The Wacky Adventures of Evening Storm and the Many wives he impregnantes!

by videomaster21XX

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Starlight Glimmer, Romance, Sunburst, Porn, Sex, Comedy, Big Macintosh, Anthro
Length: 15553

Not going to lie to you. This is porn with loose plot. Evening Storm gets into silly situations that ends up with a pregnant wife. Many former stallions...

It began with a stupid wish...

Starlight is tasked with 'testing' a magical wish stone by her former teacher Twilight Sparkle. Feeling naughty, Starlight invites Twilight's new student, Evening Storm, a shy, but good-natured unicorn stallion to aide her in some experiments. Evening just didn't know it would lead to a stallion turned into a copy of Starlight in a sexy outfit, and him being made to play the part of this new mare's husband!

It's okay though. There is a catch. The moment either Evening, or the Starlight Twin is made to cross a line they don't want to cross (Kissing, touching, etc) the spell will end and they'll be free! No way this goes on for long right!

Right?

Little does Evening know that this is just the beginning of a harem. A harem filled with pregnant wives! Many who used to be stallions!

WARNING: I'm not going to lie to you guys. This is genderbending anthro pony porn with a loose plot.

Published 2025-02-14 13:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2025-02-14 13:00:01 UTC

First Wif'e'(ves) Acquired...

“So… the ruins said it’s a wishing stone?” Twilight asked as she gently held a rainbow colored rock in her hands. It wasn’t even polished, it looked no different from any other jagged rock, just with a rainbow color scheme.

“Yes and it works. Watch.” The adventurous mare known as Daring Doo replied as she gently picked it up from Twilight’s palm. Holding it tightly she pointed to a nearby table.

“I wish there was a small, cooking pot sized basket on this table and it was full of delicious apples!”

No sooner did she say that then a basket of said apples materialized out of thin air. It was as if Twilight had blinked and suddenly there was a basket of apples! All red delicious it seemed.

“T-That’s amazing!” Twilight exclaimed, gently poking a few with her fingers. They were definitely there and not an illusion. She didn’t sense any teleportation magic or transmutation magic either.

“Still there could be a trick to this I’m not seeing, I’d have to run some tests-”

“I wish Princess Twilight would bark like a dog for three seconds.”

“ARF! BARK WOOF!” Twilight exclaimed before slapping a hand over her mouth. Try as she might, she couldn’t stop herself from barking. At least until the three seconds ended and she suddenly fell silent.

“I-Is it over?” She asked meekly, pleased she could speak as she wished. “That’s… okay no further testing needed. I couldn’t even sense a spell going off!”

“Exactly, which is why I’m giving this to you. Tell the other princesses about it if you must. I just trust you to take the proper precautions with it, given you know more about magic than any other pony I know. Even the great Starswirl!”

Twilight blushed at that. She couldn’t be THAT great could she?

“I’ll have to tell them. If this fell into the wrong hands-”

“I… think I’ve taken care of some of that.” Daring Doo replied, causing Twilight to look at her confused.

“What do you mean?”

“I wished that no one could use this stone for nefarious means.” Daring replied slowly. Truth was she wasn’t entirely sure her safe guards were really going to work. “I’ve tried to test it out in minor ways and I couldn’t form the words. It’s just…”

“It’s a big risk to outright trust it.” Twilight finished taking the stone from Daring. “Hmmm I wish I had Spike’s latest comic purchase on my desk here.” Again as if they were in an animated movie and someone had just slipped new cells into the process with the additional item painted in, the comics were just suddenly there.

“That’s a bit freaky to be honest.” Twilight commented as she stared at the pile. “Now… I wish these comics would catch on fire!”

Nothing happened. They both sat there for a bit waiting, but there wasn’t even a wisp of smoke. After what felt like minutes, both sighed in relief.

“I hope that counts as nefarious enough. Naturally I planned to replace the comics if they did catch fire, but I’d have to let Spike see them first.”

Daring raised an eyebrow. “Why is that?”

“Well the definition of nefarious is the key. I’m not sure burning something that doesn’t belong to me, only to replace it with a new one, without the original owner ever knowing would count. Doing that just to see their reaction however… not exactly A tier villainy, but it’s not nice either.”

“I see!” Daring exclaimed with a smile. “That’s smart! You really are a top rate princess!”

Twilight blushed again. “Y-You flatter me too much.”

Daring took the stone again. “It would have irked me, but I tried wishing for my name to be painted on the walls of an old temple. It was the most well… ‘nefarious’ thing I could think of. Heh glad I didn’t go with my alternative.”

“Al..ternative?” Twilight’s curiosity got the better of her. She had a bad feeling about this, but couldn’t stop herself from asking.

“Yeah I was going to say something like: I wish Twilight Sparkle was naked!”

The same as the comics just being there the next moment when Twilight made her wish. The gown Twilight had been wearing simply vanished in the next moment. Along with any undergarments she had on, leaving her completely nude.

It took a few seconds for the Princess to realize what happened.

“EEEEEK! U-Un wish that now!” She screeched, trying to cover herself with her arms!

“Ah! I wish Twilight Sparkle had clothing on!”

In a blink Twilight was wearing one of the popular ‘harem’ outfits Daring had seen some pony tribes of the desert wear. Purple in color and they showed off her belly button rather well, in addition to drawing attention to her generous bust size.

“Ah! These are the clothes it put me in? Why did you think of these!?”

“I-I panicked!” Daring yelled, trying to look away so as to not further upset the Princess. “Why did that wish go through?”

“W-Well did you have any evil thoughts about making me naked!?”

“NO!” Daring vigorously shook her head. “I just thought it’d be funny!”

“That may be why.” Twilight grumbled as she took the stone. “I wish I was in my proper outfit.”

Her princess dress returned on her as if nothing had happened. Giving herself a quick check, she sighed in relief.

“Okay so the stone can still cause trouble.”

“I thought it was too good to be true that my countermeasure wish worked.” Daring huffed, trying to move along with the conversation as if nothing happened. Just as much for her benefit as it was for Twilight’s.

“Yes, the issue with that is that not only are certain things possibly not considered ‘nefarious’ but we don’t know if something would happen if the one wishing didn’t consider what they were doing as bad.”

“I understand completely.” Daring replied with a sigh. “So what should we do with it?”

“Well normally I’d run some tests, but in truth I need to be leaving soon for Canterlot. There’s been some.. Incidents I can’t talk about that the other princesses and I need to discuss. I can bring up this stone then.”

“Incidents you could use the stone to help solve?” Daring suggested quietly. Twilight shook her head.

“Until I know more about this stone, that's too risky. “I would like to find out as much as I can as soon as possible. Hmm I think I’ll get Starlight to help me with this.”

“Er, no offense princess but are you sure you can trust her?”

Twilight beamed. “Yes. I trust Starlight immensely. She’s come a long way from where she came from. I’m certain she’ll address this task with the grace and caution it needs!”

===

Twilight’s second and most recent student looked nervous as he sat at the table across from his senior Starlight Glimmer. "Um, are you sure this is a good idea? Why am I even here?"

"Look Evening we have a gem that is said to grant wishes!" Starlight exclaimed, holding a rainbow stone in her hands. "Twilight asked me to test it, and I want your help!"

"We DID test it! We wished for various fruits and even a sandwich and it materialized all of them!" He replied in exasperation. In fact they had spent the last several hours testing the thing, and he still didn’t know why he was here.

"That's small stuff!" Starlight scoffed with a roll of her eyes. "We need to put it through a REAL test."

Evening pinched his muzzle. Given his... unique magical status, he had a knack for finding strong magical artifacts and spells. Thus he was usually asked to look over spoils of various artifacts found in the palace vaults, or treasures bought in from treasure hunters. Such as Daring Doo who just so happened to have brought this stone to them. That and only for that reason could he see the need for his presence here, and even then it wasn’t good enough. He knew Starlight could do it all without him.

“And what real test do you have planned that requires me to still be here? You better not be attempting to use that on me!”

“Don’t worry it’s not you, I want to test this one.” She replied with a smirk. She was glad for Twilight’s faith in her, and she knew this probably wasn’t what her teacher had in mind when she asked her to test the capabilities of the stone, but in truth Starlight just couldn’t contain herself. Especially not after recent events. Besides in the end it should amount to harmless fun right?

“I just want your help in playing a little trick on Sunburst.”

“W-What sort of trick?” Evening replied warily. He respected Starlight immensely, but he knew she had her… moments in the past. She had a ton of magical power, as much as Twilight did which made him rather jealous, but she also didn’t always use it responsibly…

“Oh nothing too bad, just a bit of payback.”

Evening felt a chill. “P-Payback?”

Starlight’s eyes narrowed. "Remember last month when we were boxing up some unused items for that donation drive? For some reason he thought the box on my bed was part of it. The box I had a collection of vintage kites in.”

Evening was actually stunned that he’d forgotten that. Starlight had made such a fuss, and thinking back on it he could understand why. They had tried, but it had been too late to recover them from the sale. At best she might be able to track down only a couple. It could take her years to rebuild that collection.

Sunburst had been beside himself for the mistake, and Starlight had sort of forgiven him. Evening couldn’t really fault her for being so bitter over the situation. Not only was that box not out in the hallway where the rest had been placed, but it didn't even have the donation drive sticker on them like the others!

