Then You Ain't Coming Home
Equestria.
A realm brimming with magic and wonder. From the majestic city perched on the edge of a towering mountain to the vast volcanic plains roamed by fearsome dragons, it was a mythological paradise where adventure seemed to beckon from every corner.
But not for you. Oh, no. Because you were… well, you. While the rest of this fantastical world basked in its epicness, you were stuck with a wheelbarrow full of rocks. Yes, rocks. Why, you ask? Because you worked for the Pie family of course! No monster-slaying, no grand adventures, and definitely no sweeping a princess (or two) off her hooves. Just you, some dirt, and an endless supply of stupid rocks.
But you can't be too mad at them. Because they're the ones that took you in when you had nowhere else to go.
Gracious, wasn’t it?
Not too long ago you were wandering aimlessly through a storm and stumbled across a farm ran by little, colorful, ponies.
It’s been nearly a year since that fateful day, and in that time, you’ve been working for them in exchange for room and board. Strange as it sounds, you’ve grown close to them—the quirky, hard-working, colorful little ponies that they are.
But right now, you were stuck in your own personal hell. You’d been trudging through this unforgiving mountainous terrain for what felt like an eternity, and judging by the unchanged horizon, you were no closer to home than you’d been an hour ago. The sun beat down relentlessly on the back of your neck, your sore feet protested with every step on the uneven gravel, and as if that wasn’t bad enough, the wheelbarrow you were hauling insisted on wobbling precariously with every bump. More than once, it nearly tipped over, and each time, you found yourself debating whether you should just fling the whole thing—and maybe yourself—over the nearest ledge.
Of course, every close call was met with an earful from your oh-so-cheerful companion.
"Careful, dummy! Don’t you know how to handle a wheelbarrow? Or is that too advanced for your tiny brain?"
The obnoxious voice cut through the oppressive silence like nails on a chalkboard. You adjusted your grip on the cart, glancing down at your left to meet the glaring eyes of Limestone Pie, whose frown seemed permanently etched on her face.
"Take a chill pill, will ya? You’ve been riding my ass all day. I’ve got it, alright?" you shot back, your voice sharper than you intended as you picked up your pace.
She snorted, rolling her eyes with enough force to make you wonder if they’d stick that way.
Limestone Pie, the ever-grumpy Pie sister, had apparently decided to hate your guts from the moment you set foot in their house. No matter what you did, she always had some snarky comment or harsh criticism ready to throw your way. The worst part? She wasn’t like that with everyone. You’d seen her laugh and joke around with the others, even crack a rare smile now and then. But the moment her eyes landed on you, it was like flipping a switch—suddenly, she was all scowls and daggers.
“And you’ve been struggling with that thing since we left. So don’t get mad at me when I get pissed if you spill the cargo.”
You let out a low grumble, barely audible over the crunch of gravel beneath your boots.
“Why’d you even come along anyway? You know damn well this is a one-man job.” You caught the wheelbarrow just as it tilted from another unlucky bump, muttering curses under your breath as you steadied it.
Limestone huffed, blowing a stray strand of her mane out of her face. “To make sure you don’t scare everypony in Mount Bluff. The sight of you’s enough to send somepony screaming.”
You raised an eyebrow at that, letting out a short laugh. “Oh, come on. I don’t scare them… anymore. Hell, I get along with Arctic Storm now. She even gave me a bouquet, if you can believe it.”
At that, Limestone visibly stiffened, her steps faltering just enough for you to notice. Her cheeks flushed a faint shade of red, though she quickly tried to cover it with a scowl.
“S-so? What does that prove? She wasn’t even there today. Maybe she finally figured out what a creep you are.” Her words lacked their usual bite, coming out more mumbled than sharp.
You smirked, catching her in the corner of your eye. “That’s probably because you chased her off before I could even make it to the store.”
Limestone froze for a moment, clearly recalling the scene. You could almost see the gears turning in her head, trying to come up with a retort.
“She gave us the wrong shipment!” she finally snapped, her tone defensive.
“And didn’t it turn out to be the right one?” you countered, guiding the cart around a particularly large lump in the trail.
Her mouth opened as if to argue, but no words came. Instead, she glanced back at you, eyes narrowing in frustration as her ears twitched. For a brief second, you thought she might admit you had a point, but then she stomped her hoof, turning away with a growl.
“Shut up, dummy,” she muttered, her voice low and clipped.
You chuckled under your breath, amused at how flustered she seemed. For all her fierce-tongued remarks, Limestone had a habit of folding under the slightest pressure.
“Whatever you say, boss,” you teased, adjusting your grip on the wheelbarrow as the trail stretched endlessly ahead.
The two of you walked in relative silence, the crunch of gravel beneath your feet and hooves the only sound for a while. It wasn’t until the monotony of the trek began to gnaw at you that you spoke again.
“Why does the shipment even matter? They’re just rocks.”
Limestone came to an abrupt stop, whipping her head around to glare at you like you’d just committed sacrilege.
“They’re not just rocks,” she scoffed, as if the very idea offended her. “Each shipment we collect is unique. Different types, different classifications. Do you have any idea how precise we have to be when sorting them?”
You raised an eyebrow, squinting down at her. “I guess I don’t. I mean, I’ve been working on this farm for nearly a year now, and I still don’t get why rock farming is so important.”
She narrowed her eyes at you, her expression somewhere between offended and exasperated. “Of course you don’t understand. Why would an ape like you be able to grasp the complexities of geology?” she said with a haughty sniff, tossing her mane as if she’d just delivered a devastating blow.
You blinked at her, unimpressed. “Wow. The monkey jokes. You’re really branching out today.”
She ignored you, tossing her mane again with a self-satisfied huff.
You hummed a noncommittal response, deciding against diving headfirst into what was clearly going to be a long, tedious lecture about the deep, mystical “lore” of rocks. Instead, you tipped your head back and looked up at the sky, squinting against the brightness of the sun. Somehow, it seemed hotter and harsher than before, the heat settling uncomfortably on your neck and shoulders.
“When’s the rain coming?” you asked, breaking the silence again.
“The Pegasi said there’s a storm planned for two-thirty,” she answered curtly. “And if you don’t get your fat flanks moving, we’ll be stuck right in the middle of it.”
You rolled your eyes at that, adjusting your grip on the wheelbarrow. “My fat flanks? That’s rich coming from the pony who stopped every five minutes to yell at me for a loose rock.”
She whipped her head around to glare at you, her nostrils flaring slightly. “Excuse me? Maybe if you weren’t wobbling the wheelbarrow like a drunk minotaur, I wouldn’t have to stop!”
“Uh-huh,” you deadpanned, stepping over another lump in the trail. “I’m sure that’s why.”
Limestone huffed loudly, muttering something under her breath that you were pretty sure was another insult. You decided to let it slide, content to keep the peace for at least another few minutes. The looming rainstorm already felt like punishment enough without adding a full-blown argument to the mix.
The two of you continued onward, the trail stretching endlessly ahead as the distant mountains shimmered under the heavy sun. Somewhere, dark clouds began to gather on the horizon, creeping ever closer.
The two of you trudged along in silence, broken only by the crunch of gravel beneath your feet and hooves and the distant chirping of birds in the trees. The stillness felt heavy, weighed down by the oppressive heat that seemed to cling to the air.
Sweat trickled down your forehead, stinging your eyes as you focused on steering the cart, carefully avoiding every rock and bump in the trail that threatened to tip it over. Each jolt felt like a personal vendetta from the universe.
You let out a quiet sigh of relief and silently thanked your past self for having the foresight to pack a bottle of water. Without it, you were pretty sure you’d be a dried-up husk by now, with your dry, lifeless body sprawled out on the side of the trail like some tragic cautionary tale about dehydration.
Your gaze eventually drifted to Limestone. The heat seemed to be wearing her down; her breaths came heavier, and the occasional flick of her tail betrayed her growing irritation. But then your eyes lingered a little longer than they should have.
Unconsciously, you found yourself noticing things you hadn’t before—how her toned muscles rippled beneath her soft, grey coat with each determined step, or how her flanks were… well, perfectly proportioned, and maybe—
Jesus. Stop. Get a grip.
You shook your head, swallowing hard as a wave of guilt rolled over you. Of course, you didn’t find little ponies attractive. Not at first, anyway. But over time, you had to confront a shameful truth: you did. Somewhere along the way, their charm had snuck under your skin.
Not that you’d ever admit it out loud. No, those thoughts were going to the grave with you. God only knew what Igneous Rock would do if he ever caught wind of this. Probably bury you alive—if you were lucky.
“Oh, fuck!” you shouted as you tumbled forward, arms flailing. As if the gods themselves had a grudge against you, the wheelbarrow tipped over, sending its entire load of rocks scattering across the trail.
Behind you, Limestone let out a loud, theatrical groan. “Great job, dummy! Really outdid yourself this time, huh?”
“Shut up,” you growled, wincing as you pushed yourself off the ground. Dust clung to your palms and knees, and your already sore muscles protested as you stood upright.
Turning back, you spotted the culprit: a tree stump hiding just off the edge of the path, perfectly positioned to ruin your day. You muttered a string of curses under your breath and brushed the dirt off your pants, glaring at the scattered rocks like they’d personally offended you.
“Now look at what you’ve done!” Limestone snapped, stomping a hoof for emphasis. “You better start cleaning this mess up.”
“Me?” You shot her a look of disbelief.
“Yeah, you!” she said, gesturing at the scattered rocks like it was obvious. “You’re the one who spilled it, so you’re the one who’s gonna pick it all back up.”
“Oh, hell no!” you barked, jabbing a finger in her direction. “You’re the one who begged your dad to let you tag along on this trip, remember? So guess what, bossy pants—you’re helping.”
Her ears pinned back, and for a moment she opened her mouth to argue, but you didn’t let her get a word in.
“Don’t even try it!” you continued, pointing at the overturned wheelbarrow. “This is as much your problem as it is mine, so get over here and start grabbing some rocks.”
Limestone hesitated, her gaze flickering between you and the spilled cargo. Then, with a surprising lack of conviction, she stammered, “W-well… I’ll tell Ma and Pa about those drawings you’ve been hiding!”
Your blood ran cold.
“…What?” you said flatly, though your voice wavered ever so slightly.
“You heard me!” she snapped, a sly grin creeping onto her face. “You think I don’t know about those little doodles you’ve been working on? You really think Ma and Pa won’t take one look at those and—”
“Okay, okay, stop!” you cut her off, panic bubbling up in your chest. The thought of Igneous and Cloudy Quartz even glimpsing the things you’d drawn was enough to make your stomach drop. You could already picture the stone-faced glare of Igneous, silently digging your grave somewhere on the farm while Cloudy recited scripture over your soon-to-be lifeless body.
Without another word, you dropped to your knees and began the tedious, painful process of gathering the scattered rocks. Every muscle in your body screamed in protest, but you bit your tongue and kept working, not daring to look in Limestone’s direction.
Above you, she let out a triumphant little snort. “That’s what I thought,” she said, smugness practically dripping from her tone.
You gritted your teeth, hands gripping one of the larger rocks a little too tightly. If you had any energy left after this ordeal, you were definitely going to get back at her. But for now, you kept your head down and prayed to whatever higher power existed that this damn day would end soon.
“You fucking asshole! Why couldn’t you hurry up?” Limestone shouted, her voice cutting through the roaring storm as she galloped ahead on the muddy trail.
“It would’ve been faster if you actually helped!” you snapped back, struggling to keep the wheelbarrow balanced as it threatened to tip on the slick, uneven ground.
The hot spring day had turned into chaos in the blink of an eye. The two-thirty rainstorm had arrived an hour early, catching you and Limestone completely off guard. Rain poured in sheets, soaking you to the bone and turning the dirt path into a treacherous, muddy mess. Thunder rumbled overhead, followed by the sharp crack of lightning splitting the darkened sky.
Limestone, of course, was faring far better than you. Mud splattered her legs as she darted ahead, her tail flicking in frustration as she turned her head to shout back at you. “Hurry up, or I’m leaving your fat flank behind!”
“Not with my cart, you’re not!” you snapped, desperately gripping the handles to keep the overloaded wheelbarrow from tipping over entirely. The muddy trail made it nearly impossible to gain traction, and you cursed under your breath with every slipping step.
Suddenly, she veered quickly to the right, disappearing into a thick patch of bushes. “This way!” she yelled, her voice barely audible over the storm.
“What the—Limestone, wait!” you yelled, but there was no time to argue. Gritting your teeth, you forced the cart to follow her path, the mud and rain fighting you every inch of the way. Branches and leaves clawed at your face as you barreled through the underbrush, and for a moment, you couldn’t see anything but wet greenery.
Finally, you emerged on the other side—and immediately skidded to a halt, your breath catching in your throat.
A river raged before you, swollen and furious from the sudden downpour. White-capped water churned violently as it crashed against shallow rocks, the howling winds whipping up sprays of water that stung your face. The current looked strong enough to rip a tree out by its roots, let alone a wheelbarrow—or you.
“Come on, dummy!” Limestone’s voice snapped you out of your daze. Limestone stood a few feet ahead, her mane plastered to her face as she glared at you, ears pinned back against the storm. “If we cross now, we’ll make it back by supper!”
“Are you insane?!” you shouted, planting your feet against the mud as the wheelbarrow wobbled dangerously. “That river will kill us! One wrong step and we’re goners!”
“Don’t be such a sissy!” she shot back, her glare somehow more intense in the storm. “I’ll even let you go first!”
