Merely Ornamental

by Love_Bite

Rating: everyone
Tags: Sugar Belle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Comedy, Starlight Glimmer, Trixie, Queen Chrysalis, Adventure
Length: 3675

Trouble is ahoof in Starlight’s old village as an old enemy conspires their revenge on this Hearth’s Warming.

Written for Catpaw616 for Jinglemas 2024.

A chance encounter leads Queen Chrysalis to a remote village out in the Badlands. When she learns her hated enemy, Starlight Glimmer, will be visiting soon, Chrysalis hatches a devious plan to exact her revenge and ruin this Hearth’s Warming for everypony.

Published 2024-12-26 07:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-12-26 07:10:00 UTC

Maybe Sentimental

Rage burned in Queen Chrysalis’s chest like an unquenchable fire. Every step she took across the barren expanse of the Badlands felt heavier than the last, not because of the cracked earth or biting winds, but because of the weight of her failure. Her throne, her hive, her power—all stolen from her. Each memory of her once-mighty kingdom clawed at her mind, a relentless reminder of how far she had fallen. Her subjects, her children, had betrayed her for the lies of love and unity. And for what? To become pastel-colored mockeries of themselves.

Her hooves scraped against the frozen ground as the first snowflakes began to fall, but she barely noticed the chill. Hunger gnawed at her, but it was nothing compared to the ache of her wounded pride. She had ruled, she had commanded fear and respect, and now she was nothing. A fugitive. A queen without a crown.

“This isn’t over,” Chrysalis hissed, her voice slicing through the icy air. Her words echoed faintly, swallowed by the vast emptiness around her. “I will take back what is mine.”

The wind carried no answer, but it did carry something else—a faint, tantalizing sensation that stopped her in her tracks. She lifted her head, her sharp senses honing in on the source. It was subtle, like a whisper on the breeze, but unmistakable: love. Real, unguarded, radiant love. Her mouth curled into a grin, and for the first time in days, her steps quickened.

The trail led her to the crest of a ridge, where she crouched low, her piercing teal eyes scanning the valley below. A small village sat nestled among snow-covered hills, its thatched roofs dusted with white and its chimneys puffing thin streams of smoke into the cold evening air. Ponies moved between the buildings, their laughter and chatter rising faintly to her ears. Even from this distance, Chrysalis could feel the warmth radiating from them, the bonds of friendship and affection that pulsed through the little settlement like a heartbeat.

Her lip curled, equal parts hunger and disdain. “Pathetic,” she muttered. Yet the feast of love was undeniable. It would be so easy to descend upon them, to take what she needed. But then, as she lingered, she caught a snippet of conversation drifting up from below.

“…And Starlight Glimmer is arriving tomorrow to help with the decorations! Isn’t that exciting?”

The name hit her like a kick to the plot. Starlight Glimmer. That insolent unicorn who had stolen everything from her. Chrysalis’s eyes narrowed, and her chest heaved as anger roared back to life, drowning out the cold and the hunger. How dare she? How dare Starlight come here, to this inconsequential village, to bask in admiration and spread her lies of friendship?

A low, dangerous laugh escaped Chrysalis’s throat. Perhaps this was no coincidence. Perhaps fate had delivered this opportunity to her on a silver platter. Slowly, a plan began to take shape in her mind, one that would twist Starlight’s beloved ideals into a weapon of destruction. She would take this village, warp its love into fear, and tarnish the name of Starlight Glimmer forever.

With a shimmer of green fire, Chrysalis transformed into her unicorn nemesis. She examined her reflection in the icy surface of a nearby rock, adjusting her expression into that familiar mask of humility and charm. Perfect. The ponies wouldn’t suspect a thing.

As she approached the edge of the village, she spotted a lone mare—a purple-coated unicorn with a streaked mane, busy hanging garlands over a modest doorway. Chrysalis recognized her instantly—Sugar Belle. One of Starlight’s former followers. Perfect.

“Sugar Belle,” Chrysalis called, her tone warm and inviting. The mare’s head shot up, and her face lit with recognition.

“Starlight! You’re here early!”

Chrysalis offered a practiced smile, her eyes gleaming with malicious intent. “I couldn’t wait to see all of you again,” she said smoothly. “I thought I’d come lend a hoof to make sure everything is perfect for Hearth’s Warming.”

