The Cozy Who Isn't Me

by CozyGlow5

Rating: everyone
Tags: Cozy Glow, Equestria Girls, Tragedy, Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle, Sad
Length: 3470

Cozy Glow meets her EG counterpart...and her EG counterpart's parents.

Everypony told Cozy Glow that her parents died in an accident. But that's not true, because suddenly Cozy is a weird tall creature with hands who stands on her back legs, and her parents are still alive. She can't wait to make up for all the lost time she spent with them...but what if they're not actually her parents at all?

Cover art is by me. It really doesn't have anything to do with the story except that it's a picture of EG Cozy Glow.

Published 2025-01-20 19:30:00 UTC
Last updated 2025-01-22 20:17:35 UTC

A very short prologue sort of thing

“You turned a filly to stone?”

Sunset Shimmer’s eyes widened as she looked at Twilight Sparkle in disbelief.

Twilight sighed and stared down into her hot chocolate. “Technically, I didn’t do it. But yes, Cozy Glow was turned to stone.”

The two Unicorns-turned-girls were hanging out at the coffee shop in Canterlot City, which they didn’t get to do nearly enough, especially now that Twilight Sparkle had been crowned ruler of Equestria. But Twilight had managed to convince the rest of the Mane Six to cover for her for a day, and now she and Sunset were finally getting a much-needed chance to catch up.

“That’s horrible,” Sunset said, shaking her head. “I mean, I don’t hold you accountable, if you thought it was the right decision, but…well, just imagine if you’d turned me to stone after I tried to destroy our school.”

Twilight sighed again. “I guess it was just easier to get through to you. The only person who might even possibly be able to get through to Cozy Glow is Cozy Glow herself.”

Sunset took a long, slow sip of her coffee. “That gives me an idea.”

Author's Note

Very short chapter, I know. It's mostly just setup for the rest of the story. :pinkiehappy:

Cozy in Canterlot City

“Ouch!” I yelp as my body is flung onto what I think is concrete.

In any case, it’s hard and uncomfortable, and I think I’ve just scraped more than one of my limbs. I squinch my eyes shut and try to conjure up a batch of tears, the same way I always used to do when I was a really little filly and fell on the playground. If I managed to cry hard enough, sometimes my parents would buy me ice cream.

“Are you okay?” asks Twilight’s friend, Sunny Sunshine or whatever her name is. She sounds almost like she’s trying to hold back a laugh. Maybe she thinks I’m too old to cry about something like scraping a foreleg.

I stop crying.

“Yeah, I’m—” I’m about to say I’m fine, but then I open my eyes and see my hooves. Only, they’re not hooves anymore. They’re claws, or hands, or something like that, and they don’t belong on my body. I let out a long, loud scream.

“Cozy Glow! You can’t do that! You’ll cause a scene,” Twilight’s friend cries, panic in her voice. I look up at her and see that she’s not a pony anymore, either. What she is, I have no idea, but she’s tall and she’s lost her horn and she’s standing on her back legs. I sincerely hope I don’t look like her, but judging by everything I can see of myself without a mirror, we look the exact same. I start to scream even louder.

Twilight’s friend claps her hand over my mouth. “Cozy Glow, you have to stop screaming. I brought you here because there’s someone I want you to meet. But if you keep screaming, it’ll be no problem at all to turn around and take you right back to Equestria.”

And turn you back to stone. The unspoken ending to her sentence makes my stomach churn. I nod and make a silent vow not to scream again, no matter what it takes. I’ll do anything not to return to my horrible, suffocating statue prison.

“I know. It must have been awful to be a statue,” Twilight’s friend says sympathetically.

I don’t remember saying that out loud. Did I say that out loud?

“Whoops. Sorry,” Sunny Sunshine says as she removes her hand from my face. “Anyway, I need you to be on your best behavior. You think you can handle that?”

“I do,” I reply, nodding slowly.

“Good. Now, I have the address of our destination written down in the Notes app on my phone. I was thinking we could just walk there, but now that I think about it, you’re probably not used to those legs yet.” She frowns and taps her chin. “You know what, I’ll call an Uber.”

Twilight’s friend tells me that the thing that takes us to our destination is called a car, and I don’t like it one bit. It’s tiny and cramped and it smells weird, and on top of that I don’t understand how turning a wheel and pushing some pedals can make something move. I’m glad when the car stops and we can finally get out.