To emphasize her point, she stepped aside and gestured to the rushing water, her hoof pointing at the most turbulent stretch like it was some kind of challenge.
You stared at her in disbelief, rain dripping off your face. “Are you serious?”
Her expression didn’t waver. “Move.”
Grumbling every curse you could think of, you trudged to the edge of the riverbank, your boots sinking into the mud. This was already a nightmare, but crossing a raging river with a fully loaded wheelbarrow? That was a death sentence. Yet, here you were, positioning yourself to do exactly that.
The water was ice-cold as it hit your legs, nearly knocking you off balance the second you stepped in. Each step was a battle as the current tried to drag you downstream, your feet slipping over slick rocks beneath the surface. Rain lashed against your face, and the roar of the river drowned out everything else.
Behind you, Limestone stood watching, her smug expression unwavering despite the storm. “Hurry it up! The longer you take, the wetter my rocks get!”
“Your rocks?! Oh, for fuck’s sake!” you shouted back, your voice cracking with frustration. But there was no time to argue. Gritting your teeth, you pressed on, praying the whole ordeal wouldn’t end with you being swept off into oblivion.
With all the strength you could muster, you forced your way through the raging water, your arms trembling as you did your best to keep the wheelbarrow balanced atop the slick rocks below. Every step felt like a battle, the current threatening to rip your legs out from under you.
But then, a sudden scream cut through the roar of the river, nearly making you lose your grip.
“Help me! Help me! HELP ME!”
You whipped your head around, ready to bark at Limestone for distracting you, but your anger evaporated the moment you saw her. She was frozen midstream, her face contorted in panic as she yanked at her trapped hoof, which was wedged tightly between two jagged rocks just beneath the surface. The churning river battered her small frame, threatening to topple her at any second.
Panic hit you like a punch to the gut.
“Hold on!” you shouted, though your voice wavered under the weight of the storm.
Your eyes darted from the wheelbarrow to Limestone, your heart racing as the two priorities fought for space in your mind. But it wasn’t even a choice, really.
Cursing under your breath, you let go of the cart.
The river wasted no time as it snatched it instantly, sweeping it away in the blink of an eye, dragging it downstream until it vanished beneath the churning water.
You didn’t care.
Limestone was screaming, and nothing else mattered.
Gritting your teeth, you pushed forward, every step a battle as icy water crashed against your legs and threatened to drag you under. The river’s roar was deafening, drowning out everything but the sound of your heart pounding in your ears. The sharp edges of submerged rocks scraped against your shins, but you pushed through the pain, eyes locked on Limestone.
When you finally reached her. She was gasping, her breaths short and quick as tears mixed with the rain streaming down her face. Her usually fierce eyes were instead wide with fear, darting between you and the merciless river.
“I-I can’t move it! I can’t—” she cried, yanking at her hoof again. The water’s pull only made it worse, pinning the rocks on her hoof like a vice.
“Hold still!” you barked, forcing yourself to sound calm despite the adrenaline roaring through your veins.
Planting your feet as firmly as you could, you bent down and wrapped your hands around the rock trapping her hoof. The jagged edges bit into your palms as you shoved with all your strength, but it didn’t budge.
“Come on!” you shouted through clenched teeth, trying again. Every muscle in your body screamed in protest as you strained against the relentless force of the water. With a final, desperate push, the rock shifted just enough.
“Pull now!” you shouted.
She didn’t hesitate. With a yank, she freed her hoof, stumbling as the current nearly swept her legs out from under her. But before she could fall, you lunged forward and scooped her into your arms.
“Don’t let go of me!” you shouted over the roar of the river as you turned back toward the shoreline.
She didn’t argue. Her forelegs clung tightly around your neck, her trembling body pressed against you as you turned and fought your way back toward the riverbank. The current battered you relentlessly, each step harder than the last. Twice you nearly fell, your foot slipping on the slick rocks below, but somehow—somehow—you managed to keep moving.
When your feet finally hit solid ground, you collapsed onto the muddy bank, the cold, rain-soaked earth doing nothing to cushion your fall. Limestone was still clinging to you, her chest rising and falling in uneven gasps as she buried her face against your shoulder.
The two of you lay there, utterly spent, as the river raged just a few feet away. Rain hammered down in relentless sheets, slapping you both harsh droplets as thunder growled in the distance. Your own chest heaved, every breath feeling like a knife to your ribs, but at least you were alive. At least she was alive.
For a long time, neither of you moved. The adrenaline ebbed slowly, leaving behind an aching silence punctuated by the steady rhythm of the rain.
Limestone sniffled quietly against you, her trembling starting to subside. She wiped her face with a trembling hoof, still refusing to meet your gaze.
“…You didn’t have to do that,” she muttered at last, her voice barely above a whisper.
You turned your head to look at her, your own exhaustion weighing you down. “Of course I did,” you said hoarsely, your throat raw from shouting. “What, you think I was just gonna leave you there?”
Her ears flattened against her head, and she looked away, her cheeks flushing despite the cold rain. “I-I would’ve been fine,” she mumbled, but the words lacked any real conviction.
You let out a weak chuckle, staring up at the stormy sky. “Yeah, sure. Fine. That’s what you call screaming bloody murder while stuck in a river?”
Her eyes darted toward you, glaring briefly before softening again. She sighed, her shoulders sagging as she wiped at her face with a trembling hoof. “…Thanks,” she murmured, so quietly you almost didn’t hear it.
You smiled faintly, too drained to say much else. “Don’t mention it.”
For once, Limestone didn’t have a snarky comeback. For once, you didn’t feel the need to fill the silence with a quip of your own. The two of you simply lay there, side by side, as the rain fell around you.
The rain didn’t let up. It fell in icy sheets, hammering down on you and Limestone as you lay sprawled on the muddy riverbank. The cold seeped deep into your bones, making your soaked clothes cling to your skin like a frigid second layer. Each breath you took was heavy and ragged, your chest aching with every rise and fall. Lightning lit up across the darkened sky as thunder rang out loud and low, offering no sign that the storm would end anytime soon.
Groaning, you forced yourself upright, every muscle in your body screaming in protest. Pain radiated from your arms, your legs, even muscles you didn’t know you had. Your boots squelched in the mud as you rose to your feet, swaying slightly from exhaustion. Limestone still hadn’t moved. She was curled up in the mud, her soaked mane plastered to her face, her small frame trembling against the relentless cold.
“You okay?” you asked, your voice hoarse and raw from shouting over the storm.
For a moment, she didn’t respond. The rain roared, drowning out nearly everything else, and you wondered if she’d even heard you. But then her ears flicked back, and she gave the smallest nod, her voice barely audible over the downpour.
“Yeah,” she muttered, though her tone was as drained as you felt. “I’m fine.”
“Sure you are,” you muttered under your breath, not bothering to hide the skepticism in your voice. Dragging a hand down your soaked face, you glanced at her again. She didn’t move, didn’t even try to push herself upright. With a resigned sigh, you held out your hand. “Come on. We can’t just sit here. We’ll freeze to death if we don’t keep moving.”
Her eyes flicked up to meet yours, but they lacked the familiar fire that seemed to fuel her every glare. There was no snarky remark waiting on her tongue, no protest ready to throw back at you. She just sighed softly, the sound nearly lost to the storm, and reached out to take your hand. Her hoof was cold in your grip as you pulled her to her hooves.
The moment she stood, she stumbled, wincing as her injured hoof slipped in the mud. You caught her by the shoulder, steadying her before she could fall, and her ears pinned back against her head in frustration.
“You sure you can walk?” you asked, your tone more gentle than sarcastic this time.
“I said I’m fine,” she snapped reflexively, though the words came out softer than usual, her voice trembling slightly. She took a tentative step, favoring her injured hoof, and immediately gritted her teeth as pain shot through her.
You frowned, watching her struggle for a moment before shaking your head. “Alright, that’s it,” you said, crouching down in front of her with a heavy sigh. “Get on.”
“What?” she barked, her ears perking up despite her exhaustion. “No way. I don’t need you to carry me!”
“You can barely walk,” you shot back, glancing over your shoulder at her. “Stop being stubborn and just get on. We’ve still got a long way to go, and I’m not leaving you here.”
She glared at you, her soaked mane clinging to her face, the fire in her eyes flickering back to life for a brief moment. “I don’t need your help,” she muttered, lifting her chin in defiance. But as she took another step, her injured hoof slipped again, and she winced hard, biting back a pained gasp.
“Yeah, you’re doing great,” you said dryly, turning back around. “Just get on, Limestone. I’m not arguing about this.”
Her glare narrowed, and for a second, you thought she might fight you on it. But then she sighed, ears flattening as her stubbornness gave way to exhaustion. With a grumble, she stepped forward, wrapping her forelegs around your shoulders as you hooked your arms under her hind legs and hoisted her onto your back.
“This is so stupid,” she muttered as you adjusted your grip, making sure she wouldn’t slip.
“Tell me about it,” you shot back, gritting your teeth as you rose to your feet. She wasn’t particularly heavy, but after everything you’d been through, it still felt like carrying a boulder.
The two of you started the slow, grueling trek back toward the farm. The trail was nearly unrecognizable now, the rain turning the dirt into a slippery, muddy mess. Every step was a struggle, the mud sucking at your boots while the wind howled through the swaying trees above. The storm showed no mercy, lashing you with freezing rain as lightning occasionally lit up the dark sky.
For a while, neither of you spoke, the silence broken only by the relentless storm. Finally, Limestone shifted slightly on your back, her voice quiet when she asked, “Do you think Ma and Pa’ll be mad?”
“Mad? Why?” you asked, glancing over your shoulder at her.
“Because we lost the shipment,” she muttered, not meeting your eyes. “And we’re late. Supper’s probably already over by now.”
You let out a tired chuckle, shaking your head as rain dripped from your soaked hair. “Pretty sure they’ll care more about us being alive than a bunch of rocks.”
She didn’t respond right away. Her ears twitched slightly at your words, and for a moment, you thought she might argue. But then she let out a soft huff, her breath warm against the back of your neck. “…I guess.”
The silence returned, the only sound the squelch of your boots in the mud and the steady drumming of the rain. Despite the miserable conditions, a faint sense of relief settled over you. You were alive. Limestone was alive. That was what mattered.
After a while, she shifted again. “…Thanks,” she mumbled, so softly you almost didn’t hear her.
“For what?” you asked, glancing at her as best you could.
“For… you know,” she muttered, her cheeks flushing faintly even as the rain washed over her face. “Saving me back there. Even though you’re a total dummy.”
You smirked faintly, the exhaustion and ache in your body doing little to dampen your amusement. “Don’t mention it,” you said. “What are friends for, right?”
She was quiet for a moment before resting her chin on your shoulder with a soft sigh. “…Yeah. Friends.”
And so, step by step, you carried her through the storm, the farmhouse waiting somewhere beyond the endless curtain of rain.
The rain continued its unrelenting assault, though it had lost some of its earlier fury. Now it fell in a steady, cold drizzle, the kind that seeped into your skin and made your bones feel heavy. The trail was barely visible under the dim light of the storm, each step through the slick mud growing slower, heavier.
But then, through the misty haze of rain and shadows, a faint, familiar silhouette came into view. Your heart leapt in your chest.
“There,” you croaked, your voice hoarse and strained. “I can see it. The farm.”
Limestone stirred on your back, lifting her head slightly. Her soaked mane stuck to her face as she squinted through the rain. For a moment, she didn’t say anything, as if unsure whether to believe you or if her exhausted mind was just playing tricks on her. But then she saw it too—a faint outline of the farmhouse and the distant shape of the silo standing tall against the dark horizon.
“Finally,” she muttered, her voice thick with exhaustion and relief.
The two of you trudged forward, the promise of shelter giving you just enough strength to keep going. The sky had grown impossibly dark, not just from the storm but from the sun slipping behind the horizon. The faint orange and purple hues of sunset had long since faded, leaving only the deep gray of twilight blanketed by low, churning clouds.
Despite the rain, you could make out the warm glow of light spilling from the farmhouse windows, a beacon in the endless storm. It seemed impossibly far away, but the sight of it gave you something to focus on, something to aim for.
The trail widened as you neared the farm, the muddy ground giving way to the familiar gravel path that led to the house. Your boots dragged over the stones as you staggered forward, your legs screaming in protest with every step. Limestone shifted on your back, her grip loosening slightly as her weight leaned more heavily against you.
“You hanging in there?” you asked, your voice a little louder now that the roar of the storm had softened.
“Barely,” she muttered. Her tone was edged, but it lacked bite. “Don’t drop me, or I’ll make your life a living hell.”
You let out a weak chuckle, your lips curling into a faint smirk despite the ache in your body. “Don’t worry. You’re stuck with me.”
Her ear flicked, but she didn’t respond, her chin resting against your shoulder once more.
The farmhouse grew closer, the glow of the windows cutting through the stormy darkness. The familiar outline of the silo loomed to the side, its roof glistening with rain, while the windmill creaked softly in the distance, silhouetted against the blackened sky. The smell of wet earth and freshly turned mud filled the air.
By the time you reached the outer fence, your knees nearly gave out. Your legs trembled violently, screaming for rest, but you forced yourself to keep moving. The farmhouse door stood just ahead, its sturdy wooden frame a promise of safety and warmth. You focused on it, clinging to that hope as you dragged yourself up the gravel path.
“You’re almost home,” you muttered, mostly to yourself, though Limestone’s ear twitched slightly at the words.
