Nighttime Magic

by tragicCaligula

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Romance, Trixie, Rarity, Sex
Length: 3257

A human and two gorgeous ponies

After a frustrating day, this male worker wished only to relax for the night. Unfortunately, his landlord and roommate do not let him off so easily.

This story is for practice reasons. Don't go to apeshit on it but please do leave me some constructive feedback so I can know what to do right next time.

Cover picture drawn by the awesome Megasweet

Published 2012-11-15 04:10:02 UTC
Last updated 2012-12-17 19:41:47 UTC

Part 1

I walked down the dark corridor, squinting my eyes so I could see properly. There was a nearby window that illuminated the corridor by a bit. It was night time; a star filled and beautiful one at that. I have been in the Everfree Forest all day, risking life and limb, trying to find the Cutie Mark Crusaders. Apparently, the fillies were on their way to the home of a zebra named Zecora and got lost. Their shrieks of fear were so loud that I heard them from town.

Due to my bad habit of volunteering in dangerous tasks to help others, I went inside the forest in place of the Elements. Don’t ask how I talked them into staying home.  I had scrapes, bruises, scratches, bite marks, and even sore muscles by the time I came out with the troublesome fillies. I returned them to their families, getting thank you’s from Applejack, Rarity, and shockingly Rainbow Dash. Never figured her for the adoptive type.

I went to the local hospital to have my injuries checked out, I do not want an infection or some broken bones make lose out on weeks of work. They checked my injuries and said that nothing was broken nor was there any internal damage, thank the Lord. They just applied some salves and stitched up my cuts. However, my muscles were sore and the doctor recommended me to lie down for a day or two or bathe in hot water to alleviate some of the pain.

By the time I left for Rarity’s Boutique, which was the place I lived, it was already sunset and the townsfolk were closing shop and calling it a day. When I got there, Trixie and Rarity were arguing...again. Trixie, or the "Great and Powerful Trixie", as she liked to call herself, was also living with Rarity after I found her struggling to survive just outside the damn forest, coincidentally. After begging to the fashionista, she reluctantly agreed only if Trixie pulls her own weight and gets a real job. Trixie had a talent for pyrotechnics and illusions, of course. She landed a job at the local cabaret as an actual magician. However, her demeanor did not change and fights with my landlord and her were now common.

I ignored them as I usually did and went straight for the tub. The thought of the warm water mending my sore muscles prodded me to hurry. Once I reached the bathtub, I quickly started the water and jumped in, savoring the pleasant sensations. That didn't last long, though. I began to hear a scuffle coming from downstairs and moving to the outside hallway. Those two started fighting once again. I think it was their 4th scrap this week. I facepalmed knowing that immediately after I get out of the tub, I had to end their pointless argument.

I heard a door slam and then... silence. Nothing at all.

I finished up my bath and dried myself off, headed to my room and put on my pajamas - yes, I still wear PJ’s despite being a 24-years old.

Anyway, back to where I was.

Heading down the corridor, a sliver of light caught my attention. It was Rarity’s door, it was open. Remembering the noises from when I was bathing, and remembering they abruptly stopped when I heard a door slam, I carefully motioned towards the door. Not wanting to peek in someon- somepony’s room, I lightly tapped on the door.

“Rarity. Trixie. You two okay in there?” I asked. No response. I was about to knock again but the door open slightly on its own. Deciding to risk it, I went inside.

What I saw, however, made my jaw drop and another part of me rise.

There on Rarity’s bed was Trixie and Rarity... kissing! They were making out with each other, making passionate moans. Trixie was underneath Rarity as she was rubbing circles on the alabaster pony’s flank. Rarity was moaning in ecstasy as she kissed Trixie, lightly nipping the magician’s neck and then returning to kiss Trixie’s lips. All the while, both mares were grinding upon each other with unmatchable lust.

