Sunny Starscout stirred in the warm glow of dawn, a light that filtered through the luminous walls of the Crystal Brighthouse. The bed beside her shifted, Misty Brightdawn's soft blue mane catching the morning rays. Sunny smiled to herself, savoring the quiet moment before the day began in full force. It was Winter Wishday, their first together as a couple, and Sunny’s heart thudded with excitement at the thought of celebrating this magical time with her marefriend and their fathers.

"Morning, Misty," Sunny whispered, brushing a hoof through Misty's mane, earning a gentle sigh in return. Misty's violet eyes fluttered open, a lazy smile spreading across her face as she snuggled closer, her muzzle brushing against Sunny's neck.

“Mmm, morning Sunny… What a perfect day to wake up to,” Misty murmured, voice still heavy with sleep but filled with warmth. "I can't wait for today… our first Winter Wishday together."

Sunny’s heart warmed at the thought. "Me neither. We’ve come so far."

They shared a tender moment, their bodies gently pressing together under the soft covers before Misty pulled back with a small chuckle, eyes sparkling mischievously. "You know… it’s still early. We could celebrate a bit before the others wake up."

Sunny smirked, leaning in close. “You’re reading my mind, Misty.”

But before the moment could escalate further, the quiet murmur of voices from the hall reminded them that they weren't alone. Izzy’s cheerful tone echoed through the brighthouse, talking excitedly with Comet. With a sigh, Sunny rolled onto her back, gazing up at the twinkling crystal ceiling. The day was only just beginning, and there were still things to be done.

They rose from bed, quickly making their way downstairs where the others had already gathered. Izzy was bouncing excitedly on her hooves, practically glowing with energy as she explained her plans to the group.

“Sunny! Misty! I was just telling everypony about my epic adventure with Comet today!” Izzy exclaimed, her voice brimming with excitement. Comet grinned up at her, clearly just as eager.

Sunny raised an eyebrow, surprised. “Wait… you’re going on an adventure today?”

Izzy nodded enthusiastically. “Yup! I promised Comet I’d take him all over Equestria - well, you know, just the coolest spots. I know it’s Winter Wishday, but this is going to be super fun!”

Misty leaned in closer to Sunny. “Guess it’s just us for today then,” she whispered with a smile.

Just then, Hitch galloped into the room, a worried look on his face. “Guys, I’m sorry, but I won’t be able to join the celebration either,” he announced, his voice tight with concern. “Grandma Figgy’s fallen ill, and I need to go take care of her.”

Sunny’s heart sank a little. “Oh no, Hitch… I hope she’ll be okay.”

“I’m sure she will, but she needs me right now. I’ve gotta head out soon,” Hitch replied, giving them all a reassuring but hurried smile.

Zipp and Pipp, who had been quietly listening from the corner, exchanged glances before Zipp flared her wings. “And we’ll be in and out, grabbing everything we need for today,” she said, a determined edge to her voice. “We’ve got some royal duties to deal with, but we’ll be back before you know it!”

Sunny nodded, smiling gratefully at her friends. "Thanks, everypony. We’ll make the best of it, even if things aren’t going exactly as planned."

As her friends began to scatter, heading off to their respective tasks, Sunny glanced at Misty, her heart swelling with affection. “Looks like it’s just you, me, and our dads.”

Misty grinned. “And that sounds like the perfect way to celebrate.”

* * *

The warm morning light bathed the Crystal Brighthouse in a soft glow as Sunny and Misty sat across from each other at the breakfast table, the scent of fresh hay pancakes and syrup hanging in the air. The place felt peaceful and still, the kind of calm that came when the world was just beginning to wake up. Both mares had been enjoying the quiet, but there was something lingering between them, unspoken.

Their fathers, Argyle and Alphabittle, were still in Bridlewood, planning to visit later that night. That gave them time - time to talk about something that had been on both of their minds but neither had quite found the courage to bring up.

Sunny set her fork down, glancing at Misty, who was absently pushing her pancakes around her plate. “Hey, Misty,” she began, her voice soft but intent, “I’ve been thinking… about us. About, you know, starting a family.”

Misty blinked, looking up with a mix of curiosity and excitement. “You mean… us becoming moms?” She smiled, but there was a hint of nervousness in her voice. They’d talked about it before, but only in passing, like a dream they weren’t quite ready to chase.

“Yeah,” Sunny said, her chest tightening with a combination of excitement and uncertainty. “We’ve been talking about it for a while, and… I really think we’re ready. I think it’s time we figure out how to actually make it happen.”

