would crash with the force of a dying star, bray like a prostitute getting gangbanged, should Zecora give his length just the briefest of touches. It was already amazing enough for Applejack to see the light getting facefucked, so now he was on the cusp of fully embracing the process and engaging in his herd for real.

“Seems like you’ll actually be, unf, joining my herd for real hmm?” Zecora snickered, his other forehoof sneaking towards Applejack’s length as he was nearing his own orgasm. “That’s a good sub, why don’t you show how badly you want to join the club~?”

Zecora’s touch briefly glided up and down Applejack’s dark orange length, causing the orange farmpony’s eyes to nearly bulge out of his head as he loudly brayed against Zecora’s hot zebra bitchbreaker. Blushing hard, heart thundering in his chest, pure pleasure reaching its crescendo, Applejack came all over the couch as he spontaneously hilted the zebra stud’s entire length into his mouth and down his own throat as Zecora grunted and reached his own climax. The position was perfect as he could cum his potent ropes of superior zebra seed down his newest sub’s throat and claim his mouth as soon as he would the orange stallion’s backdoor in a future date. Applejack kept still, even if it made his throat sore to have such a thick dick inside. He knew he’d need to make some tea to relieve the soreness later, though all Applejack could feel was how the forbidden sensation made him need more. Though, as he finished gulping Zecora’s many ropes of seed, Applejack removed his mouth off of the stud’s cock and gasped for air.

“Doing well? I can’t really tell,” Zecora asked, using his forehoof that was still against the back of Applejack’s head to move gently up and down and soothe the farmpony as he continued. “I didn’t quite have any expectations for this, though I’m surprised by the sheer amount of bliss.”

“Y-Yah, ah feel the exact same way,” Applejack panted, his blonde tail swinging from side to side as he yearned for more. Though he knew that he was going to sit and think through a lot of his new discoveries and revelations the moment Zecora left, and decided to savor the post-nut glow of just how good it felt to give somepony else the reins. “Ah wanna cuddle for a few minutes longer, and then ah can walk you out…”

“Sounds like a plan~” Zecora agreed, the time flying back as they cuddled well past midnight. The zebra stud would’ve tried to spend the night had his pegasus subs not had Applejack to themselves the next day, allowing everything to happen naturally without pushing it. Eventually, the both of them got off the couch as Applejack inched towards the front door slowly. The fact that his whole family was occupied spending the night elsewhere was nothing short of a miracle, giving Applejack the chance to not have their implicit hold on him as he got to seek out what it really meant to be him.

As Applejack pressed his forehoof against the door, he paused feeling unresolved as he looked intently at Zecora.

“Can ah…um,” Applejack bit his lip, feeling even more shy about asking the zebra stud for something far more innocent. “Could ah get a goodbye kiss?”

Zecora’s eyes lit up, a youthful smile dancing upon his muzzle briefly before he stepped forward and swooped in to meet the farmpony’s lips. Their first kiss, feeling Zecora’s tongue briefly dance in his mouth, sent Applejack swooning in deep and perfect fulfillment as he longed for more. He almost wanted to say fuck it to the dates for the next few dates and hide Zecora in his room to himself, the selfish and yet beautiful hunger taking hold as he opened up to what he deprived himself of for years. Zecora sighed into the kiss, and Applejack hummed in response, before their muzzles parted and the muscular zebra stallion turned around and began walking out the door.

“See you Applejack, don’t forget to meet them at Butters’ cottage tomorrow you fruity little snack~!” Zecora said, his voice a pitch higher as he felt the energy high that was shared with Applejack. The orange farmpony watched as Zecora got smaller and smaller, the longing in his heart tugging him towards his image despite staying still. All until Zecora disappeared from sight altogether.

And with a shocking jolt of realization, of erotic epiphany, Applejack realized that he hadn’t thought of Elusive during that entire blowjob.

Potential Pegasus Paramours

Author's Note

Sex Scene Participants: Applejack/Rainbow Blitz/Butterscotch
Contains resolved tension of past installments, power bottom blowjobs, wingjobs, the Sonic Wingjob, rimming, anal, voyeurism, ball-sucking, deepthroating, and a messy finish!

Potential Pegasus Paramours

Applejack trotted along the forest path, the orange farmpony feeling far more excited jitters than the still nervousness he felt right before his one-on-one date with Zecora. He knew that Eris was not only not there, but she had taken a lot of the animals that Butterscotch normally takes care of to a different part of the forest after they had been extensively taken care of by him. Rainbow Blitz, still much to Applejack’s shock, didn’t have the Wonderbolts to worry about in the first place and was easily able to make time to be at the cottage. Shock over what had been happening the past year and several months ago was starting to sink into the farmpony’s mind, especially given that this had all started with Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch when they couldn’t figure out their relationship problems until the smooth zebra adonis had snuck his way into their relationship. At least, that’s how Applejack imagined the events occurred. And then Elusive was seduced, prompting Applejack to act and then be seduced as well. He knew deep down that this was all his own will and actions, though thinking that this was Zecora’s plan the whole time only made the sexual relationship all the hotter. Remembering the days where the pegasus stallions were a couple, Applejack blinked rapidly as he was astounded that he would be getting intimate with the two at some point. Possibly before the day was over if everything went really well.

Stopping in front of the cottage door, his mind flooded with memories of everything that had happened between the three of them. Ignoring Butterscotch, getting the heated anger of Rainbow Blitz, and then witnessing the latter getting fucked by Zecora months later at their anniversary party. Forgiving and returning to being friends was one choice, but it was certainly another to be dating them by default as they were all subs of this big zebra stud. He didn’t know if their issues had truly resolved themselves enough to properly earn being sexual and romantic with the two pegasi, and yet, motivated by Zecora’s lustful appetite and Elusive’s beautiful personality, Applejack took a deep inhale and knocked on the door. Right away, shockingly quick, was Rainbow Blitz in his bright blue and striped glory. A far cry from the absurdly skinny athlete with an ego the size of the moon, the still-toned blue pegasus with a chubby rainbow-flanked butt had bright pink eyes that were more doey and friendly as his former ego was all gone. Slowly trotting up beside him was Butterscotch, also striped and with a bubbly butterfly ass that was several times bigger than when he had first started dating Rainbow Blitz. Though Applejack was not to take him lightly, as Butterscotch was apparently more dominant than the pegasus lead on. Still, they smiled warmly at him as Butterscotch trotted ahead with Rainbow Blitz obediently following him out of the cottage.

“Hey Applejack!” Butterscotch chirped, extending one long yellow wing out from his side and resting it on the orange farmpony’s sturdy shoulders. “How was your date with our Master last night? I mean, I’m sure it went well enough since you’re still going on the date with us. And Zecora looked brighter than a tomato when he came back. We needed to get a lot of loads out of our big guy before he could properly go to sleep~”

Applejack’s mouth opened a little in shock before he clamped it shut with the realization of how much of it made sense. He knew that he was going to be sharing Zecora with three other ponies, and that he would be sharing himself with all of them eventually, but it didn’t occur to him that Zecora would help himself to his subs not an hour after their date was over. Applejack thought to himself, that he should’ve felt cheapened by such an event. But he only could feel himself getting slightly hard from the idea of Zecora asserting himself in the way that he deserved to. Why shouldn’t Zecora get to help himself to however many plushy and pastel pony subs as he wanted to? Applejack only felt a warm sense of honor in his heart as he was another chosen member of the herd. Rainbow Blitz smirked, a familiar expression of his old self, as he placed his long blue wing on the other side of Applejack’s shoulders.

“Sounds like that doesn’t bother you so much, huh?” Blitz snickered, glancing down between Applejack’s hind legs before his expression shifted into something more earnest. “Don’t worry about it though, seriously. Zecora makes sure each and every one of us are loved dearly on top of making sure we cum from that beautiful dick of his. Though, this isn’t how our compatibility with him is it? Not today, at least.”

“Nope, we’re going to go on a forest stroll together in a special place for you both~” Butterscotch giggled, taking the lead and walking through the trail where Applejack came from. Applejack looked to his former rival, and was surprised to see that the blue pegasus was just as confused as the farmpony was as the two walked alongside each other and stared at their secondary dom’s bubbly canary yellow butt rippling with each step he made towards their unknown destination. The trees gradually shifted from their normal appearance to completely different trees that Applejack and Rainbow Blitz recognized as ones they had kicked the leaves off of many times, as if they were in…

“The Running of the Leaves!” Applejack and Rainbow Blitz shouted almost in unison, with Butterscotch grinning widely as he looked at the two over his shoulder.

“That’s right~” Butterscotch giggled. “That was so many years ago, when you two were trying to size each other’s dick with various feats of strength and speed. Then it got so bad that you two entered that annual event and tied for last place! Even Dusk Shine did better than you both.”

Applejack was the first to blush over the past rivalry and how it nearly ruined the event, though when he turned to look at Rainbow Blitz, he just saw the blue pegasus roll his eyes and laugh as if the memory was a joke to him now. Some frustration bubbled to the surface, though that was quickly dashed as Rainbow Blitz spoke.

“Oh great Solaris, that was hysterical,” Blitz cackled. “And back when I was busting my ass to be part of the Wonderbolts too! My whole identity was around being the most awesome stallion alive, and I didn’t realize what that really meant for me until…well…these stripes and big flanks of mine speak for themselves I would say. Wouldn’t you agree, Applejack?”

Applejack looked at his former rival’s bubbly blue and black butt cheeks wobble from his twerk, and found himself surprised at how flirty the two were right off the bat. No doubt that with how well his night with Zecora was, the two felt that Applejack’s welcoming into the herd was a guarantee and they were simply waiting for the signal to jump the farmpony’s bones or at least play with him. Though, while Applejack felt happy from their interest, he knew it wasn’t right to push for that without talking about everything.