If he had to guess, Sunburst was likely just that tired. Still what’s done is done. The box was gone and so was everything in it. Evening didn’t think Starlight would hurt Sunburst, but when she got emotional she tended to go a bit overboard sometimes.

He didn’t exactly like it, but he figured it’d be better if he was around to try and minimize the danger.

"...Okay fine, but nothing too crazy got it?"

Starlight beamed. "That's the spirit! Now I wish I knew if we were close enough for this to even affect him?" She paused for a moment then grinned. "He fell asleep in the other room! We're good! So let's get started!"

"Okay and why do we have to be in the dining room for this?" Evening asked, looking around. Well there was a large pile of dishes in the sink. “Are you going to make him do your chore of the dishes tonight?”

“Well that may be part of it.” She replied with a grin. Evening definitely didn’t like the feel of this. He silently made a note to not piss her off.

"Okay first I wish Sunburst would wake up and come out here to do the dishes, but would not notice me or you at all. It'd be like we aren't even in the room."

Not a few minutes after speaking her wish, Sunburst walked into the room yawning as he strode right past both of them without so much as a blink of the eye. It certainly looked like he hadn’t noticed them. Guess the stone was capable of that too.

Still not acknowledging them, he got to the sink and began to quietly wash the dishes. Only after a few seconds of work did he seem to notice what he was doing.

"That's odd..." He murmured as he worked. The load of dishes was actually rather large due to various circumstances, so it'd likely take a little bit to finish. "Why am I doing this?”

He seemed to ponder it a bit as he worked, only to shrug. “Oh well they need to be done and maybe Starlight will be happy I helped her out."

If those words had an effect on Starlight, she didn’t show it. Instead she just watched him work, seeing if he’d notice her. It was kind of funny actually. The sink was on a stand alone counter in the middle of the room. If he looked up he could easily see the dining table both Starlight and Evening were seated at, but was indeed acting as if they weren’t there.

For Starlight and Evening however, this allowed them to get a clear view of the orange stallion washing away. It was kind of eerie having him so close but seemingly unable to sense them.

"So I assume he can't hear us either?” Evening asked in a bit of a low voice, simply unable to help it. “Or do we sound like ghosts right now?”

He cupped his hands around his muzzle. “Woooooo!" He moaned in a voice loud enough that it should be impossible to ignore. Yet Sunburst paid him no mind.

"Fun as that would be no, he can't see or hear us, so that's one thing the stone can do that we should be concerned about." She was eyeing Sunburst with mischievous glee, before suddenly turning to Evening, and holding the stone out to him, balanced on the palm of her hand.

"I wish you'd accept this stone, and answer my next question honestly. I then wish you'd follow one command of mine, then I wish you'd pass the stone back.” After speaking, she tossed the stone over, which Evening instinctively caught.

"Wait what? What are you up to?”

"It's to test to see if it'll grant wishes in a row like that." Starlight explained. She adjusted the business-like suit she was wearing. It was the same professional outfit she wore to her counseling job at the Friendship and Magic school. She looked good in it, but it didn't do her curves any favors.

Evening tried not to blush. This was not the time to be ogling his fellow pupil. Even if she had technically graduated already. Also he didn’t need to let her know he thought of her like that. At least not until he knew for certain if she liked Sunburst. A question and command huh? He tried not to let his mind wander into lewd territory.

"Okay well I caught it...."

Starlight nodded her expression calm and collected. "Tell me, what sexy articles of clothing do you wish I was wearing right now? Also I command you to wish me in said assembles"

"Then I wish you were wearing sexy purple and white stockings, a pair of sexy white panties, matching high heels, a cute white apron, and a frilly white cloth choker."

The color drained from Evening's face the moment those words slipped out of his mouth.

BUCK! I’m dead! He wanted to run for it, but the wish that would cause him to pass the stone back prevented him from moving. Instead of the usual stone’s affairs of causing things to just BE. This time her suit glowed a soft white light before everything morphed into the exact articles of clothing he had just mentioned. Just as he’d imagined them to look!

Despite the feeling of danger he’d had a few minutes ago, the sight of this beautiful mare dressed like this caused a bit of a brain short. The simple fact was, Starlight was very sexy and he hated to admit it, but he’d give quite a lot right then for the consent of touching her body.

Starlight took a few moments to look herself over, her expression steady enough that he couldn't tell what she was thinking.

"H-Hey! This is your fault!" He cried, tossing the stone back to her. When she finally expressed emotion, she showed not anger or embarrassment, but rather. Arousal? That… that couldn’t be right could it?

"Oh wow this IS pretty sexy isn't it?" Starlight purred, looking herself over. "Nice choice!"

Evening sputtered. That was NOT the reaction he expected."I... aren't you mad or something?"

Starlight snorted. "Oh please, I know stallions think I'm pretty, and I didn't think you thought any differently.” She waved a hand in the air before going back to admiring herself as Sunburst still washed dishes in the background.

“Besides, unlike some guys out there, I know you'd never try to get in my panties or touch me inappropriately using magic or even try to bully me into dating you or something."

"O-Of course not!" He protested.

Starlight smiled. “And for that, just think of this as a reward.” She winked.

Wait, did Starlight... like him or something?

…nah, she was just caught up in the moment.

"Now for the real fun!" Starlight giggled, holding up the stone. Speaking of which, here we go. Evening braced himself for what could possibly be next.

"I wish Sunburst would turn into what could be considered my exact twin sister, right down to the same outfit I'm wearing! I wish she wouldn't notice the change right away!"

Dumbstruck, Evening watched as Sunburst's body glowed a bright rainbow light and morphed itself into a slightly smaller, and much more feminine package. True to her wish. What now stood in the kitchen washing dishes was an exact copy of Starlight Glimmer. She had even begun to hum while washing, which changed in pitch to match Starlight's own voice.

She was also wearing the exact same ‘sexy outfit’ Evening had put the real one in. It was so very odd seeing two of them dressed like that this close to each other. It also was nowhere near anything he had thought Starlight was going to do!

"Starlight what the hay!?" Evening bellowed standing up. Sadly this exposed something that had begun when he first saw Starlight in said ensemble. Most notably when his quickly stiffening dick bumped the underside of the table, causing him to hastily sit back down in shame.

"Just why?” He asked, waving at the new Starlight clone. “What are you doing!?"

"Now we know it can not only change the target’s gender, but their entire body to resemble somepony else!" Starlight said matter of factly. “I’d say these are pretty good tests for figuring out the stone’s limits.”

"So you turned your best friend into a girl!?" Evening exclaimed trying to calm himself down enough so he could stand without it being awkward. “Your clone to be more precise!”

"Oh relax I'll change him back." She waved her hand again. "This is just going along with what he said about paying me back. If you recall, he said he’d do anything to make it right."

"I don't think he had this in mind!"

She shrugged. "What's done is done, besides we’re gathering important info.”

She gripped the stone again. “Now I wish she could only refer to herself as Starlight Glimmer. I wish for her to remember who she really is, but be unable to tell anyone that. I wish for her to only refer to herself as Starlight Glimmer, not become her mentally. Though I do wish she'd also have to refer to herself as Starlight Glimmer in her thoughts."

Evening grunted. "Excessive much?"

"Hush you have to be precise about these things. Also I need to see if there is any limit to how many wishes you can stack." She turned her attention back to her twin, who was blissfully washing dishes without a care in the world or any acknowledgement of her new body or what was just said.

"Now I wish she'd splash her chest with water, and when she does, she'll realize what has happened to her body and clothes."

Seconds after Starlight spoke those words, Sunburst reached over to grab the spray nozzle attached to the sink. Upon attempting to wash out a cup, she misaimed and got her ‘apron’ instead. Right where her new boobs were.

"Gah! Ugh I can't believe I did that!" She sighed, patting herself dry with a hand towel. “Right in the boobs too…” You could almost see the gears turning in her head as she stopped to process that, her eyes growing wider and wider.

"BOOBS!? Why do I have boobs!?” She cried, grabbing hold of them only to let out a strangled moan. “T-They feel… wait my arms! My hands! My voice! M-My mane?"

She reached up to pull forward a few locks that were hovering over her vision, examining the colors. "I-Isn't this how Starlight's hair looks?" Amusingly, as if right out of a cartoon, she picked up a wet clean plate to see her reflection. "I AM Starlight! What!?"

She turned this way and that in frantic panic, which Evening hated to admit, made her look super adorable. He’d never seen the real Starlight act like that. It was a bit of a shame. This did fit Sunburt’s personality however. He wondered what Sunburst might be like if born a mare? She’d probably be pretty cute.

As for the new Starlight, she was currently grabbing the edge of the sink, trying to calm herself down with deep counted breaths. Evening felt really guilty he was still finding this cute. The poor guy must be so freaked out.

"Okay Starlight, just calm down, get a hold of yours... wait Starlight? I know I look like Starlight Glimmer, but I'm Starlight Glimmer!" Her eyes widened again.

"I mean I'm Starlight Glimmer, not Sunburst! GAH!"

The actual Starlight erupted into a fit of giggles, which Evening shamefully joined in on. He wasn't fully on board with this, but even he thought it was pretty funny to see Sunburst like this. He just needed to make sure they changed him back before anything bad happened.