Misty’s heart raced a little, her cheeks flushing as she nodded. “I’ve been thinking about that too, Sunny. I really want us to have a family together.” She paused, her ears flicking slightly as a thought crossed her mind. “But… how are we going to do it? I mean, we thought about asking Hitch, but with him being all about Sprout now…”

Sunny laughed lightly, shaking her head. “Yeah, Hitch is a no-go. He’s totally wrapped up in Sprout, and besides, he’s already got a foal to take care of, or well, a dragon. And you know him - he’d probably go on about paperwork and legal stuff.”

Misty giggled, picturing Hitch with a stack of forms, and for a moment, the tension between them lifted. But as the laughter faded, the conversation shifted back to its serious core. Sunny leaned forward slightly, her voice softening.

“I’ve been thinking… maybe we should ask each other’s dads.”

Misty froze for a moment, her eyes widening as the weight of Sunny’s words settled in. “You mean… your dad?” she asked slowly, her heart thudding in her chest. “And… Alphabittle?”

Sunny nodded, her expression earnest but calm. “Yeah. I know it’s a big ask, but… it feels like the right thing. We love our dads, and they love us. They’ve both missed out on so much of our lives, but this could be a way to bring them closer to us. I mean, Argyle’s always cared about you like family, and Alphabittle’s been like a second dad to me ever since we became close.”

Misty’s mind raced as she considered it. The idea was bold, even a little wild - but it made sense. Argyle had always been gentle and loving, and she knew he’d do anything for Sunny. And Alphabittle - he’d missed so much of her foalhood, and now he was so proud of the mare she had become. It would be a way for him to be part of something bigger, something that could bring them even closer.

“But… you think they’d actually say yes?” Misty asked, her voice soft, unsure but intrigued. “That’s… really intimate, Sunny.”

Sunny smiled, her hoof reaching across the table to gently touch Misty’s. “I know it is. But I think they’d understand. They love us, and they’d do anything to help us be happy. Besides, who better to help us have a foal than somepony who already loves us like family?”

Misty’s eyes softened as she met Sunny’s gaze, the idea settling in her heart. It was unconventional, yes, but that didn’t mean it was wrong. If anything, it felt like a natural extension of the love they already shared with their fathers.

“You’re right,” Misty whispered, a small, hopeful smile spreading across her face. “It would make our family even closer, wouldn’t it?”

Sunny’s face lit up with relief and excitement. “Exactly. It’s not just about us starting a family - it’s about connecting with the ones who’ve always been there for us, even when they couldn’t be.”

Misty took a deep breath, the nerves giving way to a quiet sense of resolution. “Alright,” she said softly, her voice steadier now. “When they get here… we’ll ask them.”

Sunny grinned, her eyes shining with hope and love. The decision was made, and though they didn’t know how their fathers would react, they felt a sense of rightness in their choice. It was more than just starting a family - it was about building something meaningful, together.

* * *

As the quiet moments stretched between them, Misty’s smile faltered slightly. She shifted in her seat, her hooves fidgeting with the edge of her plate. Sunny noticed, raising an eyebrow. “Misty? What’s wrong?” she asked, her voice soft, sensing something was troubling her.

Misty hesitated, biting her lip, her eyes darting around the room as if she were searching for the right words - or maybe the courage to say them. Finally, she looked at Sunny, her voice barely above a whisper. “Sunny, before we ask our dads… there’s something I need to tell you.”

Sunny tilted her head, concern flickering in her eyes. “You can tell me anything, Misty. You know that.”

Misty took a deep breath, her heart racing. “I know, but this… this is different. You have to promise me you won’t tell anypony. Ever.”

Sunny’s expression softened, but the seriousness in Misty’s tone made her sit up straight. She reached across the table, taking Misty’s hoof in hers. “I swear, Misty. Whatever it is, I won’t tell a soul.”

Misty’s eyes darted to the door, ensuring they were still alone. When she finally spoke, her words came out in a shaky rush, as if confessing this would make her heart explode. “Sunny… I don’t want your dad to put a foal inside of me.”

Sunny blinked, her mind whirling for a second as she processed the confession. “Wait, what do you mean? I thought… I thought we agreed on-”

“No.” Misty’s voice shook, but she pressed on, her eyes burning with a mix of shame and something darker. “It’s not that. I… I want my own dad to do it. I want Alphabittle to put a foal inside of me.”

Sunny’s breath caught in her throat, her heart pounding in her chest as the weight of Misty’s words hit her. Her mind reeled, stunned into silence. Misty’s face was flushed, her eyes wide with fear of rejection or judgment, but there was a burning honesty in them that couldn’t be ignored.

“I know it’s wrong,” Misty continued, her voice breaking. “I know it’s bad, and I shouldn’t even want this. But I do. I’ve thought about it for so long, Sunny. I can’t help it… I just need it to be him. I need… more of him, you know?