“The memory isn’t as funny to me,” Applejack admitted. “Ah know how happy you are now, Rainbow Blitz. You’re a sub for a zebra and that brings you incredible bliss, and ah’m pretty damn sure it does the same for me too. But even with mah honesty, the image ah was fighting for at the time ate away at me. Not just that, but how ah treated ya both last time y’all were staying at mah farm. You were helping hooves, and ah treated you both with great disrespect. Ah just feel unworthy to be dating you both like nothin’ happened.”

“That means so much to me that you care,” Butterscotch’s smile widened as he turned around to face Applejack, all three of them stopping their walk as the yellow pegasus continued. “But we talked about this, remember?”

“Ah know,” Applejack shrugged. “And it was easy to just resume being friends again, but ah don’t know how to date the two of you when ah’ve wronged ya both so deeply. Ah couldn’t stand that Blitz here was better at certain skills than me, and ah was angry that ah had made yer life harder when you first turned into Butterbat. Ah don’t know how good a partner ah could be to you both when ah done that.”

“Don’t you think ponies can change?” Rainbow Blitz asked, placing his blue wing on Applejack’s shoulders and soothing the bigger farmpony by moving his feather appendage up and down. “I’m certainly not that arrogant athlete that was an asshole all the time anymore, now am I? Being at Zecora’s command and being whatever pony him and Butters what me to be has shifted me into a happier and free version of myself. Plus, me and Butterscotch had plenty of tension leading up to Zecora taking us both. Does that mean we should just give up on everything, or accept change?”

“Ya, ah’ve been stuck in the same way cause of mah family though,” Applejack admitted. “And ya know how much they matter to me, more than all the other ponies in Equestria. If ah let them down, what kind of an Apple am ah?”

“With Zecora having tripled your farm’s profits, I kinda think that’s impossible, dude,” Rainbow Blitz pointed out, and Applejack couldn’t deny that truth. Even if he hurt them emotionally, he knew that they would still love him and benefit off his and Zecora’s collective efforts more than they could’ve ever dreamed of since his parents died. The gears were turning inside of his head, and Applejack looked to his former rival with a small smile.

“Thanks Blitz, ah suppose there’s nothin’ wrong with change so long as the key parts of me are still intact,” Applejack realized, even if it would take weeks or even months for that feeling to truly settle in and affect his life for the better. Butterscotch stepped forward, pressing the tip of his pale yellow muzzle against Applejack’s orange muzzle, the energy of kindness extending into the warm and blossoming touch. Rainbow Blitz extended his muzzle forward, touching their muzzles as they embraced the three-way muzzle nuzzle. It wasn’t as spicy as a kiss, but it was more intimate than a hug. So Applejack sighed into it before all three of them pulled away simultaneously with Butterscotch turning back around as they continued walking through White Tail Woods.

It was nearing the end of spring, so the leaves weren’t red and orange like that fateful day he had tried racing Rainbow Blitz at the expense of others when it came to their competition of stallion superiority. Ironically enough, it was Zecora who bested the both of them in that very regard, and the two seemed to love that more and more with each day. Even Rainbow Blitz had the jet black stripes to prove that he had long since given up such a feat in favor of being zebra property. The only one of the three that had anything close to being strong and powerful was Butterscotch as he held his head high and gently smiled as he watched the critters moving about in the trees and flying past him. Applejack certainly couldn’t stop staring at his jiggling globes and that small dark yellow length and balls between his hindlegs. He wasn’t quite sure how the sub with the smallest dick was Zecora’s second-in-command switch, but that was something that Applejack looked forward to finding out in due time.

After some time of walking, ending up in a clearing in White Tail Woods, Butterscotch nodded as he looked at the pink flowers before turning around.

“Well, first one back gets their dick sucked,” Butterscotch said clearly, though really fast to the point where Applejack wasn’t even sure he heard him right. But before Rainbow Blitz could even open his wings, Butterscotch was taking off into the air past the trees and into the open sky. Blitz gawked at how speedy Butterscotch was, before opening his own pair of wings and giggling as he flew after him. Much to Applejack’s shock, he noticed that Rainbow Blitz didn’t fly away like the normal blur of rainbow flash that surpassed all pegasi. Instead, the lithe blue pegasus gently flew away slightly slower than Butterscotch did. It was almost as if Rainbow Blitz wanted to lose.

Oh.

Torn between going just as slow and letting Butterscotch win and bolting fast to make the competition fun, Applejack steeled his resolve and settled on the latter. Taking a deep breath and readying his muscles for the sprint, Applejack galloped with his powerful earth pony strength as dozens of trees disappeared past him with how fast his thick hooves took him. He was so fast with his powerful muscles and determined gallop, it didn’t take too long for him to see Butterscotch and Rainbow Blitz flying in the air braying at each other. Applejack couldn’t hear much due to how much sound was drowned out by the force of his gallop, but he could make out sinful promises and teases from Butterscotch who was dripping with confidence of his incoming victory. Even if Applejack never ended up dominating again after Zecora officially made him zebra property, the orange farmpony was determined to have both pegasi serving him up a satisfying reward. Surging forward, seeing the cottage in sight and no longer able to see Butters and Blitz above him, Applejack’s eyes widened as he drew closer within seconds.

Just as he heard the loud screeches of the two pegasi subs, Applejack nearly crashed inside Butterscotch’s cottage as he threw the door open and stumbled forward. Feeling sweat dripping down his orange fur, gasping for air as the adrenaline started to wear off his body with the dawning realization what his victory meant, Applejack stood back up on all four hooves as he shakily turned around and saw Butterscotch and Rainbow Blitz fly back into the cottage. With Rainbow Blitz using a quick hindleg to close the door behind him, Butterscotch smirked and rolled his eyes as he pointed at the bathroom down the hallway.

“Alright Applejack, just take a quick minute showering off before sitting on the couch, we’ll be ready to serve you and show you the pleasures that a pegasus can truly offer~” Butterscotch licked his own lips, staring deep into Applejack’s eyes. Applejack gulped, obediently trotting towards the bathroom. Even with his victory over the two pegasi, Butterscotch was still calling the shots as Applejack should’ve expected. Before Applejack could voice the concern, Butterscotch continued. “And don’t worry, Applejack, this’ll just be a nice little teaser. We won’t be going all the way today.”

“Um, is there anything I could make for you while you’re in the shower?” Blitz asked, his voice considerably more feminine with the question as he pawed his own foreleg with the other forehoof, demurely looking at the ground. It was undeniably cute, and Applejack was becoming more understanding as to why Elusive had begun falling for him. Even if the orange stallion wanted to take Blitz’ place in Elusive’s eyes. That was something Applejack had no problem rivaling against Rainbow Blitz over, especially since the blue pegasus still had the carnal company of Zecora and Butterscotch no matter what. Applejack grinned as he flickered his blonde tail towards the kitchen.

“Ah’d like a tall glass of water and some snacks for when ah come out, please,” Applejack answered, and Rainbow Blitz flew to the counter right as he opened the bathroom door and made quick work of the shower in Butterscotch’s cottage. Soaping his orange pelt as well as his ponut and length, scrubbing shampoo through his mane and tail, and rinsing it all off within two minutes, Applejack turned off the shower and trotted out of the shower stall. Getting a towel and throwing it over his back, Applejack hummed a tune to himself as he subconsciously twerked his own firm apple cheeks while he started drying himself. Feeling like at least five minutes passed, sufficient time for Rainbow Blitz to fetch stuff for him and for the two to get ready, Applejack exited the bathroom and saw the two pegasi sitting on the floor right in front of the coach. Their wings were open with arousal, twitching as Blitz was blushing and Butterscotch looked to Applejack like he was a meal to be devoured. Applejack wasn’t quite sure why Butterscotch was giving him those eyes if he was supposed to be the one in charge. Feeling like he was walking into a seductive trap, not quite knowing why or what, Applejack saw that on the coffee table behind them was the tall glass of water and a tiny loaf of bread for him to keep up his energy. Trotting forward, Applejack picked up the water and chugged it down before taking a big bite of the bread beside it. Not wanting to keep his pegasi waiting any longer, Applejack sat on the couch right in between the subs waiting on the floor. He was already anticipating them sucking his dick as promised, his big dark orange length beginning to stiffen fully ready for Butterscotch and Rainbow Blitz to service him proper. Butterscotch placed his forehooves on Applejack’s hindleg as he leaned forward.

“You know, just because I said I’d be sucking your dick, doesn’t mean that you’re the one in charge~” Butterscotch showed off his teeth, two of them being those bat pony fangs that Rainbow Blitz told him about, before he lunged. Just as Applejack realized that Butterscotch planned on taking the reins no matter what, the yellow pegasus opened his mouth wide and engulfed the entirety of Applejack’s cock into his mouth and throat like it was a walk in the park. And impressively enough, none of Butterscotch’s teeth even touched besides the very subtle prick of his fangs before they stopped touching his length. With astonishing force that proved Butterscotch’s point, the yellow pegasus sucked the farmpony’s length like he was sucking a demon out of it. Applejack gasped loudly as his green eyes rolled to the back of his head, his forehooves pressing up against the couch cushions as he involuntarily bucked his hips up into the yellow pegasus’ powerful blowjob. Rainbow Blitz giggled as he moved forward, softly sucking on Applejack’s balls as a sharp contrast to the vicious delivery of the blue pegasus’ coltfriend-turned-zebra-switch. Applejack didn’t realize the diabolical plan of Butterscotch’s until it was too late, highly suspecting that the yellow pegasus allowed him to win on purpose. Butterscotch’s cyan eyes stared intently at Applejack, barely blinking as he bobbed his head up and down.

“Ah, fuck, Solaris,” Applejack groaned, feeling himself about to bust even though barely a minute had passed. Butterscotch’s blowjob technique, likely from how many times he sucked off Zecora, was mastery at its finest. Rainbow Blitz, his former rival that was dead set on beating the orange farmpony all those years ago, was eagerly sucking his balls and that was starting to do him in. The blue pegasus, once proud and mighty, was sucking his former rival’s balls on a zebra’s behalf while wearing said zebra’s stripes all over his body. Applejack moaned, feeling stars exploding in his vision as he bucked his hips fully once more and unloaded rope after rope of his hot cum down Butterscotch’s throat until his cock was thoroughly milked of his entire load. Butterscotch pulled away, licking his own fangs thoroughly before standing up on all four hooves and looking at Applejack with a big smirk.

