Diamond Tiara’s Special Potion (aka WTF Did I Just Write?)

by debrecen

Part 1: A Potion, My Kingdom for a Potion!

Load Full StoryNext Chapter

Spoiled Rich paced back and forth in the grand foyer of their mansion, her voice echoing off the marble walls as she berated Diamond Tiara for her latest social faux pas.

"I can't believe you embarrassed us like that at the gala, Diamond Tiara! You're supposed to be my daughter, not a liability!" Spoiled Rich's voice dripped with disdain as she glared down at Diamond Tiara, who stood with her head held high despite the barrage of insults.

Diamond Tiara clenched her jaw, her patience wearing thin after years of this kind of treatment. "Oh, please, Mother. Like anyone even noticed me amidst your melodramatic antics with the Canterlot elite."

Spoiled Rich gasped, her eyes narrowing dangerously. "How dare you speak to me like that! I won't tolerate this insolence, especially not from you!"

Diamond Tiara matched her mother's glare with steely ire. "Maybe if you treated me like a daughter instead of a pawn in your social climbing game, we wouldn't be having this conversation."

Spoiled Rich scoffed, her voice rising in indignation. "I've given you everything, Diamond Tiara. I expect you to uphold our family's reputation and status, not drag it through the mud!"

Diamond Tiara took a step forward, her voice cutting through the tension like a knife. "All you care about is appearances! You don't care about me at all."

Spoiled Rich laughed bitterly. "You think I should care about your feelings? You're weak, Diamond Tiara. A disappointment…and the rich should never have to settle for disappointments."

That was it. The final straw.

Diamond Tiara's eyes blazed with fury. "You know what, Mother? I'd rather live with the yaks than in this household where I'm beaten down and abused every day!"

Spoiled Rich's eyes widened in disbelief, then narrowed into icy slits. "How dare you say such things to me! You ungrateful little—"

Diamond Tiara cut her off, her voice trembling with suppressed emotion. "I mean it, Mother. I've had enough of your overbearing ways. I'm done."

Spoiled Rich sneered, her composure cracking. "Fine! Go ahead and leave, Diamond Tiara. See how far you get without me."

Diamond Tiara's chest heaved with anger, her eyes glistening with unshed tears. "I'd rather take my chances alone than stay in this gilded cage you call a home."

Spoiled Rich's expression turned cold and calculating. "You're just like your father. Weak and spineless. No wonder he doesn’t want to spend time at home as much anymore, you are clearly the driving force behind all of that."

Those words hit Diamond Tiara like a physical blow. She staggered back, her heart breaking anew at the mention of her absent father. "You... you don't even care about me, do you? You never did. You’re really blaming me for this?"

Spoiled Rich waved a dismissive hoof. "Don't be ridiculous. Everything I've done, I've done for you. You just can't appreciate it."

Diamond Tiara shook her head, her voice trembling with emotion. "You've never cared about me. All you care about is yourself and your precious reputation."

Spoiled Rich turned away, her tone dismissive. "If you're so unhappy here, then leave. See if I care."

Diamond Tiara's vision blurred with tears, her voice cracking as she delivered her final barb. "Believe me, Mother, I will, one of these days. And one day you are going to feel sorry! I’ll make you pay!"

With that, Diamond Tiara turned on her hooves and stormed out of the mansion, leaving Spoiled Rich standing alone in the echoing silence of the foyer.

Outside, Diamond Tiara ran blindly through the streets of Ponyville, tears streaming down her cheeks. She had finally stood up to her mother, but the weight of their confrontation hung heavy on her heart.

As she made her way to the area around the town hall, she came to a calm pond and sat next to a willow tree on the pond’s edge. Diamond Tiara buried her face in her hooves, letting the sobs wrack her body. She had always tried to please her mother, to live up to her expectations, but it had never been enough.

In the distance, she heard the faint sound of hoofsteps approaching. She looked up, wiping away her tears to see Starlight Glimmer standing there, concern etched on her face for one of arguably the most spoiled (albeit improving) pupils in the School of Friendship.

