Pained cries

by Babycord

Rating: teen
Tags: Original Character, Tragedy, Princess Celestia, Human, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person, Princess Luna
Length: 7471

A human just wants the pain to stop

He doesn't have a name.

He doesn't understand why he's here,

But it hurts.

It hurts so much

Published 2024-11-11 13:20:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-11-11 13:20:00 UTC

Home is gone

The night was heavy, thick as iron, as he sat alone in the darkness. Silence pressed in, broken only by faint echoes from memories he wished he could bury: the clinking of chains, the hollow calls of the overseer, the suffocating closeness of worn-out bodies packed too tightly. He tried to remember a time before that darkness, but his mind could barely conjure anything beyond survival.

His fingers pressed against his chest, feeling the muted thud of his heart—his one certainty. It beat, steady and relentless, a reminder that despite everything, he was alive. This heartbeat was the only thing that felt like it belonged to him. Everything else—the scars, the silence, even the fear—felt like something forced upon him, woven into his skin against his will.

He closed his eyes, feeling the remnants of old bruises across his body as he drifted through a fog of memories. Suddenly, the familiar clang of chains pulled him out of his reverie, but this time it was different—stranger, louder, reverberating like thunder. His body tensed, senses sharpening, and his heart began pounding in a way that felt different from before: it was racing, trying to keep up with something unknown, something not of this world.

The darkness around him suddenly splintered, and in a heartbeat, the world shifted. He felt as if he were being pulled, dragged through space and time. Strange colors flashed around him, and his body seemed to float weightlessly in the void. Terror gripped him, a feeling far worse than any he’d known in his life before. Whatever was happening, it was beyond his understanding; he was trapped in a storm of lights and shadows, a storm that seemed to tear at the fabric of his being. He clutched at his chest, trying to hold onto the one familiar rhythm—the steady beat of his heart.

Then, as abruptly as it began, the storm stopped.

He hit solid ground, his legs giving way beneath him as he fell, sprawled across something cool and damp. His eyes blinked open, his vision swimming as he tried to make sense of his surroundings. Trees stretched up around him, massive and imposing, their branches twisting into strange, intricate patterns that made no sense to him. He had never seen trees like this. They looked more alive, more vibrant than any he’d known. The air felt…different. It was cool, crisp, tinged with an earthy fragrance that was unfamiliar yet oddly soothing.

He staggered to his feet, body tense and senses heightened, taking a shaky breath as he looked around. It was beautiful here, in a way, but he couldn’t shake the fear gnawing at his gut. This place wasn’t his world; it wasn’t anything he understood. He felt like a trespasser, something foreign and unwelcome in this strange, vibrant land.

He barely had a moment to breathe before he heard voices. He turned, heart racing, as a group of ponies emerged from the shadows. They were unlike any creature he’d ever seen—brightly colored, with large, expressive eyes, and…horns? Wings? His mind reeled. What were these things? Where had he been taken?

He wanted to run, but his legs felt like lead. He took a step back, eyes darting from one figure to another, trying to understand their expressions, their intentions. They murmured to each other in a language he didn’t recognize, their voices sounding both strange and, somehow, unsettlingly familiar. The ponies’ gazes fixed on him, a mix of curiosity and something else…something that made his stomach turn.

Before he could react, they moved closer, surrounding him. He tried to fight, but his strength was sapped from the transition, his limbs heavy and uncooperative. He felt himself being restrained, their hooves binding his wrists and ankles with strange, magical energy. Panic surged in his chest, and he thrashed against his bindings, desperate to break free, but it was no use. They held him firm, dragging him through the forest.

A wave of helplessness washed over him, sinking into his bones. These creatures, strange as they were, treated him the same as those who had held him captive before, as something to be controlled and contained. His heart sank, a dull, sickening weight that settled in the pit of his stomach. He had hoped—against all reason—that maybe, somehow, he’d finally escaped. But freedom, it seemed, was still just a dream.

The ponies brought him to a cold, dimly lit room deep within a hidden facility. He was strapped down to a metal table, his body still weak and aching from his struggle. Strange instruments loomed over him, their cold surfaces glinting ominously in the dim light. Shadows danced across the walls as a pony—a unicorn with a steely gaze—adjusted some sort of machine, muttering under her breath.

They prodded him, poked him, and ran tests he couldn’t comprehend. Lights flashed in his face, searing his vision, and strange, buzzing magic ran over his skin, making his flesh crawl. He clenched his jaw, his fists tightening as he fought to keep still, to keep calm. Every time he flinched or resisted, they held him down harder, whispering to each other in that strange, foreign language. He didn’t know what they were saying, but he could feel the detachment in their voices, the clinical curiosity. To them, he was an object, an anomaly to be studied.