As I was a male, it should be obvious to you that this was incredibly hot for me, but I thought I was going to get the tar beat out of me for intruding on their... session. The two mares stopped their amorous display and looked at me, a trail of saliva breaking away from their lips. I brought my hands to my face, looking away and bracing myself for a beating for intruding on them. Nothing happened. I, once again, risked it and opened my eyes. Instead of angry glares and horns shining and at the ready, I was met with smiles and bedroom eyes.

“Oh, hello there! We didn’t see you there, darling. We were... busy.” Rarity said with a giggle. She looked at me with sultry eyes. I have never seen her like this before. I fumbled around, trying to say something that could diffuse this awkward situation. I couldn’t think of anything. They both giggled.

“Wait.. uh, I thought... you two were fighting?” I asked nervously. Again, they both giggled at my bashful nature.

“We were arguing about such a silly thing, Trixie does not remember what, though. It lead to us wrestling and then... it led to something else.” said Trixie, gently rubbing Rarity’s chest.. She and Rarity shared a quick kiss and then looked back at me. My face was burning red. The heat alone was enough to fry an egg. I couldn’t take the scene in front of me. It was too much to resist.

“Um... uh, well, I’ll leave you two to... yourselves then. Sorry.” I went directly for the door but it was quickly surrounded by an aqua aura and slammed shut and locked. Several candles were lit and the wicks burned a light purple flame. Yeah, it was going there.

“Leave? Surely you wouldn’t just leave us after catching us here, you naughty boy.” Rarity said seductively. I turned around the awkwardness becoming unbearable but deep down, I kind of liked this.

“Besides, Trixie still needs to thank you for rescuing her from the forest. It is something Trixie must have done a long time ago.” Trixie said.

“And I must repay you for saving Sweetie Belle and her friends and helping around the Boutique. I cannot believe I could be so selfish!” exclaimed the Fashionista.

“Uh, you two don’t have to do anything. Living here with you two is reward enough.” I mentally face-palmed for such a cheesy comeback.

“Aw, he is so cute, isn’t he?” said Rarity. Before I could blink, Trixie’s horn lit up and the same aura from before enveloped me. It was pointless to struggle as I fell onto the bed, between the two amorous and... very beautiful mares. The two said mares came close to my face, my resolve at it’s breaking point. They smelled of lavender and roses, their striking faces so close to mine, the heat from their bodies in conjunction with the silky touch of their coats was too much for me to handle.

They came closer and our lips met. That was the trigger; my resolve broke and my body took over.

Part 2: The Main Course

When our lips separated, the gorgeous mares in front of me looked at me with want, with lust. I could somehow feel that they were waiting for this. The way they bit their lower lips and their half lidded eyes were a good indicator of it. Not wanting to keep Rarity and Trixie waiting, I made the first move. I moved my hand to Rarity's shining coat, rubbing it as slowly as possible. It managed to get her to lay on her back, humming and relaxing against my touch. Moving my free hand to Rarity's stomach, I massaged every inch of her body, eliciting heightened moans from the unicorn mare. I almost forgot someone else. Trixie! I looked over to my left, still stroking Rarity's coat, and saw Trixie pleasuring herself with her hoof, oblivious to my attention.

With a red face, I turned back to the writhing unicorn underneath me. Making a mental note to give Trixie double the effort for leaving her second, I turned my attention back Rarity. There she was waiting patiently for my next move, looking up and down my body with her azure eyes. I was going to show my landlord gratitude for her generosity: the only way I knew how.

I lowered my head to her neck, my breath making her shudder in delight. I kissed her neck and reveled in her pleasure but I didn't stop there. I peppered her neck with kisses but I slowly trailed down her body, rubbing her soft, plump flanks as I did so. From behind, I could hear Trixie moaning with pleasure as I kissed Rarity's warm body. Didn't take a genius to tell what she was doing. Moving down to her belly, I stopped. I knew what was going to come next but wanted to see the unicorn's expression.