"Diamond Tiara," Starlight said softly, sitting down beside her. "Are you okay?"

Diamond Tiara shook her head, her voice choked with emotion. "No, Starlight. I'm not okay…but I will be."

Diamond sighed heavily. "I had to do things this way. I fought with my mom. I couldn't take it anymore, Starlight. Living in that house with her... it was suffocating."

Starlight nodded understandingly. "I understand. Just don’t burn bridges right away, okay? Honestly, I know from experience how bad it can be when you lose those close to you."

Diamond Tiara managed a weak smile, grateful for Starlight's unwavering support. "Thank you, Starlight. I don't know what I'm going to do yet, but... I'll figure something out."

Starlight squeezed her shoulder gently. "Take your time. You don't have to have all the answers right now."

“I just can’t take any more of these spats!” shouted Diamond into her hooves. In her mind, ideas were brewing, but she didn’t want to reveal them to Starlight yet.

“That bitch will pay,” though Diamond, “no matter what happens, I will be sure my mom pays!”


It was a Tuesday, a full three days after her quarrel with her mother, when Diamond Tiara stomped into Starlight Glimmer's office in the School of Friendship, her expression overflowing with frustration and determination. Starlight, noticing her visitor's mood, raised an eyebrow but gestured for Diamond Tiara to take a seat.

"Hey there, Diamond Tiara. What brings you here today? How are you feeling after what happened this last weekend?" Starlight asked, leaning back in her chair.

Diamond Tiara huffed and crossed her forelegs. "It's my mom, Spoiled Rich. She's unbearable! All she cares about is status and putting others down, especially me."

Starlight nodded sympathetically. "Parents can be tough sometimes, especially when they have high expectations."

"Tough? Try impossible!" Diamond Tiara exclaimed, her voice echoing off the walls. "I need something powerful, something magical to make her change her ways."

Starlight raised an eyebrow. "Magic isn't always the solution to personal conflicts, Diamond Tiara. Changing someone's behavior isn't exactly straightforward."

"But you're powerful, right? You can do magic that changes things," Diamond Tiara insisted.

Starlight sighed softly. "I can, but it's not as simple as waving a wand. Magic has consequences, and using it to alter personalities—"

Diamond Tiara cut her off, her eyes narrowing. "I don't care about consequences! I just want my mom to stop being so... so... mean!"

Starlight leaned forward, her expression serious. "Diamond Tiara, listen to me. There are better ways to handle this. Maybe we can talk to her, find a compromise—"

Diamond Tiara shook her head adamantly. "No! She won't listen. She never listens! I need something drastic."

Starlight pondered for a moment, then asked cautiously, "What exactly do you have in mind?"

Diamond Tiara leaned in, her voice dropping to a whisper. "I heard about a powerful magical concoction. Something that can change a pony…completely. Can you make it?"

Starlight hesitated, her mind racing through the possibilities. "I... I might know of something. But Diamond Tiara, you have to understand, this isn't something to be taken lightly. It could have unintended consequences."

Diamond Tiara shrugged dismissively. "I don't care about consequences, I told you. Just tell me what it is and how we can use it on my mom."

Starlight sighed again, rubbing her temples with her hooves. "Alright, let me think. There are a few options we could consider. One potion could alter her perception of things, maybe make her see the world from a different perspective. Another might enhance her empathy, make her more understanding."

Diamond Tiara tapped her hoof impatiently. "Those sound... okay. But I want something that really gets to the core of her, you know? Changes her from the inside out."

Starlight frowned, realizing where Diamond Tiara was heading. "You're talking about a personality-altering potion. That's... risky. And highly unethical."

Diamond Tiara smirked. "Unethical? Come on, Starlight, we're talking about my mom here. She practically invented unethical."

Starlight winced at the truth in Diamond Tiara's words; she had seen in passing how truly awful and disparaging Spoiled Rich could be to her own daughter. "Even so, we can't just—"

"Why not?" Diamond Tiara interrupted, her voice rising again. "You said you're powerful. You said you could help. So help me."