Sunny’s mind spun, trying to find the words, the right response. Her heart was racing, not just from the shock of what Misty had confessed, but because a part of her - an unspoken, hidden part - felt the same. She hadn’t dared to admit it to herself, not fully. But now that Misty had laid her darkest desire bare, it cracked something open inside of Sunny, too.

“Misty…” Sunny whispered, her voice barely audible. “I… I didn’t want to say anything either, but… I feel the same.”

Misty’s eyes widened, her breath catching. “You do?”

Sunny nodded slowly, her cheeks flushing as she spoke the words she’d been afraid to say, even to herself. “I don’t want anypony else but my dad to put a foal inside me, either. I thought it was wrong, that I shouldn’t feel this way, but… hearing you say it…” She trailed off, her pulse racing as the confession hung between them, raw and exposed.

The room seemed to close in around them, the air thick with the weight of their shared secret.

Sunny’s heart hammered in her chest, but she felt a strange sense of relief, as though admitting it had lifted something heavy off her shoulders. She had thought her Dad was dead, had thought that for a very long time, but when they defeated Opaline… he was freed from some magical prison. He was back, living in Bridlewood, but back. He had missed so much of her life that the idea of her needing more of him resonated in her soul.

Misty looked at her, eyes wide and filled with a mix of fear and relief, realizing they weren’t so alone in their desires. “We both want the same thing…” Misty murmured, her voice trembling with the realization.

Sunny’s eyes widened as the weight of their shared confessions sank in, but instead of fear, something else flickered in her gaze - determination. Without a word, she stood up from the table, her mind racing. Misty watched her, confusion blooming on her face.

“Sunny? Where are you going?”

Sunny hesitated for just a moment, then looked back at Misty with a wild spark in her eyes. “There’s something I need to show you,” she said, her voice urgent. “I found it a few weeks ago… in my dad’s old study. It explains everything.”

Before Misty could say anything, Sunny dashed out of the room. Misty sat there, her heart pounding, a strange mixture of curiosity and nervousness swelling in her chest. A few minutes later, Sunny returned, clutching a large, worn leather-bound book. The cover was cracked with age, its golden lettering faded but still legible.

“What is that?” Misty asked, her voice barely above a whisper.

Sunny set the heavy book down on the table with a soft thud, her hooves trembling slightly as she opened it to a marked page. “It’s an old text,” Sunny began, her eyes scanning the familiar words. “I found it when I was going through my dad’s things. It talks about how… incest wasn’t always seen as wrong. Not like it is now.”

Misty blinked, leaning closer to peer at the yellowed pages. “What do you mean?”

Sunny’s voice was hushed, but there was an intensity in it as she continued. “Back in the old days of Equestria, incest was common. Twilight Sparkle… and her whole family… they were involved in it. Her brother, her parents - they all shared this kind of bond.”

Misty gasped, her eyes widening. “Twilight Sparkle? But she’s a legend! I never… I never heard anything like that.”

Sunny flipped through a few more pages, her hoof tracing the old text. “And it wasn’t just her. There are stories about the ponies of Sire’s Hollow too. The Apple family, the Orange family, the Pears, even the Pies. They all… kept things within the family.”

Misty stared at the book, her heart thudding in her chest as she took in what Sunny was saying. “Are you saying this was normal back then?”

Sunny nodded, her voice soft but firm. “Yes. According to this book, it was. Ponies back then didn’t see it the way we do now. Even Princess Celestia and Princess Luna…” She hesitated, her cheeks flushing slightly. “They had a thing with each other too.”

Misty’s breath caught in her throat. “Celestia and Luna…?”

Sunny nodded, flipping to a passage that detailed the bond between the royal sisters. “It was part of who they were, part of their lives. And there are even more stories - dozens of them, showing that it wasn’t as taboo as it is now.”

Misty’s mind raced, the weight of everything Sunny was telling her crashing over her like a tidal wave. She had always thought her feelings, her desires, were wrong - twisted somehow. But hearing this… it changed everything. If even the greatest ponies in Equestria had shared these kinds of bonds, maybe what she wanted wasn’t as unnatural as she’d feared.

Sunny looked up from the book, her eyes meeting Misty’s, full of emotion. “I’m not saying we have to do anything… but this shows that it’s not as wrong as modern ponies think it is. It’s not some terrible thing, Misty. It was part of our history.”

Misty sat back, her mind reeling, her heart pounding as she absorbed what Sunny had just shared. The revelation sent a shiver down her spine, not from fear but from the overwhelming realization that maybe, just maybe, their desires weren’t as forbidden as they’d thought.

“What… what do we do now?” Misty whispered, her voice trembling slightly as the truth of their shared secret settled deep within her.