"Ready?" I asked. Rarity looked into my eyes and nodded quickly. Her hair was frizzled and her face red; a rather cute sight. She wanted this badly. Licking my lips for some slight lubrication, I moved downwards. I reached the mare's glorious pussy, the lips were white like their owner's coat but I could see a sliver of pink in the middle. Grinning inwardly, I plunged my tongue into the waiting mare's snatch, licking her inner walls as the mare in question bucked her legs; her moans became louder. She was practically screaming as my tongue explored the inside of her marehood.

She tasted sweet, almost like honey. I thought it was peculiar but pushed it out of my mind when I realized I wanted more. Rarity's screams of ecstasy and her tasty pussy drove me to pleasure this mare to the point where she won't be able to contain it.

"Please, don't go so... fast, darling." pleaded Rarity. As much as I wanted to continue drinking her glorious nectar, she was right. I didn't want to end the session this early on.

And besides, making a lady cum so early is just plain rude.

I stopped eating out the mare for a few seconds because I once again remembered Trixie was off by her lonesome, forsaken to masturbate alone while Rarity had my attention. Having sex with one mare at a time was going to be awkward on my part. I needed to please both of these mares at the same time using all of my endurance. They deserved it, and hell, this can be a great way to alleviate the pain my body felt.

"Why did you stop?" questioned Rarity, off of her sexual high.

"Yes, why did you stop? You were putting on such a fantastic show for Trixie!" said the magician mare, wiping her sticky hoof on her coat.

"I think it is time for the main course. If we are going to do this, then we will do it together!" I exclaimed. The two mares in smiled at each other and then looked at me with malicious smiles. Quickly, Trixie used her magic to push me onto the bed and kept me there, the azure mare loomed over me. Rarity, meanwhile, moved over to my pinned form and used her own magic to get rid of my PJ's that I neglected to take off. Both of the horny mares looked at me with such fierce intent.

"Aren't you the impatient one," said Trixie.

"Indeed. You must want this more than we do, don't you?" said Rarity as she tossed away my pants and shirt, leaving only a pair of boxers with a huge bulge in the middle. And here I thought I was being nice.

I never met a girl with as much sexual want these two mares were exhibiting. Come to think of it, I've never even met girl who wanted t-

"Ooh, excited, aren't we?" said Rarity, rubbing my concealed with her hoof. Both she and Trixie shared a quick, sloppy kiss and smiled at each other. Before I could let out a stammer, my boxers were ripped from my body, my trapped cock sproing-ing out; erect and free from its prison. At first, I thought Trixie and Rarity would be unimpressed by how large I was. Male equines biologically have a larger penis than a male human does. I thought I was decent size by human standards but by pony standards, I wasn't so sure.

My musings were stopped dead in their tracks when I felt two wet tongues envelop my shaft.

I threw my head back into the pillow, a sudden wave of ecstasy and pleasure rocked my body. Endorphins were rushed throughout my body. If I died at this exact moment, I would be a happy man. The warm, wet sensations danced around my dick as I laid there on the bed, unable to do anything as the euphoria gripped my body with it's pleasurable grip.

"Enjoying yourself?" I heard Trixie's sensual voice reach my ears. I begrudgingly opened my eyes and fought the pleasure to see what the two mares were doing. What I got instead was Trixie's sweet looking pussy just a few inches away.

"Oh, I will..." I smirked. I brought my tongue to her pussy and gave it a long, slow lick. Her juices tasted almost exactly as Rarity's, sweet like honey. I did not stop with just a lick, I lapped at the unicorn's pussy, making sure that her nectar that was leaking out did not go to waste. Trixie moaned in delight as she joined her companion Rarity back in their session with my engorged member. I completely pushed away the thoughts of size difference. If the two unicorns were not complaining, I sure as hell wasn't going to either.

Minutes felt like long, blissful hours as we all sucked and slurped each others genitals. I was fingering Trixie's tight cunt, making her moan passionately. Eventually, Rarity stopped her sucking and spoke up.