Starlight sighed heavily, torn between her desire to help Diamond Tiara and her ethical boundaries. "Alright, let's say hypothetically we go down this road. Do you have any idea how we'd administer such a potion?"

Diamond Tiara's eyes gleamed with a mischievous light. "I was thinking something dramatic. Like spiking her tea. She never misses her morning tea."

Starlight shook her head, feeling the weight of the situation settle on her shoulders. "Diamond Tiara, this is serious. We can't just sneak around and drug your mother."

"Why not?" Diamond Tiara challenged, her tone defiant. "She's always sneaking around, doing things behind my back. It's time she got a taste of her own medicine."

Starlight hesitated, knowing Diamond Tiara had a point but still uneasy about the plan. "Let's... let's not rush into anything. I need to do some research, see if there are safer alternatives."

Diamond Tiara slumped back in her chair, crossing her forelegs again. "I’m not the sort of pony to just wait around while some wannabe Twilight Sparkle tries to figure out basic magic! I want to teach her a lesson she won't forget, and quick."

“And how do you intend to do that?”

“I know you are going to protest, but I need her to become…well, a bit of a bimbo.”

“What in the hay do you mean?”

“Well, she is already such an egotistical airhead, imagine the lesson she would learn by being taken down a peg and becoming someone else's…pegboard,” Diamond let out with a bit of a knowing laugh.

“Goodness, I mean, I am no stranger to the darker side of magic, but this…it’s a whole different level.”

“Are you forgetting how much you owe me after helping you slip your cringey love potion into Sunburst’s punch at the last Friendship Soiree? Or have you also forgotten how I helped you get the locks of Stellar Flare’s mane just so you could make that temporary incest spell between her and Sunburst just so you could blackmail him into dating you?

“Well, no I didn’t forget, but…”

No buts! By this time Friday, I expect to have a spell to turn my mom into a witless, submissive slave in my hooves! Got it?”

“Okay, got it, just calm down!” pleaded Starlight. "I'll see what I can find. Just... try to be patient, Diamond Tiara. And in the meantime, maybe avoid any direct confrontations with your mom."

Diamond Tiara scoffed. "Hah, you think I haven't tried that already? She's relentless. And is this really the time to try talking sense to me?"

Starlight offered a small smile. "Okay, okay, I get it. But trust me, rushing into this won't solve anything."

Diamond Tiara fumed, her frustration palpable. "That’s what you think, Starlight."

As Starlight began to gather her books and scrolls, Diamond Tiara started on her way out, briefly turning her head and staring daggers at the older unicorn. "And Starlight? Don't take too long. I'm not known for my patience."


Three days later, on an otherwise unsuspecting and ordinary Friday, Diamond Tiara stood outside Starlight Glimmer's cottage, her heart pounding in anticipation. She took a deep breath, squared her shoulders, and knocked on the door with her hoof. Starlight opened it almost immediately, a serious expression on her face.

"Come in, Diamond Tiara," Starlight said, stepping aside to let her enter.

Diamond Tiara walked in, her eyes scanning. A small cauldron bubbled on the stove, and a variety of magical ingredients were scattered across the table. Starlight gestured for Diamond Tiara to sit down, and she complied, feeling a mixture of excitement and apprehension.

Starlight took a seat across from her, her expression grave. "Alright, so I've brewed the potion, Diamond Tiara. But before we go any further, I need to make sure you understand the gravity of what you're asking for."

Diamond Tiara rolled her eyes, trying to mask her nervousness with bravado. "Yes, yes, I get it. It's powerful, it's dangerous, blah blah blah. Just give me the potion already."

Starlight frowned, her voice firm. "This isn't a joke, Diamond Tiara. The potion I made is extremely potent. The effects will be permanent and will dramatically change your mother. Are you sure this is what you want?"

Diamond Tiara nodded resolutely. "Absolutely. My mother needs to change, and this is the only way. She'll never listen to reason."

Starlight sighed, her horn glowing as she levitated a small vial filled with a shimmering liquid. "This is it. One sip, and the effects will take hold almost immediately."

