Night of the inbred apples

by Elegant Absudity

Rating: mature
Tags: Non-consensual, Big Macintosh, Scootaloo, Sweetie Belle, Applejack, Apple Bloom, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish, Porn, Sex
Length: 5250

Apple Bloom finds out about her parentage and what Nightmare Night has to do with it

The older she got, the more that Apple Bloom started to feel like something was wrong about her. Something about her origin. There was a really big gap between the death of her parents and her birth so what gives? Was she adopted? Why didn't they tell her?

In this one particular Nightmare Night, she finds a tape with all the answers and a lot more than she could have possibly wanted....

Kinks Include: possesion, incest, Oral, Anal, Vaginal, Size Difference, impregnation and watersports (in the second chapter)

This work was a commission for a twitter user

Published 2025-02-01 18:30:00 UTC
Last updated 2025-02-01 18:30:00 UTC

One night long ago

Once upon a midnight dreary, a young pony wandered weary over long forgotten photo books. The foal's name was apple bloom and she was looking for any and all information about her family. Recently a thought popped in her head. Who were her parents? Any other time it would have dissipated, but she was an orphan, curiosity about her parents was as normal as it was frequent. However, that was a part of the problem.

She did the math, and unless her entire family forgot a few birthdays, she was born two years after they died. And that meant she was conceived a full year after her mom died.

What in any other situation would have been a passing thought became an outright obsession, for the last few days she had been taking any free time she had and went through every attic or shed trying to look for any information she could about herself. Papers, memories, pictures, anything she could find.

The album was full of them. so many pictures of who were supposed to be her parents, a strawberry blond pony ironically named Pear Butter, and her husband, the yellow redhead Bright Mac. The pictures painted a clear timeline, first it was just Pear Butter and Bright Mac, it was them with a very young Big Macintosh, a few years passed, it was them, Big Mac and the then young Applejack. A few years pass. and it's just Big Mac and Applejack. For a time no one added more pictures, but then, there were some with Applejack, Big Mac and her, the tiny Apple Bloom. She was adorable as a foal, but she didn't let that distract her.

All it did was increase her suspicion but it didn't provide any confirmation to them. She made her way back to the same box she took this photo album from and started looking for more. She felt hopeful about this, this place was the metaphorical last stone unturned. And unlike everything else she had tried, this one had promise. There was so much old stuff in this shed that there had to be something about her here.

And she wasn’t wrong, she found a bunch of her oldest baby pictures in another photo album, but she grumbled at how little new information they shined on the situation that was making her curious. It was starting to feel like she was really going to get nowhere.

But that was impossible. Wasn’t it? She did the math, sure she wasn’t the best at math in school, but the date of her birth, minus 2 years, always resulted in her having been conceived, gestated and birthed starting a year after her parents died. This was a mystery, she knew there had to be something weird about it, something that wasn’t the obvious. She didn’t think about it consciously, but deep inside she was terrified of being adopted. Being a part of the great apple family was such a central part of who she was that the mere idea of not belonging chilled her to her apple core.

If she even had one of those anyways.

From the distance, yet rather loudly she heard the voice of her sister calling her “Apple Bloom! Come out from wherever yer are! Yer friends are here!”.
It was like a lightswitch flipped in her head, she had been so focused on the mystery of her birth that she had completely forgotten about the entire night ending in a sleepover that she and her friends were going to be having in that specific nightmare night.

And that is all that it would have been if she had run out through the door like she meant to, but before she could leave she tripped on something, when she stood up she was going to kick it or mash it with her food but then she noticed what it was.

It was a VHS tape.

Man everything here was old. VHS tapes were used way before her time, hell they were used way before her siblings’ time. For that reason alone she was curious about it, but something else made her pick it up in a hurry. The label on it read “Apple Bloom”, there was no more context. Just her name in a random VHS tape that she found on the ground of a shed that had had way too few visitors in the last few years.

