A Promise Between Us

by Caladis

Rating: teen
Tags: Sex, Sweetie Belle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Sad, Romance, Button Mash
Length: 4570

Sweetie Belle and Button Mash come together for the first time and make promises for the future.

This story is a Prequel for Sweetie Belle Would Never Cheat on Button Mash...

* * *

Sweetie Belle and Button Mash love spending time together playing games. On one such occasion, they discover deeper feelings. While they explore, they come to the realization that they aren't ready, but they make promises for the future.

* * *

Published 2024-11-16 02:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2024-11-16 02:10:01 UTC

Whispers of Trust

Sweetie Belle giggled as her avatar on the screen jumped and twirled, her tail flicking with excitement. “You always fall for that, Button,” she teased, her green eyes sparkling mischievously under her soft, curly mane. The gentle glow from the game console bathed the clubhouse in hues of blue and gold, catching the silken sheen of her coat. They sat on their haunches, surrounded by scattered game cartridges, crumpled snack wrappers, and empty juice boxes. Laughter bounced off the walls, mingling with the familiar beeps and boops of the game.

“Hey, that’s only because you cheat,” Button Mash huffed, a smirk playing on his muzzle as his hooves worked frantically over the buttons. He could feel the warmth radiating from Sweetie Belle, their flanks just barely brushing. The slight touch sent a tingle through his coat, making his ears twitch.

Sweetie Belle’s smirk deepened, and she leaned in, her velvety fur pressing into his side. “What can I say? I’m just that good.” Her giggle carried a victorious lilt as she pressed the final button, sealing her win. Button’s avatar tumbled across the screen in defeat, prompting a dramatic groan from him.

He turned to face her, their muzzles so close he could see the faint freckles dotting her cheeks. “Okay, that was definitely cheating,” he whispered, voice low with playful accusation. The game’s noises seemed to melt away, replaced by the racing thump of his heart and the rustle of their tails brushing.

Sweetie Belle’s laughter softened, her eyes locking with his, playful but glinting with a newfound boldness. “Maybe,” she said, her voice barely above a whisper, “but what are you going to do about it?” The challenge in her tone hung between them like a spark ready to ignite.

Button’s hoof stilled on the controller, his gaze shifting to her parted lips and the way they quivered in anticipation. His muzzle edged closer, drawn by the soft, inviting warmth of her breath.

Sweetie Belle’s eyes widened as Button’s muzzle brushed hers, the warmth of the touch sending a shiver down her spine. The controller in her hooves slipped and clattered to the floor, forgotten as the gap between them disappeared. His breath fanned against her cheek, and for a moment, all she could hear was the rapid thumping of her heart echoing in her ears.

Button Mash hesitated, caught in the sweetness of the moment, his chest tightening as he watched her expression shift from surprise to something deeper. Sweetie Belle’s lashes fluttered, and a soft sigh escaped her lips, coaxing him to press closer. Their muzzles met in a gentle kiss, tentative at first, the light brush of fur and warmth making the world outside blur into irrelevance.

The kiss deepened, and Sweetie Belle’s hooves found their way around Button’s neck, pulling him closer as her mane cascaded around them in soft, curling waves. Button’s heart raced, pounding so hard he thought she might hear it. The scent of her - vanilla and the faintest hint of wildflowers - enveloped him, making his head spin.

He pulled back slightly, eyes searching hers for any hint of doubt, but Sweetie Belle’s smile was bright, her gaze lidded and full of excitement. Emboldened, she tilted her head, nuzzling into the crook of his neck, her breath warm and uneven. “Looks like you’re not too mad about losing after all,” she teased, her voice playful but tinged with something new, an edge of affection that made Button’s ears flick.

Button chuckled, his voice low as he leaned into her touch. “Not when I’m winning at this,” he replied, pressing a kiss to her cheek.