One pony in particular, a mare with a soft green coat, lingered longer than the others, watching him with an intensity that made his skin prickle. She didn’t look at him with the same detachment; there was something else there, something he couldn’t quite read. But her gaze still held that same, unsettling focus, a mix of pity and fascination. She took notes, scribbling down every reaction, every twitch, every soundless scream.

He bit down, trying not to let them see his fear. His body shook, but he forced himself to stay silent, his mind retreating into itself, slipping back to memories of the chains and the darkness. In some ways, it was easier to focus on the past than face the terror in front of him now.

As he lay there, shivering and silent, the green-coated mare—the spy—couldn’t ignore the pang of guilt that twisted in her gut. She watched him, her quill scratching across the parchment as she documented every detail, every reaction. She had joined this organization to learn, to uncover secrets that could benefit Equestria, but now…she wasn’t so sure. The creature on the table, with his eyes wide and dark, his body trembling, looked far too much like a lost soul rather than an anomaly.

She took note of his silent resilience, his refusal to make a sound despite the pain they put him through. And as she watched, she began to feel the weight of her actions pressing down on her. Maybe, just maybe, there was more to him than they were willing to see.

When she finished her notes for the day, she added a subtle line, just enough to hint at her concerns: “Subject appears responsive to emotional cues; signs of distress noted.” It was vague, non-committal, but she hoped it would catch the attention of the right pony.

Moon guard

Princess Luna paced through the dim, marble halls of Canterlot Castle, her mane rippling with stars and midnight hues, casting an ethereal glow against the stone walls. The night was hers—quiet, steady, and full of secrets known only to her. She had ruled over dreams, guided her subjects through their nightmares, and understood their hidden fears. But tonight, a peculiar disturbance gnawed at her mind.

A scroll lay on a small table before her, unopened but thrumming with an aura she found unsettling. It bore the seal of a trusted informant embedded within a covert organization, a mare who reported only the most crucial findings, and the urgency of the seal told Luna this was no ordinary report. She hesitated, sensing something profoundly troubling, but her resolve held firm as she reached for the parchment, carefully breaking the seal.

As she read, her eyes darkened, pupils narrowing to slits as she absorbed the mare’s account. A human—a being not from Equestria—had somehow arrived, captured and experimented upon. His captors saw him as nothing more than a curiosity to be dissected and studied. Her heart clenched. This was wrong. She had learned of humans only from ancient, scattered lore—beings of resilience and tragedy, a species capable of light and shadow in equal measure.

The report described his silence, his terror, and the clear signs of trauma he bore, both from his own world and now from Equestria. Luna’s expression softened as she pictured him, alone and terrified in a strange land. Memories of her own isolation, her struggles in the shadows, surfaced, and she felt a pang of empathy she couldn’t ignore.

“Such cruelty…” she murmured, her voice barely a whisper. She rolled up the scroll with a calm but determined grip. This matter would not go unanswered. No creature, especially one so clearly vulnerable, deserved such treatment—not in her kingdom.

She summoned her guard, a select group of ponies who served as her protectors and confidants. They assembled swiftly, their eyes fixed upon her with unwavering loyalty. Luna’s presence, regal and serene, filled them with pride, but tonight, they could sense her tension, a shadow that seemed to reach beyond the physical realm.

“Tonight, we ride to end a grave injustice,” she began, her voice steady but edged with conviction. “A creature from beyond our world has been brought here, imprisoned and tormented by those who should have offered it refuge. I will not tolerate such darkness in Equestria.”

Her guards nodded, their gazes fierce and resolute. They knew Luna’s compassion, her dedication to justice, and they shared her disdain for cruelty. To them, her mission became theirs, as sacred as the night sky they watched over. Luna dismissed them to prepare, her mind already focused on the operation.

Before she could leave, however, she heard soft hoofsteps approaching. She turned to find her sister, Princess Celestia, standing in the doorway, her expression concerned yet supportive. It was rare for Luna to request secrecy, but Celestia trusted her sister’s judgment without question.

“Are you certain you must do this alone?” Celestia asked, her voice gentle.

Luna’s gaze softened. “I must, sister. I fear this creature’s heart is fractured beyond what simple kindness can mend. It needs patience, someone who can understand its shadows. And I, too, have known darkness.”

Celestia nodded, recognizing the unspoken weight of Luna’s words. “Then go with my blessing. But do take care, Luna. Such pain can be unpredictable.”