The young pony decided to pick it up and take it. Best case scenario she got an answer to her ongoing situation, worst case scenario it was just some video of when she was a little filly, probably doing something embarrassing. Anyway it went and it ended up as a positive, so she decided what the heck, it was worth showing to the other cutie mark crusaders, nightmare night was supposed to be fun.

And for the best part of the time they had together, it was fun. Big Mac chaperoned them around town as they went trick or treating, and they even managed to be a part of Princess Luna’s yearly scare-a-thon with their friends from school. It was a great night.

Sweetie Belle had tried to say that now that they had their cutie marks they were too old to go around in costumes, but Applejack managed to brow beat that stupid idea out of their heads a couple of days before Nightmare Night proper… Which was enough time for Apple Bloom and Scootaloo to make their costumes (a pirate, and literally Rainbow Dash, respectively), it wasn’t enough for Sweetie Belle who had to conform to go around wearing her sister’s flower costume. It wouldn’t have bothered her so much if it wasn’t really tight at the back. It made her feel inappropriate because it meant her plot was getting as big as her sister’s.

She wasn’t the only one to discover weird feelings while having fun during nightmare night. Apple Bloom and Scootaloo were also victims to the whims of puberty during the night. Big Mac kept himself to the background through most of the night, letting the girls scare her friends and get candy from the houses they went to, but when they went on their way back to Sweet Apple Acres he made sure to go in front leading the way.

It was unintentional, but that meant that he subjected three rather hormonal preteens to seeing his big fat balls swinging from side to side almost hypnotically. Ponies like them didn’t normally wear clothes, so they had seen this particular ballsack a million times before, and it did nothing to them, it hadn’t awoken anything until now.
They didn’t know what it meant, their bodies felt like those balls were calling to them, they, but particularly Apple Bloom, instinctively felt like their bodies wanted to go to those balls, lick them and get that powerful member out of its sheath and use it for what it and their bodies were made for.

The trio of soon to be teenagers didn’t know it yet but this peculiar nightmare night was the eevee of their first estrus.

Something that they were just mere minutes away from realizing. And their journey of discovery through the wonders of marehood wouldn’t have happened on this day without Apple Bloom and her tape.

Which she practically rushed to show them once they got home. It took a bit of convincing, but a few minutes after they got to her room, they got out of it, sneaked all the way back to the shed and tried to carry out an old tv, one of the CRT ones with the slot for VHS tapes, before they realized that Sweetie Belle could just levitate it all the way back, and so she did. She was very annoyed with the entire situation, it was tiresome, and all because in her young girl wisdom, Apple Bloom hadn’t realized that they didn’t have a way to play it on the TV Apple bloom had in her room.

Still, they were back in her room, and after putting it down and plugging in all that needed to be plugged in, they turned it on and put in the tape that got Apple Bloom so excited.

Like most CRT TVs this one took a bit to turn on and show an image. The anticipation was awful, the room was silent with only a mild zooming noise breaking through the quiet. During this pause they realized how much space the big TV took, and that they were just a bunch of mildly horny fillies huddled in a room, which made Sweetie Belle a bit sweatier than the other two.

There wasn’t much more time to think though, as the screen finally spread open and started to show a blue screen.

They forgot to press play.

Apple Bloom leaned in, putting a bit too much of her ass in front of a Sweetie Belle whose body was only getting hotter by the minute.

With the button pressed, the tape began to play as static danced across the screen. The girls groaned, not caring for the issues old technology brought to them. Although Scootaloo, the only one of them that had used a VHS for a substantial amount of her childhood, thought that this entire situation felt somewhat nostalgic.

Soon though the tape corrected itself and brought up footage of the barn as Applejack and Big Macintosh were working moving barrels and haystacks around the barn. They looked rather young giving clue to Apple Bloom that this was some time before she was born, if the albums she had been seeing through the day were all organized chronologically, this event should have happened around a year before she was born.

“Hoo boy that was some Nightmare Night eh Big Mac?” Applejack said as she stacked another bale of hay.

“Eyup, those kids really seemed to like the batch of apples this year. They kept coming back making sure to get ‘em,” Big Mac replied.

“Boy howdy you said it. Awful lot of cute little fillies and foals comin’ about this year. Bless their little hearts,” Apple bloom exclaimed as she seemed almost sad by the fact, and a sigh gave it all away.

“Wonder what's got AJ so sad?” Sweetie Belle asked.

“Yeah, she just said they had a good night,” Scootoo added on.

“I dunno, ma sister never brought up wantin’ kids before. She always seemed so content not being in a relationship either,” Apple Bloom explained. She wasn’t the brightest lightbulb around, but even in that dim head of hers, the idea that the reason that her sister felt no need to have kids anymore was because AJ had to take care of her did manage to pop up, still she put the idea aside and continued watching.

“Yep, the town is really growing,” Big Mac said as the tape kept playing. “We're still young but I wonder how long it will be before we have our own little ones to bring up.”

After Big Mac said his piece there was a flicker of light and static on the screen. Applejack seemed fine one moment and the next her head began to whip around as a green light began enveloping her. The girls wondered if it was a trick of the eye or an issue with the tape. Scootaloo moved up to the old TV to smack it to fix it, but it corrected itself before she could, this old TV may have seen enough percussive maintenance to be afraid of it.

Applejack turned around and faced Big Mac, this time with a big smile on her face and a look in her eye. The girls watched and recognized the look was similar to the one that they saw Cheerlee have when they gave her and Big Mac the love poison. It confused the girls as this was Applejack looking at her brother in such a way, all three were thinking about it, about how there could be no way in tartarus that what they thought was about to happen could happen

“Ya know Big Mac, I've actually thought a lot about the idea of havin’ me some little ones,” Applejack said as she trotted over to her brother.

“Oh yeah? That's surprisin’ considerin’ ya never really been big on findin’ a partner like that,” Big Mac replied, still moving barrels, unaware of AJ as she moved closer to him.

“Well, no one really interested me in town, no one with the right “equipment” for that anyways. Besides, now that i think about it… why bother findin’ a partner when I had one so close fer so long,” AJ said as she reached her brother and began nuzzling against him.

The girls gasped as they watched the younger version of AJ getting really close to her brother. Scootaloo gesticulated her disgust as she wasn't much for romance in general much less the un-sibling-like behavior that AJ was showing on screen.

Sweetie Belle blushed after seeing her be so lovey dovey with her brother, Sweetie, who lived mostly with her sister was raised on raunchy romance novels, so the idea of forbidden love not only wasn’t alien to her but it was something that she was very interested in seeing, but she’d rather die that let the others in the room know that, so she tried her best to dissimulate her intense curiosity by trying to imitate Scootaloo’s expression. Her attempt was failing.

Not that the others could notice, all three of them were enthralled by the events in the TV. Apple Bloom most of all was silent however as she wasn't sure what to feel about a scene like this being in a tape with her name on it. The gears in her head were turning and she didn’t like the way that they were spinning.

“AJ, you feelin’ alright?” Big Mac said with a shudder in his voice.

“Never better,” AJ replied as she kept rubbing up on him. “In fact, I could say I just got into a type of mood and I think only you can help with that.”

“Seriously, ‘jack, why you gettin’ this way. I know we're country folk but even you said we ain't like that. You hated all those jokes kids made like that about us growing up,” Big Mac said trying to move away from AJ.

“Yeah, those folks made those jokes. But maybe they had a point. I mean, you were always such a handsome colt. Always lookin’ out for me. Protectin’ me from dem ponies that laughed at us. Didn't realize it then but maybe I just needed you,” AJ said, her voice sounding hypnotic.

“AJ, think about it. We're siblin's. We shouldn't be doin’ none of this ya hear,” Big Mac continued to protest. His mind was trying to resist but his body vehemently disagreed. His flared cockhead came out of his sheet, aroused by the sheer implication of Applejack’s intent.

“I mean, yer sayin’ that Big Mac, but I think this here is actually speaking over ya,” AJ said as she moved and poked her head under his body to nudge his now fully extended dick.