“So this is enough right?” Evening asked, though he regretfully had a feeling it wouldn’t be. “We don’t want to freak him out too much right?”

"Just a little more,” The Starlight across from him said, holding up the stone. “I wish Sunburst would make a wish to see herself with whatever bust size he secretly enjoys on a woman. I wish for that wish to come true."

"T-This can't be real!" The Starlight Twin exclaimed, still trying not to freak out. "Though I really wish this body had the same bust size that Fluttershy has."

Naturally this caused the new mare to stop in her tracks as her brain registered what she just said out loud.

"Wait, why in Equestria would I say th-AH!" She let out something that was a cross between a moan and a groan as her chest swelled, and swelled, and swelled. The boobs that had likely been a C cup at best, Evening didn’t dare try to actually measure them, were quickly becoming what even Evening believed was an E cup. Of course he never measured Fluttershy’s chest either, but she had some… unique ones. A pair most stallions weren’t immune to wishing to explore. Evening was no exception and apparently neither was Sunburst.

"H-How? What? They're huge!" Twin Starlight exclaimed, cupping her breasts. That proved to be a bit of a mistake as she let out a much louder and more lewd moan. Evening had always kinda guessed, but if they really were just like Fluttershy’s then they were probably as sensitive as he always thought those were.

‘Starlight Clone’ shook herself as she snatched her own hands away, trying to forget what she just felt by the looks of her expression. "N-Never mind! I have to find a way to fix this! I can't let actual Starlight see me! O-Or anyone for that matter!"

"Damn I'm jealous." ‘Actual’ Starlight quipped, before giving a low chuckle. "Ha! Jealous of what is basically my own body just with bigger boobs. What do you think? Should I use the stone to match her?"

“I uh, j-just what is your plan here anyway?” Evening said, trying to change the subject. Damn it of course he wanted to see that, but it’d be bad to just come out and say that right?

“I mean you made him your twin and now gave him... those." Having two incredibly sexy Starlight Glimmers in the room was almost torture. Especially when she had them both wearing that stupid outfit he blurted out. He ended up taking to glancing away from both of them to try and not invade some sense of their privacy. “So are you done? Why did I need to be here to see this anyway?"

"Oh this was just the pre-show!" Starlight exclaimed, a dangerous glint back in her eyes. Evening gulped. He wasn't sure he liked where this was going. Was he about to be used as a transformed test subject as well?

"First off I wish I knew if my new twin was suffering." A moment passed. "Well a little. She's panicked on why she just became my twin with big gazongas of course, but she's also really curious about that body. I think she wants to strip naked to see what I'd look like!"

"I-I see.” Damn it, his dick was almost fighting with his mind on what to do. Seeing her naked would be… No, that's wrong!

“Uh, on another topic, this stone is proving to be rather dangerous…" He added.

"Oh certainly, Twilight was right to be worried about it and test it. Thinking along those lines…” Starlight straightened up, her demeanor taking on a much more professional aura. “In regards to what might happen, I wish only we here, and Twilight Sparkle herself could use it. I wish to know if that worked." She blinked. "Oh hey! It does! Huh I didn't think it'd be that easy."

"That's... actually really smart!" Evening was honestly impressed with her idea. He wasn't sure he'd have been able to come up with that. "But what if we need the Princess to use it?”

“Twilight should be able to wish for them to have access as well.” Starlight replied while looking the rock over. “Come to think of it, I wish to know if there was a time limitation on that wish. I also wish to know if there was an outside way of overriding that command…”

She blinked again. Evening wondered if that was a side effect of getting information pretty much just placed into your head like that.

“Okay no time limit, and only very powerful magic could override those limitations of access. W-well that or if we all were murdered.” She actually looked pale. “S-Some wishes are undone if the original wisher dies. I-I’m not about to play with life and death and wish for not being killed, s-so we may want to be careful with who we tell about this.”

“A-Agreed.” Evening felt cold. It was fun and games with it right here, but this was seriously dangerous. All the reason they probably shouldn’t be playing with it. Then again, now that they knew some more of what they could do with it, there should be a countermeasure for if they weren’t in possession of said stone… Maybe if he…

“Hey uh, can I see if for a sec? I might have an idea to help us in the future.”

"Sure but I wish you couldn't undo the wishes currently on my twin there." She said before handing it over. Evening did wince a bit at that. He had considered trying to free Sunburst who was likely rationalizing her still doing dishes as a means of calming herself down.

“I wish to know myself if Sunburst is suffering.” He swore he felt himself blink. He just knew. Knew that Sunburst was confused and uneasy, but deeper down there was… curiosity? Excitement? So it was true. There was a part of him that leaned into what was happening. Though likely small at the moment.

“Told ya, though I suppose I can’t blame you for wanting to know yourself.” Starlight said, her tone low, possibly hurt. Evening felt guilty for asking, but he needed to know himself.

“I-I’m sorry I-”

But Starlight shook her head as she held up a finger. “No look, yes it stings a little that you wouldn’t trust me, but you also don’t know if I’m being manipulated. That stone could have had an evil essence in it.”

“It could!?” Evening yelped, nearly dropping the thing.

“Yes, but I think from the fact you are holding it proves that it’s just a wish granting stone… Wow that sounds weird put like that.”

Evening felt a little silly upon realizing he didn’t sense any maliciousness from the stone. He was actually rather skilled at telling when a particular type of magic was harmful in nature or not. Likely due to the craziness of his own magical talent and cutie mark.

In fact this stone didn’t actually feel dangerous. If anything it felt like a kindred soul to his own magic. It was strange, but there almost seemed to be a connection…

“Anyway what did you want to use it for?” Starlight’s words knocked him out of his musings.

"Oh right, uh, okay I wish that we didn't have to hold the stone to use it. I wish that as long as we are in its area of effect, we can just say our wish and it'd be granted. I also wish we could know the location of the stone whenever we want."

“Now to test.” He pulled the stone under the table and put it in one of his hands before presenting them both to Starlight. "Which one?"

She thought for a moment and grinned. "The right hand."

"Correct!" He said, revealing it. "Lucky guess or did the wish work?"

"It did! I just thought about where it was and it came to me! Nice wishes!"

Evening blushed. Guess he had his moments after all. He placed the stone in the middle of the table and let go of it completely, leaning back. "Now for the next test. I wish for your twin there to be as comfortable as she can be in that body right now."

The still rather frazzled mare, visibly relaxed, though she wasn't quite at ease, she was at least able to hold it together better. Or at the very least appeared to be doing so.

"Okay why am I even still doing dishes? What magic IS this?" She cried as her body continued to work on the piles in the sink.

"Clever, you can’t undo a wish on her, but adding is fine." Starlight mused as she watched the former stallion. "Now, I just have one last thing I want to see play out."

The grin on her was wider and more mischievous than any of her previous ones. Evening had a REALLY bad feeling about this one.

"And what is-" He began but she didn’t wait for him to finish.

"I wish for you to remain silent and seated there until I say." Starlight commanded. Evening felt his body tense up, unable to move. Shit! Had he made a fatal mistake? Was this Chrysalis or something just disguised as Starlight!? Did she make a hidden wish earlier that he couldn't sense some dark magic from the stone?

"Forgive me, but I'm glad you trusted me enough not to make a wish to prevent this. Now." She looked at Sunburst, now ‘Starlight’. "I wish for her to act as your loving wife. I wish for her to act out any sexual fantasy you might have about me, or just in general as long as no harm will come to either of you.”

She continued to grin. “Not that I feel you'd do something so horrible. Now to set out the guidelines of this roleplay."

Evening couldn't move or speak, but his eyes could apparently still widen. What in the world was she up to!? Starlight visibly winded up to start speaking again.

"I wish for you to go along with this. I wish for you to be unable to tell her what is going on. However, I wish for both of you to only go as far as you are comfortable with. I wish that the moment either of you get to a point that you don't want to cross, you'll both revert to normal. I wish to know if that means what I hope it does."

Another pause and blink.

"Great! Yes according to this you'll only play out this role play for as long as either of you are comfortable doing. You both will indeed be free of all the wish magic the moment you feel forced to do something you do not want. Now I wish you could move freely again."

Evening jolted up. "What are you thinking!?"

"I'm thinking that this will be fun to watch. Also I wish you can't make any wishes till I say so."

Horsefeathers! He missed his chance! This couldn’t be right! Was he really about to treat Sunburst as his loving wife? No way she’d go along with it right? Yeah this would be over in seconds! Why was Starlight even doing this!?

What was worse is he couldn't believe the part of him that hoped it’d go down differently. That they might actually…No, this was beyond what was okay! Yet being able to get his hands on Starlight’s body, even if it’s a copy. He barely found his voice.

"I-I can't... I... " He tried to protest, but his body was already walking toward this 'Sunburst Glimmer'.

"Oh and I wish Sunburst could see and hear you again."

"Hmm? Evening?" Sunburst almost immediately asked as Evening walked around the counter toward him… her.

“Just to be safe, I wish I could know Sunburst’s current thoughts.” Starlight whispered as she watched them get close to each other. Said thoughts came in loud and clear.

Great! He can help me! I just need to tell him who I am! That I'm Starlight Glimmer! Wait no!