With a final, labored step, you reached the porch. The overhang shielded you from the rain for the first time in what felt like hours, the sound of raindrops striking the wooden roof above suddenly louder in the relative quiet. You crouched low, carefully letting Limestone slide off your back and onto her hooves.
She stumbled slightly, her injured hoof skidding against the slick wood, but you caught her before she could fall. She gritted her teeth, her familiar stubbornness flickering back to life as she pushed herself upright.
“I’m fine,” she grumbled, though the way she winced betrayed her words.
“Sure you are,” you said, stepping back to give her space. You glanced up at the farmhouse, taking a deep breath as your chest rose and fell heavily. The warm glow of the windows spilled onto the porch, illuminating the rain-slicked boards beneath your feet.
Limestone glanced at the door, her ears flattening slightly. “Ma and Pa are gonna kill us,” she muttered, her voice low and uncertain.
You raised an eyebrow at her, your exhaustion momentarily forgotten. “They’ll be more worried about us than a bunch of missing rocks,” you said, shaking your head. “If anything, they’ll probably kill me first for letting you get hurt.”
Her lips twitched, almost forming a smile, but she quickly looked away. “Yeah, well… don’t think I’ll bail you out.”
You smirked faintly, leaning against the porch railing as the rain continued to fall just beyond the overhang. “Noted.”
For a moment, neither of you moved, the silence between you broken only by the soft patter of rain and the occasional creak of the porch. The storm still lingered in the distance, but it seemed less menacing now, its edge dulled by the promise of warmth and safety just beyond the door.
Limestone shifted slightly, her gaze flicking toward you. “…You’re coming in, right?” she asked, her voice quieter now, almost hesitant.
You turned to her, raising an eyebrow. “What, you think I’m gonna sleep out here in the rain?”
Her lips twitched again, this time forming a small, tired smirk. She didn’t say anything else, instead limping toward the door and nudging it open with her shoulder. Warm light spilled out onto the porch, accompanied by the faint crackle of a fire from within.
The moment you stepped through the farmhouse door, you were enveloped by a wave of warmth so comforting it nearly buckled your knees. The biting chill of the storm melted away, replaced by a gentle, all-encompassing heat that seemed to seep into your very bones. For a brief second, you just stood there, your body soaking in the contrast, barely aware of the puddle forming beneath your boots.
Then, the smell hit you—a deep, earthy scent of firewood burning in the hearth, mingled with the faint aroma of something sweet lingering in the air. It was a smell you’d come to associate with this place: simple, grounding, and undeniably homey.
Limestone limped in behind you, her mane still dripping and her breaths shallow as the warmth coaxed her shivering body into stillness. She barely had time to close the door behind her before a voice filled with worry, broke the silence.
“Limestone?!”
Cloudy Quartz appeared in the archway to the living room, her ever-present shawl wrapped tightly around her shoulders. Her turquoise eyes widened in shock as they landed on her daughter, taking in Limestone’s soaked mane, mud-caked hooves, and the unmistakable way she leaned on her uninjured leg.
“Oh, heavens above! What happened to you?!” she exclaimed, rushing over with surprising speed, her hooves clacking against the wooden floor. Her eyes darted between Limestone and you, her expression a mix of panic and maternal concern.
“We’re fine, Ma,” Limestone muttered, though her voice was weak and unconvincing. “It’s nothing.”
“Nothing?! You’re limping, Limestone!” Cloudy shot back, her voice tight as she stepped closer. Her gaze swept over you, taking in your drenched clothes and exhausted posture. “And you! What in Equestria happened out there?”
Before you could answer, the sound of hurried hoofsteps came from the staircase. Two familiar figures emerged from the shadows of the upper floor, their faces etched with worry.
“Limestone?” Marble’s soft voice broke through first, her light gray mane falling across her face as she trotted down the stairs. Her wide, anxious eyes darted between you and her sister. “Are you okay?”
“I’m fine, Marble,” Limestone said quickly, though the slight wobble in her stance betrayed her words.
Maud followed close behind, her steady, unflappable gaze taking in the scene with a quiet intensity. Her dull, even tone cut through the rising tension. “You don’t look fine.”
“Thanks for the observation, Maud,” Limestone snapped, though her words were missing the venom. She swayed slightly, and you instinctively reached out to steady her before she could stumble.
Marble rushed forward, her soft demeanor giving way to alarm. “You’re hurt!” she exclaimed, her voice trembling as she looked up at you for answers. “What happened?”
You opened your mouth to respond, but another voice—deeper, sterner—cut through the room.
“What is the meaning of all this commotion?”
Igneous Rock stepped into the doorway from the living room, his presence commanding even in the warm glow of the hearthlight behind him. His stoic eyes swept across the room, taking in the scene with a practiced calm that somehow made the air feel heavier. His jaw was tight, his expression somewhere between worry and disapproval.
“Limestone,” he said, his tone steady but firm. “Explain yourself.”
Limestone stiffened under her father’s gaze, though she didn’t quite meet his eyes. “We got caught in the storm,” she muttered, her voice low. “The wheelbarrow tipped, and then I… I got stuck in the river. He helped me out.” She gestured vaguely toward you, her ears flattening slightly. “It’s not a big deal.”
Cloudy Quartz gasped softly, her hoof flying to her chest. “The river? Limestone, you could have been—”
“I said I’m fine!” Limestone interrupted, though her voice cracked as she spoke. Her frustration was evident, but so was the exhaustion that weighed heavily on her shoulders.
Igneous’s eyes lingered on her for a moment before shifting to you. His expression didn’t soften, but there was a glimmer of something—gratitude, perhaps—hidden behind his stern demeanor. “Is this true?” he asked, his tone low but direct.
You nodded, forcing yourself to stand a little straighter despite the ache in your legs. “Yes, sir. She got stuck in the current, so I pulled her out. We… lost the wheelbarrow and the shipment, though.” You winced, bracing yourself for his reaction.
Igneous’s brow furrowed, and he let out a slow, measured sigh. “The rocks can be replaced,” he said, his voice calm but firm. “You cannot.” He glanced at Limestone, his expression softening ever so slightly. “Both of you.”
Cloudy stepped forward again, her worry undeterred. “Igneous is right. You’re both lucky to be here at all. Now, Limestone, sit down before you fall over. And you—” She turned to you, her voice softening, though her worry was still clear. “You need to get out of those wet clothes before you catch your death.”
“I’m fine, really,” you started to protest, but the look she gave you made it clear that wasn’t up for debate.
Maud and Marble stepped closer, their concern still evident as they hovered near Limestone. Marble nudged her gently, her wide eyes shimmering with relief. “We were so worried,” she murmured.
Limestone huffed, trying to brush off her sister’s concern. “I told you, I’m fine,” she muttered, though her voice was quieter now, less defensive.
Maud tilted her head slightly, her expression as neutral as ever. “You’re hurt,” she said simply, as if stating a fact. “You should listen to Mom.”
Limestone grumbled something under her breath but didn’t argue further, allowing Marble to guide her toward the living room.
You hesitated, unsure whether to follow or retreat upstairs, but Cloudy’s voice broke through your thoughts.
“Come now,” she said, her tone firm but kind. “You’ve done enough for one day. Let’s get you warmed up.”
The rest of the evening passed in a blur, exhaustion blunting the edges of every moment. The hot shower offered little relief, doing just enough to warm your chilled bones but not enough to erase the weight of the day. Leftover dinner—rock soup, thick, hearty, and as earthy as ever—barely registered as you ate. You shoveled it down on autopilot, your mind miles away, replaying the chaos of the storm, the icy grip of the river, and the fleeting look of gratitude that had crossed Limestone’s face.
Before you even realized it, you were lying in bed, staring up at the slanted ceiling above you.
Your "bedroom"—if it could even be called that—was the attic. It wasn’t much, but it had a quiet charm, and more importantly, it was yours. The Pie family had gone out of their way to make it livable when they’d taken you in, even crafting a makeshift bed large enough to accommodate your size. It now sat snugly beneath a small, round window that overlooked the rocky fields stretching into the horizon. On clear nights, you could see the stars spill across the sky like scattered jewels, but tonight the heavens were still veiled in the heavy, brooding clouds left behind by the storm.
The attic itself was like stepping into another era, a time capsule of forgotten memories. Dusty boxes stacked in the far corner held secrets long abandoned, their faded labels barely legible in the dim light. A worn armchair slouched against the wall, its threadbare cushion sagging under the weight of years. An old grandfather clock stood near the foot of your bed, its cracked face and frozen hands marking a time no one cared to remember. The air smelled faintly of aged wood and the tang of rain seeping through the farmhouse’s weathered frame. It should have been stifling, but instead, it was comforting, like a well-worn blanket you couldn’t bring yourself to part with.
You shifted in bed, letting out a tired sigh as the day’s events played on repeat in your mind. The storm. The river. The relentless pull of the current as the wheelbarrow vanished beneath the frothing water. And Limestone—her shouting, her panic, the way she’d cried out for help. But most of all, the moment she’d looked at you—truly looked at you—and said, “Thanks.”
You scoffed softly to yourself, shaking your head as you turned onto your side. “She’s just as stubborn as the rocks she loves,” you muttered under your breath, though the words carried no malice. If anything, they held a reluctant fondness. Despite everything, a small, involuntary smile tugged at the corner of your lips, lingering for just a moment before fading.
Your gaze drifted to the small window by your bed. Through the patchy clouds, the moon managed to break through, spilling a dim silver light over the rocky fields below. The farmhouse had settled into its usual quiet, the kind of silence that felt alive in its stillness. Faint creaks echoed through the old wooden beams, the house adjusting to the cooler night air. Outside, the rain had softened to a light patter against the roof, its rhythm steady and calming. Occasionally, a distant rumble of thunder rolled across the horizon, muted but ever-present, like a fading memory of the storm that had tested you just hours before.
For the first time in what felt like forever, there was peace—a fragile, fleeting kind of peace. It felt strange, almost foreign, after the chaos of the day.
You exhaled slowly, closing your eyes and willing sleep to take you. But your thoughts refused to quiet. They drifted unbidden back to Limestone—her stubbornness, her vulnerability, the way she’d leaned on you both figuratively and literally. You couldn’t help but replay the way she had clung to you in the river, the quiet way she’d thanked you on the walk back, and the moment on the porch when she’d asked if you were coming in.
The rain tapped softly on the roof above, a steady rhythm meant to lull you into rest. But even with the quiet settling in, sleep felt distant, just out of reach.
You sighed again, heavier this time, as you rolled onto your back. The dim light of the moon played across the ceiling, the clouds shifting slowly in its glow. For now, all you could do was lie there, your mind swimming in the storm’s aftermath and the strange, unshakable presence of Limestone in your thoughts.
The faint creak of floorboards snapped you out of your thoughts. You sat up quickly, your heart skipping a beat as your eyes locked onto a figure standing at the foot of your bed.
Your mind scrambled to process the sight, still foggy from exhaustion. And then it clicked.
Limestone.
Well, speak of the devil… wait, what?
Her wide-eyed expression betrayed her surprise at being caught, her mouth slightly open like a kid caught sneaking a cookie. But it didn’t last long. In an instant, her face twisted into the familiar scowl she always seemed to wear around you, her annoyance snapping into place like a shield.
“Why aren’t you asleep, dummy?” she hissed, her voice low but cutting clean through the quiet attic.
It took you a second to shake off the grogginess and fully register what was happening. You blinked at her, rubbing your eyes as if she might disappear, then glanced at the cracked face of the grandfather clock—as if it would tell you anything remotely useful.
“Why,” you said slowly, voice dripping with disbelief, “are you standing at the foot of my bed in the dead of night? And…” your gaze drifted down to her bandaged hoof, “how did you even get up here with that leg?”
Her ears flicked back and you saw her blush. A deep crimson crept across her cheeks, bright enough to be visible even in the dim moonlight streaming through the attic window. She stammered, her attitude crumbling like brittle stone. “W-well, I… uh…”
Her gaze darted to the side like she was searching for an escape route, but the blush only deepened. Then, as if remembering who she was supposed to be, she stomped her hoof—immediately wincing at the pain—and glared at you. “Shut up!” she snapped, her tone defensive. “I came here to… to tell you something. Something important.”
You raised an eyebrow, leaning back against the headboard and folding your arms. “Important,” you repeated, skepticism heavy in your voice. “At this hour?”
Her scowl deepened, but there was no hiding how flustered she was. She huffed, her gaze darting around the room like the attic walls might magically give her the words she needed. Whatever had brought her here clearly wasn’t coming out the way she’d rehearsed it.
“Alright,” you said, your voice somewhere between curious and exasperated. “I’m listening. What’s so important that you had to sneak into my room like a thief in the night?”
Her ears pinned back as her blush flared up again. “I’m not sneaking!” she hissed, stomping her good hoof for emphasis. “And I didn’t come up here to get interrogated by you!”
You raised your hands in mock surrender, biting back a smirk. “Okay, okay. My bad. Please, do go on,” you said, though you didn’t bother hiding the touch of sarcasm in your tone.
She glared at you for a long moment, her jaw tightening like she was fighting some internal battle. The fire in her eyes seemed to dim slightly as her they flicked downward, and her tough exterior cracked just enough for you to notice the uncertainty underneath. She shifted her weight from one hoof to the other, her fidgeting betraying her nerves.
“I just… wanted to say…” she started, her voice barely audible now. “I… uh…”
You tilted your head, your curiosity starting to outweigh your frustration at being woken up. She was really struggling, and it wasn’t like her. The quick-tongued, headstrong Limestone Pie, reduced to a stammering, fidgety mess? It was almost surreal.