Diamond Tiara's eyes widened as she took the vial from Starlight, her hooves trembling slightly. "Thank you, Starlight. I know this wasn't easy for you." For a second it seemed that her politeness lessons from the School of Friendship were shining through her otherwise calculating facade.

Starlight gave her a cautious look. "Just remember, Diamond Tiara, once she drinks this, there's no going back. You need to be absolutely sure this is what you want."

Diamond Tiara met Starlight's gaze with unwavering determination. "I am sure. It's high time I get my way, and get it exactly how I want it."

Starlight hesitated, then nodded. "Alright. But please, be careful."

Diamond Tiara smirked, slipping the vial into her saddlebag. "Don't worry, Starlight. I know what I'm doing."

As she stood to leave, Starlight reached out and placed a hoof on her shoulder. "Diamond Tiara, promise me you'll think about this one last time before you give it to her."

Diamond Tiara sighed impatiently. "I promise, Starlight. Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a potion to deliver."

With that, she stepped out of the building, the door closing softly behind her. She took a deep breath, feeling the weight of the glass vial in her saddlebag. This was it. The moment she had been waiting for. It was time to go home and face her mother.

The first half of her walk back to the mansion was a blur. Diamond Tiara's mind raced with thoughts of what was to come. She knew her mother wouldn't make it easy if she had even a suspicion of her plan, but she was ready for whatever happened.

“Wait a second,” Diamond said to herself as she saw three familiar (but very annoying) blank-flank ponies on the edge of her vision. “Not them! Anyone, but not them!”

Apple Bloom, always the first to engage, called out, "Hey there, Diamond Tiara!"

Diamond Tiara sighed, already feeling her patience wearing thin. "What do you want, Apple Bloom?"

Apple Bloom trotted up to her, a friendly smile on her face. "We were just headin' back to Sweet Apple Acres. Thought we'd say hi."

Diamond Tiara rolled her eyes. "Well, I'm not in the mood to talk. Or bully you, for that matter."

Apple Bloom's smile didn’t falter. "Aw, come on now. No need to be so prickly. You know, my sister Applejack told me somethin' the other day."

Diamond Tiara raised an eyebrow, her curiosity piqued despite herself. "Oh really? And what piece of wisdom did the oh-so-erudite Applejack impart this time?"

Apple Bloom glanced back at Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle, who were hanging back, watching the interaction with interest. "She said the reason you act the way you do is 'cause you don't have a lovin' family like mine. She reckons you might be hurtin' inside so ya just lash out at others as a way of protecting yerself and yer own fragile emotions."

Diamond Tiara's eyes narrowed. "Oh, please. I don't need your dime-store psychology, Apple Bloom."

Apple Bloom's expression softened. "I ain't tryin' to psychoanalyze ya, Diamond Tiara. Just tellin' ya what my sister said. Sometimes folks act out 'cause they're hurtin'."

Diamond Tiara huffed, pulling Apple Bloom aside, away from the prying eyes and out of earshot of Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle. "Listen, I don't need a lecture on why I do what I do. But if you'll just hear me out, I have an offer that might smooth things over between us."

Apple Bloom tilted her head, curiosity evident in her eyes. "What kinda offer?"

Diamond Tiara glanced around to make sure they were definitely out of earshot. "If you listen to what I have to say, and agree to it, I promise to be nice to you. No more bullying."

Apple Bloom raised an eyebrow, intrigued but cautious. "Go on."

Diamond Tiara leaned in closer, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper. "Listen, Apple Bloom. I've got a deal for you. You know how I can be a bit, well, bothersome at times?"

Apple Bloom raised an eyebrow, her curiosity piqued. "Yeah, you've been a darn pain in the flank more times than I can count. What's your point?"

Diamond Tiara's smirk widened. "If you can get Big Mac to come over to my place tonight, I promise I won't bother you anymore. No more teasing, no more snide remarks. It'll be a win-win situation for both of us."