“Well Applejack, would you say I did a good job?” Butterscotch giggled, and Applejack nodded his head really fast before the yellow pegasus could even properly finish his sentence. “Well we’re not done yet, we should show you the unique way of how we give our Master pleasure as pegasi lovers. Something that neither you or Elusive could bring to him~”

“Though Elusive does have a lot more that he could give than any of us,” Rainbow Blitz laughed, smiling fondly at mentioning the svelte unicorn as he remarked. “Literally, that is.”

Butterscotch placed his forehooves back on Applejack’s powerful orange leg again, but instead of putting his hooves or mouth on the orange farmpony’s dick, the yellow pegasus extended his long feathery wings forward. Both ends of his wings grabbed Applejack’s dick, giving the orange farmpony an entirely new sensation to savor as his cock went alight with a deep warm fuzziness that was exciting as it was relaxing as he audibly shuddered. They weren’t firm like forehooves, or as wet and hot as a mouth, but he felt light and delightful as they glided gently up and down his length as it started to get hard again. Rainbow Blitz simply watched Butterscotch’s technique with wide fuchsia eyes, sneakily extending one of his long and thin blue wings towards his own painful erection and starting to jerk himself off to the show. Butterscotch noticed out of the corner of his eye, though he didn’t really say anything. And from where Applejack was sitting, it was more than obvious. Soon enough from Butterscotch’s wingwork, Applejack was completely hard again and twitching needily for a second orgasm. That was when Butterscotch stopped using his wings and stepped back closer to the coffee table as he looked at Rainbow Blitz.

“Why don’t we have a little fun?” Butterscotch suggested using his wing to tap Rainbow Blitz and get the blushing blue pegasus’ attention as he looked to his secondary dom. “Rainbow Blitz here will do his wings on your dick, while I fuck his backdoor. And when he gets close to his own orgasm, Rainbow Blitz will do his special Sonic Wingjob to make you cum at the same time. Is that something you’re down for, Applejack?”

“Of course, ah’d love to watch this sissy at your mercy,” Applejack snickered, staring right into Rainbow Blitz’ eyes as he whined and stopped jerking off his own cock, stepping forward and placing his wings on the farmpony’s cock and started to slowly jerk him off. Butterscotch walked up behind him, digging his tongue into the rainbow-maned pegasus’ dark blue ponut and getting him to moan and whimper for a few minutes before the yellow pegasus determined he was ready. As Rainbow Blitz began to speed up his motions slightly, Butterscotch hummed as he mounted the blue pegasus and threw his forelegs over his shoulders. His smaller cock tip was pressed against Rainbow Blitz’ salivated backdoor, causing the rainbow slut to pant and move faster with his wings.

It was like a porno that Applejack got to watch while being jerked off at the same time, and admittedly it was a perfect pace to witness them in action before he got his ponut involved. Giving him an idea of what to expect, as well as Butterscotch filling him in on the scenario for his consent on the first date, made Applejack’s shoulders relax all the way as he fully trusted his dear striped friends. Butterscotch narrowed his eyes, looking more predatory like his former bat pony self as he bared his fangs and pushed all of his length inside Rainbow Blitz’ hole. Applejack was sure that since it wasn’t even half of Zecora’s monstrous length, it wasn’t anything devastating. But Rainbow Blitz’ eyes rolled to the back of his head and his tongue lolled out of his mouth all the same, making Applejack wonder how much of it was Butters’ psychological effect on him over time through his dominance. Butterscotch’s fat pegasus ass wobbled with each movement back and forth as he slowly thrusted in and out, though each time he thrusted inside his best friend, he nearly knocked Rainbow Blitz into Applejack. The orange farmpony couldn’t help but let out grunts and moans from the speedy wingjob that the panting Rainbow Blitz was starting to do. Butterscotch snarled and grunted as he plapped Blitz’ cheeks, really using faster thrusts to make up for his smaller length as his best friend was starting to lose his mind. He was speeding into an orgasm, and so Rainbow Blitz’ eyes locked onto Applejack’s as he whispered.

“I’m gonna…gonna do it now~” Rainbow Blitz gasped, managing to focus his eyes on Applejack again as he was jerking him off. Applejack didn’t need to ask what it was, as Rainbow Blitz suddenly moved his wings in an exceptionally fast blue blur that made the orange farmpony cum instantly before the blue pegasus could even cum. Applejack moaned deeply, though he knew with time Zecora would make sure his orgasms were far more feminine in the future, as ropes of his hot seed flew everywhere from the couch to onto the faces of the two pegasi facing him. Butterscotch’s eyes lit up with the impressive feat performed by Rainbow Blitz, even if he knew he could do it, and went nearly as fast as his best friend’s wings could go as he made sure he hit the blue pegasus’ p-spot hard enough. Rainbow Blitz brayed to the heavens, sounding more like a mare than a stallion, as he came all over the rug and began to clean off any cum on the cushions or Applejack’s legs that he could. Applejack groaned at what a dutiful sub Rainbow Blitz had become, though instead of using him for that, the orange farmpony took notes. Since he was no longer interested in besting Rainbow Blitz in feats of ability, the orange farmpony intended on being the better zebra sub~

Butterscotch gasped with delight as he hilted himself inside Rainbow Blitz’ cheeks during the end of his orgasm, cumming hot ropes of his own seed inside the stallion as he slumped over the lithe blue pegasus. Rainbow Blitz held strong, even though he nearly collapsed underneath the crushing weight of his slightly heavier pegasus switch. Applejack slumped over and passed out on the couch from the weight of two orgasms now, closing his eyes and feeling Butterscotch waking him up.

“Huh?” Applejack frowned as he looked at the scenery around him. “Where did Rainbow Blitz go?”

“He went back to Zecora’s hut,” Butterscotch laughed, causing Applejack to fully wake up as he jumped off the couch and trot towards the window curtains. Pushing them open and staring into the dark, Applejack glancing back at the yellow pegasus over his shoulder.

“How long was ah out for?” Applejack asked.

“A few hours, Eris came back with all the animals and I checked up on them while you rested,” Butterscotch explained. “I wanted to make sure you got back to the barn so you could meet up with Elusive tomorrow.”

“Oh it's not midnight yet?” Applejack smiled. “That’s a relief then. Lemme just wash mah face and ah’ll be on my way. And Butterscotch?”

“Yes?” Butterscotch asked as he trotted closer, causing Applejack’s heart to unexpectedly stir as he thought of their past history. Them becoming friends was nothing short of a relief, and them somehow becoming more was a miracle in itself. While not being Elusive, Butterscotch’s sweet and mischievous nature was something that Applejack had desired before the sleepover shifted his feelings in a new direction. Now? Applejack got his pick of being dommed by either Zecora or Butterscotch, so the orange stallion figured he would embrace such a change.

Pressing his muzzle against Butterscotch’s ear, Applejack spoke in a higher pitch for a change.

“I look forward to you fucking my brains out, Butterbat~” Applejack snickered, licking Butterscotch’s ear before walking over to wash his face. As soon as he walked back to Butterscotch, seeing a narrowed and hungry look in his eyes, the yellow pegasus lunged forward and locked lips with the farmpony. Tasting like vanilla and cherries, Applejack moaned into the taste and allowed Butterscotch’s tongue to enter his mouth and dance inside it before the yellow pegasus pulled away and led him to the door.

“Goodnight, Applejack,” Butterscotch said, and as Applejack was walking off into the night, the yellow pegasus continued. “And I look forward to taking up your offer soon enough~”

Building and Breaking the Farmpony

Author's Note

Sex Scene Participants: Zecora/Applejack/Elusive
Contains: romantic dinner date, brief depiction of implied racism, gay threesome, loss of virginity (bottoming), making out, frottage, 69 position, doggy style, missionary, mild "cucking" fantasy, anal, blowjobs, ball-sucking, rimming, blindfolds, light bondage, creampie, cumshot, and confession of love!

Building and Breaking the Farmpony

The moonlight fluttered in from the window of Applejack’s room, causing the orange farmpony’s eyes to flutter open with the pounding of his heart and the warmth of years longing finally about to come to a proper payoff. Most of the day was spent bucking apples and making sure the barn chores were taken care of, and after a long shower, the muscular earth pony had taken a long nap so that he’d be rested and energized for the date that he was looking forward to the most. Elusive, in all his svelte glory and charismatic charm, would be showing up to take him on a special one-on-one date fitting for the Element of Generosity. He highly suspected that unlike the other two dates before, Elusive was far more likely to take him out and about given how flashy the stallion was. Applejack couldn’t have rolled out of bed quickly enough as the orange stallion stumbled into the bathroom as he overheard his family in the kitchen.

“Hey Applejack, did you want some apple pie before you left?” Big Mae asked, though unaware of the truth of why he was going out with Elusive. Applejack didn’t want to spoil his appetite, or worse yet, throw up with the jitters of being around that silky stallion. Turning around, Applejack spoke up.

“No thanks, ah’ll just get ready,” Applejack felt his heart starting to float even more than before, wondering if his family would question him dressing up more than usual, even if they saw him but for a mere few seconds before he trotted out the door. Getting out the brush that Elusive got for him, Applejack smoothened out all the knots in his blonde mane before getting out a perfume that his big sister often used. Spraying the candy apple scent over himself and placing it back in the exact position that it was at before just in case, Applejack then attached a dark purple bow to his hat as he took a deep breath and stared at himself in the mirror. Being satisfied with the finishing touches to himself, Applejack exited the bathroom and trotted back to his room. He knew that if he had walked out and waited at the same table as he family, he would very well risk them catching on to how differently he felt. Heart pounding, blushing through his orange fur, and tapping his hoof a lot more than usual, Applejack longed to be honest with his family more than he already was. Fortunately, only a couple minutes passed of him sitting on the corner of his bed before a loud doorbell ring caused his ears to perk up from his blonde mane as he jumped up from his bed and galloped to the door. The sudden realization of his enthusiasm caused his ears to burn on top of the rest of his body, though his family who was right behind him didn’t say anything much to his relief. Opening the door and closing it behind him without another thought, Applejack became glad that he did when he surveyed Elusive properly.

