Before Cookie Crumble could finish cleaning off his cock, Button took a few steps away from the couch, trying to catch his breath after busting two loads over the milf. He looked at the clock and saw he had been here for almost an hour. The thought of Sweetie Belle coming back from her hunt for candy made him nervous. He looked down and saw the mess he made, trying to quickly figure out a fast escape in case she walked inside.

"So..." Cookie Crumble cooed, licking the cum from her fingers and smiling seductively at him. "You wanna do anything else?" She stood there, a dazed look on her face as she licked the jizz off of her massive chest. Her body was covered in his seed, and she was panting hard.

"No, sorry, but I need to go home." Button replied, quickly grabbing his pants and attempting to adjust his shirt. However, without warning, both clothes vanished, leaving him completely naked in front of her. "H-hey! Give those back!"

"That wasn't me..." She giggled at all his nerdy muscles and body frame exposed. "Looks like a certain somepony wants you to stay a bit longer."

Button's head whipped around as his eyes narrowed. His ears flicked at the lustful breath behind him. The sound of footsteps coming closer and the feeling of a warm presence next to him. "Oh no..." He shivered in absolute terror at the possibility. Confusingly, a purple mane drifted over his shoulders, followed by arms that were clearly not Sweetie Belle, a large pair of breasts bouncing around his head.

"Mother, dear. You are so selfish," Rarity's voice echoed behind him. "To take such a cute and lovely young stallion, without inviting me!" She tilted him around to the visage of her own sexy costume, a pirate outfit with an open front for her cleavage, and a small cut-off skirt, showing her large ass, thighs, and long legs in black heeled boots. "And to think, I was generous enough to let you ride my Spikey on occasion. The least you could do is share."

"I'm so sorry, daughter." Cookie leaned back and let her daughter enjoy the snack. "You can have him next. He's very nice and polite." She licked her lips and climbed onto the couch to watch them work.

Rarity's eyes narrowed and her smile grew. "So... how about a little trick or treat, handsome?" She spun him against the wall and dropped down to her knees, pushing his cock into her cleavage.

Button let out a loud gasp, his body shivering. He felt her soft, smooth breasts engulf his shaft. The leather of her costume kept a tight grip on his member, the coolness of the material compared to the heat of her chest sending shivers up his spine. He watched her rub her boobs together, the sensation of her hard nipples poking into his dick caused him to buck his hips, his balls twitching.

Rarity giggled, her voice low and seductive, pressing her arms against the wall and trapping him in place. She slowly moved her chest up and down, her breasts squeezing his cock, and her body shivering against his balls, the soft texture of her skin and the warm heat of her body were driving him insane. Button closed his eyes, his breathing was ragged and uneven, and his face was red and hot from the sheer thought of both women alone. His mind reeled as her boobs continued to massage his shaft.

"You have such a big and juicy cock." Rarity cooed, her breath brushing against his skin "It's so thick and hard... I can't wait to have it inside my tight ass." She whispered, shaking her chest harder.

"Please... stop teasing me..." Button begged, his eyes watering, his heart racing. He felt his body tremble, his cock pulsing and throbbing, the pressure in his balls building up. Again, just like clockwork, the phone rang again. Luckily, this time, it was Rarity's phone, not his

"Oh my, that's Sweetie's ringtone." Rarity laughed, letting the phone ring for a bit and then picking it up and placing it between her shoulder and ear. "Hello dear, did you get a lot of candy tonight?" Her eyes narrowed, and her grin got bigger as her breasts went faster.

"Sister?! Have you seen Button Mash?" Sweetie shouted, the sounds of a party echoing in the background. "I've been looking everywhere for him!"

"Well, why yes, I have." Rarity's voice was calm and collected, though the sounds of her tits squelching over Button's wet and sloppy dick was obvious.

"What's that noise?" Sweetie pleaded, sounding so desperate. "Did I interrupt you and Spike again?"

"No, he's out trick-or-treating too." Rarity's tone was casual and nonchalant. "Something about visiting Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon. Maybe Button Mash is over there."

"Oh no..." He gulped and took a deep breath, the sound of his wet and sticky dick plopping against the fashionista's boobs was obvious.

"What's wrong dear sister?" Rarity smirked, her tits working faster. "It's not like your coltfriend is being held against his will. You can go check on him." She bit her lip at the irony of her words, feeling his cock throbbing against her chest.

Sweetie Belle huff and groaned. "He's not my coldfriend?!"

"Then why are you calling me?" Rarity asked, her eyes glued to the young stallion, who was about to bust a nut in her cleavage. Button winced harder as merely hearing Sweetie Belle's voice was too much. "I'm sure Button will call you when he's done..." She shuttered at the building pressure hung up the phone, then pushed her breasts even tighter, causing him to squeal.

"Please... Rarity, stop teasing me!" Sweetie Belle huffed and hung up, giving her final word. "I'm heading home."

"Oh Button..." She licked her lips, her hands grasping the sides of her boobs and squeezed them around his length. "You truly are a heartless stallion--" She was cut off as white sticky fluid shot from his tip, and coated her face. The young stallion gasped, his body twitching, his mind blanking. Rarity closed her eyes and mouth, but she couldn't help herself and moaned as his seed splashed her lips. "Sweetie Belle has quite the spell over you. But, we're not done yet."

Button's legs shook as his orgasm ended, his body slumped forward, his chest heaving. He was a sweaty mess, and his dick was still rock-hard. Especially as Rarity swung her body around and puffed up her ass, giving him a perfect view of her dripping pussy and perky anus.

"We better move faster." Rarity growled, rubbing her ass against his crotch, her eyes glowing with lust. "Don't want Sweetie Belle walking in on all of this." She giggled as her mother began rubbing herself out to the scene. "Since we don't have all night..." She smirked and pushed his dick against her anus, the heat making him groan.

Button moaned, his hips bucking as her ass pushed him into the wall. He felt the softness of her skin and the wetness of her flesh. The fashionista's ass was soft and plump, and her tight hole gripped his shaft like a vice. He couldn't believe this was happening twice in one night. Inside another mare so quickly.

"Fuck, your dick is amazing." Rarity groaned, her hands against the floor, gyrating her hips as the young stallion began to slowly push back. Her tits slowly swung left and right out of her pirate jacket, her hair flowing freely. "Yes, right there... That's the spot."

Button placed his hands on her ass and squeezed her cheeks. He pushed his cock back and forth, having little effort in making her scream with joy. She was so tight, and the friction of her anal walls was incredible compared to her mother's overused pussy. He gritted his teeth and leaned in, taking a hand full of her hair.

"Harder, young punk!" She screamed out, her hips bucking back into him. Her body just kept shattering any sense of composure.

His balls were aching with more lust then he had in a long time. The young stallion growled, hips moving on their own, hands slowly riging up to spank her asscheeks. He could feel her anus gripping his shaft, the heat of her body and the pressure of his cock made his heart race and body tingle. The young stallion couldn't help but yank her hair back harder and get lost in the moment. The phone rang one final agonizing time and this time, he flat out ignored it, knowing it was his phone but too much in lust to care.

Rarity let out a loud squeal, her body convulsing, her juices coating his dick and thighs. Her ass cheeks rippling with each hit and her face flushing red. "Yes, yes, yes!" She moaned, her hips jerking as the young stallion began plowing her harder, his balls churning and cock throbbing.

Button gritted his teeth as the visages of Sweetie Belle returned. Somehow, after plowing both her mother and older sister, the annoying young mare's image just keeps reappearing in his head. However, where inside her mother all he could think about was how cruel Sweetie Belle was treating him, all he could see now was all the softer and kind moments they shared.

From their many night marathon video games and binging anime. Her many trips to his house to try out some new cosplays with him and go to cons. On the rare chances that he didn't even need to ask her to wear sexiest pieces, the mare would just show up in them and tease him. And the nights he spent holding her and stroking her mane after they got drunk with friends. All the times she cuddled him for warmth on those cold nights outside. The memories flashed before his eyes as his body gave in.

"Ahh!" Button cried out, his body tensing up. "Sweetie Belle..." His breathing got worse the moment he spoke her name out loud.

"That's it, baby... Cum out at her name." Rarity whimpered, pushing him out of her anus and slapping the cock right between her asscheeks. She grinned at the sounds of the door unlocking, making sure he was in full view of anypony that dare come through the entrance. "Shower me in the white seed Sweetie Belle kept refusing!!"

"Sweetie Belle!" Button gasped, his balls tensed and his cock flexed, his body shivering. Just as the door flew open and Sweetie Belle's real voice hit his ears, all the semen rained over Rarity. A huge amount splashed her ass and back, the rest covered her costume and hair, and a little dripped onto the floor.

"What the fuck is going on here?!" Sweetie Belle stood in the doorway, her jaw hanging open. Button Mash flipped around in a mess of confusion, lust still steering within him. Especailly upon seeing Sweetie Belle's costume. He was in such boredom before hearing her choose trick or treating that he totally ignored her costume originally. However, after fucking her mother and older sister, his senses were in overdrive upon seeing her full cleavage and thighs on display in a princess peach costume, his favorite video game girl now less, all he could do was bust another rope.

The sight of her mother and sister covered in Button's cum was crazy enough for Sweetie Belle, but upon seeing Button blast off another right in front of her, all over her sister's ass, just kick things even higher. She dropped her candy, slammed the door, and charged right at him. "You bastard!"

Button's heart sank into total terror and he held his hands up, trying his best to mend anything out of all these mistakes. However, it just kept jumping from 10 to 0 then to a full 20. As with no regard that her mother and sister had just ridden him like a wild horse, Sweetie Belle braced Button against the wall and locked lips with him.

******

Author's Note

Well, Sweetie Belle seemed pretty mad... And Button was a total asshole... I guess things were bound to go this route