Sweetie Belle’s giggle turned softer, breathier as Button’s lips grazed her cheek. The warmth of his touch left a trail that made her fur prickle in the best way. She shifted, pressing herself closer until their foreheads touched, and the soft curls of her mane tickled his brow. The clubhouse seemed to tighten around them, cozy and filled with the shared heat of their closeness.

“Button…” she murmured, the word hanging between them like an invitation. Her hooves trailed down his shoulders, lingering in a caress that made his breath hitch. His brown eyes met hers, wide with a mix of excitement and wonder. He could barely think past the rapid drumming of his heart, the way Sweetie Belle’s eyes seemed to glisten, reflecting the soft light and the moment they were weaving together.

He leaned in again, this time with a little more confidence, capturing her lips in a kiss that deepened slowly, naturally. Sweetie Belle sighed into it, the sound soft and sweet, her body responding with a shiver as their chests pressed together. Button’s hoof came up to cradle her face, gentle and steadying, as if anchoring them both in the moment.

They parted for breath, only to find themselves drawn back again, their movements synchronized in an unspoken rhythm. Sweetie Belle’s tail swished behind her, brushing against Button’s hind legs, adding to the fluttering sensation that rippled down his spine.

Her voice broke the quiet, husky and barely above a whisper. “You know, we could play this game all day…” She traced a tiny circle on his chest, her eyes bright with mischief, “but I think I found something I like even better.”

Button grinned, a rosy flush spreading under his chestnut fur. “Yeah?” His voice had a slight quiver, an edge of disbelief that this moment was real. Sweetie Belle nodded, her smile a blend of shyness and boldness that made his heart flip.

“Definitely,” she said, and their laughter mingled softly as they leaned into each other once more, the sounds of the outside world melting away into blissful silence.

Sweetie Belle’s lips brushed Button’s with renewed urgency, a hunger sparking between them that felt electric. The soft rustling of their movement was the only sound in the clubhouse, each shift of hooves and bodies bringing them closer, pressing into each other as if they needed the contact to breathe. Her tail flicked and curled behind her, brushing his side as they deepened their embrace, the touch sending a shiver rippling through Button’s body.

Button’s hoof moved down her back, tracing the curve of her spine, feeling the warmth radiating from her. Sweetie Belle responded with a soft sound, leaning into him, her mane falling like a curtain around their faces. Their breath mingled in the small space, hot and shared, and Button could feel the erratic thumping of his heart against hers. It was almost dizzying how natural it felt, as if this moment had been waiting for them all along.

“Button,” she whispered, breaking the kiss but keeping her muzzle close enough that every word trembled against his lips. Her eyes, wide and searching, held a spark that made Button’s breath catch. It was a look that asked a question and gave an answer all at once.

He didn’t need words to respond. Instead, he pressed another kiss to her neck, lingering there, feeling her pulse quicken under his touch. Sweetie Belle sighed, the sound turning into a quiet hum as his lips explored down, leaving a warm path along the edge of her jaw and down to the soft dip between her shoulders. Her hooves tightened around him, holding him close, a silent encouragement that left no doubt of her desire.

The clubhouse, their once simple hideaway for games and laughter, became something more - an intimate cocoon that held their shared secret, a moment where they were no longer just friends but something deeper, more entwined.

Sweetie Belle tilted her head back, eyes fluttering closed as Button's kisses sent ripples of warmth cascading through her. The gentle press of his lips on her neck made her fur stand on end, every sensation magnified in the closeness between them. She felt his breath, warm and steady, as it traced along her collarbone. Her hooves slid over his shoulders, holding him tighter, wanting more of the electrifying connection that made the air hum around them.

Button paused, drawing back slightly to take in her expression. Her cheeks were flushed, her green eyes opening to meet his gaze with a mixture of curiosity and trust. The space between them seemed to crackle, alive with the unspoken feelings that had built over time. He raised a hoof, brushing a stray lock of her mane from her face, hoof lingering as he let himself get lost in the soft curve of her smile.

“Are you okay?” he asked, voice low, breaking through the quiet with a tone that was tender, searching.