Sunny smiled softly, closing the book with a soft thud. “We figure it out together. We decide what we want. No judgment, no shame. Just us.”

* * *

Meanwhile, in Alphabittle’s tea shop nestled deep in Bridlewood, the quiet hum of early morning was broken only by the sounds of clinking cups and shuffling supplies. The shop, typically a peaceful haven, buzzed with preparation as Alphabittle and his new co-worker, Argyle Starshine, worked side by side, packing boxes and double-checking lists. They had a big trip ahead of them—heading to the Brighthouse to spend time with their daughters for Winter Wishday.

But something felt off.

Alphabittle, normally cheerful and steady, seemed quieter today. His usual lighthearted banter was missing, and there was a heaviness to his movements that hadn’t gone unnoticed. Argyle, who had become a close friend to Alphabittle since reuniting with his daughter, watched him carefully, sensing something was wrong.

After a few more minutes of silence, Argyle finally broke it. “Hey, Alphabittle,” he said, glancing over as he folded a tea towel. “You’ve been awfully quiet this morning. Is something on your mind?”

Alphabittle grunted, his focus still on the boxes in front of him. “It’s nothing, Argyle. Don’t worry about it.”

Argyle smiled softly, knowing there was more to it. He wasn’t one to push too hard, but he also didn’t like seeing his friend clearly weighed down by something. “Come on now,” he said, his voice gentle but persistent. “I know when something’s bothering you. You can tell me. We’ve got time before we need to head out and getting it off your chest might help.”

Alphabittle paused, his jaw tightening as he placed a teapot into the box. He let out a heavy sigh, clearly debating with himself whether to speak or keep it bottled up. Argyle’s patient silence finally won him over, and Alphabittle put down what he was holding, turning to face him.

“Alright,” Alphabittle muttered, rubbing the back of his neck. “But don’t laugh, okay?”

Argyle gave him an encouraging nod. “Promise. What’s on your mind?”

Alphabittle hesitated for a second, then sighed deeply, his shoulders sagging a little. “It’s just… this trip. Spending time with Misty, and, well… seeing her all grown up.” His voice trailed off, and for a moment, he seemed lost in his thoughts. “I missed so much of her life, Argyle. So many years where I wasn’t there for her, and now… I don’t know how to handle it. Being a father now, when she’s already her own mare.”

Argyle listened closely, his brow furrowing with empathy. “That’s not easy,” he said softly. “I get it. I feel the same way sometimes, even though I’ve always been close with Sunny. You want to make up for lost time, but it feels like… like you’re too late.”

Alphabittle nodded, his eyes distant. “Exactly. I feel like I missed my chance to be the kind of father she needed. And now, I’m not sure how to make it right. She’s strong, independent, in a committed relationship that feels real and I’m proud of her. But part of me just… wants to protect her. Like I should have done all those years ago.”

Argyle gave a thoughtful hum, crossing his arms as he leaned back against the counter. “I hear you. But you know, Misty doesn’t hold that against you. She loves you, Alphabittle. The fact that you’re here now, that you’re trying - that’s what matters. She’s not expecting you to make up for the past. She just wants her dad in her life.”

Alphabittle’s eyes softened as Argyle’s words sank in. “I know you’re right. I just… can’t shake this feeling, you know? Like I’m not doing enough. By all the crystals in Bridlewood… she lives in Maretime Bay now. We only see each other on holidays and special occasions.”

Argyle smiled gently. “I’m in the same boat… I live in Bridlewood with Sunny in Maretime Bay also. I want to do more for her, be there, but she’s her own mare now and I felt like I needed to give her space. You’re doing more than enough, my friend. Trust me. It’s hard, being away for so long and trying to step back into the role of a father, but you’re here now. That’s what counts. Misty knows you care. Just as I hope Sunny knows I care.”

Alphabittle nodded slowly, feeling the weight in his chest ease just a little. “I guess you’re right. It’s just hard not to think about what could’ve been different.”

Argyle clapped him on the shoulder, giving him a reassuring smile. “I know. But you’ve got now, Alphabittle. And the future. That’s what you focus on. You’re here for her now, and that’s what’s important.”

Alphabittle’s expression darkened after a moment of silence. His hooves trembled slightly as he set down the item he was holding, his voice low, almost like he was choking on the words. “Argyle… there’s something else. Something I haven’t told anypony.”

Argyle stopped mid-motion, glancing at his friend. “What is it, Alphabittle?”

Alphabittle took a deep, shuddering breath, his face etched with guilt and shame. “I’m a horrible father, Argyle. I’ve been trying to be there for Misty, but… I can’t stop thinking about her in a way I shouldn’t.” His voice cracked as he continued. “I can’t get it out of my head - how much I want her. How much I want to be with her, in the worst way. To be inside her.”

