Limestone Pie always prides herself on getting the best gifts possible for everypony, except for one pony who seems to constantly prove impossible: Pinkie Pie. This Hearth's Warming, Limestone is determined to break the curse and get her cheerful sister a gift that shows how much she's appreciated.

There's just one problem, Limestone doesn't have a clue what to get for somepony as cheerful and outgoing as Pinkie. So, after consulting with Marble, Limestone takes advantage of a scheduled trip to Ponyville to visit Maud and ask her.

Can Marble and Maud help Limestone find the right gift for Pinkie in time?