"Hey babe, what are you still doing up?" Evening said as he inwardly winced. Babe? He wouldn't call a woman babe like that! Well, unless he did marry Starlight, he could kind of see that being a loving nickname for her. Crap he had to stop thinking like that! This wasn't Starlight, it was Sunburst in a copy of her body!

"Oh I was just thinking about stuff..." Sunburst replied looking forlorn.More of his thoughts rang through. Wait what? The only thing I have on my mind is how to change back! Why can't I tell him something is wrong!? Why am I thinking of myself as Starlight in the first place? W-why doesn't this scare me as much as I feel it should?

Sunburst felt herself smile, unknowingly giving bedroom eyes. "Though I don't mind an interruption from you..." With that she pressed herself against him, her breasts squished firmly against his chest. His wonderfully chiseled chest…

Wait! What am I doing!? What is this!?

"Oh feeling feisty tonight?" Evening replied, rubbing her shoulders. Damn it she was so damn sexy, and he hated that the thought it was a grown man stuck in this sexy feminine body was turning him on. What must be going through her head right now? Did she enjoy the feeling this body gave her? He wanted so bad to explore the sensations even further with her. See how it compares to her old body! See if they really enjoyed simulation while a mare better than when they were a stallion.

Ugh, why was he like this?

Still this was Sunburst and not Starlight. It wasn't a body he asked for, so it was his duty as a friend to try and break her free of it.

"Well you are my handsome husband..." She purred, cooing at his touch. T-This feels too good. Damn it, why does having him rub my shoulders feel this wonderful? He really is a good husband.

Her eyes widened. HUSBAND!? She wasn't his wife! Right? Why did that sound wrong? Why did being married to this man feel so right? She was a stallion! A stallion!

A Stallion with a mare’s body she’s always felt was amazing to look at, but to be in it. To naturally flaunt this beauty and power. Would she have the same capabilities for magic?

"And you're my sexy little wife..." Evening whispered back, looking into her eyes. He couldn't lie to himself. This wonderful sexy mare before him was perfect in body. A great ass, perfect hips for foal birthing. Her adjusted chest was... it was so amazing! This mare was like a cross between Starlight and Fluttershy. He’d love to have a wife like this! It’s just she was a mare with the mind of a dear friend of his.

In a messed up way that didn’t make it less alluring. He liked Starlight, but he had a good relationship with Sunburst as well. I-If Sunburst had been born a mare. Would that have led to him wanting to ask her out? It was getting harder and harder not to see her as perfect wife material. That... that was going to make this very dangerous.

Unless…

Starlight said it’d end when they crossed a line they didn’t want. He hated the fact that even knowing Sunburst was in there, his lust for the body was messing with his mind, but surely Sunburst wouldn’t want anything to do with being treated like a mare right? Yes there was that small amount of curiosity he knew was in there, but being bucked by a stallion likely went way beyond the comfort zone. He just had to pour the affection on, and it’d push them past that bar so they could break free!

Trying not to worry over it, he gently lifted her muzzle up to his, staring into those perfect eyes.”

“My beautiful sexy wife…” He whispered as he leaned forward. This was it, this should break it right away. Feeling more eager than he liked, he pressed his lips to hers in a kiss.

Made to act like his wife, her body happily complied, pushing her own lips back in response.

That should do it! Evening thought triumphantly. This pony was a stallion in a mare's body forced to kiss another guy! That should be more than enough to break the magic!

He's kissing me! He's kissing me! Repeated over and over in Sunburst's brain as she eagerly and hungrily kissed back. It felt... Damn it, it felt amazing! Her entire body shivered in arousal from their lips meeting.

Why didn't she find this repulsive? Why? Why did she enjoy this so much? W-why was it making her think of doing more? She couldn't possibly let herself do more!

As for Evening, he still couldn't believe he held a beautiful mare in his arms as he savored the sensation. Her lips tasted wonderful. The warmth of her body, her breasts pressed against him in this exchange of affection was… magical.

He felt he held this for far longer than was ever needed. The same beautiful mare stared back up at him after he broke the kiss. Why hadn't she turned back? That should have ended it!

"Mmm so what were you thinking about?" He asked, giving her rear a little rub. Damn her ass was fine. If only this was the real Starlight. No he had to focus. The kiss didn’t work and thanks to the ‘roleplay’ wish he felt himself acting further. Touching… touching parts of her he only dreamed of. What, what if this went on further? Would he get to touch… those? No surely it’d never get so far.

So preoccupied with his thoughts, he almost didn’t hear Sunburst’s response. Almost.

"About how wonderful it would be to get a jump start on that large family you've always dreamed of..." She cooed back.

The words caught Evening off guard, his body reacting very positively to it, his dick practically throbbing at the idea of pumping foal batter into this goddess of a wife.

"Oh so that's your desire." The real Starlight quipped from her seat at the table. Evening was aware she was there, but as far as the mare in his arms was concerned. They were alone.

Damn it, why did that have to come out! Maybe he could use the stone to make her forget this part…

The actual Starlight had made a silent wish earlier that Evening wouldn't pay what she was doing any mind unless she wanted to talk to him. She had made said wish to hide the fact she was rubbing her cunt with a couple of fingers rather vigorously. Truth be told for her, she found this whole thing super HOT. Like really hot and steamy! She was loving this!

It was a part of her she had grown afraid of in the past. She loved that sense of control over a pony. She could never utilize this sort over most ponies of course. It sickened her to remember her actions like this in the past. It was only because she really trusted both Sunburst and Evening, and her conditions to break this scenario, that she was able to let loose like this at all.

She was also here to stop it if for some reason it started to go too far. She just wanted to tease Sunburst about enjoying her body. Not traumatize him. As for Evening. Well she was genuinely curious as to what he might feel towards her. She sorta had crushes on both of them, and this was her way of being playful.

This was also why she didn’t act upon her feelings. She didn’t think they’d like this part of her.

That led her to think about Evening’s desire in this. A large family huh? Truth be told she wouldn't mind either of them having foals with her. Maybe she'd ask Evening out for real after tonight? Or offer to go out with Sunburst if he wasn’t too mad at her. She sighed. Part of her actually envied Sunburst right now. She wondered what the mare was thinking at the moment?

Oh right she should be able to tune in thanks to the stone.

JUMP START WHAT!? NO NO NO NO NO!

Despite her mental protests, Sunburst couldn't make herself pull away from him. She was in NO way ready to be a mother! She wasn't even supposed to be a mare! Yet... yet the idea of having this stallion explore her body in such an intimate manner. It was doing something. Poking something inside her. Buck, was she getting turned on? There was no way!

Damn it! Ponies always asked why he and Starlight didn't hook up and it was because, while he liked her alot, he never felt he was good enough for her. Plus he hated that he envied her so much. Even now he wasn’t jealous free. She was a perfect ten in his eyes and her ability and versatility with magic was… It was something he desperately wanted for himself.

So much that it was making it hard not to enjoy having that very body as her own. Even in a situation like this!

"Really? You mean it?" Evening exclaimed rubbing her belly. "You're ready to have life growing inside you?"

Evening wondered if the spell was even really doing anything now. The most he felt it did was make him admit to what he wanted. A deep desire he had kept buried. After all, he was a screw up. His magic caused so many problems.

Who wanted a husband like him? Who wanted somepony like him as a father to their foals?

So with it appearing as if he had a willing mare. He really wanted to go for it. He wanted to jam his dick inside her and buck her raw till she was bred! He wanted to see her tummy bloated to the max with his foals inside! Damn it! He couldn’t actually let that happen. This wasn’t Sunburst’s choice.

Wait no, that was it. No matter how far they got there was no way he’d be okay with that. That was the line he had to cross. Damn it he was going to have a long talk with Starlight after this. This wasn’t fair making him long for something he’d never have.

It didn’t matter. What was important right now was he needed to hurry up and break Sunburst free of this spell!

"Y-Yes! Let's go for it!" This was wrong! Her whole body was on fire, and yet she knew it was wrong! She didn't want to become pregnant! She didn’t want to carry a foal inside a womb she wasn’t meant to have for months on end and yet... How crazy would that be to experience?

No, she had to make sure it couldn’t happen. Summoning up some magic she was already casting an anti pregnancy spell. With Starlight's magic it was a cake walk. She doubted Evening would even notice. This would let him keep his dream of k-knocking her up while allowing her to enjoy the sex with no worries!

Wait, shouldn't she be trying to prevent sex all together!? And why was she wanting to let Evening live out his fantasy of knocking up a wife? What was wrong with her!?

Evening did indeed miss the spell being cast, but the real Starlight did not, though she naturally did nothing to stop it from being executed.

‘Interesting,’ Starlight thought to herself as she watched in silence. Well silence that didn’t include her having summoned a dildo to shove into her own snatch. ‘I wonder why she cast that and didn't just stop them from going any further? Is she actually... interested in going that far? Should I let her? Maybe this is okay? But what if there is a problem with the wish?’

She stopped her self satisfaction. This could be dangerous. If prodded, she might lose her composer due to lust and end up trying to get knocked up after all. Starlight was going to have to keep a close eye on both of them in order to step in if needed. Maybe she should just wish to have it impossible for Sunburst to get pregnant? No no, it couldn’t get that far, and if they even got far enough that penetration happened, she could just make that wish then.