He stared down at his hooves, his heart heavy with the admission, his voice barely above a whisper. “It makes me feel like some sick, twisted monster. I shouldn’t even be thinking like this about my own daughter.”

Argyle’s brow furrowed as he listened, but there wasn’t a hint of judgment in his expression. He didn’t recoil, didn’t turn away. Instead, he watched Alphabittle with quiet sympathy, waiting for him to finish.

“I… I don’t know why I feel this way, but I can’t make it stop. And I just… I needed to tell somepony. I know it’s wrong, and I don’t expect you to understand, but I couldn’t keep it inside anymore,” Alphabittle finished, his voice thick with anguish. “I’m terrified of what this makes me.”

Argyle, calm and collected, reached out and placed a hoof on Alphabittle’s shoulder, squeezing gently. “It’s okay, Alphabittle. It’s okay to feel this way.”

Alphabittle’s eyes shot up, shock clear on his face. “How can you say that? I just admitted I-”

Argyle cut him off gently, shaking his head. “I’m not judging you, Alpha. Feelings like this… they’re not as unnatural as you think. Trust me.” He paused, taking a breath before continuing. “I’ve come across things in my studies, things that explain exactly what you’re going through. And it’s more common than you’d think.”

Alphabittle blinked, confusion mixing with his shame. “What are you talking about?”

Argyle gave him a small, understanding smile. “Stay here. I have something to show you.”

Without waiting for a response, Argyle left the shop and walked over to a small building beside it - his new study. He’d set it up not long ago, full of the books and artifacts he had gathered over the years, especially from his travels before being trapped in magical stasis. After a few moments, he returned, holding a large, ancient book - its leather cover worn but still sturdy.

It was the same kind of book Sunny had found.

“This,” Argyle said as he placed the book on the counter between them, “is one of the books I found during my travels. It’s from the olden days of Equestria, written by Princess Twilight Sparkle herself.”

Alphabittle’s eyes narrowed as he looked at the old tome, curiosity stirring within him. “What… is this?”

Argyle opened the book carefully, flipping through the delicate, yellowed pages until he found the section he was looking for. “During my travels, I found a lot of old books, documents from the time before modern Equestria. This one… it details how things were back then. Incest wasn’t seen the way it is now. In fact, it was part of many families’ lives. Even the most well-known families - the Apples, Oranges, Pears, Pies… even Twilight’s own family.”

Alphabittle stared at the pages, his breathing shallow as Argyle continued.

“There are stories of Twilight Sparkle and her brother, her parents… even Princess Celestia and Luna had a bond that went far beyond what we’d consider normal today. It was just part of life back then, something ponies embraced.”

Argyle paused, his gaze meeting Alphabittle’s. “It’s not as wrong as modern ponies think it is. These feelings, they’ve always been part of our world. And there’s no reason for you to feel like you’re some kind of monster.”

Alphabittle’s heart pounded in his chest as he stared at the book, the weight of Argyle’s words pressing down on him. “But… this is all so…”

“Shocking?” Argyle finished, nodding. “I know. But I’m telling you, it’s okay to feel what you feel. You’re not alone in this, and you’re not the first pony to struggle with it.”

Alphabittle swallowed hard, the shame and confusion still swirling inside him, but now mixed with something else—relief, and perhaps a glimmer of understanding. “So… you’re saying it’s not wrong? What I’m feeling?”

Argyle smiled gently. “I’m saying that it’s not as simple as right or wrong. Ponies have felt this way for generations, and it’s only in recent times that things have changed. You’re not alone in this, Alphabittle. And you don’t have to carry this guilt.”

Alphabittle’s gaze dropped back to the book, his mind still racing but now with the weight of possibility. The history of Equestria, the hidden stories buried in its past - it all seemed to paint a very different picture than what he had believed.

The teahouse was quiet, dimly lit by the soft glow of candles scattered on the tables, their flames flickering in the comfortable warmth of the room. Argyle sat back in his chair, swirling his tea idly, his eyes fixed on Alphabittle across the table. The clinking of their cups and the crackle of the hearth were the only sounds filling the space. No other ponies were there to overhear them, not that they’d understand the tension hanging in the air anyway.

Argyle broke the silence first, his voice low, almost a whisper. “You ever find your eyes lingering a little too long on a mare, Alpha? Noticed the way she moves, the way her tail flicks just right sometimes?”

Alphabittle didn’t answer right away, but his ears twitched. He knew where this was going. Argyle had that look in his eyes, the one that said he was about to tread into dangerous territory. Still, Alphabittle stayed silent, letting Argyle carry on.