Twilight’s friend gives some money to the creature sitting in the front seat of the car, and then we emerge in front of a small white cottage with a garden of roses in front of it. I can’t help but think of my mom. Roses were her favorites. We used to grow them, too, back when she was still alive.

I reach out to touch one of the flowers, but Twilight’s friend grabs my hand. “Don’t take that, Cozy. It’s not yours.”

“I wasn’t going to take it,” I protest.

Twilight’s friend takes her hand off of mine. “I know you weren’t. I’m sorry, Cozy.”

Golly, she sure changed her mind about that quickly. Nopony has ever believed me right away like that. I swear, it’s like she can see what’s going on in my head.

Twilight’s friend walks up to the door and I follow her, even though I’m still a little unsteady on these new legs of mine. She knocks on the door and a cheery voice from inside the house calls, “Coming!”

My stomach jumps. I know that voice.

I laugh inwardly at myself. Don’t be an idiot, Cozy Glow, I tell myself. There’s no way that—

But then the door opens, and suddenly I’m face-to-face with my mom.

No. There is no way this can be happening. Everypony told me that both of my parents died in an accident. A magic spell gone wrong. I’ve heard the story a hundred times. My mom tried a teleportation spell on herself and my dad, but she wasn’t experienced enough, and it killed them—except it didn’t kill them, because my mom is standing right here in front of me.

She’s not my mom the way I’m used to seeing her, of course. She’s a weird tall creature like me. But her wavy fuchsia hair, sunburst yellow skin, and radiant smile are unmistakable. How? How is this happening? Why did everypony lie to me, and tell me she was dead?

“Mom?” I ask.

“Cozy!” she cries, scooping me up in a hug. She knows my name! It is her! I hug her back and inhale her floral perfume, the one I thought I would never smell again. I used to wear one of her sweaters all the time after she (allegedly) died, because it smelled like her perfume, until I wore it so much that it didn’t smell like her anymore. I hated myself after that. I worried I would forget what she smelled like. “I thought you were at the library to work on a school project?”

I shake my head no, not knowing or caring where she got that idea. “I missed you so much, Mom. Is Dad here?”

Twilight’s friend bites her lip and interrupts. “Mrs. Glow, I’m Sunset Shimmer from Canterlot High School, and I’m so sorry, but this Cozy isn’t—”

“He’s in the kitchen, making dinner,” my mom replies, apparently not hearing Sunset. “We’re having pancakes tonight.”

“Dad makes the best pancakes!” I cry happily. I tried more than once to use his recipe to make pancakes of my own, but they were never as good. After my fifth attempt, I cried and cried because I would never get to have good pancakes again. And now we’re having them for dinner. I’m still not sure exactly what’s going on, but I’m so happy right now, I could cry.

My mom gestures for Sunset Shimmer to come inside, and the two of us step into the house. Sunset has an uneasy look on her face, but I ignore it, instead choosing to follow the scent of pancakes until I find my dad in the kitchen, where I wrap my arms around him and give him a big hug.

“What a greeting, Cozy Glow,” he replied, patting my curls. “Do pancakes sound good for dinner?”

“They sound amazing,” I reply. “Oh! And then maybe after dinner, we could play a game of chess. I’ve gotten so much better in the past few years. I might be able to beat you. I even have my cutie mark in chess now, you know.”

“Cutie mark?”

I giggle. “You know, back from when we lived in Equestria. When we were all ponies. You weren’t around when I got my cutie mark, but that’s okay. We can still throw a late cute-ceañera party. Ooh, do you think Mom would make her famous chocolate cake?”

My dad chuckles and pats my curls again. “You have quite the imagination, Cozy Glow. And yes, of course we can play a game of chess after dinner.”

Suddenly I have a burst of inspiration. “Oh, and I scraped my foreleg. I mean, arm, or whatever. It really hurts. Can we go out for ice cream tomorrow?”

My mom walks into the kitchen. “I don’t see why not. But Cozy, Sunset Shimmer has something important to tell us. I think we need to listen, okay?”

“Okay,” I agree amiably. I’d agree to anything my mom asked of me right now. I’m just so happy to have her back.

Sunset opens her mouth, but before she can get a word out, the front door creaks open and a face even more familiar than my parents’ faces peeks into the house.

My heart skips a beat. Something isn’t right.

