A Fluttering Star

by ObabScribbler

Rating: everyone
Tags: Slice of Life, Main 6, Trixie, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Spike, Starlight Glimmer, Romance, Fluttershy
Length: 4297

Starlight Glimmer prepares for her first date with Fluttershy. It would be a lot easier if she was not such a big ball of raging anxiety about dating one of her friends.

Starlight Glimmer prepares for her first date with Fluttershy. It would be a lot easier if she was not such a big ball of raging anxiety about dating one of her friends.

Written as a Secret Santa gift for Marianne Studios.

Published 2024-12-24 23:30:04 UTC
Last updated 2024-12-24 23:30:04 UTC

"Fluttershy’s dating? Does Discord know?"

Starlight Glimmer paced nervously outside Fluttershy’s cottage. She had double-checked everything: her mane was sleek and shimmering, thanks to a visit to the spa, and she had polished her shoes to a perfect shine. Those pieces of her appearance did not bother her. Her outfit, however ...

Trixie had insisted on helping. And Trixie and Starlight, though good friends, did not agree on aesthetics when it came to clothing. Starlight pulled at the neck of the amethyst-coloured dress that clung delicately to her frame. Starlight had intended to just wear a ribbon or something, but Trixie had been adamant.

“You need to stand out, but not in a ‘look at me’ kind of way. Think ‘mysterious enchantress’ rather than ‘asinine show-off’.”

Nervous that this was even happening at all, Starlight had not had enough energy to spare from keeping her anxiety in check to prevent herself from being browbeaten into accepting Trixie’s help. The dress had a high neckline adorned with delicate silver thread in an intricate swirling pattern that matched Trixie’s best performance cloak. A matching silver belt cinched Starlight’s waist. Her shoes were also silver, with a gentle sparkle that caught the light with each uneasy step she took. For added flair, Trixie had selected a thin, sheer veil to drape over her friend’s shoulders, claiming it ‘added an air of mystery without being too extravagant’. To complete the look, a small silver pendant engraved with Starlight’s own cutie mark hung delicately from a silver chain around her neck.

“It has a ‘keep clean’ enchantment on it,” Trixie had told her, somewhat more grudgingly than Starlight might have expected if she wasn’t busy questioning her life choices. “Nothing huge, just a little one to stop your shoes and clothes from getting grubby.”

She had not even thought to ask where Trixie had gotten the pendant, but the knowing looking Twilight had exchanged with Spike when Starlight left the castle this evening made her think they were involved somehow.

Despite her initial reservations, Starlight had to admit that Trixie’s apparel choices did make her feel a little more confident. Maybe this would not be so bad after all, she thought, smoothing the fabric one last time and glancing again at the cottage door. Almost immediately, an anxious thought squashed the positive one flat. She was early. She should not have come early. What kind of absolute idiot arrived early for a date?

She took a steadying breath. “Okay, Starlight. You’ve faced ancient magic, changeling queens and time loops. You can handle one date … right?”

Her mind flashed back to the moment she had decided to ask Fluttershy out. It wasn’t something that had happened overnight. Starlight’s feelings had built slowly over time and been her most closely guarded secret – even more so than her teenage goth phase. Since obviously it wasn’t ever going to go anywhere, she had managed to convince herself her emotions were just platonic appreciation for Fluttershy’s kindness and strength. After all, how could they be anything more? Starlight was still relatively new to the world of non-toxic friendships and could not be trusted to know her own feelings on things like that.

And then, of course, there was Discord.

Everypony had assumed that Fluttershy and Discord were a couple. Their closeness was legendary: the tea parties, the private in-jokes, the way they seemed to understand each other on a level no-one else could comprehend. Starlight had assumed the same. Even if her own feelings were more than platonic friendship, how could she compete with someone like Discord? He could literally bend reality to make Fluttershy happy. She couldn’t even make herself ask Fluttershy out to a totally platonic and not at all romantic teahouse date without overthinking it.

