Starshimmer : And the School of Magic

by Mellow Mare

Chapter 4: The Detention

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

The atmosphere in Ironmane’s office was as cold and stony as the professor himself. Starshimmer and Shimmer Hooves sat side by side, both of them doing their best to avoid Ironmane’s piercing gaze as he paced back and forth in front of them.

“So,” Ironmane said, his voice low and gravelly, “you thought making jokes about your professors was appropriate behavior?”

Shimmer Hooves shrank slightly in his seat, his wings twitching nervously. “It was… just a joke,” he muttered. “We didn’t mean any harm.”

Ironmane’s green eyes narrowed. “Intentions matter little when discipline is at stake, Shimmer Hooves. You’ll learn that soon enough.”

Starshimmer kept her eyes fixed on the floor, biting her lip to keep from saying anything. She had known they were going to get in trouble for their jokes, but the weight of Ironmane’s disappointment still sat heavily on her shoulders.

“Now, for your punishment,” Ironmane said, stopping in front of them. “I originally planned to have you clean out the potion storage rooms, but it seems an opportunity has arisen for a more… practical lesson.”

Starshimmer’s heart sank. She didn’t like the sound of that.

“A creature has escaped from Professor Earthsong’s enclosure,” Ironmane continued, his voice matter-of-fact. “A baby manticore, to be specific. It broke free earlier this evening, and as you both know, manticores—young or not—can be extremely dangerous if left unchecked.”

Shimmer Hooves froze, his eyes widening with panic. “A m-manticore? With a… with a scorpion tail?”

Ironmane raised an eyebrow, his expression unyielding. “Correct.”

Starshimmer could feel Shimmer Hooves stiffen beside her, his usual bravado replaced by a palpable wave of fear. She glanced at him, her concern growing. Shimmer had mentioned once, in passing, that he wasn’t exactly a fan of scorpions, but she had never seen him look this scared before.

“You will be accompanying Steelheart into the woods to retrieve the creature and return it safely to its enclosure,” Ironmane said, as though sending two first-year students out to hunt a baby manticore in the middle of the night was the most logical punishment in the world.

Shimmer Hooves looked like he was about to faint. “W-wait, what? You’re sending us into the woods? At night? With a manticore on the loose? We’re first-years! Isn’t that—well—dangerous?”

Ironmane’s eyes gleamed with amusement, though his expression remained as hard as ever. “You signed your school contracts, did you not?”

Starshimmer frowned, exchanging a glance with Shimmer Hooves. “Well… yeah, but what does that have to do with—”

“Everything,” Ironmane interrupted. He waved his hoof, and a scroll appeared in front of them, unfurling to reveal the school’s contract in elegant, looping script. His voice was calm and measured as he began to recite: “Clause four, subsection three: ‘Punishments and corrective actions administered by faculty are to be considered subjective and may take the form of any practical, magical, or educational activity deemed suitable by the instructor.’”

Starshimmer groaned inwardly. She remembered signing the contract, of course, but like every other first-year student, she had been too excited about getting accepted to Celestia’s School of Magic to actually read the fine print.

Shimmer Hooves’ mouth opened and closed a few times before he finally managed to stammer, “B-but… but we could get seriously hurt!”

Ironmane’s lips twitched into what might have been the faintest hint of a smirk. “Which is why Steelheart will be accompanying you. You’ll be perfectly safe under his watch.”

“Safe?” Shimmer Hooves squeaked. “We’re going to be chasing a baby manticore through the woods! Nothing about that sounds safe!”

Starshimmer swallowed hard, her own nerves twisting in her stomach. She wasn’t thrilled about the idea of wandering the woods at night with a potentially dangerous creature on the loose either. But arguing with Ironmane was clearly a losing battle.

Ironmane gave them both a long, appraising look before finally turning toward the door. “Steelheart is waiting for you by the main gate. You will leave immediately.”

Shimmer Hooves’ ears flattened against his head. “I’m going to die,” he muttered under his breath.

Starshimmer took a deep breath and stood, nudging Shimmer Hooves gently. “Come on,” she whispered. “We’ll be fine. We’ve got Steelheart, right?”

Shimmer Hooves shot her a look that clearly said he wasn’t convinced.

With a final glance at Ironmane, they both trudged out of the office, their hootsteps heavy with dread.


The night air was cool and crisp as they made their way toward the main gate. The towering spires of Celestia’s School of Magic loomed in the distance, bathed in the soft glow of the moon. But the woods beyond the school’s grounds were dark and ominous, the trees casting long, jagged shadows that seemed to stretch out like claws.

As they approached the gate, Starshimmer spotted Steelheart standing in his usual imposing stance, his massive frame illuminated by the flickering lantern light. His midnight-blue coat blended into the shadows, and his stern gaze was fixed on the forest ahead.