“I’ve seen it with Sunny,” Argyle continued, his tone soft, deliberate. “When she’s trotting around all determined-like, her head high, tail swishing back and forth, like she doesn’t have a care in the world... sometimes it shifts just enough to give you a peek.” His eyes glinted with something dark and unspoken, his voice almost growling now. “And you can’t help but think, just for a second, what it'd be like to press her down right there, tail lifted, her breath catching in her throat as you-”

Alphabittle’s throat tightened. He didn’t say anything, but he knew the feeling Argyle was describing. He had seen Sunny that way too, more than once, though he’d never admit it outright. He shifted uncomfortably in his seat, but Argyle caught the movement and smiled knowingly.

“It’s okay,” Argyle said, as if sensing Alphabittle’s unspoken thoughts. “We’re stallions, Alpha. We notice these things. We’re wired to.” He leaned in a little closer, lowering his voice even more. “And it’s not just Sunny, is it? I’ve seen how you look at Misty.”

Alphabittle’s ears flattened slightly, his heart skipping a beat. He had tried to keep it subtle, to keep his glances innocent, but Argyle had clearly picked up on it. Misty had this way of trotting around, so unaware of how her hindquarters swayed or how her tail would lift just enough when she bent down to grab something. It was innocent, completely natural... and yet, it stirred something primal inside him.

“She’s got that same naive charm, doesn’t she?” Argyle continued, his grin growing. “Always so shy, so sweet... and yet every now and then, when she moves just right, that tail of hers lifts up enough to make you wonder. Makes you think about what it would be like to have her under you, doesn’t it?”

Alphabittle’s throat tightened, his eyes narrowing as a flicker of guilt crossed his face. But Argyle was right. There were moments when Misty’s innocent demeanor only made the thoughts more intense, more tantalizing. She had no idea what ran through his mind when her soft tail flicked, momentarily revealing a glimpse of something she wasn’t even aware of.

Argyle leaned back, his expression now a mixture of understanding and something darker. “We can’t help but let our thoughts wander sometimes, happens to all stallions of all ages. You see that curve under a mare’s tail, you catch a glimpse when she’s not paying attention... and for a moment, your imagination runs wild.”

Alphabittle finally spoke, his voice rough, low. “I’ve thought about it. Misty... she’s just got this innocence to her, makes you want to protect her... but also makes you wonder what she’d sound like if you... fucked her. Start with a soft whisper and make her scream your name…”

Argyle chuckled softly, nodding. “Exactly. We all think it, even if we don’t say it. It’s fine to let your mind wander. It’s healthy, in fact.” He paused, his eyes glinting with something mischievous. “But you know the line, right? You can think it, maybe catch a peek when they’re not looking, maybe imagine them with their tails lifted high, begging for it... but you don’t act.”

Alphabittle glanced down at his tea, considering Argyle’s words. The line between thought and action blurred so easily, especially when those thoughts lingered too long. But he nodded slowly, acknowledging the truth in what Argyle was saying.

“Just enjoy the view when you can,” Argyle continued with a smirk. “No harm in that. A little glance when the tail sways just right, a little peek when they don’t notice... that’s as far as it goes. We think it, we imagine it, but we never touch. We never cross that line. It was okay once upon a time, but I don’t know anypony that still does it. If any do… it’s a well-kept secret.”

The words hung in the air, a silent agreement passing between them. Both stallions knew the thoughts that drifted through their minds, the fleeting fantasies that came with each swish of a mare’s tail or the accidental glimpse beneath. But it would stay that way - just thoughts, just fantasy.

Argyle took another sip of his tea, the tension easing from his voice as he smiled again. “No harm in a little perving every now and then, right?”

Alphabittle stared into his tea, the warm liquid swirling in his cup, but his mind was elsewhere - lost in thoughts that weighed heavier with each word Argyle had spoken. He shifted in his seat, the quiet of the teahouse only amplifying the tension between them, the unspoken confessions hanging in the air.

"She’s a lot like her mother," Alphabittle said suddenly, his voice rougher than usual, as if the admission itself was a burden. His gaze lifted to Argyle, searching the other stallion’s face for understanding.

Argyle nodded, his expression softening, the usual mischievous glint in his eyes replaced by something far more somber. “Sunny... yeah, she’s just like her mother too,” he admitted, his voice quieter now. “The way she looks, the way she’s so determined, always out there trying to change the world... it’s like I’m seeing her all over again. When she was young…”

For a moment, the room seemed to breathe with the weight of shared loss. Both stallions sat in the dim light, the memories of their loved ones filling the spaces between their words, filling the teahouse with a sense of absence, a sense of longing that neither of them could fully express.