Luna gave a solemn nod, silently appreciating her sister’s trust. She had made her choice; now it was time to act.

The forest around the hidden facility lay still under the shroud of night, its shadows thickening as Luna and her guards approached. She took a moment to cast a cloaking spell over herself, melding into the darkness as her guards positioned themselves strategically around the perimeter. Her heart pounded—not with fear, but with a fierce determination.

Luna moved silently through the shadows, her hoofsteps soundless against the damp earth. Her senses were heightened, catching every faint rustle of leaves and whisper of wind. The facility loomed ahead, a stark, foreboding structure half-hidden by twisted trees and creeping vines. Its dark, cold exterior spoke volumes about the horrors within.

With a subtle nod, she signaled to her guards. The ponies moved in unison, slipping through the entrances, magic ready as they subdued any resistance without a single spoken word. Luna’s presence filled the hallways, her very essence seeming to press down upon any who dared to stand in her way. She moved with purpose, her mind focused on one thing alone—the human who had been stripped of his freedom and dignity.

Finally, she found herself outside a small, dimly lit cell. She paused, her breath steadying as she reached out with her magic, sensing the presence within. He was there—she could feel his heartbeat, rapid and fearful, a bird caged within walls that offered no escape. Carefully, she opened the door, her magic casting a soft, blue glow around her as she stepped inside.

The human lay on a cot, his form silhouetted against the faint light. He was curled in on himself, tense and wary, his eyes dark and hollow as they darted up to meet hers. For a moment, they simply stared at one another. Luna’s heart ached as she took in his gaunt form, the haunted look in his eyes. She knew that look—it was one she had seen in her own reflection many times.

She raised a hoof slowly, trying to convey gentleness. “I am Princess Luna,” she said softly, her voice barely more than a whisper. “I have come to help you.”

But his gaze remained cold and distrustful, his body coiled like a spring ready to snap. Luna could feel the fear radiating off him, a silent scream that echoed louder than words ever could. She didn’t move closer; instead, she lowered her hoof, respecting the invisible boundary he had drawn around himself.

“It is understandable that you do not trust me,” she continued, her voice calm and unwavering. “You have been hurt, and I cannot undo the past. But I swear to you, I mean no harm.”

The human’s eyes narrowed, suspicion and pain flickering across his face. He didn’t speak—she had been informed he might not be able to—but his expression was enough. Luna sensed the weight of his mistrust pressing down on her, as thick and impenetrable as a wall of ice. She would have to work slowly, to chip away at that wall piece by piece, and it would not be easy.

For now, she reached into her saddlebag, carefully pulling out a small loaf of bread and a canteen of water. She placed them on the floor, within his reach but far enough that he wouldn’t feel threatened. Then, slowly, she backed away, giving him the space he needed.

“Take your time,” she murmured. “I will return soon. Until then, you are safe.”

With a final, gentle nod, Luna stepped out of the cell, closing the door quietly behind her. As she walked away, she felt the weight of his gaze lingering on her, wary but curious, like a flickering flame that had been almost snuffed out yet still clung to life.

Back in the open air, Luna took a deep breath, feeling the cool night breeze wash over her. Her heart was heavy, her mind filled with the haunted look in the human’s eyes. She had known this would be difficult, but seeing his pain up close made it all the more real.

One of her guards approached, offering a respectful bow. “Princess, shall we escort him back to the castle now?”

Luna shook her head. “Not yet. He is…not ready. I fear if we force him to move, he may shatter entirely.”

The guard nodded, though his brow furrowed with concern. “Then, what shall we do?”

“We shall watch over him,” Luna replied, her gaze distant but resolute. “I will visit him every night, show him that not all in Equestria seek to harm him. Only through patience can we mend what has been broken.”

The guard inclined his head, accepting her decision. And as Luna turned her gaze back toward the darkened forest, she whispered to herself, a promise as much as a vow: “I will help you heal…no matter how long it takes.”

The night is safe

Another night settled over Equestria, and with it, Princess Luna found herself once more drawn to the dim cell deep within the castle. The human had been moved here under her supervision, though she knew even this could hardly feel like a safe haven to him. For the past week, she had visited him nightly, each time leaving small gestures of goodwill: a blanket, a meal, clean water. Every time, she had spoken a few gentle words, always allowing him space, respecting his silence.

Tonight, however, as she stepped into the shadows of his cell, something felt different. He sat up as soon as she entered, his dark eyes narrowed with mistrust but sharp, as though he was expecting her.