Standing at the porch with a bouquet of red roses, and wearing a tuxedo, his family would’ve instantly known about everything as soon as they saw Elusive’s getup. Though the fear of getting caught was instantly replaced with processing the svelte femcolt’s look, he was dressed up like this for Applejack. The orange farmpony felt himself thrilled beyond belief, his heart warming up with unashamed delight as he stepped forward and stopped caring if anypony in the barn saw him with Elusive, stripes and all. Trotting forward, taking the bouquet in his orange foreleg, Elusive looked down coyly before looking back up at Applejack while fluttering his eyelashes.

“I don’t suppose you’re hiding anything from them, are you?” Elusive giggled. “Normally I would be more careful about this, but Applejack? You’ve always been proud about your honesty. Are you going to compromise that now of all times?”

Elusive spoke testingly, not with anger or frustration, but with confidence as his piercing blue eyes remained on Applejack. The orange farmpony felt that very certainty rubbing off on him in face of disappointing the family name, of that he had never stopped being a true Apple and that pursuing something for himself wouldn’t make that stop. Feeling a fire under his ass that he’d never felt before, Applejack took a deep breath as his nervousness faded into nothing. Turning around and opening the door, all four ponies at the kitchen table gasped at the bouquet of flowers in Applejack’s foreleg as he rushed past them and got a vase full of water.

“Applejack? Are ya goin’ out on a date?”

“Is that what ya doin’ with Elusive? Does that mean…?”

“Is Zecora going to be there???”

Applejack took the red roses and placed them in the vase, before leaving them on the counter. He stopped and looked at Grandpa Smith, the frail green stallion giving him a look of ire that was arguably more telling than words. Big Mae, her twink coltfriend, and Apple Buck looked at Applejack and his newfound happiness with their eyes wide and jaws dropped but their muzzles uplifted in partial smiles. The affirmation that he needed more than anything, as his bubbly smile came through with a small nod he gave to them.

“Yes, ah’m going out with Elusive on a date,” Applejack nodded. “Ah’ve been going on dates with the rest of the herd as well.”

“That’s beautiful, Applejack,” Sugar Beau remarked, with his older sister giving a stoic nod. Apple Buck, who absolutely loved Zecora to bits, was bouncing in chair when Grandpa Smith opened his mouth. Applejack thought to his dead parents, feeling them speaking gently in his mind.

We love you, he didn’t approve of us either.

You don’t need to stay for what’s about to happen, honey. We love you.

Steeling his resolve, and burning his green gaze on Grandpa Smith with no compromise, Applejack turned around and walked out the door.

“If ya don’t think I’m going to throw away those flo-”

SLAM!

Applejack yanked the door closed as hard as possible with a tug from his blonde tail, trotting fast with intention of leaving as quickly as possible, but not full-on galloping as he had no interest in spending the rest of the evening in fear. Elusive following him, his blue eyes wide and his mouth partially hanging open as he barely managed to catch up with the orange stallion.

“Darling, you certainly didn’t need to do that!” Elusive sputtered. “I just figured you were going to tell them and leave.”

“Ya, ah did,” Applejack shrugged. “Only reason ah slammed the door was because Grandpa Smith began yelling about it, but the rest of the family approved. So that’s good enough for me.”

“Oh,” Elusive’s ears flattened against his glittering dark purple mane, as he slowly looked away before looking back at Applejack. “Did you want to resch-oh!”

Before Elusive could further express worry for his date, Applejack smirked as he swatted the svelte unicorn’s diamond cutie marks with his big and blonde tail as hard as he could, which wasn’t really that hard. Still, Elusive’s snow white cheeks exploded with red brightness and surprise as he looked at Applejack.

“Stop worrying, sugarcube,” Applejack assured the striped unicorn. “Ya know me well enough by now to know that ah would tell you if ah was upset. It’s disappointin’, sure, but it certainly beats the whole family disapproving. Ah don’t think ah’d be able to continue if they all were angry about it.”

“That’s fair, sorry,” Elusive laughed, leaning his body against Applejack’s muscular body as they trotted out of Sweet Apple Acres and into Ponyville as Artemis’ moon and twinkling stars hung over the two of them. “At least my date is an exciting one, I would like to say. I made sure of that.”

“Well, could you give me a hint?” Applejack beamed as he looked down at the unicorn femcolt gently shaking his head with a tsk.

“Where would be the fun in that?” Elusive quipped.

Applejack felt his heart fluttering with bubbly warmth in his sturdy chest, everything playing out essentially how he’d imagined it. Elusive all dressed up, with the big orange stallion following him for the fancy femcolt’s ideas of fun and splendor while Applejack eagerly followed along despite not understanding most of it. Their differences were as foreign as they were thrilling, and Applejack was all too happy to follow Elusive to the center of Ponyville where twinkling lights of pastel yellow, pink and green decorated the roofs of the buildings while the open space was filled with small stands for the local businesses that were selling various products around Ponyville Square. Since the Apple family had more than enough money thanks to Zecora, it was an event that Applejack vaguely heard about but knew they weren’t going to host their own stand due to lack of necessity. They were still shipping various packages of uniquely-flavored apples for a long waitlist from Ponyville alone, let alone several of the neighboring towns and cities. Applejack was relieved for it all, much rather being the one to enjoy the random treats and knick-knacks rather than having to bust his ass just to have the hope of selling enough apples if they were lucky.

Elusive saw as Applejack stopped to stare at the sights, and nudged the orange farmpony’s shoulder to get his attention.

“I take it you really like the surprise?” Elusive asked, quietly smiling at Applejack before the orange farmpony grinned openly down at the femcolt.

“Do ah?!” Applejack giggled, his country twang emphasized by his bubbling enthusiasm as his limbs shook with restraint. “There’s so many different items ah could get! Cause well…um…”

“You can say it, darling.”

“Ah’ve never been to a business fair as a customer before, not as an adult at least.”

“Yes, I could’ve guessed that,” Elusive sighed, giving a withering glance over his shoulder back in the direction of the barn before looking back to Applejack as he put his forehoof inside of his tuxedo for a few shuffling moments before taking out a hoofful of bits and slapping it into Applejack’s extended forehoof. “Don’t turn it down, darling, that’s just a fraction of Zecora’s bits from hosting that sex show back in Canterlot. Not even a tenth, actually.”

Applejack clamped his mouth shut, the swelling pride of refusing somepony else’s bits vanishing entirely from Elusive’s well-timed explanation. Nodding and trotting to the first stand that demanded his attention, a cotton candy stand, Applejack galloped the rest of the distance there and pointed at the sky blue cotton candy next to the shopkeeper.

“Ah’d like that flavor, pretty please,” Applejack asked, turning and looking at Elusive as the svelte femcolt trotted up to the farmpony while the shopkeeper started spinning the cotton candy for him. The unicorn leaned against Applejack, waiting for the pony to hoof him the blue cotton candy before he looked at Elusive.

“The pink one,” Elusive nodded in the direction of the other flavor, watching as the pony went back to spinning a new flavor of cotton candy before turning to look at Applejack. “Don’t load up on too many sweets, though. I’ll be taking you out to dinner to a fancy Canterlot-like restaurant across the street, but nothing like the old Canterlot establishments. This one opened shortly after Saffron Masala got his restaurant’s business booming again.”

“Oh thank Solaris for that,” Applejack remarked, watching as Elusive got his cotton candy and the two trotted along the fair and looked to the different stands that sold different items. Stuffed animals, jars, cups, necklaces. Applejack obviously had a decent portion of bits underneath his hat, wanting to be able to treat Elusive before Zecora’s bits made such an act unnecessary. But now, as they were looking at the necklaces and various jewelry offered by an older mare that was beaming at the two wide and carefree of any of the world’s worries, Applejack settled his green gaze on a slightly expensive diamond necklace. Even if Elusive covered everything else including the dinner, Applejack felt his heart glowing with the certainty of his decision. Walking up to the older mare and opening his hat, Applejack placed a lot of bits on the glass counter gently as he smiled down at the older unicorn mare.

“For the diamond necklace, please and thank you,” Applejack nodded in the direction of the item, even though the shopkeeper was already skipping over there with the item being one of its kind. Elusive, barely having heard the transaction, gasped as he saw the shopkeeper taking out the necklace from the display case and bringing it towards the muscular farmpony.

“Darling, that’s too much!” Elusive gawked, though Applejack saw that tell-tale mini blush like that of a mare getting proposed to. That restrained enthusiasm that told more to the Element of Honesty than anything else.

“Oh hush now,” Applejack chuckled. “Such a paragon of grace and fashion deserves such a gift. And ah know that Zecora is going to be your stud, as am ah happily. But if nothing else, you’re the one that ah’ve loved the most and the longest, and not just romantically or sexually. You’ve been the perfect opposite to me, Elusive, in all the right ways. And it brought out the best in me. Of course, we’ll grow to learn and love other ponies and develop our own relationships with them, but ah’ll always have you as the last pony on mah mind before ah fall asleep. That ah promise.”