"W-What are you waiting for?" Sunburst nearly moaned out as her hand reached down to touch Evening's bulge, giving it a little rub. Damn! For a unicorn he was pretty hung! D-Did she really want this thing inside her? "Take me! Show me I'm yours!"

Evening couldn't believe what he was hearing. How were they this far? How has Sunburst not reverted yet? And now she was stroking him? What was happening? Was this just a dream?

'S-Starlight..." He whispered, giving her little kisses along her neck. Without thinking, one of his hands snaked up to reach under the ‘apron’ and got a nice handful of marshmallow boob. The sensation he got from squeezing was nearly exactly like that. Large warm marshmallows with these hard little milk duds in the center. Dear Celestia, he loved this mare's body!

"AH! E-EVEE!" What was that!?” She squeaked out in shock. The feeling of his hand! It was on her... oh heavens that's what it felt like to have a mare's breast!? To have ones as big as Fluttershy? It was mind blowing! She bet Fluttershy secretly played with them all the time! She certainly was going to when Evee wasn't! Wait no! She shouldn’t have them in the first place! Even if they felt so good! So soooooooo good!

No, No she had to keep her mind focused! She wasn't a mare! She wasn’t supposed to have boobs! T-This was just a temp thing! Yeah! She bet it was some prank by the real Starlight! She'd have to get her back good! Ha! Maybe she'd take lots of lewd pictures of her and Evee doing all sorts of dirty things! That'd show her!

"It’s all ready for you..." She heard Evee say. What? What did he mean by that? It took her a few seconds to register that his dick was pressed firmly against her. What’s worse it was pressed against a very eager and moist pair of pussy lips.

HER’S.

Right, her only wearing an apron meant he had easy access. Wait but he was clothed, where did his clothing go? This thought led her to realize she was holding something in her hands. Some sort of fabric. His shirt! She had Evening’s shirt in her hands! Had… had she been undressing him this entire time?

Seems she had begun by unbuckling his belt as both his pants and underwear lay somewhere on the ground. So were her panties! When had she taken them off? Had Evening done that?

Feeling the tip of his dick press against her, she felt her body lung forward a bit from the sensation. It was just enough to get the tip to almost slide in, but he shifted away from her. It was also enough however, for her nipples to press against his chest. This meant she’d also lost her apron at some point. All she had on now were the stockings and the choker. Buck, knowing she was dressed like that turned her more on somehow! What was with her!?

She had no way of knowing it, but she wasn't the only naked female in the room. The real Starlight had long since discarded her own outfit, though she had stripped practically completely naked save for the choker.

"D-Dear Celestia This is getting good!" Starlight murmured to herself as she got worked up. Her mind slightly buzzing from her own arousal. She had a brief thought of Sunburst snapping out of the spell and reaching for the stone to change himself back. That wouldn’t do!

"I-I wish Sunburst couldn't undo a wish without my permission!" Forgotten was the wish of only them being able to use the rock. She pictured Sunburst in her body begging her to change her back. Shamed that she was loving that body so much. She wanted to hear him say it. Say she loved her time in that body. It'd be the cherry on top of it all!

Her hands worked tirelessly at kneading her own tits as she watched the scene before her. Maybe she really should wish for funbags that big. Evening clearly liked them. She wondered if Trixie would?

Oh to Tartarus with it! “I wish my boobs matched the size of my twin over there!”

She had to nearly bite her tongue to keep from moaning. They were expanding! She could feel them growing bigger in her hands! It felt so amazing! She wanted someone to touch them!

Hmm, if she didn't get with Evening or Sunburst after this, she wondered if she could get with Trixie? Heck she was pretty sure the blue mare was just as bi as she was. Maybe they could have a threesome? Or an orgy! If only Trixie hadn't left for Klugetown two days ago! She had almost considered asking to tag along, but given the last time they had tried to travel together like that, she thought better.

Course if she had gone with her, then she wouldn’t be here right now to witness the fun before her. Damn it, Evee and her twin were practically about to buck, and her girl crush was miles away because she didn't do well in nature. It wasn’t fair!

"Ugh, I just wish I could have a wonderful time traveling with Trixie!" She moaned, before feeling a magical warmth start to overcome her. Oh no! She said that out loud!

"No wa-" but it was too late. Before she knew it the surroundings of the kitchen faded away to become some outdoor scenery. She was somewhere in some valley like area inside a... giant oil drum of water? And what was that pushing against her back! They felt soft.

"S-Starlight! What are you doing in Trixie's bath! Why are you naked except for a choker!?"

Starlight barely managed to move her body around so they were face to face, causing her breasts to press against Trixie's. Said mare had a healthy blush. Oh geez having boobs this big pressed against Trixie’s was certainly something.

“I-Is that really you Starlight?”

“Y-Yeah… uh hey Trixie.”

“A-Are your boobs bigger?”

“Y-Yes on that as well. Um It’s kinda tight in here. A-And hot.”

“I-It is… it hurts a little.” The blue mare just stared at her friend for a few moments.

"Trixie… Trixie isn’t daydreaming is she?"

Though a worry about what might happen at the scene Starlight had left behind did linger in her mind, she was far too horny to care at the moment. "Trixie. I'm real. I got here by magic. Now can I ask you something?"

"W-What is it?"

"Can we please make out like we're horny teens?"

The blue mare smiled in response.

"I thought you'd never ask!"

* * *

Meanwhile Evening had moved on to alternating between kissing and sucking on Sunburst's nipple, leaving her a wiggling, panting mess.

If the real Starlight had stayed, she’d be able to hear her twin's thoughts screaming. Yes! Oh Celestia yes! Keep doing that!

"J-Just think, soon these will be filled with milk... I bet they grow even larger..."

Oddly enough Sunburst actually felt a twinge of guilt at that. Afterall she technically lied to him. Lied about being ready for a family. A small shiver of fear ran up her spine when thinking like that. She couldn't let that bother her. If she got that far it'd be too much.

Much as she didn’t want to admit it, she was loving this. Loved the feeling of how worked up this female body was getting. Loved the idea of being able to harness its magic. But still, she couldn't get pregnant! That would get her stuck like this!

S-Stuck with such an amazing body…

"It's time babe..." Evening barely got out, doing his best to not only go along with the role play, but to make sure he gave this Starlight every chance she had at breaking away. The plan was still to get Sunburst to stop him, but the longer this dragged on, the less he could bring himself to want it to stop.

Pushing her off of him, he backed up toward the table, and after spinning a chair around, took a seat, his dick up and ready. "D-Do as you will..."

This was it. It was the only other out he could muster. He didn't want to give it. He hated himself, but he didn't want to give it. Instead he began to hope they could go all the way. He felt such a need to go all the way. He wished he could stop himself but… but it had to be up to her now.

For Evening, this was a dream come true.

Sunburst stared at the male appendage before her. Her pussy practically ached to have it shoved inside her. If she did this... If she did that'd be it. She doubted she could pull herself off in time once started. He'd fill her. He'd attempt to BREED her and only the spell would be able to save her from motherhood. A spell that had, though minor, a small chance it could still fail. Was it really worth the risk?

Buck it, of course it was!

There was no stopping this now. She frankly didn't want to. Instead she strode right up to him and lined herself up, her breathing increasing with each moment. Lowering herself, she felt the tip pressing against her maidenhood once more. She was a male! She was a stallion! This isn't how sex should be for her! She wasn't supposed to have a dick inside her!

She played every reason she shouldn’t want to go through with this in her head. Part of her hoped that something might hold her back. Something would convince her that this was a bad idea! She needed something, anything to weigh her choice away from this!

She felt her body plunge itself down, inviting him inside. The sudden shock caused her to let out the mother of all moans as she felt his hot thick shaft wedge itself into her. No! She wasn't a male right now! She was a mare! A beautiful sexy mare! Her body was perfect! She wanted this! Neigh, she needed this!

Her mind began to haze over as she bounced herself up and down. She couldn't believe the feeling of his rough skin rubbing against her inner walls like this! She could practically feel the veins on his dick! Each one rubbing a different spot inside her!

As if to reward her further, Evening kissed her again, his hands once more finding her the gigantic pillows she now had for breasts His fingers kneading into the soft tender flesh, gently rubbing the hard as rock nubs on the end!

So many sensations! Sensations she never would have been gifted as a male! She hardly wanted to go back to being one! This! This was just too perfect! This was the body she should have! Not that horrible male one!

Evening was in just as much bliss as his lover was. He couldn't think about who she was supposed to be, he could only focus on the role play. On having a wife. A beautiful voluptuous wife who's tight little snatch was squeezing his dick inside of her.

It felt so... he could feel it building. She was his! She had given herself to him! He had been given permission to breed her! To fill her with foals! He could picture her belly bloated during pregnancy already! Her hand lovely rubbing the taunt skin filled with their future family!

His mind flashed forward. She’d be a perfect mother and teacher to their foals. Sunburst’s vast intelligence stuffed inside a beautiful mare’s body. The magical power she’d be able to harness with that body. She’d be ready for any task… She’d just be so wonderfully perfect…

It was too much. With one last ravenous kiss, he unloaded all he had inside her. Pump after pump of his seed. Little swimmers eager to wiggle their way into any of her many eggs. Barely being denied by the spell Evening wasn’t aware of.