Her mouth opened and closed a few times as if she was trying to force the words out but couldn’t quite manage. Watching her stumble over herself was so strange—and honestly kind of amusing—that you almost forgot to be annoyed. Almost.
“Well?” you prompted gently, breaking the awkward silence that was stretching out between you. “What is it?”
Judging by the way her glare suddenly intensified, she could tell she was floundering, and she wasn’t happy about it. “This would’ve been a lot easier if you were asleep!” she hissed angrily, her voice low enough to avoid potentially waking the rest of the house.
You almost gave her a haughty remark right then and there, something like, "Oh, sorry, let me lie perfectly still next time you break into my room at midnight." But you stopped yourself. She looked so… off-kilter. Uncharacteristically vulnerable, even. And if she’d built up this much courage to approach you, it didn’t feel right to scare her off with one of your snarky remarks.
Still, you couldn’t resist a bit of dry humor. Crossing your arms, you let out a small scoff and said, “Would you like me to pretend to sleep?”
What started as a joke quickly took an awkward turn when Limestone didn’t fire back with her usual quick retort. Instead, her eyes darted to the side, her ears flattening against her head like she was actually considering it. The silence stretched longer than it should have, the air between you thick with hesitation.
You raised an eyebrow, unable to help yourself. “Wait… seriously?”
Then, to your surprise, she nodded.
For a second, all you could do was blink at her, stunned. “You’re kidding,” you muttered, searching her expression for even the faintest hint of sarcasm. But no—Limestone Pie, the queen of snark and biting remarks, wasn’t kidding. She stared at you expectantly, her hoof tapping lightly against the floor in what could only be described as impatience.
Letting out a long, dramatic sigh, you flopped back onto your bed with the grace of someone who’d just given up on life. “Fine,” you grumbled, turning on your side and squeezing your eyes shut. “But if you smother me with a pillow, I’m haunting you. Forever. No refunds.”
You thought you heard her mutter something under her breath—probably some choice insult about your “dummy brain”—but you didn’t catch it.
The mattress creaked slightly as you shifted, settling into your best “totally asleep” pose. You kept your breathing slow and steady, feigning sleep as convincingly as possible. The room grew quiet again, save for the soft patter of rain on the attic roof and the occasional groan of the old wooden beams.
But you could feel her there. Her presence was impossible to ignore, hovering at the edge of the bed like a ghost who didn’t quite know how to haunt properly. You resisted the urge to peek, though curiosity gnawed at you. What in the world was she waiting for?
Her hoofsteps were soft, hesitant, as she shuffled closer. You heard the faint scuff of her hoof brushing against the floorboards, followed by the smallest creak as she shifted her weight. She lingered, her presence practically buzzing in the quiet room, and you could swear you felt her staring at you.
The seconds dragged on, each one longer than the last. Whatever she had to say, she was clearly fighting some kind of internal war to get it out. The tension hung thick in the air, pressing down on you like the heavy storm clouds outside.
Finally, the silence broke with the faintest rustle of movement, followed by the soft sound of her stepping even closer.
“Okay,” she muttered under her breath, her voice barely audible over the soft patter of rain against the attic window. “You can do this, Limestone. It’s not that hard. Just… say it.”
There was a pause, followed by a long, shaky sigh. “He’s asleep. Yeah. Totally asleep,” she said to herself, though her tone wavered like she was trying to convince herself you weren’t just lying there, pretending.
Her voice softened, losing the edge you’d come to expect from her. You almost had to strain to hear it. “I… I don’t even know why I’m doing this.”
You stayed perfectly still, your breaths slow and steady. Whatever she needed to say, it was taking all her strength to get it out, and for once, you weren’t about to interrupt.
“It’s just…” Her words faltered. There was a frustrated huff, followed by the faint scrape of her hoof dragging against the floor as if she were pacing in place. “You’re so… stupid.”
There it was. That was more like the Limestone you knew. You almost snorted but managed to hold it in, biting the inside of your cheek to keep up the act.
“I mean, who risks their life for a wheelbarrow full of rocks?” she snapped quietly, though her voice cracked with something raw beneath the frustration. “And then—then turns around and saves my stupid—” She cut herself off abruptly, another scrape of her hoof punctuating the silence, followed by a low growl of irritation.
The air felt thick with her indecision, her frustration with herself as much as with you. There was another pause, longer this time. Then, a deep breath, shakier than before.
“You’re stupid because… you care,” she admitted, her voice softer now, almost trembling. “About everything. About… me. Even when I don’t deserve it.”
Your chest tightened. You stayed still, your breaths measured, but it was getting harder to maintain the illusion of sleep.
Her words came faster now, like they were tumbling out of her in a rush she couldn’t stop. “Do you have any idea how hard it is to be around you sometimes?” she said, her tone rising slightly, though still careful not to wake the rest of the house. “You drive me crazy! You’re annoying, and loud, and you don’t know when to shut up!”
For a moment, you thought that was it. That she’d stop there, let her irritation take over and leave it at that. But then her voice wavered again, and when she spoke next, it was softer—softer than you’d ever heard it.
“But at the same time… you’re good. You’re kind. Even when I make it impossible.” She hesitated, the words catching in her throat. Her tail swished behind her, the nervous motion almost out of place for someone as guarded as Limestone Pie. “You make me feel… safer than I ever thought I’d feel with someone like you.”
The silence that followed was deafening. The air felt heavy, almost as though the room itself was holding its breath. And then, in a voice so quiet it was barely more than a whisper, she added, “I guess I just… don’t hate having you around as much as I thought I did. Or maybe I never hated you in the first place.”
A brittle, nervous laugh escaped her, shaky and unsure. “Celestia, this is so stupid,” she muttered, more to herself than to you.
The mattress creaked faintly as she hesitated at the edge of the bed. You felt the shift of her weight as she climbed up, moving tentatively, as though testing the waters of her own courage. Then, she settled beside you, close enough that you could feel the faint warmth of her presence cutting through the lingering chill of the rain.
Your heart pounded in your chest, but you stayed still, the rhythm of your breathing steady and even.
“I’m probably gonna regret this,” she muttered under her breath, the words thick with embarrassment. Then, louder, like she was ripping off a bandage, she blurted out, “But I like you, okay? There. I said it. I like you.”
Her voice cracked on the last word, and you could feel the weight of her confession settle over the room like a heavy blanket. The storm outside had softened to a faint drizzle, the raindrops tapping lightly against the window, but inside the attic, the world felt completely still.
For a moment, you weren’t sure if you’d heard her right. The words hung in the air, raw and unpolished, echoing in your head like you needed to replay them just to make sense of them.
She liked you? Limestone Pie—the perpetually grumpy, sharp-tongued, rock-obsessed pony who made it her life’s mission to call you an idiot every other minute—liked you?
Your heart thudded against your ribs, loud enough that you were sure she could hear it. You opened your mouth to say something, anything, but your mind was a mess of scrambled thoughts. Half of you wanted to laugh at the absurdity of it all, while the other half was frozen, caught somewhere between disbelief and… something else.
You didn’t move. You didn’t even breathe.
Limestone shifted beside you, and you could feel the tension radiating off her like a physical weight. She hadn’t said anything else, but you didn’t need to look at her to know she was regretting every second of what she’d just said. Her tail flicked nervously against the mattress, and you caught the faint sound of her hooves fidgeting against the blanket.
“Forget it,” she muttered suddenly, her voice tight and shaky. “This was stupid. Just—just forget I said anything.”
You blinked, startled out of your daze. Before you could process what she’d just said, you felt the mattress shift again as she tried to get up. She didn’t get far, though—her bandaged hoof slipped against the blanket, and she hissed in pain, wobbling unsteadily. Without thinking, you reached out, your hand finding her shoulder.
“Wait,” you said quickly, your voice cracking just a little.
She froze under your touch, her body stiff. For a second, you thought she might pull away, but she didn’t.
“Limestone…” you started, unsure of where you were going with this. You sat up slowly, turning to face her. Her back was to you, her shoulders rigid, and her ears were pinned flat against her head. Even in the dim light of the attic, you could see the blush still burning on her cheeks.
She didn’t look at you, and when she spoke, her voice was barely above a whisper. “What?”
You hesitated, your hand still resting lightly on her shoulder. Your mouth felt dry, and your brain was doing its best impression of a broken engine. But beneath the whirlwind of disbelief and confusion, there was a strange warmth growing in your chest.
“I…” You paused, searching for the right words. How were you supposed to respond to something like this? You’d seen Limestone angry, annoyed, smug, even panicked—but this? This was a side of her you’d never thought existed, and it left you completely off balance.
But you couldn’t let her walk away like this. Not after she’d clearly wrestled with herself to come up here, to say what she’d said.
“I don’t think it’s stupid,” you said finally, your voice softer now.
That made her pause. Her ears flicked, but she still didn’t turn to face you. “You’re just saying that,” she muttered, her tone sharp, but it wavered at the edges.
“I’m not,” you insisted, and this time you gave her shoulder a gentle squeeze. “Limestone, I mean it. What you said—it’s… it’s not stupid. It took guts to come up here and tell me that.”
She let out a bitter laugh, shaking her head. “Yeah, well, it doesn’t feel like it.”
For a moment, neither of you said anything. The attic was quiet except for the faint patter of rain and the creaks of the old wood around you.
You let out a slow breath, your hand dropping from her shoulder. “Look,” you started, your voice careful, “you caught me off guard, okay? I mean, I didn’t think… I never thought you—” You cut yourself off, realizing you were rambling.
She finally turned her head slightly, her piercing green eyes catching yours, though her expression was guarded. “Didn’t think what?”
You scratched the back of your neck, your gaze dropping briefly. “Didn’t think you’d ever feel that way. About me,” you admitted, your words quieter now. “I mean, let’s be honest—you kind of make it your mission to remind me how much I annoy you on a daily basis.”
Her lips twitched, just barely, like she was fighting the ghost of a smile. “You do annoy me,” she said, though the fire in her voice wasn’t quite there.
You couldn’t help but smirk faintly, despite the heat creeping up your neck. “Yeah, well… you’re not exactly a walk in the park either.”
For the first time since she’d entered the room, you saw the faintest flicker of her familiar confidence return. She simply rolled her eyes.
The humor softened the tension between you, but it didn’t erase the weight of what she’d said. You hesitated, then leaned forward slightly, your voice quieter now, more earnest.
“Limestone,” you said, holding her gaze. “I’m glad you told me.”
Her eyes widened slightly, and she blinked, as if she wasn’t expecting that. “You… are?”
“Yeah,” you said, and this time your smirk softened into a small, genuine smile. “Because now I can say something I didn’t think I’d ever have a chance to.”
Her breath hitched slightly, and for once, she was the one looking caught off guard. “And… what’s that?”
You hesitated for only a second before answering. “I like you too.”
The silence that followed felt almost as heavy as her earlier confession, but this time, it wasn’t uncomfortable. Her expression shifted, her scowl melting into something softer, almost unrecognizable. She didn’t say anything right away, but her eyes searched yours, like she was trying to figure out if you were serious.
And then, after a long moment, she let out a shaky breath and looked away, her blush deepening. “You’re such a dummy,” she muttered, but her voice had no bite to it.
“Yeah,” you said lightly, leaning back against the headboard, “but apparently I’m your dummy.”
That earned you a glare, though the corner of her mouth twitched like she was fighting back a smile.
For a moment, the room felt suspended in time. The rain continued its steady rhythm against the attic window, and the occasional creak of the farmhouse settled into the background. But none of it registered. All you could focus on was Limestone.
She still hadn’t looked back at you, her gaze fixed firmly on the floor. Her ears were pinned back, her shoulders stiff, and the blush on her cheeks burned brighter than ever. You’d never seen her this vulnerable before—this… human. It was almost disarming.
“Limestone,” you said softly, breaking the silence.
Her ears flicked at the sound of her name, but she didn’t turn. “What?” she muttered, her voice tight, like she was trying to rebuild the walls she’d just let crumble.
You hesitated, searching for the right words. “Are you… okay?”
She let out a huff that was probably meant to sound annoyed, but it came out shaky. “Why wouldn’t I be?”
“I mean, you just confessed that you like me,” you said, your voice light but careful, “and I’m guessing that’s not something you do every day.”
Her head snapped toward you, her eyes narrowing in a familiar glare. “Don’t make it weird,” she hissed, but the bite in her tone was missing.
You held up your hands in mock surrender, biting back a smirk. “I’m not. I promise.”
She stared at you for a long moment, her eyes searching yours for something you couldn’t quite name. Then, with a small, frustrated sigh, she turned her gaze back to the floor, her hoof tracing idle circles on the blanket. “This is so stupid,” she muttered, more to herself than to you.
“It’s not stupid,” you said gently, leaning forward slightly. “It’s brave.”
Her ears twitched again, and for a second, she looked like she might argue. But then her shoulders slumped, and she let out a quiet laugh—soft and dry, but real. “Brave, huh?”
“Yeah,” you said, a small smile tugging at your lips. “It takes guts to be honest about how you feel. Especially for someone who doesn’t exactly hand out compliments for free.”
That earned you a glance, but this time, her glare felt more like habit than actual irritation. “Don’t push your luck, dummy,” she muttered, though her tone was softer now, almost playful.
You chuckled, the sound low and warm. “Noted.”