“Applejack~” Elusive whispered, his eyes watering with tears as he felt the longing of throwing his smaller unicorn body against the orange-furred powerhouse. He stood still as patiently as he could, watching as Applejack took the diamond necklace from the older mare and walked towards Elusive. He moved around, placing the necklace around Elusive’s necklace with surprising gentleness considering the big farmpony’s rough forehooves. On top of that, Elusive felt an electric excitement he didn’t expect from Applejack’s hooves touching his neck, the farmpony’s hot breath gently tickling his snow white fur and turning into a foreplay in its own right with how sensual the feeling was. Elusive looked to the shopkeeper, who was clapping her forehooves in celebration quietly as to not disturb the moment between the two stallions, and then to the inevitable hoofful of locals trying to look away and not stare at the perplexing sight of a striped Element of Harmony being romanced by another non-striped one. If Elusive had to guess, one of these ponies would blab to the press and the headlines would rear their ugly heads.

Though, perhaps Elusive was proud to be part of Zecora’s influenced herd even if most of what they said was true.

“This is so beautiful,” Elusive whispered, bringing a forehoof to his new diamond necklace as he thought to his previous dreams of being taken by a stallion of rich or royal regard in Canterlot. That if he did so, he would get everything that he wanted and more. Never did he think in a million years that taking on a zebra dom with a growing herd of his own best friends, would give him exactly that. The universe had a funny way of working everything out for him, and especially Applejack too, as despite their years of not saying anything and Zecora getting involved, they found themselves on a date. Applejack placed his hat with the rest of the bits back on his head.

“Well,” Applejack shrugged, his coy little smile on his muzzle as he kept staring at Elusive. “Not as beautiful as you, of course.”

“You flatter me so,” Elusive giggled. “Well, is there anything else you want to look at before we go to the restaurant?”

“Nah, ah’m ready to sit down with ya,” Applejack grinned wide, trotting away from the stand and slowing down so that Elusive could trot ahead of him and towards the unknown restaurant. The twinkling lights disappeared as they had long since finished their cotton candy and left with the diamond necklace on Elusive’s neck as a memento for their time at the business fair…

“This food is simply divine, wouldn’t you say darling?”

Elusive stared at Applejack, who was humming in agreement as he had finished his food in the pristine restaurant that had white tablecloths and plates, as well as a chandelier nearby that really emphasized the aesthetic. The food portions, thanks once again to Saffron, were a far cry from the nibbles that would’ve likely left them both dissatisfied as they had both ordered generously portioned salads. They had spent time talking about Zecora and the herd, and Applejack finished wiping his muzzle with the napkin before looking to Elusive.

“Sugarcube, there’s a question ah do want to ask,” Applejack spoke up, gaining Elusive’s attention with a pinch of nervousness flickering in his brain. “Did you only start to have feelings for me after ah told you how ah felt? Ah’m no fool, and ah’m certainly not angry either, but ya didn’t act like ah did falling hard for you. Ah don’t know if it’s simply because you were distracted with your career, or if ya wanted somepony else before Zecora came into the picture.”

“Oh dear,” Elusive laughed, though Applejack’s expression remained blank as he refrained from judgment till he got his answer. The femcolt’s heart started pounding as he had already known Applejack to be this perceptive, but had no idea when he was going to push this out into the open, let alone in a public restaurant. “Well, remember the sleepover that Dusk Shine invited us over to when we were at each other’s throats years ago?”

“Of course! That’s when ah really started to want ya,” Applejack nodded with his honest-clad certainty, which made Elusive wince as he looked down at his empty plate.

“Well, I had started to find myself fancying Dusk Shine that day forward,” Elusive admitted, willing himself to stare into Applejack’s widened eyes. “Neither of us could’ve known that Dusk would become an alicorn like Solaris and Artemis, but he had that authoritative energy about him in his determination to support his friendships. It’s no wonder he became the Prince of Friendship! And when he had become an alicorn, it confirmed my growing suspicions of the stallion he was meant to be. And I couldn’t stop thinking about him, though with each day he focused more and more on Equestria and less on himself, I realized that it was a hopeless endeavor. I don’t think anypony could get to him.”

“No, ah don’t think so either,” Applejack briefly pushed his seething jealousy aside to remind himself that they were thinking of Dusk here, somepony that they both cared deeply for as a friend despite anything else. Thinking back to the sleepover, Applejack groaned as he buried his face in his forehooves. “Ah was a real hardass then, wasn’t ah?”

“Maybe, but I was pretty arrogant and still hoping for a royal Prince to sweep me away from here, pretty selfish for an Element of Generosity,” Elusive sighed with a small smile, waiting for Applejack to place his forehooves back on the table to place his dainty unicorn hoof on the farmpony’s big hoof as they looked into each other’s eyes. “We were so caught up in everything else, in vain hopes of what could be, instead of focusing on what we could actually have. And even after I’ve admitted probably the most disappointing news you’ve heard tonight, you still wish to be an official member of the herd?”

“Yeah, ah definitely do,” Applejack grinned, moving out of his chair since the bill was already paid for. Elusive did the same, and he had thrown his foreleg around the orange farmpony and acted swiftly. Using a magic spell to bring them to Zecora’s hut in the Everfree forest, Applejack’s eyes went wide as he looked left to right. Could Elusive really be suggesting…?

“Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch aren’t in there, darling,” Elusive reassured him, and Applejack let out a deep exhale of relief that he didn’t realize that he was holding in. “And Zecora is out on errands, though I will be forthcoming and say that he’ll be back soon. Though I don’t know when, think you can handle both of us?”

“Ah’m a big stallion,” Applejack pushed the door open, the two entering the hut with Elusive swiftly closing the door behind him with his magic while Applejack was facing away from him. Slowly, Applejack turned around and spoke again. “So, what did you-mmph!”

Applejack’s senses went alight with deep hunger and excitement rushing from his brain down to his powerful limbs and especially his hardening length. Elusive had moved faster than Rainbow Blitz during his former Wonderbolts practices, rushing forth in a white and purple blur as his lips pressed against the farmpony’s lips with eager passion. Applejack took a few seconds to process it, but closed his eyes and slipped his tongue in as he savored his first kiss with Elusive and the mental fireworks that played out in his brain as a result. To say it was what he’d hoped for was an understatement, and Applejack moved his heavy forelegs to gently rest on the femcolt’s shoulders until Elusive suddenly pulled away from making out with the orange farmpony.

“Well, even if we can’t quite top each other like Zecora could…” Elusive giggled, looking over Applejack’s shoulder and at the bedroom that normally carried many orgies and various other forms of zebradom bliss. “I would still like us to explore each other’s bodies, become very familiar with one another~”

“Ah would love that~” Applejack agreed, placing his signature hat on the table as he knew that Elusive and eventually Zecora’s treatment of him would probably leave him cum drunk at the very least. Probably passed out. All he was certain was, and that Elusive knew as well, was the orange farmpony was ready to go all the way with both the unicorn femcolt and Zecora. Maybe, Applejack thought with perverse delight, he would get to see Zecora fuck Elusive in front of him and assert who was the true stud of the two. Not that Applejack was genuinely competing, of course.

Trotting to the bedroom, seeing that it was as empty as Elusive promised, Applejack went up to the foot of the bed as he threw his forelegs over it and moved his hindlegs apart. Moving his big blonde tail out of the way and to the side, the orange farmpony looked over his shoulder smirking at Elusive as he was blatantly showing off his dark orange ponut and heavy balls while shaking his firm ass cheeks.

“Don’t ya think ah should be warmed up if ah’m going to take zebra dick for the first time?” Applejack teased, though he was feeling a nervousness starting to come to life with the daunting task laid before him. Thinking of how strong Zecora’s monstrous length was going to be, Applejack blushed and added. “Though please use more than just your tongue, ah’d love to make sure ah’m actually ready for mah new Master…”

“I thought you’d never ask, darling~” Elusive fluttered his eyelashes at his newest fellow sub, trotting over and laying on the floor as he brought his face at eye level with Applejack’s backdoor. Inhaling it was nearly his undoing, blowing any expectations out of the water from previously rimming the pegasi subs’ backdoors dozens of times. That sweet and musky apple scent was intoxicating, and Elusive would’ve completely caved had he been a dom. Though, he had no interest in giving the reins to anypony else besides Zecora, so Elusive enjoyed Applejack in the way he was good at. Opening his mouth and bringing his tongue out, Elusive savored that gentle shiver and gasp from touching the outer rim of Applejack’s ponut and getting the true apple cider ponut that nopony else outside of the herd was able to have. And in that moment, Elusive owned Applejack’s ponut and nopony else. Likely it was probably the first time that any stallion had licked Applejack there, and Elusive was profoundly honored to be the first if it was true.

As Elusive stopped simply rimming his ponut and dove his tongue inside, he suddenly thought to the zebra stud that would be arriving in the bedroom anytime now. If Zecora ended up keeping Applejack both in the hut regularly as well as a full member of the herd, Elusive knew that they were going to have to make renovations to the small hut that was physically meant for a bachelor. On top of that, Elusive also thought about when Zecora whispered in his ear that he was falling for him on stage. It had only been a few weeks since that had happened, and they hadn’t talked about it. Sure it was way too soon for Zecora to be saying it to Applejack, but Elusive felt a yearning in his heart as he longed to hear those words from both stallions that he was going to be hooking up with.

Of course, true to his promise, Elusive didn’t just use his tongue. Slipping his tongue out of Applejack’s mouth and lighting up magic from his horn with a deep smirk that the orange farmpony wasn’t privy to, Elusive created a magical dildo made of light purple light as he had slipped it inside of Applejack. Granted it wasn’t nearly as thick as Zecora and his exotic and erotic length, but it would certainly prepare Applejack better than not being filled out at all. Plunging it inside his well-lubed backdoor, Applejack gasped at Elusive preparing him. Love blossomed from his heart at the idea of being prepared by the pony he most deeply cherished, and lust followed suit as he imagined Zecora and his rippling zebra figure. Applejack felt that physically intrusive yet perfect sensation of the magical toy inside of him as he kept his hindlegs still and felt his eyes roll to the back of his head.

“Gah~” Applejack blushed harder at the sudden sound that escaped his lips, another lapse of his masculinity. Though with each day he was submitting to becoming one with the herd, it became more of a relief. Better to leave it to the zebra stallion that knew his sense of studliness naturally than to try and take on hopeless delusions. The Element of Honesty needed to be such, and if being dominated by a powerful stallion would help him be true to his Element, then so be it.