Sugar Belle beamed, her warmth palpable. “That’s wonderful! Everypony will be so glad to see you. Double Diamond and the others are at the square setting up the tree. Shall I take you there?”

“Please,” Chrysalis replied, her voice syrupy sweet. “There’s nothing I’d like more.”

As she followed Sugar Belle into the heart of the village, Chrysalis’s smile widened. At the far end of the town a large tree rested in calm anticipation of the coming festivities. The gears within Chrysalis’s mind whizzed to life as her plan took shape, and she knew then that by the time Starlight Glimmer arrived, there would be nothing left to save.

—————-

Starlight pulled her scarf tighter as she trotted through the snow-dusted streets of Ponyville. Hearth’s Warming decorations adorned every house and shopfront, their lights twinkling like stars against the encroaching dusk. The crisp air carried the scent of pine and freshly baked gingerbread, mingling with the sound of carols sung by a group of foals near the fountain.

She paused for a moment, letting the scene soak in. Hearth’s Warming always carried a special kind of magic, one that made her chest feel both warm and tight at the same time. The laughter and cheer were infectious, but there was an unease she couldn’t shake, as though the holiday’s brightness only made the shadows seem darker.

“Happy Hearth’s Warming, Starlight!” Roseluck called from her stall, where she was weaving holly into wreaths.

“You too, Roseluck,” Starlight replied with a smile, though it didn’t quite reach her eyes. She continued on, nodding to other ponies who greeted her as she passed. Despite the warmth of their words, she couldn’t stop her thoughts from wandering. Twilight had tasked her with helping her old village prepare for Hearth’s Warming, but Starlight couldn’t shake the feeling that there was more to it than just spreading holiday cheer.

By the time she reached Trixie’s wagon, the unease had settled into a dull thrum at the back of her mind. Starlight rapped on the door with her hoof.

“Behold, the Great and Powerful Trixie is… busy!” came the muffled reply from inside.

Starlight raised an eyebrow. “Busy doing what? Avoiding work?”

The door creaked open to reveal Trixie in her starry magician’s hat and cape, a smug grin plastered on her face. Behind her, the wagon’s interior was a chaotic mess of props, scrolls, and an overturned tin of cookies.

“Trixie is perfecting her Hearth’s Warming Eve spectacular,” she announced, gesturing dramatically. “It’s going to be the talk of Ponyville… once I clean up a few minor… complications.”

Starlight sighed, stepping inside and levitating the tin upright. “Well, while you’re cleaning up, how about tagging along with me? I’ve got a mission, and it’ll go a lot smoother with a friend.”

Trixie’s grin faltered. “A mission? That sounds suspiciously like work.”

“It’s Hearth’s Warming preparations,” Starlight said, rolling her eyes. “Not exactly life-threatening. Unless you’re afraid of tinsel.”

Trixie huffed, but there was a twinkle in her eye. “Fine, but only because Trixie’s greatness should not be confined to a single wagon. Lead on, dear friend, and prepare to be amazed by my holiday expertise!”

Starlight chuckled, the unease lifting slightly as they stepped out into the snowy streets together. Whatever lay ahead, at least she wouldn’t face it alone.

—————

The Sun was starting its daily descent by the time Starlight and Trixie found themselves trudging through the narrow path that led to the village. Their breath fogged the chill air as they walked. Snow blanketed the landscape around them, muffling their hoofsteps and lending a serene stillness to the air. But as the village came into view, that stillness turned unsettling.

“Okay, is it just me,” Trixie began, flicking a strand of her mane out of her eyes, “or is this place way too quiet?”

Starlight glanced around, her brow furrowing. The houses lining the main street were adorned with garlands and strings of lights that twinkled cheerily, but the streets themselves were empty. Not a single pony was in sight.

“You’re right,” Starlight said slowly. “It’s Hearth’s Warming. The streets should be bustling with ponies, not… this.” She gestured to the eerily deserted road ahead.

“Maybe they’re all inside sipping cocoa or something,” Trixie offered, though her tone betrayed her unease.

“Let’s keep going,” Starlight said, shaking off the knot of anxiety building in her chest.

The two turned a corner, and Trixie let out a low whistle. “Well, that’s new.”

Standing where Starlight’s old house used to be was a massive tree adorned in Hearth’s Warming regalia. Its branches sagged under the weight of a thousand glittering ornaments and colorful lights. Around the tree, ponies were gathered, singing carols in perfect harmony as they carefully placed decorations on its lower branches.