The tension between you began to shift, the edges of her discomfort softening into something quieter, more intimate. The air in the attic felt different now—heavier, but not in a bad way. It was charged, like the moment before a storm, but instead of chaos, it was filled with possibility.
She glanced at you again, her gaze lingering this time. Her eyes, so often narrowed in irritation or burned with intensity, were softer now, searching. “You really mean it?” she asked quietly, her voice barely above a whisper. “What you said earlier?”
“About liking you?” you asked, meeting her gaze.
She nodded, the movement small and hesitant.
You didn’t hesitate this time. “Of course I meant it.”
Her breath hitched slightly, and for the first time since she’d come up here, she didn’t look away. The blush on her cheeks deepened, but she didn’t try to hide it. Instead, she held your gaze, and something unspoken passed between you—an understanding, a shared vulnerability that made your chest feel tight.
“You drive me crazy sometimes,” you admitted, your voice softer now, more serious. “But I don’t mind. I like who you are, Limestone. All of it.”
Her eyes widened slightly, her tough exterior cracking just a little more. She opened her mouth as if to respond, but no words came out. Instead, she just stared at you, her expression caught somewhere between disbelief and something softer—something fragile.
The silence stretched again, but this time it wasn’t awkward. It was tense, the kind of silence that made your heart beat faster and your breathing feel heavier.
Then, slowly, you reached out, giving her plenty of time to pull away if she wanted to. Your hand brushed her cheek, your fingers grazing the soft fur beneath her jaw. She stiffened at first, her ears twitching back, but she didn’t move.
Her eyes flicked down briefly, then back up to yours. “You’re so dumb,” she muttered, her voice barely more than a breath.
“And you’re stubborn,” you shot back softly, your lips curving into a small smile.
Her eyes narrowed slightly, but there was no real fire behind it. “I’m so utterly done with you.”
“And yet, here we are.”
For a moment, neither of you moved. The rain outside had softened into a gentle drizzle, the rhythm steady against the window.
Then, almost imperceptibly, she leaned in. It was hesitant, almost cautious, as if she wasn’t entirely sure what she was doing—or if she should be doing it at all. Her gaze flickered to your lips for the briefest second before darting back to your eyes, as if asking for permission.
You answered by closing the remaining distance, your lips brushing hers in a kiss that was soft and tentative, like the first notes of a melody just beginning to form.
Her breath hitched, and for a split second, she froze. But then, slowly, she melted into it, her shoulders relaxing as she leaned into you. Her lips were warm, soft, and slightly unsure, but there was something achingly sincere in the way she kissed you back, like she was pouring every unspoken word into the moment.
When you finally pulled back, the space between you felt heavier, more meaningful. Her cheeks were flushed, her eyes wide and searching as she stared at you. She didn’t say anything, and you didn’t feel the need to fill the silence either.
The rain continued to fall outside, soft and steady, as the two of you sat there, the weight of what had just happened settling over you like the faintest touch of the storm's breeze.
For a moment, neither of you moved. The kiss had left you both frozen in place. Limestone's wide eyes searched yours, her expression teetering between shock and something deeper—curiosity, hunger, and maybe even disbelief that she'd let herself go that far.
But she didn’t pull away. If anything, she leaned closer, her breath warm against your lips as her gaze flickered down to them again. Whatever restraint she’d been clinging to seemed to crack, and in a moment of impulsiveness, she surged forward, closing the distance once more.
This kiss was different. Where the first had been hesitant and soft, this one was urgent, filled with a kind of heat that made your heart lurch. Her lips pressed firmly against yours, her movements less cautious, more deliberate. Her hoof came up to rest lightly on your chest, and you could feel her trembling—not with fear, but with the weight of everything she’d been holding back.
You responded instinctively, your hands finding their way to her sides, holding her gently but firmly as the kiss deepened. Her fur was soft under your touch and her body radiated warmth. The faint smell of wet earth and firewood lingered between you, grounding you in the moment as her lips moved against yours.
And then, just as you thought you’d reached the peak of the kiss, you felt her tongue.
It was tentative at first, a small, exploratory flick against your lower lip, as if testing the waters. The sensation sent a jolt through you, and your lips parted almost automatically, granting her the invitation she seemed to be asking for.
She didn’t hesitate this time. Her tongue slipped into your mouth, warm and slick, moving with a surprising mixture of boldness and hesitation, like she wasn’t entirely sure what she was doing but didn’t care enough to stop. The sensation was… different.
Her tongue wasn’t like yours. It was rougher, textured in a way that made every movement against your own feel electric. The differences were stark—where your tongue was smooth, hers had a slight rasp to it, not unpleasant but strange and wholly unique. It was flexible, agile, and insistent, exploring your mouth with a confidence that was growing by the second.
You couldn’t help but respond in kind, your own tongue meeting hers halfway. The contrast was thrilling. Her movements were more instinctive, less precise, but there was an eagerness to her that made your pulse quicken. She tasted faintly of the rock soup you’d both eaten earlier, earthy and salty, but there was something else. You couldn't put a finger on it but it made you crave more.
A soft, almost inaudible noise escaped her throat—a mix between a sigh and a hum—as your tongues tangled together, the kiss growing more heated by the second. Her hoof pressed more firmly against your chest, and she leaned into you, her weight grounding you as her lips moved hungrily against yours.
Your hands slid upward, one brushing against the back of her neck while the other settled just below her jaw, guiding her closer. Her fur was softer there, and you could feel the rapid thrum of her pulse beneath your fingertips. She shivered at your touch but didn’t pull away. If anything, she leaned into it, her movements becoming bolder, more confident.
You tilted your head slightly, deepening the kiss further as your tongues continued to dance, the contrast between them sending sparks down your spine. Her rougher texture against the smoothness of your own created a friction that was intoxicating, a constant reminder of the differences between you—and how they somehow fit together so perfectly in this moment.
Her breathing grew heavier, her chest rising and falling against yours as the intensity between you built. The small noises she made—the occasional hitch in her breath, the soft hums that escaped when your tongue slid against hers—were enough to make your head spin.
You felt her shift, her hoof sliding up from your chest to your shoulder, her grip tightening slightly as if she needed to hold onto something solid. Her tail flicked behind her, brushing lightly against your arm, and the unexpected sensation made you smile against her lips.
She pulled back just enough to break the kiss, her breathing ragged as she stared at you, her eyes dark with emotion. Her lips were parted, swollen from the kiss, and her face was still flushed, a stark against her gray fur. For a second, you thought she might say something, but instead, she let out a frustrated growl and leaned in again, capturing your lips with renewed fervor.
This time, there was no hesitation, no lingering doubt. She kissed you like she’d been holding back for months, and you met her halfway, pouring everything you had into the moment. Your hands slid back down to roam gently over her sides, memorizing the curves and textures that made her, her. The chill of the attic was long forgotten, replaced by a heat that seemed to radiate from both of you, wrapping you in a cocoon of shared warmth.
The rain outside continued to tap softly against the attic window, but the world beyond it faded into nothing. There was only Limestone—her lips, her tongue, her warmth—and the way she made you feel like nothing else mattered.
The kiss broke again, this time with a wet gasp as both of you pulled back for air. Limestone’s breathing was uneven, her chest rising and falling rapidly as she stared at you, her green eyes clouded with something wild and unrestrained. Her cheeks were flushed deep crimson, her lips glistening and slightly parted as though she wanted to say something, but the words hadn’t quite formed yet.
You opened your mouth to speak, your own breath ragged, but before you could get a word out, Limestone’s hoof shot up, pressing firmly against your chest and pinning you back against the bed.
“Don’t,” she said quickly, her voice low and husky. “Don’t ruin this with your dumb words.”
You blinked, startled by the sudden command, but the heat in her gaze left no room for argument. Whatever was happening right now, Limestone was firmly in control, and you weren’t sure if that thrilled you or terrified you—or maybe both.
“Okay,” you said, swallowing hard. “No dumb words. Got it.”
Her lips quirked upward for the briefest second, something between a smirk and a scowl. But then her eyes darted downward, scanning over you, her expression shifting into something more serious, more determined. Her hoof slid from your chest down to your stomach, pressing lightly but with enough intent that your heart started to race all over again.
“You’re wearing too much,” she muttered, her tone brusque but with a hint of nervousness she was clearly trying to hide.
Your eyebrows shot up. “Excuse me?”
She glared at you, her cheeks flushing even darker. “Don’t make me say it twice, dummy.” Her hoof prodded at the waistband of your pants for emphasis. “These need to come off.”
You stared at her, your brain grinding to a halt as it tried to process what she was asking—no, demanding. “Uh, I mean, that’s… a bit sudden, don’t you think?” you stammered, a nervous laugh escaping before you could stop it.
Her glare deepened, but the blush on her face betrayed the fact that she was just as flustered as you were. “Oh, sudden?” she shot back, her voice dripping with mock indignation. “You’re telling me what’s sudden after we had our tongues in each other's mouth five minutes ago?”
You couldn’t help it—you laughed. It was the kind of laugh that burst out unbidden, a mix of nerves and genuine amusement. “Fair point,” you admitted, holding up your hands in surrender. “But, uh… you’re really not gonna give me a choice here, are you?”
“Not if you don’t want me to kick your stupid butt,” she retorted, though the way her ears flicked back and her hoof hesitated against your waistband gave away the nervous energy she was trying to mask. “Just… shut up and do it.”
Her bluntness caught you off guard, but the fire in her gaze, mixed with the obvious vulnerability behind it, made your hesitation melt away. Limestone Pie wasn’t the kind of mare who asked for things—she demanded them. But this was different. This wasn’t just her usual bossy attitude; this was her putting herself out there in a way you doubted she ever had before. And as ridiculous as her delivery was, you couldn’t help but feel the weight of what it meant for her to trust you like this.
“Alright, alright,” you said, your voice softening as you reached for your waistband. “No need to kick my butt. I’m doing it, see?”
You started to shimmy out of your pants, but Limestone let out an impatient groan, rolling her eyes. “Would you hurry it up already? It’s not rocket science.”
“Wow, so romantic,” you muttered under your breath, and she shot you a look that could have melted steel.
“Don’t test me,” she growled, though her voice cracked slightly, betraying her nerves.
Despite the absurdity of the situation, you couldn’t help but smile. You kicked off your pants, letting them fall in a heap on the floor, and glanced up at her with raised eyebrows. “Happy now?”
Her gaze flicked downward, her blush somehow managing to deepen as her eyes lingered on you. “Underwear too,” she said quickly.
Your cheeks flushed, and you chuckled nervously. “Going straight for the jackpot, huh?”
She groaned again, this time burying her face in her hoof. “Will you just do it already?” she snapped, though the way her voice wavered made it hard to take her frustration seriously. “You’re killing the mood.”
“Alright, alright!” you said, holding up your hands again. “No need to bite my head off.”
Her hoof lowered just enough for you to see the smoldering glare she was giving you. “Keep talking, and I might,” she muttered, but there was a flicker of a smirk on her lips now.
You hesitated for only a second longer before hooking your thumbs into the waistband of your underwear and sliding them down. The cool air of the attic brushed against your skin, and you felt your cheeks heat up even more as you kicked them aside.
Limestone’s eyes flicked downward again, and for a moment, she just stared, her expression unreadable. Then her gaze snapped back up to yours, and the fire in her eyes was back, stronger than ever. She leaned in closer, her breath warm against your lips as she growled softly, “There. Was that so hard?”
“Not as hard as you’re making this,” you shot back, grinning despite yourself.
Her lips shot upward in a lopsided smirk. “You’re such a dunce,” she muttered, and before you could come up with a reply, she kissed you again—hard.
This time, there was no hesitation, no holding back. Her tongue slipped past your lips immediately, hot and insistent, and you couldn’t help but groan as she pressed her body against yours. Her hooves found your shoulders, gripping tightly as her kiss deepened, her movements bold and demanding.
Your hands found her sides again, pulling her closer as the intensity between you ramped up. The contrast between the roughness of her tongue and the softness of her lips was overwhelming, sending shivers down your spine as the kiss turned messy, passionate, wild.
Limestone let out a soft, breathy moan against your mouth, and the sound sent a jolt of heat through your entire body. Her tail flicked behind her, brushing against your leg as she pressed herself more firmly against you, her movements driven by a need neither of you could ignore anymore.
Again, she broke the kiss, her breath warm and heavy against your lips as a thin thread of saliva connected you before breaking. Her cheeks were red as ever, her eyes hazy with something unspoken as she lingered close for a moment longer.
Then, wordlessly, she began shifting lower, carefully bracing herself as she moved between your legs.
You watched her, your heart hammering in your chest as she leaned down, her injured hoof barely touching the mattress as she made sure to avoid putting too much weight on it. Her movements were cautious but deliberate, her lips pressed into a firm line as though she were focusing on a task far more serious than the situation really called for.
Finally, she settled between your thighs, her gaze dropping to what was now fully on display for her. For a moment, she just… stared, her ears flicking back slightly as her eyes widened.
You swallowed hard, suddenly hyper aware of the weight of her stare. “Uh… is it, uh… up to standard?” you joked nervously, though your voice cracked halfway through.
She blinked up at you, her eyes flicking up to meet yours briefly, and then shrugged nonchalantly, as if you’d just asked her to comment on a particularly boring rock formation.
“I don’t know,” she said bluntly. “Never seen a dick this close before.”
Her gaze dropped back down, and her expression twisted slightly, one ear twitching as she tilted her head. “It looks… weird.”
That statement hit you like a bucket of cold water. “Excuse me?” you blurted, your tone a mix of offense and disbelief.