The girls watching all covered their mouths to suppress a gasp. Scootaloo was shocked about Big Mac's manhood, Sweetie Belle was enamored by it feeling tingly inside. Apple Bloom felt strong conflict as she didn't want to see brother’s manhood looked like but couldn't help but stare at him, she was a growing girl, just now getting interested in the opposite sex and her brother was in fact a peak specimen of what a stallion is supposed to be. Not only that but the camera caught AJ at just the right angle to see her marehood, which looked much more pronounced and wet than any of them had ever seen it be before, in pony society nudity was normal, they’ve seen vaginas before, but this is the first time they’d seen one that was excited, aroused and about to have sex.

Applejack's ass was more than pronounced, it was huge. Her backside had always been strong and toned from years of apple bucking. The strength she developed in her backside was greater than most other ponies and showed in the ample size of her flank. Not only that but her pussy was on display as well to the camera, winking continuously as a sure sign she wanted to breed. Sweetie and Apple Bloom couldn’t take their eyes off of it, if they were asked about their budding bisexuality they would deny it vehemently, but as that exact moment, they didn’t care that much, Applejack’s body was hypnotizing.

The three girls weren’t aware of it yet, but the combination of two of the sexiest bodies that they had ever seen getting aroused and ready was making them enter into their first ever estrus, just like the one that Applejack had in the video.

“This big feller sure seems to like what I’m doing, oh brother of mine.” she said, teasing him with a tone she knew he hated “I think I should give it some appreciation for that now shouldn't I?” AJ asked as she began to nuzzle Big Mac's cock with her nose.

It looked as though AJ was inhaling her big brother's scent as she caressed his dick with her snout. Her pussy was winking faster as she grew more and more aroused being exposed to her brother's manhood. Big Mac seemed conflicted as he was trying to resist his sister's advances, but he was a young virgin stallion, there were a lot of parts of him that he could lie to himself about but what his penis wanted was not one of them. And it wanted to rut his sister right then and there, they all could see it on his face.

Applejack pushed further in the act of showing her brother some attention. Sticking out her tongue she began to lick and run her tongue along his massive shaft. The taste of him ran across her tongue only strengthening her desires for her brother. He was truly manly, one she could rely on and be there for her, the one example of sheer manhood that she always had near her, after her (now late) father of course. She kept on giving his cock attention as she knelt down and positioned herself to better service him.

AJ opened wide and began taking Big Mac's dick in her mouth. Her head bobbed back and forth as Big Mac let out a whimper of pleasure. He looked like he was distressed in receiving such attention. The guilt of letting his sister do such lewd things mixed with the undeniable fact that she was doing a good job. It was his first time receiving this kind of attention, hell it was his first time doing anything other than masturbating, and he knew for a fact that it was her first time doing anything sexual, with a guy at least (what happens at summer camp cabins, stays in summer camp cabins), but it felt like a woman with experience was doing it, like she had practice or a guide telling her what to do.

Big Mac stomped his front hoof a few times as he panted. AJ suddenly stopped though as she felt him throbbing. It only lasted for a few moments, Big Mac turning to his sister and looking at her with a disappointed look on his face.

“Why did you stop?” he asked.

“Oh so you were enjoying it?” AJ retorted with a smug smile.

Big Mac stayed quiet as he felt answering would incriminate him. All four women, Applejack in the tape and the cutie mark crusaders outside of it, knew that all that staying quiet did was the opposite of that. All of them knew he wanted it just as much as Applejack did, his mouth was closed but the expression on his face was screaming it.

“I just don't want to waste that seed of yers. After all, it goes inside a mare, you know that. Momma would be disappointed if she knew you were going around letting it fall to the ground or shooting it in some gals’ throat. If you want to get off best do it inside me proper like Celestia intended, or you can deal with bein’ pent up like that fer a while, yer choice,” AJ told Big Mac, making the ultimatum clear.

Big Mac began to sweat nervously. He stared at AJ, unable to believe she of all people would say such a thing. AJ just turned away from him and trotted a few steps, before looking back at him with a sultry look. He stared directly at her large ass, which was more than ready to take him.

