A decision of one
Chapter 1
Load Full StoryNext ChapterIt was a wonderful day in Ponyville, where Pinkie Pie and her friends were having a party in the garden and a lot of fun. It was a normal day again with laughs and friendship, blue sky without clouds, everything was perfect at the moment and Pinkie Pie has planned this day to tell Fluttershy her feelings for her.
Twilight Sparkle: Okay girls, I think it's time to go.
Applejack: Yeah, Big Mac needs some help tonight in the farm, see ya. (Leaves).
Fluttershy: Well I think we all have to go now, thank you for this amazing afternoon. (Smiling).
Rainbow Dash: Ohh Fluttershy you barely said a world. (Everyone laughs).
Fluttershy: But... I had a lot of fun.
RD: I'm kidding I had fun too but time to go. (Leaves flying at super speed).
Rarity: Good night, tomorrow I'll have to take care of Sweetie Bell so I've to rest. (Leaves with Twilight).
Pinkie Pie: Umm... Fluttershy can I go with you so you can tell me something about Gummy?.
FS: Of course, is he ok?. (They started to walk to Fluttershy's house).
PP: He's fine, but let's get first to your house. (Smiling).
Flash Back
Pinkie Pie was staring at one of her pictures of Fluttershy when she was a model and thinking to herself "Oh my, she is just beautiful" she realizes that something was not ok with her and her feelings to Fluttershy and the pictures just gave her the power to dream awake. "Why am I thinking about Fluttershy this way recently?".
Few days later she just couldn't stop thinking about her love and also she knew she was perfect for her I mean Pinkie Pie was super active, always jumping and if she meets a new pony she immediately becomes friend of the new pony and talks a lot and Fluttershy was just the opposite so they might be each other complement.
That day Rainbow Dash was in a cloud just waiting for a prank she was planning "I've never joke with Fluttershy, but what makes her different from the other ponies?" she was wondering if she had reveal her feelings for Fluttershy or if it was just something that will go with the time, but everything reminded her Fluttershy, a butterfly, the birds, the sky and she had an idea while jumping of joy, she will tell her about this in her way... a party.
Flash Forward
The two mares arrived at Fluttershy's home and by that time Pinkie Pie was so nervous that Fluttershy noticed that something was wrong with her because she had never seen Pinkie Pie this way, she was with her eyes closed as if she had seen a ghost or something.
FS: Pinkie? Are you ok?.
PP: F-Fluttershy, I'm n-not here because of Gummy. (She said it really shy).
FS: You can tell me anything I'll help you, what is it about?.
PP: Well... is about you. (Said extremely softly).
FS: What do you mean?.
Pinkie Pie knew that Fluttershy will understand even if they don't share the same feelings, but she had to say it for one reason, love.
PP: I think I... LOVE YOU. (She shout strong enough so Fluttershy little friends were now looking at them).
Fluttershy was amazed by the worlds but Pinkie Pie got enough energy to say it again.
PP: No, I don't think that I know I love you and this is all true I'd never lie to you. (She was now confident of herself but kind of sad).
FS: Pinkie Pie I- I... (Interrupted).
PP: I just wanted to say it, and I understand if you don't share the same feelings (Now crying softly).
FS: Pinkie Pie is not what you think, you know I- I've been in love with you too, but I was afraid to tell you something l-like this (said this softly ), you always treat me so kindly and you care about me (said closing her eyes but confident).
Pinkie Pie was staring Fluttershy and yes, Fluttershy has been in love with two ponies and one of them was Pinkie Pie.
FS: So what do you think?.
Pinkie Pie She was so happy that couldn't help herself and hugged Fluttershy and she hugged her too and then after a few seconds Fluttershy kissed her in the lips fast and softly.
PP: Wow, I didn't expect that coming from you.
FS: I didn't expect that you loved me (Smiling).
This time Pinkie Pie kissed her passionately and all the little animals were looking at them without knowing what was going on and Fluttershy became uncomfortable with this.
PP: I'm sorry I didn't want you to feel this way.
FS: Is not that, it's... umm... even if they are all animals I don't like it when they see me doing this.
PP: Well I think I should go, anyway it's getting late and ummm... Fluttershy can we keep this as a secret for the moment?.
FS: Sure, we'll tell the others when we're ready.
PP: This is the best day ever. (She jumped).
Fluttershy was looking at her "she is really happy" thought, "Knowing her she'll make a party soon, but she said to keep it in secret I just wonder why". Fluttershy was concerned about it, because Pinkie has done the hard part so far, making it public will need courage but not this much but then she thought that if we're talking about two mares in love of course it'll take a little longer. Any way she was really happy just to see her face happy.
PP: Well... will I see you tomorrow?.
FS: Y-Yes, I mean if you don't want to... s-stay .
Pinkie Pie couldn't hear the last part.
PP: What did you say?.
FS: Well it's getting dark and if you want to stay it'll be ok.
Pinkie's face showed a happiness that only can be compared by the happiness when she saw the rainbow for first time.
PP: Ohhh yeah we'll have a slumber party 'cause Twilight had one already and she didn't invited me...
FS: Pinkie.
PP: ... but we can have one now and it will be awesome because you'll be in there...
FS: Pinkie!. (A little louder than the first time).
PP: ... yes Fluttershy?.
FS: Come inside, I'll make you a tea.
Once inside Pinkie was more relaxed and she was acting like Pinkie Pie but Fluttershy was still nervous because she need another kiss like the last one, but she'd never ask for something like that.
FS: So what kind of tea do you like?.
PP: I'd rather chocolate milk. (Smiling).
FS: I think I have a little here. (Looking at the fridge). Here you are.
PP: Thank you. (She drank a little and then put it at the table).
FS: And well... I-I'm curious, what do you like about me?.
PP: First of all your innocence and shyness, that makes you super cute (Pinkie started to blush) and... well you are extremely kind with the animals and ponies, also you are beautiful.
At this time Pinkie was really embarrassed but Fluttershy knew she was saying the truth.
FS: I don't know what to say...
PP: You can tell me what do you like from me
FS: Well you're always happy and for some reason when I'm with you I-I feel more confidence in myself and you are kind with me you always treat me as your little sister or something even if I'm one year older... (In a depressive tone) I've been alone since I was a filly and I trust you a lot, also I-I think you' re beautiful too.
Pinkie kissed her again and for some reason Fluttershy fell and dropped chocolate milk in her face, she also drank a little due to that and Pinkie Pie licked the rest. Fluttershy was thinking about how good it felt and then kissed Pinkie in the mouth.
PP: Fluttershy I love the taste of chocolate (Licking Fluttershy's tongue) and if it comes from you it's delicious.
Fluttershy thought to herself "This is crazy I love this and for one reason I can't stop, I have never done this before, this is not right" she was having a conflict with herself because she wanted it, but her innocence said it was wrong.
FS: Pinkie, I like it, but for some reason I think this is not right.
She was hoping not to upset Pinkie Pie .
PP: That's one of the reasons I love you, you're innocent, what if we go to sleep?.
This fact made Fluttershy blush and happy.
FS: Well... do you want to sleep with me or...
PP: Of course (Smiling).
The two mares went to sleep but Pinkie Pie was awake thinking about how wonderful it'll be if they keep this way, and also how happy she was, because she had this secret for few weeks and now she doesn't have to hide her feelings anymore, well at least she doesn't have to hide her feelings to Fluttershy. Pinkie kissed Fluttershy in the cheek and went to sleep.
Next Chapter