She rolled her eyes at you, her firery expression briefly returning. “Not in a bad way, dummy,” she snapped, though her voice softened slightly as she glanced down at you again. “It’s just… different. I don’t know how else to describe it.”
Her stare lingered, and for the first time in what felt like forever, Limestone Pie looked… uncertain. Not nervous, exactly, but hesitant, like she was seeing something completely unfamiliar and wasn’t sure what to make of it. Her lips parted slightly, and then she muttered under her breath, “It’s kind of… mesmerizing.”
You choked on your spit, coughing as your brain struggled to process what she’d just said. “Uh… thanks? I think?”
A brief, awkward silence hung between you, the sound of the rain tapping softly against the attic window filling the space as she continued to stare. You weren’t sure what to say—or if you should say anything at all. But before you could spiral further into the awkwardness, Limestone broke the silence in the most Limestone way imaginable.
“Can I suck on it?” she asked, her tone flat and matter-of-fact, as though she’d just asked you to pass the salt at dinner.
Your eyes shot open wide, and for a second, you weren’t entirely sure you’d heard her correctly. “I—uh—what?” you stammered, your voice cracking.
She looked up at you, one eyebrow raised, clearly unimpressed by your reaction. “I said, can I suck on it?” she repeated, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world. “You’re not just expecting me to stare at it all night, are you?”
Her deadpan delivery caught you so off guard that all you could do was blink at her in stunned silence. Slowly, your brain caught up to her words, and you found yourself choking out a nervous laugh. “Well, no,” you managed to say, arching a brow. “I just didn’t think you’d be so, uh… direct about it.”
“Do I look like the kind of mare who beats around the bush?” she shot back, her signature glare making a brief comeback before softening just slightly. “If you don’t want me to, just say so, dummy.”
“Wait, no, that’s not—” You sighed, running a hand through your hair as you looked down at her. “Of course you can,” you said, a faint smile tugging at the corner of your lips. “You don’t need to ask permission for this… kind of stuff. I just wasn’t expecting you to say it like that.”
She smirked, her earlier awkwardness melting away as her confidence returned. “Well, get used to it,” she said, her tone teasing as she leaned forward slightly. “I’m not exactly great at sugarcoating things.”
You chuckled softly, shaking your head. “Yeah, I’ve noticed.”
Her smirk lingered as she rolled her eyes. “Dummy,” she muttered under her breath, but there was no bite to the word this time—only warmth.
Then, without another word, she shifted closer, her focus dropping back to where it had been before. Her green eyes glimmered faintly in the dim moonlight spilling through the attic window, and you could feel your pulse quicken as her lips parted, her breath warm against your skin.
A sudden gasp escaped your lips as her warm, soft mouth enveloped the tip of your length. The sensation was immediate—intense and all-consuming, the heat of her lips and the subtle pressure of her tongue sending a jolt of electricity through your entire body.
Limestone’s ears flicked at the sound, and her eyes darted up to meet yours briefly, her expression shifting into something smugly pleased. She let out a soft hum, the vibrations rippling through you and amplifying the pleasure in a way that made your hips twitch involuntarily.
But she didn’t stop there.
Her tongue, rough yet flexible, began to move with purpose, lapping at the underside of your tip in slow, deliberate strokes. The texture was unlike anything you’d ever felt, and the contrast sent a shiver racing down your spine. Each drag of her tongue against you was maddeningly precise, leaving you breathless as she repeated the motion again and again.
The little noises she coaxed from you only seemed to spur her on. Her lips sealed tighter around you, and she sucked gently, her movements unhurried but intentional, as though she were savoring every reaction you gave her.
You couldn’t stop yourself—your hands fisted the blanket beneath you, your body shuddering with every pass of her tongue, every subtle shift of her lips. She wasn’t rushing, wasn’t pushing herself too far, but somehow that made it even more overwhelming. The deliberate pace, the attention she paid to every little movement, every sound you made, was intoxicating.
With a wet pop, she finally released you, a satisfied hum escaping her throat as she pulled back. Her lips glistened in the dim light, curled into a faint, smug smile that made your heart skip a beat.
“I haven’t even put the whole thing in, and you’re already enjoying yourself,” she teased, her voice low and playful as she wiped the corner of her mouth with her hoof.
You let out a shaky breath, your chest heaving slightly as you looked down at her with an arched brow. “I thought you said you’ve never done anything like this before,” you managed to say, your voice tinged with both surprise and accusation.
Her smugness faltered for a moment as she glanced to the side, avoiding your gaze, and let out a small, nervous huff. “Well… I haven’t,” she admitted, her voice uncharacteristically quiet. “But I’ve, uh… read a few magazines.”
You blinked, stunned for a second before letting out a breathy laugh. “Magazines?”
Her blush deepened, and her eyes shot back to you, narrowing in irritation. “Don’t laugh!” she snapped, though her voice cracked slightly, betraying her embarrassment. “It’s not like there's a lot to do around here, okay? And I guess I… wanted to… I don’t know… be good at it.”
You stared at her for a moment, your chest tightening unexpectedly at the sight of her so flustered, so out of her element. It wasn’t like Limestone to get nervous, let alone to admit she’d put thought into something like this.
“I wasn’t laughing at you,” you said softly, the teasing edge leaving your voice. “I just didn’t expect you to care about that kind of thing.”
Her ears flicked back, and she glared at you half-heartedly. “Of course I care,” she muttered, her blush refusing to fade. “I mean… you’re special or whatever, so…”
Her words trailed off, and her gaze dropped, her hoof idly brushing against your thigh as she fidgeted nervously.
“Lime,” you said gently, reaching down to brush a strand of her mane away from her face. She stiffened slightly at the touch but didn’t pull away, her eyes flicking back up to meet yours. “You don’t have to prove anything. You’re already amazing.”
For a moment, she just stared at you, her eyes wide and searching. Then, with a huff, she rolled her eyes and muttered, “Dummy.”
But the small smile tugging at the corners of her mouth betrayed her, and before you could say anything else, she leaned back down.
“Anyway,” she said, her tone more confident now as her hoof traced lightly along your inner thigh, “I didn’t stop just so you could start getting sappy on me.”
You let out a soft chuckle, your body tensing slightly as her lips brushed against you again. “Right. Wouldn’t want to ruin the mood.”
Her smirk returned, and she shot you a sly glance before lowering herself once more. This time, she didn’t hesitate. Her lips parted, and the heat of her mouth enveloped you again, deeper this time, her tongue gliding along your length with that same maddening roughness.
The noise you made in response was involuntary, a low groan that earned you a triumphant hum from her. Her hooves braced lightly against your thighs as she began to move, her head bobbing in a slow, deliberate rhythm that made your breath hitch with every pass.
Her confidence grew with every reaction she pulled from you, every shudder and gasp that escaped your lips. She alternated between sucking gently and swirling her tongue around you, her movements experimental but increasingly bold. It was clear she was paying attention, noting every little sound and shift in your body to figure out what drove you wild—and she wasn’t shy about exploiting it.
You couldn’t stop your hand from drifting to her mane, your fingers tangling gently in the strands as your hips twitched slightly beneath her. She let out another hum at the contact, the vibrations sending a fresh wave of pleasure through you as her movements quickened just enough to drive you closer to the edge.
“Lime,” you gasped, your voice strained as the intensity built, “I—”
She pulled back just enough to glare up at you, though her lips remained maddeningly close. “What did I say about talking, dummy?” she teased, her voice breathless but filled with that familiar fire.
And then, with a smirk that could have melted stone, she dove back down, silencing whatever protest you might have made and leaving you at her mercy once more.
Shamefully, you found yourself clamping a hand over your mouth, desperate to silence the moans threatening to escape your lips. Maybe it was an unconscious effort to keep from talking and ruining the moment. Or maybe it was because you knew Limestone—ever sharp, ever snarky—would have something to say about it if you got too loud.
Either way, the sight of you trying so hard to keep quiet must have been amusing, because she chuckled softly, her laughter vibrating around you. The sensation rippled through your body like a shockwave, making you shudder and bite down on the edge of your palm to keep from completely losing yourself.
She didn’t stop. If anything, your reactions seemed to spur her on. Her tongue dragged against you with purpose, her rough texture igniting every nerve as she continued to work her way down. Slowly, deliberately, she pushed herself deeper, taking you closer to the base. The sensation was overwhelming, her warm mouth wrapping tightly around you as she tried to hilt you entirely.
You could hear her gag slightly, the tightness of her throat squeezing around your length as she fought against her natural reflex. But Limestone Pie wasn’t the kind of mare to back down from a challenge. She pressed on, her determination almost admirable as she pushed herself to take more, to make sure you felt every second of this.
Your hand tightened over your mouth, muffling the sounds that you couldn’t entirely stop from slipping out. The heat, the wetness, the sheer feeling of her lips and tongue moving with such intent—it was too much. The way she moved, the way she hummed every time you twitched, made it clear she was enjoying this almost as much as you were.
But like all good things, you could feel the end approaching. That familiar heat began to coil low in your stomach, building quickly with every flick of her tongue, every shift of her head. Your breathing grew ragged, and instinctively, you wanted to warn her. But you swallowed the words, knowing full well that interrupting her might earn you one of her infamous glares—and possibly worse.
Instead, you hesitated for a moment before tapping lightly on her head, a silent plea for her attention. She glanced up at you, eyes locking onto yours as her movements slowed for just a moment. Even now, she still looked smug, her expression unreadable yet somehow knowing.
With a tilt of her head, she seemed to understand your unspoken message. And then, without missing a beat, she picked up her pace.
Her head bobbed faster now, her lips sliding along your length with a precision that made your head spin. But what made it worse—better, really—was the way she kept her eyes locked onto yours. The intensity in her gaze, the unwavering confidence, the slight glint of amusement behind it all—it was maddeningly, overwhelmingly hot.
You couldn’t hold back any longer. Your hips twitched as your body betrayed you, your length throbbing against her tongue. Limestone felt it, too, and she moved quickly, pulling her head back with a slick pop just as your cum surged forward.
Before you could even process what was happening, she stuck out her tongue, keeping her mouth wide open as she positioned herself just right. Her aim was perfect.
And then it hit.
The first rope of your climax spilled onto her tongue, and you let out a loud, broken moan—immediately muffled by your hand as you pressed it back against your lips, hard. Your body shuddered with each pulse, each spurt of warmth that landed in her waiting mouth. She didn’t flinch, didn’t pull back. If anything, she leaned closer, letting every drop hit its mark as she held her position.
Her expression was unreadable at first—focused, maybe a little smug—but you could tell she was enjoying this.
Finally, as the last wave subsided, she stayed still for a moment, her tongue still out, letting you watch as your release pooled on its surface. The sight alone was enough to leave you breathless.
Then, with a sly glance up at you, she closed her mouth, her lips curling into a mischievous smirk. You could see her throat bob slightly as she swallowed, her movements slow and deliberate. When she opened her mouth again, it was empty.
Gone.
“Hot,” you muttered breathlessly, the word slipping out before you could even think about it.
Limestone raised an eyebrow, her smirk widening slightly as she leaned closer, her hoof brushing lightly against your thigh. “Damn right it is,” she quipped, her voice low and teasing.
You let out a weak laugh, your chest still heaving as you tried to catch your breath. “I don’t know whether to thank you or be terrified of how good you are at this.”
Her ears flicked, and her eyes narrowed slightly. “Told you I’ve done my homework,” she said simply, her tone almost too casual. But then her smirk faltered for just a second, replaced by a flicker of uncertainty as she looked away briefly. “Was it, uh… good?”
The question caught you off guard—not because it was unexpected, but because of the way she asked it. She tried to sound indifferent, like she didn’t really care about the answer, but the way her gaze flickered nervously and her hoof fidgeted against the mattress gave her away.
You smiled softly, reaching down to brush a strand of her mane out of her face. “Limestone,” you said, your voice steady now, “it was amazing.”
Her eyes darted back up to meet yours, and for a moment, you swore she looked relieved. But then her familiar smirk returned, and she scoffed, rolling her eyes. “Of course it was,” she said, though her voice was quieter, softer. “Like I’d let you down, dummy.”
You chuckled, shaking your head as you leaned back against the bed. “Guess I should’ve known better than to doubt you.”
She didn’t reply right away, but the small, genuine smile that tugged at her lips said more than words ever could.
Limestone shifted back onto her haunches, her chest rising and falling as she tried to steady her breathing. Her mane was a mess, clinging to her forehead in damp strands, and her eyes burned with that familiar determination you’d come to associate with her—sharp, focused, and relentless. But there was something else in her gaze now, something quieter beneath the fire.
She looked at you without saying a word, her eyes scanning over you, as if she were sizing you up for whatever she was planning next. For a second, she seemed confident, even commanding. But as she began to move closer, her hoof brushing lightly against your chest as she guided you to lie back down, you noticed the faint hesitation in her movements.
“Stay still,” she muttered, her voice low but uncharacteristically soft.
“Wasn’t planning on going anywhere,” you murmured, a small smile tugging at your lips.
The faintest flicker of a grin crossed her face, but it was gone just as quickly. She swung her good forehoof over your waist first, her focus entirely on positioning herself. Her brow furrowed in concentration as she leaned forward, her weight shifting. But when it came time to bring her injured hoof across, she faltered.
Her balance wavered, and she hissed through gritted teeth, pulling back slightly as her injured leg trembled beneath her. “Damn it,” she muttered under her breath, frustration flashing across her face.