Looks like we found everypony,” Trixie quipped, though her voice lacked its usual bravado.

Starlight’s eyes narrowed as she took in the scene. Something was wrong. The villagers—many of whom she recognized from her time here—were smiling as they sang, but their expressions were unnervingly vacant. Their eyes, usually full of life, were glazed over as if they were in a trance.

“Stay close,” Starlight murmured. She approached the crowd cautiously, her unease growing with every step.

“Sugar Belle?” she called out, spotting the familiar unicorn among the carolers.

Sugar Belle didn’t respond. She continued hanging ornaments with a serene smile, her movements mechanical.

“Sugar Belle!” Starlight tried again, louder this time. When that failed, her horn flared, and in a flash of light, she teleported the mare several feet away from the tree.

Sugar Belle blinked rapidly, shaking her head as if waking from a dream. “Starlight?” she said, her voice uncertain.

Starlight exhaled in relief. “Yeah, it’s me. Are you okay? What’s going on here?”

Sugar Belle’s expression shifted from confusion to a warm smile. “Oh, everything’s fine! We’ve just been decorating the tree, just like you told us to.”

Starlight froze. “Like I told you?” she repeated. “Sugar Belle, I just got here. I never said anything about decorating the tree.”

Sugar Belle looked surprised for a moment, then laughed softly. “Oh, Starlight, of course you did. It was your idea to bring us together, to help spread the Hearth’s Warming spirit.”

Starlight exchanged a glance with Trixie, who raised an eyebrow.

“Sugar Belle,” Starlight said carefully, “something isn’t right here. We need to get everypony away from the tree.”

The warmth drained from Sugar Belle’s expression, replaced by something cold and unyielding. “No one is to stop the decorating,” she said flatly. “Not even you.”

Before Starlight could respond, other villagers began turning toward her and Trixie, their glazed eyes locking onto them with unsettling focus.

“Uh, Starlight?” Trixie said, backing up a step. “I think it’s time for one of your brilliant plans.”

“Run!” Starlight shouted. The two turned and bolted as the villagers surged after them, their hooves pounding against the snow-covered ground. Lights flickered ominously as the chase wound through the village, and the carols, once harmonious, warped into a haunting echo that seemed to follow them at every turn.

Starlight and Trixie darted down the narrow alley, their breaths coming in quick puffs of steam as the hypnotized villagers thundered after them. The chilling chorus of warped carols echoed through the streets, growing louder with every passing second.

“This way!” Starlight called, skidding around a corner.

“Wait, Trixie has an idea!” Trixie halted abruptly, fumbling in her cape. She pulled out a small sphere and tossed it to the ground. With a loud pop, a plume of thick, glittering smoke filled the alley.

“Go!” Trixie yelled, grabbing Starlight’s hoof and dragging her through the haze.

They emerged on the other side and bolted, the shouts of the villagers momentarily confused behind them. Starlight glanced over her shoulder, her heart pounding. The smokescreen wouldn’t hold them off for long.

“Nice trick,” she panted.

“Of course it was,” Trixie replied, though her voice wavered with nervous energy. “Trixie’s brilliance knows no bounds. Now, keep running!”

The two raced through the village, weaving between buildings and darting into side streets. They scaled a stack of barrels to climb onto a rooftop, but the villagers, with unnatural coordination, began to climb after them.

“They’re relentless!” Trixie shouted, leaping onto an adjacent roof. “Are you sure these are the same ponies who couldn’t organize a bake sale?”

“I’m open to theories!” Starlight replied, firing a burst of magic to knock over a ladder a group of villagers was using to reach them.

The chase continued, Starlight and Trixie narrowly avoiding capture at every turn. Finally, they found that they’d circled back around to the tree and were forced back against its trunk as the villagers surrounded them. The hypnotized villagers closed in, their glazed eyes reflecting the soft glow of the enchanted tree in the distance.

“Well, well, well,” came a familiar, mocking voice.

Starlight’s head whipped around, her eyes narrowing as an all-too-familiar figure emerged from the shadows. It was her—and yet not her. Starlight stared at her doppelgänger a long moment before the realization hit her. The imposter’s expression twisted into a sinister grin, and with a flash of green flame, Starlight’s doppelgänger transformed into the towering, jagged form of Queen Chrysalis.