“There you are,” Steelheart rumbled as they approached. “About time.”

Shimmer Hooves swallowed loudly, his wings twitching nervously. “Y-you sure we should be doing this? I mean… it’s a manticore. With a scorpion tail.”

Steelheart raised an eyebrow but said nothing for a moment, clearly unimpressed by Shimmer’s fear. Then, in a voice as steady as the mountain itself, he replied, “You’ll be fine. The baby manticore isn’t fully grown, and while its venom can sting, it’s not lethal. As long as you don’t provoke it, we’ll have it back in Earthsong’s enclosure before the hour is up.”

Shimmer Hooves’ face drained of color. “Oh, great. Only a sting. That’s so much better.”

Starshimmer did her best to keep her own fear in check. She wasn’t exactly thrilled about the situation either, but they didn’t have much of a choice. Steelheart didn’t seem the type to accept complaints—or cowardice, for that matter.

“Let’s get this over with,” Starshimmer said quietly, nudging Shimmer Hooves again. “The sooner we find the manticore, the sooner we can get back.”

Shimmer Hooves gave her a weak nod, though his legs were shaking slightly.

Steelheart turned and led them into the woods, his heavy hooves barely making a sound as he moved through the dense underbrush. Starshimmer and Shimmer Hooves followed closely behind, their eyes darting nervously around the darkened forest. The trees towered overhead, their branches twisting and curling like ancient, gnarled claws. The only sound was the rustle of leaves and the occasional snap of a twig beneath their hooves.

Starshimmer’s heart raced as they ventured deeper into the woods. The shadows seemed to move with them, flickering at the edges of her vision. She tried to stay focused, to keep her mind on the task at hoof, but every now and then, she caught a glimpse of something in the darkness—an animal, perhaps, or the faint glow of magic.

“So,” Shimmer Hooves whispered beside her, his voice trembling slightly, “remind me again why we’re doing this?”

Starshimmer sighed, trying to keep her voice steady. “Because Ironmane hates us, apparently.”

Steelheart glanced back at them but said nothing, his expression unreadable as ever. He seemed completely unfazed by the darkness, his eyes sharp as they scanned the forest for any sign of the escaped manticore.

After what felt like hours of walking, Steelheart suddenly stopped, raising a hoof. “Quiet.”

Starshimmer froze, her heart pounding in her chest. She listened carefully, straining to hear what had caught Steelheart’s attention.

There it was—a faint rustling sound, coming from a cluster of bushes just ahead. Something was moving.

Steelheart nodded toward the bushes. “Stay behind me. I’ll handle this.”

Shimmer Hooves looked like he was about to pass out, but he managed a shaky nod, stepping closer to Starshimmer as Steelheart advanced toward the bushes. Starshimmer’s pulse quickened as she watched, her magic flickering to life in her horn, just in case.

Steelheart reached the bushes and slowly pushed them aside, revealing a small, scaly creature crouched among the leaves. The baby manticore was even more intimidating up close than Starshimmer had imagined. Its lion-like body was covered in sleek, golden fur, but its scorpion tail flicked dangerously behind it, the stinger gleaming in the moonlight.

The manticore let out a low growl, its bright yellow eyes narrowing as it locked onto them.

Shimmer Hooves made a strangled noise, stepping back instinctively. “Oh, no. No, no, no.”

Steelheart held up a hoof, signaling them to stay still. “Don’t move. Manticores respond to strength. If you show fear, it will see you as prey.”

Shimmer Hooves swallowed hard, clearly doing everything in his power not to run.

Starshimmer watched, her heart racing, as Steelheart slowly approached the creature. The manticore growled again, its tail twitching, but Steelheart remained calm, his movements slow and deliberate.

“Easy now,” Steelheart murmured, his deep voice soothing but commanding. “We’re not here to hurt you.”

The manticore’s growl softened slightly, but its tail remained raised, ready to strike.

For a tense moment, the entire forest seemed to hold its breath. Then, just as Steelheart reached out to the creature, the manticore let out a sharp hiss, spinning around and darting into the shadows.

“After it!” Steelheart barked, his voice sharp.

Without thinking, Starshimmer took off after the creature, her hooves pounding against the forest floor as she followed its trail. Shimmer Hooves let out a strangled yelp but followed closely behind her, his wings fluttering in panic.

The manticore darted through the trees, its movements quick and agile, but Starshimmer kept her focus, her horn glowing as she tried to cast a binding spell. The spell fizzled out before it could reach the creature, and she cursed under her breath.

“Starry! Do something!” Shimmer Hooves called, his voice high with fear.