Apple Bloom's eyes widened in surprise. She had always dreamed of a life completely free of Diamond Tiara's torment. This could be her chance to finally have some peace. "Why do you want Big Mac to come over? And why would that make you leave me alone?"

Diamond Tiara's eyes sparkled with mischief. "Well, let's just say that I know from some friends of mine that Big Mac hasn't had the pleasure of any filly friends recently, if you catch my drift. I reckon he's been feeling rather... pent up lately. If you can arrange for him to come over, discreetly of course, ensuring he doesn’t suspect a thing, it'll be a golden opportunity for him…let’s just say that it’ll be a ‘rich’ experience. If you do this, I promise I won’t bother you."

Apple Bloom's mouth dropped open in shock. She couldn't believe what she was hearing. Diamond Tiara wanted her to set up a secret rendezvous for Big Mac without him knowing what was going on. It was a weird proposition, to say the least.

"But... but that just ain’t fair to Big Mac," Apple Bloom stammered. "He deserves to know what he's gettin’ into. We can't just use him like that."

Diamond Tiara rolled her eyes, dismissing Apple Bloom's concerns. "Oh, come on, Apple Bloom. You're overthinking it. It's not like we're forcing him into anything. He's a grown stallion, he can make his own decisions."

Apple Bloom hesitated, conflicted by the tempting offer before her. On one hoof, she yearned for a final escape from Diamond Tiara's backhoofed taunting. On the other, she couldn't bear the thought of manipulating Big Mac's feelings.

After a moment of contemplation, Apple Bloom finally spoke. "Alright, Diamond Tiara, I'm interested. But only if we can find a way to make it fair for Big Mac. No sneakin’ around or trickin’ him into anythin’."

Diamond Tiara grinned triumphantly. "Deal, Apple Bloom. We'll make it a fair arrangement. And trust me, it'll be an unforgettable night for both of them…I mean, for him. Just for him. Just make sure he comes over tonight. Let’s agree on 8 pm sharp.”

“Fine, I guess I’ll make it work,” acquiesced Apple Bloom.

Artfully sealing the deal with Apple Bloom and finding her way beyond the Cutie Mark Crusaders, now with a renewed resolve and hope that the potion would work, she approached the front door of her home, she took one last deep breath, steeling herself for the confrontation ahead.

She pushed the door open and stepped inside, the familiar scent of her mother's favorite perfume filling the air. Spoiled Rich was in the sitting room, sipping her morning tea and reading the latest issue of "The Canterlot Times."

Diamond Tiara squared her shoulders and marched into the room, her eyes fixed on her mother. Spoiled Rich looked up, her expression turning to one of mild annoyance.

"You're back," Spoiled Rich said coolly. "I was beginning to think you'd run off for good. Or at least as much as you could…after all you never seemed to be able to commit to things."

Diamond Tiara ignored the jab. "I have something for you, Mother."

Spoiled Rich raised an eyebrow. "Oh? And what might that be?"

Diamond Tiara pulled the vial from her saddlebag, holding it up for her mother to see. "It's a special tea. It will change everything."

Spoiled Rich's eyes narrowed suspiciously. "A new tea? In a vial? What kind of nonsense is this?"

Diamond Tiara stepped closer, her voice steady. "Just drink it, Mother. Trust me, it will make things better."

Spoiled Rich laughed, a harsh, mirthless sound. "Better? You think some silly new herbal trend will make things better? You're delusional, Diamond Tiara."

Diamond Tiara's grip tightened on the vial, her resolve hardening. "Just drink it, Mother. Please."

Spoiled Rich sneered, reaching for the vial with a dismissive wave of her hoof. "Fine. If it will shut you up, I'll drink your ridiculous tea."

Diamond Tiara watched as her mother uncorked the vial, poured it in her Earl Grey, and brought the mixture to her lips. Her heart pounded in her chest, a mixture of fear and anticipation coursing through her veins.

As Spoiled Rich tipped the cup back and drank the lightly steaming liquid, Diamond Tiara held her breath, waiting for the change to take hold.

Next Chapter