Standing in the doorway is…well…me. Or, at least, a girl who looks exactly like me. She’s carrying a stack of books in her arms and has a bewildered look on her face.

“What’s going on?” she asks in my voice.

Sunset smiles. “Cozy Glow, meet Cozy Glow. I was hoping the two of you could talk about—”

“What’s happening?” my mom interrupts. “Why are there two Cozies?”

I’m wondering the same thing.

“You see,” Sunset explains, “the Cozy I brought over is the Cozy of my world. She’s not actually your daughter. This Cozy Glow is the Cozy of your world. They look the exact same and share a lot of the same mannerisms, but they’re different people. I know it’s really confusing, but I can try to explain it to you with some diagrams that my friend Twilight Sparkle made…”

I’m not listening. I can’t. My brain went blank after “She’s not actually your daughter.”

My mom and dad aren’t mine. They parent the Cozy of this world. Not the Cozy of Equestria. A.k.a. me.

My parents really are dead.

And I will not be the Cozy eating those pancakes.

My stomach starts churning again. I feel like I’m losing my mom and dad for a second time. I inhale a deep breath and run out of the house as fast as I can on these weird tall legs. Sunset runs after me, and because she’s more used to the weird tall legs, she catches up to me in no time at all.

“Cozy, I’m so sorry. I should’ve explained things to you beforehand.”

“You’re right,” I reply. “You should’ve. But you didn’t.”

I inhale another deep breath and my chest floods with envy for the Cozy who still has the parents, who still has roses and pancakes and chess and ice cream when she scrapes her limbs. For the Cozy who isn’t me.

I turn to Sunset. “Take me back to Equestria. And turn me back to stone. I don’t care.” I feel tears, real tears, forming in my eyes. “But I am not staying in that house one minute longer.”

Sunset looks down at the sidewalk. “Right. I’ll call another cab.”

And we stand there, in silence, until the car comes.

Author's Note

Originally this story was going to end here, but judging by all of the feedback I got (which includes both the comments from other Fimfiction users and the comments from the family members that I forced to read my story :rainbowlaugh:), it needed another chapter. So I added one. :pinkiehappy:

Sunset's apology

I glance at the filly-turned-freshman in the seat next to mine. Her gaze is fixed on the floor, but I can see tears in her crimson red eyes. I sigh and look out the window of the cab as the scenery whizzes by. Cozy may have just shot down my attempt at reforming her, but yet at the same time, she’s somehow shown me that she’s not completely evil. There are real, honest emotions underneath those bouncy curls and that insincere smile. She doesn’t have a heart of stone, and she doesn’t deserve to have a body of stone, either.

“Cozy Glow, I’m so sorry.”

My words hang in the air like a heavy storm cloud. I swallow hard and fix my own gaze on the floor. Why didn’t I think about the fact that it might have been confusing for Cozy to meet the human world counterparts of her parents? Why didn’t it occur to me to explain things to her first, before she became reunited with the people she missed the most—only to find that they weren’t really the people she missed the most?

“Honestly, Cozy, I’m so sorry. I should’ve thought things through better,” I say, softly placing my hand on her shoulder. She jerks away, but not before I’m overwhelmed by a flood of Cozy’s memories.

I see a young filly celebrating a somber cute-ceañera by herself, to celebrate the cutie mark that she earned playing chess against herself. I see a stack of burnt pancakes with a sulking Cozy behind them, as she cries because she’ll never be able to make pancakes as good as her dad’s. I see a deep purple sweater being thrown across a room because “it doesn’t smell like her perfume anymore,” according to an angry Cozy with tears running down her face.

I can’t help but blink back tears of my own, in spite of myself.

“You must miss them so much, Cozy,” I say.

“I do miss them.” Cozy curls her hand into a fist and dashes away the tears in her eyes. “I won’t lie to you about that.”

“I’m so, so sorry I took you there. Really, I am. I didn’t think through the fact that your parents might be there. Or that it could be so hard on you. I just thought it might be nice for you to have someone you could talk to who thinks the same way you do.”

“You’re talking about my duplicate, right?” Cozy asks dryly.

“How do you know you’re not her duplicate?” I reply, but the look on Cozy’s face tells me that this is not the time for jokes. “Yes. I meant your human counterpart. I thought maybe having someone who gets you could help you work through some of the things you were struggling with.”

