Proving Her Wings

by ba1leyy

Rating: everyone
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, My Little Pony: A New Generation, Sunny Starscout, Adventure, Crossover, Twilight Sparkle
Length: 1249

Sunny Starscout’s unexpected alicornhood brings her to Princess Twilight Sparkle, who imposes strict rules and tests to determine if she’s truly worthy and deserving of her new role.

After Sunny Starscout unexpectedly ascends to alicornhood, she seeks guidance from Princess Twilight Sparkle, the ruler of Equestria. But Twilight, burdened by the weight of her own experiences, is less than welcoming. Under strict rules and grueling lessons, Sunny must prove that she’s worthy of the wings she never asked for, facing the real world, along with the consequences —while Twilight wrestles with what it means to pass the torch.

Published 2024-12-30 07:40:00 UTC
Last updated 2024-12-30 07:40:00 UTC

Under Twilight’s Watch.

Author's Note

This story is written from Twilight’s POV. I wrote this purely for a bit of fun. I hope you all enjoy.

Under Twilight’s Watch.

The throne room was quiet, save for the ticking of the grand clock and the faint rustle of scrolls. I sat on my throne, my wings tucked tightly at my sides, as I reviewed the latest reports. My eyes skimmed over words that blurred together, meaningless in the face of what was consuming my thoughts.

The stained-glass windows caught my attention. Each one was a testament to a chapter of my life: the triumphs, the battles, the sacrifices. The images shimmered in the light, mocking me with their permanence. Equestria had changed since those days, and no amount of magical artistry could restore what was lost.

Spike entered the room, a scroll in his claws and a pensive look on his face. “Twilight,” he began, his voice careful, “this just came in. You’re going to want to see it.”

I doubted it was something I hadn’t seen before, but curiosity got the better of me. I levitated the scroll from him, breaking the seal with precision. As I read, my eyes narrowed.

“A young mare named Sunny Starscout,” I muttered, my voice growing sharper with every word, “united the tribes, restored magic… and ascended to alicornhood?”

Spike nodded, folding his arms. “Yeah. Sounds like she’s done some pretty big things.”

I set the scroll down, my magic sparking faintly with suppressed frustration. “Big things? Spike, do you know what I went through to earn my wings? The trials, the lessons, the sacrifices? Alicornhood isn’t something that just happens—it’s earned. It’s a burden you prepare for, not a reward handed out like a prize.”

Spike rubbed the back of his neck. “I get it, Twilight. It doesn’t seem fair. But she did bring back harmony. That’s gotta count for something, right?”

I rose from my throne, pacing the length of the room. “Harmony crumbled the moment we were gone. Everything we built fell apart, and now, because she managed to patch things together, she gets to be an alicorn?”

Spike followed me with his gaze, his expression conflicted. “Look, I’m not saying it’s fair. But maybe it’s a good thing. Equestria needs leaders, and if she’s willing to step up—”

“She’s not ready,” I snapped, cutting him off. “She doesn’t understand what it means to carry this responsibility. If she thinks she can just walk into this role without knowing what it costs, she’s mistaken.”

Spike sighed, crossing his arms. “You’re right. She probably doesn’t know what she’s in for. But if anypony can help her figure it out, it’s you.”

I stopped pacing, my wings twitching in agitation. His words were true, but they didn’t make this any easier.

Sunny Starscout arrived two days later. The castle doors opened, revealing a young mare with wide, hopeful eyes. Her wings were awkwardly folded at her sides, her small horn glimmering faintly with magic she didn’t yet understand.

“Princess Twilight,” she said, her voice trembling with awe and nerves. “It’s an honor to meet you.”

I descended the steps slowly, my gaze sharp and unyielding. “You’ve come a long way.”

Sunny nodded eagerly, smiling stupidly. She was young, I couldn’t judge, I was in her hooves once, but something about this whole situation didn’t feel right. “I wanted to meet you. I’ve heard so many stories about you and your friends. You’re my hero, Princess Twilight. I want to learn from you, to be the best I can be for Equestria.”

Her sincerity was almost disarming, but I didn’t let it soften my resolve. “And what do you think it means to be an alicorn?” I asked, my tone cold.

Sunny hesitated, her wings twitching nervously. “I think it means helping others, protecting harmony, and…” she paused, not quite knowing the answer. “…and leading with kindness.”

I narrowed my eyes. “Helping others? Leading with kindness?” I scoffed at the pathetic answer. “Those are things anypony can do. Being an alicorn is more than that. It’s a burden you carry every day, knowing the weight of an entire kingdom rests on your shoulders. Do you understand what you’ve taken on?”

Sunny’s ears flattened, but she met my gaze. “I-I didn’t ask for this,” she said quietly. “I just wanted to help. I didn’t know this would happen.”

“And yet, here you are,” I said sharply. “Do you think your wings make you my equal? Do you think you’re ready to bear the responsibilities that come with this role?”

Sunny took a shaky step back, but her voice was steady. “No, I don’t. That’s why I came here. I want to learn. I want to do this right.”

Her determination was admirable, but it wasn’t enough. “If you want to learn,” I said sternly, “you’ll follow my rules. And they will be strict. Do you understand?”

Sunny nodded quickly. “Yes, Princess Twilight. I’ll do whatever it takes.”

I stepped closer, towering over her. “Good. Because this won’t be easy. You’ll study under me here in the castle. You’ll follow a rigid schedule, and every action you take will be under scrutiny. One mistake could have consequences far beyond what you can imagine. If you’re serious about this, there’s no turning back. Do you still want to stay?”

Sunny hesitated for a moment, then stood taller. “Yes. I’m ready to do whatever it takes.”

Spike, who had been silently watching from the corner, finally spoke. “You’re being hard on her, Twilight. But… I get it. She has to earn this.”

“She does,” I said, my tone unyielding. “Alicornhood isn’t a gift. It’s a responsibility. If she wants my help, she’ll prove she’s worthy of it.”

Weeks turned into months, and Sunny struggled under the weight of her lessons. Magic was her greatest challenge; her spells often fizzled out or misfired, leaving her frustrated and exhausted.

“Focus,” I instructed sharply one afternoon as her horn sputtered again. “Your magic is a tool, not a toy. Control it, or it will control you.”

“I’m trying!” Sunny shot back, her voice strained.

“Trying isn’t enough,” I replied coldly. “Do it again.”

Her determination never wavered, even as the weeks wore on. Late one evening, I found her in the training hall, practicing the same spell over and over. Sparks flew from her horn, lighting the room in bursts of gold and violet.

She didn’t see me watching as she closed her eyes, took a deep breath, and cast the spell one more time. This time, the magic flowed smoothly, forming a glowing sphere of light that hovered steadily before her.

Sunny exhaled shakily, her wings drooping in exhaustion. “Not that it matters,” she muttered to herself. “She won’t care.”

She turned to leave, but I stepped into the room, my hoofsteps echoing softly. “You’re wrong,” I said, my voice softer than it had been in weeks.

Sunny froze, her eyes wide. “Princess Twilight?”

I approached the glowing sphere of light, studying it carefully. “You’ve been practicing,” I said. “And it’s paid off. This is… impressive.”

Her mouth opened in surprise. “You think so?”

I nodded, allowing a small smile to cross my face. “You’ve come a long way, Sunny. I’m proud of you.”

Her expression lit up with joy, and for the first time, I saw a glimmer of the leader she ~~might~~ could become. Maybe, just maybe, she was ready to carry the weight of her wings.