Hanau Island

It truly amazed Flawless that after everything, he was still able to walk. Every so often he would shutter from the breeze that blew against his flank, where he felt another drip of cooling cum run down his leg. He may have been embarrassed to even be walking to his cabin in such a state, yet from the other guests who got done with their activities, he wasn’t alone.

Pushing through the curtain of beads, Flawless found his wife there on the bed reading a book. There was a moment of silence between them until Ivory spoke up. “Looks like you had fun.”

“I… yeah. I did.” He nodded. “And I need a shower after all that.”

“Yeah, I don’t blame you. I think there’s still a towel in there. By the way, what time is the dinner?”

“It’s in an hour. Just give me some time to get decent.”

Flawless pulled on part of the bamboo wall and slipped into the restroom. Minutes later, Ivory heard the shower being turned on.

“So…” Ivory closed her book.

“Hm?” Flawless asked from the shower.

“How was it?”

“The orgy?”

“No, the boat ride. Yes, the orgy. How was it?”

“To be honest? I was a lot more intense and exhausting then I thought it would be.”

“Oh yeah?”

“Yeah, I uh… Let’s just say that plenty of stallions there took turns with me as I did with them. Still, I wish there wasn’t a lot. You know?” Another pause. “And how was your experience?”

“More or less the same, but by noon I felt I needed a nap. After the… ninth stallion came in me, I was already full. And I can safely say that I might be pregnant after all this.”

Flawless gave an impressed whistle from the shower. “You know, I’m beginning to think that the one thing we have in common is that we like getting gangbanged.”

“Still, I wish I could have been there to see it. Maybe you should sign up for that porno thing so I could see it later.”

“I’ll think about it. Right now, I think I want to rest my flank for at least a day.”

“Really, how many stallions-”

“Let’s say that after ten I stop keeping count.”

“Oh…” Ivory blushed.

“But uh… Over there I ran into someone. Remember Greg and Sha? The griffon the zebra husband from last night? I ran into Greg during the orgy.”

“Funny, because Sha was also there too. And he also… well, he was one of the first in line let’s say.”

“Really? Well anyway, Greg suggested that we should exchange addresses where maybe he and his husband could come over."

Ivory nodded. “That might be a good idea. Because if I do get pregnant… and I’m pretty sure Sha might end up being the father, that at least he may have some involvement with us.”

“Make sense.” The couple fell silent for a long time.

Several minutes later, the shower was turned off and Flawless walked out with a towel over his flank. His mane was damp, yet at least now he was much cleaner than he was.

“I know what you’re thinking,” Ivory told him.

“What?”

“About Greg and Sha. If they’re up for it, and if they really want to, maybe we could form a sort of herd?”

“A herd?”

“I mean, why not? We just walked out from a fuck fest, and let’s be honest – we both enjoyed it. Like really enjoyed it. Perhaps what we could do going forward is see if we could get another couple involved with us. Like Greg and Sha for instance.”

“Well, I don’t know… I mean we just met them.”

“Yes. But I’m saying that we can open up our marriage to those that would make us feel more… you know… complete. I don’t know how exactly it would work, but just today alone has shown us that we both love being loved by groups. Even if Greg and Sha don’t want to, at least we would have a starting point to look.”

“Maybe…” Flawless sat down on the other side of the bed. “Still, I say let’s rest on this for a few days and just relax for a bit. We still have plenty of time here at the resort anyway, so let’s at least think it over before we jump into that.”

Ivory nodded, “Alright. Fair enough. Let’s get you all dried off and then head over for dinner.”

If anyone cared to look towards the beach throughout the day, they might have seen staff preparing for a feast. They may have seen the piles of hot coals that cooked piles of food, wrapped in banana leaves in sand pits. They may also have seen tall screens going up that sectioned off the rest of the beach where tables, a stage, tiki torches, and few well-placed plants were being set up by the staff. It was here that the luau was being taken place.

By the time Flawless and Ivory had arrived, they were first greeted by a buffet where they were encouraged to eat as much as they want. Like yesterday, they were offered a rainbow of fruits, veggies, drinks, and for the more carnivorous guests – a roasted pig. There were mounds of rice, stacks of freshly shredded cabbages, piles of macaroni salad, ponds of sauces, and fields of desserts. And yet, keeping to the theme to being a nymphomaniac resort, the buffet also included the option of flavored lubricants, candy underwear, fake condoms made of gummies, and small dildo lollypops.