She paused, offering a soft nod. "Good evening."

The human’s gaze flickered briefly before he looked away, his jaw tense. Though he still refused to approach her, she noticed he hadn’t discarded the items she’d left. The blanket was wrapped around his shoulders, the bread eaten, and the water canteen was half empty. It was progress, even if only in small steps.

Luna carefully placed a small tray with more food at the edge of the cell, as she had done each night, and then settled on the floor, positioning herself a respectful distance away. She stayed silent, giving him time to make the first move—or not, if he chose. She wanted him to feel that he could make his own decisions, that no force or manipulation would be used here.

After a long, tense moment, he finally looked at her directly, and she felt a flicker of recognition, a slight softening in his hardened gaze. He opened his mouth, as though he were about to say something, but then stopped, a shadow of fear and doubt clouding his expression.

Luna inclined her head gently. "You may ask anything you wish," she said softly, encouraging him without pushing. "Or say nothing at all, if you prefer."

There was another silence, and then, at last, a hoarse whisper broke the stillness. "Why?"

The question was almost too soft to hear, but Luna felt its weight like a stone. She knew he wasn’t just asking why she had come tonight, but why she kept coming back at all. Why anypony would care after everything he had endured. Why she was here, trying to reach him, despite the walls he had built.

Luna took a deep breath, meeting his gaze with unwavering sincerity. "Because no being should have to suffer alone. No one deserves to be treated as you were."

He looked away, his face a mixture of pain and disbelief. She knew her words couldn’t erase his trauma, nor did she expect them to. But she hoped they might offer a glimmer of light—a possibility that not all of Equestria wished him harm.

In the days that followed, Luna continued her visits, each time sensing a subtle shift in his demeanor. He was still wary, still guarded, but he no longer looked away immediately when she entered. Occasionally, she caught him watching her from the corner of his eye, as though studying her, trying to understand her intentions. It was a start.

One evening, as she set down the food tray, she decided to try something new. She conjured a soft, magical flame—a gentle, blue glow that cast comforting warmth. She placed it between them, allowing it to flicker and dance, hoping it might ease the tension between them.

The human stared at the flame, his gaze transfixed, and for a moment, his face softened. The light reflected in his eyes, casting away some of the darkness that lingered there. Luna waited, watching him closely, sensing that he was beginning to let his guard down, even if just a little.

Finally, he spoke again, his voice hesitant. "I... I don’t understand."

Luna tilted her head, her expression warm and patient. "What is it you do not understand?"

"Why…" he began, struggling with his words, "why… are you different?"

The question hung in the air, carrying layers of mistrust, confusion, and vulnerability. Luna could feel the weight of his past experiences pressing down on him, shaping his every thought. She could see the memories lurking behind his eyes—flashes of betrayal, of suffering, of kindness that had turned to cruelty.

"I was once feared, too," she said softly, her voice laced with empathy. "In ways not unlike yours, I was shunned and seen as a threat. It took a long time to heal… and even longer to be trusted. But through kindness, I learned there was still hope."

He frowned, his gaze clouded with doubt, yet a flicker of understanding passed across his face. She knew he might not fully believe her yet, but at least he was listening. It was more than she had hoped for.

Scene 4: A Small Breakthrough

A few nights later, Luna arrived to find him sitting at the edge of his cot, his posture less tense than before. The tray from the previous night was empty, his canteen drained. It was the first time he seemed almost… expectant, as though waiting for her.

Encouraged, Luna brought out a small bundle, wrapped in cloth. She unwrapped it slowly, revealing a simple loaf of bread and a few pieces of fruit. She noticed his eyes linger on the food, and she carefully placed it closer to him than she had before, then settled back, allowing him to make the next move.

To her quiet surprise, he reached forward and took the bread, watching her cautiously as he ate. The silence was thick, but it felt different now—more a quiet understanding than an uneasy distance.

As he ate, Luna began to speak softly, sharing stories of her own struggles and regrets. She spoke of her transformation into Nightmare Moon, her time spent trapped in darkness, and the long, lonely journey back to redemption. She chose her words carefully, revealing enough to convey understanding, but not so much as to overwhelm him.

For the first time, he seemed genuinely interested, his gaze softening as he listened. She could see a glimmer of something beyond fear—a cautious curiosity, a fragile openness.

When she finished, he looked at her, his voice barely a whisper. "Do… do you believe in forgiveness?"

Luna’s heart ached at the question, understanding the turmoil that lay behind it. She met his gaze with unwavering sincerity. "Yes," she replied softly. "I believe every creature, no matter their past, can find peace. And forgiveness, too."