“Do you like that, darling?” Elusive giggled as he had slipped in five inches of the dildo, and with jarring shock and joy, Applejack realized that this was the first object that he had inside of him. His first dick in his ass was always going to be Zecora, without a shadow of a doubt. But Elusive being the first one to play with his ponut entirely shook him down to his apple core as the toy of magic hit his p-spot and made his dark orange cock fully hard. Eventually, the entire toy was hilted inside of him, only a vague sense of glitter indicating that anything was inside the orange farmpony at all. Applejack nodded as if Elusive was going to make the toy disappear any second, and the unicorn giggled as he slowly pulled out the toy until only the tip of the magical object of light was inside, before swiftly slipping it back in.

“Very good, darling, you’re doing a fantastic job,” Elusive smiled as he continued guiding the muscular farmpony. “I’ve already assumed that you’ve never had something inside of your backdoor before, and lots of ponies wouldn’t be able to take eight inches on the first go. Goodness, if you can take this, Zecora shouldn’t be a problem.”

Applejack whined, though not with pain, as he felt hot beads of pre-cum dripping from his twitching length as the toy hitting his p-spot over and over again was breaking his carefully crafted image. His tongue lolled out of his mouth, his loins were fired up as he was breaking past the barriers of restraint. Years and years of remaining true to his family, to his friends, in order to do right by them. And he was wasting years of his life not enjoying real pleasure as a result. Applejack even allowed himself to be dirty in a different way, bucking his hips back and forth into what Elusive was doing, so that he could further embrace everything he was feeling. Elusive stared at Applejack’s ponut, watching his purple magic slip in and out faster and breaking the once proud farmpony. Rainbow Blitz was quick to fall, and it was no surprise that Applejack being so similar to him would eventually follow. After several long minutes of stretching out Applejack’s hole enough to comfortably fit at least some of Zecora’s dick, Elusive’s magic stopped and the toy dissipated into glittering light.

“You already know that we’re going to be cumming more than once, even if Zecora has to give us potions to keep our stamina going~” Elusive began saying, causing Applejack to step off the bed and turn around to face the unicorn as the farmpony was so very close to having finished. “So why don’t we properly have a challenge of some sorts? Zecora might just not care for the winner, since he is the Master after all, but why don’t we suck each other both off and the stallion that lasts longer gets a turn with him first?”

“But you nearly made me cum just now, how is that fair?” Applejack pouted, though he couldn’t actually bring himself to be mad, not when he still found himself eager to eventually see Elusive be taken by Zecora in front of him. Elusive smiled back at his pathetic attempt at a scowl, and Applejack’s firm face broke as he grinned. “Yah, you may be full of tricks, but ah sucked Zecora’s dick pretty good the other day. Ah’d like to say the first time is plenty of experience and that you’ll lose~”

“Really, you think you can lose to a blowjob slut that is a unicorn?” Elusive mock-scoffed, placing a forehoof against his silky chest as he started to get hard himself from Applejack’s sudden shift of brazen confidence. Even though Applejack and Rainbow Blitz were strikingly alike considering how many times they butted heads, Elusive didn’t realize how much the former actually was a powerhouse while Rainbow Blitz merely pretended to be one. Applejack took a lot more effort to “break” and Elusive knew that Zecora would be up to the challenge when it happened later. Applejack didn’t falter, slowly nodding his head as he jumped onto Zecora’s bed and laid on his back as he splayed out his hindlegs and showed off his musky length. Elusive took a deep inhale, the sweet apple scent nearly being his undoing right then and there as he was gobsmacked at how effective Applejack’s mere teasing was. It was no surprise that he considered himself to be a dom so long, though Elusive trotted onto the bed as he stood over the farmpony’s face and dangled his dark gray length over Applejack’s muzzle.

Lowering himself, Elusive gasped and let out a moan as he felt Applejack’s mouth slobbering all over his full cum-tanks full of seed at the ready. Normally his dick had been reverted to a clit thanks to Zecora and Butterscotch’s regular use of his backdoor, but this time, Elusive could feel a sense of enjoyment of using it as intended as Applejack took in half his length into his mouth. Not one to lose a challenge, and knowing that Applejack was painfully close before he had abruptly stopped, Elusive lurched forward and inhaled all of Applejack’s length in one go. Having taken much more from Zecora, Elusive swirled his tongue and only used his magic to make it reasonably comfortable to have Applejack’s length down his throat. He moved his mouth up and down swiftly, half-hoping for Applejack to cum his sweet fruity seed right off the bat, but the orange farmpony merely groaned before matching Elusive’s pace. The two had a stunning date to say the very least, and now they were sucking each other off like young stallions on prom night. Their quick step from friendship into romantic debauchery was truly a testament to how perfect they were together, and Applejack shuddered as Elusive began fucking his face with eager excitement while the two competed in earnest.

The two heard somepony close the front door in the main room, and they only moved faster in their horny anticipation of Zecora coming into the bedroom. They had never bothered to close the door, and so they heard those heavy hoofsteps coming closer as they heard the tell-tale shuffle of a grocery bag of sorts. While Applejack couldn’t see anypony entering the room thanks to Elusive’s ass eclipsing his entire view, the svelte unicorn looked as Zecora in his striped glory entered the room. And then the white and black unicorn’s eyes landed on the brand that was on Zecora’s bag. It was the sex shop that Zecora frequented whenever he felt some inspiration to further lock his subs in Zebrican bliss, and with his intense gaze on Elusive as he stepped into the room, the unicorn femcolt shuddered with a quivering moan as he came down Applejack’s throat. Just the sight of Zecora ready to pound them both into quivering messes was enough to completely annihilate Elusive’s restraint as he felt Applejack gulping each load of his. Zecora set the bag down on the floor as he waited for Elusive to finish cumming before the unicorn shakily got off the bed with a heavy red blush.

“Ahn, fuck me, we were having a contest to see who would get to be fucked by you first,” Elusive explained, his dainty limbs quivering with each step as he awaited Zecora’s response. “Pardon my language, Master, though I suppose it mattered little since you probably wanted to get started on taking Applejack.”

“That depends on him,” Zecora looked to Applejack as he slowly got off the bed to stand beside Elusive, the two body types night and day even though the zebra stud would conquer them both all the same. “Is this farmpony ready to give his ponut virginity to a zebra on a whim?”

“Certainly wouldn’t be a whim, Master,” Applejack let the word slip before he could stop himself. “Ah’ve been thinking over everything as the dates go by, considering how life-changin’ it’ll be for the rest of mah life. And you’ve been such a sweet stud, ah wouldn’t want to choose anypony else to take my backdoor except for you~”

Applejack and Elusive looked at each other knowingly without having to say a word, and the two turned around to present their asses to Zecora as they parted their tails to the sides and twerked for their new mutually shared Master. While Butterscotch was the one truly with the fattest cake of his subs, Applejack and Elusive were delightfully delicious in their own right. The orange pony’s ass was clearly bigger considering the earth pony’s stark size difference in both weight and height, though Zecora knew from plenty of experiences that Elusive’s rear was more silky and durable. As Zecora looked at Applejack’s dark orange ponut that he couldn’t get off his mind, and Elusive’s dark gray ponut that he delighted in filling many times, the two subs looked over their shoulders to look at Zecora with half-lidded eyes and deep blushes before they looked to each other. They moved forward, locking lips and swapping spit as their tongues engaged in their fiery dance for their Master as they both closed their eyes. Applejack still hadn’t cum, and he was losing his mind on just how good it felt to submit to the desires of this zebra stud. As he felt Zecora’s heavy body mount him with no more patience to wait, feeling his thick tip pressing against the farmpony’s ponut, Elusive’s magic activated as he massaged the back of Applejack’s neck to give him a sense of comfort for the pressure of zebra dick that was about to enter his body. Applejack’s eyes shot wide as he felt Zecora’s bitchbreaker penetrate his backdoor, feeling inch after inch very slowly enter his body out of respect for it being the farmpony’s first time receiving.

“Mmmmmph,” Applejack moaned into Elusive’s mouth, his eyes rolling to the back of his head as he was surprised at how well he was able to take it. Zecora’s steadiness as well as Elusive’s sensual touch made the difficult feat more than manageable, and the zebra stud managed to get just over half his length inside. Had he not been hornier than a sex addict having withdrawls, Applejack might’ve gotten into a proper missionary position like to be expected for a first time with a lover. But their situation was far from normal, so having Zecora mount him with his chest pressing against the foot of the bed while he was making out with Elusive felt like a fitting climax to the situation.

Then, Zecora pulled out most of his length until only the tip was inside, and surged forward with a hard thrust. Seeing stars, Applejack brayed into Elusive’s mouth as he felt the most intense and pleasurable sensation in his life, a feeling that nearly made him buckle and fall over. His limbs shook, his body shuddered, and he nearly blacked out to the pure bliss of getting pleasure beyond what he thought was possible. He came a few ropes of apple seed all over the bottom of the bed and onto the floor as Elusive pulled away briefly to give him a chance to breathe during the orgasm, though after a couple of gasps for air from Applejack, the mischievous unicorn femcolt giggled before locking lips with the orange farmpony again.

“Of course the apple of my eye came with speed, now to show you your true submissive need~” Zecora growled, and Applejack was in awe of how much his buddy-ol-pal was replaced with the savage sex beast that had conquered half of his best friends. While Applejack loved every part of him, he couldn’t pretend that he wasn’t started to become addicted to the heavier weight on him or the unapologetic dominance that Zecora had to offer. Pulling out most of his length again, Zecora thrusted into Applejack again and started jackhammering over half his length inside the orange farmpony like this wasn’t the first time they fucked. Applejack was no longer able to makeout with Elusive, bucking up onto the bed halfway as he rested his forehooves on the bed for dear life from how intense the fucking was. He barely got a respite of his dick getting hard again before he was diving helplessly into a second orgasm with his normally deeper voice breaking an octave higher with the further destruction of his former masculinity, of his dominance, as he gave it all up to serve as a proper slave for his Master.