“I’m trying!” Starshimmer shouted back, her mind racing. She needed to stop the manticore before it escaped into the deeper part of the forest, but her magic was still sputtering, uncooperative.

Just then, the manticore came to a sudden stop, skidding to a halt in a clearing. It turned to face them, its yellow eyes glowing in the darkness, its scorpion tail raised high.

Shimmer Hooves froze, his entire body trembling. “No, no, no…”

Steelheart appeared beside them, his horn glowing with a powerful aura. “Stay back,” he commanded.

But before Steelheart could act, the manticore lunged—its tail flashing through the air in a deadly arc.

Starshimmer’s magic flared to life without warning, a burst of energy shooting from her horn and forming a protective shield around them just as the manticore’s stinger struck. The creature’s tail bounced off the shield with a sharp crack, and it let out a surprised growl, stumbling back.

Steelheart’s eyes flicked toward Starshimmer, and for a moment, there was a flicker of approval in his gaze.

“Now!” Steelheart barked, casting a binding spell that wrapped around the manticore, holding it in place.

The creature struggled for a moment before finally going still, its growls softening into a low, defeated rumble.

Starshimmer’s heart was racing, her breath coming in short gasps as the shield flickered out. She had done it again—her magic had worked, but only when she was pushed to the limit.

Steelheart nodded, his expression unreadable. “Well done, Starshimmer. You showed real potential there.”

Starshimmer blinked, her mind still spinning from the rush of magic. “I… I did?”

Steelheart didn’t answer, turning his attention back to the manticore. “Let’s get this creature back to Earthsong’s enclosure. Quickly.”

Shimmer Hooves, still shaking, let out a weak laugh. “I… I’m never making fun of Ironmane again.”

Starshimmer chuckled, though her thoughts were elsewhere. Something was happening with her magic—something she didn’t fully understand. But whatever it was, it was growing stronger.


The journey back to Professor Earthsong’s enclosure was quiet, save for the occasional rustle of leaves as Steelheart led them through the darkened forest. The baby manticore, still wrapped in Steelheart’s binding spell, let out the occasional growl of protest but otherwise seemed subdued.

Starshimmer’s mind raced, her thoughts swirling between what had just happened and Steelheart’s brief words of praise. Her magic had worked when it mattered most, and though it had felt wild and uncontrolled, she had protected them. She had acted without thinking, driven purely by instinct, and it had worked.

Beside her, Shimmer Hooves was walking stiffly, still pale from the ordeal. Every now and then, his eyes flicked nervously toward the manticore, as if expecting its scorpion tail to lash out at them again. But even through his fear, he couldn’t help but glance at Starshimmer with a mix of awe and relief.

“Starry,” he whispered, nudging her as they neared the enclosure, “that was incredible back there. I mean, I thought we were goners, and then boom, you throw up a shield like it’s nothing!”

Starshimmer flushed, glancing down at her hooves. “I don’t know how I did it… It just happened.”

“Well, it happened at the right time,” Shimmer Hooves said with a shaky grin. “I was about two seconds away from fainting.”

Steelheart’s deep voice interrupted their conversation as they arrived at the entrance to Professor Earthsong’s enclosure. “Quiet, you two. We need to calm the creature before we put him back.”

The enclosure was peaceful in the moonlight, the crystalline plants casting faint glimmers across the ground. The baby manticore growled softly as Steelheart levitated it over to a large, sturdy cage, carefully placing the creature inside. Once the door was secured, Steelheart pulled a thick, woven blanket from a nearby shelf and draped it over the cage, his movements slow and deliberate.

The manticore let out a low, rumbling noise, but the darkness and warmth of the blanket seemed to soothe it. After a moment, the growling subsided, and the manticore curled up into a ball, its tail tucked safely beneath it.

“There,” Steelheart said, his voice softer now, though it still carried the weight of command. “That should keep him calm for the night.”

Starshimmer watched as Steelheart stood beside the cage for a moment, his imposing figure illuminated by the soft light of the enclosure. She had always seen him as intimidating, a wall of muscle and authority. But now, in this quiet moment, she saw something different—a kind of gentleness in the way he had handled the manticore, and a quiet understanding that went beyond the tough exterior.

As if sensing her thoughts, Steelheart turned to face her and Shimmer Hooves. “You both did well tonight,” he said, his voice firm but not unkind. “Especially you, Starshimmer. What you did back there—using your magic in the face of danger—that’s what we expect from students at Celestia’s School of Magic. Bravery doesn’t mean acting without fear. It means acting despite it.”

Starshimmer’s heart swelled at his words, a small, warm glow of pride settling in her chest. For the first time since she had arrived at the school, she felt like she had done something right, something worthy of recognition.

“Thank you, sir,” she said quietly, her voice filled with gratitude.