Sweetie Belle nodded, her eyes never leaving his. “More than okay,” she whispered, her voice trembling just slightly, enough to make Button’s chest tighten. Emboldened by her words, he leaned in again, their noses brushing before their lips found each other in a kiss that was deeper, more insistent. Sweetie Belle’s breath hitched, a tiny sound escaping her as she shifted, her body pressing into his with newfound urgency.

Their hooves roamed, exploring the familiar yet exciting terrain of each other's forms. Button’s heart thudded in his chest as his hoof traced down her side, feeling the rise and fall of her breath, the warmth of her body under his touch. Sweetie Belle’s mane spilled over his foreleg as she leaned further into him, the softness of it tickling his fur and adding to the heady mix of sensations.

Time seemed to slow, the boundaries of the clubhouse fading as they lost themselves in the heat building between them. Sweetie Belle’s tail curled and brushed against Button’s hind leg, a subtle, instinctual movement that made them both shiver. Her giggle, soft and breathless, broke the silence for a moment, a shared acknowledgment of how much everything was changing, and how right it felt.

Their kisses deepened, and the playful giggle that escaped Sweetie Belle turned into a soft sigh as Button’s hooves caressed her sides, tracing the delicate line of her ribs and down to her hips. The touch was gentle, almost hesitant, but the warmth behind it sent sparks through her, making her press even closer. She could feel the rapid thud of his heart against her chest, mirroring the wild beat of her own.

Sweetie Belle’s mane tumbled over her shoulders as she shifted, her body brushing against Button’s with each movement. The soft caress of his coat against hers was almost hypnotic, every tiny shift drawing a new rush of warmth that made her fur prickle. The space between them, once filled with playful banter, now held a different energy - one that wrapped around them, heady and electric.

“Sweetie…” Button’s voice cracked slightly as he whispered her name, a mix of awe and longing that made her ears perk and a new shiver run down her spine. She met his gaze, the shared look saying everything their words hadn’t. There was a pause, an unspoken question held in the air, and Sweetie Belle answered it with a smile, leaning in and capturing his lips again, more firmly this time.

The kiss carried them, deeper and deeper, hooves exploring with a curiosity that only grew with each touch. Sweetie Belle’s tail wrapped around Button’s leg, a subtle, instinctive move that pulled them even closer. The warmth of their bodies, the quickened breaths, and the mingling of soft fur and steady heartbeats created a rhythm that felt natural and thrilling.

Button’s hoof found its way up to cradle her face, drawing soft circles just beneath her ear, while his other leg wrapped around her, holding her against him. Sweetie Belle felt a blush spread across her cheeks and down her neck, the heat spreading as she shifted, their muzzles brushing as they caught their breath, eyes locked.

“Still winning?” she teased softly, her voice a whisper that made Button grin, his face lighting up even as it flushed.

“Definitely,” he said, his laugh a warm, shared breath between them before they closed the distance again, their world shrinking to just this, just them.

The air around them felt thick with anticipation, every breath mingled as Sweetie Belle leaned deeper into Button’s embrace. The way his hooves held her, firm yet trembling, sent a thrill coursing through her. She felt his chest rise and fall in sync with her own, a shared rhythm that made everything else fade into a blur of warmth and closeness.

Button’s heart raced as Sweetie Belle’s soft mane brushed against his muzzle, the subtle scent of vanilla filling his senses. His hoof traced down her neck, pausing as he felt her shiver at his touch, a silent signal that made him bolder. The space between them all but disappeared as their bodies pressed together, exploring the uncharted connection they were creating moment by moment.

Sweetie Belle nuzzled into the curve of his neck, planting a gentle kiss that made Button’s breath hitch. She could feel the tension in his frame, the mix of nervousness and excitement that mirrored her own. It was new and exhilarating, a discovery that made her heart flutter with each shared caress. Her voice, soft and teasing, broke the quiet. “I never knew you could be so daring, Button.”