He looked down, his expression unreadable, but she sensed a shift within him, a small crack in the walls he had built. She knew that his journey to healing would be long and fraught with setbacks, but in this moment, there was hope—a fragile, flickering light.

As Luna rose to leave, she paused, offering him a gentle smile. "I will return tomorrow."

For the first time, he nodded, a subtle gesture, but one filled with meaning. Luna felt a quiet sense of triumph as she turned and left the cell, knowing that while the road ahead was uncertain, she had begun to earn a sliver of his trust.

Small steps

The morning sun crested the horizon, casting Equestria in a gentle glow. Inside the royal chambers, Princess Luna met with her sister, Celestia, to discuss her progress with the human. Luna’s tone was measured, carefully selecting her words, but Celestia could sense the weight of her sister’s frustration.

Celestia listened closely, her brow furrowed with concern. “Luna, you’re spending so much of your time with him. I fear this task may be taking more of a toll on you than you realize.”

Luna’s gaze hardened slightly, a flicker of defensiveness in her eyes. “I am fine, sister. He deserves a chance. If I can help him see that not all ponies mean him harm, then I must.”

Celestia nodded, yet her eyes were troubled. She had faith in Luna, but she also understood the depth of the trauma this human carried. “I will trust your judgment, Luna, but please remember that this journey will be a long one—for both of you.”

Luna gave a small nod, knowing that her sister’s words came from a place of love. But she also knew that progress could not be rushed, no matter how slowly it moved.

Later that evening, Luna returned to the dimly lit cell, sensing an air of unease from the human. He stood by the far wall, his back turned, shoulders tense, and his silence weighed heavier than before.

“Good evening,” Luna greeted, her voice gentle as she approached. When he didn’t respond, she noticed his gaze fixed on something she hadn’t expected: a faint scuff on the floor, the subtle sign of recent movement.

“They were here,” he whispered, his voice taut with anger. “Other ponies… looking at me, watching me like I’m some… thing.”

Luna’s heart sank, realizing the royal guards had likely performed routine checks in her absence. Though she had instructed them to keep their distance, their mere presence had shaken him. She moved a step closer, choosing her words with care. “No one will harm you here. I give you my word.”

He turned, his gaze sharp and filled with mistrust. “Your word,” he echoed bitterly. “It means nothing. You might be different, but the rest…” His voice trailed off, laced with memories that had yet to fade.

Luna felt his mistrust like a blade, but she kept her composure, determined to be the steady presence he needed. “I know that my words cannot erase what has been done,” she said softly. “But I will keep my promises.”

Days passed with little progress, and each evening, Luna continued to visit, her presence a constant thread in the human’s dark world. Gradually, he began to relax in her presence, though his guard was always up, as if fearing any slip might lead to betrayal.

Then, one night, as Luna entered the cell, she found him curled up on the floor, his body tense with fear even in sleep. His face twisted in a silent expression of terror, a look that resonated with Luna, a reflection of the nightmares she herself had once endured.

Without hesitation, she reached out gently, brushing her magic over him to calm his fitful sleep. His body relaxed slightly, but as he stirred awake, his eyes widened in panic at her proximity. Instinctively, he jerked away, pressing himself against the wall, his breathing shallow and rapid.

Luna took a step back, raising a calming hoof. “It’s alright. You were having a nightmare.”

He swallowed hard, his gaze haunted. “It’s… they never go away,” he whispered, the vulnerability in his voice a stark contrast to the guarded silence he usually held.

Luna nodded, understanding the torment of memories that refused to fade. “I know. I have seen my own share of darkness, and it has taken time to find peace. But… it is possible.”

He looked at her, a flicker of doubt mingling with something deeper—perhaps hope. She offered a soft smile, one meant to reassure, and then allowed the silence to linger, letting him process without pushing.

The next night, Luna brought a small, simple gift—a feather she’d enchanted to glow faintly in the dark. She placed it near him, saying nothing, allowing him to decide what he would do with it.

At first, he ignored it, his gaze averted. But as the minutes passed, his curiosity grew, and he glanced at the feather, reaching out to touch it lightly. Its soft glow bathed his hand in light, and he seemed almost mesmerized by its warmth.

Luna watched him, her heart swelling with a quiet sense of hope. It was a small gesture, but it represented something more—an unspoken trust he was beginning to extend, even if only a little.

After a long pause, he looked up at her, his eyes still wary but softened with a hint of gratitude. “Why?” he asked, his voice barely a whisper.

Luna met his gaze, her voice steady and filled with compassion. “Because you deserve kindness,” she replied, her words simple but powerful. “And I am here to show you that.”

He seemed to struggle with her words, as though the concept of kindness was foreign, something he’d long forgotten. But he didn’t turn away. Instead, he allowed the feather to remain in his hand, a fragile symbol of the bridge they were building, one small step at a time.

The following morning, Luna found herself once again speaking with Celestia, who had grown curious about her nightly visits to the human. The elder sister listened closely as Luna described the slow progress, the moments of trust mingled with fear, and the delicate balance she was trying to maintain.

Celestia’s gaze softened, a glimmer of pride in her eyes. “You have come so far, sister. I know this journey is not easy, but your dedication is inspiring.”

Luna nodded, her expression thoughtful. “It is… challenging, but I see glimpses of hope. Small, but they are there.”

Celestia gave her a gentle smile. “Perhaps, when he is ready, I may meet him as well. I trust you will know the right time.”

Luna hesitated, her protective instincts flaring. Though she knew her sister’s intentions were good, she feared that even the presence of another pony, especially one as powerful as Celestia, might undo the trust she had worked so hard to build.

“Perhaps,” she replied carefully. “But only when he is ready. I don’t want to risk overwhelming him.”

Celestia nodded, her respect for Luna’s judgment evident. “Of course. Take all the time you need.”

As the days passed, the human’s cautious acceptance of Luna’s presence continued to grow, though the shadows of his past lingered, ever-present. They spoke more frequently now, their conversations small and tentative, like stepping stones across a turbulent river.

One evening, as Luna prepared to leave, he spoke, his voice so soft she almost missed it. “Thank you… for the feather.”

Luna paused, a gentle warmth spreading through her heart. She turned to him, her

Fragile

Luna was aware of the delicate progress she'd been making with the human. She’d noticed how his trust, though still tentative, was beginning to anchor itself in the safety of her presence. Each evening, she found herself able to approach him a bit more closely, speaking a bit more freely.

But on this particular evening, things would not go as planned.

As Luna entered the quiet corridor leading to his cell, she noticed a faint shimmer of golden light escaping through the doorframe—a glow she recognized instantly. A surge of alarm shot through her, and she quickened her pace, her heart pounding as she opened the door to find her sister, Celestia, standing just inside.

Celestia turned, her expression gentle but curious as she observed the human with a look that, to Luna, felt too invasive. The human, frozen at the far corner of the cell, had his back pressed tightly to the wall, his eyes wide with fear as he stared at the unfamiliar figure.

“Sister!” Luna said, a mix of shock and irritation coloring her voice. “What are you doing here?”

Celestia’s gaze shifted to Luna, an apology in her eyes. “I meant no harm, Luna. I was only curious and thought I might introduce myself, just to see—”

Before she could finish, a sharp, pained sound escaped from the human, a sound that sent chills down both princesses' spines. He was trembling, his fists clenched, his face twisted with a mix of terror and rage.

Luna moved swiftly between him and Celestia, her expression fierce as she addressed her sister. “You shouldn’t have come here,” she said, her tone low and reprimanding. “He isn’t ready.”

Celestia looked taken aback but nodded, understanding dawning in her eyes. “I’m… I’m sorry,” she murmured, glancing toward the human with genuine regret before retreating from the cell.

As soon as the door closed, Luna turned to face him, her heart sinking as she saw the look of betrayal etched into his face. He had trusted her to keep him safe, to shield him from the others, and she had let him down.

The silence was tense and brittle, hanging heavily between them. The human’s shoulders heaved, his breath shallow as he glared at her with an anger she hadn’t seen before. Luna wanted to speak, to apologize, but she knew that words alone would not heal the damage that had been done.

He turned away from her, his fists clenched. “I knew it,” he muttered bitterly, his voice shaking. “I knew you were all the same. I was stupid to think… to think you’d be different.”

The accusation stung, and Luna swallowed hard, fighting to keep her voice steady. “I am sorry,” she said softly. “I did not know she would come. I would never have allowed it if I had.”

He shook his head, his posture rigid with anger. “It doesn’t matter. All of this… it was just to get me to trust you. And for what? So you could parade me around, like some… some thing you’ve tamed?”

Luna flinched at his words, the bitterness in his tone cutting deep. She had tried so hard to show him kindness, to give him a sense of safety, and yet in a single moment, all of that effort felt as though it had been stripped away.

But she did not retreat. Instead, she took a step closer, speaking with a quiet firmness. “You may never believe me, but I meant every word, every gesture. I have nothing to gain from your trust, except the chance to see you free of the shadows that haunt you.”

He looked at her, his eyes searching hers with a look of distrust mingled with something else—something that almost looked like doubt.

“I don’t know if I can trust you again,” he whispered, his voice raw and pained.

Luna nodded, accepting his words. “Then let me prove myself, as I did before. I will not ask for your forgiveness, only that you allow me the chance to make this right.”

He did not respond, but she saw a flicker of something in his eyes—a small, fragile glimmer of possibility. And in that moment, she knew that while the road ahead would be even harder than before, she would not give up.

Back in her chambers, Celestia sat by her window, troubled by the day’s events. She had not meant to intrude, and yet, in her desire to help, she had only made things worse.

She thought of Luna, her sister’s dedication to this one broken soul, and how her own actions had nearly unraveled all that Luna had worked so hard to achieve. A quiet sigh escaped her as she gazed out over Canterlot, the city bathed in moonlight.

A knock at the door drew her attention, and Luna entered, her expression tense but calm. Celestia rose, an apology already forming on her lips. “Luna, I am so sorry. I didn’t realize…”

Luna held up a hoof, stopping her. “I know you meant no harm, sister. But he is… he is not ready for others. Trust is something he does not give easily, and now I fear I may have lost what little I had earned.”

Celestia’s expression softened, and she placed a gentle hoof on her sister’s shoulder. “You have always been stronger than you realize, Luna. If anyone can regain his trust, it is you.”

Luna nodded, her resolve firm. She would not let this setback deter her, but the road ahead now felt steeper, and the burden heavier.

The following evening, Luna returned to the human’s cell, bracing herself for whatever she might face. She found him in his usual spot, his back to the wall, his gaze distant and unfocused.

She approached cautiously, lowering herself to his level. “I know you may not wish to hear this, but I want you to know that my sister’s visit was not planned. She does not understand what you have endured, nor did she mean to cause you harm.”

He said nothing, but she sensed the tension in his body easing slightly. It wasn’t forgiveness, but it was enough to give her hope.

“Tomorrow,” she continued softly, “I will bring you somewhere outside this cell, if you wish. Somewhere quiet, where no one else will be. Just… somewhere to remind you that there is more to this world than walls and shadows.”

He looked at her then, a glimmer of curiosity mingling with his wariness. She could see the conflict in his eyes, the desire to trust battling with the fear of being betrayed once again.

Finally, he gave a small nod, his expression guarded. “Fine. But just you.”

Luna nodded, her heart lifting. “Just me,” she promised.

The next evening, Luna guided him to a secluded garden within the castle walls. It was a quiet place, hidden from view, bathed in soft moonlight. She had chosen this spot carefully, knowing it would offer the peace and privacy he needed.

He stood at the edge of the garden, his gaze taking in the open space, the gentle sway of flowers in the breeze. For a long moment, he simply stood there, breathing in the cool night air, his eyes filled with a mixture of wonder and disbelief.

Luna watched him in silence, allowing him to take it all in without interruption. She felt a sense of pride, a quiet satisfaction in seeing him experience something beyond the confines of his cell.

“This… this is real?” he asked, his voice barely above a whisper.

“Yes,” she replied softly. “And there is more—so much more, if you are willing to see it.”

He didn’t respond, but she saw a flicker of hope in his eyes, a small, hesitant step toward the possibility of something better. It was fragile, delicate, but it was there, and for now, that was enough.

As they stood together under the stars, Luna felt a renewed sense of purpose, a reminder that even in the face of setbacks and hardships, she would not give up on him. She would be his guide, his protector, and, if he allowed it, his friend.

And in that moment, she knew that while the path ahead was uncertain, she would walk it with him, step by step, until he no longer needed her to light the way.

A way forward

Luna arrived at the garden just after dusk, the silver glow of the moon casting a tranquil light across the landscape. She found the human waiting at the entrance, his expression guarded but tinged with something softer—a hint of anticipation.

“Good evening,” Luna greeted, her voice gentle, respecting the quiet atmosphere of the garden.

He nodded, remaining silent, but she could sense a shift in his demeanor. He wasn’t as tense tonight. Perhaps he was beginning to trust that this space, at least, would offer him a kind of sanctuary.

Luna took a seat on a low stone bench, gesturing for him to sit as well. He hesitated but eventually sat down on the ground nearby, his posture defensive yet open to her presence. They sat in silence, the only sounds the soft rustle of leaves and the occasional chirping of distant crickets.