Steelheart gave a small nod, his expression softening for just a moment before returning to his usual stern demeanor. “Now, both of you, back to your dormitories. It’s well past curfew, and I don’t need to remind you what kind of trouble you’ll be in if you’re caught.”

Shimmer Hooves groaned. “More trouble? I think we’ve had enough punishment for one night.”

“Then don’t linger in the hallways,” Steelheart said, his voice carrying a note of finality. “Get back to your dorms, and keep quiet.”

With that, he turned and disappeared into the shadows of the enclosure, leaving Starshimmer and Shimmer Hooves standing in the soft glow of the moonlight.

Shimmer Hooves let out a long, exaggerated sigh of relief. “Okay. We survived. Barely.”

Starshimmer smiled, still feeling the rush of Steelheart’s unexpected praise. “Come on, let’s get back before we run into any more trouble.”

The two of them started walking back toward the school, their hootsteps quiet on the forest path. The night air was cool and crisp, and the towering trees around them seemed to watch silently as they made their way through the shadows.

“Steelheart’s actually kind of… nice,” Starshimmer said after a moment, her voice thoughtful. “I mean, he’s still scary, but not in the way I thought.”

Shimmer Hooves nodded, though he was still glancing nervously over his shoulder every few steps. “Yeah, a gentle giant. Emphasis on giant. I’d hate to be on his bad side, though.”

Starshimmer chuckled. “Same.”

They walked in companionable silence for a while, the looming towers of the School of Magic growing closer as they neared the edge of the forest. The night was still, the only sounds the rustle of leaves and the distant call of a night bird.

As they entered the school grounds and approached the main building, Shimmer Hooves let out a low whistle. “We are way past curfew. I don’t think we’ve ever been out this late before.”

Starshimmer nodded, feeling a slight twinge of nervousness. Getting caught wandering the halls after curfew would definitely land them in more trouble—something she was keen to avoid. She was just about to suggest they hurry when a faint flicker of movement caught her eye.

She froze, her gaze narrowing as she looked toward one of the side corridors that led deeper into the school. At first, she thought it was just a trick of the shadows, but then she saw it again—a figure moving quietly, almost stealthily.

“Hey, do you see that?” Starshimmer whispered, stopping in her tracks.

Shimmer Hooves’ ears flicked nervously. “See what?”

“There,” she said, pointing with a hoof toward the side hallway. “Somepony’s sneaking around.”

Shimmer Hooves squinted, his wings stiffening as he followed her gaze. “Maybe it’s just a teacher doing rounds. We should—”

His words trailed off as the figure stepped into the dim light of a nearby lantern, revealing a tall, cloaked pony with a flowing beard and a familiar, towering hat.

Starshimmer’s heart skipped a beat. “That’s Professor Starswirl.”

They both stood frozen, watching as Starswirl moved silently down the corridor, his hooves barely making a sound on the stone floor. But what caught Starshimmer’s attention most wasn’t just that it was Starswirl—it was where he was heading.

At the far end of the hallway stood a large, ornate door made of dark wood, its frame carved with intricate runes and symbols. Starshimmer had seen that door before—everypony knew what it was. The entrance to Headmistress Celestia’s forbidden library.

“What’s he doing?” Starshimmer whispered, her curiosity piqued.

Shimmer Hooves’ wings snapped open in alarm. “Whoa, whoa. No. We are not getting involved in whatever this is. You saw what happened last time we went after something dangerous!”

“But he’s sneaking into the forbidden library,” Starshimmer said, her eyes wide with intrigue. “That’s not normal. Why would he be doing that at this hour?”

Shimmer Hooves looked like he was about to take off into the air. “Does it matter? We’re already past curfew, and we’re definitely not supposed to be here! We don’t need more trouble, Starry.”

Starshimmer’s hooves shuffled restlessly, torn between her curiosity and the very real threat of getting into more trouble. But the temptation to follow Starswirl was strong. What could he be doing in the forbidden library so late at night?

Before she could take another step, Shimmer Hooves grabbed her tail with his teeth and yanked her back. “No. We are not following him. We’ve had enough adventure for one night, and I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to spend the rest of the year in detention.”

Starshimmer huffed, her ears drooping slightly. “Fine. But something’s going on, Shimmer. I just know it.”

Shimmer Hooves let out a nervous laugh, flicking his tail as he nudged her toward the dormitories. “Yeah, well, you’ll have plenty of time to figure it out when we’re not sneaking around after curfew. Let’s go before we run into another professor.”

With a final glance back at the shadowy corridor, Starshimmer reluctantly followed her friend, her hooves tapping quietly against the stone as they made their way back. Her mind was racing, filled with questions. What was Starswirl doing in the forbidden library? And why did it feel like something bigger was happening behind the scenes?

Next Chapter