He chuckled, the sound low and breathless. “Neither did I,” he admitted, eyes searching hers with a mix of affection and disbelief at how naturally they’d fallen into this moment. The faintest hint of a grin touched his lips before he leaned in, capturing her mouth in another kiss, this one more confident, more sure.

Sweetie Belle’s hooves traced the outline of his jaw and down to his chest, the rise and fall of it quickening under her touch. She felt a warmth build between them, spreading like fire under her coat, every shift and movement igniting more of that electric feeling. Button’s hoof slid down her back, leaving a path of shivers in its wake, as if he wanted to memorize every part of her.

Sweetie Belle’s breath came in soft, shallow waves as she pressed her forehead against Button’s, eyes half-lidded with a mixture of desire and uncertainty. The warmth of his hooves wrapped around her felt grounding, yet it amplified the fluttering in her chest. She bit her lip, hesitating for just a moment before the words spilled out, soft and trembling.

“I want to go further,” she whispered, the sound barely more than a breath against his ear. “But… I’m not sure that we should.” Her eyes searched his face for an answer, something to calm the rush of thoughts racing through her mind. The uncharted thrill of their closeness was balanced on a knife's edge with her lingering doubt.

Button’s ears twitched, catching her whisper. He pulled back just enough to look at her, brown eyes soft and earnest, taking in every nuance of her expression. The warmth of her words lingered between them, and for a moment, all he could do was listen to the quick, shared rhythm of their breathing.

“Sweetie,” he said gently, his voice a steady reassurance. He brought a hoof up to touch her cheek, tracing its softness as he continued, “We don’t have to do anything we’re not ready for.” His gaze held hers, full of understanding and patience, even as his own heart raced with the intensity of the moment.

She nodded slowly, the tension in her shoulders easing as Button’s words sank in. The room felt quieter, calmer, the fire between them simmering down to a warm, mutual glow. Sweetie Belle’s lips quirked into a small, grateful smile.

“Thanks,” she murmured, pressing a soft kiss to the corner of his mouth, her heart still fluttering but now wrapped in a sense of safety.

Button Mash’s ears turned crimson as he realized the undeniable response of his body, betraying him despite his words. His eyes darted down for a split second before he shifted, trying to tuck his tail tighter to obscure himself, the embarrassment rolling over him in waves. He bit his lip, the heat in his cheeks almost too much to bear as he glanced at Sweetie Belle, hoping she hadn’t noticed, yet knowing it was impossible for her not to.

Sweetie Belle’s eyes dropped to the subtle movement, and a blush spread across her own cheeks. For a moment, neither of them spoke, the air thick with the mixture of affection, nerves, and unspoken curiosity. She shifted her weight, the hesitant smile still playing on her lips as she looked back up into his wide, nervous eyes.

“It’s okay, Button,” she said softly, breaking the silence, her voice filled with understanding and a touch of shyness herself. The reassurance in her tone was enough to make Button’s racing heart skip a beat. She reached out, placing a hoof on his, the simple touch speaking more than words could.

Button swallowed hard, managing a sheepish smile as he relaxed under her gentle gesture, the embarrassment still present but tempered by her warmth.

Sweetie Belle’s blush deepened, but a playful smile curved her lips as she shifted, the shyness in her eyes balanced by a glimmer of trust and curiosity. “I’ve seen yours,” she whispered, her voice soft but carrying an undeniable spark. “Look at mine.”

The room seemed to still around them, the quiet enveloping them like a cocoon. Button’s breath caught in his throat as his gaze met hers, searching for any hint of uncertainty. What he found instead was warmth, the same shared curiosity that had been building between them.

Slowly, Sweetie Belle shifted, moving just enough to reveal herself, the vulnerability of the moment only making the air between them feel more intimate. Button’s ears burned with a mix of surprise and anticipation, his heart thudding loudly as he took in the sight. It was a moment suspended in time, filled with the silent exchange of trust and the bond they were deepening together.