So, for the longest time, Starlight had kept her confusing feelings buried, accepting that Fluttershy was someone to only admire from afar. She tried to convince herself that being her friend was enough. She was lucky she had any fiends at all, after all. Not all former villains got the chance to reform and build a new life for themselves.

That belief was shattered the day Fluttershy mentioned her date with Strawberry Sunrise.

Starlight still remembered how her stomach had dropped when Fluttershy casually said, “Oh, I’m going out with Strawberry tomorrow. She asked me on a date, and I thought, why not?”

Starlight had smiled politely, wished Fluttershy luck, and spent the rest of the day wrestling with a mix of jealousy and confusion.

Fluttershy’s dating? Does Discord know?

The next day, when Fluttershy invited Starlight over to her cottage for tea and recounted the disastrous date (awkward silences, an offhanded comment about how ‘animals are too much work’ and absolutely no spark) Starlight had tried not to look too relieved. Yet what truly stunned her was when Discord himself had popped in mid-conversation to add his own commentary to Fluttershy’s story.

“Oh, finally,” he had said with a theatrical sigh. “I was beginning to think everypony would assume Fluttershy and I were married before she cleared things up. For the record, we’re friends - best friends, mind you - but nothing more. I do get to approve of all her potential paramours in future though. Strawberry Sunrise? Seriously? What were you thinking, dear Fluttershy?”

“She was nice to me,” Fluttershy had shrugged awkwardly. “And it’s not like I get a lot of date requests. Everyone seems to think we’re an item no matter what I say, Discord.”

“You need to speak louder, obviously. Hmm, would it be crude to make a billboard on the edge of town about it? I can whip up some neon lights and a speaker that says ‘Fluttershy and Discord are just friends’ anytime anyone goes past.”

Starlight had nearly dropped her teacup. “Wait, really?”

“Yes, really.” Discord’s mismatched eyes had twinkled as he leaned closer to her. “And for the record, I think she deserves someone who truly appreciates her.” He had detached his mouth and pressed it against her ear to whisper: “So don’t mess it up.” Then, with a wink and a snap of his fingers, he was gone, leaving Starlight flustered and bewildered.

Fluttershy had sighed and sipped her tea. “I know Strawberry Sunrise was probably a bad choice but … it was worth a try. I mean, I’ve always liked both mares and stallions, but I suppose I’m still figuring out what I want personality-wise.”

Starlight had felt her entire world shift. “You’re… bi?” she had managed, trying to sound casual as her heart attempted to beat right out of her chest.

Fluttershy had nodded, hiding behind her hair. “Oh, yes. I think it’s just about finding the right pony. Someone who really understands me. Somepony I could … love.”

Those words had stayed with Starlight, echoing in her mind long after she had gone home that evening.

Was it possible? Could she really take that leap?

The answer had come during one of their group evenings in Twilight’s castle. Fluttershy and Starlight had taken up chairs by the fire and Fluttershy had been talking animatedly about a new group of rabbits at her sanctuary, her eyes sparkling with a passion that left Starlight utterly captivated. She had always admired Fluttershy’s compassion, but seeing her in that moment, so radiant and alive, had made something inside her shift. Before she could even realise what she was doing, the words had spilled out.

“Would you ever … I mean, do you think we could … do you want to go out with me? Like, on a date?”

It had been clumsy, awkward and painful. She had instantly braced herself for rejection. Fluttershy would be nice about it, of course. She would let Starlight down gently by saying something like: “Oh, Starlight, I’m very flattered, but I don’t think of you that way.”

Instead, Fluttershy had tilted her head, her cheeks dusted with pink, and softly replied: “Yes, I’d love to.”

The cottage door creaked open, snapping Starlight back to the present. Fluttershy peeked out. Her pink mane cascaded over her one visible shoulder. She wore a soft smile that immediately melted Starlight’s nerves.

“Hi, Starlight. You’re right on time.”

“Of course! I mean, I wouldn’t want to keep you waiting. You look lovely, um, by the way. Not that you don’t always look nice but … um …” Shut up, shut up, shut up! You sound like a moron! Shut up already!

“Oh, thank you,” Fluttershy murmured, brushing a hoof shyly against the ground. “You look wonderful too.”

“Thank you!”

“That outfit is really pretty. It suits you.”

Starlight’s breath hitched as Fluttershy stepped out from behind the door. It was completely rude and she should stop right the heck now but all she could do was stare.

Fluttershy wasn’t just pretty, she was breathtaking. She wore a simple dress of pale green, its delicate hem embroidered with hundreds of tiny flowers. Her mane cascaded in glossy waves, accented by a single daisy tucked behind her ear.

Starlight’s mouth went dry. She scrambled for words. “Wow. Fluttershy, you … you look … amazing.”

Fluttershy’s cheeks pinkened. “Oh, thank you. Rarity helped me pick this out. She thought it would suit the evening.”

Of course she did, Starlight thought, simultaneously grateful and intimidated by Rarity’s impeccable taste. She could practically hear Trixie’s voice in her head, dripping with exaggerated sarcasm. “Oh, sure, Starlight. No pressure at all, dating a pony with literal fashion royalty as a friend. At least you have me and Twilight’s stupid pendant to make sure you don’t completely embarrass yourself.”

Her thoughts were interrupted by a faint movement in the window behind Fluttershy. Angel Bunnie stood on the windowsill, little arms crossed. He scowled out at them. After a moment, however, still scowling, he gave Starlight a thumbs-up and hopped out of sight.

“I guess Angel approves,” Starlight blurted. Oh my gosh, what am I saying? That was so dumb.

Fluttershy giggled. “He can be a little protective sometimes, but I think he likes you.”

Starlight swallowed hard. Her nerves tangled with a warm rush of affection. “Well, that’s … good. I think? Better than being on his bad side, at least. Um … shall we get going?”

“Sure.” Fluttershy closed the cottage door behind her. “Where are we going?”

“You’ll see.”

As they began their walk side by side, Starlight’s thoughts briefly drifted back to earlier that day, when Trixie had grudgingly helped her prepare. As helpful as Trixie has been, she had teased Starlight mercilessly about how hopelessly smitten she was, mimicking her nervous rambling and dramatically reenacting worst-case scenarios.

“Don’t worry,” Trixie had said with a sly grin as Starlight fretted over her outfit for the fifth time. “Even if you completely mess this up, you’ll still be able to say you went on a date with Fluttershy. That’s more than most ponies can dream of.”

Starlight had groaned at the time. Now, however, walking beside Fluttershy, surrounded by the crisp evening air and the gentle fragrance of wildflowers, she could not help but feel a wave of gratitude. Rarity and Trixie might have had wildly different approaches, but thanks to both of them, this night was already more magical than she had ever dared imagine.

“I’m glad you suggested this.” Fluttershy’s voice was just as gentle as the breeze around them. “It’s a lovely evening. Usually I’m working with my animals too much to take the time to appreciate how lovely the evening is.”

“I’m glad you said yes. I … wasn’t sure if this was something you’d want to do.”

Fluttershy glanced down at her hooves. She had not bothered with shoes, which instantly made Starlight feel overdressed. “Oh, well … I wasn’t sure you’d want to ask me. I mean, I don’t always think of myself as … someone others would choose for something like this.”

“What?” Starlight stopped mid-step, eyes wide with disbelief. “Fluttershy, you’re incredible! I can’t imagine anypony not wanting to spend time with you.”

Fluttershy peeked up at her through her hair. “That’s very kind of you to say, Starlight. It means a lot. You’re … a very special friend to me.”

The word ‘friend’ hit Starlight like a runaway carriage. Her breath caught, not with warmth this time, but with icy dread.