The girls watched, holding their breaths as to what he was going to do. His pause felt way longer than it really was, the wait for his decision felt like such an intense moment, they could see it in his expression. In the end was Big Mac going to cross that line and fuck his sister? Or was he going to resist and maintain his integrity as a big brother? The film continued on with a slight flicker of static that lingered on the screen.

Big Mac on the screen hung his head down as he approached AJ and stuck his nose right up against her eager pussy. He seemingly resigned himself to what needed to happen. She threw her head back and let out a neigh as Big Mac returned the favor his sister gave him from before. He made his choice and it looked like he gave into the sweet temptation that she presented to him earlier.

“Oh my gosh,” AApplebloom said as she witnessed her older siblings engaged in such lewd behavior together. There was a small pang of terror in the back of her head as the reason why the tape was named “Apple Bloom” became more and more clear, but her teenage hormones were doing an excellent job of keeping it contained, as her eyes were more focused on her older brother’s giant dick swaying with every single move he made than on the moral failure of her siblings.

“They’re really doing it,” Sweetie Belle added, in shock. Using one hoof to cover her mouth and the other to discreetly try to mastubate. Sure, all of her discretion was worth dick, if the girls even glanced to her direction they would both know exactly what she was doing. But all three of them were too focused on the tape’s contents to notice that all three of them were jilling off.

“That’s so gross,” Scootaloo blurted out, while shamelessly flicking the bean. It was almost as if she wasn’t aware of the actions of her own body, not that she cared. Out of all three of them, she was the one that was welcoming the pleasure the most.

As the fillies protested the actions on the old screen, they couldn’t help but look at it as the events unfolded, no matter the issues they had with it. The three little hypocrites wouldn’t admit to it if asked, but at the moment all three of them were incredibly wet. They had been since Big Mac walked them back to the farm, and the fact that they had been masturbating practically since they saw Big Mac’s cock come out of it’s sheet wasn’t really helping the case of their hypocrisy.

Meanwhile, the tape played on, showing Big Mac engaging in the throws of passion with his sister. His large cock hung, throbbing at the promise that he would stick his cock inside her. Big Mac certainly lived up to his name in both strength and now could be seen applied to his manhood, now that it was clear that even as a teenager his dick was bigger than most in town. It throbbed and pulsed as he continued to enjoy his sister’s juices as they dripped from her pussy.

Once he had his fill, Big Mac pulled his snout away from AJ’s slit and readied himself up to mount her. He was a big boy, and while AJ was smaller, she was still as strong to handle his weight. Getting up onto AJ, his cock slid between her legs as his hips drove forwards. He kept thrusting, intent on reaching her eagerly. Dismounting, he attempted to do it once more, this time hitting the right spot.

AJ let out a loud neigh that caused the girls to quickly turn down the volume on the TV with the fear of being caught. They leaned in closer to hear the muffled moan of AJ as she was being penetrated by her brother’s massive cock. Big Mac thrusted and grunted with each one. He snorted as he gave it to his sister, nice and hard. His strength seemed to be useful as he fucked AJ who seemed to be reveling in it, almost glowing with joy and pleasure.

“That’s it Big Mac, fuck me good and hard,” AJ started to blurt out. “Give me that big strong cock. Sweet Celestia I been waitn’ to feel that thing inside me for ages. Keep going, I’m almost…”

AJ whipped her head about as she felt the euphoric bliss that her brother was granting her. A loud neigh once again came from her mouth as she felt her pussy clamp down and around her brother’s meaty cock. Big Mac let out a similar grunt as he felt his sister's tight pussy grip him on the next stroke bringing him to orgasm.

The young colt's cock pulsed and throbbed as he shot out buckets of cum inside his kin. His hips kept thrusting as he used his sister to grant him such a blissful feeling. More cum was coaxed out as AJ continued to push back into him as he seemed too enamored to move himself.

“That's it sugar cube, give mama all that seed. I reckon you might just get me pregnant iffin’ ya fillin’ me up like this,” AJ said, her voice sounding somewhat distorted.

“Don't be sayin’ some foolish nonsense like that. We can't be havin’ no kids together,” Big Mac protested, still inside of her.