Their eyes met again, and a small, nervous giggle escaped Sweetie Belle, breaking the tension with its sweetness. Button couldn’t help but smile in return, his earlier embarrassment easing as he reached out, their hooves brushing, grounding them both in the shared experience.

Button Mash felt his pulse quicken as he swallowed hard, a nervous shiver running down his spine. Slowly, he moved his tail aside, letting the barrier between them fall as he met Sweetie Belle’s gaze, eyes wide with a mix of awe and vulnerability. The soft warmth of the moment was threaded with anticipation, and he could feel every heartbeat like a drum in his chest.

“That was brave of you,” he whispered, his voice carrying the weight of sincerity. His lips quirked into a smile, shy but genuine. “I’ve liked you for a while, Sweetie Belle, but I didn’t think it was possible to respect you more than I already do.”

Sweetie Belle’s cheeks flushed a deeper pink, the flutter in her chest intensifying as his words sank in. The honesty and admiration in his voice sent a warmth spreading through her, softening the nervous tension between them. She reached out, her hoof gently covering his, and squeezed lightly, a silent thank you for his openness.

“I’ve liked you too,” she admitted, the confession carrying an air of relief and joy. The shared secret now spoken felt like a bridge between them, connecting them in a way that made everything around them fade into the background.

Button’s eyes softened, the vulnerability in his gaze now mingled with a quiet, determined warmth. He took a breath, steadying himself before speaking, his voice a tender murmur that seemed to resonate between them. “With your permission,” he said, his hoof moving gently to cup her cheek, “I’d like to love you.”

Sweetie Belle’s eyes glistened as she took in his words, the sincerity and patience they carried. The rapid thrum of her heart slowed, steadied by the gentle weight of the moment. She leaned into his touch, the soft fur of her cheek pressing into his hoof as she nodded, a small, genuine smile breaking across her lips.

“I’d like that too,” she whispered, the words filled with a mixture of anticipation and trust. The world outside the small clubhouse felt distant, insignificant compared to the closeness they now shared.

Button’s heart swelled at her response, the space between them charged with a warmth that was deeper than anything he had imagined. Slowly, he leaned in, their foreheads touching as they shared a breath, their world narrowing to just them, just this moment.

Button and Sweetie Belle shared a nervous laugh, the initial rush of their confession settling into an uncharted, tender awkwardness. They exchanged glances filled with curiosity and a bit of uncertainty, their cheeks flushed as they tried to figure out what came next. Their hooves, tentative and unpracticed, moved in gentle exploration, each touch sparking tiny jolts of excitement and hesitation.

Button’s hoof traced down Sweetie Belle’s side, light as a feather, as if he feared going too fast. She shivered at the touch, a soft, involuntary reaction that made them both giggle, breaking the tension. “Sorry,” he muttered, his smile sheepish and his eyes wide with wonder.

Sweetie Belle shook her head, the curls of her mane brushing against him. “Don’t be,” she said, her voice warm and breathy. Her own hooves moved along his shoulders, exploring the strong lines beneath his fur, the unfamiliar territory making her heart pound. Their movements were clumsy, their breath quickening as they adjusted and shifted, figuring out the rhythm between them.

They paused now and then, exchanging glances and reassuring smiles, the occasional giggle escaping when their hooves bumped or they hesitated in uncertainty. It was an innocent dance, the fumbling touches more meaningful because of the care and trust they shared. Every moment was a new discovery, a step further into a closeness neither had ever experienced.

Sweetie Belle’s eyes darted up to Button’s, wide with a flicker of panic as she let out a shaky breath. The warmth and thrill of the moment had been replaced by a sudden rush of uncertainty. “Button,” she whispered, her voice quivering with nerves, “what feels natural? What should we do next?”

Button’s expression softened as he took in the hint of worry in her eyes. He gave a gentle smile, his own heartbeat still pounding in his ears. He reached up, cupping her cheek with a comforting touch. “Hey,” he said softly, brushing a curl of her mane behind her ear. “It’s okay. We don’t have to rush this or try to figure it all out right now.”