Friend? Oh no. She thinks I’m just her sad, desperate friend, doesn’t she? She probably agreed to this date because she felt sorry for me. Oh, Celestia, what if she didn’t even realise this was supposed to be a date? What if this was all just some big, horrible misunderstanding!? She tried to keep her expression neutral but her brain latched onto every insecure thought it could muster. Of course that’s what it is. Why would Fluttershy want to date me? She’s kind, gentle, wonderful and I’m ... me. An awkward, impulsive former villain who doesn’t understand emotions and constantly second-guesses everything.

“Thank you,” Starlight said reflexively. She looked away, pretending to focus on the path ahead. “You’re a … good friend to me too, Fluttershy.”

Pull yourself together, Starlight. Don’t ruin this by freaking out. Just... stay calm and get through tonight. At least you’ll still have her as a friend, even if it’s not what you want.

Yet even as she tried to steady her breathing, her heart sank. The warmth that had filled her moments ago was replaced by the kid of hollow ache that came from hoping for something too good to be true.

They reached the meadow just as the last rays of sunlight painted the sky in hues of orange and pink. A soft picnic blanket was spread out beneath a tall oak tree, adorned with a basket and a few lanterns that cast a warm, golden glow.

Fluttershy’s eyes lit up. “Oh, Starlight, this is lovely.”

“I’m glad you think so.” Relief sluiced through Starlight. “I wanted tonight to be special.”

They settled on the blanket, the soft fabric cushioned by the cool grass beneath them. The lanterns cast a warm, flickering glow over their little picnic, and for a moment, Starlight let herself breathe, hoping the tranquil setting would calm her racing nerves and loud mind.

“So, um,” Fluttershy began, her voice barely above a whisper as she glanced at the plate of sandwiches between them. “These look lovely. Did you, um, make them yourself?”

“Oh! Yes, I did!” Starlight replied, her tone a little too enthusiastic. She winced, trying to reel herself in. “I mean, they’re not anything fancy. Just ... sandwiches.” She let out an awkward laugh that sounded forced even to her.

Fluttershy picked one up and took a delicate bite. Sweet Celestia, even the way she nibbled food was cute. “They’re very nice.”

“I’m glad you like them. I, uh, wasn’t sure what your favourite was, so I tried to keep it simple.”

Fluttershy nodded, her gaze dropping to the rest of the picnic blanket’s contents. “That’s very thoughtful of you.”

The silence that followed felt heavy. Starlight scrambled for something to say to keep the conversation alive.

“So, uh … how are the rabbits? The new group you mentioned?”

“Oh, they’re settling in nicely.” Fluttershy brightened. “It’s a bit tricky sometimes because they’re, um, not used to living near other animals yet. But I think with a little patience, they’ll feel at home.”

“That’s great!” Starlight nodded a little too enthusiastically. Smooth, Starlight. Riveting commentary. She took a sip of lavender lemonade, hoping the cool drink would hide her growing anxiety.

Fluttershy hesitated, gaze flicking up to meet Starlight’s for a brief moment before darting away again. “It’s just, um, so nice to have someone to talk to about these things. Sometimes I worry I go on too much about my animals.”

“What? No, not at all!” Definitely too loud that time. Starlight cursed herself when she saw Fluttershy flinch. She softened her tone, leaning forward slightly. “I mean it. The way you talk about them, it’s so clear how much you care. That’s really inspiring.”

Fluttershy toyed with the edge of the blanket. “Oh, um, thank you. That’s very nice of you to say. Though I’m sure you’re just being polite.”

Starlight’s stomach sank. Great. She thinks I’m just being polite. Am I coming off as insincere? Or, worse, boring?

She fumbled for another topic. “I … I guess it’s a bit like, uh, my magic projects. You know, figuring out spells and stuff. It’s not exactly the same, but I get what it’s like to be passionate about something. I hope that’s not ... weird to say.”

“No, not at all!” Fluttershy said quickly. “I think that’s wonderful. You’re so talented with magic.”

“Oh. Well, thanks. I, uh, try, I guess.”