“Right. Because a girl who lives a perfect life with her loving, caring parents is the perfect girl to sympathize with me about trying to rule Equestria and being turned to stone,” Cozy replies as she folds her arms across her chest and rolls her eyes up towards the ceiling.

I can’t help but chuckle, despite the tragic situation. “Fair point,” I say, smiling sadly at her so she knows I’m not trying to be disrespectful by laughing. “I guess that I, of all people, should’ve known that just because you and that other Cozy have so much in common doesn’t mean that you’re the same person.”

Cozy sniffs and wipes away another batch of tears. “Why does she still have her parents, and I don’t? It’s not fair.”

I know the obvious answer. It’s that her parents died in a magic-related accident, and there isn’t as much magic in this world. Or, at least, not the same kind of magic. But something tells me that’s not the answer Cozy’s looking for. After all, magic or no, Cozy is right: it isn’t fair. But I can’t explain why fate works the way it does. I can’t explain why some villains get reformed and some get turned to stone, why some friendships fade and some last forever, why some people lose the ones they love…and some people don’t.

“I don’t know, Cozy,” I answer honestly.

The young girl sobs harder, and I can only imagine the memories running through her mind at the moment.

The car comes to a stop in front of CHS, and I suddenly realize that Cozy and I just had that entire conversation in front of our Uber driver. He doesn’t seem to mind, though. He tells me how much I owe him, and I pay him what he’s due before Cozy and I step out of the car and walk onto the school grounds.

The portal is silhouetted against the flaming sunset sky. My heart aches as Cozy walks toward it, probably to return to Equestria and ask Twilight to turn her back to stone. I can’t let that happen.

“Cozy, wait!” I cry, and she stops in her tracks.

“What do you want?” Cozy Glow asks, turning around to meet my eyes.

“I don’t want you to get turned back to stone, Cozy. You’ve shown me today that you don’t deserve that.” I take a deep breath. “I don’t think you’re really evil at heart, Cozy. And even if you were, well, who would I be to judge? I used to be the most awful girl at Canterlot High. I wanted power and popularity, and I would stop at nothing to make sure I achieved it.” I shudder just thinking about how awful the Old Me was. “But Twilight and her friends gave me a second chance, and now I’d like to give you that same thing. If you want it, that is.”

Cozy cocks her head to one side. “I didn’t know you used to be evil.”

“The evil-est.”

“And now you’re friends with Twilight Sparkle?”

I chuckle. “I’m friends with so many people and ponies now. And it’s the best thing that’s ever happened to me.”

Cozy bites her lip, and I see something starting to click in her brain. Like maybe someone is finally getting through to her. Like maybe someone finally gets her—or, at least, some of her.

“You’ve been really nice to me this whole time,” Cozy states as she looks at me with a blank expression on her face, like she’s trying to understand why I would do such a thing.

“I’ve tried,” I reply. I smile at her. “Everypony deserves kindness, Cozy Glow, no matter how many times they’ve tried to conquer Equestria.”

Cozy frowns. She looks like she’s thinking this over.

“If you want it, I’d like to be your friend,” I offer.

She gives me a halfhearted smile. “I’d like to be your friend, too,” she says. Then she pauses. “After all, friendship is power.”

“Cozy,” I say warningly, raising an eyebrow at her.

“Kidding,” she says, giggling behind her hand. Then her expression becomes serious. “So…if I choose to take you up on your offer and be your friend, I don’t have to go back to Equestria and get turned to stone?”

I shake my head. “You can stay at my place, if you want. I have a guest room you can sleep in.”

Cozy’s eyes fill with tears. “Well, thanks,” she says softly, wiping her eyes with her hands.

I want to walk over to her and give her a hug to let her know everything is okay, but I’m not sure if the gesture would seem friendly or threatening. Instead, I point to my legs. “Think you’ve gotten used to these enough that you can walk home with me? I’m going to go broke if I keep calling cabs.”

Cozy takes an experimental step forward. “I think I can handle it,” she says.

And with that, we begin our walk home.

I don’t know how things will work out for Cozy from here. I guess it’s up to her, really. But I do know that the magic of friendship is a powerful thing. After all, making a friend is all it took for me to reform. I don’t know what it’ll take for Cozy Glow, but I have faith that it will work out for her in the end.

Author's Note

Hopefully this new ending to the story is more satisfying than the original. In any case, it's a lot happier :rainbowlaugh:.

As always, constructive criticism is welcome, but please be kind. :twilightsmile: