Equestria's Nightmare Night Party Hijinks

When Sunny, Izzy, Hitch and Sparky arrived with Sprout and Posey to prepare for the prank at the upstairs library, Sunny closed the door and said; “I'm sure it was in here.”

“Yeah! This sound is getting louder.” Izzy said.

Suddenly, Sprout turned off the lights, leaving Sunny, Izzy, Hitch and Sparky confused at what’s going on, only to find that the tape recorder in the cabinet is missing!

“Uh… what just happened here?” Hitch asked.

“Sprout, what are you waiting for?!” Posey whispered, feeling rushed.

“I can’t find it!” Sprout exclaimed as he was looking at the cabinet.

“What do you mean, you can’t find it?” Posey asked. “Something doesn’t feel right…”

“Like I said, "I'm sure it was in here!" Sunny said.

“Besides, it’s coming at us!” Izzy said.

“…and the noise is getting louder and louder!” Hitch continued.

Then, the Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin-headed figure that looked exactly like the one Sunny, Izzy, Hitch and Sparky saw earlier suddenly comes floating into the room. Posey and Sprout gasp at this unusual sight. As the figure floats closer to them, it vanishes in a cloud of dust. Sunny, Izzy, Hitch and Sparky chuckles as Posey and Sprout run out of the room screaming.

“Pretty cool prank, huh?” asked Sunny.

“Were you scared?” Hitch asked.

“Boy, those 2 earth ponies are REALLY scared!” Izzy laughed, while Sparky laughed along.

“That was MEAN!” Sprout cried.

“VERY MEAN!” Posey yelled.

“AND I MEAN, VERY VERY, MEAN!” Sprout complained.

“Yeah! And worse than that, you guys stole our prank!” Posey complained.

“What? No, we didn't.” Sunny said.

“We would never steal a prank!” Izzy said. "Did we...?" She continued.

“We NEVER did, honest!” Hitch said.

"Guys, did you steal their prank?” asked Sunny, until there was no response. “Misty? Pipp? Zipp? Comet?”

“Where are you…?” Hitch asked.

“Ponies, where are you?” Izzy asked as she started looking for them, until Pipp, Zipp, & Comet came out from another room across from them.

“Hey, guys!” Pipp said as she and the others came out of the room.

“Here we are!” Zipp said, then she whispered to Sunny and the others; and said: “We have to get them to go in the playroom.”

“It was the only way to set up our prank.” Comet whispered too.

“Yeah. The library was locked. We set up in the playroom.” Pipp whispered.

“We had no other choice but to set up in the playroom.” Zipp responded. "It was the only way to set up the prank." She continued.

“Locked?” Izzy asked, while Sparky looked confused.

“What? What do you mean, “The library was locked”? Hitch said.

“What are you talking about? It’s not locked, it worked perfectly.” Sunny said, being honest.

“Yeah, the library wasn’t locked and the prank worked perfectly. Boy, those ponies are so scared!” Izzy exclaimed.

“We didn't do it.” Pipp said.

“Pipp has a point.” agreed Zipp. “Besides, there's a bunch of cool balloons and props over there. Also, a neat old tape recorder, too.” She continued as she pointed to the objects in the room.

Sprout and Posey saw the balloons and the old tape recorder, looking confused, that they found their props and thought that one of them had put them in there.

“Uh… Did you put them in there?” asked Sprout to her Posey.

Suddenly, The jack-o-lantern teen comes up from inside the prank-room, making the rest of the other ponies look very confused.

“Okay, Misty. What’s going on?” Sunny asked to the jack-o-lantern teen, looking annoyed,

“You mind telling us what the heck is going on?” Hitch asked, looking annoyed,

“Why did you pick a different room for our prank, while our prank was supposed to be at the library?” Izzy asked, looking annoyed. “Besides, why are you so silent lately? You’re sometimes talkative when you’re with your friends, but you, being silent?” She continued.

But at that moment, the real Misty, who arrived, comes hurrying up wearing a Handmare's costume from "The Handmare's Tale", panting.

“Sorry I’m late, guys. But I walked into the refrigerator and broke my pumpkin.” Misty said. “Can I be a Handmare instead?” she asked.

“What? There’s two Misties?” Izzy asked. “But, how?”

“There can’t be two Misties in this Equestria.” Hitch said.

“No, there aren’t…” Zipp replied

“Misty… If you just got here…” Sunny said as she and the others started to get frightened… “Then... who is...?” She asked as she and the others saw the hooded figure who they think is their friend.

Suddenly, the Mane 7, Sparky Sprout, & Posey finally realized that the Jack-O-Lantern-wearing teen pony doesn't have any hooves, meaning it's... AN ACTUAL GHOST!!! When the others saw the ghost, All them rushed downstairs and were screaming in horror, similar to that of Scooby-Doo and Ghostbusters, running away for their lives to brace themselves from the haunting creature as they rushed over to the adult ponies to explain what happened.

To Be Continued…