You frowned, watching as she tried again, slower this time, carefully adjusting her weight to avoid straining her leg. But the pain was obvious—she winced, her jaw clenching tightly as her hoof slipped against the mattress, forcing her to catch herself before toppling over entirely.
“Lime, wait,” you said softly, sitting up to steady her. Your hands found her sides instinctively, holding her firmly as you helped her balance.
“I’m fine,” she snapped automatically, though there was no bite in her voice. Her gaze flicked away, and you could tell she was trying to brush off your concern. “I can do it. Just… give me a second.”
You raised an eyebrow, your grip on her steady but gentle. “You sure? Because you’re one bad move away from face-planting right now.”
Her glare shot back to you immediately, piercing but faltering. “Don’t you dare make fun of me,” she warned, though her voice wavered slightly. It wasn’t just frustration in her tone—it was uncertainty.
You couldn’t help the soft chuckle that escaped you. “I’m not making fun of you,” you said, shaking your head lightly. “But maybe let me help before you break something else.”
Her ears pinned back, and she scowled at you, though the blush creeping up her cheeks betrayed her. “I don’t need—”
“Limestone,” you interrupted, your tone firm but kind. You met her gaze, holding it steadily as your hands stayed at her sides. “It’s okay. Let me help. You don’t have to do everything on your own.”
For a moment, she froze, her eyes searching yours. Her glare softened, and though she was clearly still annoyed, you could see the vulnerability peeking through—something rare, something raw. She let out a reluctant sigh, her shoulders sagging just slightly. “Fine,” she muttered, her voice barely above a whisper. “But if you drop me, I swear—”
“You’re not exactly heavy,” you teased, giving her a reassuring smile as you adjusted your grip.
Her glare returned instantly. “Dummy,” she muttered, but the faint twitch of her lips gave her away.
Gently, you shifted her weight, guiding her injured hoof out of the way as you helped her settle into position. She let out a quiet huff, clearly irritated at needing assistance, but she didn’t fight you. You carefully eased her down onto your lap, her legs straddling your hips as she leaned forward slightly to balance herself.
“There,” you said, your hands resting lightly on her waist to steady her. “See? Easy.”
She rolled her eyes, avoiding your gaze as her ears flicked back again. “Easy for you to say,” she muttered, her cheeks still flushed. “I’m the one stuck relying on you.”
You chuckled softly, the sound earning you a glare. “What’s so funny?”
“Nothing,” you replied, though your smile lingered. “It’s just… you’re cute when you’re flustered.”
Her blush deepened immediately, and she scowled at you, her lips pulling into a pout that was more endearing than intimidating. “I am not flustered,” she snapped, though the way her ears flattened against her head told a different story.
“Sure,” you said with a smirk, your thumbs brushing softly along her sides. “Whatever you say.”
As you spoke, you began to lean back onto the mattress again, making sure your movements didn’t shift her injured hoof. She adjusted with you, her good foreleg pressing against your chest for balance while her mane fell in loose strands around her face. When you finally settled, she hovered above you, her eyes locking onto yours with an intensity that made your breath hitch.
She looked stunning like this—flushed, focused, and completely unguarded. The fiery confidence that was so uniquely hers was still there, but it was tempered now by something softer, more vulnerable.
She must have noticed the way you were staring because she tilted her head slightly, her brows knitting together. “What?” she asked, her voice softer now, tinged with quiet curiosity.
“Nothing,” you breathed, your hands sliding to rest on her hips. “I’m just… you’re beautiful.”
Her eyes widened slightly, and for a second, she looked like she didn’t know how to respond. Then, with a snort, she rolled her eyes. “You’re such a weirdo,” she muttered, though her voice lacked any real venom.
Before you could reply with a teasing remark, she leaned down suddenly, her lips brushing against yours in a kiss that was quick but no less passionate. Her mane tickled your face, and her warmth pressed against you as the kiss deepened for a brief, stolen moment.
When she pulled back, her face was flushed even darker, but this time, the nervousness in her eyes was impossible to miss. She shifted slightly, her gaze flicking away from yours as she hesitated. “Well… uh, let’s get this started,” she muttered, though her voice cracked slightly.
Her good hoof fidgeted against your chest, and you could feel the slight tremble in her body as she tried to steel herself.
You reached up, brushing a strand of mane from her face as your fingers lingered against her cheek. “Hey,” you said softly, waiting until she met your gaze again. “We don’t have to rush this. If you’re not ready…”
She shook her head quickly, her lips pressing into a thin line. “I want to,” she said, her voice firm despite the faint quiver. “I just—” She hesitated, swallowing hard. “I’ve never… done this before.”
The admission hung in the air, vulnerable and raw.
You smiled gently, your hand sliding back down to her waist. “It’s okay,” you murmured, your tone steady and reassuring. “We’ll take it slow. Together.”
Her gaze softened, and after a moment, she let out a small, shaky breath. “Dummy,” she whispered, though there was no anger behind it this time—only warmth.
Slowly, Limestone began to lift herself, her body trembling slightly as she adjusted her position. Her movements were deliberate, careful, as though she were trying to steady herself both physically and emotionally for what was about to come.
Your gaze flicked downward instinctively, and the sight made your breath hitch. She was wet with arousal, the slickness between her legs glistening faintly in the dim light of the attic. It was undeniable now—she wanted this as much as she’d said, maybe even more.
Carefully, she guided herself down, her hoof braced on your chest for balance. Her breathing quickened as she positioned herself at the tip of your length, her folds brushing against you with a warmth that sent a shiver through your entire body. The sensation was fleeting, but it was enough to make both of you gasp softly, the shared intimacy drawing you closer.
Limestone paused there, her chest rising and falling with shallow breaths as she steadied herself. Her eyes flicked downward, watching where your bodies met, and you could see the faintest waiver of hesitation in her expression. She bit her lip, her ears twitching slightly as she muttered something under her breath.
“Just like ripping off a band-aid…” she whispered, so quietly you almost didn’t catch it.
Before you could reach out to reassure her, to tell her there was no rush, no pressure, she moved.
Without a word, she slammed herself down in one swift motion, her folds parting around you as you sank into her. The sensation was overwhelming—the tight, wet heat of her body enveloping you completely, taking you in all at once.
You gasped sharply, your hands instinctively gripping her waist as you tried to process the sudden rush of pleasure. But Limestone’s reaction was far different.
Her entire body tensed, her back arching slightly as she froze in place. Her good hoof shot up to her mouth, muffling the sound of her scream as she bit down on it, her eyes squeezing shut.
It wasn’t hard to tell why. You could feel it—the unmistakable resistance you’d broken through as you pierced her hymen. She had been ready for this, but no amount of preparation could completely ease the initial shock of that first time.
“Limestone,” you said softly, your voice laced with concern as your hands gently slid along her sides, steadying her trembling form. “Are you okay?”
She didn’t respond right away, her breathing ragged as she slowly lowered her hoof from her mouth. Her eyes fluttered open, and for a moment, she just looked at you, her cheeks flushed a deep crimson.
“I-I’m fine,” she muttered, though her voice wavered slightly. Her gaze dropped for a second, avoiding yours, before flicking back up. “I just… needed a second.”
Her honesty was rare, vulnerable, and it made your chest tighten. You loosened your grip on her waist, letting your thumbs rub small, soothing circles against her fur. “Take your time,” you said softly. “We don’t have to rush this.”
She let out a shaky breath, her body relaxing slightly as she adjusted to the sensation. “I’m not a quitter,” she said, though the fire in her tone was softened by the faintest tremble. “I can handle this.”
You couldn’t help but smile at her determination, even in such a vulnerable moment. “I know you can,” you said gently. “But that doesn’t mean you have to push yourself too hard.”
Her lips twitched, a small, grateful smile breaking through her otherwise flustered expression. “Dummy,” she muttered under her breath, though there was no anger behind the word—only warmth.
For a moment, neither of you moved. Her breathing began to steady, the tension in her body easing as she adjusted to the feeling of you inside her. You could feel the slight tremors in her legs begin to subside, replaced by a tentative confidence as she shifted her weight experimentally.
The smallest movement sent a ripple of pleasure through both of you, and Limestone sucked in a breath, her eyes widening slightly as her hoof pressed against your chest.
“Okay,” she said finally, her voice firmer now but still soft. “I think… I think I’m ready.”
You nodded, your hands steadying her as you offered her a reassuring smile. “Just go slow,” you said quietly. “We’ve got all the time in the world.”
Her gaze locked onto yours, and for a moment, something unspoken passed between you—trust, affection, and an undeniable connection that neither of you could ignore.
“Slow, huh?” she said, a faint smirk tugging at her lips despite the blush still staining her cheeks. “You’re lucky I like you.”
And with that, she began to move, her hips rolling ever so slightly as she tested the waters, drawing a quiet gasp from both of you.
Limestone’s movements started tentative at first, a slow roll of her hips as she adjusted to the sensation of you inside her, her walls clenching in reflex. Her breaths were shallow, each exhale shuddering slightly as she focused on finding her rhythm. The fur along her chest and neck was damp with sweat, and her cheeks remained flushed as her eyes flickered between you and where your bodies met.
You let her set the pace, your hands remaining steady on her waist as you offered gentle support. “You’re doing great,” you murmured, your voice soft but filled with sincerity.
Her ears flicked at the praise, “Of course I am,” she muttered, her bite returning, “I’m not gonna half-ass this.”
Despite her words, you could feel the nervous tension still lingering in her body, the slight hesitations in her movements as she tested her limits. You tightened your grip on her hips, just enough to ground her, and let your thumbs rub soothing circles into her fur. “Just take your time,” you said softly. “We’re in no rush.”
Her gaze flicked to yours, and the intensity in her green eyes sent a jolt through you. For a second, she looked like she might snap back with her usual sarcasm. But then she let out a shaky breath, her expression softening slightly as her body began to relax.
She shifted her weight again, this time a little more deliberately. The slow drag of her body against yours sent a ripple of pleasure through both of you, and she gasped softly, her lips parting as her hooves braced against your chest.
“There we go,” you said with a small smile, your voice low and encouraging.
“Shut up,” she softly muttered.
Her movements grew bolder, each roll of her hips a little more confident, a little more intentional. The initial hesitation began to melt away, replaced by a steady rhythm that made your head spin. You could feel her adjusting to you, her body relaxing further with each passing moment, and the soft noises escaping her lips became less restrained.
At one point, she let out a quiet moan, quickly biting her lip as though trying to suppress it. Her ears flattened briefly, and she glanced down at you, her blush deepening. “Don’t you dare say anything,” she warned, though her voice cracked slightly, betraying her embarrassment.
You couldn’t help but chuckle, your hands sliding up from her hips to rest gently on her barrel. “I wasn’t going to,” you teased, your tone light and playful. “But for the record, you sound incredible.”
Her ears twitched, and she let out a small huff, clearly flustered but unwilling to admit it. Sh-shut up,” she muttered harshly though her tone had softened into something warmer.
Her pace began to pick up, the slow roll of her hips turning into something more deliberate, more purposeful. The heat between you grew with every movement, every soft gasp and moan that slipped from her lips despite her best efforts to hold them back. Her hoof slid up from your chest to your shoulder, her grip tightening slightly as she leaned forward, her mane brushing against your face.
You let out a low groan as the friction increased, your hands gripping her sides more firmly to steady her. “Limestone,” you breathed, your voice tinged with both awe and desperation.
Her gaze snapped to yours, her eyes blazing with something raw and unfiltered. “What?” she asked with a gasp.
“You’re amazing,” you said, the words tumbling out before you could stop them.
For a moment, she froze, her ears flicking back as her expression wavered. “W-what'd I say about being sappy,” she muttered, though her voice was quieter now, almost unsure.
“I mean it,” you insisted, your hands sliding up to frame her face. You brushed a strand of her mane out of her eyes, your thumb grazing against her flushed cheek. “You’re incredible.”
Her lips parted as if to argue, but only another moan escaped her. Instead, she leaned down suddenly, capturing your lips in a kiss that was hot and unrestrained. Her body pressed against yours as her movements grew more urgent, her hips grinding against you in a way that left you breathless.
The kiss deepened quickly, her tongue slipping into your mouth as she took full control. The mix of the kiss and her walls squeezing your length sent sparks through you.
Her good hoof ran through your hair as she kissed you fiercely, her body moving against yours in perfect rhythm. The room felt impossibly hot, the air between you charged with an intensity that left no space for hesitation or doubt.
“Limestone,” you gasped against her lips, your voice breaking slightly as your hands gripped her waist again.
She pulled back just enough to meet your gaze, her breathing ragged as her eyes locked onto yours. “What?” she asked, her voice low and husky.
“I…” you hesitated for a moment, “I love you,” you said, the words coming out like a prayer.
For a moment her breath got caught in her mouth, though the small, genuine smile tugging at her lips softened the gesture “You’re such a dummy,” she muttered, but there was no malice in her words—only warmth, only affection.
Her movements became even bolder, her hips grinding down against you with a newfound confidence. The soft moans slipping from her lips grew louder, less restrained, and she leaned down again, her forehead resting against yours as she rode you with a passion that left you both trembling.
The heat between you was overwhelming, the connection undeniable. It wasn’t just about the physical—there was something deeper in the way she looked at you, the way her body moved with yours, the way her touch lingered as though she didn’t want to let go.
And as her pace quickened, the tension building between you both reaching its peak, you couldn’t help but think that this moment—this connection—was more than you could have ever dreamed.