Sunburst had been feeling her own build up from her body. The bouncing, the feeling of his dick twitching in her cunt. The way he so gently yet eagerly played with every little part of her. It was heavenly! How had she gone through life without this? How could she go back to not having it?

She could tell he was about to cum. Being a guy before, she knew the signs. She could practically feel his dick getting ready to fill her up! The sensation was so hot! So damn hot! She wanted to feel his seed! She needed it inside her! She wanted every last drop to be pumped into her womb!

Her body shook the second she felt the first pump of foal batter shoot up inside her. It was perfect! So perfect! She wanted more of this! More!

She could barely register what happened with her body the moment she was pushed over the edge. The world, time itself became a blur. Her mind shaken. All she knew was that she loved the feeling. She loved feeling his seed sloshing around inside her.

Both mare and stallion just felt so... complete.

"W-Wow..." Sunburst murmured, her body still slumped against Evee's. In truth she could barely move. She almost hoped she was in this body long enough to go again.

Yes… Almost.

"I can't say I don't mind hearing that..." Evening replied as he rubbed her sides. She loved how he was doing that. "Though uh, we should probably cast a conception spell on you, you uh, probably don't really want to become pregnant."

"Y-yeah or I'll be stuck as Starlight's twin for keeps!" She giggled back, before her brain seemed to reboot. "W-Wait I just said how I'm not really Starlight, but I'm really Sunburst!"

Evening coughed sheepishly. "Y-Yeah Starlight kinda... made you her twin and had us play out this role play as a sorta revenge for the whole donation incident."

Sunburst just sat there in disbelief, still trying to process that she was a mare impaled on her friend Evening's dick, and not feeling the need to move. "S-Seriously?"

"Yeah I... oh geez I'm sorry. She set it up so we wouldn't go too far but we just... I thought you'd not want to!"

Sunburst's face turned red. "I-I uh... look I know this is awkward, and maybe somepony else would be mad, but dear Celestia I loved the sex we just had!" She snapped her mouth shut the moment those words left her mouth, but it was too late. The simple fact of the matter was those words were true. This was going to make it so awkward between them once she was back to normal.

"I... yeah,” Evening began, his face red as an apple, “I sorta... really liked it too but uh. We can change you back. S-So don't worry. We can change you back."

"T-That's good! I uh, don't want to be stuck like this!" She needed to end this soon. Those feelings she had just now. If she spent too long as Starlight, just as a mare in general. She was afraid of what it might lead to. What she might begin to crave.

"Y-Yeah..." Evening replied, though Sunburst could tell he wasn’t too keen on the idea. Just one more reason to get this over with. What if… what if he fell for her? It was such a weird thing to ponder. She’d never have thought she’d be in a situation like this, and yet here she was.

It wasn’t fair to him. She couldn’t stay this way. It wasn’t fair to break his heart like this.

They remained silent for a moment, both just sitting there, one inside the other before finally, Evening couldn't take it anymore.

"So uh... why did you go all the way? What if you got pregnant for real?"

She blushed hard. "I uh... I didn't want to be pregnant, but I couldn't stop myself. It felt so good a-and it's not like I hated pretending to be your wife.”

Evening raised an eyebrow. “Seriously?”

“Yeah it… I dunno I’ve been single for so long. Feeling this.” She shivered. “I just... oh geez I feel I should see if there is a spell to make us forget all this! How are we supposed to just go on after this? I can't just pretend it didn't happen!"

"I'm sorry. I should have tried harder to stop Starlight. I-I should have fought to stop it from going this far b-but..." Evening couldn't look at her right now. Not with what he had secretly hoped for. It wasn’t fair to her. Damn it Starlight, you have no idea how serious this actually is!

Sunburst had an idea on what he was thinking. "You really want a large family don't you?"

"I-I do..." Evening sighed, and turned to look her in the eyes. "I don't know why I want it so bad, but it's bad enough that I dream of a harem. How stupid right? As if I could get one mare as wonderful as you to marry me. Let alone others."

"It's not that stupid..." Sunburst said, her voice a bit more firm than she had anticipated her making it. "I wouldn't mind kids just I don't think I’d want to carry them, wait a mare as wonderful as me? B-But I’m not really a mare!"

“I-I know you aren’t really a mare I…” Evening sputtered, trying to find the words.

“Oh you mean one like Starlight.” Sunburst replied. Why did that hurt to say? “She is pretty great, even though she’ll occasionally do things like this.”

“No I don’t mean Starlight, I mean like you!” Evening blurted out before he could stop. Realizing he couldn’t leave it at that. “You… look that body and your personality, your intelligence and curiosity. Your drive to learn. I… think you’d be a great mother a-and wife…”

Sunburst could feel her face heating up. Oh Celestia she must look like a tomato! “I-I uh…”

Evening spoke up rather quickly. "A-Anyway, that's why we need to cast a conception spell! You can't get stuck-"

She placed a finger on his lips with a sad smile. "I uh, actually cast one before we began that was... that was the one line I wasn’t ready to cross… How ironic. It might have been the thing to break the spell.”

"Oh...Oh!" Evening felt some of the tension drain from his body. If she cast that then they should be good. She wouldn’t get stuck being his pregnant wife! What a… relief.

He tried to force the deep down feeling of disappointment. It made him feel even worse that he felt that at all. "T-That's great! It wasn't a good idea, and I'd probably be a bad dad anyway..."

For some reason that annoyed Sunburst. A bad father? Him? He was such a kind and thoughtful stallion! Always trying to improve the lives around him! Always trying to be helpful! Always making sure he did the maximum effort he could to make up for any spell mishaps he caused! She found herself speaking before she could think. "I wish you'd be more honest about that dream! I wish you'd tell me what you really wanted."

"I..." Evening tried to keep his mouth shut, but couldn't prevent the words from coming out. "I wanted to knock you up! I wanted to see you pregnant! Very pregnant! With like twins or triplets! I want you to stay this sexy mare and be my wife! One I hope of many!" He slapped a hand over his mouth. How? How could he say that? It was as if magic forced it out of him! But that shouldn’t be possible!

He glanced toward the stone and a certain thing Starlight said jumped back into the forefront of his mind. “I wish only we here and Twilight Sparkle could use the stone.”

‘We here!’ Sunburst had been right there next to them when she made that wish! That meant he, or she was included in the list of ponies that could use it! She was able to make wishes!

Meanwhile, Sunburst didn't think her face could get any more red. Damn it that sounds way too hot and wonderful. This is getting very dangerous. That settled it, she needed to change back before she did something she couldn’t take back.

"W-Wow, uh well I guess I can't blame you. G-Given how I look..." She looked down at her perfect breasts. Starlight would be soooo jealous.

"Yeah I uh,” Evening shook his head. “Look we should forget about that. Let's focus on fixing you."

"R-right uh... fixing me." Sunburst nodded. “And uh, how do we do that?”

“Well this happened because of this stone.” Evening replied using magic to lift it into the air to hover between them. “It grants wishes, and because of some Starlight made, only a few can use it. Which includes you.”

“M-Me?”

“I don’t think she meant to set that up.” Evening replied. “However it does mean you can wish yourself back.”

“Oh uh great. I should… probably get off you huh?”

“It’d be… awkward if you changed back while we’re like this yes.”

Sunburst sat there unmoving. Damn it why didn’t she want to move? She needed to end this, no matter how great it felt to have him inside her!

“Uh, anytime now?” Evening said awkwardly.

“S-sorry it’s just… a lot to think about. Soon I’ll be back to normal.” She shivered. “Are we sure we don’t want to use a wish to make ourselves forget?”

“I-I’m not sure…” Evening replied. “On uh, one hand this is going to be so weird to have on our conscious after you’re male again. On the other hand, I kinda don’t want to forget the sex.”

Both of them blushed.

“Yeah.. I… geez I wish I could be more honest with my feelings.” Sunburst murmured, not realizing the stone picked up on that and did its thing.

Evening couldn’t help but tilt his head. “W-What do you mean?”

She shook her head. “I know I should change back but It’s well..” She sighed. "Just uh... know this. I think I kinda wish I had cast a fertility spell instead."

She had expected Evening to be surprised by that confession, but not by becoming pale. "E-Evee?"

"Oh no! Oh no!" Evening was shouting, panic clear on his face. "We've got to fix you now! I wi…I wi..." Damn it! Thanks to Starlight he couldn’t make the stupid counter wish!

"Evee? Evee what's wrong?"

"T-that might have counted as a wish! That means you have a very high chance of.. of…!"

Sunburst felt her heart leap into her throat. “W-Wait it wouldn’t really count wo-”

She was stopped dead in her tracks as her midsection suddenly warmed up. It DID count! This was bad! This was very bad!

“I-It’s not a guarantee r-right?” She tried to convince herself. “I mean there’s never a one hundred percent on these!”

"I don't know! You need to get off me and wish yourself back!” He tried to lift her up, ignoring how smooth and wonderful her skin felt.

“Damn it! It might already be too late! Ugh, if only there was some easy way for us to tell! Maybe if you were several months along with them I could just look at your tummy. Wait no! Why did I say that!?" That’d be the worst way to tell! Good thing he couldn’t make wishes, he had no doubt he’d screw it up!