“What, you sayin’ I wouldn't be a good momma?” AJ asked, sounding a little offended. “I think you'd make a good daddy.”

“What I mean is that we bein’ siblin's and all might be a bit of a problem,” he replied.

“Oh donkey spidle, no one needs to know. Maybe tonight I hooked up with some handsome stallion? That's a half truth after all ain't it?” AJ reasoned to her brother as she began moving her body once more stimulating her brother again.

“Ain't you always telling me the value of honesty?” Big Mac grunted out as he felt his dick getting hard again with his sister's motions.

“I do, and I am being honest with ya. I want a baby with ya Big Mac, and I ain't gonna stop until I feel knocked up by ya,” AJ said as she began forcing her backside onto Big Mac's dick.

Big Mac stayed still for a moment as his sister used him to pump her pussy, stirring up the cum inside her. He eventually gave in and began pumping himself into her. AJ moaned out in joy that he came to see things her way.

The three fillies continued to watch the video as the two Apple siblings two engaged in a hot night of passion as they kept fucking again and again. After the second orgasm Big Mac pulled out showing his massive cock dripping with cum and his sister's juices. Scootaloo verbally showed her disgust with an audible “ew”, but she didn’t stop pleasuring herself, Sweetie Belle put her other hoof between her legs as she began rubbing her nipples and felt her pussy winking as she continued masturbating.

Apple Bloom just couldn't help but watch as her siblings were doing this. Again and again she witnessed her sister, someone she looked up to and admired, doing such lewd things with her own flesh and blood. What perplexed her the most was that her name was on such a take, it couldn’t be could it?

Why was this tape labeled like this if the contents were nothing more than a taboo amateur porno? What possible connection did this have with her?

Fast forwarding a few times, Applebloom watched as the siblings seemed to be going at this for hours according to the time on the tape. There was a few spots where the two stopped to get a drink of water or eat a few candied apples left over from that Nightmare Night's festivities to recharge, but when that was done it was back to fucking. AJ did her part to keep Big Mac going as she played with his cock after each session to get him hard. Even with a few protests from him that he was spent she still managed to get him going again.

Soon, the tape ended to the group's surprise. Applebloom was shocked and scared she broke it. With a press of the rewind button though she made it to the part she needed to see. The siblings were now finished, cuddled up to one another.

“I feel so full, you really gave me a lot of your seed tonight,” AJ said, nuzzling up to Big Mac.

“Eyup, you were really persistent to get it all,” Big Mac replied with a nuzzle back.

“What can I say, I really wanted to be a momma. Even with the bit that's drippin’ out I think I got enough seed to grow a baby,” AJ said.

“You figured a name for what we havin’ since you were so set on this?” Big Mac asked.

“Mmm, I was thinking something like Macintosh Red if it's a boy, and Apple bloom if it’s a girl…” AJ said before the tape cut out and filled the screen with static and an uncharacteristic green glow.

“It is” Apple Bloom, said barely above a whisper, “It is a recording of the night of my conception…”

The shock of learning that her siblings were in fact her parents, didn't deter her from continuing to masturbate as the green glow enveloped them. They tried to have a rational conversation about it, Sweetie Belle tried to console her, Scootaloo tried to tell her that they will keep the secret.

But all that came out were things like

“That was so hot” from Sweetie Belle.

“Did you see the size of his cock?” from Scootaloo.

And “I want a baby too” from Apple Bloom.

They looked at each other, not noticing the same greenish glow in their eyes that applejack had in the video, and Apple Bloom said “Cutie Mark Crusaders, i know what we are doing tonight”

The other two simply nodded and walked behind her. As the three horny and dripping wet fillies followed Apple Bloom’s lead, the THING inside the tape, the same thing that had been inside of Applejack that fateful night thought to itself “yes, yes girls, go give grandma some grandchildren!” Because the spirit of Pear Butter wasn’t satisfied with just one child.

The Ghost that had possessed her own daughter to make her one more daughter, now wanted grandkids, and she wanted a lot of them.