"Well, well, well, darling. I did not know you could last so long with the two of us pleasuring your large, and might I add tasty, cock," Rarity said while she wiped some excess saliva from her lips.  "So, how about we move to the grand finale?" she suggested. Ah, actual penetration? I gave Trixie's now puffy cunt one last lick - gaining another cry of ecstasy - and sat up on the bed. I was sweating all over, my torso was covered with Trixie's vaginal fluid, and yet my cock stood erect and proud.

Trixie positioned her plot over my cock. I was ready to fuck this unicorn silly. Rarity, meanwhile, slid beneath Trixie's muzzle, spreading her legs and positioning her netherlips with Trixie's mouth. I could sense the azure unicorn's mouth water at the sight of the white unicorn's pussy; I know I would. Prepared to end this session with a bang, Rarity gave us the signal to start and the rest history.

I slowly inserted my rock-hard cock into the pussy of the waiting mare, her vagina lubricating my shaft as I agonizingly went deeper and deeper in her tight, hot marehood; a feeling that was next to indescribable. On the other end, Trixie practically screamed with delight and sexual pleasure. Her moans as my cock rested in her pussy were laced with lust, with burning want. As her screams died down, I decided to make the next move. I gingerly removed my dick from Trixie's tight cunt halfway and quickly slammed back in her. I did it again and again until this became the norm. I, however, was in nirvana. The feeling of pumping in and out of such a tight, wet, hole was breathtaking. Instead of words, only pants, grunts, and huffs came out of my mouth as I made love to the moaning unicorn below.

When I said I was going to put some effort into Trixie, I meant it.

Trixie was having the time of her life. As she rode my dick, she was able to fight against the pleasure to move her muzzle downwards into the slit of the patient Rarity. Once Trixie made touchdown unto Rarity's waiting marehood, she began to lap up the unicorn's sweet nectar. Rarity started to moan in pleasure as the azure mare licked and slurped her clit. All three of us fucked in perfect harmony: while I fucked Trixie, she would move her tongue in and out of the alabaster mare's slit. Rarity, meanwhile, moved up and down to match Trixie's tonguing. All the while, our bodies glistened with sweat, the purple candlelight making this evident. We all let time slip by us as we fucked in unison. Moans where the only things spoken.

Finally, that was when things were coming to a close.

"I'm going to..." moaned out Trixie. She was close to the edge.

"Oh my, so am I..." moaned Rarity. She was close too. I myself was close to the edge too. I was ready to cum into the unicorn below me. I suddenly felt this feeling overtake my body. I was about to-

"I'm gonna cum!" I yelled. It wasn't very romantic but I wasn't really focused on that. I felt Trixie's inner walls tighten and lurch. She was going to cum too. I put out all stops, I sped up the rate of pumping into Trixie. My feral instinct took over as I relentlessly fucked Trixie.

Finally, it happened.

I came in Trixie with explosive force. My warm seed filling her inner walls. Trixie screamed in pleasure as her walls tightened around my cock and she released her juices all over my cock. Her warm fluids coated my dick as I pulled out of her, my cum and her fluids trailing down her leg as I collapsed onto the bed, energy spent and gone. Rarity, however, was way ahead of me. She was not moving as vaginal fluids leaked out of her slit. A majority of it formed into a small stain on the quilt. Trixie had already made her cum before I did. She's good. I looked over to Trixie: she lied in between my legs as she too was collapsed on the bed, the mixture of sperm and vaginal fluid coating her fur and the bed.

Not wanting to leave ourselves like this, I used whatever energy I had left and lifted both Rarity and Trixie beside me; Rarity to my left and Trixie to my right. They cuddled against my body and I brought them closer to myself. The candles in the room were going out one by one, slowly blanketing the room in a peaceful darkness. I thought back to what just happened: I just had sex with two mares that were least likely to do this with me in the first place. I found them about to have sex earlier and I joined them. I got to taste their delicious nectar, received oral sex from both of them and had a harmonic threesome with the two unicorns.

Personally, I was glad I walked in here and I would never do anything to change it.

I wrapped my arms around the mares as the final candle died. I closed my eyes and dozed off into a dreamland of bliss with the two peaceful, beautiful mares nestled in my arms.