They both fell silent again, each nibbling on their food and stealing occasional glances at the other. Starlight’s thoughts swirled. She must be so disappointed. This is going terribly. I’m babbling about sandwiches and rabbits while she’s probably wishing she were anywhere else.

She risked a glance at Fluttershy, who was carefully pouring more lemonade into her cup. The faint blush still lingered on her cheeks. Her eyes flicked toward Starlight before darting away again.

Or maybe ... she’s nervous too? Starlight’s heart gave a hopeful tremble. She quickly crushed it. Don’t get ahead of yourself. She’s probably just being polite.

Fluttershy broke the silence. “I … I hope I’m not being boring. I know I can be quiet sometimes, and I don’t want you to think I don’t want to be here.”

Starlight’s eyes widened. “What? No! You’re not boring at all. If anything, I was worried I’m the boring one. I’m not exactly great at, uh, this sort of thing.”

“Oh! I... didn’t think that at all. I think you’re very interesting, Starlight.”

For a moment, they stared at each other, their awkwardness hanging between them like a delicate thread. Then, to Starlight’s surprise, Fluttershy smiled; a genuine smile that made Starlight’s chest warm like she has swallowed a hot coal.

“Maybe we’re both just not very good at this.”

“Yeah, maybe. But, um, I’m still glad we’re here.”

“Me too.”

The stars were beginning to peek through the twilit sky, their soft light flickering like tiny flames in the vast expanse. It was very pretty, which had been Starlight’s intention when she chose this for a date. She had not thought that dinner in a fancy, loud restaurant would be to Fluttershy’s taste, but since her dating life was a woeful one completely lacking in experience outside what was written in romance novels, Starlight had been a a loss to think of anything else before Pinkie Pie stepped in and recommended a picnic.

Starlight paused. Trixie, Rarity, Pinkie Pie, Twilight, Spike … it seemed like most of their friends had helped this date happen in some way. Even Applejack had made fritters when she heard about the plan and delivered them to the Castle of Friendship right when Starlight was packing the picnic basket. And Rainbow Dash had cleared away the cloud cover that would have obstructed their view of the moon and stars.

Fluttershy turned to Starlight abruptly. Her smile was barely more than a curve of her lips, but it was enough to make Starlight's heart skip a beat. "You’re so thoughtful, Starlight. I … I feel really lucky to be here with you."

For a moment, Starlight forgot how to breathe. Lucky? "I..." She hesitated, heart pounding so loudly she was certain Fluttershy could hear it. She needed to say something that wasn’t just another nervous ramble or awkward stutter. She took a breath, letting the cool air fill her lungs as she turned her gaze back to Fluttershy. "I feel lucky too. Being with you, it’s like … everything feels brighter. You make me want to be the best version of myself."

Fluttershy blinked, her lips parting slightly in surprise. Starlight felt a sudden surge of doubt. Had she said too much? Come on too strong? She sighed with relief when Fluttershy smiled. It was the kind of smile that made Starlight feel as though she could spill all her secrets and still be safe in her presence. To be able to feel vulnerable and safe at the same time was … intoxicating.

"You … you really mean that?" Fluttershy asked.

"Of course I do," Starlight replied. "I’ve never felt surer of anything."

For a long moment, they just looked at each other, the words hanging between them like a fragile thread, neither willing to break the spell that had settled over them. Starlight could feel the electricity in the air, the quiet tension building slowly. She thought she saw something in Fluttershy’s eyes - a glimmer of curiosity, perhaps? - but she couldn’t be sure.

Ask her. Ask her for a kiss. You’re both here, together, and she feels the same way. At least, I think she does. She could do it. It was simple. It would be a natural step. But her nerves flared again, the familiar rush of self-doubt clouding her thoughts. What if I’m misreading this? What if I’m pushing too hard, or making her uncomfortable? What if I’m screwing this all up and I’m just too dumb and inexperienced to know it!?

Starlight bit her lip, trying to quiet the storm of thoughts. She could ask. She could do this. It was just a kiss. Nothing but a little request. No big deal.