Her rhythm steadied, each movement deliberate and fluid as she found a pace that felt natural. The tension that had lingered earlier was gone now, replaced by something electric, something primal. Limestone's confidence grew with every passing moment, her body moving in perfect harmony with yours.
Her hooves rested firmly on your chest and shoulder, grounding herself as she leaned forward, her mane falling loosely around her face. Her eyes softened, replaced by an intensity that left you breathless. She was in control, and for once, you were content to let her lead.
The warmth of her body enveloped you completely, her movements drawing you deeper with each roll of her hips. The pressure built steadily, the sensation overwhelming but impossible to resist. You groaned low in your throat, your hands gripping her hips to steady her as she drove you both higher.
Limestone’s breath hitched, a soft sound escaping her lips as her head tilted back. Her movements quickened, the pace becoming more demanding, more desperate, as her body adjusted fully to yours. The tension in her shoulders melted away, replaced by fluid, natural motion as she leaned into the pleasure coursing through her.
Her lips parted, and a quiet moan slipped out, unrestrained and genuine. It was intoxicating—the way she let herself go, the way her walls had crumbled, leaving only raw emotion and desire. You couldn’t take your eyes off her.
"Lime," you breathed, your voice hoarse. You didn’t have the words to finish the sentence, but the way her gaze flicked to yours told you she understood.
Her eyes locked on yours, her flushed face framed by strands of her mane clinging to her cheeks. She bit her lip, her hips never faltering as she ground against you, driving both of you closer to the edge. The connection between you was magnetic, her expression carrying an unspoken mixture of challenge and affection, daring you to match her intensity.
Her hoof slid from your chest to your arm, her touch firm and grounding. "You’re not tapping out on me now, are you?" she asked, her voice breathless but teasing.
You let out a strained chuckle, your grip on her tightening as your body responded instinctively to her pace. "Not a chance," you murmured, your words coming out as a low growl.
The moment pushed past words after that. The air around you was thick with heat, the sound of your mingled breaths and the rhythmic movement of your bodies filling the space. She leaned down, her forehead brushing against yours, her eyes fluttering shut as her lips hovered dangerously close to yours.
Her pace shifted again—faster now, the roll of her hips more urgent, more deliberate. The pleasure was almost unbearable, each movement sending waves of heat coursing through you. You could feel the subtle tremble in her legs, the slight hitch in her breath as her own release began to creep closer.
Your hands slid up from her waist, brushing along her sides before one settled at the small of her back, pulling her closer. The other cupped her cheek, guiding her into a kiss that was messy, desperate, but filled with passion. She moaned softly against your lips, the sound muffled as her tongue brushed against yours.
Her movements faltered briefly, her hips stuttering as her body tensed. Her breath hitched, and she broke the kiss, her lips hovering against yours as she whispered your name—a sound so soft and vulnerable it sent a shiver down your spine.
"Limestone," you groaned, your voice strained as the heat in your core built to a breaking point.
Her eyes snapped open, and for a moment, her gaze was locked on yours, her expression raw and unguarded. "I’m close," she admitted, her voice barely a whisper.
You nodded, your hands steadying her as you matched her movements, guiding her as her pace quickened further. The world around you faded, leaving only the heat, the connection, and the overwhelming sensation of her body moving in sync with yours.
Her moans grew louder, less restrained, as her hips moved frantically now, chasing the release she so desperately sought. You could feel her trembling, her body taut like a bowstring as the tension built higher and higher.
And then, suddenly, she broke.
Her head tilted back, her mouth falling open as a strangled cry escaped her lips. Her body clenched tightly around you, her hips stuttering as waves of pleasure rippled through her. You held her firmly, guiding her through the moment as she rode out her climax, her body trembling violently in your arms.
The sight, the sound, the feeling of her unraveling pushed you over the edge. Your release followed seconds later, the pressure breaking as your body tensed and heat surged through you. Shot after shot of your cum was driven deep inside her. A deep, guttural groan tore from your throat as you clung to her, the world fading to white for a blissful, shattering moment.
Limestone collapsed against you, her body trembling as her head rested against your shoulder. Her breath was hot against your neck, ragged and shallow as she clung to you, her hoof still gripping your arm.
For a long moment, neither of you moved, the only sound in the room the faint creak of the bed and the rapid beat of your hearts. The air was thick with the lingering heat of your passion, your bodies still tangled together as you both slowly came down from the high.
Finally, Limestone shifted, her breath evening out as she lifted her head to meet your gaze. Her eyes were softer now, her expression unreadable as she searched your face.
"Well," she said after a moment, her voice hoarse but steady. "Guess I didn’t break you after all."
You let out a weak laugh, your hand brushing a stray strand of mane from her face. "Guess not," you murmured, your lips curving into a small smile.
She looked away briefly, her hoof trailing idly along your chest. "You’re still a dummy, though," she muttered, though there was no venom behind her words.
"Yeah," you said softly, your smile widening. "But I’m *your* dummy."
Her lips twitched, and she rolled her eyes, but the faint smile she gave you afterward told you everything you needed to know.
The room was still, the only sounds the soft patter of rain against the attic window and the slow, rhythmic breaths you and Limestone shared as you lay tangled together. Her body was draped across yours, her weight grounding you as she rested her head against your chest. Her mane, damp with sweat, clung lightly to your skin, and you absently ran your fingers through it, soothing the tension that lingered in her frame.
The fiery intensity from earlier had dimmed, replaced by a comforting warmth that settled over both of you like a heavy blanket. Your hands traced gentle patterns along her back, her fur soft beneath your touch. She was quiet, her breathing still a little uneven, but the way her hoof clung lightly to your arm told you she wasn’t quite ready to let go yet.
For a while, neither of you spoke. The silence wasn’t awkward—it was peaceful, a shared stillness that neither of you wanted to break. But as the minutes ticked by, you felt her shift slightly against you, her body stiffening just enough to catch your attention.
“Something wrong?” you asked softly, your voice cutting through the quiet like a gentle breeze.
She didn’t answer immediately, her hoof idly brushing against your chest as she stared somewhere past you, her eyes distant. Then, after a long pause, she let out a quiet huff, her ears flicking back. “I was just… thinking,” she muttered, her voice quieter than usual.
You tilted your head to look at her, your hand stilling against her back. “Thinking about what?”
She hesitated again, her brow furrowing as her lips pressed into a thin line. “It’s stupid,” she said finally, though the way she avoided your gaze told you she didn’t believe that.
“Hey,” you murmured, your hand moving to cup her cheek, guiding her to meet your eyes. “If it’s bothering you, it’s not stupid. Talk to me.”
Her ears twitched, and for a moment, she just looked at you, her expression conflicted. Then, with a reluctant sigh, she shifted slightly, propping herself up enough to look down at you.
“I was just… wondering,” she began, her voice halting as if she was choosing her words carefully. “About, y’know, what just happened.”
Your brow furrowed slightly, unsure of where she was going with this. “What about it?”
She looked away, her cheeks flushing as she fidgeted with the blanket beneath you. “You… didn’t, uh, y’know… pull out,” she said, her voice barely above a whisper.
It took you a second to process what she meant, and when it clicked, your eyes widened slightly. “Oh.”
She groaned, covering her face with her good hoof. “Ugh, forget it. I told you it was stupid.”
“Limestone, it’s not stupid,” you said quickly, sitting up slightly and resting a hand on her shoulder. “You’re worried about getting pregnant.”
Her ears pinned back, and she gave you a sideways glare, though it lacked its heat. “Well, yeah,” she muttered. “I mean, I don’t know how this stuff works with… with you.” She gestured vaguely at you, her blush deepening. “You’re not exactly… a pony.”
You couldn’t help the small smile that tugged at your lips, though you quickly hid it, knowing she wouldn’t appreciate you finding humor in her concern. “Hey,” you said gently, brushing a strand of her mane out of her face. “You don’t have to worry about that. It’s not possible.”
She raised an eyebrow, skepticism clear in her expression. “What do you mean it’s not possible?”
“I mean,” you explained, your tone calm and reassuring, “you’re a pony, and I’m… well, not. Our biology is way too different. It just doesn’t work like that.”
She stared at you for a moment, her expression unreadable. “You’re sure?”
“Positive,” you said firmly, your hand moving to rest lightly on her hoof. “I promise, Limestone. You don’t have to worry about that.”
She exhaled slowly, the tension in her shoulders easing slightly as she processed your words. “Okay,” she said finally, though her tone was still a little uncertain. “I’ll take your word for it. But if I end up with a weird hybrid foal, I’m blaming you.”
You chuckled softly, leaning up to press a light kiss to her forehead. “Fair enough,” you said with a smile.
She huffed, though the corners of her lips twitched upward. “Dummy,” she muttered, but there was no malice in the word—just warmth.
As the weight of her worry lifted, she relaxed against you again, settling back into your arms with a quiet sigh. Her head rested against your chest, and her hoof traced small, absent patterns along your skin.
The silence returned, but it was comfortable now, the two of you wrapped in a cocoon of warmth and contentment. Your fingers continued their gentle path through her mane, and you felt her breathing even out, her body melting into yours as the rain outside softened to a faint drizzle.
“You’re not going anywhere, are you?” she murmured after a while, her voice drowsy but tinged with something softer—something vulnerable.
“Not a chance,” you replied, your arms tightening around her.
“Good,” she muttered, her lips curling into a small, sleepy smile. “Because I kinda like having you around.”
Your chest tightened at her words, and you couldn’t help but smile, pressing a soft kiss to the top of her head. “I kinda like being around,” you murmured.
Her response was a quiet hum as her eyes drifted shut, her body completely at ease against yours. You stayed like that for a long time, the storm outside fading into nothing as the two of you drifted off together, wrapped in the kind of warmth you hadn’t known you needed until now.
The sun hung low on the horizon, painting the sky in streaks of gold, orange, and soft pinks. The rocky fields stretched out before you, their jagged beauty softened by the warm evening glow. A gentle breeze swept across the farm, carrying the faint scent of earth and stone—the unmistakable aroma of the Pie family’s world.
You leaned back against the porch railing, your arms crossed loosely as you watched the last rays of sunlight dance over the hills. The day had been long, as they always were on the farm, but there was a kind of satisfaction that came with it now—a sense of belonging that hadn’t always been there.
A familiar voice broke through the quiet.
“You gonna sit there all night like a lump, or are you actually gonna help me?”
You turned your head to see Limestone standing a few feet away, a basket of rocks balanced effortlessly on her back. Her green eyes sparkled with that familiar sharpness, but there was a softness beneath it now, a warmth that hadn’t been there when you first met her.
“Define ‘help,’” you replied with a smirk, leaning casually against the railing.
She rolled her eyes, but the faint curve of her lips betrayed her amusement. “You’re insufferable,” she muttered with a chuckle.
“And yet, here I am,” you shot back, your grin widening.
“Yeah, yeah.” She turned her head to adjust the basket, her mane falling across her cheek in loose strands. “You better be grateful, you know. Not everyone would put up with a dummy like you.”
You chuckled, pushing off the railing and walking toward her. “And yet, here you are,” you said, echoing her words with a teasing lilt.
She shot you a glare, but it didn’t last long. As you approached, her expression softened, and she let out a small sigh. “Sometimes I wonder why I let you stick around.”
“Because you’d miss me if I wasn’t here,” you said simply, your voice quieter now.
Her ears flicked, and for a moment, she didn’t respond. Then, with a huff, she turned her head away, her cheeks flushing faintly. “Don’t push your luck,” she muttered, but the smile tugging at the corners of her mouth told you everything you needed to know.
The two of you fell into step together, walking side by side toward the barn as the last light of day began to fade. The farm was quiet now, the others having turned in for the evening, leaving only the soft crunch of gravel beneath your boots and her hooves.
As you reached the barn, Limestone set the basket down with a small grunt, her movements practiced and precise. You leaned against the doorway, watching her as she worked, the soft glow of the lantern casting warm light across her features.
“Staring again?” she asked without looking up, her tone dry but laced with humor.
“Can you blame me?” you replied, your voice light.
She glanced at you out of the corner of her eye, her green gaze steady. “You’re lucky you’re cute,” she muttered, shaking her head as she grabbed a smaller basket from the corner.
You raised an eyebrow. “Did you just call me cute?”
“No,” she said quickly, avoiding your gaze. “Don’t make it weird.”
You couldn’t help but laugh, the sound earning you a halfhearted glare. But as you reached out and gently tugged the basket from her grasp, she didn’t pull away.
“Hey,” you said softly, your tone shifting. “Thanks. For, you know… everything.”
Her gaze softened, and for a moment, she just looked at you, her expression unreadable. Then she let out a small huff, stepping closer until her hoof pressed lightly against your chest.
“You’re a dummy,” she said, her voice quiet but warm. “But you’re my dummy.”
You smiled, your hand coming up to rest over her hoof. “Always.”
The two of you stood there for a while, the quiet of the farm wrapping around you like a blanket. The stars began to peek through the fading twilight, their soft light spilling across the fields, and for the first time in what felt like forever, you felt completely at peace.
Perhaps you didn't need to go on a grand adventure full of monster slaying or princess sweeping. At least not without Lime trying to strangle one of the princess’—or you—in the process.
But you were content with this simple farm life facing whatever challenges that may lay ahead. But you knew you’d face them together—one stubborn, sharp-tongued mare and one very lucky human.
And for now, that was enough.
Author's Note
You know what it is.
Chat, be honest. Did I cook or did I burn the fucking kitchen down?