“Goodness, darling~!” Elusive laughed, knowing that any sort of “shame” Applejack would’ve felt from the gesture would’ve only served to turn him on even more. Leaning forward and smirking widely, Elusive continued. “I don’t even think I came that much the first time Zecora and Butterscotch penetrated me at the same time~”

Applejack’s eyes widened at the image, the zebra stud and his switch using Elusive as they wanted while the orange stallion was still helplessly pining away for a possible chance to date the unicorn femcolt. By Solaris’ sun butt, Applejack didn’t understand why the idea of being surpassed by them turned him on so much. Perhaps instead of being broken over Elusive not exactly choosing him, Applejack preferred to be turned on instead. To submit and give up the fruitless fight, especially when such a powerful stud was fucking him senseless so much that he could barely think straight.

“Take a deep breath and then some, for I’m about to cum,” Zecora grunted, his fat zebra balls slapping against Applejack’s smaller dark orange balls and putting the earth pony in his rightful place. Applejack shuddered and gasped, feeling the world spinning in profound pleasure as he came a third time the moment that Zecora sharply hilted his entire length inside of him, the feat possible from Elusive’s last-minute spell to adjust Applejack’s backdoor to take the last four inches. Applejack brayed, bucking his hips rapidly back and forth before passing out against the bed, his hindlegs dangling over the bed as Zecora slipped out his foot of zebra dick with a deep smirk as he looked to Elusive.

“Making you my sub has been such a treat in a shorter amount of time than I’ve dated my pegasi, though if they asked I might tell a lie,” Zecora admitted, glancing at Applejack to see if he’d heard the statement before looking to Elusive again. “Bringing our herd to the news as well as encouraging Blitz to quit his Wonderbolt team, and then helping Applejack realize his suppressed subby dream. Do you remember what I whispered right before I fucked you on stage?”

“You know I didn’t forget~” Elusive nodded, his heart fluttering inside of his chest as Zecora’s sonorous words of praise tickled him fancy. And even more excitement rushed through him, though a pang of worry surfaced in the back of his mind with what Zecora was about to say. It took half a year for Zecora to tell Rainbow Blitz and Butterscotch that he loved them both from what Elusive had heard, and he hadn’t even dated the zebra stud for that long! Though, he knew that the two pegasi had fallen for Elusive just as much, and so the white unicorn steadied his brief panic as he fluttered his eyelashes at Zecora. “So maybe you should cut to the chase so I don’t fret~”

“Rhyming like a true zebra mare,” Zecora stepped towards the silky unicorn, cupping his muzzle and lifting his face to look into his cyan eyes as he grinned. “Should I dare?”

“Yes, you absolutely should,” Elusive practically begged, his heart racing inside of his chest as he felt more alive in that bedroom than ever before.

“I love you, Elusive,” Zecora confessed, and the big zebra stud lurched forward and pressed his lips against his unicorn sub’s dainty lips hard enough to nearly knock the femcolt over. The silky unicorn felt like his heart was on fire, the validation of their entire relationship thus far sparking a flame inside of him. Zecora’s much bigger tongue plunged into his smaller muzzle, nearly taking Elusive’s breath away were it not for him learning to breathe frequently through his nostrils. Zecora pulled away after a few seconds, gesturing his head towards the side of the bed that Applejack wasn’t leaning against.

“While we give Applejack time to recover, why don’t you lay on there and show you that you’re my lover~” Zecora gently ordered the unicorn, watching as Elusive jumped on the empty side of the bed and barely made a sound as he did so. The svelte femcolt was practically light as a feather and a feast for the eyes as he laid on his back and splayed out his hindlegs, showing off his dark gray ponut and lighting up a magic spell to properly lubricate his backdoor. Zecora trotted over to Elusive’s side of the bed, steadily getting hard again as he got onto the bed and stood his lumbering zebra figure over the unicorn as he pressed his fat bitchbreaker against the much smaller length of his diamond-flanked sub. The two frotted as the motion helped Zecora get harder with each movement back and forth, the zebra stud smirking as he stopped after a few minutes, pressing the tip of his powerful length against Elusive’s ponut. Zecora didn’t have to hold back, or have a brief moment of worry, as he knew that Elusive was incredibly durable and skilled with his endurance. Penetrating Elusive, Zecora stared intently at his unicorn sub’s contorted face of pleasure as his eyes rolled to the back of his head and he had bit his lip.

“There you go, you never fail to give me a good show~” Zecora chuckled, pushing forward as inch after inch of his length stretched out Elusive’s backdoor once more. On that beautiful cutie mark that was striped onto Elusive’s stomach was the imprint of Zecora’s dick, the unicorn femcolt looking down at it in awe in the moments it existed before it disappeared as his Master began pulling out most of his length until only the tip was inside. Elusive thought back to everything, when he engaged in an orgy with the throuple months ago for the first time, when he was striped in Canterlot and then fucked on stage. And now here he was, making love to Zecora after he had conquered his best friend-turned-lover. Elusive savored the present moment as Zecora began properly plapping his unicorn’s cheeks, the zebra’s balls slapping his sub’s ass over and over again as warmth took over. Elusive felt the intense fullness of getting fucked by Zecora, moaning and sighing as he felt himself starting to reach a breaking point. Zecora kept hitting his p-spot, not an hour after confessing that he was in love with the unicorn, and Elusive didn’t want it any other way. Glancing over at Applejack’s closed eyes, gentle breathing, and drool spilling out of his open muzzle, Elusive began to whine louder as Zecora truly made him his bitch. His Zebrican thrusts sped up into closer to that of a blur, and Elusive couldn’t take it anymore as he brayed. With his loud orgasmic cry, Zecora lunged forward and pressed his lips against Elusive’s lips as they made out while the unicorn’s ropes of pathetic seed coated both his own stomach fur and Zecora’s chest fur.

Zecora didn’t take too long to finally hilt himself, grunting as he had his balls against Elusive’s ass and unloaded another bountiful load of zebra cum into Elusive’s ass. Shortly after he finished doing so, Zecora pulled out all of his length and stepped off the bed to look over his work with a big smirk. There Elusive was laying on his back from the missionary position, cum dripping out of his dark gray ponut, as well as the normally masculine powerhouse Applejack, slumped against the bed from the doggy style position that he was spontaneously taken in because of how truly worked up they both were from the mounting sexual tension that had built. Cum seeped out of his dark orange ponut as well, and his blonde tail was off to the side as he had his ass on full display.

Smiling wide, Zecora turned around and walked out of his room. He certainly wasn’t done with the two of them, not by a long shot, though he knew he’d need to circle back to his Zebrican roots in order to keep everything going without a hitch. Walking up to his beloved potion shelf in the main room near his signature cauldron, Zecora took a potion of strength, something used by generations of zebra studs before him to bring renewed life into his muscles in addition to a generous amount of arousal. After drinking it down, Zecora placed the empty vial on the bottom shelf before taking two potions filled with aphrodisiacs that brought ponies to desperate submissiveness. The ingredients had to be carefully applied to the potions for his subs because just a few grams more and they’d be mind broken permanently. Only capable of basic functions such as eating and breathing, and constantly needing to be fucked. Nevermind that such an absurd concept was easily getting Zecora rock hard again, or perhaps that was the potion he just took. Zecora held the two potions for Applejack and Elusive respectively before trotting over back to his room, where they were in the exact positions as before. Placing one potion on the nightstand, Zecora hummed as he brought the other one to Applejack’s face before using his free forehoof to gently tap the orange farmpony awake.

“If you’d like to continue feeling carnal bliss, do drink this~” Zecora explained, watching as Applejack took the potion out of Zecora’s grip with his forehooves and popped open the cork before drinking down the potion’s contents and giving the empty vial back to his new zebra Master. He knew entering this life, that the potion he just drank would be the first of many. Endlessly serving his Zebrican Master, catering to his every whim with a moan and a smile, becoming a cumdumpster for him. Applejack shuddered from the merciless excitement that wracked his body as his balls became full with several loads of seed again. Zecora took the other potion vial that still had its magical contents before trotting to the other side of the bed where Elusive laid. Elusive didn’t pass out quite like Applejack did, so his magic lit up almost right away as he opened the potion vial and drank the contents swiftly before returning both empty vials to the nightstand. From the tip of his horn to the bottom of his hooves, Elusive felt an energy surge through him more authentic than caffeine. In fact, the unicorn felt better than when he had first walked into the hut. His body glittered with renewed energy, and the hot form of arousal spiked his dick back to full mast, as he jumped off the bed and bowed to Zecora.

“How may I be of assistance, my dear zebra Master?” Elusive asked the big zebra stud.

“You can start by removing stuff from the bag, I thought of trying something out with Applejack after removing the tag,” Zecora watched as Applejack rolled off the bed far less gracefully than his unicorn friend, standing up on all four hooves as he looked at the zebra stallion expectedly. Zecora looked into his eyes as he continued. “I have an inkling that with your proficiency in ropes, you might enjoy going down the BDSM slopes. Is this something that is true, that trying this out would perhaps interest you?”

“Yah, ah haven’t tried it and your hunch is right,” Applejack nodded as he continued. “Ah’ve used ropes so much that ah’ve certainly wondered how it’d feel to be restrained during sex.”

“And you claimed to be a dom during these thoughts?” Zecora laughed.

“Yah yah, though ah did genuinely believe it, ah wouldn’t tell a lie,” Applejack rolled his eyes with a small laugh that joined in his new Master’s chuckle, feeling his cluttered mind starting to clear with how thoughtful Zecora was. Even after pounding him into a mess, Zecora was still his best friend as they’d been before. Such a familiarity brought Applejack’s body to a mild relaxation, though he was still very much bricked thanks to the potion. Elusive’s magic pulled out a black blindfold and restraints made of a similar fabric, bringing them into Zecora’s open foreleg as he turned to Applejack.