"T-Them?" Sunburst gulped. To be pregnant was nerve racking enough, but the amount Evee likely wanted to see her with. "L-Let’s not go crazy here! Look, I wish it was that easy to tell as well bu- AH!" Her stomach area blazed in heat, almost like it was burning. She used I wish again! Buck! How could she be that stupid!?

“Ohhhhhhh!” She moaned and cried in a twisted sense of harmony. Her insides seemed to shift as a strange cross between pain and pleasure washed over her midsection. She could feel it begin to stretch outward. Larger and larger, the skin becoming taunt and red.

In mere moments she could feel it press against Evening, a flurry of movements kicking up inside her.

"E-Evee?" She said her voice was eerily calm.

"Y-Yeah?"

"I-I think I'm pregnant with our foals... There are uh... two or three in there..." As she spoke that sentence, her breathing began to come quicker and quicker. This was a dream! It wasn’t happening! How was she so careless to let this happen!? She could barely hear Evening also freaking out.

"Oh Celestia! Oh Celestia I'm sorry! Oh crap what are we going to do?"

"I-I don't know! Why are you sorry? I’m the idiot who just wished that! Oh Celestia I wish I wasn't so scared right now!" She blinked. "O-Oh right... Uh well I'm not as terrified anymore."

"Y-Yeah but that doesn't solve the problem! You're a copy of Starlight and now pregnant! AND you think we’re married!"

“S-Should be get married?”

Evening balked. “W-what?”

“I-I mean I’m carrying your foals s-so should we? Ugh, what should I do? That stupid wish is keeping me calm enough, but… I can’t believe I did that!”

“L-Look we can figure something out when we find Starlight. I-I don’t know what but she can give me permission to make wishes again.”

Sunburst blinked. “You can’t make wishes?”

He shook his head. “She wished I couldn’t till she gave me permission. So at least I can’t make this worse for you.”

He gave her a weary smile, which thankfully got him one in return.

"R-right!” Sunburst chirped trying to get herself together. Just because she wasn’t terrified didn’t mean she was collected. “K-Knowing how things go all wild with you, you might have blurted something out like: “I wish Sunburst loved being pregnant and wanted to bear more of my foals in the future!”

She didn’t know Evening could look pale. "SUNBURST!"

"Oh sh-" A wave of bliss washed over her. She was pregnant! She was going to give birth to her husband's foals! As many as he wanted! She felt herself gently rubbing her taut tummy. "I-Uh... that one was on me."

“Both of those wishes are on you! What are you thinking!?”

Sunburst winced. “I-I’m going through a lot right now okay? You try being turned into a sexy mare and having the best sex of your life, only to wind up like several months pregnant in mere minutes! Oh I wish we really were married so I’d have your support!”

A Ring appeared on each of their index fingers.

Evening just stared at her blankly. “You… seriously?”

Sunburst could scarcely believe it herself. The most she could mutter out was a soft: “W-well you will support me right?”

“O-Of course I will! Those are my foals growing inside you. I couldn’t just abandon you! B-but now you aren’t just pregnant with my foals, but are really my wife!”

"I uh mean yeah? I guess so? Truth be told right now I don't mind being your wife…"

"But.. that could just be the wishes..."

She thought about it, but slowly shook her head. "I don't... think so? In any case I uh, sorta really like the idea of being a mom now. I know that I was hesitant, but being this sexy mare, a mother and your wife? It just… doesn’t seem so bad."

“I still think some of that are the wishes.” Evening replied. He loved hearing that this wonderful mare wanted to be his wife and carry his foals, but it came because of the stupid rock.

“Look I don’t think we can un-wish the foals, o-or I don’t want to do that.”

Sunburst shivered. “N-Neither do I.”

“But the wish to be my wife it’s… I think you should unwish that one.”

Sunburst felt hurt. “Y-You don’t want me as-”

He held up a hand. “It’s not that I don’t, it’s that I don’t want it to be because of a wish if we can help it. Look unwish that and I’ll still support you a-and… who knows…” He looked away embarrassed. “Perhaps one day we can get officially married…”

Magic wish or not she didn’t really want to stop being his wife, but she saw the logic. “R-right one step at a time. I wi-” Her mouth shut tight.

She blinked. “Huh?”

Evening looked concern. “Something wrong?”

“Yes I went to unwish it but… I wi-” Her mouth snapped shut again. She couldn’t do it, and not in an emotional she didn’t want to give this up way. She legit could NOT utter the wish to undo it.

“I-I can’t…”

Evening sighed. “Look it’s just the wish ma-”

“No I mean I really can’t!” She cried gripping his shoulders. “I try to say it and it’s like this force stops me!”

“Wait… seriously?”

She nodded.

Evening paused for a bit then pinched the spot between his eyes. “I bet Starlight made a wish that’s behind this. Great I don’t even know what wish it could be!”

Sunburst just sat there, still impaled on her husband’s wonderful cock, his offspring nestled safely in her womb. It was so comforting. Should she be concerned that it might all be because of the magic wish stone? Did she really care?

“W-well then I guess I’m still your wife at the moment.” She replied softly. “So what steps do we take now?”

"Now... " Evening sighed. "We're in this deep so we'll take it one step at a time. First things first though. Repeat after me: I wi- I wi-”

He groaned. “After saying I ‘the w word’ repeat after me: ‘I'd keep my feminine curves, but my body looked more as if I were a female version of Sunburst. Just a really curvy one.’"

“R-Right, I wish I’d keep my feminine curves, but my body resembled more my male body, just if I had been born a girl. J-Just a really curvy one… with Starlight’s ability for magic.”

“Well not exactly what I said, but I think that works bet- wait what was that last part?”

Instantly Sunburst could see her fur change back to its natural tanish color, complete with the fiery red for her mane and tail. Of course being a female, she didn’t get her goatee back.

Damn it! She frowned while rubbing her chin. It felt naked without it. Once her colors changed back to their natural palette, she waited for the rest of her body to shift. Except, it really didn’t. Her hips were still about as wide, ass just as plup and her tits were not only still as massive but... leaking. Great, she was leaking milk. She honestly should have seen it coming being several months along. Looking down at them she did a small bounce to see them jiggle. Yep still super sexy.

Evening was watching her with pleasant awe. "Oh damn! You looked good as Starlight, but you look even better like this!"

She blushed, a new warmth flowing through her body. Y-You really think so?"

"Absolutely."

She looked over her body as best she could, admiring her natural colors. “I’m going to need to get to a mirror later.” She pulled some strands of her mane in front of her to see. “Huh from Starlight to looking like her.”

“Who?”

“I-I’ll tell you later.” Sunburst coughed. "So, I guess I'm your wife now." She looked down at her tummy. "And soon to be mother of your foals."

"I-I guess so..." Evening replied. The sat there in silence for a few moments. "Are you... really okay with that?"

“I… the magic wishes aside…” She thought about it. She thought about it for a good little while, pleased that Evening was patient to let her think. This isn't how she thought her life would go that’s for sure. She was afraid of that that wish to be happy with this might mean in the future. Yet if she really thought about it. Thought about this moment and what it might lead to.

"I don’t dislike it." She kissed him. It wasn’t a perfect answer, but this was a strange situation. “I’m okay with seeing how it goes.”

Evening slowly nodded. "I-I guess we'll see if we can make this work then."

"Sounds good." Sunburst replied with a smile. She was certain he wouldn’t be a bad husband, and this feeling of being a pregnant mare wasn’t horrible. Neither was the feeling of being a drop dead gorgeous mare with Starlight’s magic.

“What about you?” She asked. “Any issues with being married to me?”

“No. I-I’m sorry but the idea that you are Sunburst stuck in a sexy pregnant mare’s body and my wife now is really damn sexy and hot.”

She gave him an odd look.

He sighed. “I know, but I can’t hide these feelings right now thanks to your wish. I know it’s a weird… I don’t fetish? Desire? I just… I’m really happy with you.”

She smiled. “So no regrets at all? Not sad that I’m not the real Starlight?”

At that Evening looked away sheepishly "I do kinda regret that I didn’t marry Starlight. I’ve had a small crush on her since we met." He shut his eyes trying not to admit the next part. “I-I used to dream about having a threesome with her and Trixie.”

He peeked at her. “That doesn’t upset you does it?”

Sunburst rolled her eyes. “I’d be a hypocrite if I did. I had the same dream not too long ago. Heh I wonder how they are going to react to me?"

She reached down to pat her tummy. “I doubt Starlight ever thought we’d go this far.”

"Oh it's going to blow her mind." Evening added with a weak smile.

"Hmm maybe I should invite them to bed with us?" She laughed at the absurdity of it all. “I mean I dreamt of sleeping with them myself. We could have a huge orgy!”

She could tell Evening liked the idea by the feeling of his dick stirring back to life. "Oh feels like you're on board."

"H-Hey we need to slow down!” Evening hissed trying to calm himself down. He couldn’t deny her words, but what got into her? “I-I just got you for a wife, and that’s more than I ever thought I’d get!”

“I mean you said you wanted a harem though right?” She teased. It felt good to tease her husband. This was a new playful side to her that she didn’t know she had. She liked it. “I mean I wanted to bed, them, you want to bed them. It works out perfectly!”

“I… they’d never go for it.”