"Starlight?" Fluttershy’s voice broke through her spiralling thoughts. “Are you okay?”

"Yeah?" Starlight replied, her voice betraying the flicker of nerves she hadn’t quite managed to hide. “I mean yeah! Yeah, I’m okay. Just … thinking.”

“Oh.” Fluttershy looked up at the sky. “I’m really glad you asked me to come out here tonight.”

Starlight’s heart jittered. Just one more step, just one more word, and I could be where I’ve wanted to be all along. I bet she tastes like flowers. But instead, she took a deep breath, centring herself. There was no rush. Not yet.

"I’m glad too, Fluttershy."

And for a moment, there was only the quiet of the night and the steady rhythm of their breathing. The two mares sat together silently, watching the glitter of stars high above.

Starlight turned her head to ask Fluttershy another question. Before she could speak, Fluttershy leaned forward and closed the distance between them. In a heartbeat, Fluttershy’s lips were on hers. Starlight froze. Her mind raced, a jumbled whirlwind of shock and disbelief.

But the warmth of Fluttershy’s touch and the sweetness of the kiss soon washed over her. After a moment of stunned hesitation, Starlight allowed herself to lean into it. The kiss was brief, tender and full of unspoken words.

When they pulled back, both of them were blushing furiously, and the quiet between them felt almost too loud. Fluttershy’s eyes were wide, her cheeks flushed as she fidgeted nervously with her hooves.

“I’m … I’m so sorry, Starlight! I should’ve asked first. I didn’t mean to make you uncomfortable.”

Starlight shook her head quickly. “No, no! I-” She faltered, trying to find the words. “I wasn’t expecting it, but I’m not upset, I just …” She chuckled softly, feeling a little giddy despite the awkwardness. “I guess I just didn’t expect you to make the first move.”

Fluttershy’s eyes dropped to her own hooves, twisting nervously in front of her. “I’ve wanted to kiss you for the longest time,” she confessed in a small voice. “From the moment you arrived at my door tonight. You just looked so beautiful, and I … I couldn’t stop thinking about it.”

Starlight’s heart just about stopped entirely. “Seriously?”

“Uh-huh.”

“I … I didn’t think you felt that way. I’ve kind of been afraid to hope for more than you just agreeing to be here at all, but …” She smiled shyly, looking into Fluttershy’s eyes. “Now I’m glad I didn’t let those doubts stop me.”

Fluttershy gave a relieved smile and reached out to touch Starlight’s hoof. “I’m glad too.”

The air between them seemed to lighten just a bit.

"I guess that was our first kiss, huh?" Starlight huffed with laughter.

Fluttershy nodded. "Yeah. And, um…” She slid her gaze sideway to Starlight. “I’d like to have more."

Starlight’s heart skipped at her words. "Me too, Fluttershy. Me too."

Without another word, they leaned in again, this time with less hesitation. The second kiss was more certain; the soft press of their lips a comforting reminder of the connection they had only just started to explore.

When they finally pulled apart, both of them lingered in the quiet, their foreheads resting gently against each other. The world around them seemed to slow, as if giving them a moment to just exist in the simplicity of being together. The night air felt cooler now, the stars above sparkling like distant promises, but they were warm against each other, a perfect fit in their shared space.

Starlight let out a quiet sigh, her heart full and her mind, for once, not jangling with anxious thoughts. "I don’t think I’ve ever felt this at ease."

Fluttershy gave a tiny laugh. "Me either. It's like everything just … clicked. It feels right."

Starlight nodded. Her eyes drifted closed for a moment. She didn’t need to say anything more. There were no grand speeches; no need for words to fill the air. They were both content in the quiet joy of each other's presence.

And so they sat there in the stillness, wrapped up in the warmth of their new bond, the stars above them bearing gentle witness to the beginning of something beautiful. No more doubt, no more second-guessing. Just two hearts, beating together, ready for whatever might come next.