“And that’s what makes this harder, doesn’t it?” Alphabittle said, his voice laced with a bitter edge. “Not having them here anymore.” He sighed, rubbing his temple with a hoof, as if trying to push the thoughts away. “I see so much of her in Misty. The way she moves, the way she smiles... it’s like being haunted sometimes. And it makes me... makes me think things I shouldn’t.”

Argyle leaned back, staring at the ceiling for a moment before speaking. “Yeah, I get it. Every time Sunny walks into a room, I catch myself thinking the same thing. Not just about how much she’s grown up, but how much she is her mother. It’s hard, knowing she’ll never really understand how much of her mom is in her. And it pulls at you, makes you want to hold onto that... even if it’s wrong.”

Alphabittle nodded, his jaw tight as he struggled with the same feelings. “It’s not just the memories,” he murmured, his voice thick with regret. “It’s the wanting to relive it, to capture what we had. When Misty looks at me with those innocent eyes, when her tail flicks just the way her mother’s used to... it makes me wish things were different. Like I could somehow bring her mother back through her.”

There was a silence then, thick and almost suffocating, the unspoken truth between them looming like a shadow neither could outrun.

Argyle shifted in his seat, his tone softer now, as if he was walking a fine line. “And it’s hard not to wonder, right? What if they noticed? What if they said something? Asked for more? Would you turn them down?”

Alphabittle sighed heavily, his hoof tracing the edge of his cup as he considered the question. His thoughts drifted back to Misty, her shy smile, the way her movements - so unaware - mirrored those of her mother. He’d tried to keep his distance, to keep the line drawn, but he couldn’t lie to himself any longer.

“No,” he admitted quietly, the words carrying a weight he hadn’t wanted to confront. “I don’t think I could. She’s too much like her mother, and I... I miss her too much. I’d tell myself it was wrong, that I shouldn’t, but if she was serious, if she came to me and said she wanted to be with me... I wouldn’t be able to turn her away.”

Argyle was silent for a moment, nodding slowly, his own gaze fixed on the floor. “Same here,” he said at last, his voice low. “If Sunny came to me... no, I wouldn’t turn her down either. It’d be like having her mother back, in a way. And that’s the hardest part, isn’t it? It’s not just the wanting. It’s the missing. It’s knowing they’ll never really understand how much we lost.”

They both sat there, the fire crackling in the hearth, the weight of their shared confessions pressing down on them like the ache of an old wound that had never quite healed. Neither of them needed to say more. The absence of their loved ones, the echoes of the past, and the impossible desires that followed - these were burdens they carried alone, even if, in this moment, they weren’t quite as alone as they used to be.

Argyle let out a bitter laugh, one that seemed to hang in the air, sharp and jagged against the quiet of the teahouse. His eyes darkened as he stared into his tea, the weight of memories pressing down on his shoulders.

“My wife... she disappeared without a trace when Sunny was young,” he said, his voice rough, edged with a pain that time hadn’t dulled. “We always talked about having a huge family. I wanted more than anything to have a house full of little ones running around. But when she disappeared, those dreams vanished with her. It’s funny, in a way. Sunny is almost the same age her mother was when she disappeared, but I didn’t age at all while I was in that magical cave. The age gap now is less like father and daughter and more like husband and wife…”

Alphabittle’s ears flicked, his eyes meeting Argyle’s, understanding the pain but not knowing how to respond to the depth of it. He knew loss, but there was a sharpness to what Argyle had gone through, something raw that he couldn’t touch.

Argyle’s gaze shifted, distant now, as if he were looking through time, staring at the life he might have had. His mouth twisted into a dark smile, the kind of smile that came when the truth was too painful to face head-on. “And then there’s Sunny,” he continued, his voice almost too quiet to hear. “She’s all I have left of that dream. And if she ever came to me, told me she wanted a foal...”

He trailed off, but Alphabittle could hear the tremor in his voice, the conflict raging just beneath the surface.

“I wouldn’t say no,” Argyle said finally, the confession falling like a stone between them. “How could I? After all these years of wanting that... if Sunny told me she wanted to carry my foal, to give me that family I lost... how could I turn her away?”

Alphabittle shifted in his seat, his throat tight. He understood now, in a way he hadn’t before. It wasn’t just the desire to relive the past or to hold onto a piece of something long gone. It was the yearning for what could have been, the need to rebuild what had been lost. And that made it all the more dangerous.

“You’d do it, wouldn’t you?” Alphabittle murmured, his voice low. “If she asked... if she came to you with that same look her mother used to give... you’d give her everything.”

Argyle didn’t hesitate. “Yes. I would. I wouldn’t even think twice.” He looked up then, meeting Alphabittle’s eyes with a kind of resigned honesty. “Because it wouldn’t just be about the act, or even the desire. It would be about getting back that piece of my life that was stolen from me. I’d be reliving everything I lost... and in that moment, I wouldn’t care if it was right or wrong.”