She giggled. "Oh I know, but wouldn’t that be wild? Oh I wish we could somehow arrange that! Heck I wish I could see THEM knocked up with your foals afterward!"

"S-SUNBURST THE STONE IS STILL GRANTING WISHES!"

She froze. What the hay? She wanted to slap herself. Why would she be so careless? She knew the stone granted wishes!

“I… BUCK I can’t unwish that either! Ugh, why am I being so stupid tonight?!”

“I don’t know. Damn it I wi- wi… really would like to be able to use the stone myself!” Evening groans.

"We'll have to wait for them to get back here before we can fix that.” Evening shivered. The idea that he’d be able to do that was alluring, but he had enough trouble from today. “Unless you can wish them here?”

“I wish Starlight and Trixie were here with us!” They looked around. Nothing happened.

“Damn it I wish I knew why that didn’t work!” Sunburst blinked. “They’re out of range? Seriously!?”

“Figures.” Evening sighed. “Maybe we can wish for something to keep them protected from that when they get here?”

"That might work, you got a plan?”

“I uh… maybe? Can you not think of anything?”

“I can but it involves getting you worked up again for a round two.” She smiled at how hard the flesh rod inside her got at him hearing that.

“Okay let’s try this.You think of what you want right now and I'll do this.” She straightened up. “I wish I’d say outloud the plan Evening has in his mind. I wish I’d say it in the form of a wish!." She shivered. "I wish he could have more encounters where he gets to knock up pretty mares, especially if they were former stallions, wait WHAT!? EVENING!"

Evening was mentally kicking himself, but he couldn’t keep quiet. “You wished for me to be open about what I want that's what went through my head when put on the spot like that! Maybe we can wish the doors locked tight?”

Before either could say another word, as if on cue Big Mac walked in wearing nothing but a pair of farm shorts, a large sleeveless shirt, and some work shoes.

"S-Sorry to interrupt, but I was supposed to talk to Twilight abo-" A sudden glow took over his body, causing it to rapidly shrink and morph into a rather buxom red mare. Her tits weren't as big as Sunburt's own at the moment, but if one had to guess they were double D's. Her shirt barely contained them, now pushed out enough to expose her belly button. Her shorts were clinging for dear life as she immediately tripped out of her shoes, causing her to go stumbling toward Evening.

"W-Whoa!" Sunburst swore the next several minutes were a comedy act made real. She. had finally managed to lift herself up and off the unicorn, giving her just enough time to swing to the side as Big Mac tried to regain her balance, only to practically leap into his arms, her new boobs pressing into his chest. The force was enough to knock the chair over, letting her fall on top of him. They lay there for a bit, her boobs rubbing against his chest, before she finally sat up, her ass rubbing against Evening’s now fully erect again cock.

"I-I what? I... why am I a mare?" She cried cupping her new breasts. “O-Oh wow these feel… it’s this what it’s like for my sisters? Is this really happening?”

“B-Big Mac can you please get up? A-And off of me?

That seemed to snap her back to reality. “Right get up..” She slid herself upward, only to suddenly drop back down, Evening’s dick shoved into her new snatch, causing the unicorn stallion to grunt in surprise.

“W-Why did you do that!?”

“I-I don’t… my body moved on its own!” The new mare cried, her eyes wide from the sensation. She could feel the dick twitch inside her. "W-Why... why are you thrusting your hips?!"

"I-I'm not! You’re bouncing up and down!" Evening cried as the sexy mare continued to hold him down with her weight. “G-Get off me!”

“I-I can’t s-stop myself!” Big Mac moaned pulling Evening’s hands up to grope her new breasts. Said stallion couldn’t help but squeeze once they were in his grasp. It was like an instinct.

“W-What do you mean… B-Big Mac I’m going to c-cum inside you!” Evening cried, feeling a sense of dread. This had to be because of that stupid wish! He wasn't, was he? If he came inside her…

Shit... that sounds really hot... Sunburst thought as she shook her head. What was she doing? She should be trying to stop this! Try as she might though she couldn't muster the will to interrupt. There was something about seeing this new busty mare ride her new husband that just… it made her hot. Seeing him break in another former stallion into being his sexy little mare wife. If he got her pregnant? Her hand snaked its way to rub her own slit. What was wrong with her? Why was she getting off on this?

"C-Cum inside me?" Big Mac repeated as she began to let out moan after moan. "T-That sounds... why does that sound so good?"

It was no use. Sunburst watched as her husband bucked this newly made sexy mare till it was clear he was reaching his limit. She was honestly surprised and impressed he had it in them after he’d just knocked her up. It made her just that much more horny. Neither her husband or the mare form of Big Mac paid her any mind as she began to fondle her own tit while shoving two fingers into her snatch.

She knew this was messed up, but couldn’t bring herself to care. Was it the magic of the wishes, or…

Or had she always held this deprived little slut inside her?

“B-Big Mac s-seriously!” Evening groaned, trying so hard to stop himself from doing the inevitable. “I-I can’t h-hold it for long! You need to get off! It’s not safe! Y-You’ll end up having my foals!”

“I-I’m trying to get off!” Big Mac yelled back, her new body a slave to the sensations she was feeling. Never did she think she could feel something like this. This is what she’d been missing in sex! She knew she never wanted to be the big stallion! Oh Celestia the mares had it so much better!

“P-Please I need this!” She cried, arching herself backward. The image of that before him was too much. Evening knew what this would lead to, but she was just so beautiful. She’d make another perfect wife. A wonderful mother. It was the idea of her rubbing her own swollen tummy that did it. He came. HARD.

Big Mac joined him in a cry of pleasure, basking in the sensation of being filled. They sat there catching their breaths for a few seconds when Big Mac looked down at her tummy in concern as it blazed with heat.

Evening watched in horrified arousal as her stomach area began to push outward, more and more. Till it was just as swollen and stretched as Sunburt’s. He watched and listened as Big Mac let out soft little gasps as it happened. Hated himself for feeling pride at seeing her rub the outer skin that held life within it.

"I-I'm pregnant?" The stunned mare simply said looking down at her tummy. "Is this a dream? I'm going to be a mom? T-That's wonderful!" She kissed Evening who was still trying to process what happened.

“Y-You’re happy about this!?” He cried.

The new mare blushed. “W-well uh… it’s a long story but this might have been a secret dream of mine. Oh hey listen to me talk! I’m talking so much! Isn’t that weird? I was always silent as a stallion but now it’s like I can’t shut up! So how do I look? Am I pretty? I feel pretty!”

"Oh this is going to be trouble..." Sunburst sighed, trying to clean up her own little mess without them noticing. She couldn’t believe she did that. She couldn’t believe a lot of things she was feeling right now.

Things were definitely going to get more complicated if they didn’t figure out some fixes soon. She hoped Starlight or Twilight got back soon. They’d have a clearer head. Well more so Twilight. Sunburst was going to have to be careful that a wish wasn’t made to add her to this harem.

Mmm the princess of Friendship begging to be filled with her hunky husband’s foals… That could-

She shook her head. Okay that was dangerous thinking. The wish magic must have messed with her a lot more then she feared. What was her own thoughts and what were the result of the spell? Did she even truly love Evening?

Watching him try to help the new mare he impregnated caused her heart to flutter. There had to be some truth to it, but how deep did it go? Maybe she should send a letter to Princess Cadance? She might be able to help her determine that.

For now though, her husband had two new wives he needed to help get settled. They’d figure the rest out tomorrow after a long rest.

Well, first she’d get Big Mac to instigate a threesome with their husband, but sleep after that.

Sunburst and Big Mac… She should probably look into them choosing newer, better names…

Author's Note

First off some of you might be thinking: Why in the heck are people phrasing things as "I almost said: I wish for (blah blah blah)" That's stupid!

There IS a reason. The characters just don't know it yet.

This might need some more touching up, but in order to get it out today, this was the best I could get it. I'll work on it more as time permits, but I don't think this draft is too bad.

By all means, as always if you see anything that needs fixing, just point it out. I love when readers do that. No joke.

This is something I wrote on a whim on my Patreon to go behind the five buck pay wall. It's very loosely based on an RP I did. Never thought it'd get much attention, but my readers over there loved it, so it became a thing.

There IS another part rough drafted on the Patreon you can read right now behind the five buck pay wall. I'll touch it up and release it on here eventually this year, but past that I won't update this here till likely NEXT Valentine's day. It will get more constant rough draft updates over on the Patreon.

You can read how Twilight's parents come to visit in the next chapter and what happens with them.

Then soon to be written we have Discord becoming Eris, and the new Eris talking with the rest of the harem in getting Evening a gamer wife. Button would be perfect, but he's not a mare.

But what if he was swapped into his mom's hot body?

Also on the Patreon we have a soon to be launched "Choose the Adventure" story where Shining Armor becomes Celestia's daughter Golden Feather.

We currently have "Make a Wish" where you can comment on the posts what 'wish' the MC makes. Currently we are following Angel Bunny turned Fluttershy's mare daughter and how the CMC are helping her get acquainted with her new body. (All characters are 18 or up)

Finally you can read the next few parts of Liar Liar Breast Amliphier.

Patreon Link:
https://patreon.com/user?u=119033086&utm_medium=unknown&utm_source=join_link&utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator&utm_content=copyLink

Thanks for reading!