Pinkie Pie comes to the Cutie Mark Crusaders with yet another terrifying tale. This time, she tells a story about a Princess Rarity and her bodyguard, Twilight Sparkle. Having to spend Nightmare Night cooped up together, Twilight tells her princess about her foalhood fear of Bloody Moory, a cow spirit that can be summoned from a mirror. Intrigued, Rarity decides they should summon her now. After all, what's the worst that could happen?

This is set in the Bodyguard AU (BGAU), and having read previous stories helps, but it isn't necessary.

There is no need to have read the previous Terrifying Tales.

Late Halloween story, second of two unrelated stories.