After a few moments, Luna spoke, her voice soft and steady. “Would you like to hear a story?”

He looked at her, a flicker of curiosity in his eyes. “What kind of story?”

“A tale from Equestria’s ancient past,” she replied. “One about resilience and hope.”

He shrugged, but she could see that he was listening.

“There was once a pony,” she began, “who was not like the others. This pony was filled with darkness and pain, shunned by her kind. But one day, she found herself in a place of peace, much like this garden. And though the path to healing was long, she discovered that there were those who could see past her darkness and understand her pain.”

He glanced at her, his eyes narrowing slightly. “Did they really understand?”

Luna paused, considering his question carefully. “Not completely. But they were willing to try, and that was enough to help her begin to heal.”

A faint, skeptical smile crossed his face. “Doesn’t sound like anyone I’ve met.”

Luna smiled gently. “Perhaps not yet. But sometimes, all it takes is a single person willing to try.”

As the night wore on, the human began to relax, his guard dropping just enough for Luna to notice. He traced his fingers through the grass absentmindedly, and for the first time, he seemed less wary, almost… calm.

“Do you miss your world?” Luna asked softly.

His face tightened, a flash of pain passing through his eyes. “There wasn’t much to miss. My life… wasn’t something anyone would want.”

Luna nodded, her heart aching for him. “It’s still a part of you. Painful or not, it’s the path that led you here.”

He looked away, his jaw clenched. “Maybe that’s why I don’t want to remember.”

She wanted to reach out, to offer some form of comfort, but she knew he wasn’t ready for that. Instead, she spoke in a low, comforting tone. “If you ever wish to share your story, know that I am here to listen.”

He gave a slight nod, though she could tell he was still holding back. But there was a vulnerability in his expression now, something he was no longer trying to hide. And in that moment, Luna saw a small crack in the walls he had built around himself—a sign that he was, perhaps, beginning to trust her.

Over the next few days, Luna continued bringing him to the garden, each night feeling a little less guarded than the last. He began to open up in small ways, sharing brief glimpses of his past and the trauma that had shaped him.

But his progress was tested when Celestia visited once again. This time, Luna made sure her sister approached with care, ensuring that her presence would not feel like a violation.

When Celestia entered the garden, the human stiffened immediately, his gaze wary as he watched her every move. Sensing his discomfort, Luna placed a reassuring hoof on his shoulder, a silent promise that she would protect him.

Celestia approached slowly, her movements gentle and respectful. “I apologize for my intrusion last time,” she said softly, bowing her head. “I should have respected your space.”

He eyed her warily, but there was a trace of something softer in his gaze—an acknowledgment of her apology, even if he wasn’t ready to forgive.

“I… I don’t trust you,” he said, his voice barely above a whisper.

Celestia nodded, her expression understanding. “I would not expect you to. Trust is something that must be earned, not demanded. And I am willing to wait as long as it takes.”

For a moment, he looked at her, a mixture of fear and curiosity in his eyes. And though he said nothing more, Luna could see a slight softening in his posture, a tiny step forward in the long journey toward trust.

One evening, as they sat in the garden under the stars, he looked up at the sky, his expression thoughtful. “Back in my world… there was nothing like this. No peace, no stars, just darkness.”

Luna listened, her heart aching for him. “Darkness is something I know well,” she said softly. “But even in the darkest places, there is light to be found. Sometimes it just takes time to see it.”

He glanced at her, his eyes filled with questions he couldn’t bring himself to ask. “You talk like you’ve been through something.”

She nodded, her voice barely a whisper. “I have. And though it took me a long time to see it, I learned that there is always a way back to the light.”

For a long moment, they sat in silence, the weight of shared pain and understanding hanging between them. And in that moment, Luna knew that he was beginning to see her not as a pony, but as someone who had faced her own darkness and survived.

As the days turned into weeks, he began to open up more, sharing small details of his past—a life of hardship and suffering, a world where he had been treated as less than nothing. Luna listened without judgment, offering only understanding and compassion.

One evening, he looked at her with a hesitant, almost hopeful expression. “Do you… do you think someone like me could ever find peace here?”

Luna placed a gentle hoof on his shoulder, her eyes filled with warmth. “Yes. It may be a long journey, but I believe you can find peace here. And you will not have to walk that path alone.”

He looked down, a faint smile playing at the corners of his mouth. “Thank you… for everything.”

In that moment, Luna felt a sense of hope—a fragile, delicate hope that he was beginning to believe in a future beyond his past. And as they sat together under the stars, she knew that while his journey was far from over, he was finally taking his first steps forward.