Sweetie Belle’s breath steadied, her gaze searching his as she found solace in his words. The tenderness in Button’s eyes made her chest tighten in a different way - full of trust, not fear. He let out a small, nervous chuckle, a sound that eased some of the tension. “Let’s just… go with what feels right. Even if that’s just holding each other.”

Sweetie Belle’s smile returned, small and grateful. “I think I’d like that,” she said, the anxiety in her tone replaced by a soft warmth. Button wrapped his hooves around her, pulling her into a close, secure hug. They stayed like that for a moment, heartbeats calming as they felt the simplicity of being near each other. The gentle rise and fall of their chests aligned, and suddenly the need to rush disappeared, replaced by the contentment of being together in their shared, tender space.

Sweetie Belle’s eyes glistened, tears threatening to spill as her voice came out trembling, fragile. “Will you wait for me, Button? Can you wait until I’m ready? I don’t want to lose you.”

Button’s heart ached at the sight of her, the vulnerability in her voice cutting through him. Without hesitation, he tightened his embrace, pressing his forehead to hers, the warmth of their connection grounding them both. He drew a deep breath, steadying himself before speaking, his tone gentle and resolute.

“Sweetie Belle,” he whispered, his voice thick with emotion, “I’d wait as long as you need. You mean too much to me for it to be any other way.”

A tear rolled down her cheek, but a small, relieved smile followed. The fear of losing him eased, replaced by the reassuring steadiness in his words and the warmth in his eyes. She closed her eyes, leaning into him as they sat there, wrapped in each other’s presence and the unspoken promise that time wouldn’t change how they felt.

Sweetie Belle’s voice wavered, the question laced with doubt as she looked up at Button, searching his face for an answer that would soothe the ache in her chest. “I’m worried, Button. There are so many fillies in this town… and then there are older mares like my sister. You have so many options. Why would you wait for me?”

Button’s eyes softened, a quiet determination settling into his features as he listened to her. He gently reached for her hoof, intertwining it with his and holding it firmly between them. The touch was warm, anchoring them both as he spoke.

“Sweetie Belle, it’s not about options,” he said, his voice steady and sure. “It’s about you. I don’t want anypony else. You’re the one who makes me laugh, who challenges me, who makes every day feel brighter just by being there.” He paused, letting the words sink in as he met her gaze, deep and unwavering.

“I would wait for you because there’s no one else who makes me feel the way you do,” he continued, a gentle smile touching his lips. “It doesn’t matter how many others there are out there. You’re the one I care about.”

Sweetie Belle felt the weight in her chest lighten, the sincerity in his voice melting her worries away bit by bit. The fear of not being enough was still there, but it was softened by the glow of his words, the way his eyes never strayed from hers. She nodded slowly, a small, hopeful smile forming as she leaned into the comfort of his touch.

Sweetie Belle's lips curled into a playful smirk, her eyes shining with mischief as she tilted her head to look at Button. “Good,” she said, a teasing lilt in her voice. “Because if you betray me, I promise the punishment will be epic. And I expect you to take it like a good colt who would be very sorry.”

Button’s eyes widened before a grin tugged at the corners of his mouth, the tension between them easing into something lighter, familiar. He chuckled, shaking his head as a warm blush crept up his cheeks. “I wouldn’t dare cross you, Sweetie Belle. I’ve seen what you can do when you’re determined,” he replied, trying to match her playful tone but unable to hide the genuine affection in his voice.

Sweetie Belle’s smile softened, the hint of humor in her eyes fading into something more tender. She squeezed his hoof and leaned in, pressing a quick kiss to his cheek. “Good. Because I’d rather spend forever with you happy than ever having to make you regret it.”

Button’s heart thumped harder at the unexpected touch, his smile growing as he looked at her. “Forever sounds perfect to me,” he said, the words slipping out easily, like a promise meant only for them.

* * *

Author's Note

I Write Commissions. DM me with story ideas.