“Ready to submit in body after having submitted in mind?” Zecora asked, to which Applejack nodded. Zecora took the blindfold as the obvious first step, placing it around Applejack’s eyes and slowly tightening it. “Tell me when it's comfortably snug enough to keep you vision blind.”

“It’s good,” Applejack said almost right away, and Zecora let it go as he saw it remained firmly over the orange farmpony’s eyes. Taking the first restraint band, similar to the blindfold though it was obviously longer, Zecora waited till Applejack was on the bed on his back as he moved the restraint past the farmpony’s shoulders so it was tightly secured around his forelegs. Then, Zecora did the same around Applejack’s hindlegs until it was comfortably tightened closer to his ankles. Zecora moved Applejack so his butt was raised partially in the air, his hindlegs pointed towards the ceiling as he was blind and immobile. The zebra stud wanted to take Applejack right then and there, but made room for pause as he processed just how vulnerable the earth pony was. Only a few days ago Applejack was sheepish about becoming a zebra’s sub, and now he had eagerly and willingly brought himself to be blindfolded and tied up. Standing over Applejack on the bed while his hindlegs pressed up against Zecora’s, the zebra stud leaned forward and kissed the orange farmpony’s forehead before moving his lips down to the center of his newest sub’s chest. Applejack’s chest was not silky like Elusive’s chest was by any means, having a rough coarseness that held a rustic charm of its own. Zecora savored it, having gone from holding reluctance to taking a pony so different from his other subs to absolutely loving it. He moved his lips down Applejack’s chest to his stomach, before shifting back around to facing the farmpony’s butt again and kissing down all the way to his apple cutie marks.

“Nngh, hah, fuck!” Applejack blushed as he shook in his confines, not seeing anything as he only felt the fluttering feathery kisses that surprised him coming from Zecora’s firm lips. Elusive, not one to be denied after having been given a powerful potion of arousal, crawled up the bed right behind Zecora and lunged forward as he began making out with the zebra’s ponut. While having no intention of domming the zebra, Elusive knew that such a paragon of strength and masculinity deserved to have all of his body worshiped. Inhaling his backdoor deeply, not giving a flying fuck about the seeping desperation kicking in from the potion combined with Zecora’s musk, Elusive moaned into the zebra ponut he was licking vigorously.

Zecora sighed with contentment at such treatment, before pressing his fully hard cock against Applejack’s ponut once again. This time, it would be a tighter fit considering that Applejack’s hindlegs were bound together, though Zecora knew that was part of the appeal. Applejack didn’t have to see to know what he was feeling, processing just how firm it was before Zecora grunted and penetrated him. Being without some of his main senses, Applejack felt he was flying in air as he brayed to the heavens from such a thick intrusion entering him once again. As Zecora shifted his body to enter more of his zebra dick inside, Elusive gently moved along with him to keep punching his tongue in and out of his Master’s backdoor while his eyes rolled to the back of his head. Zecora grinned, as he eventually hilted his entire dick inside of Applejack’s backside once again while his butt was partially lifted to meet the lower half of the zebra stud’s body.

“How does it feel, only having the feeling of dick stuffing you and the sounds and smell to attract your appeal?” Zecora asked, keeping his dick firmly inside of Applejack and not moving till he made sure the orange farmpony was okay. Applejack shuddered, biting his lip before opening his mouth.

“It’s the most glorious feeling ah’ve ever felt, Master~” Applejack moaned, his ears flickering excitedly since his legs couldn’t. “Please, ah need more.”

“Since my sub begged so sweetly,” Zecora hummed, pulling out most of his length before surging forward and clapping the orange farmpony’s cheeks louder than thunder. He moved so fast that he pulled away from Elusive’s tongue, and the unicorn witnessed Zecora’s rhythm over and over before moving back and licking his black ponut again. He moved along with Zecora, feeling silly for doing so but not truly caring when he was hornier than a slut about to attend an orgy. Eventually, when Elusive felt as though he got enough of Zecora’s backdoor as he savagely plapped the moaning and blindfolded Applejack, the unicorn femcolt moved down and began sucking on Zecora’s balls whenever they moved towards his face.

“FUCK ME, ZECORA!” Applejack brayed with desperation piercing his loins, feeling Zecora oblige as he pistoned his thick bitchbreaker in and out of the orange farmpony’s backdoor. Years of repression, of not allowing the deepest of his desires, and Applejack had fallen harder than any of his subs before. Zecora snorted, knowing that he wasn’t about to let the orange farmpony escape his sights anytime soon, daring to even keep him in the hut for a few days while the rest of his subs were busy with other responsibilities. Carnal hunger spiked inside of him, ready to claim another herd member and not caring if there was an end in sight for the femcolts he’d collect, as he got Applejack to convulse and cum all over himself. Applejack didn’t have the sight of his own orgasm to see, only feeling the peak of his arousal into insanity as he felt his warm seed seep into his chest fur and face. Applejack felt his mind broke for what time he couldn’t even process, only melding both mentally and physically into the sensation of Zecora savagely fucking him until he had hilted himself inside of Applejack and gave a deep groan as he came inside him once again. Zecora slipped his length out of Applejack’s backdoor, gently removing the blindfold from the farmpony’s face as he turned towards Elusive.

“Something tells me that you would want to see up and close what has become of your long time love,” Zecora laughed, his voice deeper with the untold promise of truly breaking any chance of Applejack having Elusive all to himself. They would have the satisfaction of loving each other, and that was something Zecora would never wish to take away. But he would make sure that Applejack knew who truly owned the unicorn femcolt by the time the night was over. Elusive’s eyes lit up as he moved off the bed until his forelegs were draped over the blankets and he was standing on his hindlegs. Zecora slumped off the bed entirely and walked around Elusive before mounting his much heavier striped body over the dainty femcolt. Elusive shuddered, and Applejack stared with his eyes wide and his blush heavy as his restrained desire was cumming to life. Elusive stared right into Applejack’s eyes, biting his lip before speaking.

“I really do like you, Applejack, perhaps even more than that,” Elusive confessed, even as Zecora pressed the thick tip of his dick against the femcolt’s dark gray ponut, hungering for a filling he was about to get. “But, well, you know how Zecora can be. This strong hunk of a stallion absolutely can ravage me just as passionately as he can love me, and that’s more of what I neeeeeeeeeee!”

Elusive’s sentence broke just as sharply as his composure did, his vision briefly blacking out into stars as he shrieked with the sudden motion of having his much smaller body once again being filled with a dick that shouldn’t have been able to fit in there. And yet, as he glanced down and saw Zecora’s imprint against the sun mark on his silky belly, Elusive knew that they were perfect puzzle pieces fitted together despite their jarring differences. Several minutes passed by of fat zebra meat making its way through Elusive’s tight backdoor, something that hardly changed thanks to the unicorn’s impressive ponut spells he had recently been using. Applejack laid on the bed, all four of his limbs still restricted with the physical binds as he started panting heavily from the show. Despite not being able to move, Applejack was easily able to voice his protest if he so chose. But he didn’t want to in the slightest, only getting more turned on by his voluntary helplessness as his dick grew hard all over again with nothing for it to do in his position. Elusive finally focused his gaze onto Applejack, but only after Zecora had his entire length back inside the svelte femcolt. As Elusive shakily smiled and winked at his dear Applejack, Zecora took the moment to swiftly pull out most of his length and slam it all back in at once, breaking the unicorn from the moment before proceeding to jackhammer himself inside his unicorn prize. Without asking if it was okay, Elusive set a magical spell to remove the bindings restricting Applejack’s forelegs. Zecora nearly stopped his jackhammering to punish his slave for his insolence, when he had seen the intent of Elusive’s act come to fruition. Bringing a swift forehoof to his own length, Applejack furiously jerked off to the show as he groaned and shook as if he was still getting fucked.

“Zecora, please fuck Elusive hard,” Applejack begged, and with that sudden moment of clarity, Zecora knew he had truly broken the orange farmpony.

“I’m glad to hear you fully submit, now time to treat your crush with a satisfying fucking that just won’t quit~” Zecora grinned at Applejack as he pistoned his fat length in and out of Elusive’s hole, mostly for his own gratification now. What was originally a show to prove himself better to Applejack was really moot, as it seemed the orange farmpony had figured out the rightful hierarchy a while ago. Certainly by the time he had asked for a blowjob at the barn and possibly before he even asked to be in the herd! Looking down at Elusive, Zecora continued. “I normally cum in your backdoor, but I think this situation warrants more to explore~”

“Yes, YES ZECORA!” Elusive brayed, even lifting a hindleg to show his erect length desperate for an orgasm with how hard the zebra adonis was smashing his p-spot. “Darling, I know exactly what you are suggesting! Bathe both of us in your seed, please!”

Zecora quickly looked to Applejack, who was resting his head against the headboard, his green eyes rolled to the back of his head and had his tongue lolling out of his mouth by the time his eyes finally met the zebra stud’s once again. Realizing just what Zecora was waiting for, Applejack swiftly nodded with a need he didn’t know he had. Zecora pulled out of Elusive’s length, pointing it towards Applejack, and feeling the surprise sensation of the unicorn’s magic jerking off his fully hard zebra cock as his white femcolt’s magicjob was the finishing touch to everything. Giving a sharp grunt, a long rope of zebra cum landed right between Applejack’s eyes and on his neck and chest. Then the second one landed on his chest and stomach, causing Applejack to gasp loudly as he came to his own jerking off as well as the hot sensation of zebra cum on his body. Zecora’s last few orgasms landed on Elusive’s normally pristine purple mane and diamond cutie marks.

And as he pulled out and watched Elusive climb on top of Applejack’s body and slump onto the powerful farmpony-turned-zebra-slave, the two passing out in zebra cum, Zecora felt a rush of pride and fulfillment at showing two more Elements of Harmony their rightful place~