Even before they had put enough food on their plates, they couldn’t help but notice what was happening on stage. While upbeat, tropical music was being played, on top of the guests giving happy whistles, there were three ponies on stage dancing. Two mares and a stallion. The couple wouldn’t even pay any attention to this, except for two things: three poles were sticking out from the stage that the dancers were using, and they were teasing the audience by stripping. Around their hips were skirts made of long green leaves that in between their suggestive dance moves, they would pluck a leaf where it revealed more and more.

“Hey! Over here!” Their attention was grabbed when they heard someone call out to them. Over on another table, they caught sight of Greg and Sha waving to them. So, they went over to them, being greeted with smiles. Sha propped his chin by his forelegs. “What’s up sluts?” He jokingly asked.

The couple set their plates down and sat at the table. “Doing pretty well, thanks,” Ivory told them. “How are you?”

“I can safely say we had fun today.” Greg stretched his arms, then relaxed them to hook around his husband. “Your hubby did incredible for his first day here.”

“And I can say the same for you as well,” Sha winked at her. “Not every mare would do what you did, you should be proud.”

Ivory blushed, “Even so, I should be thanking you.”

Sha tilted his head, “For maybe knocking you up?”

“For letting us start a family.”

“And… Let me indulge in my sexuality.” Flawless said, blushing also.

“Like I said earlier, you took it all like a champ.” Greg laughed. “Ya know, it isn’t every day that someone like you would do all that – both in the giving and receiving, if you know what I mean.”

“I still wish I could see it,” Ivory said. “Or at least have someone record the whole thing.”

Sha hummed thoughtfully, rubbing his chin. “I know for a fact there’s a porno class that does that. Tell you what? If your hubby is up for it, we could record a three-way for you.”

Flawless’s blush deepened at the thought of that. “Maybe in a day or so. But right now, I was…” He looked over to his wife. “No… We were thinking of something.”

“Oh yeah?” Greg raised an eyebrow, “And what would that be?”

“First of all, we don’t expect either of you to say yes to this. But we are throwing this out there.” Flawless took a deep breath. “If, given the chance, would you two like to maybe… hook up with us more often?”

Sha and Greg blinked. Briefly glancing at one another to be sure the other heard that right.

“I get it if this might be crossing a line,” Ivory added. “But really, with you maybe the biological father and my husband praising yours; we were thinking if maybe you want to be more involved with our lives as well.”

“You guys are wonderful.” Flawless nodded. “With me, having to spend so many years without having that emotional and sexual connection with anyone, I would love to get to know you two better. But I understand if this is moving too fast since we just met yesterday, and you have no reason for agreeing to something like this. Yet it would be lovely if you do.”

Greg raised an eyebrow, “Huh… Wow. This is new. Even for us.”

“Really?” Ivory asked.

Sha nodded. “Believe it or not, even with all the times we come here, nopony has ever asked what you two are asking. Besides, even if we did say yes, I’m not entirely sure how this would work exactly.”

“I imagine that it would be a pretty big commitment,” Greg added. “Don’t get me wrong, I for one am flattered that you would even ask this.”

Flawless looked between them. “So… Is that a no?”

“To me, it’s not a yes or a no. But this is something that I think we should sleep on before we dive into this.” Sha explained. There was a pause when Sha had a thoughtful look on his face. “Unless…”

Greg tilted his head. “Unless?”

Sha smirked, leaning over to whisper something in Greg’s ear. The griffon’s face changed from curious to intrigued.

“What is it?” Flawless asked.

Nodding to his husband, Greg answered, “Well, Sha had thought up a deal. We’ll do it, but my hubby wants one thing.”

“That being…?” Ivory tilted her head.

“We’ll do this herd thing for about a year, or at least until your foal is born,” Sha said. “Now if that foal isn’t biologically mine, then we would have no need to continue. But if it is, not only will move to Canterlot, but I’ll even father your second baby as well.”

Ivory looked between the two husbands, “Are… Are you sure about this?”

“Hey, we know what you’re both really after.” Greg pointed out. “Besides, lately we have been debating about maybe raising foals as well. Something that we should have disclosed earlier, but here we are. Again, I do love Sha with all my heart. But in this case, I’m willing to share him if it turns out that you’re pregnant with his foal. And I’ll be there to help raise them. That, and I wouldn’t mind getting to know your husband too.”

Flawless and Ivory looked at one another, and for the first time in their marriage, this was something that they were sure they wanted to do.