“I knew I hadn’t seen the last of you,” Starlight growled. “Queen Chrysalis!”

“Oh, how delightful. You remembered me,” Chrysalis purred, her voice dripping with malice. She glanced at Trixie. “And you brought a sidekick. How quaint.”

“Trixie is no sidekick!” Trixie snapped. “She is the Great and Powerful Trixie, thank you very much!”

Chrysalis rolled her eyes. “Charming. Truly.” Her gaze shifted back to Starlight. “I must thank you, Starlight Glimmer. Your little village and its festive spirit have provided me with quite the opportunity.”

“What are you talking about?” Starlight demanded.

Chrysalis’s smile widened. “The tree, of course. A little enchantment here, a touch of manipulation there, and voila!” She gestured dramatically. “Every pony who decorates it falls into a blissful trance, eternally compelled to spread Hearth’s Warming cheer. And while they do, I feast on the love they radiate. A perfect plan, wouldn’t you agree?”

“You’re sick,” Starlight spat.

“Oh, don’t be so dramatic,” Chrysalis said, waving a hoof dismissively. Her horn glowed, and a tendril of magic coiled around Trixie, forcing her to turn around and face the tree.

“Let me go!” Trixie shouted, struggling against the magic.

“Let’s see how your friend handles the enchantment, shall we?” Chrysalis sneered. With a flick of her horn, she forced Trixie’s quivering hoof to place an ornament on the tree.

Trixie’s resistance faltered immediately. Her eyes glazed over, and a serene smile spread across her face. She began humming a carol as she reached for another ornament.

“Trixie!” Starlight shouted, panic rising in her chest.

Chrysalis laughed, the sound echoing in the cold night. “Don’t worry, Starlight. You’ll join her soon enough. Imagine it: the great Starlight Glimmer, reduced to a mindless decorator. A fitting end, wouldn’t you say?”

Desperation clawed at Starlight as she searched for a way to fight back. Her eyes darted to the tree, its branches laden with ornaments that shimmered with an eerie glow. An idea struck her. Summoning all her strength, she bucked the tree with her hind legs. One of the ornaments fell and shattered on the ground, it was the one that Trixie had just placed.

Trixie blinked, the haze lifting from her eyes. She stumbled back, clutching her head. “What just happened?”

“No time to explain,” Starlight said quickly. “Help me take down the ornaments!”

Realizing what Starlight was attempting, Chrysalis roared in fury. “Stop them!” she commanded, sending the still-hypnotized villagers after them.

The next few moments were a chaotic blur. Starlight and Trixie worked frantically, pulling down ornaments as the villagers closed in. Freed ponies joined them, shaking off their trances and helping to remove the decorations.

Chrysalis swooped down repeatedly, trying to block their efforts, but Starlight’s magic and Trixie’s quick thinking kept her at bay. At one point, Trixie used her smoke bombs to blind a group of charging villagers, only to get tangled in a string of tinsel herself.

“Trixie, focus!” Starlight shouted, yanking her friend free.

“I’m trying, but this tinsel is relentless!” Trixie huffed, flinging the offending strand to the ground.

Meanwhile, one of the freed villagers, Double Diamond, tackled a hypnotized pony who had been guarding a particularly large cluster of ornaments. “I’ve got this one! Go for the star topper!” he yelled.

“We’re not there yet!” Starlight replied, blasting a wreath off the tree while dodging a flying garland thrown by another villager.

“These decorations are surprisingly aerodynamic!” Trixie quipped as she ducked a stray bauble.

More and more villagers snapped out of their trances as ornaments shattered on the ground. Some joined the effort to dismantle the tree, while others held off Chrysalis, who was becoming more frantic with each passing moment.

Finally, only the tree topper remained. Chrysalis floated protectively beneath it, her fangs bared.

“You will not ruin this for me!” she screeched.

“Everypony, together!” Starlight shouted.

The freed villagers rallied, their combined strength shaking the tree. The topper wobbled, then toppled to the ground, shattering into countless pieces. The glow around the tree faded instantly, and the remaining villagers blinked as the enchantment broke.

Chrysalis let out a furious scream, her form flickering with unstable magic. She glared at Starlight, her eyes burning with hatred. “This isn’t over, Glimmer!” she snarled before vanishing in a flash of green fire.