Alphabittle swallowed hard, the weight of the conversation settling in his chest. He thought of Misty, how much she reminded him of her mother, how much he’d been aching to hold onto what had slipped through his hooves. The thought of her coming to him, asking for the same thin - his heart twisted.

“Maybe we’re not so different,” Alphabittle muttered, half to himself. “If Misty asked me the same thing... I don’t know if I’d say no either. Not when she’s all I’ve got left of her mother.”

The two stallions sat there in the dim light, the flicker of the fire the only movement in the room. Their confessions, raw and unfiltered, lingered in the air like smoke, and for the first time, they both realized just how deeply their losses had shaped them - how much they both longed for something that might never come.

And yet, if their daughters came to them, asking to fill that void... neither of them could refuse. Not after all they had lost. Not after all they still yearned for.

Argyle sighed, the weight of his own confession settling in his chest. The rawness of it, the dark honesty that had slipped out between them, lingered in the air like the last glow of the firelight. But now that it was spoken, now that the unspoken desires were out in the open, it felt... lighter somehow. A shared burden, no longer festering alone in his thoughts.

He glanced at Alphabittle, who was staring into his own tea, the same conflicted expression mirrored in his eyes.

Argyle let out a quieter, softer laugh this time, shaking his head. “Of course, it’ll never happen,” he said, almost to himself, the admission gentle but final. “We’re just stallions... with old dreams and a bit too much time to think.” He paused, taking a deep breath before continuing. “But... I’m glad to have gotten it off my chest. It’s been haunting me for a while.”

Alphabittle looked up, the tension in his shoulders easing as he gave a slow nod. “Yeah,” he agreed, his voice steady but quieter now. “I didn’t realize how much it was weighing on me until I said it out loud. It’s strange, isn’t it? You carry these thoughts with you, thinking they’re wrong, that nopony else would understand... but now that it’s out there, I feel... lighter.”

Argyle smirked, raising his teacup in a mock toast. “Guess we’re not so different after all.”

Alphabittle raised his own cup, tapping it lightly against Argyle’s. “Not so different at all,” he said with a chuckle. He glanced at the fire, the flames dwindling to embers, and added, “And don’t worry. I’ll keep your secret.”

Argyle gave a nod, a small but sincere smile tugging at the corners of his mouth. “And I’ll keep yours. No need to let anypony else in on this. What we talked about... it stays between us.”

The air in the room seemed to shift, lighter now, the weight of their shared confessions settling comfortably into the quiet understanding between them. It was a secret they would both carry, but one they no longer had to carry alone. And that was a relief.

Argyle stood up first, stretching his legs as he looked out the window. The world outside was still dark, but the promise of dawn wasn’t far off. “We should get ready,” he said, turning back to Alphabittle. “The journey to Maretime Bay isn’t short, and we’ve got a Winterwish Night to celebrate with our daughters.”

Alphabittle rose from his seat as well, nodding. “Yeah... we’ve got to be there for them. They deserve a good celebration.” His voice softened, almost wistful. “And, honestly, I’m looking forward to seeing Misty. It’s been too long.”

Argyle smiled, pulling on his saddlebag and fastening it securely. “Same here. Sunny’s been working so hard lately... it'll be nice to spend some time with her. Plus, she’s always loved Winterwish Night.”

They moved around the small teahouse, gathering their things and preparing for the trip. The room was silent save for the sound of hooves on wooden floors and the occasional rustle of saddlebags being adjusted. The weight of their earlier conversation still hung in the air, but it was no longer oppressive. Instead, it was like a shadow cast by something they had already faced, something they had accepted.

As they stepped outside, the cool night air brushed against their coats, crisp and refreshing. The stars overhead twinkled like icy pinpricks in the deep blue sky, a sign that Winterwish Night was just around the corner.

Alphabittle glanced over at Argyle, a small smile on his face. “Let’s head out. We’ve got a long way to go, and I don’t want to miss a single moment with Misty.”

Argyle grinned, his earlier darkness now replaced by something warmer, lighter. “Same here. Let’s make this a Winterwish Night they won’t forget.”

Together, they set off toward Maretime Bay, the promise of a peaceful holiday with their daughters ahead of them, and the weight of their confessions left behind in the quiet of the teahouse. They both knew the truth - that the fantasies they had spoken would never come to pass. But having the space to share them, to speak them aloud and leave them in the realm of dreams, was enough.

And with that unspoken understanding, they walked side by side into the morning, prepared to do some last-minute shopping, and ready for what awaited them in Maretime Bay.

* * *

Author's Note

This is a Commission

For commission requests, DM me,