As the villagers began to recover, Starlight collapsed to the ground, exhausted. Trixie sat beside her, brushing shards of an ornament from her cape. “Well,” Trixie said, her voice shaky but defiant, “next time, we’re staying home.”

Starlight managed a weak laugh, the warmth of victory settling over her despite the chaos. Hearth’s Warming was safe—for now.

Starlight stood amidst the wreckage, her chest heaving as she surveyed the bare tree. The once-enchanted branches now stood stark and empty, stripped of every shimmering ornament. Around her, villagers began to stir, shaking off the remnants of the spell. Some stared blankly at the broken shards scattered across the snow, while others rubbed their eyes as if waking from a dream.

A low murmur spread through the crowd. Then came the sighs, and soon after, the tears. Sugar Belle knelt by a pile of shattered ornaments, her hooves trembling. “We… we worked so hard on these,” she whispered, her voice thick with emotion. “Now we’ll never have the tree ready in time for Hearth’s Warming.”

Her words seemed to ignite a wave of despair. Double Diamond sat down heavily, his usually bright expression dimmed. “She’s right. Hearth’s Warming isn’t Hearth’s Warming without the decorations.”

Starlight’s ears drooped as she watched her old friends begin to lose hope. The adrenaline from the battle had faded, leaving her with a hollow ache. Had they truly saved the village, or had Chrysalis still managed to ruin the holiday?

“Ahem!” Trixie’s voice rang out, loud and theatrical as ever. She stepped forward, brushing off her cape and standing tall. “If I may have your attention, dear villagers,” she began, her tone grandiose.

All eyes turned to her. Even Starlight blinked, caught off guard by her friend’s sudden confidence.

“I understand your disappointment,” Trixie said, gesturing dramatically to the bare tree. “The decorations were lovely, I’m sure. But—and this is a very important ‘but’—what happened here tonight wasn’t about ornaments or tinsel. It wasn’t about lights or garlands.” She paused, her voice softening. “It was about all of you.”

The villagers exchanged puzzled glances.

“Think about it,” Trixie continued. “When Chrysalis tried to take over, you didn’t give up. You fought back. Together. You helped each other, you trusted each other, and you stood united against her.” Her eyes swept over the crowd, and despite herself, she blushed slightly. “That… that is the true spirit of Hearth’s Warming. Not the decorations, but the love and unity you’ve shown tonight.”

A silence followed her words, heavy and thoughtful. The villagers looked at one another, their expressions slowly shifting. Sugar Belle wiped her eyes and stood, a small smile tugging at her lips. “She’s right,” she said softly. “We… we didn’t let her win. We came together, just like we always do.”

Double Diamond nodded, his usual energy returning. “Yeah! Who needs ornaments when we’ve got each other?”

The murmur of agreement grew louder until it turned into cheers. Ponies hugged one another, their earlier despair melting away. Trixie stepped back, looking equal parts proud and embarrassed as the crowd’s spirits lifted.

Starlight approached her with a smile, tears glistening in her eyes. “That was beautiful,” she said, pulling Trixie into a hug.

“Of course it was,” Trixie replied, though her voice wavered slightly. “The Great and Powerful Trixie always knows the right thing to say.”

“Sure you do,” Starlight teased, squeezing her a little tighter.

—————

The next morning, the village buzzed with life. Ponies sang carols as they worked together to clean up the remnants of the enchanted tree and transform the square into a makeshift celebration. Homemade decorations replaced the shattered ornaments, and laughter filled the air as foals played in the snow.

Starlight stood near the tree, watching as Double Diamond hung a garland made of pinecones and string. “Not bad for a last-minute fix,” he said with a grin.

“It’s perfect,” Starlight replied. She turned as Trixie approached, carrying a tray of steaming cocoa.

“For the saviors of Hearth’s Warming,” Trixie declared, levitating two mugs toward Starlight and Double Diamond.

Starlight laughed, taking a mug. “Thanks, Trixie. For everything.”

“Don’t mention it,” Trixie said, her voice softening. “Seriously, don’t. I’ll cry.”

The three shared a laugh as the sounds of celebration swirled around them. Despite the chaos of the previous night, Hearth’s Warming had been saved, not by magic or decorations, but by the bonds that held the village together. And that, Starlight thought, was a gift no spell could ever replace